California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 9, 1998
Student v. Buckeye Union Elementary School District
SEHO Case No. SN 623-97 · Hearing Officer Keltie Jones
Buckeye Union Elementary must reimburse Waldorf tuition, tutoring and independent assessments; its December 1997 mainstream offer was upheld.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Parents of a 13-year-old sixth-grader at Cedar Springs Waldorf School filed for due process against Buckeye Union Elementary School District. The District had classified the student as having "limited intellectual functioning" (mentally retarded). The parents believed she was learning disabled. The Hearing Officer found both the 1996 and 1997 District assessments inappropriate. The school psychologist relied almost entirely on one IQ test (WISC-III), which was unreliable given the student's severe language deficits, and the 1996 assessment did not measure adaptive behavior at all. The District had to reimburse the parents for independent assessments by Dr. Gordon Ulrey and Dr. Arthur Singer, but not for Dr. Singer's school observations done to prepare for the hearing. For 1996-97, the District never made a formal placement offer. Its May 1997 IEP offered 60% special education without naming a class or school, which failed the Union School District v. Smith requirement for a clear written offer. A December 1997 offer of full mainstreaming at Rolling Hills Middle School, with special education support and teachers skilled in the arts, did provide a FAPE starting January 5, 1998. The District had to reimburse Waldorf tuition, tutoring and transportation through that date, plus summer 1996 and 1997 tutoring, because it offered no appropriate extended school year (ESY) program. Claims for gross motor services, swimming, and a reading-for-the-blind program were denied. The District also had to hold an IEP meeting to reconsider the student's eligibility category.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Union School District v. Smith. An IEP that gives only percentages of special education, without naming a class, school or setting, was not a valid placement offer. It also shows that an eligibility finding based on one IQ test that ignores a student's language deficits can make an assessment inappropriate.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessments conducted by Arthur Singer, Ph.D. and Gordon Ulrey, Ph.D.?
District's 1996 and 1997 assessments were inappropriate because they relied on a single test (WISC-III) that did not account for the student's language deficits; parents reimbursed for Ulrey and Singer assessments, but not for Singer's school observations prepared for the hearing.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2. Did the District offer a FAPE for the 1996-97 school year?
District never made a formal placement offer, orally or in writing, for 1996-97 and so did not offer a FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Did the District offer a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year?
May 1997 IEP offering 60% special education without naming a class or school was not a proper placement offer; the December 1997 fully mainstreamed offer at Rolling Hills Middle School with special education support was a FAPE from January 5, 1998.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of placement at Waldorf, including transportation and private tutoring, during the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school years, through the date of the hearing decision?
Waldorf and tutoring were proper and met the student's needs; parents reimbursed for tuition, tutoring and transportation through January 5, 1998, but not after the District's appropriate offer.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5. Should the District be ordered to prospectively place the student at the Waldorf School for the duration of the 1997-98 school year and seek a waiver from the Department of Education?
Because the December 1997 offer was appropriate, the request for prospective Waldorf placement was denied.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 6. Did the District offer an appropriate program for the extended school year during the summers of 1996 and 1997?
Student needed ESY to retain skills; the year-round placements the District relied on were inappropriate, so it did not offer appropriate ESY.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 7. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private tutoring during the summers of 1996 and 1997?
Summer 1:1 tutoring by the Waldorf teacher met the student's needs and provided benefit; parents reimbursed under Burlington.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 8. Did the IEPs adequately address delays in gross motor skills?
Information given to the District showed good gross motor skills, so it had no reason to suspect a need to assess or serve that area.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 9. Should the District reimburse the parents for the swimming program, including transportation, during the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school years?
No evidence showed swimming was necessary for the student to benefit from her education.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 10. Should the District reimburse the parents for the cost of the Reading for the Blind and Dyslexic program?
No evidence showed the program was necessary for the student to benefit from her education.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- IEE at public expense. District to reimburse parents for assessments by Dr. Ulrey and Dr. Singer upon proof of actual amounts paid; not required to reimburse Dr. Singer's school observations.
- Reimbursement. District to reimburse Waldorf tuition and private tutoring for 1996-97 and for 1997-98 through January 5, 1998, including transportation to and from school, upon proof of amounts paid and distance; transportation at the District's employee reimbursement rate.
- Reimbursement. District to reimburse cost of tutoring by Ms. Connolly during the summers of 1996 and 1997 upon proof of actual amounts paid.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District to convene an IEP team meeting within 15 days of the decision to determine the appropriate classification of the student's disabilities, including her speech and language disability and any others the team determines.
