California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 18, 1997
Student v. Rio Elementary School District
SEHO Case No. SN 64-97, SN-64-97 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
Rio Elementary's Penfield preschool offer held appropriate with a transition aide; Montessori aide and reimbursement claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a three-year-old filed for due process after an IEP dispute with Rio Elementary School District. The student was eligible for special education based on a speech impairment and multiple developmental delays. He was moving from regional center services to the District. He attended the Montessori School of Ojai, where his parents paid for a one-on-one aide during the two-hour morning work period to help with transitions. The hearing focused on the District's offer of the Jump Start class at Penfield. This Ventura County program mixes special and general education preschoolers. The parents argued that Penfield was bilingual, that its multilingual classroom labels would confuse him, and that its "free choice" periods lacked structure. They sought a District-funded aide at Montessori and reimbursement.
The Hearing Officer found that Penfield taught in English and that any exposure to Spanish was incidental. The labels would not confuse a child who could not yet read. Free choice at Penfield closely resembled Montessori's morning work period, and Penfield had a lower student-teacher ratio. Penfield did not match the IEP, which called for a special day class two hours a day, three days a week. Even so, the Hearing Officer held that Penfield was appropriate under Rowley if the student had a one-on-one aide during the transition. The District had to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days to conform the IEP to Penfield and plan the aide's gradual phase-out. The aide and reimbursement claims were not reached.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO compared a district's play-based inclusive preschool with a private Montessori program under Rowley. The parents' claim that the class was bilingual was weighed against testimony from classroom staff. The district's offer was upheld even though it did not match the written IEP, and the district was ordered to revise the IEP and plan a transition aide.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Has the District proposed an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
Penfield's English-language, fully integrated Jump Start class met the student's unique needs and was designed to give him educational benefit under Rowley, as long as he had a one-on-one aide during the transition. The placement did not match the IEP, so the District had to convene an IEP meeting to conform the IEP to it.
- Not reachedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Is the District required to provide a one-on-one instructional aide for two hours per day at the Montessori school STUDENT currently attends?
Not reached, because the District's proposed placement at Penfield was found appropriate.
- Not reachedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. If the District has not proposed an appropriate placement, is the Montessori school STUDENT currently attends an appropriate placement? If yes, is the District required to reimburse Petitioner for expenses incurred at Montessori from December 1996 to the date of this decision and to place Petitioner at Montessori?
Not reached, because the District's offer was appropriate. In a footnote, the Hearing Officer questioned the private speech evaluation, since the same test had been given only one to two weeks earlier.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting to conform the IEP to the Penfield placement. The team must also develop a transition plan for the student to enroll at Penfield, including assigning a one-to-one aide and phasing the aide out gradually. All of Petitioner's claims for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Rowley
People named in the decision
- David Gomez, assistant superintendent, Rio Elementary School District
- Sean Goldman, school psychologist (District assessor), Rio Elementary School District
- Pattis Thompson, speech and language specialist (District assessor), Rio Elementary School District
- Grace Brandt, private speech-language pathologist, Funded through Tri-Counties Regional Center
- Wendy Odom, regional center representative (home support), Tri-Counties Regional Center
- Jan Meisel, private speech-language pathologist, Spectrum Speech and Language program
- Victoria Matthews, director of private preschool, Montessori School of Ojai
- Janet Lindquist-Lang, private preschool teacher, Montessori School of Ojai
- Renee Warner, 1:1 aide, Montessori School of Ojai
- Carrie Saetermore, expert witness for District (developmental psychologist), California State University, Northridge
- Wayne Saddler, principal, Ventura County Superintendent of Schools (Penfield)
- Ruth Hammond, special education teacher, Jump Start program, Penfield (Ventura County Superintendent of Schools)
- Tri-Counties Regional Center, regional center (Early Start services provider)
- Boswell Center, Early Start program
- Children's Wonderland, private preschool
- Montessori School of Ojai, private preschool
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Oxnard, California, on March 18 and 19, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Andrew Koenig. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were his parents, MOTHER and FATHER, and his grandmother, GRANDMOTHER. Respondent Rio Elementary School District (District) was represented by attorney Sharon Watt. Also present on behalf of the District was David Gomez, assistant superintendent, and Sean Goldman, district psychologist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Has the District proposed an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
(2) Is the District required to provide a one-on-one instructional aide for two hours per day at the Montessori school STUDENT currently attends?
