California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 2, 1998
Student v. Ross Valley School District
SEHO Case No. SN 503-98 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
Ross Valley School District must provide full inclusion with a 1:1 aide in all academic classes; evaluation reimbursement denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 13-year-old girl eligible for special education because of a language impairment filed for a due process hearing against Ross Valley School District. She had attended Allaire School, a small nonpublic school, for two years. She was returning to White Hill School for eighth grade. The District offered two options. One was a "modified inclusion" program with mostly general education classes, a resource specialist history class, and a "push-in" aide in English. The other was a special day class (SDC). The parents wanted full inclusion with a 1:1 aide in every academic class, or a nonpublic school.
The Hearing Officer did not decide whether the SDC option was appropriate. The written offer described it in a single sentence, which did not meet the clear written offer rule of Union School District v. Smith. On the inclusion option, the District gave no sound reason to keep her out of general education history while placing her in general education English. The Hearing Officer held that the least restrictive environment was full inclusion with a 1:1 aide in every academic class, including remedial math. The aide had to be the same special education instructional aide in each class. A request for different speech-language services was denied because it was never raised as a hearing issue. The parents' request for reimbursement of private evaluations by Kay Runyan, Virginia Reiss, and Marian Diamond was also denied. The District had to revise the IEP within 15 days and review her progress within 60 days after school started.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied the preference for the least restrictive environment when a district put a student in general education English but not history without a clear reason. It also shows that a one-sentence alternative offer could fail Union v. Smith. Evaluations obtained for the hearing were not reimbursed without proof that the district's assessment was inappropriate.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Has Ross Valley School District proposed an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year?
The SDC alternative was too vaguely described to satisfy Union v. Smith and was not evaluated. The District gave no sound reason for a resource specialist history class, so the least restrictive environment was full inclusion with the same special education instructional aide in every academic class, including remedial math. A request for different speech-language services was denied because it was not raised as a hearing issue.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 2. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for certain costs relating to services provided by Kay Runyon, Virginia Reiss, and Marian Diamond?
No reimbursement. The Runyan and Diamond evaluations had no written reports in the record. The Reiss assessment came a year before the District's assessment, when there was no District assessment to disagree with. Evaluations obtained to prepare for hearing are not reimbursable on that basis alone.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of receipt of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to conform the IEP to the decision. The program must follow the District's May 21, 1998 proposal, except as listed in the next remedy.
- Order to provide or change services. Enroll the student in a regular education history class with a push-in aide and provide a push-in aide in remedial math. The IEP must state that the aide is a special education instructional aide and the same person for all academic classes.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. The IEP team must reconvene no later than 60 days after the first day of the 1998-99 school year to review progress and adjust the inclusion program as needed.
Key authorities
W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Union School Dist. v. Smith; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5); Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56507(d)
People named in the decision
- Rosemary LePage, program manager, Ross Valley School District / White Hill School
- Kay Runyan, educational consultant, expert witness for Student, private practice
- Virginia Reiss, licensed educational psychologist, expert witness for Student, private practice
- Marian Diamond, clinical psychologist and neuropsychologist, expert witness for Student, private practice
- Gail Benvenuta, resource specialist and assessor, White Hill School, Ross Valley School District
- Carolyn Taormina, school psychologist and assessor, Ross Valley School District
- Barbara Gaman, special day class teacher, White Hill School, Ross Valley School District
- Allaire School, nonpublic school, nonpublic school for children with learning disabilities
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 503-98 Case Year: 1998 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Placement Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 21-75002 District: Ross Valley Elementary Disability Type: Speech or Language Impairment
Case Details This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, on June 4 and 5, 1998, in San Rafael, California.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Amanda Metcalf. Also present on STUDENT's behalf were her parents, MR. AND MRS. PARENT. Respondent Ross Valley School District was represented by attorney Lenore Silverman. Also present on Respondent's behalf was Rosemary LePage, program manager, White Hill School.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments only. Upon receipt of the parties' closing briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Has Ross Valley School District proposed an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year?
