California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 10, 2003

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 528-03 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard

Los Angeles Unified denied FAPE by cutting direct behavior services without an assessment; Hearing Officer orders 96 compensatory hours.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 4 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Footnote 1 says this is an amended decision that corrects printing errors, which had left out text at the top or bottom of pages 14, 16, 17 and 18 of the original. The decision is otherwise unchanged. It also refers to the related prior case SN01-01210, which settled through a Final Mediation Agreement in February 2003, and to an April 7, 2003 order denying stay put.

Summary

The parents of a six-year-old girl filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District over a March 4, 2003 IEP that had been required by a mediation agreement. She was eligible under other health impairment and specific learning disability after a stroke at birth, and she showed autistic-like behaviors. She attended a private kindergarten at the Westside Jewish Community Center with a full-time aide. She also received in-home "floor time" behavior therapy from Smart Start, a nonpublic agency. The IEP offered a special day class at Carthay Elementary with a one-to-one aide and five hours a month of behavior supervision. It eliminated all direct behavior services.

The Hearing Officer found that the district had never done a psycho-educational assessment. The mediation agreement waived earlier claims but did not end the district's duty to assess current needs. Without that information, the district could not properly choose a class or cut services. Witnesses who knew the student showed that she needed direct floor time therapy, especially while moving to a new school, teacher, classmates and aide. The IEP offered no real transition plan, so the offer denied FAPE.

The district was ordered to:

- complete a full psycho-educational assessment

- make a new offer with a transition plan by August 15, 2003

- restore 8 hours a week of direct services and 6 hours a month of supervision through Smart Start

- provide 96 hours of compensatory behavior services, at least 50 of them direct

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated a mediation waiver of past claims as separate from a district's ongoing duty to assess current needs. It also shows that cutting all direct behavior services during a major school transition, without a formal assessment, was found to deny FAPE under the Rowley standard.

Issues and holdings

  1. Dismissed / withdrawnStay put

    Issue Withdrawn Issue 2 (original statement of issues). Whether the District failed to comply with the February 4, 2003 Final Mediation Agreement in Case No. SN01-01210 by not providing the stay put services stated in the agreement.

    Student withdrew the issue on the first day of hearing after the April 7, 2003 stay put order. The Hearing Officer rejected the District's request to be named prevailing party, because stay put is a pre-hearing remedy and not an issue heard and decided.

  2. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1(1). Has the District denied Student a FAPE from March 4, 2003, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and ESY by failing to provide any direct behavior intervention implementation (BII) services and an appropriate amount of behavior intervention development (BID) supervision services?

    Cutting all direct floor time services and offering only 5 hours a month of supervision did not meet the student's behavior, consistency and transition needs. The failure to do a psycho-educational assessment was a procedural violation with substantive effect. Eight hours a week of BII and six hours a month of BID were found appropriate.

  3. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1(2). Has the District denied Student a FAPE by failing to offer her an appropriate placement designed to meet her unique needs?

    Without a psycho-educational assessment or other competent evidence, the District had no sufficient basis to place the student in the Carthay SDC, a class made up mostly of students with learning disabilities, and it gave her too little behavior support during the transition.

  4. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. If the District denied Student a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory behavioral services?

    The Hearing Officer awarded 96 hours of compensatory behavior services from Smart Start, at least 50 of them direct, in addition to the reinstated services.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to assess. Within 10 days of the decision, the District must prepare an assessment plan for a comprehensive psycho-educational assessment of the student's cognitive and academic needs in light of her multiple disabilities. The assessment must include guidance on the class structure, behavioral supports, peer disability type and age composition of an appropriate SDC.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. The District must complete the assessment, hold an IEP meeting, and make an offer for 2003-2004 by August 15, 2003, or the start of the 2003-2004 school year, whichever is earlier. The offer must include an appropriate transition plan.
  • Order to provide or change services. Within 10 days, the District must hold an IEP meeting to provide 8 hours per week of BII and 6 hours per month of BID through Smart Start NPA. These services run for the rest of the 2002-2003 school year and ESY, or until the ordered assessment and IEP are completed.
  • Compensatory education. 96 hours of behavior services from Smart Start, in addition to the services above. The IEP team decides the split between direct in-home services and supervision/consultation for the SDC staff and aide, with at least 50 hours direct. Unless the parties agree otherwise, the hours must be provided by December 31, 2003.

Total: 96 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Burlington; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Wendy Watson, one-to-one therapeutic companion (parent-hired), Private
  • Kimberly Shapiro Abrams, private kindergarten teacher, Westside Jewish Community Center
  • Heather Santoro, floor time behavioral therapist, Smart Start Therapeutic Intervention Services (NPA)
  • Sharon Lowery, behavioral intervention supervisor; Smart Start co-owner, Smart Start Therapeutic Intervention Services (NPA)
  • Smart Start Therapeutic Intervention Services, nonpublic agency providing behavior services, Nonpublic agency
  • Shannon Troy, private educational and behavioral consultant; expert witness for Student, Private
  • Rochelle Berkowitz, assistant principal; IEP chair, Carthay Elementary, LAUSD
  • Nathalie Aluisi, occupational therapist, LAUSD
  • Joan Pylman, adapted physical education teacher, LAUSD
  • Tali Shwartz Matalon, early elementary special day class teacher, Carthay Elementary, LAUSD
  • Vicki Brown, 4th-5th grade special day class teacher, Carthay Elementary, LAUSD
  • Brick Baker, program specialist, LAUSD
  • Melissa Marie Gutierrez, occupational therapist, LAUSD
  • Renee Denise Quarles, special day class instructional aide, Carthay Elementary, LAUSD
  • LaVerne Dumay, due process specialist, LAUSD
  • Natalie Johnson, paralegal, LAUSD counsel
  • Marianne O'Brien, adapted physical education assessor, LAUSD
  • Lanie Ronen, speech and language assessor, LAUSD
  • Ellen Lenokan, private pediatric occupational therapist assessor, Private
  • Dr. Greenspan, private evaluating physician, Maryland
  • Dr. Wieder, private clinical psychologist evaluator, Maryland
  • Dr. Robinson, private evaluating physician, Descanso Medical Center for Development and Learning

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Los Angeles, California, on April 10, 11, 22, 23, and 24, 2003.

Petitioner Student (hereafter Student) was represented at the hearing by attorney Carol Hickman Graham. Student’s father was present on April 10 and 11, 2003, and her mother was present on April 22 through 24, 2003 at the hearing on her behalf. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (hereafter District) was represented at the hearing by its attorney Peter Keup. On April 10 and 11, 2003, paralegal Natalie Johnson was present. Also present on the District’s behalf throughout the hearing was its due process specialist LaVerne Dumay.

