California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 18, 2003

Student v. Long Beach Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 621-03 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary

Long Beach Unified denied FAPE for three school years; Hearing Officer orders comprehensive independent assessment and defers compensatory education.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The Hearing Officer retained jurisdiction to decide compensatory education after reviewing the court-ordered assessments and the proposed 2003-2004 IEP. Any further remedy orders are not part of this document.

Summary

A 17-year-old with Down syndrome and profound mental retardation (now called intellectual disability) was represented by his mother. She challenged his program at Long Beach Unified's Lakewood High School for 2000-2001 through 2002-2003. He had been in District programs since age three but was still nonverbal, was not toilet trained, and was becoming more aggressive. The Hearing Officer found that the District denied a FAPE in all three years. In 2000-2001, the District held the IEP meeting without either parent. It accepted consent from the group home administrator, who had no educational authority. For 2001-2002, the District never produced the IEP and could not meet its burden of proof. That year's program also lacked a one-to-one aide and effective communication and toilet-training instruction. The December 2002 IEP had no aide and no goals for toileting, fine motor, or independence skills. A January 2003 addendum cut him to one hour a day of home instruction without addressing his behavior. The March 2003 shortened-day offer still ignored his communication and life-skills needs. The District's 2000 triennial review was also inadequate. The Hearing Officer ordered the District to produce records, propose a comprehensive assessment by independent professionals, and hold an IEP meeting on the results. No evidence supported the requested nonpublic school placement. Compensatory education was deferred.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated consent from a group home administrator as invalid when no one had given her educational authority. It also shows that a district's failure to produce IEPs defeated its burden of proof. Finally, the Hearing Officer ordered assessments first and kept jurisdiction to set compensatory education later.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during the 2000-2001 school year?

    The District held the November 2000 IEP meeting without either parent and accepted the group home administrator's consent although she had no educational authority. This critical procedural error denied FAPE, so substantive claims were not reached.

  2. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during the 2001-2002 school year?

    The District never produced the 2001-2002 IEP and could not carry its burden on procedure. The program also failed to meet the student's needs for one-to-one instruction, communication, and toilet training.

  3. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 3. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during the 2002-2003 school year?

    The December 2002 IEP had no aide and no goals for toileting, fine motor, or independence skills. The January 2003 addendum cut him to one hour a day of home instruction without addressing behavior. The March 2003 shortened-day offer with an aide still did not address communication or life skills. None offered FAPE.

  4. Issue 4. Is the Petitioner entitled to a multidisciplinary independent educational assessment at the District's expense?

    The request made in the pre-hearing motion and at hearing was enough. The 2000 triennial review, with no review of assessment data and no parent input, was not appropriate. The District must have a comprehensive assessment done by qualified independent professionals.

  5. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 5. If the District failed to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during any of the above-stated school years, is he entitled to a remedy and, if so, what is that remedy?

    The student is entitled to a remedy. Prospective placement at the Speech and Language Development Center was not supported by evidence. Compensatory education is deferred until after the assessment, and the Hearing Officer retains jurisdiction.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Within 10 calendar days, the District must give the Hearing Officer and the mother all IEPs covering any part of 2000-2001, 2001-2002, and 2002-2003, all assessment reports the IEP teams reviewed, and all documents from the last comprehensive assessment.
  • Order to assess. Within 15 calendar days, the District must submit to the Hearing Officer a proposed plan for a comprehensive assessment by independent, qualified professionals, with each assessor's identity, curriculum vitae, and assessment area. The assessors must include a physician, a developmental psychologist, an educational psychologist, an occupational therapist, an augmentative/assistive communication specialist, and others as needed for vision, hearing, motor abilities, general intelligence, communicative status, self-help, orientation and mobility, and social-emotional status. Assessors must address what an appropriate 2000-2003 program would have been, the progress it could have produced, and compensatory placement and services. The District must give assessors all relevant documents.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. After the assessment, the IEP team must consider the results and propose a prospective IEP for 2003-2004, with a copy to the Hearing Officer.
  • Placement ordered. Until his 2003-2004 placement is determined, the student stays in a placement at Lakewood High School with a one-to-one aide. The parties may increase his time at school.
  • The Hearing Officer retains jurisdiction to decide compensatory education and issue further orders after reviewing the assessment reports and the proposed IEP.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range School District; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri; Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5; Cal. Educ. Code § 48884; Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b)

People named in the decision

  • Susan Melly, SELPA administrator; District representative on first day of hearing, Long Beach Unified SELPA
  • G. Robert Roice, educational consultant; District representative, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Merrie Lyn Shickler, District administrator, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Marissa Tunstall, group home administrator and case manager; witness for Student, Group home (BCH-1)
  • Kathy Dadourian, coordinator of nonpublic school placements, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Loan Tran Wendt, school psychologist, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Erica Paizer (also spelled Pazier), special day class teacher, Lakewood High School
  • Charlotte Bockholt, special education team leader, Lakewood High School
  • Selina Calloway, 1:1 instructional aide, Lakewood High School
  • Jill Jeffery, assistive technology specialist, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Mr. Willert, special day class teacher, Lakewood High School
  • Dr. Gandolfo, consulting psychologist for group home, Group home (BCH-1)
  • Rosario Santiago, former group home administrator listed in District records as guardian, Group home (BCH-1)
  • Harbor Regional Center, regional center
  • Speech & Language Development Center, nonpublic school requested by parent, Buena Park, CA

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Long Beach, California, on May 21, 22 and 23, 2003.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his mother, PARENT (Parent or Ms. PARENT).

Respondent Long Beach Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented on the first day of hearing by Susan Melly, administrator of the special education local plan area (SELPA). On the second and third days of hearing, the District was represented by educational consultant G. Robert Roice. Merrie Lyn Shickler, a District administrator, was also present at various times throughout the hearing.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: FAMILY FRIEND 1, FAMILY FRIEND 2, FAMILY FRIEND 3, and FAMILY FRIEND 4, all friends of Ms. PARENT who had observed STUDENT with his mother at her office, at his school, or at Best Care Home No. 1 (BCH-1), the group home where he has resided for many years. Petitioner also called FAMILY FRIEND 5, another friend of Ms. PARENT who is a licensed speech and language pathologist and college professor, and Marissa Tunstall, the person who has been primarily responsible for STUDENT’s health and welfare as his case manager and the administrator at BCH-1, for at least the last three years.

The District called the following witness: Kathy Dadourian, the coordinator of nonpublic school (NPS) placements for the District; Loan Tran Wendt, the District’s school psychologist; Erica Paizer, STUDENT’s SDC teacher for most of his first three years at Lakewood High School (Lakewood); Charlotte Bockholt, the team leader for the special education students at Lakewood; and Selina Calloway, recently assigned as a one-to-one instructional aide to STUDENT.

The oral and documentary evidence was presented at the hearing. Closing arguments of the parties were heard, and the record was closed on May 23, 2003.

ISSUES (Footnote 1)

Issue No 1: Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during the 2000-2001 school year?

Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during the 2001-2002 school year?

Issue No. 3: Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during the 2002-2003 school year?

Issue No. 4: Is the Petitioner entitled to a multidisciplinary independent educational assessment at the District’s expense?

