California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 1, 2005
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 620-04 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown
Los Angeles Unified prevails as Hearing Officer denies a seventh grader's requests for more occupational therapy and educational remediation.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 13-year-old seventh grader at Los Angeles Unified's Patrick Henry Middle School filed for due process, represented by her mother. She is eligible for special education under other health impairment due to attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). She received resource specialist program (RSP) services. Since September 2002 she had also received 30 minutes a week of occupational therapy (OT), mostly under stay put. She claimed the District should have assessed her OT needs as early as 2000. She also sought two hours a week of OT, one hour a week of educational remediation, and compensatory OT.
The mother argued the three-year limitations period should run from September 2003. That was when she completed a due process form at the school and, she said, a clerk promised to send it on. The Hearing Officer rejected this estoppel argument because the form told parents to send it to the Hearing Office themselves. Claims before March 18, 2001 were therefore barred. On the merits, the Hearing Officer found OT was not a suspected area of disability before 2002, based on average visual-perception scores and teacher testimony. Four occupational therapists found the student's handwriting poor but functional for school. Their views outweighed independent neuropsychologist Dr. Karen Schiltz, who recommended two hours of weekly OT but is not an occupational therapist. Teachers said the student could access class with accommodations, and her grades improved. All relief was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied tort-claim estoppel rules when a parent said school staff had promised to file her due process request. It also shows a Hearing Officer giving more weight to registered occupational therapists than to a neuropsychologist's OT recommendation. The decision treated poor but functional handwriting as not requiring OT.
Issues and holdings
Issue 1. Are Student's claims arising prior to March 18, 2001, barred by the statute of limitations?
The District was not equitably estopped from raising the three-year limitations period. The school's due process form told parents to send the original to the Hearing Office, and the mother did not show a clerk promised to file it. Claims before March 18, 2001 were barred.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2. From September 2000 to the present, did the District fail to timely assess Student's occupational therapy (OT) needs and/or deny her a FAPE by failing to offer her a sufficient amount of OT services?
OT was not an area of suspected disability from March 2001 through 2001-2002, given average visual-perception scores and teacher testimony. From September 2002 on, 30 minutes per week of OT was enough, so there was no denial of FAPE.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3a. For the next six to twelve months, does Student require OT for two hours per week by a certified nonpublic agency (NPA) to receive a FAPE?
The testimony of registered occupational therapists that the student does not need OT outweighed the recommendation of a neuropsychologist who is not an occupational therapist. Two hours per week of NPA OT is not required.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3b. For the next six to twelve months, does Student require educational remediation for one hour per week to receive a FAPE?
The independent assessor's general suggestion did not show a need for remediation beyond existing RSP services and accommodations. Teachers testified the student functions in class, and her grades improved.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. If Student was denied a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory education services of intensive OT for two hours per week by a certified NPA?
Because there was no denial of FAPE, there was no basis for compensatory OT.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; Alexopolous v. San Francisco Unified School Dist.; John R. v. Oakland Unified School Dist.; Johnson v. San Diego Unified School Dist.; DeYoung v. Del Mar Thoroughbred Club
People named in the decision
- Pablo Pauig, occupational therapist present on District's behalf, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Harriet Watson, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Mikie Douglas, assistant principal, Patrick Henry Middle School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Lori Foster, fifth-grade teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Robert Romero, third-grade teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Doug Howard, assistant principal and former resource specialist program (RSP) teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Mary Demetrion, sixth-grade social studies teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Niraj Jaju, occupational therapist (nonpublic agency); conducted 2003 OT assessment, Progressus Therapy
- Shirin Khosraviani, occupational therapist (nonpublic agency) providing student's OT, Progressus Therapy
- Susan Two-Coats, seventh-grade English teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Ashley Edelhart Hall, occupational therapist; conducted 2002 OT assessment, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Susan Pfau, occupational therapist; conducted 2003 OT assessment, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Shirley Parry, RSP teacher (sixth grade), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Gina Sarabia, school clerk, Patrick Henry Middle School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Debbie Arndt, school clerk, Patrick Henry Middle School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Karen Schiltz, clinical neuropsychologist; independent evaluator (District-funded by agreement); not permitted to testify, Independent
- Joyce Paul, District counsel at earlier session, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Marilyn Woollard, SEHO Hearing Officer (earlier session), Special Education Hearing Office
- Mark Brylski, SEHO Hearing Officer (earlier session), Special Education Hearing Office
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter convened for hearing on January 25 and 28, and February 1, 2005, before Suzanne B. Brown, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law. On January 25, the hearing convened in Los Angeles, California, but thereafter convened in Northridge, California, for the two subsequent hearing days of January 28 and February 1.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter A Petitioner or ASTUDENT) was represented at the hearing by her mother, MOTHER. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (hereinafter A District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Mary Kellogg. Present on the District’s behalf was occupational therapist Pablo Pauig. District due process specialist Harriet Watson was also present on the first day of hearing.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother; Mikie Douglas, District assistant principal; Lori Foster, District fifth-grade teacher; Robert Romero, District third-grade teacher; Doug Howard, District assistant principal and former resource specialist program (RSP) teacher; and Mary Demetrion, District sixth-grade teacher. The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Niraj Jaju, occupational therapist with Progressus Therapy; Shirin Khosraviani, occupational therapist with Progressus Therapy; Susan Two-Coats, District seventh-grade teacher; and Ashley Edelhart Hall, District occupational therapist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties delivered oral closing arguments by telephone, and then the matter was closed and submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
This matter initially convened for hearing on April 8, 2004, before Hearing Officer Marilyn Woollard. Petitioner was represented by her mother, MOTHER, and the District was represented by attorney Joyce Paul. The hearing participants clarified the Petitioner’s hearing issues, including a claim that the District had denied Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) beginning in the 2000-2001 school year. Because the District had not previously had notice of this claim, Hearing Officer Woollard subsequently granted the District’s motion for a continuance of the hearing. The hearing was rescheduled to convene on April 29, 2004. As recounted in a summary order dated April 14, 2004, Hearing Officer Woollard also reminded Petitioner’s mother, MOTHER, that, pursuant to California Education Code section 56505(e)(7), the District had the right to receive, at least five business days prior to hearing, a copy of any documents Petitioner intended to introduce at hearing and a list of witnesses Petitioner intended to call. MOTHER indicated that any of the witnesses she would call were on the District’s witness list. At the hearing and also in the April 14 summary order, Hearing Officer Woollard advised Petitioner’s mother that the District may not call all of the witnesses on its list, that she should determine which witnesses she believed to be necessary to her case and so advise Ms. Paul [District’s counsel].
