California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 25, 2003

Student v. San Diego Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 506-03 · Hearing Officer Heather A. Hoyle

San Diego Unified's manifestation finding overturned; student's school conduct ruled a manifestation of disability, and expulsion barred.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

A footnote states that the decision was amended to correct its title and page numbers, with no substantive changes.

Summary

The student's parents asked for an expedited hearing after San Diego Unified School District decided that his conduct was not a manifestation of his disability. He was 17, in ninth grade at Patrick Henry High School, and eligible for special education because of an auditory memory processing disorder. On February 20, 2003, staff found a box cutter and marijuana on him at school, and the District recommended expulsion. Four days later, a team of three made up of the school psychologist, a resource specialist and the vice principal found no link to his disability.

The Hearing Officer found three procedural errors. First, no general education teacher attended, even though he spent most of his day in general education. Second, his mother got one business day's notice and was told she did not need to come. She was not offered another time or the option to join by phone. Third, the team members did not each review his IEP, his assessments and reports from his teachers. The Hearing Officer then decided the substance. Since 2000 his IEPs had called for counseling, and his assessment listed conduct, aggression, anxiety and depression as main concerns. Even so, the District provided no counseling for over two years. Evidence tied his low self-esteem and attention-seeking rule-breaking to his learning disability. Because the District did not provide services as his IEP required, the conduct counted as a manifestation. The District may not discipline him for the incident and must reinstate him.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This case shows how SEHO applied the 1997 IDEA manifestation rules. When a district failed to provide IEP counseling that was related to a student's behavior, the conduct had to be treated as a manifestation of his disability, even for weapon and drug possession. Short notice that discouraged the parent from attending was a procedural error.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 1. Did the District appropriately determine that STUDENT's behavior on February 20, 2003, was not a manifestation of his disability?

    The District made three procedural errors at the manifestation meeting: no general education teacher attended, the parent got inadequate notice and was told she need not attend, and team members did not review the relevant records. It also failed to provide the counseling in his IEP for over two years, which had a link to the conduct, so the conduct had to be treated as a manifestation of his disability.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order finds the District failed to conduct a proper manifestation determination meeting and that the student's conduct is a manifestation of his disability; the District may not impose discipline on the student for the February 20, 2003 incident.
  • Placement ordered. The District must reinstate the student to Patrick Henry High School upon his release from Juvenile Hall Authority.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

34 C.F.R. § 300.523; 34 C.F.R. § 300.345; Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5; Cal. Educ. Code § 56341; Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5; Farrin v. Maine School Administrative District No. 59 (distinguished)

People named in the decision

  • Kathleen Edwards, educational advocate, witness for Student
  • Chelsea Meyers, case manager, witness for Student, San Diego Choice Program
  • Kristee Beres, clinical psychologist, independent assessment, witness for Student, Psychiatric Centers at San Diego (PCSD)
  • Psychiatric Centers at San Diego (PCSD), private provider, independent assessment
  • San Diego Choice Program, case management agency (probation referral)
  • New Beginnings, counseling provider named in 2000 IEP
  • David Evans, school psychologist, manifestation team member, San Diego Unified School District
  • James Good, vice principal, manifestation team member, Patrick Henry High School, San Diego Unified School District
  • Cheryl Keenan, resource specialist, manifestation team member, Patrick Henry High School, San Diego Unified School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Heather A. Hoyle, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Diego, California, on April 1, 2, and 8, 2003.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Thomas Nelson from the law firm of Cochrane and Nelson.(Footnote 1) STUDENT’s mother, was also present on behalf of the Petitioner. San Diego Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorney Ricardo Soto.

The following witnesses were called to testify on behalf of the Petitioner: PARENT ; Kathleen Edwards, educational advocate; Chelsea Meyers, case manager; and Kristee Berer, clinical psychologist. The following witnesses were called to testify on behalf of the Respondent: David Evans, school psychologist; James Good, vice principal; and Cheryl Keenan, resource specialist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of oral closing arguments on April 8, 2003, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING

