California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 21, 1996
Student v. San Bruno Park School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 568-95 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
San Mateo County Office of Education and San Bruno Park must place student on a regular campus, not a separate site.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
An earlier hearing request filed in June 1995 by prior counsel was taken off calendar by agreement on June 26, 1995, and later recalendared. The decision notes no remand, vacatur, or correction.
Summary
The student was 13 and eligible for special education because of below-average intellectual functioning. He functioned at about a pre-kindergarten level. He was in a San Mateo County Office of Education special day class (SDC) under stay put, although everyone agreed that class was wrong for him. The District and County Office proposed returning him to Judy Curran's class for students with serious emotional disturbance at Palos Verdes, a separate site that serves only students with disabilities. The student filed for a hearing. He sought a class for students with limited intellectual functioning (LIF) on a regular campus, plus a better behavior plan.
The Hearing Officer found Ms. Curran's class appropriate under Rowley. She also found that an LIF class on a regular campus would be appropriate if he kept his one-to-one aide. Applying Rachel H. and Roncker v. Walter, she held that the regular campus was the less restrictive setting. The agencies' main reason for a separate site was safety, tied to his running away and inappropriate touching. Yet the June 1995 behavior plan addressed only hand-biting. The Hearing Officer held that the agencies had to try an adequate behavior plan and aide support before moving him to a segregated site. He had done well on regular campuses before, and cost was not an issue. She ordered a new functional analysis assessment, a revised behavior plan, placement in an LIF class on a regular campus within 35 days with the aide continued, and follow-up IEP meetings.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Rachel H. and Roncker v. Walter when two classes were both appropriate. The safety concerns behind the separate-site proposal came from behaviors that the behavior plan never addressed. So the Hearing Officer required the agencies to try an adequate plan and supports on a regular campus before choosing a segregated site.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. What is the appropriate and least restrictive placement for STUDENT?
The SED class on a segregated site was appropriate. But an LIF class on a regular campus, with an aide and an adequate behavior plan, was also appropriate and less restrictive, so the Hearing Officer ordered that placement.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to assess. Within 10 calendar days of the decision, Respondents must begin a functional behavioral analysis consistent with Education Code sections 56520-24 and 5 CCR section 3052.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 25 calendar days, convene an IEP meeting to revise the behavioral intervention plan to address inappropriate behaviors, including running away and inappropriate touching, in compliance with Education Code sections 56520-24 and 5 CCR section 3052.
- Order to provide or change services. Within 35 calendar days, implement the revised behavioral intervention plan.
- Placement ordered. Within 35 calendar days, place the student on a regular school campus in a special day class for students with limited intellectual functioning. The class must have a small, structured, safe setting, a low student-to-teacher ratio, same-aged peers with similar functional abilities, chances for one-to-one and small-group instruction, and instruction in functional academics and communication, pre-vocational, independent-living, self-help and social skills.
- Order to provide or change services. Continue to provide an instructional assistant in the LIF SDC to keep the student-to-teacher ratio appropriate.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 65 calendar days, convene an IEP meeting to revise the behavioral intervention plan as needed.
Key authorities
Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Roncker v. Walter; Poolaw v. Bishop; OSEP Policy Letter (March 21, 1986); Education Code sections 56520-24; 5 CCR section 3052; Education Code section 56364; Education Code section 56031
People named in the decision
- Nancy Korry, special day class teacher (current placement, Parkway Heights and Westborough Middle School), San Mateo County Office of Education
- Judy Curran, SED special day class teacher at Palos Verdes (proposed placement), San Mateo County Office of Education
- Therese McLaughlin, SED special day class teacher at Fernando Rivera School, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Robin Foster, SED special day class teacher at Portola Elementary School, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Marian Galvarin, elementary SED special day class teacher at Palos Verdes, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Linda Gulas, LIF special day class teacher at Parkside Intermediate/Junior High School; observed student, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Ralph Howe, school psychologist; conducted functional analysis and developed behavioral intervention plan, District/COE
- Bonnie Yamane, secondary education services manager, San Mateo County Office of Education
- John Piper, Ph.D., educational services manager/program manager, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Jane Lubin, Ed.D., director of special education, San Bruno Park School District
- Elizabeth Caire, speech and language therapist, District/COE
- Linda McGlaughlin, speech and language therapist, District/COE
- Kent Rezowalli, compliance coordinator; represented Respondents, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Karen Grites, educational specialist; independent assessor, Children's Health Council
- Children's Health Council, private assessment agency
- Shelley Davis, J.D., behavioral specialist; expert witness for Student, Language and Educational Assistance for Preschoolers (LEAP)
- Rae Miller, head teacher, after-school and summer program; witness for Student, Project REACH
- James Cusack, owner/director/principal of nonpublic school, Sand Paths Academy
- Louise Emerson, program director of nonpublic school, Morgan Center
- Jennifer Kennedy, advocate for Student
- Paul Foreman, attorney for Student
- Michael A. Zatopa, former attorney for Student
- Jack Boland, police department staff who gave information to the assessors, San Bruno Police Department
- Kate McKinley, District Attorney's office staff who gave information to the assessors, District Attorney's Office
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in San Mateo, California, on December 12 and 13, 1995, and January 16 and 17, 1996.
STUDENT was represented by attorney Paul Foreman. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were Jennifer Kennedy, advocate; STUDENT's mother; and STUDENT's sister. Respondents San Bruno Park School District (District) and the San Mateo County Office of Education (COE) were represented by Kent Rezowalli, COE compliance coordinator. Jane Lubin, Ed.D., director of special education, was also present on behalf of the District and Bonnie Yamane, secondary education services manager, was present on behalf of the COE.
Oral and documentary evidence was received, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE
What is the appropriate and least restrictive placement for STUDENT?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner is 13 years old. He is eligible for special education because of severely below average general intellectual functioning. STUDENT has significant deficits in all areas of development and generally functions at a pre-kindergarten level. STUDENT currently is placed in a COE special day class (SDC) at Westborough Middle School.(Footnote 1) The class is taught by Nancy Korry. The parties agree that Ms. Korry's class is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT; however, because they are unable to agree on another placement, STUDENT remains in Ms. Korry's class pursuant to "stay put." A one-to-one aide is provided and STUDENT receives 40 minutes weekly of speech and language therapy. He also is entitled to transportation to and from school. STUDENT's current IEP contains goals and objectives to improve fine-motor, social/emotional, communication, pre-vocational, functional academic, and independent/self-help skills. Goals for STUDENT to remain in group activity and to refrain from biting his hand are included in a behavioral intervention plan developed in June 1995.
From September 1984 through June 1988, STUDENT received special education services in Sacramento. In October 1988, STUDENT moved with his family from Sacramento to Belmont in San Mateo County. He was placed at Cipriani School in a COE SDC for students with limited intellectual functioning. (Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 135-148) In December 1988, speech and language services were added to STUDENT's IEP. STUDENT continued in an LIF SDC through February 1991. On February 27, 1991, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be transitioned to an SDC for SED students to meet his goals and objectives, "in particular, communication, social skills, and behavior." (Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 95) In September 1991, STUDENT was transferred to the non-categorical SED SDC at Portola Elementary School.
STUDENT's IEP at the end of the 1991-92 school year indicates that his hours of classroom instruction had been decreased from six to five hours per day. The IEP also states that STUDENT would participate with regular education peers daily for 35 minutes on the playground and for 15 minutes during nutrition. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT continue in a similar SED SDC placement in the fall of 1992. (Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 81-94) STUDENT remained in Robin Foster's SED SDC at Portola during the 1992-93 school year. He integrated daily with regular education peers for lunch and recess and once each per week for music and art. Peer tutors also came into the classroom on a daily basis to work with STUDENT and the other SDC students.