(3) If the District has not proposed an appropriate placement, is the Montessori school STUDENT currently attends an appropriate placement? If yes, is the District required to reimburse Petitioner for expenses incurred at Montessori from December 1996 to the date of this decision and to place Petitioner at Montessori?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT turned three years old in December 1996. He was born with cocaine and alcohol in his system. Three days after STUDENT was born, MOTHER and FATHER were given custody of him, and they adopted him in July 1996. Tri-Counties Regional Center (Tri-Counties) began providing services to STUDENT when he was three weeks old. STUDENT was enrolled in the Early Start program at Boswell Center. STUDENT had a one-on-one aide and received occupational and physical therapy.
When STUDENT was nineteen months old, he transferred out of the Early Start program and began receiving private speech and language therapy from Grace Brandt. Four months later, STUDENT enrolled in Children's Wonderland preschool because Tri-Counties told his parents he needed interaction with nondisabled peers. STUDENT attended Children's Wonderland three days a week. However, after two months his teachers became frustrated with STUDENT because he had problems with transitions and did not talk. STUDENT was removed from Children's Wonderland after two and a half months.
Following STUDENT's removal from Children's Wonderland, Tri-Counties recommended enrollment in a Montessori program. In March 1996, when STUDENT was two years and three months old, his parents enrolled him in the Montessori School of Ojai (Montessori). STUDENT has remained at Montessori since. Also in March 1996, a representative from Tri-Counties, Wendy Odom, began working with the FAMILY at home to teach them how to deal with STUDENT's problems with transitions. Ms. Odom continued working with the FAMILY until September 1996.
During STUDENT's first few months at Montessori, he had significant problems with transitions. STUDENT's problems included yelling, screaming, and throwing things. As a result, STUDENT's teacher requested that his parents provide him with a one-on-one aide to help with transitions during the "academic" portion of the day, which was from 8:30 - 10:30 a.m. Since the aide was provided, STUDENT's problems with transitions have been eliminated and he is no more disruptive than any of the other children in the class. STUDENT does not have a one-on-one aide during the remainder of his day at Montessori.
In preparation for STUDENT's transfer from Tri-Counties to the District when he turned three years old, the District conducted a psychoeducational evaluation and speech and language assessment in November and December 1996. The psychoeducational evaluation was completed by Sean Goldman, school psychologist. According to the results, STUDENT's cognitive skills were at the 30-36 month developmental level; his fine motor skills were also at the 30-36 month developmental level; his gross motor skills ranged from the 42-48 month level to the 54-60 month level; his pre-academic skills were at the 24-30 month level; his social development was at the 22-month range; and his adaptive skills were at the 24-month age range.
The speech and language assessment was completed by Pattis Thompson, speech and language specialist. On the Preschool Language Scale-3 (PLS-3), STUDENT scored in the 9th percentile with a standard score of 80 in auditory comprehension, and in the 4th percentile with a standard score of 73 in expressive communication. Based on the assessment results, Ms. Thompson concluded that STUDENT was significantly delayed in articulation/phonology, semantics, syntax/morphology, auditory processing, and pragmatics. Ms. Thompson recommended that STUDENT "receive speech and language services in a functional environment with particular attention paid to semantics, syntax, auditory processing, and pragmatics."
Based on the results of both assessments, Mr. Goldman concluded that STUDENT qualifies for special education due to a speech impairment and multiple developmental delays.
On December 10, 1996, Grace Brandt completed a speech and language progress report for Tri-Counties. Among the tests Dr. Brandt administered was the Preschool Language Scale-3 (PLS-3), the same test that Ms. Thompson had administered for her assessment a week earlier. However, at the time she administered the PLS-3, Dr. Brandt was not unaware of the fact that the District had also recently administered the same test. STUDENT had also been administered the PLS-3 by Dr. Brandt in August 1996. Dr. Brandt also administered the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised (EOWPVT-R) during her assessment in December.
