California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 1, 2002
Student v. Paradise Unified School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 604-02 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski
Paradise Unified, Butte County Office of Education and county mental health must fund reading assessment and tutoring after denying FAPE in reading.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A nine-year-old boy's parents filed for hearing against Paradise Unified, Chico Unified, the Butte County Office of Education and the Butte County Department of Behavioral Health. The boy was eligible for special education under emotional disturbance. From September 2000 to May 2002 he attended a special day class and day treatment program at Marigold School in Chico. The county office ran the program, and Behavioral Health provided the mental health services. The parents argued the program had too much counseling and too little reading, writing and math.
The Hearing Officer found the program met the boy's emotional and behavioral needs. His acting-out behaviors were gone by spring 2001. But in both school years he got only about 30 minutes a day of language arts and 30 minutes of math. He met none of his reading or writing goals, and his test scores showed no gains. The Hearing Officer held that both IEPs denied FAPE in reading and written language. Chico supplied only the classroom and lunches, so it was not liable.
The family was moving permanently to Missouri, but the Hearing Officer still awarded compensatory education. The award took into account 23 unexcused absences and the parents' decision to end individual and family therapy. The other respondents must hold an IEP meeting within 20 days. They must also reimburse a reading assessment, five hours a week of tutoring for one school year plus ESY, and reading materials, all provided in Missouri.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a therapeutic day treatment placement that improved a student's behavior but gave too little academic instruction. It held that a program must address academic needs as well as emotional ones. It also shows a Hearing Officer awarding compensatory education to a student who had moved out of California.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the Respondents provide Student with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year (ESY)?
The September 5, 2000 IEP met Student's emotional and behavioral needs. But about 30 minutes a day of language arts was not designed to meet his reading and writing needs and was not reasonably calculated to give some educational benefit in those areas, so FAPE was denied. The claim about sugars and dyes in food was not proven, and Chico was not responsible.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the Respondents provide Student with a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year until May 10, 2002?
Once his behavior improved, the focus should have moved to academics. Respondents did not show he got more than about one hour a day of academic instruction, and his reading and writing scores showed no progress. The September 4, 2001 IEP therefore denied FAPE in reading and written language. The parents' decision to stop individual and family therapy did not excuse the academic shortfall.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. If the Respondents denied Student a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY, and/or during the 2001-2002 school year until May 10, 2002, is he entitled to compensatory education?
The family's permanent move to Missouri did not bar compensatory education for a past denial of FAPE. The award was shaped by equitable factors, including unexcused absences and the parents ending therapy. Paradise, the Butte County Office of Education and Behavioral Health must fund a reading assessment, tutoring and materials in Missouri. Chico owes nothing.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the decision, Respondents must hold an IEP meeting, with the parents joining by telephone, to arrange compensatory services in Missouri. Within 10 calendar days, the parents must give Respondents a telephone number. The parents are ordered to take part and to provide information Respondents reasonably request.
- Order to assess. A complete reading assessment, to be done in Missouri by a public school or an appropriately certified private agency, guided by the type of assessment described in the District's April 19, 2002 offer letter. Respondents reimburse the cost when given written receipts.
- Compensatory education. Five hours per week of reading and written language tutoring for one academic school year and ESY, provided in Missouri by an appropriately qualified reading and/or writing specialist. Respondents reimburse the cost when given written receipts showing the services and dates.
- Reimbursement. Reimbursement of the reasonable cost of reading intervention materials needed for the tutoring during the award period, when given written receipts.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District
People named in the decision
- Robert Roice, educational consultant representing the district and county office (non-attorney), Paradise Unified School District; Butte County Office of Education
- Frank Terstegge, director of special services, Paradise Unified School District
- Gregory Einhorn, attorney, Chico Unified School District
- Elizabeth McGie, deputy county counsel, County of Butte, for Butte County Department of Behavioral Health
- Martin Akimoto, program manager, Butte County Department of Behavioral Health
- Corin Meester, director of special education, Butte County Office of Education
- Dallis Duty, special education teacher (day treatment special day class), Marigold School day treatment program
- Angel Minto, school psychologist, Paradise Unified School District
- Ana Vicuna, mental health clinician (therapist), Butte County Department of Behavioral Health
- Scott Kennelly, clinical supervisor, day treatment program, Butte County Department of Behavioral Health
- Valerie Peck, former ED coordinator, Butte County Office of Education
- Lynette Brown, 1:1 instructional aide, Day treatment program at Marigold School
- Dana Matlin, 1:1 instructional aide (replacement)
- Dr. Susan Mallory, provider of dietary restrictions referenced in the district's offer
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Paradise, California, on May 16 and 17, 2002 (Footnote 1).
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by his parents, PARENT, and PARENT. Respondent Paradise Unified School District (Paradise) was represented by educational consultant Robert Roice (Footnote 2). Also present on behalf of Paradise was Frank Terstegge, director of special services. Respondent Chico Unified School District (Chico) was represented by attorney Gregory Einhorn(Footnote 3). Respondent Butte County Department of Behavioral Health (Behavioral Health) was represented by attorney Elizabeth McGie, deputy county counsel with the Office of County Counsel, County of Butte. Also present on behalf of Behavioral Health was Martin Akimoto, program manager for Behavioral Health. Respondent Butte County Office of Education (BCOE) was represented by educational consultant Robert Roice. Also present on behalf of BCOE was Corin Meester, Butte County’s director of special education (Footnote 4).
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Dallis Duty, special education teacher; PARENT, STUDENT’S mother, and PARENT, Jr., STUDENT’S father.
Respondent Paradise called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Angel Minto, school psychologist for Paradise, and Frank Terstegge, director of special services for Paradise. Respondent Behavioral Health called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Martin Akimoto, program manager for Behavioral Health; Ana Vicuna, a mental health clinician with Behavioral Health; and Scott Kennelly, a clinical supervisor for the day treatment program. Respondent BCOE called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Corin Meester, director of special education for BCOE, and Valerie Peck, a former ED coordinator for BCOE.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES (Footnote 5)
1. Did the Respondents provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year (ESY)?
2. Did the Respondents provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year until May 10, 2002?
3. If the Respondents denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY, and/or during the 2001-2002 school year until May 10, 2002, is he entitled to compensatory education?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
I. Motion to dismiss Chico Unified School District as a Party
Respondent Chico Unified School District made several motions to be dismissed as a party to this proceeding. The motions were denied because it was unclear throughout the hearing what Chico’s involvement was in the education of STUDENT’S (Footnote 6).
