California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 30, 2001

Student v. Bellflower Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 575-01 · Hearing Officer Maxine R. Benmour

Bellflower Unified cannot graduate a 19-year-old until it provides missing transition services; at least one year of training ordered.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 2 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A 19-year-old Bellflower High School student and his parents filed for hearing after Bellflower Unified said he had earned enough credits to graduate at the end of fall 2000 and was no longer eligible for special education. He had been eligible since kindergarten under specific learning disability and emotional disturbance, and he attended general education classes with resource support. The Hearing Officer found that he met the District's course and proficiency-exam requirements on his own. She did not accept the parents' argument that their homework help earned his grades. However, a valid diploma also requires adequate transition services. The District made appropriate community referrals and gave him work experience. It did not give enough job-related instruction. It also gave almost no training in daily living skills such as managing money, buying groceries, paying rent, and getting along with others. Because his transition services were incomplete, he had not finished his prescribed course of study and stayed eligible. The Hearing Officer also found that the District improperly ended his schooling in February 2001. The parents asked for transition services until age 22. Instead, the Hearing Officer ordered an independent living skills assessment within 30 days, an IEP-ITP (individual transition plan) meeting within 15 days after that, and at least one year of intensive job-related and independent living skills training. The IEP team will decide whether he needs more.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated adequate transition services as a condition of a valid diploma. A student who met credit and exam requirements stayed eligible because the district had not taught job-related and daily living skills. The Hearing Officer then ordered an assessment and a time-limited period of training rather than services until age 22.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Does Petitioner continue to be eligible for special education?

    Student met the District's course-credit and proficiency-exam requirements, but the District did not give enough job-related instruction or daily living skills training. Because transition services were incomplete, he had not finished his prescribed course of study and remains eligible. The District also improperly ended his schooling in February 2001. The parents' prior-notice claim was not reached.

  2. Student prevailed in partTransition

    Issue 2. If Petitioner continues to be eligible for special education, must the District provide him with transition services until he reaches twenty-two years of age?

    Instead of services until age 22, the District must provide at least one year of intensive job-related and independent living skills training, or until the student reaches the maximum age, whichever comes first. The IEP team will decide whether he needs more.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to assess. District to provide an independent living skills assessment by a qualified independent living skills expert within 30 calendar days of the decision, and to incorporate the expert's recommendations into the IEP-ITP goals and objectives.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days after the assessment is completed, District to convene an IEP-ITP meeting to develop a transition plan with appropriate goals and objectives. Student must be invited to all IEP-ITP meetings.
  • Order to provide or change services. District to provide job-related and independent living skills training under the IEP-ITP goals for a minimum of one year, starting immediately after the IEP-ITP meeting. The IEP-ITP team decides whether more training is needed beyond one year.
  • District to consult with the independent living skills expert throughout the training.
  • Goals must address job-related training (interviewing, resumes, job applications, interview dress), social interactions with co-workers, money management (budgeting, purchases, paying rent), and obtaining a driver's license.
  • District may not graduate the student until he completes appropriate transition services in job-related instruction and daily living skills, or reaches the statutory maximum age, whichever comes first.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994); Student v. Novato Unified School District, SN 886-94; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(c)(4); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3070

People named in the decision

  • Maricella Perez, advocate for Student, Harbor Regional Center
  • Linda Smedley, District director of student services; District representative at hearing, Bellflower Unified School District
  • Juan Morataya, vocational rehabilitation counselor, California Department of Rehabilitation
  • Christine Basch, high school counselor, Bellflower Unified School District
  • Kathy Deeds, resource specialist (RSP teacher), Bellflower Unified School District
  • Geraldine Howe, school psychologist, Bellflower Unified School District
  • Barbara St. Clair, job developer and transition coordinator, Bellflower Unified School District
  • Meg Tan, assistant principal, Los Angeles County Office of Education

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Bellflower, California, on May 31 and June 1, 2001.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was present at the hearing and was represented by his parents, MOTHER and FATHER. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf for part of the hearing was Harbor Regional Center advocate Maricella Perez. Respondent Bellflower Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by Linda Smedley, District director of student services.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: STUDENT, Petitioner; MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother; FATHER, Petitioner’s father; and Maricella Perez, Harbor Regional Center advocate.