The results from these two tests indicated that STUDENT had made significant progress on the PLS-3. In Auditory Comprehension, STUDENT had improved from a standard score of 75 in August 1996 to a standard score of 95 in December 1996. In Expressive Communication, STUDENT improved from a standard score of 77 to a standard score of 82. STUDENT's Total Language standard score improved from 73 to 87 during the same time frame.
Based on her results, Dr. Brandt concluded that STUDENT continued to have a moderate expressive language disorder that was reflected in his articulation, syntax, and semantic development. Dr. Brandt also indicated that STUDENT's receptive language skills had increased dramatically.
On December 16, 1996, an IEP team met to determine STUDENT's eligibility for special education. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education for the same reasons identified by Mr. Goldman. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT receive speech and language services for 15-30 minutes three times per week and that he attend a special day class for two hours three times per week. The IEP team also adopted goals and objectives in the areas of attention span, readiness skills, gross motor skills, self-help skills, semantics, and syntax. The IEP team did not agree on a specific placement and continued the meeting to January 10, 1997, to provide STUDENT's parents an opportunity visit several proposed placements. Among the placements offered by the District are Penfield (a county operated program in the Ventura Unified School District at the Saticoy Elementary School campus), Rio Plaza, Los Nogales, Assistance League, Head Start, and Las Posas.
On January 10, 1997, the IEP team reconvened to review the placement options. At that time, STUDENT's parents objected to the proposed placements and did not consent to the IEP. On January 16, 1997, STUDENT's parents requested a due process hearing to resolve the issue of his placement.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
Petitioner's Witnesses
MOTHER
MOTHER, STUDENT's adoptive mother, testified extensively regarding STUDENT's history, educational needs, and the programs available for him.
MOTHER testified that STUDENT has exhibited a significant amount of progress in all areas over the past year, including speech, transitions, and behavior. In the area of speech, MOTHER testified that in August 1996, "words started flowing" from STUDENT and he started to communicate his needs. MOTHER also testified that STUDENT has improved 100% in transitions since March 1996.
MOTHER visited the Penfield(Footnote 1) program twice. The specific class proposed for STUDENT is called Jump Start and includes special education and regular education students in the same class. While MOTHER was observing the Penfield program, she noted the classroom schedule. According to MOTHER, the schedule is as follows:
8:30 a.m. -- Free choice 9:45 a.m. -- Group time, music, academic work 10:00 a.m. -- Snack 10:15 a.m. -- Free choice 11:15 a.m. -- Story 11:30 a.m. -- Departure
MOTHER testified that free choice is a period of time when the children can choose activities inside or outside of the classroom and that there is no structure during this time. MOTHER testified that STUDENT needs an academic, structured program and that the Penfield program is too play-based and unstructured. According to MOTHER, STUDENT would "go wild" during free choice.
In addition to needing a placement that is academic and structured, MOTHER testified that STUDENT needs a monolingual English program with integration with nondisabled peers. MOTHER testified that Penfield would not provide such a program because everything in the class is labeled in English, Spanish, sign language, and pictorial symbol. MOTHER counted fourteen regular signs and approximately thirty smaller signs containing the multiple languages. According to MOTHER, all of these labels would be confusing to STUDENT.
MOTHER also testified that she observed some lessons taught in Spanish and some students speaking in Spanish with each other. In MOTHER's view, the students at Penfield are not language peers for STUDENT because of the sign language and Spanish.
FATHER
FATHER, STUDENT's adoptive father, testified that he has noticed significant progress in STUDENT's speech and social development since he enrolled at Montessori. FATHER attributes the progress in speech to Dr. Brandt's therapy, the Montessori program, and maturational progress.
Regarding transitions, FATHER testified that STUDENT still has some difficulty, but he has improved significantly. FATHER testified that without a one-on-one aide, STUDENT's teacher would not be able to help him through transitions.
Grace Brandt
Dr. Grace Brandt is the speech and language pathologist who has provided speech and language therapy for sixty minutes per week for STUDENT since August 1995. Dr. Brandt's therapy was provided through Tri-Counties and was scheduled to end on March 26, 1997. All of Dr. Brandt's therapy sessions with STUDENT have been one-on-one and she has not observed him in group settings or at Montessori.
