California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 6, 1999

Student v. Panama-Buena Vista Union School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 595-98 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Panama-Buena Vista Union and Kern County Superintendent denied FAPE for three years; must reimburse private school costs and fund compensatory education.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 8 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 10-year-old boy with autism and mental retardation (now called intellectual disability) filed against Panama-Buena Vista Union School District and the Kern County Superintendent of Schools, which ran the district's special education program. In May 1998 they moved him from a special day class at Hort Elementary to Valley Achievement Center, a nonpublic school. The Hearing Officer found that Respondents denied him FAPE for three school years. For 1995-1996, no IEP meeting was held and no IEP was written. For 1996-1997 and 1997-1998, the Hort class did not meet his needs. His self-injurious and disruptive behaviors were serious, but there was no functional analysis assessment or behavior intervention plan, which California's Hughes Bill required. Data collection was poor, the room was noisy, occupational therapy was minimal, and his progress was trivial. Promised integration and speech services were not fully delivered. However, the Hearing Officer found that the new summer 1998 class and the 1998-1999 class at Del Rio Elementary did offer FAPE. Both used discrete trial training, with consultation from Dr. Ronald Leaf. Respondents must reimburse Valley Achievement Center costs, including transportation, from May 1998 through the end of that school year. An IEP team that includes Dr. Leaf or an associate must decide compensatory education for 1998-1999 and 1999-2000. Reimbursement for the parents' private assessment was denied because Respondents' 1997 assessment was appropriate.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a student with autism whose serious behaviors went without an FAA or behavior plan. The Hearing Officer treated that gap, along with poor data and undelivered IEP services, as a denial of FAPE. It also illustrates compensatory education being left to an IEP team that had to include an outside expert.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1 (1995-1996). Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1995-1996 school year?

    No IEP meeting was held and no legally sufficient IEP was developed for 1995-1996. This caused a loss of educational opportunity, seriously infringed parent participation, and denied FAPE under W.G. v. Target Range.

  2. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1 (1996-1997). Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1996-1997 school year? (a) needs; (b) educational benefit; (c) conformity with IEP

    The Hort class denied FAPE. It had no functional analysis assessment (FAA) or behavior plan despite serious behaviors. Data collection was inadequate, the room was distracting, and OT was late and insufficient. Progress was de minimis, and integration and speech services were not delivered as written.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1 (1997-1998). Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year? (a) needs; (b) educational benefit; (c) conformity with IEP

    The program had no effective behavior plan, a deficient discrete trial training (DTT) component, a distracting setting and minimal sensory supports. The student made no progress in communication (PECS) or behavior, and integration and speech services were not fully delivered, so FAPE was denied.

  4. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2. Did Respondents offer STUDENT a FAPE for the extended school year (ESY) during the summer of 1998?

    The new two-student DTT class offered for summer 1998 met the student's needs and conformed to his IEP. It included daily speech, added OT and APE, an extra aide, sensory equipment and an offered FAA/BIP.

  5. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Did the District offer a FAPE for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 school year?

    The Del Rio Elementary autism class offered in the August 11, 1998 IEP offered FAPE. It had three hours of daily DTT, direct OT and APE, daily speech, one or two aides, community outings, integration, an FAA/BIP and ongoing consultation from Dr. Leaf.

  6. Issue 4. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attending the Valley Achievement Center (VAC)?

    VAC was appropriate and the parents gave timely notice. Reimbursement was ordered from May 1998 through the end of the 1997-1998 regular school year, but denied for ESY 1998 and 1998-1999 because FAPE was offered for those periods.

  7. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. Is STUDENT entitled to an additional year of school to compensate for the District's failure to provide him with FAPE during the 1995-1996, 1996-1997, and 1997-1998 school years?

    Compensatory education was awarded for three years of denied FAPE. Instead of an extra year past age 21, which was too speculative, the IEP team (with Dr. Leaf or an associate) must set the form of compensatory services for 1998-1999 and 1999-2000, including ESY.

  8. Issue 6. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an assessment completed by Robin J. Eliason?

    Respondents' 1997 triennial, OT and APE assessments were appropriate under Education Code sections 56320 and 56324, so the parents were not reimbursed for the Eliason assessment.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 15 calendar days of receiving proof from the parents, Respondents shall reimburse the costs, including transportation, of the student attending Valley Achievement Center's educational program from his May 1998 enrollment to the end of the 1997-1998 regular school year. No dollar amount stated.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 business days of the decision, Respondents shall convene an IEP meeting, with Dr. Leaf or one of his associates participating, to determine the appropriate form of compensatory education.
  • Compensatory education. Compensatory education for three years of denied FAPE, supplementing the student's current program and his 1999-2000 program, including ESY. The IEP team must weigh his needs and ability to tolerate a longer school day against his right to compensation. It must consider additional PECS instruction, individual DTT instruction and support to parents. Day-for-day replacement is not required (Puyallup). No hours specified.
  • Order to assess. If the parents enroll the student in Respondents' 1998-1999 program, Respondents shall immediately begin a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of his behavior.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. When the FAA is complete, Respondents shall convene an IEP meeting to discuss it and develop a behavioral intervention plan consistent with the FAA and the Hughes Bill, and shall implement the BIP immediately once developed.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Alamo Heights v. State Board of Education; M.C. ex rel. J.C. v. Central Regional School District; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Todd D. v. Andrews; Landgraf v. USI Film Products

People named in the decision

  • Janis Spinozzi, coordinator of special education, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
  • Wanda Hall, director of special education; principal of Richardson Center, Kern County Superintendent of Schools
  • Sue (Susanne) Cowan, special day class teacher (1991-1994, Pioneer School), KCSOS
  • Regina Beck, special day class teacher, Blair Learning Center, KCSOS
  • Julie MacDonell, special day class teacher, Hort Elementary School, KCSOS
  • Anthony W. Coe, school psychologist (1997 triennial assessment), KCSOS
  • Sherilyn Sarff, speech-language therapist and assessor, KCSOS
  • Phyllis Hix, occupational therapist (OT assessment), KCSOS
  • Bill (William J.) Kalivas, adapted physical education teacher and assessor, KCSOS
  • Ronald Leaf, Ph.D., autism consultant, co-director of Autism Partnership, Autism Partnership (contracted by KCSOS)
  • Gregory Rhoten, teacher of preschool children with autism; DTT consultant and trainer, KCSOS
  • Robin J. Eliason, private behavior consultant; expert witness for Student, Applied Behavioral Consultants
  • Dave (David) Onsum, Ph.D., director of special services/special education, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
  • Nana Colleen O'Neill, teacher of ESY 1998 autism class at Richardson Center, KCSOS
  • Lizette Swanson, teacher of proposed 1998-1999 class at Del Rio School, KCSOS program at Rosedale Union Elementary School District campus
  • Pamela Woodruff, assistant coordinator; former service coordinator, Kern Regional Center
  • Jean Calvillo, service coordinator, Kern Regional Center
  • Catherine Godges, registered occupational therapist providing OT at VAC, Valley Achievement Center (contracted)
  • Melissa Dawn, program specialist, Valley Achievement Center
  • Richard Couch, Ph.D., clinical director, Valley Achievement Center
  • Janet Buis, occupational therapist who assessed student as an infant
  • Edward Ross Ritvo, M.D., expert witness for Respondents, retired, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
  • Danielle A. Bresee, program specialist, KCSOS
  • Mark Fulmer, Ed.D., director of special programs, KCSOS
  • Stacy Lee Quint, behavioral specialist (Del Rio program), KCSOS
  • Fletcher Scott, speech and language therapist (Del Rio program), KCSOS
  • Valley Achievement Center, certified nonpublic school (parents' unilateral placement), Bakersfield

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Bakersfield, California, on June 23, 24, 25, and 26, August 12, 13, and 14, and September 3, 1998. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by Debra J. Wright, paralegal with the law offices of Maureen Graves. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was attorney Andrea Brook Waks of Ms. Graves’ office and STUDENT’s mother. STUDENT’s father and grandmother were present for portions of the hearing. Respondents Panama-Buena Vista Union School District (District) and Kern County Superintendent of Schools (KCSOS) were represented at the hearing by attorney Stacy L. Inman of Schools Legal Service. Attorney Melvin Peters of Schools Legal Service was present for a portion of the hearing. Also present on behalf of the District was Janis Spinozzi, coordinator of special education. Present on behalf of KCSOS was Wanda Hall, director of special education.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and, following receipt of written closing briefs, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1995-1996, 1996-1997, and 1997-1998 school years?

(2) Did Respondents offer STUDENT a FAPE for the extended school year (ESY) during the summer of 1998?

(3) Did Respondents offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?

(4) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s attending the Valley Achievement Center (VAC)?

(5) Is STUDENT entitled to an additional year of school to compensate for the District’s failure to provide him with FAPE during the 1995-1996, 1996-1997, and 1997-1998 school years?

(6) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an assessment completed by Robin J. Eliason?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a 10-year-old student with the diagnosis of autism and mental retardation. He also has mild cerebral palsy. STUDENT resides within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Panama-Buena Vista Union School District. Special education services for the District are provided by contract with the Kern County Superintendent of Schools. STUDENT’s individualized educational program (IEP) includes goals and objectives to improve gross motor, independent living, communication, vocational, domestic, self-help, and leisure skills. STUDENT is entitled to speech and language, occupational therapy (OT), adapted physical education (APE), and transportation. On May 8, 1998, STUDENT’s parents removed him from the KCSOS special day class (SDC) he had been attending and enrolled him in Valley Achievement Center (VAC), a certified nonpublic school in Bakersfield, California. STUDENT continues to attend VAC.

