California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 11, 2001
Student v. San Diego Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 506-01 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy
San Diego Unified must reimburse private CCHAT preschool costs after cutting a hearing-impaired preschooler's special day class to four days.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a preschool boy with a significant hearing loss filed for a hearing against San Diego Unified School District. His last agreed IEP placed him in an auditory-oral preschool special day class at Lafayette Elementary five days a week, three hours a day. In August 2000 the District cut the class to four days for all students. At fall 2000 IEP meetings it offered the four-day class plus several add-ons: an afternoon model preschool that used signing, two hours a week of itinerant services from a deaf and hard of hearing teacher, state preschool or Head Start options, and three hours a week in a preschool language group. The parents moved him full time to the CCHAT Center, a certified nonpublic agency.
Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy found that the four-day class did not meet the boy's language needs. District witnesses admitted he had not met his goals even with five days and needed daily repetition. None of the add-ons filled the gap. The afternoon preschool used signing, was not a special day class, and was taught by a new teacher on an emergency credential. The language group was supported only by a hearsay memo that no witness backed up. The District also failed to provide transportation to a fifth day of speech therapy. Claims about the FM system and audiology failed, and the procedural claims were not decided. The District must reimburse CCHAT and transportation costs for 2000-2001.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO weighed a districtwide cut in instructional days against one child's IEP. District witnesses' own testimony about the need for daily language instruction undercut their claim that four days was enough. The decision also shows that an uncorroborated hearsay memo could not support a finding, and that a private placement was not inappropriate just because it was not the least restrictive environment.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1A. Did the District fail to offer Student a FAPE designed to meet his unique needs for the 2000-2001 school year? A. Placement
Cutting the auditory-oral preschool special day class from five days to four did not meet Student's language needs. None of the offered add-ons fixed this: the total-communication afternoon model preschool, the deaf and hard of hearing itinerant services, the state preschool and Head Start options, and the preschool language group (which was supported only by uncorroborated hearsay).
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1B (transportation). Related services: transportation to the fifth (Friday) day of speech and language therapy
Student needed speech-language therapy five days a week, and Friday sessions were held when no school was in session, so the District's failure to provide transportation to the Friday session was a failure to provide a related service.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1B (assistive technology). Related services: timely provision of the Phonak Microlink FM system
The District obtained a loaner unit from the manufacturer, tested it, and provided it promptly, so the assistive technology was provided in a timely manner.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1B (audiology). Related services: adequacy of audiology services
Two licensed audiologists were available at Lafayette at all times, and this testimony was not contradicted, so the audiology services were adequate.
- Not reachedIEP procedure
Issue 2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE in the fall of 2000 by violating the procedural safeguards set forth in State and federal law?
The Hearing Officer did not decide the procedural claims (including the unilateral cut to four days without an IEP meeting) because a denial of FAPE was already found on Issue 1, and held that neither party prevailed.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. If the District failed to offer Student special education services to meet his unique needs for the 2000-2001 school year, are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the private services they secured for him?
CCHAT, a certified nonpublic agency running a qualified auditory-oral special day class, addressed Student's IEP needs and he made progress there. The fact that it was not the least restrictive environment did not make it inappropriate, so reimbursement was ordered.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof, the District must reimburse the parents for expenses they incurred for services at CCHAT during the 2000-2001 school year, plus any recoverable costs of transporting Student to and from school. No dollar amount was stated.
Key authorities
School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985); Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986); 20 U.S.C. §1401; 20 U.S.C. §1414(d); Cal. Ed. Code §56031; Cal. Ed. Code §56345; 5 C.C.R. §3082(b)
People named in the decision
- Dr. Jim Johnson, special education advocate for Student
- Ricardo Soto, attorney for District, San Diego Unified School District
- Bernice Stanley, program manager for due process hearings and mediations, San Diego Unified School District
- Laura Lee, preschool special day class teacher (1999-2000), deaf and hard of hearing; District witness, San Diego Unified School District, Lafayette Elementary School
- Maggie Keyser, preschool special day class teacher for deaf and hard of hearing students (2000-2001), San Diego Unified School District, Lafayette Elementary School
- Donna Morris, speech-language pathologist; District witness, San Diego Unified School District
- Ms. MacNeil, program manager for low incidence disabilities, San Diego Unified School District
- Kate Curly, afternoon model preschool teacher (emergency credential), San Diego Unified School District, Lindbergh-Schweitzer Elementary School
- Linda Schroeder, supervising audiologist, San Diego Unified School District
- Ms. Fischer, District staff member (author of an internal memo on state preschools), San Diego Unified School District
- Betsy Smith, deaf and hard of hearing itinerant service provider, San Diego Unified School District
- Ms. Aaberg, special day class teacher at private placement, CCHAT Center
- CCHAT Center, nonpublic agency; private placement
- John Tracy Clinic, private clinic; summer program and assessments, University of Southern California
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on May 31, June 1, and July 24, 25, 26, and 27, 2001, in San Diego, California.
Student (hereinafter “Student” or “Petitioner”) was represented by special education advocate Dr. Jim Johnson. Also present on his behalf were his parents. San Diego Unified School District (hereinafter “District” or “Respondent”) was represented by attorney Ricardo Soto. Bernice Stanley, the District’s program manager for due process hearings and mediations, was also present on behalf of the District.
The Hearing Officer received oral and documentary evidence during the course of the proceedings. The parties submitted written closing arguments for the case and legal briefs on the issue of alleged procedural violations. The briefs, postmarked August 10, 2001, were received by the Hearing Officer on August 15, and the record was closed.
ISSUES(Footnote 1)
1. Did the District fail to offer Student a free and appropriate education (FAPE) designed to meet his unique needs for the 2000-2001 school year?
2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE in the fall of 2000 by violating the procedural safeguards set forth in State and federal law?
3. If the District failed to offer Student special education services to meet his unique needs for the 2000-2001 school year, are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the private services they secured for him?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Student was born on [date redacted], was five years and six months old at the time the hearing concluded. He presently lives with his parents and two sisters in San Diego, California, and attends school at CCHAT Center. Student has been significantly hearing impaired since birth. He is diagnosed with asymmetrical binaural sensory neural hearing loss. In his right ear, Student’s hearing loss is estimated from normal to mildly impaired at low tones, and from moderately severe to severely impaired at higher frequencies. His hearing loss in his left ear is considered moderately severe to severely impaired. Student was originally diagnosed with a hearing loss by his pediatrician in June 1998, at age two years and four months. He is presently fitted with digital hearing aids, which he began wearing in March of 1999 at the age of three years and two months.