Dr. Brandt testified that in August 1995, STUDENT was not using words, only gestures. By December 1996, STUDENT had shown progress in his ability to follow directions and his use of words to communicate rather than gestures. According to Dr. Brandt, STUDENT was up to 3-4 word utterances. Dr. Brandt attributed STUDENT's progress to fact that he has developed some prelanguage skills, that his parents work with him at home, and that he started attending preschool five days per week in March 1996.
Regarding STUDENT's needs, Dr. Brandt testified that, while STUDENT has some distractibility problems, he has a good attention span. Dr. Brandt recommended that STUDENT continue in one-on-one therapy. Dr. Brandt testified that STUDENT's educational program should be in an environment with typically developing language peers to allow STUDENT the opportunity to learn language through interaction and modelling.
Dr. Brandt also testified that whichever assessor gave the second PLS-3 in December 1996 would have invalid results because of either the practice effect or boredom factor. Dr. Brandt testified that with the same test being given a second time so shortly after the first time, a child is likely to either perform better than expected because he or she recognizes the test and does well. A child may also perform worse than expected because he or she is bored with the test having taken it so recently.
Jan Meisel
Jan Meisel is a speech and language pathologist with the Spectrum Speech and Language program. Ms. Meisel provided speech and language therapy twice a month to STUDENT from March 1996 through September 1996. Ms. Meisel stopped providing services to STUDENT because his parents were looking for a service provider closer to home. Ms. Meisel has not seen STUDENT since September 1996.
Ms. Meisel testified that STUDENT had a significant speech and language delay. He had only a few expressive words, and a significant receptive language delay. Ms. Meisel testified that STUDENT worked well in one-on-one sessions but that he was very distractible and needed a quiet, focused environment.
While Ms. Meisel acknowledged that she did not have any experience with students in bilingual classes, she stated that a student with a significant language delay should work on his or her primary language first before being exposed to a second language. Ms. Meisel testified that STUDENT needs to be in a monolingual program to progress as much as possible. Ms. Meisel testified that a bilingual program may not necessarily harm STUDENT, but that he might not progress as quickly. Ms. Meisel also testified that labels such as those in the Penfield program would be confusing to STUDENT.
Victoria Matthews
Dr. Victoria Matthews is the director of the Montessori School of Ojai. According to Dr. Matthews, Montessori provides a very structured environment that allows students to move freely within the environment and make choices regarding activities. The staff participates in ongoing training. However, there are no special education credentialed personnel on the Montessori staff. Dr. Matthews testified that speech and language services are not provided at Montessori.
Dr. Matthews testified that there are fifteen students in STUDENT's class of two- to four-year-olds with one teacher and one aide, in addition to the one-on-one aide assigned to STUDENT. Dr. Matthews testified that the students in STUDENT's class are primarily English speakers. Dr. Matthews testified that STUDENT needs a one-on-one aide to normalize his behavior.
Janet Lindquist-Lang
Janet Lindquist-Lang is STUDENT's teacher at Montessori. This is Ms. Lindquist-Lang's first year as a teacher after working for five years as an aide at Montessori. Ms. Lindquist-Lang has a Montessori certificate but does not have any teaching credentials or education in special education.
Ms. Lindquist-Lang testified that a one-on-one aide was requested for STUDENT because he was becoming increasingly difficult to work with in class. She testified that she raised the possibility of such an aide because she was concerned about the safety of the other children in the class. Once the aide was assigned, there was an immediate improvement because STUDENT stopped throwing things. Ms. Lindquist-Lang testified that when the aide was first assigned, STUDENT had to be taken outside for timeouts on a daily basis and he did not participate in group activities. Currently, STUDENT only has be taken out of the classroom once every week or two, and he enjoys participating in group activities.
Ms. Lindquist-Lang also indicated that STUDENT's speech and language have improved since the aide started working with him. Ms. Lindquist-Lang attributed STUDENT's speech and language progress to the speech and language therapy, interaction with nondisabled peers, and the ability of the aide to keep STUDENT focussed on work. Ms. Lindquist-Land testified that Montessori has not yet developed a plan for removing the aide.
