California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 21, 2003

Student v. Saddleback Valley Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 517A-03, SN03-00517A · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown

Saddleback Valley Unified prevails: student's loss of International Baccalaureate diploma eligibility was not a disciplinary change of placement.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Bifurcated case. This expedited decision (SN03-00517A) follows an oral ruling read on the record on April 4, 2003. The non-expedited eligibility and FAPE claims were assigned SN03-00517B and set for hearing beginning May 29, 2003. An earlier prehearing stay put motion was denied on March 26, 2003.

Summary

A 17-year-old senior at Mission Viejo High School asked for a "stay put" order to keep her in the school's International Baccalaureate (IB) diploma program. She had never been found eligible for special education. In February 2003 she was placed on an attendance contract. On March 13 she was suspended for two days and briefly dropped from her classes. The District put her back in all of her classes by March 20. On March 28, IB coordinator Dr. Jerome Chris told her she could no longer earn the IB diploma because she had not turned in her required 4,000-word essay. The student argued that losing the IB program was a disciplinary change of placement lasting more than ten days. If so, she could claim discipline protections as a student the District had reason to know had a disability. The parties agreed to hear her eligibility and FAPE claims separately after an assessment was done. The Hearing Officer found no disciplinary change of placement. The essays had to be mailed by March 7, before the suspension, so the suspension did not cause her to miss the deadline. The IB Board in Geneva, not the District, decides who meets IB requirements, and the District could not reinstate her. Because there was no disciplinary change of placement, the Hearing Officer did not decide whether the District had "basis of knowledge" of a disability. The stay put request was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled discipline protections under the 1997 IDEA for a student not yet found eligible. These protections applied only if a disciplinary removal lasted more than ten days. Losing a program because of academic deadlines, or because of rules set by an outside organization, was not treated as part of the District's discipline.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 1. Did Student's removal from the International Baccalaureate (IB) program constitute a disciplinary change of placement pursuant to 34 C.F.R. section 300.519?

    Loss of IB diploma eligibility resulted from missing the essay mailing deadline, not from the two-day suspension, and was controlled by the IB Board, not the District; it was not a disciplinary change of placement.

  2. Not reachedDiscipline

    Issue 2. If the District subjected Student to a disciplinary change of placement, did the District have a basis of knowledge in March 2003 that Student was a student with a disability pursuant to 34 C.F.R. section 300.527(b)?

    Not reached because no disciplinary change of placement of more than ten days occurred.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Petitioner's request for stay put in the IB program denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8); 34 C.F.R. § 300.519; 34 C.F.R. § 300.527; Cal. Education Code § 56505(d)

People named in the decision

  • Timothy Vargish, history/government teacher, Mission Viejo High School
  • Jerome Chris, Ed.D., humanities teacher and International Baccalaureate coordinator, Mission Viejo High School
  • Stephen Workman, assistant principal, Mission Viejo High School
  • Troy Roelen, English teacher and IB advisor, Mission Viejo High School
  • Ron Osimi, student's IB advisor, Mission Viejo High School
  • Rona Martin, special education director, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Robert White, SELPA director, South Orange County SELPA
  • David Larsen, attorney for the District (correspondence), Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Vikki Rice, advocate for Student
  • Rodney Ford, advocate for Student

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on April 3 and 4, 2003, in Mission Viejo, California, before Suzanne Brown, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Tania Whiteleather. Present on STUDENT’s behalf were advocate Vikki Rice, STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, and STUDENT herself. Additionally, advocate Rodney Ford was present for a portion of the second day of hearing.

Respondent Saddleback Valley Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Dan Harbottle. Present on the District’s behalf were District special education director Rona Martin, and South Orange County SELPA director Robert White.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Timothy Vargish, history/government teacher at the District’s Mission Valley High School (MVHS); Jerome Chris, Ed.D, humanities teacher and International Baccalaureate (IB) coordinator at MVHS; STUDENT, Petitioner; MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother; Stephen Workman, MVHS assistant principal; and Troy Roelen, MVHS English teacher and IB advisor. The District examined these witnesses but did not call any additional witnesses. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties delivered oral closing arguments at the hearing on April 4, 2003, and on that date the matter was submitted for decision.(Footnote 2)

ISSUES

(1) Did STUDENT’s removal from the International Baccalaureate (IB) program constitute a disciplinary change of placement pursuant to 34 C.F.R. section 300.519?

