California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 10, 1997

Student v. Laguna Beach Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 56-97 · Hearing Officer Keltie Jones

Laguna Beach Unified need not pay for Lindamood-Bell assessment, therapy, counseling, or mileage; Hearing Officer denies all claims.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of an eight-year-old second grader filed against Laguna Beach Unified School District. She was eligible for special education under specific learning disability. She attended a general education class at Top of the World Elementary with one hour a day of resource (RSP) support, speech-language therapy, and vision therapy. In late 1996 the parents obtained a private Lindamood-Bell assessment and asked the District to fund intensive one-to-one Lindamood-Bell therapy. While the IEP team was still reviewing the request, they took her out of school and enrolled her in the program four hours a day. They sought $475 for the assessment, $16,092 for 298 hours of therapy, private psychiatric counseling, mileage, and 120 more therapy hours.

Hearing Officer Keltie Jones denied every claim. The District's assessments were appropriate. Credentialed staff gave them, they noted the student's medications, and the Lindamood-Bell co-director agreed that at least nine District tests measured auditory processing. By contrast, the Lindamood-Bell testers lacked credentials and used outdated tests and selected subtests. Applying Rowley, the Hearing Officer found the District's program met the student's needs, followed her IEP, and gave her educational benefit, as test gains and goal progress showed. Lindamood-Bell was a methodology the parents could not require. The parents never asked for counseling, and the evidence did not show she needed it to benefit from her education. The mileage and future-therapy claims failed with the main claims. No remedy was ordered.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley's educational-benefit standard to deny reimbursement for intensive private Lindamood-Bell therapy. Steady test gains and goal progress in the district program defeated the claim, and the Hearing Officer treated Lindamood-Bell as a methodology parents could not demand. Assessor credentials also weighed against reimbursing the private assessment.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the $475 assessment completed by Lindamood-Bell?

    The District's assessments were appropriate. Credentialed staff conducted them, they addressed auditory processing and noted the student's medications, so the private Lindamood-Bell assessment is not reimbursable.

  2. Issue 2. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement in the amount of $16,092 for 298 hours of remediation by Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes?

    Under Rowley, the District's program met the student's unique needs, conformed to her IEP, and provided educational benefit. Lindamood-Bell is a methodology the parents cannot compel, so no reimbursement is owed.

  3. Issue 3. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the psychiatric counseling provided by Robert Dobrin, M.D.?

    The District offered FAPE, and the parents never asked for counseling. The evidence also did not show counseling was necessary for the student to benefit from her education.

  4. Issue 4. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for transportation costs from their home to the Lindamood-Bell clinic and return, a total of 8,850 miles?

    The Lindamood-Bell program is not reimbursable, so travel to and from it is not reimbursable either.

  5. Issue 5. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for transportation costs to and from the office of Robert Dobrin, M.D.?

    The counseling is not reimbursable, so travel to and from it is not reimbursable either.

  6. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 6. Shall the student receive, at District expense, an additional 120 hours of Lindamood-Bell Learning Process to complete her therapeutic progress for weak concept imagery?

    The District provided an appropriate placement for 1996-97, so no compensatory or prospective Lindamood-Bell services are owed. The program was not necessary for the student to benefit from her education.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 7. Shall the parents be reimbursed for their transportation expenses incurred for the additional Lindamood-Bell therapy?

    No additional Lindamood-Bell services are owed, so the District need not pay transportation for them.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington; Lachman v. Illinois Board of Education; Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56320; Education Code § 56324(a)

People named in the decision

  • Virginia Russell, educational consultant for parents (witness for Student), Private consultant
  • Carol Hayes, coordinator/director of special education and school psychologist, Laguna Beach Unified School District
  • Robert White, District representative; SELPA director, South Orange County SELPA
  • Thomas Kampwirth, expert witness for District; professor of educational psychology, California State University, Long Beach
  • Robert Dobrin, private psychiatrist (witness for Student), Private practice, Laguna Hills
  • Patricia Lindamood, co-director and program developer (witness for Student), Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes
  • Nancy Bell, author of the Visualizing and Verbalizing program (not a witness), Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes
  • Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes, private provider of assessment and intensive one-to-one therapy, Private clinic
  • Gordon Weatherhead, clinical psychologist and family friend (witness for Student by telephone), Private (Ohio)
  • Sharon Maloney, principal, Top of the World Elementary School, Laguna Beach Unified School District
  • Deanna Lynne (Dee) Walker, resource specialist / special day class teacher, Top of the World Elementary School, Laguna Beach Unified School District
  • Mary Minerman, second grade general education teacher, Top of the World Elementary School, Laguna Beach Unified School District
  • Courtney Graham, first grade general education teacher, Top of the World Elementary School, Laguna Beach Unified School District
  • Suellen Heard, speech-language pathologist (assessor and therapist), Laguna Beach Unified School District
  • Mary Ghan, speech-language pathologist (assessor), Capistrano Unified School District
  • Annie Kumar, speech-language pathologist (assessor), Not stated
  • Cathy Pieper, school psychologist (assessor), District psychologist (district not specified)
  • Providence Speech and Hearing Center, private provider of central auditory processing evaluation, Private clinic
  • UC Irvine Child Development Center, private program for children with attention deficits and learning disabilities, University of California, Irvine

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 56-97 Case Year: 1997 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Assessment Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 30-66555 District: Laguna Beach Unified Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability

Case Details This matter was heard on May 20, 21, 22, and 23, 1997, in Laguna Beach, California, before Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Tania Whiteleather. STUDENT's parents, MOTHER and FATHER, and educational consultant Virginia Russell also appeared on behalf of Petitioner.

Respondent Laguna Beach Unified School District (District) was represented by Robert White, the director of the South Orange County SELPA. Also present on behalf of the District was Carol Hayes, the coordinator of special education and the District's school psychologist.

Oral and documentary testimony was received and the matter left open for the submission of closing arguments. Closing arguments were received, the record closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the $475 assessment completed by Lindamood- Bell?

2. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement in the amount of $16,092 for 298 hours of remediation of STUDENT by Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes?

3. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the psychiatric counseling provided by Robert Dobrin, M.D.?

4. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the transportation costs from their home in Laguna Beach to the Lindamood-Bell Clinic in Solano Beach and return, a total of 8,850 miles?

5. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the transportation costs from their home in Laguna Beach to the office of Robert Dobrin, M.D.?

6. Shall STUDENT receive, at District's expense, an additional 120 hours of Lindamood-Bell Learning Process to complete her therapeutic progress for weak concept imagery?

7. Shall STUDENT's parents be reimbursed for their transportation expenses incurred for the additional Lindamood-Bell therapy?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Prior to the hearing, the Petitioner submitted as part of the evidence packet copies of tapes of IEP meetings held on December 15, 1995, September 17, 1996, October 24, 1996, December 12, 1996, and January 16, 1997. At the hearing, Petitioner presented transcripts of all the tapes, except that of the meeting of September 17, 1996, and asked that the transcripts be admitted into evidence. The District objected because it had not had an opportunity to review the transcripts to verify that they were an accurate record of the tapes. The Hearing Officer ruled that the District would have five days to review the transcripts to verify their accuracy, and that any corrections could be discussed in a telephone conference before the transcripts were officially admitted into evidence. In the meantime, the parties could refer to the transcripts during the hearing. Any objections to the accuracy of the transcripts were to be sent to the Hearing Officer by the close of business on May 27, 1997. The Hearing Office did not receive any objections to the accuracy of the transcripts, so they were admitted into evidence on May 28, 1997. (Footnote 1.)

During his testimony for the District, Dr. Thomas Kampwirth referred to a page in the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test (LAC Test) manual. The page was copied for all parties and the Hearing Officer. After Dr. Kampwirth's testimony, the Petitioner moved to strike his testimony because he had referred to a document that was not in evidence. The Petitioner indicated that she would not object to the testimony if the entire manual were admitted into evidence. The District moved to admit the one page of the manual that Dr. Kampwirth referred to into evidence, indicating that the District did not have a copy of the entire manual that Dr. Kampwirth used his own copy and took it with him. The Petitioner objected to admitting only one page because it would be taken out of its context in the manual. Because Dr. Kampwirth referred to only one page, the Hearing Officer admitted that one page into evidence, noting that the fact that the page was taken out of context would be taken into account when it was considered. The Petitioner was invited to admit the entire LAC Test manual if she believed that it was necessary for the Hearing Officer to make a decision in this case. The Petitioner did not submit the manual.

