California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 19, 1998
Student v. Ontario-Montclair School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 618-97 · Hearing Officer JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman
Ontario-Montclair, San Bernardino County Office of Education and West End SELPA must repay and fund in-home CARD behavior program.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The student's parents filed for due process against Ontario-Montclair School District, the San Bernardino County Office of Education and the West End SELPA. Their son was seven and eligible for special education because of multiple handicaps. He had neurological damage, was legally blind and had severe language delays. He showed some behaviors linked to autism, but he had no autism diagnosis. A private psychologist recommended an intensive home program. In May 1997, the parents took him out of his special day class at Deer Canyon Elementary. They enrolled him in an in-home discrete trial program run by the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD).
The Hearing Officer found that the Deer Canyon class was the only valid written placement offer. Under Union School District v. Smith, the IEPs did not offer a TEACCH class or a Lincoln School class, because neither named a specific class and the TEACCH mention was only an invitation to visit. The Deer Canyon class did not address his behavior or attention problems. He also got no educational benefit there in 1996-97. The Hearing Officer rejected the claims that CARD used banned aversives and that he was too old or "not autistic" for the program. The respondents had to repay CARD costs from June 2, 1997 and fund CARD through the 1997-98 school year and extended school year. They also had to provide a 1:1 aide trained by CARD and choose a new special day class. Then he would move back to class gradually while his home hours dropped from 40 to 20 per week.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Union v. Smith: an invitation to visit a class, or a class described only in testimony, was not a formal placement offer. It also shows a Hearing Officer refusing to accept a low IQ score as the reason for years of unmet goals. Intensive behavior services were ordered based on the student's needs, not an autism label.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Have Respondents offered Petitioner an appropriate placement from May 1997 through the 1997-98 school year?
The only valid written offer was the Deer Canyon multiple-handicap class. The TEACCH and Lincoln School classes were never formally offered under Union. The Deer Canyon class did not meet the student's behavior and attention needs and had given him no educational benefit.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. If Respondents have not offered an appropriate placement, is Petitioner entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the costs and related expenses of his private placement in the CARD program from June 2, 1997 to the date of decision?
The in-home CARD program was proper under IDEA. Respondents did not prove that the techniques used were prohibited aversives, so they must reimburse CARD costs, including supervision, consultation and workshop training.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Do Petitioner's unique needs require that Respondents provide him prospectively with an intensive in-home behavior intervention program through CARD for the 1997-98 school year?
The student's needs, not an autism label or his age, controlled. Respondents must fund CARD through the 1997-98 school year and ESY, with a gradual return to a new special day class supported by a CARD-trained 1:1 aide.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receiving proof, reimburse the parents for the costs and all related expenses of the CARD program, including supervision, consultation and workshop training, from June 2, 1997 through the date of the decision. No dollar amount stated.
- Prospective funding of private placement. Fund the CARD in-home program from the day after the decision through the 1997-98 school year, including the extended school year. The program must include daily data collection and recording, four hours per month of supervision, consultation, and additional therapist training.
- Order to provide or change services. Provide or contract for a 1:1 classroom aide, trained and supervised by CARD, who preferably already knows and has worked with the student in the CARD program. The aide continues after the transition, and the IEP team may later fade the aide if appropriate.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the order, convene an IEP meeting that includes the student's CARD clinical supervisor. The IEP must cover the remainder of 1997-98 and ESY and include the CARD program, the 1:1 aide, the special day class and the transition plan.
- Placement ordered. The IEP team must select an appropriate special day class other than the Deer Canyon class. The class must address language, socialization and peer interaction, offer a developmentally appropriate curriculum, accommodate his visual impairments, provide positive behavior intervention, and be compatible with the CARD program.
- Order to provide or change services. Transition plan: begin with three half-days per week in the special day class and increase to full time if appropriate. Gradually reduce in-home CARD hours from 40 to 20 per week. After the transition, continue 20 hours per week of in-home CARD services.
- Staff training. CARD must train the in-home therapists and the 1:1 classroom aide in general behavior modification techniques and proper implementation of discrete trial training.
Key authorities
Union School Dist. v. Smith; Rowley; Burlington School Comm. v. Mass. Dept. of Ed.; Landgraf v. USI Film Products; 5 CCR 3001(d), 3052(l) (Hughes Bill); Ed. Code 56001(i); Ed. Code 56031
People named in the decision
- Diane Boydell, special education teacher, Deer Canyon special day class, Deer Canyon Elementary School
- Sue Andrews, school principal; administrative representative at May 1997 IEP, Ontario-Montclair School District
- Dr. Mitchel Perlman, private clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student
- Jennifer Hutchison, clinic supervisor; witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, psychologist and clinical director; expert witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), private in-home behavior intervention provider
- Pamela Fuentes, special education teacher; witness for Respondents
- Carol Hubbard, language, speech and hearing specialist; witness for Respondents
- Melanie Jernigan, adaptive physical education specialist; witness for Respondents
- Madelain Willman, special education kindergarten teacher, Monte Vista Elementary; witness for Respondents
- Sharon Bolle, area director; witness for Respondents, San Bernardino County Office of Education
- Dr. Terry Tibbetts, SELPA program manager; representative and witness for Respondents, West End SELPA
- Dr. Frank Gresham, psychologist, UC Riverside professor of school psychology; expert witness for Respondents
- Jeri Roth, school principal; witness for Respondents
- Dr. Todd Eachus, educational psychologist and behavior analyst who observed the home program; witness for Respondents, Tobinworld (program director)
- Dr. Bryna Siegel, developmental psychologist; expert witness for Respondents, Langley Porter Psychiatric Institute
- Debra Cockrell, director of pupil personnel services, Ontario-Montclair School District
- Jeanne Davis, SELPA administrator, West End SELPA
- Peggy McDonald, specialist for the visually impaired program (triennial vision assessment)
- Debra Jahnke, language, speech and hearing specialist (triennial assessment)
- Bonnie Bewley, school psychologist (triennial psychoeducational assessment)
- Christy Coyne, attorney observer for Student, Lewis & Lewis
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Rancho Cucamonga, California, on September 3, 4, 5 and October 28 and 29, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Shelli J. Lewis of Lewis & Lewis, and attorney Christy Coyne of the same law firm observed for a portion of the hearing. STUDENT's parents, PARENTS, were also present on his behalf. All three Respondents, Ontario-Montclair School District (District), San Bernardino County Office of Education (COE), and the West End Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA), were represented by Dr. Terry Tibbetts, program manager for the SELPA. Debra Cockrell, director of pupil personnel services for the District, Jeanne Davis, administrator of the SELPA, and Sharon Bolle, area director for the COE, were also present during the hearing on behalf of the respective Respondents.
Petitioner presented seven witnesses: Diane Boydell, special education teacher; PARENT; PARENT; Sue Andrews, school principal; Dr. Mitchell Perlman, private psychologist; Jennifer Hutchison, clinic supervisor at the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD); and Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, psychologist and clinical director of CARD. Respondents called ten witnesses: Pamela Fuentes, special education teacher; Carol Hubbard, language, speech and hearing specialist; Melanie Jernigan, adaptive physical education specialist; Madelain Willman, special education teacher; Ms. Bolle; Dr. Tibbetts; Dr. Frank Gresham, psychologist and professor of school psychology at University of California-Riverside; Jeri Roth, school principal; Dr. Todd Eachus, educational psychologist; and Dr. Bryna Siegel, developmental psychologist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Have Respondents offered Petitioner an appropriate placement from May 1997 through the 1997-98 school year?(Footnote 1)
2. If Respondents have not offered an appropriate placement, is Petitioner entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the costs and related expenses of his private placement in the CARD program from June 2, 1997 to the date of decision?
