California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 27, 1999
Student v. Central Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 637-98 · Hearing Officer Marie Ward
Central Unified may not expel student with learning disability; Hearing Officer orders compensatory tutoring, new placement, and independent assessment reimbursement.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None stated. Footnote 1 notes that evidence Petitioner offered after the record closed (January 22, 1999) was not admitted.
Summary
A 16-year-old tenth grader at Central High School, East Campus, filed for due process after Central Unified School District recommended expelling him for coming to school under the influence of alcohol. He was eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability but had a long history of social-emotional, attention, and behavior problems. After the incident, the District moved him to independent study at home, where it kept him for months.
Hearing Officer Marie Ward ruled for the student on the expulsion. The District's preexpulsion assessment focused on his thinking skills. It did not explain how his emotional and attention problems affected his behavior. The incident was part of a chronic pattern of behavior tied to his disability. His placement was also inappropriate: his behavior plan no longer worked, and his IEP had no academic goals for 1997-98. The Hearing Officer also found that independent study denied him a FAPE. His mother was his only teacher, and he got no special education instruction. Because the District's assessment was inappropriate, the parent was entitled to reimbursement for an independent assessment. The request for a nonpublic school was denied for lack of evidence.
The District was ordered to drop the expulsion and hold an IEP meeting within 15 school days for a new structured placement with counseling, a new behavior plan, and an assessment. It must also provide compensatory home tutoring.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a preexpulsion assessment and manifestation review under the Education Code of the time. It looked past the eligibility label to the student's actual social-emotional and attention needs. It also held that independent study at home, with only a parent teaching, was not an appropriate interim placement, even a temporary one.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedDiscipline
Issue 1. May the District proceed with its recommendation to expel STUDENT for the incident on February 26, 1998?
The District may not expel the student. Its preexpulsion assessment was inadequate, the misconduct was a manifestation of his disability, and his placement was inappropriate.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 1A. Did the District conduct an appropriate preexpulsion assessment of STUDENT?
The assessment focused on cognitive ability. It did not explain how his social-emotional and attention problems (ADHD) affected his behavior, so it did not assess all areas of suspected disability under Ed. Code §§48915.5 and 56320.
- Student prevailedDiscipline
Issue 1B. Was STUDENT'S misconduct caused by, or a direct manifestation of, his identified disability?
Coming to school under the influence of alcohol was one more example of a chronic pattern of disruptive behavior that made up his disability, so it was caused by or a direct manifestation of that disability.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1C. Was STUDENT appropriately placed at the time the misconduct occurred?
The placement was inappropriate. The BIP was no longer effective, the IEP had no RSP academic goals for 1997-98, and educational benefit could not be measured.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the period he was in independent study?
Placing him in independent study at home denied him a FAPE for a sustained period, and he is owed compensatory tutoring.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2A. Was independent study an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
Independent study made his mother his only teacher. It provided no special education instruction, no social setting, and no way to carry out the BIP, and staff monitoring was insufficient. It did not meet his needs, did not provide benefit, and did not comport with the IEP.
- Not reachedIEP procedure
Issue 2B. Did the District commit procedural errors sufficient to deny STUDENT a FAPE?
The Hearing Officer did not reach the procedural claims about the March 5 and March 26, 1998 IEP meetings because of the substantive findings.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2C. If the District did deny STUDENT a FAPE by placing him in independent study, what type of compensatory education is he due?
Applying equitable principles from Burlington and Puyallup, the Hearing Officer ordered home tutoring by a credentialed teacher for 3 hours per school day until placement, then 1 hour three times a week through fall 1999.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for obtaining an independent assessment?
Because the District's preexpulsion assessment was inappropriate, the parent is entitled to reimbursement under Ed. Code §56329(b). Reimbursement does not require showing the independent assessment was itself appropriate.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 4. Is a nonpublic school an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
The request was denied. No evidence was offered about any nonpublic school or why one was suitable, and Petitioner had said he would accept placement at Central High School East Campus.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- The District shall not proceed with expulsion proceedings for the February 26, 1998 incident.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 school days, the District must convene an IEP meeting to identify and offer a new placement, considering both private and public options.
- Placement ordered. The new placement must include a small special education class with a low student/teacher ratio and a highly structured classroom with transitions kept to a practical minimum, with some consideration given to one classroom for most of the day.
- Order to provide or change services. The new placement must include the psychological counseling recommended by school psychologist Simone Flaming, a new functional behavioral analysis and behavioral intervention plan, and a program to address his social/emotional difficulties and behavioral problems.
- Order to assess. The District must assess the significance of the student's pattern of falling asleep in class and consider whether he should be classified as SED.
- Compensatory education. Within 10 calendar days, the District must provide one-to-one home tutoring by a credentialed teacher for 3 hours per school day until the student begins his new placement. After that, it must provide tutoring by a credentialed teacher for 1 hour three times a week for the rest of 1998-99 and the fall semester of 1999-2000. The District decides the content based on his current academic needs.
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof of the fee, the District must reimburse Petitioner for the independent assessment by Dr. Richard Komm. No amount is stated.
Key authorities
Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479; Petaluma Joint Unified School District, SN 25-96, 25 IDELR 262 (1996); Cal. Educ. Code §48915.5; Cal. Educ. Code §56320; Cal. Educ. Code §56329(b); 34 CFR 104.35
People named in the decision
- Cindy Toews, Coordinator of special education, Central Unified School District
- Gail Egoian, SELPA representative, Fresno County Office of Education SELPA
- Dr. Richard Komm, Independent assessor; expert witness for Student (testified by telephone)
- Deedee Johnson, Program specialist, Central Unified School District
- Patricia Gomes, School nurse, Central Unified School District
- Cheryl Rothe, School psychologist; preexpulsion assessor; FBA author and behavior intervention case manager, Central Unified School District
- Mike Thornton, Special education teacher; RSP case manager, Central High School, East Campus
- Anne Biggs, Special education teacher, Central High School, East Campus
- Mike Nolte, Modified P.E. teacher, Central High School, East Campus
- Mr. Gibbs, RSP history teacher, Central High School, East Campus
- Mrs. Galan, RSP English 2 teacher, Central High School, East Campus
- Kent Albertson, Business teacher, Central High School, East Campus
- Ray Muncy, RSP U.S. History teacher, Central High School, East Campus
- Mary Yarbrough, SDC science and modified P.E. teacher, Central High School, East Campus
- Simone Flaming, School psychologist (1996 triennial assessment), Central Unified School District
- Debra Winger, Teacher (BIP input), Central Unified School District
- Mrs. Farino, Teacher (contact during independent study), Central Unified School District
- Mr. Wilson, School liaison, Central High School, East Campus
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Marie Ward, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Fresno, California, on October 13, 14, 20, 21, 22 and November 17 and 18, 1998. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by Eulalio Castellanos, Esq. of Central California Legal Services, Inc. Petitioner’s mother, PARENT, was also present on her son’s behalf.
