California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 24, 1998

Student v. Conejo Valley Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 647-97 · Hearing Officer Keltie Jones

Conejo Valley Unified denied FAPE in special day class placements and must reimburse private school, speech, and educational therapy costs.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 8 issues (2 in part)Vanaman German LLP represented the student

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a seven-year-old boy filed for hearing against Conejo Valley Unified School District. He was eligible for special education due to learning disabilities and speech and language delays. Los Angeles Unified had placed him in regular kindergarten with support. After his family moved, the District placed him in a preschool/kindergarten special day class (SDC) at Aspen Elementary taught by a speech and language specialist, and it dropped his separate speech therapy. His behavior and attitude toward school got worse. In January 1997 his parents moved him to Children's World, a private program, and later to the Montessori School of Agoura.

Hearing Officer Keltie Jones found that the IEPs lacked present levels of performance, a link between needs, goals and services, a reason for the restrictive placement, and objective evaluation criteria. These defects alone did not deny FAPE. However, the 1996-97 placement and the 1997-98 offer did deny FAPE. Neither gave him independent hands-on work, four hours a week of one-to-one instruction, three hours a week of individual speech therapy, or enough time with typically developing peers. The District must hold an IEP meeting within 15 days and offer those services. It must also reimburse $3,062.50 for Children's World, plus Montessori academic tuition, private speech therapy, and Dr. Barbara Silton's evaluation and educational therapy. The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for a private speech assessment and a psychiatric exam.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO kept IEP paperwork defects separate from the substance of a placement. Missing present levels and missing LRE explanations were not enough to deny FAPE by themselves. Failing to meet the student's identified needs was. The decision also shows parents being reimbursed for a private evaluation when the district had notice that more assessment was needed.

Issues and holdings

  1. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP content

    Issue 1a. For 1996-97: Did the District commit procedural errors (IEP lacking present levels, measurable goals, specified services, a direct relationship among levels, goals and services, an LRE justification, and objective evaluation criteria) that resulted in the denial of a FAPE?

    The IEPs lacked present levels of performance, a direct link between levels, goals and services, a statement of why a less restrictive setting would not work, and objective evaluation criteria. Goals and services were adequately specified. The defects alone did not deny FAPE.

  2. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1b. For 1996-97: Was the placement designed to meet the student's unique needs?

    The SDC did not meet his needs for independent hands-on work with manipulatives, four hours a week of one-to-one instruction, three hours a week of individual speech therapy, or time with typically developing peers. The February 1997 offer of group speech therapy at another school without transportation also fell short.

  3. Issue 1c. For 1996-97: Was the placement designed to provide educational benefit?

    Not reached because the placement did not meet the student's unique needs.

  4. Not reachedImplementation

    Issue 1d. For 1996-97: Did the placement conform to the student's IEP?

    Not reached because the placement did not meet the student's unique needs.

  5. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1e. For 1996-97: Did the placement educate the student in the least restrictive environment?

    By failing to meet his need to be with typically developing peers, the District also failed to educate him in the LRE. Four 50-minute integrated sessions a week were not enough.

  6. Issue 2. Are the student and his family entitled to reimbursement for the costs they incurred to provide him an appropriate program between January 1997 and August 1997?

    The Hearing Officer awarded reimbursement for Children's World academic tuition, the Montessori summer academic program (needed because ESY was found eligible but never offered), private speech therapy, and Dr. Silton's program evaluation. The District had notice that more assessment was needed. Reimbursement for the private speech assessment was denied because nothing required the District to reassess speech.

  7. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Does the program offered for 1997-98 comply with legal requirements for identifying services on an IEP, and could it provide an appropriate education in the least restrictive environment?

    The K/1 SDC, where 10 of 11 classmates had speech and language delays, did not provide typically developing language models or the LRE. It also lacked one-to-one instruction and adequate individual speech therapy, so it denied FAPE.

  8. Issue 4. Is the District required to reimburse the family for expenses incurred, and to be incurred, to provide an appropriate program with related services for 1997-98?

    The Hearing Officer awarded reimbursement through the decision date for Montessori academic tuition, private speech therapy, and Dr. Silton's educational therapy. A psychiatrist's medical exam confirming a prior diagnosis was denied, and future expenses were too speculative to order.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting and prepare a new IEP. It must include present levels of performance and new goals and objectives clearly tied to his needs and present levels.
  • Placement ordered. The new IEP must offer a placement that lets him learn with typically developing peers, gives tactile and visual instruction, and lets him work independently on concrete, structured manipulative tasks.
  • Order to provide or change services. Provide three hours per week of individual speech and language therapy and four hours per week of one-to-one instruction from an educational therapist. Also provide adapted physical education and occupational therapy as recommended in the May 9, 1997 and September 15, 1997 IEPs.
  • Reimbursement. Reimburse the parents $3,062.50 for the academic portion of the Children's World program (24.5 weeks at $125 per week).
  • Reimbursement. Reimburse the academic portion of the 1997 summer program and the 1997-98 school-year program at the Montessori School of Agoura through the decision date, once the parents document the academic-portion costs.
  • Reimbursement. Reimburse speech and language therapy from Farryl Dickter and Associates, once the parents document how much of the fee was for therapy rather than assessment.
  • Reimbursement. Reimburse the program evaluation and educational therapy provided by Dr. Barbara Silton through the decision date.

