California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 26, 1999
Student v. Temple City Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 538-99 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda
Temple City Unified's preschool special day class offers upheld; Hearing Officer orders added speech therapy, 30 weekly DTT hours, and dedicated aide.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
This case concerned a three-year-old boy diagnosed with autism who was moving from Regional Center services to Temple City Unified School District. He attended the Villa Esperanza infant program, a nonpublic school, and his family wanted him to stay there. The District offered either of two Los Angeles County Office of Education preschool special day classes: one at Wilkerson School, taught by Teresa Behnke, or one taught by Barbara Swisher that was moving from Canyon School to Mayflower Elementary. Either class came with a full-time one-on-one aide. The family worried about safety because he tends to run. They also objected to the time with typical peers, the missing net swing, and the distance to the bathroom. The Hearing Officer found that both classes were language-based and structured, were taught by credentialed teachers, and offered planned time with typically developing peers. The dedicated aide addressed safety. Both placements met the Rowley "some educational benefit" standard. On speech therapy, the Hearing Officer relied on the family's longtime private therapist, Connie Stratton. He ordered two individual half-hour sessions and one small-group half-hour session each week. The District's offer had not said how its sessions would be split between group and individual time. The parties mostly agreed on Discrete Trial Training (DTT), and the order set 30 hours per week. The extended school year (ESY) offer was found reasonable. The District had to hold IEP meetings to write transition, behavior, sensory and ESY plans.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO decided a dispute between a family's preferred nonpublic school and district special day classes. A parent's preference did not defeat an offer that met the child's needs. A dedicated aide satisfied the safety concerns. The decision also shows that an offer of "group and individual" speech therapy that does not say how the time is split can be replaced with specific minutes.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Has the District offered Student a placement for the 1999-2000 school year which will enable him to obtain a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?
Both offered LACOE preschool special day classes (Wilkerson or Canyon/Mayflower), with a dedicated one-on-one aide, met the student's unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, conformed to the IEP, and offered interaction with typical peers; safety, net swing and bathroom objections rejected.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2a. Does Student require two one-hour sessions of individual speech and language services and one hour (elsewhere stated as thirty minutes) of small-group services each week to obtain minimal educational benefit?
Crediting the private speech pathologist, the Hearing Officer found two one-hour sessions unnecessary but ordered two half-hour individual sessions plus one half-hour small-group session weekly, more than the District's unspecified 'group and individual' offer of two 30-minute sessions; Petitioner declared to have substantially prevailed.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2b. Does Student require Discrete Trial Training to obtain minimal educational benefit?
Based on the weight of the evidence, student requires 30 hours of DTT per week, with no more than four hours per day at school; Hearing Officer stated neither party prevailed because there was essentially no disagreement.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 3. Was the District's offer of an extended school year program for the 1999-2000 school year legally sufficient?
The IEP's statement that the student was eligible for ESY, with options to be discussed once placement was determined, was reasonable under the circumstances; IEP meeting to develop ESY nonetheless ordered.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. District shall provide either the Wilkerson preschool special day class (Teresa Behnke) or the Mayflower preschool special day class (Barbara Swisher) for the 1999-2000 school year.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 business days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to develop (a) a transition plan from Villa Esperanza to Wilkerson or Mayflower; (b) a behavioral plan with behavioral goals and objectives, giving careful consideration to Joyce Tu's behavioral assessment; and (c) a 'sensory diet,' considering a net swing, weighted vest and other devices.
- Order to provide or change services. Behavioral plan shall provide 30 hours of Discrete Trial Training per week, with no less than three and no more than four hours per day in the school environment.
- Order to provide or change services. Two half-hour sessions of individual speech therapy and one half-hour session of small-group speech therapy (no more than three students, including Student) each week during the 1999-2000 school year, unless the parties agree otherwise.
- Order to provide or change services. Full-time one-on-one aide for 1999-2000, trained in Discrete Trial Training before the student's transition, assigned only to the student and not used for other purposes.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 60 days after the student enters Wilkerson or Mayflower, convene a second IEP meeting to develop an appropriate extended school year program.
Key authorities
Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District
People named in the decision
- Teresa Behnke, special education teacher, proposed preschool special day class, Wilkerson School (Los Angeles County Office of Education)
- Barbara Swisher, special education teacher, proposed preschool special day class, Canyon School / Mayflower Elementary School (Los Angeles County Office of Education)
- Janice Taylor, coordinator of special education / program specialist, Temple City Unified School District
- Jill Pedersen, speech-language pathologist (district assessor and provider), Temple City Unified School District
- Frankie Conner (also spelled Connor), school psychologist (psychoeducational assessor), Temple City Unified School District
- Irene George, adapted physical education assessor, Temple City Unified School District
- Scott Shepard (also spelled Sheppard), autism consultant, expert witness for District, Avenues; California State University Northridge
- Joyce Tu, behavior consultant / behavioral assessor, witness for Student, Applied Behavior Consultants, Inc.