Respondent Central Unified School District was represented by Trevin Sims, Esq. of Lozano, Smith Smith Woliver & Behrens. Also present on behalf of the respondent was Cindy Toews, coordinator of special education for Central Unified School District. Gail Egoian, Fresno County Office of Education, Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA), was present on October 13 and 14, 1998.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: PARENT and Dr. Richard Komm.
The following witnesses were called by Respondent to testify: Cindy Toews; Deedee Johnson, program specialist for Central U.S.D.; Patricia Gomes, school nurse; Cheryl Rothe, school psychologist; and special education teachers Mike Thornton, Anne Biggs, and Mike Nolte. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties’ written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.(Footnote 1)
ISSUES (Footnote 2)
1. May the District proceed with its recommendation to expel STUDENT for the incident on February 26, 1998?
A. Did the District conduct an appropriate preexpulsion assessment of STUDENT? B. Was STUDENT’S misconduct caused by, or a direct manifestation of, his identified disability? C. Was STUDENT appropriately placed at the time the misconduct occurred?
2. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the period he was in independent study? A. Was independent study an appropriate placement for STUDENT? B. Did the District commit procedural errors sufficient to deny STUDENT a FAPE? C. If the District did deny STUDENT a FAPE by placing him in independent study, what type of compensatory education is he due?
3. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for obtaining an independent assessment?
4. Is a nonpublic school an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On October 6, 1998, Petitioner filed a motion to permit telephone testimony of his expert witness, Dr. Komm. On October 9, 1998, the Hearing Office granted Petitioner’s motion.
On October 14, 1998, Petitioner addressed the issue of whether independent study was an appropriate placement. Respondent contended that Petitioner was raising the issue of the appropriateness of independent study for the first time. The Hearing Officer ruled that Respondent had been informed, in a timely manner, that Petitioner considered his placement in independent study inappropriate.
BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a 16-year-old student who was in the tenth grade at Central High School, East Campus, in Fresno, California, at the time of the incident which gave rise to the due process hearing. It is unclear whether STUDENT satisfactorily completed the tenth grade. On February 26, 1998, STUDENT came to school under the influence of alcohol. STUDENT is contesting the District’s recommendation to expel him for that behavior.
STUDENT has been involved with the special education program since the first grade, when his mother referred him for a special education assessment because of her concerns about his attention, impulsivity, and perceptual skills. Assessment results revealed average to low average cognitive skills, weak visual-perceptual and visual-motor skills, and weak performance in reading. His strengths included his auditory perception of language. It was noted that STUDENT had significant ability to draw upon his understanding of the world and used language well for thinking and reasoning. These strengths compensated for many of the difficulties he encountered. STUDENT was identified as having a learning disability (SLD) and began receiving services from a resource specialist (RSP).
STUDENT began attending the third grade at McKinley Elementary in Central Unified when he was eight years old. During his fourth grade year, the school was concerned about managing STUDENT’S behavior, especially when he was on the playground. His mother stated that he often fought with older children and that he fought to injure. STUDENT was briefly admitted to Cedar Vista Psychiatric Hospital due to “behavioral dyscontrol.” In the hospital he behaved well and increased his attention span in the small, individualized classroom environment provided there. Various interventions, including the administration of drugs and continued therapy were recommended.
During sixth grade, STUDENT was placed in the Fresno County intervention Program at Herndon Barstow School. The purpose of this program was to further assess his psychological and educational needs and to work on modifying his behavior so that he would act more appropriately. At the end of STUDENT’S six months in this classroom, it was reported that STUDENT had made significant improvements in his task behavior, in dealing with confrontations, with decision making and was behaving appropriately in his mainstreaming classes. It was noted that he still had a difficult time initiating and maintaining his attention and verbalizing his feelings. Suggestions were made for improving his work production including prompting, encouragement, individual assistance and using a reward system. The assessment report stated that STUDENT was not seriously emotionally disturbed (SED), but that his low self-esteem, poor self-concept, and fear of failure combined with a learning disability and intermittent oppositional behavior were affecting his school performance. STUDENT was placed back in regular education with RSP support for the remainder of the school year.
STUDENT moved to El Capitan Middle School for seventh and eighth grade. After three months in regular education with RSP support, STUDENT was moved into a special day class (SDC). He struggled to maintain appropriate behavior and his mother began to spend a good portion of the day with him in the classroom. His teacher recommended him to the Fresno County Mental Health Department so that he could receive counseling services to help him with his decision- making skills and other emotional issues. The teacher noted in her referral that STUDENT behaves appropriately when he is in a structured environment. STUDENT was authorized to receive these counseling services in April 1995. Goals were set to increase his self-control and to have him become more responsible for his behavior. STUDENT’S reluctance to participate in these sessions minimized their consistency and effectiveness, though he made some improvement. His greatest difficulties occurred during breaks and other unstructured times. STUDENT was considered for placement in an SED class or on a half day at El Capitan Middle School when he was having behavioral difficulties, but PARENT rejected both these proposals. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 15.)
At his triennial assessment, on May 7, 1996, the school psychologist’s report stated that STUDENT did not have a learning disability which qualified him for special education, but that his educational needs appeared to extend beyond the reaches of the regular education curriculum and its remedial resources. The report stated: “It does not appear to be in the child’s best interest to remove him from special education at the present time because of his social-emotional difficulties and his difficulties succeeding in the regular classroom.” It was recommended that STUDENT continue in counseling.
STUDENT began high school in August 1996. He was in an SDC for 88 percent of his school day. For the other 12 percent he was at lunch or on breaks. No recommendation was made for counseling. It was recommended he have small group instruction primarily because of his specific learning disabilities and low cognitive functioning.
In December 1996, a functional analysis was completed. At his May 1997 IEP, a Behavioral Intervention Plan (BIP) was finalized and STUDENT’S placement was changed to RSP for 80 percent of his day. For the remaining 20 percent of his day, he was scheduled for regular education in selected academic classes, breaks and lunch. This was the IEP in place when the incident occurred which gave rise to this due process hearing. At the time of the incident the BIP was also in place.
On February 9, 1998, PARENT had gall bladder surgery and was bedridden for almost a month. According to PARENT, this upset STUDENT very much. She testified he would tell his grandmother that his mother was going to die. He complained that his mom would not be able to go to school with him, and he cried in the mornings worrying if she was going to be all right. She testified that he was a sixteen-year-old who would prefer to have his mother at school with him, that it was a “hassle” to get him to school, and that his stomach would hurt because he would worry whether she would be able to pick him up on time. STUDENT’S mother’s illness resulted in a change in STUDENT’S school schedule because PARENT was not able to attend fourth period with him every day as she usually did.
