California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 4, 2002
Student v. Poway Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 658-01 · Hearing Officer Judy F. Hirano
Poway Unified must complete an occupational therapy assessment; Hearing Officer finds no denial of FAPE in 2000-2001 school year.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None stated. The decision refers to earlier SEHO decisions in SN 442-99 and SN 232-00 and to SN 1523-00, which was dismissed under a settlement agreement in October 2000.
Summary
A 13-year-old's mother, representing him herself, challenged Poway Unified School District's program for the 2000-2001 school year. He was home-schooled until January 2001, when he returned to Mesa Verde Middle School on a shortened schedule of resource specialist classes. He was first eligible under speech or language impairment and was found eligible for a specific learning disability in February 2001.
The Hearing Officer upheld Dr. Mark McDonough's neuropsychological assessment. He skipped two tests checked on the assessment plan, but he used comparable tests and reviewed them with the parent, and other assessors covered auditory processing. However, the District failed to assess occupational therapy (OT) needs. The adapted PE motor test did not measure handwriting, which was the known concern, and the assessor was not an occupational therapist.
On FAPE, the District properly held a September 2000 IEP meeting without the parent after documented efforts to get her there. Holding the May 2001 meeting without a general education teacher was a procedural violation, but it did not deny FAPE. The IEPs addressed his needs and gave him some educational benefit. Leaving mental health goals out of the IEP was a minor flaw because the parent declined those services. She also declined added general education time and did not pursue the ESY the District offered. No compensatory services were awarded. The District must complete an OT assessment within 25 days and hold an IEP meeting within 40 days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled an adapted PE motor test offered in place of an OT assessment. The Hearing Officer found it inadequate because it did not test handwriting, the known area of concern, and the assessor was not an occupational therapist. It also shows how declined services and parent scheduling choices weighed against FAPE claims.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1(a). Did the District conduct appropriate assessments during 2000-2001, given that Dr. McDonough's November 2000 neuropsychological assessment did not administer the TAPS-R and VMI-4 marked on the assessment plan and did not diagnose a specific learning disability?
The neuropsychological assessment was appropriate. The plan listed tests that 'may include, but are not limited to' those marked; the parent reviewed the tests in advance; comparable tests were given; auditory processing was adequately assessed; and the depression finding matched other assessments.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 1(b). Did the District fail to assess all areas of suspected disability by not conducting an occupational therapy assessment of fine motor skills after the parent's December 2000 request?
The adapted PE assessment did not assess handwriting, the known OT concern, and the assessor was not a qualified occupational therapist. The District failed to assess an area of suspected disability and must conduct an OT assessment.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2A(1). Did the District deny FAPE by holding the September 20, 2000 IEP meeting without a parent present?
The District scheduled the meeting at a time the parent said she was available, documented its efforts including phone calls, and was unable to convince the parent to attend. There was no procedural violation that denied FAPE.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue 2A(2). Did the District deny FAPE by convening the May 3, 2001 IEP meeting without a regular education teacher?
The teacher's absence was a procedural violation. It caused no loss of educational opportunity or serious infringement on parent participation: the parent consented to proceed, and the assistant principal and resource teacher knew the grade 7 curriculum.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2B(a). Was the District's program during the 2000-2001 school year (February 9, 2000, December 13, 2000, and February 6, 2001 IEPs) substantively appropriate: designed to meet unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, in conformity with the IEP, and in the least restrictive environment?
The IEPs addressed the student's needs and provided some educational benefit. Leaving the AB 3632 mental health goals out of the IEP was a de minimis technical violation because the parent declined those services. The parent declined added general education time, and the District did not keep him from attending classes before January 2001.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 2B(b). Did the District deny FAPE by failing to provide ESY during summer 2001 under the February 6, 2001 IEP?
The District offered ESY. The parent showed interest in regular summer school instead and did not pursue ESY, so there was no denial of FAPE.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3(a). Is Petitioner entitled to Lindamood Bell services as compensatory education?
No compensatory services were awarded because FAPE was not denied.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3(b). Is Petitioner entitled to cognitive remediation services as compensatory education?
No compensatory services were awarded because FAPE was not denied.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3(c). Is Petitioner entitled to counseling services from Charles Hogan, Ph.D., as compensatory education?
No compensatory services were awarded because FAPE was not denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to assess. Within 25 calendar days of the decision, the District shall arrange for, provide, and complete an occupational therapy assessment of Petitioner's educational need for OT by a qualified occupational therapist (conforming to Gov. Code § 7572).
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 40 calendar days of the decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to review the OT assessment and revise the IEP as necessary.
