California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 12, 2005

Student v. Cupertino Union School District

SEHO Case No. SN 521-05 · Hearing Officer Claudia J. Wrazel

Cupertino Union must add speech, OT and one-to-one support to its autism program offer; private school reimbursement and placement denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 8 issues (3 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision mentions earlier due process cases between the same parties (SN04-00128, filed by the parents, and SN04-00824, filed by the District), which were resolved by a settlement in May 2004.

Summary

The parents of a seven-year-old boy with autism filed for due process against Cupertino Union School District in March 2005. Since March 2004 the boy had attended The Bay School, a private program in Santa Cruz. The parents argued he needed a "verbal behavior" Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) program monitored by a board-certified behavior analyst. They sought reimbursement from June 2004 and placement at The Bay School for 2005-2006. The District offered an ABA class at Dilworth Elementary plus Comprehensive Autism Program (CAP) instruction, speech-language therapy and occupational therapy (OT).

Hearing Officer Claudia J. Wrazel found the District's offers largely provided a FAPE. The District erred by holding the June 2004 IEP meeting without a teacher or provider from The Bay School, but the error did not deny FAPE. The IEPs referred to the private school's goals without attaching them, and that was not an error. The District did not have to use a particular method or provide oversight by a board-certified behavior analyst. However, both transition plans failed to cover speech and OT during the transition. The 2005-2006 offer also wrongly dropped the one-to-one CAP tutor in class and the exclusively one-to-one CAP sessions after class. No reimbursement was owed because the transitions never happened, and fees for private observations were not reimbursable. The District had to revise its offer within 15 days.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated a demand for a specific autism method under Rowley. Parents' preference for verbal behavior therapy and board-certified oversight did not make a different ABA program inappropriate. The Hearing Officer still required transition plans to cover the related services the district's own offer included. She also required continued one-to-one support the student still needed.

Issues and holdings

  1. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 1A(1). Was the District required to secure the attendance of the Student's TBS teacher at his June and October 2004 IEP meetings, and did it fail to do so?

    Holding the June 2, 2004 IEP meeting without a special education teacher or provider from The Bay School was a procedural error. It did not deny FAPE because the parents' attorney insisted on the date and the team reviewed extensive TBS information. A TBS provider attended the October 2004 meeting.

  2. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1A(2). Was the District required to include the Student's goals in his June and October 2004 IEP documents, and did it fail to do so?

    The TBS goals were adopted and incorporated by reference. Not physically attaching them was not a procedural error.

  3. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1B(a). Was the two-week transition plan offered for the 2004 ESY designed to meet the Student's unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

    A two-week transition paid at TBS's basic daily rate, without one-to-one services, was appropriate. Failing to pay for or provide speech-language and OT services during the transition was inconsistent with FAPE.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1B(b). Was the program offered for the 2004 ESY and 2004-2005 school year (ABA class with one-to-one CAP tutor, additional one-to-one CAP instruction, OT and speech-language) designed to meet the Student's unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit?

    The offer provided a FAPE. The Student was not entitled to a verbal behavior program using specified techniques or to monitoring by a board-certified behavior analyst.

  5. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2A. Did the District's three-month transition plan encompassing the 2005 ESY and extended ESY offer a FAPE, including whether conditioning it on enrollment and conveying it by letter after the IEP violated Union v. Smith?

    The three-month transition, the enrollment condition and the follow-up letter were proper, with no Union violation. Failing to pay for speech-language services or offer OT during the transition was inconsistent with FAPE.

  6. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2B. Did the District offer the Student a FAPE for the 2005-2006 school year?

    The ABA class and CAP program remained appropriate despite later critiques. Dropping one-to-one CAP tutor support in class and exclusively one-to-one CAP instruction after class failed to meet the Student's needs.

  7. Issue 3. If the District failed to offer FAPE for the 2004 ESY and 2004-2005 school year, is the Student entitled to reimbursement for his educational expenses during that period?

    No reimbursement was owed because the transition never occurred and no expenses resulted from the error. Fees for private observations and consultations are not special education or related services, so they were not reimbursable.

  8. Issue 4. If the District failed to offer FAPE for the 2005 ESY and 2005-2006 school year, is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the 2005 ESY and prospective placement at TBS for 2005-2006?

    No 2005 ESY reimbursement was owed, and prospective TBS placement was denied because the District could correct its offer to add one-to-one support.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to revise the offer for the 2005 ESY and 2005-2006 school year.
  • Order to provide or change services. The revised offer must include a transition period of at least three months. During it, the District must (1) pay for the TBS program at the Basic Daily Rate, (2) provide individual OT equal to the OT offered for 2005-2006, and (3) at the District's option, either provide individual speech-language services equal to the 2005-2006 offer or pay for ongoing speech-language services at $240 per month for three months.
  • Order to provide or change services. The 2005-2006 offer must provide classroom support by a CAP tutor for the full six-hour ABA class day and exclusively one-to-one instruction in the two-hour CAP sessions after class.
  • The District must remain ready to implement its offer (District Exhibit 28), as modified, for the rest of the 2005 ESY and extended ESY and for the 2005-2006 school year. All other claims for relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Clyde v. Puyallup School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Adams v. State of Oregon

People named in the decision

  • Lorrie Wernick, Ed.D., coordinator of special education, Cupertino Union School District
  • Richard Taylor, director of pupil services, Cupertino Union School District
  • Randy Karel, principal, Dilworth Elementary School
  • Anne Brown, former principal, Dilworth Elementary School
  • Patricia Erickson, special day class teacher, Dilworth Elementary School
  • Erica Mazariegos, special education (ABA class) teacher, Dilworth Elementary School
  • Raj Pawar, former ABA class teacher, Dilworth Elementary School
  • Heidi Farber, speech-language pathologist, Cupertino Union School District
  • Ruth Cantwell, SELPA program specialist, SELPA
  • Chelsea Contreras, supervisor, Comprehensive Autism Program, SELPA
  • Susan Clare, Ph.D., psychologist and educational consultant, witness for District, District consultant
  • Nejat Romodan, instructional aide, witness for Student
  • Hilary Baldi, executive director; consulting behavior analyst, witness for Student, Behavioral Intervention Association
  • Paul C. Lebby, Ph.D., neuropsychologist, expert witness for Student
  • Patricia Ann Mittelstadt, Ph.D., pediatric neuropsychologist, expert witness for Student
  • Ethan Long, Ph.D., executive director (BCBA), The Bay School
  • Barry Morgenstern, Ph.D., former executive director (BCBA), The Bay School
  • Kristyne Jolly, lead teacher (associate BCBA), The Bay School
  • Jessica Franco, speech therapist and BCBA, private evaluator, verbal behavior home program through Aspen Center for Autism
  • Ralph Lewis, parents' former attorney
  • The Bay School, private school (certified nonprofit) where Student was placed
  • Aspen Center for Autism, private home ABA provider (Colorado)
  • Fort Collins Youth Clinic, private speech-language evaluator (Colorado)
  • Poudre School District, prior school district (Colorado)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of Pacific=s McGeorge School of Law, in Cupertino, California, on June 8, 14-16, and 21-23, 2005.

Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was represented at the hearing by attorney Kathryn E. Dobel. Also present on the Student’s behalf were his parents, PARENTS. Respondent Cupertino Union School District (District) was represented by attorney Bridget Flanagan. Also present on behalf of the District was Lorrie Wernick, Ed.D., coordinator of special education for the District.

The Student called the following witnesses: Hilary Baldi, executive director of the Behavioral Intervention Association (BIA); Paul C. Lebby, Ph.D., neuropsychologist; Nejat Romodan, instructional aide; Dr. Wernick; Ethan Long, Ph.D., executive director of The Bay School (TBS), a certified nonprofit private school; Barry Morgenstern, Ph.D., former executive director of TBS; Patricia Ann Mittelstadt, Ph.D., pediatric neuropsychologist; Kristyne Jolly, a teacher at TBS; and PARENTS.

The District called the following witnesses: Randy Karel, principal of Dilworth Elementary School (Dilworth); Susan Clare, Ph.D., psychologist and educational consultant; Patricia Erickson, special day class (SDC) teacher at Dilworth; Heidi Farber, speech and language (S/L) pathologist for the District; Ruth Cantwell, program specialist for the District’s special education local planning area (SELPA); Anne Brown, former principal of Dilworth; Chelsea Contreras, supervisor of the SELPA’s comprehensive autism program (CAP); and Erica Mazariegos, special education teacher at Dilworth.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the receipt of the final closing brief on July 11, 2005, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

Issue No. 1: Did the District offer the Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from June 2, 2004 through the end of the 2003-2004 extended school year (ESY) and for the 2004-2005 school year? (Footnote 1)

Issue No. 2: Did the District offer the Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 ESY and the 2005-2006 school year? (Footnote 2)

Issue No. 3: If the District failed to provide the Student with an offer of FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year, is the Student entitled to reimbursement for his educational expenses during that period?

Issue No. 4: If the District failed to provide the Student with an offer of FAPE for the 2005 ESY and the 2005-2006 school year, is the Student entitled to reimbursement for his educational expenses for the 2005 ESY and to prospective placement at The Bay School (TBS) for the 2005-2006 school year?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Student asserts that, due to his unique needs associated with his autism, he requires a particular autism intervention method known as “verbal behavior” therapy, delivered through specified teaching techniques, and monitored by a board-certified behavior analyst (BCBA). The Student contends that when he enrolled in the District in December 2003, he was provided with a thirty-day administrative placement at Dilworth, his neighborhood elementary school, but that the placement was inappropriate to his needs. As a result, his parents withdrew him from the District in January 2004 and placed him at The Bay School (TBS), where he receives a BCBA-monitored verbal behavior therapy program and where he contends he has made significant progress.

The Student notes that in May 2004, the parties reached an agreement settling their dispute over his placement through June 1, 2004. He asserts, however, that for the 2004 ESY and 2004-2005 school year, as well as for the 2005 ESY and 2005-2006 school year, the District continued to offer him programs at Dilworth that were inappropriate for him, and that constituted substantive denials of a FAPE. Further, he asserts that the District procedurally denied him a FAPE by failing to secure the attendance of his TBS teacher at his June and October 2004 IEP meetings, and by failing to include in his IEP documents the goals and objectives agreed to at those IEP meetings.

The Student asserts that the District is unable to meet his needs in a public school placement, and that the appropriate placement for him is at TBS. He seeks an order requiring the District to pay for his educational expenses at TBS from June 2, 2004 through the end of the 2005 ESY, and for the costs of specified privately-obtained consultation services and observations. Finally, the Student seeks placement at TBS for the 2005-2006 school year.

The District contends that its program and placement offers to the Student since June 2, 2004 have constituted offers of FAPE, and denies the Student’s claims of procedural error. The District asserts that it should not be required to reimburse the Student for his requested expenses, and that the Student’s request for prospective placement at TBS should be denied.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a seven-year-old boy who was diagnosed with autism at age two. In 2000, when STUDENT was three years old, he moved with his parents from Singapore to Fort Collins, Colorado due to his father’s job transfer. STUDENT was evaluated for his speech and language (S/L) capabilities by the Fort Collins Youth Clinic, and was treated by an S/L pathologist for several months in 2001-2002. Early evaluations indicated that STUDENT could understand many words and simple commands, but had almost no expressive language. (S. Exhs. 1, 3.) Generally, STUDENT communicated with gestures and vocalizations, including a high pitched squeal to gain attention or to protest. (D. Exh. 1.)

