California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 7, 2003
Student v. Capistrano Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 657-03 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino
Capistrano Unified must fund OT, compensatory speech therapy and an auditory processing assessment for a student with autism; mainstreaming claim denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. Footnote 20 says the District's proposed triennial assessment plans were the subject of a separate due process hearing request.
Summary
Parents of a student with autism challenged Capistrano Unified School District's program from April 2000 through May 2003. He attended a special day class at Ole Hanson Elementary with a full-time one-to-one aide, speech-language therapy, and intensive behavior intervention. The Hearing Officer rejected a claim that the District had to hold a "pre-IEP" meeting under Government Code section 7572. The District's triennial psychoeducational evaluation was not a mental health assessment. The District should have assessed for occupational therapy (OT) needs, given low motor scores and sensory-seeking behavior. It also should have given a formal auditory processing assessment, since the student's own behavior plans cited a "severe deficit in auditory processing." A private finding of verbal apraxia did not outweigh years of contrary evaluations. Offering no OT services denied FAPE. Speech-language services were adequate until February 2002. Then the District cut them from 135 to 105 minutes weekly despite little progress, which denied FAPE through May 2003. A special day class with partial mainstreaming met least restrictive environment requirements. The District must add two 50-minute individual OT sessions weekly plus consultation for at least one year. The IEP team must design compensatory speech-language services, and the District must obtain an audiologist's auditory processing assessment. It must also reimburse $800 for the private OT assessment plus the cost of a July 2002 speech assessment.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a district's failure to assess areas flagged in its own records, such as OT warning signs and behavior plans citing auditory processing. It also shows a Hearing Officer leaving the amount of compensatory services to the IEP team, and weighing a single private diagnosis against years of contrary evaluations.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1. Did the District deny a FAPE from April 3, 2000, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year by failing to hold a "pre-IEP" meeting under Cal. Gov. Code section 7572(a), (c), and (d)(1)?
Section 7572 covers mental health assessments. The school psychologist's triennial psychoeducational evaluation was not one, so no pre-IEP meeting was required.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 2A (OT). Did the District deny a FAPE from April 3, 2000, through 2002-2003 by failing to conduct assessment in the area of occupational therapy?
The District's own records showed red flags: low gross-motor and visual-motor scores, impulsivity, and sensory-seeking behavior. OT was a suspected area of disability from April 2000 through May 2003, and the District failed to offer an assessment.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2A (verbal apraxia). Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to conduct assessment in the area of verbal apraxia?
Only one January 2003 private report found verbal apraxia, and the same clinic's more thorough July 2002 report contradicted it. The student does not have verbal apraxia, and no assessment was required.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 2A (auditory processing). Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to conduct assessment in the area of auditory processing?
Auditory processing was a suspected area of disability; the student's own behavior plans cited it. Incidental speech test data and behavior-plan monitoring were not a formal assessment, and the District had to offer one.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2B (OT). Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to offer services and goals and objectives addressing OT-related needs?
The student needed services for sensory-integration deficits. The District offered none, which denied FAPE from April 3, 2000, through May 2003.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2B (verbal apraxia). Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to offer services and goals and objectives addressing verbal apraxia?
The student has no needs arising from verbal apraxia, so there was no denial of FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2B (auditory processing). Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to offer services and goals and objectives addressing auditory processing?
Without a formal assessment, it could not be determined whether the Earobics program and the behavior plan met the student's needs. The Hearing Officer ordered an audiologist's assessment, with any compensatory services left to the IEP team.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2B (speech and language). Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to offer an appropriate level of services to address the student's speech and language deficits?
Services were appropriate from April 2000 to February 2002, including the February 2001 shift to some group sessions. Cutting services from 135 to 105 minutes per week in February 2002, despite little progress, denied FAPE through May 2003.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2C. Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to place the student in mainstream classes with a full-time one-to-one aide?
The student's behavior, attention, and language deficits meant more regular-class time would have been counterproductive. The District's special day class with partial mainstreaming met LRE requirements.
- Student prevailed in partIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3 (reimbursement). Is the District required to reimburse the parents for the cost of private assessments?
The parents were reimbursed $800 for the OT assessment and for the July 2002 speech-language assessment. Reimbursement was denied for the January 2003 apraxia assessment, the neuropsychological evaluation, and witness testimony and preparation.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 3 (compensatory education and other remedies). Is the District required to provide compensatory education and other remedies?
The Hearing Officer ordered prospective OT services, compensatory speech-language services set by the IEP team, and an auditory processing assessment with possible compensatory services. All other requested relief was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the decision, and later as needed, the IEP team must meet to carry out the orders.
- Order to provide or change services. Amend the IEP to provide two 50-minute individual OT sessions per week, plus OT consultation to school personnel, addressing sensory processing/integration, motor planning, work behaviors, and peer interaction. The team must develop OT goals and objectives. The split between clinic-based and school-site OT is left to the IEP team. Services continue for at least one year; the IEP team then sets future OT services.
- Compensatory education. The IEP team must design a compensatory speech-language program, with the amount at its discretion. The program must be consistent with three findings: speech-language is a crucial need; 135 minutes per week, mostly individual, was the minimum required from February 2002 through May 2003, while only 105 minutes were offered; and different strategies must be considered.
- Order to assess. The IEP team must develop a plan for a comprehensive auditory processing assessment by a qualified audiologist. The assessor is to comment on effects on speech-language, social skills, academics, and behavior, and recommend services. If a disorder is confirmed, the team must write present levels, goals, and services, and decide whether to give compensatory services for April 3, 2000, through May 2003.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 days, the District must reimburse the parents $800 for Laurie Cohen's February and March 2003 OT assessment.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receiving a correct invoice, the District must reimburse the reasonable cost of Speech Pathology Associates' July 2002 speech-language assessment. Charges for testimony or hearing preparation are excluded. No amount was stated.
Total: $800 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.
People named in the decision
- Diane Lappi, District executive director for special education; speech-language pathologist witness, Capistrano Unified School District
- Kimberly Gaither, District legal assistant, Capistrano Unified School District
- Christine Majors, Ph.D., Private neuropsychologist; expert witness for Student, Private
- Laurie Cohen, Private occupational therapist; independent OT assessor and expert witness for Student, Private
- Barbara Moore, Speech-language pathologist, clinic director; expert witness for Student, Speech Pathology Associates
- Ms. Toyama, Private speech-language pathologist (July 2002 assessment), Speech Pathology Associates
- Mr. Howell, Private speech-language evaluator (January 2003 assessment), Speech Pathology Associates
- Speech Pathology Associates (SPA), Private speech-language clinic, Private provider
- Lisa Bland, District speech-language pathologist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Roberta Brady, District speech-language pathologist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Matt Colapinto, General education fifth-grade teacher, Capistrano Unified School District
- Randi Vazzano, 1:1 aide (independence facilitator), Capistrano Unified School District
- Sue Puccinelli, General education fifth-grade teacher, Capistrano Unified School District
- Kelly McKinnon, Consultant in autism and behavior analysis, Consultant to District
- Charla Pitzen, District autism specialist and IBI program director, Capistrano Unified School District
- Cynthia Johnson, Special day class teacher (also a speech-language pathologist), Capistrano Unified School District
- David Stoffel, School psychologist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), Nonpublic agency providing discrete trial/ABA services, Private provider
- Newport Language and Speech Center, Private speech-language evaluator (September 2001), Private provider
- California Department of Education Diagnostic Center, State diagnostic assessment (1997), California Department of Education
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on May 15, 16, 21, and 22, 2003, in San Juan Capistrano, California.
Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Scott Ayers from the law office of Roberts & Adams. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his mother, MOTHER, and his father, FATHER. Respondent Capistrano Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by education advocate Robert Roice. Also present on the District’s behalf was Diane Lappi, District executive director for special education, and Kimberly Gaither, District legal assistant.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses: MOTHER; Christine Majors, Ph.D., licensed psychologist/neuropsychologist; Laurie Cohen, occupational therapist; and Barbara Moore, speech and language pathologist. The District called the following witnesses: Diane Lappi; Lisa Bland, District speech and language pathologist; Roberta Brady, District speech and language pathologist; Matt Colapinto, District fifth-grade teacher; Randi Vazzano, District one-to-one independence facilitator; Sue Puccinelli, District fifth-grade teacher; Kelly McKinnon, consultant in autism and behavior analysis; Charla Pitzen, District autism specialist and intensive behavioral instruction (IBI) program director; and Cynthia Johnson, District special day class (SDC) teacher.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until the Hearing Officer’s receipt of closing briefs on June 16, 2003, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
Issue 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from April 3, 2000, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year by failing to hold a “pre-IEP” (individualized education plan) meeting pursuant to Cal. Gov. Code section 7572 (a),(c), and (d)(1)?
Issue 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE from April 3, 2000, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year and during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, and 2002-2003 school years by:
A. Failing to conduct assessment in the areas of occupational therapy (OT), verbal apraxia, and auditory processing;
B. Failing to offer services and goals and objectives addressing OT-related needs, verbal apraxia, and auditory processing, and failing to offer an appropriate level of services to address STUDENT’s speech and language deficits; and
C. Failing to place STUDENT in mainstream classes with a full-time one-to-one aide?(Footnote 1)
Issue 3: Because of the District’s failure to appropriately assess STUDENT and failure to provide STUDENT a FAPE, is the District required to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of private assessments and to provide STUDENT with compensatory education and other remedies?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born [date redacted], is eligible for special education as a child with autism. He began receiving special education and related services from the District at the age of 3 years. From kindergarten through a portion of first grade in the 1998-1999 school year, he attended a special education class at Riley Elementary School. From the second half of first grade through the 2002-2003 school year, he attended SDCs at Ole Hanson Elementary School (Ole Hanson) and received various related services.(Footnote 2)
The Petitioner’s contentions in this case extend back to April 3, 2000, corresponding to the three-year statute of limitations. In April 2000, STUDENT was in the third grade at Ole Hanson. His annual individualized education program (IEP) written on February 22, 2000, provided for SDC five days per week, a full-time one-to-one aide, 45-minute one-to-one speech and language sessions three times per week, intensive behavior intervention (IBI) services from District personnel for 10 hours per week on a District school site, behavior therapy services from a nonpublic agency (NPA), and adapted physical education (APE). The IEP stated that STUDENT would be spending 75 percent of his school day in special education programs. STUDENT’s mother signed her consent to the IEP.