Student called the following witnesses: her father and her mother, her one-to-one therapeutic companion Wendy Watson, her current regular education kindergarten teacher at the Westside Jewish Community Center Kimberly Shapiro Abrams, her Smart Start floor time behavioral specialist Heather Santoro, her Smart Start behavioral intervention supervisor Sharon Lowery, and her private educational and behavioral consultant Shannon Troy. The Student also called the following District employees as witnesses: Carthay Elementary School assistant principal Rochelle Berkowitz, occupational therapist (OT) Nathalie Aluisi, adapted physical education (APE) teacher Joan Pylman, Carthay early elementary special day class (EE/SDC) teacher Tali Shwartz Matalon, Carthay 4th-5th grade SDC teacher Vicki Brown, and program specialist Brick Baker. The District presented its case by cross-examining the witnesses called by the Student. In addition, the District called the following District employees witnesses: OT Melissa Marie Gutierrez, Carthay EE/SDC instructional aide (IA) Renee Denise Quarles, and due process specialist LaVerne Dumay.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. By May 16, 2003, the Hearing Officer had received all parties’ closing briefs and exhibits. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.(Footnote 2)

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On the first day of the hearing, the Student’s attorney stated her intention to withdraw Issue 2 from her April 2, 2003 statement of issues, in light of the stay put order issued by the Hearing Officer on April 7, 2003. That issue was whether the District “failed to comply with the February 4, 2003 Final Mediation Agreement [in Case No. SN01-01210] by not providing the stay put services stated in the agreement?” The District objected and argued that withdrawal of this issue was not appropriate because the Hearing Officer had made a legal ruling in its favor on the stay put motion. The District sought a finding that it was the prevailing party on this issue pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d). The parties were granted leave to address this matter in their closing briefs.

The Hearing Officer finds that there is no basis for precluding the Student from withdrawing this issue or for determining that the District was the prevailing party on the stay put issue. First, as a general matter, the party requesting a due process hearing determines what issues he or she wishes to raise, subject to jurisdictional limitations. Second, stay put is a pre-hearing remedy designed to ensure stability during a due process hearing. A determination of the merits of a stay put motion is derived from the written argument, declarations, and exhibits submitted by the parties outside the context of a due process hearing. As a consequence, there is no need for testimony regarding stay put services to determine the appropriate stay put placement. By contrast, Education Code § 56507(d) provides that the “hearing decision shall indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided....” [emphasis added]. That section is clearly applicable to issues litigated at the due process hearing. Third, the District made no showing that it suffered any prejudice by the withdrawal of this issue on the first day of hearing. Rather, the record in this case demonstrates that the stay put issue was resolved on April 7, 2003, and that the District was on notice that this particular issue would not proceed for hearing. Accordingly, Student’s Issue 2 was appropriately withdrawn at the outset of the hearing.

ISSUES

1. Has the District denied Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from March 4, 2003, through the conclusion of the 2002-2003 school and extended school year (ESY) (1) by failing to provide her any direct behavior intervention implementation (BII) services and an appropriate amount of behavior intervention supervision (BID) services, and/or (2) by failing to offer her an appropriate placement designed to meet her unique needs?

2. If the District denied Student a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory behavioral services?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Student contends that the District’s March 4, 2003 individualized education program (IEP) did not offer her a FAPE because it eliminated all of her direct behavior intervention implementation (BII) “floor time” services and offered only five hours a month of behavior implementation development (BID) supervision/consultation services at school. In Student’s view, she requires ten hours a week of direct BII floor time services, and eight hours a month of BID supervisory services. Student also contends that the District’s March 4, 2003 IEP offer of placement in Ms. Shwartz’s early elementary special day class (EE/SDC) at Carthay Elementary School was not an offer of FAPE because it was not designed to meet her unique needs. In her view, the District did not have sufficient information about her unique needs to offer either an appropriate placement or services because it ignored the recommendations of persons familiar with her and because it has never conducted a psycho-educational assessment of her. Student also asserts that the District ignored her unique need for transition services during her move from her current school at the Westside Jewish Community Center (WJCC) to public school, by eliminating all her direct behavior services. Student further contends that the Carthay SDC class is not a small, structured class with an appropriate behavior modification plan in place. In addition, she argues that neither its teacher nor its instructional aide (IA) have sufficient training and experience in working with “other health impaired” (OHI) students, like her, who have autistic-like characteristics due to brain damage caused by a stroke. Finally, Student requests compensatory behavioral services for the services lost when the District eliminated those services following the March 4, 2003 IEP.(Footnote 3)

The District contends that it had sufficient information to determine Student’s unique needs from the assessments it conducted for her 2002 triennial, from observation of Student at WJCC, and from the reports of her current service providers at the March 4, 2003 IEP team meeting. It also asserts that, by signing the Final Mediation Agreement in SN01-01210 and waiving all claims through February 4, 2003, Student waived her right to raise the lack of a psycho-educational assessment as part of her triennial review in 2002. In the District’s view, the March 4, 2003 IEP offered Student a FAPE because it provided for her placement in a small SDC classroom at her neighborhood school with students who are primarily within her disability classification of specific learning disabled (SLD). The District also asserts that Carthay’s EE/SDC teacher, Ms. Shwartz, and her IA, Ms. Quarles, have experience working with children with autistic-like characteristics and with behavioral modification techniques. In addition, the District asserts that its offer appropriately addressed Student’s unique behavioral needs by providing a full-time one-to-one temporary support assistant (TSA) to assist her throughout her school day plus five hours a month of BID supervisory level behavioral consultation to the SDC staff and the TSA at school. In the District’s view, any home-based direct behavior intervention implementation services should be provided by the parents or sought from the Regional Center. The District requests a determination that Student is not entitled to any compensatory services.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Student is a special education student who will turn seven on June 13, 2003. Since her initial individualized education plan meeting (IEP) at age three, Student’s eligibility for special education has been consistently determined to arise from her “other health impairment” (OHI), as well as from her specific learning disability (SLD). She has also been identified as a student with an additional eligibility of language and speech (LAS).(Footnote 4) Student is currently attending a private kindergarten at the Westside Jewish Community Center (WJCC) in a class with approximately fifteen typically-developing children. The class is taught by Kimberly Shapiro, a non-certified teacher with six years of teaching experience. Student receives one-to-one support at school from Wendy Watson, her full-time therapeutic companion. Both Ms. Shapiro and Ms. Watson consult frequently with independent behaviorist Shannon Troy, who is privately retained by Student’s parents. Until shortly after the March 4, 2003 IEP at issue, Student received in-home behavior intervention implementation (BII) services in the form of one-to-one “floor time” therapy provided by therapists from Smart Start Therapeutic Intervention Services, a nonpublic agency (NPA). One of these therapists, Heather Santoro, has worked with Student for two years. Student’s treatment team, including Ms. Shapiro, Ms. Watson, Ms. Troy, and Student’s Smart Start floor time therapy (BID) supervisor, Sharon Lowery, participated in team meetings for Student every four to six weeks to ensure consistency and continuity in her educational programs. Student’s parents are currently seeking a placement for her in a small, well-structured public special day class program with an appropriate behavior modification plan and trained staff where she can participate in mainstream classes. According to Student’s mother, Ms. MOTHER, the parents want to be sure that Student is placed into an appropriate SDC class because they believe she will remain in this class for the next several years.