In September 2001, STUDENT was placed an integrated preschool in the Poudre School District in Fort Collins, but seemed unaware of his environment, resisted tasks, and engaged in aggressive behavior. On the advice of a psychologist, the PARENTS instituted a home-based Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) program to supplement his preschool program. At the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, the PARENTS reduced STUDENT’s preschool attendance from five to two days per week, and increased his ABA program to 30 hours per week. (S. Exhs. 5, 6; D. Exh. 2; testimony of MOTHER.)

By the summer of 2003, the PARENTS concluded that STUDENT was showing little progress in the ABA home program, and that his self-stimulatory and problem behaviors were increasing. They believed the repetitive discrete trial drills in the “Lovaas-style” ABA program frustrated STUDENT, who was a slow learner. The PARENTS researched autism support groups on the Internet, and decided to consult with Jessica Franco, a speech therapist and board-certified behavior analyst (BCBA) recommended by an Internet support group. In July 2003, they began to provide STUDENT with a “verbal behavior” ABA home program provided through the Aspen Center for Autism for twelve to fifteen hours per week. (Testimony of MOTHER.) (Footnote 3)

Ms. Franco evaluated STUDENT in August 2003, and determined that he exhibited severely delayed expressive and receptive language and moderately delayed articulation. He showed cognitive strengths and was able to repeat words, however, which suggested a strong prognosis for improved language skills “if recommended services are pursued.” (S. Exh. 8.)

Ms. Franco recommended thirty hours per week of intensive ABA therapy focusing on verbal behavior, with an emphasis on the development of “requesting, labeling, and receptive language.” She also recommended specific teaching procedures including errorless teaching, intermittent reinforcement, mixed instructional demands and difficulty levels, rapid progression from one trial to the next, and a high level of initial prompts. (Footnote 4) She also recommended that STUDENT’s program be monitored by a BCBA, with progress evaluated every four to eight weeks. (Id.) In accordance with Ms. Franco’s recommendations, the PARENTS kept STUDENT in the verbal behavior home program provided through the Aspen Center for Autism, and increased his program to thirty hours per week by November 2003. (Testimony of MOTHER.)

STUDENT’s initial placement by the District (December 2003 - January 2004)

In August of 2003, FATHER’s employer notified him of another pending transfer to one of several regions in the United States, and the PARENTS began researching public and private autism treatment programs in these areas. MOTHER was unable to obtain detailed information from public school districts, but did obtain information on several private programs specializing in verbal behavior, including TBS in Santa Cruz, California.

The PARENTS moved to Cupertino, California in mid-November 2003. In the last week of November, they brought STUDENT to a meeting with District special education coordinator Dr. Wernick and director of pupil services Richard Taylor. The PARENTS provided Dr. Wernick with a copy of STUDENT’s May 2003 IEP from the Poudre School District, and the parties discussed his needs, his prior placements, and the placement options available in the District. (Testimony of MOTHER and Dr. Wernick; see D. Exh. 4, S. Exh. 115, p. 21.)

The PARENTS stated that STUDENT had been in an integrated preschool in Colorado, and that they wanted his social skills to be addressed. They noted that he also had been in an ABA program but had not performed well in that setting. Based on this information, Dr. Wernick determined that for STUDENT’s initial thirty-day “administrative placement” in the District, it would be more appropriate to place him in the special day class (SDC) at Dilworth, his neighborhood school, instead of the more intensive ABA class at that school. Although the PARENTS had not yet had an opportunity to view the District’s placement options, they agreed to Dr. Wernick’s recommendation because it was for a thirty-day placement only, after which a permanent placement would be determined. (Testimony of MOTHER and Dr. Wernick.)

STUDENT began to attend the Dilworth SDC on Wednesday, December 3, 2003. The next day, District S/L pathologist Heidi Farber drove MOTHER to school so she could observe STUDENT in the classroom. MOTHER was not happy with what she observed. She did not see any specific therapies being implemented, and she felt that the class lacked structure. The SDC teacher, Mrs. Erickson, did not seem to be paying attention to STUDENT, and the classroom aides were not controlling him. MOTHER thought the aides did not appear to be trained professionals, and were not intervening in the students’ self-stimulatory and escape behaviors. She also felt that tantrum behaviors were being reinforced. (Testimony of MOTHER.)

That weekend, the PARENTS took STUDENT to Fresno to be assessed by Dr. Lebby. On the following Monday and Tuesday, STUDENT did not attend school due to illness. On Wednesday, STUDENT’s fourth day in the Dilworth SDC, Dr. Lebby came to Cupertino to observe STUDENT in class. Dr. Lebby also observed other special education classes at Dilworth that morning, and observed the TBS program in Santa Cruz in the afternoon. (S. Exhs. 14, 43.) (Footnote 5)

After observing STUDENT in his SDC for approximately twenty-five minutes, Dr. Lebby informed MOTHER that it was not an appropriate placement for him. Dr. Lebby told her that he had seen no implementation of any language program in the class, and that at age six, STUDENT was at a critical age where his language deficits needed to be addressed immediately.

In a written report issued after his observations, Dr. Lebby stated that he believed the SDC would be harmful to STUDENT’s continued educational development, and that he would expect regression if STUDENT were to continue there. Dr. Lebby noted that he also believed that the ABA class at Dilworth was inadequate due to its strict “discrete trial” structure, which the PARENTS had found to be inappropriate for STUDENT in Colorado. He added that his own assessment of STUDENT had indicated that he could not tolerate or benefit from such a program. Dr. Lebby was very impressed with the TBS program, however, due to its provision of one-to-one instruction, rapid changes in stimulus presentation, and use of errorless learning techniques. Dr. Lebby recommended TBS as an appropriate placement for STUDENT. (S. Exh. 14.)

STUDENT continued to attend the Dilworth SDC until the holiday break on December 19, although MOTHER noted in her log that he often cried and seemed reluctant to go to school. When classes resumed on January 5, 2004, STUDENT returned to school and remained in attendance, except for some sick days, through January 20, 2004. In total, STUDENT spent 19 days in the Dilworth SDC. (Testimony of Dr. Wernick; see S. Exh. 43.)

Events preceding STUDENT’s withdrawal from school (January 2004)

On January 8, 2004, the District sent the PARENTS a notice indicating that the IEP meeting to determine a permanent placement for STUDENT would be held on January 20, 2004, at 2:15 p.m. The PARENTS responded that January 20 was not a convenient date, and suggested alternate dates. For the next week, the PARENTS and District staff exchanged messages in an attempt to work out a mutually agreeable IEP date when all interested parties could attend. According to documents and testimony, the District was left with the impression that the PARENTS were unable to meet on January 20, whereas the PARENTS were left with the impression that the IEP meeting would go forward on January 20 as originally scheduled. (Testimony of PARENTS and Ms. Brown; see S. Exh. 115, D. Exh. 35.)

On January 20, the PARENTS and their attorney Ralph Lewis arrived at the District at 2 p.m. to attend STUDENT’s IEP. Dilworth principal Ms. Brown was surprised to see them, and informed them that she had scheduled another student’s IEP for that date because she had understood that the PARENTS were unavailable. Ms. Brown also stated that she had met briefly with SDC teacher Mrs. Erickson and S/L therapist Ms. Farber that morning, and would be recommending the goals they had suggested in the draft IEP sent to the PARENTS the previous week. The PARENTS and Mr. Lewis took this information to mean that the IEP had been held in their absence, and left in anger. (Testimony of PARENTS and Ms. Brown.)

On January 21, Ms. Brown wrote to the PARENTS apologizing for the miscommunication about STUDENT’s IEP, asking when they could meet to hold the IEP, and suggesting possible dates the following week. On January 27, Ms. Brown telephoned the PARENTS and left a message again offering to reschedule the IEP, and on January 28, Dr. Wernick wrote to the PARENTS seeking to schedule an assessment of STUDENT as well as an IEP meeting. On the advice of Mr. Lewis, the PARENTS referred all communications to him and did not respond to Ms. Brown or Dr. Wernick. (Testimony of PARENTS and Ms. Brown; see D. Exh. 35, pp. 22-23.)

STUDENT did not return to school after January 20, 2004.

Filing and resolution of first two due process cases (January-June 2004)

On January 22, the PARENTS initiated a due process hearing against the District, alleging that the District had failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year. (Case No. SN04-00128.) On March 29, 2004, STUDENT began to attend school at TBS. (Testimony of MOTHER; see S. Exh. 22.) (Footnote 6)

From late January through May, 2004, the District made several unsuccessful attempts to schedule an IEP meeting for STUDENT. (See D. Exh. 35, pp. 22-38.) On April 8, 2004, the District initiated a due process hearing seeking to assess STUDENT. (Case No. SN04-00824.) In May 2004, the parties entered into an agreement resolving their disputes through the date of June 1, 2004, and agreeing to hold an IEP meeting for STUDENT on May 28 or June 2, 2004. (Testimony of FATHER.)

District offer for 2004 ESY and 2004-2005 school year

Prior to the IEP meeting agreed to in the parties’ May 2004 settlement, STUDENT was assessed and observed on several occasions by District staff, TBS staff, and private specialists retained by the PARENTS. Written reports describing these assessments and observations were discussed at the IEP meeting held on June 2, 2004, and were attached to the IEP document. Although the reports contained varied and at times inconsistent observations and conclusions, there was general agreement that STUDENT had very little spontaneous speech, was echolaic and perseverative, often communicated by squealing, and had difficulty staying on task. He had somewhat better receptive communication skills, sufficient adaptive skills to self-feed, dress, and use the toilet with minimal assistance, and sufficient motor skills to walk and run, cut with scissors, and complete a simple jigsaw puzzle. (D. Exh. 8, pp. 57-58, and attachments A-K).

At the June 2 IEP meeting, the PARENTS stated that they no longer wanted to pursue the goals and objectives that had been a part of STUDENT’s May 2003 IEP from Colorado. Instead, the PARENTS submitted the twenty-two goals and objectives currently being implemented in STUDENT’s educational program at TBS. According to the IEP, the District accepted the TBS goals, and offered five additional goals for consideration. (Footnote 7) The PARENTS did not accept the goals offered by the District. (D. Exh. 8, pp. 59-60, 121-123; testimony of Dr. Wernick.)

For the 2004 ESY, the District offered STUDENT (1) a two-week transition program from TBS to District services; (2) a four-week ESY session in the Dilworth ABA class with a one-to-one tutor from the Comprehensive Autism Program (CAP), additional hours of one-to-one CAP instruction, and occupational therapy (OT) and speech/language (S/L) services; and (3) a five-week “extended” ESY session consisting of daily one-to-one CAP instruction sessions. (D. Exh. 8, pp. 67-68; D. Exh. 10.) (Footnote 8)

For the 2004-2005 school year, the District offered STUDENT placement in the Dilworth ABA class with a one-to-one CAP tutor, additional hours of one-to-one CAP instruction, and OT and S/L services. (D. Exh. 8, p. 69; D. Exh. 10.)

