California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 10, 2002
Student v. Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 541-02 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary
Livermore Valley Joint Unified correctly found a student with ADD ineligible and need not pay for three independent assessments.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District filed for due process to defend its assessments of a 13-year-old seventh grader. Two days later, the student's parents filed their own case. The student had been diagnosed with attention deficit disorder (ADD) and a tic disorder described as Tourette's syndrome. She attended general education classes and had a Section 504 plan in her prior district. After its fall 2001 assessment, the District found her not eligible for special education. The parents disagreed and paid for independent assessments from Lindamood-Bell, psychologist Dr. Clyde Burch, and Dr. Sandie Frawley.
The Hearing Officer found she did not qualify as other health impaired. Teachers and assessors saw no tics, and her ADD did not harm her performance; she earned good grades and stayed focused in class. She also did not qualify as having a specific learning disability. Dr. Burch's high IQ scores were invalid because the same test had been given only months earlier, and valid scores showed no severe discrepancy. Both of the parents' private evaluators recommended only classroom accommodations. The parents' procedural claims also failed. They never asked for an interpreter. The missing regular education teacher at the IEP meeting did not change the outcome. The District properly refused further assessment, and the meeting was delayed only at the parents' request. Because the District's assessments were appropriate, the Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for the independent assessments. No relief was ordered.
Why it matters
This case shows how SEHO handled eligibility for a student with ADD who was doing well in general education. A diagnosis alone was not enough. The parents' own evaluators recommended only accommodations, which weighed heavily. It also shows that repeating an IQ test within months can make the results unreliable.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education on the basis of her ADD or Tourette's Syndrome?
Neither ADD nor Tourette's syndrome limited the student's strength, vitality or alertness or harmed her educational performance, so she did not meet the other health impairment criteria. Valid test data showed no severe discrepancy, and any gap could be addressed in regular education, so she did not meet the specific learning disability criteria either. She is not eligible.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2a. Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to provide an interpreter at the IEP meetings?
The parents never asked for an interpreter, even though the meeting notice offered one. The mother communicated with the District in English and understood the process, so the District met its duty.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue 2b. Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to have one of STUDENT's teachers attend the IEP meeting?
No regular education teacher attended the November 20, 2001 IEP meeting. This may have been a procedural violation, but the evaluators had already gathered and considered teacher input, and the violation did not lead to a wrong eligibility decision. There was no denial of FAPE.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2c. Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to conduct additional assessments?
The reassessment-on-request rule in Education Code section 56381 applies to students who already have IEPs. The District's assessments were appropriate and properly evaluated the student's ADD, so refusing the parents' February 2002 request for more assessment was proper.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2d. Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to comply with the statutory time line for convening an IEP meeting?
The District scheduled the meeting for November 13, 2001, inside the 50-day deadline that ran to November 16. It was postponed to November 20 at the parents' request, so there was no violation.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of independent assessments?
Because the District's assessments were appropriate, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments by Lindamood-Bell, Dr. Burch and Dr. Frawley.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of the Student's claims were denied.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. No. 23; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist. No. 3; Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; Cal. Educ. Code § 56339; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030
People named in the decision
- Patrick Fitzpatrick, Director of student services and special education, Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District
- Karen Shackelford, General education math teacher, Junction Avenue Middle School
- Stacey McMillin, General education core subjects teacher, Junction Avenue Middle School
- Deborah Rogers, School psychologist (District assessor), Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District
- Sally Sutcliffe, Resource specialist (District assessor), Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District
- Victoria Scudder, Principal, Junction Avenue School
- Vivian Edmonds, Speech-language assessor, Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District
- Clyde Burch, Ph.D., Private psychologist, independent evaluator and expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Bob Burgoine, Jr., Private tutor and former teacher, witness for Student, Private
- Sandie Frawley, Ed.D., Licensed educational psychologist, independent evaluator, Private practice
- Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes, Private provider, independent evaluation, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes
- Jackie Wenzel, Educational advocate for Student (settlement discussions only)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Livermore, California, on August 6, 7, 22 and 23, 2002.
Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District (District) was represented at hearing by Dan Osher of the Lozano Smith law firm. Also present on behalf of Patrick Fitzpatrick, director of student services and special education. STUDENT was represented at the hearing on the morning of the first day for settlement discussions only by educational advocate Jackie Wenzel. At the conclusion of the settlement discussion, Ms. Wenzel withdrew. STUDENT was represented at the remainder of the hearing by her parents, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT.