II. Motion to Dismiss Case
Respondents Paradise and Behavioral Health moved to dismiss the case in its entirety on the parties’ stipulated facts that STUDENT’S parents had disenrolled him from his school program on May 10, 2002, and had not returned him to school, and that his parents had indicated their intention to move with STUDENT permanently from California to Missouri on May 20, 2002. Respondents also argued that any remedy sought by Petitioner (compensatory education services in the form of a private school placement or services within Missouri) was not available to STUDENT as a matter of law, should the Hearing Officer find that Respondents had denied Petitioner a FAPE (Footnote 7).
The Hearing Officer orally denied the motion because at the time of the hearing, Petitioner continued to reside in California and because Petitioner was seeking a remedy for the past denial of a FAPE. Moreover, the Hearing Officer stated on the record that although Petitioner’s parents sought compensatory education in the form of unidentified private school services outside of California (in the State of Missouri), the Hearing Officer has equitable authority to fashion a remedy appropriate under the circumstances, if the Hearing Officer makes a determination that Respondents had denied Petitioner a FAPE.
CONTENTIONS
Petitioner contends that he was denied a FAPE during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years because his placement included too much counseling and not enough time for academics (in the subject areas of reading, writing, and arithmetic). Petitioner also contends that Respondents failed to implement his individualized education programs (IEPs) and failed to adhere to parental requests that he not be given foods containing sugars and dyes, and that Respondents referred to the “Golden Rule” in violation of his religious rights.
Respondents contend that Petitioner was provided with a FAPE during the relevant periods and that Petitioner’s parents are responsible for twenty-three unexcused absences during the 2000-2001 school year, thereby diminishing the effectiveness of the day treatment program during that school year. Respondents also contend that Petitioner’s parents prevented Respondents from fully implementing his day treatment program during the period October 31, 2001, until May 10, 2002, by unilaterally ending individual and family therapy, and that this interference interrupted STUDENT’S progress during the 2001-2002 school year. Respondents also contend that even if Petitioner was denied a FAPE, Petitioner is not entitled to a remedy, because Petitioner has permanently moved to the state of Missouri, and there is no legal basis or precedent for awarding compensatory education in this instance.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
Petitioner STUDENT is a nine-year-old student with an emotional disturbance (ED). He was enrolled in Paradise and attended a special day class (SDC) and day treatment program at the Marigold School in Chico, California from September 2000 through ESY and from September 2001 until May 10, 2002 (Footnote 8). The program, by agreement among the Respondents, is operated by BCOE, with mental health services provided by Behavioral Health. Chico provided only the classroom facility and lunches and did not provide educational or mental health services.
STUDENT was first found eligible for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED) while enrolled in a Paradise kindergarten class. In April and May 2000, when STUDENT was attending first grade in a Paradise elementary school, STUDENT was re-assessed by Angel Minto, the school psychologist. Referral concerns included significant and pervasive behavior and educational difficulties during kindergarten and first grade, with an increase in inappropriate behaviors during the second half of his first grade (spring 2000). (Dist. Exh. 19) The behaviors included acting out, defiance toward teachers, difficulties sustaining attention, difficulties getting along with peers, exhibiting fear in the dark (during school assemblies) and stealing. (Test. of Ms. Minto) Ms. Minto testified that she observed STUDENT in all settings and observed STUDENT being very argumentative, out of his seat frequently, and walking around the classroom.
At the time of the evaluation, STUDENT was receiving pull-out services in reading and push-in services in writing due to difficulties with fine motor skills. (Test. of Ms. Minto) STUDENT, who had been diagnosed with ADHD and had been on medication, had difficulties sustaining attention and making progress in learning. STUDENT also exhibited difficulties in a large environment setting, and many interventions had been tried. (Test. of Ms. Minto) Ms. Minto found that STUDENT continued to be a student with an ED based upon several ED criteria. Ms. Minto also found that STUDENT did not have a specific learning disability. (District Exh. 19 and Test. of Ms. Minto)
STUDENT also underwent a mental health assessment in the summer of 2000 to determine if he qualified for related mental health services. In a report dated August 14, 2000, STUDENT was found to qualify for related mental health services “as his emotional disturbance [prevented] him from benefitting from his educational services.” (Dist. Exh. 17 and Test. of Ms. Vicuna) Ms. Vicuna, STUDENT’S mental health clinician (therapist) at the Day Treatment program, testified that STUDENT and his parents visited the day treatment program at Marigold prior to his enrollment there and that STUDENT was “obviously upset - with his ears covered,” “didn’t want to be at the school site,” and refused to go outside to be shown around the school site.
On September 5, 2000, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT would be placed 100% of the school day in a special day class (SDC) five days per week, six hours per day, at the Marigold School in Chico. On page 2 of the IEP, at paragraph 17 (“How disability affects involvement and progress in general curriculum...”), the following notation is made: “Emotional problems inhibit STUDENT’S academic performance, [and] low self-esteem causes avoidance of academics. STUDENT’S low average fine-motor skills inhibit his writing performance.” (District Exh.7) The program was to be administered by a BCOE and a Behavioral Health clinician. The last page of the IEP indicates that STUDENT was to “maintain current goals and objectives in academic areas [of] reading, written language, and math.” The IEP also contains the notation “develop school adjustment goal,” and the IEP contains three goals in the following areas of need: reading, written language, and math skills.
