California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 11, 1997

Student v. Ramona Unified School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 611-97 · Hearing Officer Keltie Jones

Ramona Unified must provide transportation, reimburse mileage, and keep blind student at Santee's Carlton Oaks for a transition year.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 5 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Footnote 1: On October 23, 1997, Santee filed a motion asking the Hearing Officer to reconsider the stay put order. The Hearing Officer did not rule on it because this decision addresses the issue it raised.

Summary

A seven-year-old second grader who is blind attended the visually impaired program at Carlton Oaks Elementary in Santee School District. She lived with her foster parents in Ramona Unified School District. Ramona offered its own visually impaired program at Miller School and refused to provide transportation to Santee. The student filed for due process, represented by an attorney. Her therapist, Julia Tirpak, and her social worker, Debra Reid, testified that she reacts strongly to change and loss and needs a gradual move. The Hearing Officer found that Miller School was not yet appropriate. Carlton Oaks is the right placement for the rest of 1997-98, with a detailed plan to move her to Miller in fall 1998. Santee argued the Hearing Officer had no power to keep her there, but the Hearing Officer disagreed. Santee had served her for over two years and must keep serving her through the transition. Ramona had never assessed her emotional needs, so its triennial assessment must cover social and emotional needs, and her IEP must add goals in that area. The foster parents had not given up transportation by driving her or by signing interdistrict transfer permits. Ramona, not Santee, must transport her and repay the foster parents' mileage at its employee rate. The student lost her claim that bus rides must be under one hour, because she had no problems on rides of up to 55 minutes.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO treated emotional needs as part of placement decisions, even for a student whose eligibility was based on blindness. It held that parents do not give up special education transportation by driving the child themselves or by signing interdistrict permit forms. It also required a serving district to stay involved during a transition.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Is Carlton Oaks the only placement that can provide STUDENT with the emotional continuity she uniquely needs to benefit from special education during the 1997-98 school year?

    Because of her emotional needs, Miller School was not yet appropriate. Carlton Oaks is the appropriate placement for the rest of 1997-98, with a detailed transition plan to Miller in fall 1998. Santee, which had served her for over two years, must keep serving her through the transition.

  2. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2. Must Ramona properly assess STUDENT's disability and recognize that STUDENT's emotional health should be factored into future placements?

    Ramona never assessed or considered the student's emotional needs even after it was told about them. The triennial assessment must cover social and emotional needs, and the IEP must include goals in that area.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Is STUDENT entitled to transportation as a required related service?

    The foster parents did not waive transportation by driving her themselves or by signing interdistrict permits. Ramona, as the district of residence, must transport her to Carlton Oaks; Santee has no transportation obligation.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Does STUDENT require reasonable transportation of one hour or less each way to and from school regardless of her placement?

    The evidence was not enough to show she needs bus rides under one hour. Opinions that she did were speculative, and she had no problems on rides of up to 55 minutes.

  5. Issue 5. Are the FOSTER PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for past transportation to and from Carlton Oaks Elementary at the prevailing rate?

    Ramona offered an inappropriate placement, so the foster parents must be reimbursed for mileage for all transportation to and from Carlton Oaks while the student has lived with them, at Ramona's employee rate.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Ramona and Santee must hold an IEP meeting with appropriate staff from both districts within 15 days of the order.
  • Placement ordered. The IEP must place the student at Carlton Oaks Elementary School in Santee for the rest of the 1997-98 school year.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP must include a detailed transition plan to prepare the student to move to Miller School in fall 1998. Therapist Julia Tirpak should be on the IEP team and help prepare the plan. If the agency paying for her therapy will not pay for this work, Ramona must pay for her time. The plan must address how the student's therapy needs will be met.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP must state that the student is entitled to transportation to and from school, including to and from Carlton Oaks, as a related service. The IEP team will decide the mode of transportation.
  • Order to assess. Ramona must conduct the triennial assessment, including the student's social and emotional needs. Those needs must be considered in placement decisions, and the IEP team must write social/emotional goals and objectives.
  • Reimbursement. Ramona must reimburse the foster parents for mileage for all actual transportation to and from Carlton Oaks, at the rate Ramona uses for its employees. No dollar amount was stated.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Student v. Huntington Beach Union High School District, SN 872-94 (distinguished); Students v. Paradise Unified School District, SN 984-96 & 985-96; Education Code § 48200; Education Code § 56320(f)