Issue No. 5: If the District failed to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during any of the above-stated school years, is he entitled to a remedy and, if so, what is that remedy?

CONTENTIONS

The Petitioner claims, generally, that although he has been a student in the District’s programs since he was three years old, he has little of benefit to show for it.(Footnote 2) Now seventeen years six months old, Petitioner alleges that he has no effective communication system, continues to wear diapers, and is not prepared for independence. He contends that his aggressive behaviors, for which the District prohibited him from attending school, were caused by his disability. Petitioner requests that the Hearing Officer find that the District has failed to provide him a FAPE during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, and 2002-2003 school years. As a remedy, he seeks an order that the District funds a multidisciplinary independent educational assessment. In addition, he seeks his prospective placement at the Speech & Language Development Center in Buena Park, CA, a nonpublic school (NPS) that focuses on the development of communication skills.(Footnote 3) The District generally claims that the placement and program it has provided to STUDENT for the last three years has been appropriate. It asserts that STUDENT is a profoundly mentally retarded young man and that his individualized education plans (IEPs) have met his unique needs and provided him with an educational benefit. The District also asserts that prior to the hearing Petitioner’s parent had expressed no disagreement with the District’s assessments and had made no request for an independent assessment. The District requests that the Hearing Officer find that it has provided a FAPE to Petitioner and that all claims to relief be denied.

BACKGROUND

STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old (DOB: [date redacted]) young man who has been attending schools and programs within the District since he was three years old. His parents are the late Mr. PARENT and Ms. PARENT.(Footnote 4) STUDENT’s diagnosis is profound mental retardation and Down syndrome. It is possible that STUDENT also has some autistic tendencies, though the existence and nature of these have not been determined.

STUDENT has long been a client of Harbor Regional Center (HRC). Pursuant to an agreement between the parents and HRC, STUDENT has been living for many years in a group care home, BCH-1.(Footnote 5) During the many years of STUDENT’s residence at BCH-1, the administrator of that group home has assumed primary responsibility for providing for his health and welfare. Doctors, psychologists and other professionals under contract with BCH-1 provide medical and related services. Either HRC or the Department of Health Services (MediCal) pays for these services. However, the District has at all times pertinent been responsible for meeting STUDENT’s educational needs.

Sometime before the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, the earliest year at issue here, Mr. and Ms. PARENT separated and eventually divorced. A dispute concerning STUDENT’s continued placement at BCH-1 arose between them. During the summer of 2000, before STUDENT started high school, the Superior Court for the County of Los Angeles issued various orders regarding the dispute between the parents, including an order that Ms. PARENT not unilaterally remove STUDENT from the group home. None of the orders denied Ms. PARENT the right to exercise educational authority for STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer was provided with no information about assessments of STUDENT, his educational needs, or his educational placement and services prior to the 2000-2001 school year, his first year at Lakewood. The Hearing Officer does not know whether STUDENT has ever been fully assessed. If he has, that assessment did not occur more recently than his triennial review in 1997, approximately six years ago. The Hearing Officer also was not provided with the IEP that transitioned STUDENT from middle school to high school and presumably would have described his program for the first few months of the 2000-2001 school year.

District school psychologist Loan Tran Wendt conducted an educational reassessment of STUDENT on approximately November 16, 2000. This was not a full assessment, but was intended to satisfy the requirement that reassessment occur at least every three years. It consisted of a review of some of STUDENT’s earlier IEPs, consultations with his teachers, paraeducators and the District’s lead psychologist, and a classroom observation by Ms. Wendt.(Footnote 6) Ms. Wendt did not review any assessment reports or data. Neither the IEP team as a group nor either of STUDENT’s parents was involved in the planning for this triennial assessment. As a result of this assessment, Ms. Wendt prepared a report that generally described STUDENT’s then present levels of performance, including his need for toilet training and control of aggressive behaviors. She also noted STUDENT’s need for constant one-to-one assistance. Ms Wendt concluded that STUDENT had the potential to grow and learn in the classroom with an appropriate program, but she did not explain the bases for her belief or make any recommendations for placement and services that would be appropriate.

An IEP meeting was convened on November 20, 2000. There was no evidence that either of STUDENT’s parents was invited to attend, and neither was present at the meeting. The District chose to convene and proceed with the meeting in the absence of the parents. The IEP meeting minutes contain no reference to suggest that the District was concerned about proceeding without the advice and consent of STUDENT’s parents. On the contrary, the District accorded Marissa Tunstall, the BCH-1 administrator, the status of STUDENT’s guardian or surrogate parent. It accepted her agreement to the IEP and her acknowledgment of receipt of the parent rights and procedural safeguards as though she had the authority to act on STUDENT’s behalf. Ms. Tunstall was not STUDENT’s guardian or surrogate parent and had not been granted educational authority for STUDENT.

The November 2000 IEP did not refer to any specific assessment data beyond the mere observations of STUDENT at school.(Footnote 7) Although the IEP indicates that prior test scores were reviewed, the only witness to testify regarding assessment data reviewed was Ms. Wendt. She acknowledged that only anecdotal information was provided to the IEP team to determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance and educational needs.

The IEP indicates that STUDENT’s cognitive ability was in the mentally retarded range based upon a report dated November 19, 1997, but the report was not attached and there was no evidence that any team member had reviewed it. Ms. Wendt estimated STUDENT’s intelligence quotient (I.Q.) at less than fifty. She explained that this was only her conclusion based upon his eligibility classification. The IEP’s description of STUDENT as a visual, auditory, and kinesthetic learner was also purportedly based, in part, on a review of records and test scores. Again, there was no credible evidence that assessment results were reviewed by any member of the team. Even if they had been reviewed, they would have been at least three years old at the time (and six years old now). STUDENT’s skills were characterized as “pre-academic,” but it was stated that most of his pre-academic attempts were unsuccessful because of his aggressive behavior. STUDENT was described as “unwilling” to perform tasks within his range of skills. The IEP stated that STUDENT required constant supervision to minimize his aggressive behavior and the risk that he might try to run away. STUDENT’s needs, if any, in the area of fine motor skills were not addressed.

The IEP described STUDENT as nonverbal and noted that he had been seen using the American Sign Language (ASL) sign for “food” while waiting for his lunch in the school cafeteria. There was no indication that the District had provided services in the past to address STUDENT’s needs in the area of communication. The IEP indicates that STUDENT was not toilet-trained but was capable of being trained through a program consistently implemented at school and at BCH-1. There is no stated basis for the opinion that STUDENT was capable of being toilet-trained, no description of the District’s past efforts to help him progress in this essential life skill, and no explanation of why he had apparently made no progress in this and other areas during his twelve years in District placements.

The November 20, 2000 IEP maintained STUDENT’s placement in Ms. Pazier’s moderate-to-severe handicap special day class (MS-SDC) at Lakewood.(Footnote 8) He was to receive community-based instruction (CBI) as an “elective” for two hours weekly. CBI was to consist of practical life skills training in mobility, socially appropriate behavior, and safety both within the campus environment and in the outlying community. There was no evidence to show that CBI actually occurred. STUDENT was also to participate in an adaptive physical education (APE) class for two hundred minutes weekly. No other designated instruction and services (DIS) were offered or provided. The IEP team requested a speech and language screening to assist with STUDENT’s communication needs, but there was no evidence that this was ever done. Lunch, recess, passing periods and school activities were to be with the general education students “when staff was available,” but no full-time aide was assigned to ensure that availability. The evidence did not show how much time STUDENT actually spent in APE or with the general education population during the school year.