(2) If the District subjected STUDENT to a disciplinary change of placement, did the District have a basis of knowledge in March 2003 that STUDENT was a student with a disability pursuant to 34 C.F.R. section 300.527(b)?

PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

On March 19, 2003, the Hearing Office received from Petitioner a written motion requesting stay put at her educational placement at the District’s Mission Viejo High School (MVHS). On March 25, 2003, the Hearing Office received the District’s opposition to the stay put motion. The opposition argued that Petitioner was not entitled to stay put because Petitioner had never been found eligible for special education and because she had returned to her placement at MVHS. Also on March 25, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s response to the District’s opposition to the stay put motion. In that response, Petitioner argued that the District had a basis of knowledge that she was a student with a disability, and that she was not permitted to attend some portions of her educational placement at MVHS. In an order dated March 26, 2003, the Hearing Office denied Petitioner’s motion for stay put on the ground that an evidentiary hearing was required to determine whether the District had the requisite basis of knowledge that Petitioner was a student with a disability.

In a written motion dated April 1, 2003, the District argued in part that this case should no longer be scheduled as an expedited hearing because “Petitioner is not in danger of being expelled from her program, and is currently attending her classes at Mission Viejo High School.” Petitioner responded to this motion verbally during a prehearing telephone conference in this matter on April 2, 2003. Petitioner argued that she was still being subjected to a disciplinary change of placement because of her removal from the International Baccalaureate (IB) program. The District responded that it was not the entity that had removed STUDENT from the IB program, nor did it have authority to reinstate STUDENT into the program.

After further discussions during the prehearing conference, it appeared that two expedited issues existed: (1) whether Petitioner’s removal from the International Baccalaureate (IB) program constituted a disciplinary change of placement and (2) if so, whether the District had a basis of knowledge that Petitioner was a student with a disability pursuant to federal law. The District reiterated its request to dismiss the expedited issues on the ground that it had no authority to reinstate STUDENT in the IB program. In a subsequent minute order, the Hearing Officer denied the motion on the ground that whether the District had control over Petitioner’s removal from the IB program was a question of fact which required an evidentiary determination.

Also during the telephone conference, Petitioner’s attorney indicated that Petitioner’s mother had recently signed her consent to an assessment plan designed to evaluate Petitioner’s eligibility for special education. No special education assessment of Petitioner had ever been conducted. In light of these facts, both parties agreed that the determination of Petitioner’s eligibility and FAPE claims should not proceed until the assessment has been completed and the assessment report is made available. The parties stipulated that the eligibility and FAPE claims would be bifurcated and heard separately from Petitioner’s expedited claims. The parties further agreed that the hearing on those non-expedited claims should be scheduled to begin approximately fifty (50) days from the date of the telephone conference, to allow time for completion of the special education assessment.(Footnote 3)

This matter convened for hearing on April 3, 2003. Prior to the presentation of any evidence, the parties proposed that the Hearing Officer should first make a finding regarding whether STUDENT was subject to a disciplinary change of placement (Issue #1) before the parties presented any evidence regarding whether the District had a “basis of knowledge” about STUDENT’s disability (Issue #2). If the Hearing Officer determined that no disciplinary change of placement occurred, then there would be no need to hear evidence regarding whether the District had a basis of knowledge. The Hearing Officer agreed that she would hear all evidence regarding the disciplinary change of placement and provide the parties with a brief ruling on that issue prior to hearing any evidence regarding whether the District had a basis of knowledge.