Petitioner objected to the District's closing argument on the grounds that it exceeded the agreed- upon page limit of 15 pages and included charts of STUDENT's assessment scores that were not admitted into evidence. The District responded, pointing out that the written argument consisted of 13 pages and that the charts were provided to organize assessment results that were admitted into evidence. In preparing this decision, the Hearing Officer considered only the 13 pages of the District's closing argument; the charts of the STUDENT's assessment scores were not considered.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is an eight-year-old second-grader who has been diagnosed as having attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), obsessive compulsive disorder, and language development deficits. STUDENT is eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability. Her most recent IEP's describe her handicapping condition as "disorder in attention, visual-motor, language and pragmatics interfere with acquisition of math and independent accomplishment of instructional tasks." The placement the District offered STUDENT consists of regular classroom placement with one hour per day of pull-out for RSP class, vision therapy, and speech and language therapy. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was not currently attending school in the District. She had just completed intensive therapy at the Lindamood-Bell clinic and was enrolled in the UC Irvine Child Development Center (UCI CDC).

STUDENT has been in special education since preschool, when she was evaluated and identified as having a speech and language disability that adversely affected her educational performance. During the summer of 1994, STUDENT was placed in a special day class (SDC) for the communicatively handicapped (CH). She attended an SDC located at Crown Valley Elementary School within the Capistrano Unified School District because STUDENT's home district did not have a program to serve her needs.

During the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT attended kindergarten in CH SDC at George White Elementary School, again in the Capistrano District. During the summer of 1995, STUDENT attended summer school at Wood Canyon School, in a diagnostic class that included children with various learning disabilities. In the fall of 1995, STUDENT attended Marian Bergeson Elementary School in the Capistrano District. STUDENT spent part of her day in a regular education first grade class and part in a CH SDC.

In December 1995, STUDENT's parents requested an IEP meeting to discuss transferring STUDENT from the Capistrano District back to her home school, Top of the World Elementary School (TOW), in Laguna Beach. STUDENT's parents wanted STUDENT mainstreamed as much as possible and wanted STUDENT to have an opportunity to make friends who lived nearby. IEP meetings were held on November 8, 1995, December 11, 1995, and December 15, 1995, to discuss STUDENT's transition to TOW. Mary Ghan, a speech pathologist, and Dr. Carol Hayes, the District's school psychologist, assessed STUDENT in November and December 1995 to help with the placement decision. At the IEP meeting of December 11, 1995, STUDENT's eligibility identification was changed from speech and language disability to specific learning disability. Pet. Exh. Q. At that same meeting, STUDENT's parents requested a visual-perceptual skill assessment.

STUDENT started at TOW in January 1996. She was mainstreamed in Courtney Graham's first grade class, with a pull-out for one hour per day for RSP math with resource specialist Dee Walker. During the summer of 1996, STUDENT's parents enrolled her in the UCI CDC, which specializes in helping children with attention deficit disorders and learning disabilities. The UCI CDC program includes special classes for the parents to help them continue the program at home and in the child's regular school.

STUDENT moved into second grade with her classmates, and her program consisted of regular education with one hour per day of RSP class. On September 17, 1996, an IEP meeting was held to discuss the results of the visual-motor evaluation. At that meeting, vision therapy was added to STUDENT's special education program, and the IEP team recommended a speech and language evaluation and behavior observations in class as additional assessments. Pet. Exh. U.

On September 26, 1996, speech and language pathologist Suellen Heard conducted a speech and language assessment of STUDENT. Ms Heard concluded that STUDENT showed deficits in the areas of semantics, syntax, morphology and pragmatics, and made several recommendations for STUDENT's program. On October 24, 1996, Ms. Heard's report was presented and discussed at another IEP meeting. At that meeting, the IEP team added speech and language services to STUDENT's program. STUDENT was to have two thirty-minute speech therapy sessions with Ms. Heard per week. The team also reviewed STUDENT's progress and wrote the annual goals and objectives for both RSP and speech and language services. Pet. Exh. Y.

On November 22, 1996, MOTHER, requested an IEP meeting to discuss further assessment of STUDENT. On November 25, 1996, STUDENT's parents had STUDENT assessed at the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes clinic in Del Mar. The parents presented the results of that assessment at the IEP meeting held on December 12, 1996, and asked that the District pay for STUDENT to receive the program recommended in the Lindamood-Bell assessment. At the meeting, MOTHER, also expressed a great deal of concern over STUDENT's social interactions, indicating that STUDENT did not have any friends at school and that she was being teased and abused by her peers. The parents proposed that STUDENT be placed on home schooling while she was receiving the intensive therapy at Lindamood-Bell four hours per day. The team agreed to schedule another meeting in January to allow the District an opportunity to review the Lindamood-Bell report and recommendations. Pet. Exh. EE.

On January 5, 1997, STUDENT's parent informed the District that they had commenced the Lindamood- Bell program, and that, because of the intensive nature of the program, STUDENT would not be attending regular school until the therapy was completed. On January 13, 1997, just before the last IEP meeting, STUDENT began seeing Dr. Robert Dobrin, a psychiatrist, to help with her self-esteem problems. At the IEP meeting on January 16, 1997, the District members of the IEP team recommended continuing to work within the current IEP goals, objectives and services rather than funding the Lindamood-Bell program. The parents disagreed with that conclusion, and on January 17, 1997, they requested a due process hearing. During the mediation process, the parties agreed to have STUDENT assessed at the Providence Speech and Hearing Center, and the results of that assessment were discussed at an IEP meeting on March 11, 1997. STUDENT completed the Lindamood-Bell program in April 1997, and has been attending the UCI CDC program since then.

SUMMARY OF ASSESSMENTS

STUDENT has been formally assessed several times since 1994. In May 1994, speech and language pathologist Annie Kumar gave STUDENT the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals (CELF)- Preschool, the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test - Revised (PPVT-R), and the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test (EOWPVT). Resp. Exh. 104-106. Also in May 1994, District psychologist Cathy Pieper gave STUDENT the Weschler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence - Revised (WPPSI- R), the Beery Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration, and the Brigance Diagnostic Inventory of Early Development, and resource specialist Dee Walker gave her the Woodcock-Johnson - Revised tests (WJ-R). Resp. Exh. 98-101. The IEP of May 8, 1995, indicates that both the PPVT-R and the EOWPVT-R had been given to STUDENT recently. Pet. Exh. I.

In November and December 1995, speech pathologist Mary Ghan gave STUDENT the EOWPVT, the Test of Language Development-2-Primary (TOLD-2 P), the CELF-R, the Listening Test, and the Comprehensive Receptive and Expressive Vocabulary Test. Pet. Exh. O. Also in November and December 1995, District psychologist Carol Hayes gave STUDENT the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC-III), the Motor Free Visual Perceptual Test, the Bender Gestalt Design Copying Test, the Draw-A-Person test, the California Verbal Learning Test - Children's Version (CVLT), the Wide Range Achievement Test - Revised (WRAT-R), and the Woodcock-Johnson Scales of Independent Behavior. Pet. Exh. P. In November 1995, Dee Walker gave STUDENT the WJ-R test. Pet. Exh. Y.

In September 1996, speech and language pathologist Suellen Heard gave STUDENT the CELF-R and the PPVT-R. Pet. Exh. V. In October 1996, Dee Walker gave STUDENT the WJ-R test again. Pet. Exh. Y.