After Student’s initial diagnosis, his parents contacted the San Diego Unified School District, and an Individual Family Service Plan (IFSP) was prepared for him. In August 1998 he was enrolled for the 1998-1999 school year in the infant program, a communication class for hearing-impaired children in his age group at the District’s Lafayette Elementary School. Signing was the mode of communication in the class, and both Student and his parents learned to sign. Student’s mode of communication at home and school that year–to the extent his communication skills had developed–was predominately signing. He did acquire some oral language skills during that time, which mostly consisted of two- or three-word utterances beginning with “I want.” However, he responded more quickly when signing was used as a mode of communication.
For the 1999-2000 school year, Student was placed in the morning auditory-oral preschool special day class at Lafayette Elementary School. Ms. Laura Lee was assigned as his teacher that year. There were five other children of similar age and with similar hearing impairments in his class. The sole mode of communication in the special day class was auditory-oral.(Footnote 2) During the school year, Student was assessed by the District in the area of speech and language, and an assessment report was issued on January 23, 2000. The report indicated that Student was assigned to an auditory-oral preschool and that the focus of his placement was to assist him in acquiring skills in oral-spoken language, receptive and expressive vocabulary, speech reading, speech, and auditory training. The assessment included informal observation of Student and formal assessment tests in vocabulary, grammar, listening skills, and articulation-speech skills.(Footnote 3) The assessment results indicated that Student was age-appropriate in language skills as compared to other hearing-impaired children, and that he was delayed in speech and language skills when compared to hearing children. Additionally, the assessment report noted that he had begun to use longer sentences to express himself–an average of three words per sentence. The report also observed that Student continued to demonstrate the ability to acquire information auditorially and that his listening skills were age-appropriate and comprised an area of strength for him.
The report did indicate, however, that speech and articulation skills continued to be an area of weakness for Student. Although the report indicated that Student appeared to be producing longer sentences, a concern was raised that his spontaneous speech and his intelligibility continued to be reduced. The assessment report noted that it was difficult to determine exactly what language structures Student used. Finally, the report stated that Student continued to qualify for intensive speech and language services and recommended that he remain in his then-current class placement. The report also made the following recommendations:
1. Continue receptive and expressive vocabulary development.
2. Introduce new language structures and concepts which are developmentally appropriate (not age appropriate). The concepts should be introduced within the context of a sentence, not through the vocabulary word alone. 3. Continue to provide intensive speech/language therapy daily. 4. Expect production of intelligible speech, when provided with a model, and encourage carry-over into various situations. 5. Encourage use of language in all situations (requesting items, sharing information, etc.).
On January 26, 2000, an IEP was prepared for Student, which his mother approved. To address his deficiencies, the IEP team prepared annual IEP goals for Student that included increased vocabulary, increased length and complexities of utterances and spontaneous expressive language, increased receptive understanding of complex spoken messages, the ability to describe objects using basic prepositions, and increased intelligibility. The IEP and its annual goals were scheduled to be reviewed in January 2001. To assist Student in attaining his goals, the IEP called for him to remain in his preschool special day class five days per week for three hours each day. In addition, the IEP indicated that Student was to receive 20 minutes of speech and language therapy five times per week and a minimum of one hour of audiology services each year.
Following the 1999-2000 school year, and prior to the conclusion of the subsequent extended school year, Student’s parents enrolled him in a three-week program at the John Tracy Clinic at the University of Southern California. Student’s parents also took part in the program, which emphasized parental involvement. At John Tracy, Student received a number of additional language assessments in the areas of language, speech, and audition. On August 11, 2000, the Tracy Clinic issued a report, which observed that Student was able to orally produce a number of speech sounds and possessed various discrimination skills using audition alone. The report concluded that Student’s goals should be “presented in a manner using audition alone.” (Emphasis in original) The Tracy report further observed that Student had full access to all sounds in the speech range. It also emphasized that it was important for Student to have full access to all sounds in his speech range and for him to use his auditory capabilities throughout the day in school and at home.
On August 16, 2000, at the conclusion of Student’s program at the Tracy Clinic, the Student’s parents sent a letter to the District requesting an IEP team meeting, which the District set for September 11, 2000. Thereafter, on August 21, 2000, the Student’s parents received a letter from the District stating that the preschool special day class at Lafayette was being reduced from five to four days a week. On August 23, 2000, the Student’s parents received a phone call from Maggie Keyser, the District’s special day class teacher for deaf and hard of hearing students at Lafayette Elementary School, who also informed them of the reduction in service.(Footnote 4) Additionally, the District informed the Student’s parents that Student’s speech and language therapy services would be reduced from five to four days. A flier from the school noted that a fifth day of speech and language services would be made available on Fridays by appointment, but that parents would have to provide their own transportation. The reductions in the special day class and the speech and language services were made across the board for all of the students at Lafayette Elementary School. The reductions were accompanied by the planned addition of an afternoon preschool program that included deaf, hearing impaired, and hearing children. This class was to be located at the District’s Lindbergh-Schweitzer Elementary School and was scheduled to meet four days per week between 11:30 a.m. and 3:00 p.m.
On September 5, 2000, Student began attending Maggie Keyser’s morning preschool special day class four days a week for three hours a day at Lafayette Elementary School. He also received 20 minutes of speech and language services four days each week. On September 11, 2000, an IEP meeting was held. The District did not make a formal written offer at that time. The District’s meeting notes indicated that a number of issues were discussed, including amplification, the Tracy assessments, Student’s goals and objectives, placement, and the Student’s parents’ concern that Student’s educational program allow him to “catch up.” Another IEP team meeting was set for September 25, 2000.
The September 25, 2000 IEP document observed that Student did not “relate events,” that he “consistently used three-word phrases beginning with “I want” or “look at,” that he was “inconsistent in his production of final consonants and in the production of “sh,” “ch,” and “z” sounds,” that he differentiated vowels only “50% of the time,” and that he did not “differentiate consonants at all.” The IEP team set forth several language-based goals and objectives to address Student’s deficiencies and allow him to progress in his educational program. His goals and objectives anticipated that he would increase his use of cognitive language, improve his use of complex language structures, increase his receptive understanding of complex spoken messages, increase his core noun and verb vocabulary, increase his intelligibility through the production of final consonants, and increase his auditory perceptual skills. While the team members agreed to the goals and objectives, the Student’s parents did not agree to the specific program proposed by the District.
