California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 16, 2000

Ravenswood City School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 619-00 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard

Ravenswood City School District's assessment upheld in most areas, but it must assess the student for other health impairment and screen hearing and vision.

Student prevailed in part

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Ravenswood City School District filed for due process to defend its initial special education assessment of a 9-year-old fourth grader at Flood Science and Technology Magnet School. The IEP team had found him not eligible, and the parent asked for an independent educational evaluation (IEE). A non-attorney advocate represented the student. He argued that the district skipped areas listed on the assessment plan, including behavior, motor skills, asthma, hearing and vision.

The Hearing Officer found that the district's psychoeducational, academic and speech-language assessments met Education Code section 56320. The tests were not discriminatory. School psychologist Maria Rogers gave the Woodcock-Johnson achievement test, not the IQ test that Larry P. v. Riles bars for African-American students. All assessors were qualified, including a speech therapist working under a state waiver. These assessments properly covered suspected emotional disturbance, learning disability and speech-language impairment, so the district did not owe an IEE in those areas.

However, the district never assessed a suspected other health impairment. Teachers repeatedly reported that the student fell asleep in class, and the district knew he had chronic asthma and allergies and took medications. The district also skipped the hearing and vision screening that state regulations require for every initial assessment. Within 20 days, the district must provide a health assessment by a qualified licensed physician and complete both screenings. It must then hold an IEP meeting within 10 days of receiving the health assessment. Claims under Section 504 were outside the hearing office's jurisdiction. Each side prevailed in part.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's request to defend its assessment. Strong tests in some areas did not excuse skipping a suspected health condition that teachers repeatedly raised. The Hearing Officer also held that California's required hearing and vision screening applies to every initial assessment, even when no hearing or vision disability is suspected.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Whether the District's assessment of Student for special education eligibility is appropriate or whether it must pay for an independent educational assessment as requested by the parent.

    The district's assessments for emotional disturbance, learning disability and speech-language impairment were appropriate, so no IEE was owed in those areas. The district failed to assess a suspected other health impairment (asthma, medications, sleepiness in class) and skipped the hearing and vision screening state law requires, so it must complete those assessments.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to assess. Within 20 days of the order, the District must complete an other health impairment assessment by a licensed physician qualified to assess the student's chronic asthma, allergies, any potential sleep disorder, his medications and/or their effect on his ability to stay alert and focused in class. The physician must also be prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors (Ed. Code § 56324(b)).
  • Order to assess. Within 20 days of the order, the District must conduct a hearing screening and a vision screening of the student.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 days of receiving the other health impairment assessment, the District must convene an IEP meeting to discuss how the assessment affects eligibility, and must also consider the hearing and vision screening results.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Larry P. v. Riles; Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education; David D. v. Dartmouth School Committee; Student v. Capistrano Unified School District, SN 686-99

People named in the decision

  • Stephanie Allen, general education teacher, Ravenswood City School District, Flood School
  • David Dyer, general education math and science teacher, Ravenswood City School District, Flood School
  • Sandra Lee Way, speech/language therapist (assessor, state waiver), Ravenswood City School District
  • Ann Petrik, resource specialist teacher (academic assessor), Ravenswood City School District
  • Jerri Lane Armstrong-Walker, principal, Flood Science and Technology Magnet School
  • Maria Teresa Rogers, school psychologist (assessor), Ravenswood City School District
  • Joseph John Totter, assistant superintendent, Ravenswood City School District
  • Howard Rose, O.D., private optometrist, Private provider
  • Makhoba Morojele, parent advocate and independent education consultant, Student's representative

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 619-00 Case Year: 2000 Petitioner: RAVENSWOOD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT Issue: Assessment CDS Code: 41-68999 District: Ravenswood City Elementary Disability Type: Mental Retardation

Case Details This matter was heard before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in East Palo Alto, California, on June 22 and 23, 2000.

Petitioner Ravenswood City School District (hereafter Petitioner or the District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Peter E. Keup of the law firm of Jones & Mason. Also present on the District's behalf at the beginning of the hearing was Dr. Joseph John Totter, the District's assistant superintendent. As discussed below, following a motion by Respondent, Mr. Totter agreed to be present at the hearing only for the purpose of his testimony.

Respondent STUDENT (hereafter Respondent or the STUDENT ) was represented at the hearing by parent advocate and independent education consultant, Makhoba Morojele. Also present on STUDENT's behalf was his mother, STUDENT's MOTHER.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: regular education teachers Stephanie Allen and David Dyer, speech therapist Sandra Lee Way, resource specialist teacher Ann Petrik, Flood School principal Dr. Jerri Lane Armstrong-Walker, school psychologist Maria Teresa Rogers, and assistant superintendent Joseph Totter.