In November 1996, the Lindamood-Bell center gave STUDENT the PPVT-R, the Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude (DTLA) subtests on Verbal Absurdities and Visual Attention Span for Letters, the DTLA-2, the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test - Revised, the WRAT-R, the Gray Oral Reading Test (GORT), the GORT-R, and the LAC test. Pet. Exh. BB. In March 1997, Lindamood-Bell repeated the PPVT-R, the DTLA Verbal Absurdities, the DTLA-2, and the GORT-R. Dist. Exh. 45. Also in March 1997, the

Providence Speech and Hearing Center performed a central auditory processing evaluation on STUDENT. Pet. Exh. RR. In April 1997, Lindamood-Bell repeated all of the tests given in November 1996. Pet. Exh. AAA.

The following tables reflect STUDENT's scores on the tests that were given to her more than once before and during the time she was in attendance at TOW. (Footnote 2.) Where two scores are indicated, the first is the standard score and the second is the percentile.

CELF-R 5/94 11/95 9/96

Concepts and Directions 7 - 16% 5 - 5% Sentence Structure 8 - 25% 7 - 16% 6 - 9% Word Classes 6 - 9% 7 - 16% Word Structure 7 - 16% 14 - 91% 8 - 25% Formulated Sentences 8 - 25% 11 - 63% 4 - 2% Recalling Sentences 6 - 9% 8 - 25% 7 - 16%

Receptive Language Score 95 - 37% 80 75 - 5% Expressive Language Score 84 - 14% 106 78 - 7% Total Language Score 88 - 21% 92 5 - 5% Age Equivalent 4-2 5-2 5-4

PPVT-R 5/94 5/95 9/96 11/96 3/97 4/97

Score 76 - 5% 6% 73 - 4% 88 - 21% 16% 95- 37% Age Equiv. 3-9 4-5 6-10 6-10 7-9

EOWPVT 5/94 5/95 11/95

Score 6 - 7% 12% 93 - 32% Age Equiv. 3-6 4-5 6-4

Intelligence Scales (WPPSI-R, WISC-III) 5/94 11/95

Verbal IQ 82 87 Performance IQ 85 77 Full Scale IQ 81 - 10% 80

WJ-R 5/94 11/95 10/96 Broad Reading 110 - 75% 102 110 Broad Math 79 - 8% 87 89 Written Language 96 95

WRAT-R 11/95 11/96 4/97

Reading 93 105 - 63% 102 - 55% Spelling 93 103 - 58% 104 - 61% Math 75 72 - 3% 99 - 47%

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

Petitioner's Witnesses

MOTHER

MOTHER testified that she first noticed problems with STUDENT in preschool, when STUDENT was 4 ½ years old. When STUDENT turned five, MOTHER noticed that her language development seemed to be behind her peers, and STUDENT seemed isolated at her own birthday party. MOTHER described STUDENT's special education programs from kindergarten through second grade. (See Background Facts.) MOTHER testified that STUDENT was diagnosed with ADHD, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and minor depression in March 1995.

MOTHER stated that she and STUDENT's father asked for STUDENT to be transferred to TOW because they felt that STUDENT was not connecting to children in either the SDC or mainstream class at Marian Bergeson. They also wanted her to have an opportunity to make friends with children who lived in her area. MOTHER testified that she volunteered in all of STUDENT's classes. When STUDENT transferred to TOW, there was an instructional aide in the class for about 1 ½ hours per day, but the aide was in the class after lunch, during the least academic part of the day.

MOTHER testified that she became very concerned about STUDENT's social development in March 1996. STUDENT was not making friends at TOW, and the friend-making strategies recommended by the IEP team were not working. STUDENT did not seem to be problem solving on the playground, and was using the strategy of buying other children snacks so they would be her friends. When MOTHER observed on the playground, she noticed that the coach who was supposed to be keeping an eye on STUDENT was watching all 300 students and did not stay within earshot of STUDENT.

MOTHER stated that they put STUDENT in the UCI CDC summer program because they thought it could equip STUDENT with problem-solving techniques and provide behavior modification techniques that she and FATHER could use at home and school. The UCI CDC program included a parent training program. One technique used was a daily report card on four different target behaviors. The report card graded the child's performance on a scale of one to five for each of the behaviors three times a day. Good performance was rewarded at the end of the day. MOTHER testified that when she asked Mary Minerman, STUDENT's second grade teacher, to continue the report card, she refused. Ms. Minerman believed that she had appropriate behavior modification in place and was willing to report on only one behavior per day. MOTHER testified that Sharon Maloney, the TOW principal, told her to back off on insisting that more than one behavior be monitored because Ms. Minerman was not in a good emotional state for her to be pushing the issue.

MOTHER testified that she and STUDENT's father asked for a speech and language assessment in September 1996, because STUDENT was still having a hard time with conversation and had a limited vocabulary. She stated that she was saddened by the results of the assessment because it appeared to her that the tests showed STUDENT had regressed. MOTHER testified that Suellen Heard, the speech pathologist, told her that STUDENT could not perform at all on the formulated sentences test; STUDENT could not write any sentences using a given word. MOTHER said she was surprised by these results because she thought that STUDENT was improving.

MOTHER stated that although the IEP team added two half-hour sessions of speech and language therapy per week to STUDENT's program, she did not know whether STUDENT was getting that much time per week. She state that she believed that Ms. Minerman kept STUDENT in the class sometimes instead of sending her to the therapy sessions. At that time, Ms. Minerman and Ms. Walker thought that STUDENT should stay in the regular classroom for math so that she could observe her peers' problem- solving skills, but MOTHER testified that STUDENT did very poorly when she was mainstreamed for the subject. According to MOTHER, STUDENT was also doing very poorly in her language arts homework. MOTHER stated that she helped STUDENT a lot with her homework, so what the teacher saw did not reflect STUDENT's actual ability. In December, she stopped helping so much, and it became apparent that STUDENT could not do the work on her own. MOTHER stated that her expectations of the speech and language therapy were not being met.

MOTHER stated that she first heard of the Lindamood-Bell program in October 1996. She researched the program and took a workshop at one of the clinics. She state that STUDENT exhibits every one of the symptoms on a list of who would benefit from the Lindamood-Bell programs. Pet. Exh. BBB.

At the December 1996 IEP meeting, MOTHER described STUDENT's social problems, including an incident of sexual harassment that occurred on the bus. Ms. Maloney later spoke with the boy who harassed STUDENT. MOTHER had requested a functional behavior analysis in October 1995, but it was never performed. She requested that analysis because STUDENT was hitting other children and was not functioning well in class. MOTHER stated that she felt their concerns about STUDENT's behavior were never addressed in STUDENT's IEPs. According to MOTHER, the District did not suggest any alternatives to Lindamood-Bell and did not say that it was an inappropriate program for STUDENT. At the January 1997 meeting, the District did not suggest changes to STUDENT's program and did not offer any cognitive therapy. Neither did the District offer any counseling or an AB 3632 referral.

MOTHER stated that STUDENT had "moments" of happiness at school, but that she would not say that STUDENT grew at TOW. MOTHER testified that she did not believe that TOW was a hostile environment generally, but that it was hostile for a child with STUDENT's challenges because she could not communicate effectively with other children.

MOTHER testified that up to the January 1997 meeting, the District was generally cooperative and responded to their placement requests. MOTHER stated that although past IEP's addressed auditory memory, semantics pragmatics, and thought organization, auditory processing is broader than those factors and was never addressed. MOTHER asserted that the District never responded to the issues Mr. Weatherhead raised in the December 1995 IEP and never provided STUDENT with cognitive therapy. MOTHER testified that they were told that Dee Walker was trained in Lindamood-Bell programs, but that she never saw Ms. Walker using the auditory discrimination in depth (ADD) or verbalization and visualization (VV) programs when she visited her class. MOTHER also testified that at certain meetings, time seemed more important to the District members of the IEP team than adequately addressing and discussing the IEP goals. MOTHER testified that there was never a methodical review of STUDENT's goals and objectives at IEP meetings. However, MOTHER stated that STUDENT was making some educational progress and agreed that STUDENT's program was designed to allow her to make educational progress. According to MOTHER, the January 1997 meeting was not a team participation meeting. Ms. Hayes did most of the talking and it appeared that a decision on funding the Lindamood-Bell program had been made prior to the meeting.