The annual goals and short-term objectives in STUDENT’s February 2000 IEP provide information about STUDENT’s levels of performance at that time. Goals and objectives covered deficit areas in school readiness skills such as STUDENT’s reciting his phone number, writing his complete address, and demonstrating receptive knowledge of the concepts of “most,” “least,” “between,” and “next”; reading skills such as being able to orally answer questions posed regarding a page from a first-grade reader; written language skills such as listing characteristics of a familiar object, i.e. color and shape, and writing sentences using capitals and periods; math skills such as subtracting two-digit and three-digit numbers; social skills such as appropriately asking a classmate to play a game or asking other questions, sitting in his seat appropriately and working for 10 minutes, and not touching others without their permission; receptive language skills such as listening to short stories of five or six sentences in length and answering “wh” questions about the stories and following three-step verbal directions; and expressive language skills such as repeating six-word phrases, using a sentence to describe a picture or event, and asking “wh” questions.
The February 2000 IEP also contained a behavior management plan. The primary behavior targeted by the plan was STUDENT’s difficulty with being able to stay in his seat and work independently. The plan stated that at least five times daily for a period of several minutes STUDENT would be off task. He would leave his seat and wander the room looking for objects to play with, and he would leave the room without permission to go to the bathroom or obtain a snack. The plan characterized STUDENT’s behavior as being “very disruptive to the others working in the classroom.” The plan stated that STUDENT’s “severe deficit in auditory processing” was causing the behavior problems.
Notations written on STUDENT’s goals and objectives indicate that by February 2001 STUDENT had met about half of the goals and objectives in readiness skills, none in reading skills, one of three in written language, most in math skills, and most in social skills. No notations were made regarding progress in receptive and expressive language.
STUDENT’s February 13, 2001 annual IEP, written while he was in the fourth grade at Ole Hanson and consented to by STUDENT’s mother, listed basically the same program as in the prior IEP except for the nature of the speech and language services. The prior IEP and the new IEP each provided for 135 minutes of weekly speech and language services, delivered through three 45-minute sessions. However, the prior IEP had provided for all of the 135 minutes to be delivered in individual, one-to-one sessions. The new IEP provided for 105 minutes in individual sessions, but the remaining 30 minutes would be delivered in group sessions to address pragmatics. Pragmatics was defined in the new IEP as meaning engaged interactive conversation with peers. The IEP stated that STUDENT would be spending 75 percent of his school day in special education programs.(Footnote 3) Revised goals and objectives reflected STUDENT’s academic progress. However, the revised goals and objectives for speech and language indicate that although STUDENT had made some progress in expressive language from February 2000 to February 2001, he had made minimal or no progress in receptive language during that same period.
Notations written on STUDENT’s goals and objectives indicate that by February 2002, STUDENT had met all his goals and objectives in readiness skills and reading comprehension; about half of the goals and objectives in written language; and one out of three in social skills. His status regarding receptive and expressive language goals and objectives was described as “ongoing.”
The next annual IEP meeting was on February 5, 2002. STUDENT was in the fifth grade and was still attending Ole Hanson. STUDENT’s parents did not sign their consent to the IEP proposed at that meeting. The District intended for the IEP to be operative pending an anticipated meeting in in three months to discuss STUDENT’s transition into a sixth-grade class at a middle-school. The February 2002 IEP shows that the District offered SDC five days per week, supplemented by some mainstreaming; a one-to-one independence facilitator for six hours per day; speech and language services for one 45-minute individual session and two 30-minute group sessions per week (a reduction from the prior IEP); ten hours of weekly IBI services on school grounds, plus IBI supervision; and APE. The IEP stated that STUDENT would be spending 75 percent of his school day in special education programs. STUDENT would be mainstreamed for art class, recess, lunch, and assemblies. The IEP contained essentially the same behavior management plan as in the previous IEPs.(Footnote 4)
The present levels of performance and goals and objectives in STUDENT’s February 2002 IEP show that in reading skills, STUDENT was at the fourth-grade level in reading decoding but only at the first-grade level in reading comprehension. Goals and objectives included answering “wh” questions after reading a first-grade text and working on suffixes. In written language skills, spelling was at the fifth-grade level, and STUDENT was using some capitalization and punctuation; however, sentence length and complexity was a major concern. Goals and objectives included short-sentence writing (three to five words) on teacher-chosen topics and use of cursive. In math, STUDENT was performing at the first-grade level. Goals and objectives included addition and subtraction of two- and three-digit numbers. In the social and emotional area, STUDENT was still exhibiting loud verbalizations, excessive “video talk,” inability to stay on task, and impulsive behaviors with many perseverations.(Footnote 5) He was described as an affectionate and generally happy child who seemed to enjoy school and the company of students and staff. Goals and objectives included STUDENT utilizing a quiet, classroom-appropriate voice over a five-minute period with no more than two verbal prompts and remaining in his seat for five minutes during work time with minimal prompting; initiating play; cooperating in rules of games; turn taking; using a person’s name; and accepting “no” and expressing displeasure appropriately. In the area of receptive language, STUDENT could successfully complete one- and two-step directions. Response to “wh” questions was inconsistent. Goals and objectives included following functional three-step oral directions and responding orally to “wh” questions after being exposed to a short story or picture cues. In expressive language, STUDENT was reportedly able to use basic language to express his needs, desires, and concerns. He was using nouns, pronouns, verbs, and verb-object structure with about fifty percent agreement.
The District held an IEP meeting on April 22, 2002, to discuss STUDENT’s transition to a sixth-grade SDC at a middle school. The District proposed that STUDENT would attend a sixth-grade SDC for five periods and have one period of a regular education elective, all at Shorecliffs Middle School (Shorecliffs). IBI services would be provided for one hour daily in the SDC during social skills group and one hour daily after school on the school site, including during homework club. Speech and language services and the independence facilitator would continue with the same frequency as in the prior IEP. APE was offered. STUDENT would also have an after-school program. This plan was indicated to result in STUDENT’s placement in a special education setting for 83 percent of the school day in middle school.
The next and final IEP meeting prior to commencement of the due process hearing was on June 17, 2002. The team met to again discuss STUDENT’s sixth-grade placement and after-school services. The District continued to recommend placement and services as stated in the April 22, 2002 IEP. The parents did not consent to the District’s proposed placement and program. By letter dated June 21, 2002, STUDENT’s mother informed the District that she disagreed with the District’s assessments of STUDENT and she was requesting that the District pay for independent assessments. By letter dated July 9, the District requested clarification regarding the dates of the assessments and the portions of the assessments that the parents were in disagreement with.
On referral by the parents’ attorney, STUDENT was assessed by Speech Pathology Associates (SPA) on July 2, 2002. In a detailed report, SPA recommended that STUDENT receive intensive speech and language therapy in three sixty-minute individual sessions and one 60-minute group session per week, audiological evaluation, and auditory processing evaluation.
During the summer of 2002, the District and the parents’ attorney exchanged letters to clarify what was termed as a “mutually agreed upon stay put placement” pending resolution of their disputes regarding placement and services. The parties decided that STUDENT would remain in Ms. Johnson’s SDC at Ole Hanson for the 2002-2003 school year. The District did not offer the increased speech and language services recommended by SPA, and the parents continued to assert that the amount of speech and language services was inadequate. Also in the summer of 2002, the District proposed a speech and language assessment, and the parents refused to provide consent. In the fall of 2002, the District sought to conduct STUDENT’s triennial assessment, but agreement on the plan was not reached.
Christine Majors, Ph.D., performed a private neuropsychological evaluation in December 2002 and January and April 2003 at the parents’ request. During the course of her evaluation, Dr. Majors suspected that STUDENT had apraxia of speech, and she referred STUDENT to SPA for further testing. SPA evaluated STUDENT on January 24, 2003, and concluded that STUDENT had “moderate to severe verbal apraxia,” “sensory integration difficulties,” and an “underlying language disorder that impedes STUDENT’s ability to process and formulate language to his potential.” SPA changed its prior recommendation to intense individual speech and language therapy four times weekly in 60-minute sessions to target verbal apraxia and language processing. SPA also recommended an OT evaluation. An independent OT evaluation was performed on February 26 and March 11, 2003, by Laurie Cohen. Ms. Cohen concluded in her March 2003 report that STUDENT’s performance in school was adversely affected not only by STUDENT’s autism but also by substantial deficits in the OT-related areas of sensory processing, motor planning, work behaviors, and peer interaction. Ms. Cohen recommended OT to address those deficits.
Dr. Majors concluded in her detailed April 16, 2003 report that STUDENT’s symptoms were consistent with autistic disorder. In addition, she concluded that his intellectual level was probably in the low-average to average range. She stated that cognitively, STUDENT exhibited deficits in attention/executive functioning, particularly in the areas of “inhibition, shifting, and self-monitoring”; verbal memory; and visual-motor integration. He also exhibited behaviors “suggesting problems” in the areas of attention, hyperactivity, and social skills. His adaptive functioning was in the significantly delayed range. Dr. Majors’ report also includes a discussion regarding her opinions that the District should have assessed for auditory processing deficits and identified apraxia years earlier.
For the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT has remained in Ms. Johnson’s SDC at Ole Hanson. Her class included primarily fifth-graders and at least one sixth-grader in addition to STUDENT. The current request for due process hearing was filed on April 2, 2003. The Petitioner’s issues and contentions, stated in detail below, generally reflect the differences between the District’s program over the past four school years compared to the recommendations made in the relatively recent and privately-obtained evaluations by Dr. Majors, SPA, and Ms. Cohen.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE from April 3, 2000, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year by failing to hold a “pre-IEP” meeting pursuant to Cal. Gov. Code section 7572 (a),(c), and (d)(1)?
Individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. §1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code §56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards and conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. §1401(8). State law further defines the term “special education” as meaning specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services” that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code §56031.
The Petitioner asserts that after a psychoeducational evaluation was performed by District school psychologist David Stoffel in February 2000, the District denied the Petitioner a FAPE by violating Cal. Gov. Code section 7572. According to the Petitioner, the violation of section 7572 arose from the District’s failure to hold what the Petitioner terms a “pre-IEP meeting” to discuss Mr. Stoffel’s psychoeducational evaluation.
Section 7572 applies to “psychotherapy or other mental health assessment” as described by section 7572 and related sections in Title 1, Division 7, Chapter 26.5 of the Government Code.(Footnote 6) The provisions of Chapter 26.5 generally concern psychotherapy or mental health assessment performed by a county mental health agency. The evaluation by Mr. Stoffel was a District evaluation, performed as part of a triennial reassessment. Mr. Stoffel evaluated STUDENT’s present levels of intellectual functioning, visual-motor integration skills, academic progress, and adaptive behavior. He did not perform a “psychotherapy or other mental health assessment” within the meaning of section 7572 or Chapter 26.5. No mental health agency was involved. Accordingly, the Petitioner’s allegation of a section 7572 violation is groundless.
Issue 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE from April 3, 2000, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year and during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, and 2002-2003 school years by (A) failing to conduct assessment in the areas of OT, verbal apraxia, and auditory processing; (B) failing to offer services and goals and objectives addressing OT-related needs, verbal apraxia, and auditory processing, and failing to offer an appropriate level of services to address STUDENT’s speech and language deficits; and (C) failing to place STUDENT in mainstream classes with a full-time one-to-one aide?