Thereafter, the parties agreed to continue the hearing until June 3, 2004, and subsequently agreed to take the case off calendar. In November 2004, the matter was placed back on calendar and scheduled to begin on December 16, 2004. On December 15, 2004, the Hearing Office granted Petitioner’s motion for a continuance of the hearing and rescheduled the hearing for January 2005.
On January 11, 2005, this matter convened for hearing before Hearing Officer Mark Brylski. MOTHER again appeared on behalf of Petitioner, while attorney Mary Kellogg represented the District. On that date, the parties engaged in settlement negotiations off the record and outside the presence of the hearing officer. As recounted in a memorandum dated January 12, 2005, Petitioner requested a continuance to obtain educational and/or legal opinions on the appropriateness of a written settlement offer made by the District. Over the District’s opposition, the Hearing Officer found good cause and granted a continuance to enable Petitioner to obtain counsel.... The hearing was continued until January 25, 2005.
When this matter convened before Hearing Officer Suzanne Brown on January 25, 2005, Petitioner had not provided the District with a list of witnesses Petitioner intended to call, despite the instructions to do so from Hearing Officer Woollard, memorialized in the written summary order dated April 14, 2004. At the hearing on January 25, 2005, the Hearing Officer asked Petitioner to identify the persons she would like to call as witnesses at the hearing. Petitioner identified several District employees who were not listed on the District’s current witness list, although most had been previously identified by attorney Joyce Paul on the District’s April 2004 witness list. The District objected to the lack of notice of Petitioner’s witnesses. Considering that Petitioner was not represented by an attorney, the Hearing Officer ruled that the District employees Petitioner identified would be permitted to testify despite Petitioner’s failure to identify the witnesses five business days in advance of the hearing. However, to minimize any prejudice to the District and also to allow time for the District to arrange for the appearance of those witnesses, the Hearing Officer ordered that those witnesses could appear to testify at a later date. Accordingly, after consultation with the parties, the Hearing Officer ordered that the hearing would go forward on January 25, but would not reconvene again until January 28, 2005. Neither party objected to this scheduling.
Petitioner also indicated that she wanted to call as a witness Dr. Karen Schiltz, a neuropsychologist who had conducted an assessment of STUDENT in July 2004. Petitioner stated that she could not afford to pay Dr. Schiltz’s hourly fees for expert testimony, and therefore requested that the District be ordered to pay for Dr. Schiltz’s appearance. The District objected to both the lack of notice of Dr. Schiltz’s appearance and the imposition of costs on the District. Unlike the District employees Petitioner identified as witnesses, Dr. Schiltz had never been listed on either party’s witness list. The Hearing Officer ruled that: (1) the District had not received the required advance notice that Dr. Schiltz would be called as a witness and (2) no basis existed to require the District to pay for Petitioner’s expert witness. For those reasons, the Hearing Officer denied Petitioner’s requests to call Dr. Schiltz as a witness and to order the District to pay Dr. Schiltz’s expert witness fees.
ISSUES
1. Are STUDENT’s claims arising prior to March 18, 2001, barred by the statute of limitations?
2. From September 2000 to the present, did the District fail to timely assess STUDENT’s occupational therapy (OT) needs and/or deny her a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to offer her a sufficient amount of OT services?
3. For the next six to twelve months, does STUDENT require the following to receive a FAPE:
(a) OT for two hours per week by a certified nonpublic agency (NPA); and (b) educational remediation for one hour per week?
4. If STUDENT was denied a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory education services of intensive OT for two hours per week by a certified NPA?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old girl who lives with her mother and sister within the boundaries of the District. She has been determined eligible for special education under the category of other health impairment (OHI), due to attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). She currently attends seventh grade in the District’s Patrick Henry Middle School.
STUDENT attended kindergarten through fifth grade at the District’s Andasol Elementary School (Andasol). In December 1999 and January 2000, when STUDENT was in third grade, the District conducted a special education assessment of her, but her individualized education program (IEP) team determined that she was not eligible. (Dist. Exhs. 11, 15; Pet. Exh. N.) At her mother’s request and a teacher’s suggestion, for the 2000-2001 school year STUDENT repeated third grade. In November 2000, the District conducted another special education assessment. As a result of that assessment, STUDENT’s IEP team determined that she was eligible for special education under the category of OHI, due to her attention deficits. Thereafter STUDENT remained in general education but also received resource specialist program (RSP) services pursuant to her IEP. (Dist. Exh. 12.) Her IEP also provided for instructional accommodations such as seating at the front of the room and teacher prompting to focus attention.
For the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT attended general education fourth grade and also received RSP services. On April 29, 2002, STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, requested that the District reassess STUDENT and also evaluate her in the area of occupational therapy (OT). District occupational therapist Ashley Edelhart Hall conducted that OT evaluation in June 2002, and conducted some additional testing in early September 2002. Ms. Hall determined that although STUDENT had many strengths in OT, she also had some needs in visual motor skills related to handwriting and in fine motor skills related to having a functional pencil grasp. (Footnote 1) Ms. Hall believed that these OT needs could be addressed either in the general education classroom or in OT services, and so she did not make a specific recommendation regarding whether OT services should be added to STUDENT’s IEP. (Dist. Exh. 1; testimony of Ms. Hall.) When the IEP team met in September 2002 to discuss the OT assessment, the team agreed to add thirty minutes of OT per week to STUDENT’s program.
Beginning in September 2002, STUDENT attended general education fifth grade and received RSP and OT services. In January and February 2003, occupational therapist Susan Pfau, who had been providing STUDENT’s OT services, conducted another OT assessment to determine if OT continued to be a necessary related service for STUDENT. Ms. Pfau’s assessment concluded that STUDENT did not have any areas of need related to school-based OT, and therefore the assessor did not recommend continuing OT as a related service for STUDENT. (Dist. Exh. 2.) Also in January 2003, the District conducted an assistive technology (AT) assessment of STUDENT. The AT assessment concluded in part that STUDENT demonstrated functional motor abilities to access her curriculum, using current strategies, accommodations and tools. The AT assessment also found that STUDENT did not require any AT devices for her penmanship, and instead recommended modifications such as adult prompting to remain on task and extended time for writing. (Dist. Exh. 18.)