The District noted in the Special Factors section of the IEP document that Student required a specialized communication strategy in the form of auditory-oral instruction. Similar to Student’s January 2000 IEP, the proposed September 25, 2000 IEP also noted that Student’s opportunity for direct instruction and communication with peers and adults in his mode of communication was a placement in an auditory-oral special day class. According to the proposed IEP, the class would include specialized instruction provided by a teacher specially trained to teach deaf and hard of hearing students and would provide Student with an opportunity for peer interaction. At that IEP team meeting, the District offered Student continued placement in Ms. Keyser’s morning preschool special day class four days each week for three hours per day.(Footnote 5) The District also offered Student 30 minutes of speech and language therapy five times each week and a minimum of one session per year of audiology services.(Footnote 6) The District’s IEP meeting notes state that Ms. MacNeil would investigate other preschool programs within the District and that the afternoon model preschool program was one option. The Student’s parents, who were present at the IEP meeting, did not approve or sign the document. On October 2, 2000, the Student’s parents sent the District a letter notifying them that they were placing Student in the CCHAT program on Fridays to make up for the lost day in the District’s morning special day class.
On October 30, 2000, another IEP team meeting was held. At this meeting the District again offered Student placement in the morning special day class at Lafayette for four days a week for three hours each session. It also offered him the speech and language services five times a week for 30 minutes per session and a minimum of one time per year with the audiologist. The face of the IEP document also referenced designated instructional services to include “DHH itinerant” services two hours a week at home or at the neighborhood school. Reference to the afternoon model preschool program did not appear on the face of this IEP. The District’s IEP team notes indicated that the Student’s parents wanted the fifth day of preschool instruction made up and, to that end, requested that the District agree to have Student attend the CCHAT program on Fridays. The notes also stated that Ms. MacNeil shared with the Student’s parents other preschool options the District had to offer. Four other programs were referenced in the notes: State preschools at Chavez and Balboa schools, a Head Start program behind Logan School, and a preschool language group (PLG) located at Lindbergh-Schweitzer School. The October 30 IEP notes mentioned that there were two PLG groups, each meeting twice a week for one hour. The notes indicated that the group was taught by a speech pathologist and that Student could attend up to three hours each week. Additionally, the IEP notes indicated that Ms. MacNeil said “she would still be willing to provide a DHH itinerant to see Student at either the head start or state preschool program should the parent choose this option [DHH itinerant].” On November 14, 2000, the Student’s parents sent the District a letter indicating that they intended to enroll Student full time in the CCHAT program on November 28, 2000. In their letter, the Student’s parents commented that no details on the alternative preschools, such as class size and curriculum, had been provided to them. They also noted in their letter that they had agreed to investigate the proposed alternatives if the District would provide the times for such visits, but, their letter alleges, the District failed to provide those observations times in the two weeks since their original request.
On November 20, 2000, Ms. MacNeil, on behalf of the District, sent the Student’s parents a letter responding to their November 14 letter. In her letter, Ms. MacNeil stated that the San Diego Unified Schol District was prepared to offer Student the morning special day class at Lafayette, the speech and language services, and the audiology services. The levels of services were the same as those specified at the September 25 and October 30 IEP meetings. The letter also offered the two hours of itinerant services for the deaf and hard of hearing that was referenced in the October 30 IEP meeting. Additionally, Ms. MacNeil’s letter specified the three hours per week at the PLG at Lindbergh-Schweitzer that was described in the IEP team meeting notes on October 30. On November 28, 2000, Student began attending the CCHAT program full time. On March 14, 2001, the Student’s parents filed a request with the Hearing Office for a due process hearing.
POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES
Student contends that the District did not offer him placement and designated instructional services to meet his unique needs for the 2000-2001 school year. Furthermore, he alleges that the District committed procedural violations of such magnitude that it denied him a FAPE. Specifically, Student takes the position that his unique needs require that his program include the following components: placement in a special day class five days a week for a minimum of three hours each day, exclusive use of auditory-oral modes of communication, a teaching methodology utilizing a cognitive-based curriculum, inclusion of parental training and participation, an acoustically quiet classroom, adequate audiological services, speech and language therapy for five days a week for 30 minutes each session, and an appropriate amplification system. From Student’s point of view, the District’s offered placement and designated instructional services did not provide him with any of these components.
Additionally, Student argues that the District denied him FAPE when it unilaterally reduced his preschool special day class from five to four days without prior parental approval or an IEP team meeting. He contends that the procedural violation was of a nature and of sufficient severity to deny him a free and appropriate public education.
The District’s position is that it offered Student a program to meet his unique needs. Moreover, it denies committing any procedural violations, and if it did, these violations did not rise to a denial of FAPE. The District insists that reducing Student’s preschool special day class from five to four days did not adversely impact his program and that the four-day program was still sufficient in itself to meet his unique needs. The District also argued that if the four days of special day class were not enough by itself to meet Student’s unique needs, the addition of the afternoon model preschool program would have been. Moreover, the District argues that the speech and language, audiological, and assistive technology services it offered Student were all designed to meet his unique needs.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue Number 1: Did the District fail to offer Student a free and appropriate public education designed to meet his unique needs for the 2000-2001 school year?
A. PLACEMENT
Applicable Law
The federal Individuals With Disabilities Act (IDEA) states that a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) means special education and related services that are provided in conformity with the individualized education program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. §1401(8).) The IDEA also requires that the IEP include a statement of measurable annual goals, including benchmarks and short term objectives, that relate to meeting the child’s needs, which result from the child’s disability. Additionally, the statute specifies that the child’s special education placement must allow the pupil to advance appropriately toward attaining his or her annual goals.(Footnote 7) (20 U.S.C. §1414(d)(1)(A).)
State law echoes the federal IDEA on these points. (Cal. Ed. Code §56345(a).) Furthermore, California law defines special education as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent, to meet the unique needs of individual with exceptional needs, whose educational needs cannot be met with modifications of the regular instructional program, and related services, at no cost to the parent, that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. (Cal. Ed. Code §56031.) The California Code of Regulations states that the IEP must show a direct relationship between present levels of performance, the goals and objectives, and the specific educational services to be provided. (C.C.R. §3040(c).) Moreover, State regulations provide that special educational placement means that unique combinations of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the IEP. (C.C.R. §3042(a).)