The KCSOS initially assessed STUDENT when he was eight months old. In July 1989, STUDENT began receiving services through the KCSOS’ infant development program. He attended school two days each week for a total of four hours. Beginning in April 1991, STUDENT attended an SDC taught by Sue Cowan. The initial purpose of the placement was to further evaluate STUDENT. STUDENT’s placement continued with Ms. Cowan at Pioneer School through the 1993-1994 school year. In June 1994, STUDENT entered the SDC at Blair Learning Center, which was taught by Regina Beck. He attended Ms. Beck’s class during the 1994-1995 school year. There is no evidence of an agreed-upon IEP for the 1995-1996 school year; however, STUDENT returned to the SDC at Blair in the fall of 1995. Shortly after the beginning of the school year, STUDENT’s parents removed him from the class because of the staff’s use of physical restraints with STUDENT. While visiting the classroom, MOTHER had observed STUDENT seated with his shirt pulled over the back of the chair. STUDENT also had a strap wrapped around him and the chair, which was secured in the back with Velcro. A long-term substitute teacher was present in the class at that time. The report of this incident resulted in staff being reassigned elsewhere and curriculum changes being made. STUDENT returned to the SDC for the remainder of the school year. Throughout the 1995-1996 school year, a number of meetings took place between the parents of children with autism and KCSOS administrators. By April 1996, KCSOS presented an outline for a new program for the children with autism. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 3K.)

In the fall of 1996, STUDENT entered the newly formed SDC at Hort Elementary School. The class was designed to teach children with autism utilizing the TEACCH model. Julie MacDonell taught the class of six students, who ranged in age from 9 years old to 15 years old. STUDENT, as well as other students, had picture schedules of their daily activities. STUDENT also had a picture exchange system (PECS). STUDENT’s IEP called for the speech and language therapist to work with him in the classroom two times a week on PECS. STUDENT’s IEP also called for mainstreaming during recess and lunch. Goals and objectives in the IEP addressed improving STUDENT’s language, functional communication, fine and gross motor, self-care, socialization, and cognitive skills.

As part of a triennial assessment in January and February 1997, school psychologist Anthony W. Coe completed a psychological assessment of STUDENT, Sherilyn Sarff completed a speech and language assessment, and Ms. MacDonell completed an assessment of STUDENT’s developmental levels. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 2Z; Respondents’ Exhibit 41.) On February 19, 1997, the IEP team met to review the results of the triennial assessment. The team agreed to supplement previous goals and objectives and to add integration with nondisabled peers during nutrition. The parents requested additional assessments, including OT and APE. On April 15, 1997, the IEP team reconvened to discuss the results of the OT assessment completed by Phyllis Hix on March 12, 1997, and the APE assessment completed by Bill Kalivas on April 1, 1997. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 2T and 2S) The IEP team did not develop OT goals and objectives; however, the team recommended that STUDENT receive 20 minutes of OT consultation per month. The team developed APE goals and objectives and recommended weekly APE for 20 to 30 minutes. The IEP team also discussed a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) that had been developed related to STUDENT’s behavior on the bus. STUDENT had difficulty remaining seated while riding on the bus and a harness was employed to keep him from getting out of his seat. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 2R)

STUDENT returned to Ms. MacDonell’s class for the 1997-1998 school year. In January 1998, STUDENT’s parents and the Kern Regional Center arranged for STUDENT to attend an after-school program at VAC. The IEP team met on March 5, 1998, to review STUDENT’s progress. The team wrote goals and objectives for OT. District and KCSOS members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT continue in his current placement at Hort, which then included the services of speech and language therapy two times a week, OT, and APE.(Footnote 1) The parents requested that the IEP team consider placing STUDENT in VAC’s school program. The IEP team did not reach an agreement on goals and objectives or placement. Sometime after the IEP meeting, KCSOS contracted with Ronald Leaf, Ph.D., co-director of Autism Partnership, to provide consultation services to Ms. MacDonell’s class. Gregory Rhoten, a teacher of preschool-age children with autism for KCSOS, was also asked to consult with Ms. MacDonell.

On April 17, 1998, the IEP team reconvened to further discuss STUDENT’s placement. Members of the IEP team from the District and KCSOS again recommended that STUDENT continue attending Hort. They also recommended increasing STUDENT’s speech and language therapy to three 30-minute sessions each week. The parents did not consent to the proposed goals and objectives or placement and continued to request that the team consider placing STUDENT at VAC.

In a letter dated April 27, 1998, STUDENT’s parents informed Kern County Schools and the District of their belief that the Hort School program was not meeting STUDENT’s needs. They also stated their intent to remove STUDENT from Hort on May 8, 1998, if an independent assessment of STUDENT by Robin Eliason substantiated their concerns. On May 1, 1998, Ms. Eliason observed at both Hort and VAC. (Petitioner’s Exhibit U) On May 4, 1998, the PARENTS confirmed to the District and KCSOS that STUDENT’s last day at Hort would be May 8, 1998. Additionally, on May 4, 1998, they requested a due process hearing. On that same date, Respondents sent a notice for an IEP meeting on May 13, 1998. The notice to the PARENTS was incorrectly addressed. It is unclear when they actually received the notice; however, on May 11, 1998, Respondents faxed a notice of the meeting to Ms. Wright, STUDENT’s advocate. In a letter dated May 8, 1998, Dave Onsum, Ph.D., District director of special services, informed the PARENTS that the District and KCSOS were in the process of developing a new program to address STUDENT’s educational needs. Dr. Onsum stated that the class, which was scheduled to open on June 1, 1998, would be located at the Richardson Center, which also housed a preschool class and a Head Start program. Dr. Onsum identified the teacher as Nana O’Neill. In the letter, Dr. Onsum offered the following services for STUDENT: weekly OT for 30 minutes, weekly APE for 45 minutes, and three 30-minutes sessions per week of speech and language. (Petitioner’s Exhibit Y)

In a letter dated May 12, 1998, Maureen Graves, an attorney retained by the parents, informed the Respondents that the PARENTS would not be attending the scheduled IEP meeting.(Footnote 2) She suggested in the alternative that the parties mediate their dispute. The IEP team convened on May 13, 1998; however, neither the PARENTS nor their representatives were present at the meeting. Members of the IEP team from the District and KCSOS recommended that STUDENT attend the new program for the period from June 1 to September 10, 1998. The proposed IEP states that the class would employ discrete trial training (DTT) and applied behavioral analysis (ABA) models. STUDENT would also receive daily sensory intervention (SI). A PECS would be employed throughout the day, and social interaction with age appropriate peers would occur two times a week for one hour. Goals and objectives, which were initially drafted at an IEP meeting on April 17, 1998, would continue. Respondents offered the following additional services: an additional one-to-one aide, daily speech and language therapy sessions of 30 minutes each, two sessions a week of APE, and weekly OT consultation. Respondents also offered to obtain the services of someone from Autism Partnership to conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA), to develop a behavior intervention plan (BIP) as a result of the FAA, and to provide weekly consultation. The IEP team also offered an additional one-to-one instructional assistant and recommended that STUDENT’s APE be increased to two 30-minute sessions each week and that STUDENT be provided two additional sessions of speech and language by an aide. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 2F.) Ms. Hall took a copy of the IEP to MOTHER at her place of employment, which is the Kern County Regional Center. MOTHER did not consent to the IEP and the matter proceeded to hearing.

On August 11, 1998, the IEP team met to discuss STUDENT’s placement for the 1998-1999 school year. Respondents offered the same level of speech and language, APE, and OT as in the IEP developed on May 13, 1998. The following changes were made to the program described in the prior IEP: in situations recommended by the behavioral specialist, an additional aide would be provided so that STUDENT would be assisted by two aides; and weekly community-based activities were added. (Respondents’ Exhibit 89)

Petitioner contends that Respondents have not offered him an appropriate placement and that he is entitled to have his enrollment at VAC funded by Respondents. Petitioner also contends that he is entitled to compensatory services during the 1999 to 2000 school year as a result of Respondents’ failure to provide him with FAPE for the past three school years. Respondents contend that Ms. O’Neill’s class offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT, that they offered him an appropriate placement for the ESY 1998, and that the class taught by Lizette Swanson at Del Rio School in the Rosedale School District offers STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1998-1999 school year.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1995-1996, 1996-1997, and 1997-1998 school years?

Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; California Education Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).)(Footnote 3)

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provided instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Rowley, 458 at 207-208.)

In determining whether the school district has offered a FAPE, the focus is on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307. If the district has offered a FAPE, the district is not required to place the student in the program preferred by the parents, even if their preferred program is likely to result in greater educational benefit to the student than the district’s program. Id.

In addition, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (Education Code § 56301.)

In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.) STUDENT’s parents are seeking compensatory services for the alleged denial of FAPE for the school years 1995-1996 through 1997-1998. They also are seeking reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s attending VAC beginning in May 1998. The appropriateness of STUDENT’s educational program for each school year is addressed below.

1995-1996 School Year

The Supreme Court in Rowley recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ participation in the IEP process may result in the denial of a free appropriate public education to the student. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479.

Petitioner contends that multiple procedural violations by the Respondents resulted in a denial of FAPE to him. Petitioner asserts that there was no IEP meeting and, hence, no agreed-upon IEP for the 1995-1996 school year. The IEP team must meet at least annually to review the student’s progress, the IEP, and to make any necessary revisions. Education Code § 56343.

The last IEP for STUDENT prior to the 1995-1996 school year is dated October 25, 1994. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 4B.) This IEP covers goals, objectives, placement, and services that continued only to October 1995. There was no evidence of an addendum to the IEP extending the effective date of the IEP or of parental consent to waive time lines for developing a new IEP. Therefore, pursuant to Education Code § 56343, Respondents were required to convene an IEP in October 1995. Respondents’ exhibits include a partially completed IEP, which appears to have been drafted by Respondents in anticipation of an IEP meeting. (Respondent’s Exhibit 39.) Neither MOTHER nor any other witnesses recalled participating in an IEP meeting at any time during the 1995-1996 school year to review STUDENT’s progress or to plan STUDENT’s program for the 1995-1996 school year. The Hearing Officer concludes that there is no persuasive evidence that the IEP meeting took place or that an IEP was developed for the 1995-1996 school year.

Even if the Respondent’s Exhibit 39 could be construed as an IEP, it was never offered to the parents, never agreed to by the parents, and is significantly deficient. A legally sufficient IEP must include the following: present levels of educational performance; annual goals and short-term objectives; special education instruction and related services; the extent of mainstreaming; the projected date for initiating the program and services and their anticipated duration; and objective evaluation procedures to determine progress toward meeting objectives. Education Code § 56345(a). The information contained in the draft IEP is limited to the following: general information identifying STUDENT, present levels of performance, goals, and objectives. The IEP also indicates the date for which the meeting apparently was scheduled--October 11, 1995. The IEP does not include any information regarding placement, services, or the extent of mainstreaming for the 1995-1996 school year, and there are no signatures on the document.