People named in the decision

  • Jeanne Taber, attorney for Student
  • Robert Roice, educational consultant representing Ramona (non-attorney), Ramona Unified School District
  • Deborah Burke, director of pupil services; witness, Ramona Unified School District
  • Carol Bartz, SELPA director, North Inland SELPA
  • Bridget Flanagan, attorney for Santee, Santee School District
  • Bill Stumbaugh, director of special education; witness, Santee School District
  • Mr. Kull, administrator at November 1996 IEP meeting, Santee School District
  • Debra Reid, social worker; witness for Student
  • Julia Tirpak, private therapist; witness for Student, therapy funded through Department of Social Services and a victims of crime program
  • Monica Moe, visually impaired program teacher at Miller School; witness for Ramona, Ramona Unified School District
  • Laurie McBride, neutral observer during trial week at Miller School; witness for Ramona
  • Craig Wood, director of transportation; witness for Santee, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on September 22 and 23 and October 13, 1997, in Ramona, California, before Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law.

The Petitioner was represented at the hearing by attorney Jeanne Taber. Also present at the hearing on Petitioner’s behalf were her foster parents, FOSTER MOTHER and FOSTER FATHER.

Respondent Ramona Unified School District (Ramona) was represented at the hearing by educational consultant Robert Roice. Also present at the hearing on Ramona’s behalf were Deborah Burke, director of pupil services, and Carol Bartz, director of the North Inland SELPA. Respondent Santee School District (Santee) was represented at the hearing by attorney Bridget Flanagan. Bill Stumbaugh, director of special education, was also present at the hearing on Santee’s behalf.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: social worker Debra Reid, therapist Julia Tirpak, FOSTER FATHER, and FOSTER MOTHER.

Ramona called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: teacher Monica Moe, neutral observer Laurie McBride, and Ms. Burke.

Santee called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Mr. Stumbaugh, and Craig Wood, director of transportation for La Mesa Spring Valley School District.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and closing arguments were presented orally at the end of the hearing. The record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.(Footnote 1)

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 2)

1. Is Carlton Oaks the only placement that can provide STUDENT with the emotional continuity she uniquely needs to benefit from special education during the 1997-98 school year?

2. Must Ramona properly assess STUDENT’s disability and recognize that STUDENT’s emotional health should be factored into future placements?

3. Is STUDENT entitled to transportation as a required related service?

4. Does STUDENT require reasonable transportation of one hour or less each way to and from school regardless of her placement?

5. Are the FOSTER PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for past transportation to and from Carlton Oaks Elementary at the prevailing rate?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner currently attends the visually impaired program at Carlton Oaks Elementary School in Santee, although she resides with her foster parents in Ramona. Petitioner contends that, although the visually impaired program at Miller School, which Ramona wants her to attend, would serve her academic needs, her emotional needs require her to remain at Carlton Oaks through this school year. Petitioner also contends that, although her foster parents agreed to transport her to Carlton Oaks in January 1996, they did not intend to waive her right to receive transportation as a related service and they are entitled to reimbursement for the transportation they provided. Petitioner asserts that any bus ride, regardless of placement, must be one hour or less each way.

Ramona originally asserted that it had offered Petitioner an appropriate placement at Miller School and that she should be required to attend there immediately. During the hearing it became apparent that Ramona agreed that STUDENT requires some sort of transition to make the move from Carlton Oaks to Miller School, but that such a transition could be accomplished either by the Thanksgiving holiday or the winter break of 1997. Ramona contends that the Petitioner’s foster parents waived the right to receive transportation to Carlton Oaks as a related service by applying for and receiving an interdistrict transfer permit allowing the Petitioner to attend a school outside her district and SELPA of residence. Ramona further contends that the bus route it has designated to transport Petitioner to Miller School is appropriate.

Santee contends that the Hearing Officer has no jurisdiction to order that Petitioner be placed at Carlton Oaks, which is outside her district and SELPA of residence. Santee further contends that it never was responsible for transporting Petitioner to Carlton Oaks, that the district in which she resides has always borne that burden.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a seven-year-old second-grader who is blind and has been diagnosed as having attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). STUDENT became blind at about six months when her biological parents shook her violently and caused retinal damage. STUDENT was hospitalized at that time, and after she left the hospital, she was placed briefly with a foster family. STUDENT then went to Arizona to live with her great-grandparents. When STUDENT was about four years old, she returned to California because her great-grandparents’ health was failing.

STUDENT was placed with a foster family in La Mesa, California, in the La Mesa-Spring Valley School District. STUDENT stayed with this family for about one-and-a-half years, during which time she started school. STUDENT attended the visually impaired (VI) program at Carlton Oaks Elementary School in Santee because La Mesa-Spring Valley did not have a VI program. Santee operates a VI program for all the districts in its SELPA, including La Mesa-Spring Valley. La Mesa-Spring Valley transported STUDENT to Carlton Oaks and back.