Key authorities
Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982); W.G. v. Board of Trustees, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992); 34 C.F.R. § 300.345; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f); Cal. Gov't Code § 7572(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5; Cal. Educ. Code § 56343.5
People named in the decision
- Emily Shieh, program specialist (District representative at hearing), Poway Unified School District
- Mary L. Cote, hearing officer (observer), Special Education Hearing Office
- Theresa Kurtz, special education director, secondary program, Poway Unified School District
- Linda Scarpa, school psychologist, Poway Unified School District
- Jon Eyler, former resource specialist teacher and case manager, Mesa Verde Middle School, Poway Unified School District
- Laura Hulsey, school psychologist (January 2001 psychological assessment), Poway Unified School District
- Martha Ingham, Ph.D., head school psychologist, East Region, Poway Unified School District
- Gayle Kehrli, school psychologist (administered CAS), Poway Unified School District
- Mark McDonough, Ph.D., clinical neuropsychologist; independent neuropsychological assessor
- Herbert Hudgins, director, student welfare and attendance, Poway Unified School District
- JoAnn Murphy, executive director, special education and health services, Poway Unified School District
- Deborah Toups, assistant director, special education, Poway Unified School District
- Roger Tso, former assistant principal, Black Mountain Middle School
- Marilyn Pobiner, resource specialist, Poway Unified School District
- Dorothy Long, resource specialist, Poway Unified School District
- Gail Adams, M.Ed., resource specialist (academic assessment), Poway Unified School District
- Jill Gonzalez, program specialist; former adapted PE teacher who conducted the APE assessment, Poway Unified School District
- Todd Pizitz, Ph.D., registered psychologist, county mental health outpatient provider, Children's Rancho Bernardo Center
- Charles Hogan, Ph.D., private treating psychologist
- Judith Hooyen, L.C.S.W., AB 3632 mental health assessor, San Diego County Mental Health Services
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Diego, California, on September 18-19, October 4-5, 10-11, 18-19, November 13-16, 2001, and January 15, 2002. STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented by his mother, PARENT. Also present on his behalf for a few days were support persons SUPPORT PERSON 1 and SUPPORT PERSON 2. Respondent Poway Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Justin Shinnefield. Also present on the District’s behalf for most of the days was Emily Shieh, program specialist. Mary L. Cote, hearing officer, was present as an observer on September 18, 2001. Petitioner requested an open hearing, and members of the public were observers on several days.
Petitioner and Respondent called the following witnesses: PARENT, STUDENT’S mother; Theresa Kurtz, District special education director, secondary program; Linda Scarpa, District school psychologist; Jon Eyler, former resource specialist teacher, Mesa Verde Middle School; Laura Hulsey, District school psychologist; Martha Ingham, Ph.D., District head school psychologist, East Region; Gayle Kehrli, District school psychologist; and Mark McDonough, Ph.D., clinical neuropsychologist. Petitioner also called the following witnesses: Herbert Hudgins, District director, student welfare and attendance; JoAnn Murphy, District executive director, special education and health services; Deborah Toups, District assistant director, special education; Roger Tso, former assistant principal, Black Mountain Middle School; Marilyn Pobiner, District resource specialist; and Dorothy Long, District resource specialist. Respondent also called the following witnesses: Gail Adams, M.Ed., District resource specialist; Jill Gonzalez, District program specialist; and Todd Pizitz, Ph.D., registered psychologist, Children’s Rancho Bernardo Center.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. The parties’ closing briefs were received. Following a ruling on Petitioner’s request that the Hearing Officer listen to an audiotape admitted as his Exhibit 50, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for a decision.(Footnote 1)
ISSUES(Footnote 2)
Issue 1: Did the District conduct appropriate assessments of Petitioner during the 2000- 2001 school year?
Issue 2: Did the District deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) on procedural and substantive grounds during the 2000-2001 school year, including the summer 2001 ESY session?
Issue 3: If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, including summer 2001, is he entitled to the following as compensatory education services:
a. Lindamood Bell?
b. Cognitive remediation services?
c. Counseling services from Charles Hogan, Ph.D.?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 13-year old eighth-grader within the Poway Unified School District. He was first found eligible for special education because of a speech and language impairment and, during the 2000-2001 school year, a specific learning disability (SLD). He has a significant history of allergies and has been diagnosed with dysthymic disorder. In the past, he has received speech and language services, adapted physical education (APE), occupational therapy (OT), and designated instruction and services (DIS) counseling. During 2000, he receive private therapy from a psychologist.