- Diane Howard, educational consultant providing one-on-one support, witness for Student, Education Spectrum
- Connie Stratton, private speech-language pathologist, witness for Student
- Carol Perez, Regional Center service coordinator, East Los Angeles Regional Center
- Larry E. Gaines, Ph.D., evaluator who initially diagnosed student
- Betty Durazo, current classroom teacher, Villa Esperanza
- Villa Esperanza, certified nonpublic school (infant program), funded by East Los Angeles Regional Center
- Education Spectrum, private service provider, funded by East Los Angeles Regional Center
- Applied Behavior Consultants, Inc., behavioral assessment agency, funded by East Los Angeles Regional Center
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Temple City, California, on June 17 and 18, 1999. Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Carol Hickman Graham. Also present on STUDENT's behalf were his mother, MOTHER, and his grandmother, GRANDMOTHER. Respondent Temple City Unified School District (District) was represented by Educational Consultant G. Robert Roice. Also present on the District's behalf was Janice Taylor, the District's coordinator of special education. The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: GRANDMOTHER ; MOTHER ; Teresa Behnke, special education teacher at the Wilkerson School; Joyce Tu, behavior consultant; Diane Howard, educational consultant; Connie Stratton, speech pathologist. The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Scott Sheppard, consultant on autism; Jill Pedersen, speech pathologist; Frankie Connor, school psychologist; Barbara Swisher, special education teacher at the Canyon School; and Janice Taylor. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.ISSUES (footnote 1)1. Has the District offered STUDENTa placement for the 1999-2000 school year which will enable him to a obtain a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?2. Does STUDENTrequire the following support services to obtain minimal educational benefit: a. Two one-hour sessions of individual speech and language services and one hour of small-group services each week? b. Discrete Trial Training?3. Was the District's offer of an extended school year program for the 1999-2000 school year legally sufficient? BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT was born [date redacted]. At approximately eighteen months, his family grew concerned because he was not responding to sounds. His hearing was evaluated at Huntington Memorial Hospital and found to be normal. STUDENTwas referred to the East Los Angeles Regional Center, where, at twenty-four months, he began receiving services, including individual speech and language therapy two times per week in one-hour sessions. At approximately thirty months, STUDENTwas evaluated and diagnosed with Autistic Spectrum Disorder and Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disorder. He began attending the infant program at Villa Esperanza, a certified nonpublic school, funded by the Regional Center, in November 1998. STUDENTcontinues to attend Villa Esperanza's infant program four times per week. Also in November 1998, STUDENTbegan receiving services from Education Spectrum, also funded by the Regional Center. In the fall of 1998, either October or November, Janice Taylor, the District's coordinator of special education, first met STUDENTand his family at a transition meeting arranged by the Regional Center service coordinator, Carol Perez. (Testimony of Janice Taylor) The District began to assess STUDENTin February 1999, and completed its assessments in early March 1999. The District assessed in four areas: speech and language development, adapted physical education, cognition, and pre-academics. The District interviewed STUDENT's mother, grandmother, and current classroom teacher, and observed STUDENTat Villa Esperanza. (District's Exhibit Nos. 6, 7 and 8). Irene George, in a report dated March 10, 1999, determined that STUDENT's gross-motor skills are at age-level, with some possible delays in kicking and hopping. Ms. George also found that significant delays are evident in perceptual motor and fine motor areas. She recommended that STUDENTbe enrolled in Adapted Physical Education (APE), with the support of a program involving consistent motor skill development and perceptual motor opportunities. (District's Exhibit No. 8) Jill Pedersen, the District's speech pathologist, found that STUDENThas both receptive language and expressive language deficits. Regarding expressive language, she found that STUDENTprimarily communicates nonverbally. Throughout her observation, STUDENTdid not vocalize, with the exception of a few vowels and bilabial sounds. She recommended that STUDENTbe placed in a special education language-based preschool program "which can appropriately address his speech and language needs." (District's Exhibit No. 7) Frankie Conner completed a psychoeducational evaluation. Her report dated March 10, 1999, indicates that STUDENThas developmental delays and notes that he has recently been diagnosed with Autistic Spectrum Disorder, as well as Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder. She administered the Merrill-Palmer Scale of Mental Tests and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales. She also examined previous tests administered in September 1998 by Larry E. Gaines, Ph.D, who initially diagnosed STUDENT. Ms. Conner determined that STUDENT's "cognitive and adaptive functioning is in the mild deficient range . . ." and that STUDENT's cognitive and adaptive skills are similar to those of a one- to two-year-old. Her recommendations are as follows: Enrollment in a special education preschool program to continue to provide general developmental intervention and close supervision. STUDENTneeds behavior modification to deal with his inappropriate behavior patterns. Speech/language and Adapted P.E. services are warranted. (District's Exhibit No. 6) The District convened the initial IEP meeting on March 10, 1999, four days before STUDENT's third birthday. Present at the meeting were MOTHER , GRANDMOTHER, Irene George, Jill Pedersen, Frankie Conner, as well as Carol Perez, the service coordinator from the regional center, and Janice Taylor, the special education coordinator for the District. No teacher was present. (District's Exhibit No. 7) The District recommended placement in a preschool program in the Los Angeles County special day class located at the Wilkerson School (Wilkerson), as well as a range of services. Although STUDENT's grandmother, GRANDMOTHER, had visited the program, MOTHER had not yet had the opportunity. GRANDMOTHER expressed her concern that Wilkerson was not safe for STUDENTbecause of his propensity to run. (Testimony of GRANDMOTHER) MOTHER declined to accept the program, but agreed to visit the class. (District's Exhibit No. 7) The District offered services including adapted physical education, two thirty-minute sessions per week; speech and language services, two thirty-minute sessions each week "group & individual"; and two hours of individual occupational therapy. The IEP team developed goals and objectives in the areas of receptive and expressive language, alternative communication, pragmatics and social skills, gross motor, object control and perceptual motor, as well as goals and