When Student was one day old, she suffered seizures and a stroke. She was placed in a phenobarbital-induced coma for her first two weeks of life to control ongoing subcortical seizures. During this period, Student’s EEG showed that she was in continuous seizures. Later, a CAT scan revealed that Student had a left frontal and left temporal lobe anoxic stroke. Following this episode, Student remained on phenobarbital for the first year of life and was subsequently seizure free. Due to her stroke, Student exhibits a variety of behaviors, including poor impulse control, low frustration levels, distractability and inability to sustain attention. Student exhibits aggressive behaviors such as hitting herself, hitting, kicking and biting others, and grabbing objects from others. She frequently becomes obsessed with a particular student. Student also craves physical stimulation and exhibits many sensory-seeking behaviors that include rolling on the floor, and kissing and licking people and books.

Student began to attend Smart Start, a private developmentally-based preschool co-owned by Ms. Lowery, at age three, pursuant to an IEP with the District. Since that time, Student has consistently received behavior services from Smart Start and from Ms. Troy. Student’s primary behavior therapy model over these years has been “floor time therapy,” a one-to-one systematic developmental approach of working with a child to help her climb the developmental ladder. The developmental milestones the child must achieve during floor time therapy are, in sequence, developing shared attention, engaging in relationships, engaging in two-way purposeful communication (a “circle of communication”), increasing the number of circles of communication, creating mental representations (i.e., emotional symbols, ability to pretend play), and creating bridges between internal representations or complex ideas (making connections between different representations) (District Ex. 16). In August 2000, the parents had Student evaluated by Dr. Greenspan, M.D., and by clinical psychologist Dr. Wieder, in Maryland. Following assessment, each recommended that Student participate in a home program of spontaneous “floor time” sessions.(Footnote 5)

On June 5, 2001, Student filed a request for a due process hearing in Case No. SN01-01210. As discussed below, this case was ultimately settled in February 2003.

Student’s triennial review IEP meeting occurred on April 24, 2002, at Smart Start preschool. An additional purpose of this IEP was to transition Student from Smart Start preschool to a District kindergarten, Fairburn Elementary, for the 2002-2003 school year. District staff conducted the following assessments for the triennial review: an occupational therapy (OT) assessment by OT Nathalie Aluisi; an adapted physical education (APE) assessment by APE specialist Marianne O’Brien; and a speech and language assessment by therapist Lanie Ronen. A private pediatric OT assessment was also conducted by OT Ellen Lenokan. The District did not conduct a psycho-educational assessment of Student for the triennial review. Student’s parents provided the IEP team with an October 30, 2001 report from Dr. Robinson from Descanso Medical Center for Development and Learning, who indicated Student had been diagnosed with “a neonatal stroke and follow-up symptoms that have been characterized as autistic spectrum behaviors.” Student’s special education eligibility was confirmed as OHI, SLD, and LAS. In addition to services in the areas of speech, occupational therapy, and APE, Student was offered twelve hours a week of behavior implementation intervention BII (direct) services and two hours a week of behavior implementation development BID (supervision) a week. She was also offered the support of an inclusion specialist. The parents consented to the triennial IEP, except for LAS and OT services.

For reasons the parties dispute, Student did not attend Fairburn Elementary during the 2002-2003 school year. Instead, in September 2002, at age 6.5, Student began attending a private kindergarten at the Westside Jewish Community Center (WJCC), with children who were approximate a year and a half younger than she. The parents hired a full-time therapeutic aide for Student who was not successful with her. In approximately October 2002, they hired Student’s current full-time therapeutic companion, Wendy Watson. On September 24, 2002, the IEP team met again to review new District assistive technology (AT) and augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) assessment reports and to amend the triennial to incorporate AT support. The IEP continued to offer Student both BII and BID support.

On October 18, 2002, Student filed a request for a stay put order in Case No. SN01-01210. On November 8, 2002, the Hearing Office issued a stay put order partially granting her request, and ordered the District to provide Student with the following services during its pendency: placement in a resource specialist program (RSP) for sixty minutes per day, twelve hours per week of behavior intervention implementation (BII), eight hours per month of behavior intervention development (BID), thirty minutes per week of adapted physical education (APE), the support of an inclusion facilitator, the services of a temporary support assistant (TSA) for two hundred minutes per day, sixty minutes per week of school-based occupational therapy (OT), sixty minutes per week of clinic-based OT, and two hours per week of language and speech services (LAS). Reimbursement for the cost of a therapeutic companion during the pendency of the due process proceeding was denied.

On February 4, 2003, the parties entered into a Final Mediation Agreement (hereafter, FMA) in Case No. SN01-01210, relating to Student’s education from September 2002 through February 4, 2003. Pursuant to the FMA, the Student received reimbursement for private school tuition at WJCC and for the cost of her therapeutic companion during this period as well as attorney’s fees. The Student waived all claims for compensatory education and settled all claims against the District through that date. The FMA also included an agreement to convene an IEP meeting within thirty days “for the purpose of recommending an appropriate placement for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, including ESY.” Pending that IEP meeting, the District agreed to maintain the following current related services: 1 hour per week each of OT and LAS, 8 hours per week of BII (direct), and 30 minutes a week of APE. The parties further agreed that, “in the event that there is a dispute between the Parents and the District at this IEP, the stay-put services will be the recommendations of that IEP Committee.” The FMA was fully executed on February 6, 2003 and resulted in the withdrawal of SN01-01210.

On March 4, 2003, pursuant to the FMA, an IEP team meeting was convened and conducted over a period of approximately five hours. The IEP meeting was held at Carthay Elementary and chaired by its assistant principal, Rochelle Berkowitz. Student’s parents and her service providers from WJCC and Smart Start were present at the IEP meeting along with Carthay’s SDC teachers Talia Shwartz and Vicki Brown, District OT providers Melissa Gutierrez and Nathalie Aluisi, APE teacher Joan Pylman, and program specialist Brick Baker. At this meeting, Student’s eligibility as a student with an OHI and a SLD was confirmed. A majority of the meeting involved discussion of Student’s behavior services. A disagreement arose among the parents, Student’s service providers, and some of the District representatives regarding whether Student required a TSA or any direct behavior intervention implementation services (BII) at home.