(2) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for certain costs relating to services provided by Kay Runyon, Virginia Reiss, and Marian Diamond?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Prior to the introduction of evidence, the Hearing Officer advised the parties that due to the Hearing Officer's schedule and how hearings are calendared, the entire matter would have to be heard and concluded in the two days scheduled or rescheduled for another hearing officer at a later date. After some discussion, both parties indicated a willingness to proceed and this matter was concluded by the end of the day on June 5, 1998.
On June 22, 1998, the parties submitted written closing arguments. On June 26, 1998, Ms. Silverman objected on behalf of the District to portions of Petitioner's closing brief. Specifically, the District objected to "that portion of Petitioner's closing argument that contains test results from Dr. Marion Diamond's assessment." Dr. Diamond's assessment was not introduced into evidence at the hearing. The Hearing Officer notes that the parties' closing briefs are not evidence to be considered by the Hearing Officer. In any case, the record had already been closed for the submission of additional evidence. The only evidence that will be considered is that which was introduced by the parties at the hearing. Those portions of either party's closing brief which contain facts or other evidence which was not introduced into the record during the hearing will not be considered by the Hearing Officer in rendering a decision.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that STUDENT should be placed in a full inclusion program for the 1998-99 school or, if such a program is not appropriate for her, in a nonpublic school. Petitioner further contends that, if STUDENT is placed in a full inclusion program, she requires a 1:1 aide in all of her academic courses. Petitioner also contends that she is entitled to reimbursement for assessment-related expenses. The District contends that it has proposed an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year in either a "modified" inclusion program or in the special day class program at White Hill School.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 13-year-old student in the Ross Valley School District (District). Her most recent IEP states that she is eligible for special education services as a result of a language impairment. STUDENT has attended Allaire School, a small nonpublic school for children with learning disabilities, for the past two years. STUDENT will be starting the eighth grade in September 1998.
On March 13, 1997, STUDENT was evaluated by Virgina Reiss, licensed educational psychologist, at her parents' request. Ms. Reiss administered a range of standardized tests, including the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III); the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT); the Bender-Gestalt; and several other tests. On the WISC-III, STUDENT received a Full Scale IQ score of 73, with a Verbal IQ score of 79 and Performance IQ score of 72. On the WIAT, STUDENT's standard scores ranged from 75 in reading comprehension to 92 in basic reading and spelling. Ms. Reiss concludes:
From the above findings it is important for STUDENT's parents to be sure that her learning environment is small (not many children), and structured. She would fare best in a predictable situation where she can anticipate what will be happening next, and where changes are small and gradual. With too many transitions, or too loose a structure, STUDENT could quickly regress and forfeit her momentum in learning.... It's hard to imagine STUDENT in a regular middle school or high school in the near future. Even if she were in a special day class, she does not yet have the social skills to cope in those environments.
On October 31, 1997, STUDENT received her first quarter report card from Allaire. All but one of her ten grades were "A," with the other grade being an "A-." The Comments section states:
STUDENT's attitude has markedly improved as well as her social interactions with everyone. She occasionally kids around and uses appropriate sarcasm. Working on "please" and "thank you" would be a good goal. STUDENT even has helped us prepare the room in the morning without balking.
On January 16, 1998, STUDENT received her second quarter report card from Allaire. She received six grades of "A" or "A-", three "B's" and one "B-." The Comments section states:
STUDENT is making good progress. Her increased in-class socialization, probably a good and normal sign, has interfered with her amount of productivity, thus lower grades during the independent learning activities. Once her new stage of sociability finds a happy medium between enjoying herself and completing enough work, her grades will get back on target.... STUDENT participates more openly in our content subject areas and shows a general perkiness which is refreshing!
On February 27, 1998, Gail Benvenuta, resource specialist, completed the educational portion of STUDENT's triennial reevaluation for the District. Ms. Benvenuta administered several academic achievement tests, including the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (KTEA), Peabody Individual Achievement Test-Revised (PIAT-R), and TOWL-3. The results of these tests, compared with administration of the tests in May 1997, showed that STUDENT made a six-onth gain in reading comprehension on the KTEA and a two-onth drop in reading comprehension on the PIAT-R, a three-onth gain in spelling on the KTEA, a six-month gain in math computation on the KTEA, and a four-month gain in math applications on the PIAT-R. Ms. Benvenuta also noted that STUDENT's writing sample indicated "slight growth in style and writing conventions ... STUDENT produced a scorable story this year, which she did not do last year." Ms. Benvenuta concluded
STUDENT's cooperation with this examiner for this assessment was exemplary.... STUDENT remains eligible for special education services. In this assessment setting, she continued to demonstrate cognitive, language, and academic delays that would impact her performance in the classroom. She can benefit from support in all academic areas. It is recommended that she be considered for placement in a small, highly structured environment that can meet her instructional level, not only for academic subjects, but as well for functional and social needs. She would benefit from a predictable environment wherein she can develop trust in those working with her so that appropriate progress can be made with social interaction skills and skills that will support her in developing a good/positive sense of self and an understanding of problem-solving within her immediate environment. A setting that offers peer counseling support would be beneficial for her.