Transition and behavior plans were included in the IEP. There were some goals associated with the transition plan. For example, the transition plan states that STUDENT would have goals that included (1) attending to a table-top activity for fifteen minutes; (2) participating in CBI with his class; (3) assisting with toileting and hygiene; and (4) learning how to ride the bus with supervision. The behavior plan focuses on the aggressive behavior that is described as unpredictable. No clear behavioral goals are described. Nor are any other specifically identified and measurable annual goals contained in the November 2000 IEP admitted into evidence.

STUDENT attended Ms. Pazier’s MS-SDC during the 2000-2001 school year. There were twelve to fourteen students in the class. Some were severely limited cognitively and/or physically. Three of those had full-time assigned aides. Two full-time paraeducators and two college students also assisted Ms. Pazier. In spite of the two-to-one ratio of students to adult staff, STUDENT’s behavior problems continued throughout the year. There was no documented progress in the areas of communication or daily living skills, including toilet training. STUDENT had some increase in his ability to sit at his desk, but the amount of progress was not documented.(Footnote 9) The one area he excelled in was gross motor activities. The IEP states that STUDENT went from being essentially nonparticipatory in gross motor activities early in the year to maximum participation by year’s end. However, there is no historical data to show what STUDENT could do the prior year in middle school and no documented analysis of whether or not this increased participation was due to anything other than his increased social comfort in his new school.

The November 20, 2000 IEP expired on November 20, 2001. The Hearing Officer requested but was not provided with a copy of an IEP that would have identified STUDENT’s placement and services from November 21, 2001, to on or about December 12, 2002, the date of the next IEP in evidence. Almost nothing is known about STUDENT’s needs and the program and services provided to him during the 2001-2002 school year except that he continued in his placement in Ms. Pazier’s class. The class size remained about the same, but two of the assigned one-to-one aides were no longer with the class.

It appears from references in various documents and from Ms. Pazier’s testimony that the District continued to provide some form of toilet training and help with communication using a picture exchange communication system (PECS).(Footnote 10) The nature and amount of these services are unknown. It is clear that, apart from some progress in his ability to remain seated at his desk, there was no documented progress in any other area of suspected need.

STUDENT continued in Ms. Pazier’s MS-SDC for the first few months of the 2002-2003 school year. During this school year, the students in the MS-SDC rotated among several classrooms and instructors. In addition to their time in Ms. Pazier’s class, the students were rotated to a physical education class, a life skills class, and a gross and fine motor skills class.(Footnote 11) As stated above, there was no IEP in evidence adequately identifying STUDENT’s areas of need and showing how the District sought to meet those needs, if at all, during the first few months of the 2002-2003 school year. It was only through reference to other evidence that the Hearing Officer was able to glean that staff was still working on increasing his ability to remain seated, to communicate, and to use the bathroom.

STUDENT’s aggressive behavior increased over the first few months of school. It appeared to at least some of the staff that he was preying on smaller or weaker students. He would poke or hit them and try to tip them over in their wheelchairs or walkers. He also was hitting staff and knocking objects off tables and shelves.

On November 26, 2002, Ms. Pazier and Ms. Bockholt, the team leader at Lakewood, referred STUDENT for an assistive technology/augmented communication consultation to explore the possibility of a communication system for him. The consultation was completed on December 5, 2002. The result was a recommendation by Jill Jeffery, an assistive technology specialist, to consider developing an alternative communication system, such as one using photographs or objects, and the use of a picture schedule to provide some order to STUDENT’s day.

The next IEP meeting shown by the evidence was on December 12, 2002. Ms. PARENT was present. By then, STUDENT’s ability to remain seated at his desk had increased, but only to something in excess of thirty minutes. The focus shifted to increasing his attention to a desktop activity while seated. There also was an increase in his aggressive behavior. He still had no functional communication and was not toilet-trained. He continued to require full-time supervision. Gross motor skills were reported as good, but fine motor skills were reported as poor. The IEP in evidence states that STUDENT had difficulty holding a pencil and handling small objects. This is the first indication in the evidence that he has poor fine motor skills. Only gross motor present levels are discussed in the November 2000 IEP. However, there was no evidence that fine motor was a new area of deficit.

Three annual goals were developed for the December 2002 IEP. By December 2003, STUDENT was to (1) attend to a pre-academic activity at his desk for thirty minutes; (2) make a request or express his needs three times daily using an alternative communication system; and (3) decrease his aggressive behavior by eighty percent, though no baseline was clearly identified.

Pursuant to the December 2002 IEP, STUDENT’s placement in Ms. Pazier’s class continued. The IEP also required behavior data monitoring. It makes no mention of STUDENT’s participation in APE or CBI. Ms. Pazier testified that although APE services stopped, STUDENT did continue to participate in CBI as often as three times weekly. Training in augmented or assisted communication also was to be provided for thirty minutes weekly for eight weeks pursuant to the IEP. There was no evidence to describe this communication training or to show that it actually occurred. The IEP notes that the school psychologist, Ms. Wendt, recommended a full-time, one-to-one aide for STUDENT, but one was not provided in the IEP. Another behavior plan was included.

STUDENT’s aggressive behavior escalated.(Footnote 12) An IEP meeting was convened to address the problem on January 23, 2003. The IEP team, including Ms. PARENT, agreed that STUDENT would be placed on of home/hospital instruction one hour daily for four to six weeks. It also was agreed that the staff and consultants of BCH-1 would evaluate his behavior and explore the possibility that medication might help with STUDENT’s aggressive behavior. There was no evidence that the District assumed any responsibility for addressing the behaviors that were interfering with STUDENT’s education. The team was to reconvene in March to consider the matter further.

The IEP team met again on March 19, 2003. The HRC counselor, the administrator of BCH-1, and the consulting psychologist for BCH-1 were present. According to the minutes of the meeting, the group home’s consulting physician had prescribed a medication for STUDENT since the last meeting, but his mother would not give her consent allowing it to be administered. There was no evidence regarding this consulting physician’s evaluation, diagnosis, or recommendations. Ms. Tunstall reported that STUDENT’s behavior at the group home had improved. The team members, except Ms. PARENT, recommended a continuation of home/hospital instruction until arrangements could be made to return STUDENT to a different MS-SDC at the school for shortened days with a one-to-one aide. He was to be placed in the SDC taught by Mr. Willert. Dr. Gandolfo, the BCH-1 psychologist, was also to work with STUDENT in the classroom, but the details of this were not specified in the IEP.

Ms. PARENT expressed her lack of confidence in virtually all the involved entities – HRC, BCH-1, and the District – to meet the needs of her son. She did not agree to the District’s offer to transition STUDENT back into the school environment for shortened days with a one-to-one aide. Ms. PARENT wanted STUDENT to be placed in the Speech and Language Development Center in Buena Park at District expense. Her request for a due process hearing was filed on March 31, 2003.