At the conclusion of the IEP meeting, the District offered Student the following services: one hour per week of school-based occupational therapy (OT) services, one hour per week of school-based speech and language services (LAS), thirty minutes a week of APE services, five hours a month of behavior supervision (BID), and a Behavior Support Plan that addressed Student’s behavior of “inattentive, difficulty with focus.” All of Student’s direct behavior services outlined in the FMA (8 hours per week) were eliminated. Placement was offered in Ms. Shwartz’s EE/SDC class at Carthay with a TSA for an unspecified time and duration. Finally, the IEP team agreed to meet in six months, in October 2003, “to discuss Student’s level of success in public school as well as the TSA and BID services that are necessary in order for Student to access the curriculum.”

On March 10, Student’s father signed his disagreement to the IEP document and stated his request for stay put “of all services pending due process.” Thereafter, on March 17, 2003, the Hearing Office received the parents’ request for due process hearing and a stay-put order on Student’s behalf. On March 13, 2003, the District notified Smart Start by letter that all services under its contract for Student were terminated pursuant to the IEP of March 4, 2003. On April 7, 2003, the Hearing Officer denied the student’s motion for stay put. The Hearing Officer rejected the parents’ argument that the services recommended at the March 4, 2003 IEP could not be Student’s stay put services without their consent. Interpreting the FMA’s stay put provision as a whole, the Hearing Officer concluded that the parties had agreed to accept the recommendations of the District members of the IEP team as the “stay put” services, in the event that the District and the parent disagreed about them at the IEP. See Summary Order Re: Stay Put (April 7, 2003). As a consequence, stay put services did not include any direct behavior intervention implementation/floor time services.

Student is a client of the Regional Center. Student’s Mother testified that the Regional Center has determined that Student is eligible for their services as an individual in the Autism Spectrum. Student currently receives gymnastic services twice a week and weekly therapeutic horseback riding from the Regional Center. According to Student’s parents, the Regional Center told them that it does not provide any behavior services to its clients.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997).

“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). Education Code Section 56363 (a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. At 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Thus, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold. The hearing officer must determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been satisfied and whether the FAPE provided was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S at 206-207. To constitute a FAPE as required by the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s offer must meet the following substantive requirements: (1) have been designed to meet Student’s unique needs; and (2) have been reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit.(Footnote 6)

I. Has the District denied Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from March 4, 2003, through the conclusion of the 2002-2003 school and extended school year (1) by failing to provide her direct behavior intervention implementation services and an appropriate amount of behavior intervention supervision services, or (2) by failing to offer her an appropriate placement designed to meet her unique needs?

A. Procedural Appropriateness

Student contends that the District violated the IDEA by failing to conduct a psycho-educational assessment of her at any time and that this failure has denied her a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds. The District asserts that Student waived any argument on this basis when she signed the FMA and gave up all claims against the District through February 4, 2003, including claims relating to her triennial review in April 2002. The District also contends that this waiver extended into the future, at least until the March 4, 2003 IEP mandated by the FMA.

Student is clearly precluded by the FMA from raising procedural or substantive violations in her 2002 triennial review or any other claim to the date she executed the FMA on February 6, 2003. The Hearing Officer finds that the FMA does not, however, relieve the District of its responsibility to assess Student’s present unique needs. The IDEA requires that a student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability and reassessed “whenever conditions warrant....” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A), 1414(b)(3)(C). As discussed below, Student has unique cognitive and academic needs arising out of her multiple disabilities. It was undisputed that a psycho-educational assessment has not been conducted on STUDENT. The evidence established that the District completed assessments on Student in the specific areas of occupational therapy, adapted physical education, and speech and language; however, no assessment was conducted in these other crucial areas. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that, after the execution of the FMA, conditions warranted an assessment of Student’s cognitive and academic needs, and that the District’s failure to conduct a psycho-educational assessment addressing these areas constituted a procedural violation of the IDEA.

It is well established that “procedural flaws will not automatically require a denial of a FAPE.” W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist., 960 F.2d 1479, 1485 (9th Cir. 1992). Only “procedural inadequacies that result in a loss of educational opportunity, or seriously infringe the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process, clearly result in the denial of a FAPE.” Id. In this case, there is no contention that the parents were denied an opportunity to participate in Student’s IEP process. The Hearing Officer finds that a procedural violation such as this does not necessarily result in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT.(Footnote 7) However, as discussed below, the Hearing Officer finds that this violation had substantive dimensions and that, in the absence of such an assessment or other competent evidence, the District did not have sufficient information to determine the type of placement and support services Student requires, or to eliminate any of her existing behavior services.

B. Substantive Appropriateness

Student’s Unique Needs

To determine whether the program offered to Student by the District at the March 4, 2003 IEP was designed to meet her unique needs for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school and extended school year, the Hearing Officer must first determine what those needs are. Student has many unique needs underlying her occupational therapy, adapted physical education, and speech and language services. These needs include postural stability, motor planning, fine and gross motor skills, self help skills, and expressive and receptive language development. Because these areas are not disputed by the parties, they are not addressed in this Decision. In addition, the parties also agree that Student has a unique need for a small structured classroom placement with a behavior modification plan.

Unique Behavior Needs

Student’s behavior in her WJCC kindergarten class was characterized as very inconsistent and sporadic by both her teacher, Ms. Shapiro, and her one-to-one therapeutic companion, Ms. Watson. Ms. Watson testified that Student seems to cycle in and out of behavior patterns. She would be focused for three weeks then go through an intense phase of negative behaviors (touching, kissing, rolling on ground, aggressive). According to Ms. Shapiro, Student has great days and bad days, split roughly fifty-fifty, and unpredictable spikes and drops in her aggression and behavior. Ms. Shapiro also testified that Student can be very disruptive to the classroom because of her screaming, crying, and out-of-control behavior. If Student is not able to calm down in the separate area set aside for her in class for such occasions, Ms. Watson takes her out of the classroom. Ms. Shapiro testified that Student has to leave the classroom a minimum of twice a day, or between ten to fifteen times a week. According to Ms. Shapiro, Student has a major obsession (of varying intensity) with one of the students in her class that interferes with the entire class.