The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Juan Morataya, vocational counselor with the California Department of Rehabilitation; Christine Basch, District high school counselor; Kathy Deeds, District resource specialist; Geraldine Howe, District school psychologist; Barbara St. Clair, District job developer and transition coordinator; and Meg Tan, assistant principal with the Los Angeles County Office of Education.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the briefs on July 10, 2001, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

1. Does Petitioner continue to be eligible for special education?

2. If Petitioner continues to be eligible for special education, must the District provide him with transition services until he reaches twenty-two years of age?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a nineteen-year-old student at Bellflower High School who has been diagnosed with pervasive developmental disorder, right parietal lobe dysfunction, and depressive disorder. He has been eligible for special education since kindergarten under the categories of specific learning disability and emotional disturbance. The District placed STUDENT in a special day class (SDC) from kindergarten through the sixth grade. During middle school, the District placed STUDENT in an SDC for children with emotional disturbances with the Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE). STUDENT’s aggressive behavior during elementary and middle school improved with medication so that when STUDENT entered high school, the District placed him in regular education classes with resource support services (RSP).

When STUDENT was in the ninth grade, the District provided him with RSP, speech and language, counseling, and adaptive physical education services. In the tenth grade, the District provided only RSP and counseling services. In the eleventh and twelfth grades, STUDENT required no services other than some RSP assistance with his homework assignments.

In February 1998, when STUDENT was sixteen years old and in the tenth grade, the District held an individual transition plan (ITP)-individualized education program (IEP) meeting. The purpose of the meeting was to help STUDENT transition from school to either higher education or the work force. Goals at that time were for STUDENT to investigate the possibility of a job, for his parents to teach him life skills, and for STUDENT to seek out an extracurricular activity. His anticipated graduation date was 2000. In February 1999, when STUDENT was in the eleventh grade, another ITP-IEP meeting was held, and his goals were to attend a two-year college, to attend a trade/vocational school, or to enter the work force. His anticipated graduation date was June 2000.

During the summer following the tenth grade, as part of his ITP transition goals, STUDENT began to participate in the Summer Youth Employment Program of the Private Industry Council. He was employed as a part-time landscape maintenance worker at a local high school. The following summer, after the eleventh grade, STUDENT held a part-time custodial and landscape job at the District offices. He also worked part-time during the eleventh grade as a baggage handler at a local airport. During the twelfth grade, STUDENT worked as a part-time food services aide at his high school.

An ITP-IEP meeting was again held in April 2000, when STUDENT was in the twelfth grade. Because STUDENT’s anticipated graduation date of June 2000 was approaching, the purpose of the meeting was to review the status of his graduation. At the time of the meeting, STUDENT had earned a total of 195.5 school credits of a required 220 credits for graduation. Therefore, the team decided that his graduation would take place in June 2001, instead of June 2000, presuming that he would complete his remaining course requirements.(Footnote 2) STUDENT was to attend school for four hours a day in the 2000-2001 school year to complete the required credits.

STUDENT attended school in the fall of the 2000-2001 school year for four hours per day as agreed. During that semester, he took required classes in history, science, and English, and a Regional Occupational Program (ROP) elective class in computer repair. He completed 25 units that semester and achieved a grade point average of 2.20.

STUDENT’s last day of school at Bellflower High School was on February 7, 2001. On that day, two students expressed concern to teachers that STUDENT had a large notebook with pictures of guns and bombs in it. The District did not pursue any formal suspension or expulsion proceedings as a result of this situation. Instead, District personnel asked STUDENT to leave school.

Following this incident, an IEP meeting was held in February 2001. At the meeting, the District informed STUDENT and his parents that STUDENT had completed the necessary remaining credits for graduation at the end of the fall 2000-2001 semester. The team then discussed various options for STUDENT, including adult education classes within the District, community college classes, various work options such as training with the California Department of Rehabilitation (DR) or Harbor Regional Center, and counseling services to help him succeed at school or work.