The District called the following witness to testify at the hearing: Karen Shackelford and Stacey McMillin, STUDENT’s teachers last school year (2001-2002); Deborah Rogers, a District psychologist who conducted part of the District’s assessment of STUDENT; Sally Sutcliffe, a District resource specialist who conducted some of the assessment of STUDENT; and Victoria Scudder, principal at Junction Avenue School where STUDENT has attended since the beginning of the last school year.
Student called the following witnesses: Mr. and Ms. PARENT; Dr. Clyde Burch, a private psychologist who conducted an independent psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT; and Bob Burgoine, Jr., a former teacher and STUDENT’s current tutor.
The oral and documentary evidence was presented at the hearing. Closing arguments of the parties were heard, and the record was closed on August 23, 2002
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On the first day of hearing on August 6, 2002, after the parties discussed settlement outside the presence of the Hearing Officer, Ms. PARENT requested an Mandarin interpreter. No prior request had been made. As a Mandarin interpreter could not be arranged for that date, the hearing was continued for good cause to the following morning. Ms. PARENT had the services of a Mandarin interpreter available for the remainder of the hearing.
ISSUES
1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education on the basis of her ADD or Tourette’s Syndrome?
2. Did the District deny a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT by (a) Failing to provide an interpreter at the IEP meetings;
(b) Failing to have one of STUDENT’s teachers attend the IEP meeting; (c) Failing to conduct additional assessments; and/or (d) Failing to comply with the statutory time line for convening an IEP meeting?
3. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of independent assessments?
CONTENTIONS
STUDENT contends that she is eligible for special education under the category of “other health impaired”on the basis of her ADD and Tourette’s syndrome and that the District incorrectly determined otherwise. She alleges that she was denied a FAPE as a result of the District’s failure to comply with the procedural requirements that were intended to insure the full participation of her parents in the IEP process and the timely determination of her eligibility. Finally, she asserts that the assessments conducted by the District were inappropriate and that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessments by Clyde Burch, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes and Sandie Frawley.
The District denies all of STUDENT’s contentions and asserts that STUDENT was correctly found to be ineligible for special education based upon the results of its appropriate assessments and that the District did not violate STUDENT’s procedural protections in a manner that caused a loss of educational opportunity.
BACKGROUND
STUDENT is the thirteen-year-old daughter of Mr. And Ms. Parent. She lives with her parents and brother within the geographical boundaries of the Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District. According to STUDENT’s parents, she was born prematurely and was late reaching many of her developmental milestones. However, she has attended regular education classes since kindergarten and, with the exception of approximately seven months of speech therapy in 1993-1994 when STUDENT was four years old, she has never been found eligible for special education.
In 1998, while attending school in the Pleasanton School District, STUDENT was assessed at the request of her parents for speech and language needs and found to be ineligible for services. Student study teams regarding STUDENT were convened by that district at the request of her parents in 1998 and 1999, both apparently reaching the same conclusion: that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. The parents complained to the California Department of Education (CDE) that STUDENT was denied an assessment. An assessment was done as ordered by the CDE in October 1999.
The 1999 assessment by Pleasanton School District included administration of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III), selected subtests of the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale, Fourth Edition (SB-4), the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children (KABC), the Berry Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration, Fourth Edition (VMI-4) and other tools. The results of these assessments were presented at an IEP meeting in December 1999. The District members of the team found that STUDENT was not eligible for special education.
STUDENT’s parents remained concerned about her classroom performance in her fifth grade year in Pleasanton. In January 2000, STUDENT was diagnosed with attention deficit disorder (ADD). Her doctor prescribed Dexedrine. Some of her grades were poor that year, including some “D” quarter grades in math, history and science, an “F” quarter grade in history and a “D” final grade in math. However, she also received an “A” in language arts and fourth quarter “C” grades in history and science. STUDENT took the Stanford Achievement Test Series, Ninth Edition (Stanford-9) in April 2000. Almost all scores were average or above average.
STUDENT continued to have difficulty (“D” and “F” grades) with math throughout her sixth grade year in Pleasanton. She also received a “D+” grade for her last semester health class. However, she received passing or better grades in all other classes. The Stanford-9 results from April 2001 ranged from 33% to 81%. She scored 65% on the math problem solving test and 41% on the math procedures.