On February 26, 1998, when STUDENT arrived at school in the morning he was acting in an unusual manner. The campus police officer determined he was under the influence of alcohol. STUDENT was suspended for five days and recommended for expulsion for being under the influence of an alcoholic beverage and for disrupting school activities.
On March 5, 1998, a hearing that the District refers to as a “danger” hearing was held. It lasted for approximately 15 minutes. This was followed immediately by an IEP meeting during which STUDENT’S placement was changed from RSP to staff-monitored independent study, pending the manifestation determination and/or board decision on the expulsion process. According to the IEP, STUDENT’S independent study was scheduled to end on April 28, 1998, though it is also noted on the IEP that the review date for the placement was March 5, 1999.
The preexpulsion assessment was performed and a report prepared which was dated March 25, 1998. At an IEP meeting on March 26, 1998, the IEP team concluded, in effect, that the misconduct which occurred on February 26, 1998 was not caused by, or was not a direct manifestation of, his identified disability and that STUDENT was to remain in independent study due to behavior problems. The IEP team also prepared a statement of STUDENT’S present educational performance levels, a goals and objectives summary, and a transition plan. STUDENT’S mother signed the IEP. She did not check the box indicating whether she agreed or disagreed with the placement, or initial the form to show that she had been informed of and understood her rights and due process.
On May 11, 1998, STUDENT’S mother filed a request for a due process hearing alleging procedural improprieties during and/or before the March 5, 1998, and March 26, 1998, IEP meetings. She disagrees with the determination that STUDENT’S misconduct was not caused by, or a manifestation of, his disability and with his placement in independent study. The expulsion hearing was postponed pending the outcome of the due process hearing.
The due process hearing was initially scheduled for June 4 and 5, 1998. The hearing did not begin until October 13, 1998, due to requests for continuances by the Petitioner in order to obtain an independent assessment. When the hearing was concluded, in November 1998, STUDENT was still on independent study.
CONTENTIONS OF PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District did not conduct an appropriate preexpulsion assessment in that it failed to take into account his emotional and social disabilities when concluding that the incident was not caused by, or a direct manifestation of, his identified disability. Petitioner further contends that his placement at the time of the incident was inappropriate. He contends that there were procedural problems with both the March 5, 1998, and the March 26, 1998, IEP meetings. Petitioner also contends that his placement in independent study was inappropriate and requests compensatory services in the form of tutoring. Petitioner also requests that the District remove the suspension from the school records, discontinue the expulsion proceedings, and prepare a new functional analysis assessment and behavior intervention plan. Petitioner further requests counseling services, reimbursement for the cost of obtaining an independent assessment, and a private school placement.
The District contends that the IEP team properly determined that STUDENT’S misconduct was not caused by, or a direct manifestation of, his identified disability; that he was appropriately placed at the time of the incident and that it was his excessive absenteeism which affected his educational performance. The District contends that the IEP meetings of March 5, 1998, and March 26, 1998, were conducted without procedural violations, but that if there were any violations, they did not deny STUDENT a free, appropriate, public education (FAPE), and that STUDENT’S placement in independent study was appropriate.
DISCUSSION
Issue 1: May the District proceed with its recommendation to expel STUDENT for the incident on February 26, 1998?
Special education students are subject to discipline in accordance with California law and special education due process requirements. Discipline may include suspension and expulsion when other means of correction fail to bring about proper conduct. California Education Code §48900.5. In this case, the District suspended STUDENT for being under the influence of alcohol and disrupting school activities. California Education Code §48900 (c)(k).
Expulsion of a special education student constitutes a change in placement and school officials must follow specific procedural safeguards to ensure that special education students are not excluded from school because of their disabling condition. A school district can only recommend a special education student for expulsion for an offense listed in §48900 after a preexpulsion assessment is conducted, the individualized education program team meets and due process hearings and appeals, if initiated pursuant to §1415 of Title 20 of the United States Code, are completed. California Education Code §48915.5(h).
In a matter involving a pupil with previously identified exceptional needs who is currently enrolled in a special education program, the governing board may order the pupil expelled if an IEP team meeting is held and the team determines that:
∙ the student’s misconduct was "not caused by, or was not a direct manifestation of, the pupil's identified disability”; and
∙ the pupil was appropriately placed at the time the misconduct occurred. California Education Code §48915.5(a).
A. Did the District conduct an appropriate preexpulsion assessment of STUDENT?
In determining whether a pupil should be expelled, the IEP team shall base its decision on the results of a preexpulsion educational assessment conducted in accordance with the guidelines of Section 104.35 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulation, which shall include a review of the appropriateness of the pupil’s placement at the time of the alleged misconduct, and a determination of the relationship, if any, between the pupil’s behavior and his or her disability.
California Education Code §56320 requires that the assessment instruments and procedures must not be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; the student must be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability; and the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student’s disability. In addition, Section 56320 requires that no single procedure be used as the sole criterion for determining a student’s educational placement. Therefore, when read together, California Education Code §56320 and Title 34 CFR § 104.35 provide the requirements to which schools must adhere in conducting a preexpulsion assessment.
California Education Code §48915.5(b) requires school districts to ensure that special education students subject to a preexpulsion assessment are afforded essentially the same rights included in federal and state special education law to which they are entitled when undertaking a "regular" assessment. The sole difference is that parental consent for a preexpulsion assessment is not required.
If the IEP team determines that the alleged misconduct was not caused by, or a direct manifestation of, the pupil’s disability, and if it is determined that the pupil was appropriately placed, the pupil shall be subject to the applicable disciplinary actions and procedures. California Education Code §48915.5(f).
In this case, the District’s preexpulsion assessment was conducted by Cheryl Rothe, a licensed school psychologist. The report included results from the Woodcock-Johnson tests of Achievement, Revised (WJ-R); the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC); the Child Behavior Checklist; an interview with STUDENT, a records review and a health evaluation. (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 6(Footnote 3).)
STUDENT, PARENT, Mr. Gibbs (STUDENT’S RSP History teacher), Mrs. Galan (STUDENT’S RSP English 2 teacher), Mr. Thornton (STUDENT’S RSP case manager), Mrs. Gomes (school nurse), and Ms. Rothe (school psychologist) were participants in the assessment.
Mr. Thornton administered the WJ-R, which measures reading, mathematics and writing achievement. STUDENT scored in the 28th percentile in his broad reading score, in the 17th percentile in his broad math score and in the 3rd percentile in the broad written language score.
