California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 13, 2000

Student v. Westside Union Elementary School District

SEHO Case No. SN 580-99 · Hearing Officer Judy F. Hirano

Westside Union Elementary must reimburse two independent evaluations; Hearing Officer finds kindergartner with ADHD not eligible for special education.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 10 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The family of a kindergartner with ADHD, sensory integration disorder and fine motor delays filed for due process against Westside Union Elementary School District. The boy enrolled at Cottonwood Elementary School in April 1998 and repeated kindergarten in 1998-1999. The family argued that he qualified for special education as other health impaired. They sought a finding that he was denied a FAPE, reimbursement for private occupational therapy, compensatory education, and reimbursement for three private assessments.

Hearing Officer Judy Hirano found that the boy's ADHD did limit his alertness in class. However, it did not substantially harm his educational performance. His spring 1998 retention reflected his young age and the weeks of school he had missed. In 1998-1999, his teacher's accommodations helped him meet or exceed kindergarten benchmarks, and he got along with peers. Because he was not eligible, his claims for a FAPE, occupational therapy and compensatory education failed.

The Hearing Officer still found the district's assessment inappropriate. The district never did the occupational therapy assessment in its own January 1999 plan. Its school psychologist was not familiar with sensory integration disorder. Its IQ results were unreliable because the boy could not sit still during testing. The district was ordered to reimburse the occupational therapy evaluation by Mim Anspacher and Dr. Esther Sinclair's psychoeducational evaluation at UCLA. Reimbursement for an Education Spectrum assessment was denied because it duplicated those evaluations.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO kept eligibility and IEE reimbursement separate. A parent could recover the cost of independent evaluations even though the student was found not eligible. Here the district had skipped a planned occupational therapy assessment and relied on IQ scores from a session the student could not sit through. Reimbursement was limited to one evaluation per area.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1a. Was Petitioner eligible for special education because of an other health impairment from April 28, 1998, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year?

    ADHD caused limited alertness, but his kindergarten retention reflected his young age and at least eight weeks of missed school, so a substantial adverse effect on his educational performance was not shown.

  2. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1b. Was Petitioner eligible for special education because of an other health impairment during the 1998-1999 school year?

    With his teacher's accommodations, the student met or exceeded kindergarten benchmarks and got along with peers, so his ADHD did not adversely affect his educational performance to a substantial degree.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2a. If so, did the District provide Petitioner a FAPE from April 28, 1998, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year?

    The student was not eligible, so he was not entitled to a FAPE under the IDEA during this period.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2b. If so, did the District provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year?

    The student was not eligible, so he was not entitled to a FAPE under the IDEA during this period.

  5. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Did a FAPE during the relevant period of the 1997-1998 school year and the entire 1998-1999 school year require occupational therapy as a related service?

    Because the student was not eligible for special education, he was not entitled to occupational therapy as a related service.

  6. Issue 4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of occupational therapy he received while enrolled in the District?

    Reimbursement for private occupational therapy was denied because the student was not eligible for special education.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. If the District failed to provide a FAPE from April 1998 through the end of the 1998-1999 school year, is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education?

    No compensatory education was owed because the student was not eligible and was not entitled to a FAPE.

  8. Issue 6a. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the occupational therapy evaluation by Mim Anspacher, O.T.R.?

    The District's assessment was inappropriate: it never did the occupational therapy assessment in its own plan, did not assess sensory integration, fine motor or attention, and its psychologist was unfamiliar with sensory integration disorder. Reimbursement was ordered.

  9. Issue 6b. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the psychoeducational evaluation by Esther Sinclair, Ph.D.?

    The District's IQ results were not reliable because the student could not sit still during testing, so its psychoeducational assessment was inappropriate. Reimbursement for Dr. Sinclair's assessment was ordered.

  10. Issue 6c. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the Education Spectrum developmental assessment?

    Denied. It duplicated areas covered by the reimbursed assessments, no disagreement with the District's assessment in those other areas was shown, and no assessor testified to the assessment or to the assessors' qualifications.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 25 calendar days of the decision, Petitioner must submit proof of costs to the District. Within 30 calendar days of receiving the proof, the District must reimburse the cost of the occupational therapy evaluation by Mim Anspacher, O.T.R. The amount is not stated.
  • Reimbursement. Within 25 calendar days of the decision, Petitioner must submit proof of costs to the District. Within 30 calendar days of receiving the proof, the District must reimburse the cost of the psychoeducational evaluation by Esther Sinclair, Ph.D. The amount is not stated.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(f); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026; Cal. Educ. Code § 56339; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56322; Cal. Educ. Code § 56324

People named in the decision

  • Regina Rossall, assistant superintendent for educational services, Westside Union Elementary School District
  • Mim Anspacher, private occupational therapist; independent evaluator and witness for Student, Glendale Adventist Medical Center Rehabilitation Institute
  • Esther Sinclair, Ph.D., educational psychologist; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student, UCLA School of Medicine, Division of Child Psychiatry
  • Billy Lindoff, kindergarten teacher, Cottonwood Elementary School
  • Kathleen Inman, adapted physical education specialist, Los Angeles County Office of Education
  • Brenda Martin, resource specialist, Westside Union Elementary School District
  • Lonnie Woodley, school psychologist, Westside Union Elementary School District
  • Stephanie Reble, speech therapist, Los Angeles County Office of Education
  • Diane Howard, education specialist, private developmental assessor, Education Spectrum, Inc.
  • Kathy Hollimon, education specialist, private developmental assessor, Education Spectrum, Inc.
  • Robert Nickel, developmental pediatrician (prior evaluation), Child Development and Rehabilitation Center, Oregon Health Sciences University
  • Sharon Fridrick, occupational therapist (prior evaluation), Child Development Clinic, Oregon Health Sciences University
  • Saratoga Clinic, private occupational therapy provider, Ventura, California
  • Education Spectrum, Inc., private assessment agency, Altadena, California

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Quartz Hill, California, on August 31 and September 2 and 3, 1999.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Carol Hickman Graham. Also present on STUDENT'S behalf was his mother, PARENT. Respondent Westside Union Elementary School District (hereinafter District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Jan Tomsky. Also present on the District's behalf was Regina Rossall, assistant superintendent for educational services.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: PARENT, Petitioner's mother; Mim Anspacher, occupational therapist; Esther Sinclair, Ph. D., educational psychologist and associate professor, Division of Child Psychiatry, University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA) School of Medicine; and Billy Lindoff, kindergarten teacher at Cottonwood Elementary School (Cottonwood).

Respondent called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Kathleen Inman, adapted physical education specialist, Los Angeles County Office of Education; Brenda Martin, District resource specialist; Lonnie Woodley, District school psychologist; and Billy Lindoff, Cottonwood kindergarten teacher.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for a decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 1)

1. Was Petitioner eligible for special education because of an other health impairment during the following periods: a. from April 28, 1998, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year? b. during the 1998-1999 school year?

2. If so, did the District provide Petitioner a free appropriate public education during the following periods: a. from April 28, 1998, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year? b. during the 1998-1999 school year?

3. Did a FAPE during the relevant period of the 1997-1998 school year and during the entirety of the 1998-1999 school year require occupational therapy as a related service?

4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of occupational therapy he received during the time he was enrolled in the District?

5. If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE from April 1998 through the end of the 1998-1999 school year, is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education?

6. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the following: a. occupational therapy evaluation by Mim Anspacher, O.T.R.?

b. psychoeducational evaluation by Esther Sinclair, Ph.D.?

c. Education Spectrum developmental assessment?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner STUDENT is a seven-year-old boy who was adopted from a Russian orphanage at age 11 months. He was born with a hole in his heart, developed congestive heart failure, and had been left in the hospital by his natural parents because it was believed that he would not survive. According to his adoptive mother, at the time of the adoption, he had no muscular movement because he was left to lie in bed, with little interaction with others. After his adoption, he had corrective heart surgery for a ventricular septal defect in Los Angeles at age 14 months. After the surgery, his gross and fine motor movement increased.

STUDENT has been diagnosed with Sensory Integration Syndrome and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). At age 4, he was diagnosed with a significant delay in fine motor skills and received Early Childhood Special Education services in Oregon pursuant to an Individualized Family Service Plan. At age 4-1/2, he was described as suffering from symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder. When he was age 5 and attending kindergarten in the Hueneme Elementary School District (ESD) in Ventura County, pursuant to a Section 504 plan he received occupational therapy to address fine motor skills problems with cutting and coloring. After he left the Hueneme ESD, he continued to received private occupational therapy.