************
A. Failing to conduct assessment in the areas of OT, verbal apraxia, and auditory processing.
Specific legal requirements for special education assessments are set forth by statute and regulation. “Before any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs in special education instruction, an assessment of the pupil’s educational needs shall be conducted . . .” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. Reassessment of a pupil, based upon procedures specified in section 56320, “shall be conducted at least once every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests a reassessment and a new individualized education program to be developed.” Cal. Educ. Code §56381. Most pertinent to the present issue is the requirement that a student must be “assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).
The Petitioner asserts that during the 1999-2000 school year and at all times thereafter, the District should have suspected that the Petitioner had disabilities in the areas of OT, verbal apraxia, and auditory processing and the District failed to conduct assessment in those areas. Those contentions will now be addressed.(Footnote 7)
OT assessment. Ms. Cohen, the private occupational therapist who assessed STUDENT at the parents’ request in February and March 2003, testified regarding several entries in the District’s assessment records that, in her opinion, indicated deficits in OT-related areas and should have led to an OT assessment by the District. Specifically, the January 2000 speech and language assessment report by Lisa Bland states that during the assessment, “STUDENT was easily distracted, and impulsive both verbally and physically. He would often answer quickly, and would quickly reach out to turn the pages of the testing booklets.” Ms. Cohen testified that she had seen such behavior during her assessment of STUDENT, and she considered that behavior alone to be sufficient reason for conducting an OT assessment. The February 22, 2000 APE report states that in the Test of Gross Motor Development (TGMD), STUDENT’s overall score was only in the seventh percentile. Ms. Cohen considered it unusual for a child to receive APE services while not even being referred for an OT assessment. Furthermore, she considered the degree of gross-motor control impairment measured by the TGMD to be a “big red flag” that should have resulted in an OT assessment. The February 2000 psychoeducational report by District school psychologist David Stoffel states that STUDENT ranked in the fifth percentile on the Beery Visual-Motor Integration Test (VMI). Ms. Cohen testified that the low score on the VMI indicated a significant problem with STUDENT’s ability to process information with his eyes and on paper, again indicating the need for an OT assessment. Finally, Dr. Majors’ report cites a February 1997 report by the State of California Department of Education Diagnostic Center (CDE report) that indicates a history of “vestibular and proprioceptive sensory seeking behaviors,” considered by Ms. Cohen as another “red flag” for conducting an OT assessment.
Ms. Cohen testified regarding behaviors that she observed when she assessed STUDENT. He holds objects gingerly, seeks deep pressure for his body, and attempts to inspect various objects by tasting and smelling them. When she sat next to him at school, he leaned toward her and began to smell her and push his body against her. He had difficulty maintaining balance, and that affected his ability to sit upright at his desk. He would jump in front of people to get their attention and speak loudly. Ms. Cohen testified that all of the above indicate sensory-integration deficits and many of his behaviors are a coping mechanism for those deficits. Ms. Cohen testified that from her observations of STUDENT at school and in his home, she saw enough to conclude that STUDENT’s performance in school was adversely affected by substantial difficulties in the OT-related areas of sensory processing, motor planning, work behaviors, and peer interaction, and therefore she did not perform additional testing.
At the due process hearing, the District offered no explanation concerning why an OT assessment had not been performed.(Footnote 8) The Hearing Officer found Ms. Cohen’s opinion on the longstanding need for an OT assessment to be credible and consistent with the factual evidence. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that from April 3, 2000, through May 2003, STUDENT has continually had suspected disabilities in OT-related areas.(Footnote 9) The District was required to offer an OT assessment but failed to do so. The consequences of the District’s failure to offer an OT assessment will be addressed elsewhere in this Decision.(Footnote 10)
Verbal apraxia assessment. A chief area of contention at the due process hearing involved the subject of verbal apraxia. The Petitioner asserts that he has moderate to severe verbal apraxia and he should have been assessed for verbal apraxia years ago. On behalf of the Petitioner, Barbara Moore testified that problems with speech intelligibility do not mean that a child has verbal apraxia, but verbal apraxia is one of the first areas she would evaluate in a child with poor speech intelligibility. She stated that the entry in the 1997 CDE report documenting STUDENT’s speech as being “unintelligible, particularly as sentence length increases” should have led to specific testing for verbal apraxia. She also stated because STUDENT, in her opinion, has verbal apraxia and has been working regularly with speech and language therapists, his verbal apraxia should have been apparent to the therapists “early on” and an assessment in that area should have been performed. The District denies that STUDENT has verbal apraxia or that he has needed formal assessment for verbal apraxia. The District asserts that the absence of expressed concern about verbal apraxia in the 1997 CDE report, in the District’s February 1999 and January 2000 speech and language assessments, in the course of ongoing District speech and language services, in the September 2001 report by Newport Speech and Language Center, and in SPA’s July 2002 report, confirms that verbal apraxia was not an area of suspected disability and therefore did not require assessment.(Footnote 11)
Ms. Moore and District representative Dianne Lappi testified that except in cases involving a traumatic brain injury, verbal apraxia is a condition a child is born with, and verbal apraxia becomes apparent soon after a child begins speaking.(Footnote 12) Therefore, to resolve the question of whether the District was required to assess for verbal apraxia as an area of suspected disability, the Hearing Officer will determine whether STUDENT currently has unique needs arising from verbal apraxia. If STUDENT has such needs currently, he would also have manifested those needs during the 1999-2000 school year and subsequent years, and verbal apraxia therefore should have been assessed as an area of suspected disability.(Footnote 13)
The nature of apraxia and the distinction between oral-motor apraxia and verbal apraxia were addressed by the testimony of Ms. Moore and Ms. Lappi. They explained, in general, that the body has a mechanism in place for life-sustaining tasks such as breathing, swallowing, sucking, and eating. This broad mechanism for sustaining life has an overlay function of speech capability, wherein portions of the mechanism for sustaining life are used secondarily for speech production. In oral-motor apraxia, functions pertaining to life-sustaining, non-speech tasks, such as eating, sucking, or individual tongue movements, are impaired. In verbal apraxia, properly characterized as a motor-planning deficit instead of a muscle weakness issue, one’s ability to control the life-sustaining mechanism in the manner required for speech production is impaired. Verbal apraxia, for example, can adversely affect one’s ability to control phonation and respiration functions necessary for proper speech production. Ms. Moore testified that children with verbal apraxia need remediation in the area of word planning related to the production of sounds, words, phrases, and sentences.
Ms. Moore, Ms. Lappi, and other experts provided opinion testimony regarding whether STUDENT has verbal apraxia. A chronological review of pertinent facts will facilitate consideration of those opinions in context with the overall evidence. The earliest applicable information cited by the experts consists of references to the speech and language portion of a 1997 assessment by the State of California Department of Education Diagnostic Center. As quoted and described by witnesses and in various written reports, the 1997 CDE report stated that STUDENT’s speech was “unclear” or “unintelligible,” particularly as sentence length increased, but the report made no mention of apraxia or a need to assess for apraxia. The CDE report concluded that by having STUDENT focus on developing social competency as opposed to articulation and syntax, intelligibility and syntax would improve.
District speech and language pathologist Lisa Bland began working with STUDENT in September 1998, and she provided speech and language therapy to STUDENT for approximately two years. She also assessed him in February 1999 and January 2000. Her 1999 report states that “STUDENT’s speech can be difficult to understand at times, especially when he speaks softly or too fast.” The report contains no mention of concern about apraxia. Present levels of performance and goals and objectives related to articulation are contained in STUDENT’s February 22, 1999 IEP. Throughout 1999, STUDENT received therapy from Ms. Bland, and he underwent articulation drills with the CARD therapist. The “drill summary” notes written by CARD in April 1999 indicate progress in articulation. Ms. Bland’s January 2000 report contains formal assessment data that she obtained as part of STUDENT’s triennial assessment by the District. Her report states that STUDENT’s “voice and fluency are appropriate, and his overall intelligibility is good . . . His articulation is appropriate, with the exception of the /s/, sh, and /r/ sounds, which do not affect his overall intelligibility.”
The above documents reveal that STUDENT has a history of articulation problems and that articulation was being addressed, to some extent, in the District’s program. Furthermore, the documents indicate that at least through January 2000, STUDENT had been making progress in his articulation skills.
Formal testing of STUDENT’s speech and language was performed by the Newport Language and Speech Center in September 2001. The report, as described by witnesses and documentary evidence in this case, contains no references to concern about verbal apraxia.
At the parents’ request, a private speech and language assessment was performed at SPA in July 2002. The July 2002 report, written by Ms. Toyama and signed by Ms. Moore, contains more detailed information about STUDENT’s speech and language than any other document presented at the hearing. The July 2002 SPA report contains a lengthy summary of Ms. Toyama’s review of prior assessment information, and the report lists the results of Ms. Toyama’s own formal assessment of STUDENT with various standardized tests. The report states that Ms. Toyama also conducted an informal oral-motor examination and informally observed STUDENT’s articulation, prosody, fluency, and all parameters of voice. The report states that rate of speech was judged to be “very rapid” and negatively affected STUDENT’s intelligibility. Ms. Toyama estimated STUDENT’s intelligibility to be about 65 percent for novel utterances to an unfamiliar listener, increasing to about 90 percent for rote learned phrases. The report states Ms. Toyama’s impressions and her various recommendations, including recommendations for audiological evaluation and auditory processing evaluation. The report mentions no suspicion of apraxia, verbal or otherwise, and the report contains no recommendation for assessment in the area of apraxia.
At the parents’ request, Dr. Majors commenced her psychological evaluation of STUDENT in or about December 2002. Dr. Majors suspected that STUDENT had verbal apraxia, and she referred STUDENT to SPA for reassessment to cover verbal apraxia. SPA conducted the reassessment in January 2003. The evaluation was performed by Mr. Howell, and the report was signed by Ms. Moore. The report concluded that STUDENT had moderate to severe verbal apraxia.