Total: $3,062.50 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Burlington; Carter (Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter); Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. Texas Bd. of Education

People named in the decision

  • Cheryl DeLong, special day class teacher and speech and language specialist, Conejo Valley Unified School District, Aspen Elementary School
  • Jack Bannon, associate director of special education, Conejo Valley Unified School District
  • Constance Farkas, coordinator of elementary special education programs, Conejo Valley Unified School District
  • Susan Kunz, school psychologist, Conejo Valley Unified School District
  • Susan Murray, occupational therapist, Conejo Valley Unified School District
  • Madge Bradford, speech and language specialist, Conejo Valley Unified School District, Acacia Elementary School
  • Candace Bartelson, K/1 special day class teacher, Conejo Valley Unified School District, Aspen Elementary School
  • Lance Steinberg, psychiatrist, witness for Student, Private
  • Barbara Silton, educational psychologist; private program evaluator and educational therapist, Private
  • Farryl Dickter, private speech-language pathologist, Farryl Dickter and Associates
  • Ann Culhane, Montessori school director, Montessori School of Agoura
  • Laura MacIntosh, Montessori teacher, District witness, Montessori School of Agoura
  • Lucinda Brown, law clerk for Student's counsel
  • Children's World, private school (unilateral placement)
  • Montessori School of Agoura, private school (unilateral placement)
  • Language, Speech and Hearing Center, California State University, Northridge, private speech and language evaluation and therapy provider, CSUN

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter convened for hearing on September 29 and 30, and October 1, 1997, and January 5, 6, 7, and 8, 1998, (Footnote 1) in Thousand Oaks, California, before Hearing Officer Keltie Jones of the Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) located at McGeorge School of Law in Sacramento, California.

The Petitioner was represented at hearing by attorney Valerie Vanaman. Also present on the Petitioner's behalf were his parents, MOTHER and FATHER. Law clerk Lucinda Brown also attended portions of the hearing.

The Conejo Valley Unified School District (District) was represented at hearing by attorney Sharon Watt. Also present on the District's behalf was Jack Bannon, associate director of special education.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: teacher Cheryl DeLong, psychiatrist Lance Steinberg, educational psychologist Barbara Silton, coordinator of elementary special education programs Constance Farkas, speech pathologist Farryl Dickter, Montessori school director Ann Culhane, Jack Bannon, FATHER, and MOTHER, .

The District called the following witnesses to testify: school psychologist Susan Kunz, Montessori teacher Laura MacIntosh, occupational therapist Susan Murray, speech and language specialist Madge Bradford, teacher Candace Bartelson, and Cheryl DeLong.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and closing arguments were submitted on February 9, 1998. The record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

1. Did the District provide an appropriate educational program for STUDENT with all necessary aids and services in the least restrictive environment for the 1996-97 school year?

2. Are STUDENT and his family entitled to reimbursement for all of the costs they incurred to provide him with an appropriate educational program with all necessary aids and services in the least restrictive environment for the period between January 1997 and August 1997?

3. Does the program the District has offered for the 1997-98 school year comply with the legal requirements of federal and state law as to the manner in which services are to be identified on an IEP and could such a program provide STUDENT with an appropriate educational program in the least restrictive environment?

4. Is the District required to reimburse STUDENT's family for the expenses they have incurred, and will incur, to provide STUDENT with an appropriate program with the necessary related services for the 1997-98 school year?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

In the 1996-97 school year, the District provided a program for STUDENT that consisted of a preschool/kindergarten special day class (SDC) taught by a speech and language specialist and adapted physical education (APE). In February 1997, the District offered to modify the program to include separate speech and language therapy in addition to the SDC and APE. The Petitioner asserts that neither of these programs provided an appropriate education in the least restrictive environment (LRE). The Petitioner also asserts that his IEPs were substantively incomplete. The Petitioner's parents placed him in private schools from January 1997 through August 1997.

For the 1997-98 school year, the District has offered placement in a kindergarten/first grade SDC with APE, speech and language therapy, and in-class occupational therapy. The Petitioner again asserts that the IEP is substantively defective and that the placement offered does not provide an appropriate education in the LRE. The Petitioner's parents have placed him in a private Montessori school and are seeking reimbursement for the cost of the school as well as for educational and speech therapy.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a seven-year-old boy who is eligible for special education due to learning disabilities and speech and language delays. STUDENT was born in Russia and lived in an orphanage for the first three years of his life. At the orphanage, STUDENT did not have any toys or educational stimulation. When MOTHER adopted STUDENT (Footnote 2) in October 1994, the orphanage staff told her he had speech problems in Russian, his native language, that affected his intelligibility. In the United States, STUDENT was immediately immersed in English, and he began to refuse to speak any Russian. English is now STUDENT's primary language.

As STUDENT's ability to speak English progressed, MOTHER noted that he had articulation and speech delays in this language, as well. In October 1995, MOTHER took STUDENT to the Language, Speech and Hearing Center at California State University, Northridge (CSUN) for a speech and language evaluation. STUDENT was diagnosed with a moderate to severe articulation disorder and moderate to severe expressive and receptive language delays. STUDENT received speech and language therapy at CSUN through the spring of 1996, resulting in some improvement. (Pet. Exh. 13, p.87.)

In February 1996, a school psychologist and speech pathologist with Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) evaluated STUDENT and found him to be eligible for special education due to deficits in expressive and receptive language. (Pet. Exh. 16.) In April and May 1996, another LAUSD school psychologist evaluated STUDENT and found that, in addition to his speech and language eligibility, he also qualified for special education due to visual and auditory processing delays. (Pet. Exh. 15.)