Although STUDENT was found by the Pleasanton School District to be ineligible for special education, she was offered a plan for accommodations to facilitate her learning experience in the fifth grade pursuant to Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. § 794). A similar “504 plan” was continued in the sixth grade.
STUDENT’s family moved from the Pleasanton to Livermore prior to the start of the 2001-2002 school year. On June 26, 2001, after the 2000-2001 school year for District schools concluded and before STUDENT was enrolled in the District, Ms. PARENT made a written request for a full assessment by the District. STUDENT began attending Junction Avenue Middle School (Junction Avenue) in the District on August 29, 2001. On September 10, 2001, the District convened a meeting to discuss a 504 plan for STUDENT’s seventh grade year. A 504 plan was proposed by the District, but no final agreement was reached. A special education assessment plan was given to the parents on September 18, 2001 and signed and returned by them to the District on September 27, 2001.
The assessment began on October 22, 2001, with the administration of the achievement portion of the evaluation by Ms. Sutcliffe. STUDENT’s scores on the Woodcock-Johnson III Tests of Achievement (WJ-III) were above 50% in all areas tested. She achieved superior math calculation scores, high-average math and written language scores, and average reading, reading comprehension and written expression scores. The report of this assessment states that these results were consistent with STUDENT’s grades for that quarter, an “A” in English, “A-” in math and social studies, and a “C+” in science.
The psychological evaluation by Deborah Rogers included administration of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, Third Edition (WISC-III) and the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (DT-VMI) on October 10, 17 and 24, 2001. Aside from a significant weakness in her knowledge of appropriate behaviors in social situations, Ms. Rogers stated that STUDENT’s scores in the average range indicated achievement commensurate with cognitive ability in all areas and no significant discrepancy. Her full scare IQ score on the WISC-III was 95.
The speech and language assessment was done in November 2001. In spite of some weaknesses in verbal analogies and synonyms/antonyms, STUDENT scored within the average range on all standardized tests. Her articulation, voice and fluency were also average for her age, and the assessor found that she had appropriate social language skills. STUDENT was found to be ineligible for speech and language services.
On October 30, 2001, the District sent a notice of an IEP meeting that was to take place on November 13, 2001. The meeting was rescheduled to November 20, 2001 at the request of STUDENT’s parents.
The District’s assessment data was reviewed at the IEP meeting on November 20, 2001. The District members of the team found that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. Her parents disagreed and did not sign the IEP.
On February 14, 2002, STUDENT was evaluated at her parents’ expense by Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes (Lindamood-Bell). The examiner administered approximately thirty tests. In some cases these were selected subtests, such as the spelling and arithmetic subtests of the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised 3. Of the twenty-four tests for which percentile rankings were reported, STUDENT scored within the average range (25% to 75%) on fifteen. She scored higher than 75% on seven tests. She scored below 25% on just one test: the Test of Problem Solving - Adolescent. Of those tests for which percentile ranking were not given, STUDENT scored within or above the average range on all except one, the recall portion of the Gray Oral Reading Test. The evaluator’s report concluded that STUDENT should receive 140 to 220 hours of Lindamood Bell services to develop and stabilize certain sensory-cognitive processes, after which she would be reevaluated for further treatment or follow-up.
On February 20, 2002, STUDENT’s parents asked the District to do an additional evaluation of their daughter. The District refused. Shortly thereafter, STUDENT’s parents also had her evaluated by Clyde Burch, Ph.D. on March 6, 2002. Dr. Burch administered the WISC-III, the same test that had been administered four to five months earlier by Ms. Rogers, and found STUDENT’s full scale IQ score to be 119, twenty-four points higher than as measured by Ms. Rogers. Her verbal IQ score was 115 and her performance IQ score was 119. Dr. Burch also administered parts of the WIAT-II. STUDENT achieved scores as follows:
Word Reading 97 Pseudoword (Phonic) Decoding 97 Reading Comprehension 91 Reading Composite 92 Listening Comprehension 90 Math Reasoning 99
Dr. Burch also administered Test of Visual-Motor Integration, on which STUDENT produced a score of 111, and the Goldman-Fristoe-Woodcock Test of Auditory Selective Attention, on which STUDENT produced a score below the first percentile. Although scores on some subtests demonstrated a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement, Dr. Burch did not specifically conclude in his report that STUDENT was eligible for special education and did not recommend that she receive such services. Rather, he recommended that STUDENT not be placed in special education. Instead, he recommended, among other things, frequent communication between the parents and the school, accommodations for STUDENT in the classroom, medical monitoring of the ADD, and participation in activities that would foster a positive self-image. He hoped that his recommendations could be adopted in the regular classroom as accommodations for STUDENT.