3. Do Petitioner's unique needs require that Respondents provide him prospectively with an intensive in-home behavior intervention program through CARD for the 1997-98 school year?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Petitioner's request for due process hearing was received by the Hearing Office on May 13, 1997.
On the last day of hearing, October 29, 1997, Petitioner withdrew an issue regarding denial of FAPE during the 1995-96 school year, and limited the issues for hearing to those stated above.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seven year-old boy who qualifies for special education due to multiple handicaps. He was diagnosed with hydrocephalus at birth due to a congenital blood disease which had caused numerous intracranial hemorrhages. STUDENT has had multiple shunts, which are currently non-functioning. As a result of neurological damage, STUDENT has optic nerve atrophy and cortical visual loss and is legally blind. He has problems with visual acuity and focusing on objects in the lower quadrant of his vision. STUDENT has had epileptic seizures in the past, but these are currently controlled with medication. He has also been found to have motor impairment consistent with a form of cerebral palsy. Because of the neurological damage he has suffered, STUDENT has experienced developmental delays in all areas, with particular difficulty in language acquisition and fine motor skills.
On March 25 1991, when he was approximately five months old, STUDENT was found eligible for special education services under the criteria of "other health impairment." He began to receive early intervention services for one hour per week in the Family Infant program through the Regional Center. In November 1991, STUDENT's handicapping condition was changed by the IEP team to "orthopedically handicapped" and he continued in the Family Infant program. From October 1991 through November 1992, STUDENT also received privately funded physical therapy twice a week for sensory integration. At age two, STUDENT participated in a toddler program at Margarita School in the District. The program provided services to STUDENT twice a week for a total of three hours.
In November 1993, when STUDENT turned three years old, the IEP team recommended that he transition to the COE preschool class for children with multiple handicaps at Del Norte Elementary School due to his age. The team noted that "all goals need to be continued since most were only partially met or not met at all."(Footnote 2) (Resp. Exh. 8.) In March 1994, STUDENT began attending half-day sessions, five days per week, at the preschool special day class at Del Norte. He also received speech and language services for 20 minutes twice a week, and adaptive physical education for 30 minutes twice weekly.
At STUDENT's annual IEP meeting on November 21, 1994, the team noted that he had made "significant progress especially in the area of speech and language as well as gross motor skills," but was still functioning at the two- to three-year-old level in the areas of self-help, social adaption, and prevocational skills. (Resp. Exh. 10.) However, according to STUDENT's mother, his language remained very limited and consisted of words and sounds which were intelligible only to his family. He also was not toilet-trained and did not use utensils to eat. PARENT was concerned about STUDENT's special day class for several reasons, including class size, safety, and the potential for STUDENT's language difficulties to result in his needs being overlooked or misinterpreted. She took the November 21 IEP form home to review, and eventually signed the document on December 5, 1994.
During the summer 1995 extended year program, STUDENT was bitten near his eye by another student in his class.(Footnote 3) STUDENT also had his first epileptic seizure on July 3, 1995, and was placed on medication (Tegretol) to control future seizure activity. For these reasons, PARENT removed STUDENT from the special day class until the fall semester.
In the fall of 1995, STUDENT transitioned from preschool to a kindergarten class for children with multiple handicaps at Monte Vista Elementary School. STUDENT had a new teacher, Madelain Willman, but his attendance schedule of four hours per day, five days per week, remained unchanged. STUDENT also continued to receive speech and language services and adaptive physical education on the same schedule as was established in preschool. On December 14, 1995, annual IEP goals and objectives were prepared, but the IEP team meeting did not occur until January 22, 1996. The IEP team noted that STUDENT was making "slow but steady progress," and recommended that his triennial assessment, which would normally be due in November 1996, occur in late spring 1996. PARENT was not satisfied with STUDENT's progress and had requested that the triennial assessment be performed early to assist the IEP team in determining proper placement for STUDENT in the 1996-97 school year. She also requested that STUDENT have a 1:1 aide in Ms. Willman's class, but the IEP team recommended a peer tutor instead.
In April and May 1996, at age five and one-half, STUDENT was assessed for his triennial review in the areas of visual functioning, speech and language, gross motor skills, classroom performance and overall psychoeducational functioning. Peggy McDonald, specialist for the visually impaired program, noted several visual difficulties which affected STUDENT's educational performance and made eight recommendations to assist the classroom teacher in addressing those problems. Ms. McDonald concluded that STUDENT "showed delays in all [visual] areas, ranking between the 2 and 3 year old level." (Pet. Exh. 4.) As a result of Ms. McDonald's testing, in April 1996, STUDENT's program was changed by the IEP team to add visually impaired itinerant services one time per week for 30 minutes.
In her written triennial evaluation, the language, speech and hearing specialist, Debra Jahnke, concluded that STUDENT continued to qualify for speech and language services as he had a significant deficit in all three areas of language development--semantics (word meaning and word relationships), morphology/syntax (grammar usage and sentence structure), and pragmatics (social/functional use of language). Ms. Jahnke also commented that STUDENT's functional use of language was limited to "labeling/commenting, saying bye-bye.'" (Pet. Exh. 5.)
School psychologist Bonnie Bewley completed the psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT on May 8, 1996, and concluded that his functioning was more typical of a child two or three years of age than a five-year-old. In her written report, Ms. Bewley estimated STUDENT's intellectual functioning to be within the mild to moderate range of retardation, based on the Leiter International Performance Scale, a non-verbal test of intelligence. (Footnote4) From the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, Communication section, Ms. Bewley noted that STUDENT had significant delays in both expressive and receptive language skills relative to his age. Ms. Bewley recommended that STUDENT continue in a special day class emphasizing language, social, adaptive/self-help, and pre-academic/prevocational skill development.
STUDENT's kindergarten classroom teacher, Ms. Willman, stated in her written report for the triennial assessment that he was "difficult to assess." She indicated that STUDENT "needs to explore materials in a variety of ways which are not functional in the teaching environment." (Pet. Exh. 8.) Ms. Willman noted that STUDENT had made progress on some of his IEP objectives and that he was increasing his skills in independent play, work and self-help. Ms. Willman stated that STUDENT also had problems staying on task but could be re-directed, and that STUDENT's progress was commensurate with his ability.
At an IEP team meeting held on June 5, 1996, the triennial evaluations were reviewed. The team noted that STUDENT would qualify for a full day in fall 1996 and would enroll at that time in a special day class for primary-aged children with multiple handicaps. STUDENT's parents considered two special day classes, and selected Diane Boydell's class at Deer Canyon Elementary School for the 1996-97 school year, as STUDENT appeared to be too low functioning for the other class. STUDENT's parents declined the extended school year program during the summer of 1996 because STUDENT was still not toilet-trained. PARENT worked at home with STUDENT over the summer, and he was toilet-trained by fall 1996.
In September 1996, STUDENT changed schools and entered the primary special day class taught by Ms. Boydell at Deer Canyon. At the beginning of that school year, PARENT sent a supply of Tegretol to Ms. Boydell, along with consent forms, to provide the school with seizure medication for STUDENT in the event of an emergency. Although the medication was meant only for emergency use, Ms. Boydell gave STUDENT 100 mg of Tegretol every day, by mistake, until the entire supply was depleted within about one month. STUDENT was also receiving his regular dose of Tegretol at home on a daily basis during this time. Although STUDENT suffered no permanent physical damage from the classroom "overdose," the incident affected the parent-teacher relationship between Ms. Boydell and the PARENTS through the remainder of the school year. (Testimony of Ms. Boydell,
PARENT.)