MOTHER stated that, after January 1997, she received homework packets from the District about every three weeks, STUDENT's vision therapy continues, and the District continues to make speech and language therapy available. At the Lindamood-Bell center, STUDENT received both the ADD and the VV programs. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was put in the ADD program because of the results of the Providence tests; the VV program was recommended because of the results of the Lindamood-Bell assessment.

MOTHER stated that STUDENT has shown significant progress in writing and language abilities since starting at Lindamood-Bell. STUDENT can now write many sentences on the same topic and enjoys writing. STUDENT now does her homework on her own, including making up sentences using given words. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has completed the first phase of intensive therapy and is taking a hiatus, as recommended by the Lindamood-Bell staff. The Lindamood-Bell clinic recommends that STUDENT receive approximately 120 additional hours of therapy to stabilize her progress.

MOTHER testified that she believed an appropriate program for STUDENT would include someone to work one-to-one with STUDENT who has the type of skills the UCI staff have. She stated that she did not believe that STUDENT's social problems could be addressed until her processing problems were remediated.

FATHER

FATHER testified that he found the IEP process to be very frustrating. He believed that many of the concerns he and STUDENT's mother raised were not addressed. For example, they played a tape of a conversation with their friend Gordon Weatherhead at the December 1995 IEP, but many of the issues they raised on the tape were not addressed by the IEP team. Specifically, FATHER testified that he felt the issue of using an educational psychologist, as suggested by Mr. Weatherhead, was "finessed," and the team seemed focused on educating around STUDENT's processing problems instead of remediating them. He felt that Carol Hayes never filled in to provide educational psychologist services because of the demands on her time. The RSP program was presented as a way to get at STUDENT's processing problems, but they did not see that result. In addition, when they asked for social-emotional goals for STUDENT, the team suggested waiting until after STUDENT's started at TOW to set them, but the next IEP in March 1996 involved mostly vision therapy, not social-emotional issues. He felt that STUDENT's complexity was never really addressed. FATHER also testified that the District refused to implement the behavior modifications recommended by the UCI CDC summer program STUDENT attended between first and second grade.

FATHER stated that, although there was often a lot of anecdotal discussion of how STUDENT was doing, there was no presentation on how, precisely, she got there. FATHER testified that he did not think the IEP team had a global understanding of STUDENT's needs and disabilities. FATHER stated that he did not agree with the District's classifications of STUDENT's disability. According to FATHER, that disagreement first arose at the IEP meeting of March 17, 1997; up until then, the parents and agreed with the descriptions of STUDENT's disability on the IEPs.

FATHER testified that they asked the District to fund the Lindamood-Bell program because they believed that STUDENT's needs were not being met in the District. According to FATHER, the District never offered the Lindamood-Bell program to STUDENT and did not state that it was an inappropriate program for her. Although FATHER understood that the District would investigate the program between the December 1996 and the January 1997 meetings, he did not believe that they actually investigated the program. FATHER stated that he gave up on the district between the October 1996 IEP meeting and the end of 1996. By then, they felt that they had given the District as much time as they could and that STUDENT had no time to waste because of the effect her social difficulty was having on her self-esteem.

FATHER testified that, since starting the Lindamood-Bell program, STUDENT has demonstrated significant progress. STUDENT now engages her mother in conversations, and she appears to be more interested in her environment. Her sense of self seems better, and her writing and drawing have improved.

Dr. Robert Dobrin Dr. Robert Dobrin is a child and adult psychiatrist with a private practice in Laguna Hills. Dr. Dobrin began treating STUDENT on January 13, 1997, to evaluate her and provide advice regarding

STUDENT's medications and psychotherapy. Dr. Dobrin testified that he continued to see STUDENT through the date of the hearing. Dr. Dobrin confirmed STUDENT's previous diagnosis of ADHD and obsessive compulsive disorder and also diagnosed dysthymic disorder and depression. This diagnosis was based upon his work with STUDENT, interviews with her parents, and review of her evaluations by other professionals. Dr. Dobrin did give STUDENT the Child Depressive Inventory, although he testified that he did not follow the standard procedures in giving that test and interpreted it from his standpoint as a psychiatrist only. Dr. Dobrin testified that STUDENT's obsessive-compulsive disorder was diagnosed when she was a child, but that she demonstrated symptoms of it in his presence.

Dr. Dobrin testified that when he first saw STUDENT, she was still attending Top of the World, although she had, in fact, already started at Lindamood-Bell by that time. His conclusion, as stated in his report, that STUDENT was becoming more depressed and withdrawn as a result of her school environment was based on the history from the parents, not his own observations. His conclusion that the STUDENT had receptive problems was based on his personal observation of her inability to follow him in age-appropriate discussions.

Over his time working with STUDENT, Dr. Dobrin noted improved self-esteem. He testified that STUDENT is susceptible to regression in cognitive functioning when she sees the environment as being mean. Dr. Dobrin expressed the opinion that much of STUDENT's self-esteem and depression problems were due to the "hostile environment" at TOW. He expressed the opinion that TOW was a non- facilitating environment because it was not supporting STUDENT to be as good as she could be. He also stated that if STUDENT had stayed at TOW without any changes in her program, it would have resulted in psychological trauma. Dr. Dobrin did not visit TOW and did not speak with STUDENT's teachers there. Dr. Dobrin stated that he believed that the children at TOW did not interact properly with STUDENT and did not understand her problems and that student-teacher ratio did not address STUDENT's emotional and educational needs. It was his opinion that the District could not provide a proper environment for STUDENT. However, he did not provide a concrete description of the type of environment he insisted STUDENT needed. He stated only that STUDENT needed a program with a low ratio most of the time in which processing was the priority, but he testified that he is not an educational psychologist and is not qualified to design an educational program.

As part of his treatment of STUDENT, Dr. Dobrin prepared a report that summarized some of the evaluations STUDENT received since November 1995. Pet. Exh. DDD. Dr. Dobrin stated that his report did not include any test results that showed STUDENT as performing in the normal or average range. Dr. Dobrin testified that many of the tests STUDENT received were incomplete because they did not include an analysis of how the medications STUDENT was taking would influence the test results. He stated that the District had a duty to find out what mediations a child was taking and to take those medications into account when evaluating the child. Dr. Dobrin asserted that the first time the District considered information on STUDENT's medical therapy, her obsessive-compulsive disorder, and her ADHD was at the IEP meeting of March 11, 1997. (Footnote 3.) Dr. Dobrin stated that he interpreted the IEP's as identifying STUDENT as having a single learning disability. Dr. Dobrin testified that without taking STUDENT's medical status into account, the District could not provide an appropriate program. Dr. Dobrin further testified that the District did not have sufficient information about STUDENT to be able to develop an "integrated approach" that would be appropriate for her.

Dr. Dobrin testified that he provides medical services and bills either the client or an insurance company. He stated that he discussed with STUDENT's parents that she may have a right to receive free psychotherapy as part of her special education program. However, he also stated that he believed that STUDENT needed help immediately, that she could not afford to wait for the AB 3632 referral process. Dr. Dobrin recommended that STUDENT receive additional psychological counseling and continuing medication management.

Virginia Russell Ms. Virginia Russell is an education consultant employed by STUDENT's parents. In December 1996, Ms. Russell visited STUDENT's class at TOW with STUDENT's mother, MOTHER, for about three hours in the morning. While Ms. Russell was observing, MOTHER was volunteering in the class and helping other children. Ms. Russell testified that the class appeared to be supportive for children without processing problems, but not for STUDENT. Ms. Russell observed STUDENT reading in a small group of children. During the reading time, Ms. Russell testified, STUDENT fidgeted, talked to her neighbors, and bothered the others in the group. When STUDENT was asked a question about the reading, she could not answer it.

After reading, Ms. Russell and MOTHER observed STUDENT during recess. According to Ms. Russell, STUDENT did not interact with any other children. She stood in line for tetherball, but did not talk with any of the other children in line. At the end of recess, STUDENT asked her mother for money to buy another child a snack.

