California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 27, 2002
Student v. Salinas Union High School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 514-02 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy
Salinas Union High must fund an independent assessment, cannot reclassify a student as mentally retarded, and owes compensatory speech services.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Salinas Union High School District filed for due process after a parent objected to two District plans: changing a 16-year-old ninth grader's eligibility from specific learning disability to mental retardation, and moving him into a special day class for students with mental retardation. The student cross-filed, and the cases were consolidated. The Hearing Officer ruled for the student on all four issues.
First, the District's April 2001 assessment was not appropriate. The school psychologist gave the father the Vineland adaptive behavior scale without following its instructions. She did not establish basals and ceilings, and two conflicting score forms existed. The District therefore had to pay for the independent assessment from Children's Hospital Oakland.
Second, the evidence did not support a finding of mental retardation. Language deficits lowered his verbal IQ, and his adaptive skills were not significantly limited.
Third, the District was wrong to deny speech and language services because he did not meet speech-language eligibility criteria. Related services depend on need. His scores at the 1st and 2nd percentiles showed severe need and in fact met the criteria.
Fourth, the February 2002 IEP denied FAPE. It lacked written language and speech goals. It also offered a class built around adaptive skills rather than learning and language disabilities.
The District had to pay for the assessment and hold an IEP meeting within 20 days. At that meeting, the team must set the student's program and decide on compensatory speech services.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated a test given contrary to its publisher's instructions as making the whole assessment inappropriate. It also held that a student already eligible for special education can need speech services as a related service without meeting separate speech-language eligibility criteria. Finally, it found placement in a class designed for another disability inappropriate.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for an independent assessment he obtained in January 2002?
The District's April 2001 assessment was not appropriate because the Vineland was not given according to test instructions (no basals or ceilings) and two conflicting score forms existed, so the independent assessment must be publicly funded.
- Student prevailedEligibility
Issue 2. Should STUDENT's eligibility category for special education be changed from specific learning disability to mental retardation?
Under DSM-IV, language deficits depressed the student's IQ scores and his adaptive functioning was not significantly limited, so the evidence did not support mental retardation.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Was the District required to provide STUDENT with speech and language services for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years?
Speech services as a related service depend on need, not speech-language eligibility criteria; the student's severe receptive and expressive deficits required services, and he also met the § 3030(c) criteria.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 4. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the February 2002 IEP meetings?
The offer denied FAPE because it lacked written language and speech-language goals and placed the student in a class designed for students with mental retardation instead of one serving learning and language disabilities.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving invoices, the District must reimburse the parents and/or pay the costs they actually incurred for the independent assessment from Children's Hospital, Oakland. No amount stated.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 days of the order, the IEP team must meet and, consistent with the findings, determine an appropriate educational program.
- Compensatory education. The IEP team must determine compensatory speech and language services for those denied in 2000-2001 and 2001-2002, on top of the student's regular speech services. It must consider whether all services can be given before February 2003 or should be spread over a longer period. No hours specified.
Key authorities
Hendrick Hudson Dist. Bd. of Educ. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176; 34 C.F.R. § 300.503(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56333; Cal. Educ. Code § 56363; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(c); DSM-IV
People named in the decision
- Nancy Jones-Powers, Director of Special Education, Salinas Union High School District
- Sally Gutierrez, interpreter for parent
- Jane Rutzakis, special day class teacher, Alisal High School, Salinas Union High School District
- Dr. von Witzleben, school psychologist, Salinas Union High School District
- Ms. Kuh, special day class teacher (class for students with mental retardation), Alisal High School, Salinas Union High School District
- Teresa Farrar, speech and language therapist (2002 assessment), Salinas Union High School District
- Ms. Bye, speech and language assessor (2000 assessment), Salinas Union High School District
- Alex Peterson, Ph.D., independent assessor; expert witness for Student, Children's Hospital, Oakland
- Cynthia Peterson, Ph.D., independent assessor; expert witness for Student, Children's Hospital, Oakland
- Children's Hospital, Oakland, independent assessment provider
- Phyl Diri, attorney who requested the IEE for Student, California Rural Legal Assistance, Inc.
- Marian Bodin, educational consultant for Student
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on April 30, May 1, 2, 3, and 8, 2002, in Salinas, California.
The Salinas Union High School District (hereinafter “District”) was represented by attorney Daniel Osher. The District’s Director of Special Education, Nancy Jones-Powers, was also present on behalf of the District. STUDENT (hereinafter “STUDENT” or “Student”) was represented by attorneys Sarah Clarke and Dori Rose-Inda. Also present on his behalf was his mother, STUDENT’s mother. Sally Gutierrez provided interpreter services to STUDENT’s mother.(Footnote 1)
The Hearing Officer received oral and documentary evidence during the course of the proceedings. On May 29, 2002, the Hearing Officer received closing briefs from the parties and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
The case was originally filed by the District on February 22, 2002. The District requested a due process hearing on two issues: (1) was the District required to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for independent assessments they had obtained; and (2) did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education at the February 4 and 19, 2002 IEP meetings. On March 7, 2002, STUDENT cross-filed, and in his request for hearing he also raised issues relating to reimbursement for independent assessments and FAPE. On March 25, 2002, the Hearing Office consolidated the two cases. Ultimately, the parties narrowed the issues at the hearing to reflect those issues specified below.
ISSUES
1. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for an independent assessment he obtained in January 2002?
2. Should STUDENT’s eligibility category for special education be changed from specific learning disability to mental retardation?(Footnote 2)
3. Was the District required to provide STUDENT with speech and language services for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years?(Footnote 3)
4. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the February 2002 IEP meetings?(Footnote 4)
RELEVANT BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born on [date redacted], was 16 years 8 months old at the time the hearing closed. STUDENT grew up in a bilingual household–Spanish and English–and currently lives with his parents and siblings in Salinas, California. He is presently eligible for special education as a child with a specific learning disability. At the time of this Decision, STUDENT is in the ninth grade for the second time in consecutive years. He currently attends Ms. Jane Rutzakis’s special day class at the District’s Alisal High School.
STUDENT was first diagnosed with a specific learning disability after completing a psychoeducational assessment when he was 7 years 11 months old and in the second grade. At that time an IEP team determined that STUDENT had a specific learning disability and provided him with special education services at the elementary school district he was attending at the time. STUDENT completed another psychoeducational assessment in 1998, and he was again found eligible for special education as a child with a specific learning disability. Throughout this period of time, STUDENT continued to receive special education services, and each subsequent year he advanced from grade to grade until he reached the ninth grade in the 2000-2001 school year.