Did the District appropriately determine that STUDENT’s behavior on February 20, 2003, was not a manifestation of his disability?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that the District failed to conduct an appropriate manifestation determination regarding STUDENT’s alleged conduct on February 20, 2003, and that STUDENT’s behavior subject to disciplinary action was a manifestation of his disability. Petitioner’s position is that due to the District’s failure to conduct the manifestation meeting properly and to provide him with adequate notice, he was not able to participate in the meeting. Petitioner alleges that the manifestation IEP team members were not familiar with STUDENT, did not speak to STUDENT or his mother regarding the incidents, and in particular, relied on the recommendations of David Evans, school psychologist rather than conducting their own review of the appropriate documents at the manifestation determination meeting. Petitioner asserts that in relationship to the behavior subject to discipline, STUDENT’s academic placement was inappropriate and he was not provided counseling services as set forth in his IEP. Petitioner’s position is that STUDENT has shown signs of depression, low self esteem, impulsivity, and has exhibited behaviors both in the classroom and other environments that indicate his need for counseling and other services to address his behavior. Petitioner also contends that STUDENT requires a behavior support plan or other strategies to address his behavior needs. Petitioner asserts that STUDENT’s disability impairs his ability to control his behavior and to know right from wrong.

The Respondent contends that the manifestation determination meeting held February 24, 2003, complied with applicable federal and state law. Respondent contends that it did give proper notice of the team meeting to STUDENT’s mother, and that she indicated that she would not be attending. In addition, the team members reviewed the appropriate information prior to making a determination regarding STUDENT’s disability and its effect on the conduct subject to discipline. The Respondent’s position is that after reviewing STUDENT’s placement, disability and the alleged conduct, the team members appropriately determined that the alleged behavior was not a manifestation of STUDENT’s disability. The Respondent further contends that STUDENT’s placement in relationship to the conduct subject to discipline was appropriate regardless of the District’s alleged failure to provide counseling services.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old student who is currently eligible for special education services due to an auditory memory processing disorder. He is currently in ninth grade at Patrick Henry High School.(Footnote 2) STUDENT’s behavior has been noted to impede his ability to learn, and he has been placed at various schools over the years based in part on his behavior.

STUDENT first became eligible for special education services during the 2000-2001 school year as a seventh-grader. STUDENT’s mother requested that he be assessed due to concerns regarding his behavior at school and his academic performance. In October 2000, the District conducted STUDENT’s initial assessment.(Footnote 3) The assessment included the following tools: Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC II), Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test; Beery-Buktenica Visual Motor Integration; Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills (TAPS); Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills revised; Wide Range Achievement Test Revision 3 (WRAT 3); Behavior Assessment System for Children parent and teacher rating scales (BASC); and the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery Revised (WJ-R) The District psychologist and the IEP team determined based upon a records review and the above referenced assessments that a severe discrepancy existed between STUDENT’s intellectual ability and his achievement in the areas of auditory memory and processing and that STUDENT had a mild delay in some visual motor skills. Additionally, STUDENT’s initial assessment indicated that the “primary areas of concern are related to conduct aggression and hyperactivity as well as anxiety, depression, social skills and study skills.”

STUDENT was eligible to receive resource specialist services (RSP) during the 2000-2001 school year, and he attended both RSP and regular education classes. At the end of the 2000-2001 school year, an IEP team meeting was held and an addendum to STUDENT’s IEP was created that changed STUDENT’s classroom placement to regular education, and STUDENT remained eligible to receive special education. (Footnote 4) This change in STUDENT’s classes was to be reevaluated at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. However, STUDENT’s IEP, placement and services were not evaluated again until January 2003.

STUDENT began attending Patrick Henry High School in September 2002. He attended all regular education classes when he first started at Patrick Henry. STUDENT has continued to exhibit inappropriate behavior in the classroom. He has been referred for discipline, suspended from school and attended school pursuant to juvenile court proceedings several times during the current school year. An IEP team meeting was held January 6, 2003, and an “interim IEP” was created that adjusted STUDENT’s schedule further and allowed him to attend RSP for a study skills class and remain in regular education for the rest of his school day.(Footnote 5) Another IEP meeting was held on January 23, 2003, and a full IEP was developed. The IEP provided goals and objectives for STUDENT, including one in the area of behavior, and indicated that STUDENT was to receive counseling services one time per week for thirty minutes.

On February 20, 2003, STUDENT allegedly brought a box cutter on school grounds. In addition to the box cutter, STUDENT was also found with marijuana consisting of one larger “Ziploc” bag and several smaller bags. STUDENT was approached regarding another investigation at the school site and the weapon and marijuana were found during that investigation. STUDENT was suspended and then arrested. STUDENT was initially suspended for five days and later was recommended for expulsion.