Following the IEP meeting in February 2001, STUDENT and his parents decided that none of the proposed options was appropriate for him. Instead, they decided that the best course of action for STUDENT was a referral to LACOE for admission to its transition program for students with disabilities. On March 20, 2001, the IEP team, including a LACOE representative, met to discuss his request for a referral to the LACOE program. Although STUDENT and his parents disagreed, the District indicated that STUDENT had met the requirements to receive a diploma at the end of the fall semester. Therefore, STUDENT was no longer eligible for services from the District and also was not eligible for the LACOE program. In addition to earning a total of 262.50 credits at the end of the fall 2000-2001 semester, in February 2000, STUDENT had achieved passing scores on the District’s competency examinations in all required areas. Thus, according to the District, he had met all District requirements for graduation.

On March 22, 2001, STUDENT and his parents requested a due process hearing with the Special Education Hearing Office. The basis of the request was that STUDENT and his parents disagreed that STUDENT had completed the units necessary for graduation, and they believed that the District should provide STUDENT with additional transition services.

Following STUDENT’s request for a hearing, the District did not award him a diploma and agreed to place him in a District independent study program. In May 2001, STUDENT began this independent study program, and has continued in the program pending the outcome of his due process hearing.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Does Petitioner continue to be eligible for special education?

Petitioner contends that he continues to be eligible for special education services and has not met all of the requirements for graduation from Bellflower High School. STUDENT argues that although he achieved passing grades in the courses required for graduation and passed the District’s required proficiency examinations, he would not have achieved passing grades in some classes without the assistance of his parents. He further argues that he is not ready for the work force, as he requires independent living skills that he does not currently possess in order to live independently and obtain employment. Petitioner also argues that the District unilaterally decided to graduate him and did not give prior notice of this decision to him or his parents.

The District contends that it appropriately decided that Petitioner met all of the requirements for graduation because, in addition to passing proficiency examinations, he had achieved passing grades in all required courses and achieved the requisite number of credits to graduate from high school at the end of the fall semester of the 2000-2001 school year. The District further contends that STUDENT has sufficient independent living skills and can learn additional skills from community agencies such as Harbor Regional Center. Further, the District argues that Petitioner and his parents were aware of and agreed with the decision that STUDENT would graduate when he achieved the required number of credits, as they discussed this issue at every IEP-ITP meeting held since STUDENT was in the tenth grade.

Students with disabilities who are eligible for special education are entitled to receive special education services from the responsible local educational agency (LEA) until they receive a diploma or reach the statutory maximum age without receiving a diploma, whichever comes first. Once the LEA properly awards the student a diploma, the student generally has no right to receive further special education and related services, even if the student has not yet reached the statutory maximum age. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(1)(A).

In California, an individual with exceptional needs may receive special education if he or she is between the ages of 19 and 21 years, inclusive; is enrolled in or eligible for special education services prior to his or her 19th birthday; and has not yet completed his or her prescribed course of study or has not met prescribed proficiency standards. Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(c)(4). In addition, any person who becomes 22 years of age during the months of January through June, while participating in a special education program, may continue his or her participation in the program for the remainder of the current fiscal year, including any established extended school year program.(Footnote 3) Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(c)(4)(A). In other words, a student who has received special education services prior to age 19 may continue to receive special education services for a maximum of three years after age 19. In addition, although not applicable in this case, some students may be entitled to compensatory education beyond age 22. See Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F3d 1489, 1497.

Pursuant to Section 56026(c)(4), STUDENT has not yet reached the statutory maximum age for special education eligibility, since he is currently nineteen years old. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must determine whether he met the District’s requirements for the completion of his prescribed course of study or whether he met the District’s proficiency standards as designated in his IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(c)(4); Cal. Code of Regs., Title 5, § 3070.

With regard to the high school diploma that the District proposes to award to STUDENT, California Code of Regulations, Title 5, section 3070 specifies that:

When an individual with exceptional needs meets public education agency requirements for completion of prescribed course of study and adopted differential proficiency standards as designated in the pupil’s individualized education program, the public education agency which developed the individualized education program shall award the diploma.

In addition, prior to awarding a diploma to an individual with exceptional needs, the public education agency must provide the student with transition services that will enable the student to move from school to post-school activities, such as higher education or the work force. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1.