In January 1996, in the middle of STUDENT’s kindergarten year, a situation arose among the adults involved in her foster placement that resulted in her being placed with FOSTER PARENTS. The FOSTER PARENTS originally took STUDENT as an emergency, ninety-day placement. As soon as FOSTER MOTHER learned about the placement, she contacted Deborah Burke at Ramona to discuss how to handle STUDENT’s special education needs. During that conversation, they discussed using an interdistrict transfer permit to allow STUDENT to continue attending school in Santee. At that time, FOSTER MOTHER had not met STUDENT and did not know of all her needs, but she thought it would be best to keep STUDENT at the same school because the foster placement was only temporary. FOSTER PARENTS intended to drive STUDENT to and from school in Santee for the three-month placement. The interdistrict permit was approved on February 7, 1996.

On January 14, 1996, STUDENT moved into the FOSTER PARENTS’ home. At first, STUDENT was very unemotional and reserved. She was sad about leaving the other foster family and missed the children from that family. After living with the FOSTER PARENTS for about a week, she began to have behavior problems, such as throwing serious temper tantrums and crying incessantly. These tantrums increased significantly in February, when STUDENT’s great-grandfather died. The week he died, STUDENT was behaving so badly in school that FOSTER MOTHER was asked to take her home. The FOSTER PARENTS asked for a meeting at school to discuss how to address STUDENT’s behavior problems. Bill Stumbaugh, the director of special education for Santee, recalled that FOSTER PARENTS indicated that they would be taking care of STUDENT’s transportation. FOSTER PARENTS do not recall this conversation, but their progress notes on STUDENT indicate that the director of special education was present at that meeting.

At the end of the emergency foster placement period, STUDENT was placed with the FOSTER PARENTS on a permanent basis. For the remainder of the 1995-96 school year, FOSTER FATHER drove STUDENT to and from school in Santee. Driving through Santee and dropping off STUDENT added forty-five minutes to his daily commute. Ramona set an IEP team meeting for June 12, 1996, but canceled it because the foster parents requested that STUDENT continue to be served in Santee. (Ramona Exh. 15.) In July 1996, the FOSTER PARENTS asked for an IEP meeting with Ramona to discuss the issue of transportation. The action sheet for the IEP meeting convened on July 24, 1996, indicates that the purpose of the meeting was to review program placement options and transportation. At the meeting, Ramona asserted that it had an appropriate placement for STUDENT at Miller School and that, therefore, it would not provide transportation to Santee. FOSTER MOTHER asserted that STUDENT had emotional needs that could not be served by changing schools at that time. STUDENT’s social worker, Debra Reid, and her therapist, Julia Tirpak,(Footnote 3) attended the meeting and explained how STUDENT’s past had made her react very strongly to changes and losses. Ms. Reid and Ms. Tirpak told the team that changing schools suddenly would probably cause serious behavior problems in STUDENT, as other losses and changes had. Ramona was not convinced that STUDENT’s needs required her to remain at Carlton Oaks. The action sheet for the meeting indicates that the parents “requested a psych. evaluation from Dept. of Social Services to provide additional information to district.” Ramona did not ask permission to conduct its own psychological assessment. (Testimony of Ms. Burke, FOSTER MOTHER, Ms. Reid, Ms. Tirpak; Ramona Exh. 5.)

On July 30, 1996, Ms. Tirpak and her clinical supervisor sent a letter to Ramona describing STUDENT’s emotional needs and expressing the opinion that STUDENT should not be subjected to any more major changes at that time. Ms. Tirpak expressed concerns, which FOSTER PARENTS shared, that the proposed bus ride for STUDENT to Miller School, which she had been told was two and one-half hours, was too long for a blind child with ADHD. Ms. Tirpak stated that STUDENT should continue to attend Carlton Oaks for at least another year, at which time the possibility of changing schools with “less negative impact” could be examined. (Pet. Exh. T.)

During the summer of 1996, STUDENT attended summer school in Santee, and she returned to Carlton Oaks Elementary School in the fall pursuant to another interdistrict transfer permit granted on November 21, 1996. During this period of time, FOSTER FATHER transported STUDENT to and from school because Ramona had refused to provide transportation. STUDENT also continued to attend therapy with Ms. Tirpak in La Mesa at least once a week. County workers transported STUDENT from her after-school care to therapy and back again.

On November 22, 1996, Santee held an IEP team meeting for STUDENT. That meeting went well until Ms. Burke advised the Santee administrator, Mr. Kull, to mark “none” under transportation because the parents had agreed to transport. FOSTER PARENTS objected to this because, in their minds, the issue of transportation had not been resolved. They wanted STUDENT to receive transportation to and from Santee. FOSTER PARENTS did not sign the IEP, so Santee had a parent surrogate sign it. However, the IEP indicated that the surrogate agreed to all parts of the IEP except transportation. (Ramona Exh. 11.) FOSTER FATHER testified that they did not disagree with the academic program proposed for STUDENT in the IEP.

