California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 29, 1997

Glendale Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 521-97 · Hearing Officer Keltie Jones

Glendale Unified shows its special day class cannot serve a student with serious emotional disturbance; day-treatment placement and behavior plan ordered.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Decision notes a prior parent-filed case, SN 22-97 (filed January 9, 1997), taken off calendar at the parent's request on April 11, 1997. No remand, vacatur, or correction noted.

Summary

Glendale Unified School District filed for a hearing to decide where a 10-year-old fifth grader should be placed. He was eligible for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed. He had done well in a special day class (SDC) in Los Angeles Unified. After moving to Glendale in fall 1996, he showed severe disruptive and aggressive behavior at two District schools, during home teaching, and during a visit to the SDC at Keppel Elementary. The District proposed a nonpublic school (NPS) day-treatment program. His mother wanted the Keppel SDC, with an extra aide and herself in class, or home-based independent study. She also asked for a Hughes Bill behavior plan.

Hearing Officer Keltie Jones relied on District staff who testified that an SDC could not meet his needs. She also found that having the mother in class, or teaching him at home, would not work. Applying Rowley and the Rachel H. test, she held that the least restrictive appropriate placement was a separate day program for emotionally disturbed students. It must have small classes and on-call counselors, plus individual and family counseling and a behavior intervention plan. The District gave too little evidence about its three proposed schools to approve any of them. The IEP team must meet within 15 days to choose a certified placement and write new goals. The District must complete a functional analysis assessment and behavior plan within 30 days after he starts there.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO used the Rachel H. factors to approve a more restrictive day-treatment setting for a student with severe behavior needs. It also shows that a district could win on the type of placement but still have its specific nonpublic school choices left unapproved because it gave too little evidence about those schools.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. What is the appropriate educational placement for Student? (District sought NPS day-treatment placement for SED students; parent sought the Keppel Elementary SDC with an extra aide and her daily presence, or home independent study.)

    District SDC, mother-assisted SDC, and independent study cannot meet Student's needs; the appropriate LRE is a segregated non-residential SED facility with small classes, on-call counselors, individual and family counseling, and a BIP, though the evidence was insufficient to approve any of the three NPSs the District proposed.

  2. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2 (unnumbered: Hughes Bill assessment). Parent asserted the District should conduct a Hughes Bill assessment and develop a behavioral intervention plan for Student.

    District did not contest the need; Student's behavior and attendance prevented a functional analysis so far, but he requires a functional analysis assessment and BIP as part of his placement, designed to help him return to a public school SDC.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Placement ordered. Appropriate placement shall include a segregated, non-residential facility specializing in serving SED students, with small class sizes and on-call counselors to address behavior problems; individual and family counseling; and a behavioral intervention plan. Any NPS selected must be certified by the Department of Education.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. IEP team to meet within 15 calendar days of the order to select a placement conforming to the decision and write appropriate goals and objectives for the 1997-98 school year; IEP must include individual and family counseling as designated instructional services.
  • Order to assess. District to arrange a functional analysis assessment and develop a behavioral intervention plan within the first 30 days of Student's attendance at the new placement, designed to enable transition back to a public school SDC.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H. (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398; P.L. 105-17 (1997 IDEA Amendments) §§ 602(8), 602(25), 612(a)(5); Education Code §§ 56031, 56364, 56520-56524; 5 CCR § 3052

People named in the decision

  • G. Robert Roice, educational consultant representing District, Glendale Unified School District
  • Tim Walker, special education coordinator, Glendale Unified School District
  • Georgia Katelanis, school psychologist, Franklin Elementary School, Glendale Unified School District
  • Elaine Sleeper, RSP teacher, Franklin Elementary School, Glendale Unified School District
  • Debra Friedman, school psychologist, Jefferson Elementary School (assessor), Glendale Unified School District
  • Helen Rim, SDC teacher, Jefferson Elementary School, Glendale Unified School District
  • Leonard (Lenny) Castellaneta, home teacher; continuation high school teacher, Glendale Unified School District
  • Sue Schuck, home teacher (first assigned), Glendale Unified School District
  • Nancy Chefalo, SDC teacher, Keppel Elementary School, Glendale Unified School District
  • Almansor Center, nonpublic school proposed by District
  • Dubnoff Center, nonpublic school proposed by District
  • New School for Child Development, nonpublic school proposed by District
  • Tobinworld, nonpublic school (attended by sibling)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 521-97 Case Year: 1997 Petitioner: GLENDALE UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT Issue: Placement CDS Code: 19-64568 District: Glendale Unified Disability Type: Seriously Emotionally Disturbed

Case Details This matter was heard on July 1, 1997, in Glendale, California, before Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Office, McGeorge School of Law.