The evidence establishes that the District requires that a student complete a minimum of 220 course units in order to graduate. These units must be earned in specific areas as follows: 40 units in English, 20 units in mathematics, 10 units in biological sciences, 10 units in physical sciences, 10 units in additional math or science, 30 units in social sciences, 20 units in physical education, 10 units in fine arts/foreign language, 5 units in health, 5 units in economics, 5 units in applied academics, and 55 units in electives. In addition to these course requirements, a student must pass proficiency tests in reading, writing, paragraph, mathematics, and computer literacy in order to graduate.

A review of STUDENT’s transcript reveals that he completed a total of 262.50 course units in regular education classes at the end of the fall semester of the 2000-2001 school year. In addition, his transcript indicates that he earned 40 units in English, 20 units in mathematics, 20 units in biological and physical sciences, 10 units in additional math or science, 30 units in social sciences, 20 units in physical education, 10 units in fine arts/foreign language, 5 units in health, 5 units in economics, 5 units in applied academics, and 97.50 units in electives. Thus, STUDENT’s transcript reflects fulfillment of the course requirements for graduation. In addition, STUDENT’s transcript reveals that, in February 2000, he passed the District’s competency examinations in reading, writing, paragraph, mathematics, and computer literacy. Therefore, the evidence establishes that STUDENT met the District’s requirements for graduation, as he achieved the requisite number of course units in the required subjects and achieved passing scores on the District’s proficiency examinations.

Petitioner argued at hearing, however, that he failed some courses and did not actually earn some of the passing grades he achieved because he would not have earned these grades without assistance from his parents. Both of STUDENT’s parents testified that they helped STUDENT with his homework because they believed that he did not always understand his assignments. In addition, the District granted STUDENT’s mother permission to assist him in history class during his last semester by attending class with him and copying the teacher’s notes and assignments from the blackboard. His mother testified that STUDENT required this assistance because he was unable to process information due to his learning difficulties.

District witnesses Christine Basch, Kathy Deeds, and Geraldine Howe all testified that they believed STUDENT was capable of earning passing grades in his classes. STUDENT’s transcript provided partial support for this testimony. STUDENT’s A and B grades in most of his ROP and computer classes, as well as his B and C grades in many academic subjects, supported their belief that STUDENT was capable of doing well in school. Although STUDENT failed several classes in ninth, tenth, and eleventh grades, Ms. Basch’s opinion was that he did so because he had no interest in those subjects and often slept during class.(Footnote 4) Ms. Basch explained that she believed STUDENT had failed several classes in English, mathematics, and history because he was not interested in the subject matter. Her opinion was that he did not sleep in classes that interested him. His transcript also indicates that he was able to pass the classes he failed when he repeated them in later semesters.

RSP teacher Ms. Deeds similarly testified that STUDENT achieved higher grades in classes that interested him. She attributed his below average and failing grades to his failure to do classwork; she also indicated that he slept during class. According to Ms. Deeds, when STUDENT failed to finish his homework at home, he was able to complete his assignments in class. In addition, school psychologist Ms. Howe testified that STUDENT’s teachers had informed her that STUDENT lacked motivation in some of his classes. STUDENT’s high school report cards contained similar comments from many of his teachers, stating that STUDENT did not complete assignments, did well in elective classes that he enjoyed, and lacked self-motivation.

On the basis of the testimony of the parents and teachers, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that STUDENT earned the required passing grades that he received in high school primarily on his own. Although his parents testified that STUDENT did not do his homework or classwork because of his learning disability, they presented no evidence that this was the actual cause of STUDENT’s failure to complete class assignments. In fact, they made these allegations without any support, as the evidence was to the contrary. MOTHER testified that no doctor had advised her that STUDENT was unable to do school work because of his learning disability. Further, records from STUDENT’s doctor at Kaiser indicates that STUDENT’s mother informed the doctor that STUDENT lacked motivation to do his homework because he would rather spend time playing video games.

In addition, other evidence in the record supports the District’s position that STUDENT is capable of performing regular education school work in academic areas. In the tenth grade, STUDENT scored in the average range on standardized testing completed by the school psychologist. Further, the District placed STUDENT in all academic classes, including college preparatory classes, throughout high school because of his average abilities. Although he earned below average and failing grades in some classes, as discussed previously, he achieved average and above average grades in many classes, including academic classes. In addition, STUDENT was able to pass the District’s required competency examinations in all areas tested without the use of differential standards.(Footnote 5) Moreover, he was able to pass these examinations without the assistance of his mother. In light of this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds the testimony of the District witnesses persuasive that STUDENT was capable of higher grades in those classes in which he did not achieve passing grades, but failed these classes because he lacked motivation in classes when he had no interest in the subject matter.