There was no evidence of any later IEP meeting. However, at the time of the hearing, STUDENT was attending Mr. Willert’s MS-SDC at Lakewood for shortened days with an assigned one-to-one aide, Ms. Selina Calloway. There is no evidence that Ms. PARENT, or anyone with educational authority for STUDENT, agreed to this change of placement.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No 1: Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during the 2000-2001 school year?

Ms. PARENT contends that the District failed to provide a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to her son, both substantively and procedurally, for all of the time that he has been attending Lakewood, since the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year. She alleges that in the 2000-2001 school year STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP) process was procedurally flawed in that: (1) Ms. PARENT was excluded from the IEP process, and (2) she was not advised regarding her due process rights. She also alleges that the IEP for that year was deficient because it did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs for: (1) a significant amount of individual staff attention through low student-to-staff ratios or an assigned one-to-one aide, (2) increased communication skills, (3) increased daily living skills, particularly toilet training, (4) a specialized physical education program, and (5) increased adaptive skills necessary for independence and employment. The District asserted that STUDENT’s IEP, as well as the process that resulted in the development of the IEP, was appropriate.

The Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq., and State special education law provide that a disabled student in a public school is entitled to a free, appropriate public education (FAPE). A FAPE issue can present both substantive and procedural questions.

Substantively, a FAPE is special education and related services that are available to a student at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, and are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). It includes special education and related services that are designed to meet the child’s unique needs that cannot be met with modification of the regular instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. It must enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and provide the opportunity to be educated and participate with nondisabled students to the maximum extent possible (often referred to as least restrictive environment or LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345. An appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the student. Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). Moreover, the focus of the inquiry is not on whether the student may obtain greater benefit in the placement that is preferred by the parents but, rather, whether the school district’s proposed placement is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982); Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).

Procedurally, the law requires that the IEP process be fair. The United States Supreme Court has held that the IDEA requires certain procedural protections that will allow the student and parents to effectively participate in the IEP process. Rowley, supra, at 206-207. Not every procedural flaw is critical, but one that results in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringes on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process may in and of itself constitute a denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).

In summary, to be found to provide a FAPE, an IEP must be the result of a process that adequately protected the rights of the parents and student. In addition, the IEP itself must (1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit; and (3) conform with the student’s IEP.(Footnote 13) The local educational agency has the burden of proof on all of these issues. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).

Procedurally Appropriate

It is the responsibility of the school district to ensure that at least one of the parents or guardians of each individual with exceptional needs is notified regarding the IEP meeting and attends that meeting or, at least, is given an opportunity to participate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5 (a) and (b). If the parent or guardian cannot attend, the district must use other methods to ensure their participation by telephone or otherwise. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(f). If the district cannot ensure the attendance of the parent or guardian, it must keep detailed records of its efforts to do so. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g). Furthermore, it is the obligation of the district to ensure that the parent of each individual with exceptional needs is a member of any group that makes decisions on the educational placement of the individual with exceptional needs. Cal. Educ. Code § 56342.5. These and other provisions make it clear that local educational agencies are required to make every reasonable effort to ensure the full participation of the parent or guardian in every step of the IEP process. (See, for example: Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56301, 56304, 56321, 56329, and 56341.)

The parties were informed by the Hearing Officer before the conclusion of the hearing that all of the IEPs at issue were not in evidence and that the Hearing Officer needed all IEPs covering STUDENT’s time at Lakewood. The District stated that the missing IEPs would be located and provided. No additional documents were offered. There was no evidence offered by the District to show that the IEP that would have transitioned STUDENT into high school and described his placement and program for the first few months of the school year was developed with the full participation of STUDENT’s parent or guardian. It is without dispute that the November 20, 2000 IEP was not developed with the full participation of either of STUDENT’s parents. The evidence establishes a formal notice sent only to BCH-1. The IEP itself shows that neither Mr. nor Ms. PARENT attended the IEP meeting. Marissa Tunstall from BCH-1 assumed the role of STUDENT’s surrogate parent or guardian; however, there was no evidence that Ms. Tunstall or any other representative of BCH-1 had the legal authority to act in either of those capacities.

No evidence was offered to show that a surrogate parent or legal guardian has ever been appointed for STUDENT. The evidence showed that his placement at BCH-1 was voluntary. There also was no evidence that STUDENT’s educational authority had been delegated to BCH-1 or any of its representatives. No court order showed that educational authority for STUDENT had been taken from either Mr. or Ms. PARENT. There were court orders in evidence, but these related only to the dispute between Mr. and Ms. PARENT concerning STUDENT’s continued placement at BCH-1. Although Mr. PARENT also held educational authority for STUDENT prior to his death, there was no evidence that he was informed of or actually participated in the IEP process. Under the circumstances, it was incumbent upon the District to ensure the participation of at least one of STUDENT’s parents in the IEP process. Its failure to do so effectively excluded STUDENT’s parents from the IEP process.

The District should have known that it had no authority to implement the November 20, 2000 IEP. A licensed children’s institution like BCH-1 cannot require that it be designated the educational authority for a student resident. Cal. Educ. Code § 48884. There was no court order appointing a legal guardian or limiting Ms. PARENT’s educational authority. Finally, if a surrogate parent had been appointed, the District would have been the appointing agency. There is no evidence that it did.

Even after the District finally acknowledged that Ms. Tunstall had no authority to consent to the implementation of the November 2000 IEP, the District did nothing to rectify the situation. There was no evidence that STUDENT’s parents were given a copy of any IEP or the parent’s rights and procedural safeguards before the IEP meeting in December 2002. Even after the District recognized Ms. PARENT’s right to participate in the IEP process, it did not convene a new IEP meeting prior to the end of the 2000-2001 school year to include Mr. or Ms. PARENT for the time that remained on the November 20, 2000 IEP.(Footnote 14)

The District’s failure to include STUDENT’s parents in the IEP process was a critical procedural error that prevented Ms. PARENT from participating in the IEP process. The District had no authority to implement the November 2000 IEP. On that basis alone, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during the 2000-2001 school year. It is unnecessary to discuss the substantive FAPE claims for this year.

Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during the 2001-2002 school year?

Although Ms. PARENT testified that she was prevented from participating in the IEP process for only the first six months of the 2000-2001 school year, she alleges that in the 2001-2002 school year STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP) process was procedurally flawed because she was excluded from the IEP process and was not advised regarding her due process rights. She also alleges that the IEP for that year was deficient because it did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs for one-to-one instruction and supervision, increased communication skills, increased daily living skills, particularly toilet training, a specialized physical education program, and increased adaptive skills necessary for independence and employment. The District defended STUDENT’s placement and program as both procedurally and substantively appropriate.

Procedurally Appropriate

The District failed to sustain its burden of proof on the question of the procedural propriety of STUDENT’s program for the 2001-2002 school year. If there was an IEP meeting to review and modify STUDENT’s IEP as necessary in or around November or December 2001, neither is apparent from the evidence. Ms. PARENT testified that her complete exclusion from the IEP process ended during the 2000-2001 school year. However, she alleges that there were continuing procedural deficiencies in the IEP process through the 2001-2002 school year. The District did not inquire of Ms. PARENT or any other witness regarding the specifics of an IEP meeting in November or December 2001. In spite of the Hearing Officer’s instruction that the IEP for that year be located and offered into evidence, this was not done.