On March 11, 1998, Carolyn Taormina, school psychologist, completed the psychoeducational component of the triennial reevaluation of STUDENT. Ms. Taormina's evaluation of STUDENT included observations of her during two assessment sessions and the administration of the Rorschach, Roberts' Apperception Test for Children, Piers-Harris Children's Self-Concept Scale, Children's Depression Inventory, and the Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist. On the Rorschach, STUDENT did not produce enough responses to produce a valid protocol. However, responses did produce some noteworthy characteristics, including that she "seems to deal with the world in a simple, matter of fact way;
she may be insecure and fearful of involving herself with her environment and those in it.... STUDENT seems uncomfortable with emotion and she likely backs away from emotionally charged situations." On the Roberts' Apperception Test for Children, STUDENT's responses "may indicate that she has difficulty µreading' social interactions in the environment." STUDENT's results on the Roberts "suggests that STUDENT needs to learn some basic problem-solving skills to help her through normal social conflicts with others." In her "Summary and Recommendations," Ms. Taormina stated that
Previous assessments have documented STUDENT's learning challenges: STUDENT has delays in receptive and expressive language, auditory processing, cognitive functioning, fine-motor development and academic skills. The results of the present assessment indicate that STUDENT's academic progress and social-emotional adjustment is also compromised by immature social skills, poor coping skills, problems accurately reading situations in her environment difficulty identifying and expressing emotions, and limited problem-solving skills.
STUDENT would benefit from a small, structured educational program, that will support her academic, speech and language, social-emotional, and problem solving needs. It is also recommended that STUDENT be referred to Marin Community Mental Health Services for consideration of out-patient therapy to address the above social-emotional needs.
On March 20, 1998, STUDENT received her third-quarter report card from Allaire. Her lowest grade was "B-" in language arts and math, while her highest grade was "A" in science, art, music, physical education, and spanish. The Comments section of the report card states:
Congratulations to STUDENT regarding her move to the next level reading text. She will begin looking up vocabulary words from her homework novel as needed. Dictionary skills will be developed. STUDENT does need to edit more carefully, especially for grammatic errors. STUDENT's chattyness has interfered with the amount of work she gets done in class, but it is a trade off still for her blossoming sociability.... STUDENT did a great job presenting at the Science Fair!
On April 13, 1998, Ms. Reiss submitted a "To Whom It May Concern" letter stating that "I believe it is in the best interest of STUDENT and her educational needs to have her attend her local public school on a full inclusion basis, along with the important assistance of a full-time, one-to-one aide. In addition, it is imperative for any continued progress that STUDENT continue to receive the current level of services in speech and language."
On May 21, 1998, following a series of IEP meetings in October 1997, and March and April 1998, the District made a written offer of placement which included the following components:
(1) Prior to the beginning of the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT will have an opportunity to spend a day at White Hill School to familiarize herself with the school and meet the teachers. (2) During the first week of school, STUDENT will have a staff member with her to help her transition from class to class. If necessary, this staff member will remain with STUDENT beyond the first week.
(3) During the first month of school, the resource specialist will have weekly phone contact with STUDENT's parents.
(4) STUDENT's teachers will meet at the end of the second week to review her progress and make any necessary adjustments to her schedule.
(5) STUDENT's schedule will consist of the following:
(a) Remedial math -- a general education class attended by both regular and special education students. Alternatively, STUDENT may enroll in a resource specialist math class. (b) Regular education physical education.
(c) Regular education English class with daily "push-in" support from a special education instructional assistant or resource specialist.