The great weight of the evidence established that Student has unique behavioral needs that arise from multiple sources and that require different responses. According to independent behaviorist Shannon Troy who has worked with her since September 2001, Student exhibits a wide range of maladaptive behaviors including perseverative speech, rigid thought patterns, attentional and impulsivity issues, difficulty in transitioning between activities, sensory-seeking behaviors and defiance. Ms. Troy testified that Student’s behaviors stem from many different sources–some are autistic-like, some are sensory-seeking from her neurological impairment, and some are behavioral. As a consequence, Student needs different methods to address her various behaviors, as a well as staff sufficiently trained to recognize which behavior source is involved so that the correct techniques can be implemented in response (i.e., is Student genuinely defiant in biting or is her behavior a sensory urge arising from her neurological impairment?) Testimony persuasively established that adequate staff training is particularly important for her TSA. For example, according to Ms. Shapiro, Student has made some progress in class but only with Ms. Watson’s help. She testified that Student needed constant interaction with the TSA in the classroom: to sit with her, to keep her on task with frequent prompting, to calm and refocus her with appropriate sensory input, to take her out of the group or out of the classroom when required. From her experience as Student’s therapeutic companion, Ms. Watson testified that it is important to have a TSA with some prior training and experience with autistic children, as well as training in sensory needs and behavior modification techniques.(Footnote 8)

The evidence also established that Student has unique needs for behavior services to address her sensory needs. Ms. Watson, Ms. Troy, and Ms. Shapiro testified that Student exhibits many sensory-seeking characteristics in class. She rolls around on the floor, licks books, puts many objects in her mouth, and uses a chewy necklace for oral stimulation. Ms. Shapiro testified that, if Student does not get her sensory needs met, she can become out of control and unable to contain herself. This is shown by aggressive behavior of grabbing things from other children, kicking and flailing her legs, rolling around on the floor, and making noises. This behavior is distracting to the other students(Footnote 9).

In addition, the evidence established that Student has unique needs for behavior services to address her attentional and impulsivity issues. According to Heather Santoro, who has provided direct floor time therapy to Student for the past two years, one of Student’s educational needs is to be able to attend in a group setting in a purposeful way where she can both absorb and respond to information presented. Ms. Santoro testified that Student has made great progress in the area of attending with floor time therapy. When Ms. Santoro first observed Student in class at Smart Start several years ago, Student was only able to sustain focus for several seconds at a time. Student is currently able to attend to a task for up to twenty minutes with one-to-one support in her home.

In school, Student’s ability to attend varies. Student’s triennial assessors reported that her participation was affected by her inability to consistently attend to task due to her distractibility and impulsivity. Her OT therapist, Ms. Aluisi, reported that Student is able to work up to thirty minutes on a one-to-one basis in a separate room, but immediately becomes distracted by noises or other people. In class at WJCC, where Ms. Santoro works with STUDENT, Ms. Watson and Ms. Shapiro once a week, Student is able to attend to a task for five to ten minutes with refocusing. According to Ms. Shapiro, Student’s current ability to sit in a chair in class and attend to task with one-to-one assistance of her TSA varies from two minutes to ten-to-fifteen minutes. In preferred activities, such as reading a book, Student can sit for a long time. Ms. Shapiro testified that Student can sometimes stay in a group for ten to fifteen minutes with sensory input from her TSA (i.e., back scratching). Student is reported to work better in a smaller environment with minimal auditory or visual distractors, and to benefit from the use of a three-panel cardboard divider to minimize distractions.

Unique Continuity, Consistency and Transition Needs

The evidence overwhelmingly established that Student has a unique need for continuity and consistency in her behavior services that encompasses a unique need for appropriate transition services. The people who know Student and have worked consistently with her testified that she requires a consistent, coordinated approach to ensure that the same behavior models are being used with her at home and at school. (Testimony of Ms. Watson, Ms. Shapiro, Ms. Lowery, Ms. Santoro, Ms. Troy). Student needs consistency in social cues, in behavioral rules, in expectations both in a one-to-one context and in a group, in attending and in modeling of behavior. According to Ms. Santoro, collaboration and consistency are important for Student and form the basis for her success and growth. Ms. Santoro elaborated that Student’s floor time therapy at home provides her with the skills to function in the classroom, by extensive one-to-one practice of social and behavior interactions.(Footnote 10) In class, the TSA “motors Student through” her day, with greater or fewer prompts depending upon the day. Ms. Santoro testified that a transition plan is crucial for Student’s success at a new school, due to her need for consistency. In her opinion, transitions are very difficult for Student because she relies on structure and expectations. Without an adequately structured transition plan, Student’s behavior would be unpredictable and possibly manifest as aggressive. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Santoro’s testimony particularly persuasive, based upon her educational emphasis on child development for her B.A. in psychology, her training and experience as a floor time therapist, and her three years’ experience with STUDENT, including two years of direct one-to-one work with her. Student’s unique need for appropriate transition services was also emphasized in the testimony of Ms. Troy and Ms. Lowery.

Unique Cognitive and Academic Needs Arising Out of Multiple Disabilities

Student has multiple disabilities arising from her stroke. The Hearing Officer observes that, in arguing their respective positions, the Student has focused on Student’s OHI eligibility, while the District has focused on her eligibility as a student with an SLD. The Student also sought to establish that she has unique needs arising from autistic-like characteristics. The parents testified that Student was found eligible for Regional Center services on this basis. In addition, various witnesses for the Student testified that Student has autistic-like characteristics, and that she responds positively to methodologies designed for autistic children. (Testimony of Troy, Lowery).(Footnote 11) By contrast, the District argues that Student has never been determined to be eligible as a student with autism. The District points out that Ms. Shwartz’s SDC class is composed primarily of students with specific learning disabilities like STUDENT.

A review of the evidence presented by both parties reveals conflicting diagnoses for STUDENT. For example, in his August 2000 report, Dr. Greenspan concluded that Student “evidences a Regulatory Disorder (RD),...a summary term which describes a number of processing problems or dysfunctions. These include, in her case, the motor planning, auditory processing, and, to a lesser degree, the visual spatial processing and sensory modulation. She can also be described as having a motor planning disorder and an auditory processing disorder.” Dr. Greenspan rejected a diagnosis of Pervasive Developmental Disorder (PDD) for Student “because she’s too warm and related and has the ability to use her language creatively. Even though she has some of the symptoms of that disorder, her warmth and creativity take her out of the range of PDD and autistic spectrum.”(Footnote 12) A year later, in October 2001, Dr. Robinson determined that Student had developmental delay with characteristics “that include receptive [and] expressive language delay, social/emotional growth delays, and patterns of repetitive behaviors that could be described as fitting the classification of PDD NOS....” Dr. Robinson indicated that these characteristics also fit the diagnosis of Multisystem Developmental Disorder (MSDD) secondary to her stroke and that Student had an excellent prognosis based on her past response to therapeutic treatment.