The IEP team convened on February 7, 2003, to discuss the results of the new OT and AT evaluations. The IEP notes indicate that the District members of the IEP team determined that STUDENT did not need OT as a related service, but MOTHER disagreed with that determination. The IEP notes state that parent disagrees with assessment & wishes to initiate/continue due process. (Dist. Exh. 19.) Thereafter, STUDENT continued to receive thirty minutes of OT per week pursuant to the application of stay put. (Footnote 2)
In May 2003, STUDENT’s fifth-grade teacher, Lori Foster, recommended STUDENT for promotion to sixth grade despite STUDENT’s low scores on her report card and Performance Assignment, a writing test administered towards the end of the school year. (Pet. Exh. K; testimony of Ms. Foster.) The Justification For Promotion Form that Ms. Foster filled out in May 2003 justified the promotion to sixth grade on the grounds that previous report cards indicated continuous growth and progress towards grade level standards and that promotion was recommended by the IEP team.
In June 2003, STUDENT’s IEP team convened to discuss STUDENT’s transition from elementary school to middle school. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT should continue to receive RSP services for both language arts and math, and should continue to receive instructional accommodations such as adult prompting to remain on task and additional time to complete written assignments. (Dist. Exh. 3.) The IEP notes also indicate that STUDENT would continue to receive OT services for thirty minutes per week pursuant to stay put requirements, but that the District members of the IEP team continued to conclude that STUDENT did not need OT services.
In August and September 2003, the IEP team agreed to another OT assessment. Occupational therapist Niraj Jaju, an employee of the nonpublic agency Progressus Therapy, conducted this OT assessment. Mr. Jaju found that STUDENT obtained a low score on the Visual Motor Integration (VMI) test, but that despite this score she had functional classroom skills and did not demonstrate any areas of need in OT. (Dist. Exh. 4; testimony of Mr. Jaju.)
For the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT attended sixth grade at the District’s Patrick Henry Middle School (Patrick Henry). She continued to receive RSP services and thirty minutes per week of OT services. On September 25, 2003, STUDENT’s IEP team convened to discuss the results of Mr. Jaju’s OT assessment. The District members of the IEP team again recommended that STUDENT no longer receive OT services. MOTHER disagreed with this recommendation and dissented. The District instead offered sixty minutes per month of consultation between the occupational therapist and the resource specialist teacher, but MOTHER did not agree to that proposal. (Dist. Exh. 4.)
After the IEP meeting, on September 25 MOTHER went to the main office at Patrick Henry, told the clerk that she wanted to file for due process, and filled out a due process request form. (Testimony of MOTHER; see Pet. Exh. L.) MOTHER reported that, in December 2003, she telephoned Patrick Henry Middle School to inquire about the status of her due process request because she had not received anything in the mail. The clerk told MOTHER she would look into the matter. MOTHER reported that, in March 2004, she received a telephone call from the school clerk stating that the due process paperwork had been lost. On March 18, 2004, MOTHER returned to Patrick Henry and filled out another due process request form, which the Hearing Office received by facsimile (fax) the same day.
On April 8, 2004, this matter convened for hearing. As discussed above in the Procedural Matters section, the Hearing Officer granted the District’s request for continuance of the hearing due to new issues Petitioner identified at the hearing. Thereafter the parties participated in mediation and agreed that the District would fund an independent evaluation of STUDENT by clinical neuropsychologist Karen Schiltz.
In June 2004, STUDENT’s IEP team convened for its annual review, and noted that STUDENT continued to receive OT pursuant to stay put. In July 2004, Dr. Schiltz conducted a pediatric neurocognitive assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Schiltz’s final report, issued in September 2004, suggested several interventions and modifications for STUDENT, including two hours per week of intensive OT for a period of at least six months to one year, and educational remediation to address her difficulties with attention and concentration. (Pet. Exh. A.)
In fall 2004, STUDENT began seventh grade at Patrick Henry. On October 20, 2004, the IEP team convened to discuss Dr. Schiltz’s report. The team agreed to add some additional instructional accommodations that Dr. Schiltz recommended and agreed to distribute to STUDENT’s teachers Dr. Schiltz’s recommendations for classroom management behavior techniques, such as using verbal and written praise whenever possible. (Dist. Exh. 7.) MOTHER continued to disagree with the other members of the IEP team regarding OT services, and also disagreed with the other team members’ decision not to implement Dr. Schiltz’s recommendation for educational remediation.
ANALYSIS
1. Are STUDENT’s claims arising prior to March 18, 2001, barred by the statute of limitations?
Special education law requires the party seeking a due process hearing to initiate the hearing by filing a due process request with the Hearing Office. (34 C.F.R. ' 300.507(a), (c); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56501(a).) The statute of limitations in due process proceedings is three years. California Education Code sections 56043(p) and 56505(j) both limit the claims period as follows:
Any request for a due process hearing arising from subdivision (a) of Section 56501 shall be filed within three years from the date the party initiating the request knew or had reason to know of facts underlying the basis for the request.
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has explained that the legislative intent behind the IDEA included timely determinations of disputes, and accordingly envisioned that a disabled child’s representatives would file actions and apply for hearings on his behalf near the time the contested event occurred. (Alexopolous v. San Francisco Unified School District, 817 F.2d 551, 556 (9th Cir. 1987).)
In the present case, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s due process filing on March 18, 2004, which would permit Petitioner to raise claims from the time period beginning on March 18, 2001. However, Petitioner seeks to raise claims beginning on September 25, 2000. Petitioner did not dispute that her mother knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying her request at the time the events occurred; instead, Petitioner argued that her mother filled out the District’s due process request with the District on September 25, 2003, and relied on the representations of a District employee that the due process request would be sent to the Hearing Office. Petitioner argued that, in light of the District employee’s representation that the District would file the due process paperwork with the Hearing Office, the statute of limitations should not bar her claims unless they arose more than three years prior to September 25, 2003.
In contrast, the District argued that the obligation to file Petitioner’s due process request with the Hearing Office remained with MOTHER, not the District. The District pointed out that the District’s due process form specifically directs the parent to forward the form to the Hearing Office.
While special education law does not specifically address this issue, courts have addressed similar questions when considering a plaintiff’s failure to comply with the statute of limitations for filing a tort claim against a public agency. The courts have held that a public entity may be estopped from asserting the limitations of tort claims statutes where the agency’s agents or employees have deterred the filing of a timely claim by some affirmative act. (John R. v. Oakland Unified School Dist., 48 Cal.3d 438, 445 (1989).) Estoppel as a bar to a public entity's assertion of the defense of noncompliance with a claims statute arises when the plaintiff establishes by a preponderance of the evidence that: (1) the public entity was apprised of the facts, (2) it intended its conduct to be acted upon, (3) the plaintiff was ignorant of the true state of facts, and (4) the plaintiff relied upon the conduct to his detriment. (Johnson v. San Diego Unified School Dist., 217 Cal.App.3d 692, 700-701 (1990); DeYoung v. Del Mar Thoroughbred Club, 159 Cal.App.3d 858, 862 (1984).)