PRESCHOOL YEARS

In August 1994, STUDENT attended the Child Development Center at Glendale Community College. He interacted well with other children on a one-to-one basis but became overwhelmed, "frenzied," and more active and irritable with more than one child or when the noise level increased. His teacher reported that he was easily frustrated, and the teacher expressed concern about his need to be loud, high activity level, and refusal to wear his eyeglasses.

In July 1996, when STUDENT was age 3 years, 9 months, he underwent a child development clinic evaluation at the Center for Child Development and Developmental Disabilities of the University of Southern California (USC). He was referred by his pediatrician because of "sensory integration syndrome," which was described as a "circuit overload" (that is, STUDENT"loses control and can't regain it"). His mother expressed concern that he was easily frustrated and, when frustrated, internalized his anger by banging his head and biting himself. The Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale L-M and Gesell Formboard were administered. During the testing in a one-to-one situation, STUDENT was easily distracted but was able to attend to tasks when firm limits were set. He also persevered when given praise and encouragement. However, in an unstructured play/interview situation, he displayed poor judgment and poor control and put himself at risk by engaging in activities such as throwing objects and, when frustrated, biting his hands. He appeared to be irritable, frustrated, and badly in need of appropriate restraint, but his mother acknowledged that she was unable to exercise such restraint.

On the Stanford-Binet, STUDENT attained a mental age of 4 years, 1 month, in the average intelligence range. His overall adaptive behavior was also at the 4 year, 1 month level. However, his ability to perform fine-motor, visual-perceptual tasks was at the 2-to 3-year level. Overall, he showed strengths in verbal memory and ability to match and discriminate geometric forms, verbalize basic analogies, and identify objects by use. He showed a slight weakness in fine motor skills. The report recommended a highly structured therapeutic nursery program to provide a supportive environment where limits would be set and safe play activities provided. It also recommended that his mother receive counseling in behavior management and parenting techniques. Finally, the report recommended occupational therapy (OT).

In November and December 1996, when STUDENT was age 4 years, 2 months, he was evaluated by the Douglas Education Service District in Roseburg, Oregon, for eligibility for Early Childhood Special Education (ECSE) services by an early intervention/early childhood special education specialist, a speech pathologist, and an occupational therapist. At the time, his mother had concerns about his motor development and activity level. On the Taylor Hyperactivity Screening Checklist, STUDENT scored in the "mild" and "moderate" range of hyperactivity based upon the mother's and teacher's completion of the checklist, respectively. On the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, STUDENT scored within the average range in social skills and was somewhat below average in daily living skills. On the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test- Revised, STUDENT obtained a standard score of 94, at the 34 percentile. On the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised, he scored a 104, at the 61 percentile. On the Goldman Fristoe Test of Articulation, STUDENT obtained a score at the 67 percentile. His rate of speech, voice quality and fluency were subjectively judged to be within normal limits.

On the Peabody Developmental Fine Motor Scale, STUDENT'S performance suggested a significant delay in fine motor skills. He obtained a T-score of 27, at the 1 percentile and 35-month age-equivalent level (he was age 50 months at the time). He had difficulty unbuttoning buttons and cutting with scissors. He did not have a definite hand dominance and still used an immature gross pencil grasp. He displayed a low frustration level, which appeared to interfere with his ability to do more fine motor activities. Although he was almost constantly in motion, only occasional redirection was required to complete the testing. The report stated that the results would be shared with the Early Intervention Team to determine STUDENT'S eligibility for ECSE services and suggested that STUDENT be evaluated at the Child Development and Rehabilitation Center in Eugene for his attending difficulty and high activity level. The information in the record is that STUDENT was found eligible for ECSE services based upon delays in fine motor skills and an Individualized Family Service Plan was developed.

On March 17, 1997, STUDENT was evaluated by developmental pediatrician Robert Nickel at the Child Development Clinic of the Child Development and Rehabilitation Center of Oregon Health Sciences University in Eugene, Oregon. His mother's main concerns were inattention and low frustration tolerance. Dr. Nickel stated that during the examination, STUDENT was very distractible, impulsive, and overactive but could be redirected with physical structure. Dr. Nickel diagnosed STUDENT with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) based upon the Child Behavior Checklist completed by the mother, discussion with the family related to the DSM-IV criteria, and observations in the clinic. He recommended assistance with behavioral management for the mother and consideration of a medication trial. Dr. Nickel stated that Early Childhood Special Education services would commence shortly to address STUDENT'S fine motor delay.

Also on March 17, 1997, STUDENT was evaluated by occupational therapist Sharon Fridrick at the Child Development Clinic when he was age 4 years, 6 months (54 months). His mother had noted hypersensitivity in his ability to process sensory input and delays in his fine motor skills. Ms. Fridrick had to terminate sensory testing with the Southern California Sensory Integration Test because STUDENT had difficulty remaining in his chair and attending to the test items. Based upon the sensory history provided by his mother and clinical observations during the evaluation, Ms. Fridrick noted that STUDENT displayed tactile and auditory defensiveness, vestibular processing delays, and distractibility. Although his gross motor skills were not formally tested, STUDENT appeared to have a full active range of motion, muscle tone, and strength within normal age limits. However, on the Peabody Developmental Fine Motor Scales, STUDENT'S overall score was at the 39-month age-equivalent level and 1 percentile. On the Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration, his score was at the 3-year, 11-month skill level and 14 percentile. Ms. Fridrick also evaluated his activities of daily living. She concluded that STUDENT had delays in fine motor skills, self-help skills, visual motor integration, and sensory processing. His fine motor skills were 15 months below his age level. Ms. Fridrick recommended OT to improve fine motor skills and sensory processing abilities.

On March 17, 1997, a psychological evaluation of STUDENT was also conducted. Referral issues related to his high level of activity and fine motor skills. The report states that his high activity level, very much in evidence during the evaluation, was consistent with an ADHD diagnosis. It further states that STUDENT was described as suffering from a number of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms, including frequent nightmares, difficulty sleeping, and sensitivity to hot water, based upon information of a water burn when he was younger. Recommendations included a preschool program that provided structure and a calm setting, behavioral counseling and consultation, and a behavior plan.

On September 5, 1997, when STUDENT was age 4 years, 11 months (59 months), he was re-evaluated by a Douglas Education Service District occupational therapist in Roseburg, Oregon. On the Peabody Developmental Fine Motor Scale, he receive a T-score of 34, at a 49-month age-equivalent level and 5 percentile. He did not have a definite hand dominance, often used a gross pencil grasp, and had difficulty holding and cutting with scissors. His fine motor skills were impacted by his impulsivity. On the Wide Range of Visual Motor Abilities, STUDENT achieved a score at the 37 percentile in visual-spatial matching skills, at the 30 percentile in a pegboard fine motor test, and at the 9 percentile in visual-motor drawing skills. It appeared that his fine motor difficulties were motor-based with near age-appropriate visual-perceptual skills.

KINDERGARTEN YEARS

When STUDENT'S family moved to California, he enrolled in a kindergarten class in the Hueneme ESD in Ventura County in November 1997.

In January 1998, the Saratoga Clinic in Ventura, California, performed an OT evaluation of STUDENT. In executing paper-and-pencil tasks, he lacked dynamic fluid movement patterns. His muscle gradation of movement was poor and he lacked the ability to isolate specific muscles to accomplish pencil tasks efficiently. The automatic adaptations of trunk, arm, and hand were depressed for his age. His trunk muscles were particularly weak and decreased his ability to develop skilled upper body motor patterns. In addition, when performing gross motor tasks, he showed significant muscular fatigue and decreased efficiency of motor patterns. OT was recommended once-a-week for six months.

In February 1998, when STUDENT was age 5 and in a kindergarten class in the Hueneme ESD, his teacher referred him for a speech and language screening because of a concern regarding his articulation ability. The screening results revealed that he had age-appropriate articulation, although excessive saliva was observed. A February 11, 1998 Individualized Education Program (IEP) summarizes his health, self-help and communication skills, and cognitive and motor abilities based upon previous assessments. The IEP states that he had many sensory and attentional problems and recommends that his mother check with a doctor regarding other agencies' reports that STUDENT had attention deficit disorder. However, the IEP further states that he had no handicapping condition at the time but that the district would develop a Section 504 plan to include OT. A March 1998 Pupil Transfer Report from the Hueneme ESD states that STUDENT knew some of the upper and lower case letters and some of the numbers 1 to 10 and that he was working with an occupational therapist to learn to cut and color.