The evidence demonstrates that Student has unique cognitive and academic needs arising out of her disabilities the present nature of which are largely unknown. The April 2002 triennial IEP indicates that Student has a specific learning disability with a severe discrepancy in the area of listening comprehension that is the result of disorders in attention, sensory motor skills and “cognitive abilities, including association, conceptualization and expression.” There is no assessment in evidence, however, of Student’s cognitive abilities or her academic achievement. Rather, the evidence presented at the hearing regarding Student’s cognitive and academic needs, including her unique learning style, was anecdotal. For example, Student’s floor time therapist Heather Santoro testified that Student has very high cognitive functioning given her brain injury. She testified that, although Student is missing her frontal cerebral cortex, she has exceeded all expectations, has a great memory, is very motivated to learn, and loves books. Ms. Santoro also testified that, due to her stroke, Student requires different approaches to learning and needs to develop multiple routes to access problem solving that may be completely different from those used by children without brain injury.(Footnote 13) Testimony of Ms. Shapiro also established that Student’s WJCC class focused on developmental issues rather than academics, and that Student has varying academic abilities. For example, in the area of reading, both Ms. Shapiro and Ms. Troy testified that Student decodes very well and is at the first grade level; however, her reading comprehension is at a lower level. Ms. Troy, who provides private educational therapy in academics to Student on a weekly basis, testified that Student has the ability to visually memorize words and that she must be slowed down to ensure that her comprehension remains at the same level as her decoding. Ms. Troy also testified that Student was learning basic addition and subtraction, spelling of three letter words, and had a weakness in written language. Despite these isolated bits of information, there is no current, coherent assessment of Student’s overall cognitive and academic abilities in light of her multiple disabilities as she enters her first school with an academic curriculum.

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that Student has the following unique needs:

1. unique behavior needs that require behavior services;

2. a unique need for consistency and continuity, including appropriate transition services. 3. unique cognitive and academic needs arising out of multiple disabilities that must be assessed, and 4. a unique need for a small structured classroom placement with a behavior modification plan.

A. Was the District’s Offer Designed to Meet Student’s Unique Needs?

Direct and Supervisory Behavior Services

The Student contends that the District’s offer was not designed to meet her unique needs because it did not include any direct behavior intervention implementation (BII) services and included an insufficient amount of behavior intervention development (BID) supervisory services. The evidence established that, historically, Student had been offered up to twelve hours a week of direct BII floor time services at her home, and that this amount was reduced to eight hours a week on February 4, 2003 by the interim [pre-IEP] services contained in the FMA. Student’s mother testified that Student was actually using six to eight hours of floor time therapy a week prior to the March 4, 2003 IEP. As previously discussed, all direct BII services were eliminated at the March 4, 2003 IEP and a total of five hours a month of BID services for supervision/consultation at school was offered.

The District argues that its offer of behavior services in the March 4, 2003 IEP was designed to meet Student’s unique needs. In its view, Student only requires supervisory or consultative BID behavioral services in the classroom sufficient to inform and educate her SDC staff regarding floor time principles and methods that are successful for her. In its view, this stance is in keeping with Dr. Greenspan’s book The Child With Special Needs, in which he described floor time therapy as a method to be used by the parents with their children at home and that specialists should work with the student informed of these principles. (Dist. Ex. 16).

The Hearing Officer finds that the March 4, 2003 IEP did not meet Student’s unique needs because it failed to offer any direct BII behavior services. First, the weight of the evidence from witnesses who worked with Student persuasively established that she has benefitted from and requires in-home BII floor time therapy as part of her overall behavioral program to function in a classroom setting. While the District may argue that Ms. Lowery and Ms. Santoro have conflicts of interest, both Ms. Troy and Ms. Shapiro are neutral professionals with nothing to gain from their opinions in this regard. For example, Ms. Shapiro testified that Student’s academics were good but that her behavior interferes with her work completion. In her opinion, all of Student’s behavior support, including her TSA and her floor time therapy, are important to her academically because she needs to be in control of her behavior before she can learn. Ms. Shapiro testified that, in her opinion, without this behavior component, Student would not be able to function in class. Given Ms. Shapiro’s experience in working with STUDENT, as well as her experience as a teacher and a residential counselor for students with special needs, the Hearing Office gives great weight to her testimony. The Hearing Officer further notes that, regardless of the manner in which Dr. Greenspan’s book recommended floor time to be implemented, the undisputed facts in this case establish that Student has required direct floor time therapy from persons in addition to her parents. While a precipitous behavioral decline was not documented in Student’s communication log following the termination of floor time services, Ms. Watson’s testimony established that Student’s behavior was always cyclical. Further, the log ended on April 7 and on April 10, 2003, Ms. Watson credibly testified that Student was in a “rough stage right now,” that Student had hit her three times that week, and that Student had begun talking about hitting the girl with whom she is obsessed. The Hearing Officer finds that BII floor time therapy is necessary to meet Student’s behavioral needs, including her attentional needs.

Second, the Hearing Officer finds that BII floor time therapy was also required to address Student’s unique transitional needs. As previously indicated, Student has a unique need for consistency and continuity in services, that includes a need for an appropriate transition plan. The need to maintain floor time therapy during Student’s transition “into new and upcoming educational settings” was acknowledged in her present level of behavior performance in the April 2002 triennial that planned Student’s anticipated transition to Fairburn Elementary. Nonetheless, the evidence established that the March 4, 2003 IEP failed to adequately address what can only be characterized as a monumental change in Student’s life: not only would she be going to a new school in a new environment, but she would also be encountering a new teacher, new peers, and a new TSA. In other words, Student’s transition from WJCC to the Carthay SDC could reasonably be anticipated to have a tremendous impact on her because it would entail the disruption and change in all aspects of her existing support structure. Under these circumstances, the only source of continuity would be her direct floor time services. The total elimination of Student’s direct floor time services at this juncture was not designed to meet her unique needs for consistency, continuity and appropriate transition. Moreover, with the possible exception of Ms. Aluisi whose position at the IEP meeting was disputed, Student’s service providers at the IEP team meeting, including the District’s Ms. Pylman, recommended that the BII services continue, at least for a transitional period.

Third, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s evidence to the contrary is not persuasive. First, there was no evidence of a formal behavior assessment or systematic observation of Student that would support the elimination of her direct BII services during her transition or at any other time. The Hearing Officer finds that the observation of Student at WJCC by Ms. Brown and Mr. Baker does not establish a sufficient knowledge of Student’s unique needs to overcome the lack of a formal assessment. In addition, the evidence persuasively established that their observation of Student was of limited duration, occurred on one of Student’s “good days” and involved minimal questioning of those most involved in her education. Second, as demonstrated by the testimony of Ms. Rochelle, Carthay’s then assistant principal who chaired the IEP meeting, Student’s individual unique transition needs were simply not considered. Ms. Rochelle clearly testified that transition planning is done from preschool to kindergarten, not-- as in this case-- from kindergarten to first grade. Third, as demonstrated by the testimony of District program specialist Mr. Baker, the behavior services ultimately offered were inadequate to meet Student’s unique needs. At the IEP meeting, Mr. Baker originally opposed providing Student with a TSA, but did so on the strong urging of Ms. Aluisi. Mr. Baker eventually testified that he believed the entire IEP was a transition plan and that the TSA and consultative BID services provided Student with adequate transitional support. In light of the fact that the IEP resulted in a net loss of behavior services and eliminated all of Student’s direct behavior services at a time of reasonably anticipated extreme need, it is apparent that Mr. Baker had little understanding of Student’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP was not designed to meet this important unique need. Whether Student ultimately requires ongoing floor time BII therapy can only be determined after the District has successfully transitioned her into an appropriate public school SDC class and has had an opportunity to consistently observe and assess her behavior.(Footnote 14)

From the above, the Hearing Officer also determines that the District’s offer of five hours a month of BID supervisory/consultation services by itself was not designed to meet Student’s unique behavioral or transition needs. Rather, the evidence established that six hours a month of BID supervisory services would be appropriate, but only in conjunction with direct services.