Due to their concerns regarding the special day class placement, the PARENTS sought an independent psychological assessment of STUDENT in January 1997. Clinical psychologist Dr. Mitchel Perlman performed that assessment, relying upon STUDENT's medical and academic records, interviews with STUDENT's parents and teachers, and observations of STUDENT's performance in class and therapy at school. No standardized psychological tests were administered because Dr. Perlman considered STUDENT "untestable." Dr. Perlman stated in his report that, although STUDENT did not have autism, "he demonstrates many behaviors within that spectrum." Dr. Perlman identified several behaviors that STUDENT displayed in class which, Dr. Perlman believed, hindered, and even precluded, STUDENT's learning. Dr. Perlman recommended that STUDENT be removed from his current special day class and placed in a 40 hour per week intensive 1:1 in-home training program to primarily address these behaviors.
As a result of Dr. Perlman's recommendation, the PARENTS contacted the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), and STUDENT was evaluated for their services on April 8, 1997, by Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, psychologist and clinical director of CARD. Dr. Granpeesheh concluded that STUDENT exhibited "a variety of impairments and behaviors which fall within the spectrum of Autism." She recommended that STUDENT receive 1:1 intensive behavior modification therapy through discrete trial training of 40 hours per week, with four hours per month of clinical supervision and consultation.
On May 8, 1997, the IEP team met and reviewed the prior year's goals and objectives. STUDENT's parents presented Dr. Perlman's report and recommendations and requested that the District provide the 40 hour per week intensive in-home behavior intervention program through CARD. At this point, the administrative representative, Sue Andrews, ended the meeting because she believed the parents' request for CARD services had to be considered by SELPA staff before the IEP team could proceed further. Proposed goals for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year were handed out but not discussed or finalized by the team. Ms. Andrews stated that the placement offer was for STUDENT to continue in Ms. Boydell's class. Ms. Andrews also offered to let the parents visit the new TEACCH classroom.(Footnote 5) The PARENTS declined both offers, and submitted a dissent to the IEP in which they re-stated their request that the District fund the proposed CARD program for STUDENT. The PARENTS accepted the District's offer of Designated Instruction and Services (DIS) (i.e. speech and language therapy two times per week for 20 minutes each, itinerant vision services two times per week for 20 minutes each, and adaptive physical education two times per week for 30 minutes). (Pet. Exh. 14.) However, these services were not implemented after the May 1997 IEP for unknown reasons.
After the May 8 IEP team meeting, STUDENT stopped attending his special day class at Deer Canyon. In late May, CARD provided a two-day training for the STUDENT's family and STUDENT's therapists regarding discrete trial training and behavior modification principles. On June 2, 1997, STUDENT began the in-home intensive behavior intervention program with private therapists supervised by CARD. Initially, he received 27 to 35 hours per week of discrete trial training, but this schedule was reduced to approximately 10 hours per week at the time of hearing due to the family's financial constraints. (Testimony of PARENT.)
On July 23, 1997, CARD supervisor Jennifer Hutchison reviewed STUDENT's progress for his first two months of services. Ms. Hutchison reported that STUDENT had made "incredible gains," that his behavior was significantly improved and his learning of new skills was proceeding at a rapid rate. The frequency of STUDENT's spontaneous speech had dramatically changed, with his utterances increased to three to four word sentences. (Pet. Exh. 28.)
On July 31, 1997, as a result of agreements reached by the parties at the June 29 mediation, educational psychologist Dr. Todd Eachus observed STUDENT's in-home program. Dr. Eachus later prepared a written report of his observations and recommendations in which he noted "no problematic behavior" or "nonfunctional routines" during the time of the observation. Dr. Eachus expressed concern that no data were being collected by the CARD-trained therapists to support their narrative findings or suggested training objectives for STUDENT. Dr. Eachus recommended that STUDENT be placed back in a public school setting to afford him the social interaction with peers that was missing from his in-home program. (Resp. Exh. 27.)
On August 22, 1997, the IEP team met to develop goals and objectives for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year and to discuss placement. No change in the District's placement offer resulted from this meeting.
PARENT noted dramatic improvement in STUDENT during his three months in the CARD program before hearing. She stated his self-stimulatory behavior was reduced, he was rapidly learning drills, and his jumping and hand-clapping was decreased. STUDENT was able to say "yes" and "no," and had stopped his outbursts. He also was interacting with his brother and sister, rather than engaging only in parallel play. STUDENT's spontaneous language included full sentences, such as "I want to go potty," or "I want to go out and play," and he had begun commenting on the world around him.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District has not provided or offered him a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) because the special day class for multi-handicapped children at Deer Canyon Elementary School is not designed to meet his unique needs. Petitioner claims that his failure to make progress toward his IEP goals and objectives during the past year in Ms. Boydell's class indicates that the placement is not appropriate. Petitioner contends that the TEACCH class was never offered by the District as a placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year.
Petitioner asserts that his unique needs require 1:1 instruction in an in-home, intensive behavior intervention format as provided by CARD, and requests that such services be ordered for him prospectively. Petitioner also contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for his CARD in-home program because the District has failed to offer him a FAPE.
Respondents contend that they have provided Petitioner an appropriate educational program in the least restrictive environment in Ms. Boydell's special day class for multi-handicapped students during the 1996-97 school year. Respondents assert that their offer to continue this placement into the 1997-98 school year is appropriate. Respondents state that they have offered two alternative placements to Petitioner which are also appropriate--i.e. the TEACCH program and a special day class for severely handicapped students at Lincoln School.
Respondents claim that the CARD program is not appropriate for STUDENT because he is not autistic; at age seven, he is already too old for discrete trial training and the Lovaas approach; and, the in-home program is too restrictive. Respondents argue also that the CARD program may not be ordered by the Hearing Officer, as a matter of law, because CARD allows the use of aversives with STUDENT, which are prohibited under state regulations. Finally, Respondent contends that Petitioner is not entitled to be reimbursed for the CARD program costs and related expenses.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Have Respondents offered Petitioner an appropriate placement from May 1997 through the 1997-98 school year? (Footnote 6)
Respondents contend that they have offered STUDENT three placements for the 1997-98 school--the Deer Canyon special day class for children with multiple handicaps, a special day class using the TEACCH program, and a special day class at Lincoln School for children with severe handicaps. (Resp. Closing Brief, pg. 27.) Respondents also claim that these offers satisfy the requirements of the Union case because they were made in writing by the IEP teams in the May 8 and August 22 IEPs. (Union School District v. Smith (9th cir. 1994) 15 F3d 1519.) Petitioner contends that only one offer of placement has been made for the 1997-98 school year, namely, the District's offer to continue STUDENT in the Deer Canyon special day class. The evidence supports Petitioner's position.
The case of Union School District v. Smith, supra, requires that school districts make a formal written offer of placement to the parents of disabled children in special education. The offer must also be specific so as to comply with federal law and put the parents on notice regarding the district's plans for their child. (Union, supra, at 1526.)
In the May 8 IEP, the team states: "The county IEP team members feel that we have an appropriate placement with goals and objectives. The new TEACCH classrooms were described with an offer for parents to visit these new classes with CARD affiliation through SELPA." Elsewhere on the IEP form, the team indicates that the "Site within SELPA" will be "Deer Canyon or other TEACCH/county classroom." (Resp. Exh. 21.) This IEP contains no further reference to the proposed placement for STUDENT, except in the parents' dissent, which states: "The parents do not believe the current placement is appropriate for STUDENT, nor are the current offers of placement presented at this meeting for placement appropriate." (Pet. Exh. 14.)
The August 22 IEP indicates that the 1997-98 placement for STUDENT is "to be mediated," and that the "previous IEP placement remains in effect." (Resp. Exh. 26.) No specific offer of placement is included, nor is there any reference to the TEACCH program or Lincoln School, which Respondents contend were offered earlier.