STUDENT’S intellectual abilities had been previously measured. In 1996 he was tested using the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children -Third Edition (WISC-III). The results showed his ability to be in the borderline to low average range. In 1989, he was given the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Revised ( WISC-R), which showed his ability to be in the low average range.
The BASC was given to STUDENT, his mother and a teacher, Mrs. Galan, and measured his social-emotional behavior. His scores were in the average range, which indicated there was no reason to be concerned, the at-risk range, which indicated a potential problem that may need to be monitored, or in the clinically significant range, which indicated a high level of maladjustment. Because the data showed the results might be unreliable, neither the teacher’s nor PARENT’S scores were presented.
From STUDENT’S perspective, his overall level of emotional disturbance was in the at-risk range. His attitude toward the teachers and the school subscales were in the clinically significant range; his sensation seeking subscale was in the average range. His clinical maladjustment composite was in the at-risk range. His somatization subscale was in the average range. The atypicality, social stress, and anxiety subscales were in the at-risk range and his locus of control subscale was in the clinically significant range. STUDENT’S score on the depression and sense of inadequacy scales was in the at-risk range as was his personal adjustment composite score. His self-esteem and relations with parents ratings were in the average range. His interpersonal relations subscale was in the at-risk range and STUDENT’S self-reliance subscale was in the clinically significant range.
The Child Behavior Checklist measured internalizing, externalizing, thought, social, and attention problems. The three raters were Mr. Gibbs, PARENT and STUDENT. According to Mr. Gibbs, STUDENT displayed a significant level of somatic complaints, social problems, thought problems, attention problems, delinquent behavior and aggressive behaviors. According to PARENT, STUDENT showed a significant level of somatic complaints, anxiety/depression, social problems, thought problems, attention problems and aggressive behavior. STUDENT’S self-report indicated a significant level of somatic complaints, social problems, thought problems, attention problems, delinquent behavior and aggressive behavior.
To determine whether the District’s preexpulsion assessment addressed all areas related to STUDENT’S disability, it is necessary to look at his disability. STUDENT’S IEP identifies him as specific learning disabled. A triennial assessment was made by Simone Flaming, a school psychologist, in May of STUDENT’S eighth grade year. The triennial assessment reported that STUDENT had participated in various programs and had been evaluated by several professionals due to behavioral and emotional problems. It concluded that STUDENT’S learning potential is not significantly higher than his academic achievement, he has difficulties with visual-spatial skills, memory, reasoning and attention-concentration, he has social-emotional difficulties and that these skills and processing deficits significantly interfere with his educational performance. The report further stated that STUDENT’S needs extend beyond the reaches of the regular education curriculum and its remedial resources and recommended that he remain in special education because of his social-emotional difficulties and his difficulties succeeding in the regular classroom. Ms. Flaming’s report concluded with specific suggestions to help STUDENT succeed in the classroom, many of which are specific to minimizing his attention problems. A final recommendation was that “STUDENT needs to continue in counseling to help him with his emotional struggles. It would also be a good idea for him to attend a social skills group where he learns to solve social problems more effectively.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 15.)
STUDENT has academic needs which must be addressed in the context of his placement. However, while identifying him as SLD, the District has, in fact, determined that STUDENT’S true disability is not his academic discrepancies, but his problems with reasoning and attention-concentration and his social and emotional conduct in the classroom. And indeed, STUDENT does have a nine-year history of sustained social-emotional problems with attendant behavioral problems.
The preexpulsion assessment acknowledges these needs and summarizes that STUDENT has “social problems, thought problems, attention problems, delinquent behavior, aggressive behavior and depression.” It goes on to conclude that STUDENT’S emotional and learning difficulties did not affect his ability to control his behavior. This conclusion is not supported by the evidence.
The preexpulsion assessment concludes that although STUDENT has visual and attention processing weaknesses, his intellectual abilities are in the low average range. STUDENT, however, is not in special education because of his intellectual disabilities. The conclusion that his attention weakness did not impair his ability to control his behavior is not explained. The Child Behavior Checklist measurements by all three raters show STUDENT with significant levels of social, attention, aggressive and thought problems. Ms. Rothe testified that STUDENT has ADHD (Footnote 4) with impulse control problems. The assessment does not interpret why these identified attention problems did or did not play a part in STUDENT’S decision-making process.
The conclusion ends by stating that STUDENT made the choice of drinking alcohol and attending school. The BASC summary indicates, however, that STUDENT does not feel any sense of control over his life, that he does not see himself as being able to make decisions. The assessment does not to make it clear why STUDENT’S feeling of lack of control and his problems with reasoning did not affect his ability to make this choice.
The evidence also calls into question the overall reliability of the test, In the BASC, of the three raters, the scores of two were thrown out, making STUDENT the only rater of his own behavior and personality within this measurement. It was noted that STUDENT was not feeling well at the time of the WISC-III evaluation and this had a negative impact on the skills which were being tested. Finally, STUDENT completed one of the behavioral surveys, not under the supervision of the school psychologist, but at home because he had become “restless.”
The Hearing Officer concludes that the assessment improperly focused on STUDENT’S cognitive ability to evaluate what he was doing and the resulting consequences, while the true nature of STUDENT’S disability is not with his intellectual functions, but with his emotional and social dysfunctions. Though the assessment reported the limited test results of his social and emotional needs, it did not report how these results influenced the conclusions. Finally, STUDENT has ADHD. Because the preexpulsion assessment did not sufficiently measure the influence STUDENT’S diagnosed attention problems might have had on his misconduct, the District did not assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability. In summary, the preexpulsion assessment did not evaluate with sufficiency the relationship between the STUDENT’S disability and his behavior, and thus, did not comply with the mandates of California Education Code §48915.5(e) and §56320.
B. Was STUDENT’S misconduct caused by or a direct manifestation of his identified disability?
Evidence which assists with evaluating the relationship between STUDENT’S misconduct and his disability includes the following testimony and written statements from his teachers. The written statements appear to have been prepared for the expulsion hearing.
1. “...STUDENT was a problem from the start...He was constantly getting in trouble in my class, mostly it was disruptive behavior, forcing me to send him outside for a time-out...STUDENT’S behavior got so out of control that I asked Deedee to remove him from my class. Instead of removing STUDENT, it was agreed that he could stay provided his mother came everyday with him to class. STUDENT’S behavior changed for the better once his mother started coming to class. However, not even his mother could get STUDENT to do his work on a consistent basis. Evertime (sic) STUDENT’S mother had to leave early STUDENT would return to past behaviors...” (Kent Albertson, Business Teacher, Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 21.)