Evidentiary Analysis:
The Morning Preschool Special Day Class at Lafayette Elementary School
For the Hearing Officer to determine whether the District offered Student a program designed to meet his unique needs in the fall of 2000, it is necessary to determine what his particular needs were at that time. There was no dispute as to the nature and extent of Student’s hearing impairment. He is virtually deaf in his left ear, and in his right ear, he can hear low tones normally or with a mild impairment. But as frequency increases, hearing in his right steadily decreases to near deaf. In an appropriate acoustical environment and with the help of assistive technology–namely, properly set digital hearing aides–Student can hear spoken language. Because his hearing aides allow him to actually hear sounds, Student can learn to accurately hear spoken words and communicate orally. However, because he was not identified as hearing impaired until age two years and four months and he was not “aided” (fitted with hearing aides) until age three years and two months, he is delayed in language development. Of this fact there is no dispute. There also was no dispute that hearing plays a critical role in the acquisition of language.
There is some dispute as to the extent or degree of Student’s delay in language acquisition and development. Estimates ranged between one year and three years depending on how the various assessments were interpreted. The witnesses agreed that scientifically pinpointing the exact degree of a language delay was not possible. They agreed that the best an expert could do was estimate Student’s delay based on their particular interpretation of the assessments and personal observations. Ms. Donna Morris, the District’s speech and language pathologist, testified that the mean utterance used by a child will “roughly” correspond to his age.(Footnote 8) Ms. Lee, Student’s special day class teacher for the 1999-2000 school year, recalled that Student typically used 2-3 word utterances at the time of his January 2000 IEP, and 3-4 word phrases by the following summer.
Whether Student’s language delay was one year or three years, all of the experts agreed that a child can only make up so much time in a given school year. Both the Student’s parents and the District agreed that the goal in the fall of 2000 was to mainstream Student in a regular kindergarten class by the fall of 2001 or in a first-grade class in the fall of 2002. All of the experts agreed that in the fall of 2000 Student was language-delayed and that he needed to progress in his language skills in order to be mainstreamed in the future. Thus, for the 2000-2001 school year, Student’s unique needs required that he be placed in a program that allowed him to progress in developing language skills to such a degree that he could be mainstreamed by the fall of 2001 or the fall of 2002.
Student’s January 2000 IEP, which was the last agreed-upon IEP, stated that he needed to develop language, speech, and auditory training skills in an auditory-oral special day class placement on a daily basis. The IEP further stated that he needed a specialized curriculum taught by a teacher for the deaf and hard of hearing in order for him to develop language and speech. At that time he was placed in a language-based special day class five days a week for three hours each day. In the fall of 2000, the District offered to place Student in a similar language-based special day class program four days a week for three hours each day. The District contends that four days in the special day class was sufficient to meet Student’s needs. The Student’s parents, conversely, argue that it was not.
To determine whether the program offered by the District in the fall of 2000 was designed to meet Student’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer will first look to Student’s program and rate of progress during his prior school year. In the 1999-2000 school year, Student was placed in Ms. Lee’s preschool special day class. The class exclusively employed an audio-oral of communication, and Student was assigned to it because that was the mode of communication he was using to acquire language skills. Student’s January 26, 2000 IEP noted that his profound hearing loss had led to delays in speech and language. The IEP document set out six goals for Student to meet with specific bench marks set for July 2000 and January 2001 respectively. To provide Student the means to achieve his goals, the District placed him in Ms. Lee’s preschool special day class five days a week for three hours each day. He was also provided speech and language services for 20 minutes five times a week and audiology services for a minimum of once per year.
Of critical importance to the Hearing Officer was Ms. Lee’s testimony regarding Student’s progress during the year she taught him. Ms. Lee observed that Student progressed the year he was in her class, but not as much as she had hoped. She testified that she had done all that she believed could be done for Student, and that she would not have decreased the level of service that he received that year.(Footnote 9) Student left Ms. Lee’s class in July of 2000 when he was four-and-a-half years old. Each of the speech and language experts called by the parties agreed that a child has a limited window of opportunity to acquire normal language skills. They also agreed that Student was within that window, but that it would begin closing over the next two or three years.
In August of 2000, the approximate midpoint of Student’s January 2000 IEP, the District reduced Student’s preschool special day class by one day, or twenty percent. The District eliminated the Friday session for all special day class students at Lafayette. It contended that notwithstanding the reduction in service, Ms. Keyser’s morning preschool special day class at Lafayette was an appropriate placement to meet Student’s unique needs.(Footnote 10) In support of its contention, two witnesses for the District, Ms. Morris and Ms. Lee, provided broad conclusionary opinions regarding the effects of the reduction in class time on Student’s education, but with only minimal justification. Ms. Morris, the District’s speech and language therapist, testified that she did not believe that a reduction in Student’s special day class from five days to four would adversely affect his program. She explained that four days of class were adequate because Student would be in a position to apply the knowledge that he learned in school at home on Fridays. Ms. Lee stated that she thought four days were sufficient since the Tracy Clinic, where she had previously worked, normally held classes four days a week. However, upon crossexamination, Ms. Lee admitted that she did not realize that the Tracy Clinic had switched to a five-day-per week class schedule. She also admitted that the Tracy Clinic classes were approximately six hours long, compared to the three hours at Lafayette.
In contrast, the specific testimony of these two witnesses did not support their broad conclusory opinions on the issue. Ms. Morris testified that Student needed five days of speech and language therapy for 30 minutes each session. She stated that Student needed the speech and language service daily because children like him require daily repetition in order to develop language skills. Such an opinion is inconsistent with her position that a twenty-percent reduction in Student’s language-based special day class would not adversely affect his program. Ms. Morris did not explain why the daily repetition in speech and language therapy was not also required in Student’s special day class, which included a specialized curriculum designed to teach him language. Ms. Morris also explained how Student learns language in his special day class via a high-scope or thematic curriculum. She articulated that in the preschool special day class various learning centers are set up and organized by topic or theme. In the program, the children learn language via their interaction with peers, teacher aides, and the classroom teacher. Ms. Morris described how the teacher engages the student with cognitive questions or statements that are designed to elicit a response. She added that the children also learn language as a result of adult modeling and intervention. Ms. Morris pointed out that language development is “very intense and involved.” Thus, while Ms. Morris concluded that Student would benefit just as well by spending the fifth day at home applying the skills he learned the other four days, her opinion was not consistent with her more specific description of the teacher-student learning process.(Footnote 11)
Ms. Lee echoed Ms. Morris’s description of the teacher-student learning process. Moreover, she added that a teacher must have specialized education and training to model language, prompt creative or spontaneous speech, and promote the kind of thinking or cognitive skills necessary for a child to develop language. But Ms. Lee, like Ms. Morris, could not explain how Student’s language needs would be unaffected by a twenty-percent reduction in his language-based special day class taught by a highly skilled teacher. Their conclusions simply contradict their own descriptions of the sophisticated teaching processes required to teach language to a child such as Student.