In order to constitute a denial of FAPE, procedural violations must result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. W.G. at 1481. The IEP is the foundation and the road map of the special education student’s education. It defines the direction the student’s program must take and the services that are necessary to meet the student’s needs. As to the 1995-1996 school year, STUDENT’s parents and other members of the IEP team did not have any input into STUDENT’s educational programming or to the services STUDENT required to address his needs. Without a legally sufficient IEP to guide the teacher, there also was no method for evaluating whether the program she provided was addressing STUDENT’s needs or for evaluating whether he was making progress. The Hearing Officer concludes that Respondents failure to convene an IEP meeting and to develop a legally sufficient IEP resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT and seriously infringed on the parents’ rights to participate in the IEP process. In W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals concluded that an incomplete and an insufficient IEP resulted in the denial of a FAPE and that it was unnecessary to address the issue of whether the student’s placement satisfied the requirements of a FAPE set forth in Rowley The same is true in this case. The Hearing Officer concludes that Respondents failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1995-1996 school year and that it is unnecessary to further analyze the program that he actually received during that school year.

1996-1997 School Year

As stated above, an appropriate educational program must (a) be designed to meet the student's unique needs, (b) provide the student with some educational benefit, and (c) conform with the IEP. Prior to determining the appropriateness of STUDENT’s educational program and placement for the 1996-1997 school year, it is necessary to have some understanding of STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. The evidence establishes that STUDENT has significant deficits in all areas of development. When assessed at the beginning of 1997, STUDENT’s scores on measures of independence, motor skills, social interaction, communication, personal living skills, and community living skills were near or at levels expected for a two-year-old child. (See Respondents’ Exhibit 64.) Susanne Cowan, STUDENT’s SDC teacher during the 1993-1994 school year, described STUDENT as “very distractible” and stated that in her classroom STUDENT frequently moved from one activity to another. Julie MacDonell, STUDENT’s teacher during the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998 school years, also described STUDENT’s attention as poor.

Additionally, the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers, his mother, Kern Regional Center (KRC) staff, and other professionals who have observed STUDENT establishes that STUDENT has long-standing and significant behavioral problems. Ms. MacDonell testified that STUDENT’s behavioral issues when he entered her classroom in the fall of 1996 included poor compliance, self-injurious behavior, screaming, and, at times, throwing things. According to Ms. MacDonell, STUDENT “always” engaged in self-stimulatory behavior unless he really focused on an activity.

Pamela Woodruff, assistant coordinator of Kern Regional Center (KRC), previously served as STUDENT’s service coordinator at KRC. Ms. Woodruff observed STUDENT at school on three or more occasions and attended IEP meetings on his behalf. Ms. Woodruff testified that during her observations, STUDENT engaged in self-stimulatory behavior that included chewing on his clothes, pulling clothes over his head, hitting himself in the head, slapping himself, rocking, and “going after” his ears. Other witnesses observed STUDENT shaking his head and scratching his face and neck.

Robin J. Eliason, who testified on behalf of STUDENT, holds a master’s degree in applied behavioral analysis and is employed by Applied Behavioral Consultants (ABC), a private agency providing services to children with autism. Ms. Eliason designs educational and behavioral programs for children with autism, trains teachers, and conducts workshops for parents of children with autism. Ms. Eliason testified that STUDENT engages in behavior that is dangerous to himself or to others. For example, during her observation, STUDENT hit himself in the head with an open hand. He also pulled his shirt over his head on numerous occasions. Ms. Eliason noted that STUDENT was accompanied at all times by an aide, who needed to provide nearly full physical prompt to move STUDENT from one area to the next. She also stated that the longest period of time during which STUDENT did not engage in excessive behavior was two minutes. Ms. Eliason’s observations of STUDENT occurred during the 1997-1998 school year; however, her testimony was consistent with observations of STUDENT during the 1996-1997 school year and with the testimony of his teachers and parent.

In summary, the evidence establishes that STUDENT engaged in self-stimulatory behavior, had other significant behavioral problems that included noncompliance and distractibility, and engaged in behavior that was potentially dangerous to himself or to others.

A number of witnesses testified to their belief that STUDENT’s poor attention and behavior was, in part, related to “sensory issues.” Ms. Eliason testified that STUDENT’s pulling his shirt over his head may be indicative of excessive sensory stimuli. Ms. Eliason noted that STUDENT covered his ears during DTT when it was taking place close to an operating air conditioner. She did not observe either of these behaviors during quiet periods in the classroom. Other witnesses observed STUDENT covering his ears, being distracted by both light and sound, and mouthing objects, which also could be related to sensory sensitivity. (Testimony of Ms. Woodruff, Ms. MacDonell, and MOTHER) Ms. MacDonell noted also that STUDENT likes to be held and squeezed, and to sit in the “ball pit.”(Footnote 4) These observations are consistent with subsequent observations of STUDENT by VAC staff. Catherine Godges, registered occupational therapist (OTR), has been contracted since July 1998 to provide OT services to STUDENT two times a week at VAC. Ms. Godges consulted with TEACCH classrooms in North Carolina for four years. Ms. Godges initially met STUDENT in 1991 and recently assessed him. Based on that assessment, she concluded that STUDENT is very severely sensory defensive in multiple systems. Ms. Godges also concluded that STUDENT has tactile, auditory, visual, vestibular, and proprioceptive defensiveness and that his defensiveness manifests in self-stimulatory behavior and interferes with his ability to learn.(Footnote 5) For example, in response to noise, STUDENT hits himself on the ears and scratches his back. STUDENT’s visual defensiveness prevents him from looking directly at an object. Ms. Godges noted that STUDENT functions better in natural light. STUDENT’s auditory defensiveness manifests in his difficulty in focusing on the important sounds in his environment. For example, the buzz of a florescent light competes with the teacher’s instructions for STUDENT’s attention. STUDENT has low muscle tone with tightness in his heel cord. Melissa Dawn, program specialist at VAC, testified that her first observations of STUDENT’s behavior early in 1998, let her to concluded that STUDENT is sensitive to sound and light and to some touch. The conclusions of Ms. Eliason, Ms. Godges, and Ms. Dawn were based on observations subsequent to the 1996-1997 school year; however, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s needs have remained relatively constant over time. The testimony of Janet Buis, OTR, who assessed STUDENT as an infant, substantiates that STUDENT exhibited sensory issues since infancy. Ms. Buis did not have any current recollection of her assessment of STUDENT as an infant and did not have any opinion related to STUDENT’s present ability to benefit from sensory integration therapy; however, her recommendations in 1991 included the use of sensory activities such as “deep tactile pressure, swinging, handling beads, etc. . .” She also recommended a full OT assessment. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 4J.) The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Godges persuasive. She has recently worked with STUDENT and holds appropriate qualifications as an OTR to draw conclusions regarding STUDENT’s sensory needs. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT exhibits sensory defensiveness in a number of areas.

To summarize, the evidence establishes that during the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT was distractible and had a poor attention span, was significantly delayed in all areas of development, exhibited sensory defensiveness, and engaged in self-stimulatory behavior and behavior that potentially was dangerous to himself or to others.

A number of witnesses described the essential components of an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Edward Ross Ritvo, M.D., was called to testify on behalf of Respondents. Dr. Ritvo retired two years ago from his position as a professor at the Neuropsychiatric Institute, University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), School of Medicine, with which he has been affiliated since 1963. (See Respondents’ Exhibit 90) During his testimony, Dr. Ritvo discussed several professional studies related to the education of children with autism reported by Ivar Lovaas of UCLA and by Bryna Siegel of the University of California, San Francisco. Based on Dr. Ritvo’s reading of this and other professional literature and on his many years of clinical work related to children with autism, Dr. Ritvo described what he believes to be the components of an appropriate program for STUDENT. The program must be structured and have a sufficient number of aides to assist STUDENT. The program must include OT or physical therapy (PT) services and must provide opportunities for STUDENT to integrate with nondisabled peers. STUDENT requires an individualized behavioral program such as DTT to allow him to benefit from his education. Dr. Ritvo recommended up to 20 hours per week of DTT delivered in two-hour increments because, in his clinical experience, students generally are unable to attend for longer periods of time. Dr. Ritvo concluded that it would be unreasonable to expect STUDENT to attend for a longer period of time. Additionally, STUDENT needs time during the school day to work on daily living skills.

Danielle A. Bresee has served as STUDENT’s program specialist through KCSOS since January 1996, with the exception of one summer. While STUDENT attended Hort, Ms. Bresee visited his class as frequently as two times each week. She also has observed STUDENT at VAC. Ms. Bresee previously served as an SDC teacher and is a credentialed speech and language therapist. She participated in training with Dr. Leaf and in five-day workshop on PECS. Ms. Bresee currently teaches a class in autism at California State University Bakersfield. Ms. Bresee testified that the TEACCH program employed at Hort is designed specifically for persons with autism and is based on the premise that persons with autism need to understand how the world works. Hence, TEACCH provides structure to work tasks and to the environment. Ms. Bresee testified that DTT is also an appropriate technique to employ with STUDENT because it breaks skills into small pieces which he can then learn. DTT also provides direct instruction, which is necessary because STUDENT cannot learn observationally.

Other experts who testified concurred with the testimony of Dr. Ritvo and Ms. Bresee that DTT and OT or PT are essential components of an appropriate program for STUDENT; however, they recommended a more intense DTT program than the 20 hours per week proposed by Dr. Ritvo. Those experts included Ronald Leaf of Autism Partnership, with whom KCSOS has contracted to design and implement a program for children with autism. Dr. Leaf testified that a student such as STUDENT needs approximately 30 hours per week of intensive intervention. Ms. Eliason also testified that STUDENT requires a school day that is longer than the traditional school day to allow him to receive all of the instruction and services that he requires in addition to an intense behavioral program. Those services need to address sensory needs and provide instruction to develop community and self-help skills. The essentially undisputed testimony of Ms. Godges establishes that STUDENT should be provided a “sensory diet” throughout the day to calm his system and to meet his sensory needs. A sensory diet includes brushing, heavy work, and joint compression. Ms. Godges also suggested modifying STUDENT’s environment to address sensory needs. For example, STUDENT work much better in a quiet environment that is free from “white” noise.