(d) Eighth grade resource specialist history class -- this class uses the 8th grade history curriculum modified for STUDENT as appropriate.
(e) General education electives. Prior to the beginning of each elective cycle, STUDENT's parents will meet with the resource specialist and teacher to determine whether a "push-in" aide is appropriate for the course.
(f) One period of resource specialist focusing on organization, study skills, and learning strategies.
(g) Speech and language services for 60 minutes per week (6) The resource specialist will collaborate with STUDENT's teachers and the special education instructional aide to ensure successful modification of classroom content and materials and will monitor STUDENT's classroom progress.
(7) STUDENT will be encouraged to participate in the Ventures girls group, a voluntary program focusing on social development.
(8) STUDENT will be offered structured social interaction activities provided through the Student Activities Program and will be encouraged to participate in competitive athletics.
The District also continued to offer an alternative placement for STUDENT in the special day class program at White Hill School.
Petitioner objected to both of the placement options proposed by the District and requested a due process hearing. Petitioner contends that STUDENT should be placed in a full inclusion program with a 1:1 aide or in a nonpublic school similar to Allaire.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
Petitioner's Witnesses
MOTHER
MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified that STUDENT has weak communication skills, is shy, and finds it hard to warm up to others. Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT needs a 1:1 aide at White Hill to help her with the "radical" transition from Allaire. Ms. PARENT described Allaire as a very nurturing, quiet environment with a lot of 1:1 attention. Ms. PARENT suggested that a 1:1 aide would allow for regular monitoring of STUDENT to ensure that she is getting the concepts that are being taught. Ms. PARENT tesetified that she is concerned about STUDENT's ability to do some of the things she has learned at Allaire in a larger classroom. Ms. PARENT cited as an example, the fact that STUDENT has learned to outline and edit at Allaire.
FATHER
FATHER, STUDENT's father, testified that STUDENT has a hard time taking in information and that she tends to withdraw due to her difficulties. Mr. PARENT also testified that STUDENT is hesitant to do new things because she does not trust her ability to get the information she needs to accomplish the new activity. It is only after many repetitions that STUDENT becomes familiar and comfortable with an activity.
Mr. PARENT testified that STUDENT has been successful at Allaire but that they decided to return her to White Hill for educational and social balance. Mr. PARENT testified, however, that without a 1:1 aide, STUDENT would probably not understand what is expected of her. An aide would be able to keep track of what STUDENT is doing, what she is missing, and to make sure she stays on track. Mr. PARENT indicated that he does not believe that STUDENT needs a 1:1 aide during the entire school day, but that she does need a 1:1 aide during the academic classes.
Kay Runyan
Kay Runyan is an educational consultant in private practice. Dr. Runyan reviewed STUDENT's records, administered a portion of the Woodcock-Johnson Achievement Test, and discussed school with STUDENT. Dr. Runyan has never visited any of the programs offered by the District. Dr. Runyan testified that White Hill would not provide the level of support STUDENT needs without a 1:1 aide in her academic classes because of STUDENT's problems interacting with others. Dr. Runyan testified that a 1:1 aide could help STUDENT learn to accurately read social situations. According to Dr. Runyan, STUDENT's problems with socialization can impact her academics by distracting her from the academic work.
Dr. Runyan testified that STUDENT has weaknesses in receptive and expressive language, abstract reasoning, and her ability to conceptually understand information provided by teachers. Having a 1:1 aide would help STUDENT "understand the big picture." Dr. Runyan testified that it would be appropriate for STUDENT to have a 1:1 aide who is a special education instructional assistant and who is there with her every day for each class. On the other hand, she stated that STUDENT may not need a 1:1 aide if she is in a resource specialist class with a ratio of six students per teacher or lower and the work is individualized.
Virginia Reiss
Virginia Reiss is an educational psychologist in private practice. She first met STUDENT in March 1997 and noted that, at that time, her strengths were athletics and her ability to socialize with other children, given the proper parameters. Ms. Reiss testified that as STUDENT gets older and moves closer to high school, she will need more exposure to same age peers to pratice the social skills required to "survive" on a high school campus. Ms. Reiss testified that STUDENT could do well in a regular education class with a modified curriculum and the support of an aide or teacher. Ms. Reiss testified that STUDENT needs the "experience of being in a classroom where the level of discussion will stretch her." In Ms. Reiss' opinion, a special day class would be too isolating for STUDENT and a resource specialist class would be inappropriate because the curriculum in such a class is individualized for each student and the students are not all "on the same page."