On March 11, 2002, the District filed for due process, seeking a determination that its assessments of STUDENT were appropriate. STUDENT filed for due process on March 13, 2002. Although STUDENT’s original request for hearing described a dispute concerning the alleged failure by the District to provide an appropriate Section 504 plan for accommodations, Mr. PARENT clarified the issues by letter dated March 24, 2002 that stated that STUDENT was seeking a determination that the District must reimburse the PARENTs for independent assessments and “accommodate the recommendations” of the professionals who performed those assessments.
Another IEP meeting was convened on April 16, 2002, at the request of the PARENTs. The reports of the independent evaluations by Dr. Burch and Lindamood-Bell were presented to the team. School staff summarized her grades and classroom performance. The District members of the team concluded again that STUDENT did not qualify for special education. The parents disagreed.
The most recent independent assessment of STUDENT was by Sandie Frawley, Ed.D., a licensed educational psychologist, on July 29 and 30, 2002. The SB-4 was administered, revealing academic potential in the above-average range with relative strengths in short term memory and relative weakness in verbal reasoning. The assessor recommended that consideration be given to a Section 504 plan if achievement was not commensurate with ability. The assessor makes no mention in her report of a need for special education.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Is STUDENT Eligible for Special Education on the Basis of Her ADD or Tourette’s Syndrome?
Under both State law and the federal IDEA, children with disabilities have the right to a free, appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “child with a disability” is a child with mental retardation, hearing impairments, speech or language impairments, visual impairments, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairments, or specific learning disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A). A student is eligible for special education and related services when, as a result of the student’s disability, the student requires instruction, services, or both, which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56502(a) and (b).
The Student argues that she is eligible because of her ADD and/or Tourette’s syndrome. The law clearly provides that a student with ADD is eligible for special education only if the student with ADD also meets the eligibility criteria for “other health impairment” (OHI), “serious emotional disturbance” (SED), or for “specific learning disability” (SLD). Cal. Educ. Code § 56339. Tourette’s syndrome is not specifically identified in the law as a qualifying disability. However, the Hearing Office has held that a student with Tourette’s syndrome can be eligible for special education if the condition qualifies as an OHI. Arguably, a student with Tourette’s syndrome could qualify for special education under the category SLD. Each of these categories will be considered.
OHI
A student meets the eligibility criteria for OHI when the student has a condition that is not temporary, causes limited strength, vitality, or alertness, and adversely affects the student’s educational performance. Cal. Code of Regs. tit. 5 § 3030(f).
There was some evidence that STUDENT has been diagnosed with Tourette’s syndrome. Her mother reported to Dr. Burch that STUDENT has had motor tics since she was one year old. Mr. PARENT stated in his testimony that STUDENT had Tourette’s syndrome. There was a reference to an actual diagnosis of Tourette’s syndrome is in a Kaiser Visit Verification form dated May 21, 2002, but no other information regarding the history of the symptoms or basis of the diagnosis was given. There is also a July 15, 2002 letter from a Kaiser physician stating that he had seen STUDENT for ADHD and a tic disorder but, again, the letter provides no details regarding how the syndrome was manifested in STUDENT’s day-to-day life.
There was no evidence that Tourette’s syndrome caused STUDENT to experience limited strength, vitality, or alertness. On the contrary, none of the witnesses who testified described actually witnessing an episode when STUDENT displayed a motor or vocal tic. The teachers, Karen Shackelford and Stacey McMillin, both of whom spent a substantial amount of time with STUDENT during the school day, and the various assessors, Ms. Rogers, Ms. Sutcliffe and Dr. Burch, all testified that they saw no evidence that STUDENT displayed tics. Dr. Burch stated that STUDENT told him that she was unaware that she had a tic disorder. According to STUDENT’s teachers, STUDENT performed well and within grade-level expectations during the 2001-2002 school year. Although she was somewhat shy and less inclined to speak up in class than other more outgoing students, she responded when called on and was focused and attentive. The Hearing officer was persuaded by the evidence that STUDENT’s Tourette’s syndrome did not cause limited strength, vitality, or alertness and that it did not adversely affect her educational performance. Therefore, STUDENT’s Tourette’s syndrome did not meet the requirements for OHI as a basis for special education eligibility.