STUDENT attended the ninth grade in 2000-2001 at the District’s Alisal High School. On April 3, 2001, as part of a triennial assessment, the District’s psychologist, Dr. von Witzleben, administered a psychoeducational assessment to STUDENT. Dr. von Witzleben indicated in her report that the assessments were administered to STUDENT to determine his “current level of intellectual and academic functioning.” To assess STUDENT’s cognitive ability, Dr. von Witzleben administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WISC-III); to assess his academic achievement, she administered the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT); and to assess his behavior, she administered the Behavior Assessment Scale for Children (BASC) and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale (Vineland). As part of her overall assessment, Dr. von Witzleben reviewed records and interviewed STUDENT.
As to STUDENT’s cognitive ability, Dr. von Witzleben reported that his standardized scores on the WISC-III included a full scale score of 62, a verbal scale score of 59, and a performance scale score of 70. Regarding his academic achievement, Dr. von Witzleben reported that STUDENT’s standardized scores on the WIAT ranged from 43 (written expression) to 63 (mathematics). On the WIAT, STUDENT ranked within the first percentile in all areas of academic achievement.
To assess STUDENT’s behavior, Dr. von Witzleben administered the BASC to STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Rutzakis, “to assess his emotional and social adjustment.” Dr. von Witzleben reported that the purpose of the BASC is to “measure a number of internalizing and externalizing behavioral difficulties, as well as academic functioning.” On the BASC, which is a subjective survey, Ms. Rutzakis’s responses to the questionnaire generated standardized scores that indicated that STUDENT scored “clinically significant” in the areas of hyperactivity, aggression, conduct problems, attention problems, atypicality, social skills and study skills; “at-risk” in the areas of learning problems and leadership; and “average” in the areas of anxiety, depression, somatization, and withdrawal.(Footnote 5)
As part of her behavior assessment, Dr. von Witzleben also administered the BASC –Self-Report to STUDENT. STUDENT’s standardized scores, which were also subjective responses to a survey, placed him in the “average” range in the areas of attitude to school, attitude to teachers, sensation seeking, atypicality, locus of control, somatization, social stress, anxiety, depression, relations with parents, and interpersonal relationships; and “clinically significant in the areas of sense of inadequacy and self-reliance.”
Finally, STUDENT’s father was given the Vineland, also a subjective survey designed to assess STUDENT’s “adaptive behavior skills.” Dr. von Witzleben reported that STUDENT’s father’s standardized scores on the Vineland indicated that STUDENT’s “adaptive level” was “low” in the areas of communication, daily living skills, and socialization.
In her report summary, Dr. von Witzleben noted that the test results placed STUDENT’s abilities in the significantly delayed range. She also recorded that STUDENT’s achievement and adaptive behaviors were also in the significantly delayed range and that STUDENT exhibited numerous behavior problems. In her report, Dr. von Witzleben made several recommendations regarding STUDENT’s educational program (see discussion below).
In an IEP meeting held in April of 2001, the District proposed to change STUDENT’s eligibility category from specific learning disability to mentally retarded. The District members of the team determined STUDENT’s present levels of performance, which were primarily difficulties with academics and behavior; drafted goals and objectives to address his needs in the areas of language, math, and behavior; and proposed to place him in Ms. Kuh’s special day class, which was made up of 11 children diagnosed as mentally retarded. STUDENT’s mother did not agree to the District’s offered program.
On November 20, 2001, attorney Phyl Diri, from the California Rural Legal Assistance, Inc., requested, on STUDENT’s behalf, an independent assessment for him. Ms. Diri referred to the assessment as a neuropsychological assessment, and she requested that the District select one of four specified assessors. On November 20, 2001, the District informed Ms. Diri that it had not agreed to provide an independent neuropsychological assessment, but that it would provide an independent educational assessment. On November 28, 2001, the District provided Ms. Diri with the names of three assessors.
On December 7, 2001, another IEP team meeting was held. At this meeting, STUDENT’s mother renewed her objection to the change in STUDENT’s eligibility category, although STUDENT’s mother did agree to the class schedule proposed by the District on a temporary basis.
On December 4 and 10, 2001, STUDENT obtained an independent assessment from Children’s Hospital, Oakland.(Footnote 6) The assessment was conducted by Doctors Alex Peterson, Ph.D. and Cynthia Peterson, Ph.D.(Footnote 7) Doctors Peterson and Peterson (hereinafter, when referred to jointly, “the Petersons”) administered assessment procedures to STUDENT to assess his cognitive abilities, academic achievement, speech and language, behaviors, and adaptive functioning. The Petersons, who also administered STUDENT the WISC-III, reported that his overall (full-scale) score was similar to that reported by Dr. von Witzleben, but they concluded that STUDENT’s nonverbal intellectual abilities were significantly stronger than his verbal abilities. The Petersons also related that STUDENT’s adaptive functioning–particularly social and daily living skills–was relatively intact and, as a result, excluded a diagnosis of mental retardation. The Petersons also made several recommendations regarding STUDENT’s educational program.
On February 1, 2002, the District assessed STUDENT in the area of speech and language to assess his development in this area. Teresa Farrar, the District’s speech and language therapist, administered to STUDENT the receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test and the Clinical Assessment of Language Fundamentals-3, and obtained a language sample. She also interviewed STUDENT, his parents, and his teachers, as well as reviewed his previous speech therapy records. Ms. Farrar reported that STUDENT’s total language score was in the first percentile, his receptive language score was also in the first percentile, and his expressive language score was in the second percentile. Ms. Farrar also observed in her report that STUDENT “exhibits severe receptive and expressive language delays, with relative weaknesses in the areas of following oral directions, vocabulary, and memory for detail.” She concluded that although STUDENT “exhibits extremely low language skills for his age,” he appeared to be functioning at expected levels in light of his cognitive abilities. Ms. Farrar concluded her report by stating that she recommended that STUDENT not receive speech and language services.
On February 4, 2002, another IEP meeting was convened for STUDENT. At this meeting, the District renewed its recommendation that STUDENT’s eligibility category be changed to mentally retarded. The IEP document reviewed STUDENT’s educational assessments and the team discussed his relative strengths and weaknesses–i.e., STUDENT’s needs. According to STUDENT’s IEP, his academics in all areas were at a second to third grade level, he had excessive attendance problems, and he exhibited behavioral problems, notably leaving campus when he was confronted with difficult or anxiety-producing tasks. To address his needs, the District proposed three goals, one for language, one for math, and one for attendance. (The proposed goals and objectives will be discussed in more detail below.) To assist STUDENT in achieving his goals and objectives, the District proposed to place him in Ms. Kuh’s special day class, which included 11 mentally retarded students, for 196 minutes each day (approximately three and one-half hours) five days a week, and to provide two 30-minute counseling sessions each week with the school psychologist.
