California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 11, 2002
Student v. Dublin Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 61-02 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown
Dublin Unified need not replace a student's female one-to-one aide with a male aide; parents' claim denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a 14-year-old ninth grader at Dublin High School represented their son in a case against Dublin Unified School District. He was eligible for special education as other health impaired, based on Tourette's syndrome and Asperger's syndrome. His IEP gave him a one-to-one aide for the entire school day. In fall 2001, he lost his gym clothes twice, and his physical education teacher wrote his name on a replacement shirt. A dispute followed, and he stayed home from November 2001 until mid-January 2002. The parents asked the District to replace his female aide, Diane Normart, with a male aide. They argued that a female aide limited his social contact with peers and could not go with him into the boys' restroom. They also argued this broke the IEP's "entire school day" promise. By then, a male aide was already helping him in the locker room.
Applying Rowley, the Hearing Officer found no evidence that the student needed a male aide to benefit from his education. The arguments about gender rested on stereotypes, and the restroom concerns were speculative. The IEP team never understood "entire school day" to include the restroom. The student disliked Ms. Normart, but she could still help him move between classes, bring his materials, and do his schoolwork. The Hearing Officer criticized the District for relying partly on a union contract to keep her in the job, but denied all relief.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley to a request for a particular aide. The question was whether the student needed the change to receive educational benefit, not whether it would be better. The Hearing Officer also said a union contract does not override a district's duty to provide FAPE.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. In order for Student to receive a FAPE in the least restrictive environment, does his current one-to-one aide need to be replaced by a male aide?
No evidence showed the student needed a male aide to benefit from his education. The gender-based arguments rested on stereotypes, the restroom concerns were speculative, and the assignment matched the IEP's 'entire school day' aide term. The current aide could still do her job despite the student's dislike of her.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Petitioner's claim for relief denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.
People named in the decision
- Monica Vassis, District coordinator of special services, Dublin Unified School District
- MaryAnne Lewis, special day class teacher and former case manager, Dublin High School
- Diane Normart, special education one-to-one aide, Dublin High School
- Diana Hasenpflug, physical education teacher, Dublin High School
- Brittany Smith, resource teacher, Dublin High School
- Theresa Kalashian, resource teacher, Dublin High School
- Elaine Washington, choir teacher (apparent), Dublin High School
- Dave McCarry, instructional aide (male locker-room aide), Dublin Unified School District
- Jack Taylor, assistant superintendent; investigated district complaint, Dublin Unified School District
- Bridget Flanagan, attorney for District
- Quest camp, private therapeutic social skills camp (ESY program)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard on February 26 and 27, 2002, in Dublin, California, before Suzanne Brown, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter referred to as STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented by his parents, FATHER and MOTHER. Respondent Dublin Unified School District (hereinafter referred to as District) was represented by attorney Bridget Flanagan. Also present on the District’s behalf was Monica Vassis, District coordinator of special services.
Petitioner called MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, to testify as a witness at the hearing. The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Monica Vassis, District coordinator of special services; MaryAnne Lewis, Dublin High School special day class teacher; Diane Normart, special education aide at Dublin High School; Diana Hasenpflug, Dublin High School physical education teacher; Brittany Smith, Dublin High School resource teacher; and Theresa Kalashian, Dublin High School resource teacher.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the parties’ closing briefs, the record was closed on March 11, 2002, and the matter submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
On March 7, 2002, after the conclusion of the hearing, the Hearing Office received from Petitioner’s mother a motion to add an additional exhibit, an IEP progress report. MOTHER explained that PARENTS only received this progress report in the mail from Petitioner’s school on March 1, 2002, after the hearing had concluded, and thus could not have submitted it into evidence at the hearing. Thereafter the District replied to the motion, indicating that it did not object to the admission of the progress report into evidence. Also on March 11, MOTHER moved to add another exhibit into evidence, a copy of Petitioner’s report card covering the period of January and February 2002. The District did not object to admission of this document. Considering the lack of opposition to admission of the additional exhibits, the motion is granted and the documents are admitted into evidence. The progress report is marked as Petitioner’s Exhibit 31 and the report card is marked as Petitioner’s Exh. 32.