In April 1998, STUDENT transferred to a kindergarten class at Cottonwood Elementary School (Cottonwood) in the Westside Union Elementary School District (District). His kindergarten teacher, Billy Lindoff, testified that at the end of the school year, he recommended that STUDENT repeat kindergarten because of his immaturity and low skill level.

A September 20, 1998 letter from STUDENT'S mother to the principal of Cottonwood requested an assessment of STUDENT for special education. According to the letter, the parent believed that STUDENT had a sensory integration dysfunction which impacted his academic progress. The letter further stated that he had fine motor skill delays, hypersensitivity, and trouble focusing his attention, staying seated and in line, and drawing and writing. The letter also requested modifications and services under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act.

An October 1, 1998 Antelope Valley California Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA) health assessment report states that STUDENT passed the hearing test but failed the vision test without eyeglasses with 20/30 and 20/60 right and left vision results, respectively. The report states that he had glasses but would not wear them due to hypersensitivity. The report also notes a diagnosis of Sensory Integration Syndrome.

In an October 14, 1998 report, Lonnie Woodley, District school psychologist, presented the results of his psychoeducational evaluation when STUDENT was age six and in kindergarten. According to the report, STUDENT had been diagnosed with Sensory Integration Syndrome. On the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WISC-III), STUDENT had a 75 verbal IQ, 68 performance IQ, and 69 full scale IQ score. Mr. Woodley's report states that during the testing, STUDENT was extremely active and that the testing had to be terminated because STUDENT was unable to sit still. However, the report further states that the assessment procedures were valid for the student and for the intended purposes. According to the report, when STUDENT'S kindergarten teacher, Mr. Lindoff, was asked about STUDENT'S behavior during the testing, Mr. Lindoff stated that the behavior was not STUDENT'S normal behavior and that STUDENT was generally "fairly on task."

On the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, STUDENT had the following scores:

Domain Standard Score Percentile Rank Age-Equivalent Score

Communication 91 27 5-6

Daily Living Skills 81 10 4-6

Socialization 80 9 3-3

Motor Skills 82 12 4-3

In the area of social/emotional development, Mr. Woodley's report states that STUDENT seemed to have adapted well, worked well within his classroom interpersonal groups, and on the playground interacted and played appropriately with his peers. The report notes, however, that STUDENT was impulsive and that in future grades this type of behavior could inhibit appropriate socialization, although in kindergarten it did not have this effect.

On the Woodcock-Johnson Psychoeducational Battery-Revised, STUDENT obtained the following achievement test scores:

Standard Score Percentile Grade-Equivalent

Reading 84 15 k.2

Mathematics 76 5 k.1

Written Language 77 6 k.0

On the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration, STUDENT had a 91 standard score, at the 27 percentile, and a 5-6 age-equivalent level. Mr. Woodley concluded that STUDENT did not qualify for special education because, although there was evidence of a processing problem related to attention, there was not a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement.

A November 3, 1998 speech and language assessment report by Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE) speech therapist Stephanie Reble found that on the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test (PPVT-Receptive), STUDENT had an 84 standard score, at the 14 percentile, and on the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary test, he had a 124 language standard score, at the 95 percentile, and an 8-4 language age-equivalent level. On the Test of Language Development-2 (Primary), STUDENT'S language abilities were age-appropriate although he had a slight problem with syntax and word discrimination. Ms. Reble stated that STUDENT'S fluency, receptive/expressive language skills, voice, and articulation abilities appeared to be within normal limits and were age-appropriate. Therefore, she concluded that he was not eligible for speech and language services.

A December 1, 1998 OT evaluation report was completed by occupational therapist Mim Anspacher of the Glendale Adventist Medical Center (GAMC) Rehabilitation Institute in Glendale, California. STUDENT was age 6 years, 2 months at the time. The report states that in August 1998, STUDENT'S mother had referred him for OT at GAMC because of concerns about his sensory integrative disorder, motor delays, and fine motor skill deficits. The report notes that STUDENT had clinical diagnoses of sensory integrative disorder, motor delays, and ADHD and that previously he had been receiving OT through Saratoga Clinic in Ventura.

The report notes that STUDENT had a history of sensitivity to ordinary noises and smells. Further, his mother's report and clinical observations revealed that STUDENT sought activities that involved jumping, crashing into things, pushing or pulling, or falling. Ms. Anspacher stated that STUDENT'S noted weakness in his upper extremities and trunk, coupled with his tendency to run from activity to activity, suggested that he had deficits in his proprioceptive system and, consequently, decreased body awareness. (Footnote 2) As a result, he required a large amount of proprioceptive input to focus, organize and be calm. This system also affected STUDENT'S fine motor skills, as he seemed to be unaware of the position of his hand, arm or body while writing and the amount of pressure he used during fine motor tasks. Moreover, based upon his mother's report and clinical observations, STUDENT had an aversion to light touch and a decreased pain sensitivity. These two extremes suggested that STUDENT had great difficulty regulating tactile input. With decreased pain registration, STUDENT tended to have poor safety judgment and poor protective reactions. The mother's report and clinical observations also suggested that STUDENT'S vestibular system (Footnote 3) craved an intense amount of vestibular input but could become quickly overstimulated, rendering him unable to cope or adapt. Vestibular system deficits could affect tracking ability and, thus, reading skills. Their impact on muscle tone affected STUDENT'S posture, particularly when sitting and writing. The vestibular system also influenced his ability to become alert and to regulate states of mind such as paying attention. STUDENT was also readily distracted by visual stimuli, thereby having difficulty attending to a particular activity for an extended period of time. During the assessment, STUDENT appeared to be right hand dominant for fine motor activities. However, when writing and drawing, he used a static (rather than a mature dynamic) tripod grasp. His tendency to hold some objects between his index and middle finger (for increased stability) suggested that he had decreased hand strength and joint stability in his fingers. When cutting, he held the scissors improperly. Overall, he displayed poor isolated and graded movements throughout his upper extremities and deficits in bilateral integration and coordination. In addition, STUDENT had decreased trunk control and strength. While engaged in desktop activities, his postural muscles became fatigued quickly and he often leaned excessively to the left with his head resting on or close to the desk. Regarding STUDENT'S organization of behavior, he had difficulty with self-control, distractibility, and an extreme level of activity, all of which could interfere with his academic class performance. Ms. Anspacher recommended 60-minute OT sessions one to two times a week to help develop his nervous system and enhance his developmental and neuromuscular age-appropriate skills. She also set forth proposed OT goals and objectives.

A December 16, 1998 Antelope Valley SELPA IEP states that STUDENT was functioning in the intellectually deficient range in performance skills and in the borderline deficient range in verbal skills. The IEP summarizes the test results obtained by the District school psychologist, resource specialist, and LACOE speech therapist. It concludes that STUDENT was not eligible for special education because there was not a significant discrepancy between his ability and achievement and that he also did not qualify for speech and language services. The IEP notes, however, that the IEP team discussed the possibility of a special day class in the future.

In January 1999, STUDENT'S mother requested that the District reconsider its determination that STUDENT was ineligible for special education and OT. A January 21, 1999 Antelope Valley SELPA Child Study Team (CST) report states that STUDENT'S mother brought in a copy of a current assessment and that the CST team met to discuss her concerns regarding his eligibility for District-funded OT. The CST team agreed that further assessment was required. An assessment plan developed on January 27, 1999, and signed by the parent a day later provides for an adapted physical education and OT assessment to assess psychomotor development.

A March 2, 1999 report of LACOE adapted physical education (APE) specialist Kathleen Inman sets forth the results of her assessment of STUDENT when he was age 6 years, 6 months, based upon a classroom observation, classroom teacher conference, and administration of the LACOE Psycho Motor checklist. After having STUDENT perform a number of activities to assess his gross motor and object control skills, Ms. Inman concluded that STUDENT was functioning at the 6-year-old level in both skills areas. Therefore, she recommended that APE services were not required for STUDENT at this time.