STUDENT’s mother disagreed with the IEP in its entirety. As mentioned above, the District filed for due process hearing on February 22, 2002, and STUDENT cross filed for hearing on March 7, 2002.
POSITION OF THE PARTIES
At the hearing, the District contended that STUDENT is not entitled to an independent assessment at public expense because the District’s assessment was appropriate. The District also argued that STUDENT’s category for special education eligibility should be changed from specific learning disability to mentally retarded. Additionally, the District took the position that STUDENT did not qualify for special education with a speech and language disorder under Cal. Ed. Code § 56333 and C.C.R. § 3030(c) and thus, that the District was not required to provide STUDENT with speech and language services. Finally, the District asserted that regardless of whether STUDENT was eligible for special education services as a child with a specific learning disability or as a child with mental retardation, it appropriately offered to place him in Ms. Kuh’s special day class for mentally retarded students.
As to STUDENT’s position on the first issue, he claimed that he is entitled to an independent educational assessment at public expense because the District’s assessment conducted in April 2001, was not appropriate under Cal. Ed. Code § 56329(b). STUDENT alleged that the standardized test given to his father, STUDENT’s father, which was designed to determine whether STUDENT had severe deficits in two or more adaptive functioning skill areas, was not administered in accordance with the instructions provided by the producers of the tests as required under Cal. Ed. Code § 56320(b)(3). Second, STUDENT contended that his disability should not be categorized as mentally retarded because his general intellectual functioning is not significantly subaverage nor does he have significant limitations in adaptive functioning. Third, STUDENT maintained that his unique needs require that he receive speech and language services for both the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years. Lastly, STUDENT argued that he should not be placed in Ms. Kuh’s special day class because it is designed to provide mentally retarded children with functional skills that are below his level, and it does not address his unique needs, which arise out of a specific learning disability and speech and language disorder.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue Number 1: Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for an independent assessment he obtained in January 2002?
A parent may obtain an independent educational assessment (IEE) performed by a qualified specialist at public expense if (1) the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the educational agency and (2) the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate. 34 C.F.R. § 300.503(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b)
As noted above, the District last assessd STUDENT in April 2001, as part of a triennial assessment. Dr. von Witzleben, the District’s psychologist, administered the assessment, which included the WISC-III, the WIAT, the BASC, and the Vineland. The WISC-III, the WIAT, and the BASC-Self-Report were each administered to STUDENT. The BASC (teacher version) was administered to Ms. Rutzakis, STUDENT’s special day class teacher, and the Vineland was administered to STUDENT’s father. Each of these tests is standardized, and each comes with a set of instructions from the publishers of the test on how to administer and score the tests. The District contends that the educational assessment it administered to STUDENT was appropriate and, thus, the District it is not required to reimburse STUDENT for the independent assessment he obtained from Children’s Hospital, Oakland.
State special education law specifies that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be administered in conformance with test instructions. (Education Code § 56320(b).)
Dr. von Witzleben explained that the Vineland assessment includes several distinct lists of questions relating to a student’s abilities in the areas of daily living skills, socialization, and communication. The test is administered to a parent by having the test-giver ask the student’s parent, in this case STUDENT’s father the questions on the lists. The parent answers each question verbally and the test-giver scores the answer accordingly. If the answer is “no,” the test-giver marks a zero or makes a dash next to the question; if the answer is “sometimes” or “partial,” the test-giver places the numeral one next to the answer; and if the answer is “”yes” or usually,” the test-giver places a numeral two or a check mark next to the question. The test is then scored.
In administering the test, the instructions require that the test giver establish both a basal and ceiling. The test-giver is not required to ask all of the questions on the rather lengthy lists, so a basal and ceiling are established for each list to ensure that all of the pertinent questions in a particular case are asked. In short, the establishment of a basal and ceiling eliminates the need for the test-giver to ask questions relating to things that the student is clearly capable or not capable of doing. To establish the basal, the test instructions require the test-giver to obtain seven consecutive “no” answers at the beginning and end of each list of questions. Thereafter, the person giving the test is not required to ask questions that precede the initial seven “no” answers, nor is he or she required to answer questions that follow seven consecutive “no” answers. Since the questions on each list are organized by the complexity of the task or capability being inquired into, the basal and ceiling allow the test giver to skip questions relating to tasks that the student clearly can or cannot do–i.e., the student can clearly perform tasks that are asked about in questions that precede seven “no” answers, and the student clearly cannot perform tasks that are discussed in questions that follow seven “no” answers. The basal-ceiling scheme set forth in the instructions is designed to ensure that the person giving the test does not fail to ask question that could lead to a positive response. Thus, the test is designed to forego the asking of some questions only after the basal and ceiling are established.
Dr. von Witzleben acknowledged, however, that she did not establish basal and ceiling scores for each list of questions on the Vineland. She did point out that the test instructions also require that the person administering the test engage the person taking the test in conversation in order to better determine the student’s abilities and weaknesses. Accordingly, Dr. von Witzleben took the position that the failure to establish basal and ceiling scores for each list of questions did not skew the results because she essentially obtained the same information through her conversation with STUDENT’s father. However, the test instructions specifically call for the use of both techniques–informal conversation and the setting a basal and ceiling. If it were appropriate to set the basal and ceiling through informal conversation with the person taking the test, it would not be necessary, in fact it would be redundant, to obtain a basal and ceiling via the process described in the test instructions–obtaining seven consecutive no answers at the beginning and end of each list of questions on the test. Moreover, each list includes very specific questions designed to serve a particular purpose. There was no evidence presented at the hearing to indicate that the publishers or designers of the Vineland consider test scores valid if the procedures called for in the test’s instructions are not adhered to.