Petitioner Glendale Unified School District (District) was represented by educational consultant G. Robert Roice. Also present on the District's behalf was Tim Walker, a coordinator for special education for the District. Respondent STUDENT was present at the hearing and was represented by MOTHER his mother. Also present on the respondent's behalf for portions of the hearing was FATHER, STUDENT's father.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing briefs by July 11, 1997. The Hearing Office received a closing brief from the District, but did not receive any additional argument from the Respondent. The record was closed on July 11, 1997, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUE

What is the appropriate educational placement for STUDENT?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District contends that STUDENT needs a nonpublic school (NPS) placement in a school that serves emotionally disturbed (SED) students on a day-treatment basis.

The Respondent does not want to be placed in an NPS and contends that the special day class (SDC) at Keppel Elementary School with an extra aide and his mother's daily assistance in class is appropriate for him. The Respondent also contends that an appropriate placement should include a behavioral intervention plan prepared pursuant to Hughes Bill. In the alternative, the Respondent proposes a home schooling placement.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a ten-year-old fifth-grade student who is eligible for special education because he is seriously emotionally disturbed. STUDENT first displayed learning problems in the first grade, when he often refused to participate in classroom activities. At that time, STUDENT attended school at Alessandro Elementary School in the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD). A school psychologist for LAUSD assessed STUDENT in August 1993 and concluded that STUDENT was seriously emotionally disturbed. STUDENT was placed in an SDC in second grade and continued in that SDC through fourth grade.

During the summer between fourth and fifth grades, STUDENT's parents separated and he moved with his mother to Glendale. In September 1996, STUDENT enrolled in the Glendale Unified School District, in his neighborhood school, Franklin Elementary School (Franklin). He attended Franklin for less than two weeks. There being no SDC AT Franklin, he was placed in a regular class until the District could determine his needs. Dist. Exh. 2. While at Franklin, STUDENT caused serious disturbances on at least two occasions. One incident involved his running around on the lunch tables during lunch time and refusing to obey school personnel who asked him to stop. Another incident, which may have occurred on the same day, involved STUDENT leaving his class and disturbing other classrooms while trying to find his brother. The principal ordered all classes to lock their doors to prevent STUDENT from entering any other classes. (Testimony of Sleeper and Katelanis.)

In mid-September, STUDENT was assigned to an SDC at Jefferson Elementary School (Jefferson). On his first day at the school, when he was being introduced to the SDC, STUDENT hit Debra Friedman, the school psychologist. During his attendance at Jefferson, STUDENT constantly used profane language and refused to follow directions from school personnel. STUDENT's mother accompanied him to school every day and stayed with him in class. STUDENT never stayed in school for a full day, and he stopped attending altogether in mid-October, when he was placed on home teaching at his mother's request. (Testimony of Friedman and Rim.)

The first home teacher assigned to STUDENT, Sue Schuck, refused to teach him because he ried to attack her at their first meeting. STUDENT tried to punch Ms. Schuck and to hit her in the head with a flashlight. Dist. Exh. 8. The second teacher assigned also refused to teach STUDENT. Dist. Exh 2. The third home teacher, Lenny Castellaneta, agreed to teach STUDENT in spite of STUDENT's verbal abuse and attempted physical abuse. Mr. Castellaneta was unable to teach STUDENT at home because the family did not have a table at which they could sit; therefore, Mr. Castellaneta taught STUDENT at a park close to STUDENT's house. The home teaching sessions were punctuated with STUDENT's physical abuse of his mother. (Testimony of Castellaneta, Dist. Exh. 10.) On November 20, 1996, Ms. Friedman made a child abuse report indicating that STUDENT was out of control and physically abusing his mother, Dist. Exh. 9. On the same day, the police removed STUDENT from the home and placed him in a hospital for evaluation. MOTHER checked STUDENT out of the hospital about three days later, and his home teaching sessions resumed. MOTHER terminated the home teaching as of December 20, 1996. Dist. Exh. 11.

On January 2, 1997, MOTHER and STUDENT visited another District SDC at Keppel Elementary School. They were in the class for a very short time; however, during that time STUDENT abused computer equipment, refused to listen when teacher told him to stop, tried to grab a chair from the teacher, and deliberately knocked books and a vase off a counter on his way out of the room. Nancy Chefalo, the SDC teacher, told MOTHER that she should leave and return without STUDENT. (Testimony of Chefalo.) On January 9, 1997, MOTHER filed a request for a due process hearing with the Hearing Office, Case No. SN 22-97. On April 11, 1997, MOTHER requested that the case be taken off calendar. On May 5, 1997, the District filed a request for due process hearing for this case.

On January 14, 1997, the District wrote MOTHER offering to place STUDENT in an NPS because the District's SDC program could not meet his needs. The District proposed the Almansor Center, the Dubnoff Center, and the New School for Child Development. Dist. Exh. 15. MOTHER did not agree to place STUEDENT in any of these schools. IEP meetings were held on February 18, 1997, and March 17, 1997, at which the District continued to offer the NPS placement, but agreed to fund an independent study program for sixty days. On June 20, 1997, a mediated IEP meeting was held. At that meeting, school personnel observed STUDENT hit and kick his mother, and he disrupted the meeting so that it could not continue. (Testimony of Katelanis, Dist. Exh. 20.)

