California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 15, 1997

Student v. Duarte Unified School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 603-96 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson

Duarte Unified and Alhambra Elementary must move a student with a cochlear implant into regular education with hearing peers and more speech therapy.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Parents of an 11-year-old sixth grader filed for due process against Duarte Unified School District, where she lived, and Alhambra City Elementary School District, which ran the deaf and hard of hearing program she attended at Baldwin School. She was eligible for special education as deaf. In 1993 she got a cochlear implant, which let her hear at a hard-of-hearing level. The districts kept her in a sign-language-based total communication special day class. They gave her at most 90 minutes a week of group speech and language therapy. She later stopped wearing the implant. The parents asked for a program like TRIPOD, a Burbank program that teaches deaf and hard of hearing students alongside hearing classmates.

Hearing Officer Mark Paxson gave more weight to implant experts, including surgeon Dr. Dennis Maceri, audiologist Traci Nolin, and speech-language pathologist Ruth Hiland, than to district staff with little implant experience. He found the districts' placement had failed to meet her needs since the implant. He also found too little evidence that her social-emotional needs required a special day class. Under the Rachel H. four-factor test, he held that a TRIPOD-like regular education program was the least restrictive environment. He ordered an IEP meeting within 15 days. A TRIPOD representative and an implant professional had to attend, paid for by the districts. The team had to set up a regular education placement with hearing peers, a transition plan, and at least three 60-minute individual speech sessions a week.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a student whose needs changed after a cochlear implant. The Hearing Officer gave the most weight to implant specialists over district staff. He held that a program's absence from the SELPA did not keep it from being considered, because Education Code section 56360 requires a continuum of program options.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Have Respondents provided an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT?

    The total communication special day class did not meet the needs of a student with a cochlear implant, who needed an oral program and more speech therapy; she was denied FAPE from March 1993 on.

  2. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. If not, is STUDENT entitled to placement in a TRIPOD-like program?

    A program's absence from the SELPA does not bar it from consideration; under Rachel H., a TRIPOD-like regular education program with hearing peers is the appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Have Respondents provided an appropriate amount of oral rehabilitation services for STUDENT?

    At most 90 minutes a week of group speech and language therapy was not enough; implant experts called for at least three 60-minute individual sessions a week.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Respondents must convene an IEP meeting within 15 days of the decision. The team must include at least one TRIPOD representative and one person who has worked with the student on her cochlear implant, chosen by the parents and paid for by Respondents. The District must pay for these people to attend any later meetings until a final placement and IEP are developed. The team must write new goals and objectives for the new placement.
  • Placement ordered. The IEP team must identify or develop an appropriate program that places the student in a regular education environment with hearing peers and appropriate aides and services, and must develop a transition plan for her move into that program.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP team must decide what aids and services the student needs and the appropriate level of speech and language services, with a minimum of three 60-minute individual sessions per week.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H.; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(5)(B); Education Code § 56360; Education Code § 56505

People named in the decision

  • Barbara Gottesman, special education supervisor, Duarte Unified School District
  • Maggie Azevedo, special education coordinator, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Robert Roice, educational consultant representing Respondents (non-attorney), Respondents
  • Thomas Beltran, attorney for Student
  • Dr. Dennis Maceri, cochlear implant surgeon; expert witness for Student, University of Southern California
  • Traci Nolin, clinical audiologist; witness for Student
  • Ruth Hiland, private speech-language pathologist; expert witness for Student, House Ear Institute
  • Dr. Robert Patterson, licensed psychologist; independent psychoeducational evaluator and expert witness for Student
  • Dr. Arla Strassburg Wallace, licensed clinical psychologist; private psychological evaluation
  • Carl Kirchner, executive director; witness for Student, TRIPOD
  • Jane Clausen, D/HH teacher in TRIPOD program; witness for Student, John Muir Middle School, Burbank
  • Paul Krumhauer, school psychologist, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • William Ritchie, audiologist, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Elizabeth (Liz) Ott Orban, speech-language pathologist, Respondents
  • Ann Liu, D/HH itinerant teacher, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Stephanie Cohen, D/HH counselor, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Joy Siddiqi, D/HH instructional specialist, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Barbara Ritchie, special education teacher, D/HH special day class, Baldwin School, Alhambra City Elementary School District
  • Five Acres, private counseling provider, Pasadena

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Duarte, California, on January 30 and 31, and February 25 and 26, 1997.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Thomas Beltran. Also present on STUDENT's behalf were her parents MOTHER and FATHER. Respondents Duarte Unified School District (Duarte) and Alhambra City Elementary School District (Alhambra) were represented by Robert Roice, educational consultant. Also present on Duarte's behalf was Barbara Gottesman, special education supervisor. Present on Alhambra's behalf was Maggie Azevedo, special education coordinator.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing briefs. Closing briefs were received, the record was closed, and the matter submitted for hearing.

ISSUES

(1) Have Respondents provided an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT?(Footnote 1)

(2) If not, is STUDENT entitled to placement in a TRIPOD-like program?

(3) Have Respondents provided an appropriate amount of oral rehabilitation services for STUDENT?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is eleven years old and resides in the Duarte Unified School District. She is a sixth grader at Baldwin School in the Alhambra City Elementary School District, another school district within the West San Gabrial Valley SELPA. STUDENT is eligible for special education because she is deaf and the class she is in is a total communication special day class (SDC) for deaf/hard of hearing (D/HH) students. STUDENT has been in such a class since at least 1991. Petitioner's Exhibit Z.

In March 1993, when STUDENT was seven years old, she had a cochlear implant placed in her left ear by Dr. Dennis Maceri.(Footnote 2) With the implant, STUDENT's hearing in her left ear improved to the point that she could be classified as hard of hearing rather than deaf. In addition, STUDENT has a hearing aid for her right ear. Her aided hearing in her right ear is also sufficient for her to access sounds and acquire language. (Testimony of Ruth Hiland)

For the first one and a half years after the implant surgery, STUDENT wore the implant and the hearing aid consistently. However, STUDENT became uncomfortable with the implant because it made her feel different. As a result, STUDENT stopped wearing the implant and, for awhile, the hearing aid. Currently, STUDENT consistently uses the hearing aid, but does not wear the implant. (Testimony of MOTHER) After receiving the implant, STUDENT began audiology services with Traci Nolin. Services started at once per week, but gradually became less frequent. Ms. Nolin worked primarily with STUDENT's implant, making sure that it was working properly. (Testimony of Traci Nolin)

On October 11, 1994, Paul Krumhauer, school psychologist, conducted a three-year reevaluation of STUDENT. Petitioner's Exhibit M. Mr. Krumhauer determined that STUDENT's ability was in the high average range and that her progress in academics was satisfactory and commensurate with her ability. On the Woodcock-Johnson Test of Achievement (Woodcock), STUDENT's grade equivalent scores ranged from K.0 in Applied Problems to 2.8 in Calculation. In the area of language functioning, Mr. Krumhauer found that STUDENT had not made much growth. Her expressive skills were at the middle five-year-old level, while her receptive skills were at the three-year-old level. Mr. Krumhauer recommended that STUDENT continue in the D/HH special day class and receive audiological and speech and language services, along with counseling for her poor self-concept and social adjustment.

In conjunction with Mr. Krumhauer's reevaluation, William Ritchie, licensed audiologist for Respondents, conducted an audiological evaluation of STUDENT on October 10, 1994. Petitioner's Exhibit O. Mr. Ritchie reported that STUDENT's aided hearing levels indicated that she was benefitting from the amplification provided by the hearing aid and cochlear implant. Mr. Ritchie recommended that STUDENT continue to utilize her implant and hearing aid, and continue receiving services of the "Aural Education Staff."

A speech and language assessment was also conducted in October 1994. Petitioner's Exhibit P. Liz Ott, speech and language pathologist, summarized the assessment results by stating that

STUDENT has shown some moderate growth in both receptive and expressive vocabulary. Sign language is her primary mode of communication. She will vocalized [sic] when asked to. She has little control over her voice.... [H]er speech is still less than 10% intelligible.... STUDENT's attention and attitude have been interfering with a steady progress in spoken English.