Additionally, there was substantial confusion as to how the Vineland was actually administered to STUDENT’s father, i.e., how many times did Dr. von Witzleben administer the test; was it administered in English, Spanish, or both; and why were the answers on two separate test protocols different?(Footnote 8) In the District’s case in chief, Dr. von Witzleben appeared confused when she saw two different test protocols, one in English and one in Spanish. She testified that she could not recall why there were two protocols, and she surmised that she must have given the test twice. She recalled that when STUDENT’s father began to speak, he said that he preferred to take the test in English. Dr. von Witzleben testified that she must have administered the test in both languages. When called by the District on rebuttal, Dr. von Witzleben testified that she now recalled she only gave the test once in English. She surmised that she copied the scores from the English protocol to the Spanish protocol and, in so doing, transposed a number. However, Dr. von Witzleben did not appear to have a clear recollection as to why there were two protocols and why the scores on each of them were not exactly the same. Moreover, she did not offer an explanation as to why she would have copied the responses that STUDENT’s father gave in English, which were initially recorded on an English language protocol, onto a Spanish protocol. Thus, in addition to the fact that the Vineland was not administered in conformance with test instructions as required under Education Code §§ 56320(b), there is sufficient evidence to cast doubt as to whether the test was otherwise administered appropriately to STUDENT’s father. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer cannot give any weight to the Vineland test administered by the District since there is no way of knowing which, if any, of the test protocols accurately reflect STUDENT’s father’s answers to the test questions.
In this case, whether or not the Vineland was correctly administered to STUDENT’s father is critical to determining whether the District’s assessment is appropriate. According to the District, a diagnosis of mental retardation requires a finding that STUDENT’s general intellectual functioning is significantly subaverage and is accompanied by significant limitations in adaptive functioning in at least two skill areas. The District took the position that STUDENT exhibited severe deficits in two areas of adaptive functioning–social skills and daily living skills. Dr. von Witzleben testified that in her expert opinion STUDENT was mildly to moderately mentally retarded. As part of her assessment, Dr. von Witzleben specifically utilized the Vineland to assess STUDENT’s deficits in the area of functional academics (daily living skills) and social skills. The Vineland was the testing instrument selected by the District to assess STUDENT’s abilities in this area. In order for the results to be valid, it is critical that the test be administered and scored correctly, i.e., the test must be administered in conformance with test instructions. (See Education Code § 56320(b).)
Therefore, because the Vineland was not administered in conformance with the test instructions, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessment was not appropriate.
The District argues, however, that even if its assessment was not appropriate, STUDENT is not entitled to reimbursement for his independent assessment. According to the District, the independent assessment administered by the Petersons were duplicative of those given by the District, and the Petersons administered a neuropsychological assessment when only a pschoeducational assessment was called for. The District also maintains that the Petersons did not administer all of their assessments appropriately. For these reasons, the District contends that it is not required to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for their independent assessment.
As set forth above, special education law states that a parent may obtain an independent educational assessment from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the District’s assessment and the District is unable to show at a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate. (See 34 C.F.R. § 300.503(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).) In this case, STUDENT’s parents disagreed with the District’s assessment and the District, for the reasons discussed above, was unable to show at the due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate. The statute and regulations do not place any additional requirements on the right of STUDENT’s parents to obtain an independent educational assessment at public expense (Footnote 9). Therefore, STUDENT’s independent assessment must be provided at public expense.(Footnote 10)
Issue Number 2: Should STUDENT’s eligibility category for special education be changed from specific learning disability to mental retardation?
Federal law provides that children who are mentally retarded qualify for special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i).) Special education law does not provide specific guidance on how to determine whether a pupil is mentally retarded; however, the Diagnostic and Statistical Manuel of Mental Disorders (DSM IV), which relies on the definition provided by the American Association of Mental Retardation (AAMR) for its definition, is the standard source used by professionals in the field for determining whether a person is mentally retarded. Indeed, the Hearing Office has given the DSM IV substantial weight in the past when deciding whether a student was mentally retarded. The parties agreed that in this case the DSM IV included the appropriate standard for determining whether STUDENT is mentally retarded. The DSM IV states that “the essential feature of mental retardation is significantly subaverage general intellectual functioning that is accompanied by significant limitations in adaptive functioning in at least two [of ten] skill areas.” (Student Ex. 541) The DSM IV states that the general intellectual functioning is defined by the intelligence quotient (IQ) obtained by assessment with one or more standardized tests (including the WISC-III) where the person has an “IQ of about 70 or below.” The DSM IV notes that “there is a measurement error of approximately 5 points in assessing IQ, although this may vary instrument to instrument (e.g., a [WISC-III] IQ of 70 is considered to represent a range of 65-75).”
The District asserts that STUDENT is mentally retarded because his WISC-III full scale IQ is 62 and he has significant limitations in adaptive functioning in two of ten skill areas–functional academic skills and social/interpersonal skills. Dr. von Witzleben testified that STUDENT’s WISC-III full scale IQ score of 62 accurately reflects his general intellectual functioning because it takes into account his strengths and weaknesses.(Footnote 11) Dr. von Witzleben explained that mentally retarded persons will exhibit both strengths and weaknesses on the various subtests.
Conversely, the gist of the Petersons’ report and their testimony at hearing was that STUDENT’s full scale IQ score was skewed by a “language-based learning disability.”(Footnote 12) The WISC-III was also included in the assessment that the Petersons administered to STUDENT. In their WISC-III test, STUDENT received a full scale IQ score similar to that obtained by Dr. von Witzleben–a 65. On the Petersons’ WISC-III test, STUDENT received a verbal IQ score of 56 and a performance IQ score of 79. Additionally, the Petersons noted that STUDENT’s IQ score was even higher, a score of 85, when the test’s perceptual test index was considered.(Footnote 13) Both of these scores are above 70, which is considered the IQ demarcation for mental retardation. The Petersons pointed out that STUDENT had consistently been diagnosed with an auditory processing disorder throughout his years in special education and that his verbal IQ scores were lower than his performance scores. Moreover, his verbal IQ score consistently decreased over the years. Additionally, the Petersons noted that STUDENT had severe language-based disabilities. For example, as will be discussed in more detail below, STUDENT’s total language score on the CELF-3 tests administered by the District was in the first percentile, his receptive language score was also in the first percentile, and his expressive language score was in the second percentile.(Footnote 14) These results were also similar to those found by the Petersons in their language assessment. Thus, the Petersons opined, if these factors--deficits in language and processing–are taken into account, STUDENT’s general intellectual functioning falls in the low average range and is not consistent with a mentally retarded child. Dr. von Witzleben also testified that if STUDENT had language impairments, such impairments could adversely affect STUDENT’s verbal score on the WISC-III and, thus, by extension, affect his full scale IQ score.(Footnote 15)
Indeed, the DSM IV specifies that “the choice of testing instruments and interpretation of results should take into account factors that may limit test performance (e.g., ...communicative ... handicaps).” In this case, when STUDENT’s language deficits and audio processing disorder are taken into account, the evidence supports a finding that his general intellectual functioning falls within the low-average range and is not consistent with a child who is mentally retarded.