STUDENT was first found eligible for special education because of a speech and language impairment in February 1992 and received speech and language services for articulation for a number of years. The facts related to his early school years have been set forth in prior Hearing Office Decisions in case numbers SN 442-99 and SN 232-00. (Dist. Exhs. 15 and 16.) In June 1998, before STUDENT’S fifth-grade year, a speech and language evaluation conducted at Children’s Rancho Bernardo Center (Rancho Bernardo) diagnosed a moderate central auditory processing disorder, mild to moderate receptive and expressive language disorder, and mild articulation impairment. A July 1998 psychological evaluation conducted by District school psychologist Linda Scarpa to determine DIS counseling eligibility indicated that anxiety, depression, self-esteem, and social inadequacy issues interfered with his classroom performance. Counseling, direct teaching of appropriate social behavior, and social skills training were recommended.
Also in July 1998, District school psychologist Martha Ingham, Ph.D., assessed STUDENT for suspected SLD. On the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III), he obtained a 91 verbal IQ, 89 performance IQ, and 89 full-scale IQ, in the low average range. However, Dr. Ingham concluded that he had an estimated average intellectual ability and that difficulties on tasks requiring attention, concentration, quick processing, planning, and memory suppressed his IQ scores. STUDENT’S score on the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration revealed no delay. His Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML) Memory Screening Index was in the average range. He reported having no friends and displayed showed motor functions. Projective assessments showed symptoms of depression and anxiety stemming from inadequate social relations. Dr. Ingham concluded that STUDENT’S emotional problems, allergies, problems in thinking, and auditory processing deficit all contributed to his learning difficulty. She noted that the WISC-III results revealed a scatter suggestive of depression, anxiety, and poor contact with reality. STUDENT’S academic achievement scores were in the low average to average range. Dr. Ingham concluded that a significant discrepancy did not exist between ability and academic achievement and recommended DIS counseling and a participatory teaching approach.
A September 1998 APE assessment of STUDENT revealed difficulties in running speed and agility, balance, bilateral coordination, strength, and upper limb speed and dexterity. APE was recommended. An October 1998 OT assessment revealed motor coordination and speed concerns during fine motor tasks and handwriting. Short-term OT was recommended to increase hand strength and coordination to improve handwriting and speed in writing.
Prior Decisions in case numbers SN 442-99 and SN 232-00 addressed FAPE issues related to STUDENT’S grade 4, 5, and 6 years. During the 1999-2000 school year, when STUDENT was a sixth-grader at Black Mountain Middle School (Black Mountain), he was home-schooled by his mother beginning in approximately December 1999.(Footnote 3) During the 2000-2001 school year, he continued to be home-schooled until he started attending grade 7 at Mesa Verde Middle School (MVMS) on January 2, 2001.
A February 9, 2000 individualized education program (IEP), unsigned by the parent initially, was developed during STUDENT’S sixth-grade year. The recommended placement was a resource specialist program (RSP), with regular education for 53 to 65 percent of the time. The IEP provides for 30 minutes weekly of both speech and language services and DIS counseling; 30 minutes twice weekly of APE; and extended school year (ESY). The IEP states that STUDENT required specialized instruction in a small-group environment. The February 9 IEP sets forth goals and objectives for gross motor skills, language skills, self-esteem, peer interactions, task completion, task initiation, math, written language, and spelling. The IEP provides for behavior interventions to address inappropriate comments and inappropriate responses to peer teasing. On February 10, 2000, the parents filed for due process in another case, number SN 232-00.
A March 14, 2000 psychological summary by STUDENT’S private treating psychologist, Charles Hogan, Ph.D., states that STUDENT had significant social and emotional needs, identified in July 1998, which impeded his academic success. The mother’s concerns were his depression, withdrawal, and talk about killing himself if he had to return to Black Mountain. According to Dr. Hogan, STUDENT felt alienated, expected peer teasing, and experienced anxiety, resentfulness, and sadness. He occasionally engaged in provocative acts and angry outbursts. Dr. Hogan recommended continued treatment and a small school setting with integrated counseling services to assist STUDENT’S transition back to a general education setting with special education support.
At a March 23, 2000 hearing in case number SN 232-00, the parents and the District agreed to change the school to Bernardo Heights Middle School (Bernardo Heights). A March 23 addendum to the February 9, 2000 IEP indicates that the parent agreed to and signed the February 9 IEP as amended. The mother testified that STUDENT attended Bernardo Heights for only 3 days in April 2000.(Footnote 4) He then continued to be home-schooled by his mother. In August 2000, a Decision was issued in case number SN 232-00, and the mother again filed for due process in another case (number SN 1523-00). This case addressed her request for an independent educational evaluation (IEE). (Testimony of Ms. PARENT.) This case was resolved at an October 2000 hearing by the District’s agreement to conduct an early triennial assessment. It was later agreed that Mark McDonough, Ph.D., would do a neuropsychological assessment. On November 15, 2000, STUDENTenrolled at MVMS and began receiving APE and DIS counseling only. (Id.)