The District referred STUDENT for an AB3632 mental health assessment on October 16, 1996. MOTHER apparently consented to that assessment, but later withdrew her consent. MOTHER later agreed to the mental health assessment, which was completed on June 24, 1997. The parties received the report from the mental health assessment shortly before the hearing. The report recommended that STUDENT receive individual, group and family counseling and medications as necessary, but it did not make a placement recommendation. Dist. Exh. 26. MOTHER pursued an inter-district transfer so that STUDENT could attend his old SDC in LAUSD, but the transfer was denied. (Testimony of MOTHER.)

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

District's Witnesses Georgia Katelanis Ms. Katelanis is a school psychologist at Franklin Elementary School. She first met STUDENT during his first week at Franklin Elementary School when she was called out to the playground because STUDENT was out of control. When she arrived, she saw STUDENT jumping around on the tables and yelling profanity at the teachers. Ms Katelanis stated that she had everyone leave the area to deprive STUDENT of his audience, and then she got STUDENT to some down. Ms. Katelanis convinced STUDENT to come to her room by telling him he could play games with her or do work for the principal. Ms Katelanis testified that she had to say the opposite of what she wanted STUDENT to do to get him to do anything. Ms. Katelanis stated that while STUDENT was in her room, he knocked things off shelves, kicked furniture, and swore. She ignored this behavior and tried to find out what was making him so angry, but was unable to do so. According to Ms. Katelanis, STUDENT calmed down a bit and she took him out for his lunch period. Ms. Katelanis said her approach to STUDENT was crisis intervention, but it is not an approach that could be used long-term in the regular school setting. In fact, Ms Katelanis testified that STUDENT's behavior escalated again later that day, resulting in the "lockdown" situation. (Testimony of Elaine Sleeper.)

Ms. Katelanis testified that on one occasion she observed STUDENT in the office when he was angry because he did not like a pencil he had bought from a pencil machine. He yelled "I want a refund" over and over, and then threw the pencil at the principal. According to Ms. Katelanis, the principal locked her office door, and STUDENT then banged on the door. MOTHER was present during this behavior, but never told STUDENT to stop. Ms. Katelanis stated that she told STUDENT she would call the police if he did not leave with his mother.

Ms. Katelanis testified that she attended an IEP meeting on June 12, 1997, with MOTHER, other school personnel, and a mediator. During the IEP, STUDENT came into the room and began to hit and kick his mother. Ms. Katelanis stated that MOTHER left the room with STUDENT, and then returned with him about fifteen minutes later. During the meeting, STUDENT kept whispering to his mother and elbowing her.

Ms. Katelanis expressed the opinion that STUDENT needs placement where the classes are small, the personnel are trained to deal with SED children, and counselors are on hand daily to intervene when his behavior is out of control. She also stated that STUDENT needs both individual and family counseling. Ms. Katelanis stated that she is familiar with programs proposed by the District and that she believes that each NPS proposed would provide the structure and staff support that STUDENT needs.

Elaine Sleeper Ms. Sleeper is an RSP teacher at Franklin Elementary School. She has worked in special education for about thirty years, including work at an NPS that served SED students. BROTHER, STUDENT's brother, received RSP services in her class at Franklin during the 1996-97 school year. During the first two weeks of September, STUDENT's fifth grade teacher asked her to observe STUDENT in class. Ms. Sleeper testified that she observed STUDENT being very oppositional and disruptive in class. STUDENT shook desks, pounded tables, and escalated his behavior when asked to stop. Ms. Sleeper stated that one day she observed STUDENT on the playground running around on the lunch tables, stepping on children's lunches. Some of the male teachers chased him down and took him into the school building. STUDENT was then brought to Ms. Sleeper's room, where he went through her personal belongings. Ms. Sleeper testified that she blocked the door when STUDENT tried to leave her room, but he pushed her out of the way and left. According to Ms. Sleeper, STUDENT wanted to leave school and was trying to enter other classrooms to find his brother. At that point, the principal used the public address system to call for a "lockdown," instucting all teachers to lock their doors. Ms. Sleeper atated that she had never heard the principal call for a lockdown before.

Ms. Sleeper stated that she believes STUDENT's behavior is incompatible with an SDC. Ms. Slpeer thinks that STUDENT needs a residential placement where there will be firm limits and consequences twenty-four hours a day. She testified that STUDENT's brother also has problems understanding limits.

Debra Friedman Ms. Friedman is the school psychologist for Jefferson Elementary School. She has been a school psychologist since 1982, and she was the school psychologist in charge of assessing STUDENT in September 1996. The first time she met STUDENT, he was very angry about leaving Alessandro, his old school. According to Ms. Friedman, STUDENT was unable to answer her questions, and hit her when she asked questions. She testified that she did not attempt to assess STUDENT at that time, but did attempt to assess him when she met him two weeks later. During that assessment, STUDENT did half of a task on the Bender Gastalt, but would not respond to any of the other tests. When she asked STUDENT to come see a class, STDENT hit her and swore at her. Ms. Friedman testified that STUDENT frequently swore at her.