Respondent called the following witnesses: STUDENT's MOTHER.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and an oral closing argument was made by the parties. The parties requested and were granted an opportunity to submit closing briefs by July 17, 2000. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the outset of the hearing, the STUDENT made a motion to exclude the District's supplemental exhibits 22 through 25, because these exhibits were not received by the parent's advocate until June 19, 2000, three days prior to the hearing.(Footnote 1) The STUDENT stated he was concerned by the manner in which the District had mailed the documents; however, he was not contending that he was prejudiced by the District's alleged untimeliness in serving the supplemental exhibits. As a result, the Hearing Officer denied the motion to exclude the supplemental exhibits. The STUDENT moved to exclude other District exhibits, later identified as Exhibits 12 and 14, because they contained alterations which were not on otherwise-identical documents in the STUDENT 's possession. The Hearing Officer denied the motion to exclude the exhibits on this basis, ruling that the STUDENT could explore the alleged alterations in the documents during his cross-examination of witnesses. At the conclusion of the hearing, all exhibits offered by the District and by the STUDENT were admitted into evidence.

The STUDENT also made a motion to exclude Dr. Totter from the hearing, based on the parent's discomfort in his presence.(Footnote 2) Because the District agreed not to have Dr. Totter present at the hearing except for purpose of his testimony, it was unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to rule on this motion.

ISSUE

The sole issue is whether the District's assessment of STUDENT for special education eligibility is appropriate or whether it must pay for an independent educational assessment as requested by the parent.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District contends that its assessment of STUDENT complied with the requirements of California Education Code § 56320. Specifically, it asserts that STUDENT was assessed in all areas of suspected disability raised by the parent and District staff at the time of referral and evaluation, that the tests it used in assessing STUDENT were administered in a nondiscriminatory manner, in his primary language by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions, and that no single protocol was used as the sole criterion for determining eligibility. Finally, the District asserts that other concerns noted about STUDENT's physical condition did not adversely affect STUDENT's educational performance. As a result, the District argues that its assessment of STUDENT was adequate and it should not be required to pay for an independent educational evaluation.

The STUDENT contends that the District's evaluation was not sufficiently comprehensive because all areas listed on the assessment plan were not evaluated.(Footnote 3) Specific areas of concern raised by the STUDENT were STUDENT's behavior, his gross motor skills, his asthma, his hearing and his vision. In his closing brief, the STUDENT stated that vision and hearing assessments are no longer necessary because they were conducted and paid for by the parent. The STUDENT requests an order authorizing an independent assessment to determine whether STUDENT qualifies for special education or for services under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

STUDENT attended the District's Flood Science and Technology Magnet School (hereafter, Flood) during third and fourth grade. STUDENT is an African-American student who, at the time of the events described below, was 9 years old and in the fourth grade general education program at Flood. His primary regular education teacher was Stephanie Allen. He also attended general education math and science classes with regular education teacher David Dyer.

On October 8, 1999, STUDENT's MOTHER wrote a letter to the principal of Flood School, the director of special education and to Mr. Totter to request an educational evaluation for her son, STUDENT. The reason for the requested evaluation was "because of his last report and that he has a hard time following directions." (District Ex. 1)

On October 28, 1999, the District received STUDENT's MOTHER's letter requesting an evaluation.

On November 10, 1999, an assessment plan was developed for STUDENT. The assessment plan indicated that assessments may be required in the areas of academic achievement, intellectual development, communication development, social/adaptive behavior, psycho-motor development. An additional "other" category of possible assessments was indicated to include hearing, vision, vocational, orientation and mobility and functional analysis. (District Ex. 2)

On November 19, 1999, STUDENT's MOTHER signed the assessment plan. (District Ex. 2) That same day, a STUDENT Success Team (SST) meeting was held for STUDENT. (STUDENT Ex. Q, p. 2) Concerns raised at the SST meeting were that STUDENT does not understand assignments, or recognize clues from written assignments. Changes in STUDENT's behavior were also identified. STUDENT was described as sassy, kicking STUDENT s and sleeping in class. The SST recommended various strategies to address these concerns, including an assessment to address his behavior changes, a consistent bed time to provide an additional hour of sleep, a requirement that STUDENT repeat instruction to his teachers to make certain he understands his assignments, and daily completion of a homework agenda.