On February 24, 2003, the District convened an IEP team meeting to discuss whether STUDENT’s behavior, allegedly bringing a weapon (a box cutter) and marijuana on school grounds, was a manifestation of his disability. The District manifestation IEP team members -- David Evans, Cheryl Keenan and James Good -- determined that STUDENT’s behavior was not a manifestation of his disability, that he was appropriately placed at the time of the incident in relation to the behavior subject to discipline, and that his disability did not impair his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his behavior or his ability to control his behavior that was the subject of disciplinary action. STUDENT’s mother did not attend the meeting.

On March 13, 2003, STUDENT’s parents filed for a due process hearing because they disagreed with the District’s manifestation determination.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Did the District appropriately determine that STUDENT’s behavior on February 20, 2003, was not a manifestation of his disability?

Both federal and State law provide that before a student with a disability can be expelled from school, the IEP team must determine that the conduct for which the student is being recommended for expulsion was not a manifestation of his or her disability.(Footnote 6) Pursuant to 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c), and California Education Code Section 48915.5(Footnote 7) the IEP team and other qualified personnel may only determine that the conduct was not a manifestation of the child’s disability if they (1) First consider, in terms of the behavior subject to disciplinary action, all relevant information, including: (i) evaluation and diagnostic results, including the results of other relevant information supplied by the parents of the child; (ii) observations of the child; and (iii) the child’s IEP and placement; and (2) then determine that:

(i) in relationship to the behavior subject to disciplinary action, the child’s IEP and placement were appropriate and the special education services, supplementary aids and services, and behavior intervention strategies were provided consistent with the child’s IEP and placement; (ii) the child’s disability did not impair the ability of the child to understand the impact and consequences of the behavior subject to disciplinary action; and (iii) the child’s disability did not impair the ability of the child to control the behavior subject to disciplinary action

Appropriateness of manifestation determination meeting

Federal law and related California statutes require that a manifestation determination be conducted by “the IEP team and other qualified personnel in a meeting.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c). According to California Education Code section 56341, the IEP team consists of the pupil’s parents, at least one regular education teacher, at least one special education teacher, a representative of the district, individuals who conducted an assessment, and, when appropriate, the pupil. In this case, present at the January 24, 2003 IEP meeting were David Evans, the school psychologist; Cheryl Keenan, resource specialist; and James Good, vice principal. STUDENT’s mother, STUDENT’s mother, was not present and no testimony was presented regarding the attendance of a regular education teacher. STUDENT’s program prior to January 2003 included full participation in regular education classes, and even after the addition of RSP for study skills, STUDENT still participated in regular education for the majority of his academic day. The RSP teacher, Ms. Keenan, was the only one of STUDENT’s teachers to attend the meeting. The Hearing Officer finds that the failure to have a regular education teacher present at the manifestation meeting constituted a procedural error.

Petitioner also contends that the District failed to advise STUDENT’s mother of the nature and purpose of the manifestation determination meeting or provide her with adequate notice of the scheduled meeting and, therefore, she was not able to participate. Manifestation determination team meetings must be held within ten school days after the date the decision to take disciplinary action is made. 34 C.F.R. § 300.523 (a)(2). Generally, districts are required to provide reasonable notice to parents whenever an IEP team meeting is scheduled. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(b), Cal. Education Code § 56341.5. Typically, notice of IEP team meetings is provided in writing and mailed to the parents’ home address. However, in the case of manifestation determination meetings, which are subject to strict and short time limitations, it may be necessary to provide that notice by telephone or other means, as long as the notice provided is reasonable and allows the parent the opportunity to participate. Districts may conduct an IEP team meeting without a parent present only if the district is unable to convince the parent to attend the meeting and the district has offered other methods for the parent to participate, such as by telephone. If the district is unable to secure the parent’s attendance, the district must have a record of its attempts to arrange a mutually agreed-on time and place, including a log of telephone calls, copies of correspondence between the district and parent, or visits to the parent’s home or work, to proceed with an IEP meeting in the absence of the student’s parents. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(c)-(d), Cal. Education Code § 56341.5.