Ms. Ott recommended that STUDENT continue receiving remedial speech and language services.

On February 2, 1995, Ruth Hiland, speech and language pathologist with the House Ear Institute, conducted a "Speech- Language Evaluation and Progress Report." Ms. Hiland administered the Grammatical Analysis of Elicited Language-Simple Sentence Level (GAEL-S) to STUDENT and, based on her results, concluded that STUDENT had severe delays in both receptive and expressive language, speech articulation, and oral motor development. Ms. Hiland stated that based on STUDENT's overall performance, age, and strong family support, the prognosis for increasing her receptive and expressive language skills and speech articulation production is good if she is provided with direct intervention focusing on improving her oral speech and language skills.

Ms. Hiland recommended that STUDENT continue receiving two sessions of speech therapy twice per week for 60 minutes per session. Ms. Hiland also recommended that STUDENT continue in her current educational placement but that she should have an increased focus on oral language and speech.

On May 8, 1995, STUDENT's IEP team met at her parents' request to consider moving STUDENT from the total communication SDC to "an oral placement without sign language support." Petitioner's Exhibit Y. Although the IEP team expressed concerns regarding STUDENT's social and emotional issues and her ability to handle an oral class, the IEP team agreed to try an oral placement during the summer session. Following the summer session, STUDENT was returned to the total communication SDC because her implant was not working. Once the implant was working again, STUDENT continued in the total communication class because she refused to wear the implant.

On June 28, 1995, Dr. Arla Strassburg Wallace, licensed clinical psychologist, conducted a psychological evaluation at MOTHER's request. Petitioner's Exhibit K. Dr. Wallace administered the WISC-III, Bender Visual-Motor Gestalt, and Draw A Person tests. Dr. Wallace also interviewed STUDENT, her parents, and reviewed STUDENT's records. On the WISC-III, STUDENT received a Performance IQ score of 133. On the Bender Visual-Motor Gestalt, STUDENT's performance was age appropriate; and on the Draw A Person test, her drawings were also age appropriate along with her gross and fine motor skills

Dr. Wallace concluded, based on the WISC-III results, that STUDENT was capable of achieving at a higher level than she was at that time. Dr. Wallace stated that "the program STUDENT is currently in is not working for her." Dr. Wallace recommended greater oral rehabilitation services for STUDENT, including attending the Oral Lingua School in Whittier. Dr. Wallace also recommended tht STUDENT participate in individual and family counselling, and that STUDENT's parents attend a "Parent Effectiveness Training" class to help them with STUDENT at home.

On October 10, 1995, STUDENT's IEP team met and recommended continued placement for STUDENT in the Baldwin School's total communication SDC for D/HH students. The IEP team also recommended mainstreaming during recess, lunch, physical education, music, and special activities; speech and language services twice a week for a total of 90 minutes; and audiological services. MOTHER signed the IEP in agreement with the placement and services recommended by the IEP team.

On November 21, 1995, Liz Orban was advised by MOTHER that she was no longer requiring STUDENT to wear her implant to school because it was becoming too difficult to force her to wear it. At the time, STUDENT continued to wear her hearing aid in her other ear. Respondent's Exhibit #12.

On May 6, 1996, Dr. Maceri and Ms. Nolin submitted a letter to the Duarte D/HH program recommending that STUDENT be placed in a class that would expose her primarily to "auditory only signals." Petitioner's Exhibit J. Dr. Maceri and Ms. Nolin stated that because STUDENT was currently placed in a total communication class and was exposed primarily to sign language, she was not being given the opportunity to use her implant. Dr. Maceri and Ms. Nolin also recommended that STUDENT receive a minimum of three speech therapy sessions per week.

On May 23, 1996, STUDENT's IEP team met to consider a change in placement to the Covina Valley D/HH program requested by the PARENTS due to concerns regarding STUDENT's safety at Baldwin School. The IEP team offered counselling services and a referral to Mental Health. The PARENTS indicated that they were providing private counseling for STUDENT and were not interested in counselling services from Respondents.

In response to the PARENTS' request for a change in placement, Barbara Gottesman, special education supervisor for Duarte, sent a letter to the PARENTS on May 30, 1996. That letter included Respondents' offer of placement for STUDENT, including an "Oral Program" in Alhambra, counseling services, a Mental Health referral, social and emotional functioning assessment, and payment for home-school transportation. On May 31, 1996, STUDENT's parents requested a due process hearing regarding STUDENT's placement.

Subsequently, on July 2, 1996, an addendum was added to STUDENT's IEP as a result of a mediation between the parties. The addendum called for STUDENT to receive D/HH itinerant services rather than extended year services for the summer 1996. The services were provided by an itinerant teacher in a one-to-one environment at the Duarte offices. The itinerant teacher was to target expressive language and auditory skills and meet with STUDENT five times per week for 50 minutes each session. Petitioner's Exhibit C.

On July 26, 1996, Liz Ott-Orban conducted a speech and language assessment for Respondents. Petitioner's Exhibit H. The assessment was conducted at STUDENT's parents' request to determine STUDENT's current speech and language levels. During the evaluation, STUDENT wore her hearing aid, but not her implant. Ms. Ott-Orban noted that STUDENT's primary mode of communication was sign language. Although Ms. Orban concluded that STUDENT continued to have a severe delay in expressive and receptive language abilities, she also found that STUDENT had made steady growth over the past three and six years in comparison to prior assessments. Ms. Ott-Orban attributed STUDENT's limited articulation growth to the implant and STUDENT's subsequent refusal to consistently wear the implant and aid. Ms. Ott-Orban recommended that STUDENT remain in a total communication class and continue receiving speech and language therapy.

On August 14, 1996, Mr. Krumhauer conducted a new three-year reevaluation of STUDENT. Petitioner's Exhibit G. On the WISC-III, STUDENT's performance IQ score was 110 and on the Leiter Scale, her IQ score was 106. On the Detroit Test of Visual Motor Integration, STUDENT's standard score was 114, with an age equivalent score of 14-0. On the Draw-A-Person, STUDENT's scores were "within normal limits," and on the Mann Motor Test, STUDENT demonstrated "adequate fine motor skills." Mr. Krumhauer also administered the Walker Problem Behavior Checklist, Inferred Self-Concept Scale, and the Sentence Completion Test to assess STUDENT's social emotional functioning.

In the area of social-emotional functioning, Mr. Krumhauer found that STUDENT had improved over the past couple of months and, additionally, in comparison with two years ago, had shown some improvement. Although Mr. Krumhauer had found improvement, he concluded that STUDENT continued to have social emotional weaknesses. Mr. Krumhauer stated the following:

There appears to be much turmoil inside of herself and an inability to trust others. There are conflicts in the home situation which could be more than 'usual teenage problems,' especially since previous reports have indicated she has difficulty in social adjustment. Her self confidence is weak ....

Mr. Krumhauer concluded that

STUDENT has above average mental ability with a profound hearing loss but her academic progress in some areas is weak. It is this examiner's opinion that in the last few years her progress has been affected by her weaknesses in the social-emotional area. These weaknesses need to be remediated for STUDENT to make improved academic progress.

Mr. Krumhauer recommended that STUDENT continue in the SDC for hearing impaired students with audiological and speech and language services. Mr. Krumhauer also recommended that STUDENT receive school counseling to improve her social adjustment, self-confidence, and general happiness.

On August 22, 1996, Ann Liu, with Respondents' D/HH program, conducted a triennial review of STUDENT's progress. Ms. Liu found that STUDENT had relative strengths in the areas of speech reading, writing fluency, reading vocabulary comprehension, and math calculation. STUDENT's relative weaknesses were in auditory skills and language exposure, both receptive and expressive. STUDENT's auditory skills had declined since October 1994. Ms. Liu noted that STUDENT's deficits in language had a far reaching effect on her reading comprehension, verbal expression, and solving math word problems.

On September 5, 1996, Ms. Gottesman sent a letter to the PARENTS offering placement for the 1996-97 school year in the D/HH program at Baldwin School. Respondents' Exhibit #11. The placement and services offered by Ms. Gottesman included those services indicated on the IEP dated May 23, 1996. Ms. Gottesman also indicated that Duarte had processed an inter-SELPA transfer request for STUDENT to attend the Covina Valley D/HH program.