STUDENT entered the SDC and day treatment program located at the Marigold School in September 2000. (Paradise Exh.7) STUDENT was to pursue the three goals and objectives developed by the IEP team on June 16, 2000, and adopted by the IEP team on September 5, 2000. (Paradise Exh. 8 and Test. of Mr. Duty) STUDENT continued to be noncompliant and exhibited fear-based behavior by expressing anger and acting out, or sometimes, by being withdrawn. For example, when angry, STUDENT might not sit at the table, or pick up a pencil, or perform a task requested by a teacher. (Test. of Ms. Minto). Therefore, at that time, according to Ms. Minto, STUDENT was not accessible for learning. Ms. Vicuna described STUDENT in September 2000 as “really anxious,” and stated that he “refused to listen and would cover his ears,” and “would not engage with [other] children.” STUDENT arrived with a diagnosis of bi-polar syndrome, but after making observations of STUDENT and consulting with her supervisor, Ms. Vicuna determined that his behaviors were consistent with “reactive attachment” and “ADHD” and that STUDENT as “extremely angry with female staff in our class.” (Test. of Ms. Vicuna)
STUDENT’S therapy plan within the day treatment program included the following services: pull-out once per week for one hour of individual therapy, or more as needed, to discuss issues pertinent to how he was functioning; daily group therapy; family therapy (after the school day at the school office, every other week); and milieu therapy. (Test. of Mr. Akimoto, Mr. Kennelly and Ms. Vicuna) According to Mr. Akimoto, milieu therapy consisted of general teamwork and assistance in the classroom so that a student was able to participate fully in learning. According to Ms. Vicuna, the family therapy was conducted at a school office because STUDENT’S parents did not want family therapy to occur in the family home -- the usual place for family therapy --because of privacy concerns. Mr. Akimoto described the day treatment program provided to STUDENT as “one of our most intensive programs” for students “with severe problems” who “need interventions virtually every day.” The daily in-class group therapy focused on skill building, for example, waiting for your turn, how to handle an insult, how to accept orders from someone, and how to behave on the playground. Topics in family therapy ranged from communication to parenting issues, on anxieties, conflicts, arguments and defiance and “whatever the family or child is concerned about.” (Test. of Mr. Akimoto)
According to Ms. Vicuna, STUDENT’S parents did not work well with her. For example, if STUDENT wanted to bring up an issue during the family session and his parents felt that he was being disrespectful, even though the therapist encouraged STUDENT to express himself, he was immediately stopped by his parents, or Mr. PARENT would leave the room. (Test. of Ms. Vicuna) Nevertheless, according to Respondent witnesses, STUDENT made significant behavioral progress during the 2000-2001 school year, enough to begin mainstreaming during the 2001-2002 school year, and STUDENT’S parents were asking for more general education time for STUDENT. (Dist. Exh. 16 and Test. of Ms. Vicuna and Mr. Duty)
At an IEP meeting held on September 4, 2001, to adopt STUDENT’S placement for the 2001-2002 school year, the IEP team agreed to mainstream STUDENT fifty percent of the school day (three hours of a six-hour school day) and to have an aide assigned to him to assist him academically. (Dist. Exh. 4 and Test. of Ms. Vicuna and Mr. Duty) However, STUDENT began to mainstream for two, not three, hours per day in the regular education classroom, where STUDENT was assisted by a one-to-one instructional aide, Mrs. Lynette Brown, who had served as an aide in STUDENT’S SDC during the prior year. STUDENT continued to participate four hours per day in the SDC and day treatment program. (Test. of Ms. Vicuna and Mr. Duty)
On October 29, 2001, STUDENT’S parents informed Ms. Meester that Behavioral Health staff were not to communicate with STUDENT in the classroom. (Test. of Mr. Akimoto, Ms. Meester, and Ms. Vicuna) During a meeting held on October 31, 2001 with Mr. Akimoto and Ms. Meester, STUDENT’S parents agreed to resume STUDENT’S group counseling, but did not resume individual and family therapy. On November 16, 2001, STUDENT’S parents decided that they did not want Mrs. Brown to act as STUDENT’S aide. The PARENTS believed that STUDENT was becoming too dependent upon Mrs. Brown and that Mrs. Brown was performing too much of STUDENT’S school work for him. (Test. of Ms. Vicuna and PARENTS). Mrs. Brown’s immediate replacement was Dana Matlin, a male aide. However, STUDENT apparently was not comfortable with Dana and did not “bond” with him, and after one month with Dana, STUDENT was removed from the mainstream classroom. (Test. of Ms. Vicuna) The record is unclear as to which party made the decision to remove STUDENT from the mainstream classroom.
On November 28, 2001, the IEP team met to review STUDENT’S placement within the day treatment program. Alternative placement options were reviewed. The team agreed to continue the day treatment placement and to resume daily group therapy and to provide support for academics on an “as-needed” basis by Behavioral Health. BCOE and Behavioral Health were to develop a reward system with parental input. However, STUDENT’S parents did not agree to resume individual and family therapy. (Dist. Exh. 3 and Test. of Ms. Vicuna, Ms. Peck, Ms. Minto, and Mr. Kennelly)
On December 20, 2001, the IEP team met again to review the previous IEP. The IEP team developed a positive behavioral/reward system and expressed the goal for STUDENT “to be an independent learner.” The team agreed to rotate staff to reduce dependence on one person. The team also agreed to homework assignments “in the area of reading [with] five minutes of reading each evening to begin on January 7, 2002, with a gradual increase, to include [a] sight word list.” (Dist. Exh. 2) The team also reviewed alternative placement options and options for the fall 2002-2003 and to consider restarting mainstreaming, beginning in January 2002. However, none of the parties offered any evidence to establish that mainstreaming was ever restarted.
On April 19, 2002, the director of special services for the District, Mr. Frank Terstegge, sent an offer letter to the PARENTS. Upon acceptance of the offer by STUDENT’S parents, the terms of the offer were to be to be implemented immediately. (Dist. Exh. 1 and Test. of Mr. Terstegge). The offer provided that STUDENT would continue to attend a day treatment class provided by either Chico or Paradise, with the same math and language arts goals and objectives as expressed within the September 4, 2001 IEP, and that STUDENT would resume mainstreaming into a general education classroom three (3) hours per day. The staff at the day treatment class were to follow specific dietary restrictions provided by Dr. Susan Mallory. The District also offered to conduct a “complete reading assessment” of STUDENT and, following the assessment, the District would provide appropriate reading intervention materials and training for the day treatment teacher to provide STUDENT with daily reading interventions. The District also offered to change STUDENT’S daily schedule so that STUDENT would be provided with “up to one and one half hours of reading activities daily” and that STUDENT’S parents would be provided with reports of STUDENT’S reading progress no less than on a monthly basis. The PARENTS did not accept the offer. (Dist. Exh. 1 and Test. of Mr. Terstegge) On May 10, 2002, STUDENT’S parents removed STUDENT from school. STUDENT’S parents stated on the last day of hearing, May 17, 2002, that on or about May 20, 2002, STUDENT and his parents were to move permanently to a rural area near Stockton, Missouri.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the Respondents provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY?