More importantly, however, Student’s placement needs were spelled out in his January 2000 IEP. His IEP called for placement in a language-based (auditory-oral) preschool special day class five days a week for three hours each day. As indicated above, Ms. Lee testified that she would not have decreased services for Student the year that she had him in her class. She added that Student had not progressed as much as she had hoped during the 1999-2000 school year although she had done everything that she could for him. Ms. Morris also testified that as of July 2000, Student was still working on his annual goals, which he had not yet met. Thus, according to District witnesses, Student at best was on or slightly off target to meet his annual goals and objectives at a time he was placed in a special day class five days a week. There is no evidence, however, to suggest that Student would advance toward his goals and objectives or progress in his educational program if those services were reduced by twenty percent. The Hearing Officer concludes that if Student was on target to meet his annual goals with five days of specialized instruction in an audio-oral language-based special day class, he would not remain on target, and in all likelihood would fall further behind, if his program were reduced by twenty percent.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of an auditory-oral language-based preschool special day class four days a week for three hours each day did not meet Student’s unique needs.(Footnote 12)
The Afternoon Model Preschool Program
The District also contends that even if a four-day special day class was insufficient to meet Student’s unique needs, it offered him additional placements and designated instructional service options, which when combined with the four days of special day class, would have met his unique needs. Although it is not entirely clear what the District’s actual offer was, the Hearing Officer will analyze each of the options it presented.
On September 25, 2000, the District offered to supplement Student’s program with the afternoon model preschool class at the Lindbergh-Schweitzer Elementary School. The model preschool met in the afternoon four days a week for four-and-a-half hours each session. The class included 15-17 students–five who utilized signing, six hearing impaired who utilized an audio-oral mode of communication, and four to six children with normal hearing. Ms. Kate Curly was assigned as the teacher. The class was run as a normal preschool, with the primary purpose being socialization amongst the children. The mode of communication in the classroom was signing and oral. The teacher signed as she spoke, and the children responded with either signing or speech.
Ms. Curly received her B.A. degree in Child and Family Development from San Diego State University in May 2000. While in school, she worked at the developmental preschool on campus. The preschool included deaf and hard of hearing students between the ages of 18 months and three years, and it functioned essentially as a special day class. Her duties included assisting the preschool teacher, reading to the children, preparing food, and changing diapers. She was also proficient in sign language. Ms. Curly’s appointment to the afternoon model preschool was her first teaching position after college. At that point in her career, she had not received any additional training or education in teaching deaf and hard of hearing children in Student’s age group. By the fall of 2000, however, she had obtained an emergency credential. Ms. Curly, Ms. MacNeil, and Ms. Morris were of the opinion that Student would benefit from his participation in the afternoon model preschool program. Ms. Curly stated that her class was run as a normal preschool, and that the children appeared to have progressed in language development as a result of their activities in her class. Ms. MacNeil testified that Ms. Curly’s afternoon model preschool class was designed to build social confidence in deaf and hard of hearing students. She noted that the class was designed as a result of general research on the benefits of educating deaf and hard of hearing students in the natural environment. Ms. Morris added that she believed the other deaf and hard of hearing students that she provided speech and language therapy to at Lafayette benefitted from their participation in the afternoon preschool.
The Student’s parents objected to the afternoon model preschool class because they believed that the use of signing as a routine mode of communication would be detrimental to Student’s language development. They also disapproved because they did not believe the class offered Student the critical elements required to meet his unique needs.(Footnote 13) While the Student’s parents argued that the afternoon model preschool was missing critical elements to make it an appropriate placement for Student, the issue for the Hearing Officer to decide is whether the model preschool class in conjunction with the morning special day class at Lafayette met Student’s unique needs and allowed him to progress in his educational program.
Regarding Student’s unique needs; he is significantly hearing impaired, and at the time of the fall 2000 IEP meetings, he was significantly delayed in language development. In January 2000, the IEP team noted that Student needed to develop language, speech, and auditory training skills in an “auditory-oral special day class placement on a daily basis.”(Footnote 14) The IEP further stated that he would not participate in the general education environment because he “needs [a] specialized curriculum taught by [a] DHH teacher in order to develop language and speech.” Both the January 2000 IEP and the September 25, 2001 IEP set forth goals and objectives for Student that involved the development of language, speech, vocabulary, and audition. The Hearing Officer finds that the afternoon model preschool was not an appropriate placement to meet Student’s unique needs for four reasons: It was not an auditory-oral program, it was not a special day class employing a specialized curriculum, it was not taught by a teacher for the deaf and hard of hearing, and it did not include a program designed to allow Student to advance toward his particular goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer will discuss each of these findings in turn.
First, although Student’s IEP called for placement in an auditory-oral special day class, the afternoon model preschool was not an auditory-oral program. Ms. Curly stated that her class utilized a “total communication” mode of language. She explained that total communication meant that the teacher ‘signed’ (communicated in sign language) as she spoke. The children would either respond in an oral or a signing mode according to their desire. Ms. Curly stated that she would communicate in this mode unless there were no deaf children present. However, she could not identify a time or circumstance where she would be instructing her students where deaf children would not be present. Thus, signing alongside speech would be virtually a continuous mode of communication in her afternoon model preschool class. The extensive use of signing in the afternoon model preschool class directly conflicted with Student’s IEP, which calls for an auditory-oral program.
Second, the afternoon model preschool was not a special day class that included a “specialized curriculum” as called for in Student’s IEP. According to Ms. Curly, her class was run as a “regular preschool.” Ms. MacNeil testified that she designed the afternoon model preschool to build social confidence in deaf and hard of hearing students in the natural environment. But Student’s IEP called for a program that would meet his language and not his social needs. The parties agreed that Student had a closing window of opportunity to develop minimal language skills. His IEP was not designed to mainstream him; rather, it was designed to prepare him for mainstreaming. To that end, he required a special day class with a specialized curriculum designed to help him overcome his delays in acquiring language. The afternoon model preschool was not a special day class, and it did not include such a specialized curriculum.