After recess, Ms. Russell observed the math lesson. STUDENT raised her hand to answer a question, but when she went up to the board, she did not know how to do the problem. STUDENT asked another child to come up to help her. Ms. Russell testified that this was the only time she observed STUDENT participating in class. She testified that STUDENT looked sad at school. Ms. Russell stated that although in the past she indicated that the TOW class would be fine for STUDENT after she finished at Lindamood-Bell, now she does not believe so.

Ms. Russell stated that she recommended the Lindamood-Bell program to STUDENT's parents, and that the Lindamood-Bell program could be considered a methodology or therapy. Ms. Russell testified that she attended the December 1996 and the January 1997 IEP meetings. Ms. Russell stated that at those meetings the District did not offer STUDENT the Lindamood-Bell program or any other auditory processing program. During those meetings, Ms. Russell stated that the Lindamood-Bell test results did not reveal anything new. Ms. Russell testified that although the results of the Lindamood-Bell tests were not surprising, they did provide guidance in setting up and implementing STUDENT's program.

Based on her review of all of STUDENT's IEP's, Ms. Russell testified that the District never identified STUDENT as having auditory processing problems and never provided a program to remediate those problems. Ms. Russell testified that she did not talk with the teacher of STUDENT's communicatively handicapped class about the programs used in that class.

Dr. Carol Hayes Dr. Hayes is the director of special education and the school psychologist for the District. Dr. Hayes participated in all of STUDENT's IEPs since December 1995. The goal of the December 1995 IEP meeting was to plan STUDENT's transition from the SDC at Marian Bergeson Elementary to a mainstream first-grade class at TOW. The parents had indicated a desire to have STUDENT mainstreamed in her home school, and the team was focusing on that type of placement at the parents' request.

Dr. Hayes testified that STUDENT's file contained information on STUDENT's medications. She never asked STUDENT's parents for a medical release to get STUDENT's medical records because she believed that STUDENT's parents were very educated about STUDENT's needs and would provide appropriate information.

Dr. Hayes testified that STUDENT's low scores on the digit span portion of the WISC test given in 1995 could indicate a problem with sequencing, but that a low score on a subtest could also indicate situational discomfort. Dr. Hayes also stated that STUDENT handled the auditory learning and memory portions of the CVLT given in 1995 within expectations, meaning that these scores on this test at STUDENT's age did not reveal an auditory processing problem. Dr. Hayes testified that the fifth percentile score on the story comprehension subtest of the Listening Test could indicate an auditory processing problem or inattention during the subtest. Dist. Exh. 85.

When asked if she had tested STUDENT for auditory processing problems, Dr. Hayes stated that the CVLT and the arithmetic and digit span subtests of the WISC tested for auditory skills. However, she stated that she did not test auditory processing in the same way the Providence Center did in March 1997 or the way a speech pathologist would.

Dr. Hayes testified that at the December 1995 meeting, STUDENT's parents played a tape of their telephone conversation with Gordon Weatherhead. The parents spoke with Mr. Weatherhead, a family friend and a psychologist, regarding STUDENT's program. The IEP team discussed the use of an educational psychologist, as suggested by Mr. Weatherhead, in the context of what tasks such a professional would perform. At that time, the team recommended the use of a graphic organizer, an instructional tool, to help STUDENT organize ideas. Dr. Hayes testified that use of graphic organizers in conjunction with instructional interaction could remediate visual or auditory processing problems.

Dr. Hayes testified that at the December 1995 meeting, the IEP team addressed STUDENT's social interaction issues by including goals that involved establishing friendly relationships. The team also discussed the use of personnel on the playground, referred to as coaches. Dr. Hayes testified that a particular coach is assigned to keep an eye out for problems with particular students, and that the team discussed asking a coach to keep an eye on STUDENT. She testified that at that point the team was not familiar with STUDENT because she had not yet started at TOW; therefore, the social goals were not yet well-defined.

Dr. Hayes testified that she did not believe that the District performed a functional behavioral assessment on STUDENT. She stated that such an assessment is performed when a child has exhibited extreme behavior that requires a behavior management plan. Dr. Hayes testified that STUDENT's teachers indicated that STUDENT behaved well in class.

Dr. Hayes stated that STUDENT was evaluated by two speech pathologists: Mary Ghan with the Capistrano Unified School District and Suellen Heard with the District. According to Dr. Hayes, Ms. Ghan concluded that STUDENT's biggest problems were comprehension and following directions.

Dr. Hayes testified that, when STUDENT started at TOW in January 1996, there was an additional aide in her mainstream class to help with her transition for about the first month. STUDENT's program at TOW consisted of mainstreaming with approximately one hour per day of pull-out for RSP classes with Dee Walker.

Patricia Lindamood Patricia Lindamood is a speech and language pathologist, the co-director of Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes, and the primary developer of the Lindamood-Bell ADD program. Her colleague Nancy Bell was the primary author of the VV program. Ms. Lindamood's duties include research and clinical operations for the Lindamood-Bell centers.

According to Ms. Lindamood, about thirty percent of the population has central processing problems. A central processing problem exists when a person has no trouble hearing what is said, but has problems organizing or processing what is heard. Therefore, before a person is qualified to be a Lindamood-Bell clinician, it must be determined that the person does not have processing problems. Clinicians must also undergo approximately 80 hours of training. Clinicians are not required to have speech and language pathology or psychology training. The Lindamood-Bell programs use a Socratic questioning method.

Ms. Lindamood reviewed STUDENT's test results from the Lindamood-Bell center and performed the item analysis on those tests. The item analysis consisted of reviewing the test responses and determining when a basal (a certain number of correct responses in a row) had been established and when a ceiling (a certain number of incorrect responses in a row) has been reached. Ms. Lindamood stated that the tests were given to STUDENT by a Lindamood-Bell clinician who was not a credentialed speech and language specialist and who did not have a certificate of clinical compliance. Ms. Lindamood also stated that the people doing the testing at the clinics usually recognize attention deficit disorder symptoms and address them in the report if they appeared to affect the testing. She did state that attention is a factor in the DTLA-2 oral directions subtest and that she did not know how to determine if attention problems were affecting STUDENT's scores on that test.

Ms. Lindamood testified that STUDENT's scores were rather unusual in that she had high scores in word attack, reading and spelling, but had very low comprehension scores. Ms. Lindamood stated that she believed that STUDENT's scores indicated that she probably has a very high IQ and the potential to perform above average if her processing problems are remediated. Ms. Lindamood opined that STUDENT's processing problems could affect her socially because her peers would see her as being "dumb." Ms. Lindamood also testified that the ADD program would address the problems identified in recommendation number six of the Providence report. (Footnote 4.) Dist. Exh. 46-48.

Ms. Lindamood testified that the LAC test, which she developed, measures a person's ability to use colored blocks to indicate when sounds are the same and different. She stated that STUDENT demonstrated an ability to differentiate the sounds only when they were isolated, not when they were put into syllables or words. She indicated that STUDENT's score on the LAC test was low for her age and grade level. Ms. Lindamood stated that she is familiar with Dr. Thomas Kampwirth's criticism of the LAC test as setting very high recommended scores for grades K-2. Ms. Lindamood asserted that Dr. Kampwirth was overlooking the section of the manual explaining that the recommended scores were higher than would be suggested by the norming data because in grades K-2 auditory and visual memory play a role in the results. Ms. Lindamood further testified that she never relies solely on the LAC test to identify auditory discrimination problems. Ms. Lindamood, in reference to various tests, indicated that she considers the normal range of scores to be between the 37th and 63rd percentile, which she admitted is a more narrow definition of normal than others use. Ms. Lindamood agreed that the following standardized tests measure auditory processing: CELF-R, CELF-3, PPVT, EOWPVT, WPPSI, Brigance Inventory, WISC-III, Comprehensive Expressive and Receptive Vocabulary Test, TOLD, CVLT.