On June 7, 1993, the IEP team reviewed STUDENT's placement. It is noted on the IEP that STUDENT's placement in the non-categorical SED SDC continued to be appropriate to meet his needs. It was also noted that STUDENT would move from the elementary to the secondary unit in September 1993 and that the extent of his participation in regular eduction programs would be determined at that time at the new school site.
STUDENT began the 1993-94 school year at Brisbane School. Sometime in the fall of 1993, STUDENT was transferred to Marian Galvarin's elementary SED SDC at Palos Verdes. Palos Verdes is a segregated school site for students with disabilities, whereas all the other schools STUDENT has attended in San Mateo County were regular education elementary school sites. There is no IEP reflecting STUDENT's change of placement from the SED SDC on an integrated site to an SED SDC at the segregated site. There also is no IEP reflecting that a determination had been made that STUDENT would no longer participate in any activities with regular education peers. In the fall of 1994, STUDENT moved from the elementary SED SDC to Judy Curran's secondary SED SDC at Palos Verdes. There were three male and three female students in the class. The class included students designated on their IEPs as seriously emotionally disturbed and below average general intellectual functioning. Their academic skills ranged from kindergarten to first grade and one student's skills fell below kindergarten. On October 18, 1994, the IEP team met to review a COE psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT. The IEP team agreed that Ms. Curran's class continued to be an appropriate placement for STUDENT. (Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 52-66)
In January 1995, MOTHER filed a police report asserting that STUDENT had been physically abused by one of the instructional assistants in Ms. Curran's class. Respondents dispute that anything inappropriate occurred in the classroom. An investigation followed. The District Attorney did not prosecute the case and no determination was made regarding the merits of the allegation.
On January 27, 1995, the IEP team met to discuss MOTHER's concerns regarding "STUDENT's treatment at school and a change in classroom placement." District/COE members of the IEP team stated that STUDENT's needs could best be met in his current placement. However, in response to MOTHER's concerns, the IEP team decided that a change in placement was "desirable." The team agreed to place STUDENT in an SED SDC taught by Therese McLaughlin at Fernando Rivera School. Fernando Rivera is a regular education school site. Four of the students in Ms. McLaughlin's class were designated by the COE as SED, three as below average general intellectual functioning (BAGIF), and one as severe language disordered. The class curriculum included instruction in self-help skills, functional academics, and behavioral areas. The team agreed to reconvene in 30 days to review STUDENT's placement. (Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 49)
On March 10, 1995, the IEP team reconvened and reviewed a recent update of STUDENT's speech and language skills and discussed an increase in "some negative attention behaviors (head-banging, laughter out of context)." The team recommended that a functional analysis of STUDENT's behaviors be conducted and agreed that parents and staff would visit other potential placements. (Respondents' Exhibit 47) On April 18, 1995, the IEP team convened to review STUDENT's placement. STUDENT's parents did not consent to the recommendation of District/COE IEP team members that STUDENT should be placed back in Ms. Curran's SED SDC on a "non-integrated" site. The District/COE agreed to explore other placement possibilities. (Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 45-46)
At an IEP meeting on May 22, 1995, the IEP team reviewed the functional analysis of STUDENT's behavior that had been completed by Ralph Howe, school psychologist. The team agreed to an initial plan to eliminate STUDENT's hand-biting and self-stimulating behaviors and adopted goals to improve his social interactions and to explore tactile materials. By agreement of the IEP team, STUDENT was then placed in Nancy Korry's SED SDC at Parkway Heights Middle School in South San Francisco. Ms. Korry's class was thought to be appropriate because it focuses on functional academics, behavior, and self-help skills, and the students were not as high functioning as the students in Ms. McLaughlin's class. (Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 43)
On June 12, 1995, the IEP team convened to review STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan and to discuss STUDENT's placement for the fall of 1995. District/COE members of the IEP team again recommended that STUDENT be returned to Judy Curran's SED SDC at Palos Verdes. STUDENT's parents did not consent to the proposed change in placement. The IEP team agreed to review STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan in November 1995. (Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 30) Thereafter, attorney Michael A. Zatopa requested a special education due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT regarding the provision of an appropriate education. On June 26, 1995, the matter was taken off calendar by agreement of the parties.
In July 1995, at the request of Mr. Zatopa, Children's Health Council (CHC) completed an assessment of STUDENT. (Petitioner's Exhibit pages 27-41) The CHC assessors concluded that STUDENT would function best in a "small, structured, safe, secure and nurturing classroom with a vocational emphasis that includes children of similar age and functioning." The report also states that "signing combined with oral language will be an important way for STUDENT to make his needs known in the future." (Petitioner's Exhibit p. 34) The initial report recommended the following:
Provide STUDENT with an alternate school setting from that in which he was allegedly abused and his academic needs were not adequately addressed. Include vocational training, speech/language therapy including signing, basic sight word and utilitarian math skills. Social skills and independent living skills should also be a component of his program.
(Petitioner's Exhibit p. 40)
Subsequent to the evaluation, Jack Boland of the San Bruno Police Department, Kate McKinley of the District Attorney's Office, and the District/COE provided CHC with additional information regarding the allegations of abuse. Thereafter, Karen Grites, educational specialist, wrote an addendum to the CHC report. The addendum notes:
The Children's Health Council defers to the District Attorney's office with regard to the alleged abuse and has not based diagnoses or recommendations upon the fact that abuse did or did not occur. We believe that STUDENT's placement decision must take into consideration his developmental delays, opportunities for vocational planning/training and the ability to integrate the efforts of the "parent-school team."
Observations of Palos Verde School on September 21, 1995 determined the program to be highly appropriate to address STUDENT's developmental delays and vocational planning/training needs. However, the success of the "parent-school team" is in question. Unless a coalition is formed between STUDENT's parents and his school team, it is unlikely that STUDENT will benefit from such a placement.
The recommendations in the initial report were also revised to read as follows:
Provide STUDENT with an appropriate school setting that includes vocational training, speech/language therapy including signing, basic sight word and utilitarian math skills. Social skills and independent living skills should also be a component of his program. It is essential that parents, teachers and school administrators form an effective team to insure STUDENT's success.
(Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 34)
STUDENT continued in Ms. Korry's class in the fall of 1995. Ms. Korry's class and another COE SDC relocated to Westborough Middle School, which is located in South San Francisco. This is the first year that there are COE SDCs on the Westborough campus. Of the eight students in Ms. Korry's class, two are designated by the COE as both SED and BAGIF, three as SED, and three as BAGIF. Ms. Korry's class continues to stress development of self-help skills, functional academics, and appropriate behavior, and has community-based outings every three days. On September 15, 1995, the District/COE determined that a one-to-one aide for STUDENT was necessary because of his placement in an "incorrect" class. (Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 29)
On October 19, 1995, the IEP team met to review STUDENT's current levels of functioning and to draft new goals and objectives. The meeting was continued to October 24, 1995. District/COE members of the IEP team again recommended that STUDENT return to Ms Curran's SED SDC at Palos Verdes. STUDENT's parents did not consent to the proposed placement and requested that the IEP team consider placing STUDENT in an LIF SDC on a regular school site. The District/COE IEP team members requested that Linda Gulas, who teaches an LIF SDC at Parkside Intermediate Junior High School, observe STUDENT and comment on the appropriateness of her class as a placement for him. (Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 10)
On October 27, 1995, the IEP team reconvened to discuss Ms. Gulas' observation. Ms. Gulas concluded that her class would not be an appropriate placement for STUDENT because he "needs to be in a protected segregated site to keep him safe and service his needs." District/COE members of the IEP team continued to recommend that STUDENT be placed in Ms. Curran's SDC. (Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 8) STUDENT's parents filed a letter of dissent, which is attached to the IEP, and their advocate, Jennifer Kennedy, requested that the due process hearing be recalendared for hearing.(Footnote 2) (Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 2-3) Following several continuances, the hearing convened on December 5, 1995.