It is not the responsibility of the Hearing Officer to search the record for possible references to an IEP meeting that may have occurred and may have allowed Ms. PARENT the opportunity to participate. Rather, it was the responsibility of the District to provide documentary evidence and testimony to establish the facts necessary to its case. There was no evidence upon which the Hearing Officer can base a finding that the IEP process for the 2001-2002 school year was procedurally appropriate. The Hearing Officer has no option but to conclude that the process was procedurally flawed in a way that denied Ms. PARENT the opportunity to fully participate and/or deprived STUDENT of an educational opportunity to which he would otherwise have been entitled. Although this finding is alone sufficient to support a determination that STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year, the Hearing Officer will discuss the claims of substantive deficiencies. Substantively Appropriate

Because the Hearing Officer was not given the 2001-2002 IEP, it is not possible to determine whether the design of the IEP was appropriate or whether the program actually implemented conformed to the IEP. However, the Hearing Officer cannot allow the District’s failure to prove its case to prevent an analysis of whether the program actually delivered to STUDENT was appropriate. The focus of this analysis will be whether or not the program described in testimony and other documents was calculated to meet his needs.

Ms. PARENT contends that for at least the three years at issue her son has required a one-to-one aide or, at least, a staff-to-student ratio that would guarantee substantial one-to-one attention. There is adequate evidence to support this claim.

As early as November 2000, the IEP team recognized that STUDENT required constant supervision. He engaged in threatening and aggressive behavior throughout that year and the next. The IEP team recognized then that STUDENT’s “unwillingness” to perform tasks and the aggressive behavior that was often precipitated by staff efforts to get him to do something he did not want to do interfered with his learning. Behavior plans were ineffective.(Footnote 15) STUDENT also had difficulty remaining seated at his desk. Although this was the one area in which his teacher said he had shown some progress during the 2000-2001 school year, his transition plan goal that year was to be able to sit at his desk for only fifteen minutes. STUDENT needed an aide to help him with this skill. Finally, the evidence showed that STUDENT needed intensive one-to-one instruction in some basic life skills, such as toilet training and safety, and to develop a system of communication. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that he needed one-to-one supervision and instruction. STUDENT was not assigned a one-to-one aide during the 2001-2002 school year. Therefore, his program did not meet that need.

The Hearing Officer is also convinced that it was not just the individual attention that was necessary. If STUDENT is capable of being toilet trained and acquiring a method of augmented or assisted communication, it is clear that the training and experience of his instructors would be important factors. Although Ms. Pazier had six years of experience working in a group home, she had no teaching experience prior to the 2000-2001 school year and at the time of the hearing was still working on her master’s degree and in the pre-intern program for her credential.(Footnote 16) There was no evidence of the training or experience of the paraeducators and assistants who worked with her during that year. The Hearing Officer was not convinced that Ms. Pazier and her staff possessed the necessary training and experience to effectively teach STUDENT.

There is no dispute that one of STUDENT’s most dire needs is his need to communicate. He was fifteen years old at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. He had been in District programs since he was three years old but still had no effective communication system. Several of the witnesses, including the District’s witnesses, acknowledged that his aggressive behavior may be due at least in part to his frustration with his inability to communicate his needs and wants. There was some evidence to indicate that the District may have been working with STUDENT on some kind of PECS.(Footnote 17) However, very little is known from the evidence concerning what these efforts were except that they were not effective. The evidence did not show that STUDENT actually made any progress at all in the area of communication. This may have been due to the lack of coordination of efforts between the District and BCH-1.(Footnote 18) It may have been due to inadequate intensive instruction by persons properly trained in the use of a PECS. Regardless of the cause, the Hearing Officer was persuaded that STUDENT’s program did not meet his communication needs.

The Petitioner also claimed that his program did not meet his need to improve his daily living skills, specifically toilet training. This was another of STUDENT’s longstanding and pressing needs during the 2001-2002 school year. Special education is supposed to be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and to prepare him or her for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A). Independence in using the toilet is one of the most basic of those skills. The District has recognized that this was one of STUDENT’s needs. It was referred to in the November 2000 IEP. Ms. Pazier testified that she followed an “aggressive” bathroom schedule during the 2000-2001 school year and that the schedule was gradually reduced to every two hours during the 2001-2002 school year. STUDENT remains diaper dependent. Recognizing that evidence regarding STUDENT’s abilities in this and every other area is scant or missing, the Hearing Officer turns to the only opinions offered on the subject of toilet training. Ms. Pazier believes that STUDENT is cognitively incapable of being toilet-trained. Ms. Wendt, the school psychologist, testified that STUDENT could be toilet-trained, but it would require a consistent effort at school and at the group home. The Hearing Officer had no evidence that would allow him to attribute greater weight to the testimony of one of these witnesses. Both were new to their fields when they first came in contact with STUDENT. Neither demonstrated an expertise that would better qualify her to state an opinion on STUDENT’s ability to be toilet trained. There was no assessment data that would assist with this determination. Dr. Gandolfo testified that she would defer to an occupational therapist or physical therapist for an answer to this question.

The fact remains that STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old young man who is not toilet trained and who, as a result, has limited options and opportunities.(Footnote 19) The Hearing Officer will not assume that STUDENT is incapable of being toilet-trained. STUDENT clearly has a need in that area. It was incumbent on the District to demonstrate that it provided a placement and services to meet that need to the extent that it could be met. The District did not do that.

On the basis of his findings that the District’s program for the 2001-2002 school year failed to meet three of STUDENT’s critical needs – for one-on-one instruction, improved communication skills, and toilet training – the Hearing Officer determines that the District did not provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year. It is not necessary to discuss the other elements of a substantive FAPE analysis.

Issue No. 3: Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during the 2002-2003 school year?

The Petitioner makes the same claims for the 2002-2003 school year that he makes for the prior years. In addition, he contends that the District failed to properly assess him in all areas related to his suspected disability. Specifically, Petitioner claims that the District failed to properly assess him in the following skill or need areas: cognitive, physical therapy, occupational therapy, nutrition, visual acuity, hearing acuity, artistic, and nutrition. Ms. PARENT did not allege that she was denied the opportunity to participate in the IEP process during the 2002-2003 school year.

The Hearing Officer’s findings with respect to the District’s denial of a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year apply equally to the 2002-2003 school year until the December 2002 IEP. There were three IEPs during the 2002-2003 school year. Each will be addressed below.