On November 4, 1996, Dr. Robert Patterson, a licensed psychologist, conducted a psychological-educational evaluation of STUDENT. Petitioner's Exhibit D. Dr. Patterson reported the following results on cognitive testing:

WISC-III 110 Performance IQ 75th Percentile Leiter(Footnote 3) 106 Standard Score 74th Percentile TONI-2 96 Standard Score 39th Percentile

On the achievement testing, STUDENT's scores as reported on the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) ranged from a grade equivalent of K0.3 (standard score of 50) in Writing to a grade equivalent of 2.7 (standard score of 66) in Broad Math. Dr. Patterson also administered the Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test to assess STUDENT's psychomotor functioning, and the Personality Inventory for Children, the Reynolds Manifest Anxiety, and the Piers-Harris Self-Concept Scale to assess STUDENT's social emotional functioning.

Dr. Patterson summarized his results by stating that "STUDENT is performing in the mid-average range cognitively, having slowly declined over several years from performing at the 95th percentile to the 39th percentile." Dr. Patterson noted that STUDENT's achievement skills had also shown a consistent decline. As an example, Dr. Patterson stated that STUDENT's word decoding skills in the first grade were in the mid-average range and were presently in the mildly retarded range at the 1.5 grade level, although she was a sixth grade student. Dr. Patterson also compared STUDENT's performance with an analysis of performance by other D/HH students. Based on his comparison, STUDENT is performing at the bottom of the D/HH population.

With regards to STUDENT's social emotional functioning, Dr. Patterson found that she has "a depressive disorder with anxiety relative to the sexual traumatization and difficulty at school." The "sexual traumatization" which Dr. Patterson referred to involved an incident on the school bus in which a male student placed his hands under STUDENT's shirt.

Dr. Patterson recommended that STUDENT's therapist work with her and school staff to determine why she is unwilling to use her cochlear implant and determine ways to increase her use of the implant. Dr. Patterson suggested that an appropriate program to encourage STUDENT to use the implant would be a "hearing type program."

On December 19, 1996, STUDENT's IEP team met and recommended STUDENT for an SDC placement with extended year services; speech and language services twice a week for a total of 75 minutes; audiological services; mainstreaming in physical education, drama, art, recess, lunch, and special activities; and a sign language interpreter for mainstreamed classes. Petitioner's Exhibit X. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT continue in her current SDC placement at Baldwin School in the D/HH program. STUDENT's parents disagreed with the recommendations of the IEP team because they did "not bring STUDENT into a greater integration with non-hearing impaired students." The PARENTS also stated that the team's recommendations did not include enough reinforcement to motivate STUDENT to wear her cochlear implant.

On January 22, 1997, Ms. Hiland conducted another speech and language evaluation of STUDENT. Petitioner's Exhibit V. Ms. Hiland reported that STUDENT had moderately delayed receptive language skills, severely delayed expressive language skills, severely impaired speech articulation skills, and normal oral motor development. Ms. Hiland stated that the current mapping of STUDENT's cochlear implant should provide her with "access to all sounds within the long-term average speech spectrum." Mr. Hiland concluded that STUDENT's prognosis for increasing her speech and language skills is fair to good if she "is provided with direct, intensive, intervention specifically targeting her oral communication skills."

Ms. Hiland recommended that STUDENT receive a minimum of three hours per week of individual speech language or auditory/verbal services. Ms. Hiland recommended that these services be provided utilizing a curriculum designed for children with cochlear implants. Ms. Hiland further recommended that STUDENT's education take place in a program that will provide her with greater access to oral language models, preferably in a full inclusion program.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

Petitioner's Witnesses

MOTHER

MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified that STUDENT started receiving speech and language services twice a month at the House Ear Institute in 1994.(Footnote 4) These services were paid for by California Children's Services (CCS). In April 1995, STUDENT's services at the House Ear Institute changed to audiology services because two sessions of speech and language per month were insufficient.

According to MOTHER, both Traci Nolin and Dr. Dennis Maceri did not believe Respondents provided sufficient speech and language therapy for STUDENT. MOTHER testified that Ms. Nolin told her STUDENT needed at least two sessions of therapy per week for fifty minutes of therapy each.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT began receiving counseling from Stephanie Cohen, a counselor with Alhambra City Elementary School District, after she received the implant. The counseling with Ms. Cohen continued until May 1995. MOTHER testified that she removed STUDENT from counseling with Ms. Cohen because Ms. Cohen initiated an abuse investigation against the PARENTS after misinterpreting a statement STUDENT made to her. According to MOTHER, in response Respondents offered a referral to Mental Health or counseling with Paul Krumhauer. STUDENT tried a couple of sessions with Mr. Krumhauer but she would not talk to him. MOTHER testified that STUDENT needs a female therapist. MOTHER also testified that the abuse allegations made in the investigation were not substantiated and the investigation was dropped.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT did not receive any counseling from June 1995 until January 1996. In January, she started receiving private counseling from a deaf female therapist at Five Acres in Pasadena. According to MOTHER, STUDENT is doing well with this counseling.

Regarding STUDENT's placement in the oral program during Summer 1995, MOTHER testified that STUDENT was withdrawn from that program because her implant was not working properly. MOTHER testified that she did not want STUDENT in the oral program unless the implant was working.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT requires the services of an auditory verbal specialist, which she described as a person who works with people who have just acquired the ability to hear and need to learn what they are hearing. MOTHER testified that STUDENT's health insurance would not pay for an auditory verbal specialist.

Regarding the Covina Valley placement, MOTHER testified that she requested a placement in Covina Valley prior to the time she became aware of the TRIPOD program. MOTHER requested the change to Covina Valley because she believed STUDENT was not progressing at Baldwin School. MOTHER testified that a representative from Covina Valley attended the IEP meeting in December 1996 and indicated that Covina Valley could not offer more than STUDENT was already getting at Baldwin.

Dr. Robert Patterson

As noted above, Dr. Patterson conducted an assessment of STUDENT in Fall 1996. During his assessment of STUDENT, Dr. Patterson spent approximately four to five hours with her. This is the only time he has spent with STUDENT. Dr. Patterson has not had any contact with any of Respondents' employees regarding STUDENT.

Dr. Patterson testified that the results of his assessment and Respondents' assessments indicate that the educational program STUDENT is in currently is not helping her improve in conjunction with her cognitive skills. Dr. Patterson, in stating his opinion, relied on STUDENT's low academic achievement scores and a comparison of these scores to those of regular education peers and also to those of other hearing impaired peers. Dr. Patterson testified that, based on Respondents' testing, STUDENT's cognitive ability is 10-20% above other deaf children. However, the ability scores STUDENT received during his assessment are "at the bottom of the deaf population in academic areas."

Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT achieved a standard score of 109 on the Leiter in first grade and that when he administered the Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (TONI) in Fall 1996, STUDENT achieved a standard score of 96. Dr. Patterson testified that such a drop is significant and may be attributable to emotional issues.

As another indicator of STUDENT's lack of progress, Dr. Patterson pointed to one of STUDENT's goals since the first grade -- counting change. Dr. Patterson testified that, based on STUDENT's results on the WIAT, she does not know monetary equivalents, a skill she should know based on her cognitive level. Respondents have not taught her how to count change even though counting change has been a goal since the first grade. Dr. Patterson testified that it appeared that Respondents are using the general learning sequence with STUDENT -- for example the sequence the Brigance is based on(Footnote 5) -- and not recognizing that STUDENT may have deficits which may make that sequence difficult for her. Dr. Patterson testified that instead of developing goals for STUDENT that remediate her deficits, goals are developed to reflect the teaching strategy and general learning sequence. Dr. Patterson testified that Respondents also have not tried to determine why STUDENT is not progressing in academics.

Regarding STUDENT's failure to wear her implant or hearing aid, Dr. Patterson testified that this is an educational issue and that Respondents have not tried to determine how to provide incentive for STUDENT to wear either the aid or the implant. Dr. Patterson testified that a Hughes Bill type of assessment may be appropriate to develop a program to reinforce wearing the aid and implant.