MOTHER testified that, on September 25, 2003, she went to the office at Patrick Henry Middle School and filled out the paperwork to file a due process request against the District. MOTHER testified that the clerk at the school, Gina Sarabia, said that she would forward the forms to Sacramento (the location of the Hearing Office) and the District office in Los Angeles. Shortly thereafter, Ms. Sarabia went on maternity leave. (Testimony of Mikie Douglas, MOTHER.)
By December 2003, MOTHER had not received anything in the mail regarding her due process filing, so she telephoned the middle school to inquire. The new school clerk, Debbie Arndt, told MOTHER that they did not have a due process request for STUDENT but she would look into it. In March 2004, Ms. Arndt informed MOTHER that the due process paperwork had been lost, so MOTHER filled out the form again and Ms. Arndt sent the form to the Hearing Office in Sacramento.
A document from Patrick Henry titled A Due Process Notification dated September 26, 2003, was stamped received by the District’s Special Education Division on September 30, 2003, and indicated that STUDENT’s parent filed a due process request at Patrick Henry on September 25, 2003. (Pet. Exh. L.) This document confirms that MOTHER did attempt to file a due process request at Patrick Henry on September 25, 2003. (Footnote 3)
However, other evidence supports the District’s claim that sending the due process request to the Hearing Office was the obligation of the parent, and that neither Ms. Sarabia nor any other District employee engaged in any affirmative act to make MOTHER believe otherwise. The District’s Due Process form contains a section entitled A Distribution Directions, which states that the school staff should send copies of the form to the District’s Special Education Division, while the parent should send the original copy of the request to the Hearing Office in Sacramento. Mikie Douglas, assistant principal at Patrick Henry, testified that generally the staff at Patrick Henry do not mail due process requests to the Hearing Office, because mailing the forms is left up to the parents. While Ms. Arndt, the new clerk at Patrick Henry, eventually faxed the due process request form to the Hearing Office on March 18, 2004, Ms. Arndt’s actions do not necessarily establish that Ms. Sarabia had promised to send the request to the Hearing Office in September 2003. Rather, Ms. Arndt’s actions established only that Ms. Arndt understood that MOTHER had intended to file the request with the Hearing Office, that no request had been filed, and therefore that Ms. Arndt was ensuring that the request got filed.
Thus, applying the four-part estoppel test identified above, Petitioner has not established that the District is barred by equitable estoppel in this case. Applying the first factor, the District was apprised of the fact that MOTHER sought to file a due process request. However, Petitioner has not established the second factor, i.e., that the District intended its conduct to be acted upon; in the present case, to establish that factor, Petitioner had to establish that Ms. Sarabia intended for MOTHER not to send a due process request to the Hearing Office in reliance on Ms. Sarabia sending it. MOTHER’s recounting of Ms. Sarabia’s statements are hearsay, and the instructions on the due process form MOTHER filled out contradict what Ms. Sarabia allegedly said. Thus, Petitioner has not established by a preponderance of the evidence that Ms. Sarabia represented that she would file the due process request with the Hearing Office, intending that MOTHER should rely on Ms. Sarabia to file the request. Moreover, regarding the third factor, Petitioner has not established that MOTHER was ignorant of the true facts, because the distribution directions on the due process form indicated that the parent should send the form to the Hearing Office. Considering that Petitioner has not established the second or third factors, this Decision need not analyze the fourth factor.
Accordingly, Petitioner has not established that the doctrine of equitable estoppel applies under the present facts. Therefore, the District may assert the statute of limitations in response to Petitioner’s due process claims. Additionally, Petitioner did not assert any other basis for tolling the statute limitations, such as that her mother did not know or have reason to know of the facts underlying the bases for her claims at the time the events occurred. The Hearing Officer notes that even if Petitioner had asserted tolling on this basis, the evidence indicates that MOTHER attended Petitioner’s IEP meetings and knew what services Petitioner was receiving. Thus, during the relevant time period, Petitioner’s mother knew or should have known of the facts underlying her claim. Consequently, because the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s due process claim on March 18, 2004, the three-year statute of limitations bars claims arising prior to March 18, 2001.
2. From September 2000 to the present, did the District fail to timely assess STUDENT’s occupational therapy (OT) needs and/or deny her a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to offer her a sufficient amount of OT services?
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. ' 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56000.) Under the IDEA and the decision of the U.S. Supreme Court in Board of Hendrick Hudson School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's needs, provide some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. The Rowley opinion held that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court ruled that school districts are required to provide only a basic floor of opportunity consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet the student’s unique needs and provide the student with some educational benefit. (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 207-208.)
Related services, called designated instruction and services (DIS) in California, shall be available when required for the student to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. (Cal. Educ. Code ' 56363(a); 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(22).) Occupational therapy is a type of related service that must be provided if necessary for the student to benefit from special education. (Cal. Educ. Code ' 56363(b)(6).)
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). Removal of a student from the regular education environment may occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in the regular education environment cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. ' 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. ' 300.550; Cal. Educ. Code ' 56301.)
Petitioner contended that the District should have assessed her in OT on or before September 25, 2000. Because the Hearing Office determined in Issue #1 that the statute of limitations bars Petitioner’s claims that arose prior to March 18, 2001, this Decision will analyze Petitioner’s claims beginning on that date.
March 2001 through the end of the 2001-2002 school year
Petitioner contended that the District should have assessed her in OT on or before March 18, 2001. Petitioner argued that because the District did not assess her in OT, it failed to assess her in all areas of suspected disability, and failed to provide her with a FAPE to the extent she did not receive OT services during this period.
Before any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs, an assessment of the pupil’s educational needs shall be conducted. (Cal. Educ. Code ' 56320.) Thereafter, special education students must be reassessed every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests a new assessment and that a new IEP be developed. (Cal. Educ. Code ' 56381.) The student must be assessed in all areas related to his or her suspected disability. (20 U.S.C. ' 1414(a)(2), (b)(3)(C); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56320(f).)