In November 2000, a speech and language assessment of STUDENT found no articulation problem and speech intelligibility and fluency to be within normal limits. An APE assessment found that STUDENT displayed age-appropriate gross motor skills and did not require APE. The District resource nurse also completed a health history and physical assessment. An academic assessment was also conducted. STUDENT’S Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) composite standard scores were as follows: Reading, 100; Math, 85; and Written Language, 90. On the Woodcock Johnson Tests of Achievement-Revised (WJ-R), he obtained the following standard scores: Broad Reading, 97; Broad Math, 95; and Broad Written Language, 78. He achieved the following composite standard scores on the Diagnostic Achievement Battery-Revised (DAB-2): Reading, 94; Math, 78; and Writing, 76.
In November 2000, Dr. McDonough conducted a neuropsychological assessment of STUDENT.(Footnote 5) On the WISC-III, STUDENT obtained 89 verbal, 86 performance, and 86 full-scale IQ scores, in the low-average range. Dr. McDonough noted that the drop in STUDENT’S WRAML Memory Screening Index from 37 percentile in 1998 to 7 percentile raised motivational concerns. His ability to discriminate between differences in pitch, rhythm, and phonemes was age-appropriate. His lowest WISC-III subtest score was for Digit Symbol, involving speeded fine-motor copying, and his writing ability was inordinately slow. Dr. McDonough concluded that significant visual-spatial speed and graphomotor deficits were likely caused by psychiatric factors. According to him, depressed persons generally exhibit slowed psychomotor activity. On the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory-A (MMPI-A), STUDENT displayed significantly elevated scores on the depression, anxiety, and social introversion scales. His Sentence Completion response for the phrase “Other kids” was “make fun of me.” Although his mother indicated that he had friendships, STUDENT felt close to no one. The mother’s Connors Rating Scale responses indicated an anxiety concern, and the teacher’s responses, a lack of emotional maturity. Dr. McDonough diagnosed a dysthymic disorder and concluded that issues of self-image, depression, anxiety, and a social isolation tendency and a reported history of suicidal ideation suggested a psychiatric maladjustment to factors such as obesity, social inadequacy, and below-average academic performance. He found no severe discrepancy between ability and achievement to support a determination of learning disability. He recommended individual counseling, family therapy, assessment of fine-motor skills, and weight control interventions.
A December 1, 2000 AB 3632(Footnote 6) assessment report by Judith Hooyen, L.C.S.W., of San Diego County Mental Health Services (CMH), recommended that STUDENT receive outpatient mental health services. She noted that he had a history of problems completing tasks and homework and of problematic peer relations. He feared ridicule from peers. Attached to the report is a CMH treatment plan, signed by the mother, which sets forth goals and objectives to enhance self-confidence and self-image and to improve task completion. A December 12, 2000 IEP addendum states that the IEP team agreed with the recommendation of AB 3632 services weekly for 6 months. The addendum states that the treatment would carry out the two mental health IEP goals.
A December 13, 2000 IEP provides for RSP services for 35 to 75 percent of the time, weekly AB 3632 outpatient services, and ESY. Triennial assessment results were reported for health history, academic achievement, speech and language, APE, and neuropsychology. The speech pathologist reported no current speech and language concerns. The APE teacher stated that APE was not required. Dr. McDonough reported a dysthymic disorder diagnosis and a weakness with fine-motor tasks requiring speed. He reported that there was no discrepancy between ability and achievement and no indication of an SLD. The IEP identifies speech and language impairment as the eligibility category but notes that current assessments did not find such an impairment. However, the IEP team recommended continuing services provided by the February 9, 2000 IEP until the February 2001 annual review. In the interim, further assessment would be conducted for possible emotional disturbance (ED) eligibility. The IEP sets forth an 8-period schedule for STUDENT starting on January 2, 2001, but the team agreed that he would start on a modified 4-period schedule (3 RSP classes and regular education P.E.) to assist with the transition back to school. For goals and objectives, the IEP refers to the February 9, 2000 IEP.
In a December 18, 2000 letter, STUDENT’S mother requested OT to assist with fine motor development. The District responded that it would not agree to reassess for OT until STUDENT was first determined to be eligible for special education. On January 2, 2001, STUDENT began attending grade 7 at MVMS on a modified 4-period schedule. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 107.)