The evidence also demonstrated that STUDENT’s ADD did not qualify her for special education under the category OHI. There were references in the records from Pleasanton district indicating that STUDENT had difficulty focusing, processing directions, and organizational skills, but that district found STUDENT to be ineligible for special education. Dr. Burch described STUDENT as becoming more fidgety and restless during the assessment and stated that she had a low level of frustration tolerance, an inability to selectively attend to auditory information and difficulty maintaining concentration without frequent encouragement and approval. However, Dr. Burch also said that he did not think STUDENT was eligible for special education.
Ms. Shackelford testified that she did not often have to redirect STUDENT or repeat directions for her during the last school year. Stacey McMillin testified that STUDENT was always focused and on-task. While she was aware of the ADD diagnosis, Ms. McMillin said that she never saw evidence of ADD in STUDENT’s behavior or performance in her class last school year. The results of the math, digit span, and freedom from distractability subtests administered by Dr. Burch were at least average. Ms. Rogers said that ADD would be most likely to affect performance on the digit span and math subtests of the WISC-III, but there was no evidence that it did affect STUDENT’s performance on those tests administered by her.
STUDENT’s parents were concerned that her homework was replete with errors. This was emphasized for them by Mr. Burgoine, who had been hired to tutor STUDENT. Knowing that her grades were poor while STUDENT was a student in the Pleasanton district, Mr. and Ms. PARENT were convinced that STUDENT’s teachers at Junction Avenue were artificially inflating her grades. There was no evidence that their suspicions were well-founded. Rather, the evidence showed that they were fueled by misinformation and misunderstanding. STUDENT’s parents and Mr. Burgoine did not understand the grading system for homework. Unfortunately, Mr. Burgoine focused on homework assignments. He saw none of STUDENT’s tests. He knew nothing about the teachers’ methodologies and knew little about grading policies. He did not talk to the teachers or to the school’s administration. Mr. Burgoine said that he knew nothing about what went on in STUDENT’s classes. He even questioned whether he saw enough of STUDENT’s work to draw a conclusion, explaining that he had asked STUDENT’s parents for more information but had not received it. He admitted that he really does not know what STUDENT’s academic situation is.
In summary, the evidence showed that neither Tourette’s syndrome nor ADD caused STUDENT to have limited strength, vitality or alertness that adversely affected her educational performance. Her test results, class performance and class deportment all indicated that neither STUDENT’s Tourettes’ syndrome nor her ADD had an adverse effect on her educational performance. STUDENT does not meet the criteria for OHI on the basis of her Tourette’s syndrome or ADD.
SLD
A student meets the eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability if he or she has a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in an imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26). California law states that the following three requirements must be met in order to satisfy eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability. First, there must be a severe discrepancy between the intellectual ability and achievement in oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, or mathematics reasoning. Second, the discrepancy must be due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages. Third, the discrepancy must not be correctable through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. Calif. Educ. Code § 56337.
The determination of whether a severe discrepancy exists is made by the IEP team, including assessment personnel, which bases its determination on all relevant material, and not on any single score, test or procedure. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4). When standardized tests are considered to be valid for the student, the severe discrepancy is established by reference to a comparison of ability test results with achievement test results. The test results are first converted into common standard scores with a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 15. Then the difference between the standard scores is computed. If the difference between the ability and achievement scores is equal to or greater than the product of 1.5 times the standard deviation, or 22.5, adjusted by one standard error of measurement (not to exceed four common standard points), a severe discrepancy is indicated when corroborated by other assessment data. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4)(A). If standardized tests do not reveal a severe discrepancy, the IEP team can still find that a severe discrepancy exists based on other information, including: (1) standardized test data; (2) information provided by the parents; (3) information provided by the teacher; (4) evidence of the student’s performance in class; (5) consideration of the student’s age; and (6) any other relevant information. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4)(C).