Notwithstanding STUDENT’s general intellectual functioning, the parties (and the DSM IV) concur that STUDENT cannot be diagnosed as mentally retarded unless he has significant limitations in adaptive functioning in at least two [of ten] skill areas. In this case, the District alleged that STUDENT has significant limitations in the areas of functional academic skills and social/interpersonal skills. Dr. von Witzleben explained that functional academic skills are those skills required to function in society. She testified that examples of functional academic skills include reading signs and traffic signs, following recipes, traveling by bus, applying and interviewing for jobs, finding movie listings in a newspaper, and make change at a store. She defined social/interpersonal skills as functioioning in a social setting. Dr. von Witzleben said that introducing one’s self, asking questions, and interacting or conversing with peers are examples of social skills. She agreed, however, that there is a distinction between “significant limitations” in adaptive functioning and a lack of willingness to function appropriately in various situations. She explained that the relevant question is whether the student has had an opportunity to acquire a particular skill and, if so, does he choose to use it. In STUDENT’s case, Dr. von Witzleben believed that the test results on the Vineland and information provided by STUDENT’s teachers and other IEP team members supported her contention that STUDENT had severe limitations in these two areas of adaptive functioning. However, for the reasons discussed above, the Vineland administered by the District cannot be relied on to accurately assess STUDENT’s adaptive functioning skills. However, notwithstanding the question of whether the Vineland was properly administered and scored, Dr. von Witzleben agreed that the assessment test scores themselves do not determine whether STUDENT had severe limitations in social skills and functional academics; rather, the determinative factor is whether STUDENT in fact has such limitations. In this regard, Dr. von Witzleben testified that the purpose of administering the Vineland was to assess STUDENT’s adaptive functioning. She specifically testified during the District’s case in chief that for STUDENT to be diagnosed as mentally retarded, his functional abilities outside the school setting needed to be assessed. She added that STUDENT’s “life skills” had to be determined. Indeed, this was the very reason that the Vineland was given to STUDENT’s father. Dr. von Witzleben also stated that it was important to consider the observations of STUDENT’s teachers, school personnel, and other members of the IEP team to obtain an accurate picture of STUDENT’s adaptive functioning skills.
In this regard, STUDENT’s mother testified at length regarding STUDENT’s abilities in the areas of social skills and functional academics. She described in great detail STUDENT’s numerous relationships with age-appropriate friends, none of whom were in special education, his ability to appropriately converse with his friends and engage with them in acceptable social activities, his ability to shop by himself,(Footnote 16) ride city buses, plan and go to the movies with friends and his sister, to attend and appropriately participate in church; to attend and socialize at a large formal social gathering, and to appropriately interact with family members.
On the same subject, STUDENT’s special day class teacher, Ms. Rutzakis, described how STUDENT engaged in minor misbehavior, mostly relating to attendance problems, leaving class or school without permission, and off-task behaviors. She specifically explained that STUDENT generally engaged in these behaviors when he was frustrated in situations in which “the complexity of a problem got beyond him.” Ms. Rutzakis testified that in her observation there was a definite relationship between STUDENT’s frustration arising out of the complexity of a problem and his inability to maintain his attention to an issue. Ms. Rutzakis also gave some examples of STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior in social settings. She described how on occasion STUDENT would interrupt her teaching by asking permission to use the restroom. On other occasions, she said that STUDENT would touch another boy’s shoulder or knee if he were excited about something and he was trying to draw that person’s attention to the event or thing that excited him. Ms. Rutzakis considered STUDENT’s behavior socially unacceptable because teenage boys, particularly the ones who are gang members, do not want to be touched no matter how innocent or unoffensive the touching. Some boys, she said, responded by saying, “don’t touch me. Are you gay?” Ms. Rutzakis considered STUDENT’s conduct, rather than the other boys’ responses, to be socially unacceptable. She also described an incident where STUDENT and other students were waiting to take a test and STUDENT accidently passed gas. Other students began laughing and STUDENT joined in. Ms. Rutzakis then moved STUDENT from the group, and he continued to act out, including intentionally passing gas to get the other students to respond. Ms. Rutzakis was of the opinion that STUDENT engaged in this conduct to cover for his embarrassment at initially passing gas and as a calculated means to avoid taking the test, which she believed was difficult for STUDENT.
However, Ms. Rutzakis also believed that STUDENT could read a bus schedule and utilize public transportation if the schedule were explained to him. Similarly, she believed he could find, apply, and interview for a job if he were shown how. Ms. Rutzakis stated that STUDENT had friends at school, that she observed him conversing with peers, and that he expressed an interest in being a fireman and playing football. She further described how STUDENT had taken appropriate steps to follow up on achieving those goals. Additionally, Ms. Rutzakis testified that for the most part STUDENT is kind to other children, he can carry on conversations with both his friends and his teachers, and he can change subjects and switch topics in a conversation as people ordinarily do. Ms. Rutzakis stated that she believed that STUDENT “knows what he is doing.” “I don’t think he is clueless,” she added.
Therefore, although Ms. Rutzakis observed STUDENT to engage in inappropriate behavior, she believed that by and large it was willful, that it served a communicative purpose–notably, to express frustration or to avoid work when the work became too difficult for him. Otherwise, Ms. Rutzakis’s observations of STUDENT’s social and functional academic skills were not inconsistent with that of STUDENT’s mother. Furthermore, although Dr. von Witzleben observed that all of STUDENT’s teachers and members of his IEP team would be the best source of information to determine whether STUDENT had significant limitations in his adaptive functioning skills, no other witness came forward to provide such information. In short, the evidence indicates that STUDENT is not “severely limited” in his adaptive functioning skills.(Footnote 17) However, STUDENT clearly has some limitations that need to be addressed in his educational program.
Accordingly, Hearing Officer finds that the evidence relating to STUDENT’s general intellectual functioning and his adaptive functioning does not support a finding that he is mentally retarded.
Issue Number 3: Was the District required to provide STUDENT with speech and language services for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years?
STUDENT contends that the District failed to provide him with FAPE for both the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years by not providing him with speech and language services. The District argued that STUDENT’s speech and language assessment revealed that he did not qualify for speech and language services because he did not demonstrate a significant discrepancy between his intellectual functioning and the standardized scores that he received on speech and language assessments, as required by Cal. Ed. Code § 56333 and C.C.R. § 3030(c). In arguing that STUDENT cannot qualify for speech and language services unless he meets the criteria for a speech or language disorder as set forth under Cal. Ed. Code § 56333 and C.C.R. § 3030(c), the District has taken an incorrect legal position.