Through his attorney, Petitioner STUDENT contends that prior to removing him from a regular school site, Respondents are required to provide him with supplemental aids and services--namely a behavioral intervention plan designed to ameliorate the behaviors that Respondents assert necessitate his placement at a segregated school. Petitioner also asserts that an LIF SDC with an appropriate behavioral intervention plan constitutes an appropriate and least restrictive placement for him. Petitioner alternatively proposes that he be placed in a certified nonpublic school (NPS) such as Sand Paths or the Morgan Center if an appropriate SDC on an integrated school site is not available within San Mateo County.
Respondents contend that Judy Curran's SED SDC at Palos Verdes is an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Respondents assert that during his placement in the class, STUDENT showed academic improvement and his inappropriate behaviors were significantly reduced. Respondents also assert that for safety reasons, STUDENT requires a placement located on a segregated school site.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
STUDENT's mother, testified that she does not want STUDENT to be placed in the SDC taught by Judy Curran. MOTHER testified that STUDENT should be placed in a class that serves students with disabilities similar to his and that is located on a regular education school site. She testified that she first learned a few weeks ago that "SED" stands for seriously emotionally disturbed. MOTHER indicated that she would not have consented in 1991 to change STUDENT from an LIF class to an SED class had she know this earlier. She testified that STUDENT has never been diagnosed as emotionally disturbed and should not be placed with students who are. MOTHER also expressed concern that STUDENT would model the inappropriate behavior of the SED students. MOTHER testified that the District/COE did not convene an IEP meeting or obtain her consent prior to moving STUDENT to the more restrictive placement at Palos Verdes.
In addition to the above reasons, MOTHER testified that she does not want STUDENT in Ms. Curran's class because she honestly believes that STUDENT was physically harmed by an instructional assistant in the class. MOTHER testified that after being in Ms. Curran's class at Palos Verdes for approximately 10 days, STUDENT told her that an instructional assistant was "hurting me." For the next two weeks, STUDENT continued to repeat this statement to his mother at home in the evening when relating to her what had happened during the day at school. MOTHER testified that she observed black marks on STUDENT's buttocks from September 1994 through January 1995. She initially assumed that the bruises were from a fall from his bike. She also thought that some bruising may have occurred when STUDENT fell off of a fence in September. MOTHER stated, however, that the bruises did not go away. She testified that during this time period, STUDENT bit his hand a lot and woke up in the middle of the night. According to MOTHER, STUDENT did not exhibit any of these problems during the winter break from school. However, on the first day STUDENT returned to school from vacation, he could not sit because his buttocks hurt. MOTHER reported that STUDENT cried on another occasion and told her again that someone at school hurt him.
Although the person alleged to have harmed STUDENT no longer works in Ms. Curran's class, MOTHER testified that she does not trust Ms. Curran because of what occurred in her class. MOTHER also asserted that Ms. Curran was not responsive to her concerns. MOTHER testified that she did not mention her concerns at an IEP meeting in October 1994 because Ms. Curran had reassured her that STUDENT was not being mistreated at school. John Piper, COE program manager, also told her that there were no problems with STUDENT at school. MOTHER testified that STUDENT is fearful of returning to the class. She noted that when she drove STUDENT to the Palos Verdes school yard to ride his bike, he began shaking and his heart was beating fast. She interpreted this to mean that STUDENT was frightened. MOTHER related two other occasions on which STUDENT appeared frightened after seeing someone resembling the aide from Ms. Curran's class.
MOTHER testified that until these events at Palos Verdes, she trusted the school district and agreed with whatever the district recommended for STUDENT's placement. MOTHER testified that she continues to prefer that STUDENT attend a public school. She believes that STUDENT requires a behavior modification plan developed by a behavioral specialist. MOTHER testified that because STUDENT has changed classes so many times, he probably needs to have an individual aide for now. She noted her willingness, however, to try STUDENT in a class with a student-to-adult ratio of two-to-one. In the alternative, she believes that Sand Paths, a nonpublic school in San Francisco, would be a good placement for STUDENT because there are higher functioning students at the school who would provide appropriate behavior models for STUDENT. MOTHER testified that Children's Health Council also suggested the Morgan Center as a possible placement for STUDENT.
SISTER, STUDENT's older sister, testified that she and other family members believe that STUDENT was physically abused while in Ms. Curran's class. MOTHER is a recent college graduate. She testified that beginning in October 1994, STUDENT told her one to two times a week that the instructional assistant "hurt" and, in November 1994, she began noting that STUDENT was not behaving as he usually did. STUDENT became withdrawn, appeared frustrated, did not want to engage in his usual activities such as riding his bike, and would pull away from his sisters. STUDENT also started wanting to sleep with his parents instead of in his own bed and was waking up in the middle of the night. SISTER also noted that STUDENT's sleeping patterns and other behavior returned to normal during the winter break from school and that, when he returned to school in January, his problems reappeared and continued until his placement was changed. SISTER testified that STUDENT remembers the events that took place in Ms. Curran's class. She noted that after returning from playing on the Palos Verdes yard during the summer of 1995, STUDENT told her that the instructional assistant "hit me." In response to Respondents' assertions that STUDENT cannot recall events for even a short period of time, SISTER pointed out in an IEP dated June 3, 1992, that STUDENT's teacher had noted that "he [STUDENT] can speak very clearly when he is angry. When he is upset with someone, he does not forget...." (Petitioner's Exhibit p. 107) SISTER testified that STUDENT did not seem to make progress from 1992 on. However, since his placement at Fernando Riviera, she observed that STUDENT's communication skills have improved and his vocabulary has increased. SISTER testified that STUDENT would regress if placed at Palos Verdes. It would also be highly disruptive to the family.
Rae Miller testified on behalf of STUDENT. She is the head teacher of Project REACH, an after school and summer program for special education students. Ms. Miller testified that STUDENT's behavior deteriorated at the end of 1994 through approximately April 1995. She described STUDENT now as "well behaved" and a "social butterfly" who likes to "hang out" with the regular education students on the basketball court.
Shelley Davis, J.D., who testified on behalf of STUDENT, has been a behavioral specialist for 10 years. She currently is employed by Language and Educational Assistance for Preschoolers (LEAP) and is responsible for the behavioral plans of 20 students who are language delayed or autistic.(Footnote 3) She also provides training on behavioral issues to the staff of two school districts. Ms. Davis reviewed records regarding STUDENT. She has neither met STUDENT nor spoken with his teachers. Ms. Davis criticized the District/COE's functional analysis and behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT. (See also Petitioner's Exhibit B, p. 1 - 2) Her primary concern was that only one of STUDENT's inappropriate behaviors--hand-biting--has been targeted and that neither the analysis nor the plan addresses STUDENT's dangerous behaviors, including running away, vocalizations, non-compliance, and inappropriate touching. Ms. Davis testified that all of these behaviors affect STUDENT's ability to adjust in a higher functioning environment and prevent him from benefitting from his special education and should have been addressed in the functional analysis and behavioral intervention plan. According to Ms. Davis, the functional analysis is further deficient because it lacks information regarding the frequency of hand-biting, antecedents to the behavior, and where and when the behavior occurs. Ms. Davis also questioned how the evaluator reached the conclusion that STUDENT bites his hand to "reduce excitement." She noted that other documents indicate that STUDENT bites his hand when he is frustrated.