Ms. Friedman stated that the first time STUDENT visited the SDC at Jefferson, he would not follow the class rules and was disrespectful to the teacher, Ms. Rim, swearing at her and using ethnic slurs. STUDENT left his seat, mistreated the computer equipment, and slammed a chair into his desk. When the teacher tried toredirect STUDENT, he was verbally abusive to her. The other children in the class were agitated and frightened by STUDENT.

Ms. Friedman testified that the District attempted to provide a program for STUDENT in the SDC, allowing MOTHER to come to class with STUDENT. STUDENT never stayed in class for a full day. Ms Freidman stated that sometimes he left by recess, and at least once he left after he had problems on the playground. Ms. Friedman said that she observed STUDENT's class frequently because Ms. Rim was in her first year at Jefferson. Ms. Friedman stated that MOTHER was not supportive of the teacher because she thought the teacher did not have appropriate skills or materials. According to Ms. Friedman, STUDENT was out of control in the class; he was given options and choices but refused to behave. Ms. Friedman stated that the teacher made a folder of appropriate work available to STUDENT, but he did not do the work. Ms. Friedman testified that she has also seen STUDENT out of control in her office, when he would not leave things alone and would not respond to her or to his mother. Ms. Friedman stated that she never saw STUDENT hit another child and did not recall him swearing at another child, only at the staff.

Ms. Friedman testified that Ms. Rim consulted her frequently about STUDENT'S behavior, and she told Ms. Rim that STUDENT had to comply with school rules. She stated that Ms. Rim's behavior plan for STUDENT was to provide him with choices and options, giving him warnings and using a systematic method for reminding him of appropriate behavior. Ms. Rim would give STUDENT two or three warnings about swearing before sending him out of class, but would send him out of class immediately if he became violent. According to Ms. Friedman, there were times when STUDENT was asked to leave for a time out but be would not leave. Ms. Friedman said that she spoke with STUDENT's teacher from Alessandro, who said that she was very firm with STUDENT and that it took a long time and many parent conferences about setting limits to develop the right program for STUDENT. The prior teacher told Ms. Friedman that she had concerns about limit-setting and parenting techniques, but that she was surprised by STUDENT's behavior at Jefferson. Apparently, STUDENT did not behave that way at Alessandro.

When Ms. Friedman determined in October that STUDENT COULD NOT FUNCTION IN District programs, she made an AB 3632 referral. MOTHER would not sign the release of information form at first, and later set an appointment for the assessment but canceled it. On the third referral to Mental Health, STUDENT was finally assessed. Ms. Friedman stated that the District offered counseling to STUDENT while he was on home teaching and independent study. But his mother did not bring him to Jefferson for the counseling sessions. Ms. Friedman testified that she offered the counseling sessions to MOTHER several times. She also stated that they did not perform a HughesBill assessment for a behavioral intervention plan because such an assessment requires a professional to monitor the student in the class for a significant period of time to tally the frequency of the target behaviors, and STUDENT was not in class long enough for a Hughes assessment to be done.

According to Ms. Friedman, some days STUDENT was excluded from class for the remainder of the day for his misbehaviors, and then MOTHER would not bring him back for two or three days. Ms. Friedman stated that her information about how long STUDENT spent in class came from the attendance office, and that the attendance records do not reflect that STUDENT was staying in class for most of the day during his last two weeks at Jefferson.

Ms. Friedman testified that she believed the SDC placement could not meet STUDENT's needs. She believes that STUDENT needs a program with maximum teacher-student intervention, a lot of limit- setting, a very structured environment, and a behavioral intervention plan. She stated that the District does not have an SDC that can provide the type of program STUDENT needs.

Helen Rim Ms. Rim is an SDC teacher at Jefferson Elementary School; there are approximately 14 students in her class. The 1996-97 school year was her first year teaching. When Ms. Friedman first told her STUDENT would be coming to her class, they discussed having the computer available for him because that was something he liked to work with. When Ms. Rim met STUDENT, his first response to her was profanity. She testified that STUDENT did something inappropriate in her room, and she told him to stop but he would not. Ms. Rim stated that STUDENT's language continued to be very provocative, and Ms. Friedman and MOTHER had to take him out of class.

Ms. Rim testified that STUDENT and his mother came late to class every time that came, and the longest they stayed in class was a couple of hours. She did not believe that they ever stayed for most of the day. Ms. Rim stated that she would put STUDENT out of the room for disruptive behavior and then send him, with his mother, to the office. After they went to the office, Ms. Rim did not know if they stayed at school or left.