Third, while the evidence indicated that Ms. Curly was an excellent teacher, Student’s IEP specified that he would not participate in the regular education program because he needed a specialized curriculum taught by a teacher for the deaf and hard of hearing. Although Ms. Curly had received an emergency credential to teach deaf and hard of hearing students, she had no specialized education or training to prepare her for the task. Her experience at that point consisted of part-time work as a teacher’s assistance in a preschool for deaf and hard of hearing children between ages 18 months and three years while she was an undergraduate. In Student’s IEP, the District noted that Student needed a specialized program taught by a teacher for the deaf and hard of hearing in order for him to achieve his goals. Ms. Lee, Student’s special day class teacher for the 1999-2000 school year, described in significant detail how a teacher with special skills, training, and experience in educating deaf and hard of hearing students instructed students, modeled language, mediated language between peers, and prompted cognitive thinking, which she described as underlying all language. She pointed out that such teaching methods required extensive training, education, and experience on the part of the teacher. Ms. Lee indicated that these activities were part of the program that she provided to Student in her special day class the previous year, and to the best of her knowledge, the same techniques were also utilized by Ms. Keyser in her special day class for deaf and hard of hearing students. The methods described by Ms. Lee, and echoed by Ms. Morris, Student’s speech pathologist, were specifically calculated to help Student progress in his educational program. At this point in her career, Ms. Curly simply did not have the requisite education, training, and experience to qualify as a “teacher for the deaf and hard of hearing” as set forth in Student’s IEP.
Fourth, Student’s January 2000 and September 25, 2000 IEPs, specified particular auditory and language-based goals and objectives that were designed to meet his needs and allow him to progress in his educational program. Again, Student’s September 25, 2000 IEP specifically indicated that he did not “relate events,” that he “consistently used three-word phrases beginning with “I want” or “look at,” that he was “inconsistent in his production of final consonants and in the production of “sh,” “ch,” and “z” sounds,” that he “differentiates vowels only 50% of the time,” and that he does “not differentiate consonants at all.” His IEP set forth specific language-based goals and objectives that called for him to increase his use of cognitive language, improve his use of complex language structures, increase his receptive understanding of complex spoken messages, increase his core noun and verb vocabulary, increase his intelligibility through the production of final consonants, and increase his auditory perceptual skills. The afternoon special day class was run as a “regular preschool,” and it did not include a curriculum or program designed to provide Student with an opportunity to advance toward meeting his specified language-based goals and objectives.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that in the fall of 2000, Ms. Curly’s afternoon model preschool class did not meet Student’s unique needs
Itinerant Services Option
At the October 30, 2000 IEP team meeting, the District offered to supplement Student’s placement at the morning preschool special day class at Lafayette with two hours of DHH (deaf and hard of hearing) itinerant services. The IEP team meeting notes indicated that the District “would still be willing to provide a DHH itinerant teacher to see Student at either head start or [the] State preschool program should [his] parents choose this option.”(Footnote 15) In her testimony, Ms. MacNeil reiterated that the DHH itinerant services were an option to the parents. In its closing brief, the District noted as a historical point that the itinerant services were offered. The only facts adduced at hearing regarding this program were provided by Ms. Parent on cross- examination. She testified that the itinerant service provider, Betsy Smith, assisted Student at home with his “language lessons.”
In the January 2000 IEP, which was the last agreed-upon IEP, the team determined that Student required placement five days a week in an audio-oral language-based preschool special day class. The Hearing Officer has already found that a twenty-percent reduction in Student’s special day class program did not meet his unique needs as set forth in his IEP. Therefore, the question at this point, is whether the addition of the itinerant services would make up for the lost services in the special day class and provide Student with a program to meet his needs.
Student’s special day class placement provided him with a language-based program and included various components designed to assist him in achieving his educational goals. The class was taught by a teacher with special training and experience in teaching preschool deaf and hard of hearing children with Student’s hearing impairment and language delays. The program of instruction, which utilized an audio-oral mode of communication, was designed to assist Student in attaining his IEP goals and objectives. At school, Student received instruction from his teacher and interacted with other students. His preschool teachers employed various teaching techniques to help him develop cognitive-based language, increase his vocabulary, improve speech intelligibility, improve his skills for understanding and using complex language, and to increase his auditory perceptual skills. These techniques included instruction, modeling language, questioning students regarding events or their activities, prompting spontaneous language, and stimulating critical thinking as a foundation for language development. These components of the program are what made it appropriate for Student’s needs.(Footnote 16) In contrast, according to the evidence at hearing, the itinerant services included having a teacher come to Student’s home and assist him with his “language lessons.” Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the addition of the itinerant service was not comparable to three hours of his special day class program, and it did not meet Student’s unique needs.
State Preschool Options
The October 30, 2000 IEP meeting notes indicated that Ms. MacNeil would investigate two State preschools, one at Chavez Elementary School and another at Balboa Elementary School, in addition to the Webster Head Start program located behind Logan School. No other information was provided regarding these programs. Ms. MacNeil testified at hearing that each of these alternatives was an option that the Student’s parents could have chosen. The District, however, did not actually offer these programs to the Student’s parents other than to indicate they were an option to explore. Moreover, a District internal memo from Ms. Fischer to Ms. MacNeil indicated that the two State preschool programs would not be appropriate for Student. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that these options were not appropriate to meet Student’s unique needs.
The Preschool Language Group (PGL) Option
Additionally, the October 30, 2000 IEP team meeting notes indicated that the District also offered the Student’s parents the option of sending Student to the preschool language group (PLG) that met at the Lindbergh-Schweitzer elementary School. The notes also indicated that the Student’s parents were concerned with whether the other children in the program had sufficient speech skills to benefit Student. On November 20, 2000, Ms. MacNeil sent the Student’s parents a letter offering Student three hours a week in the PLG program. According to Ms. MacNeil, the PLG program was included in the final offer because Ms. Keyser had investigated the program and had determined that it was appropriate to meet Student’s needs. Ms. Keyser memorialized her findings and opinions in a memo to Ms. MacNeil. However, Ms. Keyser did not testify at the hearing, and the parties did not call any witnesses to corroborate her findings and observations.(Footnote 17) Thus the Hearing Officer cannot rely on Ms. Keyser’s memo to Ms. MacNeil to support a finding on this issue, because it is uncorroborated heresay.(Footnote 18)
Assuming arguendo that Ms. Keyser’s memo to Ms. MacNeil is admissible evidence for the purpose of establishing that the PLG program, in conjunction with Student’s four days of special day class at Lafayette, is an appropriate program to meet Student’s needs, it fails on its merits. As discussed in more detail above, Student’s last agreed-upon IEP–January 2000–indicated that he required a specialized program with a teacher of the deaf and hard of hearing to implement the language-based goals and objectives set forth in his IEP. The goals and objectives articulated in his September 25, 2000 IEP were also language-based. Nothing in Ms. Keyser’s memo to Ms. MacNeil indicated that the PLG program was for deaf and hard of hearing students, that it was taught by a teacher with training and experience in teaching deaf and hard of hearing students, and that the program was designed or structured in such a way as to help Student advance toward his IEP goals. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the PLG program offered by the District on November 20, 2000, was not appropriate to meet Student’s unique needs.