The PARENTS declined the District’s offers for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year, and requested continued placement at TBS. (D. Exh. 8, pp. 121-123.)

October 2004 IEP meeting

STUDENT continued to attend TBS during the summer of 2004 and the 2004-2005 school year. (Footnote 9) On October 4, 2004, an IEP meeting was held at the PARENTS’ request to allow TBS to report on STUDENT’s progress and to update his goals and objectives. Dr. Morgenstern, TBS’ executive director at that time, reported that STUDENT had learned eight different signs adapted from American Sign Language (ASL) to use for “mands” (requests), and had learned two more receptive directions. He was learning to wait and to accept “no,” and problem behaviors such as tantrums, bolting and aggression had decreased. (D. Exh. 14, p. 156.)

At the meeting, Dr. Wernick and SELPA program specialist Ms. Cantwell reported on their observations of STUDENT at TBS the previous week. Dr. Wernick observed STUDENT engage in some matching, tracing, and block building activities. She saw him make sign approximations that were explained to be requests for bubbles and TV, but saw “very little” imitation of words or sounds. No other students were present during her observation, and STUDENT did not interact with his tutors or other staff.

Ms. Cantwell observed STUDENT working in a cubicle in a large common area with other students in cubicles. He did not interact with the other students, and it was reported that he ate lunch apart from the other students at his parents’ request. STUDENT’s aide engaged him in a variety of tasks of very short duration (matching, block building, and writing the letter “I”), followed by reinforcers such as bubbles or a few minutes of a Sesame Street video. Ms. Cantwell saw STUDENT use modified ASL signs coupled with verbal approximations to request reinforcers (usually bubbles). According to his aide, STUDENT could use three words as labels for objects: Chip, music, and bubbles. (D. Exh. 13.)

The PARENTS again requested placement at TBS, but the District declined the request. The District repeated its offer of the program for the 2004-2005 school year outlined in the June 2 IEP, modified to reflect a new and longer transition period from TBS to District services. The PARENTS continued to decline the District’s offer. (D. Exhs. 14-16.)

January 2005 IEP meeting

On January 13, 2005, another IEP was held at the PARENTS’ request. At the meeting, the PARENTS’ consulting pediatric neuropsychologist Dr. Mittelstadt reported on her recent psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT, and on her comparative observations of the District’s offered placement and of TBS.

In her evaluation, Dr. Mittelstadt determined that STUDENT met the criteria for mild to moderate mental retardation, and moderate to severe autism. His receptive communication skills were better than his verbal skills, which were very low. Dr. Mittelstadt believed STUDENT needed a verbally-based program with errorless learning procedures to “break up” his tendency to perseverate on incorrect responses, and a one-to-one aide to keep him focused and to address self-stimulatory or other problem behaviors.

After observing the ABA class and CAP Center at Dilworth for approximately twenty minutes each, Dr. Mittelstadt concluded that both sites would be inappropriate for STUDENT. (Footnote 10) She saw no errorless learning techniques used in either location, reinforcements were infrequent, and she disapproved of the use of a “field of two” in multiple choice tasks as encouraging guesswork. Dr. Mittelstadt approved of TBS as a placement for STUDENT because of its one-to-one teaching of a verbally-based ABA program, its supervision by a BCBA, its use of errorless learning techniques, and its constant daily adjustments to STUDENT’s program. (S. Exh. 74.)

The PARENTS’ consulting behavior analyst Ms. Baldi reported on her observation of STUDENT at TBS in December 2004. She was impressed with STUDENT’s responsiveness to verbal instructions and ability to use signs and verbal approximations of words to request reinforcements. She believed STUDENT needed a structured, rigorous learning environment with a lot of positive reinforcement, which he was receiving at TBS. (S. Exh. 75.)

The PARENTS again requested placement at TBS, but the District declined the request. The District continued to offer the program outlined in the June 2, 2004 IEP, with a one-month transition period as offered in the October 4, 2004 IEP. The PARENTS continued to decline the District’s offer. (D. Exh. 24.)

Current due process case (March 2005)

On March 2, 2005, the PARENTS initiated this due process hearing regarding the parties’ failure to agree on a program and placement for STUDENT since June 2, 2004.

District offers for 2005 ESY and 2005-2006 school year

STUDENT’s annual IEP was held on May 25, 2005. Ms. Baldi and the District’s educational consultant Dr. Clare reported on their impressions from their recent joint observations of the District’s offered placement and of STUDENT at TBS. Dr. Wernick, who was present at the TBS observation, also reported on her impressions from that visit.

At TBS, Ms. Baldi noted that STUDENT participated successfully in a group instruction setting. He also completed tasks correctly and without protest during one-to-one instruction, and began to learn new sign and word approximations for “Silly String,” a new reinforcing object. Dr. Wernick also noted STUDENT’s compliant behavior and successful completion of tasks.

At Dilworth, Ms. Baldi noted that in the ABA class, the students received one-to-one support whenever it was needed, and that the aides seemed knowledgeable and positive in their interactions with the students. She was concerned, however, that verbal instructions seemed too complex, visual cues were poorly implemented, the noise level in the class was high, and some problem behaviors appeared to be rewarded. After observing a one-to-one CAP instruction session, she concluded that the setting was “needlessly restrictive” for STUDENT, since he could now work without distraction in a classroom setting. (D. Exh. 28, attachments A-B.)

Dr. Clare reported no critiques of TBS in general, but wondered if STUDENT needed as short a period of task performance and as frequent and high an amount of reinforcement as he was receiving in his program. She was concerned that STUDENT seemed very “adult-dependent” and did not appear to engage in independent activities. In her observation of the ABA class at Dilworth, Dr. Clare noted that the students’ programs appeared to be markedly individualized, and data was regularly collected. She did not feel STUDENT was ready for the level of group instruction observed in the ABA class, since it required an ability to wait and take turns that he had not yet mastered. However, she believed STUDENT could receive individualized instruction successfully in a group setting without being unduly distracted by other students. Dr. Clare also believed the additional hours of one-to-one CAP instruction would provide a useful supplement to STUDENT’s program. (D. Exhs. 28, 30; testimony of Dr. Clare.) (Footnote 11)

The discussion then turned to the District’s offer for the 2005 ESY and the 2005-2006 school year. For the 2005-2006 school year, the District offered STUDENT placement in the Dilworth ABA class with additional hours of CAP instruction, plus OT and S/L services, with some modifications of its 2004-2005 program offer that the District believed would address his current needs. (D. Exh. 28, pp. 212-213; testimony of Dr. Wernick.) For the 2005 ESY, Dr. Wernick stated that she would send the PARENTS a letter setting forth the District’s offer in conjunction with a transition plan to allow District staff to assume the delivery of STUDENT’s program from TBS staff. On May 27, Dr. Wernick sent the follow-up letter offering a three-month transition plan that would encompass the District’s ESY and extended ESY sessions for the end of the 2004-2005 school year. (D. Exh. 29.) (Footnote 12)

The PARENTS declined the District’s offers for the 2005 ESY and for the 2005-2006 school year. STUDENT has continued to attend TBS during the summer of 2005.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Did the District offer the Student a FAPE from June 2, 2004 through the end of the 2004 ESY and for the 2004-2005 school year?

Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. (Footnote 13) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a student free of charge, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, and that are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z).

A claim that there has been a denial of a FAPE can present both procedural and substantive questions. Among the IDEA’s procedural mandates is the requirement that the process for the development of the IEP allow the parents to meaningfully participate in it. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE, but ones that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board Of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).

Substantively, the determination of a FAPE is based on the appropriateness of the educational program offered or provided by the local education agency (LEA) to the disabled student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court stated that the LEA is not required to provide a student with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. Rather, the Court held that an LEA is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to meet the student’s needs, reasonably calculated to provide him or her with some educational benefit, and that comport with the student’s IEP. Id. at 201.

The LEA has the burden of proving that it has complied with the IDEA in offering an appropriate educational placement for the student. Clyde v. Puyallup School District, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). A showing of de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” educational benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1998). Rather, a student’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and in relation to his or her potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2nd Cir. 1997). While the Rowley standard requires an LEA to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not require the LEA to guarantee successful results. Walczak, supra, 142 F.3d at 133. (Footnote 14)

In summary, a determination of whether the District has offered a FAPE requires the Hearing Officer to examine (1) whether the District met the IDEA’s procedural requirements, and (2) whether the substantive program offered to STUDENT was individually designed to meet his needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. (Footnote 15)

A. Procedural issues

The Student asserts that the District’s offer for the 2004 ESY and 2004-2005 school year was procedurally flawed because the District failed to secure the attendance of his TBS teacher at the June and October 2004 IEP meetings, and failed to include the goals and objectives agreed to at those meetings in his IEP documents. These allegations are addressed in turn below. (Footnote 16)

(1) Was the District required to secure the attendance of STUDENT’s TBS teacher at his IEP meetings, and did it fail to do so?

One of the procedural safeguards afforded by the IDEA is the right to have appropriate people attending IEP meetings to make decisions about a disabled student’s education. Federal law provides that an IEP team must include, among others:

(i) the parents of a child with a disability;

(ii) at least one regular education teacher of such child (if the child is, or may be, participating in the regular education environment); (iii) at least one special education teacher, or where appropriate, at least one special education provider of such child; (iv) a representative of the LEA [with specified knowledge and qualifications]; (v) an individual who can interpret the instructional implications of evaluation results [who may also qualify as a team member in another category]; (vi) at the discretion of the parent or the agency, other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the child, including related service personnel as appropriate; and (vii) whenever appropriate, the child with a disability.

20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B) (emphasis added). The LEA is responsible for initiating and conducting the student’s IEP meeting, and “shall ensure” that the IEP team includes the members required by law. 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.343(a), 300.344(a).

STUDENT’s June 2, 2004 IEP meeting was attended by his parents, their attorney Mr. Lewis, Dr. Lebby, and various District personnel, including special education teacher Raj Pawar, who taught the ABA class offered as a placement for STUDENT. (D. Exh. 8, p. 66.) However, no special education teacher or provider from STUDENT’s current school, TBS, was in attendance.

The District asserts that at the May 2004 settlement conference, the parties had agreed to convene an IEP meeting on either May 28 or June 2 to accommodate the schedules of Mr. Lewis and Dr. Lebby. When MOTHER later asked Dr. Wernick to reschedule the meeting to June 4 because TBS director Dr. Morgenstern was unavailable on June 2, Dr. Wernick readily agreed, but Mr. Lewis insisted on proceeding on June 2 and the PARENTS deferred to his wishes. Accordingly, the District went forward with the June 2 IEP meeting at the request of the PARENTS and their attorney, despite the absence of Dr. Morgenstern. (Testimony of Dr. Wernick; see D. Exh. 32.) In response, the Student alleges that the District should have invited Ms. Jolly, STUDENT’s teacher at TBS, to attend the June 2 IEP meeting, but failed to do so.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to secure the attendance of a special education teacher or provider from TBS at the June 2, 2004 IEP meeting constituted a procedural error. Although District special education teacher Ms. Pawar attended the meeting, the statutory requirement for the attendance of a special education teacher or provider “of such child” indicates that an educator from the child’s current program must be present, and the law makes no provision for the convening of IEP meetings in the absence of required members.