The District conducted a special education assessment of STUDENT in October and November 2000, pursuant to an assessment plan dated September 27, 2000. (Dist. Exh. 8.) That plan included assessment in motor development and perceptual development by a school psychologist, but did not provide for assessment by an occupational therapist. The District did not conduct an OT assessment of STUDENT until June 2002, pursuant to a request by MOTHER on April 29, 2002. (Pet. Exh. P.)
Thus, the question is whether OT was an area of suspected disability for STUDENT for the period from March 18, 2001 to the end of the 2001-2002 school year. (Footnote 4) STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT had severe weaknesses in fine motor skills, particularly related to handwriting, and that as a result she needed OT services. MOTHER testified that STUDENT received poor grades during the 2000-2001 school year, the year she repeated third grade. MOTHER reported that when STUDENT wrote a condolence letter to a friend that year, she wrote the letter backwards, so that it had to be read in a mirror. MOTHER also described how, during the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT was working on a report and took hours trying to retype a single page, even though she was familiar with the computer keyboard.
District occupational therapist Ashley Edelhart Hall reviewed STUDENT’s records and conducted an OT assessment in June 2002. (Footnote 5) Ms. Hall explained that the results of the November 2000 psychological assessment report conducted by a District school psychologist did not support a referral for OT, primarily due to STUDENT’s scoring in the average range for her age on visual perception testing related to OT. STUDENT received a standard score of 104 on the Motor-Free Visual Perception Test-Revised (MVPT-R) and a standard score of 102 on the Beery VMI. (Dist. Exh. 15.) Thus, these results from the November 2000 assessment do not depict a student who had a suspected disability in the area of OT from March 2001 through the end of the 2001-2002 school year.
Additionally, the evidence from STUDENT’s teachers at the time confirmed that handwriting was an area of difficulty, but did not otherwise indicate that OT was an area of suspected disability. Robert Romero, STUDENT’s third-grade teacher during the 2000-2001 school year, testified that STUDENT had poor handwriting that was below grade-level standards and often had problems writing on the lines and forming her letters correctly. Nonetheless, her handwriting was legible. Mr. Romero testified that STUDENT did not show any difficulties with motor skills and did not appear to need OT services. He explained that while STUDENT was below grade level in his class, it was not due to problems with handwriting. Mr. Romero stated that, when STUDENT was in his class, he was more concerned with her lack of motivation than her poor handwriting. (Footnote 6)
STUDENT’s RSP teacher, Doug Howard, also noted STUDENT’s poor handwriting, but did not otherwise observe OT-related difficulties in the classroom setting. Mr. Howard assessed STUDENT and worked with her from December 1999 until October 2001; thereafter, he became an assistant principal and attended STUDENT’s IEP meetings as an administrator. According to Mr. Howard’s testimony and December 1999 assessment report, STUDENT’s handwriting skills were below grade level, although he observed improvement during the period he worked with her. (Pet. Exh. N.) Mr. Howard testified that STUDENT’s handwriting was messy and she had difficulty with letter formation, but also reported that her handwriting was legible and that she was able to access the instruction in his RSP classroom despite her poor handwriting. Mr. Howard acknowledged that STUDENT’s mother had expressed concerns about STUDENT’s ability to copy down notes, but stated that he did not recall STUDENT having any particular difficulty with copying. Mr. Howard noted that STUDENT had weaknesses in visual-motor skills and attention, but did not have an opinion about whether STUDENT needed OT services. Mr. Howard explained that he would have recommended OT services for STUDENT if he had thought they were necessary.
Hence, the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers did not indicate that OT was an area of suspected disability; instead, their testimony established that while STUDENT had difficulty with handwriting during the relevant time period, OT was not an area of suspected disability. That testimony was also consistent with the findings of the November 2000 assessment, which did not indicate OT was an area of suspected disability. In light of this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that OT was not an area of suspected disability from March 2001 to the end of the 2001-2002 school year.
2002-2003 school year
Overall, STUDENT was a pleasant, well-behaved fifth-grade student with average cognitive ability, strengths in verbal skills and creative activities, and weaknesses in math, writing, and attention. (Dist. Exhs. 17, 19; testimony of Lori Foster.) There is no dispute that she needed academic assistance in math and writing, and that she received RSP services to address those needs. There is also no dispute that she needed assistance and modifications to address her short attention span and distractibility, and that she received modifications in the classroom and RSP setting to address her attentional issues. As noted previously, Ms. Hall conducted an OT assessment of STUDENT in June 2002. When the IEP team convened to discuss the results of that assessment, the team agreed to add thirty minutes per week of OT services. Thus, STUDENT’s September 2002 IEP contained goals in math, written language, attention, and OT/visual motor skills. (Dist. Exhs. 17, 19.) STUDENT’s IEP goal for OT involved writing in cursive while copying from a board, for the purpose of improving her visual motor skills.
As noted above, a school district must provide related services to a special education student when those services are required for him or her to benefit educationally from the instructional program. (Cal. Educ. Code ' 56363(a); 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(22).) Petitioner contended that the thirty minutes of OT per week that the District provided during this period was insufficient because she needed two hours of OT per week to benefit from her instructional program. In contrast, the District argued that STUDENT did not need any OT services as of February 2003, and in any event that the thirty minutes per week she received was sufficient to address her needs. Because the District continued to provide thirty minutes of OT per week during the entire 2002-2003 school year, this Decision will examine only whether that amount was sufficient to address STUDENT’s needs during this time period.
The September 2002 IEP team’s decision to add thirty minutes per week of OT services was based in large part upon the results of the June 2002 OT assessment conducted by District occupational therapist Ashley Edelhart Hall. In that assessment, Ms. Hall concluded that STUDENT had adequate to above-average skills in many areas related to OT, including visual perceptual skills, sensory processing skills, sensory discrimination, self-help skills, range of motion (ROM), postural stability, and most fine motor skills. (Dist. Exh. 1.) The only areas of concern Ms. Hall detected were in visual motor skills, as well as fine motor skills related only to STUDENT’s inefficient positioning of her pencil when writing. On the Beery Visual Motor Integration (VMI) test, STUDENT received a score of 86, which was in the low average range. Ms. Hall described how STUDENT had some difficulty with handwriting, particularly cursive writing. STUDENT’s writing was often messy and occasionally could be illegible, primarily because she would correct written errors by writing over her work without first erasing the mistakes. In light of the findings of her OT assessment, Ms. Hall concluded that STUDENT’s needs related to OT could be addressed in the classroom or through OT services, and therefore Ms. Hall did not make a recommendation to the IEP team in this regard. Ms. Hall explained that she believed the IEP team’s subsequent agreement for thirty minutes of OT per week was possibly excessive, but she did not otherwise disagree with it.