On December 15, 1999, Ms. Allen completed another referral to the SST for STUDENT. The areas of concern listed were that "STUDENT fails to complete assignments, whether in-class or homework. He comes to class with no supplies (pencils, paper, agenda, books). Lately he is reacting to situations where he's upset by yelling out in class and kicking." (District Exhibit 12)

On December 15, 1999, the District notified STUDENT's MOTHER of an individualized education plan (IEP) meeting for STUDENT on January 21, 2000. (District's Ex. 3) STUDENT's MOTHER indicated that she received the notice of IEP meeting on January 6, 2000. (STUDENT 's Ex. H)

In preparation for the IEP meeting, Ms. Allen, with assistance from Mr. Dyer, prepared a general education teacher report based upon their observations of STUDENT's performance in the classroom. (District Ex. 12)(Footnote 4) Neither Ms. Allen nor Mr. Dyer administered any formal tests to STUDENT for this report. Ms. Allen described STUDENT as "an advanced reader with a large vocabulary and excellent comprehension," who understood all the presented concepts in history and social science. He was described as talented and entertaining in visual and performing arts. In physical education, Ms. Allen wrote that "STUDENT's knee and foot problems along with his asthma are making it difficult for him to join in and keep up." While STUDENT's attendance was "near perfect," Ms. Allen noted that he "comes to class unprepared - no pencil, paper, agenda or books. He often pretends that he doesn't understand something in order to amuse his classmates. STUDENT does not turn in assignments." STUDENT's behavior was described as follows: "STUDENT often falls asleep in class. Lately, he has been kicking classmates when he is upset or even just disagrees with them. He has recently begun yelling out in class. He has also started taking things from his teacher's desk."

Mr. Dyer indicated that STUDENT has above-average ability in mathematics; however, his potential rarely shows through due to difficulties in behavior as described by Ms. Allen. In science, Mr. Dyer stated that STUDENT's "reading comprehension helps in this area. As above, he rarely completes assignments, including in-class assignments that required only coloring and cutting." (District Ex. 12)

In addition to the general education teacher report, the following assessments were conducted and memorialized in written reports for the IEP meeting: a speech/language assessment report by speech/language therapist Sandra Way (District Ex. 11); a pre-academic/academic assessment report by resource specialist Ms. Petrik (District Ex. 10); and a psychological-educational assessment report by school psychologist Maria Rogers (District Ex. 9). Formal tests administered for these assessments were as follows: Ms. Way administered the Expressive Vocabulary Test (EVT) and the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals - Third Edition (CLEF-III) for STUDENT's speech and language assessment; Ms. Petrik administered the Wide Range Achievement Test - III Revised (WRAT 3 - Rev.) and the Brigance Inventory of Basic Skills for STUDENT's pre-academic/academic assessment; and Ms. Rogers administered the Matrix Analogies Test - Expanded Form (Matrix), the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills (TAPS), the Visual-Motor Integration (VMI) test, and the Woodcock-Johnson Revised Test of Achievement for STUDENT's his psychological-educational assessment. Ms. Rogers also had STUDENT complete two projective tests ±the Tell-Me-A-Story (TEMAS) test and the Sentence Completion test.

STUDENT's initial IEP meeting was convened on January 21, 2000. The IEP meeting was cancelled, however, and was rescheduled for February 8, 2000. (District's Exhibit 7) A notice of IEP meeting for this date was prepared on January 26, 2000. (District's Ex. 8)

On February 8, 2000, an IEP meeting was held to review the assessments. The IEP team reviewed and considered the written reports of assessments conducted. Based upon the results of the assessments, all IEP team members except STUDENT's MOTHER agreed that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. STUDENT's MOTHER and her advocate requested an independent educational evaluation for STUDENT. This request was denied. STUDENT was "referr[ed] to the SST team to schedule a meeting within three weeks" in order to develop general education interventions for him. (District Exs.13, 14)(Footnote 5)

Following the IEP team meeting, two SST meetings were convened to develop strategies to address concerns about STUDENT in the general education program. These meetings occurred on March 7, 2000 and on April 7, 2000. (See: District Exs. 17 and 18)

On April 4, 2000, the District filed its request for a due process hearing to establish the appropriateness of its assessment of STUDENT. (District Ex. 19)

DISCUSSION

Under California law, before a student can receive special education services, he/she must first be assessed to determine whether he/she qualifies as an "individual with exceptional needs." (California Education Code § 56320) An "individual with exceptional needs" is defined as a person who is identified by an individualized education program (IEP) team as a µchild with a disability,' as that phrase is defined under the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA) (20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(ii)), whose impairment requires instruction, services, or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. In addition, the person must fall within various age categories and meet the eligibility criteria set forth in California's regulations. (Calif. Education Code § 56026) A student cannot be placed in special education instruction unless an assessment is conducted, the IEP team so recommends and the parent consents to the placement. (Calif. Education Code §§56323, 56346 (a))