Marian Diamond
Marian Diamond is a clinical psychologist and neuropsychologist in private practice. Dr. Diamond met and evaluated STUDENT the day prior to this hearing. Her evaluation consisted of some neuropsychological screening tests administered to STUDENT, and the Gillam Autistic Rating Scale and the Childhood Autism Rating Scale, completed by STUDENT's father. Dr. Diamond testified that the results from the two scales completed by Mr. PARENT suggested the possibility that STUDENT has borderline autism (Gillam) or mild autism (CARS). Dr. Diamond testified, based on those results and her own interaction with STUDENT, that STUDENT has a disorder in the autism spectrum, most probably a mild case of Asperger's Syndrome.
According to Dr. Diamond, the diagnosis of Asperger's should "drive a portion of her educational program." For example, Dr. Diamond testified that STUDENT has delays in her social interaction skills and difficulties with new or novel situations. She does not have the ability to bring past learning to a new situation and does not generalize skills. Therefore, if STUDENT were taught social skills in a group therapy program, it would not work. Dr. Diamond testified that STUDENT would need to learn social skills in her natural environment. Dr. Diamond also testified that regardless of what placement STUDENT is in, she will need a 1:1 aide.
Dr. Diamond testified that STUDENT should be in a regular education environment, with a variety of peers, and with an aide assigned to her. Dr. Diamond testified that STUDENT would need "somebody monitoring her constantly during a regular education class." Dr. Diamond also indicated that even if STUDENT were in a special day class she would still need a 1:1 aide assisting her with comprehension, changing subjects, transitions, and social interactions in the classroom.
District Witnesses
Rosemary LePage
Rosemary LePage is a program manager for the District who has been involved in this matter since September 1997. Ms. LePage testified that a special day class would be the most appropriate placement for STUDENT because of her multiple disabilities and academic weaknesses. Ms. LePage testified that the resource specialist program is typically for students who are 1-2 grades below grade level in their main areas of need. Ms. LePage stated that, based on the District's assessment and Ms. Reiss' assessment, the eighth grade curriculum would have to be modified in all areas for STUDENT. Ms. LePage testified that the special day class at White Hill would provide STUDENT the opportunity to work on a curriculum that parallels the curriculum used by her peers. The special day class would also provide her with opportunities to participate in the regular education program and in school activities. According to Ms. LePage, the special day class at White Hill has 14 students, all of whom are mainstreamed for a portion of the day.
Regarding the inclusion plan proposed by the District, Ms. LePage testified that the remedial class is a regular education class designed for students who are 2-3 years below grade level. Ms. LePage testified that STUDENT would not need a 1:1 aide in the remedial class because it is taught by a resource specialist and is limited to 18-20 students. The teacher would also be working with STUDENT during two other periods each day under the proposed program. Ms. LePage testified that the District selected English to be a mainstreamed class for STUDENT because English is an "experiental" course. There is a lot of small-group work, research work, and reading. Ms. LePage testified that a 1:1 aide would be important for STUDENT in this class because of all the different activities. Ms. LePage testified that the District selected a resource specialist history class rather than a regular education history class because a regular education history class "would overwhelm her." According to Ms. LePage, regular education history has a lot of homework and projects, both of which could be limited in a resource specialist history class. Finally, Ms. LePage testified that the District offered an additional resource specialist class to provide STUDENT assistance on homework, study skills, and organization skills. Ms. LePage testified that STUDENT could be successful in this type of program.
The District also offered counseling and social skills services for STUDENT. Ms. LePage testified that the Ventures group would specifically address "issues of miscues, misunderstandings, and miscommunications." STUDENT would develop some tools to ensure that she is understanding things appropriately. Ms. LePage also indicated that the speech and language therapist would work on social skills and communication.