The WISC-III was administered at least three times to STUDENT in the last four years: by Pleasanton in October 1999; by the District in October 2001; and by Dr. Burch in March 2002. The scores were as follows:
Pleasanton Livermore Burch
Verbal 100 97 115 Performance 86 94 119 Full Scale 93 95 119
The verbal and full scale IQ scores from Pleasanton and the District are relatively consistent, within three and two points, respectively. The performance IQ scores from Pleasanton and the District are more divergent. More important, however, is the substantial difference between the scores obtained by the districts and those obtained by Dr. Burch. It was the opinion of Ms. Rogers that this significant increase was due to the “practice effect” that occurs when the same testing instrument is administered twice within a short period of time. Dr. Burch testified that he was not aware that the WISC-III had been administered just four to five months earlier by the District. He agreed that his results were suspect and guessed that STUDENT’s real IQ probably lay somewhere between the District’s numbers and his own.
Achievement tests were also administered on at least three occasions: by Pleasanton in October 1999 (WIAT); by the District in October 2001 (WJ-III); and by Dr. Burch in March, 2002 (WIAT-II). Because the categories of subtests administered are different, no simple comparison is possible. Generally, though, a comparison reveals that the results from the 1999 assessment by Pleasanton and the 2001 assessment by the District produced fairly consistent results, but the assessment by Dr. Burch in 2002 produced scores ten to fifteen points lower in Reading.
The Hearing Officer’s comparison of cognitive and achievement scores in this case supports the District’s position. The cognitive scores produced by Dr. Burch’s testing are invalid. The achievement scores produced by the District are consistently ten or more points higher that its IQ scores. The same kind of result occurred in Pleasanton in 1999, though the differences were less dramatic. A comparison of the WISC-III administered by the District in October 2001 with the WIAT-II administered by Dr. Burch in March 2002 produced the most consistent results, with a discrepancy from -5 (listening comprehension) to +4 (math reasoning). Only isolated comparisons of valid test results would support a finding of severe discrepancy. Even if a comparison of some of the cognitive scores with some of the achievement scores produces a severe discrepancy as defined in the regulations, that discrepancy must be corroborated by other assessment data. In this case, the instances of such coroboration are overwhelmed by instances of contradiction. None of the valid test data indicated that STUDENT is performing substantially below her ability. Teacher reports of classroom performance and achievement showed that STUDENT was doing well and progressing in regular education. What was most telling, however, was the fact that, aside from the parents’ belief that was based upon misinformation and misunderstandings of the facts and law, no person stated that they believed that STUDENT should be receiving special education. Even Dr. Burch and Dr. Frawley, both independent evaluators hired by STUDENT, suggested only accommodations in the regular classroom. Dr. Burch specifically testified that he did not believe that STUDENT qualified for special education and he would not recommend it for her. Considering the opinions of the professionals and the absence of any substantial evidence to the contrary, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s intellectual ability and her achievement.
Even if STUDENT’s standardized test results produced some evidence of a severe discrepancy, the Hearing Officer was not persuaded that the third element required for a finding of SLD had been established. No witness testified that the discrepancies, if any, could not be correctable through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. In fact, STUDENT’s own experts, Dr. Burch and Dr. Frawley, believed that accommodations in the classroom were what was required.
The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence was sufficient to support the finding that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. However, STUDENT has alleged procedural denials of FAPE by the District which, if proved, may affect the ultimate determination of eligibility by the Hearing Officer. Those procedural claims will be determined below.
Issue No. 2: Did the District deny a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT by (a) Failing to provide an interpreter at the IEP meetings;
(b) Failing to have one of STUDENT’s teachers attend the IEP meeting; (c) Failing to conduct additional assessments;and/or (d) Failing to comply with the statutory time line for convening an IEP meeting?
The IDEA reflects the desire of Congress to ensure that there are procedural protections afforded the student and parents which will allow for effective participation in the IEP process. The Court notes that parents can be the most ardent advocates for their children, and that their full participation can be the best way to ensure that all appropriate services are being offered to the handicapped child. Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of FAPE. A procedural flaw must result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process to result in the denial of a FAPE. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S., at 206-207; See also: W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484. The District has the burden of proving its compliance with the IDEA. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, (9th Cir. 1994) 35 F.3d 1396, 1398.
Failure to Provide an Interpreter
It is the District’s obligation to ensure that the parents understand what is said at the IEP meeting. That includes the obligation to arrange for an interpreter for parents whose native language is other than English. Calif. Educ. Code § 56341.5(h).