These two IEP documents clearly show that Respondents made no formal written offer to place STUDENT at the Lincoln School special day class for severely handicapped children as required by Union. Respondents provided some testimony concerning the potential benefits of this placement. However, testimony at hearing does not satisfy the legal requirements of Union, and cannot substitute for a formal written offer of placement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Lincoln School special day class for severely handicapped children was not offered to Petitioner as a formal written offer of placement for the 1997-98 school year. Because no formal written offer was made, the Hearing Officer will not further consider the Lincoln School class.
As for the TEACCH program offer, the written IEP and the testimony at hearing indicate that no specific placement offer was made. The written IEP refers to TEACCH classrooms but makes no mention of a specific, identifiable class which is being offered to STUDENT for placement. Further, in the written summary of the May 8 IEP meeting, the team offers to allow the parents to visit the new TEACCH classrooms, but again makes no specific placement offer. An offer to visit is very different from an offer to place the student in a program determined to be appropriate for him. Sue Andrews, administrative representative at the meeting, testified that she did not feel a TEACCH class was appropriate for STUDENT because the District did not believe that he was autistic. Ms. Andrews testified that the appropriate class for STUDENT was the class he was in or some other class for children with multiple handicaps. Ms. Andrews stated that she offered to physically show the class to the PARENTS after reading Dr. Perlman's report, which referred to STUDENT's autistic-like behavior. This testimony was unrefuted, and, coming from district staff present at the IEP team meeting, was particularly credible.
Thus, based on the IEPs and testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents did not offer a specific TEACCH class as a placement for STUDENT in the May 8 IEP. The absence of a specific, formal offer of placement violates the requirements of Union. The Hearing Officer also finds that Respondents' offer of the TEACCH program consisted of an offer to visit the program, not an offer of placement. The Hearing Officer concludes that Respondents' offer to continue STUDENT's placement in the Deer Canyon special day class was the only legally sufficient placement offer made by Respondents. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will consider only the Deer Canyon special day class placement in determining whether STUDENT has been offered a FAPE.
Under state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free, appropriate public education. (Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8)(A)-(D), Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56000, et seq.)(Footnote 7) The term "free and appropriate public education" means special education and related services that -- have been provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without charge; meet the standards of the State educational agency; include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education in the State involved; and are provided in conformity with the individualized education program required under Sec. 614(d)."(Footnote 8) (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8)(A)-(D).) Special education means specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability...." (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(25); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56031.)
The U.S. Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services which must be provided to a disabled student under the IDEA in Hendrick Hudson Central School District Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176. The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services, or that the services maximize each child's potential. Rather, "the basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. (Id. at 200.)
The right to a free and appropriate education also includes the right to educational services in the least restrictive environment (20 U.S.C. 1412(5)(A); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56031.) This means that, to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities must be educated with children without disabilities. (34 C.F.R. 300.550.) Special classes, separate schooling or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment can occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (34 C.F.R. 300.550(b)(2).)
Thus, under the IDEA, Rowley, and state law, an appropriate educational placement must include instruction and services which (1) are designed to meet the unique needs of the student, (2) provide educational benefit, (3) conform to the student's IEP, and (4) are provided in the least restrictive environment.
STUDENT's unique needs
As a child with multiple handicaps, STUDENT has many needs which must be addressed in an educational setting. Six expert witnesses testified about STUDENT's needs. The Hearing Officer will review the expert testimony presented by both Petitioner and Respondents before summarizing conclusions regarding STUDENT's unique needs.
Petitioner's experts
Dr. Mitchel Perlman performed a psychodiagnostic evaluation of STUDENT in late January and early February 1997.(Footnote 9) Based on observations at school, interviews with STUDENT's teachers and parents, and a review of educational and medical records, Dr. Perlman concluded that STUDENT's classroom behaviors were a barrier to learning and had to be addressed before STUDENT could progress. Dr. Perlman observed STUDENT to have severe attention difficulties, need for self-stimulation, need to chew objects, inability to perform any task independently, need for order where everything must be closed and/or put away, need to approach tasks on his terms, withdrawal and/or refusal to engage with others, and low tolerance for frustration. (Pet. Exh. 11.)
STUDENT's ability to attend was "profoundly limited" in all settings--whether in class with seven other children, in speech therapy one to one with a therapist and one other child present, in adaptive physical education, or on the playground during recess. (Testimony of Dr. Perlman.) Dr. Perlman also noted that STUDENT had a related difficulty with perseveration, and was often unable to pull away from an activity. In addition, STUDENT displayed sensory confusion, including tactile and auditory defensiveness, which made it difficult for him to transition from one surface to another (e.g. from carpet to tile).
STUDENT's language was essentially nonexistent, and he said only one word spontaneously ("OK") during Dr. Perlman's entire three-hour observation at school. (Testimony of Dr. Perlman.) Dr. Perlman testified that STUDENT accomplished nothing on the day of observation and that STUDENT's classroom teacher, Ms. Boydell, stated that this day was "typical." The teacher added that STUDENT was the lowest functioning student in her class and that, even if he had assistance from a one to one aide, his performance would not change. (Testimony of Dr. Perlman.)
Dr. Perlman did not attempt to determine STUDENT's mental capacity or cognitive ability because STUDENT's severe attention difficulties would interfere with testing. (Testimony of Dr. Perlman.) Dr. Perlman testified that the District psychologist who completed the 1996 triennial assessment of STUDENT noted in her report that the IQ of 41 and mental age of two to three years were both estimates of STUDENT's ability and, thus, may not be reliable. According to Dr. Perlman, STUDENT will have "discontinuous learning" due to his neurological impairment. Dr. Perlman did not conclude that STUDENT was autistic, but that he displayed features associated with autism.
Based on his observation, Dr. Perlman concluded that, even with a student- teacher ratio of 8:2 or 8:4 in the special day class, STUDENT was not learning from modeling the behavior of other children, nor from direct instruction. Additionally, because STUDENT is older and has vision difficulties, it is more critical that he receive an intensive program to address his behavior and learning needs. (Testimony of Dr. Perlman.) Therefore, Dr. Perlman testified that STUDENT needs a 40 hour per week in-home intensive program to make him "available to learn." Dr. Perlman recommended that such a program be provided for six months and then re-assessed to determine the appropriate next steps.
Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh evaluated STUDENT on April 8, 1997 to determine whether he could benefit from CARD services.(Footnote 10) Dr. Granpeesheh noted that STUDENT exhibited several maladaptive behaviors, including non-compliance (four to ten times per day); tantrumming (up to two times per day for five to fifteen minutes) with screaming, crying, throwing objects, slamming doors, and pinching or pushing siblings; and self-stimulatory behavior such as hand-flapping, gazing, whining and echolalic speech, repetitive opening and closing of doors, turning lights off and on, and tapping objects to make a noise. In his social interactions, STUDENT did not make eye contact, had failed to develop peer relationships, and lacked social reciprocity. STUDENT's communication skills were described as "very delayed" in both the receptive and expressive domains. Dr. Granpeesheh recommended that STUDENT receive 1:1 intensive behavior modification therapy with discrete trial training 40 hours per week "to bring his communication and social skills up to an age-appropriate level." (Pet. Exh. 12.)
In her testimony, Dr. Granpeesheh stated that STUDENT needs to continue developing language and communication skills, to socialize and develop play with peers, and to learn how to attend and focus. Dr. Granpeesheh recommended that STUDENT be assessed in January 1998 and transitioned back to a school setting once his behavior is under control. She also testified that STUDENT's transition back to the classroom should be gradual, over several months, to ensure success. She recommended that STUDENT return to three half days in class with a 1:1 aide and continue the in-home program for 20 to 25 hours per week, with four hours per month of clinical supervision. Dr. Granpeesheh recommended that this blended program continue over the next two years.