However, the Hearing Officer also finds that the error did not result in the denial of FAPE. There is no dispute that the June 2 IEP meeting date was arranged primarily to suit the schedules of the participants most important to the Student – his attorney and neuropsychologist – and the attorney expressly refused to change his schedule to accommodate the attendance of Dr. Morgenstern. (D. Exh. 32.) It is clear that the Student believed his interests were best served by holding the IEP meeting on a date originally agreed to at the May 2004 settlement conference, and with the participants invited at his discretion, whether or not one of his current special education teachers or providers was present. (Footnote 17) Further, although the District should have invited Ms. Jolly to the June 2 meeting once it was clear Dr. Morgenstern could not attend, the evidence indicates that her absence neither resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT nor seriously infringed on his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. At the meeting, the IEP team reviewed considerable information relating to or prepared by TBS, including a functional behavior analysis and behavior support plan for STUDENT prepared by Dr. Morgenstern and Ms. Jolly. Dr. Lebby presented his report advocating STUDENT’s placement at TBS. Twenty-two TBS goals were submitted and accepted by the District. Although the District declined to offer placement at TBS, the evidence indicates that its decision was based primarily on the District’s belief that it could offer STUDENT a FAPE at Dilworth, rather than on a negative impression of TBS that might have been corrected if Ms. Jolly had been at the meeting. (D. Exh. 8.) (Footnote 18)

With respect to the October 4, 2004 IEP meeting, the Hearing Officer finds that the claim that no current special education teacher or provider for STUDENT was present is contrary to the evidence. The IEP indicates that Dr. Morgenstern attended the meeting and gave a presentation on STUDENT’s recent progress on his goals. (D. Exh. 14.) In addition, Ms. Jolly participated in the October 4 IEP meeting by telephone. (Testimony of Ms. Jolly.)

For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed error by not securing the attendance of a current special education teacher or provider for STUDENT at the June 2, 2004 IEP meeting, but that the error did not result in the denial of a FAPE.

(2) Was the District required to include STUDENT’s goals in his IEP documents, and did it fail to do so?

The Student asserts that the District was required to include the goals and objectives agreed upon at his June and October 2004 IEP meetings in the IEP documents for a teacher or service provider to implement, but that it failed to do so.

Federal and State law provide that an IEP is a written statement that includes, among other things, “a statement of measurable annual goals,” including short-term objectives, related to meeting the educational needs of a student with a disability. 20 U.S.C. §1414(d)(10(A)(ii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345. At the June 2004 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s IEP team reviewed the twenty-two goals currently implemented in his TBS program, agreed to adopt them, and made note of that agreement in both the June and October 2004 IEP documents. (D. Exh. 8, p. 59; D. Exh. 14, p. 156.) The goals themselves, however, were not included as attachments to the IEPs. (Footnote 19)

The Hearing Officer finds no error. The requirement that an IEP “include” a statement of goals is intended to ensure that goals are adopted at IEP meetings and made readily available for implementation. Although IEP goals commonly are attached to or physically incorporated into IEP documents, there is no prohibition on incorporation by reference. The Student does not assert that there was any confusion as to either the content or the location of the TBS goals, which were drafted and maintained by TBS. As the PARENTS declined the District’s offered placement and kept STUDENT at TBS during the 2004-2005 school year, his goals were readily available for implementation by TBS teachers and service providers. (Footnote 20) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to physically include the goals in STUDENT’s IEP documents did not constitute procedural error.

* * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District erred procedurally by failing to secure the attendance of STUDENT’s special education teacher or provider at his June 2, 2004 IEP meeting, but that the error did not result in the denial of a FAPE. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to physically incorporate STUDENT’s goals and objectives in his June and October 2004 IEP documents did not constitute a procedural error as the goals and objectives were clearly identified and incorporated by reference in both documents.

B. Substantive issues

A substantive review of the District’s program offer for the 2004 ESY and 2004-2005 school year first requires a determination of STUDENT’s unique needs, as indicated by the nature and scope of his impairment and his then-current levels of functioning. The District’s program then will be reviewed to determine if it was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit.

(1) STUDENT’s unique needs (a) Nature and scope of impairment

STUDENT was diagnosed with autism at age two, and there is no dispute that he shows significant symptoms of autism spectrum disorder, particularly in the areas of speech and language, cognitive development, and socialization. Psychoeducational assessments in Colorado and California have noted that STUDENT has severe deficits in expressive language, with a very limited and poorly articulated vocabulary. He exhibits moderate to severe deficits in receptive language, but understands many verbal commands and complies with simple instructions.

Although none of STUDENT’s psychoeducational evaluations to date have been able to test his cognitive skills through formal assessment tools, expert witnesses for both parties agree that he shows symptoms of mild to moderate mental retardation and moderate to severe autism. (Testimony of Dr. Mittelstadt and Dr. Clare.) In terms of his social development, STUDENT is affectionate with his parents and generally compliant with the directives of his assessors and educators, but has shown little interest in his peers.

(b) Levels of functioning

Prior to STUDENT’s June 2004 IEP meeting, he was assessed and observed on several occasions by District staff, TBS staff, and private specialists retained by the PARENTS. The resulting reports expressed general agreement that STUDENT displayed the following levels of functioning in expressive language: He rarely engaged in spontaneous speech; what speech he did produce was echolaic or a product of rote memorization (he could recite some letters and numbers in order, but not out of sequence); he could articulate the beginning of a word, but would distort or omit word endings; and he regularly engaged in squealing or yelling, both to express himself and in protest.

The reports also agreed that STUDENT could follow some verbal directions and had good motor imitation skills. He had difficulty staying on task for extended periods, however, and often perseverated on task responses (for example, he could say “horse” when shown a picture of a horse and given a verbal prompt, but would then continue to say “horse” when shown pictures of other animals). STUDENT exhibited fine and gross motor skills commensurate with age three, with scattered skills up to his age level of six. He was toilet trained, could dress and feed himself, and was able to cut with scissors, but had deficits in coordination and motor planning that interfered with these and other self-help skills. Finally, STUDENT exhibited some self-stimulatory and other problem behaviors (tantrums, bolting) that interfered with his ability to learn. (D. Exh. 8, attachments A-K.)

(c) Needs

As indicated by the various assessment and observation reports attached to his June 2004 IEP, and as confirmed by witnesses for both parties, STUDENT’s unique needs included a highly structured and intense educational program focused primarily on developing his functional language capabilities. Further, he needed one-to-one assistance in the classroom to keep him on task and redirect him from self-stimulatory or other problem behaviors. STUDENT also needed to improve his self-help skills, and needed to learn how to function alongside, and eventually interact with, his peers. Finally, STUDENT needed extended school year (ESY) services to prevent undue regression of his skills over the summer.

(2) Was the transition plan and educational program offered by the District for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, and was it reasonably calculated to offer him some educational benefit?

At the June 2, 2004 IEP meeting, the PARENTS presented the twenty-two goals and objectives currently being implemented for STUDENT at TBS, where he had been in attendance for about two months. (D. Exh. 8, p. 59.) The TBS goals addressed academics (writing and tracing, matching skills, motor imitation, learning to follow a visual activity schedule); language (increasing labeling and requesting vocabulary through modified sign language and verbalization, using words in sentences, responding to verbal directives); social skills (playing appropriately with toys, holding instructor’s hand, improving eating, toileting, and hand-washing skills); speech (improving articulation); and behavior (accepting “no,” transitioning from preferred activities without complaint, reducing screams, tantrums, and self-injury). (S. Exh. 54.)

The District accepted the TBS goals as STUDENT’s goals for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year. The District then made the following offer to STUDENT:

Transition (June 2-18): A two-week period during which District staff would coordinate with TBS staff to take over the provision of STUDENT’s program, including the implementation of his goals and objectives.

ESY (June 21-July 16) and extended ESY (July 26-August 27):

(1) During the four-week ESY, placement in an ABA classroom for three hours per day with one-to-one assistance from a Comprehensive Autism Program (CAP) tutor, followed by three hours of one-to-one CAP instruction, for a total of six hours per day (thirty hours per week), plus two forty-five minute sessions of OT therapy and two thirty-minute sessions of S/L therapy per week;

(2) During the five-week extended ESY, twenty hours per week of one-to-one CAP instruction; and (3) For the combined ESY and extended ESY, sixteen hours of program supervision.

2004-2005 school year:

(1) Placement in an ABA class for three hours per day (subject to increase as STUDENT learned to follow a class routine) with one-to-one assistance from a CAP tutor;

(2) One-to-one CAP instruction for an additional three hours per day;

(3) Five thirty-minute sessions of individual S/L therapy per week;

(4) Two forty-five minute sessions of individual OT therapy per week; and (5) Eight hours per month of CAP supervision, including team meetings.

(Testimony of Dr. Wernick and Ms. Contreras; D. Exh. 8, p. 67-69; D. Exh. 10.)

The Student asserts that the District’s proposed transition plan was “grossly inadequate.” Further, he asserts that the District failed to offer him a FAPE for either the 2004 ESY or the 2004-2005 school year, because its proposed program did not consist of an ABA verbal behavior program using specified teaching methods and monitored by a BCBA. These arguments are addressed in turn below.

(a) Transition plan

The District offered STUDENT a two-week transition plan during which “the District will coordinate with current service providers in order to transition the goals and services.” According to Dr. Wernick, the transition period would allow the District’s ABA classroom teacher, Ms. Mazariegos, and the CAP supervisors to observe STUDENT at TBS in order to ensure a smooth transition between programs. During the transition period, the District offered to pay for STUDENT’s TBS program at the “Basic Daily Program” rate, which apparently refers to his $180 daily tuition at TBS. (D. Exh. 8, p. 68; S. Exh. 100; Testimony of FATHER.)

The Student contends that the offer of a two-week transition plan was not designed to meet his unique needs, but rather was a “unilateral administrative decision” designed to coincide with the District’s predetermined ESY schedule. Further, he alleges that the offered payment of his daily tuition was inadequate because it failed to include payment for the one-to-one behavioral intervention and S/L services he received at TBS or for the OT services he received through a separate provider. (Testimony of FATHER and Ms. Jolly; see S. Exh. 100.)

Neither federal nor State special education law expressly requires a school district to offer a formal transition plan to facilitate a student’s transfer from a private school into a special education placement in a public school. (Footnote 21) Nevertheless, a transition period allowing district personnel to observe, understand, and gradually assume control of a student’s current instructional program can be of great value to both the student and the district, and is commonly included in a district’s program offer when circumstances permit. As the IDEA requires the provision of a free appropriate public education, a program offer that includes such a transition period must assume the reasonable costs of the student’s current educational program for the transition period.