SPA’s January 2003 report states that to test for verbal apraxia, SPA administered the Kaufman Speech Praxis Test (KSPT), subtests from the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-Third Edition (CELF-3), and the Goldman Fristoe Test of Articulation (Goldman Fristoe), all on January 24, 2003. Ms. Moore testified that results on Part I of the KSPT showed STUDENT’s ability to make oral movements to be in the low range of average. On Part II, STUDENT’s ability to produce vowel and consonant patterns was so low that his standard score of 58 did not come within any of the norm brackets on the test. On Part III, complex consonant production was below average. On Part IV, spontaneous length and complexity of utterance was far below average. On the KSPT rating scale of 0.0 to 6.0, STUDENT’s score of 2.8 was considered to be indicative of moderate to severe verbal apraxia. According to the SPA report, characteristics of verbal apraxia that STUDENT demonstrated were inability to consistently control saliva, manifested as mild drooling; verbal perseveration; inability to perform oral diadochokinesis; vowel distortions; sound errors, such as sh/s, /r/ distortion, /l/ distortions and blend reduction; “length of complexity factors causing the system to disintegrate, contributing to unintelligibility”; inconsistent, “off-target attempts” on certain words of increased length or complexity; and better production of single words than long utterances. The report further states: “In connected speech, STUDENT demonstrated abnormal prosody and rapid rate. Vowel distortions were prevalent. The characteristics of verbal apraxia, as noted above, were readily observed. Syntax (word order) was noted to be disordered. Intelligibility for novel utterances was judged to be 65% to an unknown listener.”(Footnote 14)
The SPA report also states that the Goldman Fristoe was administered to determine articulation skills at the word level. According to the report, “STUDENT was able to name all stimulus pictures. Errors included sh/s, /r/ distortions and blend reduction for /l/. Vowel distortions were noted in 75% of STUDENT’s productions. Intelligibility was 95% for single word productions.” On the CELF-3, STUDENT scored in the fifth percentile in sentence assembly and the first percentile in formulating sentences, recalling sentences, and overall expressive language. The overall impression of the examiner was that although STUDENT has autism, he also has other barriers that prevent him from advancing his speech and language skills. Those barriers include moderate to severe verbal apraxia, “obvious sensory integration difficulties” that require him to have constant input to his body so he can attend, and “an underlying language disorder that impedes STUDENT’s ability to process and formulate language to his potential.”
Ms. Moore testified that she agreed with the content of the January 2003 SPA report. She stated that the observations and impressions listed in the report were consistent with her own observations of STUDENT. Although Mr. Howell did the formal testing for the report, Ms. Moore devoted some time to reading with STUDENT and engaging him in conversation. She testified that the figure of 65 percent intelligibility dropped when STUDENT, as he tended to do, spoke rapidly. She also testified that STUDENT’s increase to 90 percent intelligibility with rote learned phrases was consistent with verbal apraxia because novel phrases are more of a problem for children with verbal apraxia. She stated that STUDENT’s verbal perseverations could simply be the result of his autism, but they could also be caused by his inability to motor plan and move to another word.
With regard to why verbal apraxia was not documented in the numerous prior evaluations listed above, Ms. Moore offered the explanation that Ms. Toyama did not mention apraxia in the July 2002 SPA report because SPA was not asked to test for apraxia and there was insufficient time to test for apraxia during the July 2002 evaluation. However, she did note that intelligibility was mentioned as an issue in Ms. Toyama’s report.(Footnote 15) With respect to the other evaluations and assessments, Ms. Moore theorized that STUDENT has deficits in many different areas and each particular examiner may have chosen to focus only on specific areas such as language processing or receptive/expressive language and “for whatever professional reason chose not to look at any kind of apraxia,” or they may have made the assumption that lack of intelligibility was simply due to autism and not to a separate entity. In any event, she considers the tests done by SPA in January 2003 to be definitive for showing that STUDENT has verbal apraxia.
On behalf of the District Ms. Lappi testified that if STUDENT had verbal apraxia, she would have expected the SPA speech and language pathologist, Ms. Toyama, to detect it during the July 2002 evaluation. Mr. Lappi explained that the July 2002 SPA report confirmed Ms. Toyama’s use of standard protocol by doing an informal oral-motor examination to specifically to check for any indication of oral apraxia, followed by an informal articulation evaluation to check for signs of verbal or speech apraxia. After conducting the informal oral-motor examination and informal evaluation in the areas of articulation, prosody, fluency, and voice, no indication of oral or verbal apraxia was reported by Ms. Toyama. Ms. Lappi testified that although Ms. Toyama observed a reduction of STUDENT’s intelligibility when he spoke rapidly, this was not a verbal apraxia issue.
Concerning her opinion of the January 2003 SPA report, Ms. Lappi testified that she was surprised by Dr. Majors’ recommendation that STUDENT be retested for verbal apraxia. She stated that in her years of practice she had never known a psychologist to find verbal apraxia when the child had already been assessed and treated by several speech and language pathologists and none had detected verbal apraxia. She also expressed surprise that SPA arrived at the diagnosis of verbal apraxia by relying on the KSPT as diagnostic tool for STUDENT. She stated that the KSPT, normed for children up to age 6 years, was not age appropriate for STUDENT; thus, the results must be interpreted with caution.(Footnote 16) She also testified that in her opinion, the KSPT primarily addresses oral apraxia, and although it can lead to some insights regarding verbal apraxia, it is not the test of choice for verbal apraxia. She stated that for STUDENT’s situation, tests of choice for verbal apraxia would include a language sample or working with a child over time wherein one would see a pattern of coordination problems with muscle movements, respiration, phonation, and other aspects of the speech overlay system.
Ms. Lappi also was critical of SPA’s reliance on results from the Goldman Fristoe. The Goldman Fristoe data indicated to Ms. Lappi that STUDENT has skills at the word level. STUDENT’s intelligibility being measured at 95 percent for single-word productions shows, according to Ms. Lappi, that STUDENT does not have verbal apraxia. She stated that STUDENT’s 95 percent intelligibility at the single-word level confirms that his intelligibility problems are primarily caused when STUDENT starts stringing words together and, at the same time, excessively increases his rate of speech. She testified that the Goldman Fristoe showed some minor mis-articulations, but the type of sound distortions were not indicative of verbal apraxia. Ms. Lappi stated that STUDENT’s vowel distortions would impact the “power” of his speech but have minimal impact on intelligibility. She stated that intelligibility was more a function of consonant production. She noted that the reported sh/s, /r/ distortions, and blend reduction for /l/, show that STUDENT is approximating those sounds. She characterized those errors as mis-articulations, not verbal apraxia, and stated that those types of errors had been addressed in the articulation therapy portion of STUDENT’s speech and language program. She stated that if STUDENT had any verbal apraxia, he would most likely be unable to recognizably produce those sounds, even in a distorted manner. She also noted that according to information reviewed by her, STUDENT routinely substitutes one sound for another sound, but verbal apraxia would cause multiple types of substitutions in place of the correct sound.
With respect to the overall question of whether STUDENT has verbal apraxia, Ms. Lappi stated that if STUDENT had verbal apraxia, it absolutely would have been detected during any of the various assessments and by the speech and language pathologists who were providing services to STUDENT. She acknowledged that STUDENT is difficult to listen to because he speaks in a monotone. She testified that the rapidity of speech and the documented articulation problems with production of certain sounds did not constitute verbal apraxia. She denied the existence of any “red flags” for verbal apraxia in the records. She stated that indications of verbal apraxia would be, among others, severe articulation difficulties; atypical violations of phonological processing rules; and abnormal resonation, intonation, and respiration. She testified that STUDENT’s articulation problems were initially consistent with STUDENT’s developmental age, and when the problems persisted they were effectively addressed with therapy. Ms. Lappi testified that notwithstanding STUDENT’s articulation problems and ongoing problems with rapidity of speech, she saw no indications in the 1997 CDE report, in the various District speech and language assessments, in the September 2001 Newport Language and Speech Center evaluation, or in the July 2002 SPA report that would indicate either oral or verbal apraxia. She also stated that increasing intelligibility of rote phrases, in her opinion, contraindicated verbal apraxia (the opposite of Ms. Moore’s testimony).
The District presented testimony from STUDENT’s primary speech and language pathologists. Ms. Bland, STUDENT’s speech therapist for two years ending in or about the year 2000, testified that she has no reason to suspect verbal apraxia in STUDENT. District speech and language pathologist Roberta Brady was STUDENT’s speech therapist for the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years. She also testified that she has seen no indications of STUDENT having verbal apraxia.(Footnote 17) Cynthia Johnson, STUDENT’s SDC teacher for the past two school years, is also a speech and language pathologist. She testified that STUDENT uses his articulators well, and she does not believe that he needs services for verbal apraxia.
Having considered all of the above evidence, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the conclusions in the January 2003 SPA report or by the testimony of Ms. Moore that STUDENT has moderate to severe verbal apraxia. Among the multitude of speech and language reports and observations by therapists over the past 6 years, only the January 2003 SPA report concludes that STUDENT has verbal apraxia. In spite of the severity of STUDENT’s alleged verbal apraxia and the suggestion it should have been readily observed, none of the other sources, including non-District sources, indicate even a suspicion of verbal apraxia. Except for the January 2003 SPA report and the testimony of Ms. Moore, no specific evidence was presented to indicate that the opinions expressed by those other sources should be considered unreliable, suspect, or simply incorrect. Meanwhile, the findings in the January 2003 SPA report are contradicted by SPA’s own comprehensive report from July 2002. The July 2002 SPA report is more thorough and contains significantly more detail than any other speech and language assessment offered into evidence. Furthermore, Ms. Moore’s explanation that SPA was not asked to assess for apraxia in July 2002 is contradicted by the preface in the July 2002 SPA report specifically listing articulation as a concern of the parents leading to the referral for assessment. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to conduct assessment for verbal apraxia and that STUDENT does not have unique needs arising from verbal apraxia.
Auditory processing assessment. The Petitioner asserts that auditory processing is one of his suspected areas of disability and the District therefore was required to assess his auditory processing. The District acknowledges that STUDENT has a history of auditory processing deficits, in some form, and asserts that auditory processing was appropriately assessed for the 1999-2000 school year by Lisa Bland and was periodically assessed thereafter by the ongoing monitoring of STUDENT’s progress on his behavior management plan.
District speech and language pathologist Lisa Bland testified that she conducted an assessment of STUDENT in January 2000. She testified that given STUDENT’s diagnosis of autism, it could essentially be presumed that STUDENT had auditory processing difficulties. She described auditory processing as the ability to receive input, such as the word “glove,” to make associations regarding what a glove is, to attach those associations to prior knowledge, and to make an “output” from that process. She stated that this form of auditory processing disorder could interfere with STUDENT’s performance on certain tasks and tests, and it could adversely affect his ability to follow directions and his behavior in the classroom. She testified that when she assessed STUDENT in January 2000, she assessed his auditory processing at least indirectly to some degree by administering the Comprehensive Receptive and Expressive Vocabulary Test (CREVT) and the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Third Edition (Peabody). She testified that STUDENT’s Earobics program at that time had been targeted to address auditory processing areas such as phonological skills and sequencing.
The relatively broad form of auditory processing described by Ms. Bland may not necessarily be the same form of auditory processing contemplated in the issues raised by the Petitioner. The July 2002 SPA report states that STUDENT’s delaying before responding, pointing to pictures slowly, repeating of stimulus items, and repeating items incorrectly by making individual sound substitutions (i.e. “book” > “boat,” “sock” > “shock”), may indicate decreased comprehension, a requirement for longer processing time, and possible auditory processing deficits. Although these traits may be partially analogous to the type of auditory processing deficits described by Ms. Bland, the SPA report concluded, without further explanation, that STUDENT presented with “possibly impaired auditory language processing at the phoneme level.”(Footnote 18) Auditory processing evaluation was recommended.