objectives designed to improve STUDENT's attention to task and to improve his motor planning skills. No self-help or behavior goals and objectives were developed, although the IEP notes that STUDENTneeded behavior intervention, including a school/classroom management system, and goals and objectives to address STUDENT's behavior. STUDENT's mother agreed that the goals and objectives were appropriate. (footnote 2) On April 2, 1999, the IEP team reconvened. In the interim period, MOTHER had visited Wilkerson, and mirrored GRANDMOTHER's concerns over the insufficient safety of the campus, due to STUDENT's propensity to run. (Testimony of MOTHER ) The District restated its offer of the Wilkerson special day program, and offered the services of a one-on-one aide, in part, to address Ms. PARENT's safety concerns, and also to assist with STUDENT's behavioral needs. MOTHER declined the District's offer to place STUDENTat Wilkerson (District's Exhibit No. 4) The IEP states, in pertinent part: The Temple City U.S.D. is offering the services of a one-on-one aide who can receive training by the teacher, LA COE staff, and other appropriate professionals in order to ensure STUDENT's safety and to assist in focusing his attention, and help provide instruction. The district is offering school placement at Wilkerson School as an appropriate and least restrictive environment to meet STUDENT's needs. The goals and objectives identified by his teacher at Villa Esperanza (Betty Durazo) can be addressed at Wilkerson. The Wilkerson teacher, Theresa Behnke, has a special education credential with a specialization in severely handicapped, has received Discreet Trial Training through Autism Partnership, has had TEACCH training for children with autism, and Picture Exchange Communication Services training (PECS). (District's Exhibit No. 4) The District and Petitioner agreed at the April 2, 1999 IEP meeting that the Regional Center would fund a behavioral assessment for STUDENT. The assessment included the appropriateness of a Discreet Trial Training program to address STUDENT's severe behavioral needs. STUDENTwas assessed by Applied Behavioral Consultants, Inc., beginning in April 1999. The behavioral assessment was completed in early June 1999, and delivered to the District in mid-June 1999. (Petitioner's Exhibit No. 7) Sometime after the April 2, 1999 IEP, the District offered an alternative placement at the Canyon School, also a Los Angeles County Office of Education special day class, taught by Barbara Swisher. Neither GRANDMOTHER nor MOTHER has visited the program. (Testimony of MOTHER and GRANDMOTHER) During the hearing, it was revealed that the Canyon special day class taught by Barbara Swisher would be relocating to the Mayflower Elementary School campus in September 1999. (Testimony of Barbara Swisher, Testimony of Janice Taylor) The District reaffirmed its offer by facsimile dated June 5, 1999: The Temple City Unified School District believes that STUDENT's unique educational needs can be met in either the Preschool Special Day Class program at Wilkerson School taught by Teresa Behnke, or the Preschool Special Day Class at Canyon taught by Barbara Swisher. These are half day a.m./p.m. programs and STUDENTcould attend both sessions if necessary. In either setting he would be assigned a one-on-one personal aide throughout the day. The Canyon Preschool program also offers the opportunity for integration/reverse integration with the on-site preschool program. The District has agreed to provide STUDENTwith a school/home Discreet Trial Training program in accordance with the assessment which is currently in progress. The number of hours and location of the services is contingent upon the results of this assessment. In addition to the program and services set forth above, the District has offered Speech and Language Therapy 2 times per week, 30 minute sessions, individual and small group, Occupational Therapy, 2 times per week, 60 minute sessions, APE services 2 times per week, 30 minute sessions, plus 1 hour per month Occupational Therapy Consultation. POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES Both parties agree that STUDENTrequires a language-based, structured program to benefit from his education. There is no dispute that STUDENThas severe behavioral needs that must be addressed for him to benefit from his education. Moreover, the parties agree generally that a Discreet Trial Training (DTT) program, thirty hours per week, is the best way to meet this need, along with a full-time, trained, one-on-one aide. It is similarly undisputed that STUDENThas a propensity to run and that any placement must be sufficiently safe. Finally, the parties do not dispute STUDENT's need for speech and language services, adapted physical education and occupational therapy. The crux of the dispute is in regard to which school is appropriate for STUDENTfor the 1999-2000 school year. The District contends that it has offered an appropriate placement for STUDENTin either of two Los Angeles County Office of Education special day classes, in conjunction with a Discreet Trial trained one-on-one aide, assigned only to STUDENT: The Wilkerson School special day class, or the Canyon School special day class, which is moving in September to the Mayflower Elementary School. The Wilkerson School special day class is a language-based, structured, yet flexible program taught by Teresa Behnke that the District asserts will provide significant opportunities to interact with typically developing peers. The Canyon School special day class is similarly language-based and highly structured, and is taught by Barbara Swisher. The District argues that either special day class can meet STUDENT's unique needs and provide him with some educational benefit in the least restrictive environment. The District contends that MOTHER has rejected each of the District's special day classes because she prefers Villa Esperanza. GRANDMOTHER and MOTHER would like STUDENTto remain at Villa Esperanza, a certified nonpublic school. STUDENThas been attending the infant program at Villa Esperanza since November 1998. He attends four hours per day, four days per week. The program is funded by the East Los Angeles Regional Center. If STUDENTremains at Villa Esperanza, he will transition to the "ABC" school, a five-day-per-week, six-hour-per-day preschool class. Petitioner objects to placement at Wilkerson because it does not provide him opportunities to interact with typical peers, is unsafe, lacks a "net swing," and is a distance from the bathroom. Petitioner objects to Canyon because it is currently located on a high school campus. Finally, the parties disagree about the mix (group and individual) and quantity of speech and language services, as well as the legal sufficiency of the District's offer of an extended school year program. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ISSUE NO. 1: Has the District offered STUDENTa placement for the 1999-2000 school year which will enable him to a obtain a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment? Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code 56000. The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student's individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. 1401(8). "Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. 