2. “...On the limited number of days STUDENT has attended class, the majority of the time has been spent sleeping...Attempts were made each day to wake him without success. On the times STUDENT did respond, he would listen to the directions for the assignment and tell me that he understood what he needed to do. As soon as I left his desk, STUDENT would put his head down on the desk and go back to sleep....” (Ray Muncy, RSP U.S. History, Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 26.)
3. “...STUDENT was a very energetic and inquisitive young person. His behavior most of the (time) was intolerable such as constantly running into classroom just subsequent to the tardy bell, speaking loud as he could, using profanity to express himself. He would not leave other students alone if he had a beef with them. It seemed as if he was looking for a reason to disrupt the class. ... It came to a point where PARENT was shadowing her son around campus and she would sit in on classes, trying to assist STUDENT in staying on task. At first it was an effective tool, then it became like a game to him. His mother would sit next to him patting or rubbing his shoulders to get him to attend to the task at hand... STUDENT still looked for ways to get out (of) PE by not dressing out, pushing wheelchair students in a dangerous fashion, hitting tennis balls over fences on purpose picking fights, arguing with anyone whom he caught looking at him after being removed from the activity and even spitting at or in their direction. .. (Mary Yarbrough, SDC Science, Modified P.E.( Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 23.) 4. Anne Biggs testified that STUDENT was very bright and did good work when he came to school and worked, that his poor grades were a result of his poor attendance and whether or not he liked a particular assignment. Ms. Biggs wrote: “...The first weeks of Spring semester ‘97 STUDENT did very well. He attended classes and did his work, but by the third week, his grade started slipping. ...He began to refuse to do assignments because he said ‘I do not have the life experience to do this assignment.’ (He was to write a children’s story.) He stated that he only knew violence in his life, so he could not do the assignment... About six weeks into the semester STUDENT started to fall asleep in class... Whenever he was asked to participate in class assignments he would refuse. Twice he asked to be allowed to call his lawyer... A number of times I asked his mother to sit in on the class because his behavior was unacceptable, especially his language...When she was in the class, he was great... He was very capable of completing all the work when she was in class... Often times during class he would say that he needed to call his mother because he wasn’t feeling well. He told me I had to let him use the phone because that was his right. I did and on two occasions he hung up on her, then went and put his head down and refused to do work. She called back both times, but he refused to talk to her... After Easter vacation he came to class repeatedly very ‘spaced out’ and unable to keep his eyes open. He couldn’t focus on anything, or anyone...He didn’t seem to really care about anything, and most of his assignments were late. He was out a great deal of the time for doctors appointments or allergies...” (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 25.)
5. Mike Nolte was STUDENT’S Modified P.E. teacher. He testified that he frequently spoke to Mike Thornton about STUDENT to discuss ways to work effectively with him. Mr. Nolte wanted to avoid confrontations and reduce STUDENT’S practice of overreacting to situations. Mr. Nolte wrote: “...While in my P.E. class, he was excessively absent and he participated only when he felt like it. There was an incident that I would like to explain in detail. STUDENT and two other boys were walking away from our class. I called them back twice. They ignored me and continued to walk. I then asked Mr. Wilson, the school liaison, to go and get them. They were on their way back by that time. When we questioned the boys, STUDENT was very sarcastic in his apology. He then dropped to the ground and laid on his back. I asked him to get up. He proceeded to pop up and say to me (extreme profanities)....” (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 22.)
When STUDENT’S misconduct or failure to comply with school rules reached a certain level of disruptiveness, a written report was placed in his records. These are called “Assertive Discipline Records.” Between August 1996 and February 1998, the staff wrote 46 discipline reports on STUDENT’S behavior. (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibits 16 and 17.)
The District has spent a considerable amount of time trying to help STUDENT have a successful educational experience. The evidence shows, however, that STUDENT has been out of control in his educational environment much of the time he has been in high school. Mike Thornton testified that when STUDENT’S BIP was being prepared there were so many issues to consider in assisting STUDENT it was necessary to select behaviors which were most likely to help him to learn. Reducing his use of profanity, for example, was not a priority. It is clear that STUDENT’S disability lies with his longstanding, pervasive emotional and social needs and the resulting behavioral problems.
Therefore, based on the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the incident on February 26, 1998, is yet one more example of the chronic pattern of disruptive behaviors which constitute the disability which is interfering with STUDENT’S education and that the incident was either caused by, or a direct manifestation, of his identified disability.
C. Was STUDENT appropriately placed at the time the misconduct occurred?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free, appropriate public education (FAPE). Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student’s individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(16). According to the United States Supreme Court, the student’s placement must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The school district is required to provide the student with a "basic floor of opportunity" and is not required to provide the student with the best educational available. Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176. Thus, under IDEA and Rowley, in relevant part, the program offered by the school district is appropriate when it is designed to meet the student’s unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and comport with the IEP.
1. Did STUDENT’S placement meet his unique and individual needs?
STUDENT’S unique needs are his social emotional difficulties and his difficulties succeeding in the regular classroom. He also has difficulties with written language and with visual/spatial skills, memory, reasoning, and attention - concentration for a combination of skills and processing deficits.
There was considerable testimony on whether or not STUDENT is also depressed. Dr. Komm testified that STUDENT exhibits a long-standing depression. Ms. Rothe testified that STUDENT’S school behavior on the whole was not that of a depressed student. When STUDENT was under the influence of alcohol, he made a statement about committing suicide. Dr. Komm and Ms. Rothe disagreed on the significance that should be placed on this statement. Mike Thornton has been STUDENT’S case manager for two years and was also his teacher during freshman year. He testified extensively at the hearing and showed significant knowledge about, caring and respect for STUDENT. Mr. Thornton was emphatic that STUDENT had never made any comments about suicide, nor was this level of depression characteristic of his personality.
STUDENT does have severe emotional needs. He was in a psychiatric hospital for behavior problems in the fourth grade. In the sixth grade, he was referred to the Fresno County Intervention Program. The District wanted to determine, among other issues, what the relationship was between his emotional disturbance and his learning disabilities. The County looked at, but did not recommend, an SED classification. According to the District, STUDENT was considered for an SED placement in the seventh or eighth grade, but PARENT rejected this placement. As recently as March 1998, a combination of an SDC/SED program was offered to STUDENT. Ms. Johnson testified that PARENT rejected this placement because she did not want STUDENT labeled “SED.” A conclusion that a student needs an SED class is a significant factor in evaluating whether or not that student can succeed in the educational process.
At the time of the incident, STUDENT was in a placement which had been agreed to on May 1, 1997. (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 10.) At that IEP meeting, STUDENT’S placement was changed from SDC to RSP. As teacher Anne Biggs explained, the District was “allowed” to change all SDC students to RSP. SDC Level One became RSP Level One. No level of RSP was identified on the IEP, however, because students were placed in classes in different levels depending on their abilities in a particular subject.