December 12, 2002 IEP

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs

Because STUDENT made so little progress during the 2001-2002 school year, he still had essentially the same areas of need during the 2002-2003 school year. If anything, those needs had become more critical. Although he was able to sit at his desk for over thirty minutes, he was not able to sit for that period of time while attending to a pre-academic task appropriate to his skill. Fine motor was identified as an area of need. His aggressive behaviors worsened. Ms. Pazier and other District witnesses testified that STUDENT appeared to “prey” on other students in the MS-SDC who were smaller, weaker, or more physically disabled than he was. He still needed one-to-one supervision and instruction, not only because of the increasingly urgent need for progress in the areas already mentioned, but also because his behaviors continued to interfere with his learning.(Footnote 20) Those behaviors, particularly occasional flight, also created a risk of injury to STUDENT, who did not appreciate danger. STUDENT turned seventeen in December 2002. He was bigger, stronger, and running out of time to obtain some benefit from his education.

The December 2002 IEP had three annual goals. One addressed STUDENTs’ need to increase his ability to attend to a task. One addressed his need to increase his ability to communicate his needs. The third addressed his aggressive behaviors.

STUDENT’s placement was to continue in Ms. Pazier’s MS-SDC, with fifteen percent of his school day being spent with the general education students for recess and lunch. He was not assigned a one-to-one aide. The IEP does not state that STUDENT was to continue with his APE, though it seemed clear from the testimony and from the IEP itself that he had enjoyed this activity.(Footnote 21) Ms. Pazier testified that STUDENT was allowed to continue with his CBI as often as three times weekly, but the IEP document states that STUDENT was “not ready” for off-campus instruction, so would be relegated to practicing his CBI on the school grounds. To assist with his communication needs, he was to receive thirty minutes per week of augmented or assisted communication services for eight weeks, but the precise nature of these services was not shown. Ms. PARENT consented to the IEP.

The December 2002 IEP did not provide a one-to-one aide, in spite of the obvious need for one and the recommendation of Ms. Wendt that one should be assigned. There was no annual goal for toilet training. In fact, there was no mention of this serious need except in the context of STUDENT’s present levels of performance. There was no goal to address what the IEP characterizes as STUDENT’s “poor fine motor skills.”(Footnote 22) There was a statement under the heading “Transition Services” that STUDENT would attend a life skills class “to be more independent,” but there were no annual goals relating to the acquisition of skills that would better enable STUDENT to function more independently or safely in the community. These deficiencies cause the Hearing Officer to find that STUDENT’s December 2002 IEP was not reasonably designed to meet his needs. On this basis alone, he finds that the IEP did not provide a FAPE. It is unnecessary to examine the other elements of the FAPE analysis.

January 23, 2003 IEP

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs

All of STUDENT’s needs described above remained when the next IEP meeting was convened on January 23, 2003, to deal with STUDENT’s escalating behavior. According to the meeting minutes, sixty incidents of hitting, kicking, and throwing food or other items were recorded since November 2002. The team’s response was to develop an addendum to the December 2002 IEP that prevented STUDENT from coming to school at all. It put STUDENT on home/hospital instruction one hour per day for four to six weeks. The group home agreed to “evaluate STUDENT’s behavior and prescribe medication.”(Footnote 23) The team was to reconvene in approximately six weeks to reevaluate the situation. STUDENT’s mother consented to the IEP.

The Hearing Officer has already found that the full day of instruction in the MS-SDC without a one-to-one aide and appropriate goals was not reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. A reduction in services to one hour per day of instruction in the group home was almost the equivalent of a complete cessation of services and appears to have been designed more to meet the needs of the District and its staff than the needs of STUDENT. Safety considerations are important. It was reasonable for the IEP team to take steps to protect its staff and students from STUDENT’s aggression. However, it was also necessary for the team, particularly the District members of the team, to actively address the behavior that they believed necessitated STUDENT’s isolation at the group home, while at the same time continuing to meet his other needs. This IEP addendum did not improve on the December 2002 IEP. It allowed approximately one-sixth of the time for instruction, and did nothing to address STUDENT’s needs for intense one-to-one instruction and increased communication, daily living and adaptive skills.(Footnote 24)

The Hearing Officer finds that the January 23, 2003 IEP was not reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. On that basis alone, he finds that the January 2003 IEP addendum did not provide a FAPE. It is unnecessary to address the other elements of the FAPE analysis.

March 19, 2003 IEP

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs

The most recent IEP addendum to the December 2002 IEP was developed at a meeting convened on March 19, 2003, to review STUDENT’s placement and services. There was no evidence to suggest that STUDENT’s needs had changed since the previous IEP and addendum. The group home representative reported that STUDENT’s behavior had been good since he was placed on home/hospital instruction and that the group home’s consulting doctor had prescribed medication. However, it had not yet been administered because Ms. PARENT would not give her consent. The doctor was not present at the meeting, and there was no documented discussion of his findings and recommendations.

The District members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT return to Lakewood to attend Mr. Willert’s MS-SDC for a shortened day. A one-to-one aide was to be assigned to assist STUDENT. In addition, Dr. Gandolfo, the psychologist who consulted with the group home, was to work with STUDENT in the classroom. No new annual goals were developed and no other services were offered. STUDENT’s mother did not consent to the IEP addendum. She requested that STUDENT be placed at the Speech and Language Development Center in Buena Park, California.

By assigning a one-to-one aide to STUDENT, this addendum met one of his needs. All of the other deficiencies of the December 2002 IEP remained. STUDENT would be allowed to return to school for instruction and social interaction, but his day would be short. There was no evidence to show how this shortened day in Mr. Willert’s class would meet STUDENT’s need for improved communication, daily living and adaptive skills or how the progress, if any, in those areas would be measured.

The District offered the testimony of STUDENT’s assigned aide, Selina Calloway, but she had only been working with him for a short time. Ms. Calloway is a college student studying early child development. This is her first job in education. She testified that a typical day for STUDENT includes breakfast, jumping on a trampoline, a rhythm and dance class taught by another special education teacher, physical education and going to the bathroom. She also stated that, although STUDENT was unruly and defiant for the first two weeks of her time with him, she has had no problems with him since that time. There is no ongoing effort beyond a regular bathroom schedule to train him away from needing a diaper. Ms. Calloway explained that a picture schedule is being used. For example, there are pictures of STUDENT’s various teachers to show him when it is time to go to their classes. There is also a picture of a trampoline to show him when it is time to do that activity. Beyond that, Ms. Calloway is not aware of any other efforts to address STUDENT’s needs for a functional communication system.

There was insufficient evidence to allow the Hearing Officer to determine whether the December 2002 IEP, when combined with the March 19, 2003 addendum, was reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. There is no adequate justification for a shortened day. The program does not adequately address STUDENT’s need for functional communication, toilet training, safety awareness and other life skills. Because of this finding, it is not necessary to address the other elements of the FAPE analysis. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not provide or offer a free, appropriate public education to STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year.

STUDENT is currently attending Lakewood for a shortened day that ends at approximately 11:15 a.m. He has his one-to-one aide while at school, and she is able to control his aggressive behaviors. Although Ms. PARENT did not consent to this placement and the Hearing Officer has found that the March 2003 IEP does not offer a FAPE, the Hearing Officer does not intend to return STUDENT to the less desirable placement of one hour daily of home/hospital instruction, the last placement agreed upon by the IEP team. Therefore, until STUDENT’s placement for the 2003-2004 school year is determined, he shall remain in a placement at Lakewood with a one-to-one aide. This is not intended to prevent the parties from increasing STUDENT’s time at school.