In May 1996, an optometrist evaluated STUDENT and determined that he had a visual processing disorder that might interfere with his ability to learn to read and write. The optometrist prescribed glasses, recommended vision therapy, and suggested that educational therapy may be necessary in the future. (Pet. Exh. 14, p. 89.) MOTHER did not obtain vision or educational therapy for STUDENT at that time because of the cost.

At an IEP meeting on June 26, 1996, LAUSD and the parents agreed that STUDENT would be placed in a regular kindergarten class for the 1996-97 school year and would receive support from a kindergarten transition specialist, APE, and speech and language services. (Pet. Exh. 8.)

During the summer of 1996, MOTHER and FATHER moved to Thousand Oaks. MOTHER contacted the Conejo Valley Unified School District to discuss STUDENT's special education needs and placement. Ms. Constance Farkas, the coordinator of elementary special education programs, told MOTHER that there were speech and language specialists available at STUDENT's neighborhood school and that MOTHER should enroll STUDENT in the regular kindergarten there. An administrative placement IEP was prepared on August 30, 1996, indicating that STUDENT would be attending regular education kindergarten with up to thirty minutes of RSP support 1-2 times per week, one hour of speech and language services 1-2 times per week, and twenty minutes of APE per week. (Dist. Exh. 6.) When MOTHER contacted the school to enroll STUDENT, she was informed that the only space available was in the afternoon kindergarten class. Because the speech and language specialists were available only in the mornings, STUDENT would not have an opportunity to work with them if he attended the afternoon class. MOTHER called Ms. Farkas with this information, and Ms. Farkas suggested that STUDENT be placed in an SDC at Aspen Elementary School taught by a speech and language specialist. On September 3, 1996, Ms. Farkas prepared an IEP Supplemental Information form indicating that STUDENT's thirty-day administrative placement was the Aspen SDC, and that the related service of speech and language services would be discontinued because the services would be provided in the class by the SDC teacher, Ms. Cheryl DeLong. (Dist. Exh. 5.)

On October 2, 1996, STUDENT's IEP team met to review the thirty-day placement. Prior to that meeting, Ms. DeLong gave STUDENT the Preschool Language Scale-3 (PLS-3) and prepared goals and objectives for STUDENT using the District's database. At the meeting, Ms. DeLong reported the results of the PLS-3. STUDENT's total language scaled score was 62, placing his language development at the 3 ½-year-old level. The IEP team, including MOTHER, agreed that STUDENT would continue in the SDC with APE for twenty minutes per week. (Dist. Exh. 4.)

As the fall progressed, STUDENT's parents began noticing that he was having significant difficulty with his homework. STUDENT refused to do any paper and pencil tasks, and homework time became a battle. STUDENT's parents finally stopped forcing STUDENT to do his homework because they did not want him to develop an aversion to learning. STUDENT was expressing unhappiness with school, saying that he did not need to go to "big school" anymore. At the mid-semester parent-teacher conference, Ms. DeLong told STUDENT's parents that she had a hard time putting her finger on STUDENT's disability because in some areas he was far below the class, and in others he had skills far beyond those of his peers. STUDENT's behavior in class was also becoming a problem. He was aggressive with other children or refused to finish his work. When asked to take a time out for misbehavior, he often refused. Ms. DeLong testified that she addressed STUDENT's refusal to complete work by insisting that he finish the work later instead of participating in another activity, such as playing with blocks or recess. In November, Ms. DeLong began sending a notebook home to inform STUDENT's parents of any misbehavior during the day. In the notebook, Ms. DeLong frequently praised STUDENT as having a good day if he took his time-outs without complaining. (Pet. Exh. 25.)

Over the winter break, STUDENT's parents decided that STUDENT was not benefitting from the SDC and was actually regressing in both his behavior and academic abilities. Because they did not want STUDENT to continue having an aversion to learning, they decided to place him in a private school, Children's World. STUDENT had been attending Children's World after school, so he adjusted easily to the all-day program. In mid-January, MOTHER informed the District that STUDENT would not be returning to the SDC. In late January, MOTHER and STUDENT visited the SDC to pick up some things he had left there, and Ms. DeLong suggested that MOTHER leave him there for the day for a "good-bye visit." MOTHER did so, but was called before lunch to pick STUDENT up because his behavior was out of control.

During January 1997, STUDENT was diagnosed as having attention deficit disorder (ADD). STUDENT began taking Ritalin, which improved his behavior and ability to focus.

On February 28, 1997, STUDENT's IEP team met to discuss his placement. At this meeting, the District offered an SDC placement with twenty minutes per week of APE and up to sixty minutes per week of speech and language services. The IEP did not specify which SDC the District was proposing for STUDENT. FATHER attended this meeting. He did not agree to the placement, but did indicate on the IEP that the parents requested speech and language services. (Pet. Exh. 5.) On March 19, 1997, Ms. Farkas wrote to the parents, telling them to contact the speech and language specialist at Acacia Elementary School, their neighborhood school, to arrange speech and language services for STUDENT. (Dist. Exh. 33.) Ms. Madge Bradford, the speech and language specialist at Acacia, testified that no one ever contacted her to arrange speech and language services for STUDENT. Ms. Bradford also testified that she provides speech and language therapy only during school hours. MOTHER testified that she asked the District to transport STUDENT from his private school to Acacia for speech and language services because neither she nor FATHER could transport STUDENT during the school day, but the District refused to do so.