ISSUE(Footnote 1)
In order for STUDENT to receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE), does his current one-to-one aide need to be replaced by a male aide?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old boy who lives within the boundaries of the District with his parents and his four siblings, including a twin brother who does not share STUDENT’s disabilities. STUDENT attends ninth grade in the District’s Dublin High School. He has been diagnosed with Tourette’s syndrome and Asperger’s syndrome and is eligible for special education under the category of other health impaired (OHI). STUDENT demonstrates autistic-like behaviors such as talking aloud to himself and manifesting verbal and physical tics, including hand gestures. STUDENT also has difficulties with organization, socialization and written communication.
STUDENT has been identified as eligible for special education since he was in first grade. He first enrolled in the District as a fifth-grader in September 1997. He continued to receive special education services in the District, and for the first time had a one-to-one aide. STUDENT’s mother reported that that aide was male and that he and STUDENT got along very well. When STUDENT graduated elementary school and moved on to the District’s Wells Middle School, he initially had an aide only during his time in general education. After an incident in which STUDENT left school in the middle of the day, the individualized education program (IEP) team agreed that STUDENT would have an aide for the entire school day. (Petitioner’s Exh. 26; testimony of MOTHER.)
In April 2001, when STUDENT was in eighth grade, Diane Normart became his aide for three days a week, while another female employee served as his aide for the other two days a week. Ms. Normart reported that thereafter she accepted the District’s offer to be STUDENT’s aide when he went on to Dublin High School in the fall.
On June 5, 2001, STUDENT’s IEP team convened to plan his transition to high school in the fall. Ms. Normart attended the IEP and was introduced to FATHER and MOTHER as STUDENT’s aide. Also in attendance for portions of the meeting were some of STUDENT’s teachers for the upcoming school year, including Mary Anne Lewis, who was to be STUDENT’s case manager in high school. The IEP team members agreed that STUDENT’s program would include a combination of resource specialist program (RSP), special day classes (SDCs) and general education classes. The IEP document specified designated instructional services (DIS) of occupational therapy, behavior specialist services, social skills training and one-to-one aide support for the entire school day. The IEP team discussed and agreed upon a behavior plan that had been prepared by a clinical psychologist, and the behavior plan was attached to the IEP document.
During the IEP meeting, FATHER and MOTHER voiced their concern that STUDENT would not have an aide with him in the boys’ locker room when he changed clothes for gym class, and they feared that this would leave him vulnerable to harassment by other boys and would increase the likelihood that he would forget to lock his clothes in his gym locker. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT’s locker would be located directly in front of the coaches’ office, so that the coaches would be able to see STUDENT while he was in the locker room and could assist him if necessary. The IEP document notes this provision as “preferential PE locker location.” (Petitioner’s Exh. 2, p. 6.)
During the summer of 2001, STUDENT and his twin brother went to Quest camp, a therapeutic camp that teaches socialization skills. STUDENT has attended Quest previously, and Quest is indicated on his IEP as his extended school year (ESY) program.
In fall 2001, STUDENT began ninth grade at Dublin High School. His schedule included RSP history, SDC English, SDC math, SDC study skills, and regular education classes for physical education and choir. During the first semester, several problems occurred involving STUDENT’s gym clothes for physical education class. In late September 2001, STUDENT lost his gym t-shirt and shorts. STUDENT’s aide informed his case manager, Mary Anne Lewis, who wrote a note about the situation to STUDENT’s parents. The PARENTS replied to Ms. Lewis that it was the school’s fault for not providing STUDENT with proper supervision in the boys’ locker room, as they had requested at the June 2001 IEP meeting, and that therefore it was the school’s responsibility to replace the gym clothes. Ms. Lewis then contacted STUDENT’s physical education teacher, Diana Hasenpflug, about the lost gym clothes. Ms. Hasenpflug gave STUDENT another set of gym clothes. Again in October 2001, STUDENT lost his gym clothes. Ms. Hasenpflug obtained another set of gym clothes for STUDENT and wrote “[STUDENT’s name]” in large letters with a black marker on the t-shirt prior to giving him the new clothes.
Thereafter STUDENT wore the t-shirt to gym class without incident for a few weeks. On November 6, 2001, STUDENT did not change out of his gym clothes after gym class was over. When Ms. Normart asked STUDENT why he had not changed, he explained that he had decided to wear his gym clothes to his afternoon class because he had wrestling practice after school and would just have to change back into his gym clothes for wrestling. STUDENT went to his choir class wearing the gym t-shirt with his name written on the front. During that class period, STUDENT auditioned for a singing role and received enthusiastic applause from his classmates. (Testimony of Elaine Washington.) After choir, STUDENT went to wrestling practice. After wrestling practice, MOTHER met STUDENT at school and inquired why he was wearing a shirt with his name written on it. MOTHER reported that STUDENT told her that he was wearing it as punishment for losing his gym clothes. STUDENT also told his mother that if he lost this set of gym clothes he would receive a worse punishment, in that he would be required to change for gym in the bathroom while his aide stood outside the door.