Classroom Placement

The Student contends that the District’s offer was not designed to meet her unique needs because the SDC class placement was not appropriately structured, did not have an appropriate behavior modification plan, and did not have appropriately qualified staff. Student contends that a more appropriate class would be the District’s SDC class at Overland Elementary, because the teacher appeared to be more experienced with autistic children and had a better behavioral structure. The District responds that the Overland SDC is too restrictive for Student because it is designed for students with emotional disabilities and will expose her to negative behavioral role models. Ms. Dumay testified that the Overland SDC class has three emotionally disturbed students and three students with autism.

To determine whether the District provided Student a free appropriate public education, the Hearing Officer must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district has offered a FAPE, it is not required to place a student in a parentally-preferred program, even if that program is likely to result in greater educational benefit to the student than the one offered by the district. Id. at 1307. Accordingly, the proper focus is on the appropriateness of the Carthay EE/SDC class.

The parties generally agree that Student requires placement in a small, structured special day class with qualified teaching staff, an appropriate behavior modification plan and one-to-one support of a temporary support assistant (TSA). They disagree on the whether the District’s offer of placement in Ms. Shwartz’s SDC at Carthay met those needs. The March 4, 2003 IEP Team notes described Student’s offered placement as follows: “The team agrees that a SDC (EE) is the most appropriate placement at the child’s school of residence which is Carthay Center Elementary School. There is a fully credentialed teacher–Tali Shwartz–in the Early Education class. She is experienced, there are currently 7 students: 5 boys - 2 girls, 5 of whom have an SLD eligibility. This also includes ESY which was discussed. The supports in the classroom will include the teacher, classroom assistant, a TSA and up to 5 hours a month of BID [supervisory] support which is to include strategies and techniques for the adults that work with Student thruout [sic] her school day. The BID will also help support and implement Student’s Behavior Support Plan and make modifications necessary for Student’s success at school.”

Preliminarily, the Hearing Officer finds that the offered EE/SDC placement was not designed to meet Student’s unique needs because sufficient behavioral supports were not provided while she transitioned into the classroom. As previously discussed, the evidence persuasively established that direct floor time therapy services in conjunction with adequate supervisory services are necessary for Student to succeed in any classroom. These supports were all the more essential because Student would be entering her first class with a focus on an academic curriculum, and increased expectations relating to that curriculum.

Testimony of Student’s parents established that they perceived SDC teacher Tali Shwartz to be too young and inexperienced, with insufficient knowledge and training about specific techniques for teaching students with autistic-like characteristic like STUDENT. They were also concerned that the class is designed primarily for children with specific learning disabilities who are more able to sit and attend to class lessons for extended periods of time, to raise their hands to answer questions and to learn from a blackboard than STUDENT, and that the behavior modification plan in place is inappropriate for STUDENT. While Student’s father testified that some of the questions asked of the class by the teacher seemed too hard for STUDENT, Ms. Troy testified that some of the lessons she observed seemed far below Student’s level and likely to lead to boredom and frustration.

Various witnesses testified regarding their observations of Ms. Shwartz’s classroom. Each of Student’s parents individually observed her class for a period of approximately one hour in February 2003. Behaviorist Shannon Troy observed Ms. Shwartz’s class for approximately 25 minutes during the due process hearing. These witnesses generally supported the position that Ms. Shwartz’s class is not appropriately designed to meet Student’s unique needs. District witnesses Nathalie Aluisi, Brick Baker and Vicki Brown also observed Ms. Shwartz’s class and testified to the contrary that Ms. Shwartz’s class is appropriately structured with appropriate behavior modification plans and that she is an excellent teacher with a highly trained instructional aide, Ms. Quarles. Uncontradicted testimony established that, unlike other TSAs, Ms. Quarles has a bachelor’s degree in communications disorders and is working on her master’s degree in special education. In addition, both Ms. Shwartz and Ms. Quarles testified about the class, and about their training and experience with students with behavior problems, and/or with autistic-like characteristics. Ms. Shwartz testified that, after the IEP, she had done research in floor time and was eager to learn new techniques. From the testimony of Ms. Shwartz and Ms. Quarles, it is apparent to the Hearing Officer that both Ms. Shwartz and Ms. Quarles are dedicated and willing to learn any new techniques required to assist Student succeed in class.

The Hearing Officer finds, however, that the failure to have a comprehensive psycho-educational assessment or other competent evidence of Student’s unique cognitive and academic needs has substantive dimensions for the development of an appropriate placement offer. As a result of Student’s multiple disabilities, autistic-like characteristics, and behavioral issues, it is imperative to have an assessment that not only provides standardized cognitive and academic testing, but that also examines Student as a complete child and provides guidance to the IEP team regarding the type of structure, behavioral supports, peer disability type and age composition that should be in an appropriate SDC class for STUDENT. While the District provided ample evidence regarding the particulars of Ms. Shwartz’s class, the Hearing Office finds that insufficient information was provided about the appropriateness of placing Student into a class of primarily specific learning disabled children, particularly in light of her multiple disabilities and the lack of any current assessment by a school psychologist. The IEP has been characterized as the blueprint of a child’s educational program; as such, it must be informed by a thorough assessment of a child’s unique needs and present levels of performance.

From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was not a sufficient factual basis for the District’s offer of placement at the March 4, 2003 IEP and that the District did not provide sufficient evidence that the SDC at Carthay was designed to meet Student’s unique needs.

B. Was the District’s Offer Reasonably Calculated to Provide Student Some Educational Benefit?

For the reasons expressed above, the Hearing Officer has found that the District’s March 4, 2003 IEP offer of placement and services is not designed to meet Student’s unique needs. Because the District’s offer is not designed to meet Student’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer now finds that the placement is not reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit.

* * *

From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer Student a FAPE for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school and extended school year in the March 4, 2003 IEP.

II. Is Student Entitled to Compensatory Education in the Area of Behavioral Services?

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have also extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3rd Cir. 1990) 916 F. 2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir.1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1497.