Dr. Patterson testified that social-emotional issues may be a barrier to STUDENT's education. As an example, Dr. Patterson cited STUDENT's tendency to "shut down" when she gets anxious or believes that she is not doing work correctly. Dr. Patterson testified that, therefore, STUDENT should receive counseling from a female therapist who is familiar with deaf issues and can utilize sign language to communicate with STUDENT.

Dr. Patterson testified that a TRIPOD-like environment would be appropriate for STUDENT as long as she gets appropriate support in the program, including teachers who are sensitive to her handicaps, therapy to address her emotional issues, and multisensory teaching in reading and writing. Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT needs a modified environment where use of her implant is reinforced and she is exposed to a mixture of students, including nonhearing-impaired students. Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT also needs additional speech and language services for vocabulary acquisition and speech.

Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT's lack of growth could be attributed to any of the following:

(1) a misunderstanding of her processing deficits (2) teaching techniques (3) the nature of her handicap and changes with her hearing aids and implant (4) her educational placement (5) emotional factors (6) home environment (7) integration with peers

According to Dr. Patterson, it is difficult to determine which of these factors are the major causes of STUDENT's lack of educational growth.

Carl Kirchner

Carl Kirchner is the executive director of TRIPOD. Mr. Kirchner testified that the approach to educating deaf students has changed over the years and that the preference now is to provide deaf students with an inclusive education within the hearing environment. Mr. Kirchner testified that D/HH students should be educated in a regular education environment with small classes. For instance, a class should have approximately twenty hearing children and eight D/HH children. Mr. Kirchner also testified that aides and interpreters should be eliminated as much as possible because they block inclusion of the D/HH students. D/HH students in such classes should receive as much direct instruction from the teacher as possible.

Mr. Kirchner testified that D/HH students from self-contained classes typically have lower social and academic skills than those in regular education. Mr. Kirchner attributed this difference to the fact that attendance in a regular education class forces D/HH students to improve their social skills.

Mr. Kirchner testified that a program similar to TRIPOD could be implemented anywhere if the administration and teachers support it. Mr. Kirchner testified that School Services for California completed a study in December 1996 which showed that the cost per pupil in TRIPOD was $9,000, while the cost per D/HH student in a self-contained class was $14,000.

Jane Clausen

Jane Clausen is a teacher in the D/HH program at John Muir Middle School in Burbank. Her class is part of the TRIPOD program. Ms. Clausen described the TRIPOD program as regular education classrooms which include hearing children and D/HH children. Ms. Clausen testified that no more than 1/3 of the children are D/HH and that the D/HH students are dispersed throughout the room. The D/HH students are expected to work with hearing children and are also expected to use their oral communication skills. Ms. Clausen testified that it takes about "30 seconds flat" for D/HH children to integrate into TRIPOD.

Ms. Clausen testified that the D/HH students are expected to work at the same level as the hearing students. If D/HH students need additional help, tutoring and remedial services are available.

Ruth Hiland

Ruth Hiland is a private speech and language pathologist. Ms. Hiland first met STUDENT in February 1995, when she conducted an assessment of STUDENT at the House Ear Institute. Ms. Hiland conducted a reevaluation in January 1997.

Regarding STUDENT's cochlear implant, Ms. Hiland testified that STUDENT needs training to help her learn to discriminate the sounds she can hear with the implant. Ms. Hiland testified that STUDENT's present ability to discriminate sounds -- for example, between vowels and consonants, or to filter out environmental noises -- is poor.

Ms. Hiland testified that the speech and language services STUDENT has received since receiving the implant have not been adequate to meet her increased needs. Specifically, Ms. Hiland testified that the thirty minutes of small-group speech services and sixty minutes of classroom speech services provided for in the IEP dated October 1995 were insufficient to help STUDENT to learn how to discriminate sounds. Ms. Hiland also testified that STUDENT's IEP should include goals and objectives for oral speech production.

Ms. Hiland testified that STUDENT has the capability to be in an integrated environment with hearing peers. Such a placement would result in a dramatic improvement in STUDENT because she would want to use her speech skills. Ms. Hiland testified that such an environment would have to include other hearing impaired children so that STUDENT did not feel isolated.

Ms. Hiland provided speech services at the TRIPOD program in 1995 and 1996. Ms. Hiland testified that STUDENT would become more oral with accommodations similar to those in TRIPOD. The lack of exposure to hearing peers has effected STUDENT's willingness to use her voice.

Dennis Maceri

Dr. Dennis Maceri, associate professor of oteolaryngology at the University of Southern California, performed the cochlear implant surgery. Dr. Maceri first met STUDENT in 1990 or 1991 and recommended an implant for her at that time. However, STUDENT did not have the implant surgery until March 1993. Dr. Maceri testified that he was impressed with STUDENT because she seemed to be a quick learner. Dr. Maceri testified that he saw STUDENT frequently until the end of 1994, but that he has had very little contact with her since then.

Dr. Maceri testified that an implant elevates the child's ability to discriminate sounds to a conversational level. However, after receiving an implant, the child needs oral training to identify the sounds he or she is now hearing. Without adequate oral training, the child's motivation to use the implant could be adversely impacted.

Dr. Maceri testified that a child's educational program has an impact on the success of the implant. A child with an implant needs to be educated in an oral setting with normal children because an education in a sign language class would defeat the purpose of the implant. Dr. Maceri testified that a child with an implant does not need a transition period to move to an oral program. The sooner such a child moves into an oral environment the better.Dr. Maceri testified that he visited STUDENT's school before the implant surgery and met with STUDENT's speech and language therapist and other of Respondents' personnel. At that time, he told the personnel he met with that STUDENT would need a lot of speech and language therapy. Dr. Maceri testified that he left the meeting believing that Respondents would provide daily speech and language therapy and an oral educational program.

Dr. Maceri testified that the minimum speech and language therapy STUDENT should receive is three 60-minute individual sessions and two 30-minute group sessions per week. Based on this recommendation, Dr. Maceri was of the opinion that STUDENT's speech and language therapy in October 1994 -- 30 minutes of small-group and 60 minutes of classroom therapy per week -- was insufficient to meet STUDENT's needs. Dr. Maceri also testified that the speech and language therapy provided in the IEP dated December 1996 -- a total of 75 minutes of small- and large-group therapy per week -- was also inadequate especially considering the lack of services she had received in the past.

Dr. Maceri testified that he saw gains in STUDENT during the first one and a half years that she had the implant but that her gains were not as much as he had expected. Dr. Maceri testified that he is not surprised that STUDENT stopped using the implant, considering the lack of proper training and the educational environment she was in. Dr. Maceri testified that the biggest motivational factor for a child to use the implant is to be around people who are talking all of the time.

Dr. Maceri testified that many of STUDENT's current goals are basic survival skills. In addition, the auditory goals contained in her IEP dated December 1996 should have already been mastered. Dr. Maceri testified that, considering where STUDENT is at and the lack of services she has received, STUDENT should be treated as though she has just received the implant. This would mean having her wear the implant on a regular basis, providing her with training on how to use the implant properly, and providing her with intensive speech and language therapy.

Traci Nolin

Traci Nolin is the clinical audiologist who provided audiology services to STUDENT in cooperation with Dr. Maceri. Ms. Nolin first met STUDENT in 1991 or 1992 when she helped STUDENT with her hearing aids. Ms. Nolin also provided some counseling to STUDENT's family and school before the surgery so that they would know what to expect.

Ms. Nolin testified that STUDENT was a good candidate for an implant because she was motivated to be a part of the hearing world and was not getting what she wanted or needed from hearing aids. Ms. Nolin testified that STUDENT was first fitted with the implant in March 1993. Ms. Nolin testified that the use of a hearing aid and implant placed STUDENT in hard of hearing status -- she was no longer deaf. According to Ms. Nolin, an individual who is deaf does not hear sound in any meaningful way, even with a hearing aid. An individual who is hard of hearing has a hearing loss but, with appropriate amplification through hearing aids or implants, can hear and understand speech. Ms. Nolin testified that, with aided hearing, STUDENT could hear speech at 35 decibels, a level similar to mild hearing loss. Because of STUDENT's hearing level, Ms. Nolin believed that STUDENT should no longer be treated as a deaf child.