To summarize, the uncontroverted testimony of the persons with the greatest expertise in autism establishes that an appropriate program for STUDENT is structured and offers an intensive, individualized behavioral component, such as DTT. The DTT instruction should be between 20 to 30 hours each week. The program also must provide STUDENT with instruction in community and living skills, sufficient support from classroom aides, and opportunities for integration with nondisabled peers. Additionally, STUDENT requires services, such as OT, PT, and/or APE to address his sensory and motor deficits.

(a) Did STUDENT’s placement at Hort during the 1996-1997 school year meet his unique and individual needs?

Petitioner contends that his placement during the 1996-1997 school year was deficient because it did not meet his behavioral, sensory, or communication needs. He asserts that the placement also failed to address his motor deficiencies. Respondents contend that Ms. MacDonell’s class and the services provided for by the IEP offered STUDENT an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment.

STUDENT’s IEP for the 1996-1997 school year included goals and objectives to develop functional communication, to increase fine and gross motor skills, to improve self-care in the areas of toileting and drinking from a cup, and to increase cognitive skills. STUDENT’s IEP at the beginning of the school year included speech and language therapy two times a week and integration at recess and lunch for a total of 300 minutes a week. In April 1997, the IEP team added monthly OT consultation for a total of 20 minutes and APE.(Footnote 6)

The testimony of Ms. MacDonell, SDC teacher, provided the following undisputed information regarding her class.(Foonote 7) There were four or five students with autism in the class. The students ranged in age from nine years to fifteen-years-old. Ms. MacDonell was assisted by two instructional assistants and, while STUDENT was in the class, there were three to four aides. The class began at 8:30 a.m. All of the students ate breakfast in the cafeteria, where they used PECS to request their food preferences. After breakfast, the students walked around the track to “get air and to get their energy out.” The students engaged in “work periods” throughout the day for a total of approximately 10 hours each week. Discrete trial teaching (DTT) techniques were employed throughout the school day and also delivered individually in sessions of from 5 to 15 minutes each. The room was separated by dividers into play, quiet, TEACCH, and DTT areas. Each area was identified by picture icons. STUDENT had a schedule with attached pictures to match to each area of the classroom.

There is no dispute that some appropriate teaching techniques were employed in Ms. MacDonell’s class; however, Petitioner raised concerns regarding whether sufficient data were collected to provide a consistent program and one that accurately reflected STUDENT’s progress or lack thereof. Based on a review of the available data, Ms. Eliason testified that the Hort staff did not collect sufficient or appropriate data to allow them to make decisions about the effectiveness of their teaching. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 5P.) Ms. Eliason testified that data should be taken to measure STUDENT’s progress and to determine the level of prompting that he needs. Data should also be collected so that the program is delivered with consistency and so that the next person working with STUDENT can identify what took place during the prior session. Ms. Eliason testified that identifying what is motivating or reinforcing to STUDENT is also necessary. Ms. Eliason testified that the available data appeared to have been take weekly and was difficult to read and interpret. Ms. Eliason stated that the data did not allow her to determine STUDENT’s progress. Additionally, Ms. Eliason testified that she did not observe systematic fading of prompts. For example, the staff moved from full physical prompting to verbal prompting and vise versa. They did not utilize gestural prompting and modeling.

Nana Colleen O’Neill testified on behalf of Respondents. She taught the ESY program proposed for STUDENT for the summer of 1998. Ms. O’Neill is currently working toward multiple subject and severely handicapped specialist teaching credentials, which she anticipates will be awarded in May 1999. Ms. O’Neill’s prior experience with children with autism was as a behavior specialist or a behavior technician for a private agency for approximately two years. Her responsibilities in those positions included setting up and implementing in-home programs using discrete trial teaching and providing related parent training classes. (See Respondent’s Exhibit 76) Ms. O’Neill testified generally regarding DTT. Ms. O’Neill’s testimony supports Ms. Eliason’s position related to the importance of data collection. Ms. O’Neill stated that it is important to take data to track progress, to make objective determinations related to modifying the program, and to ensure consistency. Ms. O’Neill testified that she cannot tell from the data what was happening in STUDENT’s DTT sessions in Ms. MacDonell’s class. Mr. Rhoten also testified that the data sheets Ms. MacDonell was using did not provide adequate information to allow the staff to plan a program and to provide a consistent program.

Ms. Eliason, Ms. O’Neill, and Mr. Rhoten have a great deal of experience working with children with autism. Their testimony was very detailed and demonstrated a great deal of knowledge about DTT/ABA, as well as regarding the needs of children with autism. The Hearing Officer notes that both Mr. Rhoten and Ms. O’Neill were employed by Respondents, yet testified about deficiencies in Respondents’ program. Mr. Rhoten currently consults and trains other KCSOS staff related to the use of DTT. The Hearing Officer finds their testimony persuasive that inadequate data collection led to a lack of information related to STUDENT’s progress and negatively impacted the staff’s ability to address STUDENT’s needs.

Petitioner asserts that his behavioral needs were not addressed while attending Hort. It is uncontroverted that STUDENT’s behavior significantly interfered with his ability to benefit from his education while in Ms. MacDonell’s class. As discussed above, nearly every witness expressed concerns related to STUDENT’s behavior. In fact, his lack of attention and compliance necessitated the use of a great deal of physical prompting from staff to get STUDENT to move from one area to another and to participate in classroom activities even to a limited extent. Conspicuously absent from the IEP are any goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s behavior. The IEP also does not include any services to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs. Ms. Eliason testified that there should have been a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT’s behavior and a behavior intervention plan (BIP) to address the inappropriate behaviors. Ms. O’Neill, who would have been STUDENT’s summer school teacher, testified that based on what she knows about STUDENT, his behaviors would warrant a FAA and possibly development of a BIP. There also was no evidence that any meaningful data were collected regarding STUDENT’s behavior. Ms. MacDonell conceded that there was not a written behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT; however, she stated that to address his behavioral needs, she employed a number of techniques that included ignoring the behavior and removing stimulating items from his environment.

Respondents are required to provide services that are necessary for the student to benefit from special education. Education Code § 56363. Moreover, a FAA and development of a BIP satisfying the requirements of the Hughes Bill are required whenever a special education student “exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP.” 5 C.C.R. § 3001(h).(Footnote 8) Based on the evidence regarding STUDENT’s behavior and the testimony related to the need for a BIP, it is concluded that to meet STUDENT’s needs, Respondents were required to undertake a FAA of STUDENT’s behavior and to develop a BIP consistent with the findings of the FAA. Respondents failed to conduct a FAA and to develop a BIP, except to address STUDENT’s behavior on the bus.

Petitioner asserts that his sensory deficits were not addressed during his placement in Ms. MacDonell’s class. He asserts that the noise level and general confusion in the class were overstimulating , which exacerbated his behavioral problems. Ms. MacDonell testified that the noise level in her class varied. One student was admittedly loud. She also testified that many of the students exhibited inappropriate behavior that included pinching, grabbing, biting, self-slapping, and noncompliance. Ms. MacDonell described one student as “aggressive” and noted that another student would sometimes lie on the floor. Ms. MacDonell stated that the class could be perceived as overstimulating. Given STUDENT’s distractibility and sensory defensiveness, which is discussed more fully below, the evidence establishes that the class was not sufficiently distraction free to allow STUDENT to benefit from his education.

Moreover, until April 1997, STUDENT was not provided any specific services such as OT, PT, or APE to address motor and sensory deficits. There is no evidence that Respondents assessed STUDENT’s sensory and motor deficits in a timely manner. When services were ultimately provided, they were insufficient. The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s motor skills are impaired, in part, because of mild cerebral palsy; however, Respondents did not conduct OT or PT assessments from 1991 until the spring of 1997. The Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Buis had recommended in 1991 that a complete OT assessment be undertaken when STUDENT entered school. Respondents did not present any credible evidence regarding the ways in which STUDENT’s motor deficits were addressed prior to April 1997, when the IEP team offered OT consultation. Moreover, Ms. Godges testified persuasively that 20 minutes of OT consultation was insufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Godges testified that STUDENT requires direct services and, because of sensory issues, requires an on-going sensory diet. This could not be accomplished through a brief consultation by the therapist. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Godges’ testimony persuasive regarding STUDENT’s need for OT services.

To address STUDENT’s communication deficits, the IEP called for speech and language therapy two times a week for 20 to 30 minutes. The stated purpose of the speech and language services from Ms. Sarff was to provide instruction in PECS. Ms. Sarff holds a degree in communication disorders and is working on an emergency credential as a speech and language pathologist for KCSOS. Ms. Sarff received PECS training from the developers of PECS. She described PECS as a “communication system for children without speech or signing skills.” The program is divided into “phases” and 80% mastery of the skills covered in a given phase is necessary before moving to the next phase. Ms. Sarff testified that when STUDENT entered Ms. MacDonell’s class in the fall of 1996, he was ready to work on Phase III of PECS. In this phase, students learn that pictures stand for something. Students then learn to discriminate between pictures. Ms. Sarff testified that she was in Ms. MacDonell’s class three times a week and worked with STUDENT on PECS during “teachable moments” on the PECS program. She did not work with him when he was “having a bad day behaviorally.” Ms. Bresee testified that the speech and language program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs because the therapist worked on PECS one-to-one with STUDENT in his natural environment. Ms. Bresee testified that to enable a student to learn, it is important to provide the instruction in the environment in which it will be used, because children with autism have difficulty generalizing. There was general agreement among the witnesses that PECS is an appropriate program to utilize with children with autism, and with STUDENT in particular; however, the testimony of Ms. Sarff and Ms. Eliason raised concerns regarding the way in which PECS was delivered. Ms. Sarff acknowledged that she did not provide PECS consistently. In response to Ms. Sarff’s testimony that she would not attempt to teach STUDENT PECS when he was “having a bad day,” Ms. Eliason reiterated the importance of maintaining the normal classroom routine for STUDENT. She also testified that abandoning the PECS session may reinforce STUDENT’s engaging inappropriate behavior as a means of escaping work. Ms. Eliason testified that she would attempt to motivate STUDENT to participate and would end on a task STUDENT could successfully complete. Ms. Eliason’s testimony is persuasive on this issue because she has a great deal of training and experience in the design and delivery of programs for children with autism.