B. RELATED SERVICES
Applicable Law:
As noted above, the IDEA states that a FAPE requires that both special education and related services be provided in conformity with the student’s IEP, and the related services and supplementary aids and services provided to the child must advance appropriately toward attaining his or her annual goals. (20 U.S.C. §1401(8).) Under federal law, related services include, inter alia, speech and language pathology, transportation, and audiology services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. §1401(22). Federal law also includes provision for assistive technology devices and services when it will increase, maintain, or improve the functional capability of a child with a disability. (20 U.S.C. §1401(1)(2).) State law also requires that local agencies provide eligible students with related services, at no cost to the parent, that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. (Cal. Ed. Code §56031.) State regulations provide for designated instructional services (DIS); development and remediation in language, speech, and hearing; and audiology services. (C.C.R. §§3051, 3051.1, 3051.2.)
Evidentiary Analysis:
Transportation to Speech and Language Services
The Student’s parents did not contend at hearing that the speech and language services provided by Donna Morris were inappropriate or that 30 minutes a day for five days a week was inadequate. They asserted that the District failed to provide transportation for the fifth day of service. There is also no dispute that the District did not offer to provide Student transportation to a fifth day of speech and language therapy on Fridays. Ms. Morris, the speech and language pathologist for the District who provided the service to Student, testified that Student needed the service five days each week. There is also no dispute that the school was not in session on Fridays and thus Student would not already be on the school site when the speech and language services were delivered. Therefore, Student required transportation to Lafayette School to receive his therapy and benefit from his educational program. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide Student with transportation to the fifth day of speech and language services as a related service.
Assistive Technology
The Student’s parents contend that Student required assistive technology in the form of a Phonak Microlink FM system for him to benefit from his educational program. The system connected Student’s hearing aids to a microphone worn by the teacher and transmitted her voice through FM airwaves. The District noted in the September 25, 2000 IEP document titled Special Factors Part Two that Student qualified for access to low-incidence-communication devices, equipment, and materials. The Student’s parents assert that the District failed to cooperate by timely providing Student the Phonak Microlink FM system, although they do not contest the fact that the District eventually provided the equipment.
Linda Schroeder, the District’s supervising audiologist, testified that the District had previously experienced technical problems with its Phonak system. She noted that the system frequently malfunctioned and picked up interference and therefore would not improve Student’s audio reception. She testified that the District agreed to attempt to obtain and test a “loaner” unit from the manufacturer. Ms. Schroeder testified that by borrowing the unit from the manufacturer instead of going through the purchase process, the unit could be obtained much more quickly. She explained that approximately a month later the District did in fact receive the unit from the manufacturer. The District tested it then and promptly provided it to Student for his use at home and school. The Student’s parents did not contradict Ms. Schroeder’s account of how and why the District went about obtaining the Phonak Microlink FM system. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided Student with the assistive technology he needed to benefit from his educational program in a timely manner.
Audiology
The Student’s parents asserted that Student required the services of an audiologist to ensure that his hearing aids and other assistive technology functioned properly. In January 2000, the IEP team, including the Student’s parents, agreed that Student required the services of an audiologist a minimum of one time per year. Ms. Schroeder testified that two licensed audiologists were assigned to provide services for deaf and hard of hearing students at Lafayette. She stated that these audiologists were available at all times to set and test hearing aids and assistive technology devices for students with such a need. The Student’s parents did not contradict Ms. Schroeder’s testimony. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided Student with the necessary audiological services to allow him to benefit from his educational program.
Conclusion
Because the District did not offer Student a placement to meet his unique needs, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer Student a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.
Issue Number 2: Did the District deny Student a FAPE in the Fall of 2000 by violating the procedural safeguards set forth in state and federal law?
Student also alleged that the District committed procedural violations of such magnitude that it denied him a FAPE. However, the Hearing Officer finds that it is unnecessary to address his procedural claims since the Hearing Officer found in issue number one above that the District failed to provide Student with a FAPE.
Issue Number 3: If the District failed to offer Student a program to meet his unique needs for the 2000-2001 school year, are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the private services they secured for him?
Applicable Law
Special education law provides that when a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. (School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 , 369 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. §1415(i) (1997).) Thus, the parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they procure for their child when the school district fails to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. (Burlington, supra, 471 U.S. at p. 370.) The rule in Burlington is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parents are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the Act. (Alamo Heights Independent School District v. state Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).)
Evidentiary Analysis
In its discussion of the issues, the District contended that even if the Hearing Officer finds that it failed to offer Student an appropriate placement and designated instructional services to meet his unique needs and allow him to benefit from his educational program, the Student’s parents should not be reimbursed for their costs at CCHAT. The District asserted that CCHAT was an inappropriate placement for Student since it did not educate him in the least restrictive environment.(Footnote 19)
The undisputed evidence at hearing established that CCHAT was a State-certified non-public agency (NPA), that its teachers, therapists, audiologists, and administrators were all qualified to deliver the services required to meet Student’s unique needs, and that the program of instruction and related services did in fact result in Student progressing in his educational program. The CCHAT program was a language-based auditory-oral special day class that included five hearing impaired children and one normal hearing child who attended the class on a part-time basis. The other children in Student’s special day class were of similar age with similar hearing impairments. The classroom was acoustically sound and audiological services were provided. Additionally, speech and language services were provided by a licensed speech and language pathologist. The goal of the CCHAT program was to prepare Student for mainstreaming, and to that end, his teachers worked to implement the goals and objectives set forth in his IEP.
The fact that the placement was private and not a part of the public school system necessarily means that its students are not educated in the least restrictive environment. Moreover, the parties agreed that the very purpose of Student’s special day class program, whether at the District or at CCHAT, was to provide him with an intensive program to prepare him for “mainstreaming” in kindergarten or the first grade. Thus, the fact that the CCHAT program did not educate Student in the least restrictive environment did not render his placement there inappropriate.
Therefore, because the program at CCHAT addressed Student’s needs as specified in his IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that the program at CCHAT was sufficiently appropriate under the IDEA and State law to require retroactive reimbursement for the services the Student’s parents procured for Student when the District failed to provide him with an appropriate placement.