During the spring of 1997, STUDENT began to confront the fact that her biological parents had caused her blindness. As part of that process, she met her parents during a therapy session. According to Ms. Tirpak and FOSTER MOTHER, dealing with that issue resulted in an increase in STUDENT’s tantrums and behavior problems.

On May 16, 1997, FOSTER PARENTS requested a due process hearing, seeking continued placement at Carlton Oaks and transportation.

During the summer of 1997, STUDENT attended summer school at Carlton Oaks and a week-long residential camp for visually impaired children. She also visited her great-grandmother for a week. For each of these changes of routine, FOSTER PARENTS prepared her well in advance and emphasized that the changes would be temporary. STUDENT continued to see Ms. Tirpak through the summer.

In the fall of 1997, the FOSTER PARENTS submitted another request for an interdistrict transfer permit to Ramona. However, they were informed that the permit would not be acted on until the issue of placement was resolved by due process hearing. Nevertheless, STUDENT has been attending Carlton Oaks pursuant to the stay put provisions of the IDEA. On August 27, 1997, Ramona sent FOSTER PARENTS a letter stating that there was a new bus route that could get STUDENT to Miller School in forty-five minutes, with the return trip taking one hour and ten minutes. FOSTER PARENTS considered this to be a more reasonable bus ride than routes proposed earlier, and they proposed that STUDENT attend Miller School for one week on a trial basis with a neutral observer to record her behavior. Before the trial week began, FOSTER PARENTS prepared STUDENT for the change, emphasizing that after a week she would return to Carlton Oaks. FOSTER PARENTS testified that STUDENT showed signs of separation anxiety at home before and during the trial attendance at Miller School.

STUDENT attended Miller School from September 15 to September 19, 1997. During that week, the bus ride to school was generally fifty-five minutes long, and the bus ride home was forty-five minutes. The bus left Miller School by 2:15 p.m. every day, although the school day did not end until 2:26 p.m. The bus driver indicated that the ride home would normally be longer because one child was absent during the week STUDENT rode the bus. During her week at Miller School, STUDENT attended the VI class for three full days and was placed in a mainstream second grade class for most of the last two days. When she was in the mainstream class, she had to leave the class about fifteen minutes before the end of the school day to get her medication (Ritalin) and catch the bus. Although STUDENT’s behavior was generally good during the week at Miller school, she did have some behavior problems such as being uncooperative in class and spitting on the playground. STUDENT told people at Miller School that she liked the school, but she also frequently repeated that she would only be there for a week. (Ramona Exh. 13.) According to Ms. Tirpak, spitting was a behavior STUDENT had exhibited in the past, but she had not done it in a long time. STUDENT saw Ms. Tirpak twice during that week, on Wednesday and on Friday. Ms. Tirpak requested to see STUDENT the second time because she had seemed very anxious and disoriented during the Wednesday session.

STUDENT resumed attending Carlton Oaks after her week at Miller School. FOSTER PARENTS testified that they would like STUDENT to attend Miller School, if the bus ride could be kept below one hour. However, FOSTER PARENTS also believe that STUDENT’s emotional needs require an extensive transition before a permanent move to Miller School can be made. They are opposed to transitioning her during the fall semester because FOSTER MOTHER will be donating a kidney to her father at the end of October and will not be available to provide support to STUDENT through mid-November. FOSTER PARENTS also stated that they intend to obtain a guardianship over STUDENT so that she can have the security of knowing that she will not be removed from their home.

DISCUSSION

1. Is Carlton Oaks the only placement that can provide STUDENT with the emotional continuity she uniquely needs to benefit from special education during the 1997-98 school year?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et sq.; California Education Code §§ 56000 et seq. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1402(8), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that conform with the student’s individualized education program. “Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability ...” 20 U.S.C. § 1402(25).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” 458 U.S. 176, 200.

In this case, there is no dispute about the academic portion of the program proposed at Miller School. (Testimony of FOSTER PARENTS.) Rather, the dispute is over whether STUDENT’s emotional needs can be met by immediate placement in Miller School. Furthermore, the testimony at the hearing established that Ramona agrees that STUDENT requires some form of transition to be able to move successfully from Carlton Oaks to Miller School. (Testimony of Ms. Burke.) The dispute is, therefore, over the length of time the transition should take. Ramona has proposed either the Thanksgiving or the winter break as a good time to move STUDENT to Miller School, and FOSTER PARENTS assert that the transition should occur over the remainder of the 1997-98 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Miller School is not yet an appropriate placement for STUDENT and that the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the immediate future is Carlton Oaks Elementary School in Santee with a transition plan designed to move STUDENT to Miller School, as discussed in more detail below.