It was undisputed that the District knew that Ms. PARENT’s native language was Mandarin Chinese. However, prior to the first day of the due process hearing, there had never been a request for an interpreter. Ms. PARENT stated at the hearing that she did not know that she could request one, but the evidence convinces the Hearing Officer otherwise. Ms. PARENT communicated with the District in English, orally and in writing. The District’s notice of the IEP meeting allows the parents to request an interpreter, but STUDENT’s parents did not request one when they signed and returned the form to the District. There was nothing in the evidence to suggest that Ms. PARENT lacked a complete understanding of what happened at the meeting. Ms. PARENT did not testify to any specific misunderstanding. No other witness who was present at that meeting indicated that Ms. PARENT appeared to lack an understanding of what was said. The parents declined to agree with the determination that STUDENT was ineligible. The Hearing Officer was convinced by the evidence that Ms. PARENT has understood the entire process well. The District fulfilled its obligation to ensure that STUDENT’s parents understood what was said at the IEP meeting.
Failure to Have STUDENT’s Teacher Attend IEP Meeting
A meeting to develop, review or revise an IEP is required to be conducted by a team that includes one or both parents or their representative, at least one of the student’s regular education teachers if the student is to be participating in the regular education environment, at least one of the student’s special education teachers, a representative of the district, the persons who conducted assessments, and, when appropriate, the student. Calif. Educ. Code § 56341; 34 C.F.R. § 300.344.
The IEP team that met on November 20, 2001 did not include one of STUDENT’s regular teachers. However, for the reasons stated below, the Hearing Officer finds that the absence of the teacher was not a procedural denial of FAPE.
Both Calif. Educ. Code § 56341 and 34 C.F.R. § 300.344, upon which the State statute is based, require the participation of the regular education teacher at a meeting to plan for the education of a student with exceptional needs. The purpose of the requirement was essentially to ensure that the regular education teacher who would or might be responsible for assisting the child to access the regular curriculum was involved in the planning process. Appendix A to 34 C.F.R. Part 300; 64 Fed. Regis. 12582-12583. In this instance, it had been determined by the District’s assessments that STUDENT was not a child with exceptional needs eligible for special education. Input from her teachers had been obtained and considered by the evaluators. The testimony of these teachers supported the determination that STUDENT was not eligible. While the absence of the regular education teacher from the November 20, 2001 IEP may have been a procedural violation, it was clearly not one that resulted in an incorrect determination at that meeting that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. Therefore, the violation did not amount to a denial of a FAPE.
Failure to Conduct Additional Assessments
Calif. Educ. Code § 56381 provides, in part, that a reassessment of a pupil shall be conducted if the parents request a reassessment. Arguably, this language applies only to reassessments of students who have already been found eligible and have an existing IEP. The statute is in an article of the code that deals with reviews of IEPs. The specific statutory language is stated in the conjunctive, referring to a parent’s request to reassess and develop a new IEP. An interpretation of this statutory language in a way that would allow parents to request new assessments at any time would be illogical, impractical, and clearly not what the law intends. What the law intends in a situation such as that presented in this case is that the parent be allowed to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by a district. If a request for such an independent assessment is made, a district must either agree to pay for it, or it must file for a due process hearing requesting a determination that its assessment was appropriate. Calif. Educ. Code § 56329(b).
To be appropriate, the District’s assessment must have met the statutory requirements set forth in Calif. Educ. Code §§ 56320 et. seq., which provides, in pertinent part:
(a) Testing and assessment materials and procedures used for the purposes of assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs are selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. (b) Tests and other assessment materials meet all the following requirements: (1) Are provided and administered in the pupil's primary language or other mode of communication, unless the assessment plan indicates reasons why this provision and administration are not clearly feasible. (2) Have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. (3) Are administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and other assessment materials, except that individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning shall be administered by a credentialed school psychologist.
In addition, the tests and other assessment materials must have included “those tailored to assess specific areas of educational need;... [and] accurately reflect the pupil's aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the pupil's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purport[ed] to measure.” It must also be determined that no single procedure was used as the sole criterion for determining eligibility, and the student must have been assessed in all areas related to his or her suspected disabilities. Calif. Educ. Code § 56320 (c)- (f), inclusive. Finally, the assessments must have been performed by persons who were competent to perform them, as determined by the district. Calif. Educ. Code § 56322. A psychological assessment of a student by a District must have been conducted by a credentialed school psychologist. Calif. Educ. Code § 56324.