The District’s position is that STUDENT’s mother was provided appropriate notice of the manifestation meeting. Ms. Keenan testified that she contacted STUDENT’s mother by telephone on February 21, 2003, regarding the manifestation meeting.(Footnote 8) Ms. Keenan testified that she told STUDENT’s mother the meeting was scheduled to take place February 24, 2003, and that STUDENT’s mother indicated that she was not sure she could attend the meeting because she was scheduled to work that day. Ms. Keenan testified that her impression was that STUDENT’s mother’s “plate was full.” Ms. Keenan further testified that STUDENT’s mother told her that she could not keep missing work to attend meetings regarding STUDENT. Ms. Keenan’s testimony was that she then told STUDENT’s mother that she did not think that STUDENT’s mother needed to attend the meeting but that she would call her back if STUDENT’s mother needed to attend. Ms. Keenan also testified that she explained the purpose of the meeting was to determine whether or not STUDENT’s disability was “causally” related to his learning disability. Ms. Keenan further testified that she told STUDENT’s mother that the District was under very strict time constraints as to when the meeting needed to occur. Ms. Keenan went on to explain to STUDENT’s mother that she did not believe that the conduct subject to discipline was a manifestation of STUDENT’s disability and that she did not see how it could be. Ms. Keenan did not offer to reschedule the meeting or to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate by phone. Ms. Keenan testified that she did not have the impression STUDENT’s mother would be able to attend if the meeting was rescheduled; therefore, she did not offer STUDENT’s mother that option.

STUDENT’s mother’s testimony was also that Ms. Keenan called her to inform her of the meeting. However, STUDENT’s mother indicated that she thought the call was only one day prior to the meeting. The Hearing Officer notes that February 21, 2003, was a Friday and that the meeting occurred on February 24, 2003, a Monday. It is likely that both accounts are accurate and that STUDENT’s mother was provided notice only one business day prior to the meeting. STUDENT’s mother’s testimony was that Ms. Keenan told her that she didn’t need to worry about the meeting because she didn’t have to be there. She also testified that she was not given an opportunity to participate by phone. She further testified that she has attended two IEP team meetings as well as one interim IEP for STUDENT and that she comes to all of STUDENT’s meetings, including those related to his drug use, probation, and other services.

While it is clear that the District did provide STUDENT’s mother with notice that a meeting was scheduled on February 24, 2003, it is equally clear that STUDENT’s mother was not provided enough information regarding the nature and purpose of the meeting. STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Keenan’s testimony both indicate that STUDENT’s mother was told she did not need to come to the meeting. In addition, Ms. Keenan’s telling STUDENT’s mother she did not need to attend the meeting appears to be the result of a fairly narrow interpretation of the legal requirements regarding parent participation in IEP team meetings. Ms. Keenan’s statements to STUDENT’s mother hardly conveyed to STUDENT’s mother that she would have an opportunity to contribute to the discussion at the meeting regarding the determination the team was to make as to whether STUDENT’s behavior was a manifestation of his disability and whether the District could proceed with expelling STUDENT. In addition, Ms. Keenan’s statement to STUDENT’s mother that she did not see how the behavior subject to discipline could be a manifestation of STUDENT’s disability likely also indicated to STUDENT’s mother that at least one member of the team had already prejudged the matter. STUDENT’s mother further testified that she probably would have been able to arrange to attend this meeting.

On the basis of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to adequately provide notice to STUDENT’s mother of the manifestation determination meeting and, in fact, told STUDENT’s mother her attendance at the meeting was not necessary. As STUDENT’s mother is a member of the IEP team, she is entitled to attend the meeting. While an IEP meeting may be held in the absence of a parent IEP team member, if that parent refuses to attend, a district is required to show that it took reasonable steps to convince the parent to attend the meeting, including logs of phone calls, correspondence and visits to the home. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(c)-(d), Cal. Education Code § 56341.5. In this case, it is not clear that STUDENT’s mother refused to attend the meeting, and in any event, the District did not offer to reschedule the meeting or to allow the parent to participate by telephone. The District committed a procedural error that resulted in the parent not participating in the manifestation determination meeting.