However, in January and February 2003, District occupational therapist Susan Pfau conducted an OT assessment and concluded that STUDENT no longer needed OT services. (Dist. Exh. 2.) Like the June 2002 OT assessment, the January/February 2003 assessment again noted STUDENT’s strengths related to OT, including range of motion, postural stability, visual perceptual skills, sensory processing, and sensory discrimination. Regarding visual motor skills, the area of need identified in the June 2002 OT assessment, Ms. Pfau wrote in part that STUDENT had made gains in handwriting since the June 2002 OT assessment. Ms. Pfau acknowledged that STUDENT still had difficulty with legibility and completing classroom assignments, but also noted that STUDENT wrote legibly when she slowed down and focused.
Ms. Hall, who conducted STUDENT’s OT assessment in June 2002, testified that she agreed with Ms. Pfau’s findings. Ms. Hall explained that she provided STUDENT’s OT services from February to June 2003, and the level of work she observed from STUDENT at that time was consistent with Ms. Pfau’s report. Ms. Hall testified that by February 2003, after five months of OT services, STUDENT had made progress in handwriting and had met the OT goal on her IEP. Ms. Hall indicated that, when she worked with STUDENT from February to June 2003, STUDENT could do written tasks without accommodations, did not make letter substitutions or letter reversals, and had legible handwriting that improved when she slowed down and focused on it.
Thus, while there is no question that STUDENT had difficulty with academic work during the 2002-2003 school year, particularly with cursive handwriting, the evidence does not support Petitioner’s contention that she needed more than thirty minutes of OT services per week. Petitioner argued that Ms. Hall’s report was not persuasive because it was Arushed and because, at one point on page three of the OT report, Ms. Hall referred to STUDENT by the wrong name. Ms. Hall explained in her testimony that this minor error was an oversight that did not affect the accuracy or validity of the rest of the report. The Hearing Officer found that Ms. Hall’s report was thorough and consistent with the other OT assessment reports submitted into evidence. During her testimony, Ms. Hall explained the findings in her report, and gave informative and credible answers to the questions posed. In light of these circumstances, the Hearing Officer found Ms. Hall’s testimony and report to be persuasive.
Additionally, the testimony of STUDENT’s fifth-grade teacher was generally consistent with the evidence from the occupational therapists. While Ms. Foster reported that STUDENT had difficulty with letter formation and spacing between words, and had difficulty transferring words from the chalkboard to paper, Ms. Foster also stated that STUDENT’s handwriting was poor but legible, and that STUDENT could likely have improved her handwriting by slowing down and not rushing through her work. Ms. Foster testified that STUDENT received poor grades that year and was not grasping the material, but that Ms. Foster did not believe STUDENT’s academic difficulties were related to her handwriting.
The only evidence supporting Petitioner’s contention was her mother’s testimony describing how Petitioner had difficulties with writing and with copying. While the Hearing Officer believed that MOTHER testified honestly regarding her observations, the Hearing Office found more persuasive the occupational therapists who assessed STUDENT, because they had greater knowledge about visual motor weaknesses and greater understanding regarding to what extent STUDENT needed OT services. Moreover, as discussed further below, two other occupational therapists subsequently confirmed Ms. Pfau’s and Ms. Hall’s findings. Hence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not need more than thirty minutes of OT services per week during the 2002-2003 school year. Therefore, the District’s provision of thirty minutes per week of OT services did not deny STUDENT a FAPE.
2003-2004 school year
For the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT attended sixth grade at the District’s Patrick Henry Middle School. As a middle school student, STUDENT had multiple teachers and classes: she attended RSP for math and English, and general education classes for her other subjects. Pursuant to her June 2003 IEP, DIS counseling of twenty minutes per month was added to her program. Her IEP provided for accommodations and modifications of adult prompting to remain on task, use of a multiplication chart as needed, and additional time to complete written assignments. She continued to receive OT services for thirty minutes per week pursuant to stay put. Thus, as with the 2002-2003 school year, the issue to be determined is whether STUDENT required more than thirty minutes per week of OT services.
As in fifth grade, STUDENT continued to be a well-behaved student who had strengths in verbal skills and weaknesses in math, writing, and attention. (Pet. Exhs. H, I, J; Dist. Exhs. 3, 6; testimony of Mary Demetrion.) STUDENT’s RSP teacher, Shirley Parry, wrote that her greatest area of concern was STUDENT’s inability to sustain focus, although Mary Demetrion, STUDENT’s social studies teacher, testified that attention was not a particular problem for STUDENT in social studies class. (Pet. Exh. H; testimony of Ms. Demetrion.) STUDENT continued to have poor handwriting, although Ms. Demetrion explained that STUDENT’s handwriting was nevertheless legible and did not hinder her academic progress. (Testimony of Ms. Demetrion; Pet. Exh. B.) Ms. Parry wrote that STUDENT often works quickly and her work can be sloppy at times, but when admonished, she can turn out very good products. (Pet. Exh. H.)
Regarding OT needs, in light of the disagreement between the District and Petitioner’s mother regarding the January/February 2003 OT assessment results, the parties agreed to another OT assessment, funded by the District. Occupational therapist Niraj Jaju of Progressus Occupational Therapy tested STUDENT in August and September 2003, and also reviewed her records, interviewed her mother and teachers, reviewed her work samples, and observed her in class and in the OT clinic. (Footnote 7) (Dist. Exh. 4.) Mr. Jaju found that STUDENT was at adequate to above-average levels in all areas of OT, including range of motion, strength, postural stability, visual perception, fine motor skills, sensory processing, and self-help skills. Although STUDENT’s score on the Beery VMI was only 72, which is below average, Mr. Jaju found that she nevertheless had adequate visual motor skills to function in the classroom. Mr. Jaju reported that STUDENT could accurately form letters, could write on the lines of the paper, could copy from a book and could copy from the board. Regarding handwriting, Mr. Jaju testified that STUDENT’s handwriting did not interfere with her accessing her education, and that STUDENT possessed the baseline skills for writing, which is what an occupational therapist looks for. Mr. Jaju explained that STUDENT’s poor handwriting did not warrant OT services, and that OT services could not treat STUDENT’s attentional issues. Moreover, Mr. Jaju stated that STUDENT could work on the quality of her handwriting by practicing and by using the Handwriting Without Tears program, which does not require the involvement of an occupational therapist. In light of his findings, Mr. Jaju concurred that STUDENT did not need OT services.