As a preliminary matter, the Hearing Officer must address Santee’s position that the Hearing Officer has no jurisdiction to find that a placement outside STUDENT’s district and SELPA of residence is the appropriate placement for her or to order that STUDENT remain in a public school operated by another district. Although, generally, it is not proper for a hearing officer to place a child in a public school that is not operated by her district of residence, this is not a situation in which parents are seeking a new placement outside their district. STUDENT has been attending a Santee school for more than two years, during most of which time she has lived in Ramona. Santee has taken responsibility for providing an appropriate placement for STUDENT by developing her IEPs and providing special education services to her. In fact, STUDENT’s most recent IEP indicated an intent on Santee’s behalf to provide services through November 1997, creating an obligation by Santee to provide a FAPE to STUDENT at least through November. The issue, then, is whether Santee must continue to provide services to STUDENT pursuant to that IEP, amended to reflect STUDENT’s need for a transition plan.

State law imposes the responsibility of education on the student’s school district of residence. Education Code § 48200. While school districts may enter into agreements with other districts to fulfill their special education responsibilities, neither federal nor state law abrogates this basic responsibility nor imposes it jointly on other school districts. As a general rule, a special education hearing officer cannot order a district to accept and serve a child that does not live within its boundaries. However, this case presents a unique situation involving an emotionally fragile child who has suffered significant abuse and loss in her short lifetime. STUDENT is not simply a student who is applying for an interdistrict transfer; she has attended Carlton Oaks for all of her school career, during which time Santee assumed the obligation of providing a FAPE to her. Santee has an obligation to provide a program that serves all of STUDENT’s unique needs. As discussed below, STUDENT’s needs, of which Santee should be aware, require that she have a formal transition plan to move her from Carlton Oaks to Miller School. Santee’s duty to provide a FAPE to STUDENT pursuant to her current IEP includes the duty to help develop and implement her transition plan. Because such a plan has not yet been developed, the IEP is deficient. Santee’s obligation to STUDENT cannot end abruptly in November 1997 under such an IEP. Therefore, in this exceptional situation, Santee is not free to end its services to STUDENT simply by denying an interdistrict transfer permit. The right of a district to deny an interdistrict transfer permit cannot override its obligation under federal special education law to provide a FAPE to a student it is already serving. Therefore, the Hearing Office has jurisdiction to order Santee to continue serving STUDENT through the term of her transition from Carlton Oaks to Miller School.

The Hearing Officer now turns to the issue of the length of time required to transition STUDENT to Miller School. The evidence at the hearing established that STUDENT has unique educational needs beyond accommodations for her visual impairment. Specifically, STUDENT has emotional needs due to her history of abuse and the many personal losses she has experienced at such a young age. STUDENT’s therapist, social worker, and foster parents consistently testified that STUDENT has a very difficult time dealing with change and loss. This difficulty manifests itself in severe temper tantrums and behavior problems, both at school and at home. STUDENT’s behavior in the past when she was facing change and loss interfered with her ability to benefit from her education to the extent that it required the school staff to develop a behavior management system. (Testimony of FOSTER MOTHER; Pet. Exh. V, W, X.)

Ramona disputed that STUDENT has a difficult time handling change, citing her ability to attend camp in the summer and to behave well during the one-week trial at Miller School. Ms. Monica Moe, the VI teacher at Miller School, expressed the opinion that STUDENT was a happy child who enjoyed changes. The Hearing Officer finds this opinion of STUDENT’s needs much less compelling than the opinions of her therapist, social worker, and foster parents. Ms. Moe observed STUDENT for only three days during a “trial run” at Miller School that STUDENT knew was temporary, while all of the others have observed STUDENT during many different situations over a long period of time. The Hearing Officer also notes that the evidence established that STUDENT’s first reaction to a new situation is usually fairly positive; it is not until she has been in the situation for a while that her emotional difficulties cause misbehavior. (Testimony of Ms. Tirpak, FOSTER PARENTS; Pet. Exh. V.) Moreover, the evidence showed some signs that STUDENT was having difficulties with the change to Miller School, even though she knew it was temporary. Specifically, STUDENT displayed unacceptable behavior on the playground (spitting, aggression) that she had not displayed for some time and was very anxious and unsettled at home and during therapy. (Testimony of Ms. Tirpak, FOSTER MOTHER; Ramona Exh. 13.) Although the anxiety and behavior problems at home did not appear to affect her ability to perform while at Miller School, the Hearing Officer is convinced that, had she spent more time at the school, she would move out of the “honeymoon” period. At that point, the evidence established that STUDENT would be likely to act out her discomfort with the sudden change and feelings of loss at school, too. Ramona asserted that the predictions that STUDENT would have difficulties changing school were purely speculative. To the contrary, these predictions are firmly based upon STUDENT’s history and her therapist’s, social worker’s and foster parents’ experience with her.