Ms. Nolin testified that the school setting is crucial once a child has an implant. If the school setting is not appropriate, a child with an implant cannot learn to use the implant and will not be motivated to use it. Ms. Nolin testified that she met twice with Respondents' personnel and that they seemed excited about the implant. Ms. Nolin testified that Respondents' personnel indicated that STUDENT may be transferred to an oral program at Granada School.

Ms. Nolin worked with STUDENT for one and a half years. After the first few months, she only saw STUDENT once a month or once every other month. According to Ms. Nolin, by the end of her work with STUDENT, her motivation to use the implant was not as high as it was at the beginning. Ms. Nolin attributed this to the fact that STUDENT was not progressing as fast as she wanted because she was not being exposed to the auditory information she needed. Ms. Nolin testified that STUDENT's expectations would not have been unreasonable had she been in the appropriate educational setting. Ms. Nolin testified that a total communication special day class with 8-10 other D/HH students is the wrong setting for STUDENT. Assuming that STUDENT's implant is working properly and she is wearing it, an appropriate setting for STUDENT is a predominantly oral classroom. Ms. Nolin also testified that STUDENT needs auditory training and speech and language services so that she can learn to interpret the new sounds she was hearing with her implant.

Respondents' Witnesses

Barbara Gottesman

Barbara Gottesman is the special education supervisor for Duarte, a position she has held since October 1995. Ms. Gottesman attended the IEP meeting held on May 23, 1996. Ms. Gottesman testified that MOTHER and her advocate expressed that their major concerns regarding STUDENT's placement were transportation and the presence of a student on the bus with whom STUDENT had a conflict. Ms. Gottesman testified that she offered MOTHER a transportation contract which would have allowed MOTHER to personally transport STUDENT to school and to receive reimbursement from Respondents. According to Ms. Gottesman, MOTHER refused this proposal. Ms. Gottesman testified that, ultimately, STUDENT and the other student were seated apart from each other on the bus and STUDENT was seated right behind the bus driver to ensure that no more problems occurred.

Ms. Gottesman testified that MOTHER did not express any dissatisfaction with STUDENT's speech and language services or request an auditory verbal specialist. Ms. Gottesman also indicated that the IEP team offered a referral for Mental Health services because of STUDENT's social and emotional issues.

In response to MOTHER's request for placement at Covina Valley, Ms. Gottesman contacted Covina Valley Unified School District during the Summer 1996. According to Ms. Gottesman, Covina Valley indicated they were willing to consider STUDENT for placement in their program and that Covina Valley was available for placement for STUDENT at the start of the 1996-97 school year.

Ms. Gottesman testified that the IEP meeting on December 19, 1996, lasted for four to five hours. According to Ms. Gottesman, the team discussed the various assessments, including Dr. Patterson's assessment. Ms. Gottesman testified that STUDENT's parents and teachers were very involved in the discussion. Ms. Gottesman testified that the IEP team incorporated the PARENTS' concerns into STUDENT's IEP, and also offered counseling again to address STUDENT's social and emotional issues, and speech and language therapy.

Ms. Gottesman testified that Baldwin School is a public school campus. The class STUDENT has been in is a special day class for D/HH students and is taught by a special education teacher with the assistance of one aide. Ms. Gottesman testified that STUDENT attends Baldwin School in Alhambra because Alhambra provides the D/HH program for the SELPA in which STUDENT resides.

Ms. Gottesman testified that she is unaware of any full inclusion D/HH programs within the SELPA. Ms. Gottesman testified that, a an alternative, she offered to place STUDENT within a regular education class in Duarte. Ms. Gottesman expressed numerous concerns regarding STUDENT's inclusion in a regular education environment, including motivation, study habits, prevocation skills, reliability in returning work, and social adaptive behaviors. Ms. Gottesman testified that it is the consensus of STUDENT's teachers that she is not ready to be integrated with hearing students.

Maggie Azevedo

Maggie Azevedo is the coordinator of special education for the Alhambra City Elementary School District. Ms. Azevedo's first contact with the PARENTS was during a mediation on December 3, 1996.

Ms. Azevedo testified that the assessments of STUDENT's cognitive level indicate she could be successful in a regular education hearing environment. However, social and emotional issues, along with issues relating to STUDENT's implant, have impeded her progress. Regarding the implant, Ms. Azevedo pointed to STUDENT's inconsistency in using the implant and stated that such inconsistency has affected her acquisition of language and communication skills. As to social and emotional issues, Ms. Azevedo testified that these began to surface in 1994, as reported in Respondents' assessment conducted that year.

Ms. Azevedo participated in the IEP meeting on December 19, 1996. She testified that the IEP team revised STUDENT's goals and objectives to address issues raised in Dr. Patterson's assessment. Ms. Azevedo testified that everyone was in agreement regarding the final goals and objectives that were developed by the team. Ms. Azevedo also testified that STUDENT's teacher expressed concerns regarding full inclusion for STUDENT and indicated that STUDENT was beginning to feel comfortable in her class at Baldwin. Ms. Azevedo testified that the goals and objectives developed by the IEP meeting on December 19, 1996, require more intervention than could be provided by a regular education teacher. Many of the goals would require the services of a D/HH teacher and would be better suited to a small-group environment.

Ms. Azevedo testified that speech and language development is incorporated into the entire school day at Baldwin and that STUDENT needs speech and language services in both a one-on-one environment and a classroom environment. Ms. Azevedo also indicated that D/HH teachers are trained to work on auditory speech and language development.

Ann Liu

Ann Liu is an itinerant teacher for the D/HH program at Alhambra City Elementary School District. As an itinerant teacher, Ms. Liu travels from school to school and works with D/HH students who are mainstreamed. Ms. Liu was STUDENT's preschool and kindergarten teacher. Ms. Liu also taught STUDENT's summer school class during Summer 1995.

According to Ms. Liu, the class STUDENT was in during Summer 1995 was made up primarily of students from the oral program at Granada School. Ms. Liu testified that although STUDENT was placed in the class by her IEP team because they wanted STUDENT to have more positive results with her implant, she did not wear her implant in the class because it was not working at the time. She did wear her hearing aid consistently. Ms. Liu testified that STUDENT would become withdrawn and cry at some point during the day at least four out of five days each week. Ms. Liu testified that STUDENT's social and emotional issues were interfering with her education. STUDENT did have good interaction with the other children in the class and made some academic progress, although it was difficult for STUDENT to participate in group projects.

During Summer 1996, Ms. Liu tutored STUDENT for 1 1/2 hours per day for approximately two weeks. Ms. Liu testified that, although STUDENT made progress, she was not satisfied because she was still not performing at grade level.

Ms. Liu testified that she has kept in contact with STUDENT and her family and that she saw her again at the IEP meeting in December 1996. Ms. Liu testified that STUDENT still relies on sign language instead of hearing and oral communication because she has difficulty discriminating between environmental sounds and human voices. Ms. Liu testified that inconsistent use of the implant would affect STUDENT's ability to learn.

Ms. Liu testified that STUDENT would not be comfortable in a regular class because she is shy and would not be able to communicate what she wants to the other students. Ms. Liu testified that STUDENT's biggest weakness is a lack of an enriched language environment. She needs a visual language system, such as a descriptive sign language system. Ms. Liu testified that STUDENT's perception of events is restricted because her language is so limited.

Ms. Liu testified that STUDENT needs to be in an environment where she can easily understand the language being used and that she is most comfortable with sign language. According to Ms. Liu, STUDENT needs direct contact with the language system being used in class and should not have indirect contact with the teachers and students through interpreters.

Regarding TRIPOD, Ms. Liu testified that she is familiar with the program and that three students she has worked with have gone to TRIPOD. Ms. Liu testified that STUDENT would have difficulty in such a program because she works better in a small group environment. Ms. Liu testified that STUDENT gets overwhelmed easily and would have difficulty adjusting to a new group of D/HH students.