According to Ms. Lindquist-Lang, the schedule of her class includes an "academic" portion from 8:30 - 10:30 a.m., during which time the students may choose activities to work on. Also during this time, she provides one-on-one assistance to the children. Ms. Lindquist-Lang testified that the aide is only present during the "academic" period and that STUDENT is fine during the remainder of the day without the aide. During the time when STUDENT does not have an aide, the class spends time outside, has story time, lunch, and sharing group activities. Ms. Lindquist-Lang testified that from 10:30 a.m. until the end of the day, there is more play and the students can be more active.
Ms. Lindquist-Lang testified that STUDENT is currently able to focus up to 20 minutes on tasks. In addition, his motor skills are age appropriate and his social/emotional skills have improved significantly, as demonstrated by his interactions with other children and his ability to control his behavior. Ms. Lindquist-Lang also indicated that STUDENT's language skills have improved and he is now able to indicate his needs in 2-3 word utterances. Finally, Ms. Lindquist-Lang testified that STUDENT can transition from task to task or from one environment to another without difficulty. However, Ms. Lindquist-Lang testified that STUDENT still needs a one-on-one aide because of the potential of what could happen without the aide.
Renee Warner
Renee Warner is the one-on-one aide at Montessori. Ms. Warner described her role as helping STUDENT transition from activity to activity and keeping him in line behaviorally. Ms. Warner testified that for the first few weeks STUDENT did not want to do any of the activities, participate in group activities, clean up after himself, or put work away. Ms. Warner testified that STUDENT has made a lot of progress. He now makes choices regarding activities and is more independent.
Ms. Warner testified that it has taken longer for STUDENT to improve in how he handles transitions but that he now can go through transitions without difficulty. Ms. Warner testified that STUDENT now acts appropriately in all areas but he still requires a one-on-one aide because he needs the reassurance that help is available.
District Witnesses
Sean Goldman
Sean Goldman is the school psychologist responsible for STUDENT's transition from Tri-Counties to the District. Mr. Goldman conducted the assessment of STUDENT and has attended his IEP meetings.
Mr. Goldman testified that the program at Penfield would allow STUDENT to be integrated with regular education peers for the entire school day. The program is for three- to five-year-olds. The class meets five days a week from 8:30 - 11:30 a.m. The program is a language-based program designed to develop speech and language skills throughout the day. Speech and language services are provided in the classroom in small-group sessions. Mr. Goldman testified that the program has age appropriate, cognitively appropriate, and socially appropriate peers.
Mr. Goldman acknowledged that there is "free time" incorporated into the Penfield program. However, he testified that the free time is structured and incorporates directed activities.
According to Mr. Goldman, the Penfield program is not a bilingual program. All instruction is in English. If Spanish-speaking students need additional instruction in Spanish, it takes place in a separate part of the room. Any exposure to Spanish would be incidental and not part of the formal instruction of the class. Mr. Goldman testified that STUDENT would be "fully immersed" in English.
Regarding the aide, Mr. Goldman testified that the District could provide STUDENT with an aide at Penfield and then gradually reduce the aide's time until STUDENT no longer needed the aide. Mr. Goldman also testified that he believed that if STUDENT were in a program with appropriate behavior management techniques, he would be successful without the aide. Mr. Goldman testified that the aide fosters dependency and prevents STUDENT from learning appropriate social skills.
Mr. Goldman testified that STUDENT's educational needs include a language-based program, speech and language services, and a structured environment with integration with nondisabled peers. Mr. Goldman testified that the Montessori program, combined with speech and language services, is not sufficient.
Carrie Saetermore
Dr. Carrie Saetermore is an associate professor of psychology at California State University, Northridge. Her Ph.D. is in developmental psychology. Dr. Saetermore testified that cocaine-exposed infants consistently have problems with receptive and expressive language, and attention. Preschool programs for such children need to be highly structured and the children should not have a lot of free choice. The programs should also be speech and language intensive preferably at a language level slightly higher than the child's.