FATHER and MOTHER felt that STUDENT was being singled out and discriminated against by being required to wear a gym shirt with his name on it. The next day, the PARENTS contacted the school about the situation. FATHER went to the high school and brought the t-shirt with him, and MOTHER wrote a written complaint letter, which was addressed to the school principal. Meanwhile, STUDENT went to school without his gym clothes that day. During his fourth period study skills class, STUDENT appeared agitated and told Ms. Lewis that he did not know what to do about gym class because his parents had confiscated his gym shirt. STUDENT mentioned that the shirt with his name on it made him feel like a freak. STUDENT, Ms. Normart and Ms. Lewis left the classroom and went into the hallway to discuss the situation. They discussed options that STUDENT could pursue, such as asking the gym teacher if he could wear a different t-shirt in gym class or wear the personalized t-shirt “inside-out.” STUDENT later reported that Ms. Lewis and Ms. Normart had “ganged up” on him in the hallway, although Ms. Lewis and Ms. Normart both denied that allegation and reported that the discussion in the hallway was calm and non-confrontational. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Normart, Ms. Lewis; Petitioner’s Exhs. 3, 4, 5; District’s Exhs. 19, 20.)
STUDENT went to gym class that day and discussed his t-shirt problem with Ms. Hasenpflug. Ms. Hasenpflug told STUDENT that, consistent with school policy, he could not wear the personalized t-shirt inside-out, but could wear a sweatshirt over the t-shirt. STUDENT participated in gym class that day and, although he was not wearing his gym shirt, he did not receive any markdown of his grade due to his gym clothing that day. (Testimony of Ms. Hasenpflug.)
MOTHER reported that after this incident STUDENT was depressed and experienced an outbreak of Tourette’s symptoms. STUDENT’s parents allowed him to remain out of school for several weeks, from November 8, 2001, until mid-January 2002. During that time period, the PARENTS requested an emergency IEP meeting and filed a complaint with the District, a compliance complaint with the California Department of Education (CDE), and a complaint with the U.S. Department of Education’s Office of Civil Rights (OCR). (Petitioner’s Exhs. 6, 8, 10, 14, 18, 21, 22, 23, 30.) District assistant superintendent Jack Taylor conducted the investigation of the District complaint and concluded that there was no discrimination or harassment against STUDENT and no interference with his educational program. The PARENTS appealed these findings to the District’s Board of Trustees investigated and upheld the findings of Dr. Taylor. (District’s Exh. 23.) Regarding the complaint to OCR, OCR declined to investigate because the matter was already being investigated by the District and CDE. (Petitioner’s Exh. 29.)
On November 30, 2001, the IEP team convened to discuss the issues surrounding STUDENT’s gym clothes, supervision in the locker room and STUDENT’s ongoing absence from school. The District offered to provide STUDENT with home teaching. The PARENTS requested that Ms. Normart be replaced with a male aide. The team did not reach agreement at this meeting.
On December 31, 2001, the CDE issued its findings regarding the PARENTS’ compliance complaint. The CDE found that the District had been out of compliance with STUDENT’s IEP dated June 5, 2001, because STUDENT did not have a one-to-one aide in the locker room, which was contrary to his IEP’s provision that he have an aide for the entire school day. The CDE report also found the District out of compliance regarding that IEP’s behavioral intervention plan, in that the District failed to provide STUDENT with assistance in organizing and storing his gym clothes, contrary to the behavior plan’s provision that STUDENT would receive assistance in leaving his learning materials in a safe place at school. The CDE ordered the District to conduct training on behavioral intervention for all District employees who interact directly with STUDENT and to provide STUDENT with aide support in the locker room. (District’s Exh. 21.)
On January 8, 2002, the IEP team again convened to discuss the disputed issues. The PARENTS repeated their request that the District replace Ms. Normart with a male aide. The District did not agree to this change, but the IEP team eventually agreed that a male aide, Dave McCarry, would be present to assist STUDENT in the locker room before and after gym class. The team reached agreement on other disputed issues, including the District’s provision of behavioral intervention training to District employees. The PARENTS indicated that STUDENT felt hostility towards Ms. Lewis; as a result Ms. Lewis agreed to terminate her role as STUDENT’s case manager, in order to facilitate STUDENT’s return to school. (Testimony of Ms. Lewis.) After resolution of disputed points, the PARENTS agreed that STUDENT would be returning to school.