Further, STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives demonstrate that he was capable of performing the work required of him in regular education high school classes. Beginning in the tenth grade, STUDENT’s IEP contained only four goals, in the areas of math, reading, written language, and work habits. By the time that STUDENT was in the twelfth grade in April 2000, he had met his reading, math, and written language goals. The attainment of these IEP goals further indicates that STUDENT was capable of performing regular education school work.

Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT received passing grades in the District’s required number of courses for graduation from high school. In addition, as indicated previously, STUDENT also passed the District’s required proficiency examinations for graduation in all required areas.

Given the Hearing Officer’s finding that STUDENT met the District’s requirements for graduation, the final consideration as to whether or not STUDENT has completed his prescribed course of study is whether the District has provided STUDENT with adequate transition planning and services prior to graduation. Because the IDEA does not contemplate the provision of special education or related services beyond graduation, a fundamental prerequisite to awarding a valid diploma to a special education student is that adequate transition planning and services have been provided. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1.

California Education Code § 56345.1 provides that, beginning at age 16, a student’s IEP shall contain a statement of needed transition services to promote movement from school to post- school activities, including such items as postsecondary education, vocational training, and integrated employment. These services must be based upon the individual student’s needs, taking into account the student’s preferences and interests. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1(c)(2). (d) In addition, the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act provides that all children with disabilities have available to them a free appropriate public education that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and to ultimately prepare them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 188.

Transition services provided to special education students must include instruction, related services, community experiences, the development of employment and other post-school adult living objectives, and, when appropriate, acquisition of daily living skills and functional vocational education. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1(b) and (c). See also Student v. Novato Unified School District, SN 886-94, 22 IDELR 1056 (April 14, 1995).

The Hearing Officer thus must determine if, in providing transition services to STUDENT, the District provided such services in the required areas of job-related instruction, community experiences, employment and other post-adult living objectives, and the acquisition of daily living skills, if appropriate.

First, with regard to the area of instruction, the evidence reveals that the District’s transition services failed to include sufficient job-related instruction. A review of STUDENT’s transcript and the testimony of Ms. Deeds indicates that STUDENT was enrolled in “economics/transition” classes during his senior year in high school. Ms. Deeds described these classes as teaching interviewing skills, resume writing, completion of job applications, appropriate dress for interviews, and punctuality. There is little evidence that these courses sufficiently covered the requisite skills needed by STUDENT to function in the workplace. Although Ms. St. Clair testified that STUDENT arrived very punctually to his part-time jobs, there was no evidence that he had learned any of the other job-related skills taught in these classes. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District failed to provide required instruction to STUDENT in its provision of transition services.

Secondly, as to community experiences, Juan Morataya, vocational rehabilitation counselor from DR, testified that his agency was available to provide community experiences to STUDENT. Mr. Morataya stated that the District referred STUDENT to DR’s Transition Partnership Program in 1998. Mr. Morataya further testified that his agency has contracts with a number of community groups providing job training and job coaching. Mr. Morataya also testified that STUDENT is eligible to receive these services from DR as soon as he finishes high school. The evidence thus reveals that the District provided STUDENT with appropriate community experiences in his transition plan.

Thirdly, the evidence discloses that STUDENT was successful in his goal of obtaining summer and part-time employment beginning in the summer after the tenth grade, and continuing throughout the eleventh and twelfth grades. According to Ms. St. Clair, his transition coordinator, and his ROP teachers, STUDENT performed very well at his various part-time jobs and earned mostly A and B grades in his ROP classes. Although both of STUDENT’s parents testified that they did not believe that STUDENT was ready for the workplace, the evidence reveals that STUDENT’s ROP teachers and his employment supervisors found him to be an excellent worker, needing only occasional assistance with tasks he did not enjoy. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with the development of employment and other post adult living objectives as part of his transition plan.