Ms. LePage described the "push-in" aide as a special education instructional assistant who would go to class with STUDENT and be there for the entire period to help STUDENT stay on track. The aide would also work with the other teachers and explain homework assignments to STUDENT. Ms. LePage testified that the "push-in" aide would be the same person for all of STUDENT's classes, except for when the resource specialist who serves as STUDENT's case manager served as the aide to monitor STUDENT's progress.
Carolyn Taormina
Carolyn Taormina is the school psychologist who evaluated STUDENT in February 1998. Ms. Taormina testified that STUDENT was anxious about and resistant to testing. Ms. Taormina testified that the evaluation took two sessions and that STUDENT did not establish rapport with her until they played basketball at the end of the first session. Once they started playing basketball, STUDENT "started making eye contact and relaxed more." Ms. Taormina testified that STUDENT was more comfortable and had a better attitude during the second session.
Ms. Taormina testified that she agrees with the recommendations in Ms. Reiss' report that STUDENT would benefit from a small, structured environment, that she needs development of social skills, and needs to learn to cope in new situations. Ms. Taormina testified, based on her own assessment and Ms. Reiss' assessment, that it would not be appropriate for STUDENT to be placed in a program which consists entirely of regular education classes, even with an instructional aide in all of the classes. Ms. Taormina testified that she sees STUDENT as being similar to other students in the special day class program at White Hill. Ms. Taormina testified that a special day class with maximum mainstreaming would meet STUDENT's needs because of her many learning needs in academics, social skills, and language.
Ms. Taormina testified that the inclusion program proposed by the District would also be appropriate because it provides the level of support STUDENT would need to be successful and also provides collaboration with the resource specialist program. Ms. Taormina testified that adding more regular education classes would be overwhelming for STUDENT and specifically pointed to eighth grade history as a class that is too "complex at a high language level during discussions" for
STUDENT.
Barbara Gaman
Barbara Gaman is the special day class teacher at White Hill. The program currently has 14 students and a full-time instructional aide who has worked with the class for the past five years. The students are primarily learning disabled, although some students are multiple handicapped. All of the students have a regular education grade level homeroom class and are mainstreamed for physical education and elective. The curriculum is a "parallel curriculum," which means all of the subjects are taught in the regular education curriculum on a modified basis to meet the needs of each of Ms. Gaman's students. The curriculum also includes other elements of adolescent development including social skills and daily living skills, which may not be taught in the regular education curriculum.
Ms. Gaman testified that first period is the only period when all 14 students are in the special day class at the same time. This period is designed to help the students get focussed and ready for the day. During second period, she works on math and reading; third period, language; fourth period, individual work with a small group of students; fifth period, math and, occasionally, social studies; sixth period, direct remedial instruction, auditory and visual practice, and language activities.
Gail Benvenuta
Gail Benvenuta is the resource specialist for sixth grade at White Hill who tested STUDENT in June 1997 and again in February 1998. Ms. Benvenuta testified that STUDENT was very fidgety during the first session in June 1997; she yelled some, laughed in "strange and inappropriate ways," and fell off her chair. Ms. Benvenuta also noted that STUDENT did not make a lot of eye contact. However, by the second evaluation in February 1998, STUDENT was calm, more open to testing, and engaged in some verbal exchange. Ms. Benvenuta testified that she was impressed by the difference in STUDENT's behavior. She was not as fidgety, maintained more eye contact, and provided more appropriate responses. Ms. Benvenuta testified that as of February 1998, STUDENT looked like "one of the kids I would be working with."
DISCUSSION
(1) Has Ross Valley School District proposed an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year?
In 1992, the Ninth Circuit held that procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP process "clearly result in the denial of FAPE." W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range, 18 IDELR 1019 (9th Cir. 1992). Among the procedural violations which the Ninth Circuit has held constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with IDEA's procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith, 20 IDELR 987 (9th Cir. 1994). The Smith Court stated that the "IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child." Smith, 20 IDELR 987,990. The requirement of a written offer serves several purposes, including creating "a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later" and "will greatly assist parents in µpresent[ing] complaints with respect to any matter relating to the ... educational placement of the child." Id.