The evidence establishes that developing community-living skills is an appropriate component of STUDENT’s education. The only evidence of anything related to this goals was the testimony of Ms. MacDonell that the students had gone on an occasional field trip. STUDENT’s significant deficits would not be satisfied by an occasional field trip into the community.

Based on the discussion above, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s placement during the 1996-1997 school year was not designed to address his needs, particularly related to his behavior.

(b) Did STUDENT’s placement at Hort during the 1996-1997 school year provide him with educational benefit?

Petitioner contends that he made little, if any, progress during the 1996-1997 school year. Respondents contend that STUDENT did make progress and benefitted from his education. Ms. Sarff testified that by the end of the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT was making progress using the PECS system. Specifically, he was able to use the phrase “I want” with four icons. The icons generally were edibles. Additionally, STUDENT was able to communicate several words by signing them. His signing vocabulary included “eat,” “please,” and “more.” Ms. Eliason testified that after analyzing the data maintained by Ms. Sarff, she concluded that STUDENT never reached mastery on Phase III and that STUDENT’s skills had regressed beginning in February 1997. As to Ms. Sarff’s testimony that STUDENT made progress in PECS, Ms. Eliason stated that her calculations of STUDENT’s progress based on the data maintained by Ms. Sarff establishes that STUDENT did not, in fact, master any of the PECS programs. Therefore, he would not have progressed to the next level. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 5P.) Respondents did not rebut Ms. Eliason’s calculations. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Eliason’s testimony persuasive regarding STUDENT’s performance on PECS.

David Onsum, District director of special education, has observed STUDENT at Hort and VAC, and has reviewed STUDENT’s educational records. Mr. Onsum testified that STUDENT’s self-abusive behavior decreased and that he met some of his goals and objectives while attending Hort. Ms. Bresee testified that STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors, including screaming, mouthing objects, and pulling his shirt over his head, reduced while attending Hort. She also testified that STUDENT was better able to transition from one activity to another and that the level of prompting was reduced from hand-over-hand to verbal. He also was able to do some TEACCH tasks independently.

A review of STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives by Ms. MacDonell reveals that STUDENT met only two of 13 objectives. The two objectives were in the area of improving language skills. STUDENT did not meet any goals or objectives related to improving fine and gross motor skills, cognitive skills, self-care, and socialization. The testimony related to STUDENT’s behavior during the 1997-1998 school year, which is discussed below, establishes that STUDENT continued to exhibit all of the same behaviors that he exhibited during the 1996-1997 school year. (Testimony of Dr. Couch and Ms. Dawn.) All of the witnesses who had observed STUDENT in a classroom environment described behavior that significantly interfered with his ability to benefit from his education. STUDENT’s attention was so fleeting that he required physical prompting to engage him in any activities. For example, he was able during one observation to pay attention for only 10 seconds. (Testimony of Ms. Eliason.) Ms. Sarff testified that she often was unable to work on PECS with STUDENT because of his behavior. Yet there was no behavioral program in place that provided the staff with consistent ways in which to respond to STUDENT’s behavior. Without a specific plan to address his behaviors, STUDENT could not have been expected to from whichever curriculum model was provided (DTT, TEACCH, or PECS) in the classroom. Moreover, there is no data to substantiate that STUDENT made more than de minimis progress during the 1996-1997 school year. Whatever progress STUDENT made was legally inadequate. De minimis benefit is insufficient to meet the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. M.C. ex rel. J.C. v. Central Regional School District (3d. Cir. 1996) 81 F.3d 389, cert. denied, 117 S.Ct. 176 (1996); Polk v. Central susquehana Intermediate Unit 16 (3d. Cir. 1988) 853 F.2d 171, cert. denied, 109 S.Ct. 835 (1989).

Given that STUDENT made minimal progress and the placement did not include all of the necessary elements to address his needs, the Hearing Officer concludes that Respondents’ program during the 1996-1997 school year did not to provide him with legally adequate educational benefit.

(c) Did STUDENT’s placement at Hort during the 1996-1997 school year conform with his IEP?

STUDENT’s IEP called for integration with regular education peers during recess and lunch. When the IEP team revised STUDENT’s IEP in April 1997, integration was to occur during morning snack as well. Ms. MacDonell testified that mainstreaming generally did not occur except for short periods of time in the cafeteria. Ms. MacDonell’s testimony establishes that the integration component of STUDENT’s IEP was not satisfied by his placement at Hort. STUDENT’s IEP called for him to receive weekly speech and language therapy. The testimony of Sarff establishes that STUDENT’s behavior was determinative of the frequency and duration of therapy sessions. Thus, the speech and language services STUDENT received at Hort were not consistent with the frequency and duration set forth in his IEP. Because at least two elements of STUDENT’s IEP were not provided as called for by the IEP, it is concluded that STUDENT’s placement did not conform with his IEP.

Therefore, because STUDENT’s placement did not meet his needs, provide him with legally sufficient educational benefit, or conform with his IEP, it did not satisfy the requirements of an appropriate placement under IDEA and Rowley. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that Respondents did not provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year.

1997-1998 School Year

In July 1997, most provisions of the reauthorized IDEA (IDEA 1997) related to provision of FAPE became effective. While these provisions are substantially similar to prior IDEA provisions, for purposes of clarity, the new statutes are set forth below.(Footnote 9)

Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without charge; meet the standards of the State educational agency; and are provided in conformity with the individualized educational program required under Section 1414(d). "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. . . ." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).

Under IDEA 1997 an appropriate educational program must also satisfy the following: (a) be designed to meet the student's unique needs, (b) provide the student with some educational benefit, and (c) conform with the IEP.

Petitioner’s witnesses testified persuasively that STUDENT continued to exhibit significant behavioral problems during the 1997-1998 school year. Paula Davidson, the parent of a child with autism who attended the SDC at Hort, and Jean Calvillo, service coordinator for Kern Regional Center, observed Ms. MacDonell’s class in January 1998. Ms. Davidson testified that STUDENT had difficulty sitting and standing still. She described STUDENT during a DTT session as “very distracted.” During a break from a DTT session, STUDENT whined, cried, pulled his shirt over his ears, banged his head on a hard surface, and tried to bite himself. Ms. Dawn also testified that in January 1998, STUDENT exhibited a lot of self-stimulatory behavior. She stated that he would bite himself, frequently wacked himself on the back of the head, and occasionally hit his ears. STUDENT also would try to cover himself up. Ms. Dawn testified that STUDENT could not sit at a table and wait for an activity to begin. Rather, he would grab the materials and mouth them as soon as they were set on the table. Ms. Dawn described STUDENT’s behavior as “uncontrollable.” She stated that STUDENT engaged in two to three tantrums daily and that it was very difficult to engage him in any productive work. In her opinion, if another child were in the classroom with STUDENT, he would have difficulty staying seated and focused to do work. MOTHER and Ms. Eliason similarly described STUDENT. Richard Couch, Ph.D., clinical director of VAC, testified that the assessment completed in 1997 accurately described STUDENT’s skills and behavior when he met STUDENT in February 1998. Dr. Couch also described STUDENT as having an awkward gait and being distractible. Respondents’ witnesses offered scant testimony to rebut the descriptions of STUDENT’s behavior by Petitioner’s witnesses. The testimony of Petitioner’s witnesses was based on their observations of STUDENT in Ms. MacDonell’s classroom and elsewhere. They also testified persuasively that STUDENT’s educational needs remained as described above for prior school year. Based on their testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT continued to exhibit significant deficits in all areas of development and that his maladaptive behavior continued during the 1997-1998 school year.

(a) Did STUDENT’s placement at Hort during the 1997-1998 school year meet his unique and individual needs?

Petitioner contends that his placement for the 1997-1998 school year was not appropriate because it did not address his behavioral needs and did not provide appropriate services to allow him to make progress. Respondents contend that placement in Ms. MacDonell’s class offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT because it included all of the essential elements to meet his needs and to allow him to make progress. STUDENT entered the 1997-1998 school year with IEPs dated February 19, 1997, and April 15, 1997. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 2P and 2W.) The goals, objectives, and services on these IEPs extended through February 1998. The IEPs taken together called for the following services: speech and language therapy two times a week for 20 to 30 minutes; weekly APE for 20 to 30 minutes; and monthly OT consultation for 30 minutes. Integration with regular education peers was to take place for 100 minutes each week during nutrition and for 150 minutes each week during recess and physical education. Goals and objectives were to increase functional communication, language skills, cognitive skills, gross and fine motor skills, self-care, and socialization skills.

As discussed above, STUDENT’s maladaptive behavior changed little from the prior school year; however, absent from the IEP were any goals, objectives, or services to address STUDENT’s behavior. Ms. Davidson testified that the aides “managed” STUDENT rather than engaging him in any activities. By “managed,” Ms. Davidson indicated she meant being “physically led around the room or restrained.” Ms. Sarff, simply did not work with STUDENT when he was unfocused or behaving poorly. Thus, STUDENT’s behavior interfered with the instruction he received while in Ms. MacDonell’s class. Ms. Woodruff and Ms. Eliason reiterated the importance of a plan so that staff would respond similarly to STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior. They testified persuasively that consistency is necessary to bring about change to STUDENT’s behavior. Because STUDENT exhibited behavior that was dangerous to himself and potentially dangerous to others, it is concluded that a FAA should have been undertaken and a BIP developed following the FAA. Ms. Eliason did not see a BIP during her observation and surmised that there was not one because of the staff’s varied responds to STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior. There was no evidence of a BIP of some other formalized behavioral plan to ameliorate STUDENT’s significant behavioral problems.

Petitioner contends that the classroom was too distracting to allow him to focus. Ms. Eliason described the classroom environment at Hort as “crowded and compact.” Ms. Calvillo described the environment in Ms. MacDonell’s class as “loud, chaotic, and distracting.” She stated that Ms. MacDonell told her that observation occurred on a “typical day.” Ms. Calvillo concluded that STUDENT’s behavior, including flailing, screaming, and putting things over his head, was related to the noise in the environment. Based on their testimony, it is concluded that the classroom at Hort during the 1997-1998 school year was not sufficiently distraction free to meet STUDENT’s needs.