On January 19, 2001, District school psychologists Laura Hulsey and Gayle Kehrli conducted a psychological assessment of STUDENT to assess auditory processing further and to assess for ED eligibility. On the Cognitive Assessment System (CAS), STUDENT obtained the following standard scores: Planning, 68; Simultaneous, 100; Attention, 85; and Successive, 94. His 73 auditory quotient on the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills-Revised (TAPS-R) was in the below-average range, consistent with the June 1998 assessment. The mother’s responses on the Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist were in the clinically significant range for the withdrawn, anxious/depressed, social problems, thought problems, and attention problems scales, and for the internalizing composite and total scale scores. STUDENT’S Youth Self-Report responses revealed borderline-range scores for the anxious/depressed scale, internalizing composite, externalizing composite, and total scale. The Teacher Report, completed when STUDENT had been in class for only 1 month, revealed average scores. STUDENT was found to have deficits in cognitive planning processing(Footnote 7) and auditory processing. A significant discrepancy existed between his cognitive ability, as measured by the CAS, and achievement in math and written language. The report concludes that he appeared to meet the SLD eligibility criteria. The assessors determined that it would be premature to consider ED eligibility because STUDENT had been in school for only about 6 weeks, and, thus, the ED criteria such as duration and pervasiveness would be difficult to establish at the time.
On January 25, 2001, STUDENT had an intake appointment with Todd Pizitz, Ph.D., at Rancho Bernardo Center for outpatient CMH services. At this meeting, STUDENT’S mother declined the services. (Testimony of Dr. Pizitz.)
A February 6, 2001 IEP indicates that STUDENT’S eligibility category was now SLD. The IEP states that he exhibited a significant discrepancy between ability, as measured by the CAS, and achievement in math and written language, with auditory processing and planning processing deficits. His placement was an RSP program for 50 to 75 percent of the time, with the notation that he was transitioning to regular education. He was to receive ESY but no related services “at this time.” The IEP notes state that the parent was not accessing CMH services and declined DIS counseling, which was offered, because STUDENT was returning to Dr. Hogan for therapy. The IEP contains goals and objectives for math, organization (related to assignment and homework completion and to notetaking), and writing. The IEP team felt that STUDENT would benefit from a gradual transition into regular education classes and proposed adding a humanities core class every 6 weeks or an elective, and lunch. The IEP states that the mother would decide and let the case manager know by February 9, 2001. The team added ESY but indicated that STUDENT could attend the regular education summer school, at the parent’s request.
On April 2, 2001, Petitioner filed a request for a due process hearing in the instant case. A May 3, 2001 addendum to the February 6, 2001 IEP states that the team discussed, among other things, adding to STUDENT’S schedule another class, such as social studies with modifications or an elective, with lunch. STUDENT expressed an interest in the Exploring Technology elective. The parent requested lunchtime support to avoid negative interactions. The case manager was to walk through lunch period with STUDENT to inform him of the types of support available.
In May 2001 the mother requested cognitive remediation services to address STUDENT’S cognitive processing disorder. The parents later requested Lindamood Bell services, but the District denied the request, stating that STUDENT was making educational progress and that Lindamood Bell was not necessary. STUDENT’S report card for the 2000-2001 school year from MVMS reflects the following grades for the second, third, and fourth quarters that he attended school: RSP Language Arts, D, C, C; RSP Math, D, F, D; RSP Study Skills, A, P, P; and P.E., B, C, B.(Footnote 8) The comments indicate that the fourth-quarter language arts and math grades were at the lower range of the letter grade and that there were missing or late assignments for math.(Footnote 9)
LEGAL ANALYSIS
Issue 1: Did the District conduct appropriate assessments of Petitioner during the 2000- 2001 school year?
Petitioner contends that the District failed to conduct appropriate assessments during the 2000-2001 school year in that (1) Dr. McDonough failed to administer the TAPS-R and to diagnose an SLD in his November 2000 neuropsychological assessment and (2) the District failed to assess all areas of suspected disability by not conducting an OT assessment.(Footnote 10)
(a) Dr. McDonough’s November 2000 Neuropsychological Evaluation
Petitioner first asserts that Dr. McDonough improperly failed to administer to STUDENT the TAPS-R and Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI-4) allegedly called for by the October 26, 2000 assessment plan. He contends that Dr. McDonough instead administered tests to which his parent did not consent. The District contends that the tests marked on the assessment plan were not mandatory but merely representative of the types of tests that would be used. The District asserts that Dr. McDonough’s failure to administer the TAPS-R and VMI-4 did not adversely affect STUDENT’S educational program.