Upon STUDENT’s return to school, District instructional aide Dave McCarry was available in the locker room when STUDENT had to change clothes for gym class. STUDENT has not had any reported problems with his gym clothes this semester. Ms. Normart has remained STUDENT’s aide, although STUDENT has made some negative comments about her. (Petitioner’s Exhs. 28, 29; testimony of Brittany Smith, MOTHER.) MOTHER, STUDENT’s pediatrician, and a psychologist who works with STUDENT at Quest camp all report that STUDENT continues to feel hostility towards Ms. Normart. (Petitioner’s Exhs. 28, 29.)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
In order for STUDENT to receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE), does his current one-to-one aide need to be replaced by a male aide?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); California Education Code § 56000.) Federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; California Education Code § 56000.) “FAPE” is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards, include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and that are provided at public expense and in conformity with an IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)
In determining whether the District must provide the aide services that the PARENTS are requesting, the Hearing Officer must examine the adequacy of the aide services that the District offered. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.) The U.S. Supreme Court has held that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the [IDEA] consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” (Board of Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200.) Pursuant to Rowley, the District's offer must be designed to meet the student's needs, must provide some educational benefit, and must comport with the IEP. If these requirements are met, then the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer a different program or services and even if the parents’ preferred program or services would result in greater educational benefit. (Rowley at 207-208; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist. (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.) Moreover, as long as a school district provides an appropriate education, methodology is left to the school’s discretion. (Rowley at 208.)
Additionally, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). Removal of a student from the regular education environment may occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Education Code § 56301.)
In the present case, STUDENT has Tourette’s syndrome and Asperger’s syndrome, and he manifests self-stimulatory, autistic-like behaviors. Those behaviors include talking aloud to himself and making hand gestures. In other behavioral areas, STUDENT has difficulty with organization; he will often forget his pencil, textbooks or homework. He needs frequent redirection to finish tasks or transition to new tasks. Socially, STUDENT has significant weaknesses including difficulties initiating social interactions, sustaining conversations with peers, reading nonverbal cues, and failing to consider the needs and perspectives of others. Academically, his IEP indicates that he has needs in reading, math and writing, and in particular has very poor handwriting.
One of the designated instructional services STUDENT receives to address his unique needs is a one-to-one aide throughout the school day. The aide’s functions include facilitating STUDENT’s transitions from class to class, assisting STUDENT in remembering to bring the materials he needs for each class, redirecting STUDENT when gets off-task, and assisting STUDENT with academic tasks when appropriate.(Footnote 2)
Petitioner argues that the assignment of Diane Normart as STUDENT’s aide is inconsistent with meeting STUDENT’s unique needs and allowing him to receive educational benefit. Petitioner argues that Ms. Normart cannot effectively operate as his aide because her presence creates a “hostile environment” and interferes with his ability to have social interaction with other students in the LRE. Petitioner argues that, given his difficulties with socialization, only a male employee can effectively operate as his aide because he will feel less socially limited by the presence of a male aide. Petitioner argues that having Ms. Normart as his aide is like “having his mom around him all day,” and contends that a male aide would “blend in” better with STUDENT’s peers.(Footnote 3) As support for his position, Petitioner points to his previous successful experience with having a male aide in elementary school. He argues that he was able to bond with his male aide, but has never bonded with a female aide, and has occasionally tried to run away and “ditch” his female aides.
Petitioner further contends that, in light of his physical tics, he needs a male aide so that the aide may accompany him into the boys’ restroom and prevent him from manifesting physical tics while at a urinal. Petitioner argues that, if he manifested his hand gestures and other physical tics while standing at a urinal, those gestures could be mistaken for sexual activity, potentially resulting in embarrassing rumors, school discipline or reporting to Child Protective Services. Petitioner argues that, if STUDENT was making his hand gestures in the restroom, a male aide could intervene and remind STUDENT not to make gestures.