At the manifestation determination meeting, the IEP team is required to review all relevant information. 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c)(1). Petitioner’s position generally is that the District IEP team members failed to review the appropriate information at the IEP team meeting and, in particular, that the team failed to adequately consider the results of STUDENT’s initial assessment. In this case, STUDENT’s last assessment was reviewed by David Evans prior to the meeting.(Footnote 9) Mr. Evans testified that he made his recommendations to the manifestation IEP team based on his review of STUDENT’s special education records. Mr. Evans further testified that he did not recall reviewing information regarding STUDENT’s behavior or that his IEP indicated that he was to receive counseling services to address his behavior. Mr. Evans testified that while he did not recall specific information contained in STUDENT’s last assessment or in his current IEP, his practice is to review a student’s special education file in preparation for a manifestation determination meeting. Mr. Evans indicated that his focus was on STUDENT’s auditory memory processing deficits when determining whether or not the conduct subject to discipline was a manifestation of STUDENT’s disability. Ms. Keenan testified that she was familiar with STUDENT’s IEP and that she had reviewed information in his file before but did not recall specifically reviewing information in preparation for or during the manifestation determination meeting. Mr. Good indicated that he did not review any information other than that prepared in relation to the disciplinary action the District had initiated. The Hearing Officer finds that the District committed a third procedural violation because each member of the manifestation determination team did not review the appropriate information, including STUDENT’s IEP, assessment, and report from STUDENT’s regular education teachers, when making the determination that the conduct subject to discipline was not a manifestation of STUDENT’s disability.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District committed three procedural errors in conducting the manifestation determination IEP team meeting. These errors unduly prejudiced the Petitioner’s right to participate in the IEP team meeting and led to a procedurally flawed manifestation determination. However, the Hearing Officer declines to make a determination in this case based solely on the procedural errors. (Footnote 10) Because the evidence established that the District did not provide STUDENT’s placement and services consistent with his IEP, the Hearing Officer turns to the substantive appropriateness of the manifestation determination. To determine whether STUDENT’s behavior was a manifestation of his disability, there are three factors that may establish that behavior was a manifestation: (1) whether STUDENT’s placement and services were provided appropriately in relation to the alleged conduct subject to discipline; (2) whether STUDENT’s disability impaired his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his behavior subject to disciplinary action; and (3) whether STUDENT’s disability impaired his ability to control his behavior subject to disciplinary action.

Was STUDENT’s placement and services provided appropriately in relation to the alleged conduct subject to discipline?

In this case, the focus of this Decision is on the first factor. Before a school district is permitted to move forward with disciplinary action that would constitute a change in a student’s placement, the IEP team must determine that in relationship to the behavior subject to disciplinary action the student’s IEP and placement were appropriate and the special education services and supplementary aids and services and behavior intervention strategies were provided to the student consistent with that student’s IEP and placement. 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c). If this standard is not met, the behavior must be considered a manifestation of the student’s disability. Petitioner’s position is that his placement was inappropriate and that he continued to receive poor grades and required additional assistance and other interventions to address his auditory memory processing needs. In addition, STUDENT was not receiving counseling services as identified on his IEP to address his behavior needs. Petitioner contends that the failure to provide an appropriate academic placement to address his auditory memory processing needs, as well as counseling and other strategies to address his behavior needs, was related to the behavior subject to discipline.

STUDENT’s initial IEP dated November 3, 2000, indicated that STUDENT had behavior problems that impeded his ability to learn. That IEP also indicated that STUDENT was to receive counseling through “New Beginnings” and that rewards and consequences were to be used to help address STUDENT’s behavior needs. An IEP was held in June 2001, addressing the time period from June 2001 until November 2001. The addendum IEP indicated that the team members decided that STUDENT would attend all general education classes on a trial basis and that the team would revisit the issue in the fall. No mention was made regarding changing any other aspect of STUDENT’s IEP. There was no evidence presented that indicates that another IEP was convened to address STUDENT’s needs until January 2003. STUDENT’s IEP in January 2003 also indicated that STUDENT was to receive counseling services one time per week for thirty minutes. The January 23, 2003 IEP states that STUDENT’s behavior impedes his learning and that he is disruptive, defiant, and, in addition, that his behavior outside of school has caused STUDENT to miss school. STUDENT’s mother testified, and there was no contradictory evidence presented, that STUDENT did not receive counseling services from the District at any time from November 2000 through February 20, 2003, a period of two years.

STUDENT’s mother sought an independent assessment of STUDENT that was performed by Psychiatric Centers at San Diego (PCSD) and was completed on April 3, 2003.(Footnote 11) Kristee Beres is a clinical psychologist employed by PCSD and supervised the administration by another employee of the assessment tools used to evaluate STUDENT. Ms. Beres testified that she did not meet STUDENT but that she has reviewed the results of the tools used to assess STUDENT’s needs. Generally, Ms. Beres’s testimony indicated that STUDENT has a learning disability in the area of auditory memory and processing. In addition, she also indicated that STUDENT has needs in the area of behavior that are related to his learning disability. Ms. Beres also testified that the results of the assessments indicate that STUDENT has mild to moderate attentional lapses.