Dr. Saetermore testified that she is unaware of any research showing that labels or language in other than the child's primary language would be detrimental. Dr. Saetermore testified that exposure to another language would actually broaden a child's conceptual base and that the signs posted in the Penfield class would enhance and complement the development of language.
Dr. Saetermore visited both the Penfield program and the Montessori program and reviewed STUDENT's IEP and assessments. Dr. Saetermore described Penfield as language intensive with a lot of activities. Dr. Saetermore testified that the disabled children were fully integrated with their nondisabled peers in their play and verbal interactions. Dr. Saetermore testified that language was developed by building vocabulary through informal means and through the use of language in teaching. Although the students had some freedom of choice, Dr. Saetermore testified that the choices were structured. Dr. Saetermore testified that she did not see any instruction in Spanish during her visit.
Dr. Saetermore testified that Penfield would be appropriate for STUDENT because of the expertise of the teachers, number of teachers and aides in the room, peer-to-peer interaction for language and social development, and the presence of appropriate higher functioning peers.
Dr. Saetermore testified that STUDENT needs to start becoming more independent and that his dependence on the aide prevents him from learning to redirect himself. Dr. Saetermore also indicated that STUDENT would probably benefit from full integration with peers who have speech and language skills slightly better than his.
Wayne Saddler
Wayne Saddler is a principal with the Ventura County Superintendent of Schools. Penfield is one of the programs for which he is responsible. Mr. Saddler testified that Penfield has approximately 70 students and serves severely handicapped students. Mr. Saddler testified that Penfield is located next to Saticoy Elementary School and that Penfield and Saticoy share facilities so that regular education and special education classes are at both sites.
Services available at Penfield include speech and language, occupational and physical therapy, adaptive physical education, and nursing services. According to Mr. Saddler, speech and language services are provided within the classroom setting. In the class proposed for STUDENT, the speech and language therapist is in the class two hours per day several days per week and she works primarily in small groups during the first "free choice" period. Mr. Saddler testified that while students have the choice whether to participate in speech services, no students have ever resisted the speech and language work when directed toward the speech and language therapist. Mr. Saddler also testified that additional speech and language services could be provided if needed. The special education component of the Penfield program includes home visits by the special education teacher twice per month to work with the child and his or her parents at home.
Mr. Saddler testified that Penfield is a language-based program and that it is structured in the sense that activities are set up to guide students through needed skills. He also stated that during free-choice time, children can be directed towards certain activities if they seem lost or are not using their time productively.
Mr. Saddler testified that the class STUDENT would enroll in is team taught by regular education and special education teachers. Mr. Saddler testified that there is one regular education teacher and aide, and one special education teacher and aide in the classroom, along with parent volunteers. The teachers are trained in positive behavior management techniques, and a school psychologist is available to develop a behavioral intervention plan if needed.
Mr. Saddler testified that STUDENT could be provided with a one-on-one aide for the transition into Penfield. Mr. Saddler also indicated that STUDENT's goals and objectives are typical of those of the other students in Penfield and that they could be implemented at Penfield. Ruth Hammond
Ruth Hammond is the special education teacher in the Jump Start program at Penfield. According to Ms. Hammond, the schedule of the class is as follows:
8:30 a.m. -- Arrival and free choice 10:00 a.m. -- Circle time, language work Snack 10:30 a.m. -- Free choice 11:15 a.m. -- Story and song time
Ms. Hammond testified that the philosophy at Penfield is that children learn through playing. Activities are child-initiated with teachers facilitating and expanding language development. Ms. Hammond testified that if a child is not doing anything during free choice, a teacher or aide intervenes and directs the child to appropriate activities.
Ms. Hammond testified that there are currently eleven regular education children and eight special education children in the class. Of the eight special education students, five are monolingual English speakers, two are emerging bilingual speakers, and one has no real language skills. Of the eleven regular education students, seven are monolingual English speakers, two are bilingual, and two speak Spanish at home.
Ms. Hammond testified that neither she nor the regular education teacher speaks Spanish and that all instruction is in English. Ms. Hammond indicated that the signs posted around the classroom are there to teach children that objects have labels and to expose them to language. Ms. Hammond stated that there are fewer than twenty signs in the room. Ms. Hammond acknowledged that Spanish is spoken between some of the students but that the bilingual students tend to speak English.