The assessment process is initiated by a "referral for assessment," which means any written request for assessment to identify an individual with exceptional needs made by a parent, teacher, or other service provider. (Calif. Education Code § 56029) Once that referral is made, an assessment plan must be developed and given to the pupil's parents in writing, generally within 15 days of the referral. (Calif. Education Code § 56321(a)) The parent has at least 15 days from receipt of the proposed assessment plan to review and provide their written consent for the testing. (Calif. Education Code § 56321 (c))

Upon completion of the assessment, an IEP team meeting must be scheduled to determine whether the pupil is an individual with exceptional needs and to discuss the assessments, the educational recommendations, and the reasons for these recommendations. (Calif. Education Code § 56329 (a)) The IEP team shall review the assessment results and determine eligibility. (Calif. Education Code § 56342) "An individualized education program required as a result of an assessment of a pupil shall be developed within a total time, not to exceed 50 days...." (Calif. Education Code § 56344)

If the parent disagrees with the assessment obtained by the public education agency, the "parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists,...." (Calif. Education Code § 56329(b)) The public education agency may initiate a due process hearing, however, to show that its assessment is appropriate. If the final decision resulting from the hearing is that the assessment is appropriate, the parent still has the right for an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense. Id.

If the parent privately obtains an independent educational assessment, the results of any such assessment "shall be considered" by the public education agency with respect to the provision of a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to the child, and may be presented as evidence at a due process hearing regarding the child. (Calif. Education Code § 56329(b))

In determining the appropriateness of the District's assessment, then, the focus is not on whether its determination that STUDENT is not eligible for special education is correct. Rather, the inquiry is whether the District complied with the procedural requirements relating to assessments.

Appropriateness of District Assessment

California Education Code § 56320, subsections (a) through (d), states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; be provided and administered in the student's primary language or other mode of communication; be validated for the purpose for which they are used; be administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; be tailored to assess specific areas of need; and be selected and administered to best ensure that, when administered to a pupil with impaired speaking skills, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student's aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the student's impaired speaking skills.

The evidence clearly demonstrated that the tests given by the District to STUDENT were "selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory." Prior to and at the outset of the hearing, STUDENT contended that the District had violated the prohibitions of Larry P. v. Riles (N.D. Cal.1979) 495 F. Supp. 926, aff'd in part, rev'd in part, (9th Cir. 1984) 793 F.2d 969, against the use of certain intelligence quotient (I. Q.) tests with African-American students, because it had administered the Woodcock-Johnson test to him.(Footnote 6) (See: District Ex. 22 and STUDENT Exhibit A, Clarification of the Use of Intelligence Tests with African-American Students for Special Education Assessments, and Prohibited Tests) There was no assertion of bias in any of the other assessments utilized.

At the hearing, school psychologist Maria Rogers testified that she did not administer the Woodcock- Johnson Test of Cognitive Ability to STUDENT. Ms. Rogers testified that, through training received in graduate school and at the District, she is aware that the use of this intelligence test on African-American students is prohibited.(Footnote 7) Rather, she used the Woodcock-Johnson Revised Test of Achievement to determine how well STUDENT was performing in reading, math, and written language. Because there is no prohibition on the use of achievement tests, the District's use of the Woodcock-Johnson Test of Achievement did not violate Education Code § 56320 (a). The Hearing Officer finds that no prohibited I.Q. test was administered to STUDENT.

The evidence was uncontradicted that each of the assessments given to STUDENT was administered in his primary language of English, that the tests had been validated for the specific purpose used, and that they had been administered in conformance with the test instructions. (Testimony of Ms. Way, Ms. Petrik and Ms. Rogers) The District's assessment thus complied with the requirements of

Education Code § 56320 (b) (1), (2), and (3).