Respondents' experts
Dr. Bryna Siegel testified that she reviewed STUDENT's records, including the CARD logs, Dr. Perlman's report and Dr. Eachus' report.(Footnote 11) She did not observe STUDENT in the in-home program or visit the proposed Deer Canyon placement. She testified that STUDENT clearly has problems with attention and needs a "structured teaching environment" to address these problems. Dr. Siegel stated several times that a 1:1 aide would likely be beneficial to help STUDENT transition back to the classroom.According to Dr. Siegel, a "very individualized" special day class would be appropriate for STUDENT because he would have more social and interactional opportunities. A class for children with multiple handicaps has the potential to address STUDENT's sensory and behavior problems, and either a communicatively handicapped or learning handicapped class might also be appropriate. Dr. Siegel also stated that STUDENT needs the chance to use language in a small group context. He needs a curriculum which is at the proper developmental level and provided in developmental sequence. She stated that STUDENT's visual impairments need to be addressed in his classroom setting. Whether a particular class would be appropriate for STUDENT depends on several factors, including the type of students in that class, and the teacher's experience with visually impaired students. Dr. Siegel testified that further assessment of STUDENT would be helpful to determine if he is a visual learner.
Dr. Siegel stated her opinion that a diagnosis of autism could be ruled out for STUDENT. A 35-hour-per-week program is not the most appropriate for STUDENT because it is too restrictive. Dr. Siegel expressed concern about STUDENT's CARD program because no baseline data were provided, making it difficult to determine his progress. Dr. Siegel also stated that no research study has been done to evaluate the impact of an intensive behavior intervention program initiated when the child is older than three years.
Dr. Todd Eachus was selected by the parties to observe STUDENT's in-home CARD program.(Footnote 12) He testified that this was his primary role and he was not in a position to recommend one program over another. Dr. Eachus stated that he reviewed STUDENT's school records, Dr. Perlman's report, and the CARD therapy logs before performing the three-hour observation on July 31, 1997. Dr. Eachus also visited STUDENT's proposed placement at Deer Canyon School on two occasions after STUDENT was no longer attending the class.
Dr. Eachus testified that STUDENT's 35-hour-per-week in-home program was "unduly restrictive" because of the absence of socialization, peer interaction and opportunities for STUDENT to generalize his learning and improve his language fluency. Dr. Eachus saw nothing in STUDENT's behavior which would prevent him from benefitting from a public education setting. He stated that STUDENT has made "remarkable progress," but will continue to have limitations which will likely affect his ability to conceptualize and problem solve. Dr. Eachus testified that he saw no interfering behavior by STUDENT, such as tantrums or aggression, and saw no use of "drill sergeant" (overcorrection) or time-out procedures during his observation. Dr. Eachus also stated that data collection by STUDENT's therapists should be done during the drills, and that the therapists need more training.
Two other experts testified on behalf of Respondents, namely, Dr. Frank Gresham and Dr. Terry Tibbetts. However, their testimony concerning STUDENT's needs was quite limited. Both witnesses testified more extensively regarding Dr. Perlman's report, whether STUDENT is autistic, and whether certain behavior techniques used by CARD are aversive. Also, neither Dr. Gresham nor Dr. Tibbetts had ever seen STUDENT or performed a direct assessment of him. Nevertheless, in general, these two witnesses seemed to agree that STUDENT needs to have more social and peer interaction, and that he needs to develop his language skills. Dr. Gresham testified that STUDENT needs to learn social skills with behavior support. Dr. Tibbetts also supported this view, and testified that STUDENT needs positive behavior intervention and more structure, but not 1:1 assistance. Dr. Tibbetts did not explain why he believed 1:1 assistance was inappropriate or unnecessary for STUDENT. Both witnesses believed that STUDENT should continue in a special day class.
Of the experts who testified, the Hearing Officer found the testimony of Drs. Perlman, Granpeesheh and Siegel to be the most persuasive. Dr. Perlman was the only one to observe STUDENT's performance in the Deer Canyon special day class which is the proposed placement. Although Dr. Perlman's observations were roundly criticized by Respondents' experts for lack of specificity and failure to follow a functional analysis assessment format, per the Hughes Bill, the Hearing Officer found Dr. Perlman's comments to be credible and adequately detailed to provide a valuable picture of STUDENT's experience in his special day class. Respondents' witnesses were apparently unaware that Dr. Perlman was not asked by the parents to assess STUDENT for a behavior intervention plan, but simply to evaluate his placement. (Pet. Exh. 11.) Even if Dr. Perlman's observations were somewhat inartfully expressed, many were corroborated by the testimony of STUDENT's teacher, Ms. Boydell, and his DIS specialists. For example, Ms. Boydell testified that STUDENT chewed his chair, clothes and the computer cord, and that when there was free time in class STUDENT required much re-direction. Further, at the time of her evaluation, Dr. Granpeesheh also noted many of the same maladaptive behaviors which Dr. Perlman had observed in class.
Dr. Granpeesheh evaluated STUDENT in April 1997, and has supervised his CARD program for several months. She also has extensive clinical experience in treating disabled children, like STUDENT, who have behaviors that are barriers to learning. Respondent suggests that Dr. Granpeesheh has a pecuniary interest which affects her credibility in this case because she is the director of CARD, which is STUDENT's service provider. However, the Hearing Officer did not find this contention to be borne out by the evidence. Dr. Granpeesheh stated that CARD has a lengthy waiting list for services and does not continue a child in the program if no progress is being made. Thus, although Dr. Granpeesheh has a theoretical or general financial interest as clinical director of CARD, there was no evidence that she needs to continue serving this particular child for financial reasons or that a pecuniary interest as the director of CARD has affected her testimony.
Dr. Siegel also has extensive experience in evaluating severely disabled children and has had many opportunities to review intensive behavior intervention programs. She specializes in the area of early childhood development and has trained child psychiatry residents and performed empirical research in the field of autism. Dr. Siegel has testified on behalf of both districts and parents in due process hearings. The Hearing Officer found Dr. Siegel persuasive in this case because she qualified and explained her responses, often noting where information was lacking or further assessment was necessary.
Thus, based on the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a program which will effectively address his maladaptive behaviors and ongoing attention difficulties through positive behavior intervention so that he can focus on learning. He needs to develop both receptive and expressive language, to generalize his language and learning, and to develop functional language skills. STUDENT also clearly needs opportunities for socialization and peer interaction. His visual impairments must be addressed to ensure that his visual acuity and lower quadrant vision problems, as well as his difficulty moving between varied floor surfaces, are accommodated. STUDENT needs a curriculum at the appropriate developmental level which progresses sequentially as recommended by Dr. Siegel.
The special day class proposed for STUDENT is Ms. Boydell's class for children with multiple handicaps at Deer Canyon School. No evidence was presented to indicate that any changes had been made in that class for the 1997-98 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will consider whether that class is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs based on evidence about the class format from 1996-97.
Ms. Boydell testified that the class had eight and sometimes ten students with one teacher and one aide. The class was six hours long and included small group time and individual time for Ms. Boydell and her aide to work with each student. The class schedule included the following activities in approximately half-hour increments: snack and circle time; individual time with the teacher or looking at books; recess; individual time with the teacher or playing with toys; story time; music, rhythm, and singing; lunch and lunch recess; outdoor activities; and video-watching time while the teacher and aide conferred. (Testimony of Ms. Boydell.)
Staff efforts to handle STUDENT's maladaptive behaviors in class apparently consisted primarily of redirection. There was no evidence of specific positive behavior interventions designed to handle STUDENT's unique attention difficulties. Ms. Boydell testified that STUDENT was noncompliant and would "roam the room" when not given a specific assignment, although she believed this behavior had more to do with finding something to do than with compliance. She also stated that STUDENT could "make the computer do things," but that his activities on the computer were not always appropriate.