Although STUDENT seemed much happier and more willing to go to school after enrolling in Children's World, his parents still had concerns about his lack of academic progress. In March 1997, they contacted Dr. Barbara Silton, an educational psychologist, and asked her to conduct a program evaluation of STUDENT. The purpose of the program evaluation was to determine which teaching methods and materials would help STUDENT learn. Dr. Silton met with STUDENT three times to evaluate him, reviewed his records, and observed him at Children's world. Dr. Silton concluded that STUDENT's best learning channel is his visual/tactile processing system. She recommended that STUDENT be placed in a class that allows him to work independently on highly structured, concrete manipulative tasks. She asserted that STUDENT should have little verbal language during instruction. Dr. Silton recommended that STUDENT's parents place him in a Montessori program. (Pet. Exh. 11.)

On April 4, 1997, STUDENT's parents had speech pathologist Ms. Farryl Dickter evaluate STUDENT's speech and language skills. Ms. Dickter found continuing deficits in articulation, expressive, and receptive language. In April 1997, STUDENT began seeing a speech pathologist in Ms. Dickter's practice twice a week and continued through October 1997, when his parents could no longer pay for private speech therapy.

On May 9, 1997, the IEP team met again to discuss STUDENT's placement for the 1997-98 school year. The District members of the team recommended that STUDENT be placed in an SDC with separate speech and language services for up to sixty minutes per week and APE for up to twenty minutes per week. The IEP also indicated that STUDENT was eligible for extended school year (ESY) services, but did not specify which ESY program the District was offering. STUDENT's parents did not agree with this placement and filed a request for due process hearing through attorney Valerie Vanaman on May 23, 1997.

At the end of June, STUDENT's parents enrolled STUDENT in the Montessori School of Agoura for the summer. The Montessori School has three rooms: two for children ages 2 ½ to five and one for children ages five to seven. STUDENT started in one of the rooms for the younger children during the summer because of the serious deficits in his pre-academic skills. In this room, STUDENT used many of the sensorial and practical life materials, which are designed to help children develop various sensory skills, proper pencil grasp, and left-to-right tracking.

During July 1997, occupational therapist Ms. Susan Murray assessed STUDENT and concluded that he needed occupational therapy (OT). At an IEP meeting held on September 15, 1997, Ms. Murray recommended that STUDENT receive two thirty-minute OT sessions per week in a classroom setting, with an additional twenty minutes per week for consultation with his classroom teacher. At that same IEP meeting, the District offered placement for STUDENT in either a kindergarten/first grade SDC, a first grade SDC, or RSP support in a regular classroom. During the hearing, the District clarified that the only placement currently being offered for STUDENT is the K/1 SDC taught by Ms. Candace Bartelson with related services of twenty minutes of APE per week, sixty minutes of speech and language services per week, and the OT services recommended by Ms. Murray.

In September, STUDENT moved up to the room for the older children. By that time, STUDENT's resistance to doing academic activities (those involving numbers, letters, and paper and pencil) had decreased. In November, Dr. Silton began providing educational therapy to STUDENT in her office. Dr. Silton also prepared special materials for STUDENT to use at the Montessori School. STUDENT continues to see Dr. Silton for a total of four hours per week of one-to-one instruction.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District provide an appropriate educational program for STUDENT with all necessary aids and services in the least restrictive environment for the 1996-97 school year?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et sq.; California Education Code §§ 56000 et seq. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1402(8), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability ..." 20 U.S.C. § 1402(25).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court stated that "the ‘basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." 458 U.S. 176, 200. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents' participation in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE to the student. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479.

Therefore, the IDEA and the Rowley Court's interpretation of the IDEA require analysis of the following questions to determine whether the placement the District offered for STUDENT from January through August 1997 provided a FAPE:

(a) Did the District commit procedural errors that resulted in the denial of a FAPE to STUDENT? (b) Was the placement designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs? (c) Was the placement designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT? (d) Did the placement conform to STUDENT's IEP? and (e) Did the placement educate STUDENT in the least restrictive environment?

(a) Did the District commit procedural errors that resulted in the denial of a FAPE to STUDENT?

The Petitioner argued that several defects in STUDENT's 1996-97 IEPs had the effect of denying STUDENT a FAPE. Specifically, the Petitioner asserted that the IEPs did not contain the following elements: present levels of performance; measurable goals; a statement of specific special education and related services to be provided; a direct relationship between the present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and educational services; a meaningful indication of how STUDENT would receive instruction with normally developing peers; and objective criteria or schedules for evaluating objectives.

California Education Code section 56345(a)(1) requires that an IEP include the student's present levels of educational performance. There is no dispute that the IEP documents prepared by the District do not set forth STUDENT's present levels of performance. Ms. DeLong testified that she relied upon the detailed present levels of performance contained in the May 1996 LAUSD IEP, as well as her month of experience with STUDENT, in developing STUDENT's goals and objectives. However, although the LAUSD IEP was a part of STUDENT's file, it was not referenced by the District's IEP. While the District is permitted to rely upon the documents from the prior district, the IEP must refer to those documents if they are being relied upon for required elements of the IEP. Thus, the District's IEP on its own did not provide any information about STUDENT's present levels of performance. Neither did it indicate that he had a speech and language delay. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's October 1996 IEP did not contain the required present levels of performance.

California Education Code section 56345(a)(2) requires that the IEP include annual goals and short-term instructional objectives. Petitioner argues that STUDENT's goals and objectives were too vague and general to be measurable. On the contrary, the objectives in STUDENT's IEP were very specific. The Petitioner also asserts that the goals and objectives were not individualized because they were taken from a database. The database Ms. DeLong used to prepare the goals and objectives included more than ninety possible goals and objectives. By selecting goals and modifying them with specific target dates, Ms. DeLong created a program that was individualized for STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP included goals and objectives that were specific and individualized for STUDENT.