After receiving oral and documentary evidence on the disciplinary change of placement, the Hearing Officer issued a brief order and read it to the parties on the record at the hearing on April 4. That ruling was as follows:

The termination of the student’s participation in the International Baccalaureate (IB) program did not constitute a disciplinary change of placement under federal law. Therefore, the request for stay put in the IB program is denied. A written decision will follow.

Because the Hearing Officer found that no disciplinary change of placement occurred, the Hearing Officer indicated that no evidence would be heard regarding whether the District had a “basis of knowledge.” The present Decision constitutes the written decision identified in the ruling.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old student who resides with her parents in Mission Viejo, California, within the boundaries of Saddleback Valley Unified School District (District). STUDENT is currently a senior at the District’s Mission Viejo High School (MVHS). She has never been found eligible for special education.

STUDENT began attending MVHS as a freshman in fall 1999. During her attendance at MVHS, STUDENT has maintained excellent grades while participating in the International Baccalaureate (IB) program. IB is an international program that awards a prestigious, internationally recognized diploma to high school students who fulfill the program’s rigorous academic requirements. (Testimony of Jerome Chris.) Those requirements include passing six examinations in core academic subjects, taking designated honors-level and Advanced Placement (AP) academic classes, writing a 4,000-word essay and performing 150 hours of “creative activity” such as athletics or community service. (Id.)

STUDENT remained in the IB program throughout her freshman, sophomore and junior years. In fall 2002, STUDENT began her senior year of high school and continued to participate in the IB program, with the intention of completing the program and receiving the IB diploma. (Testimony of STUDENT; Pet. Exh. P.).

STUDENT testified that she has had serious personal problems during her senior year, including a suicide attempt in January 2003. Through the fall 2002 semester and the beginning of the spring 2003 semester, STUDENT had numerous absences from school. (Pet. Exhs. L-2, U.) MVHS classified some of these absences as truancies. (Id.) MVHS assistant principal Stephen Workman spoke with STUDENT on several occasions about her attendance. On February 7, 2003, Mr. Workman called STUDENT into his office and informed her that she was being placed on an attendance contract which required her to provide a doctor’s note after every absence. (Testimony of Mr. Workman, STUDENT; Dist. Exh. 3.) At Mr. Workman’s instruction, STUDENT signed the attendance contract.(Footnote 4)

The week after this contract was executed, STUDENT was absent from school for four days and provided a doctor’s note upon her return to school on February 14. (Pet. Exhs. K-9, U.) From February 24 to February 26, STUDENT was again absent from school. STUDENT testified that she attempted to see a doctor, but did not have an appointment and eventually left the doctor’s office after waiting for several hours. The receptionist at the doctor’s office wrote STUDENT a note verifying her attempt to see a doctor; STUDENT provided that note to the school attendance clerk upon her return to school on February 26. Several days later, Mr. Workman informed STUDENT that this note did not fulfill the requirements of her attendance contract. Mr. Workman also informed STUDENT that he had determined she had been absent from particular class periods on February 21 and March 11. (Pet. Exh. U; testimony of Mr. Workman.)

During this time period, the IB students’ final drafts of their 4,000-word essays were supposed to be turned in to their MVHS IB advisors for grading, before the essays were mailed to the official IB grader in Wales. Initially the due date was February 11, but MVHS’s IB coordinator, Jerome Chris, agreed to extend the deadline so that the IB students could work on their papers during school vacation the week of February 17.

STUDENT did not turn in her paper to her IB advisor by the extended deadline. After that deadline passed, Dr. Chris spoke to STUDENT on several occasions about her paper. Dr. Chris agreed that STUDENT could turn in a late paper to Dr. Chris directly, which would be graded by Dr. Chris instead of by STUDENT’s IB advisor, Ron Osimi. Dr. Chris testified that the papers had to be mailed no later than March 7, so that they would be received by the graders in Wales by the March 15 deadline. STUDENT did not turn in her essay in time for the March 7 mailing.(Footnote 5)

On March 13, Mr. Workman called STUDENT into his office and informed her that because of violations of her attendance contract, she would be suspended for two days and withdrawn from all of her classes with “F” grades(Footnote 6). Mr. Workman reported that STUDENT had been dropped from her classes but not expelled from school, and could therefore attend MVHS’s study hall or “transfer to the independent study program at Mira Monte so that she could graduate in June with her class.” (Pet. Exh. U.)