1401(25) (1997). The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. 1401(22). Education Code 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of possible related services are language and speech development and remediation, psychological services other than for assessment and development of the IEP, parent counseling and training, health and nursing services, specially designed vocational education and career development, and counseling and guidance. 20 U.S.C. 1401(22) (1997) (former version at 20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(17) (1991)); Cal. Educ. Code 56363(b) (1983). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student's IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Id. at 200. According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student's abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. In determining whether the District offered STUDENTa FAPE, the proper focus is on the adequacy of the District's placement. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District's program reflected STUDENT's needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District offered a FAPE, even if, as here, the parent prefers another program, and even if the preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. Special education law also requires that STUDENTbe educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and the severity of his disabilities is such that education in regular education classes with use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code 56031. To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, an appropriate program must meet the following four requirements to constitute an appropriate placement: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; (3) comport with his IEP; and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment. Identifying STUDENT's Unique Needs In determining whether the District-proposed programs are designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, the first step is to identify STUDENT's unique needs. There is substantial congruity between the parties regarding STUDENT's needs. STUDENThas virtually no functional speech. His speech is limited to "ma-ma" and "bye-bye," and those phrases are used inappropriately. STUDENThas serious behavioral problems. GRANDMOTHER and MOTHER (STUDENT's grandmother and mother) testified that STUDENTengages in both self-stimulatory and self-injurious behaviors. Self-stimulatory behaviors include hand clapping, turning his head from side to side in a fast motion, rocking, walking on his toes, and manipulating objects such as beads. Self-injurious behaviors include hand-biting (which has on at least one occasion penetrated his skin), hitting his head with his hands, falling on his knees, banging his head on the floor, and pinching his cheeks. GRANDMOTHER testified that STUDENT's behaviors have escalated over the past several months, both in frequency and duration. She explained that a typical tantrum lasts between five and fifty-five minutes. Both GRANDMOTHER and MOTHER testified that STUDENTis a "runner"; he often attempts to run away. He also has the ability to open unlocked and unsecured doors, and is an adept climber. Finally, STUDENTis not potty-trained. Diane Howard has provided one-on-one support services for STUDENTone hour per week since November 1998, which are funded by the Regional Center. Ms. Howard has a bachelor's degree in psychology and sociology, as well as regular education, severely handicapped and learning handicapped teaching credentials. She has more than thirty year of experience in special education. She worked at Villa Esperanza as a special education teacher for eight years, and then as director for twenty years. For the past two and a half years, she has worked for Education Spectrum, where she provides consulting services, in addition to one-on-one support services. Ms. Howard testified that STUDENT's behavior issues include difficulty self-regulating and generally a "very difficult time pulling himself together." STUDENThas difficulty with transitions, both from place to place and from activity to activity. Ms. Howard confirmed that STUDENT's self-abusive behaviors have escalated over the past two to three months. Ms. Howard recommended a program that is "very highly structured" and that incorporates an alternative communication program such as PECS (Picture Exchange Communication System). She explained that STUDENT"needs to go from activity to activity," to have virtually no down time, and to be constantly engaged. She stressed that STUDENTrequires "immediate feedback" and "a lot of consistency." STUDENTalso requires a program with a high staff-to-student ratio, and a staff trained in autism and how to redirect STUDENT's behavior, as well as how to provide immediate feedback and maintain consistency. She also explained that STUDENT's teacher should be credentialed. She also recommended a DTT program and a full-time, one-on-one aide who is trained in behavior modification, positive reinforcement and redirection techniques, as well as DTT. Ms. Howard believes that STUDENTrequires a "sensory diet" to address STUDENT's sensory needs, methods essentially used to calm STUDENT. According to Ms. Howard, a proper sensory diet should be set up by an occupational therapist and provided "on the campus." It should include methods such as joint compressions, a "sit and move" cushion, brushing, a "weighted vest," and a net swing. STUDENT's current "sensory diet" at Villa Esperanza includes a net swing and a weighted vest. Joyce Tu, a registered behavioral specialist, received her bachelor's degree in psychology in 1996 from California State University Sacramento. She has worked for Applied Behavior Consultants since graduating. She has conducted behavioral assessments for the past two years exclusively with children diagnosed with autism. Ms. Tu assessed STUDENT's behavioral needs over a seven-week period which included eight observation hours. She recommended a program with "sameness, repetition and consistency." She also opined that STUDENTis too young for more than a four-hour-per-day preschool program, in conjunction with DTT. The District's witnesses identified similar needs. Janice Taylor is the coordinator and program specialist for special education for the Temple Unified School District. Prior to that, she worked for twenty-one years in the special education division of the Los Angeles County Office of Education, the first sixteen as a school psychologist. As a school psychologist, she has assessed between sixty and one-hundred students who have been diagnosed with autism. She has both a master's and a bachelor's degree in psychology, with an emphasis in school psychology,and has completed the first year of the Doctoral program in Educational Administration. She also has a life-time school psychology credential and is licensed by the State of California as an educational psychologist. Ms. Taylor observed STUDENTon two separate occasions, spoke with both GRANDMOTHER and MOTHER , and visited STUDENT's current placement at Villa Esperanza, as well as the District's proposed placements at Wilkerson and Canyon. She also conducted the IEP meeting on March 10, 1999, and the follow-up IEP meeting on April 2, 1999. Ms. Taylor testified that STUDENTrequires