Ms. Tirpak testified that an appropriate transition program for moving STUDENT from Carlton Oaks to Miller School should provide sufficient time for STUDENT to adjust to the idea of the change, come to closure in her relationships with teachers and classmates at Carlton Oaks, and gradually begin attending Miller School. Ms. Tirpak further stated that a proper transition should occur over a period of six to nine months. Ms. Tirpak expressed concern that she may not be able to continue to see STUDENT after she moves to Miller School because it is much farther from her office than Carlton Oaks. Ms. Reid stated that STUDENT should be prepared for a change to Miller School during the remainder of this school year, but should not be moved to Miller School until the next school year. FOSTER PARENTS also stated that they believe STUDENT needs the remainder of the school year to have a proper transition to Miller School. FOSTER PARENTS are adamantly opposed to transitioning STUDENT during this fall because of the disruption STUDENT will experience while FOSTER MOTHER is incapacitated by the kidney donation surgery, which was scheduled for the end of October. Ms. Burke testified that a proper transition for STUDENT would involve the foster parents, the staff, STUDENT’s therapist, and STUDENT herself. According to Ms. Burke, once a plan is developed, there should be various points during the transition process when all those involved could examine the progress made and determine if the change could be made sooner than planned or if the transition period should be extended. Ms. Burke expressed the opinion that the beginning of January 1998 could be a good time to move STUDENT because of the natural break of the winter vacation. Ms. Burke stated that she would not want to move STUDENT right away.

The only person who testified that STUDENT could be transitioned before the end of the current school year was Ms. Burke, an administrator who has had only tangential contact with STUDENT. The professionals who are most familiar with STUDENT’s needs are in agreement that the transition period should extend through the 1997-98 school year, with STUDENT starting at Miller School full time in the fall of 1998. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the remainder of the 1997-98 school year is Carlton Oaks Elementary School in Santee.(Footnote 4) The Hearing Officer further finds that STUDENT requires a detailed transition plan that will prepare STUDENT to transfer to Miller School in fall 1998. Santee and Ramona shall participate in planning and implementing the transition plan. As Ramona has neglected the issue of STUDENT’s emotional needs, Ms. Tirpak, as the person with the most knowledge of those needs, should be included in preparing the transition plan. If the agency paying for STUDENT’s therapy sessions with Ms. Tirpak will not pay for her work on the transition plan and the IEP team, Ramona shall pay for her time. The transition plan shall also address how STUDENT’s therapy needs will be met. If STUDENT cannot continue to see Ms. Tirpak after she moves to Miller School, she should be transitioned to a therapist located closer to Miller School.

2. Must Ramona properly assess STUDENT’s disability and recognize that STUDENT’s emotional health should be factored into future placements?

School districts have a responsibility to assess special education students in all areas of suspected disability, including social and emotional status, and to design individualized special education programs to meet students’ unique needs. Education Code § 56320(f); 20 U.S.C. § 1402(25).

At the meeting in July 1996, STUDENT’s therapist and social worker informed Ramona that STUDENT had unique emotional needs that should be considered in making placement decisions. At that time, Ramona did not take STUDENT’s emotional needs into consideration and did not request the right to assess STUDENT in that area. Ramona asserts that it did not ask to assess STUDENT because the foster parents indicated they would obtain a psychological assessment through the Department of Social Services. However, STUDENT’s therapist and social worker later determined that additional psychological testing was not appropriate at that time. Therefore, STUDENT’s emotional needs were neither assessed nor considered in the determination that Miller School was the appropriate placement for her. Moreover, STUDENT’s IEP does not contain any social/emotional goals and objectives.

The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s triennial assessment is due in November 1997. The Hearing Officer finds that the triennial assessment must include an assessment of STUDENT’s social and emotional needs, and that those needs must be considered in making placement determinations. The Hearing Officer further finds that the evidence presented at the hearing established that STUDENT’s emotional needs include the need for stability and a plan to transition her from Carlton Oaks to Miller School, as discussed above.