A BIP was also adopted at this meeting, and implemented shortly thereafter. The BIP was the result of an extensive analysis of STUDENT’S behaviors. Input for this plan was received from PARENT, her attorney, and teachers Mike Thornton, Debra Winger and Anne Biggs. Cheryl Rothe was the Behavior Intervention Case Manager (BICM). A Functional Behavior Analysis (FBA) had been prepared for STUDENT dated December 5, 1996. (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 12.) The targeted behaviors of the BIP were STUDENT’S “blurting out,” that is, his inappropriate and untimely verbal comments in class, and his lack of compliance with school rules.
On January 30, 1997, an FBA addendum was prepared. (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 13.) Both the FBA and the addendum were prepared by Ms. Rothe. The addendum had been prepared at Petitioner’s request and described the way the data had been collected for the FBA from October 17 to December 4, 1996, during a total of 85 hours of observation. The information had been compiled during several academic classes, in modified PE, by the bus driver, from PARENT and from STUDENT’S doctor. Where possible, the BIP described the antecedents of the inappropriate behaviors, and objectives were established to decrease the targeted behavior and increase the replacement behavior. Rating charts were prepared and the teachers were instructed on their use. STUDENT was rewarded for achieving a certain amount of points.
PARENT requested that she provide the reward because she knew STUDENT liked Compact Disks (CD). When the plan was implemented it was initially successful, but later STUDENT’S inappropriate behaviors began to reappear. When asked why he was acting up again, STUDENT said that his mother gave him a CD whether or not he had reached his goals. (Testimony of Anne Biggs, Mike Thornton.) The District contends that the effectiveness of the BIP was reduced by PARENT’S failure or refusal to implement the “reward” system in accordance with the plan.
However, since the teachers are usually responsible for rewarding a students’ improved behavior, it would have been appropriate for the District to retain more control of the reward component of the plan.
The BIP was continued in Fall 1997. Mike Thornton testified that STUDENT’S recorded misconducts were fewer in Fall 1997 than in Fall 1996. However, according to Cheryl Rothe, the first six weeks of 1998 were very difficult for STUDENT and he was not achieving what was expected of him.
The evidence shows that at the time of the incident, the BIP was no longer effective and the behavioral component of STUDENT’S current placement was not meeting his social-emotional needs.
STUDENT was placed into special education because his behavior problems prevented him from succeeding in the regular classroom. STUDENT’S goals and objectives for the academic component of his May 1997 IEP, appear to be referenced at the bottom of the form. There is a note indicating that the District will continue with the current goals and objectives. No RSP academic goals and objectives were set at the May IEP meeting.
The “current” goals were set at the October 1996, IEP meeting. That IEP report contains one page of transitional goals and 3 pages of academic goals, all entitled “IEP Page 2.” These latter pages are the goals and objectives for SDC science, SDC math, and SDC social studies with goals scheduled to be met by June 1997. In fact, all those goals were met by June 1997. (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 20.) California Education Code §56345 (a) (2) requires that the IEP contain written annual goals and objectives. There is no record of any RSP goals being set for STUDENT after the SDC goals were met. There is no record of any further IEP meetings until March 1998. It can be assumed, therefore, that STUDENT entered the school year 1997-1998 without any academic goals and objectives being identified to meet his unique needs.
The Hearing Officer finds that, on February 26, 1998, the BIP was no longer an effective tool in meeting STUDENT’S social and emotional needs and that because there were no RSP academic goals and objectives identified for the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT’S placement was without the guidelines which the law requires. Therefore, STUDENT’S placement at the time of the incident did not meet his unique and individual needs.
2. Was STUDENT’S placement designed to provide him with educational benefit, and did it comport with his IEP?
STUDENT’S disruptive behaviors significantly interfere with the benefit he receives in the classroom. He also exhibits one other behavior which seriously affects his classroom participation. The District referred to this behavior as “sleeping.” STUDENT would put his head down on the desk and go to sleep during class. Sometimes when he slept he would lay his head on the desk and jump up with energy when the bell rang for break. At other times his sleep was so deep the teacher found it difficult to arouse him. STUDENT’S behavior charts show these notations from history and math classes: “slept again, slept no work, slept, slept again, STUDENT slept through class today, sleeping during seatwork, a little sleeping-20 minutes, too much sleeping!” (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 14.) This problem was frequently referred to during the hearing. Dr. Komm contends that sleeping may well be “connected to the larger pattern of emotionally related problem areas abutting depression, and within what is felt by to be an ‘organic base’ in his overall functioning.” STUDENT’S teachers thought that this behavior might be caused by defiance, by his allergy medicine, or by staying up too late. In designing the BIP, the District targeted behaviors which were relatively more disruptive to STUDENT’S learning than sleeping.
At various times when STUDENT was misbehaving in class, the District allowed his mother come to school with him. Examples of how PARENT tried to control him were mentioned above. The close working relationship between family and school is an important component in the successful education of children. However, it is one of the goals of education, particularly at the high school level, to assist the student to develop as an adult. Whether a student continues on to college or enters the workforce, high school is preparation for the independence of adulthood. STUDENT’S mother was in the classroom solely to assist with controlling his behavior and to keep him focused on doing his schoolwork. These are the District’s responsibilities. For a high school boy to have his mother in the classroom for these reasons is wholly inappropriate.
The District contends that it was STUDENT’S excessive absences, not his placement, which interfered with the benefit he received from his education.
The evidence shows that STUDENT exhibits several behaviors which interfere with the benefit he could receive from his education. Because his achievement cannot be measured against his goals and objectives, however, the record does not offer the Hearing Officer sufficient information to evaluate the benefit he did receive.
While it could be argued that STUDENT’S placement comported with his IEP, the law requires the District to identify annual goals and objectives. The District failed to do so, therefore, STUDENT’S IEP was deficient.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’S May 1, 1997, placement did not meet his unique needs, that due to the absence of goals and objectives, the District was unable to show the educational benefit he received, and that his IEP was deficient.
*****
Based on the evidence disclosed at hearing and the applicable law, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s preexpulsion assessment was inadequate, that STUDENT’S misconduct was either caused by, or a direct manifestation of, his disability and that his placement at the time of the incident was inappropriate. Therefore, based on the above, the Hearing Officer concludes as a matter of law, that the District cannot proceed with its recommendation to expel STUDENT for the incident on February 26, 1998.
STUDENT has also asked that the suspension he was given because of the incident be removed from his school record. A challenge to the content of school records, however, must be made by filing a written request with the district superintendent. California Education Code §49070.
ISSUE 2. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the period he was in independent study?