Additionally, Petitioner argues that assignment of a female aide fails to conform to the IEP of June 5, 2001, which provides that he will have a one-to-one aide for the entire school day. Finally, based on his argument that a female aide restricts his socialization with nondisabled peers, Petitioner argues that assignment of a female aide denies him education in the LRE. Pursuant to Rowley, the issue is not whether a male aide would be better for STUDENT, but rather whether STUDENT needs a male aide in order to make progress on his goals and objectives and receive educational benefit. The Hearing Officer concludes that there is no evidence to demonstrate that STUDENT’s unique needs include an inability to work with female aides. Indeed, there is no dispute that a female cannot perform the primary tasks required of STUDENT’s aide, such as assisting him with academics, helping him transition from class to class, and reminding him to bring his books and other materials to class. Regarding socialization, the evidence did not establish that STUDENT needs a male aide in order to socialize with peers. Rather, the Hearing Officer considers that, by definition, any adult aide may potentially hinder STUDENT’s socialization with peers. While STUDENT may claim that having Ms. Normart as his aide is like having his mother around all day, it is not clear that STUDENT would feel much less constrained having a father-like individual with him at school all day.
Petitioner’s generalized contentions about feeling socially constrained by a female aide are essentially gender stereotypes; the effectiveness of an aide typically depends on that individual’s training, intelligence and other personal characteristics, not solely on that individuals’ gender. That STUDENT may not yet have bonded with the particular female aides he has worked with does not mean that he is unable to bond with any female aides whatsoever. In any event, it has not been established that STUDENT needs to bond with his aide in order for the aide to function effectively. While STUDENT needs an aide to ensure that he will arrive on time to his classes with the materials he needs for each class, there was no evidence that he needed an aide for emotional support.
Regarding the concern that STUDENT has on some occasions tried to evade and “ditch” his female aides, again this issue pertains to the individual aides involved and not to all female aides. In any event, STUDENT’s previous attempts to evade his aide’s oversight do not appear to be a significant problem. Ms. Normart testified that although STUDENT has tried to “ditch” her on a few occasions, he has since agreed that he will stay within her sight. Ms. Normart testified that, now that she stays several feet away from STUDENT during lunchtime, he no longer attempts to lose her. Regarding the argument that STUDENT needs aide support in the boys’ restroom, the evidence did not persuasively establish that STUDENT needs such assistance. No problems with STUDENT’s use of the restroom have been reported, and Petitioner’s concerns are speculative and do not rise to the level needed to show a unique need for assistance in the restroom.
The next contention to be considered is Petitioner’s argument that the assignment of a female aide fails to comport with STUDENT’s IEP of June 5, 2001. Petitioner points to that IEP’s provision that STUDENT will have a one-to-one aide “for the entire school day,” and argues that he is not receiving an aide for the entire school day because his female aide cannot accompany him into the boys’ restroom. This argument does not succeed. The IEP participants understood at the time they wrote the IEP document that STUDENT’s aide support for the school day would not include aide support in the restroom, because STUDENT’s female aide could not accompany him into the boys’ restroom. There is no indication that the PARENTS or any of the other IEP team members understood that the “entire school day” included STUDENT’s time in the bathroom, nor does a plain reading of the IEP document lead to that conclusion. Accordingly, the assignment of a female aide is in conformity with STUDENT’s June 2001 IEP.
Finally, regarding Petitioner’s argument that assignment of a female aide interferes with his ability to have social interaction with other students in the LRE, this Decision previously noted that the presence of any adult aide may tend to hinder socialization and create a more restrictive environment for the student. However, the evidence does not support Petitioner’s contention that a female aide creates a more restrictive environment than a male aide. Ms. Normart testified that she understands that the presence of an adult aide may discourage STUDENT from socializing, and attempts to mitigate that effect. Pursuant to an agreement reached among Ms. Normart, STUDENT and a school administrator, Ms. Normart does not sit next to STUDENT in the cafeteria or library; instead she keeps him within her sight but stays several feet away from him. Similarly, Ms. Washington reported that Ms. Normart no longer sits next to STUDENT during his choir class, and instead will sit a few feet away and walk over to talk to him when necessary.
In light of the factors discussed above, the evidence does not support Petitioner’s contention that a female is unable to function as STUDENT’s aide. However, a more difficult question is whether Ms. Normart in particular is able to function as STUDENT’s aide. The evidence clearly established that, ever since the hallway incident on November 7, 2001, STUDENT does not like or trust Ms. Normart, although he continues to work civilly with her. Both STUDENT’s pediatrician and a psychologist from Quest camp prepared written statements about how STUDENT has discussed with them that he dislikes Ms. Normart. Similarly, witnesses testified that they have heard STUDENT make negative comments about Ms. Normart, and that his comments were generally to the effect that he believes she “stabbed him in the back.” (Testimony of Ms. Lewis, Ms. Smith, MOTHER.)