Consistent with Mr. Jaju’s conclusions, Shirin Khosraviani, the occupational therapist who has worked with STUDENT since September 2003, likewise testified that STUDENT did not need OT services. (Footnote 8) Ms. Khosraviani testified that she agreed with the summary of STUDENT’s motor/OT performance level contained in the June 2004 IEP, which identified many areas of OT as strengths for STUDENT and stated that there were no areas of need related to school-based OT. (Dist. Exh. 6.) Ms. Khosraviani described how STUDENT could write quickly, could write on the lines of the paper, used good spacing of letters and words, did not make letter substitutions or reversals, and could complete writing tasks during OT sessions without the need for redirection. Regarding teacher reports of STUDENT’s poor handwriting, Ms. Khosraviani explained that poor handwriting does not warrant OT services so long as the student’s handwriting is functional for the classroom, as STUDENT’s was. Ms. Khosraviani stated that she can read STUDENT’s handwriting without difficulty, and pointed to STUDENT’s work samples of legible printing and cursive writing. (Dist. Exh. 20.)
The testimony from the occupational therapists that STUDENT’s handwriting was sufficient to allow her to function in the classroom was consistent with the testimony of Ms. Demetrion, as noted above. Additionally, STUDENT’s grades for the 2003-2004 school year were consistent with the witnesses’ position that STUDENT could access the classroom; STUDENT received all Cs in her core academic classes for the fall semester, and in the spring semester her grades improved to three Bs and one C in those classes. (Dist. Exh. 23.)
Thus, occupational therapists Niraj Jaju and Shirin Khosraviani both testified credibly that STUDENT did not require OT services during the 2003-2004 school year. The only relevant evidence that contradicted the occupational therapists’ recommendations was contained in the pediatric neurocognitive assessment from Dr. Karen Schiltz. The District funded Dr. Schiltz’s assessment pursuant to an agreement reached between the parties. Dr. Schiltz tested STUDENT in July 2004, and issued her report in September 2004. Dr. Schiltz’s assessment report constituted a thorough assessment in numerous areas, and included cognitive testing, academic achievement testing, social-emotional testing, a review of records, observations, and interviews and questionnaires of STUDENT, her mother, and her teachers. Related to OT, STUDENT scored a 76 on Dr. Schiltz’s administration of the VMI. Dr. Schiltz wrote that STUDENT had difficulty with graphomotor skills that are fundamental to handwriting. (Pet. Exh. A, p. 13.) In her recommendations, Dr. Schiltz wrote that occupational therapy (OT) is a medical/educational necessity and recommended two hours per week of intensive OT services for six months to one year, with a review of STUDENT’s progress thereafter. Dr. Schiltz suggested aids such as the Handwriting Without Tears program, a keyboard with a voice notebook device called the Palm Zire 72, and the Type To Learn software. Dr. Schiltz also wrote that all goals and objectives will be deferred to the occupational therapist. (Pet. Exh. A, p. 14.)
All three of the occupational therapists who testified explained that only registered occupational therapists are qualified to assess OT needs, and that Dr. Schiltz’s OT recommendations were outside the scope of her practice and should not be given any weight because she is not a registered occupational therapist. Dr. Schiltz’s curriculum vita confirms that, while she is an experienced psychologist with a specialty in clinical neuropsychology, she is not a registered occupational therapist and does not possess any degrees or other credentials in OT. (Pet. Exh. Q; Dist. Exh. 24.) Dr. Schiltz’s recommendations for OT services contradicted the testimony of all three registered occupational therapists who testified, and the Hearing Officer has already found that those witnesses were credible and persuasive. Moreover, Ms. Khosraviani and Mr. Jaju explained that the intervention Dr. Schiltz suggested -- Handwriting Without Tears -- could be implemented in the classroom or in RSP and did not require the intervention of an occupational therapist. Ms. Khosraviani also testified that the other measures Dr. Schiltz suggested -- Palm Zire 72 and Type To Learn -- are assistive technology tools, not OT tools. In light of all of this information, the Hearing Officer finds the testimony and reports from the registered occupational therapists to be more persuasive regarding STUDENT’s OT needs than Dr. Schiltz’s recommendations for OT.
Hence, the great weight of evidence established that STUDENT did not need more than thirty minutes per week of OT services for the 2003-2004 school year. Therefore, the District’s provision of only thirty minutes per week of OT services did not deny STUDENT a FAPE.
2004-2005 school year through March 2005
For the current school year, STUDENT is attending seventh grade at Patrick Henry Middle School. She continues to attend RSP for her math class and otherwise attends general education classes, although she receives some RSP support for her English class. She continues to receive DIS counseling for twenty minutes per month and OT services for thirty minutes per week. Her IEP includes accommodations and modifications such as extended time, priority seating, and verbal and nonverbal cues to stay on task. In October 2004, the IEP team added additional accommodations, such as a notetaker, pursuant to recommendations from Dr. Schiltz’s assessment report. As with the 2003-2004 school year, the issue to be determined is whether thirty minutes per month was a sufficient amount of OT to meet her needs for the relevant time period.
In seventh grade, STUDENT has continued to have the same general areas of need as in the prior year, although her grades of As and Bs in the fall semester of seventh grade indicate some improvement. STUDENT’s seventh-grade English teacher, Susan Two-Coats, described some difficulties STUDENT has with writing: while STUDENT’s printing is legible, her writing has poor spacing, she sometimes smashes words together, and she has difficulty copying from the board. Ms. Two-Coats testified that she implements STUDENT’s IEP accommodations, such as seating STUDENT in the front of the class and allowing extra time for writing assignments. Ms. Two-Coats testified that STUDENT does not have adequate handwriting to function in Ms. Two-Coats’s classroom without accommodations, but that with the accommodations STUDENT can function in the classroom and access the material. Like STUDENT’s sixth-grade social studies teacher, Ms. Two-Coats testified that STUDENT’s oral skills are stronger than her written skills.
As discussed above, Ms. Khosraviani continues to provide STUDENT with OT for thirty minutes per week, and continues to believe that STUDENT does not need OT services and does not have any needs related to school-based OT. The Hearing Officer determined above that STUDENT did not require more than thirty minutes of OT for the 2003-2004 school year. Given that STUDENT continues to have the same general areas of need, the Hearing Officer reaches the same conclusion regarding the current school year. While Ms. Two-Coats described some areas of difficulty for STUDENT with handwriting, that testimony did not establish that STUDENT needed additional OT services, particularly in light of Ms. Two-Coats’s testimony that STUDENT can function in the classroom when her IEP accommodations are implemented. In light of the persuasive testimony from Ms. Khosraviani and Mr. Jaju that OT services will not address STUDENT’s poor handwriting, and Ms. Two-Coats’ testimony that STUDENT can function in the classroom with accommodations, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not need more than thirty minutes of OT services from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year through March 2005. Accordingly, the District’s provision of only thirty minutes of OT per week during this time period did not constitute a denial of FAPE.