STUDENT’s official two-day suspension was for Thursday, March 13 and Friday, March 14, 2003. (Pet. Exhs. K-11; Dist. Exh. 13.) On March 14, 2003, the Hearing Office received a due process hearing request from Ms. Whiteleather on STUDENT’s behalf.

STUDENT reported that she was not allowed to return to her classes when she initially returned to school on Monday, March 17. On March 18, Petitioner filed a motion for stay put with the Hearing Office, arguing that STUDENT was not being permitted to return to school.(Footnote 7) In a letter dated March 19, David Larsen, an attorney for the District, confirmed to Ms. Whiteleather that STUDENT had been suspended for two days only, would be permitted to return to her classes, and was not being expelled. (Dist. Exh. 13.) Mr. Workman testified that, pursuant to instructions he received from Mr. Larsen, STUDENT was reinstated in all of her classes and allowed to return to those classes. STUDENT testified that she was allowed back into her classes beginning on March 20.

On March 28, 2003, Dr. Chris informed STUDENT that she was no longer eligible for the IB diploma because she had not turned in her essay. (Testimony of STUDENT, Dr. Chris; Pet. Exh. P.) STUDENT remains enrolled in her classes at MVHS and is scheduled to graduate in June 2003.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

(1) Did STUDENT’s removal from the International Baccalaureate (IB) program constitute a disciplinary change of placement pursuant to 34 C.F.R. section 300.519?

Under the stay put provisions of federal and state special education law, a special education student is entitled to remain in his or her current educational placement pending the completion of due process hearing procedures unless the parties to the hearing agreed otherwise. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Education Code § 56505(d).) In 1997, Congress amended the IDEA to extend the protections of stay put to some students not previously identified as eligible for special education and related services, and only under limited circumstances. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8); 34 C.F.R. § 300.527.) Those limited circumstances apply only when a local educational agency (LEA) enacts a disciplinary removal of the student for more than ten consecutive days, or when the student is subjected to a series of disciplinary removals that constitute a pattern and total more than ten school days in a school year. (34 C.F.R. § 300.519.)

In the present case, there is no question that the March 13 suspension resulted in a school suspension of fewer than ten school days. However, Petitioner argues that the termination of her participation in the IB program was a disciplinary change of placement lasting more than ten days. Petitioner asserts that the IB program was part of her educational placement, that her removal from the program occurred because of her suspension on March 13, and therefore that her removal from the program was a disciplinary change of placement.

In contrast, the District contends that Petitioner’s removal from the IB program was unrelated to the March 13 suspension and was not a disciplinary change of placement. The District argues that Petitioner was dropped from the IB program due to her failure to turn in the extended essay due in mid-February 2003, not due to the March 13 suspension. Moreover, the District states that Petitioner’s termination from the IB program occurred automatically under the rules imposed by the IB program’s Board of Trustees and was not a discretionary decision of the District. Indeed, the District asserts that it had no discretion to extend the essay deadline and has no discretion to reinstate Petitioner into the IB program, because such authority rests solely with IB’s Board of Trustees in Geneva, Switzerland.

Petitioner is correct that removal from a particular academic program may constitute a change of placement. However, there is no evidence to support Petitioner’s contention that her removal from the IB program was a disciplinary change of placement or was in any way caused by her school suspension. Dr. Chris testified that he wanted STUDENT to turn in her essay and fulfill her IB requirements, and therefore he agreed that STUDENT could turn in that essay after the mid-February 2003 deadline. However, Dr. Chris testified that the essays had to be mailed no later than March 7 in order to arrive in Wales by the March 15 deadline; this testimony was credible and Petitioner did not present any evidence indicating that this information was incorrect. While STUDENT testified that she was not informed of the March 7 mailing deadline, any miscommunication between STUDENT and Dr. Chris about the deadline clearly was unrelated to the discipline imposed by the MVHS administration beginning on March 13.