Ms. Lindamood testified that the intensive program, one-to-one therapy for four hours per day, was preferable for STUDENT to get her auditory processing on the right track. Ms. Lindamood indicated that during the intensive treatment program, STUDENT had little or no access to nondisabled peers, and that the treatment did not involve any core curriculum content. Ms. Lindamood testified that after about 240 hours of both the ADD and VV programs, STUDENT showed significant improvement on the tests the Lindamood- Bell clinic gave her. Ms. Lindamood dismissed concerns that STUDENT may have demonstrated a practice effect from having taken the tests in quick succession, asserting that there is professional disagreement over whether there is indeed a practice effect. However, according to Ms. Lindamood, additional hours are necessary to stabilize STUDENT's results. Ms. Lindamood stated that the goal of the Lindamood-Bell programs is to teach children how to direct their brains so that they can succeed.

Gordon Weatherhead Mr. Weatherhead is a clinical psychologist in Ohio, and a friend of STUDENT's parents, who testified by telephone. Ms. Weatherhead knows STUDENT and has discussed her problems with her parents. He testified that he thought that STUDENT needed cognitive therapy to work on her central processing problems. Ms. Weatherhead's diagnosis of processing problems was based on his personal knowledge of STUDENT, indicators in her WPPSI scores, and conversations with her parents. He described cognitive therapy as a program that gets an individual to use her environment and be aware of her relationship to her environment. It is the teaching of logical thinking skills, working from the concrete to the abstract and focusing on perceptual and spatial organization. It involves using games, exercises, and memory skill development to determine at what point the student loses track. He stated that this therapy could be provided in a school setting, but that it should be in a very structured environment to reduce STUDENT's anxiety, not a mainstream environment. He recommended two hours of cognitive therapy per day, one in the morning and one in the afternoon. Mr. Weatherhead testified that an SDC for CH students with a special education teacher with a speech and language credential could be appropriate for STUDENT if it addressed her specific needs. Mr. Weatherhead said that he reviewed the Lindamood-Bell tests and was impressed with the results.

District's Witnesses

Dr. Thomas Kampwirth Dr. Kampwirth is a professor in educational psychology at CSU Long Beach. He teaches courses on psychoeducational assessments and also performs such assessments on adults for Saddleback Community College. Dr. Kampwirth stated that he is familiar with the LAC test and has a number of concerns about that test. Specifically, he testified that the test is not well normed or standardized and has very little reliability data. In addition, there is very little evidence to substantiate that the test measures what it purports to measure because it provides no real definition of auditory conceptualization. Moreover, the scoring sheets refer to recommended minimum scores, and there is a discrepancy between the recommended minimum scores and the norm tables provided in the manual.

Dr. Kampwirth also testified that most standardized tests consider the normal range to be from the 16th percentile to the 84th percentile. Dr. Kampwirth stated that it is not appropriate to use an older version of a test once a revised version is available; results obtained using an outdated test would be unreliable.

Sharon Maloney Ms. Maloney is the principal of Top of the World Elementary School. She described the atmosphere at TOW as warm. Ms. Maloney stated that she had a lot of involvement with STUDENT, and that they only time she saw STUDENT not smiling was when they were discussing the sexual harassment incident. She testified that she dealt with the incident by bringing the boy who had harassed STUDENT into the office to discuss it and having him apologize to STUDENT. She testified that she saw STUDENT as a happy, successful child, and she was being told by her parents that STUDENT was happy. It was not until the end of STUDENT's time at TOW the STUDENT's parents told her STUDENT was unhappy.

Ms. Maloney stated that she attended most of STUDENT's IEP meetings. According to Ms. Maloney, any disputes that arose over STUDENT's program were resolved at the IEP meetings, except for the last dispute over Lindamood-Bell. She recalled Dr. Hayes discussing getting the TOW staff trained in Lindamood-Bell programs. She was surprised by the suddenness of STUDENT's removal from TOW because she thought they would discuss the program further at the January meeting.

She believed that the District was providing a program that educationally benefitted STUDENT, and that was individually designed to help STUDENT progress to third grade. She felt the IEP team was constantly adjusting STUDENT's program at the parents' request. She remembered discussing STUDENT's social-emotional needs, but could not recall if they were addressed in IEP goals. According to Ms. Maloney, the teachers believed that a lot of what STUDENT was experiencing socially was normal for second grade. With respect to the issue of the daily report card, she stated that she spoke with the UCI director, and he said that it was not necessary for the report to be exactly in the same format used at UCI. She did not recall telling MOTHER that Ms. Minerman's emotional health was a problem.

Deanna Lynne Walker Ms. Walker teaches an SDC at TOW, and also teaches the RSP students. She is a credentialed special education teacher and also has resource specialist and speech and hearing credentials. She has been

STUDENT's RSP teacher since STUDENT arrived at TOW. Ms. Walker testified that one of the areas of deficit that had been identified for STUDENT was pragmatics, which is the social intent of language and includes auditory processing. The services that Ms. Walker provided for STUDENT that addressed auditory processing included having STUDENT work on story problems, create images for problems, draw pictures in the math journal, and do sequential work like creating story maps. Ms. Walker indicated that she frequently used graphic organizers with STUDENT, which students use to create visual depictions to organize information. Ms. Walker testified that she used a multisensory approach with STUDENT. Ms. Walker testified that she used approaches from the Lindamood-Bell ADD program, as well as other programs like Slingerland.

Ms. Walker testified that she observed the ADD and VV programs at the Lindamood-Bell clinic. According to Ms. Walker, the ADD program focused on encoding and decoding skills and was very phonemic. The VV program consisted of the clinician reading a passage to the student and then asking the student to visualize the passage. Then the clinician asked the student questions to draw out a complete description from the child. This was all done orally; the student did not read or write anything. Ms. Walker stated that she used similar approaches with STUDENT, but that she used a more multisensory approach rather than just an oral approach. Ms. Walker testified that although MOTHER visited her class several times, she did not observe a full instruction period.

Ms. Walker testified that she thought that STUDENT's transition to TOW went well and that STUDENT was making progress. Ms. Walker stated that when there is more than one IEP meeting in a year, all of the goals are not reviewed and rewritten. When new goals are added, the previous goals are continued until the time comes for the annual review. Ms. Walker testified that STUDENT's goals were reviewed orally at the annual IEP on October 24, 1996, and that she made notations of the progress discussed on her copies of the IEP's. Dist. Exh. 138-39. Ms. Walker testified that STUDENT was making progress in pragmatics, the social aspects of language. She had observed improvement in STUDENT's ability to meet people and interact appropriately on entering class One area she worked on with STUDENT was her tendency to exaggerate when telling a story. Ms. Walker stated that STUDENT was also making progress in her handwriting as evidenced by her daily work samples. Ms. Walker also testified that STUDENT had mastered math facts to ten by June 1996. By October 1996, STUDENT had completed about half of her math goals.

Ms. Walker testified that STUDENT's program was designed to enable her to progress to third grade; it was an appropriate program in the least restrictive environment. Ms. Walker stated that she did not see STUDENT as a depressed child, that she did not believe that STUDENT's social problems were extreme or that STUDENT was in an emotional crises. She stated that STUDENT's being alone on the playground may indicate a need to have some down time when she did not have to communicate too much rather than a sign of depression. Ms. Walker testified that her time with STUDENT during her last two weeks at TOW was often cut short because STUDENT wanted to spend time in her regular classroom working on holiday projects. Ms. Walker stated that STUDENT actively participated in all events.

Ms. Walker recalled suggesting that she increase her level of services to STUDENT when STUDENT's parents raised concerns about STUDENT's progress in October 1996, but the parents wanted full inclusion. She stated that she was surprised when the parents proposed a much more restrictive program in December 1996. Ms. Walker testified that she had been using a cognitive approach with STUDENT in all of their sessions, including the Thinking Skills and Slingerland approaches. She stated that the multisensory approach she used would tap into strengths while remediating weaknesses.