In this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of a two-week transition plan was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. Ms. Mazariegos testified that STUDENT’s TBS goals were similar to the goals of many of her students, and that she could have assumed responsibility for his program without difficulty. Dr. Wernick, who had many years’ experience as an SDC teacher prior to becoming an administrator, testified that she considered a two-week transition period to be appropriate because STUDENT had been at TBS for only two months, and would not be so invested in its routine or personnel as to require a longer transition period. (Footnote 22) Her judgment is supported by the assessments and observations attached to the June 2004 IEP, which indicate that STUDENT is a pleasant child who works easily with new individuals and is undisturbed by the presence of observers. (D. Exh. 8, attachments A-K.) Finally, Dr. Wernick acknowledged that the transition period was intended to coincide with the District’s ESY schedule, because she believed that a schedule allowing STUDENT to attend the entire ABA summer school class would help him adjust to his new peers and instructors in the District.

The Hearing Officer also finds that the District’s decision not to offer payment for one-to-one behavioral intervention services during the transition period was reasonable. The student-teacher ratio at TBS generally is two-to-one, with one-to-one services provided at an additional cost. (Testimony of Ms. Jolly.) Although the District’s program offer acknowledged that STUDENT required one-to-one assistance in the classroom, the transition would have accommodated and even exceeded this need through the presence of the District’s ABA teacher and CAP supervisors, who would be observing, actively learning, and eventually assuming the provision of instruction and services to STUDENT.

However, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to offer payment for STUDENT’s S/L and O/T services during the transition period (or in the alternative, to offer such services through District providers) was not consistent with its obligation to provide him with a FAPE. The District’s offer to STUDENT for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year included both S/L and O/T services, indicating that the District believed those program elements were necessary to provide him with a FAPE. Accordingly, S/L and O/T services should have been provided or paid for by the District during the transition period. (Footnote 23)

For the above reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of a two-week transition plan paid at TBS’ Basic Daily Rate was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, except to the extent that it failed to offer payment for his S/L and O/T services during that period.

(b) Substantive program (2004 ESY and 2004-2005 school year)

The Student asserts that the District failed to offer a FAPE for either the 2004 ESY or the 2004-2005 school year because it failed to offer a one-to-one ABA verbal behavior therapy program with specified teaching methods (errorless learning, intermittent reinforcement, mixed instructional demands and difficulty levels) monitored by a BCBA, as recommended by speech therapist and BCBA Ms. Franco in August 2003, and as implemented by TBS. (Footnote 24) He notes that Dr. Lebby also approved of a verbal behavior approach, and had stressed the importance of errorless learning in the Student’s program.

(ii) Details of the District’s program offer

The District’s ESY and regular school year program offers included three hours per day in an ABA class taught by Ms. Mazariegos, who had been a teacher, lead teacher, and interim administrator at the Pacific Autism Center for Education (PACE) for six years prior to her employment by the District. Ms. Mazariegos had received extensive training in ABA principles and was familiar with many ABA teaching methodologies. Although she was not specifically trained in verbal behavior therapy, she was familiar with its origins and approach, and noted that many verbal behavior concepts were shared by other ABA teaching methods: For example, the teaching of “mands” (requests) and “tacts” (labels) were basic to all forms of ABA therapy. Ms. Mazariegos also had some proficiency in ASL, possessing a vocabulary of over 300 signs. (Footnote 25) She considered sign language to be a valuable tool in building a functional language, and was prepared to use sign language as a part of STUDENT’s program. (Testimony of Ms. Mazariegos.)

Ms. Mazariegos testified that STUDENT’s IEP goals were similar to the goals of other students in her ABA classes. In the summer of 2004, her class was comprised of seven students aged eight to ten, assisted by three instructional aides. Six of her students were autistic, some were nonverbal, their cognitive skills varied, and they needed and received a considerable amount of one-to-one attention. Ms. Mazariegos’ classroom contained an open area for group instruction and partitioned areas for one-to-one instruction. Her class routine included a “circle time” period of group instruction, an outdoor walk focused on labeling items in nature and learning safety skills, a language session with one-to-one attention to the students’ goals, and gross motor activities developed by an adaptive physical education (APE) specialist.

During the 2004-2005 school year, Ms. Mazariegos had eight students in her ABA class, most of whom had attended her summer school class. She was assigned an additional aide for the school year, resulting in an eight-to-five student-teacher ratio. Although Ms. Mazariegos’ regular classroom aides were trained to work with special education students, the District’s offer to STUDENT included one-to-one support in the ABA class from a more highly trained Comprehensive Autism Program (CAP) tutor during both the ESY and the regular school year.

The District’s program offer for the four-week ESY and the regular school year specified that at the end of the three-hour ABA class day, STUDENT would receive an additional three hours per day of one-to-one CAP instruction to provide him with more intensive work on his goals and objectives. (Footnote 26) CAP co-developer and supervisor Chelsea Contreras testified that CAP was initiated by the special education local plan area (SELPA) to provide the District and two other local school districts with intensive one-to-one instruction for students with autism who need additional support outside of the classroom. The instruction is delivered by CAP tutors, who receive thirty hours of initial training in various ABA teaching methodologies, and who are supervised by a team of six supervisors, most of whom previously worked in private ABA programs offering varied approaches to autism intervention and treatment.

Ms. Contreras also was familiar with the origins and philosophy of verbal behavior therapy, and described its focus on breaking language down into functional categories. She testified that, although ABA methodologies vary in their approach and terminology, the ideas underlying verbal behavior theory are used in all ABA methodologies because ABA is focused on helping students with autism to develop functional communication systems. She noted, for example, that whether verbal behavior, PECS, sign language, or another approach is used to develop a student’s functional communication skills in an ABA program, “manding” (requesting) is the first skill taught.

(ii) Discussion

The Hearing Officer finds that the program offered by the District for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. The ABA class offered for the ESY and regular school year was comprised of students only slightly older than STUDENT with similar skill deficits and similar IEP goals. It was taught by Ms. Mazariegos, an experienced ABA teacher with enough proficiency in sign language to implement that aspect of STUDENT’s TBS program as well as his other TBS-developed goals. STUDENT would have received one-to-one support in the classroom from a highly trained CAP tutor, and would have had an opportunity to develop a foundation for eventual social skills by becoming accustomed to learning in the classroom’s group environment. STUDENT also would have received additional hours of intensive instruction on his goals and objectives by a CAP tutor every day after the ABA class. His motor skill delays, echolalia, perseverative speech, and articulation deficits would have been addressed in twice-weekly sessions of OT and S/L therapy during the ESY, and the S/L therapy would have increased to five sessions per week during the regular school year. Finally, any concerns about regression of his skills between the ESY and the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year would have been addressed by the four hours of daily one-to-one CAP instruction focusing on his goals and objectives that was offered as a five-week extended ESY program. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District’s program offer would have addressed STUDENT’s need for a highly structured and intense educational program to develop his functional language capabilities, as well as his needs for one-to-one assistance in the classroom, improved self-help skills, and beginning social skills. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that a verbal behavior program delivered through specified teaching techniques and monitored by a BCBA was necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs. Autism therapy is a rapidly developing field in which teaching methodologies continually evolve and gain or lose favor, and former TBS director Dr. Morgenstern acknowledged that the research is unclear as to whether the “verbal behavior” ABA model is any more effective than a “linguistic” ABA model that focuses more on listening behavior. Although Ms. Franco recommended verbal behavior therapy due to STUDENT’s facility for verbal imitation, she and other therapists also noted that STUDENT understood and responded to simple directions, indicating some strengths in listening behavior. Dr. Lebby found that STUDENT possessed considerable visual learning skills, and he and other assessors also noted STUDENT’s motor imitation skills, which are being exercised in the sign language aspect of his current educational program. Taken together, these assessments indicate that STUDENT has the potential to develop a functional communication system from any one or a combination of ABA teaching strategies emphasizing verbal, listening, visual, or motor-based communication methods.

Similarly, the Hearing Officer finds that the Student is not entitled to a program monitored by a BCBA. Although Dr. Long testified that the recently-developed BCBA certification process can help to identify competent ABA therapists, he acknowledged that an ABA therapist could be competent without having received a BCBA certificate. District ABA teacher Ms. Mazariegos is not a BCBA, but the Hearing Officer found her to be an impressive witness who appeared to be a highly competent ABA instructor, displaying clear knowledge of ABA principles, teaching styles, and behavior modification methods. Dilworth principal Ms. Karel testified that Ms. Mazariegos is a “phenomenal” special education teacher who receives considerable unsolicited praise from her students’ parents, and to whom Ms. Karel sends other teachers to learn from Ms. Mazariegos’ methods.

With respect to the specific teaching techniques recommended by Ms. Franco (errorless learning, intermittent reinforcement, mixed instructional demands and difficulty levels), Ms. Mazariegos and Ms. Contreras testified persuasively to their familiarity and experience with these techniques and their ability to incorporate them into STUDENT’s program if the techniques proved useful. (Footnote 27) The Hearing Officer was persuaded by the testimony of District witnesses that other teaching techniques also would address STUDENT’s unique needs, and that a good program would adapt to him as an individual rather than adhering to a predetermined list of techniques. (Testimony of Dr. Clare and Ms. Farber.) (Footnote 28)

Finally, the Hearing Officer acknowledges that Dr. Lebby had concluded that the CAP program’s “strict ABA-discrete trial program” would be unsuitable for STUDENT, based in part on his own assessment of STUDENT’s lack of tolerance for repetitive tasks and in part on the PARENTS’ assertion that a similar program in Colorado had been unsuccessful. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that Dr. Lebby’s conclusion was based on a single assessment session with STUDENT, a brief observation of a CAP instruction session presumably carried out in accordance with that student’s IEP, and information about STUDENT’s lack of progress in another program the previous year. None of this information alters the conclusion that the District’s program and placement offer to STUDENT for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year were appropriate. STUDENT was a year older, the CAP tutor would be a new and different instructor, and STUDENT would have been learning a new program with new goals and objectives developed by TBS and approved by the PARENTS. (Footnote 29)

A FAPE analysis must focus on the appropriateness of the placement proposed by the school district, not on the parents’ preferred alternative. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, supra, 811 F.2d at 1314. If the school district has offered a FAPE, the appropriateness of its offer will be upheld even if the parents’ preferred alternative might have provided a greater educational benefit to the student. Id. In this matter, the Hearing Officer has found that the District’s program and placement offer for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year constituted an offer of FAPE. Accordingly, STUDENT is not entitled to a BCBA-monitored verbal behavior therapy program funded by the District. (Footnote 30)

* * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that (1) the District erred procedurally by failing to secure the attendance of a TBS special education teacher or provider at STUDENT’s June 2, 2004 IEP meeting, but that the error did not result in the denial of a FAPE; (2) the District’s failure to physically incorporate STUDENT’s goals and objectives in his June and October 2004 IEP documents did not constitute procedural error; (3) the District’s offer of a two-week transition plan was appropriate, except to the extent that it failed to assume payment for STUDENT’s S/L and O/T services during that period; and (4) the substantive program and placement offered by the District for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year constituted an offer of FAPE.