ORDER
1. Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof, the San Diego Unified School District shall reimburse Student’s parents for the expenses they incurred for services at CCHAT during the 2000-2001 school year and any recoverable costs for transporting him to and from school.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statue:
1. Did the District fail to offer Student a free and appropriate public education designed to meet his unique needs for the 2000-2001 school year? A. Placement: The Student prevailed on this issue.
B. Related Services: The District prevailed on this issue, with the exception of the issue of transportation, which the Student prevailed on.
2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE in the Fall of 2000 by violating the procedural safeguards set forth in state and federal law? Neither party prevailed on this issue.
3. If the District failed to offer Student a program to meet his unique needs for the 2000-2001 school year, are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the private services they secured for Student. The Student prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties in this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Educ. Code §56505(i).)
Date: Septmber 11, 2001 ___________________________________ Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues listed here are framed slightly differently from those stated by Petitioner in his Statement of Issues prior to the hearing. The Hearing Officer changed the wording to better clarify the issues and to more accurately reflect how the issues were framed during discussion between the parties and the Hearing Officer.
2. The parties used the term “auditory-oral” to denote a mode of communication and language development that relied on hearing and spoken words. The term “total communication” was used to indicate a mode of communication where at least one person–usually the teacher–combined signing with oral communication.
3. To test vocabulary, assessors gave Student the Receptive One Word Vocabulary Test (ROWPVT-R) and the Expressive One Word Vocabulary Test (EOWPVT-R); to assess Student in grammar, he was given the Structured Photographic Expressive Language Test (SPELT-pre), and the Grammatical Analysis of Elicited Language Skills, Preschool (GAEL-P); to examine his listening skills, Student was given the Assessment of Children’s Learning Comprehension (ACLC); the Phonetic Level Evaluation for Speech (Ling) and the Assessment of Phonological Processes (APP-R) were administered to Student to assess his articulation and speech skills.
4. Ms. Maggie Keyser was scheduled to be Student’s preschool special day class teacher at Lafayette during the 2000-2001 school year.
5. The IEP document referenced the afternoon model preschool program on the face page along with the other offered services. The document indicated that the program would be four days each week for four-and-a-half hours each day. An adjacent entry noted, “see IEP team notes.”
6. Regarding the speech and language services, the fifth day offered Student was scheduled for Friday, a day when preschool classes were no longer held. The District had previously notified parents that Friday sessions were available by appointment but that transportation would have to be provided by the parents. The District did not offer to provide Student with transportation for the Friday speech and language sessions.
7. The IDEA also includes provisions for allowing the child to participate in the general curriculum and with nondisabled peers, and to the extent that the child does not, an explanation must be included in the IEP. (20 U.S.C. 1414(d)((A)(iii).)
8. There was disagreement among the witnesses as to how to accurately determine which words or phrases in a sample should be utilized to determine the mean. Ms. Aaberg, Student’s special day class teacher from CCHAT, was of the opinion that rote phrases such as “I want” should not be counted with the word that follows since it reflects memorized words and not spontaneous and creative language. Ms. Morris believed that such words should be included and are a normal part of speech.
9. Early on in her testimony, Ms. Lee, in response to a question on direct examination from the District’s counsel, stated that she did not believe that reducing Student’s special day class in the fall of 2000 from five to four days would adversely impact his program. However, later in her testimony, Ms. Lee explained to the Hearing Officer in great detail how a teacher goes about teaching language to a child such as Student. She explained that the various techniques must be applied to Student repetitively and on a daily basis for him to make the necessary progress. It was at this point in her testimony that she acknowledged that Student had not made all the progress that she had hoped for and, thus, she would not have reduced the services in his program.
10. As noted above, the District argued that four days of Ms. Keyser’s special day class was enough to meet Student’s unique needs, and in the alternative, if it was not enough, the addition of the afternoon model preschool program would meet his needs. Because the District takes both positions, the Hearing Officer will address each of them in turn. 11. The Hearing Officer does not dispute the fact that Student or any child benefits from applying skills learned at school at home or elsewhere, the issue is how much formal education is required to develop the necessary language skills. 12. As previously noted in the “Position of the Parties” section, the Student’s parents also argued that Student’s placement required that the teaching methodology utilized include a “cognitive curriculum,” that parental training and participation be included, and that the classroom be acoustically quiet in order for Student to hear. However, as discussed above, the Hearing Officer’s finding is based on the reduction in services. 13. According to the Student’s parents, these methods included a teaching methodology that utilized a cognitive curriculum, parental training and participation, and an acoustically quiet classroom. The District countered that curricular and educational methodologies are not part of a FAPE. While its legal assertion is not per se untrue, the relevant question in this case is whether the afternoon model preschool was an appropriate placement to meet Student’s unique needs. 14. It should also be noted that Ms. Lee, who is an experienced expert in teaching deaf and hard of hearing students, agreed that Student should not be exposed to significant signing in the classroom for even half of his daily instruction. She remarked that the John Tracy Clinic took the position that a child of Student’s circumstance and age should communicate in a total oral-auditory mode and should not be exposed to signing in the classroom. Ms. Lee stated that while studies could be found to support arguments for and against this premise, she personally accepted the John Tracy position on the issue. The Tracy Clinic assessment report, like the January 2000 and September 25, 2001 IEPs, recommended an auditory-oral placement for Student.
15. The face page of the IEP document also indicated that the service could be provided to Student at his home.
16. While a FAPE may not require a particular curriculum or teaching methodology, Student’s program must be designed to meet his needs. In Student’s case, those needs are language development. Thus, the program must be designed and implemented in such a way as to not only allow him to develop language, but also to do so in the context of his IEP goals and objectives. Thus, the curriculum and teaching methodology is relevant to the extent that it addresses the stated objectives.
17. Although one might presume that Ms. MacNeil, as the District’s program manager for low incidence disabilities, would be in a position to corroborate Ms. Keyser’s findings regarding the contents of the PLG program, the fact that Ms. Keyser was sent to investigate and summarize the program in a memo to Ms. MacNeil rebuts this presumption.
18. Under section 3082(b) of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, heresay evidence may be used for the purpose of supplementing or explaining other evidence but is not sufficient in itself to support a finding, unless it would be admissible over an objection in civil actions. Ms. Keyser’s memo would not be admissible over objection in a civil action. Thus, because of the absence of corroborating evidence, the memo cannot be used as a basis to support a finding that the offered PLG in conjunction with the four days of special day class at Lafayette was an appropriate placement to meet Student’s needs
19. The District did not challenge Student’s placement at CCHAT on any other grounds, nor did it present any evidence at the hearing that CCHAT was an inappropriate placement for Student.