In the present case, the District's offer included a placement in the special day class at White Hill School. The offer states: "the District continues to make available the Special Day Class program. The SDC program at White Hill School allows students to participate in mainstream classes and all school activities, with push-in support as appropriate." There is no other written documentation regarding the SDC placement proposed by the District. Considering that STUDENT's parents were most concerned with STUDENT's interaction with regular education peers and the amount of mainstreaming she would have, the total lack of any description of what that component of the SDC program would be like for STUDENT constitutes a failure on the part of the District to comply with the brightline procedural requirement adopted by the Smith Court. In many respects, it is impossible for the Hearing Officer to analyze the appropriateness of the SDC "placement" proposed by the District because there is no description of the proposal either in the District's offer or in the other evidence submitted in this hearing. Therefore, this decision will not address the appropriateness of the SDC placement as offered by the District.
The District's "modified inclusion" proposal is almost identical to the full inclusion request made by Petitioner. The only issues Petitioner raises in her closing argument relate to the resource specialist history class, whether the "push-in" support meets STUDENT's needs, and the type of speech and language services to be provided.
History Class
In a provision referred to as the "least restrictive environment", the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) requires that to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities ... are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5).
Section 1412(a)(5) states a clear preference for eligible children to be educated in a regular education environment as a first resort and, as a last resort, for such children to be removed to more restrictive placements. The District has proposed that STUDENT participate in a program that is almost entirely regular education, with the exception of her history class. The District has provided no rational basis for the reason STUDENT's entire academic program should consist of regular education courses, with the exception of the history class. (Footnote 1) Several witnesses testified that adding another regular education academic course would overwhelm STUDENT and that the level of language in a history class is beyond STUDENT's level. This explanation makes no sense considering that the District believes STUDENT could benefit from a regular education English class with the support of a "push-in"aide. It is difficult to imagine that the level of language in English is any lower than the level of of language in History. Given the mandate of the IDEA that eligible children be educated with their nondisabled peers to the maximum extent possible and the fact that the District has provided no compelling reason for STUDENT to need a resource specialist history class, the Hearing Officer finds that the least restrictive environment for STUDENT is a full inclusion program, with all of her academic courses in regular education with the support of a 1:1 aide.
Push-in Support
There is no dispute that, if STUDENT participates in a full inclusion program, she needs an aide to assist her in her regular education academic courses. Petitioner contends that STUDENT requires a 1:1 aide in all academic courses and that the aide should be the same individual in each class. The testimony of the witnesses called by the District establishes that the "push-in" aide will be a special educational instructional assistant and that it will be the same person in all periods every day with the exception of the time during which the resource specialist monitors STUDENT's progress. There is nothing in the record that raises a question of the appropriateness of the "push-in" aide as described by District witnesses. The Hearing Officer finds, based on the overwhelming weight of the testimony of the witnesses, that STUDENT needs a 1:1 aide in each of her academic courses. This includes the remedial math class because, although the teacher of that class believes STUDENT can benefit from the class without an aide, the size of the class (18-20 students) suggests that at least initially STUDENT should have the support of a "push-in" aide. The Hearing Officer further finds that the "push-in" aide proposed by the District is appropriate, so long as the aide is a special education instructional aide and is the same person in each class in which STUDENT needs an aide.
Speech and Language
The District's offer states that "STUDENT will receive speech and language services of 60 minutes per week. The Speech Pathologist will collaborate with STUDENT's teachers to assist them with strategies to enhance and increase speech and language skills." In her closing argument, Petitioner states:
The District's offer of speech and language services for STUDENT does not meet her particular needs. For whatever reason, the District's proposal contemplates providing speech and language services "in the classroom." Apparently the sixty minutes of speech and language service being offered per week, could consist of some one/one time with the speech therapist, some time spent with a small group of students and the speech therapist, and some time during which the speech therapist would, somehoe, provide services to either one or more students in the regular classroom while the rest of the class is receiving instruction in English or History, etc.
Petitioner proposes in her closing brief that STUDENT continue receiving speech and language services from the private therapist from whom she is already receiving services.
The Hearing Officer notes that Petitioner's statement of issues submitted prior to the hearing make no mention of speech and language services as an issue for hearing. Furthermore, at the outset of the hearing during a discussion regarding the issues, Petitioner's counsel made no reference to speech and language services as an issue. The Hearing Officer, after carefully scouring the record of the hearing, found almost no mention of speech and language services in the testimony. The only mention of speech and language services was by Ms. Benvenuta who stated, in general terms, how speech and language services are provided at White Hill.