Key authorities
Union School Dist. v. Smith; Rowley; Burlington; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Bd. of Education; Educ. Code § 56320; Educ. Code § 56329(b); 5 C.C.R. § 3042(a); 5 C.C.R. § 3043
People named in the decision
- Lola Westphal, director of special education, Buckeye Union Elementary School District
- Barbara Morton, SELPA director, El Dorado County SELPA
- Patti Connolly, private school teacher and private tutor, Cedar Springs Waldorf School
- Arthur Singer, educational psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
- Gordon Ulrey, psychologist; independent assessor
- Sandy Johannsen, school psychologist, Buckeye Union Elementary School District
- Patricia Balthazor, speech and language pathologist; witness for Student
- Carol Buethe, RSP teacher; assessor, Buckeye Union Elementary School District
- Dean Orr, resource teacher; assessor, Buckeye Union Elementary School District
- Kathryn Mayr, speech and language specialist; assessor, Buckeye Union Elementary School District
- Jean Costello, speech and language specialist; assessor, Buckeye Union Elementary School District
- Ms. Canez, school nurse, Buckeye Union Elementary School District
- Gloria Silva, principal, Buckeye Union Elementary School District
- Terri Haverty, teacher, Buckeye Union Elementary School District
- Helen Brissenden, teacher, Buckeye Union Elementary School District
- Judith Meagles, general education teacher, Rolling Hills Middle School, Buckeye Union Elementary School District
- Patty Youngdahl, general education teacher, Rolling Hills Middle School, Buckeye Union Elementary School District
- Roberta Hulit, law clerk for Student's counsel
- Cedar Springs Waldorf School, private school
- Diagnostic School for Neurologically Handicapped Children (Fresno), state diagnostic center; prior evaluator
- Valley Mountain Regional Center, regional center (prior services)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 623-97 Case Year: 1997 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Assessment Eligibility Placement Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 09-61838 District: Buckeye Union Elementary Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability
Case Details This matter convened for hearing on December 11 and 12, 1997, January 22, 23, 26 and 28, and February 26 and 27, 1998, in Shingle Springs, California, before Hearing Officer Keltie Jones of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) located at McGeorge School of Law.
The Petitioner was represented at the hearing by attorney Richard Ruderman. Also present at the hearing on the Petitioner's behalf were her parents, FATHER and MOTHER. Law clerk Roberta Hulit attended for portions of the hearing.
Respondent Buckeye Union Elementary School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Ann Murray. Also present on the District's behalf were Lola Westphal, director of special education, and Barbara Morton, director of the El Dorado County SELPA.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Lola Westphal, teacher Patti Connolly, educational psychologist Arthur Singer, school psychologist Sandy Johannsen, MOTHER, FATHER, and speech and language pathologist Patricia Balthazor.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: teacher Carol Buethe, teacher Dean Orr, speech and language specialist Kathryn Mayr, principal Gloria Silva, teacher Terri Haverty, teacher Helen Brissenden, teacher Judith Meagles, Barbara Morton, and Lola Westphal.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and written closing arguments were submitted. The record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING (Footnote 1)
Assessment issues:
1. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessments conducted by Arthur Singer, Ph.D. and Gordon Ulrey, Ph.D.?
Regular School Year Issues:
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1996-97 school year?
3. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year?
4 . Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of her placement at Waldorf, including transportation costs and the cost of private tutoring for STUDENT, during the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school years, through the date of the hearing decision?
5 . Should the District be ordered to prospectively place STUDENT at the Waldorf School for the duration of the 1997-98 school year and seek a waiver from the Department of Education for her placement?
Extended school year issues:
6. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate program for the extended school year during the summers of 1996 and 1997?
7. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private tutoring for STUDENT during the summers of 1996 and 1997?
Related services issues:
8. Did STUDENT's IEPs adequately address her delays in gross motor skills?
9. Should the District be required to reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of STUDENT's swimming program, including transportation costs, during the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school years?
10. Should the District be required to reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of the Reading for the Blind and Dyslexic program?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old sixth-grader. The District has qualified her for special education services under the category of limited intellectual functioning, or mentally retarded. However, STUDENT's parents believe that she is learning disabled rather than mentally retarded.
The PARENTS took custody of STUDENT when she was three days old and adopted her at nineteen months old. When STUDENT was three months old, her pediatrician noted some developmental delays and diagnosed her with a type of cerebral palsy. STUDENT began receiving occupational therapy and speech and language therapy at a very young age and became a client of the Valley Mountain Regional Center, which serves developmentally disabled individuals. In January 1989, STUDENT began attending a communicatively handicapped preschool class in Amador County, where her family lived at the time. STUDENT made limited progress in this class.
In January 1990, psychologist Dr. Gordon Ulrey assessed STUDENT and concluded that she had borderline to low average cognitive ability, with a significant scatter in her subtest scores. STUDENT showed significant weakness in auditory processing as well as in sequential processing tasks. (Pet. Exh. 211.)
In March 1990, the Diagnostic School for Neurologically Handicapped Children (Diagnostic School) in Fresno completed a further evaluation of STUDENT. The Diagnostic School agreed with Dr. Ulrey's conclusion that STUDENT's cognitive abilities were in the borderline to low average range and found that her daily living skills were age appropriate. The Diagnostic School also concluded that STUDENT had visual and auditory processing disorders that interfered with her language and academic development. The Diagnostic School recommended a multi-sensory educational approach that incorporated music, movement, sensory experiences, and manipulatives to help STUDENT learn in spite of her processing difficulties. The Diagnostic School also suggested that STUDENT continue her involvement with "whole body motion activities," such as swimming and horseback riding.
In July 1990, the Regional Center terminated its services to STUDENT, finding that she did not qualify as developmentally disabled. (Pet. Exh. 68-69.)