California law specifies that a local educational agency must provide a special education student with those related services that are required for the child to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. The first service identified under the governing statute–Cal. Ed. Code § 56363–is speech and language services. There is no requirement under the law that a student who is otherwise eligible for special education must also meet the eligibility criteria under Cal. Ed. Code § 56333 and C.C.R. § 3030(c) before his or her need for speech and language services can be established. In short, eligibility for special education under Cal. Ed. Code § 56333 and C.C.R. § 3030(c) is not the determinative factor as to whether a student needs speech and language services. Education Code, section 56363, in its pertinent part, reads:
(a) Designated instruction and services as specified in the individualized education program shall be available when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. The instruction and services shall be provided by the regular class teacher, the special class teacher, or the resource specialist if the teacher or specialist is competent to provide the instruction and services and if the provision of the instruction and services by the teacher or specialist is feasible. If not, the appropriate designated instruction and services specialist shall provide the instruction and services. Designated instruction and services shall meet standards adopted by the board.
(b) These services may include, but are not limited to, the following:
(1) Language and speech development and remediation. The language and speech development and remediation services may be provided by a speech-language pathology assistant as defined in subdivision (f) of Section 2530.2 of the Business and Professions Code.
Thus, the relevant inquiry for the Hearing Officer is to ascertain whether STUDENT’s needs required him to receive speech and language services. To that end, the Hearing Officer looks to the two speech and language assessments administered by the District in 2000 and 2002 and the analysis of those assessment results provided by the tests’ administrators, Ms. Bye and Ms. Farrer. First, STUDENT’s speech and language assessment results indicated that he had severe deficits in the areas of expressive and receptive language. In 2000, STUDENT was administered the CELF-3 and the Test of Adolescent Word Finding, which are both standardized tests. These assessments revealed that STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language scores were within the first percentile. In 2002, two standardized speech and language assessment tests–the CELF-3 and the Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test–revealed that STUDENT’s receptive language scores were at the first percentile and his expressive language scores were at the second percentile.
Second, Ms. Bye, in her 2000 speech and language assessment report, recorded that STUDENT’s language skills were comparable to those of a five-year, six-month-old child. In her report, Ms. Bye recorded that STUDENT “lacks the basic foundations of content and form that characterize mature language use: word meanings (semantics), word and sentence structure (morphology and syntax), as well as recall and retrieval of spoken language (memory).” Ms. Bye added that STUDENT had received speech and language support since November 1993, but “on standardized tests his standard scores have decreased as his age has increased.” Additionally, in her 2002 report, Ms. Farrer reported that STUDENT “exhibits severe receptive and expressive language delays, with relative weaknesses in the areas of following oral directions, vocabulary, and memory for detail.”
Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s severe language deficits require that he receive speech and language services.
Moreover, it is worth noting that although STUDENT is not necessarily required to meet the criteria for special education eligibility under Cal. Ed. Code § 56333 and C.C.R. § 3030(c), he in fact does. California Education Code, section 56333, states in pertinent part:
A pupil shall be assessed as having a language or speech disorder which makes him or her eligible for special education and related services when he or she demonstrates difficulty understanding or using spoken language to such an extent that it adversely affects his or her educational performance and cannot be corrected without special education and related services. In order to be eligible for special education and related services, difficulty in understanding or using spoken language shall be assessed by a language, speech, and hearing specialist who determines that such difficulty results from any of the following disorders:
(d) Inappropriate or inadequate acquisition, comprehension, or expression of spoken language such that the pupil's language performance level is found to be significantly below the language performance level of his or her peers.
Under the California’s Code of Regulations, a student is eligible for special education services if he or she has a language disorder. The pupil has an expressive or receptive language disorder when he or she meets one of the following criteria:
The pupil scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean, or below the 7th percentile, for his or her chronological age or developmental level on two or more standardized tests in one or more of the following areas of language development: morphology, syntax, semantics, or pragmatics. When standardized tests are considered to be invalid for the specific pupil, the expected language performance level shall be determined by alternative means as specified on the assessment plan. (Emphasis added.)
In this case, there is no question that STUDENT scored below the seventh percentile on two or more standard speech and language assessments tests in both 2000 and 2002. (See District Exhibits 2 and 18.) As discussed above, in both 2000 and 2002, STUDENT scored below the seventh percentile on two standardized tests that assess one or more of the following areas: morphology, syntax, semantics, or pragmatics. Therefore, because STUDENT scored below the seventh percentile on two or more standardized speech and language tests, he is also eligible for special education as a child with a language impairment under C.C.R. § 3030(c)(4)(A).
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT clearly needed and qualified for speech and language services in both the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years.
Issue Number 4: Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the February 2002 IEP meetings?
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) A free appropriate public education is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student’s unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), (25). Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56303(a).) The United States Supreme Court has held that special education and related services must be individually designed to provide educational benefit to a handicapped child. (Hendrick Hudson Dist. Bd. of Educ. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 201.) California law also states that the specific special education instruction and related services are to be provided in order to assist the student in advancing appropriately toward attaining his learning goals and objectives. (Cal. Ed. Code § 56345(a)(3).)
Therefore, to determine whether STUDENT received a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, the Hearing Officer must determine his needs and then ascertain whether the program offered by the District appropriately addressed those needs.
Other than STUDENT’s speech and language needs, which are discussed in more detail above, there was virtually no disagreement between the parties regarding the balance of STUDENT’s needs. First, STUDENT has significant deficits in all academic areas. In February 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team reported that academically STUDENT performed at a second to third grade level. According to his IEP, STUDENT’s written composition skills were at a second grade level and he was reading at a third grade level. His math and number skills were also at a third grade level. The team noted that STUDENT had made little progress in the area of academics since early elementary school. Dr. von Witzleben also reported that STUDENT was significantly delayed in his academic achievements. Second, the parties and STUDENT’s IEP team agreed that he needed to increase his functional academic and pre-vocational skills. Third, the parties generally agreed that STUDENT exhibited behavior problems relating to attendance, timeliness, attention, and focus. Finally, as noted above, while the parties did not agree as to STUDENT’s speech and language needs, the Hearing Officer found in issue number three above that STUDENT has significant needs in the areas of expressive and receptive language.