Issue No. 4: Is the Petitioner entitled to a multidisciplinary independent educational assessment at the District’s expense?

Petitioner wants a thorough assessment including in the areas of cognitive functioning, physical therapy, occupational therapy, nutrition, visual acuity, hearing acuity, and artistic skills. The District states that Ms. PARENT had not requested an independent assessment prior to the hearing and that its assessments of STUDENT were appropriate.

The law requires that a child with a suspected disability be assessed by the school district “in all areas related to the suspected disability, including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general intelligence, . . . communicative status, self-help, . . . and social and emotional status.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). Occupational therapy and physical therapy are also areas of service that require prior assessment. Cal. Govt. Code § 7572. The evaluation must be “sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of the child’s special education and related services needs.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h). The IEP team must be able to rely on the information from an initial assessment to determine eligibility and to develop an appropriate educational program. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b).

A reassessment of the student must take place at least every three years or more often if conditions warrant, or if the parent requests a reassessment and the development of a new IEP.(Footnote 25) Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). The reassessment must include a review of the existing assessment data, including classroom-based assessments and teacher’s and service provider’s observations, by the IEP team and other qualified professionals. On the basis of that review and after considering input from the student’s parents, the IEP team is to determine what additional data, if any, is needed. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b).

A parent has the right to obtain an independent assessment at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment done by the school district. The school district must pay for the independent assessment unless there is a determination through due process that its assessment was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56329(b) and 56506(c).

According to several of the District’s witnesses, no one ever requested an independent assessment of STUDENT until the issue was raised at the hearing. Ms. PARENT did not dispute that assertion. The District argued that there was no request for an independent assessment, so there was no duty to provide one.

The Hearing Officer agrees that there must be a request for an independent assessment to put the District on notice that it must either provide one or defend the appropriateness of its own assessment at hearing. The Hearing Officer finds that there was such a request in the Petitioner’s motion to continue the hearing that was filed on or about May 14, 2003. The District acknowledged the request in its opposition to the motion filed two days later. There was another request on the first day of the hearing when the issues to be addressed by the Hearing Officer were identified. Under the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the appropriateness of the District’s assessments is properly before him.

There was no evidence to show when the District last formally assessed STUDENT before Ms. Wendt’s evaluation in 2000. Ms. Wendt assumed that there had been a complete assessment in 1997, but she admitted that she had no reliable information to support her assumption. Ms. Wendt’s assessment did not comply with the law in a number of respects. There was no review of the existing assessment data by the IEP team and other qualified professionals. There was a review of prior IEPs by Ms. Wendt, but she admitted that she reviewed no prior assessment reports. There was no evidence that anyone reviewed existing assessment data other than the observations by Ms. Wendt and her conversations with STUDENT’s teachers. Ms. Wendt did not speak with anyone from the group home. There also was no effort to include STUDENT’s parents in the process. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessment of STUDENT in 2000 was not appropriate.

STUDENT would be due for a triennial review and assessment in November 2003. However, the Hearing Officer is troubled by the lack of substantial assessment data, clear direction and purpose in STUDENT’s IEPs, and progress from implementation of those IEPs. Moreover, it appears likely that no one really understands the nature and extent of STUDENT’s educational needs. Certainly, the District’s evidence did not demonstrate such understanding. As a result of the District’s failure to appropriately assess STUDENT and to share the results of such assessments with the IEP team, all were at a loss to understand STUDENT’s educational needs and develop a program to meet those needs. Because adequate assessment data was not provided to the Hearing Officer, he lacks reliable information upon which to base an appropriate remedy.

The Hearing Officer finds that a complete and global assessment of STUDENT is required and that this assessment must be performed by the District utilizing independent professionals who are experienced and qualified to conduct an assessment of a young man with STUDENT’s disabilities. The assessment must include an evaluation in all areas related to the suspected disability including, but not limited to, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, general intelligence, communicative status, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, and social and emotional status. The assessors must be informed by the District regarding the possible uses of the assessment results, including use by the IEP team to develop an appropriate prospective IEP and use by the Hearing Officer to determine an appropriate remedy of compensatory education in this case, which remedy might include elements of placement and services concurrent with those provided in an IEP.

Issue No. 5: If the District failed to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during any of the above-stated school years, is he entitled to a remedy and, if so, what is that remedy?

The Petitioner requested an order that he be prospectively placed at the Speech and Language Development Center (SLDC). He offered no evidence to show that this placement would be appropriate. The District’s coordinator of NPS placements, Ms. Dadourian, testified that she inquired of this NPS regarding the availability of a place for STUDENT and was told that it would not accept him. The school explained that the low probability of significant progress and the fact that STUDENT was not toilet trained were the reasons for the decision. Ms. Dadourian did not extend her inquiry to other possible NPS placements. She checked only with the SLDC because she was told to do that. She also understood from her instructions that this was not to be a typical referral process. During the normal referral process, she would call the NPS to describe the student in detail and explore the appropriateness of a placement there. In this instance, she simply referred to STUDENT’s present levels of performance as stated in his December 2002 IEP and was told that he could not be placed at the SLDC. It appeared to the Hearing Officer that the “referral” of STUDENT to the SLDC for consideration was more an attempt to dissuade Ms. PARENT from considering an NPS placement than a good faith effort to find a suitable NPS placement for him. Nevertheless, there was insufficient evidence to allow the Hearing Officer to make a prospective placement of STUDENT at the SLDC. However, STUDENT has been denied a FAPE for the last three years. He is entitled to a remedy.

Generally, a student may be entitled to an award of compensatory education if he or she has suffered a loss of educational opportunity not otherwise compensable through an award of reimbursement to parents for the cost of assessment or other services. Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, supra, 31 F.3d at 497.

The Hearing Officer has no reliable evidence regarding the measure of the educational losses to STUDENT from the last three years. There was no reliable expert testimony or reports concerning STUDENT’s levels of functioning and his capacity to learn at the times in question. There was no expert testimony regarding how STUDENT would have been performing in the various skill areas if he had been in a placement and program that were appropriate. No competent witness explained the importance of consistency and collaboration between the school and home environments and how that can be achieved. Since the residential placement is by HRC and is not an educational placement, the Hearing Officer is reluctant to make an award that may provide less than appropriate relief because of the District’s lack of control over the residential placement.

The Hearing Officer’s inability to award an appropriate remedy is due primarily to the District’s inability or failure to produce competent and reliable evidence of STUDENT’s levels of functioning and capacity to learn in the various areas of need and at the various times at issue. He has already determined that the District must do a thorough assessment. The results of that assessment are expected to provide much of the information necessary to enable the Hearing Officer to craft a remedy. Additional information may be required. The Hearing Officer will retain jurisdiction in this matter until such time as he is satisfied that he has the information he needs to fairly compensate STUDENT for his educational losses.