California Education Code section 56345(a)(3) requires that the IEP specify the special education and related services the student needs. Petitioner asserts that the October 1996 IEP does not specify how much time STUDENT was to spend in the SDC or the amount of speech and language services STUDENT was to receive. The IEP did specify that STUDENT would be in the SDC 70-80% of the school day and would be integrated with regular education students 20-30% of the day. The IEP did not state the amount of speech and language services STUDENT would receive, but the testimony established that no separate speech and language services were to be provided because STUDENT's teacher was a speech and language specialist. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the October 1996 IEP meets the requirement that it specify the special education instruction and related services that were to be provided.

Section 3040(c) of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations requires that an IEP "show a direct relationship between the present levels of performance, the goals and objectives, and the specific educational services to be provided." The Petitioner asserts that the October 1996 IEP fails to meet this requirement due to the lack of present levels of performance and appropriate goals and objectives. There is no place on the IEP that specifically connects STUDENT's performance, goals and objectives, and services. In fact, the absence of any direct reference to STUDENT's present levels of performance makes it impossible to determine how all of the areas are related. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's IEP did not demonstrate a direct relationship between his present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and the services to be provided.

California Education Code section 56345(a)(4) requires that an IEP specify the extent to which the student will participate in regular educational programs, and section 3042(b) of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations requires that an IEP "indicate why the pupil's handicap prevents his or her needs from being met in a less restrictive environment even with the use of supplementary aids and services." The Petitioner argued that simply stating the percentage of time STUDENT will spend with regular education students does not describe the type of interaction he will have with normally developing peers. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's IEPs do specify the extent to which STUDENT will participate in regular education programs. However, the Hearing Officer also finds that none of STUDENT's IEPs meets the requirement that they include an explanation of why he cannot be educated in a less restrictive environment. Nowhere on the IEP forms is there a statement of why STUDENT must be placed in an SDC rather than a regular education classroom.

California Education Code section 56345(a)(6) requires that an IEP describe objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining whether instructional objectives are being met. The Petitioner argued that there were no objective criteria or evaluation procedures established for STUDENT's goals and objectives. STUDENT's IEP indicated that twenty-one out of twenty-three objectives were to be measured by teacher observation only. The other two -- naming of items by category and use of noun possessive form -- were to be measured by an unspecified test/assessment. The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP does not meet the requirement that it describe objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining whether instructional objectives are being met.

STUDENT's IEPs have many procedural defects. However, as stated above, these defects must have resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringed on the parents' participation in the IEP process to constitute a denial of FAPE. The Hearing Officer finds that the defects in STUDENT's IEPs reflect the inadequacy of the program offered for STUDENT. However, the defects in the IEPs did not, by themselves, deny FAPE. This is not a situation where the professionals serving STUDENT were unable to provide an appropriate program because the IEP was defective. Rather, the defects in the IEP exist because the program was not appropriate, as discussed below. STUDENT's parents had ample opportunity to participate in the IEP process, and in fact did so. Moreover, any loss of educational opportunity STUDENT had is attributable more to the inadequacy of the District's placement than to the IEP documents. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the procedural defects did not cause a denial of FAPE. However, the District should make note of the defects described above and ensure that they are not repeated in future IEPs for STUDENT.

(b) Was the placement designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs?

What are STUDENT's needs?

Before it can be determined whether the District's placement was designed to meet STUDENT's needs, it must be determined what his needs are. The Petitioner asserts that STUDENT has the following needs: one-to-one specialized instruction for five hours per week, tactile input with the opportunity to work independently on structured manipulative tasks, visual instruction, focus on basic concepts to fill in the gaps in his education, instruction with normally developing peers with age-appropriate language skills, one-to-one speech therapy for three hours per week, and OT services in a classroom setting for one hour per week. The District agreed that STUDENT needs tactile input and manipulative tasks, visual instruction, basic concepts, and OT services in class for one hour per week. The need for OT services was not identified until July 1997; therefore, the Hearing Officer will not examine whether the 1996-97 placement met that need.

The District acknowledged that STUDENT needs access to an educational therapist or instructional specialist who can break down the learning steps for him, but did not specifically agree that STUDENT needed five hours of one-to-one instruction per week. (District's Closing Argument, p. 5.) The only witnesses who testified about STUDENT's need for educational therapy were his parents and Dr. Silton. Dr. Silton concluded that STUDENT needs to have periods of focussed, one-to-one instruction to address his educational gaps, particularly his deficits in learning sound-symbol relationships. Dr. Silton recommended in her report that STUDENT receive one-to-one instruction from an educational therapist on a daily basis, but did not specify an amount of time the therapist should spend with STUDENT. However, Dr. Silton has currently been providing four hours of one-to-one educational therapy per week to STUDENT, and she testified that he needs that level of therapy. No witnesses or documents contradicted Dr. Silton's conclusion that STUDENT needed this one-to-one assistance. The Hearing Officer finds that due to the significant gaps in STUDENT's academic skills caused in part by his early deprivation, STUDENT's needs include four hours per week of one-to-one instruction with an educational therapist or a specialist who is able to break down the learning steps to a level where STUDENT can process them.