Under the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner failed to provide adequate notice that speech and language services would be an issue for this hearing. The District had no opportunity to present evidence regarding the speech and language services it would offer to STUDENT because the District had no notice that those services were at issue. The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner neither appropriately raised nore proved her contentions relating to speech and language services. The Hearing Officer, therefore, must deny Petitioner's request for speech and language services other than those proposed by the District.
The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT will be transferring from a very small nonpublic school to a regular education middle school campus. Such a transition will most likely be difficult for STUDENT, even with the support of the resource specialist program and a "push-in" aide in each of her academic courses. Therefore, the District shall convene an IEP meeting within sixty days of receipt of this decision to review STUDENT's progress and make any necessary modifications to her program.
(2) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for certain costs relating to services provided by Kay Runyon, Virginia Reiss, and Marian Diamond?
Education Code § 56329(b) provides that parents have the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment, when the parents disagree with an assessment completed by an educational agency. However, the educational agency has the right to establish at a due process hearing that its own assessment was appropriate. If the educational agency's assessment is found to have been appropriate, the parent has a right to an independent assessment, but not at public expense.
In Petitioner's closing argument, she states that "the expenses the PARENTs have incurred for assessment and evaluations in order to present their case at this hearing should be reimbursed fully." The expenses requested by Petitioner, include expenses incurred from Dr. Diamond, Dr. Runyon, and Ms. Reiss. Ignoring for the moment the issue of whether the District's assessments were appropriate, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for any evaluations performed by Dr. Diamond or by Dr. Runyon since there is no documentary evidence in the record regarding their assessments. Oral testimony does not, in and of itself, constitute an assessment. Without documentary evidence it is impossible to determine whether Dr. Diamond or Dr. Runyon completed assessments to which Petitioner may be entitled to reimbursement. It is also troubling that Petitioner believes she is entitled to reimbursement for these expenses because they were incurred by Petitioner "in order to present" her case. Based on § 56329, Petitioner is only entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments upon a showing that the District's assessments were inappropriate. There is no right to reimbursement simply because the independent assessments were conducted in preparation for hearing.
Regarding Ms. Reiss's evaluation, the Hearing Officer notes that the only assessment completed by Ms. Reiss that is in the record was completed on March 13, 1997, at a time when there was no dispute between the parties. The District did not complete its assessment of STUDENT until one year after Ms. Reiss performed her assessment, and the results of the District's assessment are entirely consistent with the results from Ms. Reiss's assessment. There is no information in the record that suggests that there was an assessment performed by the District as of March 13, 1997, which STUDENT's parents could have disagreed with thereby entitling them to reimbursement for Ms. Reiss's evaluation. Furthermore, Petitioner has failed to contend that the District should have assessed STUDENT any earlier than it did. Interestingly, all three assessors, Ms. Reiss, Ms. Benvenuta, and Ms. Taormina, had the same recommendation for STUDENT -- a small, structured environment. Under these circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to establish any right to reimbursement for an assessment that was completed a year before the District's own assessment.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for any of the assessments identified in Petitioner's closing argument.
ORDER
(1) Within 15 days of receipt of this decision, the Ross Valley School District shall convene an IEP meeting to conform STUDENT's IEP to the terms of this decision. Specifically, the program in STUDENT's IEP shall comply with the proposal of the District dated May 21, 1998, with the exception that STUDENT shall be enrolled in a regular education history class with the support of a "push-in" aide, and STUDENT will also have the support of a "push-in" aide in the remedial math class. Furthermore, the IEP shall state that the aide will be a special educational instructional aide and will be the same individual for all academic classes.
(2) To ensure that the inclusion program is meeting STUDENT's needs, the IEP team shall reconvene no later than 60 days after the first day of the 1998-99 school year to review her progress and make any necessary adjustments to her program.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Issue #1: Petitioner prevailed.
Issue #2: Respondent prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: July 2, 1998 ____________________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes 1. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT would also be in a resource specialist class for study and organizational skills. However, there appeared to be no dispute regarding the appropriateness of this course and this class does not appear to be a part of STUDENT's "academic" program.