The Hearing Officer will issue such orders as circumstances require to ensure that the requirements of the IDEA have been met with regard to STUDENT. Initially, he will order the District to produce for the Petitioner and the Hearing Officer pertinent documents that have not yet been produced and that may bear on the remedy issue. Also as part of the initial order, the District will be required to submit to the Hearing Officer a proposed assessment plan that includes the identities of the proposed assessors, their curricula vitae, and the area to be assessed by each. The proposed assessors must include a physician to assess STUDENT’s general health, a developmental psychologist to assess him developmentally, an educational psychologist, an occupational therapist, a specialist in augmented or assisted communication, and such other professionals as may be required to assess in the various areas previously identified. Finally, the District will be required to provide to the assessors copies of all documents that have any likelihood of assisting them with their task, including all IEPs and assessment reports of the kind typically reviewed and relied upon by such assessors, regardless of date.

The Hearing Officer expects to review the proposed assessment plan and issue an order either approving or modifying the plan. He will then order that the assessments be conducted pursuant to the plan and the reports provided to Ms. PARENT and the Hearing Officer. The District will be ordered to convene an IEP meeting to fairly considered the assessment results and propose a prospective IEP for the 2003-2004 school year. The IEP will be provided to the Hearing Officer. If an appropriate award of compensatory education can be determined on the basis of the information contained in the assessment reports and the IEP, a final remedy order will be issued. If the Hearing Officer believes that additional information or further proceedings are required, a further order will be issued.

ORDER

1. Within ten calendar days of this order, the District shall provide to the Hearing Officer and the Petitioner’s mother the following items:

(a) all IEPs covering any part of the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, or 2002-2003 school years; (b) all reports of assessments reviewed or considered by the IEP teams that developed the IEPs covering any part of the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, or 2002-2003 school years; and (c) all documents generated in the course of the last comprehensive assessment of STUDENT if not produced pursuant to order 1(b), above

2. Within fifteen calendar days of this order, the District shall submit to the Hearing Officer a proposed plan for the comprehensive assessment of STUDENT that includes the identities of the proposed assessors, their curricula vitae, and the area to be assessed by each. The proposed assessors must include a physician to assess STUDENT’s general health, a developmental psychologist to assess him developmentally, an educational psychologist, an occupational therapist, a specialist in augmented or assisted communication, and such other professionals as may be required to assess STUDENT’s vision, hearing, motor abilities, general intelligence, communicative status, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, and social and emotional status.

3. Each proposed assessor must be informed regarding the possible uses of the assessment results, including use by the IEP team to develop an appropriate prospective IEP and use by the Hearing Officer to determine an appropriate compensatory education award for STUDENT in this case, which award might include elements of placement and services to be implemented concurrently with those provided in a prospective IEP. The proposed assessors shall also be informed that they should address in their written reports the following issues, within their respective areas of expertise:

(a) The elements of an appropriate placement and services for STUDENT during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, and 2002-2003 school years; (b) the progress that STUDENT could reasonably have achieved with that appropriate placement and services; (c) the placement and services reasonably likely to fairly compensate STUDENT for educational opportunities lost during the three school years at issue and how that compensatory award should be blended with a prospective IEP.

4. The District shall provide to the assessors all documents that have any likelihood of assisting them with their task, including all IEPs and assessment reports of the kind typically reviewed and relied upon by such assessors, regardless of date.

5. When the assessment is completed, the IEP team has fairly considered the assessment results and propose a prospective IEP for the 2003-2004 school year. A copy of the IEP will be provided to the Hearing Officer, who will address the issue of compensatory education and will enter such additional orders as may then be appropriate.

6. Until STUDENT’s placement for the 2003-2004 school year is determined, he shall remain in a placement at Lakewood with a one-to-one aide. This is not intended to prevent the parties from increasing STUDENT’s time at school.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

The Petitioner prevailed on all issues.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: June 18, 2003 Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1 The issues are not listed specifically as stated on the first day of hearing. They have been organized by the Hearing Officer for the purposes of adjudication, but the issues have not been changed. 2. The specifics of the parties’ allegations will be discussed in the context of the issue analysis, below. 3. Ms. PARENT also sought to make various claims against BCH-1 and wanted the Hearing Officer to issue an order that STUDENT be discharged from BCH-1 and returned to live with her and under her care. The Hearing Officer explained that because STUDENT was placed at BCH-1 by HRC, his placement there was a matter between her and HRC and that the Hearing Office had no jurisdiction to order HRC to release STUDENT to her care. 4. Mr. PARENT died in June 2002.

5. It appears from the evidence that STUDENT has resided at BCH-1 since approximately 1993. 6. The IEP states that the District was unable to test STUDENT’s vision and hearing, or to measure his height and weight on September 27, 2000. It is not known why these could not be done. 7. The only copy of the November 2000 IEP in evidence was offered by Ms. PARENT. Because the pages of that IEP are not numbered, the Hearing Officer cannot be sure that the entire document is in evidence.

8. Ms. Pazier testified that STUDENT had been in her class since the beginning of that school year. 9. As noted above, his goal was to be able to sit at his desk and attend to a desktop activity for fifteen minutes. 0. A PECS uses representations of objects or actions, such as photographs, icons or objects themselves that can be selected by the student and given to another person to communicate. For example, a picture of a toilet might be used to communicate a desire to use the bathroom. 11. There was some conflict in the evidence regarding whether the rotation began in the 2001-2002 or the 2002-2003 school year, but this discrepancy has no significant impact on the issues.

2. Documents indicate that sixty incidents were recorded from November 2002 to January 14, 2003.

3. The IDEA also requires that the educational placement and services enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and provide the student with the opportunity to be educated and participate with nondisabled students to the maximum extent possible. These requirements were not raised raised by Petitioner in this case. 4. Ms. PARENT testified that it took her until approximately March 2001 to convince the District that she had the right to participate in the IEP process, but as of April 1, 2003, at least some of the District’s records still identified Rosario Santiago, former administrator of BCH-1, as STUDENT’s “guardian.” 15. The Petitioner did not ask the Hearing Officer to find that the District failed to appropriately address his behavior that clearly interfered with his learning, but there was substantial evidence that this was the case. 16. She had been issued an emergency credential.

17. STUDENT had been observed attempting to use American Sign Language. The District did not explain why there was no further effort along that line. 18. In spite of the testimony by Ms. Bockholt that there was coordination of effort, the weight of the evidence showed that there was not the kind of coordination that was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. 19. As an example, there was evidence that the District inquired regarding placement of STUDENT in a nonpublic school, the Speech and Language Development Center, and was told that one reason why the school would not take STUDENT was because he was not toilet trained.

20. The school psychologist recommended a consistent paraeducator to work with STUDENT as a one-to-one aide. 21. The present levels of performance include a statement that STUDENT had been shadowing an APE class “since he seems to enjoy it so much and it is also beneficial to him.” 22. Although this was not a substantive issue specifically identified by the Petitioner, Ms. PARENT did assert that this was an area that had been neglected for assessment. 23. There is nothing in the evidence to indicate that the District would conduct any analysis of STUDENT’s behavior or take any particular steps to address its impact on his learning. 24. The change of placement described in the January 2003 IEP appears to have been an attempt to effect a disciplinary change of placement without the required procedural protections.

25. The Hearing Office has generally held that there are reasonable limitations on the right of the parents to compel a reassessment at the expense of the local educational agency. For example, a showing of changed circumstances may be required if successive requests are made within a relatively short time. Student v. Fresno Unified School District SN96-00235.