To be appropriate, the District's assessments must be conducted by persons knowledgeable about the student's disability and conducted by trained persons competent to perform the assessments. (California Education Code §§ 56320(b)(3), 56320 (g), and 56322) In addition, California Education Code § 56324 (a) specifically requires that any psychological assessment be performed by a credentialed school psychologist. Again, the uncontradicted evidence demonstrated that the District complied with these provisions. Ms. Rogers testified that she has been a credentialed school psychologist for the past three years. During this period, she has administered each of the tests she administered to STUDENT on numerous occasions. Similarly, Ms. Petrik testified that she has been a resource specialist for the past three to four years and was previously a special day class teacher. She holds multiple credentials, including a learning handicapped life credential. Ms. Petrik testified that, as a resource specialist teacher, one of her responsibilities is conducting academic assessments of new students referred to the special education department. She has administered the WRAT - 3 (Revised) and Briggance Inventory on numerous occasions over a ten year period. The only challenge STUDENT specifically raised to the qualifications of his assessors was regarding Ms. Way's qualifications to conduct his speech and language assessment. The evidence revealed, however, that Ms. Way has a current valid waiver for this purpose from the State of California. Ms. Way testified that she has conducted over 90 such assessments during the past two years, has received training in assessments and is in the middle of her course work for speech and language therapy.(Footnote 8) She has administered both the EVT and the CLEF-III many times before. The Hearing Officer finds that the assessments were conducted by trained competent persons as required by Education Code §§ 56320(b)(3), 56320(g), and 56322.

California Education Code § 56320(e) and (f) require that no single procedure be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs and that a student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. As indicated below, multiple assessment tools were utilized and there was no violation of Education Code § 56320(e). The District contends that it assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability of which it was aware, based upon the information available to it at the time. According to the District, STUDENT's suspected disabilities at the time of the referral were in the areas of emotional disturbance, specific learning disability, and/or speech or language impairment. (Closing brief at p. 10)

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT in these areas of suspected disability within the meaning of California Education Code § 56320(e) and (f).

First, as demonstrated by the assessments conducted by school psychologist Ms. Rogers (District Ex. 9) and resource specialist Ms. Petrik (District Ex. 10), STUDENT was appropriately assessed for the suspected disabilities of emotional disturbance and specific learning disability. Ms. Petrik testified that she conducted the pre-academic/academic assessment of STUDENT over several sessions in January 2000. In addition to administering the WRAT 3 - Rev. and the Brigance Inventory of Basic Skills, she also met with Ms. Allen and Mr. Dryer and observed STUDENT in class. The results of the WRAT 3 - Rev. indicated that STUDENT was "within the academic instructional range of the fourth grade classroom." Specifically, the test showed that STUDENT was at a beginning fourth-grade level equivalent in arithmetic computation; at a seventh grade level in decoding and reading words from a graded word lists; and scored at an eighth grade level in writing spelling words from dictation. Ms. Petrik was generally impressed with STUDENT's reading fluency and with his confidence in writing. She observed him to be somewhat hesitant in arithmetic, but testing on grade level. The results of the Briggance reading comprehension test indicated that STUDENT's reading comprehension was above average, on the seventh grade level.

In her report, Ms. Petrik wrote that STUDENT could benefit from "mastering" basic addition, subtraction, multiplication and division problems. Based on her experience, Ms. Petrik believed that STUDENT did not have a learning disability but simply that he could do better and required work in this area within the regular education program. Ms. Petrik also noted that STUDENT needed to complete and turn in his homework. Ms. Petrik detected no processing difficulties in STUDENT. Rather, STUDENT was sure of his answers, worked well and had a good grasp of the subjects.

School psychologist Ms. Rogers conducted STUDENT's psychological-education assessment over a seven-day period. She observed STUDENT on three occasions before she began her formal tests and diagnostic interview of STUDENT. STUDENT's scores on the Matrix, which tests nonverbal reasoning, were within the average range for his age. His scores on the TAPS were also well within the average range for his age. The TAPS results revealed that STUDENT is able to think and reason well, to demonstrate mental flexibility and to successfully use rote memory. He is able to meaningfully interpret enough auditory matter to verbally express it. STUDENT's scores on the VMI, which tests the ability to integrate fine motor skills with visual content, were within the average range. On the Woodcock-Johnson Revised Test of Achievement, STUDENT's broad reading score was at a 7.1 grade equivalent. His broad math score was at a 4.2 grade equivalent and his broad written language was at a 3.6 grade equivalent. Both the broad math and broad written language scores were within the average range based upon STUDENT's standard score.

To gain insight into STUDENT's social and emotional state, two projective tests±the TEMAS and the Sentence Completion test-- were administered. Ms. Rogers acknowledged the "many frustrations" STUDENT has had to endure from teasing of classmates about his weight.(Footnote 9) Nonetheless, Ms. Rogers testified persuasively that these tests revealed that STUDENT had no major depression or serious emotional issues. On the contrary, they demonstrated that STUDENT is capable of expressing his feelings eloquently, that he wants to establish relationships with people and that he enjoys doing so. His mother plays a central role in his life and he enjoyed a prior relationship with a counselor. He would be amenable to counseling services.