The District placed STUDENT on independent study on March 5, 1998, where he remained through, at least, the end of the hearing on November 18, 1998. Whether STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education would depend on whether or not independent study was an appropriate placement for him. Petitioner contends that it was not. As previously stated, students with disabilities have the right to a free, appropriate public education (FAPE). The standards for determining whether a placement is appropriate are identified under IDEA and Rowley. Thus, the program offered by the school district is appropriate when it is designed to meet the student’s unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and comport with the IEP.
A. Was independent study an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
1. Did STUDENT’S placement in independent study meet his unique and individual needs?
STUDENT’S unique needs are his social, emotional difficulties and the behavioral difficulties which contribute to his inability to succeed in the regular classroom. He also has difficulties with written language and with visual/spatial skills, memory, reasoning, and attention - concentration for a combination of skills and processing deficits.
The independent study program into which STUDENT was placed required PARENT to pick up his work at the school and bring it home for him. In this case, independent study meant that STUDENT would not be provided with the services of a teacher at home, at all. The District was aware that PARENT had problems at home with STUDENT’S behavior and had, at some point, her own home behavior plan. It may be argued that removing STUDENT from the stimulus which occurs at school might increase his ability to concentrate by reducing distractions. Even if it was assumed that STUDENT did improve his behavior while studying at home, it could not be said that he would be able to work on his difficulty succeeding in the regular classroom with this placement. In addition, his BIP was designed to address problems in a school setting.
PARENT was STUDENT’S only teacher from March 1998, at least through the end of the due process hearing in November 1998. During this time, STUDENT had none of the professional special education classroom benefits which would sustain or improve his written language skills, or processing needs. He was also without the milieu which provided him the opportunity to improve his social difficulties. Finally, the home environment was not an appropriate place in which to continue or improve his behavior intervention plan. It is clear that independent study did not meet STUDENT’S unique and individual needs.
2. Was STUDENT’S placement designed to provide him with educational benefit and did it comport with his IEP?
The IEP meeting which changed STUDENT’S placement to independent study was on March 5, 1998. Under “Instructional Setting”, the District wrote “staff to monitor independent study pending manifestation determination and/or board decision on expulsion process no longer than April 28, 1998, continue goals and objectives.” The placement rationale is that “STUDENT requires monitored independent study during expulsion process.” (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 4).
At the March 26, 1998, IEP meeting, the independent study was continued “due to behavior problems,” with the staff again monitoring the independent study. (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 3.)
On many of STUDENT’S IEPs, it is noted as a placement rationale that he requires small group instruction. Instruction on a one to one basis is certainly small group instruction. PARENT does spend a considerable about of time assisting STUDENT with his school work at home and at school, however, she is not a trained teacher. According to PARENT, she would pick up STUDENT’S work at the school from the school secretary. She testified that because the instructions were not sufficient, she was staying up until one in the morning trying to prepare his lessons, and that getting him to start his work was difficult with the distractions in the house. One of STUDENT’S teachers, Mrs. Farino, called on several occasions to discuss the work and to give PARENT instructions as simply as possible. PARENT testified that she was thankful for that assistance. No teacher came to STUDENT’S home. On May 11, 1998, Ms. Johnson wrote PARENT:
The expulsion hearing is scheduled for May 20, 1998. Until that hearing, STUDENT will remain on independent study. If he were to stay on independent study for the remainder of the school year, he will be expected to complete and pass a comprehensive final for each class, on this school site. He will receive special permission to attend these finals if necessary. It is important that we have evidence of his mastery of the assigned curriculum prior to awarding a passing grade. I’m confident that this should not present a problem for him as you have stated how hard he is working and how well he is doing on his course work at home. (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 32.)
On April 24, 1998, however, the continuing case record for STUDENT shows this notation: “PARENT said she is having (a) hard time helping STUDENT in Math. She may have to hire a tutor. Wait on work till Mon.” (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 19.)
STUDENT’S final report, June 5, 1998, showed:
RSP Math 2 F
RSP US HIST 2 D
3D Design F RSP English D (Petitioner’s Exhibit 30.)
The March 26, 1998, IEP has an academic skills annual goal that “STUDENT will pass all core classes with ‘C’ or better.” The stated short term objective is that STUDENT will complete all classwork and homework with 75% accuracy and he will complete 90% of his own assigned work by himself. From the above, it appears that the monitoring and communication between staff and with PARENT was less than sufficient to reach the expectations of Ms. Johnson or to meet STUDENT’S goals and objectives.
According to the District, the placement was temporary and made to accommodate PARENT’S preferences. Several District witnesses testified that PARENT was offered other placements. The District also contends that independent study was not its preferred choice for STUDENT. Mr. Thornton stated that the District was concerned that teaching STUDENT might be difficult for PARENT, as she had a busy schedule.
Whatever other placements were considered, it is undisputed that the District recommended independent study as an appropriate placement. The District contends that the placement was temporary, but according to the above letter from Ms. Johnson, the placement could extend until the end of the school year. In any case, there is no legal support for an inappropriate placement, however temporary.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement of STUDENT in an independent study program in his home did not meet his unique needs and that with his mother as his only teacher for a good part of two semesters, the placement did not provide educational benefit to STUDENT. Finally, it did not comport with the IEP which required the staff to monitor the independent study so that STUDENT could continue the educational process. The evidence shows that whatever monitoring was done, it was not sufficient to assist STUDENT to successfully continue with his education.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’S placement in independent study denied him a FAPE for a sustained period of time. He is due some form of compensation for this loss.
B. Did the District commit procedural errors sufficient to deny STUDENT a FAPE?
Petitioner contends that the District made procedural errors during and/or before the March 5, 1998, and March 26, 1998 IEP meetings.
The Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT’S placement in independent study on March 5, 1998, was inappropriate. It was also determined that STUDENT’S misconduct was a manifestation of his disability. Because of these findings, the Hearing Officer does not need to reach the procedural issues.
C. If the District did deny STUDENT a FAPE by placing him in independent study, what type of compensatory education is he due?
Petitioner requests that the District provide a tutor for STUDENT for the period he was in independent study. Because independent study was determined an inappropriate placement for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer will consider this issue.
In School Committee of the Town of Burlington v Department of Education, 471 U.S.359, 374, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985), the Supreme Court concluded that equitable considerations are relevant in determining relief under the IDEA. Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See e.g. Parents of Student W. v Puyallup School District, 31 F. 3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994.) However, the Ninth Circuit has held that compensatory education does not involve an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity or time missed. Id. at 1497. The purpose of compensatory education is to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA. Id. Because compensatory education is an equitable remedy, equitable considerations are relevant in considering and fashioning relief. See Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 960 F. 2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992); Parents of Student W., 31 F. 3d at 1496. “The conduct of both parties must be reviewed to determine whether relief is appropriate.” W.G., 960 F.2d at 1486.