STUDENT's mother testified that she visited his special day class for an entire day after the medication incident in the fall of 1996. From this and subsequent visits, it was apparent to PARENT that STUDENT's teacher did not know how to handle his behaviors. (Testimony of PARENT.) STUDENT was noncompliant, self-stimulated by looking at books repeatedly, chewed his clothes and desk, and self-stimulated at the computer by clicking the mouse and listening to the screen humming. None of these behaviors was addressed in class. (Testimony of PARENT.) STUDENT's teacher asked PARENT, "What do you do with him at home all day?" PARENT concluded that the special day class staff did not know how to engage STUDENT or help him focus and attend. PARENT also testified that she did not observe any academic activity or 1:1 work with STUDENT during her visit.
Dr. Perlman's testimony concerning STUDENT's behavior in class corroborated many of the observations of both STUDENT's mother and his teacher regarding STUDENT's lack of attentiveness and non-compliant behavior. For example, Dr. Perlman found that STUDENT "gravitated toward low repetitive sounds and clicks" and often self-stimulated on noises from the computer, losing focus on the task at hand. (Pet. Exh. 11.)
Ms. Boydell testified that she worked on some speech and language goals in class with STUDENT but that she was not directly responsible for these goals. No specifics were provided as to the nature of Ms. Boydell's individual or group work with STUDENT on language goals or, for that matter, any other IEP goals and objectives.
Concerning STUDENT's peer interactions, Ms. Boydell testified that STUDENT played with two other children during the year. One child was a classmate who acted like "a little mother" to him. (Testimony of Ms. Boydell.) The other was an older child from a regular education class who taught STUDENT how to ride a tricycle. Dr. Perlman did not observe any peer interaction on the day of his classroom visit in late January or early February 1997. (Testimony of Dr. Perlman.) In fact, he noted that STUDENT did not engage with anyone, and failed to show connection by looking at people even when he was being talked to. Dr. Perlman testified that STUDENT behaved as though other people did not exist. Dr. Perlman observed no staff efforts to address STUDENT's lack of socialization and interaction.
Ms. Boydell testified that she knew STUDENT had a vision problem, but did not notice any problems with his vision which required change in the classroom. She stated that she did not work on STUDENT's vision goals in the IEP.
No information was presented concerning the curriculum used with STUDENT or the curriculum used overall in class. Ms. Boydell testified that STUDENT was the lowest functioning child in her class and that she thought it would be "helpful" if he were in a more restrictive environment. Dr. Perlman also testified that, during his observation, both STUDENT's teacher and the classroom aide emphatically stated that STUDENT did not belong in that particular special day class.
Based on the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the Deer Canyon special day class for multi-handicapped students is not designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs. The evidence indicates that STUDENT's maladaptive behavior and ongoing attention difficulties are not adequately addressed so as to allow him to focus and learn. STUDENT's other needs, as noted above, cannot even begin to be addressed if his behaviors and attending skills are not appropriate for a classroom setting and have not been successfully managed in that setting.
Educational benefit
To determine whether STUDENT will receive educational benefit in the Deer Canyon special day class during 1997-98, the Hearing Officer will review the record concerning STUDENT's performance during 1996-97 in that class. The testimony and other evidence indicate that STUDENT received negligible educational benefit in the Deer Canyon class during the 1996-97 school year. Most of STUDENT's IEP goals and short-term objectives for the classroom in the areas of preacademic/ readiness skills, social/behavioral, speech and language, and self-help were not met or only partially met during 1996-97. (Pet. Exh. 9.) Further, STUDENT had been working on many of these goals for several years, because they were established in prior IEPs and continued year to year with only minor changes. (Pet. Exhs. 1-6, 8; Resp. Exh. 4, 5, 8, 10; testimony of PARENT.)
PARENT testified that she expressed concern during the May 1997 IEP team meeting that STUDENT's progress in class was not what it should be. She stated that, in settings where he worked 1:1, such as occupational therapy, STUDENT was able to consistently meet his goals and objectives, and show improvement. However, in the educational setting at school, STUDENT did not consistently meet his IEP goals and objectives, and had not met them for three years. (Testimony of
PARENT.)
Ms. Boydell testified that, at the beginning of the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT was using one- or two-word responses in his speech. At the end of the year, he could say his first name and was working on the concept of "yes" and "no," but Ms. Boydell did not know if he understood the meaning of these two words. STUDENT had no concept of number quantities, did not know any letters and could not read. (Pet. Exh. 23.) Ms. Boydell testified that STUDENT learned to ride his tricycle that year with the help of his older friend. She characterized his progress as "slow but steady" and "appropriate for his IQ." (Pet. Exh. 22.)
Several of Respondents' witnesses echoed Ms. Boydell's assessment of STUDENT's progress, apparently relying heavily on his estimated IQ of 41 to explain his repeated failure to master even the simplest IEP goals. With this testimony, Respondents, in effect, concede that STUDENT made little progress in Ms. Boydell's class, and that he failed to benefit from his educational program. Respondents attempt to justify this lack of benefit by suggesting that STUDENT's low IQ meant that he was not able to benefit. However, the Hearing Officer finds that this position is not credible, particularly considering STUDENT's significant gains in the CARD in-home program over the course of a few months during the summer of 1997. The evidence also showed that STUDENT made "good gains" in his private occupational therapy program during 1996-97, where he received 1:1 attention. (Pet. Exh. 15.) In addition, as the testimony of at least two witnesses (i.e. Dr. Perlman and Dr. Granpeesheh) and the evaluation of the school psychologist indicate, STUDENT's abilities may not yet be fully known. (Resp. Exh. 15.)
Therefore, based on the evidence above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT received no educational benefit during the 1996-97 school year in the Deer Canyon special day class. The Hearing Officer further finds that this class will not provide STUDENT with educational benefit during the 1997-98 school year.
Conforms with the IEP; least restrictive environment
Analysis of these requirements is not necessary because the Hearing Officer has already found that Respondents' placement offer of the Deer Canyon special day class for multi-handicapped students is not designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs and will not provide him with educational benefit.
In sum, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Deer Canyon special day class for multi-handicapped children is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year. The class is not designed to address STUDENT's unique and individual needs, and will not provide him with educational benefit based on his experience and performance during the 1996-97 school year.
Issue No. 2: If Respondents have not offered an appropriate placement, is Petitioner entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the costs and related ex- penses of his private placement in the CARD program from June 2, 1997 to the date of decision?
In Burlington School Comm. v. Mass. Dept. of Ed. (1983) 471 U.S. 359, the U.S. Supreme Court held that parents of disabled children may receive retroactive reimbursement for the tuition and related expenses of unilaterally placing their child in a private special education program. Such reimbursement is an appropriate remedy where the school district has failed to offer the child a FAPE and the private placement is determined to be proper under the Act. (Burlington, supra, at 369-370.)
Here, the Hearing Officer has determined that Respondents' placement offer for the 1997-98 school year is not appropriate and will not offer STUDENT a FAPE for reasons noted above. Shortly after this placement offer was made at the May 1997 IEP team meeting, STUDENT was withdrawn from the Deer Canyon special day class and placed by his parents in a private program operated by CARD. STUDENT began his in-home intensive behavior intervention therapy through CARD on June 2, 1997, although workshop training for his therapists and family was provided before that date.
The CARD program provides intensive 1:1 behavior intervention which addresses both deficits in learning and excesses which prevent learning. (Testimony of Ms. Hutchison.) The program provides a series of discrete trials or drills which progress step-by-step according to the student's individual needs and are continually evaluated and modified as mastery is achieved. Discrete trials are intended to develop a range of skills, such as expressive and receptive language, self-help, fine and gross motor, and attention and behavioral skills. (Testimony of Ms. Hutchison.)