Finally, there is little evidence that the District taught STUDENT any daily living skills. Both parents testified that they believed STUDENT does not currently possess the skills needed to live independently. They testified credibly that he lacks appropriate social skills, cannot keep track of money expenditures, does not know how to buy groceries or pay rent, and is emotionally not ready to achieve his goal of obtaining a driver’s license. STUDENT’s lack of social skills was corroborated by the testimony of Ms. Deeds that STUDENT sometimes bothered other students during class. In addition, both District and Petitioner’s witnesses testified that STUDENT made inappropriate drawings when he became angry with someone.

With regard to STUDENT’s money management skills, STUDENT’s mother testified credibly that the Social Security Administration made her STUDENT’s representative payee for his Supplemental Security Income benefits because he cannot manage his money independently. Ms. Deeds testified that she taught STUDENT how to budget money in her math class, and believed that he learned these skills. However, other than this testimony, there was no evidence that anyone taught STUDENT skills related to keeping track of expenditures, buying groceries, or paying rent. In addition, at the beginning of twelfth grade, STUDENT’s ITP-IEP team indicated that financial planning was an issue of concern for him.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony that the acquisition of daily living skills is a critical area of need for STUDENT in his transition from school to the work force, and that the District committed a significant failure in not providing STUDENT with training in his area of greatest need. In fact, Ms. Deeds testified that she did not teach STUDENT living skills in her class, and that she believed that he would benefit from such instruction. The undisputed evidence is that STUDENT is currently unable to live independently, pay rent, purchase food and other items, obtain a driver’s license, or relate appropriately to other people.

The evidence thus establishes that although the District held annual ITP-IEP meetings with STUDENT and his parents beginning at age sixteen, it failed to provide STUDENT with all of the appropriate transition services. From the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to provide STUDENT with sufficient job-related instruction and training in the acquisition of daily living skills as required in its provision of transition services. Because STUDENT did not complete transition planning and services, he did not complete his prescribed course of study and is not yet eligible to receive a high school diploma. Therefore, the District shall not graduate STUDENT from high school until he either completes transition services that reflect his unique needs and provide him with appropriate benefit in the areas of job-related instruction and the acquisition of daily living skills, or reaches the statutory maximum age for special education eligibility, whichever comes first.(Footnote 6)

In addition, since STUDENT continues to be eligible for special education, the District improperly terminated him from school in February 2001. If the District had reason to believe that STUDENT committed inappropriate activities in school, and it believed that such activities were not related to his disability, the District could have taken measures to suspend or expel him from school. However, it could not terminate special education status or services. Services to a special education student may be terminated if he or she graduates or reaches the maximum age for eligibility, as discussed herein, or if the local education agency determines that the student is no longer eligible for special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(1)(A); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(5). As neither of these categories applies to this case, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not properly terminate STUDENT’s education in February 2001.

ISSUE NO. 2: If Petitioner continues to be eligible for special education, must the District provide him with transition services until he reaches twenty-two years of age?

As indicated in the previous section, STUDENT continues to be eligible for special education because the District failed to provide him with transition services in the areas of job-related instruction and the acquisition of daily living skills. Therefore, STUDENT is eligible for special education until he either completes transition services in the areas of job-related instruction and daily living skills, or reaches the statutory maximum age for special education eligibility, whichever comes first. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(c)(4).

The Hearing Officer recognizes that given STUDENT’s severe deficits and long-term neglect in the area of the acquisition of job-related instruction and independent living skills, he needs an intensive program with services that focus on these skills. However, the Hearing Officer also recognizes that, in light of the fact that STUDENT is currently nineteen years old, he requires that this training be provided as quickly as possible so that he can enter the work force and begin to live independently.

Because of STUDENT’s critical needs in the areas of job-related instruction and independent living skills, and the necessity that these services be provided as quickly as possible, the Hearing Officer concludes that independent living skills provided during a three-year period would not meet STUDENT’s need for provision of services in a timely fashion. The Hearing Officer finds that a minimum of one year of intensive training is more suited to ensuring that STUDENT’s severe needs are met as expeditiously as possible. The Hearing Officer leaves it to the expertise of the IEP team to determine if STUDENT requires additional training at the end of one year.