In a March 25, 1999 Addendum to the District's October 14, 1998 psychoeducational evaluation report, school psychologist Mr. Woodley reviewed the prior October 14 report, the March 2, 1999 LACOE APE assessment, the recommendations of the OT evaluation by occupational therapist Sharon Fridrick, the March 17, 1997 report of developmental pediatrician Dr. Robert Nickel, and the February 11, 1998 IEP from Ventura County. The Addendum states that all of the psychological reports indicated that STUDENT had major distractibility issues and was diagnosed with ADHD. Morever, according to his kindergarten teacher, evidence of the ADHD was being seen in the classroom. Nevertheless, based upon an interview with the teacher and STUDENT'S current report card, Mr. Woodley stated that STUDENT was meeting kindergarten standards. Mr. Woodley stated that although STUDENT had a processing problem related to attention, there was not a discrepancy between his cognitive and academic achievement scores that would indicate that STUDENT suffered from a learning disability. Morever, there was no evidence that STUDENT'S diagnosed ADHD interfered with his academic performance and, thus, that he was eligible for special education as other health impaired. Therefore, Mr. Woodley concluded that STUDENT was able to remain in a regular education program at this time.

An April 22, 1999 Antelope Valley SELPA IEP states that the IEP team, with the exception of the parent, had found STUDENT ineligible for special education. The IEP notes that in his March 25, 1999 addendum report, school psychologist Mr. Woodley had reviewed the March 1999 APE assessment and stated that STUDENT was functioning at an age-appropriate level in gross motor and object control skills and that APE services were not recommended. The IEP states that the District staff did not dispute the results of the OT report presented by the parent but that, according to STUDENT'S teacher, STUDENT was achieving grade-level expectations and, therefore, the District staff did not find that STUDENT met the eligibility criteria for special education. The IEP states that STUDENT'S mother disagreed with the staff's conclusion and would pursue her due process rights. The IEP also states that the IEP team agreed that STUDENT should no longer be classified as a limited English proficient child because he displayed no language acquisition difficulty.

A May 7, 1999 report of Diane Howard and Kathy Hollimon, Education Specialists at Education Spectrum, Inc., in Altadena, California, sets forth the results of their developmental assessment of STUDENT when he was 6 years, 8 months. The assessment was based upon administration of the Brigance Diagnostic of Early Development and observation. During the assessment, STUDENT was easily distracted and had definite problems with attention to task but responded to redirection. STUDENT displayed gross motor skills ranging from a developmental age of 3-0 to 6-0 with an overall developmental age of approximately 4-6. He revealed definite problems with activities requiring motor planning such as coordinated kicking, throwing, and walking heel to toe. He demonstrated fine motor skills ranging from age 4-6 to 6-0 with an overall developmental age of approximately 5-1. His major area of difficulty related to paper-and-pencil activities such as writing and drawing. He held a pencil with a static tripod grip. He copied uppercase letters with very poor quality and had difficulty coloring within line limits.

STUDENT'S demonstrated speech and language skills ranged from age 4-6 to 7-0 with an overall developmental age of approximately 5-8. His problem areas involved personal information and overall sentence length. In the area of general knowledge and comprehension, STUDENT displayed a range of skills from the age 4-0 to 7-0 level, with an overall developmental age of 6-1. In the social-emotional development area, STUDENT was observed only in the office, not at school or with his peers. He took turns with assistance, exhibited signs of independence by wanting to try things himself, and was able to work with an adult on an activity for up to five minutes and to help put things away. He revealed attention-based problems with concentration and persistence, but was cooperative and responded quickly to redirection. In the area of readiness, basic reading and basic math skills, STUDENT exhibited a scattering of academic and readiness skills within the developmental ages of 4-0 to 7-0, with an overall developmental age of approximately 6-0. A weak area was discriminating and identifying lower case letters of the alphabet. He was able to print only uppercase letters and reversed the letter "J." His printing did not meet the criteria for slant, size, spacing, alignment, and formation. When he attempted to write numerals, most were reversed. He also had weak decoding and sight reading skills.

The report states that it was unclear whether STUDENT may have a visual processing problem as evidenced by letter reversals, poor posture when writing, and the position of his head held at an extreme angle. Recommendations were to increase his auditory processing ability; increase skills related to drawing, writing clarity and overall fine motor control; and increase gross motor skills, particularly those related to motor planning. Other recommendations were to increase his knowledge of quantitative concepts and math skills and also literacy skills including phonemic awareness, decoding, and sight reading. The report also recommended intervention strategies. STUDENT'S teachers should assist him to attend to task, persist with activities and process information. In addition, STUDENT should have the opportunity to learn in groups of three to four children, which are small enough to give him frequent turns, to permit monitoring of his attention to task and to evaluate his understanding of the materials presented. Further, STUDENT requires intervention to address gross motor needs related to playground skills and fine motor needs related to paper-and-pencil classroom activities. It was also recommended that STUDENT have a developmental and functional vision assessment to determine whether a visual processing problem may contribute to his fine motor problems and short attention span.

In August 1999, educational psychologist Esther Sinclair, Ph.D., of UCLA conducted an independent assessment of STUDENT when he was age 6 years, 10 months, and about to enter grade 1 in the fall. Dr. Sinclair reviewed reports of previous assessments and evaluated STUDENT during four 60-minute sessions. She noted that STUDENT was extremely hyperactive, was easily distracted, had a low frustration tolerance, and required much encouragement to attempt difficult tasks. According to her, he responds better to tasks presented in small segments with frequent breaks, and firm statements of expectations and limit setting. He has difficulty with concentration, attention, and focus.

On the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children III (WISC III), STUDENT obtained a 92 verbal IQ, 91 performance IQ, and 91 full scale IQ, which placed him in the average to low average range. On the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), STUDENT had standard scores ranging from 84 and 85 for Listening Comprehension and Reading Comprehension, respectively, to 98 and 99 for Mathematics Reasoning and Spelling, respectively. His reading composite and mathematics composite scores were 91 (1.0 grade equivalent level) and 94 (K.9 grade-equivalent level), respectively. On the Woodcock Johnson Tests of Achievement-Revised (WJ-R), STUDENT had broad reading, broad mathematics, and broad written expression scores of 92, 99, and 103, respectively. In math computation, STUDENT wrote numbers such as seven and three backwards. In writing, he held the pencil appropriately but because he did not anchor the paper with his other hand, his printing looked sloppy. Moreover, most letters were very large. On the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration, he had an 83 standard score, at the 13 percentile and 5 year, 6 month age-equivalent level.

Dr. Sinclair noted that STUDENT had been diagnosed with ADHD, PTSD, and sensory integrative disorder. She noted that details available related to his 11-month stay in a Russian hospital and orphanage suggest extreme neglect and abuse, and his fears and anxieties stemming from this treatment and PTSD are not behind him. Moreover, she noted STUDENT'S history of sensory hypersensitivity and delays in gross motor and fine motor skills. According to her, he had made improvement, probably due to the OT services he received during the past 18 months, but was still hypersensitive to noise and smell. Dr. Sinclair stated that STUDENT clearly met the DSM-IV diagnostic criteria for ADHD according to teacher, parent and previous evaluators' reports. She noted that STUDENT'S behavior at UCLA was characterized by hyperactivity, distractibility, inattention, lack of focus, and inability to stay on task without redirection and one-on-one adult attention. She stated that STUDENT is extremely impulsive and cannot delay gratification, but his inappropriate behavior is not due to oppositionality but an inability to control his impulsivity. Dr. Sinclair stated that STUDENT has difficulty with oral directions and often does not attend to auditory input. In addition, he has visual-perceptual and visual discrimination difficulties, as evidenced by his confusion regarding directionality and his misreading of text. She concluded that STUDENT qualified for special education as other health impaired based upon his ADHD and auditory and visual processing deficits. Moreover, she stated that his auditory, visual and language processing deficits, coupled with his impulsive, hyperactive behavior, would require much individualization for him to benefit from his education.

Dr. Sinclair stated that STUDENT shuts down when bombarded with excessive sensory stimuli, including the amount of work that he is expected to do. Therefore, he requires extraordinary support to complete his assigned work. She further stated that although his academic achievement levels are at the kindergarten to first-grade level, he will have difficulty in a grade 1 program in which he is expected to acquire academic skills immediately. Dr. Sinclair made the following recommendations. STUDENT requires a small, structured classroom with a teacher trained to address his learning and behavioral needs. He requires modification of the curriculum because he will shut down if presented with too much work. His inattention, impulsivity, and hyperactivity should be addressed with firm statements of expectation, limit-setting, adult support, and rewards, with both school and home working together. To deal with reversals, he needs continued OT services and a multi-modal approach to correct formation of letters and numbers. If his difficulty with phonics and sound blending persists, he should enroll in a reading program such as Lindamood-Bell. He requires a comprehensive speech and language evaluation in terms of central language processing skills. Behavioral, educational and other interventions to treat the ADHD and PTSD should be provided by a child psychiatrist. School recommendations include preferential seating, minimal noise and distractions, written instructions for assignments, and a clear understanding of directions with the opportunity to obtain clarification before starting class work.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

ISSUE 1: Was Petitioner eligible for special education because of an other health impairment during the following periods: a. from April 28, 1998 through the end of the 1997-1998 school year? b. during the 1998-1999 school year?