In accordance with the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(D); Cal. Educ. Code § 56500. A “free appropriate public education” is one which provides special education and related services to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meets the State educational standards and that conforms to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE, the proper focus is on the adequacy of the District’s placement. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District’s program reflects STUDENT’S needs, provides some benefit, and comports with the IEP, the District has offered or provided a FAPE, even if the parent or guardian prefers another program, and even if the preferred program would have resulted in a greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. 207-08; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. While the school district is required under Rowley to provide to a child with a disability a meaningful access to education, it does not require the district to guarantee success. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. The Court stated that districts are only required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley at 207-08. However, a de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some benefit.” Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d at 130 (2d Cir. 1998).
In addition, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that a child be removed from the regular education environment only when the nature or severity of the child’s disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program for STUDENT must meet the following three requirements to constitute an appropriate educational placement: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; and (3) comport with his IEP. The program must also be provided in the LRE. The Hearing Officer will now analyze the application of these requirements to determine whether the Respondents provided STUDENT with a FAPE. Petitioner did not allege procedural violations of the IDEA, and therefore the analysis within relates to the substantive appropriateness of STUDENT’S educational placement.
Was the September 5, 2000 IEP placement offer designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs?
To determine whether the IEP dated September 5, 2000, was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, the first step is to identify STUDENT’S unique needs. The parties do not dispute that in September 2000, STUDENT was a student with an ED, and that he needed the behavioral and emotional support services provided by the day treatment program. The program was operated by the BCOE and BCBH at the Marigold school in Chico, California. However, STUDENT’S parents contend that the program involved too much counseling and did not provide a sufficient amount of time for academic instruction (in the areas of reading, writing and arithmetic), and that STUDENT did not progress academically and showed very little behavioral progress. The Respondents contend that STUDENT’S emotional and behavioral issues first needed to be addressed and that the placement also offered some academic instruction.
STUDENT’S emotional and behavioral needs
It is undisputed that in September 2000, STUDENT needed a structured environment in a small class setting with therapeutic support. The evidence establishes that the day treatment program was designed to provide STUDENT with appropriate individual and group therapy, milieu therapy, and family therapy tailored to his emotional and behavioral needs. (Test. of Mr. Akimoto). The class size, with eight to ten students, also was designed to meet STUDENT’S need for a small-class setting. Moreover, both a clinician and a counselor were in the classroom for a majority of the time, and an instructional aide, Ms. Lynette Brown, was also present. Five adults, including Mr. Duty, were usually present. (Test. of Mr. Duty) Mr. Duty recalled that when STUDENT first attended his class, “for a day or two,” STUDENT “walked in with his hands held up in front of his face, cupped together like an open prayer book” [and that] “he was hiding his face.” The fact that the day treatment program did result in progress for him emotionally and behaviorally is reflected in the IEP team decision the following September to mainstream STUDENT fifty percent of the school day during the 2001-2002 school year. According to Mr. Duty, within three or four months of the start of the school year, STUDENT engaged in only occasional crying, whining or refusal. STUDENT’S acting out behaviors had been extinguished as of the spring of 2001. (Test. of Ms. Vicuna) The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Vicuna and Mr. Duty, who worked with STUDENT in the classroom, credible. Although the evidence establishes that PARENTS frequently observed STUDENT in the classroom during the 2000-2001 school year (Test. of Mr. Duty), the PARENTS did not provide testimony concerning their observations. Accordingly, the day treatment program was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique behavioral and emotional needs.
STUDENT’S academic needs
It is undisputed that STUDENT’S primary needs were behavioral and emotional in September 2000. To access learning, STUDENT’S behavior and emotions needed to be brought under control. (Test. of Ms. Minto and Mr. Duty). However, it is undisputed that STUDENT also had significant needs in the academic areas of reading, writing, and arithmetic. On the WJ-R conducted in April 2000, STUDENT’S standard score in passage comprehension was 75 (percentile of 5%), in broad reading 81 (percentile of 11%) and in broad math, 82 (percentile of 12%). Moreover, Mr. Duty’s experience with STUDENT led him to believe that STUDENT’S standard score of 92 in broad written language (percentile of 30%) seemed high to him in relation to his ability to perform in class. In contrast with STUDENT’S low achievement scores, the WISC-III intelligence test results placed STUDENT in the average range of cognitive ability. (Dist. Exh. 19)
Goals and objectives developed at an IEP meeting held on June 6, 2000 were adopted by the IEP team on September 5, 2000, for the 2000-2001 school year. In the area of reading, STUDENT was to reach, by June 2001, the following reading goal: “Using Dolch pre-primer words, STUDENT will be able to read common sight words, word families and read with fluency with 75% accuracy.” The first short-term objective, using Dolch service words (common sight words), was to read with 95% accuracy by October 2000. The second short-term objective, using Dolch pre-primer words, was to read common sight words with 70% accuracy by February 2001. (Dist. Exh. 7) In the area of written language, STUDENT was to reach, by June 2001, the following reading goal in written language: “When given a writing prompt, STUDENT will write 3 sentences with legible printing [and] spacing of words with 60% accuracy.” The following baseline was given: “STUDENT can write simple words (is, in, to, etc.) and attempts to write sentences (poor spacing of words, letter formation).” The first short-term objective, when given “priority words,” was to spell correctly with 50% accuracy by October 2000. The second short-term objective, when given priority words, was to spell correctly by February 2001 at a percentage of accuracy unidentified on the IEP. It is undisputed that STUDENT had not reached the short-term objectives or the annual goals for reading and written language as of the hearing in mid-May 2002. (Test. of Mr. Duty) In the area of math skills, STUDENT was to reach, by June 2001, a goal in addition and subtraction with 75% accuracy. Short-term objectives were established for October 2000 and February 2001 with lower percentages (50% and 60%, respectively.) Mr. Duty testified that STUDENT had achieved his math short-term objectives and math goal. The person responsible for helping STUDENT reach the three annual goals and corresponding short-term objectives, according to the IEP, was the instructional aide.