The District’s October 26, 2000 assessment plan, signed by the parent, provides for testing in the psycho-motor development/perceptual functioning area, among other areas. The TAPS-R and VMI-4 are among the tests listed in this category, with check marks in the boxes before these two tests. The assessment plan states for each category of tests, including the psycho-motor development/perceptual functioning area, that the “[t]ests may include, but are not limited to” those tests marked. It is undisputed that Dr. McDonough did not administer either the TAPS-R or VMI-4. Instead, he gave STUDENT other tests not listed or marked on the assessment plan. The question is whether this resulted in an inappropriate assessment.
Dr. McDonough testified that the District had requested a complete neuropsychological evaluation. He administered to STUDENT the WISC-III, Halstead-Reitan Neuropsychological Test Battery, Rudel Cancellation Test, Child Neuropsychological Questionnaire, WRAML, Beery Test of Visual-Motor Integration (Beery VMI), Grooved Pegboard, Wide Range Achievement Test-III, Controlled Verbal Fluency, Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test, Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test, MMPI-A, Sentence Completion Blank, and Connors Rating Scale. He also reviewed prior assessments and educational records and conducted interviews with STUDENT and his mother. Although Petitioner’s parent asserts that Dr. McDonough improperly administered to STUDENT tests to which she did not consent, Dr. McDonough’s undisputed testimony is that before he began the assessment, he reviewed with the parent each test he was going to give to STUDENT. Thus, the evidence supports the conclusion that the parent was informed in advance of the tests to be performed and permitted the administration of these tests.
Moreover, the mere fact that Dr. McDonough failed to administer two specific tests does not render his assessment inappropriate. Instead of the VMI-4, he administered the Beery VMI, another test of visual-motor integration. He found STUDENT’S 89 standard score to be commensurate with his low average intellectual functioning. There is no evidence that the failure to administer the VMI-4 resulted in an inaccurate measure or otherwise inappropriate assessment.
The mother testified that the TAPS-R was to assess for an auditory processing disorder. However, in June 1998, a speech pathologist had administered the TAPS-R to STUDENT and diagnosed a moderate central auditory processing disorder. This diagnosis was reflected in the September 8, 1998 IEP.(Footnote 11) Dr. McDonough testified that the Speech Sound Perception and Seashore Rhythm tests assessed auditory processing. According to him, the test results showed STUDENT’S ability to discriminate between subtle differences in pitch, rhythm, and phonemes to be commensurate with his age-peers. Dr. McDonough testified that his assessment did not reveal an auditory processing problem. He also testified that although not an audiologist, he is qualified, as a pediatric neuropsychologist, to diagnose a central auditory processing disorder. In January 2001, District school psychologist Ms. Hulsey administered the TAPS-R to STUDENT and found his below-average 73 auditory quotient to be consistent with that of the June 1998 assessment. Thus, during the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT’S auditory processing ability was adequately assessed.
Next, Petitioner contends, in effect, that Dr. McDonough’s neuropsychological assessment was inappropriate in that he failed to diagnose an SLD and instead diagnosed depression. The District asserts that it assessed all areas of suspected disability appropriately. The parent’s complaint about Dr. McDonough’s failure to administer the TAPS-R may be related to her concern that he failed to diagnose an SLD. However, as noted above, STUDENT had already been diagnosed with an auditory processing disorder in 1998. At that time, he did not meet the SLD eligibility criteria because a severe discrepancy did not exist between his IQ and academic achievement scores.(Footnote 12) Similarly, Dr. McDonough found no severe discrepancy between STUDENT’S IQ and academic achievement scores. Thus, like Dr. Ingham in 1998, he concluded that STUDENT failed to meet the SLD eligibility criteria. It is true that in January 2001, District school psychologists Ms. Hulsey and Ms. Kehrli found STUDENT eligible for special education as having an SLD. However, Ms. Kehrli administered the CAS, and it was STUDENT’S average CAS standard scores (in contrast to his low average WISC-III IQ scores) which were used as the cognitive scores to find a severe discrepancy between his cognitive ability and academic achievement. (Testimony of Ms. Hulsey.) Moreover, it cannot be said that Dr. McDonough’s assessment was inappropriate because he administered the WISC-III, not the CAS, to assess STUDENT’S intellectual functioning. The Hearing Officer takes official notice that the WISC-III is widely accepted by psychologists as a valid measure of intellectual capacity. By contrast, the CAS is not as commonly used. Ms. Hulsey testified that she had asked Ms. Kehrli to administer the CAS because Ms. Kehrli had much more experience with it. Thus, it cannot be concluded that Dr. McDonough’s assessment was inappropriate because he did not administer the CAS.