Under California special education law, an individual with exceptional needs is one who meets the definition of a child with a disability, as set forth in the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i), and, as a result of the impairment, requires instruction, services, or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular education program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a), (b). The disabilities identified in the IDEA are mental retardation; hearing, speech or language, visual, orthopedic, and other health impairments; serious emotional disturbance; autism; traumatic brain injury; and specific learning disabilities. 20 U.S.C. §1401(3)(A)(i); see Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(a)-(j).

Petitioner contends that he was eligible for special education from April 1998, when he enrolled in the District. When an IEP meeting was held in December 1998 following the District's October 1998 psychoeducational evaluation and November 1998 speech and language assessment, the IEP team, with the exception of STUDENT'S parent, found him ineligible for special education as having either a specific learning disability or speech and language impairment. Petitioner contends that he was eligible for special education as other health impaired based upon his ADHD, sensory integration disorder, and fine motor skills delay.

However, under both federal and state law, none of these impairments, by itself, is listed as a disability which renders a student eligible for special education. Nonetheless, under California Education Code Section 56339(a), a student whose educational performance is adversely affected by a suspected or diagnosed ADHD is entitled to special education and related services if he meets the eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability, other health impairment, or serious emotional disturbance. (Footnote 4)

Petitioner does not contend that he is eligible for special education based upon a specific learning disability or serious emotional disturbance. Therefore, the question is whether he is eligible for special education based upon an other health impairment.

Under the federal regulation, other health impairment means:

having limited strength, vitality or alertness, including a heightened alertness to environmental stimuli, that results in limited alertness with respect to the educational environment, that (i) Is due to chronic or acute health problems such as asthma, attention deficit disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, diabetes, epilepsy, a heart condition, hemophilia, lead poisoning, leukemia, nephritis, rheumatic fever, and sickle cell anemia; and (ii) Adversely affects a child's educational performance.

34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9) (italics added). Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, Section 3030(f) includes chronic kidney disease, cystic fibrosis, and tuberculosis and other communicable infectious diseases as additional chronic or acute health problems falling within the definition of other health impairment. Section 3030(f) further states that the physical disabilities shall not be temporary in nature, as defined by Section 3001(v).

a. From April 28, 1998 through the end of the 1997-1998 school year

To determine whether STUDENT was eligible for special education as other health impaired from April 28, 1998, it is necessary to address whether, in late April 1998, he had limited strength, vitality or alertness (including a heightened alertness to environmental stimuli, that resulted in limited alertness with respect to the educational environment) due to a chronic or acute health problem such as ADHD, and, if so, whether that limited strength, vitality or alertness adversely affected his educational performance.

STUDENT was diagnosed with ADHD in the March 1997 assessment by the Child Development and Rehabilitation Center in Oregon, and in the August 1999 UCLA psychoeducational assessment. The March 25, 1999 Addendum to the District's October 1998 psychoeducational evaluation report stated that all of the psychological reports indicated that STUDENT had major distractibility issues and that he had been diagnosed with ADHD. The March 1999 Addendum further stated that, according to STUDENT'S teacher, evidence of STUDENT'S ADHD was observed in the classroom. Therefore, the evidence establishes that STUDENT suffers from ADHD.

Moreover, the record, including the assessment reports prior to April 1998, contains evidence of his heightened alertness to environmental stimuli that resulted in limited alertness with respect to the educational environment. Even before he was age two, STUDENT was described at the Glendale preschool as being highly active, easily frustrated, and loud, and becoming overwhelmed and "frenzied" with increased noise or with more than one child. Approximately two years later when he was evaluated at USC, he was again described as being easily distracted and frustrated, displaying poor judgment and poor control, and engaging in activities which placed himself at risk. In late 1996, when STUDENT was evaluated by the Education Service District in Roseburg, Oregon, at a little over age four, he was rated as being in the mild and moderate range of hyperactivity by his parent and teacher, respectively. According to his mother, he was impulsive, highly active, distractible, and disobedient at times. His teacher noted that in addition, he tended to squirm and poke other children. During the assessment, the examiner noted STUDENT'S low frustration level, loud voice, and almost constant motion, swaying in his chair, handling objects, and moving his hands and feet. The examiner recommended an evaluation for his attending problem and high activity level.

Moreover, during a March 1997 evaluation by the Child Development Clinic in Eugene, Oregon, when STUDENT was age 4-1/2, he was described as very distractible, impulsive, and consistently overactive. It was noted that he was clearly influenced by the surrounding activity level, that his high activity level was consistent with ADHD, and he was diagnosed with ADHD. Because STUDENT was very distractible and was unable to remain seated and attend to test items, administration of a standardized sensory integration test had to be terminated. Recommendations included a medication trial and assistance with behavioral management for the mother. Mr. Lindoff, STUDENT'S kindergarten teacher from April through June 1998, testified that STUDENT was distractible with respect to directions and had problems attending in class. Therefore, it is concluded that the evidence establishes that from even before late April 1998 and through June 1998, because of his ADHD STUDENT had a heightened alertness to environmental stimuli which resulted in a limited alertness with respect to the educational environment.

The next question is whether STUDENT'S limited alertness due to his ADHD adversely affected his educational performance. STUDENT first attended kindergarten during the 1997-1998 school year. According to his mother's testimony, he started kindergarten in the Hueneme ESD on approximately November 10, 1997, after the family moved from Oregon. In April 1998, STUDENT began attending kindergarten at Cottonwood Elementary School in the District. At the time, approximately eight weeks remained in the school year. Mr. Lindoff, STUDENT'S teacher, testified that in June 1998, he told the principal that STUDENT was having problems in class and he recommended retention because of STUDENT'S immaturity and low skill level. Specifically, Mr. Lindoff testified that STUDENT was distracted easily, had difficulty attending in class, preferred to play with toys, had coloring and writing skills below the expected level, and had trouble with the alphabet and letter sounds. Mr. Lindoff testified that retention was an "unusual" measure and during his approximately 14 years of teaching, he had recommended that only two children (including STUDENT) be retained. He further testified that because retention was recommended, no special education assessment of STUDENT was conducted at this time.

The District argues that at the time of the retention recommendation, there was no evidence that a special education assessment was warranted. According to the District, STUDENT, who became age 5 in late September 1997, was a "young" kindergarten student who had missed at least one-third of the instructional year when he enrolled in the District in late April 1998. STUDENT'S mother testified that when STUDENT first enrolled in kindergarten in November 1997, school had already been in session for eight weeks. Moreover, he left the Hueneme ESD on April 3, 1998, according to the Hueneme ESD Pupil Transfer Report, but he did not enroll in the Westside Union Elementary School District until approximately April 28, 1998, following the Easter break. Therefore, he missed at least eight weeks of school, or more, during the 1997-1998 school year. STUDENT'S mother testified that STUDENT enrolled in Mr. Lindoff's kindergarten class in late April and that she agreed with the recommendation that he be retained in kindergarten. The Hearing Officer finds that because STUDENT was a relatively young and immature kindergarten student who missed at least eight weeks of school, the fact that he was retained in kindergarten is insufficient to establish that limited alertness due to his ADHD had a substantial adverse effect on his educational performance. Therefore, the evidence does not establish that he was eligible for special education during April through June 1998.

b. During the 1998-1999 school year

It was found above that STUDENT suffers from ADHD. Thus, to determine STUDENT'S eligibility for special education as other health impaired during the 1998-1999 school year, it is necessary to address whether he had limited strength, vitality or alertness (including a heightened alertness to environmental stimuli, that resulted in limited alertness with respect to the educational environment) due to his ADHD, and, if so, whether that limited strength, vitality or alertness adversely affected his educational performance. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(f).