Issue No. 2: Did the District offer the Student a FAPE for the 2005 ESY and the 2005-2006 school year?

At the May 25, 2005 IEP meeting, reports on recent observations of STUDENT at TBS were delivered by the PARENTS’ behavioral consultant Ms. Baldi, the District’s educational consultant Dr. Clare, and Dr. Wernick. All of the observers noted that STUDENT had appeared to function successfully in a group instruction setting with other TBS students. PARENTS also reported that STUDENT was learning to wait and take turns, but Dr. Clare noted that in her opinion, STUDENT had not yet appeared to master waiting and turn-taking skills sufficiently to participate in more advanced group learning situations. (D. Exh. 28.)

The parties agreed that STUDENT’s TBS goals and objectives, which had been updated at the October 2004 IEP meeting, would continue for the 2005 ESY and the 2005-2006 school year. The District then made the following offer to STUDENT for the 2005-2006 school year:

Placement in the ABA class for a full six-hour class day, five days per week;

CAP instruction for an additional two hours per day, provided either one-to-one or in a small group of two to three students;

Four thirty-minute sessions of S/L therapy per week; and

Two forty-five minute sessions of OT therapy per week. (Footnote 31)

At the meeting, Dr. Wernick stated that she would send the PARENTS a letter detailing the District’s offer for a transition program and for the 2005 ESY and extended ESY. Two days later, Dr. Wernick sent the PARENTS a letter stating that, to accommodate STUDENT’s transition from TBS, the District would pay for his TBS program at the “Basic Daily Rate” from June 2 through August 24, 2005, incorporating the ESY and extended ESY periods. (Footnote 32) The transition offer was made contingent upon the PARENTS’ agreement to enroll STUDENT in the District as of August 25, 2005, the first day of the 2005-2006 school year. (Testimony of Dr. Wernick; D. Exh. 28, pp. 212-213; D. Exh. 29.)

A. Transition plan (encompassing the 2005 ESY and extended ESY)

The Student contends that the District’s proposed transition plan was not designed to meet his unique needs, failed to offer full funding of his TBS program during the transition, and was inappropriately conditioned on his enrollment in the District for the regular school year. Further, he contends that the District’s “after the fact” letter setting forth the proposed transition plan violated his right to a formal written offer as described in Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965 (1994).

For the reasons stated in Issue No. 1 above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s three-month transition plan was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. Ms. Mazariegos, who continues to teach the ABA class at Dilworth, found STUDENT’s IEP goals to be similar to the goals of her other students, was prepared to assume responsibility for his program during the transition at TBS, and was ready to implement the program after STUDENT’s transfer into her ABA class. Dr. Wernick credibly testified that the offer of a three-month transition plan was in recognition of the fact that STUDENT had been at TBS for over a year, and could be best served by a longer transition timed to allow him to begin the regular school year with his peers. In light of this evidence, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that a three-month transition period was appropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer further finds that the District’s conditioning of its offer to pay STUDENT’s transition costs on his enrollment in the District for the regular school year did not constitute error. The point of the transition plan was to move STUDENT from TBS to a District program; if in the end, the PARENTS had decided that the transition should not occur, there would have been no point in the District assuming the costs of STUDENT’s TBS program during the transition period.

In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s conveyance of its proposed transition plan in a letter two days after the May 25, 2005 IEP meeting did not constitute a Union violation. The IDEA requires a school district to provide “written prior notice” to the parents of a special education student whenever the district proposes to initiate or change the student’s educational placement. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3)(A). In Union, the Ninth Circuit explained that the purpose of formal written notice is to help parents decide whether to accept the district’s program offer, to assist them in bringing complaints about the program, and to avoid later factual disputes about the program.

Here, the District gave the PARENTS formal written notice of its offer for the 2005-2006 school year in the May 25, 2005 IEP document, which included written notice that a letter outlining its proposed transition plan and its offer for the 2005 ESY and extended ESY would follow shortly. Dr. Wernick’s letter constituting formal written notice of the terms of the proposed transition plan, which would encompass the ESY and extended ESY, was sent to the PARENTS on May 27, two days after the IEP meeting and almost two weeks prior to the commencement of this due process hearing on June 8, 2005. At the hearing, there was no evidence of a factual dispute about the District’s proposed transition plan, and no testimony that the offer was too vague to allow the PARENTS to bring complaints about it or to decide whether to accept it.

Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s decision not to offer payment for one-to-one services at TBS during the transition was appropriate in light of the combined number of TBS and District teaching staff who would be participating in the transition process. For the reasons stated in Issue No. 1, however, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to assume payment for STUDENT’s ongoing S/L services or to offer him OT services during the transition was not consistent with its obligation to provide him with a FAPE. (Footnote 33)

B. Substantive program (2005-2006 school year)

At the time of the May 2005 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s needs were substantially the same as they had been at the time of the District’s previous program offer in June 2004, but with a noticeable improvement in his ability to learn alongside his peers. According to TBS staff, STUDENT had learned some new signs and receptive directions, and was making progress learning to wait and to accept “no.” His problem behaviors had decreased, and he was now participating with a few other students in a group instruction setting. The IEP team decided to continue STUDENT’s 2004 goals, as updated at the October 2004 IEP meeting, for the 2005-2006 school year. (D. Exh. 28.)

The District offered STUDENT a placement and program similar to that offered for the previous school year, but with modifications reflecting STUDENT’s progress over the last year. It increased the time offered in the Dilworth ABA class from three hours per day to a full (six-hour) day, and no longer offered one-to-one services from a CAP tutor in the classroom. In addition, the District reduced the offer of additional CAP instruction time from three to two hours per day, and noted that CAP instruction would be provided “either individually or in a small group of two to three.” The offer of individual S/L services was reduced from five to four thirty-minute sessions per week, and the offer of individual OT services remained the same at two forty-five minute sessions per week. (D. Exh. 28, pp. 212-213.)

The Student asserts that the substantive program offered by the District for the 2005-2006 school year did not constitute an offer of FAPE because it did not consist of an ABA verbal behavior program monitored by a BCBA. Further, he asserts that, after the District extended its 2004-2005 program offer in June 2004, various experts had observed the Dilworth ABA class and CAP program and had found them to be unsuitable for him. Finally, the Student notes that the District’s 2005-2006 offer no longer provided for one-to-one classroom support, which the Student asserts he continues to need in the classroom.

As noted in In re Gregory K., a FAPE analysis must focus primarily on the District’s proposed placement, not on the alternative preferred by the parents. 811 F.2d at 1314. Here, the District’s 2005-2006 offer was a modified version of its offer for the 2004-2005 school year, which the Hearing Officer found to be an offer of FAPE. In light of this earlier finding, the analysis of the District’s 2005-2006 offer will focus on the critiques of the CAP program and ABA class made after June 2, 2004, and on whether the District’s proposed program modifications for the 2005-2006 school year were appropriate to STUDENT’s changing social needs.

(1) Were the District’s CAP program and ABA class appropriate for STUDENT?

Between STUDENT’s annual IEP meetings on June 2, 2004 and May 25, 2005, Dr. Lebby, Dr. Mittelstadt and Ms. Baldi visited the CAP program and ABA class at Dilworth Elementary School and wrote reports describing their observations. Dr. Lebby observed a CAP instruction session for approximately one hour in June 2004, and was critical of the CAP tutors’ teaching capabilities. He noted that the aides often chose tasks based on what the students wanted to do, and that they often prompted the students’ responses but failed to follow up in a manner consistent with approved ABA teaching techniques. (Testimony of Dr. Lebby; S. Exh. 111.) Dr. Lebby also observed the Dilworth ABA class, which at the time was taught by Raj Pawar. (Footnote 34) He saw no use of verbal behavior therapy or errorless learning techniques, and felt that the aides were reinforcing maladaptive behaviors and inconsistently reinforcing positive behaviors. (Id.)

In September 2004, Dr. Mittelstadt conducted an assessment of STUDENT, and observed the Dilworth ABA class and CAP program for approximately twenty minutes each. She later observed the TBS program for approximately two hours. Dr. Mittelstadt believed STUDENT needed a verbal behavior therapy program monitored by a BCBA, errorless learning, and a finely calibrated, “micromanaged” program in order to succeed, all of which she observed at TBS but not in the Dilworth ABA class or CAP program. Dr. Mittelstadt also was critical of the ABA class instructors’ use of a “field of two” for some students’ discrimination trials, asserting that at least three options should be presented in a discrimination trial to decrease the possibility of guesswork. (Testimony of Dr. Mittelstadt; S. Exh. 74.)

In May 2005, Ms. Baldi observed the Dilworth ABA class and a CAP instruction session for about fifteen minutes each. Although she had some positive impressions of the ABA class, she was concerned about instances where the instructors appeared to be reinforcing negative behavior, and believed the noise level in the class was quite high. During her observation of the CAP instruction session, she was concerned that the instructor was presenting the materials to the student at an unusually high pace and volume. She also felt that a one-to-one CAP instruction session would be needlessly restrictive for STUDENT, given his apparent progress in participating in group instruction settings. (Testimony of Ms. Baldi; S. Exh. 96.)

In response, District witnesses asserted that many of the reported observations lacked necessary context. With respect to Ms. Baldi’s critical observation of a CAP session, for example, Ms. Contreras testified that the student in question had demonstrated a specific need for instruction at a high pace and volume. Regarding some observers’ reports of reinforcement of tantrums or other problem behaviors in the ABA class, Ms. Mazariegos testified that what may have appeared to be inappropriate reinforcement was in fact an effort to calm and refocus the students before requiring them to complete the task at hand. With respect to Dr. Mittelstadt’s critique of the use of a “field of two” in discrimination trials, Ms. Mazariegos testified that, as with errorless learning, she had found the use of a field of two to be an effective way to introduce new tasks to students who were easily overwhelmed or discouraged by a greater array of choices.

Discussion

The Hearing Officer finds that the above-referenced critiques do not alter her earlier conclusion that the Dilworth ABA class and CAP program would be appropriate placements for STUDENT. First, the observations giving rise to the critiques were of very short duration and without the benefit of context that might have been provided by an understanding of the observed students’ IEP goals and the instructors’ approaches to meeting those goals.

For example, Dr. Lebby concluded that the District’s ABA class and CAP program did not offer the linguistically stimulating program, errorless learning, and rapid change in stimuli he believed STUDENT needed to succeed. Dr. Lebby’s observations, however, were of students other than STUDENT, who were being instructed in accordance with the specific requirements of their individualized programs. STUDENT’s IEP for the 2005-2006 school year consists of linguistic-intensive goals that were adopted with Dr. Lebby’s approval in 2004. (D. Exh. 8, p. 59.) Ms. Mazariegos and CAP supervisor Ms. Contreras testified to their familiarity with a variety of teaching techniques, including errorless learning, and their readiness to implement the techniques that worked best for STUDENT in his program.