Ms. Davis testified that the behavioral intervention plan as written does not include sufficient information to be implemented. For example, the plan does not identify an immediate replacement behavior for hand-biting and does not specify how data will be collected in order to evaluate the success of the plan. Ms. Davis testified that STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan should be revised because, since November 1995, STUDENT has received daily behavioral incident reports and a contemporary intervention plan would assist the new staff who will be working with STUDENT to address his needs. Ms. Davis did not have an opinion regarding what constitutes an appropriate placement for STUDENT; however, she testified that STUDENT could benefit from being in an SDC located on an integrated school campus because there would be appropriate peers for him to model.
James Cusack, owner/director/principal of Sand Paths Academy, testified regarding the program offered by the certified nonpublic school, which is located in San Francisco. Louise Emerson, program director, testified regarding the program offered at the Morgan Center, a certified nonpublic school.
Karen Grites, educational specialist, Children's Health Council (CHC), conducted the educational portion of the assessment of STUDENT by CHC in July 1995. Ms. Grites observed STUDENT at Westborough and also observed Ms. Curran's SDC at Palos Verdes. Ms. Grites testified that, in making placement decisions, consideration must be given to the student's age, cognitive functioning, and academic and social needs. An appropriate placement should include a teacher who is flexible and creative and able to meet the needs of the students regardless of the label given to the class. Ms. Grites testified that Ms. Curran's class is an appropriate setting for students with disabilities such as STUDENT's because there are age-appropriate peers and the curriculum stresses development of the students' daily living skills. Ms. Grites noted that neither she nor the CHC team has drawn any conclusions regarding whether STUDENT would benefit from mainstreaming. Ms. Grites testified that she initially thought an alternative classroom setting should be found for STUDENT because of the family's perception that STUDENT had been abused while attending Ms. Curran's class. Ms. Grites offered the opinion that, without the cooperation of STUDENT's parents, it is possible but not likely that he will be successful if returned to Ms. Curran's class. Ms. Grites testified that the Morgan Center is "potentially" appropriate for STUDENT. She stated that it is a well-respected nonpublic school and includes appropriate peers.
Bonnie Yamane, COE education services manager, testified that STUDENT should be placed where he will be safe and successful, and where his IEP goals and objectives can be implemented. She concluded that Ms. Curran's class offers an appropriate placement for him. As to whether STUDENT is fearful of returning to the class, Ms. Yamane testified that STUDENT has never appeared distressed or disturbed at Palos Verdes. She testified that on the first day of summer school, STUDENT accidentally got off the bus at Palos Verdes. He proceeded to walk to his prior class. She noted that STUDENT has also been to the vocational center at Palos Verdes on field trips with his current class.
In Ms. Yamane's opinion, STUDENT's placement on an integrated site contributes to his overall behavior problems and specifically to the effectiveness of the behavioral intervention plan. She testified that the District/COE has not been successful at alleviating STUDENT's hand-biting because his inappropriate placement causes him stress. In regard to STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan, Ms. Yamane testified that the professional opinion of the COE staff is that one behavior at a time should be targeted by the plan. Hand-biting was selected because STUDENT's teacher reported that the behavior was getting worse. In regard to alternative placements proposed by the PARENTS, Ms. Yamane noted that she has referred students to the Morgan Center when the COE and school district are unable to meet the student's needs. She testified, however, that the Morgan Center is a more restrictive placement than the District/COE's proposed SDC placement. She also noted that many of the students at the Morgan Center have behavioral problems. In response to MOTHER's testimony, Ms. Yamane stated that at no time did it appear to her that MOTHER lacked understanding that STUDENT had been placed in an SED class.Judy Curran, SDC teacher at Palos Verdes, had STUDENT in her class from September 1994 through January 1995. Ms. Curran stated that when compared to the other students in the class, STUDENT's language and academic skills were lower and his gross-motor skills were higher. He generally functioned at a pre-kindergarten level and had limited language skills, especially when attempting to express his feelings. He was able to follow verbal directions, to independently use the bathroom, and to feed himself. Ms. Curran described STUDENT as "nice, out-going, and polite." Ms. Curran testified that STUDENT did not exhibit any behaviors that she could not manage. He followed the program and was not physically dangerous to himself or others. Ms. Curran stated that she did not have any reason to refer him for a Hughes Bill behavioral assessment. Ms. Curran testified that STUDENT benefitted from her class and was making gains in social and emotional areas. She noted that as STUDENT learned the structured class routine, his ability to focus and pay attention increased. Ms. Curran stated that STUDENT was "on the verge" of meeting several of his IEP goals and objectives.
Ms. Curran's class includes one student who is designated as other health impaired/autistic, three who are designated as SED, and two who are BAGIF. Ms. Curran testified that her class is appropriate for STUDENT and could address his IEP goals and objectives. She employs a functional curriculum that stresses development of daily living skills, language, prevocational skills, and simple functional math. The classroom includes a washer and dryer, kitchen, sink, bathroom, and garden. Ms. Curran testified that the class works at a food distribution center and takes weekly trips to the community, including the grocery store. Ms. Curran testified that she employs a positive behavioral intervention system for all of the students in the class and that students receive points for following the class rules and directions. Some students also have individual behavioral contracts. Ms. Curran was unable to find any information in STUDENT's educational record to indicate that STUDENT has had problems with non-special education students. Ms. Curran believes, however, that STUDENT would have more difficulty on an integrated school site. In response to testimony relating to the alleged abuse, Ms. Curran testified that STUDENT did not have a good concept of time or the ability to recall prior events. She stated that an hour would be too long for STUDENT to remember something and it would be unlikely that STUDENT would remember something occurring one year earlier. She also noted that his communication skills are limited.
John Piper, Ph.D., is an educational services manager for the COE. Dr. Piper described STUDENT as happy, cheerful, and relaxed during Dr. Piper's observations in Ms. Curran's class in December 1994 and January 1995. Dr. Piper testified that STUDENT was very successful while attending Palos Verdes. His attention span and social skills were improving. Dr. Piper testified that Ms. Curran has a "strong" behavioral background and is skilled in working with students with behavioral problems. Dr. Piper believes that the PARENTS are genuinely concerned about STUDENT's experiences at Palos Verdes.
Therese McLaughlin, SDC teacher, had STUDENT in her class from January 24 through April 1995. Ms. McLaughlin testified that there were nine students in the class whose functional skills ranged from pre-kindergarten through the fourth grade. Ms. McLaughlin was assisted by a full-time aide and a part-time aide. Ms. McLaughlin testified that STUDENT also required a one-to-one aide so that she could continue to implement the regular curriculum of the class. The class stressed functional academics, community training, and behavioral management skills. Ms. McLaughlin testified that STUDENT was quiet the first several weeks of class. After that, he began to regress and she had to move him to the back of the classroom to work one-to-one with his aide. Ms. McLaughlin testified that STUDENT had difficulty communicating with the other students and would do inappropriate things to get their attention. In her opinion, the integrated school setting was too stimulating for STUDENT and caused him to be "uncontrollable." For example, in the cafeteria, STUDENT jumped on the table, grabbed an aide's breast, and grabbed his own crotch. On the playground, STUDENT would get in a student's face and laugh. In physical education, STUDENT would twirl in circles and "hump" the floor. Ms. McLaughlin expressed concern that STUDENT's behavior would result in his being hit or otherwise hurt by another student. Ms. McLaughlin testified that Ms. Curran's class is appropriate for STUDENT because it is on a segregated site and the curriculum stresses development of independent living skills and pre-vocational skills.
Elizabeth Caire, speech and language therapist, provided group language sessions to the students in Ms. McLaughlin's class; however, because STUDENT was too distractible, Ms. Caire worked individually with him. She testified that STUDENT was focused and worked well when she presented information at his level. She recalled that STUDENT spoke in two- to three-word noun and verb phrases. Ms. Caire testified that STUDENT appeared younger than the other students in the class. She observed that he did not appear comfortable in the cafeteria and did not seem to be a part of the group.