Based upon her assessments, Ms. Rogers did not find that STUDENT had either a specific learning disability or a serious emotional disturbance. She testified that, based upon all of the tests, there was no significant discrepancy between STUDENT's abilities and his achievements.

Second, as demonstrated in the assessment of speech and language therapist Ms. Way, STUDENT was appropriately assessed for the suspected disability of speech and language impairment. This speech and language assessment (District Ex. 11) was conducted over two or three sessions and involved formal testing as well as observations both in the class and during the formal testing. The results of the EVT showed that STUDENT was above age level, with an age equivalent score of 10 years 5 months.(Footnote 10) On the CLEF-III, STUDENT's receptive language score of 66 was above age level, as was his expressive language score of 55. STUDENT's total language score on the CLEF-III was higher than expected for his age. STUDENT scored below average on one subtest, "recalling sentences." Ms. Way testified that this subtest measured word for word recall accuracy. Because STUDENT is a very good reader who paraphrases, he recalled the sentences but with slight differences. This lowered his score. Ms. Way concluded that STUDENT did not have speech or language disabilities or need speech or language services. A low score on a single subtest (recalling sentences) was not a basis for finding eligibility. Ms. Way testified that STUDENT was in the top ten percent of the students she has tested. In her written report, Ms. Way's diagnostic summary was that STUDENT scored above-average for his age on all assessment measures. She recommended that the general education teacher continue supporting STUDENT in his speech and language development through the use of age-appropriate models, teacher models and combined verbal/visual clues.

The Hearing Officer concludes that, in addition to the areas of suspected disability discussed above, STUDENT had an area of suspected disability of "other health impairment," which the District failed to assess. Pursuant to 34 C.F.R. § 300.7 (c) (9), an "other health impairment" means "having limited strength, vitality, or alertness,..., that (i) is due to chronic or acute health problems, such as asthma,....and (ii) adversely affects a child's educational performance." This area of suspected disability is based upon several factors. First, persistent sleepiness in class was one of the principal concerns which was repeatedly raised about STUDENT. This concern had been noted by both Ms. Allen and Mr. Dyer. Ms. Allen wrote in their joint report to the IEP team that "STUDENT often falls asleep in class." (District Ex. 12) Mr. Dyer testified that STUDENT's above-average potential in math rarely shows through due, in part, to this behavior. This concern was discussed with the parents at the two SST meetings which occurred prior to the IEP meeting and at the IEP meeting.(Footnote 11) Ms. Allen testified that how long STUDENT slept in class would depend on when he was awakened by her or by another classmate. Both Ms. Allen and Mr. Dyer testified that STUDENT turned in only fifty to sixty percent of his in-class assignments. Ms. Rogers also testified that STUDENT's sleeping in class was a concern. Second, STUDENT has chronic asthma as well as allergies. While the focus of the concern at both the SST and IEP meetings was on the adequacy of STUDENT's sleeping routine at home, STUDENT's MOTHER testified that STUDENT's medication made him sleepy. Ms. Allen also raised concerns that STUDENT's asthma, as well as his "knee and foot problems" make it difficult for him to join and keep up in physical education. (District Ex. 12)

The District was aware that STUDENT had asthma. Due to its no drug tolerance policy, the District kept both STUDENT's inhaler and his medications in the principal's office. STUDENT's medications were administered either by Flood principal Dr. Walker or by her secretary. Although Dr. Walker testified that she had only seen STUDENT in her office on a few occasions for his asthma, STUDENT's MOTHER testified that she was called to the school on multiple occasions because they could not find his inhaler, or because the school staff could not find his medications. STUDENT's MOTHER testified that she went to Flood to provide medications for STUDENT or to pick him up because he was sleeping. Thus, the District had a sufficient factual basis to suspect an other health impairment based upon STUDENT's chronic asthma, particularly when coupled with his allergies, the fact that he was on multiple medications and his persistent sleepiness in class. While it is true that STUDENT's sleepiness could be attributable to his sleeping regime at home, these conditions also raise the possibility of physiological or pharmacological side effects from his medications or other health issues. Nonetheless, no health assessment was conducted to determine STUDENT's eligibility for special education. The IDEA specifically authorizes the use of a licensed physician for diagnostic or evaluation purposes. (34 C.F.R. § 300.24 (a) and (b)(4); see also, California Education Code § 56324(b)) The District must conduct a health assessment of STUDENT by a licensed physician who is qualified to assess STUDENT's chronic asthma, his allergies, any potential sleep disorder, his medications and/or the effect of any medications on his ability to remain alert and focused in the classroom.