William Ritchie

William Ritchie is an audiologist with Alhambra City Elementary School District. Mr. Ritchie conducted an audiology evaluation of STUDENT when she first entered Respondents' program and has conducted audiology updates annually since. Mr. Ritchie also attended the meeting with Dr. Maceri and Traci Nolin at which they discussed STUDENT's implant with Respondents' personnel.

Mr. Ritchie testified that for aids and implants to work effectively, training must be provided and the aids and implants must be used consistently. Mr. Ritchie testified that the amplification provided by the aids and implants has to be consistent, otherwise a child's auditory skills and speech and language development could be adversely impacted. Mr. Ritchie indicated that STUDENT has not worn her implant for one and a half years.

Stephanie Cohen

Stephanie Cohen is a D/HH counsellor for Alhambra City Elementary School District. Ms. Cohen first met STUDENT in Summer 1994, when she provided group guidance counseling in STUDENT's class. Following the IEP meeting in October 1994, Ms. Cohen began providing individual counseling to STUDENT pursuant to her IEP. Ms. Cohen provided the counseling until approximately April or May 1995, when MOTHER withdrew STUDENT from the counseling.

Ms. Cohen testified that when she started providing counseling in October 1994, STUDENT's teacher told her that STUDENT cried a lot in class and MOTHER told her that STUDENT had self-image problems. Ms. Cohen also testified that she noticed during group sessions in STUDENT's class that she was not willing to participate fully because of a lack of confidence. By the end of Ms. Cohen's counseling sessions with STUDENT in Spring 1995, STUDENT was crying more in school and did not want to come to school. Ms. Cohen testified that she recommended a referral to Mental Health because she was concerned about STUDENT's social and emotional functioning and STUDENT's parents had withdrawn her from her counseling with Ms. Cohen. Ms. Cohen testified that STUDENT's parents did not follow through on the Mental Health referral and, instead, obtained private counseling for STUDENT.

Ms. Cohen testified that she has continued to see STUDENT in the group sessions in her class which she works with the students on social skills. According to Ms. Cohen, STUDENT's social skills are appropriate, although she continues to be reluctant to participate. Ms. Cohen testified that STUDENT's emotional issues impact her education because she has difficulty concentrating, is reluctant to participate, and is preoccupied.

Ms. Cohen testified that STUDENT would be very hesitant in a regular education classroom. STUDENT holds back in new situations and is very fearful of risks. Ms. Cohen believes that STUDENT would gravitate toward other D/HH students in her class if placed in a regular education environment that included other D/HH students.

Elizabeth Ott Orban

Elizabeth Ott Orban, a speech and language pathologist for Alhambra High School District, was asked to conduct a speech and language assessment prior to STUDENT's implant surgery. Ms. Ott Orban also attended the meeting with Dr. Maceri and Ms. Nolin. Ms. Ott Orban testified that she had concerns regarding STUDENT's receiving an implant because she was prelingually deaf.

Ms. Orban testified that she was STUDENT's primary speech and language pathologist beginning in 1994. Ms. Orban's last speech and language session with STUDENT was in July 1996. Ms. Orban testified that, although STUDENT was wearing her implant in Fall 1994, it did not appear to be working and, as far as she knows, the implant was not working from September 1994 through May 1996. Ms. Orban testified also that STUDENT came to therapy without her hearing aids many times. Ms. Orban estimated that during the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT had her hearing aid in only about 20-30% of the time. Ms. Orban testified that a long period of time without use of the hearing aid would affect STUDENT's acquisition of language skills.

Ms. Orban provided speech and language therapy to STUDENT twice a week for 30 minutes each, usually in small groups of two children, during 1994. In subsequent years, the therapy Ms. Orban provided was once a week in small groups for 30 minutes and once a week in large groups for 60 minutes. Ms. Orban testified that she worked on auditory skills with STUDENT and that STUDENT's teacher also worked on auditory skills.

Ms. Orban testified that STUDENT needs a total communication program and that she was making progress in her program at Baldwin given her improved ability to communicate, the length and quality of her communications, and her ability to get across her wants and needs. Ms. Orban testified that oral instruction was always going on in STUDENT's classroom. Ms. Orban testified that STUDENT would probably not do well in a regular education class because she would not be able to function without an interpreter. Ms. Orban also indicated that STUDENT is very easily distracted and, if she were in a larger classroom with more teachers and more things going on, she would very easily go off-task. According to Ms. Orban, STUDENT also would not get anything out of oral instruction if she does not have on her aid or implant.

Paul Krumhauer

Paul Krumhauer is a school psychologist for the Alhambra City Elementary School District. He has worked with the D/HH program for the past 17 years. Mr. Krumhauer conducted assessments of STUDENT in 1991, 1994, and 1996. Mr. Krumhauer testified that he sees STUDENT in her academic environment approximately once a week.

Mr. Krumhauer testified that he first saw signs of social and emotional problems with STUDENT in 1994. At that time, STUDENT was quiet with a "lack of affect." Mr. Krumhauer testified that STUDENT's teacher expressed some concerns regarding STUDENT's behavior in the classroom. Mr. Krumhauer testified that STUDENT's behavior was similar during the 1996 assessment. Furthermore, Mr. Krumhauer indicated that STUDENT's test results indicated interpersonal difficulties and problems with self-concept.

Mr. Krumhauer testified that STUDENT's social and emotional problems would affect her in academic areas that require concentration, memory, and sequencing, such as math and reading comprehension.

Mr. Krumhauer testified that he is opposed to enrolling STUDENT in an oral program because she has low self-concept and problems with interpersonal relationships. Mr. Krumhauer testified that, with an implant, STUDENT would stand out in an oral program. Furthermore, since STUDENT's peers in an oral program would be communicating orally, STUDENT would have difficulty effectively communicating, making her peer relationships more difficult. Mr. Krumhauer testified that STUDENT's experiment in a oral program during the summer confirmed his opinion.

Mr. Krumhauer testified that it is understandable that STUDENT's parents would want to withdraw STUDENT from counseling with Ms. Cohen after the report regarding possible child abuse.

Mr. Krumhauer testified that Granada School is an Alhambra City school with an oral program for children who have lesser hearing deficits and can learn through the auditory channel. Baldwin School, where STUDENT is enrolled, is for students who cannot be taught through their auditory channel and, therefore, the program relies more on visually-based teaching.

Joy Siddiqi

Joy Siddiqi is a D/HH instructional specialist with the Alhambra City Elementary School District. Ms. Siddiqi testified that STUDENT is the first student in the D/HH program who has received a cochlear implant. Ms. Siddiqi has known STUDENT since she was in preschool, although she did not become significantly involved with STUDENT until October 1995, when concerns regarding STUDENT's transportation were raised.

Ms. Siddiqi attended the IEP meeting in October 1995 and testified that, at that time, STUDENT was returning to Baldwin School after participating in an oral program in the summer. Ms. Siddiqi testified that STUDENT's parents requested additional speech and language services but agreed to maintain the current level until December 1995 because of problems with STUDENT's implant. In December 1995, according to Ms. Siddiqi, MOTHER withdrew her request for additional speech and language services because STUDENT was no longer wearing her implant. Ms. Siddiqi testified that MOTHER also withdrew her request for an oral program in January 1996 because STUDENT was no longer wearing her implant.

Ms. Siddiqi testified that for an implant to be successful, the child has to wear it all of the time. Ms. Siddiqi testified that STUDENT does not even bring the implant to school any more. According to Ms. Siddiqi, other children with abilities and impairments similar to STUDENT's have done better in the D/HH program than STUDENT.

Barbara Ritchie

Barbara Ritchie is a special education teacher in the D/HH program at Baldwin School. She has been STUDENT's teacher since October 1996. According to Ms. Ritchie, STUDENT's performance in class places her in the middle of the other students. There are approximately ten students in the class ranging from fifth to eighth graders. Ms. Ritchie testified that she prefers that her students use total communication, which she described as using sign language and speech simultaneously.

Ms. Ritchie testified that STUDENT does not wear her hearing aid or implant in class and, from October 1996 until December 1996, she did not even bring the hearing aid to school. Ms. Ritchie testified that she has told STUDENT that she needs to bring her hearing aid to school but STUDENT still does not. The students in Ms. Ritchie's class also have auditory trainers available to them.(Footnote 6) Ms. Ritchie testified that STUDENT has to use the auditory trainer every day and will do so in Ms. Ritchie's class but not in her other classes.