Petitioner appears to argue that the March 13 suspension prevented her from turning in her extended essay on March 13, and therefore her current ineligibility for the IB program constitutes a disciplinary change of placement because it was caused by the suspension.(Footnote 8) This argument is not persuasive. As noted above, Dr. Chris testified that he mailed the IB students’ essays by March 7, and he did not believe that the IB regulations permitted him to mail one student’s essay separately from the other students’ essays. Thus, even if STUDENT had turned in her essay on March 13, it would have been too late to submit it to the IB grader in Wales.(Footnote 9)

Finally, it is significant that the District has no authority to change STUDENT’s current ineligibility for the IB program. Dr. Chris testified that decisions regarding a student’s compliance with the IB requirements are made by the IB Board in Geneva, Switzerland. Dr. Chris’s testimony established that neither he nor the District has any power to persuade the IB Board to re-enroll a student or otherwise change the requirements for a particular student.(Footnote 10) (2) If the District subjected STUDENT to a disciplinary change of placement, did the District have a basis of knowledge in March 2003 that STUDENT was a student with a disability pursuant to 34 C.F.R. section 300.527(b)?

Because STUDENT was not subject to a disciplinary change of placement for more than ten days, this Decision does not reach the issue of whether the District had a basis of knowledge that STUDENT was a student with a disability.

ORDER

Petitioner’s request for stay put is denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: April 21, 2003 ___________________________________ Suzanne B. Brown Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Because this case has been bifurcated, the Hearing Office identifies the two cases with separate case numbers: SN03-00517A addresses the expedited hearing issues and SN03-00517B addresses the non-expedited hearing issues. 2. As discussed further in this Decision’s Procedural Background section, at the hearing the Hearing Officer took evidence solely on Issue #1 and then issued a brief order regarding her findings on that issue. Because of the Hearing Officer’s findings regarding Issue #1, the hearing did not proceed to address Issue #2. 3. The hearing regarding those non-expedited issues is scheduled to begin on May 29, 2003. 4. Mr. Workman testified that he telephoned STUDENT’s mother on February 7 and informed her of the contract. (See Pet. Exh. U.) MOTHER testified that she learned of the contract from STUDENT, not Mr. Workman 5. STUDENT testified that she did not know about the March 7 deadline and instead believed that Dr. Chris could mail her essay later in March. 6. Mr. Workman reported that STUDENT responded to this information by using profanity and “storming” out of his office. (Testimony of Mr. Workman; Pet. Exhs. K-11, U.) STUDENT testified that she became very upset after hearing about her suspension and used profanity when reporting the news to her mother over the telephone while Mr. Workman was within earshot. 7. As detailed in this Decision’s Procedural Background section, the Hearing Office denied Petitioner’s prehearing stay put motion on the grounds that an evidentiary hearing was required to determine whether the District had a “basis of knowledge” that STUDENT was a student with a disability.

8. In fact, STUDENT testified that her essay was “95% completed” as of March 13, but stated that she could have turned it in by March 13 had she known of the March 15 deadline. In any event, regardless of who was at fault for STUDENT’s misunderstanding about the deadline, that misunderstanding was not caused by her suspension and was not part of any disciplinary action against her. 9. Additionally, even if the suspension had prevented STUDENT from turning in her essay, Petitioner has not established that the resulting termination from the IB program would have constituted a disciplinary change of placement by the District. The IB program is operated by an organization entirely separate from the District; even if the District’s suspension had caused STUDENT to fail to comply with the requirements of the IB program, the IB Board’s decision would not become part of the District’s disciplinary action. The removal from IB could have been a result of the discipline, but would not necessarily have been part of the discipline. 10. For example, Dr. Chris recounted an incident in which he had asked the IB Board to make allowances for a student who had cancer, but the Board denied his request.