It was previously concluded that DTT is an appropriate instructional methodology for STUDENT; however, the program at Hort continued to have deficiencies related to its implementation and data collection. Ms. MacDonell testified that she provided DTT interspersed throughout the school day. On the other hand, Ms. Davidson testified that STUDENT received DTT for a total of slightly less than 10 minutes during her observation of Ms. MacDonell’s class in January 1998 and that during the session, STUDENT did not pay attention to the instruction. Comments made by the instructional assistants during observations by Petitioner’s witnesses, which were related during testimony, substantiate Ms. Davidson’s observation that DTT was not consistently provided to STUDENT. Mr. Rhoten recalled Dr. Leaf observing that a “lot needed to be done in the classroom.” Mark Fulmer, Ed.D., director of special programs for KCSOS, also understood that Dr. Leaf had some concerns about the DTT component of the Hort program.

Dr. Ritvo and Ms. Sarff continued to express the opinion that Ms. MacDonell’s class was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs; however, the differences between the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998 programs were insignificant, and it has already been determined that the 1996-1997 school year program did not offer STUDENT a FAPE. Moreover, the lack of an effective behavioral intervention program, a deficient DTT program, a distracting environment, and minimal attention to STUDENT’s sensory needs compel the Hearing Officer to conclude that the program offered to STUDENT during the 1997-1998 school year did not address his unique and individual needs.(Footnote 10)

(b) Did STUDENT’s placement at Hort during the 1997-1998 school year provide him with educational benefit?

Ms. MacDonell testified regarding STUDENT’s progress toward meeting goals and objectives. She stated that STUDENT achieved one of three objectives related to the goal to improve cognitive skills, one of three objectives related to improving language skills, three of six objectives related to improving gross motor skills, and one of two objectives related to improving fine motor skills. STUDENT met all of the objectives related to improving self-help and socialization skills. Most of the objectives that were not met were dropped because the IEP team determined that STUDENT’s program should focus on developing functional rather than academic skills. (See Respondents’ Exhibit 41.)

Bill Kalivas, APE teacher for KCSOS, assessed STUDENT in April 1997 and provided him with APE. Mr. Kalivas testified that STUDENT showed improvement on two of his APE goals and objectives. Specifically, by May 1998, STUDENT would sit on the swing and allow someone to push him. By March 1998, STUDENT began to balance on his bicycle. He learned to pedal a bicycle and, by May 1998, rode three-quarters of a mile on it. Ms. Kalivas did not work on peer interaction and STUDENT did not show improvement in static/dynamic balance.

Although the evidence establishes that STUDENT did make some progress during the 1997-1998 school year, he did not make progress in two very important areas--functional communication and behavior. Ms. Eliason testified that STUDENT did not make progress on PECS during the 1997-1998 school year. Her testimony was based on an evaluation of the data collected by Ms. Sarff. Ms. Sarff saw STUDENT’s skills begin to decline in January 1998. She had various explanations for the decline, such as the fact that he began an afternoon program at VAC; however, it is just as likely that the decline in skills was caused by the inconsistent instruction in the use of PECS within the classroom. Ms. Sarff apparently continued her practice of providing STUDENT instruction in PECS only on those days when he was fully cooperative. It has already been established that STUDENT requires a consistent program to benefit from his education. The Hearing Officer does not find Ms. Sarff’s explanations persuasive as to the reasons for STUDENT’s decline. Moreover, the ultimate result is that STUDENT did not make progress on PECS.

There are no reliable data to substantiate Ms. MacDonell’s vague claim that STUDENT’s behavior improved. The observations of others in the classroom establish that STUDENT continued to exhibit maladaptive behaviors throughout the 1997-1998 school year. (Testimony of Ms. Eliason, Ms. Woodruff, and others.) It has already been concluded that STUDENT required a behavioral intervention plan to address his behaviors and that his behaviors interfered with his receiving instruction and his ability to attend. No such program was developed during the 1997-1998 school year. For all of the above reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s placement during the 1997-1998 school year was not designed to provide him with educational benefit.

(c) Did STUDENT’s placement at Hort during the 1997-1998 school year conform with his IEP?

STUDENT’s IEP called for integration with nondisabled peers. Ms. MacDonell testified that this did not occur. Ms. Sarff’s testimony establishes that STUDENT did not always receive the amount of speech and language therapy called for by his IEP. Thus, the placement at Hort did not conform with his IEP.

In summary, STUDENT’s placement for the 1997-1998 did not satisfy the requirements of FAPE because it was not designed to meet his needs or to provide him with educational benefit. The placement also did not conform with his IEP.

ISSUE (2): Did Respondents offer STUDENT a FAPE for the extended school year (ESY) during the summer of 1998?

Petitioner’s contend that the ESY program offered by Respondents for the summer of 1998 was not appropriate. MOTHER and Ms. Calvillo described the summer classroom as “small and cramped.” They also testified that the class was loud and noisy. During their observation, one student was crying and falling on the floor and another student was watching cartoons on the television. Ms. Calvillo testified that STUDENT required a quieter and calmer environment than that offered in the summer program. Ms. Eliason concurred with Ms. Calvillo’s description of the program. She also noted that the area identified for sensory activities was located across campus, which would not have allowed for easy access to the equipment when needed to help calm down a student. Petitioner raised concerns about the length of the school day and asserted that the length of the school day was made for administrative convenience rather than to meet STUDENT’s needs.

In a letter dated May 19, 1998, Respondents offered to place STUDENT in a new program beginning on June 1, 1998, and to supplement the services he had been receiving. (Respondent’s exhibit 20.) On May 13, 1998, the IEP team members from the District and KCSOS met.(Footnote 11) At that meeting, Respondents offered to provide the following services beginning June 1, 1998: daily speech and language therapy, APE two times a week, weekly OT consultation to student and staff, social interaction with age-appropriate peers, sensory intervention, and a one-to-one aide. The IEP indicates the DTT/ABA (applied behavioral analysis) would be employed. Respondents also offered to undertake a FAA and to develop a BIP under the consultation of Behavioral Associates. The IEP called for an ESY program of five-and-one-half hours and integration with age-appropriate peers two times a week for one hour. (Respondents’ Exhibit 46 and testimony of Ms. Hall.)

Ms. O’Neill described the class schedule during the summer 1998. There were two students in the class. The school day was broken into 20-minute increments for instruction, which were separated by five-minute breaks. Recess began at 10:15 a.m. and lasted for 30 minutes. Lunch was at 11:30 a.m. and was followed by a second 30-minute recess. The students received instruction utilizing DTT techniques for approximately 180 minutes daily. The same techniques were employed during other periods of the day, including lunch and recess. Ms. O’Neill and her staff took on-going data regarding the students’ performance on tasks. (See Respondents’ Exhibit 75.) The students in Ms. O’Neill’s class participated with two age-appropriate peers in outdoor play and in art projects on a weekly basis. The class also received weekly community-based instruction for approximately two hours to allow the students to have opportunities to generalize skills they had learned. Ms. O’Neill testified that the students who participated in the class made good progress on the KCSOS curriculum. She expressed the opinion that from what she knows about STUDENT, he would also have had a chance to show good improvement. Ms. O’Neill testified that her curriculum for the summer taught functional living skills that included setting a table, cooking, and making a bed. Ms. O’Neill disputed the testimony that a child was being instructed in DTT while another student watched television. Dr. Fulmer testified that the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs as described by MOTHER. He testified that Ms. O’Neill received training from Dr. Leaf, who was present in the class on at least two occasions. Dr. Fulmer testified that the Richardson Center houses preschool programs for both regular and special education students and, therefore, could meet STUDENT’s need for integration. Wanda Hall, director of special education for KCSOS, also serves as the principal for Richardson. Ms. Hall testified that sensory equipment was available at Richards and that, if STUDENT had attended the program, it would have been put in place for his use.

The testimony of Ms. O’Neill establishes that the ESY was designed to provide STUDENT with DTT instruction and also to address STUDENT’s other areas of need, including self-help (or functional-living skills) and community-living skills. Ms. O’Neill’s very detailed testimony regarding DTT and the data she collected on children in her class establish that she delivered a DTT program that was consistent with the recommendations of the experts. The design of the classroom was such that hands-on practical instruction could be done in functional-living skills. Because of the small number of students in the class and the additional aide for STUDENT, there would have been opportunities throughout the school day for him to receive individual instruction. The testimony of Petitioner’s witnesses regarding the noise level of the classroom during one observation is not persuasive that the class would not otherwise meet STUDENT’s needs for a relatively distraction-free environment. There were only two students in the classroom, thereby allowing the noise level to be closely monitored. The small number of students would have alleviated the distractions for STUDENT. Moreover, additional services were offered during the summer to address STUDENT’s needs. Additional OT services were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and would have allowed sensory issues to be addressed. The new placement had SI equipment available to use with STUDENT. The Respondents offered daily speech and language, which would provide consistent opportunities for STUDENT to develop PECS skills and to address communication and language goals and objectives.

Dr. Leaf stated that there was not sufficient time to develop a functional ESY program from its inception to implementation. Ms. Eliason concurred and also testified that Ms. O’Neill did not receive sufficient support from an expert in autism. To make her point, Ms. Eliason then described the support she provided in setting up another new program, and stated her belief that support of a similar level was necessary for Respondents’ new program to succeed. For the first three months, she provided 32 hours of consultation and another consultant was available twice a week. Thereafter, she consulted one to two times a week for the next year and continued to monitor the program for three years. Ms. Eliason then described the how she prefers to set up a new program. Regarding Petitioner’s assertion that an appropriate program could not be set up in such a short period of time, the evidence in this case was not persuasive that the ESY program was deficient because it was not set up according to the model described by Ms. Eliason. The evidence establishes that the program was in place for the beginning of the summer program. The teacher had experience delivering instruction to students with autism. Her testimony demonstrated that she was familiar with the DTT model and had implemented it in the past. The class was appropriately staffed to provide individual instruction to the STUDENT. Based on the evidence discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the program offered to STUDENT was designed to meet his unique and individual needs and to provide him with educational benefit.

As established above, STUDENT’s behavior interfered with his ability to benefit from his instruction. To address STUDENT’s behavioral needs, Respondents offered to contract with Dr. Leaf’s group to conduct a FAA and to develop a BIP following the FAA. The parents, at the advise of their attorney, Ms. Graves, did not attend the IEP meeting at which these offers were made and did not consent to the FAA.