Ms. Ritchie testified that STUDENT is mainstreamed during electives. During the current semester, STUDENT's electives are art and painting. Ms. Ritchie testified that she does not know what the speech and language therapist works on with STUDENT.

Ms. Ritchie testified that she believes her class is appropriate for STUDENT because it is a total communication class and provides a threat-free environment for her. Ms. Ritchie also testified that STUDENT has made progress on some of her goals and objectives. Regarding the goals and objectives, Ms. Ritchie testified that STUDENT's reading and math goals are equivalent to what second or third grade regular education students would be working on.

DISCUSSION

(1) Have Respondents provided an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT?

State and federal law requires that students with disabilities receive a free appropriate public education. California Education Code § 56000 et seq. and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child, including classroom instruction, instruction in physical education, home instruction, and instruction in hospitals and institutions."

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." 458 U.S. 175, 200.

Taken together, the IDEA and the Rowley Court's interpretation of the IDEA provide three factors for analyzing whether the Respondents' placement is appropriate for STUDENT. Those three factors are as follows:

(1) Is the placement designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs?

(2) Does the placement conform to STUDENT's IEP?

(3) Is the placement designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT?

The first factor -- whether the Respondents have provided an educational placement for STUDENT that is designed to meet her unique needs -- requires an analysis of STUDENT's unique needs.

Respondents contend for several reasons that STUDENT's needs include a self-contained special day class that utilizes total communication. First, Respondents contend that STUDENT could not be successful in an oral program because of social and emotional issues. Second, Respondents contend that STUDENT needs the visual communication system that could be provided in a total communication class because she relies on sign language.

With regards to Respondents' contentions, Petitioner responds that STUDENT's social and emotional problems stem largely from an incident involving another student which was enhanced because of her lack of oral skills to communicate what was happening. Petitioner also contends that STUDENT's social and emotional problems also are a result of Respondents' failure to provide her with an appropriate placement that allowed her to learn how to use her implant and to effectively communicate orally. Finally, Petitioner contends that it is STUDENT's reliance on sign language that requires her to be enrolled in an oral program such as TRIPOD. Petitioner contends that until STUDENT is placed into an oral program and, essentially, required to use her aid and implant and learn to communicate orally, she will always rely on sign language and not be motivated to learn oral communication skills.

Prior to March 1993, when STUDENT had the implant surgery, STUDENT was a child with profound hearing loss. However, once the implant surgery was performed and STUDENT's cochlear implant activated, STUDENT became a child who was hard of hearing and possibly, according to Ms. Nolin, a child with only a mild hearing loss. With both the implant and aid, STUDENT acquired the ability to hear sounds at a level that allows her to learn oral language and to communicate orally.

Once STUDENT had the implant, her unique needs included increased speech and language therapy, as testified to by Dr. Maceri, Ms. Nolin, Ms. Hiland, and Dr. Patterson. The purpose of increased speech and language therapy was to teach STUDENT to identify sounds she was hearing were and to teach her oral communication skills. In addition, as testified to by Dr. Maceri, STUDENT needed exposure to hearing and speaking peers so that she would use her implant and acquire language skills.

Although Dr. Maceri and Ms. Nolin testified that they advised the Respondents of the impact the cochlear implant would have on STUDENT and the increased need for speech and language services and an oral environment, the Respondents did not make any significant changes other than to increase her speech and language services to two 30-minute sessions per week in October 1993 and then to one 30-minute session and one 60-minute session per week in October 1995. Respondents continued to provide STUDENT's educational placement in a total communication special day class with little interaction with hearing peers.(Footnote 7)

The evidence shows that STUDENT's social and emotional issues did not develop until at least one and a half years, and possibly two years, after she received the implant. Mr. Krumhauer testified that he did not detect any signs of social or emotional problems until he conducted an evaluation of STUDENT in October 1994, one and a half years after STUDENT received the implant. This was the same time that STUDENT stopped wearing her implant. It is significant that STUDENT's social and emotional problems appeared to develop at the same time that she became so frustrated with her implant that she stopped wearing it.

The Hearing Officer finds that there is insufficient evidence that STUDENT's social and emotional needs require that she be placed in a total communication special day class. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's social and emotional problems may have stemmed, at least in part, from Respondents' failure to provide an appropriate oral program and speech and language services such that STUDENT learned to use her implant and to communicate orally. In other words, if Respondents had modified STUDENT's educational program to meet her needs once she had the implant, it is likely that the social and emotional needs which developed later may not have occurred, or at least not to the marked degree to which they did. In any case, the Hearing Officer is not convinced that STUDENT's current social and emotional needs require her to be placed in a special day class.

The Hearing Officer also finds persuasive Petitioner's argument with regards to STUDENT's reliance on sign language. As noted above, once STUDENT received the implant she became a different child. The implant provided her with the means to hear and to orally communicate. Rather than placing STUDENT in an oral program which would provide STUDENT with an opportunity to fully utilize the implant, Respondents maintained her placement in a total communication class where STUDENT could rely on sign language and not be required to use the implant. Respondents' failure to modify STUDENT's program has strengthened her dependence on sign language and weakened her need for the implant. STUDENT needs to be placed in an oral program that will require her to use her implant and acquire oral communication skills.

In addition, the speech and language services provided by Respondents were not adequate to meet STUDENT's unique needs. As testified to by several of Petitioner's witnesses, once STUDENT received the implant, her ability to hear changed dramatically. STUDENT's sudden exposure to the hearing world required an increase in speech and language services and oral training that Respondents have never provided. Dr. Maceri testified that STUDENT needed three 60-minute sessions per week of individual therapy and two 30-minute sessions per week of small-group therapy. Ms. Nolin and Ms. Hiland provided opinions that were consistent with Dr. Maceri's. The most speech and language therapy Respondents have ever provided for STUDENT was a total of 90 minutes per week during the 1995-96 school year, none of which was individual therapy. Based on the opinions of Dr. Maceri, Ms. Nolin, and Ms. Hiland, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's unique needs included more speech and language therapy than that provided by Respondents.

The District contends that many of Petitioner's witnesses have not worked regularly with STUDENT and have not worked with her in an educational setting, while the District's witnesses have had years of experience working with STUDENT in her educational setting. The District contends, therefore, that greater weight should be given to the District's witnesses. While the Hearing Officer generally finds that the educational professionals who work directly with a child are the more credible and are given significant weight, this case presents an unusual scenario. STUDENT is a child with a cochlear implant. Many of Petitioner's witnesses -- including Ms. Hiland, Dr. Maceri, and Ms. Nolin -- have extensive experience with children with cochlear implants, while the District's witnesses have relatively little experience with such children. Ms. Siddiqi testified that STUDENT was the first student in the District to have a cochlear implant. The Hearing Officer, therefore, has given significant weight to the testimony of the witnesses most familiar with cochlear implants regarding STUDENT's educational needs.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents did not provide a placement that met STUDENT's unique needs once she received her cochlear implant.(Footnote 8) Therefore, Respondents have not provided STUDENT with a free and appropriate placement as required by the IDEA and Rowley since she received her implant in March 1993.(Footnote 9)

(2) If not, is STUDENT entitled to placement in a TRIPOD-like program?

During the hearing, Respondents contended that TRIPOD, or a program similar to it, should not be considered because no such program existed in the West San Gabriel Valley SELPA. Contrary to Respondents' assertion, however, the mere fact that a particular type of program does not exist or does not have an opening does not preclude such a program from being considered.

As noted above, special education law requires that each child's educational placement be based on that child's individual and unique needs. Furthermore, Education Code § 56360 requires that each district, special education local plan area, or county office shall ensure that a continuum of program options is available to meet the needs of individuals with exceptional needs for special education and related services.

A program similar to TRIPOD, which provides D/HH students the opportunity to be integrated into the regular education environment with hearing peers and other nonhearing peers, is clearly a program which may be considered a part of the continuum of program options to be made available to meet the unique needs of an individual student. If a TRIPOD-like program is the type of program which will meet STUDENT's unique needs, § 56360 requires that Respondents make such a program available to her, whether they develop such a program themselves, or locate a similar program elsewhere.