To address his needs, STUDENT’s IEP team drafted three goals (with measurable objectives), a transition plan, and a behavior plan. STUDENT’s goals and objectives were in the area of language arts, math, and behavior. In the area of language arts, the IEP team drafted one goal for STUDENT that called for him to read a passage written at the third grade level at a rate of 60 words per minute with 90% accuracy, and to answer oral and written questions about the passage with 90% accuracy. The team designed one math goal for STUDENT that required him to solve a set of multi-digit multiplication and division problems with 90% accuracy. In the area of behavior, STUDENT was given a goal to attend school and arrive to every class with the appropriate class materials, including his completed homework. STUDENT’s transition plan called for him to receive a vocational aptitude assessment, research vocational training options, obtain a work permit, learn the rules and procedures necessary to utilize public transit, establish positive attendance habits, complete a job application, and obtain a social security number. STUDENT’s Behavior Intervention Plan observed that noncompliant behaviors were a result of his difficulties with understanding or carrying out commands. The IEP team drafted a behavior goal calling for STUDENT to ask for clarification of a command or assistance in complying with the command when he is unsure how to comply with directions or when he exhibits anxiety as a result of his not understanding. Because the District had taken the position that STUDENT did not need speech and language services, the IEP team did not draft any goals in this area.
STUDENT contends that the goals and objectives proposed by the District were inappropriate to meet his needs. However, other than speech and language, which was addressed above, STUDENT only presented evidence to support a finding that his language arts goals were inappropriate. As noted above, the parties agreed that STUDENT was significantly delayed in the area of language arts, including reading and written composition. However, STUDENT’s language arts goals only address his reading deficits and did not mention his written language needs. Ms. Rutzakis testified that STUDENT had written language needs, including grammar, sentence structure, spelling, and vocabulary. She also stated that STUDENT’s program should address this area, yet no goals were proposed to address these needs.(Footnote 18) Thus, STUDENT’s goals and objectives were inappropriate because they did not include goals and objectives for written language, nor did they include speech and language goals to address his deficits in expressive and receptive language.
The focus of the parties’ dispute related to his placement. The District proposed to place STUDENT in Ms. Kuh’s special day class for 196 minutes (approximately 3 hours and 15 minutes) each day, five days a week, at the District’s Alisal High School. The District’s offer also anticipated that STUDENT would select elective courses in the general education program to fill the balance of his school day. The District also offered to provide STUDENT with two 30-minute counseling sessions each week with the school psychologist. Additionally, the IEP team proposed to refer STUDENT for a mental health assessment. Again, no speech and language services were offered to address STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language deficits.(Footnote 19)
The District contends that Ms. Kuh’s special day class is the appropriate placement for STUDENT even if the evidence does not support a finding that he is mentally retarded. Ms. Kuh’s special day class includes 11 students, all of whom have been diagnosed as mentally retarded. Dr. von Witzleben and Ms. Rutzakis testified that Ms. Kuh’s special day class for mentally retarded children will provide STUDENT with structure, as well as furnish him with an opportunity to address his functional academic needs. Ms. Kuh testified that she could also provide STUDENT with an individualized academic program to address his deficits in those areas.
STUDENT takes the position that Ms. Kuh’s special day class is not the appropriate placement for him. In support of his position, the Petersons both credibly testified that the nature or source of STUDENT’s impairment is different from that of students who are mentally retarded. STUDENT’s cognitive abilities, they explained, are low-average, and he has a language disorder. In contrast, the pupils in Ms. Kuh’s special day class, by virtue of the fact that they have been diagnosed as mentally retarded, have lower intellectual functioning combined with severe limitations in adaptive functioning. The Petersons explained that STUDENT’s needs are markedly different from those of mentally retarded children. Specifically, children who are mentally retarded typically focus on adaptive functioning skills. STUDENT, however, has a specific learning disability that involves an audio processing disorder–a learning disability that co-exists with a speech and language deficit as well. The Petersons asserted that STUDENT requires a placement that focuses primarily on learning and language disabilities. They believed that STUDENT requires an educational placement in which his instruction is designed and delivered in a way to accommodate students with needs similar to his. The Hearing Officer finds the Petersons’ testimony to be persuasive and supported by both the Petersons’ and the District’s psychoeducational and speech and language assessments, each of which revealed aspects of STUDENT’s language impairments.
Ms. Kuh testified that her special day class is indeed specifically designed for mentally retarded children and that her curriculum emphasizes adaptive functioning and social skills training for these children. As the District explained, the essential feature of mental retardation is significantly subaverage general intellectual functioning that is accompanied by significant limitations in adaptive functioning in at least two [of ten] skill areas. Ms. Kuh’s class is tailored to serve children with these needs. But STUDENT’s needs are markedly different. Rather than being mentally retarded, STUDENT has a specific learning disability arising out of an audio processing disorder and a severe language disorder. Thus, STUDENT requires a placement that is designed to meet his unique needs. To that end, the evidence indicates that STUDENT needs a highly structured placement that is formulated to address his learning and language disabilities.(Footnote 20) Moreover, because STUDENT, unlike the mentally retarded students in Ms. Kuh’s class, does not exhibit significant limitations in adaptive functioning, he should not be placed in a class that is designed primarily to address such deficits.(Footnote 21) Finally, because STUDENT’s disability is qualitatively different from that of mentally retarded children, and because one of the essential features of mental retardation involves significant limitations in adaptive functioning, it is not appropriate to place STUDENT in a class primarily serving mentally retarded children. Such a class is not likely to provide STUDENT, a 16-year-old teenager, with social peers and role models.
Therefore, because Ms. Kuh’s special day class is designed to serve mentally retarded children and not students with specific learning disabilities and language disorders, her class is not the appropriate placement for STUDENT. Rather, STUDENT requires a special day class designed to serve students with significant specific learning disabilities and language disorders.
Therefore, the program offered by the District at the February 2002 IEP meetings did not constitute a FAPE.(Footnote 22)
Remedy
At hearing, STUDENT requested reimbursement for the independent assessment he obtained from Children’s Hospital in Oakland. Additionally, STUDENT requested that if the Hearing Officer determined that the District’s February 2002 offer did not constitute a FAPE, the Hearing Officer should order an IEP meeting be convened to determine the appropriate program for STUDENT. Additionally, STUDENT requested that if the Hearing Officer determined that the District should have provided him speech and language services for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, the Hearing Officer should order the District to provide him with compensatory education for those services not provided. Rather than specify a particular program for compensatory speech and language services at the hearing, STUDENT requested the Hearing Officer to order the IEP team to establish appropriate compensatory speech and language services in light of his needs and deficits. Although the District contested STUDENT’s underlying claims regarding a FAPE and speech and language services, it did not contend that if the Hearing Officer found in STUDENT’s favor on those claims that the remedy sought by STUDENT was inappropriate. Therefore, the Hearing Officer orders the following:
ORDER
1. Within 20 calendar days of presenting invoices, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents and/or pay the costs they actually incurred for the independent assessment they obtained from the Children’s Hospital in Oakland, California.