In addition, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to conduct the hearing and vision screening of STUDENT which is mandated under California law for all pupils being assessed for initial special education services. (Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3027) Evidence at the hearing indicated that the last hearing or vision screening in STUDENT's cumulative school file was conducted four years earlier, in 1996. Ms. Rogers testified that she carefully combed STUDENT's cumulative file for more current records but was unable to find any. There was testimony by Dr. Totter and Dr. Walker that the District routinely tests entire class grades for hearing and vision on alternate years and that STUDENT's name did not appear on any list of students who failed such screenings. Ms. Way also testified that his name did not appear on this list. There was no affirmative evidence, however, that STUDENT's fourth grade class had in fact been tested in either hearing or vision. The District argues that these concerns were only raised after the IEP meeting and that STUDENT did not have either a hearing or a visual impairment as defined under federal or state law. This reasoning presupposes the outcome of the assessment. In addition, pursuant to Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3027, "[a]ll pupils being assessed for initial and three- year review for special education services shall have had a hearing and vision screening, unless parental permission was denied." (Emphasis added) STUDENT's MOTHER consented to the assessment in all areas, including hearing and vision. Thus, California law imposes a higher standard for assessment of a student for special education than does the federal law.(Footnote 12) In addition, California's mandate to conduct these screenings does not require a threshold finding that the pupil may be eligible as either visually or hearing impaired. As a result, testimony that STUDENT was not suspected of a disability in these areas is not legally relevant to the appropriateness of the District's assessment.

In his closing brief, STUDENT stated that the hearing and vision screenings are no longer necessary because they were conducted and paid for by the parent. These screenings, conducted after the IEP meeting, revealed that STUDENT had a very serious middle ear infection and that he required eyeglasses. (District Ex. 17) The evidence also demonstrated that STUDENT's MOTHER has been unwilling to provide the District with STUDENT's medical records as requested. (See: District Ex. 14)(Footnote 13) Due to the parent's unwillingness to provide the District with medical records documenting STUDENT's hearing and vision screenings, reimbursement for the cost of these tests is inappropriate. Furthermore, STUDENT does not request reimbursement for these tests. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District must independently conduct a hearing and vision screening of STUDENT.

Finally, the STUDENT requests that the Hearing Officer issue an order authorizing an independent assessment to determine whether STUDENT qualifies for special education or for services under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act. The Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction over claims of eligibility under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, U.S.C. § 794. (See: California Education Code § 56501 (a); STUDENT v. Capistrano Unified School District, SN 686-99 (Sept. 30, 1999) Accordingly, any issues raised about § 504 of the Rehabilitation Act are not addressed by this decision.

ORDER

1. Except for the "other health impairment" assessment and the vision and hearing screenings ordered below, the District's assessment of STUDENT was appropriate, within the meaning of Education Code § 56329(b). Accordingly, the District is not required to fund an independent educational evaluation of STUDENT in any of the following areas of suspected disability: emotional disturbance, specific learning disability and speech and language impairment.

2. Within twenty (20) days of the date of this order, the District must complete an assessment of STUDENT in the suspected area of disability of "other health impairment." This assessment must be conducted by a licensed physician qualified to assess STUDENT's chronic asthma, his allergies, any potential sleep disorder, his medications and/or the effect of any medications on his ability to remain alert and focused in the classroom. Pursuant to Education Code § 56324(b), the physician performing the assessment must also be prepared to assess any cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to STUDENT.

3. Within ten (10) days of the receipt of the assessment on "other health impairment," the District must convene an IEP meeting for STUDENT to discuss the effect of this assessment on STUDENT's eligibility for special education services.

4. Within twenty (20) days of the date of this order, the District shall conduct both a hearing and a vision screening of STUDENT. The results of these screenings shall also be considered by the IEP team convened pursuant to Order No. 3.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

The District prevailed in part and the STUDENT prevailed in part.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: August 16, 2000 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes

Footnote 1: A written motion dated June 20, 2000, to exclude the supplemental exhibits had not been ruled on at the time of the hearing. This motion requested that the supplemental exhibits be excluded on the additional grounds that they were submitted only after the District had an opportunity to review STUDENT 's evidence and because the District had "not raised the Larry P. Law and the Intelligence Quotient (I.Q.) Tests for African American students...until STUDENT submitted documentation to the inappropriateness of the Woodcock-Johnson test." These arguments were not raised at the hearing. Neither reason would be a basis for excluding the District's supplemental exhibits. Footnote 2: The STUDENT 's written "motion to exclude Dr. Totter from the hearing" was based on his MOTHER'S belief that Dr. Totter seemed "combative" toward her in her efforts to educate her children. The Hearing Office construed this as a motion to exclude Dr. Totter as a witness and denied it by Minute Order dated May 23, 2000. The matter of witness testimony was left to the discretion of the presiding hearing officer. Footnote 3: The STUDENT also argues that the District violated its "child find" obligation and that the District's teachers had a professional obligation to refer STUDENT for assessment earlier. These issues are not appropriate for resolution in the context of this hearing. Should the parent file a request for a due process hearing to challenge the District's denial of STUDENT's eligibility for special education services, these issues can be raised at that hearing. Footnote 4: Exhibit 12 is one of the documents which STUDENT alleged was altered by the District. A comparison of the STUDENT 's version of this document, STUDENT 's Exhibit G, to the District's copy, District Exhibit 12, reveals added dates and notations and there was no dispute that additional information was written on this document. Dr. Totter testified that the additions were in his handwriting and that he made these notations at the IEP team meeting based upon the teams's discussions. Under reading/language arts, Dr. Totter wrote "Grade 5 reading group;" under "Behavior," in reference to STUDENT's falling asleep in class, Dr. Totter wrote "8:30 - 9:30" and "5:00 a.m." Dr. Totter testified that this was information provided about STUDENT's bedtime and waking time. Similarly, under visual and performing arts, Mr. Totter wrote in the phrase "talented in this area." The Hearing Officer found that there was no prejudice from these alterations on the report. Footnote 5: District Exhibit 14 is a letter dated January 10, 2000 from Mr. Totter to STUDENT's MOTHER following the IEP meeting of February 8, 2000. (STUDENT Ex. L) Dr. Totter testified that he altered the District's copy of this letter (District Ex. 14), by crossing out "January" in the date and writing in "Feb." over it in order to correct a typographical error. The Hearing Officer concluded that there was no prejudice from the alteration of this document. Footnote 6: In his closing brief, STUDENT appears to have abandoned this issue. For a comprehensive review of the Larry P. litigation, see Memorandum of Order Denying in Part and Granting in Part Motions to Dismiss and to Exclude Evidence in STUDENT v. Ravenswood Elementary School District, et al. (March 26, 1998), SN 988-97. Footnote 7: Dr. Totter also testified that the District has hired a psychologist under contract with the California Department of Education to train staff in assessing African- American students and that Ms. Rogers had been trained in this area by both himself and the consultant. Footnote 8: Ms. Way testified that she has completed twelve units toward her degree. Ms. Way currently holds a Master of Arts degree in Education from Stanford University, was a teacher for several years and holds a multiple subject teaching credential. Footnote 9: According to STUDENT's MOTHER, such teasing has been the antecedent to STUDENT's kicking behavior. Footnote 10: As pointed out by STUDENT's MOTHER, Ms. Way's report incorrectly identified STUDENT's date of birth as [date redacted], rather than his true birth date of [date redacted]. Despite this inaccuracy, STUDENT still tested above-average for his age. Footnote 11: Ms. Allen testified that she discussed STUDENT's sleeping in class with STUDENT's MOTHER to determine what his home schedule was. STUDENT's MOTHER told her that STUDENT had to wake up very early, at 4:30 or 5:00 a.m. in order to be brought to school. See also, footnote 4, ante. The SST team tried to get him to sleep an extra hour. Footnote 12: California's assessment procedures are more protective in some ways than the federal standards. Courts have long recognized that the states may adopt substantive and procedural standards for special education students which are higher than those provided for by federal special education law. See: Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts (1st Cir. 1984) 736 F.2d 773; David D. v. Dartmouth School Committee (1st Cir. 1985) 775 F. 2d 411, 414. Where California special education law is more protective of students than the federal law, the Hearing Office has consistently held that California law controls. (See: SN 449-00, SN 1357-97, SN 754-98). Footnote 13: STUDENT's MOTHER testified that she refused to give the District medical information about STUDENT's middle ear infections or to provide the District with STUDENT's health insurance policy number. The STUDENT did introduce a letter, dated May 25, 2000, from Dr. Howard Rose, O.D., describing the results of his March 3, 2000 eye exam of STUDENT. (STUDENT Ex. Y) In his pre-hearing statement of June 6, 2000, STUDENT indicated that Dr. Rose concluded that "his acuity is fine without the infections." No finding can be made, however, based upon this hearsay statement. 5 C.C.R. § 3082(b).