In the context of STUDENT’s situation, Dr. Majors described auditory processing disorder as generally meaning a language processing problem wherein the brain does not “keep up” with the rate of speech. Thus, her description, like that of Ms. Bland, was very broad. Dr. Majors testified that the nature of STUDENT’s behaviors, attention problems, and language delays suggest an auditory processing disorder. Dr. Majors noted that the behavior management plans in STUDENT’s IEPs consistently contained the statement that the behaviors were occurring because of STUDENT’s “severe deficit in auditory processing.” She testified that although the IEP team believed STUDENT had an auditory processing disorder, he was never assessed for auditory processing. She observed that it would be appropriate to use a behavior plan to compensate for an auditory processing disorder, but not to treat it. To formulate treatment, assessment would be necessary. She also noted that in the District’s January 2001 assessment documentation, the teacher reported that STUDENT’s poor auditory processing skills made formal testing unreliable. However, the team still did not recommend an auditory processing assessment. Dr. Majors testified that she does not know whether STUDENT has an auditory processing problem, but he should at least have an assessment in that area.
Ms. Moore testified that assessment should be performed for auditory processing by an audiologist because an audiologist can administer a very definitive assessment. She stated that to formulate treatment for an auditory processing disorder, assessment would be necessary so that the IEP team would know what needed to be addressed.
Having considered the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s auditory processing is an area of suspected disability. However, STUDENT has never had a formal auditory processing assessment. The District has attempted to characterize Ms. Bland’s incidental data and the IEP team’s periodic monitoring of STUDENT’s progress toward his behavior management plan as appropriate assessment in auditory processing. The District’s position on this matter is unfounded. The array of deficits that could be characterized as part of an auditory processing disorder is significantly more extensive than would be gleaned from the cursory consideration of auditory processing made by STUDENT’s IEP team. The evidence shows that STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits could involve sound discrimination at the phoneme level in addition to broader deficits. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was required to offer a formal auditory processing assessment but failed to do so. The consequences of the District’s failure to offer an auditory processing assessment will be discussed elsewhere in this Decision.
B. Failing to offer services and goals and objectives addressing OT-related needs, verbal apraxia, and auditory processing, and failing to offer an appropriate level of services to address STUDENT’s speech and language deficits.
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet the student’s unique needs and provide the student with some educational benefit. Rowley, at 207-208.
To determine whether a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district's proposed program addresses the student’s unique needs, provides some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP, then that district has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.(Footnote 19)
In the present case, the Petitioner asserts that the District denied him a FAPE from April 3, 2000, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year and during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, and 2002-2003 school years by failing to offer and provide a placement and program designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. More specifically, the Petitioner asserts that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to offer services and goals and objectives addressing OT, verbal apraxia, and auditory processing, and failing to offer an appropriate level of services to address STUDENT’s speech and language deficits.
Before examining each of the Petitioner’s contentions, it is first necessary to review the Petitioner’s unique needs. Thereafter, the Hearing Officer will examine the District’s program and placement offers to determine whether they were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
(1) STUDENT’s unique needs.
OT-related needs. The Hearing Officer has already determined that during all times at issue in this case, the District was required to offer an OT assessment, yet no OT assessment was offered until at least November 2002 and possibly not until April 2003. In any event, the program for the 2002-2003 school year had already been formulated and offered for the 2002-2003 school year, and the District had ample time to have offered and conducted an OT assessment prior to November 2002. Therefore, irrespective of whether OT assessment was first offered in November 2002 or April 2003, and irrespective of whether the parents acted appropriately in not consenting to the recent assessment plans, the Hearing Officer concludes that in this present case the District is responsible for the consequences of not having earlier offered an OT assessment.(Footnote 20) The District has no assessment information to refute the impressions and recommendations in Ms. Cohen’s March 2003 report. Ms. Cohen’s report and her opinions were generally consistent with the evidence. On the basis of that report and the related evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs services to address his sensory-integration deficits that have likely caused or contributed to his sensory-seeking behaviors and his ongoing history of being easily distracted and being verbally and physically impulsive.
Verbal apraxia. The Hearing Officer has previously determined that STUDENT does not have unique needs arising from verbal apraxia.
Auditory processing. Although there was no consensus among the Petitioner’s experts that STUDENT actually has an auditory processing disorder, Ms. Bland’s testimony and the content of STUDENT’s IEPs show a strong likelihood that STUDENT has auditory processing deficits. However, Ms. Bland’s testimony provided no detail regarding the particular nature of those auditory processing deficits. Furthermore, the numerous references to auditory processing deficits made in STUDENT’s behavior management plans are too vague and their source is too speculative to allow a determination as to the specific nature of STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits or what an appropriate program to address those deficits would be. On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires a comprehensive auditory processing assessment by a qualified audiologist. Until STUDENT undergoes a comprehensive auditory processing assessment by a qualified audiologist, one can only speculate on the specific nature of STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of auditory processing and the services necessary to appropriately address those needs.
Speech and language. There is no dispute that speech and language is a major area of deficit for STUDENT. The District’s January 2000 assessment report/three-year re-evaluation by Ms. Bland states that STUDENT’s speech was characterized by short, choppy sentences of two to three words (i.e. “want scissors”). When verbally cued to use more words, sentence length could reach four to five words (i.e. “I want scissors please”). Except for greetings, he seldom engaged in social communication. His rate of speech was fast and rushed. Articulation was appropriate except for “sh” and “r” sounds. At his chronological age of 8.11 (years.months), STUDENT’s receptive vocabulary was indicated to be at about the 5.5 age equivalent level, and expressive one-word vocabulary was at about 6.11. He was generally unable to indicate color, function, or category of objects. He had “great difficulty” listening to short stories and responding to “wh” questions, either about the story or about himself. During the July 2002 SPA evaluation, STUDENT’s receptive vocabulary at the one-word level on the Peabody was measured at about the 5.10 age equivalent level. Expressive vocabulary at the one-word level was measured by the Expressive Vocabulary Test (EVT) as being at 3.11 age equivalent. However, expressive vocabulary had been measured in the average range by a different form of test in September 2002. Thus, the 3.11 age equivalent score was believed by the SPA examiner to indicate word retrieval/semantic relationship issues rather than a poor expressive vocabulary. On the CELF-3, a test normed for children aged 6.0 to 8.11 years, STUDENT’s scores were equivalent to the first percentile in receptive and expressive language, although his Word Classes subtest score was equivalent to the fifth percentile.
In spite of the fact that STUDENT’s progress in speech and language over the past three years has been modest at best, the witnesses were in general agreement that STUDENT can and will benefit from intensive speech and language therapy. Furthermore, as shown by Dr. Majors’ evaluation and the District’s assessments of STUDENT, his intellectual/cognitive ability is within the average range, and improvement of STUDENT’s speech and language skills should significantly aide his academic progress. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs intensive speech and language therapy to address his receptive and expressive language deficits.
(2) The District’s program and placement offer.
The Hearing Officer will now examine the Petitioner’s specific contentions that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to offer services and goals and objectives addressing OT-related needs, verbal apraxia, and auditory processing, and by failing to offer an appropriate level of services to address STUDENT’s speech and language deficits.
Occupational therapy. In the area of STUDENT’s OT-related needs, the Hearing Officer has previously determined that STUDENT needs services to address his sensory-integration deficits that have likely caused or contributed to his sensory-seeking behaviors and his ongoing history of being easily distracted and being verbally and physically impulsive. The District offered no services specifically designed to meet STUDENT’s OT-related needs or reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit in that area, and the District did not offer an OT assessment until some number of months after commencement of the 2002-2003 school year. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by offering no services designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit in the area of OT for the period from April 3, 2000, through May 2003.
Verbal apraxia. The Hearing Officer has previously determined that STUDENT does not need services to address verbal apraxia. Accordingly, there was no denial of FAPE in the area of verbal apraxia.
Auditory processing. The Petitioner asserts although he needed services to address auditory processing deficits, none were offered during the time period at issue. Ms. Bland testified that the Earobics program addressed auditory processing to some extent during the 1999-2000 school year, and Ms. Moore from SPA acknowledged that Earobics is an accepted treatment for some forms of auditory processing disorders. However, the District has failed to obtain appropriate assessment information regarding STUDENT’s auditory processing. Thus, it remains unknown whether the Earobics program was addressing any or all of the auditory processing deficits that STUDENT may have. The evidence also shows that although the behavior management plans in STUDENT’s IEPs were designed to enable STUDENT to compensate for auditory processing deficits, the behavior plan itself was neither designed nor intended to specifically treat or remediate an auditory processing disorder. Until STUDENT undergoes a comprehensive auditory processing evaluation by a qualified audiologist, one cannot determine the specific nature of STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of auditory processing and the services necessary to appropriately address those needs. The consequences of this situation will be addressed below in Issue 3.
Speech and language. The Petitioner asserts that the level of speech and language services offered by the District was insufficient in the amount of intensive one-to-one services. The Hearing Officer will examine this contention by separately addressing the period between each of STUDENT’s applicable annual IEPs.
April 3, 2000-February 2001 Follow-up notations written on the February 1999 IEP speech and language goals and objectives pages for receptive, expressive, and social language indicate that STUDENT had made significant progress through February 2000. The annual goals and short-term objectives had generally been met, although some of the short-term objectives were met at later dates than the target dates, and in some cases STUDENT required more prompting than the target amount. Ms. Bland testified that prompting remained a major issue for STUDENT during the time she provided him with services, but she believed that he had made good progress on the speech and language goals and objectives contained in the February 1999 IEP.(Footnote 21) STUDENT’s IEP team continued the same plan for speech and language when formulating the February 2000 IEP. The frequency and duration of STUDENT’s speech and language services listed in the February 2000 IEP are the same as those listed in the prior annual IEP from February 1999. Both IEPs provided for 45-minute one-to-one speech and language sessions three times per week to address receptive and expressive language.
The Petitioner’s speech and language expert, Ms. Moore, did not directly criticize the amount of speech and language services stated in the February 2000 IEP, except to the extent that she believed additional services were required to address verbal apraxia. The July 2002 SPA report written by Ms. Toyama recommended 60-minute individual sessions three times per week, but the report expressed no direct opinions regarding the intensity of prior speech and language services. Ms. Bland, STUDENT’s former therapist, was the expert most familiar with STUDENT’s speech and language needs at that time, and she indicated her belief that the speech and language services were appropriate.