The assessments were described in detail by Ms. Rogers and Ms. Sutcliffe. The reports of these assessments and of the speech and language assessment were also in evidence. Counsel for the District established through this evidence that the testing and assessment materials and procedures were properly selected and administered and satisfied all of the elements for appropriate assessments. The only argument made by STUDENT was that the tests did not adequately evaluate STUDENT for the effects of her ADD. The Hearing Officer was satisfied from the testimony of Ms. Rogers that her assessment appropriately evaluated the nature and extent of STUDENT’s impairment by ADD.
Ms. Sutcliffe testified that on February 20, 2002, just three months after the District had determined through its assessments to deny eligibility to STUDENT, her parents requested that additional assessments be conducted. By then, STUDENT’s parents had already obtained an assessment by Lindamood-Bell. The District refused the request for an additional assessment. The refusal by the District to conduct additional assessments was proper under the circumstances and was not a procedural denial of FAPE
Failure to Comply with the Statutory Time Line for Convening an IEP Meeting
An IEP required as a result of an assessment must be completed within fifty days of the date of receipt of the parents’ written consent to the assessment. Calif. Educ. Code § 56344. The District received the signed consent on September 27, 2001. It had fifty days from that date, or until November 16, 2001 to convene the IEP meeting. The District scheduled the timely IEP meeting for November 13, 2001. It was postponed to after November 20, 2001, to accommodate STUDENT’s parents. There was no procedural violation.
In summary, there were no procedural defects that resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to the STUDENT or that seriously infringed on her parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Therefore, there was no procedural denial of a FAPE.
Issue No. 3: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of independent assessments?
As stated above, the Student’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessments obtained by them if they disagreed with the District’s assessments and it is determined here that the District’s assessments were not appropriate. Calif. Educ. Code § 56329(b). The Hearing Officer has determined that the District’s assessments were appropriate. Therefore, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments obtained by them from Lindamood-Bell, Dr. Burch and Sandie Frawley.
CONCLUSION
The District’ assessments of STUDENT were appropriate. An IEP meeting was properly convened, and STUDENT’s parents were allowed to fully participate in the IEP process. Based upon the District’s assessments, STUDENT was correctly determined to be ineligible for special education. STUDENT’s independent assessors agreed with that determination. There was no denial of a FAPE. No relief is warranted.
ORDER
All of the Student’s claims are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
The District prevailed on all issues.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code Section 56505(i).
Dated: September 10, 2002 Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Ms. Shakckelford taught mathematics. Ms. McMillin taught core subjects: social studies, language arts, and reading.
2. Ms. PARENT appeared to have an adequate command of the English language. She utilized the services of the interpreter sporadically throughout most of the hearing, at times choosing to question witnesses in English or to respond immediately in English to questions asked or statements made by others. Ms. PARENT waived the assistance of the interpreter for closing arguments.
3. The issues for the District have been consistently described as relating to the parents’ request for reimbursement for independent assessments and to eligibility. STUDENT’s parents have also consistently stated their request for reimbursement, but have described other issues at different times. Some have related to their request for appropriate accommodations pursuant to Section 504 or for attorney’s fees, issues over which the Hearing Office has no jurisdiction. The issues are not listed specifically as stated on the first day of hearing but have been reorganized for this Decision to facilitate analysis. They are all of the issues raised by the parties that are within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office to decide.
4. Dr. Burch testified that he administered less than half of the subtests from the WIAT-II.
5. Ms. PARENT stated that STUDENT contended that she was eligible because she met the criteria for SLD. However, the Hearing Officer also considered OHI criteria as a possible basis of eligibility. There was no claim, and no evidence, that STUDENT would meet the criteria for SED.
6. The broad reading, broad math, and broad written language scores were 106, 114, and 117, respectively. The math calculation score was 123.
7. Although he does recommend individual counseling to decrease anxiety and improve self-confidence, he testified that he did not view this as a District responsibility.
8. STUDENT’s parents had been involved in the IEP process for years before moving to the District. There had been prior IEP meetings, and they had received prior notifications of procedural safeguards. There was no evidence of prior requests for an interpreter.
9. The federal regulation speaks in terms of a “child with a disability.”
10. Vivian Edmonds did not testify regarding her speech and language assessment, but there is no genuine dispute regarding STUDENT’s eligibility on that basis.