Two primary problems emerge regarding whether the ESY placement conformed to STUDENT’s IEP. First, the class was located on a preschool campus, which lacked age-appropriate peers for integration. While this was less than ideal, Ms. O’Neill testified that she provided opportunities for her students to have experiences with age-appropriate peers. Her testimony was not disputed. The Hearing Officer concludes that the program sufficiently conformed to STUDENT’s IEP in regard to integration. The second concern is related to the level of support provided to the class by someone from Autism Partnership. The IEP called for weekly consultation. Mr. Rhoten testified that Dr. Leaf observed on two occasions during the summer and that he personally did not provide any assistance to Ms. O’Neill. On the other hand, STUDENT did not enroll in the class and there is no evidence that the Respondents would have failed to provide the offered amount of consultation had he attended the summer program. The Hearing Officer concludes that the program offered by Respondents sufficiently complies with STUDENT’s IEP. To summarize, because it has been concluded that the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and to provide him with educational benefit, and conformed with the IEP, the Hearing Officer concludes that it satisfied the requirements of an appropriate program as set forth in IDEA and Rowley.

ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District offer a FAPE for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 school year?

As to STUDENT’s needs for the 1998-1999 school year, witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT described the progress that he has made since attending VAC. Dr. Couch testified that STUDENT has improved in the area of self-care skills. For example, he is able to sort laundry. According to Ms. Dawn, STUDENT now has only two to three toileting accidents per week, whereas when he entered VAC, he had two to three accidents daily. Ms. Dawn testified that STUDENT’s readiness skills have also improved. STUDENT is now able to sit at a table and to wait for up to 15 seconds, whereas he used to immediately grab items set within his reach. STUDENT complies to the instruction “come here” and is able to independently walk a greater distance between aides than when he entered VAC. He also is able to independently retrieve PECS icons. Ms. Dawn testified additionally that STUDENT’s behavior has improved. Self-injurious behaviors have decreased significantly, STUDENT rarely mouths objects, and he no longer tries to hide or escape. He continues to chew his shirt occasionally. Dr. Couch testified that STUDENT continues to require a room that is free of distractions and also requires assistance from two persons to maintain his focus during instruction. He testified that DTT is an appropriate teaching technique as are activities that address STUDENT’s developing self-help and community-living skills.

While some improvements have been noted in STUDENT’s behavior, the testimony of VAC personnel establish that STUDENT continues to have the same needs as described above. To summarize, STUDENT’s primary needs are in the areas of behavior, self-help, and community-living. He also exhibits deficits in motor skills and sensory areas, and requires an educational environment with distractions minimized. DTT continues to be an appropriate technique to address his needs.

(a) Is Respondents’ proposed placement for the 1998-1999 school year at Del Rio designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs?

Respondents’ offer of placement for the 1998-1999 school year is contained in Respondents’ Exhibit 89. The IEP dated August 11, 1998, includes goals and objectives developed at the IEP meeting on April 17, 1998, and the services offered at the IEP on May 13, 1998. Both are supplemented to some extent. (Respondents’ Exhibits 42 and 46.) Ms. Bresee provided most of the information regarding the placement proposed by Respondents for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 school year. The class is located in two regular size relocatables on the campus of Del Rio Elementary School, which is within the Rosedale Union Elementary School District.(Footnote 12) One of the relocatables is used for the classroom and the other is set up for OT and functional living skills. The functional living skills area includes a bedroom, living room, a small kitchen, a washer and dryer, and a bathroom. There are three students with autism in the class. They range in age from 7 to 10 years old. There are two full-time aides. The aides previously worked with Mr. Rhoten and have been trained by Dr. Leaf. The class program includes three hours daily of DTT and weekly community outings. In setting up the class and the curriculum, the staff are following the direction of Dr. Leaf. During the first week of school, one of Dr. Leaf’s associates was present in the class on Monday and Tuesday and two associates were present from Wednesday through Friday. One of the associates was in the class for the entire second week of school and was scheduled to be available weekly thereafter. The KCSOS program specialist also spent the first week of school in the classroom and is currently available as needed. Additional support available to the staff include the school psychologist, Mr. and Mrs. Rhoten, and the KCSOS and Del Rio Elementary School staff. Ms. Hall stated that she plans to meet weekly with staff. Dr. Leaf testified that he is committed to consult with KCSOS for the entire school year. Ms. Hall provided information regarding the additional staff at Del Rio. For example, Stacy Lee Quint is a behavioral specialist. She will work with the parent component. Fletcher Scott, a speech and language therapist, will provide speech and language services to the class. He has experience working with children with autism. Ms. Bresee testified that the placement offered to STUDENT is designed to meet his needs by providing him with one-to-one training and instruction in functional living skills. Functional living skills can be addressed in an environment that simulates the home. The classroom also offers opportunities for STUDENT to begin to work while a small number of other adults or students are present in the environment. The staff available to work with STUDENT have experience and training to work specifically with young children with autism. The campus also offers opportunities for STUDENT to mainstream with regular education students during recess and lunch.

The goals and objectives contained in the IEP are designed to address deficits in gross and fine motor, self-help, communication, vocational, leisure, community, and domestic skills, and to address attention, peer interaction, and sensory processing. The IEP provides for direct OT and APE to address motor deficits and sensory issues, and daily speech and language therapy to address communication needs and to provide STUDENT with PECS instruction. The IEP also calls for a one-to-one aide with two aides to assist STUDENT in situations recommended by the behavioral specialist, and weekly community-based activities. The IEP identifies DTT/ABA as the instructional model that will be followed. Finally, the IEP identifies twice weekly integration for social skills development. To address STUDENT’s behavioral needs, Respondents have agreed to undertake a FAA and to develop a BIP with a behavioral specialist. The teacher has received training from Dr. Leaf and his associates, and a plan for on-going consultation is in place. Respondents have hired a staff with training in and experience working with children with autism. The staff includes a professional to coordinate a parent component. The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP and the credible testimony of Respondents’ witnesses establish that the program offered for the 1998-1999 school year is designed to address STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. Petitioner did not provide persuasive evidence to rebut this persuasive evidence.

(b) Is Respondents’ proposed placement for the 1998-1999 school year at Del Rio designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit?

Respondents have developed a comprehensive program to address all of STUDENT’s identified needs. The IEP and services offered for the 1998-1999 school year, when implemented in what has been described as an appropriate educational environment, would provide STUDENT with opportunities to improve his behavior and to minimize sensory deficits, which have interfered in the past with his ability to benefit from his education. With all of the appropriate components as described above in place, completion of a FAA, and implementation of a BIP, it is concluded that the placement offered by Respondents for the 1998-199 school year is designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

(c) Does Respondents’ proposed placement for the 1998-1999 school year at Del Rio conform with STUDENT’s IEP?

The program offered for the 1998-1999 school year as described by Respondents’ witnesses conforms with STUDENT’s IEP. There is no evidence to the contrary.

Because the placement offered by Respondents for the 1998-1999 school year is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and to provide him with educational benefit, and conforms with the IEP, it is concluded that the placement offers STUDENT a FAPE pursuant to the requirements of IDEA and Rowley.

ISSUE NO. 4: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s attending the Valley Achievement Center (VAC)?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) and the private placement or services are determined to be appropriate under IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. Moreover, parents need not procure the best possible private placement or services in order to be entitled to reimbursement. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.

It was determined above that STUDENT’s placement was not appropriate during the 1997-1998 school year. In May 1998, the parents elected to place STUDENT at VAC. They provided timely notice to Respondents of their intent to do so. The testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Eliason, and VAC personnel establishes that VAC is a certified nonpublic school (NPS) that is designed to meet the needs of children with autism. At VAC, STUDENT receives individual instruction with the assistance of two aides utilizing a DTT approach. His program is structured and is relatively distraction free. STUDENT is the only student in the room while receiving individual instruction. VAC also has reduced environmental distractions such as buzzing lights and other noise. At VAC, STUDENT participates in activities to address his sensory needs and receives direct OT. He also participates in activities to address self-help skills such as toileting. STUDENT’s behavior is addressed by close monitoring by instructional assistants and through the provision of a very structured program. The testimony of witnesses establishes that STUDENT’s program at VAC is generally designed to meet his unique and individual needs.

VAC offers STUDENT appropriate instruction to address his needs. The testimony of VAC personnel, Ms. Eliason, and MOTHER establishes that STUDENT has made progress while attending VAC. MOTHER’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s improved ability to function in the family was particularly compelling. The evidence demonstrates that STUDENT has improved compliance and has attained self-help skills since entering VAC. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the program STUDENT receives at VAC is designed to provide him with educational benefit.

At VAC, STUDENT receives instruction in DTT and PECS. He receives OT, and his goals and objectives are addressed through his individual instructional program at VAC. Thus, the evidence establishes that the program at VAC generally conforms with STUDENT’s IEP. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s placement at VAC sufficiently meets the criteria of an appropriate placement to warrant reimbursement for the period STUDENT attended the school component of VAC during the regular school year 1997-1998.

The Hearing Officer concluded in issues above that the District offered appropriate placements to STUDENT for the ESY program for the summer of 1998 and for the 1998-1999 school year. Therefore, the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for those periods.

ISSUE NO. 5: Is STUDENT entitled to an additional year of school to compensate for the District’s failure to provide him with FAPE during the 1995-1996, 1996-1997, and 1997-1998 school years?

Petitioner contends that he is entitled to compensation for Respondents failure to provide him with a FAPE for at least three school years. In Burlington, the Supreme Court concluded that equitable considerations are relevant in determining relief under the IDEA. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Because compensatory education is an equitable remedy, equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning relief. Burlington 471 U.S. at 374; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1486.