3. Is STUDENT entitled to transportation as a required related service?

The right to receive a FAPE includes the right to receive related services, including transportation, that are necessary for a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). In this case, there is no dispute that STUDENT needs to be transported to and from school to benefit from her special education. The dispute lies in whether Ramona or Santee is required to transport her from her home in Ramona to Santee. Both Ramona and Santee claim that FOSTER PARENTS have waived STUDENT’s right to receive transportation to Carlton Oaks by their statements and actions. Ramona further asserted that it has made an appropriate placement at Miller School available to STUDENT, to which it is willing to transport STUDENT, and that there is no entitlement to transportation when a student attends a school in another district on an interdistrict transfer. Santee asserted that it has never been responsible for STUDENT’s transportation because her district of residence provided that service.

The assertion that STUDENT’s right to transportation to Carlton Oaks has been waived is based on the fact that FOSTER PARENTS agreed to transport STUDENT when she came to them in January 1996, that they have continued to transport her, and that they signed interdistrict transfer permit applications that purport to relieve both districts of responsibility for transportation. FOSTER PARENTS admit that they agreed to transport STUDENT in the beginning because they believed that the foster placement would be for no more than three months. After they agreed to keep STUDENT on a permanent basis, they contacted Ramona to request a meeting to discuss transportation. It was at the July 1996 meeting that Ramona formally refused to transport STUDENT to Carlton Oaks, and FOSTER PARENTS have been pursuing the transportation issue ever since. FOSTER MOTHER also signed the interdistrict transfer permits, which contain the following statements at the bottom of the forms:

This permit applies to the regular program only and does not include special education. Neither district shall assume responsibility for transportation of any pupil granted this permit.

(Ramona Exh. 3.) Both of FOSTER PARENTS testified that they did not believe the statement about transportation applied to special education transportation because of the statement that preceded it. The districts’ witnesses testified that the first statement means only that a student’s special education placement cannot be changed using this form only; an IEP team must act to change a special education placement.

The Hearing Officer finds that neither FOSTER PARENTS’ statements and actions, nor their signing of the interdistrict transfer permits constitutes waiver of STUDENT’s right to receive transportation to her special education placement. FOSTER PARENTS never intended to waive the right to transportation, as evidenced by their active pursuit of transportation after they learned the foster placement was permanent. Moreover, the language on the interdistrict transfer form does not constitute a waiver of the right to transportation because it states that the permit, including the restriction on transportation, does not apply to special education. The districts’ witnesses correctly stated that a special education placement cannot be altered simply by using that form. Transportation was part of STUDENT’s special education placement and, as such could not be deleted from STUDENT’s IEP without an IEP meeting and agreement of the team.

Ramona’s argument that it does not have to provide transportation to Carlton Oaks because an appropriate placement was offered at Miller School is without merit in light of the Hearing Officer’s finding that the only currently appropriate placement for STUDENT is Carlton Oaks. Ramona’s assertion that there is no entitlement to transportation when a student has an interdistrict transfer is also without merit. Ramona cited the Hearing Office decision in Student v. Huntington Beach Union High School District et al., SN 872-94, in support of this position. That case is distinguishable from the case at hand. Huntington Beach involved a written agreement between the parties that the parent would provide transportation to and from school, and the hearing officer found that the district had offered an appropriate placement within the district. Thus, it was not necessary for the student to travel out of the district to obtain a FAPE, and the district was not obligated to provide transportation to the school the parents preferred. A more applicable decision is that in Students v. Paradise Unified School District et al., SN 984-96 & 985-96, in which the hearing officer found that the students had to travel out of the district to obtain a FAPE and that, therefore, the district of residence was required to provide transportation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to the related service of transportation to and from Carlton Oaks as part of her special education placement.(Footnote 5)

With respect to Santee’s responsibility for transporting STUDENT, the evidence established that Santee has provided only the VI program for STUDENT, in the same way it provides that program to other districts within its SELPA. Santee has never borne the responsibility for transporting STUDENT, even though her right to receive transportation is noted on the IEP Santee prepared for her in November 1995. In fact, when FOSTER PARENTS sought transportation to and from Carlton Oaks, they contacted Ramona only. In the absence of any evidence that Santee assumed responsibility for STUDENT’s transportation, the Hearing Officer finds that Santee is not obligated to pay for STUDENT’s transportation. Ramona, as STUDENT’s local educational agency, has the responsibility of providing her a FAPE, which includes transportation to and from Carlton Oaks.

4. Does STUDENT require reasonable transportation of one hour or less each way to and from school regardless of her placement?