Therefore, in order to meet STUDENT’s needs for job-related and independent living skills training for at least one year, the District shall provide STUDENT with an independent living skills assessment by a qualified independent living skills expert in order to determine the best way in which to provide this training to STUDENT. The District shall incorporate the recommendations of the independent living skills expert in formulating and implementing STUDENT’s IEP-ITP goals and objectives. Following the completion of the independent living skills assessment, the District shall convene an IEP-ITP meeting to develop an IEP-ITP for STUDENT, with appropriate goals and objectives consistent with his other interests and activities. Further, in order to ensure that goals and objectives are appropriate for STUDENT and consistent with his other interests and activities, the District shall invite STUDENT to attend all IEP-ITP meetings. The District shall also consult with the independent living skills expert throughout the course of STUDENT’s training in order to ensure that appropriate training is being provided.

In addition, in developing appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT, the IEP team must carefully and fully address all of STUDENT’s important areas of transition needs, including but not limited to:

1. Job-related instruction in the areas of interviewing skills, resume writing, completion of job applications, and appropriate dress for interviews.

2. Appropriate social interactions with co-workers and supervisors.

3. Money management skills, including budgeting, making purchases, and paying rent.

4. Obtaining a driver’s license.

ORDER

1. The District shall provide STUDENT with an independent living skills assessment by a qualified independent living skills expert in order to determine the best way to provide this training to STUDENT. The District shall incorporate the recommendations of the independent living skills expert in formulating and implementing STUDENT’s IEP-ITP goals and objectives. This assessment shall be completed within thirty (30) calendar days of the date of this decision.

2. Within fifteen (15) calendar days of the completion of the independent living skills assessment, the District shall convene an IEP-ITP meeting for STUDENT to develop a transition plan with appropriate goals and objectives, consistent with STUDENT’s other interests and activities. The District shall invite STUDENT to attend all IEP-ITP meetings.

3. The District shall consult with the independent living expert throughout the course of STUDENT’s training to ensure that appropriate training is being provided.

4. The District shall provide STUDENT with job-related and independent living skills training, pursuant to his IEP-ITP goals and objectives, for a minimum of one year. The IEP-ITP team shall determine if STUDENT requires any additional training beyond one year. Services shall begin immediately after the IEP-ITP meeting.

5. In developing appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT, the IEP-ITP team must carefully and fully address all of STUDENT’s important areas of transition needs, including but not limited to:

a. Job-related training in the areas of interviewing skills, resume writing, completion of job applications, and appropriate dress for interviews.

b. Appropriate social interactions with co-workers.

c. Money management skills, including budgeting, making purchases, and paying rent.

d. Obtaining a driver’s license.

6. All of Petitioner’s remaining claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Does Petitioner continue to be eligible for special education? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

2. If Petitioner continues to be eligible for special education, must the District provide him with transition services until he reaches twenty-two years of age? Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that the District must provide him with transition services for a minimum of one year, unless the IEP team decides otherwise, or until he reaches the statutory maximum age for special education eligibility, whichever comes first.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: July 30, 2001 ____________________________________ Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1.For purposes of clarification and orderly adjudication, the Hearing Officer has reorganized Petitioner’s statement of the issues. 2.District school counselor Christine Basch testified that the District does not have mid-year graduation ceremonies. Therefore, IEP documents always include the standard graduation ceremony date of June even when students complete graduation requirements at the end of the fall semester. 3.STUDENT’s date of birth is [date redacted]. Therefore, the provisions of this section apply to him if he continues to be eligible for special education services. 4.STUDENT’s mother testified that she also observed STUDENT sleeping in class when she attended his history class. However, she attributed his sleeping to feeling overwhelmed by the subject matter. 5.A special education student may complete a district’s prescribed course of study and thus be eligible for graduation by passing proficiency tests that are based upon differential standards as determined by a student’s IEP team. Cal. Code. Regs., Title 5, § 3070. However, this provision does not apply to STUDENT as he was able to pass the District’s proficiency examinations for regular education students. 6.Because of the Hearing Officer’s finding that STUDENT is not yet eligible for high school graduation, there is no need to address Petitioner’s contention that the District failed to give him appropriate notice of its intent to graduate him.