Mary Minerman Ms. Minerman was STUDENT's second grad regular education teacher. She testified that STUDENT was an excellent decoder but had problems with comprehension when she read. Ms. Minerman stated that STUDENT was making progress on sequencing and identifying the beginning, middle and end of a story. STUDENT was generally very focused, and was easy to get back on task when she got distracted. STUDENT was doing okay with addition and subtraction, but was having problems with money facts and telling time. Ms. Minerman testified that she intended to concentrate on these areas more in January. Ms. Minerman stated that STUDENT was making progress under the program identified in the IEP's and that she expected her to advance to third grade with her peers.

Ms. Minerman testified that STUDENT usually seemed happy, but she had up and down days. She did not appear to be depressed. According to Ms. Minerman, STUDENT had one close friend in the class, but her social interactions were not always appropriate. She stated that she understood that Suellen Heard, the speech and language therapist, was working on those problems. Ms. Minerman testified that she did not see STUDENT as being in crisis in December.

Ms. Minerman testified that she is trained to teach children with limited English proficiency, and that she uses many of the visual techniques from that training with her class. These techniques appeared to help STUDENT's comprehension. She stated that the day Ms. Russell observed was a bad day for STUDENT; it was not indicative of STUDENT's usual behavior and participation in class. According to Ms. Minerman, STUDENT often raised her hand in class and often had the right answers. Ms. Minerman stated that she also uses graphic organizers as a teaching tool.

Dr. Carol Hayes Dr. Hayes testified that a functional behavioral analysis is used for children whose behavior is a disruption or threat to the campus. None of STUDENT's teachers reported that type of behavior from STUDENT so the team did not recommend that such an analysis be performed. Dr. Hayes testified that STUDENT's scores over the years demonstrate that she was making progress.

Dr. Hayes stated that she thought they would be discussing the Lindamood-Bell program in more detail at the January 1997 meeting, as well as the problems the parents thought the program could solve. She stated that the parents had not heard about what the TOW campus could offer to address those problems. When the meeting occurred, Dr. Hayes thought the point was moot because the parents unilaterally decided to place STUDENT at Lindamood-Bell. She thought that the parents wanted to discuss only whether or not the District would pay for the program or not.

Dr. Hayes testified that she did not think STUDENT needed the Lindamood-Bell program to benefit from her education. Dr. Hayes also testified that STUDENT's stated progress since beginning the Lindamood-Bell program could be a manifestation of the skills she had been learning at TOW, particularly with respect to the writing sample STUDENT produced just two weeks after she started the program. Pet. Exh. III. Dr. Hayes also speculated that the progress could be a result of the significant increase in one-to-one attention STUDENT received, or the Hawthorne effect, in which significant improvements in performance can be observed when more attention is paid to an individual.

DISCUSSION

ISSUE #1: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the $475 assessment completed by Lindamood-Bell?

California Education Code § 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation.

For the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which include that tests be administered in a nondiscriminatory manner by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions, validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, and tailored to assess specific areas of educational need. Section 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. No single procedure can be used as the sole criterion for determining the appropriate program. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists. Educ. Code § 56324(a).

Petitioner is not asserting that the District's assessments were discriminatory, nor that only one procedure was used to determine the appropriate program. Petitioner argues that the District's assessments of STUDENT were inappropriate because they did not assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. Specifically, Petitioner asserts that the District's assessments never tested STUDENT for auditory processing problems. (Testimony of Virginia Russell.) Dr. Dobrin also testified that he believed the assessments were inadequate because they did not take into account STUDENT's medical status. Both of these assertions are contradicted by documentary evidence and testimony of the Petitioner's own witnesses. In December 1995, both Mary Ghan and Dr. Hayes documented STUDENT's medical background and medications in their speech and language and psychoeducational assessments reports. Pet. Exh. O & P. In addition, Ms Patricia Lindamood testified that at least nine of the tests the District had given STUDENT measured auditory processing. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioner's assertion that the District's assessments of STUDENT did not comply with the statutory requirement to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability is not substantiated.

Not only are Petitioner's stated reasons for objecting to the District's assessments not supported by the evidence, but the District presented substantial evidence of the appropriateness of the assessments pursuant to the other statutory criteria. The District established that the individuals conducting the various assessments were properly trained to do so. The speech and language evaluations were performed by Mary Ghan and Suellen Heard, speech pathologists, and the psychological assessments were performed by Dr. Hayes, a credentialed school psychologist. In contrast, the assessments at the Lindamood-Bell clinic were performed by individuals who did not have the appropriate training and credentials, and did not appear to be given in conformance with the testing instructions (e.g., using outdated tests, using only selected subtests). (Testimony of Patricia Lindamood & Dr. Kampwirth.) The District provided a number of assessments at the parents' request, including visual-motor and speech and language assessments. (Footnote 5.)

The Hearing Officer finds that the District's assessments of STUDENT were appropriate and, therefore, STUDENT's parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the assessment completed by Lindamood-Bell.

ISSUE #2: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement in the amount of $16,092 for 298 hours of remediation of STUDENT by Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). California Education Code §§ 56000 et seq.; Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. §§ 1400 et seq. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child ..." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the µbasic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." 458 U.S. 175, 200.

In School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 105 S.Ct. 2003, the United States Supreme Court determined that when the proposed public school placement is inappropriate, parents of a student eligible for special education may be entitled to reimbursement for expenses that they incur in educating their child. Therefore, it must first be determined that the placement offered by the District was inappropriate before it can be found that STUDENT's parents are entitled to reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell program.

Taken together, the IDEA and the Rowley court's interpretation of the IDEA provide the following three factors for analyzing whether the District's placement was appropriate for STUDENT:

1. whether the District's placement is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs; 2. whether the District's placement conforms to STUDENT's IEP; and 3. whether the District's placement is designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.

1. Was the District's placement designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs?

To determine whether the District's placement was designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, those needs must be identified. The parties appeared to agree that STUDENT had very complex learning problems, including a diagnosis of ADD, visual-motor integration problems, and speech and language problems, including comprehension problems, limited vocabulary, and difficulties communicating with peers. STUDENT's parents asserted that her auditory processing problems and her social-emotional difficulties were not being met.

STUDENT's handicapping condition was described on her IEP's as "disorder in attention, visual- motor, language and pragmatics interfere with acquisition of math and independent accomplishment of instructional tasks." STUDENT's parents agreed with this description until March 11, 1997, when Ms. Russell indicated on the IEP that the parents disagreed with the description, without stating an alternative description or what part of the description they disagreed with. Pet. Exh. SS. Although this description does not use the term "auditory processing," which was one of the areas that the parents believe was not addressed, it does refer to disorders in language and pragmatics. Ms. Lindamood defined auditory processing as the ability to receive auditory input, think about it, and respond to indicate understanding. It appears that "disorders in language and pragmatics" that interfere with "independent accomplishment of instructional tasks" could encompass an auditory processing disorder. Therefore, the fact that the term "auditory processing" was not included in the description of her disability does not mean that the placement was not designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs. Rather, we must look beyond the description of her disability to the services the District was providing.

The program the District offered STUDENT included one hour of RSP class per day, two half-hour speech and language therapy sessions per week, and vision therapy. STUDENT's IEPs included goals for language development, math skills, problem solving skills, and social skills (pragmatics).

STUDENT's RSP sessions with Ms. Walker focused on math, language, and processing skills. In about October 1996, STUDENT began doing math in her regular classroom and spent more time with Ms. Walker on language arts. Ms. Walker testified that, even when working on math, she used many different techniques to help STUDENT with processing information, including a multisensory teaching approach, graphic organizers, and Socratic questioning. Ms. Walker also worked with STUDENT on pragmatics, or the social aspects of language.

There was no testimony on the content of STUDENT's speech and language therapy sessions. However, Suellen Heard stated at the IEP meeting of October 24, 1996, that she would be focusing on STUDENTS's difficulties with understanding and interpreting oral requests, sentence formulation, and pragmatics. There was no evidence that the sessions did not address those needs. The goals written for the October 1996 IEP also reflected those areas. There was no dispute over whether STUDENT's vision therapy was addressing her visual-motor needs.