The purpose of STUDENT's participation in the CARD program was to provide 40 hours per week of 1:1 discrete trial training "to bring his communication and social skills up to an age-appropriate level." From the evidence presented, it is clear to the Hearing Officer that STUDENT had made significant progress at the time of hearing in both of these areas.
According to the testimony of STUDENT's mother, his clinical supervisor, Ms. Hutchison, and Dr. Granpeesheh, after just a few months in the CARD program, STUDENT's negative behaviors had been greatly reduced and he had made notable progress in several areas. STUDENT's mother testified that she had seen dramatic improvement because STUDENT's self-stimulation was reduced, his jumping and hand-clapping had decreased, and he had no more outbursts. She also stated that STUDENT was learning rapidly through the drills, and that he was speaking spontaneously in full sentences and commenting on things around him. PARENT testified that STUDENT was interacting with his brother and sister rather than engaging only in parallel play as before. She stated that he was also generalizing his learning and not just performing during therapy.
Ms. Hutchison stated that she evaluated STUDENT's progress after learning of Dr. Tibbett's concerns about the program in late July. She testified that STUDENT was experiencing a "rapid rate of acquisition" of skills, and that he was generalizing. She testified that STUDENT's behaviors had also improved and his aggressive behavior and jumping were nearly extinguished. STUDENT was speaking in full sentences, identifying objects, and using "I want" statements. He was also participating more in family activities and was more social. (Testimony of Ms. Hutchison; Pet. Exh. 28.)
Dr. Eachus reported that, during his observation, STUDENT achieved 60% to 80% accuracy on the seventeen tasks which he performed. Dr. Eachus found that some skills were "well established" in STUDENT's repertoire and others appeared not to have been established at all, such as identifying a color from among two or three other colors. Dr. Eachus reported the therapists' observation that STUDENT's social skills had improved. Dr. Eachus observed no problem behaviors or "nonfunctional routines" during his three-hour observation. (Resp. Exh. 27.)
Respondent contends that the CARD program uses improper aversives in its behavior modification program with STUDENT, and cites to sections of STUDENT's CARD therapy log to support this contention. The three claimed aversives include, "drill sergeant" or overcorrection, time-out, and use of noxious substances, i.e. lemon juice to stop STUDENT from spitting and "blowing raspberries." (Pet. Exh. 21., Resp. Closing Brief, pgs. 33-36.) This last procedure, use of noxious substances, was never actually undertaken, but only mentioned as a possibility by one therapist. (Testimony of Dr. Granpeesheh, PARENT.) The other two appear to be mild techniques which were not designed, or likely to, cause STUDENT pain, physical discomfort, trauma, or other prohibited reactions. (See 5 CCR Secs. 3001(d), 3052(l).) Dr. Eachus testified that he saw no use of overcorrection or time-out during his observation. Further, Dr. Granpeesheh specifically testified that these techniques were used by CARD for distraction and positive outcomes, and that aversives were expressly prohibited under CARD policies. (See Resp. Exh. 53.) She stated that the techniques were not aversive for STUDENT because they have succeeded in modifying his behavior, and he has progressed in the program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents have failed to establish that the drill sergeant and time-out techniques were aversives prohibited under state law, or that these techniques were in any way aversive for STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's in-home intensive behavior intervention program through CARD is proper under the IDEA. Respondents must reimburse Petitioner for the costs and related expenses, including supervision, consultation, and workshop training, of STUDENT's placement in the CARD program from June 2, 1997 to the date of this decision.
Issue No. 3: Do Petitioner's unique needs require that Respondents provide him prospectively with an intensive in-home behavior intervention program through CARD for the 1997-98 school year?
The Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT's unique needs require a program which will effectively address his maladaptive behaviors and ongoing attention difficulties through positive behavior intervention so he can focus and learn. STUDENT also needs a program which will remediate his severe language delays. In Issue No. 2 above, the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT's current CARD in-home intensive behavior intervention program has successfully addressed his maladaptive behaviors and has helped him develop and generalize language. The program has also helped STUDENT improve his social skills within his family, and is designed to meet his individual needs by developing skills in other areas such as self-help, and fine and gross motor skills. (Testimony of PARENT, Ms. Hutchison.)
Respondents' claim that STUDENT's CARD program may not be ordered prospectively for several reasons, namely that: (1) CARD improperly allows the use of aversives, in violation of state law and regulation; (2) STUDENT is not autistic and is older, such that a Lovaas-type program is not appropriate for him; (3) the CARD program successes cannot be effectively measured because there are no baseline data, and data collection during discrete trials are nonexistent; (4) the therapists are inadequately trained and supervised; and (5) the in-home program is too restrictive because it does not provide socialization and peer interaction. The Hearing Officer will review each of these points below.
Concerning the use of aversives, the Hearing Officer has already discussed Respondents' contentions above, and found that the two techniques used were not proven to be aversive under state law. Respondents' contention that STUDENT should not be in the CARD program because he is not autistic was repeatedly and unnecessarily a focus of Respondents' case. A child's label or diagnosis is not the driving force for determining his program under the IDEA. His individual and unique needs are. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56031; Hendrick Hudson Central School District Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176.) In fact, the California Legislature has expressed its intent that special education programs avoid the unnecessary use of labels in providing services. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56001(i).) In STUDENT's case, the testimony from CARD personnel, as well as STUDENT's parents, indicated that his label was not and is not important in determining whether he could benefit from CARD services. A student need not be labeled autistic and need not be under a certain age to receive CARD services. (Testimony of Dr. Granpeesheh, Ms. Hutchison.) The fact that research studies have shown greater success where the Lovaas approach is implemented with a child of preschool age does not preclude STUDENT from being successful in the program at the age of seven years. Indeed, preliminary results from just three months in the program indicate that STUDENT is progressing well.
Dr. Granpeesheh testified that baseline data were provided by STUDENT's parents at the time of intake, and any goals and objectives which STUDENT had achieved during previous classroom activities would not be part of his initial CARD program. As for the need for data collection, Dr. Granpeesheh stated that trial-by-trial data recording is not always necessary, and that STUDENT's log books contain the minimal necessary information to track his progress. Dr. Eachus recommended that STUDENT's academic and behavioral progress be assessed "on the basis of data taken daily." (Resp. Exh. 27.) The need for additional training and supervision for STUDENT's therapists was not disputed by Dr. Granpeesheh or Petitioner. Dr. Granpeesheh recommended at least four hours per month of supervision, and further training for STUDENT's therapists in the areas of general behavior modification techniques, implementation of discrete trials, and ethics.
Finally, several of Respondents' witnesses testified that STUDENT's CARD program is too restrictive because it does not provide the socialization available in a school setting. However, this testimony appears somewhat academic considering STUDENT's inability to interact with other children due to his many maladaptive behaviors presented in the classroom setting. Until those maladaptive behaviors are effectively managed and extinguished, STUDENT cannot move forward in his learning. Further, both Dr. Granpeesheh and Dr. Perlman recommended that STUDENT be returned to a school setting as soon as possible, and, in any event, that he return once his maladaptive behaviors are under control. The evidence presented on the last day of hearing indicated that STUDENT's maladaptive behaviors were effectively under control at that time. (Testimony of PARENT.)
Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's unique needs require that he continue in an intensive, in-home behavior intervention program through CARD for the remainder of the 1997-98 school year, including the extended school year. However, STUDENT's hours in the CARD program must be reduced to allow him to transition back to a school setting now that his maladaptive behaviors are under control. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's transition back to the classroom must begin immediately and proceed in a slow and smooth manner over several months time to ensure a satisfactory adjustment and retention of the gains already achieved.