During the District's October 1998 psychoeducational evaluation when STUDENT was age 6 and repeating kindergarten, his behavior was described as extremely active as he ran around the room, crawled on the floor and got up on the table. In fact, the testing at the first session had to be terminated because STUDENT could not sit still. During the LACOE speech and language assessment a month later, STUDENT was again described as being active and having trouble focusing at times. An OT evaluation at the Glendale Adventist Medical Center a month later disclosed that because of deficits in STUDENT'S proprioceptive system, he required a great deal of proprioceptive input to focus, organize and be calm. Deficits in his vestibular system limited his ability to be alert, and he was readily distracted by visual stimuli and thus had difficulty attending to a task for a long period of time. Because of problems with his organization of behavior, STUDENT had difficulty with self-control, distractibility, and an extreme level of activity, all of which could interfere with his academic performance in class. The District's March 1999 Addendum to its October 1998 psychoeducational evaluation report stated that an updated report from STUDENT'S teacher was that STUDENT had difficulty keeping his hands to himself when sitting on the floor, had trouble waiting his turn, and would still "blurt" out in class.

Moreover, a May 1999 Education Spectrum developmental assessment report stated that during the assessment, STUDENT was easily distracted, had problems with attention to task, frequently turned around in his chair or engaged in off-topic conversation, and required much prompting. He also revealed attention-based problems with concentration and persistence but responded to redirection. The report stated that STUDENT'S impulsive, off-task behavior was due to information processing and attention deficits, not noncompliance problems. The August 1999 UCLA psychoeducational assessment report stated that during the evaluation, STUDENT was extremely hyperactive, licked himself often, and made chuckling noises. He was easily distracted, extremely impulsive, had a low frustration tolerance, and had difficulty with concentration, attention, and focus. The teacher's comments on STUDENT'S report card during the second half of the year were that he talked too much when he should have been working and had trouble sitting still. It is concluded that because of his ADHD, STUDENT had a heightened alertness to environmental stimuli which resulted in a limited alertness with respect to the educational environment.

Petitioner argues that his ADHD adversely affected his educational performance because, as his teacher testified, he needed redirection in the classroom approximately twice a day and he had difficulty with handwriting. He further contends that because, as school psychologist Mr. Woodley testified, Mr. Woodley did not know about sensory integration disorder when he assessed STUDENT, and the District did not conduct its own OT evaluation, the District lacked the requisite knowledge about the disability and its effect on STUDENT'S educational performance to be able to conclude that he was eligible for special education.

Dr. Sinclair, who conducted the UCLA psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT, testified that because of STUDENT'S high activity level, impulsivity, distractibility, attention problems, and tendency to "shut down" when confronted with challenging material, she found it difficult to conceive that he could function in a normal kindergarten class with 20 students. She also testified that she believed that STUDENT was eligible for special education as being other health impaired based upon his ADHD since April 1998, when he entered the District. However, she acknowledged that she did not observe STUDENT in the classroom or speak to his teacher because she had thought that school was not in session in August, when she assessed him.

Despite STUDENT'S highly active behavior and attention and distractibility problems, he was able to perform class work at a kindergarten level of expectancy, according to Mr. Lindoff, his teacher. Mr. Lindoff testified that there were approximately 17 to 18 students in his class, and an aide was present in the classroom for 40 minutes each day. It is noted that STUDENT'S teacher engaged in unique modifications in the classroom that other regular education teachers might not be able to replicate.The testimony of Mr. Lindoff and Mr. Woodley, who observed STUDENT in the classroom, provide evidence of the accommodations and modifications which enabled STUDENT to function in the regular education classroom. According to Mr. Woodley, he observed STUDENT standing at his desk while drawing. Mr. Lindoff testified that in his class, the students moved to different activity centers approximately every fifteen minutes. Moreover, according to Mr. Lindoff, he paired STUDENT with another student, and the competition with the other student spurred STUDENT to do his class work. If STUDENT asked for help and said that a task was too difficult, Mr. Lindoff gave him additional time. Further, when STUDENT lost focus and attention, Mr. Lindoff redirected him an average of about twice a day.

Moreover, the evidence does not establish that STUDENT'S limited alertness due to his ADHD adversely affected his educational performance. The March 1999 LACOE APE assessment performed when STUDENT was 6 years, 6 months, found that he was functioning at the 6 year-old level in both gross motor and object control skills areas, and the assessment report concluded that he did not require APE services. Moreover, the District's March 25, 1999 Addendum to its October 14, 1998 psychoeducational evaluation report stated that the updated report from Mr. Lindoff, STUDENT'S teacher, was that STUDENT was performing within the academic expectancy level of a kindergarten student, even though he had problems keeping his hands to himself when sitting on the floor, waiting his turn, and blurting out in class. The May 1999 Education Spectrum independent developmental assessment obtained by STUDENT'S mother when he was age 6 years, 8 months, revealed these overall developmental age scores for the following areas: gross motor skills, approximately 4-6; fine motor skills, approximately 5-1; speech and language skills, approximately 5-8; general knowledge and comprehension, 6-1; and readiness, basic reading and basic math skills, approximately 6-0. In the August 1999 UCLA psychoeducational assessment, STUDENT achieved the following results: WIAT reading composite and mathematics composite scores of 91 (1.0 grade equivalent) and 94 (K.9 grade equivalent), respectively; WJ-R broad reading, broad mathematics, and broad written expression scores of 92, 99, and 103, respectively.

Additionally, on his report card for the last quarter of the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT received only two "needed improvement" marks (for displaying self-control and working neatly) and received "mastery" marks in the categories of name, colors, and letters, and for six out of ten items in the mathematics category. The teacher's comments for the second progress report period were that STUDENT had trouble rhyming words and talked too much when he should be working but that his academics were good. The comments for the second semester were that he complained when there was a lot of writing to be done, had sloppy writing, and had difficulty sitting still, but that his academics had improved during the year and he did fine on his work. On the District kindergarten checklist for end-of-year grade level expectations in language arts, STUDENT received a score of 32, or 86 percent, which was at grade level. On the District kindergarten reading comprehension assessment, he received a score of 6 out of a possible 6. On the kindergarten mathematics assessment, he received a score of 22 out of a possible 24, or 92 percent, which was above grade level.

Moreover, although the evidence is that STUDENT had difficulty waiting his turn, and Mr. Lindoff testified that STUDENT did bother other students and wanted to talk to his neighbor when he needed to be doing his class work, Mr. Lindoff also testified that STUDENT had many friends in class. The District's October 1998 psychoeducational report also stated that STUDENT seemed to have adapted well and worked well within interpersonal groups in the classroom, and on the playground he interacted and played with his peers in an appropriate manner. Thus, although the evidence related to his socialization skills is sparse, it appears that STUDENT was able to get along with the other children in his class and had friends at school.

Therefore, the evidence establishes that even if STUDENT suffered from a limited alertness stemming from his ADHD, his educational performance was not adversely affected to a substantial degree. Consequently, it is concluded that he was not eligible for special education during the 1998-1999 school year.

ISSUE 2: If so, did the District provide Petitioner a free appropriate public education during the following periods: a. from April 28, 1998 through the end of the 1997-1998 school year? b. during the 1998-1999 school year?

It was concluded above that STUDENT was not eligible for special education either from April 1998 through the end of the 1997-1998 school year or during the 1998-1999 school year. Therefore, he was not entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) under the IDEA during these periods.

ISSUE 3: Did a FAPE during the relevant period of the 1997-1998 school year and during the entirety of the 1998-1999 school year require occupational therapy as a related service?

The evidence did not establish that STUDENT was eligible for special education based upon an other health impairment, a sensory integration disorder, or a delay in fine motor skills. Because STUDENT was not eligible for special education during the relevant periods, he was not entitled to a FAPE or occupational therapy as a related service.

ISSUE 4: Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of occupational therapy he received during the time he was enrolled in the District?

In light of the determination above that STUDENT was not eligible for special education while enrolled in the District and thus was not entitled to OT as a related service, he is not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of OT he received during this period.

ISSUE 5: If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE from April 1998 through the end of the 1998-1999 school year, is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education?

As discussed above, STUDENT was not eligible for special education and thus was not entitled to a FAPE under the IDEA while enrolled in the District. Therefore, he is not entitled to compensatory education.

ISSUE 6: Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the following: a. occupational therapy evaluation by Mim Anspacher, O.T.R.?

b. psychoeducational evaluation by Esther Sinclair, Ph.D.?

c. Education Spectrum developmental assessment?

A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student from a qualified specialist, at public expense, if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the District, unless the District shows at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).