After receiving the Diagnostic School report, the PARENTS began to look into the kindergarten options available for STUDENT. They were looking for a classroom that would provide the type of learning environment the report recommended. In the fall of 1990, the PARENTS enrolled STUDENT in the Cedar Springs Waldorf School (Waldorf). Waldorf uses a holistic teaching style, incorporating music, art, movement, and visual and auditory stimuli. The PARENTS concluded that Waldorf provided precisely the type of learning environment STUDENT needed. Waldorf enrolled STUDENT on a conditional basis, indicating that she could remain at the school so long as the teachers believed they could serve STUDENT's special needs. At that time, the PARENTS stopped requesting IEP meetings and stopped receiving services from their school district.
STUDENT stayed in the Waldorf kindergarten for two years, which is not unusual for Waldorf. (Testimony of Ms. Patti Connolly.) When STUDENT was ready to enter first grade in 1992, the teacher for the class, Ms. Connolly, agreed to take her if the parents provided an aide to help with her learning difficulties. During the first-grade year, Ms. Connolly determined that STUDENT performed better when she did not have the one-to-one aide, and the services of the aide were discontinued. STUDENT did receive special one-to-one tutoring from Ms. Connolly during times when the rest of the class were studying Japanese. In the Waldorf style, a class has the same teacher from first grade through eighth grade. Therefore, Ms. Connolly has continued as the teacher for STUDENT's class through the present time. Ms. Connolly's annual reports indicate that STUDENT has made significant progress at Waldorf, but that her reading and math skills remain below grade level.
In September 1995, the PARENTS moved to Shingle Springs in the Buckeye Union Elementary School
District to be closer to STUDENT's Waldorf school. In February 1996, the PARENTS requested that the District perform a complete psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT. (Dist. Exh. 40.) On March 20, 1996, RSP teacher Carol Buethe administered the Woodcock-Johnson Test of Achievement - Revised (WJ-R). (Dist. Exh. 18, 19.) On March 29, 1996, Dr. Sandy Johannsen administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC-III) and the Bender Motor Gestalt test. (Dist. Exh. 17.) On April 3, 1996, Ms. Canez, the school nurse, performed a health, vision and hearing screening. (Dist. Exh. 13.) On four days during April and May, speech and language specialists Kathy Mayr and Jean Costello performed a speech and language evaluation, including the following tests: Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals - 3 (CELF-3), Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test (PPVT), Token Test, Listening Test, SCAN Test, Bracken Basic Concept Scale, and Wepman Auditory Discrimination Test.
An IEP team meeting convened on May 9, 1996, to discuss the assessment results. The sole documentation of the meeting is a two-page comments sheet summarizing the reporting of the assessment results. The IEP document lists the following needs for STUDENT:
Learning safety issues - reasoning Academic - increasing skills Receptive and expressive language Life skills with students with like disabilities Peer interactions with students with like maturation
The comments also indicate that the team agreed that STUDENT qualified for special education services under the category "Limited Intellectual Functioning," although the parents did not sign the document and did not agree with that categorization. There is no specific placement identified on the document, but it does state that the "parents will think about recommendations and make their determination." (Dist. Exh. 5.)
According to MOTHER, the District suggested that the PARENTS observe the special day class (SDC) that would be available for STUDENT at Silva Valley Elementary School. The PARENTS did observe the Silva Valley sixth grade SDC, even though they did not agree that STUDENT needed to move into sixth grade from the fourth grade Waldorf class. MOTHER testified that Ms. Buethe told her that the class at Silva Valley might not be operating during the next academic year and that they should also look at the SDCs at Blue Oak Elementary School or Rolling Hills Middle School or a fifth grade SDC. MOTHER testified that the class they observed at Silva Valley would not meet STUDENT's needs. While MOTHER was there, children moved in and out of the class and she did not see a multi-sensory approach in use, such as that recommended by the Diagnostic Center. (Footnote 2)
After deciding that the services the District had to offer would not meet STUDENT's needs, the PARENTS decided to obtain their own summer services as they had in the past. During the summer of 1996, the PARENTS hired Ms. Connolly to provide tutoring for ten hours per week for eleven weeks.
On August 20, 1996, the PARENTS wrote to the District, indicating their dissatisfaction with the SDC they viewed and requesting that STUDENT receive the speech and language therapy recommended in the May 1996 assessment. An IEP team meeting convened on September 5, 1996, to discuss the issue of speech and language therapy. There was no discussion at that meeting of the classroom placements available for STUDENT. MOTHER signed the IEP, agreeing to the speech and language therapy recommended. STUDENT began receiving one half-hour of speech therapy per week after school. On January 17, 1997, an IEP team meeting convened to review the speech and languages goals and progress. Speech and language therapy services were continued.
In May 1997, STUDENT had another series of assessments. On May 2 and 5, Ms. Mayr conducted a speech and language evaluation. (Dist. Exh. 12.) On May 1 and 2, Dr. Johannsen administered the WISC-III, the Bender Motor Gestalt, and the Normative Adaptive Behavior Checklist. (Dist. Exh. 11.) On May 2, resource teacher Dean Orr administered the WJ-R. Dr. Johannsen again concluded that STUDENT had limited intellectual functioning. Dr. Johannsen stated that STUDENT needed to be placed in a class with students her own age and to associate with students with like disabilities.