Many witnesses testified that STUDENT needs to be with normally developing peers who provide appropriate language and behavior models. (Testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Silton, Ms. Dickter, FATHER, and Dr. Steinberg.) The District did not present any evidence or argument that this is not one of STUDENT's needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's needs include instruction with normally developing peers.MOTHER and Ms. Dickter both testified that STUDENT needs intensive one-to-one speech therapy to remediate his speech and language deficits. Ms. Dickter testified that STUDENT needs three hours of one-to-one therapy per week. The District provided no testimony or evidence to contradict these assertions other than testimony about how speech and language services were provided in Ms. DeLong's class. There was no evidence establishing that STUDENT's needs could be met with group rather than individual therapy or that he needed only one hour of therapy per week, as asserted by the District. On the contrary, there was substantial evidence that STUDENT still has significant speech and language delays that must be addressed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's needs include one-to-one speech and language therapy for three hours per week.

Did the District's placement meet STUDENT's needs?

The District's placement from September 1996 through February 28, 1997, consisted of placement in Ms. DeLong's SDC with twenty minutes per week of APE. On February 28, the District offered a placement in an unspecified SDC with twenty minutes of APE and up to sixty minutes of speech and language services per week. Although the SDC offered at that time was not identified as Ms. DeLong's class, Mr. Bannon testified that there were no other SDCs in the District during the 1996-97 school year for students of STUDENT's age at a pre-K grade level (the other SDCs for STUDENT's age level in the District were for seriously emotionally disturbed or developmentally delayed/limited learner students). Therefore, with the exception of offering extra speech and language services, the placement offered in February was the same as that provided in September.

Ms. DeLong testified extensively about how her class operated and the materials she used. Ms. DeLong stated that she used a very visual, tactile approach to learning, providing many different manipulatives to teach her students basic concepts, such as shapes, numbers, and letters. For the most part, she used these materials in group instruction, with very little one-to-one instruction. Ms. DeLong could not recall the extent to which she had used many of the materials she described with STUDENT. Ms. DeLong also testified that she provided speech and language services to the children in the class in groups of three or four students for fifteen or twenty minutes per day. The children in Ms. DeLong's class spent recess with the regular education kindergarten class. Four days a week the children from Ms. DeLong's class and the regular education kindergarten class were integrated for fifty minutes. During that time, the combined classes were divided into four groups, with each group doing one of four center activities taught by either Ms. DeLong, the regular kindergarten teacher, or one of Ms. DeLong's two instructional aides. Ms. DeLong also testified that she used various tracing activities to help develop the students' writing skills. Ms. Susan Kunz, the school psychologist, testified that she observed Ms. DeLong's class on several occasions and that Ms. DeLong uses a visual, tactile teaching approach.

MOTHER observed and volunteered in Ms. DeLong's class at least two times during the fall of 1996. MOTHER testified that most of the instruction she observed in the class was verbal and that she did not see Ms. DeLong using manipulatives or a visual approach. MOTHER also testified that when Ms. DeLong worked on speech and language, she used black and white pictures to illustrate the concepts she was teaching. STUDENT's parents both testified that the homework assignments often consisted of paper and pencil tasks to which STUDENT became very averse.

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. DeLong used a visual, tactile approach in her class. However, the Hearing Officer also finds that the evidence did not establish that STUDENT was actively using the manipulative materials Ms. DeLong presented or that STUDENT had an opportunity to use those materials independently. STUDENT needs more than just watching the teacher or others use manipulative materials to demonstrate concepts; he needs to physically touch and manipulate the items himself and be an active participant in the process. Ms. DeLong testified that at the time STUDENT left, she was using the manipulative materials with small groups but the children had not started using the materials independently. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's placement did not meet STUDENT's need to use his tactile learning channel and to work independently on structured, concrete manipulative tasks.

The Hearing Officer also finds that the District's placement did not meet STUDENT's need for one-to-one instruction to help fill in the gaps in basic concepts. Ms. DeLong was not able to spend significant time on an one-to-one basis with the students in her class.

The Hearing Officer further finds that the District's placement does not meet STUDENT's need to be with normally developing peers. The District provided no legitimate reason why STUDENT was placed in an SDC when his IEP from LAUSD placed him in a regular education kindergarten with support services. Spending four fifty-minute sessions per week with normally developing peers did not meet STUDENT's need to have appropriate language and behavior models.

The Hearing Officer also finds that the District's placement did not meet STUDENT's speech and language needs. STUDENT came to the District with an IEP that called for sixty minutes per week of speech and language therapy, and the District removed that related service from his IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language instruction STUDENT received from Ms. DeLong did not meet his needs. As for the speech and language services offered in February 1997, Mr. Bannon testified that speech and language services would be provided in small groups unless the IEP specified that the services would be provided individually. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer made in February did not meet STUDENT's need for individual therapy. Moreover, the speech and language services were offered at his neighborhood school during the regular school day. MOTHER testified that she and FATHER were unable to transport STUDENT to these services during the day and that the District refused to transport him when she requested transportation.

(c) Was the placement designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT? (d) Did the placement conform to STUDENT's IEP?

(e) Did the placement educate STUDENT in the least restrictive environment?

Because the District's placement did not meet STUDENT's unique needs, it is not necessary to examine the remaining factors. By failing to meet all of STUDENT's unique needs, the District did not provide an appropriate placement for STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year. However, the Hearing Officer finds that by failing to meet STUDENT's need to be with normally developing peers, the District also failed to educate STUDENT in the least restrictive environment.

2. Are STUDENT and his family entitled to reimbursement for all of the costs they incurred to provide him with an appropriate educational program with all necessary aides and services in the least restrictive environment for the period between January 1997 and August 1997?