FOSTER PARENTS testified that STUDENT cannot tolerate a bus ride of more than one hour each way because of her ADHD. Ms. Tirpak also testified that she would not recommend a bus ride of more than one hour and fifteen minutes each way because a long bus ride could lead to more acting out behaviors. However, the opinions expressed about the need for a bus ride of less than one hour were based on speculations about how STUDENT would react. There was no evidence presented of STUDENT having difficulty with bus rides. The only evidence about STUDENT’s behavior on the bus was of her rides to and from Miller School. The observer did not note any behavior problems on the bus rides that lasted up to fifty-five minutes, and there is no evidence that would contradict those observations. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that there is insufficient evidence to establish that STUDENT must have a bus ride of less than one hour each way.

5. Are FOSTER PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for past transportation to and from Carlton Oaks Elementary at the prevailing rate?

In School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 105 S.Ct. 2003, the United States Supreme Court determined that when the proposed public school placement is inappropriate, parents of a student eligible for special education may be entitled to reimbursement for expenses that they incur in educating their child. In this case, Ramona proposed an inappropriate placement by insisting that STUDENT transfer immediately to Miller School without considering her emotional needs. As a result, FOSTER PARENTS were forced to incur the expense of driving STUDENT to and from Carlton Oaks. Therefore, they are entitled to reimbursement for providing that necessary related service at their own expense. Moreover, FOSTER PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for transportation provided during the entire period that STUDENT has been living with them. Agreeing to drive a special education child to school does not waive her right to receive transportation as a related service. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that FOSTER PARENTS are entitled to receive reimbursement from Ramona for mileage for all actual transportation to and from Carlton Oaks at the rate Ramona has set for reimbursing its employees.

ORDER

1. Ramona and Santee shall convene an IEP team meeting with appropriate staff from both districts within fifteen days of this order to develop an IEP for STUDENT that places STUDENT at Carlton Oaks Elementary School in Santee for the remainder of the 1997-98 school year. STUDENT’s IEP team must also develop a detailed transition plan that will prepare STUDENT to transfer to Miller School in fall 1998 and include that transition plan in her IEP. Ms. Tirpak should be a member of the IEP team and be included in preparing the transition plan. If the agency paying for STUDENT’s therapy sessions with Ms. Tirpak will not pay for her work on the transition plan and the IEP team, Ramona shall pay for her time. The transition plan shall also address how STUDENT’s therapy needs will be met, and may include transitioning STUDENT to a therapist closer to Miller School if it is concluded that she cannot continue to see Ms. Tirpak. The IEP shall indicate that STUDENT is entitled to the related service of transportation to and from school, including to and from Carlton Oaks, as part of her special education placement.

2. Ramona shall conduct STUDENT’s triennial assessment, which shall include an assessment of STUDENT’s social and emotional needs. Those needs must be considered in making placement determinations, and the IEP team must prepare social/emotional goals and objectives for STUDENT.

3. Ramona shall reimburse FOSTER PARENTS for mileage for all actual transportation of STUDENT to and from Carlton Oaks at the rate Ramona has set for reimbursing its employees.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Issue 1: Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue 2: Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue 3: Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue 4: Respondents prevailed on this issue.

Issue 5: Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

Date: November 11, 1997 Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. On October 23, 1997, the Hearing Office received a motion for reconsideration of the stay put order from Santee. All of the briefs relating to that motion were received by November 4, 1997. The Hearing Officer did not rule on the motion because the issue it raised is addressed in this decision. Preparing an order on the motion would have delayed the issuance of this decision. 2.The issues were presented by the Petitioner in a different order with slightly different wording than they are presented here. The Hearing Officer modified the order of the issues to conform to the order in which they will be discussed in this decision. In the statement of issues dated September 11, 1997, the Petitioner asserted that she needed to remain at Carlton Oaks for at least two school years, but the Petitioner agreed at the commencement of the hearing that a transition could be made to Miller School at the end of the 1997-98 school year. Petitioner also had presented issues regarding the use of a surrogate other than her foster parents and the inclusion of the proper persons on the IEP team, but indicated at the hearing that these issues had been resolved. 3.STUDENT received therapy from Ms. Tirpak through the Department of Social Services and a victims of crime program. Therapy is not part of STUDENT’s special education placement. 4.Ramona and Santee may fulfill their obligations under this order by approving the interdistrict transfer permit for STUDENT. Whether or not such a permit is granted will not change the districts’ obligation to provide STUDENT with an appropriate program. 5.The parties provided testimony and documentation regarding the expense of providing a bus to transport STUDENT to Carlton Oaks, but the Hearing Officer was not asked to rule on the appropriate mode of transporting STUDENT. In fact, the Petitioner indicated in closing arguments that FOSTER PARENTS would rather continue transporting STUDENT to Carlton Oaks, with reimbursement, than have her moved to Miller School immediately. The determination of the appropriate and most cost-effective mode of transporting STUDENT is left to the IEP team.