Similarly, one of the central critiques by the Student’s witnesses – that ABA and CAP instructors reinforced students’ problem behaviors with inappropriate attention instead of redirecting or ignoring the behaviors – was not persuasive when considered in context. Ms. Mazariegos credibly testified that at times, successful management of tantrums, crying or other problem behaviors first requires her to help the child regain emotional control. Once the child has calmed down, Ms. Mazariegos requires him or her to complete the task interrupted by the problem behavior, thereby teaching the child that problem behaviors will not work as an “escape” from difficult or non-preferred tasks. As children with autism often exhibit problem behaviors to escape tasks, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that paying attention to or comforting a child engaging in problem behaviors does not constitute inappropriate reinforcement if the behavior is not allowed to interfere with completion of the task.

The Hearing Officer also finds that the critiques’ persuasive force was lessened by the fact that they were at times internally inconsistent or inconsistent with each other. For example, Dr. Lebby stressed the importance of keeping STUDENT interested and motivated when learning, but criticized the CAP tutors for choosing tasks based on what their students wanted to do – a practice intended to keep students interested and motivated. Dr. Lebby believed STUDENT demonstrated visual processing strengths, whereas Ms. Baldi determined that STUDENT was “not a visual learner.” Dr. Lebby and Dr. Mittelstadt believed STUDENT needed a consistently high rate of reinforcement, whereas Ms. Franco stressed the importance of “intermittent reinforcement,” in which the student would not know when or how often reinforcement would occur.

Finally, some critiques of the District’s program appeared more reflective of the PARENTS’ preference for verbal behavior therapy than independently critical of the District’s ability to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. For example, Dr. Lebby criticized the ABA and CAP instructors’ failure to use verbal behavior therapy techniques, which Dr. Lebby advocated based on the PARENTS’ report that verbal therapy had worked for STUDENT in Colorado. (S. Exh. 8, pp. 2, 4; S. Exh. 111, pp. 1, 3.) Similarly, Dr. Mittelstadt concluded that STUDENTneeded a BCBA-monitored verbal behavior therapy program, but offered no explanation for this conclusion other than by reference to Dr. Lebby’s and Ms. Franco’s earlier recommendations. (S. Exh. 74.) (Footnote 35)

The Hearing Officer already has found that the District’s offered placement in its ABA class and CAP program constituted an offer of FAPE to STUDENT, and that he is not entitled to the BCBA-monitored verbal behavior therapy program preferred by his parents. The above-referenced critiques of the District’s offered placement do not constitute sufficient evidence to alter that finding. (Footnote 36)

(2) Did the District’s program modifications appropriately address STUDENT’s changing social needs?

According to Dr. Wernick, the District’s offer for the 2005-2006 school year was intended to recognize and encourage STUDENT’s budding social development. The increase in ABA class hours and corresponding reduction in CAP instruction hours, as well as the use of small group CAP instruction if appropriate, was intended to reflect STUDENT’s ability to learn alongside his peers. The overall increase in his school day (from the six hours offered in 2004-2005 to eight hours in 2005-2006) was considered appropriate in light of his increased age and the decrease in problem behaviors that interfered with his learning. The offer of S/L sessions was reduced from five to four per week in recognition of the increased language opportunities he would receive in an eight-hour school day.

Dr. Wernick also testified that the District’s previous offer of a one-to-one CAP tutor was not renewed for the 2005-2006 school year because STUDENT’s ability to work alongside his peers reduced his need for one-to-one attention, and because the District had changed its approach in the way it used its aides in the classroom. In addition, Ms. Mazariegos testified that her ABA class for the 2005-2006 school year currently is comprised of six enrolled students and five assigned instructional aides, providing a one-to-one student-teacher ratio. Ms. Mazariegos added that she had been assured by Dr. Wernick that if STUDENT needed a one-to-one aide after the transition had occurred, one would be provided.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s 2005-2006 offer appropriately addressed STUDENT’s changing social needs, except to the extent that it no longer offered STUDENT one-to-one support from a CAP tutor in the ABA classroom and no longer specified that his CAP instruction would be provided exclusively in a one-to-one setting.

The Hearing Officer notes that, in modifying its 2004-2005 program offer to address STUDENT’s unique needs in the 2005-2006 school year, the District proceeded on the theory that STUDENT’s ability to function alongside a few of his peers at TBS indicated that he was ready to learn in a group setting. According to observers’ reports, however, the group learning skills STUDENT had demonstrated to date consisted of working without distraction in the presence of other students, and participating in some choral response activities (waving and clapping as a group). As noted by Dr. Clare, there was no indication that STUDENT had mastered the waiting and turn-taking skills necessary to benefit from a broader group instruction experience. Further, the witnesses generally agreed that STUDENT’s tendency toward perseveration required the sort of intensive intervention that one-to-one classroom support provides.

Although the District has indicated that in its current configuration, Ms. Mazariegos’ ABA class has a one-to-one ratio of instructors to students, the Hearing Officer notes that one of the features stressed by the District in its 2004-2005 program offer was that STUDENT would be supported in the ABA class by a more extensively trained and experienced CAP tutor. The District’s assertion that the decision not to offer one-to-one classroom support was prompted in part by a “change in the District’s approach” to its use of aides was unexplained and appears irrelevant to the District’s obligation to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Further, the Hearing Officer notes that the District’s offer of two hours per day of CAP instruction “either individually or [in a] small group of two to three” does not specify the basis for deciding between individual or small group instruction, and appears to offer a less intensive instructional experience in the CAP program than was offered in the 2004-2005 school year. Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s apparent willingness to provide STUDENT with eventual one-to-one classroom support “if necessary” fails to address his unique needs at this time. Instead, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs would be met by providing him at the outset with a one-to-one CAP tutor in the ABA class, and one-to-one CAP instruction after class, until the IEP team finds that one-to-one support in either or both settings no longer is necessary.

* * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed three-month transition plan, which encompassed the 2005 ESY and extended ESY, constituted an offer of FAPE, except to the extent that it did not include an offer to pay for STUDENT’s weekly S/L services or to offer him OT services during the transition from TBS to the District. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer for the 2005-2006 school year constituted an offer of FAPE, except to the extent that it failed to provide for one-to-one support by a CAP tutor in the ABA class, and failed to provide exclusively for one-to-one CAP instruction after class.

Issue No. 3: If the District failed to provide the Student with an offer of FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year, is the Student entitled to reimbursement for his educational expenses during that period?

The Student seeks reimbursement for his educational expenses for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year, as well as for the cost of the clinical observations, classroom observations, and consultation services provided by Dr. Lebby, Dr. Mittelstadt, and Ms. Baldi between June 2004 and May 2005. (Footnote 37)

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the cost of placement or services procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE, and when the placement provided by the parents is appropriate under the IDEA. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(ii); 34 C.F.R. 300.403(c); School Committee of the town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 370 (1985).

In this matter, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year, except to the extent that it failed to offer payment for STUDENT’s ongoing S/L and O/T services during the two-week transition period offered before the start of the ESY session. However, as the S/L and O/T services at issue were a part of a proposed transition that did not occur, the PARENTS were not obliged to purchase any services to compensate for this error, and incurred no reimbursable expenses as a result. Therefore, the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for STUDENT’s educational expenses during the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year. With respect to the observation and consultation expenses for which reimbursement is sought, the Student’s closing brief describes Dr. Lebby’s observations and consultations as “necessary to consider [the District’s] program/placement/service options,” and Dr. Mittelstadt’s and Ms. Baldi’s observations and consultations as “necessary for STUDENT’s IEP team given his complicated issues [and] behavioral needs.” As described in the Student’s brief and as further illuminated in documents and testimony, these services do not meet the definition of specially designed instruction and “related services” for which reimbursement is allowed under Burlington. See 20 U.S.C. §§ 1401(22), 1401(25); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z). As the Student offers no authority for reimbursement of such expenses, and the Hearing Officer is aware of none, the Student’s request for reimbursement for these expenses is denied.

Issue No. 4: If the District failed to provide the Student with an offer of FAPE for the 2005 ESY and the 2005-2006 school year, is the Student entitled to reimbursement for his educational expenses for the 2005 ESY and to prospective placement at TBS for the 2005-2006 school year?

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA, which may include reimbursement for the cost of privately obtained educational services, or prospective placement at a nonpublic school at the school district’s expense. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(ii); 34 C.F.R. 300.403(c); Burlington, supra, 471 U.S. at 369.

In this matter, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2005 ESY, except to the extent that it failed to offer payment for STUDENT’s ongoing S/L services or to offer him O/T services during the three-month transition proposed to encompass the ESY and extended ESY sessions. However, as the S/L and O/T services in question were a part of a proposed transition that did not occur, the PARENTS were not obliged to purchase any services to compensate for this error, and incurred no reimbursable expenses as a result. Therefore, the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for STUDENT’s educational expenses for the 2005 ESY.

The Hearing Officer also has found that the District’s offer for the 2005-2006 school year constituted an offer of FAPE, except to the extent that it failed to offer STUDENT daily one-to-one support from a CAP tutor in the ABA class and failed to provide exclusively for daily one-to-one instruction in the CAP program after class. There is no indication, however, that the District is unable to correct its offer to provide for the specified one-to-one support if ordered to do so. In all other areas, the Hearing Officer found that the District provided STUDENT with an offer of FAPE. Accordingly, no prospective placement is warranted.

ORDER

1. Within fifteen (15) calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to revise its offer to STUDENT for the 2005 ESY and the 2005-2006 school year as follows:

(a) The offer shall provide for a transition period of no less than three months, during which the District shall (1) assume the cost of STUDENT’s TBS program at the Basic Daily Rate, (2) provide for individual O/T services with a duration and frequency equivalent to the OT services offered for the 2005-2006 school year, and (3) at the District’s option, either provide for individual S/L services with a duration and frequency equivalent to the S/L services offered for the 2005-2006 school year or assume the cost of STUDENT’s ongoing S/L services at the indicated rate of $240 per month for the three-month period. (Footnote 38)

(b) The offer for the 2005-2006 school year shall provide STUDENT with classroom support by a CAP tutor for the full six-hour ABA class day, and for exclusively one-to-one instruction in the two-hour CAP sessions after class.

2. The District shall remain ready to implement all portions of its program offer to STUDENT for the remainder of the 2005 ESY and extended ESY (which would be encompassed in the new transition period) and for the 2005-2006 school year, as set forth in the offer described in District Exhibit 28, and as further modified in accordance with this Order.

3. All of the Student’s other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:

The Student prevailed on his claim that the District’s offers for the 2004 ESY and 2005 ESY denied him a FAPE to the limited extent that these offers failed to assume the cost of his S/L and O/T services, or to offer him equivalent services, during his transition from TBS to a District program.

The Student prevailed on his claim that the District’s offer for the 2005-2006 school year denied him a FAPE to the limited extent that it failed to provide him with one-to-one support from a CAP tutor in the ABA classroom and for exclusively one-to-one instruction in the CAP program after class.

The District prevailed on all other issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).

Date: August 12, 2005 _________________________________________ Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1 For ease of reference, this Decision will refer to the period from June 2, 2004 through the end of the 2003-2004 extended school year as “the 2004 ESY.”