Pattis Thompson
Pattis Thompson is the speech therapist who conducted the District's speech and language assessment in November and December 1996. Ms. Thompson testified that the results from the second PLS-3 given at that time would be invalid and that, based on the dates of the assessments, she believed that she had administered the PLS-3 before Dr. Brandt.
Ms. Thompson testified that she attended STUDENT's IEPs and believed that Penfield would provide an appropriate program for STUDENT. Ms. Thompson testified that STUDENT's language impairment is what most impairs his education and that he is in need of a lot of intervention
DISCUSSION
(1) Has the District proposed an appropriate placement for STUDENT?(Footnote 2)
Although the District proposed numerous placements for STUDENT, the evidence presented by the parties focused primarily on two specific placements -- Penfield and Rio Plaza. This decision will first address the Penfield placement.
State and federal law require that students with disabilities receive a free appropriate public education. California Education Code § 56500 et seq. and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child, including classroom instruction, instruction in physical education, home instruction, and instruction in hospitals and institutions."
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." 458 U.S. 175,200.
Taken together, the IDEA and the Rowley Court's interpretation of the IDEA provide three factors for analyzing whether the District's proposed placement at Penfield is appropriate for STUDENT. Those three factors are as follows:
1. Is Penfield designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs?
2. Does Penfield conform to the student's IEP?
3. Is Penfield designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT?
____________________
1. Is Penfield designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs?
There is little dispute that STUDENT needs a structured program designed to enhance his language development and meet his behavioral needs. The parties agree that such a program should include interaction with nondisabled peers who will provide STUDENT with appropriate language models.
The dispute between the parties arises over whether Penfield provides an appropriately structured environment with appropriate language exposure. Petitioner contends that Penfield is a bilingual program and that STUDENT's progress would be slower in such a program than if he were in a monolingual program. Petitioner also contends that the free-choice time at Penfield is too unstructured for STUDENT to benefit from it. The District contends that Penfield is not a bilingual program and that even if it were, bilingual programs do not have a detrimental effect on the acquisition of language skills on English-only speakers. Finally, the District contends that Penfield would provide STUDENT with the structure he needs.
Assuming that STUDENT requires a monolingual program, there is insufficient evidence that Penfield is a bilingual program that would not meet his language needs. The only witness who testified that Penfield is a bilingual program was MOTHER, who spent approximately ninety minutes during two visits to Penfield and who testified that she heard Spanish spoken during her visits.
On the other hand, several District witnesses testified that the Penfield program is not bilingual and any exposure to Spanish would be incidental. Most compelling is the testimony of Ms. Hammond, the special education teacher at Penfield, who testified that neither she nor the regular education teacher speaks very much Spanish, that all instruction is in English, and that if Spanish-speaking students require additional instruction in Spanish, it is done by the instructional aides in a separate part of the room.
Based on the testimony of the District witnesses, the Hearing Officer finds that the Penfield program is not a bilingual program. The evidence establishes that were STUDENT placed at Penfield, he would be in a language-based program in which his instruction would take place in English, he would have numerous English-speaking language models, and any exposure to Spanish would be incidental and would not have a detrimental effect on his language development.
Petitioner also questioned the signs placed in the classroom and contended that the signs would be confusing to STUDENT. However, Petitioner did not present any specific reason why the signs would be confusing, other than the fact that he is language delayed. Considering that STUDENT is at a developmental stage where he cannot read, the fact that the signs are in both Spanish and English should not be confusing to him. Furthermore, as testified to by District witnesses, the different languages on the signs, including sign language and pictorial symbols, might actually enhance STUDENT's development. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the signs in the classroom at Penfield do not render the placement inappropriate.
As stated above, all parties agree that STUDENT needs a structured educational environment. Petitioner contends that the free-choice periods at Penfield do not provide the structure that STUDENT needs. Interestingly, the witnesses who described free choice at Penfield and the witnesses who described the "academic" portion of the Montessori program favored by Petitioner sounded as though they were talking about the same program. During free choice at Penfield and the "academic" portion at Montessori, activities are set up by the teachers to work on skills the students require. Among the activities that are available, students are free to choose those activities in which they want to participate. In both programs, if the students are not working productively, the teachers or aides redirect the students to more productive activities.
