California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 22, 2002
Student v. Temecula Valley Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 657-01 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu
Temecula Valley Unified need not provide a laptop for general education classes or reimburse the family for buying one.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The case was taken off calendar on April 16, 2001 to pursue mediation or settlement, and put back on calendar on April 25, 2002. It was taken off calendar again on June 14, 2002 and returned on August 19, 2002. A partial settlement of most issues was finalized on September 30, 2002, the last day of hearing.
Summary
An eighth grader filed for due process against Temecula Valley Unified School District. He was eligible for special education with a specific learning disability in reading and written expression. He was also eligible under other health impairment due to attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. He first filed in 2001, claiming the district had not followed its own assistive technology assessment. Four assistive technology assessments followed, and the parties reached a partial settlement. By hearing time, both sides agreed he needed a computer with Dragon Naturally Speaking voice recognition software and Kurzweil 3000 scan-and-read software. A computer workstation would be set up in his resource class. Two questions remained. Did he need a laptop with that software in his general education science and history classes? And should his mother be repaid for a laptop she had already bought?
The Hearing Officer ruled for the district on both questions. District assistive technology specialist Dr. Susan Simmons had talked with his teachers and visited his classrooms. Her testimony carried more weight than that of the family's expert, Shelley Lacey-Castelot, who had done neither. Science teacher Brian Chang and history teacher Jack Bauer said most reading was assigned as homework and in-class writing was short. They said Student was earning a B in science and was among the top students in history. Because he did not need a laptop in general education, the reimbursement request was also denied. No relief was ordered.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO decided whether a student needed assistive technology in a particular setting. The Hearing Officer looked at what that student's actual classes required and how he was performing. An expert who had spoken with the teachers and visited the classrooms was given more weight than an expert who relied on general expectations for students of that age.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I. Should Student be permitted to use a laptop with voice recognition, "Scan and Read," and other related software in his general education classroom?
The parties agreed Student needed a computer with Dragon Naturally Speaking and Kurzweil 3000 software. But the district's assistive technology expert and the testimony of his science and history teachers showed those classes required little in-class reading or writing and that Student was doing well, so he did not need a laptop in general education to benefit from his education.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue II. Is Mother entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the laptop already privately procured for Student?
Because Student did not need a laptop in his general education classes, the request to reimburse the cost of the privately bought laptop was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Petitioner's requests for relief were denied.
Key authorities
20 U.S.C. § 1401; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d); 34 C.F.R. § 300.5; 34 C.F.R. § 300.6; 34 C.F.R. § 300.308(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363
People named in the decision
- Deborah Miller, Director of special education, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Christa Smith, Program specialist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Fred Fox, Program specialist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Shelley Lacey-Castelot, Private educational consultant and assistive technology specialist; expert witness for Student, Private
- Dr. Susan Simmons, Assistive technology specialist; assessor and witness for District, Retained by District
- Angela Domiccio, Resource specialist (RSP teacher), Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Brian Chang, Science teacher, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Jack Bauer, History teacher, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Mike Verkouteren, Assistive technology specialist; conducted November 2000 assessment, District assessment
- Anne Herrick, Assistive technology assessor; conducted November 2001 assessment, District assessment
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific in Temecula, California, on September 17 and 30, 2002.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at hearing by attorney Joyce Sweet. Also present on his behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Temecula Valley Unfied School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Andrew Arczynski. Also present on the District’s behalf was Deborah Miller, director of special education, and Christa Smith and Fred Fox, program specialists.