The Hearing Officer notes that the IEP did not indicate the precise amount of time STUDENT would be pursuing academic subjects. According to the testimony of STUDENT’S special education teacher, Mr. Duty, STUDENT was given academic instruction, on average, thirty minutes per day in language arts and thirty minutes per day in math. Given STUDENT’S unique needs in reading, written language, and math, the amount of time allocated for these important academic subject areas appears on its face to be insufficient for STUDENT’S academic development. It is undisputed that success in reading, writing, and arithmetic in the second and third grades serves as a foundation for future grade work. (Test. of Mr. Duty) Although STUDENT experienced initial behavioral difficulties adjusting to the day treatment program, STUDENT was “a lot more approachable” within three or four months (by December), and Mr. Duty couldn’t remember behaviors worse than refusing, with some crying and whining after that point. Mr. Duty also stated that the types of behavioral incidents within the day treatment classroom were “nothing more serious than stuff [he had] experienced in regular junior high school.” Mr. Duty described STUDENT’S initial reluctance to hold a book, noting that it “took quite awhile to get him to start reading.” The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’S reluctance to hold a book may be partially explained by his inability to read, and not necessarily to emotional difficulties (Footnote 9). Mr. Duty also noted that he felt STUDENT needed the counselor’s help in the classroom initially, but after awhile he didn’t need quite as much assistance. Mr. Duty also acknowledged in his testimony that “we can’t ignore the academics -- we give them as much as we can -- it’s a balance, up to two hours, and [that on] some days because of chaos or because of kids blowing out or dealing with serious behaviors that it may be less it may be even a lot less than that....” (emphasis added) Respondents failed to establish why after three or four months, when STUDENT was now accessible to learning, he wasn’t given more instruction, and why STUDENT was unable to reach any of the short-term objectives in reading and written language. On December 1, 2000, when an IEP team meeting was held to add a school adjustment goal called for within the September 2000 IEP, STUDENT’S reading and written language goals and objectives were rewritten as language arts goals and objectives by Mr. Duty. Mr. Duty acknowledged that he rewrote the goals and objectives because the September 2000 goals and objectives in reading and writing were not realistic (achievable). The Hearing Officer notes that Respondents did not call as a witness STUDENT’S instructional aide, Mrs. Brown, to describe her efforts as STUDENT’S aide in the areas of reading, writing and arithmetic, even though Mrs. Brown served as the instructional aide responsible for assisting STUDENT in achieving his academic goals and objectives (Footnote 10).
Respondents failed to establish that the amount of time allocated for reading and writing was sufficient to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, at least as of December 2000, when STUDENT was accessible for learning. The Hearing Officer notes Mr. Duty’s testimony that the state of California recommends “2 to 2 ½ hours per day of reading instruction,” and that Mr. Duty, in his classroom, “couldn’t give STUDENT enough instruction, even though he had become more approachable.” Respondents did not establish that the program offered for STUDENT was tailored to meet STUDENT’S unique needs in reading and written language once he had “become more approachable” after three or four months. Twenty to thirty minutes per day of reading instruction, without additional instructional services for STUDENT, was inadequate to meet STUDENT’S unique needs in reading and writing. Accordingly, in the area of reading and written language, the September 5, 2000 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs in reading and written language.
Was the offer reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?
The Hearing Officer has already found that the September 5, 2000 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique behavioral and emotional needs and that he had made progress in these areas within a few months. In light of STUDENT’S progress in those areas of need, the Hearing Officer also finds that the offer was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit in the behavioral and emotional areas. However, the Hearing Officer also determined that the offer was not designed to meet his unique needs in reading and written language. The Hearing Officer has already noted that STUDENT did not reach the goals set for him in the areas of reading and written language, even as of the time of the hearing in May 2002. A program that allocated, on average, only thirty minutes per day of reading instruction was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit, particularly as of December 2000, when STUDENT was approachable for learning. As an alternative, as the year progressed, the IEP team might have modified STUDENT’S classroom schedule to increase the amount of time allocated for reading and writing. The IEP team might have considered providing STUDENT with pull-out or push-in instructional services in reading and writing. Such services were provided to STUDENT during the previous school year when STUDENT was in a regular education classroom. (Test. of Ms. Minto)
Respondents contend that twenty-three unexcused absences during the 2000-2001 school year adversely affected STUDENT’S progress during the year. It is undisputed that for two days in September 2000, STUDENT went deer hunting with his father, and that in May 2001, STUDENT as “on vacation” for ten school days while attending a bible school in Arkansas. (Behavioral Health Exh. 6 and Test. of Mr. Duty and PARENTS). There was also testimony that STUDENT’S parents on occasion did not allow him to attend school as a discipline (days that were counted as unexcused absences). (Test. of Ms. Vicuna). The Hearing Officer finds that the unexcused absences also affected STUDENT’S ability to progress with his academic subjects, but twelve and one half hours of missed reading and written language class time (twenty-three days times 30 minutes per class), contrasted with the State’s recommendation of two to two and one half hours per day of reading (Test. of Mr. Duty), represents a significant but relatively small amount of time. The Hearing Officer finds that the weight of the credible evidence establishes that the program as designed, without even taking into consideration twenty-three unexcused absences, was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit in the area of reading and written language. The Hearing Officer will address Petitioner’s unexcused absences further, within the discussion of compensatory education
Did the Respondents’ services comport with his September 5, 2000 IEP?