a structured program with a consistent routine and yet enough flexibility to allow him to learn how to handle change. The program should have a single, consistent way of addressing STUDENT's behavior, and should be administered by a credentialed special education teacher. Additionally, she recommended a language-based program, with opportunities to interact with typically developing peers so that STUDENThas appropriate language and social models. Scott Shepard made similar recommendations. Mr. Shepard received his bachelor's degree in psychology, as well as a master's degree in education. He has a teaching credential in special education (severely handicapped). He specializes in autism: the bulk of his more than thirteen years of experience is in the area of supporting children, adults and families in the area of autism. He works full-time for Avenues, a nonprofit organization that supports young adults with autism and other developmental disabilities. Mr. Shepard also works part-time for California State University Northridge, where he supervises student teachers and teaches a class titled "Behavior Assessment and Positive Behavior Support," emphasizing behavior management, as well as replacement behaviors and skills. He also conducts Behavior Intervention Case Manager (BICM) training for SELPAs and districts throughout the State of California. Previously, Mr. Shepard provided training in the master's program at the University of San Francisco in the area of positive behavior support and instructional strategies. Mr. Shepard observed STUDENTfor approximately one and one half hours in his current placement, the infant program at Villa Esperanza. He also visited and compared the District's proposed placements. He testified that an appropriate program for STUDENTrequires structure with some flexibility, a predictable routine, appropriate peer models for language and social skill development, an alternative communication system, such as PECs, and a built-in opportunity to teach STUDENTcoping strategies. Petitioner raised the issue of the appropriate length of the instructional day for STUDENTin his issue statement and at the beginning of the hearing. (Petitioner's Statement of Issues, No. 2) Specifically, Petitioner argued that an appropriate placement should include instruction for six hours per day, five days per week. However, Petitioner provided no evidence to support the appropriateness of a six-hour day. Indeed, the only witness called by Petitioner who addressed the issue, Joyce Tu, testified that, because of STUDENT's age, any instructional day greater than four hours would be inappropriate. Janice Taylor testified that STUDENT's instructional day should not exceed four hours, and Scott Shepard echoed her sentiment. STUDENTrequires speech therapy, adapted physical education, and occupational therapy, as well as a Discreet Trial Training program. With the exception of the mix (individual and group) and quantity of speech therapy, these items are not in dispute. Based on the documentary evidence, as well as the testimony of the parties, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENTrequires the following in order to benefit from his education: a language-based, half-day program with significant structure, but some flexibility, taught by a credentialed special education teacher; a low staff-to-student ratio; a one-on-one aide trained in DTT; and opportunities to interact with typically developing peers. Additionally, because of his propensity to run, STUDENT's placement must be safe. Finally, STUDENTrequires an appropriate "sensory diet," which may include a net swing, a weighted vest, or other devices to address his sensory needs. (footnote 3) Is the Wilkerson school placement designed to address STUDENT's unique needs and provide some educational benefit? Teresa Behnke teaches the special day class at the Wilkerson school, located in the City of El Monte. Ms. Behnke is an experienced, credentialed special education teacher with over sixteen years of experience working with preschoolers in both special education and regular education environments. She has taught at the Wilkerson school for the past five years. She has training in Discreet Trial, PECS, sign language, and TEACCH. Additionally, she is a mentor teacher for Los Angeles County, and serves both the Curriculum Committee for Preschool students and the District Level Committee called the "Inclusion Task Force." One area of interest is that of bringing nondisabled "typical" children into contact with children with disabilities. (Testimony of Teresa Behnke) Ms. Behnke explained that her program typically has between six and eight students. The current class consists of seven students. Three have functional speech; two are learning to use alternative communication systems. Three of her current students are "runners." Over the past five years, she has taught several children with varying degrees of autism, some with very significant behavioral problems. She has one full-time aide, and the teacher for the afternoon program (held in the same room) typically comes in early (at approximately 9:00 to 9:30 a.m.), as does the aide for the afternoon class. She described the classroom as "beautiful," "air-conditioned" and "carpeted." Ms. Behnke described a typical day in her class. The program begins at 7:50 a.m., and ends at 11:30 a.m. The day begins with a structured play time, where her students and non-disabled peers interact (from approximately 7:50 to 8:25 a.m.). Throughout the remainder of the day, the children have other opportunities to interact with typical peers, including during breakfast, and "group time," as well as recess. Each activity is planned in advance and structured, including the interactions with typical peers. On Fridays, her students work in a fenced-in garden adjacent to the classroom with students from the sixth-grade classroom. Ms. Behnke also discussed each of the goals and objectives in the March 10, 1999 IEP and credibly explained how each would be addressed during a typical day. (Testimony of Teresa Behnke, District's Exhibit No. 12) Scott Shepard visited the Wilkerson program. During his visit, he observed typical peers reading to the special education students. Mr. Shepard noted that there were lots of opportunities and that "Ms. Behnke does a good job of providing structured choices for her students and tries to give them some room to 'explore', especially during recess." He also was impressed with Ms. Behnke's emphasis on teaching "functional" and "real life" skills, and the use of alternative communication systems, such as PECS. He noted, for example, that when simple tasks such as sorting are explored, a real task is involved, such as sorting dishes, which also improves the students' basic living skills. In his report under the section "weaknesses," Mr. Shepard noted: The class is not as structured as the previous class (did not necessarily follow a rigid routine), however, this may not actually be a weakness. It is important to promote some flexibility (and variety) within the routine, especially for students with the label of autism. This helps students to be better able to cope with changes in routine, etc. (District's Exhibit 13, p. 3). Frankie Conner also visited Ms. Behnke's class. She testified that the program was language-based, that the class followed a consistent routine, and that it provided significant opportunities to interact with typical peers. She was also impressed with the high teacher-to-student ratio, the developmentally appropriate instruction, as well as the teacher. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District's proposed placement at Wilkerson meets STUDENT's unique needs. It is a language-based, half-day program, with significant structure, but some flexibility, taught by a credentialed special education teacher, and has a high staff-to-student ratio. Petitioner objects to Wilkerson on several grounds. Petitioner objects because Wilkerson offers "no opportunities to interact with typically developing peers." (Petitioner's Statement of Issues, No. 2) The Hearing Officer concludes that, to the contrary, the most significant strength of Ms. Behnke's class is the opportunity to interact with typical peers. Petitioner also objects because some of the typical peers are older; specifically, sixth grade students visit the classroom on Fridays and garden with special education students. (footnote 4) Diane Howard testified that it was not appropriate to have "older" students "in and out of the class." (Testimony of Diane Howard) She explained that having children at the same eye-level, and interested in the same games, is very important. Ms. Howard also expressed safety concerns, and testified that STUDENT"does not like people in his face" and may attempt to hit or bite other children who act inappropriately. But Ms. Behnke, and others who visited the program, explained that the interactions with typical peers are structured, i.e., always at the same time of the day, and task-oriented (gardening, reading, etc.) (Testimony of Scott Shepard, Janice Taylor, Teresa Behnke) Moreover, Ms. Howard's safety concerns will be addressed by STUDENT's one-on-one aide, which the District agreed to provide at the April 2, 1999 IEP meeting. (footnote 5) Petitioner's chief concern was the safety of the Wilkerson campus. (Testimony of GRANDMOTHER and MOTHER ) MOTHER testified that she was informed by Ms. Behnke that Wilkerson was not safe for STUDENT. However, Ms. Behnke testified that with the assistance of a one-to-one aide, Wilkerson would be safe for STUDENTand that she currently has three "runners." She also explained that the campus is fenced, including the playground, but that neither the gates nor the classroom doors are locked. Additionally, to address MOTHER 's concern, the District offered the services of a one-on-one aide, who would be assigned only to STUDENT. (footnote 6) (Testimony of Janice Taylor) The Hearing Officer finds that, by offering the services of a one-to-one aide, who will be assigned only to STUDENT, the District has proposed a placement which meets STUDENT's unique safety needs. Petitioner also objects to Wilkerson on the ground that it does not have a "net swing," one of the "sensory diet" methods necessary to calm STUDENTdown. To accommodate MOTHER , the District offered to install a net swing. (Testimony of MOTHER and Janice Taylor) MOTHER explained that the absence of the net swing in the classroom persuaded her that the classroom was not designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs; she explained that the classroom should already have had a net swing. (Testimony of MOTHER ) The Hearing Officer finds that the District was required to offer a program tailored to meet STUDENT's individual needs and to provide some educational benefit. The fact that Ms. Behnke's class never had a child with the identical "sensory diet" needs as STUDENTis both irrelevant and unpersuasive. Finally, Petitioner objects to the Wilkerson placement on the ground that the bathroom is not located in, or adjacent to the classroom. STUDENTis not potty-trained. Ms. Behnke testified that it takes approximately one minute for an adult to walk to the current bathroom. She also testified that it is inconvenient for her and her staff, but that it has never posed a problem for her students for the last five years she has taught at Wilkerson. The Hearing Officer finds that the classroom's proximity to the bathroom sufficiently meets STUDENT's unique needs. In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed placement of STUDENTat the Wilkerson school, in conjunction with a one-to-one aide, meets all of STUDENT's unique needs. Moreover, it is generally agreed by the parties that a program designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, such as the placement described above, is also reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit to STUDENT. (footnote 7) Is the Mayflower school placement designed to address STUDENT's unique needs and provide some educational benefit? After Petitioner rejected the Wilkerson placement, the District offered another placement at the Canyon school, taught by Barbara Swisher. (District's Exhibit No. 2) MOTHER and GRANDMOTHER rejected the placement outright because it was located on a high school campus. (Testimony of MOTHER and GRANDMOTHER). During the course of the hearing, it was learned that the program would be moving from the Canyon High school campus to another site, the Mayflower Elementary School, located in a residential area in Monrovia, California, in September 1999. (Testimony of Barbara Swisher, Testimony of Janice Taylor). The Hearing Officer finds that, because Ms. Swisher's program is moving to a new site in September, the physical location of the present campus is irrelevant for purposes of prospective placement. Barbara Swisher presented as an excellent witness, with a pleasant, congenial manner. She testified that although her class has moved several times over the years, her program has remained the same. Her current program will not change substantively. She visited the new site and discussed details with Mayflower's principal. There is a kindergarten class on the campus, and opportunities for STUDENTto interact with typically developing peers. Her class will use the same playground as the kindergarten class. Additionally, the classroom is adjacent to an age-appropriate bathroom. She testified that her class would be located in one of two new portables that had not yet been moved to the campus. Barbara Swisher has a credential in special education and has been teaching special education children, including children with autism, for over thirteen years. Since 1991, she has taught preschool-age children. She has been trained in PECS and TEACCH. Her current class consists of eight students, ages three to six, four of whom have been diagnosed with autism. Her staff consists of herself and two instructional aids. (Testimony of Barbara Swisher) Like Ms. Behnke, Ms. Swisher testified that each of STUDENT's goals and objectives, developed at the March 10, 1999 IEP, could be implemented in her class and that other children had similar goals and objectives. She also indicated that she has experience with children who tantrum, as well as "runners." Scott Shepard observed Ms. Swisher's program at the Canyon site. He found that the location of the site was inappropriate because it was on a high school campus. However, he was impressed with Ms. Swisher's program: I was very impressed that Ms. Swisher had developed individualized communication books (using PECS and pictures) for the