In School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 105 S.Ct. 2003, the United States Supreme Court determined that when the proposed public school placement is inappropriate, parents of a student eligible for special education may be entitled to reimbursement for expenses that they incur in educating their child if the placement they provided is proper under the IDEA. To be eligible for reimbursement, the program the parents provided need not be the perfect placement for the child, nor must it be a certified nonpublic school. See Carter v. Florence County School District Four (1993) 510 U.S. 7; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. Texas Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153. STUDENT's parents are seeking reimbursement for the following expenses incurred between January 1997 and August 1997: tuition for the academic portion of the Children's World program from January 1997 through June 1997, tuition for the academic portion of the summer program at the Montessori School of Agoura, speech and language assessment and therapy provided by Farryl Dickter and Associates, and the program evaluation performed by Dr. Silton.

Because the District did not provide an appropriate program for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year, his parents are entitled to reimbursement for the educational services they obtained for him on their own if the program provided was proper. The testimony established that, although the program at Children's World was not specifically tailored to meet STUDENT's need for tactile input, it did meet his need to be educated with normally developing peers. During his time at Children's World, STUDENT's aversion to school dissipated, and his behavior improved. (Testimony of MOTHER, FATHER, Dr. Silton.) Therefore, MOTHER and FATHER are entitled to reimbursement for tuition for the academic portion of the Children's World program. The receipts provided by MOTHER established the cost of the academic program to be $125.00 per week for the 24 ½ weeks STUDENT attended from January through July 1997.

STUDENT's May 1997 IEP clearly states that he is eligible for extended school year services. However, the District neither offered nor provided an extended school year program for STUDENT. To meet his need for extended year services, STUDENT's parents placed him at the Montessori School of Agoura. The Montessori School met STUDENT's need for tactile and visual input. The fact that STUDENT was placed in a room for younger children does make this placement improper. The parties agree that STUDENT had significant gaps in his academic abilities; working with the materials for the younger children helped to fill in those gaps. (Testimony of FATHER, MOTHER, Dr. Silton, Ms. Culhane.) Therefore, STUDENT's parents are also entitled to reimbursement for the academic portion of the 1997 summer program at the Montessori School. (Footnote 3)

The speech and language therapy provided by Farryl Dickter and Associates through August 1997 were also proper. They were provided by licensed speech and language specialists and met STUDENT's need for individual speech and language therapy. Therefore, STUDENT's parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the speech and language therapy provided by Farryl Dickter and Associates through August 1997.

The issue of reimbursement for the assessments performed by Ms. Dickter and Dr. Silton does not involve reimbursement for educational services. Reimbursement for private assessments is governed by California Education Code § 56329(b), which provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. In this case, the District did not perform any assessments on STUDENT similar to those performed by Ms. Dickter and Dr. Silton. Rather, the District relied upon the assessments performed by the LAUSD during the 1995-96 school year, pursuant to California Education Code section 56325(b). The parents have not expressed any objection to the prior assessments and did not specifically ask the District to perform additional assessments. However, pursuant to California Education Code section 56381, the District is required to reassess students "if conditions warrant." Therefore, if STUDENT's behavior or performance in class while enrolled in the District put the District on notice that additional assessments were necessary, it should have asked the parents for permission to perform additional assessments.

The Hearing Officer finds that there were no conditions that would have required the District to perform an additional speech and language assessment. There were no reports that STUDENT's speech and language impairment had changed in any way, and Ms. Dickter's report is consistent with the findings in prior reports. Therefore, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for Ms. Dickter's speech and language assessment.

The purpose of Dr. Silton's program evaluation was to determine the strengths and weaknesses of STUDENT's learning channels and to develop a program that would use his strongest learning channels. (Footnote 4) The Hearing Officer finds that the District did have notice that STUDENT needed additional assessment in this area. STUDENT displayed resistance to particular tasks at school, which developed into behavior problems, as documented by Ms. DeLong's notes to his parents. Ms. DeLong informed the parents that she did not entirely understand the nature of STUDENT's learning disabilities due to his demonstrated strengths in particular areas, such as building structures. The parents' action of removing STUDENT from the District's class should have notified the District that they were not agreeing with the program it was providing, and, based upon his known behavior, the District should have asked for permission to perform additional assessments to determine how to meet his educational needs. The parents, instead, obtained their own evaluation, which was essential to determining STUDENT's educational needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents are entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Silton's program evaluation.

3. Does the program the District has offered for the 1997-98 school year comply with the legal requirements of federal and state law as to the manner in which services are to be identified on an IEP and could such a program provide STUDENT with an appropriate educational program in the least restrictive environment?

The District made an offer of placement for the 1997-98 school year at the meetings of May 9, 1997, and September 15, 1997. The placement consisted of an SDC with up to twenty percent of the day integrated with regular education students, speech and language services up to two times per week for up to sixty minutes per week, APE one time per week for up to thirty minutes per week, and two thirty-minute OT sessions per week. At the meeting on September 15, 1997, the District recommended a K-1 SDC. At the hearing, it was made clear that the only classroom being offered for STUDENT was Ms. Candace Bartelson's SDC at Aspen Elementary School. The District also agreed at the hearing to remove the phrase "up to" from the speech and language services. No new goals or objectives were prepared for the 1997-98 school year.