It is difficult to see, when comparing the two programs, how Montessori provides the structure STUDENT requires while Penfield does not. It is important to note that Penfield has a lower student-teacher ratio than Montessori. STUDENT's class at Montessori has approximately fifteen students with one teacher and one aide. The Penfield class has eight special education students with one special education teacher and one special education aide. Given the lower student-teacher ratio at Penfield, the staff at Penfield would have a greater opportunity to provide STUDENT with the direction and structure he requires.
There is also the issue of whether STUDENT would require a one-on-one aide if he were to attend Penfield. The District has offered to provide a one-on-one aide to STUDENT to ease the transition to Penfield. According to Mr. Goldman, such an aide would be gradually withdrawn from STUDENT's program. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires such a one-on-one aide at Penfield. An aide was originally assigned at Montessori because of STUDENT's problems with transitions. Although the employees of Montessori testified that STUDENT no longer has problems with transitions, they were concerned about his continuing need for an aide to provide him with help if he needs it. Furthermore, STUDENT has had a one-on-one aide for the past six months. Considering the major transition he would be making to another program if he enrolls at Penfield, STUDENT requires the one-on-one aide during the transition to Penfield.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that Penfield provides STUDENT with the structure he requires to benefit from his education. Furthermore, based on the nature of the Penfield program, that it is language-based and will provide STUDENT with integration with nondisabled peers, the Hearing Officer finds that Penfield is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs so long as a one-on-one aide is assigned to STUDENT for the transition from Montessori to Penfield.
2. Does Penfield conform to the student's IEP?
STUDENT's IEP calls for him to attend a special day class three days a week for two hours per day and to be integrated into the regular education environment for 10% of the school day. The Penfield program does not conform to STUDENT's IEP because it is a five-day-a-week program and is fully integrated for the entire school day.
3. Is Penfield designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT?
It is not an easy task to predict whether a prospective placement in which the child has not yet participated in will provide educational benefit. However, certain facts in the present case indicate that the Penfield program is reasonably designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Most important is the fact that the District's program is language-based, incorporates the services of a speech and language therapist into the class, and will provide STUDENT with a maximum amount of integration with nondisabled and appropriately developing language peers. STUDENT will also be in a program with a lower student to teacher ratio than exists in his current program.
Based on the elements of the Penfield program as described above, the Hearing Officer finds that the program is reasonably designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer also finds that it is an appropriate program for STUDENT which meets his unique needs. However, since the placement at Penfield does not conform with STUDENT's IEP, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to conform his IEP to the placement. The IEP team shall also determine how best to accommodate STUDENT's transition to the Penfield program, including the assignment of a one-on-one aide. The IEP team shall also develop a plan for the gradual phase out of the aide.
Because the District has proposed an appropriate placement for STUDENT at Penfield, the Hearing Officer does not reach the issue of whether the other placements offered by the District are appropriate. Additionally, the Hearing Officer does not reach the other two issues identified for hearing which related to placement and services that would be necessary if the District's proposed placement was not appropriate.(Footnote 3)
ORDER
(1) Rio Elementary School District shall convene an IEP meeting within 15 days of the date of this decision to conform STUDENT IEP to the placement at Penfield and to develop a transition plan for STUDENT to enroll at Penfield, including the assignment and gradual phase out of a one-to-one aide.
(2) Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56505(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: April 18, 1997 ______________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1:As used in this decision, "Penfield" refers to the Jump Start program at Penfield on the Saticoy Elementary School campus. Footnote 2:Initially, Petitioner had identified issues relating to the provision of speech and language services and occupational and physical therapy. However, at the outset of the hearing, the parties reached an agreement regarding these services. Therefore, this decision will not address the appropriateness of those services and will address only the educational placements proposed by the parties. Footnote 3: Although the appropriateness of Montessori is not being addressed, the Hearing Officer notes that the progress evidenced by Dr. Brandt's evaluation is of questionable validity based on the evidence that indicates Dr. Brandt gave a test identical to one given by the District only one to two weeks earlier.