Ms. Rim stated that the other children in the class were disturbed and frightened by STUDENT's behavior and did not want to sit next to him. STUDENT was always walking around the class, going through her desk, erasing things on the board, writing bad words on the board. Ms. Rim stated that STUDENT never hit children in her class. Ms. Rim tried to control STUDENT's behavior by using a "10-minute ticket" for computer time as an incentive for good behavior and sending him out of the room for bad behavior. Ms. Rim's class was a group-centered class; using the computer was a special treat for everyone. Ms. Rim stated that she placed STUDENT in a group based on his IEP and his test scores. She provided work for STUDENT to do, including reading and math books, but he did very little of it. Ms. Rim testified that sometimes MOTHER would try to stop STUDENT's behavior, but was unable to do so. Ms. Rim consulted with Ms. Friedman and the RSP teachers about STUDENT's behavior. She uses a behavior plan of rewards and consequences in her class, and keeps a behavior chart on all the children.

Ms. Rim testified that her class was not the appropriate environment, with more than one-to-one teacher attention and intervention.

Leonard Castellaneta Mr. Castellaneta teaches at the District's continuation high school. He has been teaching for nine years, and he was a substitute teacher for four years before that. While substituting, Mr. Castellaneta had several special education assignments, including one long-term assignment. Mr. Castellaneta served as STUDENT's home teacher during November and December 1996. During his first visit to the home, STUDENT yelled profanities him, called him "white nigger" and refused to have anything to do with him. STUDENT tried to throw a bag of water at Mr. Castellaneta. When MOTHER came outside to talk to Mr. Castellaneta, STUDENT came out and physically pulled his mother back into the house. Mr. Castellaneta testified that he saw STUDENT hit his mother and pull her hair one day when they left the park where the home teaching sessions took place. Mr. Castellaneta stated that STUDENT never hit him, but did spit at him and frequently used profanity.

Mr. Castellaneta testified that during the home teaching sessions, STUDENT refused to do anything but a few addition problems. STUDENT would not do any subtraction, and sometimes also refused to do the addition. STUDENT was always resistant to Mr. Castellaneta and usually would not speak directly to him, but would speak through his mother instead. STUDENT did have some good days, when he would complete up to four pages of math. According to Mr. Castellaneta, STUDENT manipulated his mother into doing things for him. At times, STUDENT would refused to write, telling his mother to do it for him. It seemed to Mr. Castellaneta that STUDENT was capable of doing the work; he just did not want to.

Mr. Castellaneta stated that, in his opinion, home teaching was not appropriate for STUDENT, and that STUDENT could not be successful in an SDC at a regular school because he has no respect for authority. Mr. Castellaneta believed that STUDENT could be a danger to staff and other students. Mr. Castellaneta recalled that when MOTHER told him that the District was proposing an NPS, STUDENT got very upset.

Nancy Chefalo Ms. Chefalo teaches an upper-grade SDC at Keppel Elementary School; there are approximately fifteen students in her class. She has taught special education classes for fifteen years. Her class is comprised mostly of children with learning disabilities and speech impairments, but she has taught SED children, as well. Ms. Chefalo testified that on January 2, 1997, MOTHER and STUDENT visited her class. When they arrived, they sat in the back by the computer while she finished giving an assignment to the students. When she went to talk to them, STUDENT refused to acknowledge her. Ms. Chefalo testified that STUDENT was playing with the keyboard and she asked him to stop. He stopped playing with it for a few seconds, but then started again. Ms. Chefalo stated that she asked STUDENT to move away from the computer, and then tried to move his chair away when he did not move. STUDENT ten tried to grab the chair away from her. Ms. Chefalo testified that she asked STUDENT to leave the room, and he did so. On his way out of the room, STUDENT deliberately knocked things off the counter, including a vase. Ms. Chefalo stated that during the exchange, MOTHER tried just once to get STUDENT to stop his behavior. Ms. Chefalo told MOTHER that she should leave and come back later without STUDENT.

Ms. Chefalo testified that she believed that her class was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT. She said that her children were frightened and shocked by his behavior.

Respondent's Witnesses

MOTHER

MOTHER testified that STUDENT is well-behaved at home and that he listens to adults in the family. She said that he had no problems at Alessandro. His teachers there were very structured and "tough," providing strict consequences for misbehavior. MOTHER testified that she did not notice any behavior problems over the summer; STUDENT's problems began when he started attending school in the District.

MOTHER testified that she believed STUDENT's behavior would improve as he adjusted to the new situation. She pointed out that several of Mr. Castellaneta's reports from the last few weeks he taught STUDENT showed that his behavior had begun to improve.

MOTHER stated that staff at Jefferson were very rude to her and STUDENT, staring at them and talking about them on the playground. She stated that she felt Jefferson was a hostile environment, and that Ms. Rim was inexperienced. MOTHER testified that Ms. Rim did not have appropriate materials for STUDENT. According to MOTHER, when she brought in games from home for STUDENT to work on, STUDENT was not disruptive. MOTHER said that she thought STUDENT's behavior was starting to improve before she stopped taking him to school and requesting home schooling.

MOTHER confirmed that STUDENT tried to attack Ms. Schuck, his first home teacher, when she came to their house.