The IEP team appropriately patterned the speech and language services in the February 2000 IEP to conform with the prior year’s successful program. The Hearing Officer finds that for the period from April 3, 2000, to February 2001, the level of speech and language services offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in speech and language and was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
February 2001-February 2002
STUDENT’s February 13, 2001 annual IEP provided for 45-minute speech and language services three times per week. The speech and language services continued to be one-to-one sessions, with the exception that 30 minutes of the above would be devoted to focusing on pragmatics by engaging in interactive conversation with peers. The IEP contained revised goals and objectives for receptive and expressive language. Although no documentation was presented to show the extent of STUDENT’s progress on the prior IEP goals and objectives for receptive and expressive language, the updated statement of his present levels of performance and the revised content of the new goals and objectives on the February 2001 IEP indicate that STUDENT made minimal or no progress in receptive language from February 2000 to February 2001, but he made some progress during that same period in expressive language.
During her testimony, Dr. Majors was critical of the change in speech and language services. She stated that group therapy focusing on pragmatics was a good strategy, but she questioned why the District would concurrently reduce the one-to-one services, especially without an assessment to show why it was being done and without significant progress indicated in receptive language over the prior year. Ms. Moore expressed similar criticism in her testimony.
Ms. Lappi testified that she considered the speech and language services in the February 2001 IEP to be appropriate. She described the program as a change in services compared to the prior year, not a reduction. Her testimony indicated that change in STUDENT’s program was warranted because his progress had stalled in certain speech and language areas. She stated that STUDENT, as a child with autism, likely needed a realistic, context-driven setting to facilitate and encourage meaningful communication. Thus, she believed it was appropriate to substitute some of the individual therapy with group therapy.
The Hearing Officer found Ms. Lappi’s testimony to be persuasive on the above matter. The evidence confirms that STUDENT’s recent lack of progress in certain areas of speech and language warranted a change in strategy. Changing STUDENT’s setting, as described by Ms. Lappi, could reasonably be expected to encourage STUDENT to use more words and use them in proper context. Ms. Lappi’s opinion was also consistent with the impressions of STUDENT’s therapist. Ms. Bland testified that during her individual sessions with STUDENT for two school years prior to February 2001, he showed a significant lack of intrinsic motivation to use more than a minimum number of words when speaking.(Footnote 22)
On the basis of the above-stated evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that for the period from February 2001 to February 2002, the level of speech and language services offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in speech and language and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
February 2002-February 2003
The February 5, 2002 annual IEP, not consented to by the parents, provided for speech and language services in the amount of one 45-minute individual session and two 30-minute group sessions per week. Thus, the February 2002 IEP reduced the overall level of services by 30 minutes, from 135 minutes per week to 105 minutes per week. Citing the testimony of Dr. Majors and Ms. Moore, the Petitioner asserts that it was inappropriate to, in his view, further reduce speech and language services when he was making no progress.(Footnote 23)
The District offered no satisfactory explanation for the reduction in services. Annual progress on the speech and language goals and objectives from the February 2001 IEP was notated only as “ongoing.” Roberta Brady, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist during the 2001-2002 school year, testified that STUDENT had been making some progress during the prior year, but the progress was inconsistent.(Footnote 24) She did not elaborate on what STUDENT’s progress was. She stated that STUDENT’s autism was the reason for the inconsistency in his progress.
Ms. Lappi’s rationale for providing group services with a corresponding reduction in individual services was appropriate for the February 2001 IEP, but that rationale does not support the 30-minute reduction in overall services. Furthermore, Ms. Brady’s testimony indicated that although she believed that overall amount of STUDENT’s speech and language services was appropriate after February 2001, she would have preferred to see him in more individual therapy than in group therapy by February 2002. She testified that STUDENT was more successful and/or demonstrated more progress in individual therapy than in group therapy. She described how in individual sessions, STUDENT would perform well on an activity for 15 or 20 minutes, and then work on the computer as a reward. She stated that STUDENT’s group sessions were not as successful.
The Hearing Officer concludes that given STUDENT’s lack of documented progress in speech and language for the period from February 2001 to February 2002, a change in his services was warranted. Instead of changing STUDENT’s speech and language services, the District reduced his services significantly by 30 minutes per week. This was contrary to STUDENT’s needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the level of speech and language services offered by the District from February 2002 to February 2003 was neither designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in speech and language nor reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, thereby resulting in the denial of a FAPE.
February 2003 through the date of the due process hearing
The parties have not convened an IEP meeting since June 2002. Through the date of the due process hearing, STUDENT has remained at Ole Hanson in Ms. Johnson’s SDC and has received the same speech and language services as offered in the February 2002 IEP. During that time, the Petitioner has maintained his assertion that the level of speech and language services is inadequate. Ms. Brady’s testimony indicated that STUDENT’s progress has remained at about the same rate for the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years. The evidence did not show that STUDENT’s rate of progress has justified continuation of the same program deemed by the Hearing Officer to be inadequate through February 2003. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the level of speech and language services offered by the District from February 2003 through May 2003 was neither designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in speech and language nor reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, thereby resulting in the denial of a FAPE.
C. Failing to place STUDENT in mainstream classes with a full-time one-to-one aide.
Special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and mandates that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. §1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code §56031.
STUDENT’s IEPs during the years at issue in this case generally provided for about three-fourths of each school day to be exclusively in a special education setting. STUDENT had opportunities for interaction with typical peers at recess, lunch, and supervised after-school programs. During the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years, STUDENT also attended some mainstream classes. The Petitioner asserts that the District’s placement offers did not satisfy the requirements of LRE, and that the proper LRE would have been placement in mainstream classes for a major portion of each school day with a full-time one-to-one aide. This was one of the Petitioner’s chief issues
Dr. Majors stated that STUDENT needs daily exposure to peers who will model typical language and behavior. She believes that with STUDENT’s level of intellectual functioning being in the normal range, it would be appropriate to provide him with such exposure by placing him in a regular education classroom and by continuing his participation in an after-school program with opportunities for socialization with typical peers. She testified that it was inappropriate to have STUDENT in an SDC with children who either could not talk or, at best, could not model speech for STUDENT in the manner of typical peers. She acknowledged that STUDENT has behavior issues, but she believed those behavior problems would be manageable with an appropriate behavior plan, meaning an overall plan or program that also addressed STUDENT’s OT-related deficits and auditory processing deficits, if any. In her OT report, Ms. Cohen recommended that to facilitate modeling of typical peers, STUDENT should be placed in a program emphasizing socialization with regular education students his own age.
STUDENT’s past and current performance in regular education settings was described by several District witnesses. District teacher Matt Colapinto testified that STUDENT was mainstreamed into his fifth-grade regular education class during the 2001-2002 school year. STUDENT attended Mr. Colapinto’s class for 30 minutes each day for approximately 12 weeks while the class was engaged either in oral language or math. The oral language exercise involved Mr. Colapinto writing sentences on the board, and the students were asked to identify and correct the errors in the sentences. Mr. Colapinto testified that STUDENT required constant attention by Randi Vazzano, the one-to-one aide. STUDENT would have some form of outburst every minute or two. He would be out of his seat to lie on the floor or to go to the library. More often, he would be vocalizing loudly, “yelling” phrases such as “books, books!” STUDENT was interested in the classroom library, and access to the library was given to him as part of a reward system. During the oral language exercise, STUDENT could copy from the board, with assistance, at what appeared to be about second-grade level. He could not follow the lecture portions, and instead would draw or look at books. By the end of the twelve-week period, Mr. Colapinto observed that STUDENT might detect one or two spelling errors of the 10 or 15 errors listed on the board during the oral language exercise. He stated that Ms. Vazzano was always with STUDENT and quite helpful, but he saw no improvement in STUDENT’s behavior and no academic improvement. He stated that although STUDENT’s outbursts were distracting and disruptive to the class, the regular education students were polite to STUDENT and helped him with his self esteem. However, Mr. Colapinto stated that STUDENT generally appeared to be “in his own world” and did not notice the other children in the classroom. He saw no purpose to be served by STUDENT being in the class.
Ms. Vazzano testified that she has been STUDENT’s one-to-one independence facilitator for the past five years. She stated that although STUDENT knows the campus at Ole Hanson and knows the location of his classes and the office, his seizures and other health problems make it inadvisable for him to be without an aide. Her testimony about STUDENT’s performance in Mr. Colapinto’s class was consistent with Mr. Colapinto’s testimony. She testified that STUDENT currently attends Sue Puccinelli’s regular education class for 30 minutes each day. Because STUDENT’s behavior is better in Ms. Puccinelli’s class than it was during the prior year in Mr. Colapinto’s class, she occasionally keeps him in the regular education class for more than 30 minutes. STUDENT tends to stay close to her in Ms. Puccinelli’s class and is out of his seat less often. She stated that his behaviors in Ms. Puccinelli’s class are distracting to the other students, but they can “handle it.” She believes that STUDENT’s behavior in the SDC is about the same as his behavior in the regular education classes. She believes that STUDENT has gained at least a small amount of academic benefit from being in Ms. Puccinelli’s class. She testified that the work STUDENT is asked to do in regular education classes is not modified for him; instead, he attempts to do the same work as the other students. Ms. Vazzano also testified that STUDENT has needed her with him at all times in Cynthia Johnson’s SDC. She believes that STUDENT has made little progress academically during the past two years in the SDC. She stated that STUDENT makes his needs known to her by writing or talking. Socially, he is starting to initiate conversation with typical peers, but she does not think that he models other children.(Footnote 25)
Ms. Puccinelli testified that STUDENT has attended her fifth-grade regular education class at Ole Hanson during the 2002-2003 school year for about 30 minutes each day. She stated that STUDENT needs Ms. Vazzano’s constant attention. He is quite vocal in the classroom, but the vocalizations are most frequently off topic or otherwise inappropriate. She stated that STUDENT’s frequent vocalizations and other behaviors are a distraction to the extent that it takes her focus away from teaching the other students, and she needs time to regroup and regain her “train of thought.” Approximately 12 times during the school year, Ms. Vazzano has had to remove STUDENT from the classroom. To her, STUDENT seems to be in his own world. She does not see progress being made and does not know whether STUDENT is benefitting from being in her classroom. She has asked STUDENT to share in front of the class, but he does not do it. According to Ms. Puccinelli, STUDENT does not initiate conversation with his classmates, and he does not interact with them. She testified that STUDENT generally does not respond to her and does seem to know who she is; thus, she relies on Ms. Vazzano. He usually responds to Ms. Vazzano’s redirections.
Cynthia Johnson testified that she has been STUDENT’s SDC teacher for the past two school years. She described how STUDENT has made academic progress in certain areas, but his skills are “splintered” because of his autism. Her description of STUDENT’s behavior in the SDC class was consistent with the testimony of his teachers and one-to-one aide. She testified that STUDENT perseverates, often engages in nonstop video talking, is compulsive and often inappropriately takes things that belong to other people, is often out of his seat, and lays on the floor or against his one-to-one aide. She stated that STUDENT’s verbal outbursts were significantly disruptive, even with the class having only twelve students and with STUDENT’s one-to-one aide and her own classroom aide present.