Petitioner’s parents contended that Respondents failed to implement STUDENT’S IEP. Because the Hearing Officer has determined that the offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’S reading and written language needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit in reading and written language, it is not necessary to determine whether the Respondents’ services comported with his IEP. However, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner failed to establish the extent to which sugars and dyes in food were actually provided to STUDENT and how that use adversely affected his educational performance. The Hearing Officer notes a “health alert” reference on a few of Petitioner’s IEPs to a diet free from sugars and dyes. (Test. of PARENTS, Mr. Day, and Ms. Meester) The Hearing Officer therefore finds that Chico did not engage in inappropriate conduct or activity that relates to STUDENT.
Was the program provided in the Least Restrictive Environment (LRE)?
Petitioner did not contend that the placement was not in the LRE.
Because the September 5, 2000 IEP was not designed to address STUDENT’S needs in reading and written language, and because the IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit in reading and written language, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year (Footnote 11).
ISSUE NO. 2: Did the Respondents provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year until May 10, 2002?
Was the September 4, 2001 IEP placement offer designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs?
To determine whether the IEP dated September 4, 2001, was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, the first step is to identify STUDENT’S unique needs at that time. The parties do not dispute that in September 2001, STUDENT continued to be a student with an ED and continued to need behavioral and emotional support services provided by the day treatment program at the Marigold school in Chico, California. The parties also agreed at the IEP meeting on September 4 to attempt to mainstream STUDENT fifty percent of the day because he had shown behavioral and emotional progress. However, STUDENT’S parents contend that the program continued to involve too much counseling and did not provide a sufficient amount of time for academic instruction (in the areas of reading, writing, and arithmetic), and that STUDENT did not progress academically. STUDENT’S parents also contend that STUDENT continued to exhibit some of the same behaviors at home that led to his initial placement within the day treatment program. The Respondents contend that STUDENT’S emotional and behavioral issues continued to be a primary area of need for STUDENT and that mainstreaming needed to proceed gradually to determine if STUDENT could be successful within a mainstream environment. Respondents also contend that the program offered some academic instruction and that STUDENT had made some progress academically. Respondents finally contend that STUDENT’S parents’ unilateral decision to discontinue all Behavioral Health services at the end of October 2001 and their subsequent decision to resume only group therapy adversely affected STUDENT’S ability to succeed behaviorally and academically and interfered with his progress in the program.
STUDENT’S emotional and behavioral needs
It is undisputed that in September 2001, STUDENT continued to need a structured environment for part of the day, within a small-class setting, with therapeutic support. The evidence establishes that the day treatment program, at that time, for part of the day, provided STUDENT with appropriate individual and group therapy, milieu therapy, and family therapy with his family. However, the evidence also shows that STUDENT had made sufficient progress behaviorally and emotionally and that Respondents should have at that point changed their focus from behavior and emotional issues to STUDENT’S academic needs. It is undisputed that by September 2001, the acting out behaviors exhibited by STUDENT that led to his placement within the day treatment program had been extinguished by the spring of 2001. (Test. of Ms. Vicuna and Mr. Duty).
The evidence also shows that on October 29, 2001, STUDENT’S parents decided unilaterally to terminate all Behavioral Health services for STUDENT. (Test. of PARENTS, Mr. Akimoto, Ms. Vicuna, and Ms. Meester) At an IEP meeting held on November 28, 2001, to review STUDENT’S placement, alternative options were discussed. STUDENT’S parents agreed to continue with group therapy, but individual and family therapy were not resumed, and did not resume for the remainder of the school year that STUDENT was in attendance. At a review IEP meeting held on December 20, 2001, the IEP team agreed to rotate staff with STUDENT.
Accordingly, the weight of the evidence establishes that the September 4, 2001 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique emotional and behavioral needs and in fact met those needs, notwithstanding the parents’ withdrawal from individual and family therapy.
STUDENT’S academic needs
Although the Respondents contend that STUDENT’S primary needs were emotional and behavioral, STUDENT had by now achieved sufficient progress in those areas to shift the focus to STUDENT’S areas of need in reading, writing and arithmetic. STUDENT’S present levels of educational performance indicate, based upon a WJ-III achievement test conducted on August 29, 2001, that in the area of Broad Reading, STUDENT received a percentile score of 3%, in the area of Written Language, 4%, and in Math, 23%. Each of these test scores suggest, at the very least, that no improvement had occurred over the previous WJ-R test scores. A reasonable inference is that STUDENT was achieving at a lower level than during his prior testing in the spring of 2000, even though STUDENT had benefitted emotionally and behaviorally from the day treatment program during the 2000-2001 school year. The Respondents’ contention that the test was a more difficult test than the WJ-R (Test. of Ms. Minto) and that the test results could be read as progress is not persuasive. Mr. Duty’s testimony concerning STUDENT’S lack of progress in the areas of reading and written language supports the Hearing Officer’s finding that STUDENT was not given sufficient instructional time and support in those subject areas during the prior year and that STUDENT’S needs continued in these areas during the 2001-2002 school year. Mr. Duty described STUDENT’S needs in reading and written language, at the time of the hearing in mid-May 2002, as equally “critical.”
The IEP team agreed, in September 2001, upon one annual goal in math, and three annual goals in the language arts. The Hearing Officer previously found that the IEP for the prior year was not designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs in reading and written language. Given STUDENT’S more modest behavioral and emotional needs at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, the amount of time allocated for academic instruction on the IEP, three hours, appears to be adequate on its face. However, the Respondents failed to establish that STUDENT ever received this level of academic instruction. In response to a question about the accuracy of STUDENT’S description to his parents about his school day -- “counseling, Physical Education, counseling, lunch, group counseling, 15 to 20 minutes of reading, and more counseling” – Mr. Duty replied, “He’s probably pretty close, he left out math, but it’s not in that order.” Mr. Duty further testified that for both the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, STUDENT received, on average 30 minutes per day of language arts instruction (reading and writing) and 30 minutes per day of math instruction. The Respondents did not establish that STUDENT received more than one hour per day of academic instruction, even during the 2001-2002 school year, when STUDENT was to be mainstreamed. Moreover, the Respondents did not call as a witness either STUDENT’S mainstream teacher who taught STUDENT during the fall of 2001 or either of STUDENT’S instructional aides during the fall of 2001, Mrs. Lynette Brown or Dana Matlin, to establish the amount of time STUDENT actually received academic instruction while being mainstreamed and while attending the day treatment class. Because STUDENT’S emotional and behavioral needs had diminished over the prior school year, and because STUDENT’S needs in reading and written language as of September 2001 were critical, the IEP team needed to allocate more instructional time and resources to address these foundational subjects. Even as a third-grader, STUDENT could not be described as a reader. (Test.of Mr. Duty) Accordingly, the evidence establishes that the September 4, 2001 IEP offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’S academic needs in the areas of reading and written language.