MOTHER stated that the family had a very bad experience when her son BROTHER was placed in Tobinworld, an NPS; therefore, she is very skeptical of any NPS placement. MOTHER testified that she visited the Dubnoff school proposed by the District, but STUDENT did not feel comfortable there because of the children with disabilities who attended the school. When MOTHER visited Dubnoff, she did not see the type of behavior that she had objected to at Tobinworld.

MOTHER testified that she wants STUDENT in the least restrictive environment, which she believes is the SDC at Keppel. MOTHER stated that the class has a stict, experienced teacher and is very structured. STUDENT has told her that he wants to go to Keppel and that he will do his work there. MOTHER also stated that she thinks a Hughes assessment needs to be done for STUDENT to establish a proper behavior intervention plan.

MOTHER stated that she felt that the District was constantly putting her off, that it delayed finding a placement for STUDENT. According to MOTHER, the District told her that it will not pay for an independent study program for next year. MOTHER stated that if STUDENT is assigned to an NPS, she will pay for the independent study program herself and home school him rather than send him to the NPS.

STUDENT

STUDENT testified that he has been angry since his family moved last summer. He said that he did not like Jefferson Elementary, and that he did not like his teacher. STUDENT stated that in his old class he did computer work, played games, and had friends. In Ms. Rim's class, STUDENT said he did not have anything to do. STUDENT said that he wants to go back to his old school, and that he does not want to go to an NPS. He testified that he visited the NPS his brother attended and saw the staff restraining the children. He said that he and his mother visited one of the schools proposed by the District, but he did not like it. STUDENT did not give a specific reason why he did not like the school.

STUDENT admitted that he hits and kicks his mother and that he swears a lot. He stated that he feels angry a lot and that is why he misbehaves. He believes tha the can behave properly if he wants to.

FATHER

FATHER is STUDENT's father. He testified that STUDENT did well in his class at Alessandro, and that STUDENT was never violent at his old school. When STUDENT attended alessandro, according to FATHER, he had friends, did his homework, and behaved well. FATHER stated that STUDENT listens to him. FATHER testified that he never seen STUDENT hit anyone, not even his mother. He did, however, see STUDENT get hit by his cousins, and STUDENT did not react violently. FATHER stated that the problem with STUDENT started when he and MOTHER separated and STUDENT moved into the District.

BROTHER

BROTHER is STUDENT's brother. He testified that he attended Tobinworld, an NPS, for a while. When he was at Tobinworld, he saw that staff restrain children and hurt children by jumping on their legs. He stated that he did not know if STUDENT saw that happen, but that STUDENT may have heard him tell his mother about it. BROTHER testified that STUDENT hits him, and that STUDENT hits their mother, pulls her hair, and kicks her.

GRANDFATHER

GRANDFATHER is STUDENT's grandfather. He testified that STUDENT is a very good boy when he comes to his grandparent's house. GRANDFATHER stated that STUDENT always listens to him and has never hit him. GRANDFATHER testified that STUDENT plays well at his aunt's house and with his cousins. He stated tha the has never seen STUDENT hit his mother.

GRANDMOTHER(Footnote 1)

GRANDMOTHER is STUDENT's grandmother. She testified that STUDENT behaves at her house, that STUDENT has never hit her, and that she has never seen him hit anyone. STUDENT plays well with his cousins, and he never has problems at his aunt's house.

DISCUSSION

Appropriate Placement

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). California Education Code §§ 56000 et seq.; Amendments to the Indiviuals with disabilities Education Act (IDEA), P.L. 105-17. Pursuant to P.L. 105-17, § 602(8), "free and appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with that student's individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability «P.L. 105-17, § 602(25). In addition, special education services must be provided in the least restrictive environment. P.L. 105-17, § 612(a)(5); California Education Code § 56031.

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley(1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court stated that "the µbasic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." 458 U.S. 175,200.

Taken together, the IDEA and the Rowley court's interpretation of the IDEA provide the following four factors for analyzing which proposed placement is appropriate for STUDENT:

1. whether the placement is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs; 2. whether the placement conforms to STUDENT's IEP;

3. whether the placement is designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT; and 4. whether the placement is the least restrictive environment.

1. Which placement is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs?

Both parties appeared to agree that STUDENT needs a very structured environment, one-to-one attention, limit-setting, and counseling. Moreover, the report of the mental health assessment recommends that STUDENT receive both individual and family therapy. Dist. Exh. 26. The dispute presented for hearing concerns whether a District SDC can meet those needs.

The overwhelming evidence is that the District's SDC programs cannot meet STUDENT's needs. Every single District witness testified unequivocally based upon thei many years of experience with special education students and their personal interaction with STUDENT that an SDC in a regular school cannot meet STUDENT's needs for structure, limit-setting, and on-call counselors. On the other hand, MOTHER based her opinion that Ms. Chefalo's SDC is appropriate for STUDENT on a brief five-minute visit to the class, during which STUDENT ignored and defied the teacher. Ms. Chefalo, herself, who would be very knowledgealbe about her ability to deal with difficult students, testified that her class is not the appropriate place for STUDENT. She stated that she could not provide the attention that STUDENT needs without neglecting her other students. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's SDC at Keppel Elementary would not meet STUDENT's unique needs.