2 For ease of reference, this Decision will refer to the 2004-2005 extended school year as “the 2005 ESY.”

3 “Verbal behavior” is an ABA teaching methodology derived from the concept, originally developed by B.F. Skinner, that language can be broken down into functional categories. For example, the word “pen” may be taught as a “tact” (label or name), “mand” (request), “receptive” (response to a question), or “intraverbal” (word used in conversation). The verbal behavior methodology is based on the theory that learning to use a word in varied contexts enhances understanding of the word’s meaning and of the mechanics of language. (Testimony of Dr. Long.)

4 “Errorless teaching” or “errorless learning” is a technique in which the teacher prompts the student with the correct answer before seeking a response. The purpose of the technique is to allow the student to succeed in learning the correct answer, instead of being distracted or discouraged by giving an incorrect answer. Errorless learning is most commonly used in the initial stages of teaching a new skill. (Testimony of Ms. Cantwell.)

5 FATHER testified that he arranged for Dr. Lebby’s assessment in early November of 2003, when he knew the PARENTS would be moving to Cupertino. He stated that he selected Dr. Lebby from a list of several Northern California neuropsychologists recommended by Internet support groups, and that at the time he did not realize that Fresno was so far from Cupertino. Dr. Lebby’s report indicates that the PARENTS were referred to him by Ralph Lewis, the PARENTS’ previous attorney. (S. Exh. 14.) 6 While awaiting an opening for STUDENT at TBS, the PARENTS retained private therapists recommended by an Internet support group to work on generalizing STUDENT’s current skills at home. (Testimony of MOTHER.)

7 In a letter written to Dr. Wernick after the June 2004 IEP, MOTHER asserted that the District had “summarily rejected” the TBS goals at the IEP meeting. Dr. Wernick responded that the District had accepted the TBS goals, and noted that this acceptance had been documented in the IEP. (D. Exh. 11,12.)

8 An LEA must provide for an extended school year (ESY) session when a disabled student’s IEP team determines such a session is necessary to provide a FAPE. 34 C.F.R. § 300.309; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043. In California, an ESY session consisting of no fewer than twenty days of instruction must be provided when interruption of a student’s educational program may cause regression that is unlikely to be recouped in the next school year. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043. The parties do not dispute that STUDENT needed an ESY session as a part of his program.

9 TBS is a year-round school with instruction breaks of one week between quarters instead of a long summer break. (Testimony of Ms. Jolly.)

10 Although Dr. Mittelstadt’s report states that she observed “the SDC class” at Dilworth, a comparison of her observation notes with Ms. Mazariegos’ testimony suggests that Dr. Mittelstadt actually observed Ms. Mazariegos’ ABA class, which was the class the District had offered to STUDENT.

11 Dr. Clare brought her written report to the May 2005 IEP meeting, but after listening to the discussion, decided not to submit it as a finished report at that time. She gave an oral report at the IEP meeting, and later supplemented her written report with a discussion of a “program components survey” of features common to successful autism treatment programs that she believed would address some of the questions posed at the meeting. (Testimony of Dr. Clare; see D. Exh. 30.)

12 Dr. Wernick testified that she did not present the District’s offer for the 2005 ESY at the May 2005 IEP meeting because she wanted to consult with counsel about offering a longer transition plan than had been offered at the previous IEP meeting.

13 Because the events at issue in this dispute occurred prior to the July 1, 2005 effective date of the reauthorized IDEA, the Hearing Officer applies the law that was in effect at that time.

14 Federal and State law also require that LEAs educate disabled children in the least restrictive environment (LRE), with removal from the regular educational environment occurring only when the nature and severity of the children’s disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301. As the Student has raised no LRE-related claim in this hearing, this Decision does not include an analysis of the District’s offered placements in light of LRE requirements.

15 Generally, a substantive evaluation of a special education program under the IDEA also requires an analysis of whether the services provided comported with the student’s IEP. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 201. In this case, the District’s program offers were declined, and no District services were provided to STUDENT during the time periods at issue. Accordingly, no comportment analysis is required.

16 In his closing brief, the Student also alleges that the June 2004 IEP was procedurally flawed because it failed to expressly acknowledge that the goals developed for him in Colorado were no longer applicable once his new goals had been adopted, and failed to specify the services offered in its CAP program. As these issues were not identified for hearing, however, they are not addressed in this Decision.

17 The parties did not dispute that Dr. Morgenstern qualified as a special education “provider” for STUDENT. Although Dr. Morgenstern did not provide STUDENT with day-to-day instruction, he actively participated in STUDENT’s evaluations and in the development of his educational program and behavior support plan.

18 There was no evidence that Ms. Jolly had observed the District’s offered placements prior to the June 2004 IEP meeting or that she possessed any other information relevant to the appropriateness of the District’s offer.

19 The June 2004 IEP states that the TBS goals and objectives were presented and accepted by the District, but does not indicate that they were attached to the IEP document. (D. Exh. 8, p. 59.) The October 2004 IEP states that the goals and objectives were addressed, updated, and “attached to this addendum,” but the goals and objectives are not attached to the copy of the IEP provided as an exhibit by the District. (D. Exh. 14, p. 156.)

20 During the 2004-2005 school year, STUDENT received both academic instruction and S/L services at TBS. (Testimony of Ms. Jolly.)

21 The law expressly requires IEPs to contain specific transition plans or services in two circumstances: To prepare students for post-secondary education, vocational training, or employment, and to help students transfer from a special class or nonpublic school into a regular education class in the public school system. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(vii); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56345(b)(4), 56345.1.

22 Dr. Wernick noted that, when the District renewed its offer to the PARENTS at the October 2004 and January 2005 IEP meetings, it offered a four-week transition period in recognition of the fact that STUDENT had been at TBS for several additional months, and might need more time to adjust to a new program. (D. Exhs. 14-16.)

23 In addition, the parties clearly agreed that STUDENT’s lack of functional language skills was his most severe deficit. If the District believed STUDENT’s language needs would be adequately addressed without S/L services during the transition period, it provided no evidence or argument to that effect.

24 Both Dr. Morgenstern, TBS’ former executive director, and Dr. Long, its current executive director, are BCBAs. Ms. Jolly, STUDENT’s lead teacher at TBS, is an associate BCBA.

25 By contrast, TBS teacher Ms. Jolly testified that she knew approximately 30 ASL signs, and would look up new signs in an ASL handbook when she wanted to teach a new sign to STUDENT.

26 The District also offered twenty hours per week of one-to-one CAP instruction for the “extended” ESY, the five-week period bridging the end of the 2004 ESY and the beginning of the 2004-2005 regular school year.

27 Ms. Mazariegos testified that she typically uses errorless learning to teach new skills. She provides initial prompts to allow a student to learn the correct response, and then “fades” the prompts as the skill is acquired.

28 For example, Dr. Lebby advocated errorless learning to “break through” STUDENT’s tendency to perseverate on a response (such as repeating the word “horse” when shown pictures of a variety of animals). However, District S/L therapist Ms. Farber testified that she has been successful addressing perseverative behavior with other techniques (such as switching from the picture-labeling exercise to a discrimination trial to help the student distinguish between the horse and other animals).

29 The evidence also indicates that STUDENT made some progress in his Colorado program, which included 30 hours per week of ABA therapy at the time of his May 2003 IEP. According to the IEP progress reports, STUDENT was learning to finish sentences with his known vocabulary, would comply with verbal prompts and classroom directions, could use the toilet and wash his hands with verbal prompts, and was able to trace the letters of his name with a visual model and prompting. (D. Exh. 4.)

30 After the District made its offer for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year, Dr. Lebby and others made additional observations of the Dilworth ABA class and CAP program. The Hearing Officer took these observations into account in analyzing the District’s offer for the 2005 ESY and the 2005-2006 school year (Issue No. 2, infra), but did not consider them in the analysis of the District’s 2004-2005 offer, since they were not available to STUDENT’s IEP team at the time of that offer. See Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999).

3 Dr. Wernick testified that the offers of S/L and OT therapy were intended to indicate individual therapy sessions. At the hearing, counsel for the Student indicated that the Student’s allegations of denials of FAPE did not include any challenges to the District’s offers of S/L and OT therapy.

32 In contrast to the District’s offer for the 2004-2005 school year, which included a two-week transition program preceding its four-week ESY and five-week extended ESY sessions, the District’s offer for the 2005-2006 school year included a three-month transition program that would encompass its ESY and extended ESY sessions. The proposed transition would take place at TBS, with District personnel on hand to observe and eventually assume the delivery of STUDENT’s current educational program. (Testimony of Dr. Wernick.)

33 MOTHER testified that since STUDENT’s private OT provider moved out of the area in April 2005, STUDENT has received no OT services. Nevertheless, the District’s obligation to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the transition required it to provide all related services necessary to a FAPE. As indicated in the District’s program offer for the 2005-2006 school year, those necessary related services included OT services.

34 Ms. Pawar taught the Dilworth ABA class through the end of the 2003-2004 school year. Ms. Mazariegos replaced Ms. Pawar as the ABA class teacher for the 2004 ESY, and has remained its teacher since that time. (Testimony of Ms. Mazariegos.)

35 Of the witnesses for both parties who either advocated verbal behavior therapy or professed to understand its theory and application, Dr. Mittelstadt was the only one who was unable to define it upon request. Further, Dr. Mittelstadt was unable to explain what BCBA certification provided or why BCBA monitoring was important to STUDENT’s program.

36 It is worth noting that, although STUDENT has been receiving a BCBA-monitored verbal behavior therapy program at TBS for over a year, his actual gains in functional communication skills appear limited at best. STUDENT’s goal sheets indicate that after ten months at TBS, he had mastered the vocal or sign language approximations for ten to thirteen “mands,” including “bubbles,” “chip,” “go,” and “swing.” (S. Exh. 78, p. 11; testimony of Ms. Jolly.) Dr. Lebby observed STUDENT at TBS in June 2005, and testified that he was impressed with STUDENT’s ability to respond to directions like “no” and “come here,” and to use sign approximations for “swing” and “bubbles.”

However, STUDENT’s early evaluations from Colorado indicated that at ages three and four, he understood “no,” “come here,” “sit down,” and “stand up,” followed simple instructions, and understood approximately twenty commands and fifty words. (S. Exhs. 1,3.) Further, his May 2003 IEP from Colorado (which occurred prior to his enrollment in a verbal therapy program in July 2003) indicated that STUDENT could respond to “no,” “stop,” and about twenty other simple commands, and could identify several known items, including “chip” and “swing.” (D. Exh. 4.) Finally, in a three-segment TBS video taken to show STUDENT’s progress from June to August and then to December 2004, STUDENT can be seen to use sign and vocal approximations for “bubbles,” “chip” and “go” in all three segments, without showing noticeable progress from one segment to the next. (S. Exh. 101.)

37 The Student seeks reimbursement for these observations and consultation services as educational expenses, not as independent educational evaluations sought as the result of a disagreement with District assessments. Cf. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56329, 56506.

38 The Student’s expense sheets indicate that he receives S/L services at TBS four times per month at a rate of approximately $60 per session, or $240 per month. (S. Exh. 100.)