Kelly McKinnon testified that she provides consultation to the District in matters related to autism and behavior analysis. She first met STUDENT in January or February 2002, observing him while he received IBI (intensive behavioral intervention) services in his after-school social skills program at Los Palmas.(Footnote 26) She stated that the group had three children with autism and three typical peers and met 90 minutes twice per week after school for snack, outdoor activities, and language activities. She observed that STUDENT had difficulty talking with peers on topic and sitting and attending for group discussion. He had perseverative talk about videos or off-topic subjects and often sat too close to children’s faces or bodies. He enjoyed outdoor games such as kickball, but had difficulty attending to the game and the ball. He seemed to enjoy being with other children and initiated topics for conversation, but the topics were generally perseverative in nature.(Footnote 27)
District autism program specialist Charla Pitzen testified that she oversees the IBI program. She has observed STUDENT at school and consulted with his teachers. She “absolutely disagrees” that STUDENT should be placed in a regular education class instead of an SDC. She stated that although she considers herself to be a major advocate of LRE, STUDENT needs continuous monitoring, prompting, and/or intervention. He does not respond to instructions written on the board in the classroom, and he does not make a “direct connection” with the teachers in regular education classroom settings. Instead, instructions and information must be restated by his one-to-one aide. She believes that placement in a regular education classroom for an entire school day would be detrimental to STUDENT. She believes that STUDENT has great difficulty “connecting” with typical peers in a regular education classroom, and he would not currently benefit socially or otherwise from placing major reliance on that format. Instead, she believes that to interact with typical peers, STUDENT needs the assistance offered by a structured format, such as in the social skills group containing typical peers.
As summarized above in the Background Facts, STUDENT was making progress and meeting more than a few of his goals and objectives in school readiness skills and academics through the 2000-2001 school year. Thus, STUDENT’s time in the SDCs had been productive. Given STUDENT’s behavior, attention, and speech and language deficits, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that placing STUDENT in a regular education setting for more time than what the District offered and provided through the 2000-2001 school year would have been counterproductive to meeting STUDENT’s needs and to having STUDENT make educational progress. In the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT’s excursion into a regular education classroom provided him with marginal benefit, if any. The results from STUDENT’s part-time placement in Mr. Colapinto’s class confirm that more time in a regular education setting during the 2001-2002 school year would not have been appropriate. In the 2002-2003 school year, the evidence showed that STUDENT’s time in Ms. Puccinelli’s regular education class was at least somewhat more positive than in Mr. Colapinto’s class. However, the results from being in Ms. Puccinelli’s class did not warrant or require placement in a regular education setting beyond the after-school social skills group and the other provisions of the District’s program. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program during the school years at issue was consistent with the requirements of LRE.
Issue 3: Because of the District’s failure to appropriately assess STUDENT and failure to provide STUDENT a FAPE, is the District required to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of private assessments and to provide STUDENT with compensatory education and other remedies?
(1) Reimbursement for private assessments.
Cal. Educ. Code section 56329(b) provides that a parent has a right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, if the district’s assessment, through a due process hearing, is determined to be appropriate, the parent is not entitled to have the independent assessment at public expense. In the present case, STUDENT’s parents seek reimbursement for private assessments consisting of SPA’s speech and language assessments in July 2002 and January 2003, Ms. Cohen’s OT assessment conducted in February and March 2003, and the neuropsychological assessment by Dr. Majors. STUDENT’s mother indicated in her testimony that she obtained the private assessments because she was skeptical of the District’s assessments and disagreed with them.
The Hearing Officer has found that the District’s assessment was inappropriate to the extent the District failed to conduct an OT assessment and failed to assess for an auditory processing disorder. Accordingly, STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Ms. Cohen’s OT assessment, shown by invoice to be $800.00. The parents are not entitled to the cost of Ms. Cohen’s testimony at hearing or her preparation for that testimony, as those costs were incurred strictly in anticipation of litigation and were not part of her assessment. The July 2002 speech and language assessment by SPA stressed the need for an auditory processing evaluation. STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of SPA’s July 2002 assessment. No invoice for that assessment was presented at the hearing.
The Hearing Officer has found that the matter of verbal apraxia was appropriately a non-issue in District assessments and observations and in SPA’s July 2002 assessment. Therefore, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the January 2003 verbal apraxia assessment by SPA. Dr. Majors’ report mentions OT deficits and the need for an auditory processing evaluation. However, a private OT assessment had already been performed by Ms. Cohen, and an auditory processing evaluation had already been recommended in the July 2002 SPA report. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Majors’ assessment.(Footnote 28)
(2) Compensatory education and other remedies.
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district fails to provide a FAPE, and the placement or services are determined to be appropriate under the IDEA. Equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358. Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1486. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. See Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation for missed services. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.
In the present case, the Hearing Officer has found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by (a) offering no services designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit in the area of OT for the period from April 3, 2000, through May 2003; and (b) failing to offer a level of speech and language services from February 2002 through May 2003 designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit in the area of speech and language. The Hearing Officer has also found that (c) until STUDENT undergoes a comprehensive auditory processing evaluation by a qualified audiologist, the specific nature of STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of auditory processing and the services necessary to appropriately address those needs cannot be determined. The remedy for each of the above will now be addressed.
Occupational therapy. The Hearing Officer has previously found that STUDENT needs services to address sensory-integration deficits that have likely caused or contributed to his sensory-seeking behaviors and his ongoing history of being easily distracted and being verbally and physically impulsive. Testimony from witnesses for both parties confirmed that STUDENT’s behaviors are a major obstacle to his progress in speech and language, social skills, and academics, and to his ability to be further mainstreamed into the regular education setting.
Ms. Cohen recommended that STUDENT receive two 50-minute individual OT sessions per week to address his deficits “in the OT-related areas of sensory processing, motor planning, work behaviors, and peer interaction.” She also recommended OT consultation to school personnel, placement in a regular education program emphasizing socialization with typical peers STUDENT’s own age, and utilizing “a multi-sensorial approach to learning and encouraging hands on exploration to problem solve new activities.” She testified that because of the physical apparatus needed for individual therapy, the individual therapy should be clinic-based. The Petitioner seeks implementation of Ms. Cohen’s recommendations for a period of approximately three years.
The evidence demonstrates that STUDENT’s sensory-integration and other OT-related deficits are most likely having widespread adverse affects upon STUDENT’s behavior and ability to be receptive to teaching, related services, and efforts at socialization. Thus, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that OT services to address STUDENT’s OT-related deficits are a critical area of need for STUDENT. Furthermore, testimony showed that the effectiveness of services in OT, speech and language, and auditory processing should be expected to diminish as a child becomes older, and STUDENT is already at or approaching the point where age will be a negative factor in his progress. Accordingly, STUDENT needs intensive services forthwith.
STUDENT’s IEP shall be amended to provide for his receipt of two 50-minute individual OT sessions per week, plus OT consultation to school personnel, to address STUDENT’s deficits in the OT-related areas of sensory-processing/sensory-integration, motor planning, work behaviors, and peer interaction. The IEP team shall develop annual goals and short-term objectives for the areas addressed by OT. The matters of apportionment of therapy time between STUDENT’s respective OT-related deficits, apportionment between clinic-based OT and school-site OT, and details regarding OT consultation shall be placed in the discretion of the IEP team, thereby enabling the team to incorporate future assessment data into STUDENT’s program. The amount of OT-related services specified above shall continue for a period of at least one year. At the end of one year, STUDENT’s IEP team shall, on the basis of STUDENT’s progress and other factors existing at that time, determine future amounts of OT-related services and the nature of those services in a manner consistent with the findings in this Decision.
Speech and language. The Hearing Officer has found that the level of speech and language services offered by the District was appropriate until the District reduced services from 135 minutes per week to 105 minutes per week commencing in February 2002. Speech and language is a crucial area of need for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory speech and language services for the denial of FAPE in that area.
The amount of compensatory speech and language services shall be left to the discretion of the IEP team. When determining the amount and nature of compensatory speech and language services, the IEP team shall devise a program consistent with the following findings: (a) speech and language is a crucial area of need for STUDENT; (b) speech and language services at the level of 135 hours per week, with most of those minutes being in individual therapy, was the minimum level of speech and language services required for FAPE from February 2002 through May 2003; (c) prior to February 2002, STUDENT’s progress in speech and language had slowed significantly even while he was receiving 135 minutes of therapy per week; thus, different strategies must be considered by the IEP team.
Auditory processing. The services necessary for meeting STUDENT’s FAPE requirements in the area of auditory processing, if any, will be left to the discretion of STUDENT’s IEP team following the team’s procurement of a comprehensive auditory processing assessment performed by a qualified audiologist. If the auditory processing assessment confirms that STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder, STUDENT’s IEP team shall also determine whether STUDENT should receive compensatory education services for what would then be evidenced as a longstanding denial of FAPE in the area of auditory processing. In that event, the IEP team shall consider the following findings: (a) compensatory education related to the auditory processing issue may properly include enhanced services designed to remediate STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits, and it may also include extra services to address other areas affected by STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits; and (b) given STUDENT’s age, time would be of the essence in addressing and attempting to remediate auditory processing deficits.
ORDERS
1. Within 15 days from the date of this Decision and thereafter as necessary, STUDENT’s IEP team shall meet and do the following:
(A) amend STUDENT’s IEP to provide for two 50-minute individual OT sessions per week, plus OT consultation to school personnel, to address STUDENT’s deficits in the OT-related areas of sensory-processing/sensory-integration, motor planning, work behaviors, and peer interaction;
(B) develop annual goals and short-term objectives for the areas addressed by OT.
2. The matters of apportionment of therapy time between STUDENT’s respective OT-related deficits, apportionment between clinic-based OT and school-site OT, and details regarding OT consultation are placed in the discretion of the IEP team, thereby enabling the team to incorporate future assessment data into STUDENT’s program.
3. The amount of OT-related services specified above shall continue for a period of at least one year. At the end of one year, STUDENT’s IEP team shall, on the basis of STUDENT’s progress and other factors existing at that time, determine future amounts of OT-related services and the nature of those services in a manner consistent with the finding in this Decision that OT services to address STUDENT’s OT-related deficits have been, and at the date of this Decision currently remain, a critical area of need for STUDENT.
4. At the same IEP meetings as ordered above, the IEP team shall formulate a compensatory speech and language program consistent with the following findings:
(A) speech and language is a crucial area of need for STUDENT;
(B) speech and language services at the level of 135 hours per week, with most of those minutes being in individual therapy, was the minimum level of speech and language services required for FAPE from February 2002 through May 2003, yet the District only offered 105 minutes per week;
(C) prior to February 2002, STUDENT’s progress in speech and language had slowed significantly even while he was receiving 135 minutes of therapy per week; thus, different strategies must be considered by the IEP team.