The assessment completed by PCSD also indicated that STUDENT’s learning disability, and his related academic difficulties, exacerbates his need to be accepted and liked and increases the likelihood of his acting out to impress others. Ms. Beres explained that, in addition to his learning disability, STUDENT is impulsive, has low self-esteem, and is a dependent person. Ms. Beres testified that the results of the PCSD assessment indicated that STUDENT is a student who wants to be liked to a degree that is not healthy. He is likely to be the kind of student who will do anything to fit in and to feel better about himself, including acting out to seek attention. The testimony of STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Meyers supported the findings of the PCSD assessment. STUDENT’s mother’s testimony was that STUDENT acts out in the classroom and at school because he is not able to succeed or do the work and wants to be liked and call attention to himself.(Footnote 12) In addition, STUDENT’s mother’s testimony was that STUDENT gives up easily, feels like a failure, and feels as though he doesn’t fit in.

Chelsea Meyers, a case manager for the San Diego Choice Program, testified that after STUDENT was referred to her organization in September 2002 by the probation department, she checked in on STUDENT every day either at school or at his home. Ms. Meyers testified that she provided general support for STUDENT and that a major portion of her role regarding STUDENT was to verify that STUDENT was where he was supposed to be, either at home, school or other programs related to his probation.(Footnote 13) Ms. Meyers testified that during when she made visits to STUDENT’s home, he secluded himself in his room and did not seem to spend time with the family. She also testified that STUDENT seemed depressed and lacked self-esteem and that he told her he wished he would just be sent to foster care so that he would not cause any further problems for his mom. STUDENT’s mother testified that as STUDENT has grown older, his behavior has continued to be a problem at school. STUDENT’s mother’s testimony was that STUDENT had acted out at school since at least third grade, and she was called to come and pick him up from school on many occasions due to his behavior.

Ms. Beres testified that for a student like STUDENT, failing to receive counseling could have a negative impact on behavior. Ms. Beres testified that STUDENT needs support to help stop him from engaging in inappropriate and negative behavior. Kathleen Edwards, educational advocate, testified that in her experience students with learning disability are often aware of their disability and know that they cannot catch up with their peers.(Footnote 14) Ms. Edwards also testified that a student like STUDENT who is not provided appropriate academic services and support as well as counseling may become more depressed and engage in further aggressive and defiant behavior.(Footnote 15) Ms. Edwards further stated that STUDENT’s defiance of school rules indicates to her that he is seeking help. Ms. Beres testified that STUDENT needed counseling and other interventions to address his needs. She testified that STUDENT requires tools and mechanisms to deal with his learning disability and the effect it has on his academic success. Ms. Beres indicated that STUDENT requires intervention and counseling to provide him with the skills to allow him to progress and to “feel better about himself.” Ms. Beres testified that STUDENT has fallen further and further behind academically and is likely to give up if his learning disability and related behavior needs are not addressed. He is more and more frustrated and wants to do well but does not have the ability or skills to do so. David Evans also testified that if a student needs, and is not provided, academic supports and counseling it can lead to frustration. Ms. Beres testified that with appropriate services and counseling STUDENT might not have made such a poor choice, referencing his misbehavior on February 20, 2003.

Testimony at hearing was that the District was unable to determine whether or not they had STUDENT’s current IEP during the first few months STUDENT attended Patrick Henry High School. Ms. Keenan testified that she continued to contact STUDENT’s prior school for several months to find out whether or not an IEP had been developed since November 3, 2000. At some point during the fall of the 2002-2003 school year, the District determined that the November 3, 2000 IEP was STUDENT’s last agreed-upon IEP; however, the District still did not implement the counseling services identified on that IEP. STUDENT has had several referrals for discipline and suspensions for disruption and defiance of school rules during the 2002-2003 school year, including another incident in which STUDENT had marijuana on campus. There was no evidence presented that any steps were taken by the District or the IEP team to address this prior instance of bringing marijuana to school or any of STUDENT’s other instances of defiant behavior, other than suspending him from school or requiring that he attend detention or Saturday school.