MOTHER has also proposed the she accompany STUDENT to class to help control him, or that she provide home teaching if STUDENT cannot attend the SDC. Neither of those options meet STUDENT's needs. In fact, it is clear from the evidence that MOTHER cannot control STUDENT and that his behavior toward her is the worst of all. Several witnesses, including MOTHER herself, testified that STUDENT physically abuses his mother. (Testimony of Katelanis, Friedman, Castellaneta, MOTHER, STUDENT, BROTHER.) Moreover, there is also evidence that STUDENT manipulates and controls his mother, making her perform school tasks he should be doing. (Testimony of Castellaneta.) The evidence establishes that the family dynamics have resulted in a role reversal where STUDENT controls his parents. Dist.Exh.26. These dynamics appear to be playing a role in STUDENT's inability to benefit from his education. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's needs cannot be met if MOTHER is present in his class on a daily basis or if MOTHER is STUDENT's primary instructor.

The District has proposed three different NPS placements for STUDENT, but provided very little evidence regarding the schools. The letter proposing those placements included a summary of the services provided by each school. Dist. Exh. 15. Each of the schools serves SED students and provides counseling and mental health services. Ms. Katelanis testified that the programs offer the type of structured environment with on-call counselors that STUDENT needs. There is no evidence that the schools proposed are certified by the Department of Education, and there is no evidence regarding the academic programs or class sizes offered at the schools. Therefore, the Hearing Officer, due to insufficient evidence, cannot find that any of the NPS placements proposed by the District would meet STUDENT's unique needs. However, the Hearing Officer does not find that a structured environment with small classes on-call counselors would meet STUDENT's needs. The

Hearing Officer further finds, based on the mental health assessment, that STUDENT needs both individual and family counseling to benefit from his education.

2. Which placement conforms to STUDENT's IEP?

It is not clear that STUDENT has a current IEP that contains updated goals and objectives. STUDENT's first IEP team meeting after he enrolled in the District was held on September 19, 1996, at which MOTHER requested home teaching. Dist. Exh. 4. There were no goals and objectives attached to that IEP. Another meeting was held on October 16, 1996, as part of STUDENT's triennial review. That IEP includes current information about his present levels of performance, but the only goals and objectives attached to the IEP are those from the prior school year, dated November 3, 1995. Dist. Exh. 5. Because these goals were written before STUDENT's extreme behavior began, they do not provide appropriate behavior goals. STUDENT's IEP was amended on February 19, 1997, and March 17, 1997, but neither of the amendments set forth goals and objectives. Dist. Exh. 22, 23. Therefore, because STUDENT does not have an IEP with current, appropriate goals and objectives, the Hearing Officer cannot make a finding regarding whether the programs proposed conform to his IEP. However, the absence of an appropriate IEP does not make the proposed programs inappropriate for STUDENT. Rather, the IEP team will have to convene to draft an IEP that conforms to this decision.

3. Which placement is designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT?

The evidence shows that STUDENT was unable to function in an SDC with his mother present as an aide, let alone benefit educationally. MOTHER testified that she did not think Ms. Rim's SDC had appropriate games and materials for STUDENT, and that his behavior may have been a result of boredom. However, the only materials MOTHER identified as being appropriate for STUDENT were games such as poker, blackjack, and hangman. She did not identify any other specific curriculum that would be appropriate for STUDENT in the SDC environment. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's inability to function in an SDC makes it a placement that is not designed to provide educational benefit to him.

The other option MOTHER proposed is independent study. MOTHER presented documents that apparently lists topics that STUDENT covered in the independent study program. It was impossible to determine from the disconnected listing of topics, interspersed with descriptions of field trips, whether STUDENT has benefitted educationally from the independent study program. Moreover, the evidence establishes that STUDENT manipulates his mother into performing educational tasks for him. (Testimony of Castellaneta.) In an independent study environment with his mother as his sole instructor, it is likely that STUDENT will continue to avoid doing his own work. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that an independent study program is not designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.

The District ha proposed three NPS placements for STUDENT, each of which appears to provide special education classes. There is no evidence regarding the academic programs offered by those schools, but the testimony and documents establish that each school could serve STUDENT's mental health needs, which the evidence suggest would allow him to progress educationally. (Testimony of Katelanis, Dist. Exh. 15) In the absence of evidence regarding STUDENT's academic goals and the academic programs offered by the proposed NPS placements, the Hearing Officer cannot find that any of the NPS placements are designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT. However, the Hearing Officer does find that STUDENT requires a program that serves his mental health needs to benefit educationally.

4. Which placement is the least restrictive environment?

In her statement of issues, MOTHER stated that she is seeking the least restrictive environment (LRE) for STUDENT. Pursuant to P.L. 105-17, § 612(a)(5), the District must ensure that to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities «are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from regular educational environment occurs only when that nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactory.