It has been concluded that Respondents did not provide STUDENT with an appropriate education during the 1995-1996, 1996-1997, and 1997-1998 school years and that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s attending VAC’s school program from May 1998 to the end of the 1997-1998 regular school year. Reimbursement for approximately two months of a private placement does not seem adequate compensation, given the length of time that STUDENT went without an appropriate placement; however, it was not until May 1998, when STUDENT’s parents removed him from Ms. MacDonell’s class at Hort, that Respondents initiated the process of developing a new program that would ultimately be found to offer STUDENT a FAPE. Plans for Respondents’ ESY program for the summer of 1998 were finalized near the end of the regular school year and at a time when the parents’ distrust of Respondents was heightened because of the lack of an appropriate program for their son for an extended period of time. To the reasonable observer, it appeared unlikely that the Respondents would be able to put together an appropriate program in time for the ESY, particularly given their inability to do so for the prior three school years. Thus, the parents’ apprehension of placing STUDENT in Respondents’ proposed ESY program at that time is understandable. Because of these circumstances, particularly the lack of an appropriate program for three years, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education.

Traditionally, compensatory education has been available to students who reach the age at which they are no longer eligible for special education services. Awards have been made to younger students when appropriate. Todd D. v. Andrews (11th Cir. 1991) 933 F.2d 1576; Lester H. v. Gilhool (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865 cert. denied, 111 S. Ct. 1317 (1991). As a student with significant needs, STUDENT will likely be entitled to receive services from Respondents through at least his 21st birthday. It is too speculative at this point in time to determine STUDENT’s need for an educational program beyond age 21 years to compensation him for Respondents’ failure to provide him with FAPE as an elementary school student.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the compensatory education shall be provided for the remainder of this school year and for the 1999-2000 school year, including ESY programs. The record is not sufficiently clear to fashion the form of compensatory education that would adequately compensate STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that a determination of the appropriate form of compensation should be left to the IEP team. (See e.g. State of Conn. U.S.D. No. 1 v. State Dept. Of Education (Conn. Super. Ct. 1997) 699 A.2d 1077.) To ensure that the IEP team has the necessary expertise to make such a determination, the Hearing Officer concludes the following: in addition to STUDENT’s parents, teachers, and service providers, Dr. Leaf or one of his associates shall participate in the IEP team meeting to determine the appropriate form of compensatory education to supplement the program STUDENT currently attends; in determining the appropriate form of compensatory education, the IEP team shall weigh STUDENT’s individual needs and his ability to tolerate a longer school day with his right to compensation for the denial of FAPE for three years; and as to appropriate forms of compensation, the IEP team shall consider, as options, additional PECS instruction, individual DTT instruction, and support to parents. The IEP team must also take into consideration in fashioning appropriate compensation for STUDENT the determination by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal that the right to compensatory education does not create an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for the opportunities missed. Parents of student W. ex rel. Student W. V. Puyallup Sch. D. No. 3 (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489.

ISSUE NO. 6: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an assessment completed by Robin J. Eliason?

A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student. When the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency, the parent also has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency’s assessment was appropriate. Education Code § 56329(b). For the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student's primary language or other mode of communication; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Additionally, individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist. Assessment and testing materials must also not measure the student's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless that is what the test purports to measure.

Subsection 56320(e) states that no single procedure shall be used as the “sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs.” Subsection 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. Pursuant to subsection (g), the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician. These assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Education Code § 56324(a) and (b).

Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the costs of an assessment conducted by Ms. Eliason in May 1998. Respondents’ last assessment of STUDENT occurred in January and February of 1997. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 2Z; Respondents’ Exhibit 41.) Occupational therapy and APE assessments took place in April of 1997. The initial assessment included measures designed to assess STUDENT’s psycho-educational functioning, speech and language, and adaptive or developmental functioning. Anthony W. Coe, school psychologist, conducted the psycho-educational portion of the assessment, which included administration of a number of instruments: the Adaptive Behavior Evaluation Scale-Revised, the Attention Deficit Disorders Evaluation Scale-Second Edition, the Autism Behavior Checklist, the Beery Visual-Motor Integration-Revised, the Bracken Basic Concept Scale, the Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence, the Gilliam Autism Rating Scale, the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children-Non Verbal, and the Woodcock-Johnson Scales of Independent Behavior-Revised. The assessment also included observations of STUDENT on several occasions in different environments, interviews with STUDENT’s parents and teachers, and review of prior psycho-educational assessments. The results of the assessment are contained in a comprehensive report found in Petitioner’s Exhibit 2Z.

As part of the initial assessment, Ms. Sarff assessed STUDENT’s speech and language utilizing the Preschool Language Scale-3 (PLS-3), speech and language sections of the Brigance, and the developmental language portion of the Comprehensive Learner Adaptive Scope and Sequences Assessment (CLASS). These measures assessed STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills. To assess STUDENT’s developmental skills, Ms. MacDonell utilized portions of the Brigance and the CLASS and also her personal observations. William J. Kalivas, APE specialist, conducted the APE assessment, which consisted of administration of the Ulrich Test of Gross Motor Development. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 2S.) The OT assessment consisted of observations of STUDENT by Phyllis Hix, OTR. She also engaged him in activities to assess his motor skills. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 2T.)

Petitioner raised no specific concerns regarding assessments conducted by Respondents other than to point out the fact that the OT and APE assessments were completed only as a result of the request made by the parents. It also is unclear whether the assessment procured by the parents can be considered an assessment of STUDENT. (Petitioner’s Exhibit U.) According to MOTHER, Ms. Eliason was requested to assess the appropriateness of STUDENT’s placement to assist the PARENTS in determining whether to remove STUDENT from Hort in favor of a private placement.

In any case, there is no evidence that the assessment completed by Respondents was in any way racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. The assessment was conducted in STUDENT’s primary mode of communication--English. Portions of the assessment measured nonverbal skills. The assessment was administered by trained personnel including a school psychologist, a speech and language specialist, STUDENT’s special education teacher, a registered occupational therapist, and an APE teacher. The testimony of the witnesses and a review of their resumes establish that they have knowledge of STUDENT’s disability--autism. There is no evidence that the assessments were administered in a manner other than in conformance with the test instructions, except as noted by Ms. Sarff in relation to her administration of the PLS-3. Ms. Sarff did not report standard scores on that instrument. She noted in her report that STUDENT was beyond the normed age level and that the test had been administered in a nonstandardized manner. Ms. Sarff administered two additional measures of speech and language. Thus, the use of the PLS-3 does not invalidate the assessment. Overall, the assessment included administration of multiple assessments, particularly the psycho-educational portion of the assessment, thereby satisfying the requirement that no single criterion be utilized to make educational determinations. Finally, the assessment measured intellectual functioning, adaptive behavior, speech and language, behavior, and motor skills and, therefore, assessed all areas of suspected disability.

In summary, Respondents’ assessment of STUDENT in 1997 was comprehensive and satisfies the requirements of an appropriate assessment under California Education Code §§ 56320 and 56324. Because Respondents conducted an appropriate assessment, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the assessment conducted by Ms. Eliason.

ORDER

(1) Within 15 calendar days of receipt of proof from the PARENTS, Respondents shall reimburse the PARENTS for the costs, including transportation, of STUDENT’s attending the educational program at Valley Achievement Center from his enrollment there in May 1998 to the end of the 1997-1998 regular school year.

(2) Within 15 business days of the date of this decision, Respondents shall convene an IEP meeting to determine the appropriate form of compensatory education to which STUDENT is entitled for the three years Respondent failed to provide STUDENT with FAPE. Dr. Leaf or one of his associates shall participate in the IEP. The compensatory educational shall supplement the educational program STUDENT currently attends, as well as the program he will attend during the 1999-2000 school year, including the extended school year programs. In determining the appropriate form of compensatory education, the IEP team shall:

(a) weigh STUDENT’s individual needs and his ability to tolerate a longer school day with his right to compensation for the denial of FAPE for three years; (b) consider as options additional PECS instruction, individual DTT instruction, and support to parents; and (c) take into consideration in fashioning appropriate compensation for STUDENT the determination by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal that the right to compensatory education does not create an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for the opportunities missed.

(3) Should STUDENT’s parents elect to enroll STUDENT in Respondents’ program offered for the 1998-1999 school year, Respondents shall immediately commence a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT’s behavior.

(4) Upon completion of the FAA, Respondents shall convene an IEP meeting to discuss the FAA and to develop a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) consistent with the findings of the FAA and in conformity with the requirements of the Hughes Bill.

(5) Respondents shall immediately implement the BIP upon its development.

(6) Petitioner’s remaining requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

(1) Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1995-1996, 1996-1997, and 1997-1998 school years?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

(2) Did Respondents offer STUDENT a FAPE for the extended school year (ESY) during the summer of 1998?

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(3) Did Respondents offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(4) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s attending the Valley Achievement Center (VAC)?

Petitioner prevailed as to the regular 1997-1998 school year; Respondents prevailed as to the ESY and the 1998-1999 school year.

(5) Is STUDENT entitled to an additional year of school year to compensate for the District’s failure to provide him with FAPE during the 1995-1996, 1996-1997, and 1997-1998 school years?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

(6) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an assessment completed by Robin J. Eliason?

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: January 6, 1999 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes: 1. The IEP does not indicate the frequency or duration for either OT or APE. 2. Ms. Graves continued to be the attorney of record in this case; however, she was not present at the hearing. 3. In 1997, the IDEA was amended (IDEA 1997). Several issues are related to the provision of FAPE that occurred prior to June 4, 1997, the effective date of IDEA 1997. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will apply the law in effect at the time these disputed events occurred, in accordance with general rules regarding retroactivity. (Landgraff v. USI Film Products (1994) 511 U.S. 244.) IDEA and IDEA 1997 are fundamentally similar regarding the provision of FAPE. 4. The ball pit is an area filled with small balls into which STUDENT could be immersed. 5. Ms. Godges described proprioceptive as "feeling through the joints." 6. The IEP does not indicate whether the APE services were to occur daily, weekly, or monthly. 7. Ms. MacDonell is working on an emergency credential. 8. The "Hughes Bill" refers to Education Code  56520-56524, which describe procedures, including the use of positive behavioral intervention plans, to eliminate maladaptive behavior. 9. California law regarding FAPE has not changed. 10. At an IEP meeting on April 17, 1998, Respondents offered weekly OT and added goals and objectives related to sensory issues to STUDENT's IEP; however, taken as a whole, the program, even as supplemented by the IEP developed in April 1998, was not designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs. Most notable is the lack of a behavioral intervention plan to address STUDENT's significant behavioral problems. 11. The parents did not attend; however, Respondents provided a copy of the IEP to MOTHER. 12. The Rosedale Union Elementary School District is located in the northern part of Bakersfield.