student. There was also a visual schedule of activities (using PECS and pictures to indicate specific activities), and a chart with faces displaying various emotions that was easily accessible to the students to point at and utilize while in the classroom. (District's Exhibit No. 13) Mr. Shepard found that Barbara Swisher supported her students with behavioral problems in a positive way. He noted that she emphasizes communication skills and that her program was "very structured" and provided a "predictable routine." Petitioner presented no evidence to refute the appropriateness of Ms. Swisher's program to meet STUDENT's unique needs. Petitioner's sole objection to the Mayflower site was that it cannot accommodate a net swing, necessary to calm STUDENTwhen he tantrums. Petitioner presented no evidence, however, to support that objection. The Hearing Officer finds that Mayflower's language-based, highly structured program, taught by a credentialed, qualified teacher, in conjunction with a one-to-one aide, will meet STUDENT's unique needs. Moreover, as with the Wilkerson school placement, it is generally agreed by the parties that a program designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs is also reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. Do the District's proposed placements at the Wilkerson and Canyon/Mayflower schools conform to STUDENT's IEP? STUDENT's goals and objectives are not in dispute. And as discussed above, both teachers, Teresa Behnke and Barbara Swisher, testified as to how they would implement each applicable goal and objective throughout the course of a typical day. However, STUDENThas no goals and objectives to address his behavioral needs. The parties agreed at the April 2, 1999 IEP meeting that Regional Center would fund a behavioral assessment, and the District subsequently agreed to provide STUDENTwith a school/home Discreet Trial Training program in accordance with that assessment. (District's Exhibit No. 2) The assessment, conducted by Joyce Tu, was not completed until June 1, 1999, and not delivered to the District until sometime later. The District has not yet had the opportunity to develop goals and objectives to address STUDENT's behavior, which must be developed in conjunction with the IEP team. Janice Taylor testified regarding the reasons why behavior goals and objectives were not developed at the March or April IEP meetings. She testified that STUDENT's behavior plan would be dependent in part on his placement, and the IEP team was unsure where STUDENTwould be placed during the following school year. The staff who will work with the child, including the teacher, are ordinarily involved in developing behavior plans. Additionally, the IEP team was unsure whether or not STUDENTwould remain at Villa Esperanza and he already had behavior goals and objectives at Villa Esperanza. She explained that after confirmation that STUDENTwould be moving to a new school, a behavior plan would be written specifically for that school. The Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed placements will conform to STUDENT's IEP. ISSUE NO. 2: Does STUDENTrequire the following support services to obtain minimal educational benefit: a. Two one-hour sessions of individual speech and language services and thirty minutes of small-group services each week? The parties agree that STUDENTrequires speech and language therapy. The District has offered two thirty-minute sessions of "group and individual" speech and language services each week. According to Petitioner, STUDENTrequires two one-hour individual sessions, and thirty minutes of small-group services each week. STUDENTreceived two one-hour sessions of individual services per week from Connie Stratton until March 31, 1999. Ms. Stratton has substantial experience; she has been a licensed speech and language pathologist since 1980. Ms. Stratton testified that, at the time of his discharge, STUDENTrequired two one-hour sessions of individual therapy per week. (footnote 8) Ms. Stratton testified, however, that two half-hour sessions of individual therapy would be appropriate for STUDENTif provided in conjunction with a language-based program, as well as thirty minutes of small-group therapy each week. She emphasized that the speech pathologist working with STUDENTwould need to work closely with the classroom teacher, a collaborative approach. She examined each of STUDENT's speech-related goals and objectives and surmised that, although sufficient, they could not be met in two thirty-minute individual sessions without a collaborative approach and a language-based program. Finally, she testified that the group session should include no more than three students. (Testimony of Connie Stratton) Jill Pedersen, the District's speech and language pathologist, has been treating STUDENTsince March 31, 1999. Ms. Pedersen evaluated STUDENTfor the District and helped develop the goals and objectives. Ms. Pedersen has a bachelor's degree in Communicative Disorders and a master's in Communicative Disorders and Speech Pathology. She has six years of experience. Although she was to see STUDENTtwice per week in thirty-minute sessions pursuant to his IEP, because of scheduling problems, she has been working with him for a single one-hour session each week. Additionally, STUDENThas failed to attend several scheduled sessions. She testified that because of canceled appointments, she worked with STUDENTonly four times. (Testimony of Jill Pedersen) Petitioner objects to the District's offer as vague because it states that he is to receive two thirty-minute sessions of "group and individual" without specifying the mix. Petitioner argues that if the District provided one minute of individual services, and fifty-nine minutes of group services, the District would be in compliance. Jill Pedersen explained that the unspecific "group and individual" designation was necessary because, initially, she needed to get to know STUDENTto better to understand the appropriate mix. She was not sure whether STUDENTwould benefit from PECS, and needed, at least initially, to be flexible. As a result, all of the initial sessions were to be individual. She explained that, for instance, if STUDENTwas responding to PECS, and reached Phase Three, she would likely consult with STUDENT's family and increase the amount of group sessions. Both witnesses, Connie Stratton and Jill Pedersen, were qualified and presented as excellent witnesses. However, the Hearing Officer finds Connie Stratton's testimony to be more persuasive. Ms. Stratton has been working with STUDENTfor a substantial period - over one year - as compared to Jill Pedersen, who has only worked with STUDENTfour times. Given Ms. Stratton's testimony that, with a "collaborative" approach in conjunction with a language-based program, STUDENTonly requires two half-hour individual sessions of individual therapy each week, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENTdoes not require two one-hour sessions to benefit from his education. Accordingly, STUDENTwill receive two half-hour sessions of individual speech therapy in addition to one half-hour session of small-group (no more than three students, including STUDENT) a week for the 1999-2000 school year, unless the parties agree otherwise. b. Discrete Trial Training Petitioner sought thirty