Nancy Korry, SDC teacher at Westborough Middle School, has been STUDENT's teacher since April 1995. Ms. Korry testified that STUDENT currently functions at a pre-kindergarten level in academics and is at a parallel play stage socially, whereas the skills of the other students in her class are at the first- and second-grade level. STUDENT uses one- to two-word phrases, has difficulty answering questions, and does not have either communication or social skills to interact with the other students in the class. Ms. Korry testified that STUDENT bites himself as many as 20 to 30 times a day. He also flaps his hands and grimaces. To reduce hand-biting, Ms. Korry has adapted the curriculum to STUDENT's level. When STUDENT is agitated, she removes him from the group and engages him in another activity. She also attempted to use a wrist band to redirect STUDENT's attention away from his hand and consulted with Dr. Howe, who initially developed the behavioral intervention plan, for input on appropriate modifications for STUDENT. Ms. Korry stated that either she or her aide has charted STUDENT's behavior, which indicates that the behavioral intervention plan has not reduced the frequency of STUDENT's hand-biting. Ms. Korry testified that STUDENT runs out of class and has run away during community outings. On those occasions, STUDENT did not respond to her verbal directions.
Ms. Korry testified that STUDENT can sometimes work with one or two other students on an activity such as a puzzle or on the computer. He currently has lunch with the regular education students. Ms. Korry noted that several times during passing, STUDENT has gotten in the way of the regular education students or has grabbed a student. She interpreted these actions as attempts to communicate. Ms. Korry testified that STUDENT has not made much progress in her class. She testified that the stimulation of the regular education site negatively affects STUDENT's ability to learn. In her opinion, STUDENT is also experiencing anxiety and stress because he cannot cope with the higher functioning students in the class. Ms. Korry believes that a non-integrated site would be appropriate for STUDENT because of his running away and inappropriate touching. She also stated that Ms. Curran's program will meet STUDENT's need for vocational education, development of functional skills, and access to community resources.
Linda McGlaughlin, speech and language therapist, has worked with STUDENT and one other student since September 1995. She also assessed him in October 1995. Ms. McGlaughlin testified that STUDENT does not use three-word phrases and has a "flat" growth profile since 1992. Ms. McGlaughlin testified that STUDENT has trouble generalizing information and requires a functional and prevocational curriculum.
Linda Gulas, LIF SDC teacher at Parkside Junior High School, observed STUDENT in his class in October 1995 to provide input to the IEP team in determining an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Ms. Gulas testified that STUDENT's behavior is unpredictable and he does not sense danger. Ms. Gulas testified that STUDENT's inappropriate touching of other students is a threat to his safety because of the possibility that a regular education student might react physically. Ms. Gulas testified that there can be as many as 12 students in her LIF SDC and that STUDENT would require more assistance than would be available with the current student-to-staff ratio. Ms. Gulas also expressed concern that the large number of students, the high activity level, and the continual flow of peer tutors from the reverse mainstreaming program in her class would overstimulate STUDENT. She also noted that a room is not available for him to use to calm down. Ms. Gulas testified that the students in her class have a wide range of abilities. Their adaptive behavior ranges from 4 to 12 years old. Some students have academic goals and objectives, whereas all of STUDENT's goals and objectives are related to social and emotional functioning. Ms. Gulas testified that LIF students do not have one-to-one aides and that STUDENT's needs are different from the needs of LIF students. Ms. Gulas agreed with the recommendations of the District/COE members of the IEP team that STUDENT requires a protected and segregated educational site to meet his social and emotional needs.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individual with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.
In order to determine whether placement in Ms. Curran's class or an LIF SDC constitutes an appropriate placement for STUDENT under Rowley and IDEA, it is first necessary to determine his unique and individual needs.
What are STUDENT's unique and individual needs?
The evidence establishes that STUDENT has significant deficits in all areas of development and generally functions at a pre-kindergarten level. His communication skills are limited. STUDENT's gross-motor skills are at a higher level and he is able to ride a two-wheel bicycle. With little or no assistance, STUDENT can prepare a sandwich, feed himself, and toilet. The evidence also establishes that STUDENT exhibits certain inappropriate behaviors, including hand-biting and hand-flapping, and laughs or makes sounds at inappropriate times. He also has run from the the teacher while on community outings, bolted from his classroom, and has inappropriately touched other students.
There is no dispute that STUDENT requires an instructional program that focuses on developing functional academics, communication, and social, pre-vocational, independent-living, and self-help skills. STUDENT's needs, as discussed by Ms. Grites and contained within the CHC report, call for placement in a structured, safe, and nurturing environment that includes same-aged peers with similar functional abilities. These recommendations essentially were undisputed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer adopts the above recommendations regarding the components of an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
As to the other components of an appropriate placement for STUDENT, there was also general agreement that because of STUDENT's distractibility and behavioral problems, he requires a "small" class with a low student-to-teacher ratio. The parties do not agree, however, as to what constitutes "small" or the appropriate student-to-teacher ratio for STUDENT. The CHC report recommends that STUDENT be placed in a small class and did not define a specific number of students or the appropriate student-to-teacher ratio. MOTHER indicated that if the class is otherwise appropriate and has a proper peer group, she would be willing to have STUDENT in a class where there are approximately 12 students and the ratio of students-to-teachers is higher than the ratio is in SED SDCs. Respondents contend that STUDENT requires a class of approximately six or seven students. Respondents assert that the six-to-one ratio of students-to-teaching staff in LIF SDCs is too high for STUDENT. They assert that the ratio of approximately three-and-one-half students per teacher in non-categorical SED SDCs is appropriate. STUDENT's speech and language therapists testified that STUDENT works best one-to-one and that, on some occasions, he is able to work with another student. They also testified that STUDENT is able to do some activities, such as assembling puzzles or working on the computer, with a small number of other students.
Historically, STUDENT has been successful at the elementary level in non-categorical SED SDCs that had approximately seven students. STUDENT has also been successful in LIF classes, which, according to Ms. Yamane, have as many as 12 students with one teacher and an instructional assistant. Since moving to the secondary level, STUDENT's placement in classes with smaller student-to-teacher ratios have not always been successful. Ms. McLaughlin and Ms. Korry testified, however, that STUDENT's difficulties in their classes were related to the difficulty STUDENT had dealing with an inappropriate peer group comprised of students at higher functional levels. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires a small class with a low student-to-teacher ratio, and which offers opportunities for individual and small-group instruction. However, the precise number of classmates and the appropriate student-to-teacher ratio appear to be dependent upon a number of factors in the placement, including the composition of the peer group and, therefore, are variable.
Another issue of contention related to STUDENT's program is the adequacy of the current behavioral intervention plan, which was developed in June 1995. Ms. Davis, an experienced behavioral specialist, noted a number of deficiencies in the plan, particularly the failure of the plan to address STUDENT's running away and inappropriate touching. Ms. Yamane offered her opinion on behalf of Respondents that it is appropriate for a behavioral intervention plan to address only one behavior at a time. Respondents otherwise agree that STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan needs to be revised and propose to do so when he is in a permanent placement.
STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan contains two goals. One is specifically related to eliminating hand-biting. The second goal is for STUDENT to remain in a group activity. A careful examination of the second goal reveals that it too is designed to eliminate STUDENT's hand-biting. It calls for STUDENT to take a break from the group when he becomes "overstimulated" so that he will not bite his hand. The behavioral intervention plan does not include any goals related to inappropriate touching or to eliminate running from the classroom or teacher and classmates while on community outings. Preliminary behavioral goals and objectives also did not address inappropriate touching or running away. (See Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 40 and 44)(Footnote 4)
The psychologist who was responsible for completing the functional assessment and developing the behavioral intervention plan did not testify at the hearing. Ms. Davis was the only experienced behavioral intervention specialist to testify regarding STUDENT's behaviors and the need to revise the behavioral intervention plan to address STUDENT's significant inappropriate behaviors, including running away and inappropriate touching. Ms. Davis has worked in the field for 10 years, contracts with public school districts to provide services, and is directly responsible for developing and implementing behavioral intervention plans through her current employment. Based on the testimony of Ms. Davis, as well as the testimony of STUDENT's teachers regarding STUDENT's inappropriate behaviors and their negative impact on his ability to benefit from his placement, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires a behavioral intervention plan that addresses running away and inappropriate touching. Pursuant to Education Code §§ 56520-24 and Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3052, behavioral intervention plans must be based on a functional analysis assessment. Therefore, prior to revising STUDENT's plan, it is necessary for Respondents to conduct a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT's behaviors.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that an appropriate placement for STUDENT includes the following: a behavioral intervention plan to address inappropriate touching and running away; a small, structured, and safe environment with same-aged peers with similar functional abilities; a low student-to-teacher ratio; opportunities for one-to-one and small-group instruction; and instruction in functional academics and communication, pre-vocational, independendent-living, self-help, and social skills.
Does Ms. Curran's SED SDC offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
Under Rowley and IDEA, an appropriate placement must first conform to STUDENT's IEP. The evidence establishes that a speech and language therapist works with students in Ms. Curran's class and would also be available to provide STUDENT with services. Transportation is available to the students in the class. Ms. Curran testified credibly as to the ways in which the curriculum in her class would address STUDENT's goals and objectives. Petitioner's presented no persuasive evidence to rebut Respondents' testimony regarding the ability of the instruction and services available in Ms. Curran's class to conform to STUDENT's IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Curran's SDC conforms with STUDENT's IEP.
An appropriate placement must also provide specially designed instruction and services to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs. All of Respondents' witnesses who expressed an opinion regarding Ms. Curran's class testified that the curriculum, structure, and physical layout of the class are designed to provide instruction in independent-living, self-help, pre-vocational skills, and functional academics. The curriculum of the class also focuses on developing communication skills. The speech and language therapist provides weekly therapy to students individually and in small groups. The students regularly participate in community-based activities. Ms. Curran testified that she has experience implementing individual behavioral intervention plans. Ms. Grites, educational specialist from CHC, concurred that Ms. Curran's SED SDC offers an appropriate curriculum for STUDENT and would meet his need to develop his daily-living skills. Given the small number of students in the class, there are opportunities for individual and small-group instruction. There are currently eight students in the class, one teacher, and one instructional assistant. Even with the addition of STUDENT to the class, the student-to-teacher ratio is sufficiently low to meet STUDENT's needs. The witnesses agreed that Ms. Curran's class is structured. Based on the evidence regarding the curriculum and services available in Ms. Curran's class, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed placement offers instruction and services that are designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs.
The final requirement of an appropriate placement for STUDENT is that the instruction and services must be designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. To address one of STUDENT's primary needs --to improve his behavior--Ms. Curran testified that she will implement STUDENT's individual behavioral intervention plan. Opportunities in Ms. Curran's class to develop self-help, pre-vocational, independent-living, social, and communication skills will assist STUDENT to become as independent as possible, given his disability. It is noted also that STUDENT made some progress toward meeting his goals and objectives when previously in Ms. Curran's class. The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that the instruction and services in Ms. Curran's class are designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
The PARENTS questioned the appropriateness of placing STUDENT in an SED SDC that lacks an appropriate peer group. MOTHER and SISTER testified that a class for students with emotional problems is not appropriate for STUDENT because he has limited cognitive abilities and has never been diagnosed as having emotional problems. They noted also that by placing STUDENT with students with emotional problems, there is the potential for him to copy their inappropriate behavior. In support of their position, the PARENTS pointed to STUDENT's IEPs, which designate him eligible for special education as "LIF," and to the CHC report that states STUDENT does not meet "criteria for an emotionally-based psychiatric disorder at this time." The CHC report also notes that STUDENT's current behavioral problems are "consistent with a diagnosis of mental retardation" and that he should be placed with like-aged and functioning peers. (Petitioner's Exhibit p. 32)
Ms. Yamane and Ms. Curran testified that the class includes students with behavioral and education needs similar to STUDENT's. The PARENTS did not provide any evidence that the specific students in Ms. Curran's class have dissimilar functional abilities or that they are not age-appropriate peers for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer is troubled by the fact that Ms. Curran's class is identified as SED and that one-half of the students in the class are designated as eligible for special education on the basis of SED. These facts do not, however, rebut the overwhelming testimony of other witnesses that Ms. Curran's class is appropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer particularly notes that Ms. Grites, who is employed by an independent agency that initially was contacted by Petitioner's attorney to conduct an assessment, concluded that STUDENT's needs could be met in Ms. Curran's class. Therefore, because the requirements of Rowley and IDEA have been satisfied, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Curran's class offers an appropriate placement for STUDENT.(Footnote 5)
Petitioner STUDENT contends that even if Ms. Curran's class offers him an appropriate placement, it is not the least restrictive environment in which to educate him. Petitioner asserts that all of the components of his educational program can be implemented in an LIF SDC on a regular education campus, thereby satisfying the federal mandate to educate students with disabilities in the least restrictive environment.
Does an LIF SDC offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
As discussed above, an appropriate placement must conform with STUDENT's IEP, offer instruction and services designed to meet his unique and individual needs, and offer him educational benefit. Respondents' witnesses did not dispute that an LIF SDC would offer STUDENT a program that conforms to his IEP and provide him appropriate instruction and services to meet his unique and individual needs. STUDENT has limited intellectual functioning and, according to CHC, his behavioral problems are commensurate with that designation. STUDENT's most recent SED SDC teachers testified that he has experienced problems in their classes, in part, because of the inappropriate peers in the classes. The Hearing Officer notes that these classes have included a number of students designated on their IEPs as seriously emotionally disturbed and who function at a higher level than STUDENT. According to Ms. Yamane, LIF SDCs are designed to meet the students' primary needs related to their lower cognitive abilities.
Respondents' witnesses contend that an LIF SDC would not be appropriate placement for STUDENT because LIF SDCs have a higher student-to-teacher ratio than SED SDCs. LIF SDCs generally have 12 students, a teacher, and an instructional assistant. Therefore, the student-to-teacher ratio of LIF SDCs is generally six-to-one. STUDENT currently is assisted by an individual aide. With the addition of this aide to an LIF SDC, the student-to-teacher ratio would be reduced to four-to-one, which is comparable to the ratio of non-categorical SED SDCs and, therefore, appropriate for STUDENT.
Ms. Gulas testified that an LIF SDC is not appropriate because STUDENT's IEP goals and objectives are primarily related to social and emotional issues, which are different from what is addressed in LIF SDCs. However, Ms. Yamane, who is also a COE employee, testified that LIF SDCs provide a curriculum that emphasizes development of social and community skills. An examination of STUDENT's IEP reveals that of six IEP goals, one is to improve social and behavioral skills. Other goals and objectives address development of fine-motor, functional academics, communication, and independent/self-help skills. (Respondent's Exhibit A, pp. 21-24) The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's goals and objectives are similar to those of other LIF students. STUDENT's behavior plan as written calls for implementation by the classroom teacher and there is no requirement that STUDENT's speech and language therapy be delivered in a particular type of SDC. STUDENT's IEP does not indicate that he requires any special equipment that would not already be available in an LIF class. The Hearing Officer finds, therefore, that there is nothing so unique in STUDENT's IEP that could not be implemented in an LIF SDC.