Petitioner called as witnesses his mother and Shelley Lacey-Castelot, educational consultant and assistive technology specialist. The District called the following witnesses to testify at hearing: Dr. Susan Simmons, assistive technology specialist; Angela Domiccio, resource specialist; Brian Chang, science teacher; and Jack Bauer, history teacher.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties made their oral closing arguments on the record on the last day of hearing. Following the oral closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE(Footnote 1)
I. Should STUDENT be permitted to use a laptop with voice recognition software in his general education classroom?
II. Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the laptop already privately procured for STUDENT?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old eighth grade student who is eligible for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability in the areas of reading and written expression, and an other health impairment due to his attention deficit hyperactive disorder. According to STUDENT’s most recent psychoeducational assessment, he has average to high average non-verbal capabilities and average to superior verbal cognitive ability. (Dist. Exh. 6.) STUDENT’s cognitive weaknesses are in the areas of short-term visual memory and psychomotor speed. STUDENT has difficulty attending to and recalling abstract visual information, but with repeated exposure, has an above average ability to learn and remember what he saw. Additionally, while STUDENT can accurately perceive abstract visual information, it is difficult for him to quickly reproduce what he saw on paper. STUDENT’s psychological testing also indicates that he performs best through the auditory/verbal channel of learning and therefore, any opportunity STUDENT has to express his knowledge orally rather than in writing would be beneficial. Achievement tests show that STUDENT’s cognitive deficits are in reading fluency, accuracy and comprehension. Id. Moreover, in the area of written language, STUDENT has difficulty with spelling, and punctuation, as well as identifying and correcting illogical aspects of printed sentences, combining aspects of several sentences to form one meaningful sentence, and using a variety of different words in his compositions. STUDENT is currently receiving resource program specialist (RSP) services to address his learning problems.
On October 13, 2000, shortly after STUDENT moved into the District from Florida, STUDENT’s IEP team referred him for an assistive technology assessment. That assessment was completed by assistive technology specialist Mike Verkouteren on November 2000. (Pet. Exh. 1.) In the assessment report, Mr. Verkouteren recommended that the District provide STUDENT with access to a computer utilizing “Dragon Naturally Speaking” voice recognition software to assist him with his written assignments.(Footnote 2) Specifically, the recommended assistive technology would assist STUDENT with “various stages of the writing process (i.e., brainstorming, outlining, drafting, revising, editing, publishing).”
Later that school year, on April 2, 2001, the Hearing Office received a request for a special education due process hearing from attorney Joyce Sweet on behalf of Petitioner STUDENT. At that time, Ms. Sweet alleged that the District had failed to implement the recommendations made by its own assistive technology evaluator. Therefore, Petitioner contended that the District has failed to offer and provide Petitioner with a free appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year, and he requested compensatory education as a result of the District’s alleged failure.
In order to pursue the resolution of this matter through mediation or settlement, the parties agreed to take the matter off-calendar on April 16, 2001. During the following months, the District conducted additional assessments of STUDENT. In September 2001, the District administered its psychoeducational reevaluation of STUDENT. (See Dist. Exh. 6 referenced above.) Then, in November 2001, the District conducted another assistive technology assessment of STUDENT. Anne Herrick, who conducted the assessment, recommended the use of a talking word processing software (i.e., “Write Out Loud”) and talking word prediction software (i.e., “Co-Writer”) to assist STUDENT in the areas of reading and written language. (Pet. Exh. 2.) According to Ms. Herrick’s report, the talking word processor would allow STUDENT to “check if his text sounds correct and would provide him with a strategy for hearing where changes are needed.” Additionally, the talking word prediction software “enables the user, who struggles with spelling, grammar and the physical task of writing, to construct quality sentences.”