2. Within 20 days of the date of this order, STUDENT’s IEP team shall convene and, consistent with findings of fact included in this order, determine the appropriate educational program for STUDENT. Additionally, the IEP team shall determine the appropriate compensatory speech and language services to be provided to STUDENT in addition to those speech and language services otherwise required for his program. In determining the appropriate compensatory speech and language services for STUDENT, the IEP team shall consider that the fact that the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT was inappropriately denied speech and language services for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years. In determining STUDENT’s compensatory education for speech and language services, the IEP team shall take into account STUDENT’s ability to receive all of the compensatory services before February 2003, or whether, in light of his needs, those services should be spread over a greater period of time.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statue:
1. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for an independent assessment he obtained in January 2002? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
2. Should STUDENT’s eligibility category for special education be changed from specific learning disability to mental retardation? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
3. Was the District required to provide STUDENT with speech and language services for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
4. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the February 2002 IEP meetings? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties in this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)
Date: June 27, 2002 Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. After the first day of hearing, STUDENT’s mother informed the Hearing Officer that it would be more useful to her if Ms. Gutierrez only interpreted those English words that she did not understand. All of the parties at the hearing agreed to this procedure. 2. The parties did not disagree that STUDENT should receive special education services, nor did the District dispute the fact that STUDENT qualified for special education as a child with a specific learning disability at the time it proposed to change his eligibility to mentally retarded. Thus, the question is whether the evidence supports the District’s contention that STUDENT is eligible for special education as a child with mental retardation. 3. At the hearing, STUDENT specifically stated that for the 2000-2001 school year, only speech and language services were at issue. The parties did not litigate other aspects of STUDENT’s program for that school year. 4. The February 2002 IEP indicated that the program and services the District offered STUDENT would begin on February 19, 2002, and the next IEP would be held February 4, 2003. Therefore, the question of FAPE covers the period of time between February 2002 and February 2003. 5. According to Dr. von Witzleben report, standardized scores correlate to categories set out by the tests publishers that are titled “clinically significant,” “at-risk,” and “average.” 6. The assessors retained by STUDENT were not on the District’s list of proposed assessors, and the District did not agree to Children’s Hospital conducting the assessment. 7. Doctors Peterson and Peterson were not related.
8. A careful examination of the two protocols in question reveals a number of discrepancies. For example, on the English version questions 23 and 27 are checked with a positive response, while the Spanish version has no markings next to those questions. Also, question number 53 on the English version is marked with a dash (i.e., a zero score), while question 53 on the Spanish version has a score of one. Additionally, questions 34 and 35 on the Spanish version are not marked at all, while both those questions receive a check mark on the English version. These are only a few of the discrepancies that appear on the face of the protocols. Furthermore, the score totals at the bottom of each page are different on the two protocols. Interestingly enough, the protocols do not appear the same on their face. The same questions do not appear on the same page of each of the protocols. Since one of the protocols is in Spanish, the Hearing Officer cannot determine whether the questions are identical. The District did not introduce evidence to confirm that the two protocols, which appear different on their face, in fact contain identical information. The fact that the protocols appear different–aside from the difference in language–are scored differently, and contain contradictory responses to individual question, raises significant questions as to their validity. 9. Although the District alleged that the independent assessment obtained by STUDENT was a neuropsychological examination and not an educational assessment, in fact, the assessment performed by the Petersons employed virtually the same assessment instruments as those commonly utilized in educational assessments. 10. Although STUDENT initially had also requested reimbursement for the services of an “educational consultant,” he neither contended nor presented evidence that the consultant, Ms. Marian Bodin, was either a “qualified specialist” or that she conducted an “independent educational assessment” under 34 C. F. R. § 300.503(b) or Cal. Ed. Code § 56329(b). Because STUDENT neither maintained nor presented evidence that Ms. Bodin provided him with an independent educational assessment within the meaning of 34 C. F. R. § 300.503(b) or Cal. Ed. Code § 56329(b), her services cannot be considered for reimbursement. 11. As noted above, on the WISC-III STUDENT also received a verbal scale score of 59 and a performance scale score of 70. 12. While witnesses for the District expressed much confusion over the term “language based learning disability,” it was clear from the Petersons’ use of the term that they were referring to a specific learning disability that involved processing disorders that affected receptive and expressive language. 13. The perceptual index is obtained by removing two subtests–coding and symbol serach–from the performance scale, since those subtests also involve some degree of verbal skills. 14. Additionally, for the reasons that will be discussed below, STUDENT’s scores on his speech and language assessment independently qualified him for special education in that category. 15. Dr. von Witzleben was at a disadvantage in making her diagnosis because, as she said, she was not a speech and language expert. She had to rely on the District’s speech and language therapists for their assessment of STUDENT’s impairments in this area. And, for the reasons that will become clear in the analysis below, the District was incorrect in not believing that STUDENT has a speech and language impairment as defined under C.C.R. § 3030(c). Therefore, Dr. von Witzleben was not armed with sufficient information as to STUDENT’s deficits to be able to take them into account when she interpreted her WISC-III test scores. 16. Indeed, Ms. Rutzakis testified that on one occasion she also observed STUDENT walking to the store. 17. Although Ms. Rutzakis believed that STUDENT needed and would benefit from functional academics, such as reading a bus schedule or applying for jobs, she did not suggest that he had some inherent limitation on his ability to do so. To the contrary, she stated that she believed that STUDENT could perform these tasks if he were shown how, which is consistent with the way much of the rest of the world learns. 18. Because STUDENT’s needs required him to receive speech and language services as a result of severe deficits in the areas of expressive and receptive language, the District should also have designed goals to address these deficits as well. 19. Speech and language services were addressed in section three above. 20. As a remedy for his claim that the District did not provide him with a FAPE, STUDENT did not request a particular remedy. Instead, he requested that the Hearing Officer order an IEP meeting to determine the appropriate program to address STUDENT’s present needs and remediate any past denials of FAPE. Therefore, other than a small, structured class setting, the parties did not present sufficient evidence to establish the other essential features that STUDENT’s program requires. For example, the parties did not specify an appropriate range for the teacher-student ratio in STUDENT’s placement, the use of a classroom aide, or what specific classes (electives), if any, are appropriate for STUDENT to attend in the general education program. These and other aspects of STUDENT’s program must be considered by the IEP team. 21. This does not, however, imply that STUDENT does not have some deficits in adaptive functioning that must be addressed in his educational program. 22. Although STUDENT argued he should be provided with compensatory (or remedial) education as a result of the District not offering FAPE, he did not contend or present evidence to support a finding that the program STUDENT actually participated in–Ms. Rutzakis’s special day class–denied him a FAPE.