The District’s position is that even if STUDENT’s placement and services were not implemented consistent with his IEP, that alleged failure did not affect his behavior subject to discipline. In particular the District’s position is that there is no behavior support plan, strategy or counseling that would allow or address bringing drugs or a box cutter to campus.(Footnote 16) Mr. Evans testified that while he did not recall reviewing information regarding STUDENT’s need for counseling either prior to or at the manifestation determination meeting, it would not have changed his recommendation. Mr. Evans’s testimony was that he did not consider STUDENT’s issues regarding inappropriate behavior to be a factor in determining whether or not the placement and services were appropriately implemented. Mr. Evans further explained that he would not consider a behavior support plan or other strategies unless the behavior was occurring daily or relevant to a student’s day-to-day functioning. Ms. Keenan also testified that she did not believe that STUDENT’s behavior subject to discipline was a manifestation of his disability.

STUDENT’s initial IEP stated that he was to receive counseling and that need was still identified in January 2003. Under some instances a failure to provide counseling services in accordance with an IEP might be inconsequential. In this case, however, the student was having problems at school with defiant and disruptive behavior, and his most recent assessment indicated that the “primary areas of concern are related to conduct aggression and hyperactivity as well as anxiety, depression, social skills and study skills.” Under such circumstances, the District’s failure to provide counseling is significant. However, not every failure to provide services consistent with a student’s IEP results in the determination that the behavior subject to discipline was a manifestation of the student’s disability. The service or placement not provided must have a nexus to the behavior subject to discipline. 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c).

In this case STUDENT has a history of violating school rules and exhibiting inappropriate behavior dating back to at least the 1995-1996 school year, and according to STUDENT’s mother, his behavior was the cause of several changes in STUDENT’s school attendance. STUDENT has been suspended and referred for discipline for defiance and disruptive behaviors many times over the last few years. STUDENT’s discipline history indicates that in addition to the referrals for detention or other discipline, he has been suspended from school for disruption and defiance six times and also suspended for vandalism to school property, physical injury, and a previous instance of possessing a controlled substance on campus.(Footnote 17) In addition, as STUDENT was without a properly updated IEP for over a year and one-half, it is difficult to determine whether or not any strategies were implemented during that time period to address STUDENT’s behavior needs.

The District contends that there is not a nexus between the failure to address STUDENT’s behavior needs and the behavior subject to discipline. Additionally, the District’s position is that even if the District had provided behavior strategies or counseling, these services or interventions would not have “permitted” STUDENT to possess marijuana or a weapon on school grounds. However, as stated above, behavior must be considered a manifestation of the student’s disability when a district fails to provide, in relationship to the behavior subject to discipline, a student’s special education services, supplementary aids and services, and behavior intervention strategies consistent with a student’s IEP. A district that long neglects to provide counseling and other interventions for a student who has identified needs that require such services cannot then exculpate itself when that long-term neglect leads to an escalation of behavior that might not now be amendable to a specific behavior strategy. Credible evidence was presented that STUDENT suffers from low self-esteem and a sense of failure and that he tends to act out and defy rules to gain acceptance and attention. Several witnesses also testified that STUDENT seems to have “given up.” While it is always difficult to determine whether a specific intervention would have prevented a particular event from occurring, it requires no stretch of the imagination to find that STUDENT’s open defiance of school rules by bringing marijuana and a box cutter on school grounds could have been prevented if he had received appropriate counseling services and other strategies to address his needs and replace his self destructive behaviors with positive behaviors.

In this case, the District’s failure to provide STUDENT with the services identified in his IEP, in particular counseling services for over two years, requires finding that the behavior subject to discipline be considered a manifestation of his disability. 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(d). Therefore, the District cannot expel STUDENT. Instead, the District must identify the deficiencies existing in STUDENT's IEP and placement and take immediate steps to remedy those deficiencies. 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(f). Since the Hearing Officer finds that in relation to the behavior subject to discipline, the student’s placement and services were not provided consistent with his IEP, it is not necessary to address whether STUDENT understands the impact and consequences of his actions, or is able to control his behavior.

****

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed three procedural violations in this matter, including the failure to have a regular education teacher at the manifestation determination meeting, the failure to provide adequate notice of the manifestation meeting to STUDENT’s mother, and the failure to review the appropriate information regarding STUDENT in determining that the behavior was not a manifestation his disability. In addition, in relationship to the behavior subject to disciplinary action, STUDENT’s special education services, supplementary aids and services, and behavior intervention strategies were not provided consistent with the STUDENT’s IEP and placement. Therefore, STUDENT’s conduct must be considered a manifestation of his disability.