While PARENT’S several requests for continuing the due process hearing operated in a procedural way to lengthen STUDENT’S placement in independent study, the District maintained that this placement was appropriate for him. (Letter of Ms. Johnson, Respondent’s Volume 2, Exhibits 40 and 55.)
The District did attempt to schedule an IEP meeting for September 2, 1998, which PARENT did not attend because the due process hearing was pending. However, on September 11, 1998, in opposing a motion to change STUDENT’S “stay put”, the District continued to maintain that independent study was an appropriate placement for STUDENT. (Respondent’s Volume 2, Exhibit 35.)
Despite the efforts of his mother and the school work which was provided to STUDENT, he was without a teacher or the professional resources of the special education classroom for a substantial part of 1998. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that as a compensatory remedy STUDENT will need, at a minimum, the assistance of a tutor to help him catch up on his schoolwork.
The record does not provide sufficient information for the Hearing Officer to order a more specific compensatory remedy. However, since the Hearing Officer has determined STUDENT is entitled to the services of a tutor to address the loss of an appropriate education, the District is required to design a suitable tutoring program.
Because STUDENT’S placement in his RSP program at Central High School, East Campus, has been determined to be inappropriate, STUDENT cannot return to that program. In the interim, however, it is not suitable that STUDENT should be without relief. The Hearing Officer recognizes (1) that with STUDENT’S attention difficulties, a full day of tutoring would be too intensive and inappropriate, (2) that his new placement will not be immediately available, and (3) that a temporary classroom placement would be further disruptive to his education. Therefore, during this interim time, STUDENT will receive three hours of tutoring at home during each school day.
The interim tutoring, however, will not serve to compensate STUDENT sufficiently. Since the record indicates that PARENT was his only teacher for nearly two semesters, the tutoring must continue throughout the year.
Therefore, the District will be required to provide a tutor for STUDENT, in his home, for three hours a day until he is placed. After he is placed, the District will be required to provide him with a tutor for one hour a day, three times a week.
Issue 3: Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the cost of obtaining an independent assessment?
The District prepared a Preexpulsion Psycho-Educational Evaluation Report in March 1998. Approximately five months after this assessment by the District, STUDENT obtained an independent assessment from Dr. Richard Komm. Petitioner contends the District’s assessment is inappropriate and requests reimbursement for obtaining an independent assessment.
The Hearing Officer found that the District’s preexpulsion assessment of STUDENT was inappropriate because it did not assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability, and did not evaluate with sufficiency the relationship between STUDENT’S disability and his behavior.
Under California Education Code §56329(b), a parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists, as defined by the regulations of the board, if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. California Education Code §56329(b). See also 34 CFR 300.503.
In his closing brief, Respondent refers to Petaluma Joint Unified School District, SN 25-96, 25 IDELR 262 (1996), in which it was stated that a parent may be reimbursed for an independent assessment when it is determined at a due process hearing that the district’s assessment was inappropriate and that a corresponding assessment was appropriate.
The Hearing Officer recognizes that Dr. Komm based his conclusions on a limited amount of information and misunderstood certain elements of STUDENT’S educational program. (Testimony of Dr. Komm.)
A closer reading of the applicable code sections, California Education Code §56329(b), 34 CFR 300.503, however, confirms that in order to obtain reimbursement for an independent assessment, it is not necessary to show that the assessment the student obtained was appropriate, only that the District’s assessment was inappropriate.
Because the Hearing Officer has determined that the District’s preexpulsion assessment was inappropriate, STUDENT is entitled to be reimbursed for obtaining the independent assessment.
Issue 4: Is a Nonpublic School an Appropriate Placement for STUDENT?
Petitioner has asked that the District pay for a private, nonpublic school (NPS) placement. No evidence was presented on whether STUDENT has applied for or been accepted at a NPS. There was no testimony offered on a particular school, or why an NPS is a suitable placement for STUDENT. In fact, in his Amendment to Proposed Resolutions of November 18, 1998, Petitioner states that he will accept placement at the Central High School East Campus pursuant to the May 1, 1997 IEP, but with a revised behavior intervention plan.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer denies Petitioner’s request for placement at a nonpublic school.
ORDER
1. The District shall not proceed with expulsion proceedings for STUDENT for the incident on February 26, 1998.
2. Within 15 school days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to identify and offer a placement to STUDENT. The District shall consider both private and public options. The new placement shall possesses the following characteristics:
a. a small special education class with a low student/teacher ratio as specified in STUDENT’S school records;
b. a highly structured classroom as recommended by Simone Flaming. STUDENT’S transitions throughout the day must be kept to a practical minimum. Some consideration shall be given to placing him in one classroom for the major part of the day;
c. the psychological counseling recommended by Simone Flaming;
d. a new behavioral intervention plan and functional behavioral analysis;
e. a program to address his social/emotional difficulties and behavioral problems;
f. an assessment to address the significance of STUDENT’Spattern of falling asleep in class and to consider whether STUDENT should be classified as SED.
3. Within 10 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall provide STUDENT, in his home, with one-to-one tutoring from a credentialed teacher for three hours per school day until he begins school in his new placement. For the rest of the school year, 1998-1999, and for the Fall semester of the school year 1999-2000, the District will provide STUDENT with tutoring from a credentialed teacher for one hour three times a week either during or after school. The content of these tutoring programs will be determined by the District based on STUDENT’S current academic needs.
4. Within 20 calendar days after receiving proof of the fee, the District will reimburse Petitioner for the cost of obtaining an independent assessment.
All Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §56505(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Issue No. 1: May the District proceed with its recommendation to expel STUDENT for an incident on February 26, 1998?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 2: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the period he was in independent study?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 3: Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the independent evaluation he obtained from Dr. Komm?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No 4: Is a nonpublic school an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code §56505(i).
Date: January 27,1999 _________________________________
Marie Ward, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Petitioner attempted to introduce evidence into the record on January 22, 1999, after the record was closed. That evidence was not admitted or considered. 2.The issues have been reorganized and restated to allow for effective adjudication. 3.During the hearing it was recognized that the Hearing Officer’s copy of Respondent’s exhibits may be one number out of order. 4. While ADHD is not in itself a disabling condition, the diagnosis of attention deficit is to be considered when evaluating the educational performances of a student. Ca. Education Code § 56339. A medical release form signed by PARENT does limit the District to verbal contract with STUDENT’S doctors (Respondent’s Volume 1, Exhibit 43). The District’s right to obtain more complete medical information, however, could have been asserted.