At the hearing, Petitioner’s parent also questioned Dr. McDonough’s interpretation of the variability in STUDENT’S test scores, certain of his low scores, his diminished motivation, and his slowness in speeded fine-motor tasks as attributable to emotional factors such as his depression and anxiety. According to Dr. McDonough, individuals who are depressed often display low effort and motivation. He testified that on the MMPI-A, which measures personality functioning, the depression, anxiety, and social introversion scales were significant for STUDENT. According to Dr. McDonough, STUDENT exhibited a significant degree of depressive symptoms. The mother also had reported that STUDENT had a history of suicidal ideation.(Footnote 13) On the Sentence Completion test, STUDENT responded that the future could be a “disaster,” but denied suicidal ideation. Dr. McDonough diagnosed dysthymic disorder. Previously, school psychologists Dr. Ingham and Ms. Scarpa had also identified social and emotional problems as having an adverse impact on STUDENT’S educational progress. In December 2000, at almost the same time that Dr. McDonough assessed STUDENT, a CMH assessor determined that STUDENT was eligible for outpatient mental health services. In January 2001, school psychologist Ms. Hulsey also reported that the mother’s Achenbach responses were in the clinically significant range for the withdrawn, anxious/depressed, social problems, thought problems, and attention problems scales, and for the internalizing composite and total scale scores. The findings of these other assessments are consistent with Dr. McDonough’s diagnosis of depression and anxiety and his determination that these emotional factors had an adverse effect on STUDENT’S test scores and educational performance. The evidence supports the conclusion that Dr. McDonough’s assessment was appropriate.
(b) December 2000 Denial of OT Assessment
Petitioner contends, in essence, that the District failed to assess all areas of suspected disability by not performing an OT assessment of his fine motor skills. In a December 18, 2000 letter to the District, STUDENT’S mother requested OT to help him with his fine motor development. The District denied the OT request and stated that it did not agree to an OT reassessment until STUDENT was first determined to be eligible for special education.(Footnote 14) (The recent speech and language assessment had found that he no longer qualified as having a speech and language impairment.) In his November 2000 neuropsychological assessment report, Dr. McDonough recommended an OT assessment of STUDENT’S fine motor abilities, if not already done, to rule out diagnostic concerns. (Testimony of Dr. McDonough.) In its closing brief, the District does not argue that OT was not an area of suspected disability but rather that an OT assessment was unnecessary because its November 2000 APE assessment had adequately assessed STUDENT’S fine motor ability. Thus, the question is whether the District’s November 2000 APE assessment constituted an adequate assessment of this area of suspected disability.
In November 2000, former District APE teacher Ms. Gonzalez performed an APE assessment of STUDENT. On the Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency (B-O), which includes gross motor and fine motor subtests, his composite scores were as follows: Gross Motor, 47 SS, 38 percentile; and Fine Motor, 66 SS, 94 percentile. Ms. Gonzales concluded that STUDENT demonstrated age-appropriate gross motor skills and did not require APE.
The District argues that the 1998 OT assessment had included administration of the B-O, and, thus, that the APE assessment adequately assessed fine motor skills. Ms. Gonzalez testified that the purpose of her assessment was to determine the continued need for APE services and that she assessed gross motor skills primarily, though with a fine motor component. She testified that based upon the B-O results, fine motor ability was not an area of suspected disability.(Footnote 15) She acknowledged that the conclusion section of her assessment report does not specifically mention fine motor skills. She also acknowledged that in the December 13, 2000 IEP, containing her assessment results, the motor development section of the present levels of performance says nothing about fine motor skills. She testified, however, that if the fine motor area had been a concern, she would have mentioned that in her report.
The 1998 OT assessment did include the B-O, and several other tests as well, such as the Evaluation Tool of Children’s Handwriting. The assessment recommendation was for short-term OT to increase hand strength and coordination to improve handwriting and speed of completing writing tasks. Dr. McDonough noted STUDENT’S slowness in writing a short sentence in print and cursive. RSP teacher Mr. Eyler testified that STUDENT was slow at copying from the board. Thus, the past and present OT concerns specifically involve writing. The B-O, however, assesses for such fine motor skills as cutting with scissors, drawing lines, sorting pennies, displacing pegs, drawing circles and dots, and sorting playing cards, but not writing. (Dist. Exh. 6.)