hours of DTT in his statement of issues, which, depending on the STUDENT's placement, would be either six hours per day at school, or three at school and three at home. (footnote 9) (Petitioner's Statement of Issues No. 3) The District agreed to provide DTT "in accordance with" the Applied Behavior Consultants, Inc. assessment conducted by Joyce Tu. (District's Exhibit No. 2) Ms. Tu recommended between thirty and thirty-five hours of DTT per week in her report. She testified at the hearing that STUDENTwas too young to receive more than four hours of DTT at school, and more than two to three at home. She also said that seven hours of DTT per day was inappropriate. Janice Taylor testified that STUDENTwould benefit from thirty hours of DTT. The Hearing Officer finds that, based on the weight of the evidence, STUDENTrequires thirty hours of DTT per week. No more than four hours of DTT each day shall be provided at school.ISSUE NO. 3 Was the District's offer of an extended school year program for the 1999-2000 school year legally sufficient? Petitioner argues that the District's offer of an extended school year program was inadequate. The April 2, 1999 IEP indicates only that Petitioner is entitled to extended school year. Janice Taylor, who drafted the IEP, testified that at the time of the IEP meeting, she did not know where STUDENTwould be educated, but that he would be eligible no matter where he was educated. Ms. Taylor stated that the District would convene an IEP team meeting to discuss available options after STUDENTentered into his placement. The Hearing Officer finds that the District's initial offer of an ESY was reasonable, under the circumstances. ORDER(1) Respondent shall provide either the Wilkerson preschool special day class, taught by Teresa Behnke, or the Mayflower preschool special day class, taught by Barbara Swisher, for the 1999-2000 school year.(2) Within 15 business days from the date of this decision, the Respondent shall convene an IEP team meeting to develop the following:A transition plan to facilitate STUDENT's transition from his current placement at Villa Esperanza to the Wilkerson school or the Mayflower school. (b) An appropriate behavioral plan, along with appropriate behavioral goals and objectives. This plan will provide that STUDENTwill receive 30 hours of Discreet Trial Training (DTT) each week (no less than three and no more than four hours of DTT each day shall be provided in STUDENT's school environment). In developing the behavioral plan, the IEP team shall give careful consideration to the recommendations contained in Joyce Tu's behavioral assessment. (c) A "sensory diet" to meet STUDENT's unique needs. In developing the "sensory diet," the IEP team shall consider the use of a net swing, a weighted vest, as well as other appropriate devices and methods.(3) Respondent will provide two half-hour sessions of individual speech therapy and one half-hour session of small-group speech therapy (no more than three students, including STUDENT) each week during the 1999-2000 school year, unless the parties agree otherwise.(4) Respondent shall select a full-time, one-on-one aide for STUDENTfor the 1999-2000 school year. The aid shall be trained in Discreet Trial Training prior to STUDENT's transition from Villa Esperanza to either the Wilkerson school or the Mayflower school. Because of STUDENT's unique safety needs, the one-on-one aide will be assigned only to him, and will not be used for other purposes.(5) Within 60 days from the date STUDENTenters either the Wilkerson school or the Mayflower school, Respondent shall convene a second IEP meeting. During this second meeting, the team will develop an appropriate extended school year (ESY) program that will adequately meet STUDENT's unique needs.PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:1. Has the District offered STUDENTa placement for the 1999-2000 school year which will enable him to a obtain a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment? -Respondent prevailed on this issue.2. Does STUDENTrequire the following support services to obtain minimal educational benefit: a. Two one-hour sessions of individual speech and language services and one hour of small-group services each week? -Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue. b. Discrete Trial Training? -Since there was essentially no disagreement on this issue, neither party prevailed.3. Was the District's offer of an extended school year program for the 1999-2000 school year legally sufficient? -Respondent prevailed on this issue.RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code 56505(j). DATED: August 26, 1999 _________________________ Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues listed here differ in numbering and content from those noticed by Petitioner at the hearing. Changes were made for the purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis, and to reflect the discussion held the first day of the hearing between the parties and the Hearing Officer with regard to the issues for hearing, as well as the testimony of the witnesses over both hearing days.2. The goals and objectives that were developed at the March 10, 1999 IEP are not at issue.3. Diane Howard testified about several types of devices and techniques which may be used to meet STUDENT's sensory needs. Several witnesses testified that, in STUDENT's current placement, devices such as a net swing and a weighted vest have proven successful. However, there was no testimony that a net swing and a weighted vest are the only items in an appropriate "sensory diet." The District offered to install a net swing at Wilkerson; however, Janice Taylor testified that she did not know whether such a device could be installed at Mayflower.4. Petitioner's counsel questioned several witnesses as to whether it would be appropriate for STUDENTto be in an environment where children are frequently entering and departing. No witness testified that Ms. Behnke's class has children frequently entering and departing. Ms. Behnke described a structured class where typically developing peers are invited into the class at scheduled times.5. The Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Howard did not visit either of the District's proposed placements. (Testimony of Diane Howard)6. Petitioner's counsel argues in her closing brief that, Ms. Behnke testified that if STUDENTwere assigned a one-to-one aide, the aide would be used in the classroom for other purposes. This is inaccurate. Ms. Behnke testified that if an aide were assigned to STUDENT, given that he is a "runner," the aide would not be used for other classroom purposes.7. The appropriateness of the related services will be dealt with under Issue Number 2, below.8. The District began providing speech and language services after March 31, 1999.9. In his closing brief, Petitioner now frames the issue as whether the District "must offer STUDENT the designated instructional service of Discreet Trial Training as proposed by Applied Behavior Consultants, Inc. Petitioner states in his closing brief that "to date the District has not set an IEP to implement the assessment or to commence services." Petitioner seeks to admit new evidence, the fact that the District has not convened an IEP since the last day of hearing. This new evidence is not admissible.