In March 2002, STUDENT’s parents obtained a third assistive technology assessment of STUDENT from Shelley Lacey-Castelot, a private assistive technology specialist. Ms. Lacey-Castelot reviewed STUDENT’s prior psychological and assistive technology assessments and conducted her own assessment of STUDENT’s needs. In her report, she noted STUDENT’s difficulties with reading and writing, and she concluded that the software programs recommended by Ms. Herrick were not appropriate for students with learning disabilities like STUDENT because they require the students to focus on the lower perceptual level of writing rather than on the higher cognitive task of composing. Instead, Ms. Lacey-Castelot concurred with Mr. Verkouteren’s earlier conclusions and recommended assistive technology in the form of a computer and voice recognition software (i.e., Dragon Naturally Speaking software) to aide STUDENT with his written expression. She also recommended the Kurzweil 3000 Scan and Read software to assist him with his reading.(Footnote 3) She wrote that STUDENT experienced the greatest success in written language with the Dragon Naturally Speaking and related software because STUDENT requires exposure to both auditory and visual stimulus simultaneously in order to enhance his “focus, comprehension, and achievement.” Additionally, she stated that the Kurzweil 3000 would enable STUDENT to read in a much more fluent manner because it provides the reader with both visual and auditory support. With regard to her recommendations for a computer, she indicated that the computer should preferably be a laptop computer that he could access throughout his school day. Ms. Lacey-Castelot reasoned that the provision of a laptop would enable STUDENT to use his assistive technology whenever the need for reading and writing arose, rather than requiring him to leave the classroom and his instructors to access a computer at a separate workstation.
After over a year of apparent inactivity in the due process case, the Hearing Office sent the parties notice that the case would be dismissed unless the parties informed the Hearing Office of the status of the case. On April 25, 2002, the Petitioner requested that the case be placed back on calendar. In the meantime, the District obtained a fourth assistive technology assessment of STUDENT, this time from assistive technology specialist Dr. Susan Simmons. For her assessment, Dr. Simmons reviewed the three prior assessments and interviewed STUDENT’s mother regarding her concerns about STUDENT’s education. Dr. Simmons noted that STUDENT’s writing was too slow a process to be functional for accessing his curriculum, and that the same motor processing issues that impact his handwriting also impact his keyboarding. Accordingly, she recommended the use of a voice recognition software to assist STUDENT with his writing. Additionally, she wrote that STUDENT’s lack of fluency in his reading causes his reading to be labored and slow, which results in a loss of comprehension. She also noted that, while STUDENT could effectively read short passages, he requires assistive technology support for reading textbooks and other more extensive literature. Specifically, Ms. Simmons concurred with Mr. Verkoutern and Ms. Lacey-Castelot and recommended the provision of a computer with Dragon Naturally Speaking software and related software to assist STUDENT with writing and the Kurzweil 3000 software to assist him with reading. However, unlike Ms. Lacey-Castelot, Dr. Simmons recommended creating a “workstation” for STUDENT at school rather than providing him with a laptop computer.
Following a number of continuances of the hearing dates during the months of April and May 2002, the parties again requested on June 14, 2002, that the matter be removed from the hearing calendar in order to pursue a settlement of the issues in the case. The case was then placed back on calendar at the request of Petitioner on August 19, 2002 and rescheduled to convene on September 17, 2002. In anticipation of the hearing, Petitioner requested a prehearing conference to discuss, among other things, the clarification of issues. During that prehearing telephone conference on September 2, 2002, the parties indicated that they had reached a partial settlement agreement of a substantial portion of the case and that the sole issues remaining pertained to STUDENT’s need for assistive technology services. The parties stated that they did not dispute the type of software that STUDENT requires, but whether he requires a laptop computer in his general education classroom for use with the agreed upon software. Thus, the only two remaining issues were whether Petitioner requires the use of a laptop computer with voice recognition, “Scan and Read,” and other related software in his general education classrooms and whether his parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of a laptop computer already privately procured for Petitioner.(Footnote 4)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I. Should STUDENT be permitted to use a laptop with voice recognition, “Scan and Read,” and other related software in his general education classroom?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18). An IEP is a written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each student with a disability and must include, among other things, a statement of the goals and objectives and special education and related services to be provided to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and to be educated and participate with nondisabled peers to the maximum extent possible. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343 and 56345. “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
Among the related services provided by districts to disabled students are assistive technology services and devices. 20 U.S.C. §§ 1401(1), 1414(d)(3)(B)(v); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363. An assistive technology device is any item, piece of equipment, or product system that is used to increase, maintain, or improve the functional capabilities of a child with a disability. 34 C.F.R. § 300.5. An assistive technology service is any service that directly assists a child with a disability in the selection, acquisition, or use of an assistive technology device. 34 C.F.R. § 300.6. As a related service, assistive technology devices and services must be provided when they are necessary to assist the disabled child to benefit from his educational program. Additionally, according to Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, Section 300.308(b), the use of school-purchased assistive technology devices in a child’s home or in other non-school settings is required if the child’s IEP team determines that the child needs access to those devices in order to receive a FAPE. 34 C.F.R. § 300.308(b).