* * * * * * * *
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that OT was not an area of suspected disability for the time period of March 2001 through the end of the 2001-2002 school year. The Hearing Officer further determines that STUDENT did not require more than thirty minutes per week of OT services from September 2002 to the present, and therefore that the District’s provision of thirty minutes per week of OT services did not constitute a denial of FAPE.
5. For the next six to twelve months, does STUDENT require the following in order to receive a FAPE:
(a) OT for two hours per week by a certified nonpublic agency (NPA);
The Hearing Officer has already determined that STUDENT did not require more than thirty minutes of OT per week from September 2002 to the present. The next question is whether STUDENT needs OT services for the next six to twelve months to receive a FAPE.
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found persuasive the testimony of occupational therapists Niraj Jaju and Shirin Khosraviani in determining that STUDENT did not need more than the thirty minutes per week of OT that she received. As described above, Mr. Jaju and Ms. Khosraviani explained that STUDENT did not need OT services. While Dr. Karen Schiltz recommended in a neurocognitive report that STUDENT should receive two hours of OT services per week, the Hearing Officer has already concluded that, because Dr. Schiltz is not a registered occupational therapist and has less expertise in OT than the occupational therapist witnesses, the testimony of the occupational therapists was more persuasive than Dr. Schiltz’s findings and recommendations regarding OT. For the same reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of Ms. Khosraviani and Mr. Jaju regarding STUDENT’s need for OT services in the future is more persuasive than the recommendations of Dr. Schiltz. Ms. Khosraviani’s and Mr. Jaju’s explanations that STUDENT does not need direct OT services are also consistent with the earlier findings of Ms. Hall and Ms. Pfau that STUDENT did not need OT services. The information from the occupational therapists is also consistent with the testimony from STUDENT’s current English teacher, Ms. Two-Coats, that with STUDENT’s IEP accommodations she can function in the classroom and access the material. Considering all of this evidence, the evidence established that STUDENT does not need OT services at this time.
(b) educational remediation for one hour per week?
In a brief paragraph towards the end of her lengthy assessment report, in a section entitled Intervention Suggestions, Dr. Schiltz wrote the following:
Educational remediation would be suggested given the attentional and concentrational difficulty. Advisement concerning her study skills, test-taking skills, and strategies to improve planning and organizational skills is recommended.
Petitioner asserts that she requires educational remediation as Dr. Schiltz suggested.
As discussed above, STUDENT is currently attending general education seventh grade. She attends one RSP class in math and also receives RSP assistance for English. Her IEP also provides for instructional accommodations and DIS counseling. The parties agree that STUDENT continues to have needs in math, written language, and attention, and do not dispute that STUDENT’s IEP goals for math, written language, and vocational education (voc. ed)/attention are designed to address her unique needs. At STUDENT’s June 2004 IEP meeting, the team agreed that she had met her goals and objectives in written language and voc. ed/attention. The team also agreed that STUDENT had made progress in math, although she had not achieved the level of mastery required to meet her math goals and objectives. (Dist. Exh. 6.)
As discussed above, both STUDENT’s sixth-grade social studies teacher and her seventh-grade English teacher indicated that STUDENT can function in the classroom with the accommodations in her IEP. Both teachers persuasively testified that STUDENT does not require additional tutoring beyond the RSP services she already receives. Moreover, STUDENT has received good grades in middle school, particularly in the current school year; last semester she received As in math and band and Bs in her other classes. (Dist. Exh. 23.) In light of all of the evidence to the contrary, Dr. Schiltz’s general suggestion did not establish that STUDENT needs educational remediation in addition to the RSP services and instructional accommodations she already receives.
6. If STUDENT was denied a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory education services of intensive OT for two hours per week by a certified NPA?
Because the Hearing Officer determined above that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE, there is no basis for an award of compensatory education services.
ORDER
Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on all claims heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).)
Dated: April 1, 2005 ______________________________ Suzanne B. Brown, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
This Decisions references to handwriting are intended to include both printing and cursive writing. 2 MOTHER did not file a due process hearing request with the Hearing Office prior to the present case. There is nothing in the evidence indicating whether she and the District pursued some form of alternative dispute resolution apart from that available through the Hearing Office. 3 All requests for due process hearing must be filed with the Superintendent of Public Instruction or the Superintendent’s designee, if one has been designated. (Cal. Educ. Code ' 56502(a).) In September 2003, the Superintendent’s designee was the Hearing Office at University of Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law in Sacramento, California. 4 MOTHER requested the OT assessment at an IEP meeting on April 29, 2002, and the results of the assessment were presented at an IEP meeting on September 24, 2002. The Hearing Officer notes that a school district has a period of fifty days from the date it receives the parent’s written consent for assessment, excluding vacation and days when school is not in session, to complete the assessment and develop an IEP, unless the parent agrees in writing to an extension. (Cal. Educ. Code ' 56344(a).) In the present case, there was no issue regarding the District’s compliance with the time line. 5 Ms. Hall is a registered occupational therapist. She has been as an occupational therapist for ten years, working for the District for the last four and a half years. She has a bachelor’s degree in occupational therapy and has advanced practice certifications in specialized areas of OT. (Testimony of Ms. Hall; Dist. Exh. 24.) 6 Mr. Romero explained that STUDENT had initially been promoted to fourth grade, but then was sent to Mr. Romero’s third-grade class after a few weeks. Mr. Romero observed that, because of these circumstances, STUDENT frequently seemed despondent and unmotivated in his class, although her attitude improved as the school year went on. 7 Mr. Jaju is a registered occupational therapist who possesses a bachelor’s degree in occupational therapy. Mr. Jaju testified that he has worked as an occupational therapist for Progressus Therapy for the past two years, and prior to that worked as an occupational therapist in Oklahoma for seven months. 8 Ms. Khosraviani is a registered occupational therapist who possesses a bachelor’s degree in kinesiology and a master’s degree in occupational therapy. Ms. Khosraviani has worked as an occupational therapist since October 2001, and has worked for Progressus Occupational Therapy for the past two years.