The appropriateness of the District's assessment is governed by the pertinent California special education statutes, which set forth the following requirements. Testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(a). Tests and other assessment materials must be provided and administered in the pupil's primary language or other mode of communication; must be administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b). The pupil must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development; vision, including low vision; hearing; motor abilities; language function; general ability; academic performance; self-help; orientation and mobility skills; career and vocational abilities and interests; and social and emotional status. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). The assessment shall be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(g). Assessment materials must assess specific areas of educational need and not merely provide a single general intelligence quotient. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c). Further, no single procedure shall be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for a special education child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(e).

Moreover, psychological assessments, including individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning, must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician. These assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(b)(3), 56324. Additionally, assessments must be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessments, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area. Cal. Educ. Code § 56322.

a. Occupational therapy evaluation by Mim Anspacher, O.T.R.

Petitioner argues that he is entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the December 1, 1998 OT evaluation by Ms. Anspacher because this evaluation assessed an area of suspected disability, and the District failed to conduct an OT assessment pursuant to the assessment plan provided by the District and signed by the parent on January 28, 1999.

In a September 20, 1998 letter to the principal of Cottonwood Elementary School, STUDENT'S mother requested a special education assessment. In response to the mother's request, the District assessed STUDENT. An October 1, 1998 District health assessment report states that STUDENT had passed the hearing test but had failed the vision test without eyeglasses. It states that he had glasses but would not wear them due to hypersensitivity. The report also notes a Sensory Integration Syndrome diagnosis.

The District's October 14, 1998 psychoeducational evaluation report sets forth the results of testing conducted in October 1998. School psychologist Mr. Woodley performed a cumulative record review and administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition, the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, and the Beery Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration. Resource specialist Brenda Martin administered the Woodcock-Johnson Psychoeducational Battery-Revised. The report states that during the testing, STUDENT was extremely active, running around the room, crawling on the floor, and getting up on the table. According to the report, the testing had to be terminated because STUDENT could not sit still. However, the report further states that the assessment procedures were valid. Mr. Woodley concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education because, although there was evidence of an attention-related processing problem, a severe discrepancy did not exist between his ability and achievement.

A November 3, 1998 LACOE speech and language assessment report states that speech therapist Stephanie Reble administered to STUDENT the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test, and the Test of Language Development-2 (Primary). Ms. Reble concluded that STUDENT'S fluency, receptive/expressive language skills, voice, and articulation abilities were age-appropriate and that he was not eligible for speech and language services.

The tests that were administered in the October and November 1998 assessments are instruments commonly used in an educational setting and were validated for the purpose for which they were used. Moreover, there is no evidence that the assessment materials and procedures were racially, culturally or sexually discriminatory. STUDENT was tested in his primary language. In addition, the psychological assessments, including individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning, were administered by Mr. Woodley, a credentialed school psychologist. The health assessment was conducted by a registered nurse. The assessors were competent to perform the assessments. Thus, the requirements of Sections 56320(a) and (b), 56322, and 56324 were met. The evaluations assessed STUDENT for vision, hearing, cognitive ability, academic achievement, adaptive behavior, visual-motor integration, and speech and language development. Further, no single procedure was used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. The requirements of Subsections 56320(c) and (e) were met.

However, school psychologist Mr. Woodley testified that when he conducted the initial psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT, he was not familiar with sensory integration disorder, an area of suspected disability based upon a prior diagnosis. Therefore, the requirement that the assessment be conducted by a person knowledgeable of the suspected disability was not met. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(g).

Moreover, a question exists as to whether STUDENT was assessed in all areas of suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). (Footnote 5) Petitioner claims that fine motor skills was an area of suspected disability based upon at least three prior assessments which recommended OT for STUDENT. In her September 20, 1998 letter requesting a special education assessment of STUDENT, STUDENT'S mother informed the District that he had a sensory integration dysfunction, fine motor skill delays, and hypersensitivity; and that he had trouble focusing his attention, staying seated, staying in line, and drawing and writing. She stated that she believed that he would benefit from special education services because of his learning disability.

The District's October 1998 psychoeducational evaluation assessed STUDENT for a learning disability and found no significant discrepancy between cognitive ability and achievement. However, the October 1998 psychoeducational assessment did not assess STUDENT for a sensory integration dysfunction, including hypersensitivity; fine motor skill delays, including problems with drawing and writing; or attention deficit disorder, although the assessment report noted that there was evidence of a processing problem related to attention. The psychoeducational report also stated that STUDENT was extremely active during the test administration and that the testing had to be terminated because STUDENT could not sit still. Moreover, the District's October 1, 1998 health assessment report also noted STUDENT'S hypersensitivity and diagnosis of Sensory Integration Syndrome. Therefore, the District had information about these areas of suspected disability but failed to assess in these areas.

Related to an OT evaluation, in addition to the information noted above, in her September 20 letter, STUDENT'S mother also told the District that STUDENT had been receiving physical therapy in Ventura since March 1998 and from the Glendale Adventist Hospital since August 1998. Moreover, the parent signed a January 1999 assessment plan for an adapted physical education (APE) and occupational therapy (OT) assessment to assess psychomotor development. An APE assessment was conducted in March 1999. However, the District never did conduct an OT assessment. The fact that the District's January 1999 assessment plan provided for an OT assessment is further evidence that an OT assessment was required to assess an area of suspected disability. The Hearing Officer finds that because the District failed to conduct an OT assessment, it failed to assess in all areas of suspected disability and, therefore, its assessment was not appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).

Moreover, Ms. Anspacher is a certified occupational therapist with the requisite education and training and specializes in pediatric therapy. Previously she either interned or worked at California Children's Services in Orange County and Los Angeles County. Therefore, she is a qualified assessor in this area. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). (Footnote 6) Based upon the foregoing, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the OT assessment by Ms. Anspacher.

b. Psychoeducational evaluation by Esther Sinclair, Ph.D.

Petitioner requests reimbursement for the costs of the August 1999 UCLA psychoeducational assessment by Dr. Sinclair. (Footnote 7) Petitioner would be entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the UCLA assessment if he disagreed with the District's assessment and the District's assessment was not appropriate. As discussed above under Issue 6, Subsection a., the Hearing Officer found that the District's assessment was not appropriate because it failed to assess in all areas of suspected disability.

Dr. Sinclair assessed STUDENT during four 60-minute sessions. On the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III), STUDENT obtained a 92 verbal IQ, 91 performance IQ, and 91 full scale IQ, which placed him in the average to low average range. Dr. Sinclair also administered the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test, the Woodcock Johnson Tests of Achievement-Revised, and the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration. Therefore, she administered tests to assess STUDENT'S cognitive ability, academic achievement, and visual-motor integration. These were areas assessed by school psychologist Mr. Woodley as part of the District's October 1998 evaluation.

Petitioner argues that the District's October 14, 1998 psychoeducational assessment of STUDENTwas not valid because it placed STUDENT in the low to intellectually deficient range of cognitive ability (contrary to past assessments which placed him in the average range of intelligence) without taking into account his attention problem. The District's October 1998 psychoeducational evaluation report stated that during the testing, STUDENT was running around, crawling on the floor, and getting up onto the table. Mr. Woodley testified that STUDENT was running back and forth across the length of the room while answering test questions. The report stated that the test administration had to be terminated because STUDENT was unable to sit still but that the assessment procedures were valid. Mr. Woodley testified that because of STUDENT'S activity level during administration of the WISC-III, the test results were not reliable (i.e., the same results might not be obtained if he were tested the next day) but that the results were valid (i.e., they showed what the child was capable of when he was tested). Mr. Woodley testified that he had reviewed the July 1996 USC Center for Child Development and Developmental Disabilities report when he conducted the assessment of STUDENT and was aware that the Stanford-Binet test results showed average intelligence. He further testified, however, that even if STUDENT'S IQ were considered to be 91 (STUDENT'S full scale IQ score obtained by Dr. Sinclair), there was not a significant discrepancy between STUDENT'S intelligence and achievement scores to render him eligible for special education as having a specific learning disability.

Dr. Sinclair testified that the District's WISC-III assessment of STUDENT did not accurately reflect his ability. She testified that the previously administered Stanford-Binet test showed a 92 IQ, which correlated with the IQ scores she obtained when she administered the WISC-III to STUDENT. Dr. Sinclair testified that given the extreme level of activity during the test administration described in the District's psychoeducational assessment report and the discrepancy with the IQ results she obtained, the District's IQ test results were not valid.