STUDENT's parents raised many concerns that STUDENT's social-emotional needs were not being met by the District's placement. The evidence did not support this assertion. All of the troubling social incidents that the parents described at the hearing and in the IEP meetings took place away from the school (on the bus, in her neighborhood, and at a slumber party). December 1996 IEP, January 1997 IEP. The one incident that had a connection to school, the harassment on the bus, was addressed by Ms. Maloney as soon as she knew about it. Although Dr. Dobrin testified that he thought the school was a hostile environment for STUDENT, he also testified that he believed that she was attending TOW when he started treating her on January 13, 1997, and that her continued attendance at school was causing her depression. In fact, STUDENT had not been to TOW for almost a month when she began seeing Dr. Dobrin, and had been enrolled in the Lindamood-Bell program for about a week. Dr. Dobrin's misunderstanding of STUDENT's situation when he began treating her and his flawed assertion that none of the District's assessments took into account STUDENT's medical status undermine his credibility. Moreover, not only did the District staff all testify that STUDENT appeared to be happy in school and well-adjusted, bu the parents also asserted that STUDENT was happy in school through the October 1996 IEP meeting. STUDENT's IEPs included goals in pragmatics that addressed social interaction skills. Although the Hearing Officer believes that STUDENT's parents truly thought that STUDENT was in an emotional crisis in December 1996, the District staff were equally credibly in their assertions that STUDENT was not showing signs of this turmoil in school. The District's first indication from the parents that STUDENT was so distressed was at the December 1996 IEP. The parents did not request that counseling be added at that time, and did not ask the team to take any action to alleviate the problem other than paying for Lindamood-Bell.

Therefore, based on credible testimony and documentary evidence regarding STUDENT's needs and the District's placement, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs.

2. Did the District's placement conform to STUDENT's IEP?

MOTHER, Ms. Minerman, and Ms. Walker all testified that STUDENT missed some of her RSP sessions, and perhaps some of her speech and language sessions, to work on holiday projects in her regular classroom during the last couple of weeks she was in attendance at TOW. Otherwise, the Petitioner did not assert that the placement offered did not conform to STUDENT's IEP. In fact, it appears that the IEP was appropriately modified every time a new service was added.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's placement conformed to STUDENT's IEP.

3. Was the District's placement designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT?

There was substantial testimony on the fact that STUDENT's program was designed to enable her to progress into third grade with her peers, and the District staff believed that STUDENT would advance to third grade on time. Moreover, both the testimony and documents establish that STUDENT was benefitting educationally from her program at TOW. Ms. Walker testified that STUDENT was progressing in many areas. Both the tape and the transcript of the October 24, 1996, reflect that STUDENT was making a lot of progress, although she had not overcome her disabilities. At that meeting, STUDENT's teachers and parents discussed how STUDENT was improving her sequencing and other skills. Transcript of 10/24/96 IEP, p.53, 69-70, 73-74. In reviewing her goals and objectives, the team talked about how STUDENT had completed many of her goals and wrote new, more advanced goals.

STUDENT's test scores also demonstrate that she was improving. Although STUDENT's performance on tests varied, her test scores do demonstrate that she was making progress in certain areas. For example, in the areas of vocabulary and language, from September to November 1996, STUDENT moved from the 4th to the 21st percentile on the PPVT-R, and between May and November 1995, she moved from the 12th to the 32nd percentile on the EOWPVT. Between November 1995 and October 1996, STUDENT's score on the WJ-R Broad Reading went from 102 to 110, and her score on the Broad Math went from 87 to 89. Between November 1995 and November 1996, STUDENT's reading score on the WRAT-R increased from 93 to 105, and her spelling score increased from 93 to 103. Although her WRAT-R math and her CELF-R scores showed STUDENT continued to have areas of deficit in math and receptive and expressive language, those deficits were being addressed in her IEP through her RSP program and speech and language therapy.

Overall, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's placement was designed to benefit her educationally, and that STUDENT was indeed progressing educationally. The progress STUDENT was making may not have been as fast as the parents wanted, or as significant as the parents assert that STUDENT made through the intensive one-on-one attention she received at Lindamood-Bell, but the law requires the District to provide an appropriate placement, not the best possible placement. Moreover, when a district is providing an appropriate placement, the parents do not have the right to compel the district to provide a particular educational program or methodology. Lachman v. Illinois Board of Education (7th Cir.) 1988-89 EHLR 441:156. According to Virginia Russell, who recommended the program to STUDENT's parents, the Lindamood-Bell program could be considered to be a methodology. (Testimony of Virginia Russell.) As such, the parents cannot insist that the District provide the Lindamood-Bell program while it is offering an appropriate placement.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided a free, appropriate public education to STUDENT, and the parent are not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the Lindamood-Bell program.

ISSUE #3. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the psychiatric counseling provided by Robert Dobrin, M.D.?

Because the District provided an appropriate placement for STUDENT, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for additional services that they obtained for STUDENT. Moreover, at no time did the parents indicate to the District that they thought STUDENT required counseling, and prior to filing the request for hearing, they mentioned only briefly that STUDENT was receiving counseling. Even if the parents had requested counseling, the evidence does not establish that counseling was necessary for STUDENT to benefit from her education. The Hearing Officer finds that the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the psychiatric counseling provided by Dr. Dobrin.

ISSUE # 4: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the transportation costs from their home in Laguna Beach to the Lindamood-Bell Clinic in Solano Beach and return, a total of 8,850 miles?

Parents are entitled to reimbursement for transportation to and from educationally necessary related services. Because STUDENT's parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the Lindamood- Bell program, they are not entitled to reimbursement for the travel to and from that program.

ISSUE #5: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the transportation costs to and from the office of Robert Dobrin, M.D.?

Parents are entitled to reimbursement for transportation to and from educationally necessary related services. Because STUDENT's parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the Dr. Dobrin's counseling, they are not entitled to reimbursement for the travel to and from that counseling.

ISSUE #6: Shall STUDENT receive, at District expense, an additional 120 hours of Lindamood-Bell Learning Process to complete her therapeutic progress for weak concept imagery?

The District provided STUDENT with an appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year. (Footnote 6.) As such, STUDENT is not entitled to receive compensatory education in the form of prospective provision of service such as Lindamood-Bell. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the Lindamood-Bell program is not necessary for STUDENT to benefit from her education. As discussed in Issue 2, above, STUDENT was making educational progress without the Lindamood-Bell program. The

Hearing Officer finds that the District shall not be required to provide STUDENT with an additional 120 hours of Lindamood-Bell therapy.

ISSUE #7. Shall STUDENT's parents be reimbursed for their transportation expenses incurred for the additional Lindamood-Bell therapy?

The District provided STUDENT with an appropriate placement. As such STUDENT is not entitled to receive compensatory education in the form of prospective provision of services such as Lindamood- Bell. The Hearing Officer finds that the District shall not be required to pay for STUDENT's transportation to receive additional hours of Lindamood-Bell therapy.

ORDER

All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: the District prevailed on all issues presented for hearing.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

Date: July 10, 1997 ___________________________________ Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes (Footnote 1.) The parties should note that the Hearing Officer both reviewed the transcripts and listened to the tapes. (Footnote 2.) The tests that were given only by the Lindamood-Bell center are not included because those tests cannot be compared to prior test results to demonstrate whether STUDENT was making progress in the program offered by the District. (Footnote 3.) Contrary to Dr. Dobrin's belief that the District was unaware of and did not refer to STUDENT's medications when it tested STUDENT, many of the testing reports submitted as evidence for the hearing, including one of the reports he summarized, list the medications that STUDENT was taking. See, e.g., Pet. Exh. O & P. (Footnote 4.) The original recommendation from the Lindamood-Bell clinic was for STUDENT to receive the VV program only. They added the ADD program after they received the Providence test results. Testimony of MOTHER. (Footnote 5.) Although the parents testified that they requested a functional behavior analysis and that the District did not perform one, the assessment they are seeking reimbursement for was not such an analysis. Therefore, the Hearing Officer did not examine whether a functional behavioral analysis should have been performed. (Footnote 6.) The parties have not yet met to establish a program for the 1997-98 school year; STUDENT's annual review is not due until October 1997.