ORDER

1. The District failed to conduct a proper manifestation determination meeting.

2. STUDENT’s conduct is a manifestation of his disability. The District may not impose discipline on STUDENT for the incident of misconduct on February 20, 2003.

3. The District must reinstate STUDENT to Patrick Henry High School upon his release from Juvenile Hall Authority.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 5607(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner prevailed on the issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: April 25, 2003 ______________________________ Heather A. Hoyle, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

*The Decision is amended to reflect the correct title and the correct page numbers of the Decision. No substantive changes were made. 1. Attorney Michael Cochrane also of the law firm of Cochrane and Nelson was present during part of the first day of the hearing and represented the Petitioner regarding several preliminary issues decided the first day of hearing. 2. STUDENT was apparently attending a program pursuant to Juvenile Hall Authority based on the conduct subject to discipline at the time the hearing was conducted. 3. STUDENT’s “Assessment Report” is dated October 16, 2000. Petitioner’s Exhibit 21. 4. Petitioner’s Exhibit 30 and 67.

5. Petitioner’s Exhibit 44.

6. This hearing is being held pursuant to expedited hearing procedures provided for the review of manifestation determinations pursuant to 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.523-300.528. The issues are limited to review of the procedures used in making that determination and the conclusions concerning whether the behavior in question was a manifestation of the Petitioner’s disability. It is not within the scope of this Decision to determine other issues such as whether the alleged conduct occurred or whether the proposed discipline is appropriate. 7. Effective January 1, 2003, California Education Code section 48915.5 was amended to incorporate federal law regarding discipline of special education students. The section now provides that “an individual with exceptional needs, as defined in Section 56026, may be suspended or expelled from school in accordance with subsection (k) of Section 1415 of Title 20 of the United States Code, the discipline provisions contained in Sections 300.519 through 300.529 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, and other provisions of this part that do not conflict with federal law and regulations.” 8. Ms. Keenan testified that she began working for the District in 1986, and prior to joining the District she had been a special education teacher since 1971. 9. Mr. Evans testified that he has been a school psychologist since 1991, and has attended one other IEP team meeting for STUDENT but was not able to stay for the entire meeting. 10. The likely result of deciding this case solely on the basis of the procedural errors committed would be to order the parties to hold a proper manifestation determination IEP team meeting. Because the evidence establishes that the District failed to provide STUDENT’s placement and services consistent with his IEP, that failure could not be remedied by holding another meeting. Therefore, in the interests of conserving valuable time and resources, this Decision will reach the substantive issues regarding the manifestation. 11. Petitioner’s Exhibit 68.

12. Ms.PARENT’s testimony was that STUDENT had been transferred to several different schools based on his behavior, but that STUDENT had not been expelled. STUDENT’s mother testified that during the 2001-2002 school year he was without a school placement for approximately four months. 13. Ms. Meyers testified that she is a case manager employed by the San Diego Choice Program and has been involved in STUDENT’s case since September 2002. Ms. Meyers has worked for the San Diego Choice program since October 2001, and has a B.A. in communication from San Francisco State University.

14. Ms. Edwards testified that she is currently an advocate for children with special need. Ms. Edwards has a doctorate in education, with emphasis in curriculum and instruction as well as special education. Prior to becoming an advocate she has worked as a teacher for children with learning disabilities and as an RSP.

15. Ms. Edwards also testified that during one of STUDENT’s previous periods of probation he came to a meeting required by probation “high” on marijuana. Ms. Edwards indicated that at that time STUDENT was only a few days from completing his probation and that she viewed that as another instance where STUDENT refused to follow the rules to call attention to himself. 16. The District also relied on the holding in Farrin v. Maine School Administrative District No. 59, 165 F.Supp. 2d 37 (2001) for the proposition that impulsivity is not related to the selling of marijuana and not a manifestation of a student’s disability. While the Farrin case did address issues regarding a student with a disability allegedly selling marijuana, it was in the context of whether the impulsivity affected the student’s ability to control their behavior and understand the impact and consequences of their actions. While evidence was presented at hearing regarding those two factors, the Hearing Officer makes no finding regarding whether or not STUDENT could control his behavior or understand the impact and consequences of his actions. 17. Petitioner’s Exhibit 61.