This placement is essentially the same placement offered during the 1996-97 school year, with the addition of OT services and a different teacher. Ms. Bartelson is an enthusiastic first-year teacher. She testified about the visual and tactile teaching methods she uses, which the Hearing Officer finds could meet STUDENT's needs for visual and tactile input if he has an opportunity to work independently with the structured manipulative tasks described. However, Ms. Bartelson also testified that ten of the eleven children in her class have speech and language delays. Therefore, the placement offered by the District for the 1997-98 school year does not meet STUDENT's need to be educated with normally developing peers who can provide appropriate language models. Nor does this placement provide education in the least restrictive environment because, once again, the District failed to indicate any reason why STUDENT needs to be in a self-contained classroom for eighty percent of the day. The District's proposed placement also does not meet STUDENT's need for one-to-one instruction for four hours per week. The speech and language services offered also do not meet STUDENT's needs, for the same reasons that the services offered in 1996-97 did not meet his needs.

Therefore, because the placement offered for the 1997-98 school year does not meet STUDENT's needs, the Hearing Officer finds that it does not provide a FAPE.

4. Is the District required to reimburse STUDENT's family for the expenses they have incurred, and will incur, to provide STUDENT with an appropriate program with the necessary related services for the 1997-98 school year?

STUDENT's parents are seeking reimbursement for the following services they obtained for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year: tuition at the Montessori School of Agoura, speech and language therapy from Farryl Dickter and Associates, educational therapy provided by Dr. Silton, and the neuropsychological assessment by Dr. Lance Steinberg. As discussed above, because the District has not offered an appropriate placement for the 1997-98 school year, the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the services they obtained if those services were proper. For the same reasons discussed above, the parents are entitled to receive reimbursement for tuition at the Montessori School and speech and language therapy provided through the date of this decision. The educational therapy provided by Dr. Silton met STUDENT's need for one-to-one instruction and thus was proper for STUDENT. Therefore, STUDENT's parents are also entitled to reimbursement for the educational therapy services provided by Dr. Silton through the date of this decision.

The services provided by Dr. Lance Steinberg were medical. Dr. Steinberg saw STUDENT for a medical consultation, and he billed STUDENT's parents for an "initial exam." The IDEA definition of related services includes "medical services, except that such medical services shall be for diagnostic and evaluation purposes only." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). Special education students have a right to receive related services when those services are necessary to help the student benefit from special education. Id. The purpose of STUDENT's visit to Dr. Steinberg was to confirm the diagnosis of ADD, which another doctor had made in January 1997. Dr. Steinberg met with STUDENT and performed a mental status exam through observation and questioning. He did not prepare a report or conduct any psychoeducational testing. There was no evidence that this meeting with Dr. Steinberg was necessary for STUDENT to benefit from special education, nor that this meeting constituted an educational assessment that the District should have performed. Moreover, because Dr. Steinberg was consulted to confirm a previous diagnosis of ADD, the services he provided were duplicative. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Steinberg's exam was not an educational service for which STUDENT's parents must be reimbursed.

As for expenses the parents "will incur," such expenses are purely speculative. The parents have not asked for an order requiring prospective placement at the Montessori School, and, because the Montessori School is not a certified nonpublic school, the Hearing Officer cannot make such an order. However, the District is required to provide a FAPE that meets STUDENT's needs as described in this decision. If the District determines that it has no program available to meet STUDENT's unique needs, it could obtain a waiver to place him at the Montessori School or a nonpublic school that can serve his needs.

ORDER

1. Within fifteen days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting for STUDENT at which the team shall prepare a new IEP for STUDENT including, but not limited to, the following elements:

a. STUDENT's present levels of performance.

b. New goals and objectives that are clearly related to STUDENT's needs and his present levels of performance. c. A placement which will allow STUDENT to be educated with normally developing peers, provide tactile and visual instruction, and allow STUDENT to work independently with concrete, structured manipulative tasks. d. Provide three hours of individual speech and language therapy per week. e. Provide four hours of one-to-one instruction per week from an educational therapist. f. Adapted physical education and occupational therapy services as recommended on the IEPs of May 9, 1997, and September 15, 1997.

2. The District shall reimburse STUDENT's parents $3,062.50 for the academic portion of the Children's World program, pursuant to the receipt provided with the closing argument.

3. The District shall reimburse STUDENT's parents for the costs incurred through the date of this decision of the academic portion of the summer program and the academic portion of the school year program at the Montessori School of Agoura, upon receipt of documentation of the cost of the academic portions of those programs.

4. The District shall reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of the speech and language therapy provided by Farryl Dickter and Associates, upon receipt of documentation specifying what amount of the fee charged by that firm was for therapy rather than assessment.

5. The District shall reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of the assessment and therapy services provided by Dr. Barbara Silton through the date of this decision.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Issue 1: The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue 2: The Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.

Issue 3: The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue 4: The Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

Date: March 24, 1998 Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The hearing was not reconvened until January due to the busy schedules of the attorneys and the winter holidays.

2. MOTHER and FATHER are not married. Due to the complexity and expense of the adoption process, they decided that MOTHER would adopt STUDENT on her own. Although FATHER is not STUDENT's adoptive father, STUDENT refers to him as his father. This decision shall refer to MOTHER and FATHER collectively as STUDENT's parents.

3. The testimony at the hearing established that the summer program consists of academic activities in the morning and "camp" activities in the afternoon. The receipt provided with the Petitioner's closing argument does not specify what portion of the fee paid was for the academic portion of the summer program.

4. Dr. Silton used the term "learning channels" frequently in her report and her testimony to refer to the various ways people learn (e.g., through tactile, visual, or oral stimulation). Dr. Silton concluded that STUDENT's strongest learning channel is through tactile experience, including the use of manipulatives.