Was the offer reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?
The Hearing Officer has already found that the September 4, 2001 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique behavioral and emotional needs. In light of STUDENT’S continued progress in those areas of need, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit in the emotional and behavioral areas. However, the Hearing Officer has also determined that the offer was not designed to meet his unique needs in reading and written language. The Hearing Officer again notes that STUDENT had not reached his goals in reading and written language (established during the 2000-2001 school year) at the time of the hearing in May 2002. A program that allocated, on average, just 30 minutes per day of instruction in the area of language arts and just 30 minutes per day in math, was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. The District’s director of pupil services, who attended the September 4, 2001 IEP, acknowledged the deficiencies in STUDENT’S reading program and was prepared to offer Petitioner services in that area, but did not because Petitioner’s parents had already agreed to the services offered by the Respondent members of the IEP team. (Test. of Mr. Terstegge) The District subsequently, belatedly, offered to provide STUDENT with a complete reading assessment in April 2002, and to provide additional services in that area following testing. (Dist. Exh. 1 and Test. of Mr. Terstegge) As of May 2002, STUDENT was already two grade levels behind in reading and written language, and one grade level behind in math.
Although the Respondents acknowledged that STUDENT had made sufficient progress behaviorally and emotionally as of the fall of 2001 to begin mainstreaming Petitioner, the Respondents did not offer a reading assessment during the fall of 2001 and did not offer additional reading and writing instruction in the fall of 2001 (even though the District subsequently offered up to one and one half hours per day of reading instruction in April 2002), nor did the Respondents offer one-to-one tutoring assistance in reading and writing. Moreover, Mr. Duty acknowledged that his recommendation, when he testified in mid-May 2002, was that STUDENT should be retained in the third grade in a regular education classroom, because STUDENT“needed a foundation to become a reader.” The Respondents contend that the decision by STUDENT’S parents to unilaterally stop individual and family therapy services on October 29, 2001, and to change his one-to one aide resulted in STUDENT regressing emotionally and behaviorally, thereby undermining STUDENT’S success. (Test. of Ms. Vicuna) But the Respondents did not establish that STUDENT was achieving more than de minimis progress in reading and written language, and the credible testimony of Mr. Duty indicates that STUDENT should be retained in the third grade. The Hearing Officer finds that the lack of sufficient instructional time and support in reading and written language, rather than the conduct of STUDENT’S parents relating to the cessation of individual and family counseling, is the more plausible explanation for STUDENT’S continued significant deficits in reading and written language during the 2001-2002 school year. Accordingly, the evidence shows that the September 4, 2001 IEP offer was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit in reading and written language.
Did the services provided by Respondents comport with his September 4, 2001 IEP?
In light of the Hearing Officer’s determination within that the Respondents did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE, it is unnecessary to determine whether the Respondents’ services comported with STUDENT’S September 4, 2001 IEP. However, the Hearing Officer again finds that Petitioner failed to establish the extent to which sugars and dyes in food were actually provided to STUDENT and how that use adversely affected his educational performance. As indicated above, the Hearing Officer again finds that there was no inappropriate conduct or activity by Chico that relates to STUDENT.
Was the program in the Least Restrictive Environment (LRE)?
Petitioner did not contend that the placement was not in the LRE.
Because the September 4, 2001 IEP was not designed to address STUDENT’S significant needs in reading and written language, and because the IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit in reading and written language, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year until May 10, 2002, when STUDENT was removed from school by his parents. The Hearing Officer also finds that Petitioner did not establish that the denial of FAPE was the result of inappropriate conduct or activity by Chico.
ISSUE NO. 3: If the Respondents denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY, and/or during the 2001-2002 school year until May 10, 2002, is he entitled to compensatory education (Footnote 12)?
Compensatory education is an equitable remedy to compensate a student for lost educational opportunity when the District has failed to provide the student with appropriate special education services. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1). The Ninth Circuit has held that compensatory education does not require that the student be compensated by providing a day for day replacement fo reach educational day lost. “Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief...designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Parents of Student W. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1496, 1497.
Respondents argue that because Petitioner has moved out of California permanently (to Missouri), the Hearing Office lacks authority to award compensatory education to Petitioner. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the Hearing Office is precluded from awarding compensatory education services in this instance for the following reasons: (1) The Hearing Officer has found that Respondents denied Petitioner a FAPE for two past school year periods, arising out of obligations the Respondents had to Petitioner in the past, but did not meet. Moreover, the Hearing Officer does not award Petitioner a prospective private school placement in Missouri (Footnote 13); (2) The Hearing Office has, on prior occasions, awarded compensatory education services to students denied a FAPE who have subsequently moved to other districts within California, and Respondents have not shown a logical basis for denying an award of compensatory education services (based upon a finding of a past denial of FAPE) for a student who has subsequently moved outside of California; (3) California special education law specifically provides for the funding of special education and related services within and outside of California to certified nonpublic agencies, in accordance with law; (4) Equitable considerations and fairness warrant an award of compensatory education in this case (Footnotes 14); (5) Interstate moves are common occurrences in American life and should not be the basis for a denial of compensatory education where a student has established a denial of a FAPE and has subsequently moved out of California.
The Hearing Officer has found that the Respondents denied Petitioner a FAPE in the areas of reading and written language. In determining the amount of compensatory education to be awarded, the Hearing Officer takes into account the behavior of the parties. The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner had twenty-three unexcused absences during the 2000-2001 school year. The Hearing Officer also finds that the unilateral decision to terminate all individual and family therapy reduced the effectiveness of the day treatment program for the period October 31, 2001 through May 10, 2002. Further, Petitioner’s parents removed STUDENT from class on May 10, 2002, and did not return him to class from May 10, 2002, through May 17, 2002, resulting in at least five additional unexcused absences for Petitioner.