An IEP team meeting convened on May 12, 1997, to discuss the results of the assessment. At that meeting, the PARENTS requested that the District fund STUDENT's placement at Waldorf. They also expressed their continuing disagreement with categorizing STUDENT as mentally retarded. The District offered special education services consisting of sixty percent "special education program or service" and forty percent "mainstreamed" with continuing speech and language services. The IEP did not specify which class the District was recommending for STUDENT. The PARENTS also asked for educational services during the summer break. The District did not offer a classroom program for the summer, but did eventually arrange for speech and language services to continue through the summer using four different therapists to cover the sessions. The PARENTS eventually chose not to use the speech and language services offered in July and August because they did not believe STUDENT would adjust well to working with so many different therapists. The PARENTS did not sign agreement to this IEP and filed a request for due process hearing on May 19, 1997.
During the summer of 1997, the PARENTS again hired Ms. Connolly to tutor STUDENT for ten hours per week. On June 17, 1997, STUDENT was assessed by psychologist Dr. Arthur Singer. On five different days from May through July 1997, STUDENT was also assessed again by Dr. Ulrey. Both Dr. Singer and Dr. Ulrey concluded that STUDENT is not mentally retarded.
On December 1, 1997, the District offered to place STUDENT in a fully mainstreamed program at Rolling Hills Middle School with special education assistance for all of the academic classes. The academic classes would be taught by teachers who have strengths in art and drama. In addition, STUDENT would take band and physical education without any special education assistance in those classes. During the hearing, the PARENTS had an opportunity to spend a day at Rolling Hills to observe the placement being offered. Although the PARENTS thought the classes they observed were very good for regular education students, they did not believe that they would meet STUDENT's needs.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Assessment issues:
1. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessment conducted by Arthur Singer, Ph.D. and Gordon Ulrey, Ph.D.?
California Education Code § 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation.
For the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which include that tests be administered in a nondiscriminatory manner by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions, validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, and tailored to assess specific areas of educational need. Section 56320(d) requires that aptitude and achievement tests are selected to ensure that a student's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills do not affect the accuracy of the results. No single procedure can be used as the sole criterion for determining the appropriate program. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists. Educ. Code § 56324(a).
The Petitioner asserts that the District's assessments performed in 1996 and 1997 were inadequate because the assessors erroneously concluded in both assessments that STUDENT is mentally retarded (MR). The Petitioner argues that these conclusions are based solely on an inaccurate measure of her cognitive ability and that the assessors ignored other available information regarding her ability to perform in an educational environment.
The District asserts that both the 1996 and 1997 assessments were complete assessments that appropriately found STUDENT to qualify for special education as MR pursuant to the law. Under California law, a student is MR if she "has significantly below average general intellectual functioning existing concurrently with deficits in adaptive behavior and manifested during the developmental period, which adversely affect a pupil's educational performance." 5 C.C.R. § 3030(h). The District insists that it accurately concluded that STUDENT has low cognitive ability and adaptive behavior deficits that qualify her as MR.
Each of the assessments will be discussed separately.
1996 Assessment:
The 1996 assessment consisted of cognitive ability and achievement tests, as well as a full battery of speech and language tests. All of the tests were given by qualified specialists (school psychologist, resource specialist, and speech and language specialists). The Hearing Officer finds that, although the basic elements of an appropriate assessment were present, there were significant deficiencies in the assessment and the assessment report from Dr. Johannsen that make the 1996 assessment inappropriate.
Dr. Johannsen used only one cognitive ability measurement with STUDENT, the WISC-III. (Footnote 3) On that test, STUDENT obtained a Verbal IQ score of 62, a Performance IQ of 68, and a Full Scale IQ of 62. The report of the cognitive ability testing was dated March 29, 1996, the same day as the testing. The report did not discuss how STUDENT's results on the speech and language assessments, which were performed after March 29, may have affected this measurement of her cognitive ability. Specifically, the Token Test and the Listening Test showed that STUDENT had severe language deficits, including difficulty understanding lengthy verbal instructions. (Dist. Exh. 16.) STUDENT scored better on the portions of the WISC-III that did not involve verbal instructions or that supplemented verbal instructions with visual examples. (Testimony of Dr. Singer.) In addition, the WISC-III is not the best test to use to measure cognitive ability with language-disordered students. (Testimony of Ms. Westphal.) The Hearing Officer finds that the cognitive ability test was selected and administered without any consideration of the effect STUDENT's speech and language impairments would have on the accuracy of the results, and that, therefore, the results of the WISC- III are unreliable.
Dr. Johannsen concluded that STUDENT qualified as MR, and the District proceeded to indicate that category on her IEPs. However, during the 1996 assessment, Dr. Johannsen failed to assess adaptive behavior, a crucial element of MR. Dr. Johannsen relied entirely on the WISC-III scores in classifying STUDENT as MR and recommending she be placed in a class with students with like disabilities.
Dr. Johannsen's two-page, handwritten report concludes with the following paragraph:
STUDENT is tall and physically mature for her chronological age. This testor [sic.] questions the current 4th grade placement in the private school. A 6th grade placement in a class for students with like disabilities is recommended. In a public school, this would be a special day class. She needs to learn "coping-life skills" as soon as possible.