Dr. Sinclair has a Ph.D. in Education from the University of Southern California and a school psychologist's credential from the California State Department of Education, and is a licensed educational psychologist in California. She is an associate professor and Special Education Faculty Coordinator with the Department of Psychiatry at the UCLA School of Medicine. She also testified that at UCLA she has experience working with and evaluating children with ADHD.

The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Sinclair is a highly qualified expert in the area of school psychology and testing and that her testimony is entitled to great weight. The Hearing Officer further finds that because of STUDENT'S high activity level during the District's administration of the WISC-III, the District's WISC-III results are not reliable, and the District's October 1998 psychoeducational evaluation is not appropriate on this ground. Petitioner is entitled to test results that are both valid and reliable. These unreliable IQ scores were used to determine that a significant discrepancy did not exist between STUDENT'S cognitive ability and academic achievement to render him eligible for special education as having a specific learning disability. The March 1999 Addendum to the October 1998 psychoeducational evaluation report again used these unreliable IQ scores in comparison to STUDENT'S adaptive functioning skills level. In this case, a significant discrepancy does not exist between STUDENT'S ability and achievement even when Dr. Sinclair's IQ scores, rather than the District's unreliable scores, are used. Moreover, because of the unique modifications and accommodations afforded STUDENT by his kindergarten teacher, he was able to function in the regular education class. However, reliance upon inaccurate, unreliable IQ scores can affect not only a determination of eligibility for special education and, once a student is found eligible, the special education programs and services provided to him but also the modifications and accommodations to the regular education program which might be offered to a student. Therefore, such unreliable scores can have a detrimental effect upon the student and upon the education he receives.

The California special education statutes governing assessments require that tests be administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions, except that psychological assessments, including individually administered intelligence tests, shall be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(b)(3), 56324. Further, the assessment shall be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56322. The assessment shall also be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(g). All of these requirements that special education assessments be performed by persons with the proper training, credentials, knowledge and competence, without doubt, are intended to ensure that the assessment results are valid and reliable as bases for decisions related to special education eligibility and programs and services. Therefore, to the extent that the assessment results are not valid and reliable, the statutory requirements are not met. Because the District's WISC-III test results were not valid and reliable, the Hearing Officer finds that the October 1998 psychoeducational assessment was not appropriate under the law.

Moreover, the evidence establishes that Dr. Sinclair is a credentialed school psychologist and a licensed educational psychologist in California. Thus, she is a qualified specialist to conduct an independent educational assessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). Therefore, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the costs of Dr. Sinclair's assessment.

c. Education Spectrum developmental assessment

Petitioner requests reimbursement for the costs of the May 1999 Education Spectrum assessment. He argues that because the District failed properly to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, his parent was required to obtain a valid assessment from Education Spectrum to determine an appropriate educational program and services. Petitioner would be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the Education Spectrum assessment if he disagreed with the District's assessment and the District's assessment was not appropriate. Moreover, as discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that the District's assessment was not appropriate because the District failed to assess in all areas of suspected disability and failed properly to assess STUDENT'S cognitive ability, and the Hearing Officer granted reimbursement for the costs of the OT and UCLA assessments.

Ms. Howard and Ms. Hollimon, Education Specialists at Education Spectrum, conducted a developmental assessment of STUDENT. They administered the Brigance Diagnostic of Early Development to assess his gross and fine motor skills, speech and language skills, general knowledge and comprehension, social-emotional development, and readiness and academic skills. The District's October and November 1998 assessments assessed, among other areas, STUDENT'S cognitive ability, academic achievement, and speech and language skills. The District's October 1998 psychoeducational evaluation report addressed STUDENT'S social-emotional development based upon Mr. Woodley's observations in the classroom and on the playground. The Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales administered by the District assessed motor skills as one of the domains. However, there is no evidence that school psychologist Mr. Woodley or Education Spectrum's Ms. Howard or Ms. Hollimon is an occupational therapist qualified to conduct an OT evaluation. Moreover, as discussed above, motor skills was an area assessed by the OT evaluation of occupational therapist Ms. Anspacher, for which reimbursement was granted. In addition, cognitive ability and academic achievement were assessed by the psychoeducational evaluation of Dr. Sinclair, for which reimbursement also was granted. Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for more than one assessment of the same areas.Moreover, the District contends that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the Education Spectrum assessment because he failed to present evidence that he disagreed with the District's assessment in the areas assessed by Education Spectrum (academic achievement, social-emotional development, speech and language skills, and gross and fine motor skills.) Except for the motor skills area, discussed above under Issue 6, Subsection a., there is no contention that the District's assessment in the areas assessed by Education Spectrum was lacking or otherwise inappropriate. The District also contends that reimbursement should be denied because no assessor testified to verify the assessment's authenticity or to establish the assessors' qualifications. When an assessor does not testify to establish assessment credentials and to authenticate the assessment results and procedures, an assessment carries less weight.

Based upon the foregoing, it is concluded that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the Education Spectrum assessment.

ORDER

1. Within twenty-five calendar days of the date of this decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District proof of the costs of the following assessments. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for the following:

a. the occupational therapy evaluation by Mim Anspacher, O.T.R., and b. the psychoeducational evaluation by Esther Sinclair, Ph.D.

2. All of Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Petitioner prevailed on the issues related to reimbursement for the costs of the following assessments:

a. the occupational therapy evaluation by Mim Anspacher, O.T.R., and b. the psychoeducational evaluation by Esther Sinclair, Ph.D.

2. The District prevailed on all of the other issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: January 13, 2000 ____________________________________ Judy F. Hirano, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office Moreover, the District contends that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the Education Spectrum assessment because he failed to present evidence that he disagreed with the District's assessment in the areas assessed by Education Spectrum (academic achievement, social-emotional development, speech and language skills, and gross and fine motor skills.) Except for the motor skills area, discussed above under Issue 6, Subsection a., there is no contention that the District's assessment in the areas assessed by Education Spectrum was lacking or otherwise inappropriate. The District also contends that reimbursement should be denied because no assessor testified to verify the assessment's authenticity or to establish the assessors' qualifications. When an assessor does not testify to establish assessment credentials and to authenticate the assessment results and procedures, an assessment carries less weight.

Based upon the foregoing, it is concluded that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the Education Spectrum assessment.

ORDER

1. Within twenty-five calendar days of the date of this decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District proof of the costs of the following assessments. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for the following:

a. the occupational therapy evaluation by Mim Anspacher, O.T.R., and b. the psychoeducational evaluation by Esther Sinclair, Ph.D.

2. All of Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Petitioner prevailed on the issues related to reimbursement for the costs of the following assessments:

a. the occupational therapy evaluation by Mim Anspacher, O.T.R., and b. the psychoeducational evaluation by Esther Sinclair, Ph.D.

2. The District prevailed on all of the other issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: January 13, 2000 ____________________________________ Judy F. Hirano, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1)To facilitate the analysis, the order of the issues has been altered and the issues have been clarified, based upon the parties' discussion at the hearing. 2)According to Ms. Anspacher's report, the proprioception system provides conscious and unconscious information to receptors in the muscles, joints and ligaments that permit the brain to know where and how the body is moving and with what amount of force. This system plays a major role in the integration of reflexes, ability to motor plan, development of body scheme, and the ability of the nervous system to organize itself. 3)Ms. Anspacher's report states that the vestibular system regulates body and eye movement relative to head movements and influences muscle tone, oculomotor control, bilateral coordination, and balance. 4)When the federal IDEA was amended in 1997, the term "serious emotional disturbance" was changed to "emotional disturbance," and the accompanying federal regulations embody this change. See 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4). However, the California special education regulation still uses the term "serious emotional disturbance." See Calif. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(i). 5)Another question related to the adequacy of the District's intelligence testing will be addressed in the discussion under Issue 6, Subsection b. 6)Under Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, Section 3001(af), "qualified" means that "a person has met federal and state certification, licensing, registration, or other comparable requirements which apply to the area in which he or she is providing special education or related services . . . and adheres to the standards of professional practice established in federal and state law or regulation, including . . . the California Business and Professions Code." 7)For the first time in his closing brief, Petitioner specifically requests reimbursement for the costs of transportation to the UCLA and Education Spectrum assessments. However, California Education Code Section 56329(b) provides solely for reimbursement for the cost of an independent educational evaluation. It does not provide for reimbursement for the cost of transportation to the evaluation site, and Petitioner has provided no authority for such reimbursement.