See also Education Code § 56031, 56364. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has developed a four- factor test to determine an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). Those four factors are:

(1) educational benefit, (2) non-academic benefit, (3) effect on the teacher and children in the regular class, and (4) cost.

All of the placements proposed for STUDENT involve segregation from nondisabled peers. The SDC placement would be the least restrictive; STUDENT would be educated with other disabled students, but would be located at a regular school campus and would have opportunities to interact with nondisabled peers. The NPS placements are more restrictive because they are at segregated sites where only disabled students attend. The independent study program would be the most restrictive, because STUDENT would be at home where he would not be interacting with any peers, let alone nondisabled ones. Therefore, in considering which is the least restrictive appropriate environment for STUDENT, only the elements contained in the SDC and NPS placements will be weighed.

The issue of cost has not been raised by either party. With respect to educational benefit, the Hearing Officer has found that the SDC placement would not provide educational benefit to STUDENT, and that the NPS placement is the most likely to provide educational benefit. As for non-academic benefit, the evidence established that STUDENT did not interacted appropriately with any of his peers in the SDC, and that STUDENT did not stay in school long enough each day to spend time with nondisabled peers. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT would probably not derive any non-academic benefit from the SDC placement. On the other hand, the testimony established that an NPS could provide structure and interventions STUDENT needs to learn how to socialize appropriately.

When respect to the effect on the teacher and children in the class, the teachers o both the Jefferson and the Keppel SDC's testified that the children in those classes were frightened of STUDENT and deeply disturbed by his behavior. Moreover, the testimony established that STUDENT's behavior is so extreme he demands significant attention from the teacher, to the detriment of the other children in the class. (Testimony of Chefalo.) In contrast, a facility that serves SED students is designed to deal with this type of behavior and has counselors on staff who can intervene to address it. (Testimony of Katekanis.)

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the least restrictive placement for STUDENT shall include the following elements: a segregated, non-residential facility that specializes in serving SED students, provides small class sizes, and has on-call counselors to address behavior problems; individual and family counseling; and, as discussed below, a behavioral intervention plan. Hughes Bill Assessment

MOTHER asserted in her statement of issues that she wanted the District to conduct a Hughes Bill assessment and develop a behavioral plan for STUDENT. The District did not contest that STUDENT needed a Hughes assessment, but asserted that STUDENT was not in school long enough to complete the functional analysis necessary to develop a Hughes-type behavioral intervention plan.

As stated above, removal from the regular education environment should occur only when "the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and service cannot be achieved satisfactory." P.L. 105-17, § 612(a)(5). A behavioral intervention plan is a service that is often used to help a child remain in the least restrictive environment. Education Code §§ 56520-56524, 5 CCR § 3052. The evidence clearly established that STUDENT has severe emotional disturbance and behavioral problems. The testimony establishes that STUDENT's behavior is violent and dangerous. STUDENT has both verbally and physically attacked several District staff members while on campus and in is own home. His behavior appears to be a result of the extreme amount of anger he has been experiencing since the changes in his family circumstances that occurred last year. As such, it appears that the anger that underlies the behavior must be addresses as well as the behavior. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's behavior and lack of attendance made it impossible to develop a proper behavioral intervention plan that would allow STUDENT remain in the less restrictive SDC environment. The Hearing Officer further finds that a behavioral intervention plan could not be used satisfactory at this time to enable STUDENT to stay in the less restrictive SDC environment.

However, because STUDENT was successful in an SDC until the recent changes in his family circumstances, the Hearing Officer does believe that if a behavioral intervention plan were developed and successfully implemented and STUDENT's emotional disturbance brought under control, the plan could be used to help STUDENT transition back to and succeed in an SDC or other less restrictive environment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires a functional analysis assessment and a behavioral intervention plan as part of his placement. The assessment and plan should be prepared by District staff or the staff at whichever facility STUDENT attends and should be designed to enable STUDENT to transition back to a public school SDC environment.

ORDER

1. The appropriate placement for STUDENT shall include the following elements: a segregated, non- residential facility that specializes in serving SED students, provides small class sizes, and has on-call counselors to address behavior problems; individual and family counseling; and a behavioral intervention plan. If an NPS is selected, it must be certified by the Department of Education.

2. STUDENT's IEP team shall meet within fifteen calendar days of the date of this order to select an appropriate placement for STUDENT in conformance with this decision and to write appropriate goals and objectives for the 1997-98 school year. The IEP shall include both individual and family counseling as designated instructional services.

3. The District shall arrange for a functional analysis assessment and develop a behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT within the first thirty days of his attendance at his new placement. The terms of the behavioral intervention plan shall be designated to enable STUDENT to transition back to the public school SDC environment.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Educational Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extentto which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: the District prevailed to the extent that it established that STUDENT's needs cannot be met in the District's SDC program.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within (90) days of the receipt of this decision. Educational Code § 56505(i).

DATED: July 29, 1997 ______________________________ Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes Footnote 1: GRANDMOTHER testified in Spanish. FATHER, her son, translated both the questions and her answers.