Nothing in the report indicates that STUDENT has deficits in "coping-life skills," and, at the hearing, Dr. Johannsen could not recall the basis for this conclusion. Dr. Johannsen did not observe STUDENT in her Waldorf class and could not testify about whether STUDENT was physically out of place in her class. In fact, the class picture submitted into evidence shows that STUDENT is not the largest student in her class. (Pet. Exh. 1.)
The Hearing Officer finds that the assessment conclusions are inappropriate, based upon the information that was available to Dr. Johannsen. The Hearing Officer further finds that Dr. Johannsen's placement recommendation of a "class for students with like disabilities" was based upon only one procedure -- the WISC-III test -- the results of which Dr. Johannsen admitted in her report were questionable due to STUDENT's discomfort in the testing environment. Placing a child based solely upon her IQ scores is in direct violation of Education Code section 56320, which provides that one single procedure cannot be used as the sole criterion for determining placement. Moreover, the scores relied upon were unreliable because they did not conform to the requirement of section 56320(d) that test results reflect actual ability, not a student's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills.
1997 Assessment:
For the 1997 assessment, Dr. Johannsen repeated the WISC-III and Bender tests and also prepared a Normative Adaptive Behavior Checklist, which consisted of asking STUDENT to perform certain tasks. STUDENT's Performance IQ score was 74, her Verbal IQ score was 56, and her Full Scale IQ score was 62. STUDENT's score on the Perceptual Organization Index, which is a combination of several nonverbal performance subtests, was 83. (Dist. Exh. 11.)
Again, the only cognitive ability test given to STUDENT was the WISC-III, which, as established above, is unreliable for students with language disorders. Although Dr. Johannsen did administer a test to measure adaptive behavior for this assessment, her report provided virtually no information about what the results of that test meant, other than to indicate that STUDENT was knowledgeable about three convenience foods and could not make change. (Dist. Exh. 11.) Dr. Singer testified that a test that requires STUDENT to perform tasks in front of the tester would not provide an accurate measure of STUDENT's abilities in the real world. Dr. Johannsen did not seek any input from STUDENT's parents or teachers in evaluating STUDENT's adaptive behavior.
Dr. Johannsen's 1997 report concludes with the following summary of STUDENT's needs:
The needs for STUDENT would be similar to the needs listed last year. She is a tall, well developed young lady and must feel unusual in a class of 5th graders. Perhaps a placement in a class of students nearer her own age could be considered. She needs to associate with students with like disabilities. She needs to learn "life skills" along with academics.
(Dist. Exh. 11.) Again, these conclusions are based upon unreliable tests and do not take into account other information that was available to the assessor, such as STUDENT's classwork and ability to perform in an educational environment.
The Hearing Officer finds that both the 1996 and 1997 District assessments were inappropriate because Dr. Johannsen relied exclusively, or too heavily, on a single procedure, the WISC-III test, for her conclusions and recommendations. The Hearing Officer further finds that the evidence established that the IQ scores generated by the WISC-III are not a reliable measure of STUDENT's cognitive ability because her language deficits were not taken into account in the selection and administration of the test. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's conclusion that STUDENT qualifies as MR is erroneous because it is not supported by proper assessment procedures, as delineated in Education Code section 56320. (Footntoe 4)
Given that the District's assessments were not appropriate, STUDENT's parents are entitled to an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist. In this case, the PARENTS are seeking reimbursement for the assessment performed by Dr. Ulrey, the assessment performed by Dr. Singer, and the observations of the Waldorf and District programs by Dr. Singer. The Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Ulrey's assessment and for the assessment Dr. Singer performed to complete his report dated June 17, 1997. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the school observations Dr. Singer performed and the reports he prepared were not part of his educational evaluation of STUDENT. Rather, those observations and reports were part of the Petitioner's preparations for the due process hearing and the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for those costs pursuant to Education Code section 56329(b).
Regular School Year Issues:
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1996-97 school year?
The IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes a placement for a student. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3)(A-B). In Union School District v. Smith, (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, the court stated, "this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously." The court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement: (1) to alert the parent of the need to consider seriously whether the proposed placement was appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services, and (3) so that the district is more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence to the Hearing Officer for the appropriateness of the placement. Smith, at 1526. Moreover, the Smith court found that "a school district cannot escape its obligation under the IDEA to offer formally an appropriate education placement by arguing that a disabled child's parents expressed unwillingness to accept that placement." Ibid.
For the 1996-97 school year, the District did not make any written offer of placement for STUDENT. The District argues that, in spite of the lack of a written placement offer, the PARENTS understood what program the District was proposing for STUDENT because they visited a class at Silva Valley and decided to reject that class. The evidence at the hearing did not support this contention. In fact, the PARENTS were confused about what the District was offering for STUDENT because they were told that the class they visited in spring 1996 may not be operating during the 1996-97 school year. Moreover, there was no evidence that the District ever clearly delineated which class it proposed for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not offer a FAPE to STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year because it never made a formal placement offer, either orally or in writing.
3. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et sq.; California Education Code §§ 56000 et seq. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1402(8), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability ..." 20 U.S.C. § 1402(25).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458
U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court stated that "the µbasic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." 458 U.S. 176, 200.
Taken together, the IDEA and the Rowley Court's interpretation of the IDEA provide the following four factors for analyzing whether the placement the District offered for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year provided a FAPE:
(a) whether the placement was designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs; (b) whether the placement provided an education in the least restrictive environment; (c) whether the placement was designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT; and (d) whether the placement conformed to STUDENT's IEP.
In determining whether the District has offered a FAPE, one must focus on the adequacy of the District's program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314. If the District's program reflects the child's needs, provides some benefit, and comports with the IEP, the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents' preferred program would result in greater educational benefit.
In this case, STUDENT's placement for the 1997-98 school year was discussed at two different times: at the May 1997 IEP meeting and in settlement discussions in December 1997. Each of these circumstances will be discussed separately.
May 1997 IEP Meeting
The May 1997 IEP indicates that the District offered to provide STUDENT with special education services for 60% of the day with 40% of the day spent mainstreamed in regular education classes. (Footnote 5) The Hearing Officer finds that this offer, although written, is not sufficient to describe a placement pursuant to California law, and therefore does not satisfy the requirements of Smith. California law defines special education placement as "that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs." 5 C.C.R. § 3042(a). Although the comments portion of the IEP indicated that the team believed that STUDENT's needs would be served best in an SDC setting, the IEP did not state which SDC was being proposed or even which school STUDENT would be attending. Thus, no facility, personnel or location was specified in the IEP.
Furthermore, the confusion surrounding what SDC services consist of in the District made it impossible for the parents to make an informed decision even as to the type of services the District was offering for STUDENT. The District staff testified that SDC services can be provided either in a self-contained class or in regular education classes. However, the District staff did not explain these options to the PARENTS at the May 1997 IEP meeting. In addition, the documents the District provides to parents that describe program options do not support this position. In fact, those documents define an SDC as a separate, self-contained special education classroom. (Pet. Exh. 458, 468-471.) As a result of this confusion, not only was it impossible for the parents to make an informed decision about the services offered for STUDENT, it is also impossible for the Hearing Officer to determine what type of services the District was offering with the May 1997 IEP or whether they would meet the least restrictive environment requirement. The confusion surrounding the District's offer is precisely the type of problem the court in Smith found unacceptable.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds the May 1997 IEP did not constitute a proper placement offer and did not provide a FAPE for STUDENT.
December 1997 Placement Offer
On December 1, 1997, the District made its first placement offer that meets the definition of placement and comports with Smith. The December 1997 offer consisted of a full schedule of regular education sixth-grade classes at Rolling Hills Middle School taught by Ms. Judy Meagles and Ms. Patty Youngdahl with support from special education teachers and aides in the classes. In addition, STUDENT would take band and physical education without special education assistance. This placement would have started on January 5, 1998, because the year-round "track" to which STUDENT would be assigned was "off-track" in December. Ms. Meagles testified that she is an internationally known artist and that she incorporates art into her math and science instruction. Ms. Meagles uses a thematic instruction technique, in which all subjects follow and incorporate a single theme. Ms. Youngdahl teaches drama in addition to language arts and social studies.
MOTHER testified that, based on her one-day visit to Rolling Hills, she did not believe the placement proposed would meet STUDENT's needs. She stated that the arts were not incorporated into the regular classroom instruction. However, she did testify that there was a watercolor project in the science class and that she observed the class using tangram manipulatives during math. MOTHER testified that Ms. Youngdahl told her that drama is not used regularly in the language arts/social studies instruction, but is taught separately during the time STUDENT would take band. MOTHER also objected to the size of the classes, each of which had 30-33 students, with twice that number in band. MOTHER did note that there were at least two adults with each academic class.
The Hearing Officer finds that the December 1997 placement meets STUDENT's unique needs for multi- sensory instruction and the incorporation of the arts into academic instruction. The fact that MOTHER on one day did not observe a significant use of the arts does not change the fact that the teachers have the artistic background and skills to draw upon in teaching STUDENT or outweigh the credible District staff testimony about the use of the arts in those classes. (Testimony of Ms. Haverty, Ms. Silva, Ms. Meagles.) With respect to class size, the student-teacher ratio in the math/science and language arts/history classes is approximately 15:1, with one of the adults in the class having the specific responsibility of assisting STUDENT and other special education students. Thus, even though the classes are larger than those at Waldorf, STUDENT would still have a low student-teacher ratio. The District also proposed that STUDENT have a 1:1 aide during language arts/history. The PARENTS testified that having a 1:1 aide did not work well for STUDENT during first grade. However, the District staff testified that the special education aides in the regular education classes are there to assist various students as needed and do not generally single out particular students. (Testimony of Ms. Haverty, Ms. Silva.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposal for a 1:1 aide in language arts/history does not make the placement offer inappropriate. The Hearing Officer also finds that this placement meets STUDENT's need to be with regular education students and provides an education in the least restrictive environment. At Rolling Hills, STUDENT would spend her entire day in classes with regular education students.