The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT requires the assistance of a 1:1 aide in the classroom to assist with the transition and to help him adjust. To facilitate a smooth transition, the aide should be an individual who knows STUDENT and has already worked with him in the CARD in-home program. The aide must also be trained and supervised by CARD to ensure coordination between STUDENT's in-home and school programs. Because the Hearing Officer has found the Deer Canyon special day class to be inappropriate, the IEP team must select an appropriate special day class for STUDENT in consultation with CARD. The special day class must include the components already identified above in order to meet STUDENT's unique needs.
The Hearing Officer finds that, at the beginning of the transition, STUDENT must attend his special day class for three half-days. During the transition, STUDENT's time in class must be increased as his in-home intensive behavior intervention program hours are reduced. Once he has transitioned back to the classroom, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a program which provides 20 hours per week of in-home intensive behavior intervention paired with full time attendance, if consistent with STUDENT's needs, in the special day class. STUDENT must also have the continued assistance of the 1:1 classroom aide after the transition is completed to ensure that he has successfully adapted to the classroom environment. The IEP team may fade the 1:1 aide after the transition is completed, if the team determines that this is appropriate in consideration of STUDENT's needs and progress.
The Hearing Officer also finds that training must be provided to STUDENT's in-home program therapists and his 1:1 classroom aide, in the areas of general behavior modification techniques and appropriate implementation of discrete trial training, as recommended by Dr. Granpeesheh. This training should be provided by CARD to ensure consistency in STUDENT's program at home and at school.
ORDER
1. Within 30 days of the receipt of proof, the Respondents shall reimburse Petitioner's parents for costs and all related expenses, including supervision, consultation and workshop training, of STUDENT's CARD program from June 2, 1997 through the date of this decision.
2. Respondents shall fund Petitioner's CARD program from the day after the date of this decision through the 1997-98 school year, including the extended school year. STUDENT's in-home CARD program shall include intensive in-home behavior intervention, daily data collection and recording, four hours per month of supervision, consultation, and additional training for STUDENT's in-home therapists in the areas of general behavior modification techniques and appropriate implementation of discrete trial training.
3. Respondents shall provide or contract for a 1:1 classroom aide to assist STUDENT with the transition described in order #6 below. The aide must be trained and supervised by CARD to ensure coordination between STUDENT's in-home and school programs. To facilitate the transition, STUDENT's 1:1 classroom aide should be an individual who knows STUDENT and has already worked with him in the CARD in-home program.
4. Within 15 days of the date of this order, Respondents shall convene an IEP team meeting and develop an appropriate IEP for STUDENT for the remainder of the 1997-98 school year and the extended school year. The IEP team shall include STUDENT's clinical supervisor from CARD and any other CARD personnel which the IEP team deems appropriate and necessary. The IEP developed within 15 days of the date of this order shall include all aspects of STUDENT's program ordered in numbers 2 (intensive in-home behavior intervention program through CARD), 3 (1:1 classroom aide), 5 (appropriate special day class), and 6 (transition plan).
5. The IEP team shall select an appropriate special day class for STUDENT to attend for the remainder of the 1997-98 school year. The Deer Canyon special day class for multi-handicapped students is not an appropriate class for STUDENT. The special day class selected must be designed to meet STUDENT's individual needs for language development, socialization and peer interaction, and must offer a curriculum geared to his developmental level. The class must appropriately accommodate and address STUDENT's visual impairments, must provide positive behavior intervention for any maladaptive behaviors he may present, and must be compatible with STUDENT's CARD in-home intensive behavior intervention program. Any special day class which STUDENT attends during the extended school year program must also include all the components noted above.
6. The IEP team shall develop a transition plan to return STUDENT in a smooth and gradual manner, over several months, to the special day class selected for him pursuant to order #5 above. The transition plan must include, but need not be limited to, the following components:
a.) initial attendance at the special day class for three half-days per week to increase, as appropriate to STUDENT's needs, to full time attendance at the conclusion of the transition. b.) a 1:1 aide in the special day class to assist STUDENT in making the transition and to help him adjust to the classroom. c.) continuation of STUDENT's in-home intensive behavior intervention program through CARD with gradual reduction in hours from 40 hours per week to 20 hours per week at the conclusion of the transition. This reduction in hours at home shall be coordinated with the increase in hours in STUDENT's special day class. After the transition is complete STUDENT's program shall include, but need not be limited to, the following elements:
d.) full time attendance at his special day class, if determined by the IEP team to be appropriate in consideration of STUDENT's needs and progress. e.) continued assistance from the 1:1 classroom aide. The IEP team may review STUDENT's continuing need for the 1:1 aide once the transition is completed, and may slowly fade the aide, if determined appropriate in consideration of STUDENT's needs. f.) 20 hours per week of in-home intensive behavior intervention through the CARD program.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Petitioner prevailed on all three issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56505(i).)
DATED: February 19, 1997 ________________________________________ JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES:
1. STUDENT's Designated Instruction and Services (DIS) are not in dispute as the services offered in the May 8, 1997 IEP have been accepted by his parents.
2. The IEP team also noted that STUDENT's teacher estimated his cognition was at the 9-11 month level, and his language development at the 12-15 month level. The psychologist indicated that STUDENT was functioning at the one-year level overall. (Resp. Exh. 8.)
3. This was the second incident in which STUDENT was bitten during school hours by another student. The first incident occurred in early 1994 and involved a facial bite from the same student who bit STUDENT during the summer of 1995.
4. Ms. Bewley emphasized that the IQ score of 41 from the Leiter and other test results should be viewed with caution and considered to be only estimates of STUDENT's ability due to his age, difficulties in test administration, and his vision problems. (Pet. Exh.
5. TEACCH stands for Treatment and Education of Autistic and Related Communications Handicapped Children. Classrooms using TEACCH rely on discrete trial training and thus provide a more structured environment than other special day classes. (Testimony of Ms. Andrews.)
6. See footnote 1, supra. Because the DIS services are not in dispute, the Hearing Officer will not discuss them.
7. Petitioner submitted his request for due process hearing on May 13, 1997, approximately three weeks before the IDEA was amended on June 4, 1997 (Public Law 105-17). Neither party has argued that the Hearing Officer should apply the new IDEA in this case. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will apply the law in effect at that time under principles of retroactivity. (Landsgraf v. USI Film Products (1994) 511 U.S. 244.)
8. Section 614(d) of the IDEA does not go into effect until July 1, 1998, except for subsection (6), which concerns children with disabilities in adult prisons.
9. Dr. Perlman has a Ph.D. in clinical psychology from the California School for Professional Psychology. Dr. Perlman has been in private practice for 15 years, and has performed numerous assessments for various purposes, including differential diagnosis, forensics, child custody and education. Dr. Perlman was trained in psychoeducational assessment under Nadeen and Alan Kaufman, authors of the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children. Dr. Perlman is a licensed clinical psychologist. (Pet. Exh. 26.)
10. Dr. Granpeesheh has a Ph.D. in psychology from the University of California-Los Angeles. She specializes in developmental disabilities, autism and pervasive developmental disorders, and assessment and treatment of childhood disorders. Since 1991, Dr. Granpeesheh has been the director of CARD, which currently provides behavior modification services for 300 children. She was licensed as a psychologist by the State of California in 1992. (Pet. Exh. 29.)
11. Dr. Siegel has a Ph.D. in early childhood development. She is the founder and director of the Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic at Langley Porter Psychiatric Institute in San Francisco. Dr. Siegel has assessed over 2000 children with autism, and has worked for the past 25 years with severely disabled children with autism and related conditions.
12. Dr. Eachus has an Ed.D. in educational research. He is a registered behavior analyst, and is currently the program director for Tobinworld, a nonpublic school serving children who are seriously emotionally disturbed and autistic. Dr. Eachus has also served as a consultant to various educational entities.