As indicated above, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District denied Student a FAPE for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school and extended year. As a remedy, Student seeks compensatory behavior services. The Hearing Officer now finds that an award of compensatory behavior services is appropriate. The weight of the evidence established that Student received educational benefit in her known areas of unique need from her Smart Start behavior services, both direct and supervisory. The Hearing Officer further finds that to ensure consistency and continuity, compensatory behavior services shall be provided to Student by Smart Start, a certified nonpublic school. Given the complexity of Student’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer determines that Student is entitled to eight hours a week of direct BII and supervisory BID services, beginning the last week of March 2003, for a total of ninety-six (96) hours. These compensatory hours shall be used to supplement Student’s behavior services ordered below. The IEP team shall determine how much of the compensatory behavior services shall be provided as direct in-home services and how much shall be provided as supervisory/consultative BID services to Student’s SDC staff, including her new TSA, at school; however a minimum of fifty (50) hours shall be direct services. * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer Student a FAPE at the March 4, 2003 IEP meeting. While Ms. Shwartz’s SDC class may ultimately be determined to be appropriate for Student in conjunction with adequate behavior services, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District does not have sufficient information at this point to determine the type SDC classroom placement necessary to meet Student’s unique needs. The District must conduct a comprehensive psycho-educational assessment of Student’s cognitive and academic need in light of her multiple disabilities and complex behavioral needs. Once this assessment is completed, the District will have a reasonable basis to offer Student an appropriate classroom placement. After Student has had a reasonable time in which to transition into a new school environment, with a new teacher, new peers, and a new one-to-one trained TSA, the District will be in a position to consider whether a reduction in her direct behavior services is appropriate. Until such time, however, a reduction in those services denies Student a FAPE. Direct BII services shall be reinstated pending completion of the assessment and IEP ordered below. The Hearing Officer further notes that careful educational planning following an appropriate assessment will assist the parties in achieving their mutual goal: placement of Student in an appropriate public special day school class where she has mainstream opportunities.

ORDER

1. Within ten (10) days of the date of this Decision, the District shall prepare an assessment plan for the parents’ review and consent for a comprehensive psycho-educational assessment of Student’s cognitive and academic needs in light of her multiple disabilities. In addition to cognitive and academic testing, the assessment must examine Student as a complete child and provide guidance to the IEP team regarding the type of structure, behavioral supports, peer disability type and age composition that should be in an appropriate SDC class for STUDENT.

2. The District shall complete the assessment ordered above, convene an IEP team meeting, and make an offer to Student for the 2003-2004 school year by no later than August 15, 2003, or the start of the 2003-2004 school year, whichever is earlier. The District’s offer must include an appropriate transition plan and address Student’s unique needs as identified in this Decision and in the psycho-educational assessment.

3. Within ten (10) days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to conform the IEP to this Decision by providing Student with appropriate BII and BID services as follows: for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school and extended school year, or until the assessment and IEP ordered above are completed, Student shall be provided eight (8) hours per week of behavior intervention implementation BII services and six (6) hours a month of behavior intervention development BID services. The services shall be provided by Smart Start NPA.

4. Student is entitled to compensatory education services in the amount of ninety-six (96) hours of behavior services from Smart Start. This amount is in addition to the behavior services ordered above. The IEP team shall determine how much of the compensatory behavior services shall be provided to Student as direct services in the home and how much shall be provided as supervisory/consultative BID services to Student’s new SDC staff, including her new TSA; however a minimum of fifty (50) hours shall be in direct services. Unless the parties agree otherwise, compensatory services shall be completely provided by December 31, 2003.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The Student prevailed on each issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: June 10, 2003 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. This Decision is amended to correct printing errors in the original Decision that resulted in the omission of text at the top or bottom of pages 14, 16, 17 and 18. In all other respects, the Decision remains the same. 2. District Exhibit 16 (excerpt from The Child with Special Needs) and Student Exhibit R (communication book) are admitted into evidence. 3. At the outset of the hearing, the Student clarified that there was no longer any dispute regarding the District’s offer of either occupational therapy (OT) or speech and language (LAS) therapy. 4. For example, the March 4, 2003 IEP states her eligibility as OHI and SLD; both her April 24, 2002 triennial and her September 24, 2002 amendment to the triennial list her eligibility as OHI, SLD, and LAS. 5. Dr. Greenspan recommended that Student receive floor time approximately six times a day for twenty minutes or more each time. These sessions were to be conducted by the parents and other helpers at home in a process that “followed Student’s lead” by developing social interactions with her regarding her interests at the moment. Dr. Wieder’s recommendations included that Student receive a school-based inclusive special education program, fifteen hours a week of floor time home-based program, and daily play dates at school and at home. 6. An additional requirement for FAPE is that the services actually provided to the student comport with those offered in his or her IEP. It is unnecessary to address this requirement, however, because Student has not yet attended the class or received contested services offered by the District in the March 4, 2003 IEP. 7. It is possible, for example, that sufficient current information from other sources (eg., an independent educational assessment) would enable the District to make an appropriate offer of FAPE to Student even without a psycho-educational assessment. 8. On the first day of the hearing, the Student and District agreed that there was no dispute regarding the TSA offered to her by the District in the March 4, 2003 IEP. The Student later tried to elicit testimony about the type of training her TSA would require, in reliance on her proposed resolution that she required trained personnel. The District objected to the addition of a new issue that they were unprepared to address and that may not actually be disputed. The Hearing Officer denied the request to add a new issue of whether the District offered Student an appropriately qualified TSA; however, limited inquiry into this area was allowed to determine Student’s unique needs. The IEP team should utilize information regarding Student’s unique needs to ensure that she is assigned an appropriately trained TSA. The Hearing Officer also notes that the September 2002 amendment to the triennial IEP indicated that any TSA would be “qualified to meet Student’s specific needs.” 9. The testimony of District OT Nathalie Aluisi that Student does not consistently benefit from sensory strategies does not undercut this finding. Ms. Aluisi testified that Student receives greater benefit from a structured environment rather than sensory integration strategies. 10. Some of the methods and strategies used include social stories of how to interact with peers, explaining expectations at group time and desk time, using picture books and schedules to make expectations clear, an immediate reward system, practicing play skills with individual peers (playdates), and teaching social cues. 11. For example, Ms. Watson testified that Student demonstrating “classic autistic behavior” of perseverating on objects and rituals, using repetitive or scripted speech (but not immediate echolalia), and lack of social language skills. Student’s LAS assessor also indicated that she used scripted speech and perseverative behavior. 12. Dr. Greenspan also determined that Student “evidences a static encephalopathy..., a non-progressive disorder of central nervous system functioning...due to her stroke and insult at birth.” 13. Ms. Santoro’s testimony is supported by Dr. Greenspan’s August 2000 report that where there is “an insult to the nervous system functioning, a child doesn’t peak in abilities at the same time as other children. Often it can be later and over a longer period of time.” 14. Because BII services are required to meet Student’s unique needs for transition, it is not necessary to address the District’s contention that such services should be sought by the parents from the Regional Center.