The PARENTS also expressed concerns about moving STUDENT from one school to another in the middle of the school year. Dr. Singer and Ms. Connolly both testified that STUDENT's shyness may make it very difficult for her to adjust to a new school mid-year. However, at the time the District proposed the placement, STUDENT's potential classmates were on vacation through the beginning of January. Thus, if the PARENTS had accepted the offer, STUDENT would have started school at the beginning of a new track session after a natural break in the year. There was no evidence other than speculations that STUDENT would not be able to adjust to this new school in a reasonable period of time. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that proposing this placement mid-year did not make it inappropriate.
As for educational benefit, the Petitioner contends that this placement would not be educationally beneficial for STUDENT. However, such contentions are purely speculative, based upon the differences between this placement and the Waldorf school. The Hearing Officer agrees that Waldorf has clearly provided educational benefit to STUDENT and that the Waldorf approach is very well- suited to STUDENT's needs. With the curriculum modifications Ms. Connolly makes, STUDENT has been able to gain educational and academic benefit from the regular education Waldorf curriculum. However, the District has a duty to provide a program that will confer some educational benefit; it is not obligated to provide the ideal program. Based upon the fact that the placement includes teachers proficient in the arts, exposure to the regular education curriculum, and assistance from special education teachers to reinforce concepts and modify curriculum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's program is likely to provide some educational and academic benefit to STUDENT.
With respect to the requirement that a placement conform to the IEP, STUDENT does not have an agreed-upon IEP to which the placement would have to conform.
Because the December 1997 placement met STUDENT's unique needs in the least restrictive environment and was likely to provide some educational benefit, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE from January 5, 1998, through the end of the school year.
4 . Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of her placement at Waldorf, including transportation costs and the cost of private tutoring for STUDENT, during the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school years, through the date of the hearing decision?
In School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 105 S.Ct. 2003, the United States Supreme Court determined that when the proposed public school placement is inappropriate, parents of a student eligible for special education may be entitled to reimbursement for expenses that they incur in educating their child if the placement they provided is proper under the IDEA. To be eligible for reimbursement, the program the parents provided need not be the perfect placement for the child, nor must it be a certified nonpublic school. See Carter v. Florence County School District Four (1993) 510 U.S. 7; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. Texas Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153.
In this case, the PARENTS chose to keep STUDENT in the Waldorf school with private tutoring rather than accept the inappropriate placements offered during the 1996-97 school year and the first half of the 1997-98 school year. Therefore, so long as the Waldorf school was proper for STUDENT, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of those educational services incurred during those time periods.
The evidence at the hearing established that the program STUDENT received at Waldorf, including the 1:1 tutoring from Ms. Connolly, served her educational needs. STUDENT made progress in the Waldorf program and advanced from grade to grade with her class. (Testimony of Ms. Connolly. Pet. Exh. 248 -308.) The Waldorf curriculum served her need for multi-sensory instruction and incorporation of the arts into other subjects. The tutoring sessions with Ms. Connolly gave STUDENT the repetition she needed to reinforce concepts taught in class. The Waldorf class also served her need to be with normally developing peers. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Waldorf school and the private tutoring were proper for STUDENT and that the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of those services, including transportation, through January 5, 1998.
5 . Should the District be ordered to prospectively place STUDENT at the Waldorf School for the duration of the 1997-98 school year and seek a waiver from the Department of Education for her placement?
As discussed above, the District offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the second half of the 1997-98 school year. Therefore, the request for an order requiring the District to place STUDENT at Waldorf for the remainder of the school year is denied.
Extended school year issues:
6. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate program for the extended school year during the summers of 1996 and 1997?
California Education Code section 56345(b)(5) provides that "(b) [w]hen appropriate, the individualized education program shall also include, but not be limited to, all of the following: ... (5) Extended school year services when needed, as determined by the individualized education program team." Additionally, California Code of Regulations section 3043 provides that
[e]xtended school year services shall be provided for each individual with exceptional needs who has unique needs and requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year. Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil's educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition.
The District asserts that it had no basis to determine whether STUDENT required extended school year (ESY) services because she had never attended District schools. The District also argues that the placements it offered for the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school year were year-round programs that commenced in July, making an ESY program unnecessary.
MOTHER and Ms. Connolly convincingly testified that STUDENT needed consistent repetition over the summer months of the concepts learned during the school year to be able to retain and use those concepts. Dr. Singer also testified that he believed STUDENT qualifies for ESY services. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT qualified for ESY services in 1996 and 1997. The programs the District purported to offer for the summers of 1996 and 1997 (year-round placements starting in July) have been found to be inappropriate. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not offer appropriate ESY services for STUDENT. The District's assertion that it is not responsible for providing summer programs for private school students is irrelevant in light of the fact that STUDENT's parents were not given an appropriate public school alternative. It would be illogical to require parents to accept inappropriate public school placements simply to maintain their child's right to ESY services.
7. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private tutoring for STUDENT during the summers of 1996 and 1997?
In the absence of an appropriate summer school program from the District, the PARENTS engaged Ms. Connolly to provide 1:1 tutoring to STUDENT during the summers of 1996 and 1997. Ms. Connolly worked with STUDENT to reinforce the concepts covered during the regular academic year to ensure that she retained them. The Hearing Officer finds that the tutoring services served STUDENT's needs and provided educational benefit. Although individual tutoring is not the LRE, it would be unreasonable to expect the PARENTS to provide such an environment using their own resources. Therefore, pursuant to Burlington, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for those services.