In fashioning a remedy, the Hearing Officer must weigh all relevant facts in awarding compensatory education. The Hearing Officer first notes the credible testimony of Mr. Duty, who stated that reading and writing are “critical” areas for STUDENT, and that STUDENT is two years behind in reading and that he “is still not writing a complete sentence on his own, unless it is very, very simple.” Mr. Duty testified that STUDENT is “as far behind in written language as he is in reading” and that he “should be writing [and] printing by now” [but] “can’t always form letters.” (Footnote 15) Mr. Duty also stated that when STUDENT first began the day treatment program, STUDENT “tested on the charts” [for the WJ-R] in the first grade range, but he “hasn’t gone up since then.” Mr. Duty further stated that STUDENT can now handle a full day, and because STUDENT “hasn’t been retained, this would be a good year [for STUDENT] to be re-placed in a regular third grade classroom while a foundation is being laid...He needs to be a reader.” It is also noted that on April 19, 2002, the District offered to conduct a complete reading assessment of Petitioner by a reading specialist to find out what type of reading problem
STUDENT has and then give him potentially additional support. The support could consist of a “double dose” on a pull-out or push-in basis and “individualized reading instruction.” (Test. of Mr. Terstegge) (Footnote 16)
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer awards Petitioner a complete reading assessment to be conducted in Missouri by a public school or by an appropriately certified private agency. In making arrangements for the type of reading assessment to be conducted, the parties should be guided by the type of assessment contemplated by the District within its April 19, 2002 offer letter. The Hearing Officer also awards Petitioner five hours per week of reading and written language tutoring services for one academic school year and ESY, to be conducted in Missouri by an appropriately qualified reading and/or writing specialist (Footnote 17). The Hearing Officer also awards Petitioner reimbursement for the reasonable cost of reading intervention materials necessary for implementation of the tutoring services during the awarded tutoring period. Respondents are to reimburse Petitioner’s parents for the cost of the reading assessment, tutoring services, and reading intervention materials upon receiving documentary proof (written receipts) that identifies the services and materials provided and the date or dates of service and receipt of reading intervention materials.
ORDER
1. Within twenty (20) calendar days of the date of this Decision, the Respondents shall convene an IEP team meeting to discuss and arrange for the implementation of compensatory education services in the State of Missouri, in the form of a complete reading assessment, five hours per week of reading and written language tutoring services for one academic school year and ESY, and the reasonable cost of reading intervention materials necessary for implementation of the tutoring services. The IEP team shall enlist the participation of Petitioner’s parents in the IEP meeting by telephone conference call. Petitioner’s parents are directed, within ten (10) calendar days of the date of this Decision, to provide Respondents with a telephone number they can be reached at for participation by telephone in the IEP team meeting. Petitioner’s parents are ordered to participate in the IEP team meeting and to provide such information as the Respondents reasonably request. 2. All other claims for relief made by Petitioner are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
In accordance with California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Did the Respondents provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year? ** The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the Respondents provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year until May 10, 2002? **The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
3. If the Respondents denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY, and/or during the 2001-2002 school year until May 10, 2002, is he entitled to compensatory education? **The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal.Educ.Code § 56505(i).
Date: July 1, 2002 __________________________________________ Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The hearing initially convened on May 14, 2002, but was continued for good cause before any evidence was admitted or testimony taken.
2. Petitioner’s name was spelled “STUDENT” on the initial request for due process. However, the Hearing Officer follows the spelling “STUDENT” given on virtually all of the school and medical records in evidence, as well as on a letter and IEP addendum handwritten by Petitioner’s parents. (Pet. Exhs. 6 and 8)
3. Mr. Einhorn appeared on the first day scheduled day for hearing (May 14, 2002), and returned on the morning of the reconvened date, May 16, 2002, but did not return after arguing Chico’s third motion to be dismissed as a party and the Respondents’ motion to dismiss.
4. BCOE was added as a Respondent at the hearing on May 16, 2002, without objection.
5. The issues reflect discussions held by the Hearing Officer with the parties and are clarified to facilitate discussion.
6. Chico’s renewed motion to be dismissed as a party received after conclusion of the hearing is also denied for the same reason.
7. Respondents’ contention that STUDENT was “no longer a resident of California” was without merit because, at the time of the hearing, STUDENT and his parents continued to reside in California. Further, STUDENT’S parents indicated on the record that they would remain in California until the due process hearing had concluded.
8. STUDENT was removed on that date from school by his parents. STUDENT moved permanently with his parents to a rural area in Missouri (the nearest town is Stockton, Missouri) on or about May 20, 2002.
9. The attempt by Respondents to show that STUDENT’S reading difficulties stem from a lack of help and encouragement from his parents at home does not mean that Respondents were not required to provide adequate assistance to STUDENT in an area of need. The number of books STUDENT had at his disposal at home, contested at hearing, is also not a defense to the Respondent’s obligation under special education law to address, with appropriate instruction and assistance, an area of need. (Test. of Mr. Duty and PARENTS)
10. Mrs. Brown is listed on the District’s witness list, but Respondents did not explain why she was not called as a witness at the hearing.
11. The Hearing Officer does not address the contention by Petitioner that his religious rights were violated when the “Golden Rule” was referred to in class. Resolution of this contention does not fall within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. California Education Code §56501(a).
12. Respondents in this part refers to Paradise, Behavioral Health and BCOE. Petitioner is not awarded compensatory education services from the Chico Unified School District, because Petitioner did not establish that Chico denied Petitioner a FAPE.
13. At the time of hearing, Petitioner’s parents had not selected a private school placement or private school provider in Missouri. Petitioner’s parents were unable to provide, at hearing, any concrete evidence concerning private schools or nonpublic agencies in Missouri.
14. Although Petitioner’s parents did not seek an occupational therapy (OT) assessment, Mr. Duty also recommended an OT assessment in the area of fine motor, because “even though it is developing, it is somewhat behind [and is] holding him back.” This is consistent with a principle in equity, “where there is a wrong, there is a remedy.”