5. At the same IEP meetings as ordered above, the team shall develop a plan for a comprehensive auditory processing assessment by a qualified audiologist. The assessment plan shall provide that in the event the assessor confirms an auditory processing disorder, the assessor shall be asked to comment on how the auditory processing disorder may have affected STUDENT’s progress in the areas of speech and language, social skills, academics, and/or behavior, and what services are recommended, if any, to remediate the auditory processing deficits.
6. If the auditory processing assessment ordered above confirms that STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder, STUDENT’s IEP team shall develop a plan to address the auditory processing disorder. The plan shall specify present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and services. In that event, STUDENT’s IEP team shall also determine whether STUDENT should receive compensatory education services and the nature and amount of such services for what would then be evidenced as a longstanding denial of FAPE arising from the District’s failure to appropriately address STUDENT’s auditory processing disorder from April 3, 2000, through May 2003. In making that determination, the IEP team shall consider the following findings:
(A) compensatory education related to the auditory processing issue may properly include enhanced services designed to remediate STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits, and it may also include extra services to address other areas affected by STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits; and (B) given STUDENT’s age, time is of the essence in addressing auditory processing deficits. 7. Within 30 days from the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse to STUDENT’s parents $800.00 for the cost of Ms. Cohen’s February and March 2003 OT assessment.
8. Within 30 days after receipt by the District of a correct invoice for the cost of the July 2002 speech and language assessment by SPA, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the reasonable cost of that assessment. Reimbursement shall not include amounts charged by SPA or Ms. Moore for testimony at the due process hearing or preparation for that testimony.
9. All other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
Issue 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE from April 3, 2000, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year by failing to hold a “pre-IEP” meeting pursuant to Cal. Gov. Code section 7572 (a),(c), and (d)(1)? The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE from April 3, 2000, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year and during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, and 2002-2003 school years by:
A. Failing to conduct assessment in the areas of OT, verbal apraxia, and auditory processing. The Petitioner prevailed with regard to OT and auditory processing. The District prevailed with regard to verbal apraxia.
B. Failing to offer services and goals and objectives addressing OT-related needs, verbal apraxia, and auditory processing, and failing to offer an appropriate level of services to address STUDENT’s speech and language deficits. The Petitioner prevailed with regard to OT. The Petitioner prevailed partially with regard to auditory processing and speech and language. The District prevailed with regard to verbal apraxia.
C. Failing to place STUDENT in mainstream classes with a full-time one-to-one aide? The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue 3: Because of the District’s failure to appropriately assess STUDENT and failure to provide STUDENT a FAPE, is the District required to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of private assessments and to provide STUDENT with compensatory education and other remedies? With respect to reimbursement, the Petitioner prevailed to the extent that reimbursement was awarded for the OT assessment and one of two speech and language assessments; the District prevailed to the extent that reimbursement was not awarded for hearing preparation and testimony by the occupational therapist, for one of two speech and language assessments, for hearing preparation and testimony by SPA and/or Ms. Moore, and for Dr. Majors’ report and hearing preparation and testimony.
With respect to other remedies, the Petitioner prevailed on the relief related to OT and partially prevailed on the relief related to speech and language and auditory processing.(Footnote 29)
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code §56505(i).
Dated: July 7, 2003 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The Petitioner’s allegations regarding “verbal apraxia” were initially phrased in terms of “oral-motor apraxia.” Throughout the course of the hearing it became evident that the term most applicable to the Petitioner’s contentions in this area was “verbal apraxia,” also referred to at various times during the hearing as “verbal dyspraxia,” “speech apraxia,” and “language apraxia.” “Oral apraxia,” defined elsewhere in this Decision, was not an issue, and the Petitioner’s own expert, Ms. Moore, testified that STUDENT did not appear to have oral apraxia. 2. From first grade through the beginning of third grade (October 2000), STUDENT received discrete trial training/applied behavior intervention services through the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD). 3. For the extended school year from June 27 to July 27, 2001, the parent and the District agreed to have STUDENT receive IBI services ten hours per week at Crown Valley. 4. The notes in the February 2002 IEP state that STUDENT’s behavior problems had escalated after a change in medications for his seizures. The notes also describe how STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Ms. Johnson, considered STUDENT’s relative academic strengths to include writing, spelling, and reading (but only in reading decoding). He was writing two- to three-word sentences. He continued to have significant problems focusing on activities, especially without prompts. The parents expressed concern about STUDENT’s after-school program and were inquiring about the Boys and Girls Club as an after-school program. The District proposed moving STUDENT’s after-school program from Los Palmas to the YMCA program at Ole Hanson where, for two hours daily, STUDENT would receive homework support for his goals and objectives and support for his social skills development. The proposed move in after-school programs would be supported by a transition plan. 5. “Video talk” was described by witnesses as meaning persistent repetition or words or phrases that STUDENT had likely heard in videos. STUDENT’s particular perseverations were not described in the IEP. 6. Cal. Gov. Code section 7572(a) provides that before any action is taken with respect to the provision of “related services” or “designated instruction and services” to a child, the child shall first be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability in accordance with the procedures specified in Cal. Educ. Code section 56320 et seq. Section 7572(d) provides that such services shall only be added to a child’s IEP by the IEP team. Section 7572(d)(1) provides that whenever an OT, physical therapy, or psychotherapy or other mental health assessment has been conducted pursuant to section 7572(b) or (c), the recommendation of the person who conducted the assessment shall be reviewed and discussed with the parent and with appropriate members of the IEP team “prior to the meeting of the ... [IEP] team. When the proposed recommendation of the person has been discussed with the parent and there is disagreement on the recommendation pertaining to the related service, the parent shall be notified in writing and may require the person who conducted the assessment to attend the ... [IEP] meeting to discuss the recommendation.” 7. Except for Issue 1, the Petitioner’s specific contentions with respect to each school year are almost identical. Therefore, for purposes of clarity in analysis and to the extent feasible, the Hearing Officer will concurrently examine the contentions for all of the school years at issue. 8. The observations by Ms. Cohen largely concern matters that had already been documented in District assessments, but the District demonstrated no attempt to consolidate that data into an OT assessment or have an occupational therapist make recommendations for addressing OT-related needs. Ms. Cohen administered no standardized or criterion-referenced tests, but she did consolidate her observations into a report that described STUDENT’s OT-related deficits and made recommendations for addressing his needs arising from those deficits. 9. The 2002-2003 school year was at issue in this case. Because the parties have been in what is analogous to a “stay put” situation throughout the 2002-2003 school year and the hearing convened and concluded a few days prior to the end of the 2002-2003 school year, several of the findings in this Decision will be written as being applicable to the period through May 2003 instead of through the end of the 2002-2003 school year. 10. The District eventually offered an OT assessment as part of an assessment plan proposed by the District either in November 2002, and/or February and April 2003 (District Ex. 33). The plan was signed several days prior to the due process hearing. 11. STUDENT had been evaluated by the Newport Speech and Language Center in September 2001. The report was cited in testimony and documentary evidence, but no copy of the report was offered as evidence. Similarly, the 1997 CDE report was cited in testimony and documentary evidence, but no copy of the CDE report was offered as evidence. 12. Ms. Moore is the clinic director at SPA. She testified that she has about 35 years of experience as a speech and language pathologist. Ms. Lappi is the District special education director. Ms. Lappi testified that she has about 21 years of experience as a speech and language pathologist. Each testified regarding her extensive experience serving children with autism. 13. This sequence of analysis will enable the Hearing Officer to give appropriate consideration to ongoing and more-recent data on STUDENT, thereby lessening reliance on the District’s speech and language reports, written more than three years ago, and on double-hearsay references to the six-years-old CDE report. 14. Italics by the Hearing Officer.
15. Ms. Toyama’s July 2002 report was reviewed and signed by Ms. Moore. The report mentions poor speech intelligibility. Notwithstanding Ms. Moore’s testimony that verbal apraxia is one of the first areas she would evaluate in a child with poor speech intelligibility, the report contains no recommendation to assess for verbal apraxia. 16. The report acknowledged that STUDENT’s scores on the KSPT were to be interpreted with caution because the 72-month age level is the highest age level for which the test is normed. 17. Although Ms. Brady was a District employee and witness, she did not hesitate to offer her opinion that, contrary to the provisions of STUDENT’s February 2002 IEP, STUDENT should be receiving more individual speech and language therapy and less group therapy 18. Italics by the Hearing Officer.
19. State and federal law also requires that the district’s program conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), §1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code §56031; Rowley, supra. Furthermore, the student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20. U.S.C. §1414(d), 34 C.F.R. §300.347(a). Neither of the above matters were at issue in the present case. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. 960 F.2d at 1484. In the present case, application of a procedural violation analysis to the Petitioner’s assertions would not affect the outcome of this Decision. 20. The parties have indicated that the District’s proposed triennial assessment plans were or presently are the subject of a different due process hearing request. 21. Ms. Bland attended the February 1999 and February 2000 IEP meetings, and she helped to formulate the speech and language goals and objectives at those meetings. 22. She considered that situation to be a consequence of STUDENT’s autism. 23. The February 2001 IEP is considered by the Hearing Officer to provide a change in speech and language services, not a reduction in services. 24. Ms. Brady attended the February 2002 IEP meeting.
25. Ms. Vazzano testified that she most likely had not seen STUDENT’s behavior management plans, although portions of the plans had been explained to her. She testified that she did not know whether sensory processing deficits could affect a child’s behavior, and she did not know whether she was doing anything to address auditory processing deficits. 26. Ms. Mckinnon testified that the IBI program utilized applied behavioral intervention (ABA) techniques, wherein a basic skill is taught by breaking it into discrete steps and using reinforcement strategies, then gradually fading the prompts. 27. STUDENT’s mother testified regarding her concerns and criticisms of the social skills groups and after-school programs offered to STUDENT. Some of those concerns were addressed by the testimony of District witnesses. Further examination of these matters by the Hearing Officer would not affect the outcome of this Decision. 28. Although the record indicated a possible link whereby the parents’ decision to obtain an OT assessment originated with Dr. Majors and was relayed to the parents by SPA, that connection would be too remote to support reimbursement for Dr. Majors’ assessment and/or the January 2003 SPA assessment. 29. The Hearing Officer did not caution the parties to limit their closing briefs to a particular length, although experienced counsel and advocates should know that reasonableness is expected. The Petitioner submitted a 114-page closing brief. The excessive length of that brief was nonproductive to Hearing Officer’s analysis of this case. By comparison, the length of the District’s 19-page closing brief was appropriate for summarizing background facts as requested by the Hearing Officer and for addressing the matters at issue.