In this case, there is no dispute that STUDENT requires assistive technology in the form of a computer and software that includes the Dragon Naturally Speaking voice recognition and the Kurzweil 3000 Scan and Read software. By all accounts, STUDENT requires this assistive technology due to his specific learning disability in the areas of written expression and reading. Specifically, STUDENT’s short-term visual memory and psychomotor speed deficits impact his ability to express himself through written language and to read with appropriate fluency, accuracy, and comprehension. The only dispute between the parties is whether STUDENT should be allowed to use a laptop computer with the agreed upon voice recognition and related software in his general education classes, particularly his science and history class.(Footnote 5) Petitioner argues that he requires the laptop computer with voice recognition and related software in order to complete any reading or writing assignments required in those classes except for exams, which can be completed at his workstation in the RSP classroom. The District asserts that Petitioner does not require a laptop computer because the classes do not entail extensive reading or writing assignments that would require Petitioner to access the laptop computer with voice recognition and reading software.(Footnote 6) The evidence supports the District’s contentions.
Assistive technology specialist Dr. Susan Simmons testified STUDENT does not require a laptop computer and the agreed upon software in his general education classes in order to benefit from his education. Dr. Simmons testified that she based her opinion on her assessment of STUDENT (which included a review of the three prior assistive technology assessments and an interview with STUDENT’s mother) as well as on information obtained from discussions with STUDENT’s teachers and visits to STUDENT’s general education classrooms. From her discussions with STUDENT’s teachers, Dr. Simmons testified that the students in STUDENT’s class are not expected to read or write extensively in class. Dr. Simmons also testified that STUDENT is able to read short passages adequately by himself without the need for assistive technology. Although Dr. Simmons acknowledged that STUDENT has problems with reading and that it takes him longer to write than his peers, she concluded that the reading and writing requirements of the general education classes are “minor” and would not require that STUDENT have constant access to a laptop computer.
Dr. Simmons’ understanding of the classroom requirements in the general education environment is corroborated by the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers. Mr. Brian Chang, STUDENT’s science teacher, testified that his classroom is small and quiet and contains twenty-seven students. He also confirmed that there is no extensive reading or writing in his class. According to Mr. Chang, reading is usually assigned as homework, and the reading in class is generally limited to a one-page lab assignment that he also reviews with the class.(Footnote 7) The writing required in Mr. Chang’s class is limited to filling out a lab write-up that contains questions regarding the lab assignment. Mr. Chang described the length of the lab write-up as being a maximum of one page, front and back. Mr. Chang testified that he allows his students two days to complete the one-page lab write-ups and that his students often do not complete the assignments during class time and are required to complete them at home. Finally, Mr. Chang testified that STUDENT is able to appropriately participate in his class and complete the lab write-ups without the requested assistive technology in his class, and that he is currently earning a grade of “B.”