Related services issues:
8. Did STUDENT's IEPs adequately address her delays in gross motor skills?
The Petitioner asserts that the District did not assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability because it did not assess and address her gross motor skills. However, although gross motor deficits were identified by the Diagnostic Center in 1990, the information provided to the District in 1996 and 1997 about STUDENT indicated that she had good gross motor skills. The PARENTS told the District in 1996 and 1997 that STUDENT was swimming on a competitive team and skiing at an intermediate level; they did not identify gross motor skills as one of her problem areas. (Dist. Exh. 14.) Moreover, the yearly reports from Waldorf show that STUDENT was not having gross motor difficulties in the Waldorf games program. (Pet. Exh. 248-308.) Dr. Singer testified that although STUDENT is somewhat awkward, he did not see a gross impairment and would not recommend an OT or APE assessment for her. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not have cause to suspect that STUDENT needed to be assessed in the area of gross motor skills or that STUDENT needed special education services to address any deficits in those skills.
9. Should the District be required to reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of STUDENT's swimming program, including transportation costs, during the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school years?
Under both federal and California law, a special education student is entitled to receive related services that are necessary to allow the student to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); California Education Code § 56363. FATHER testified that STUDENT's swimming program improves her coordination and helps her with processing information by making her concentrate on and plan the sequencing of her strokes. However, there was no evidence presented at hearing that this activity is necessary for STUDENT to benefit from her education. Although swimming may be helpful for STUDENT, if it is not necessary for her to benefit from her education, the District does not have to pay for it. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is not required to reimburse the PARENTS for STUDENT's swimming program.
10. Should the District be required to reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of the Reading for the Blind and Dyslexic program?
As with the swimming program, there was no evidence presented at hearing that the Reading for the Blind and Dyslexic program is necessary for STUDENT to benefit from her education. FATHER testified that it is another tool that they use to improve STUDENT's reading, but no witnesses testified that this is a necessary service for STUDENT. As such, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is not required to reimburse the PARENTS for the Reading for the Blind and Dyslexic program.
ORDER
1. The District shall reimburse the PARENTS for the cost of the assessments performed by Dr. Ulrey and Dr. Singer, upon provision of proof of the actual amounts paid. The District is not required to reimburse the PARENTS for the school observations performed by Dr. Singer.
2. The District shall reimburse the PARENTS for the costs of tuition at the Waldorf school and private tutoring for the 1996-97 school year and for the 1997-98 school year, through January 5, 1998, including the cost of transportation to and from school, upon provision of proof of the actual amounts paid and distance of transportation provided. Transportation shall be reimbursed at the rate the District has set for reimbursing its employees.
3. The District shall reimburse the PARENTS for the cost of tutoring by Ms. Connolly during the summers of 1996 and 1997, upon provision of proof of the actual amounts paid.
4. The District shall convene an IEP team meeting within fifteen days of the date of this decision to determine the appropriate classification of STUDENT's disabilities, including her speech and language disability and any other disabilities as the IEP team determines.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessments conducted by Arthur Singer, Ph.D. and Gordon Ulrey, Ph.D.? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1996-97 school year? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
3. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year? To the extent that the placement offered in May 1997 was inappropriate, the Petitioner prevailed on this issue. To the extent that the placement offered in December 1997 was appropriate, the District prevailed on this issue.
4 . Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of her placement at Waldorf, including transportation costs and the cost of private tutoring for STUDENT, during the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school years, through the date of the hearing decision? The Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.
5 . Should the District be ordered to prospectively place STUDENT at the Waldorf School for the duration of the 1997-98 school year and seek a waiver from the Department of Education for her placement? The District prevailed on this issue.
6. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate program for the extended school year during the summers of 1996 and 1997? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
7. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private tutoring for STUDENT during the summers of 1996 and 1997? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
8. Did STUDENT's IEPs adequately address her delays in gross motor skills? The District prevailed on this issue.
9. Should the District be required to reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of STUDENT's swimming program, including transportation costs, during the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school years? The District prevailed on this issue.
10. Should the District be required to reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of the Reading for the Blind and Dyslexic program? The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
Date: June 9, 1998 Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes 1. The issues are presented in a different order than the Petitioner stated them to conform to the order in which they will be discussed in this decision. Certain issues identified by the Petitioner consisted of factors that must be examined in the analysis of other, related issues, and, thus, have been incorporated into those issues. 2. The parties generally agreed that STUDENT needs a multi- sensory teaching approach. 3. Dr. Johannsen also administered the Bender Motor Gestalt, but provided almost no discussion of that test and did not indicate that the results of that test were a measure of cognitive ability. 4. The finding that the qualification of STUDENT as MR is erroneous is not a finding that STUDENT is not eligible for special education services. STUDENT qualifies for services due to her speech and language disorder, and may also qualify as learning disabled. 5. The IEP also included speech and language services. There was no evidence presented at the hearing that indicated that the level of speech and language services is in dispute, nor were any arguments made to that effect in the closing briefs. Therefore, this Decision will not address the adequacy of those services.