The question then becomes whether STUDENT currently should be placed in a TRIPOD-like program. As stated above, the IDEA and Rowley require that STUDENT's placement be designed to meet her unique needs and provide her with educational benefit. A program similar to TRIPOD would meet STUDENT's unique needs as a child with a cochlear implant because it would provide her with a full day of interaction with hearing peers and intensive remedial work to help her catch up with her peers.

Regarding the educational benefit of a TRIPOD-like program, testimony presented by Mr. Kirchner and Ms. Clausen described the educational benefits that students in an oral program similar to TRIPOD may receive. STUDENT would be exposed to hearing peers and would be required to develop oral communication skills and to develop her hearing skills. STUDENT could also receive extra tutoring or remedial services so that she would be able to learn at the same level as her hearing peers.

Based on the testimony of Mr. Kirchner and Ms. Clausen, the Hearing Officer finds that placement in an oral program similar to TRIPOD would more likely than not provide STUDENT with significant educational benefit. First and foremost, she would be exposed throughout the day to hearing peers and be required to develop and use oral communication skills. Second, STUDENT would be provided with intensive remedial services to bring her up to the level of her peers and would be expected to perform at that level. Third, with sufficient aids and services, it may be that STUDENT will be able to overcome her social and emotional problems.

The Hearing Officer finds, therefore, that placement in a TRIPOD-like program would meet STUDENT's unique needs and would be more likely than not provide her with significant educational benefit in compliance with the IDEA and Rowley.

Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1412(5)(B), Respondents must also ensure that to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities . . . are educated with children who are not disabled, and that special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. See also Education Code § 56001(g); 56031, 56364.

The Ninth Circuit has developed a four-factor test to determine an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment pursuant to § 1412(5)(B). Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H. 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994). Those four factors are:

(1) Educational benefit (2) Non-academic benefit (3) Effect on the teacher and children in the regular class (4) Cost

Educational Benefit

As discussed above, placement in a TRIPOD-like program would provide STUDENT with significant educational benefit.

Non-academic benefit

Non-academic benefit generally refers to interaction with nondisabled peers. As opposed to Respondents' placement for STUDENT which provides her with relatively few opportunities to interact with nondisabled peers, an oral program similar to TRIPOD provides STUDENT opportunities to interact with nondisabled peers throughout the day. Through this interaction, she would develop social skills and peer interaction skills. Most importantly for STUDENT, she would continue to develop the oral communication skills she needs to benefit from her education.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that placement in an oral program similar to TRIPOD would provide STUDENT with significant non-academic benefits.

Effect on the teacher and children in the regular class

There was no evidence presented, and no reason to believe, that STUDENT's presence in a regular education class modified like the TRIPOD program to include hearing-impaired students would have an adverse effect on the teacher or other children in the class.

Cost

Respondents did not present evidence regarding the costs associated with different types of programs. Mr. Kirchner testified on behalf of Petitioner that the costs per student of the TRIPOD may actually be lower than the costs per student in a special day class.

Therefore, cost should not prohibit STUDENT from participating in an oral program.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that a regular education setting similar to TRIPOD is an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment pursuant to § 1412(5)(B) and Holland.

To develop an appropriate program for STUDENT, Respondents shall convene an IEP team meeting within 15 days of the date of this decision. The IEP team shall develop a program which provides STUDENT with an education in a regular education environment with hearing peers and appropriate aids and services. STUDENT's new IEP shall include new goals and objectives developed in conjunction with the new placement in which STUDENT is enrolled.

The IEP team shall include at least one representative from TRIPOD and one individual who has worked with STUDENT in conjunction with her cochlear implant (for example, Dr. Maceri or Ms. Nolin), to be selected by STUDENT's parents and paid for by Respondents. If additional meetings are necessary, the District shall also pay for these individuals to participate at any subsequent IEP meetings until a final placement and IEP are developed. The IEP team shall develop a transition plan for STUDENT to move into the program selected for her and determine the appropriate aids and services STUDENT needs to benefit from the program. Finally, the IEP team shall determine the appropriate level of speech and language services for STUDENT, with the minimum level to be three 60-minute individual sessions per week as recommended by Dr. Maceri and Ms. Nolin.

(3) Have Respondents provided an appropriate amount of oral rehabilitation services for STUDENT?

As already noted under the discussion regarding Issue #1, Respondents did not provide an appropriate amount of oral rehabilitation services (speech and language therapy) for STUDENT.

ORDER

(1) Respondents shall convene an IEP team meeting for STUDENT within 15 days of the date of this decision. In addition to developing an appropriate placement for STUDENT, the IEP team shall develop new goals and objectives in conjunction with that new placement. The IEP team shall include at least one representative from TRIPOD and one individual who has worked with STUDENT with her cochlear implant to be selected by STUDENT's parents and paid for by Respondents. If additional meetings are necessary, the District shall pay for these individuals to participate in any subsequent IEP meetings until a final placement and IEP is developed.

(2) The IEP team shall identify or develop an appropriate program for STUDENT that places her in a regular education environment with hearing peers and appropriate aides and services, and develop an appropriate transition plan for STUDENT to move into that program.

(3) The IEP team shall determine the appropriate aids and services STUDENT requires to benefit from the placement and determine the appropriate level of speech and language services with the minimum level of such services being three 60-minute individual sessions per week.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56505(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: Petitioner prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: May 15, 1997 _______________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1.When Petitioner originally filed this request for hearing, she was requesting placement at TRIPOD, a Foothill SELPA program in Burbank for D/HH students. TRIPOD was described by witnesses as a program in which D/HH students are integrated into a regular education school environment in a classroom that includes regular education students and D/HH students. The class is co-taught by a regular education teacher and a teacher from the D/HH program. However, evidence was introduced during the hearing that TRIPOD has become impacted and is no longer accepting students, such as STUDENT, who are not in the Foothill SELPA. Petitioner subsequently changed her request to placement in a "TRIPOD-like" program.

2.A cochlear implant is an artificial means of stimulating the auditory nerve to allow a deaf individual to access sound. It includes an implant in the ear and a transmitter and microphone next to the ear. Once the implant is performed, any natural hearing the individual had is eliminated in the ear with the implant. 3. The WISC-III and Leiter results were taken from the District's assessment conducted on August 14, 1996. 4. Prior to the services provided by House Ear Institute, STUDENT also received speech and language services beginning in 1990 from private therapists paid for by STUDENT's health insurance. STUDENT received 60 hours of speech and language services per year through her health insurance. 5.Dr. Patterson testified that the Brigance is a test developed to assess where a child is at in the general learning sequence. According to Dr. Patterson, the Brigance was developed by teachers who determined what the general sequence is for children to learn. It is this sequence that Dr. Patterson believes the District is using to guide the District's educational program for STUDENT. 6. According to Ms. Ritchie, an auditory trainer is a device which provides more amplification than a hearing aid. The auditory trainers are provided to help the students understand the teacher better. 7. It could be argued that STUDENT's lack of success in the summer oral program during Summer 1995 would indicate that she needed a total communication special day class. However, the evidence establishes that STUDENT's lack of success during that summer was attributable, at least in part, to the fact that her implant was not working at the time. It is more likely than not that, if STUDENT's implant had been working, the outcome of her participation in the summer oral program would have been completely different. 8. Because the District failed to provide a placement designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, there is no need to specifically address the other two factors. However, the Hearing Officer questions whether the District's placement was providing STUDENT with educational benefit. Over the years, many of STUDENT's goals and objectives remained the same. Furthermore, STUDENt's performance on standardized tests showed very litte progress in many areas, and virtually no progress in other areas. The Hearing Officer also questions, considering STUDENT's lack of progress and the fact that many goals remained the same, whether the IEPs developed over the years for STUDENT were appropriately designed to meet STUDENT's educational needs and provide her with a program that gave her educational benefit. 9.The Hearing Officer notes that even if the District's placement was found to be appropriate, it would not satisfy the least restrictive environment requirement of special education law, as discussed below.