Ms. Gulas testified that an LIF SDC is also not appropriate for STUDENT because regular education students come into the class for reverse mainstreaming and may "overstimulate" STUDENT. There is evidence of STUDENT's positive experiences dealing with reverse mainstream peers. According to the report in his IEP in June 1993, STUDENT worked well with the peer tutors when doing an activity of his choice. (Respondents' Exhibit A, p. 67-80). Ms. Gulas also asserts that an LIF SDC is not appropriate because LIF students do not have individual aides, whereas STUDENT does. Placement decisions are individually determined and based on a number of factors. The fact that LIF students in her class do not have individual aides has little or no bearing on the appropriateness of an LIF class for another student who does require the assistance of an individual aide. For the reasons discussed above, the Hearing Officer gives little weight to Ms. Gulas' testimony on the appropriateness of an LIF class for STUDENT.
Based on the above, it is concluded that an LIF SDC with age-appropriate students with similar functional levels offers STUDENT a placement that conforms with his IEP, that provides him instruction and services that are designed to meet his unique and individual needs, and that is designed to provide him with educational benefit. Since both placements under consideration--Ms. Curran's class and an LIF SDC--have been determined appropriate for STUDENT, it is necessary to examine whether least restrictive environment requirements are met by placing STUDENT in Ms. Curran's class or whether least restrictive environment requirements compel placing STUDENT in an LIF SDC on a regular education campus.
What is the least restrictive placement for STUDENT?
The IDEA provides that States must ensure that "to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities...are educated with children who are not disabled, and that special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily." 20 U.S.C. § 1412(5)(B); 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.550-3-00.556. This is commonly referred to as the "least restrictive environment" or "LRE" requirement.
California special education law similarly provides:
Special classes and centers that enroll pupils with similar and more intensive educational needs shall be available. The classes and centers shall enroll the pupils when the nature or severity of the disability precludes their participation in regular school program for a majority of a school day. Special classes and centers and other removal of individuals with exceptional needs from the regular education environment shall occur only when education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily due to the nature or severity of the exceptional need.
In providing or arranging for the provision of activities, each public agency shall ensure that each individual with exceptional needs participates in those activities with nondisabled pupils to the maximum extent appropriate to the needs of the individual with exceptional needs, including nonacademic and extracurricular services and activities.
Education Code § 56364.
State law further provides that special education:
is an integral part of the total public education system and provides education in a manner that promotes maximum interaction between children or youth with disabilities and children or youth who are not disabled, in a manner that is appropriate to the needs of both.
Special education provides a continuum of program options to meet the educational and service needs of individuals with exceptional needs in the least restrictive environment.
Education Code § 56031.(Footnote 6)
In a case that is factually similar to this case, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeal addressed whether a student with severe developmental disabilities should be placed in a class at a segregated school for students with disabilities or in a similar class located on an integrated school site.(Footnote 7) The court vacated an earlier decision that ordered the student to attend a segregated county school for students with mental retardation. In remanding the case to the district court, the Sixth Circuit formulated the following test to determine whether a proposed placement satisfies the least restrictive environment requirement: In a case where the segregated facility is considered superior, the court should determine whether the services which make that placement superior could be feasibly provided in a non-segregated setting. If they can, the placement in the segregated school would be inappropriate under the act.
Roncker v. Walter (6th Cir. 1983) 700 F.2d 1058, cert.denied, 464 U.S. 864 (1983). The court also noted that the student's progress, or lack thereof, while attending a class on an integrated site is a relevant factor in determining the maximum extent to mainstream the student. The court went on to say, however, that this factor is not dispositive because it must be determined whether the district could have provided additional services at the regular school site to improve the student's performance.(Footnote 8)
Taken together, State and federal special education law require that students with disabilities be placed in the least restrictive environment. State and federal law also require that, prior to removing a student from a regular education class or environment, at minimum a reasonable attempt must be made to provide supplementary aids and services. One such supplementary service is a behavioral intervention plan. The California Legislature adopted Education Code §§ 56520-24 and 5 California Code of Regulations § 3052, which delineates under what circumstances and the manner in which behavioral intervention plans are to be implemented. The California Education Code specifies that behavioral interventions are to be utilized to "assure the pupil's placement in the least restrictive environment." Education Code § 56523(b)(2)(D). Title 5 CCR 3001(f) states that a behavioral intervention plan is developed when the student's behavior significantly interferes with the implementation of the IEP goals and objectives. The section goes on to state that behavioral intervention plans are designed to "provide the individual with greater access to a variety of community settings, social contacts and public events; and ensure the individual's right to placement in the least restrictive educational environment...." 5 CCR 3001(d).
A behavioral intervention plan was developed for STUDENT in June 1995; however, the plan addresses only hand-biting and does not address the major behavioral impediments to his successful placement on a regular school site. (According to COE witnesses and Ms. Davis, the significant behaviors are running away and inappropriate touching of peers.) Respondents agree that STUDENT's behavioral plan should be revised; however, they assert that the revision should not take place until STUDENT is in a permanent placement.
In this case, the primary reason Respondents propose to place STUDENT in a segregated rather than an integrated site is because of concerns for his safety related to certain inappropriate behaviors. There was no testimony establishing that a segregated site is inherently safer. It is unreasonable that Respondents' propose to place STUDENT on a segregated school site because of safety issues that are directly related to his tendency to inappropriately touch other students and to run away, and yet these behaviors are not addressed in STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan. The Hearing Officer finds that implementation of an appropriate behavioral intervention plan would likely alleviate Respondents concerns for STUDENT's safety on an integrated site and, thereby, allow STUDENT to be placed in a less restrictive environment with opportunities for mainstreaming.
In order to determine the least restrictive environment for a student, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals adopted a four-factor balancing test. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398; cert.denied, (1994) 114 S.Ct. 2679: The four factors to weigh, as applied to this case, are:
(1) the educational benefits available to STUDENT on a regular school site, supplemented with appropriate aids and services; (2) the non-academic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled; (3) the effect of STUDENT's presence on the students and teacher at the regular school site; and (4) the costs of the placement.
The first factor to consider is the educational benefits available to STUDENT on a regular school site, supplemented with appropriate aids and services. Until 1993, when STUDENT moved from the COE elementary to the secondary program, all of STUDENT's placements were located on regular school campuses. The evidence establishes that STUDENT made slow but steady growth in some academic areas as measured by the Brigance Inventory of Basic Skills. He also showed improvement in speech and language. (See Respondents' Exhibit A, pp. 68, 82, 92, and 104) Based on his past experience, there is a substantial likelihood that STUDENT will benefit educationally on a regular education campus.
The second factor to consider under Rachel H. is the non-academic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled. According to the testimony of MOTHER, which is supported by the CHC report, STUDENT models his behavior after the behavior of his peers. Given that Ms. Curran's class is on a segregated site, the opportunities for STUDENT to interact with nondisabled peers would be sporadic or nonexistent. On the regular education site, there will be regular education students for STUDENT to model. Peer tutors are also available to work with STUDENT within his own class. The Hearing Officer finds that the non-academic benefits of STUDENT's placement on a regular education site include improved social skills and behavior.
The third factor to consider under Rachel H. is the effect of STUDENT's presence on the students and teacher at the regular school site. The Ninth Circuit used the following factors in determining the effect of Rachel's presence on the teacher and students in the regular education placement: whether there would be detriment because the student was disruptive, distracting, or unruly; and whether the student would take up so much of the teacher's time that the other students would suffer from lack of attention.