Mr. Jack Bauer, STUDENT’s history teacher, testified that he has a class of thirty-six students. Like Mr. Chang, Mr. Bauer also testified that he does not require the students to read or write extensively in his class. Mr. Bauer testified that he assigns the students reading to be completed at home. Then, during class, he reviews the reading assignments with the students by reading the passages back to them or asking students in the class to volunteer to read aloud. With regard to writing assignments, Mr. Bauer requires the students to summarize the reading assignments in paragraphs of three to five sentences. He testified that he gives the students the entire class period to complete the assignment and that STUDENT may be given additional time to complete the assignment if necessary. Mr. Bauer also testified that STUDENT was currently one of the top students in his class.
In support of Petitioner’s position, he presented the testimony of Shelley Lacey-Castelot, an educational consultant and assistive technology specialist. Ms. Lacey-Castelot testified that STUDENT should be allowed a laptop with the use of his voice recognition software in his general education classrooms because students STUDENT’s age and grade level are typically required to complete a significant amount of reading and writing in class. According to Ms. Lacey-Castelot, requiring STUDENT to leave class to read or write would disrupt STUDENT’s focus, interrupt his prewriting thought process, deprive him of any additional instruction given by the teacher in the classroom, and reduce the amount of time he has to spend on the assignments during the class time. Therefore, she concluded that STUDENT requires access to a laptop computer and software during his general education classrooms in order to benefit from his education.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the testimony of Dr. Simmons is more persuasive than that of Ms. Lacey-Castelot. Unlike Dr. Simmons, Ms. Lacey-Castelot has never spoken with any of STUDENT’s teachers or visited his classrooms. Therefore, her testimony was not based on knowledge of his actual classroom environment or class requirements, but rather on generalized statements regarding what she views is typically required of students STUDENT’s age and grade level. Because the determination regarding STUDENT’s need for the requested specific assistive technology depends on his ability to access his education, the Hearing Officer gives the testimony of Dr Simmons more weight. The testimony of Mr. Chang and Mr. Bauer regarding STUDENT’s progress in their class further supports Dr. Simmons’ conclusion that STUDENT is able to access his general education curriculum without the use of a laptop computer and related software. Hence, the preponderance of the evidence establishes that STUDENT does not require the use of a laptop computer with the agreed upon software in his general education classrooms to benefit from his education.
II. Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the laptop already privately procured for STUDENT?
Petitioner argues that he should have been provided a laptop for use in his general education classrooms and the failure of the District to provide the laptop required him to obtain one privately, for which he is entitled to reimbursement. As it was found above that Petitioner does not require a laptop computer in his regular education environment, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for his laptop computer within the scope of the issues framed in this hearing. Thus, Petitioner’s request for reimbursement is denied.
ORDER
Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the issues decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: October 22, 2002 ____________________________________ Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. As discussed below, the issues in this case were clarified with the parties during a pre-hearing telephone conference that was held on September 2, 2002. 2. According to the testimony of assistive technology specialist Shelly Lacey-Castelot, Dragon Naturally Speaking software is a program that enables the user to speak into a microphone attached to a computer and the spoken words are transcribed as text in a written document. 3. According to the report, the Kurzweil 3000 software allows written documents to be scanned into the computer, and the user can listen to the document being read aloud by the software as he reads the document on the computer screen. 4. The parties did not actually finalize the partial settlement agreement until September 30, 2002, during the last day of hearing in this matter. 5. According to his RSP teacher Ms. Domiccio, STUDENT’s language arts instruction is done in her RSP class where he is to have his computer workstation with the voice recognition and other agreed upon software. 6. The District also argued against the use of voice recognition software in STUDENT’s general education classrooms because it would be too disruptive to the other students. Given the requirement in the law to educate disabled students in the least restrictive environment, the integration of these students into the general education environment would necessarily require the tolerance of some level of distraction caused as a result. The Hearing Officer makes no determination as to what level of distraction is acceptable in general and, because it was determined below that Petitioner does not require the laptop computer in his general education classrooms, it is also unnecessary to make such a finding in this case. 7. Petitioner did not raise any issues pertaining to his need for assistive technology for use at home to complete his homework or for use in any other environment but the general education environment.