While Petitioner argues that Ms. Normart’s presence creates a “hostile environment,” that is not the legal standard generally applicable under IDEA and Rowley.(Footnote 4) Rather, the standard is whether Ms. Normart can effectively function as STUDENT’s aide to the extent necessary to meet his unique needs and allow him to receive educational benefit. Witness testimony established that STUDENT continues to work with Ms. Normart in a cool but civil manner. (Testimony of Ms. Smith, Ms. Lewis, Ms. Normart, Ms. Kalashian.) Despite STUDENT’s negative feelings towards her, Ms. Normart is able to facilitate STUDENT’s transitions between classes, remind him to bring his materials to class, and assist him with academic work in the classroom.(Footnote 5) (Id.) While it would be preferable if STUDENT had a warmer relationship with his aide, such rapport is not required in order for STUDENT to receive the aide services he needs. As discussed previously in this decision, there is no evidence to establish that STUDENT needs an aide for emotional support.
The Hearing Officer notes that it would be better for STUDENT if he was assigned a different aide. Indeed, the District has never contended that replacement of Ms. Normart would not solve the current problem, or that STUDENT was likely to behave hostilely towards any other individual assigned to be his aide. In fact, the District’s rationale for maintaining Ms. Normart as STUDENT’s aide is of concern. District coordinator of special services Monica Vassis testified that one of the reasons the District kept Ms. Normart in her current position is that the employees’ union contract gives an employee the right to remain in a particular assignment or position. This argument is disconcerting because, regardless of the contents of contractual agreements into which the District enters, the District remains bound by the requirements of IDEA and the California Education Code. To the extent that any given employee is not able to function in his or her role providing education to a special education student, and those circumstances interfere with a student’s receipt of FAPE, the District is obligated to reassign the employee or otherwise resolve the problem and ensure that the special education student receives a FAPE consistent with State and federal law.
However, such concerns are not currently at issue because the evidence shows that Ms. Normart is able to function as STUDENT’s aide. STUDENT is able to receive from her the aide services he requires to meet his needs and allow him to receive educational benefit. Because the assignment of Ms. Normart is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, is reasonably calculated to allow him to receive educational benefit and comports with the IEP, STUDENT does not require a new aide in order to receive a FAPE in the LRE.
ORDER
Petitioner’s claim for relief is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: the District prevailed on the only issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)
DATED: April 11, 2002 ___________________________________ Suzanne B. Brown Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Consistent with discussion on the first day of hearing, the Hearing Officer has revised and condensed Petitioner’s original issue statement. The revisions do not change the substance of Petitioner’s issues. Additionally, Petitioner’s closing brief raises some allegations which were not raised at the hearing. The Hearing Office ordinarily does not consider claims raised for the first time in a closing brief. In any event, if those allegations were accurate, the remedy would not include assignment of a different aide, the only remedy which Petitioner seeks. 2. Additionally, STUDENT needs an aide to remind him about, and help him with, locking up his clothes while in the locker room. However, STUDENT now has a male aide, Dave McCarry, to help him in the locker room, and Mr. McCarry’s services are not at issue. Thus, there is no current dispute regarding aide services in the locker room, and the Hearing Officer does not consider this issue when determining whether or not STUDENT requires a male aide during the remainder of his school day. 3. Petitioner’s description of Ms. Normart appears to be at least in part because Ms. Normart’s son is the same age as STUDENT and attends the same school. 4. It is possible that, at some point, a school environment may become so hostile as to prevent the student from receiving a FAPE. On the other hand, if the student is able to receive a FAPE then the District has met its legal obligations under IDEA, whether or not the school environment is particularly hostile. 5. Petitioner points to his recent progress report and to his recent report card as evidence that he is not receiving a FAPE. (Petitioner’s Exhs. 31, 32.) The progress report indicates either “some progress” or “no progress” in each area, while the report card reflects a D- in English, a D+ in history, a C in math and a B in tutorial/study skills. However, Petitioner’s entire program is not at issue, and Petitioner has not requested any changes to his program other than a different aide. Thus, this Decision analyzes STUDENT’s receipt of FAPE only as it pertains to aide services. There has been no evidence to establish that STUDENT’s two D grades or slowed progress are causally related to his aide services, particularly given that other factors may be involved, such as STUDENT’s two-month absence from school from November 2001 to January 2002.