The analysis of the third factor is complicated by the fact that there was not an appropriate behavioral intervention plan in effect while STUDENT was most recently on a regular school campus. To diminish disruptions to the class, an instructional assistant has been hired. The assistant was also necessary to allow the teacher to work with the other students in the class. The Hearing Officer finds that that, until the IEP team determines otherwise, the aide is necessary to continue to assist STUDENT. Several teachers expressed concern for STUDENT's safety on a regular campus. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that there are no substantiated reports of harm to STUDENT or to regular education students because of his presence on a regular school campus. Nor are there any reports of problems between STUDENT and regular students in the afternoon REACH program. The Hearing Officer notes also that when STUDENT was placed on a regular education campus, incidents of giggling, hand-biting, and hand-flapping, and some concerns regarding STUDENT's safety did not prevent his teacher from recommending to the IEP team in June of 1993 that STUDENT continue in a similar placement the next school year. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT's placement at that time included daily integration for lunch and recess, weekly integration in art and music, and participation in activities with regular education peer tutors.
As previously mentioned, STUDENT's last two placements included peers who were at a higher functional level than he was and also students designated as SED. The evidence suggests that placement in a class with students with similar needs and at the appropriate functional level, as well as the implementation of an appropriate behavioral intervention plan, will significantly lessen the possibility of STUDENT's disrupting the class or requiring a disproportionate amount of the teacher's time.
Under Rachel H., the costs of placement is the final factor to consider. Cost was not raised as a defense to placing STUDENT on an integrated school site nor does the evidence substantiate that the cost would be any greater to place STUDENT on a regular campus than at Palos Verdes. STUDENT currently has an instructional assistant and it is not clear whether he might also need an assistant in Ms. Curran's class.
The unusual circumstances of STUDENT's removal from Ms. Curran's class add to the reasons that support placing STUDENT elsewhere. Ms. Grites expressed reservation regarding the ability of Ms. Curran's class to be a successful placement for STUDENT without cooperation between the parents and staff. Even if the alleged abuse did not occur, STUDENT's mother and sister genuinely believe that it did, based on their observations of STUDENT and what he related to them. They testified credibly regarding the deterioration in STUDENT's behavior during the time he attended Ms. Curran's class and their belief that STUDENT has some anxiety related to Palos Verdes.(Footnote 9)
Based on the discussion above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT would receive academic and non-academic benefits from placement on a regular education site and would not unduly disrupt the teacher or other students. Cost also is not a factor. The Hearing Officer finds also that with an appropriate behavioral intervention program and an additional instructional assistant, it is feasible to provide an appropriate program for STUDENT in an LIF SDC located on an integrated school site. Therefore, placement of STUDENT in an appropriate class on a regular education campus offers a less restrictive placement for STUDENT than does Ms. Curran's SDC, which is located on a segregated site. Moreover, because neither the aide nor an appropriate behavioral intervention plan have been provided to STUDENT in an appropriate class on a segregated site, the Hearing Officer determines that Respondents are required to provide these services to STUDENT before placing him on a segregated site where there are no opportunities for mainstreaming.
A specific LIF SDC was not addressed at the hearing. According to Ms. Yamane, LIF SDCs exist within the COE.(Footnote 10) Therefore, to satisfy appropriate placement and LRE requirements, Respondents shall identify and place STUDENT in an LIF SDC with age-appropriate peers with similar functional levels that is located on a regular school site. The LIF SDC shall also include the components set forth above in the section regarding STUDENT's unique and individual needs.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner prevailed on the issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
ORDER
(1) Within 10 calendar days of the date of this decision, Respondents shall commence a functional behavioral analysis of STUDENT that is consistent with the requirements set forth in Education Code §§ 56520-24 and Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3052.
(2) Within 25 calendar days of the date of this decision, Respondents shall convene an IEP meeting to revise STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan to addresses inappropriate behaviors including running away and inappropriate touching. The plan must comply with the requirements set forth in Education Code §§ 56520-24 and Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3052.
(3) Within 35 calendar days of the date of this decision, Respondents shall implement the revised behavioral intervention plan.
(4) Within 35 calendar days of the date of this decision, Respondents shall place STUDENT on a regular school campus in a special day class for students with limited intellectual functioning that includes the following: a small, structured, and safe environment; a low student-to-teacher ratio; same-aged peers with similar functional abilities; opportunities for one-to-one and small-group instruction; and instruction in functional academics and communication, pre-vocational, independendent-living, self-help, and social skills.
(5) To ensure the appropriate student-to-teacher ratio, Respondents shall continue to provide STUDENT with an instructional assistant in the LIF SDC.
(6) Within 65 calendar days of the date of this decision, Respondents shall convene an IEP meeting to make revisions, as needed, to the behavioral intervention plan.
DATED: February 21, 1996 _____________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES:
1. The County Office of Education (COE) provides special day classes throughout San Mateo County for students with significant disabilities. STUDENT's current class is designated "SED SDC." "SED" stands for seriously emotionally disturbed. The COE also has classes designated "LIF." "LIF" stands for limited intellectual functioning. (Respondents also use the term "BAGIF" to identify students with lower cognitive abilities. "BAGIF" stands for below average general intellectual functioning.) Bonnie Yamane, COE education services manager, provided information regarding the COE's LIF and SED classes. According to Ms. Yamane, the classes are alike in many ways. LIF SDCs are for students with limited intellectual functioning and are designed to meet the students' primary needs related to their lower cognitive abilities. The curriculum of LIF classes is more socially and community oriented than that of the SED classes. LIF classes generally have higher student-to-teacher ratios than SED classes. There are generally 12 students, one teacher, and one aide in LIF classes. SED SDCs serve students with emotional, behavioral, and other disorders, including limited intellectual functioning. Many of the students assigned to SDCs with an SED designation do not satisfy the clinical diagnosis of seriously emotionally disturbed. There are two levels of SED SDC classes: non-categorical and severely behavior disordered (SBD). For the most part, students in SBD classes are more likely than students in a non-categorical class to exhibit acting out behaviors. SBD classes generally have six students, one teacher, one full-time and one part-time aide, and some have therapists. Non-categorical SED SDCs generally have seven students, one teacher, and one aide.
2. Apparently Mr. Zatopa no longer represented the PARENTS
3. Ms. Davis noted that LEAP currently serves students beyond preschool age.
4. STUDENT's IEP does include objectives for STUDENT to refrain from inappropriately touching peers and flapping his arms. The IEP does not, however, delineate in any way how these objectives are to be achieved. (Respondents' Exhibit A, pp. 21-24)
5. The Hearing Officer does not make any finding that an SED SDC other than Ms. Curran's is appropriate for STUDENT.
6. The Hearing Officer notes that the State has adopted a policy whereby all newly constructed or purchased school facilities for use by special education students shall be located on an integrated school site so as to maximize interaction between special education and other students. The State has charged county offices of education with ensuring that this policy is carried out. Education Code § 17747.5(a) and (b).
7. The student, who was functioning between a two- and three-year-old level, was described by the court as "trainable mentally retarded."
8. A recent Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals case, Poolaw v. Bishop (9th Cir. 1995) 67 F.3d 830, stands for the narrow proposition that a school district need not provide supplemental aids and services prior to placing a student in a segregated site when previously provided supplemental aids and services and attempts to mainstream did not result in significant improvement in the student's academic or communicative skills. The facts in this case are distinguishable from the facts in Poolaw. In this case, STUDENT has attended classes on regular education campuses and has been mainstreamed with success in the past. Moreover, Respondents have not previously implemented an appropriate behavioral intervention plan to address STUDENT's behaviors.
9. The Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Piper, a COE program manager, described the FAMILY's belief as "genuine."
10. Even if such a class does not exist, an OSEP policy letter dated March 1986 states that "if the evidence establishes that a special class at a regular school site would be the least restrictive environment implementing the goals and objectives of an appropriate IEP, the hearing officer must order that type of placement. The public agency must then make the services available, unless the agency appeals the decision." OSEP Policy Letter, March 21, 1986, 211:384.