At the January 20, 2000 IEP meeting (one of three held to develop the February 9, 2000 IEP), the regular education teacher reported that STUDENT’S handwriting was below average in neatness and average in legibility. The IEP notes state that Ms. Kurtz, District administrator, asked if an occupational therapist should be invited to the next meeting, but the parent’s attorney suggested focusing on more pressing needs. Thus, the OT concern for STUDENT has been with regard to handwriting and writing. Consequently, Ms. Gonzales’ APE assessment, which did not emphasize fine motor skills and did not assess writing, did not assess the OT area of concern. There is also no evidence that Ms. Gonzales has any training or background as an occupational therapist. Thus, she lacked the requisite qualifications to conduct an OT assessment. Gov’t Code § 7572(b). From the foregoing, it is concluded that the District failed to conduct an OT assessment to assess an area of suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). To that extent, its assessments during the 2000-2001 school year were inappropriate. Therefore, the District shall conduct an OT assessment of STUDENT which conforms with the requirements of California Government Code Section 7572 and which is performed by a qualified occupational therapist pursuant to Section 7572(b).(Footnote 16)
Issue 2: Did the District deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) on procedural and substantive grounds during the 2000-2001 school year, including the summer 2001 ESY session?
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A free appropriate public education is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student’s unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), (25). Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56303(a) (“designated instruction and services” shall be available when necessary for a student to benefit from his or her special education program).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA provides such a student with a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of “access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit.” Id. at 200-01. The Court stated that the specialized educational services furnished need not maximize each child’s potential. Id. at 198-99. Special education law also requires that a child be educated in the least restrictive environment and that a child be removed from the regular education environment only when the nature or severity of the child’s disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.
In addition, the IDEA requires that the states and local educational agencies guarantee to children with disabilities and their parents certain procedural safeguards with regard to the provision of a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(a). Central among the safeguards is the process of formulating the IEP, including parental participation in the process. W.G. v. Board of Trustees, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights afforded parents also include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the right to a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b).
In Rowley, the Supreme Court noted the importance of these procedural safeguards. The Court stated: “It seems to us no exaggeration to say that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process, see, e.g., §§ 1415(a)-(d), as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard.” 458 U.S. at 205-06. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in a loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process do constitute denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.
Thus, the inquiry in determining whether a FAPE has been provided is twofold: (1) has the District complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA and (2) has the District offered an appropriate educational program? Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-07. Petitioner contends that the District denied him a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds.
A. Compliance with Procedural Safeguards
Petitioner argues that he was denied a FAPE on procedural grounds during the 2000-2001 school year because the District (1) held a September 20, 2000 IEP meeting without his parents and (2) convened the May 3, 2001 IEP meeting without a regular education teacher present.
(1) September 20, 2000 IEP Meeting
Petitioner argues that he was denied a FAPE because the District held a September 20, 2000 IEP meeting without his parents present. The District acknowledges that the meeting was held without a parent present but contends that it attempted to secure the parent’s participation.
Under federal and State law, the District must take steps to ensure that at least one parent is present at each IEP meeting or is afforded the opportunity to participate, including giving notice of the meeting early enough to ensure an opportunity to attend and scheduling the meeting at a mutually agreed upon time and place. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a)-(c). If neither parent can attend, the District shall use other methods to ensure parent participation, including individual or conference telephone calls. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(c); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(f). A meeting may be conducted without a parent present if the District “is unable to convince the parents that they should attend.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(d); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g). In this event, the District must maintain a “record of its attempts to arrange a mutually agreed on time and place.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(d); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g).
It is undisputed that a parent did not attend the September 20, 2000 IEP meeting. In her August 21, 2000 letter requesting an IEP meeting, STUDENT’S mother stated that she would be able to attend a meeting “any day, between the hours of 9:00 am and 1:00 pm.” On August 21, District special education executive director Ms. Murphy notified the parent that an IEP meeting would be scheduled no later than September 30, 2000, pursuant to California Education Code Section 56343.5.(Footnote 17) She informed her that the last agreed-upon IEP placed STUDENT at Bernardo Heights and that he should enroll there.(Footnote 18) She also informed the parent that she could seek an intradistrict transfer to another school outside the IEP process. By a September 13, 2000 letter, Ms. Murphy notified the parent that the District was prepared to hold an IEP meeting at 10:30 a.m. on September 20, 2000, at Bernardo Heights. Ms. Murphy testified that a notice of the IEP meeting was enclosed. The mother responded in a September 15, 2000 letter that she had received Ms. Murphy’s September 13 letter. She stated that she had not requested an IEP meeting at Bernardo Heights, and that was the reason for her August 2000 due process filing.(Footnote 19) She requested a placement in the alternate ACE program at Black Mountain. She ended by stating, “Why would I attend an IEP meeting at a school that we refuse to send our child to.”
Ms. Murphy testified that an IEP meeting was convened on September 20, 2000. She testified that on that day, telephone calls were made to the parents to confirm whether or not they would attend. The District was unable to confirm that a parent would attend. The District also did not receive notification that a parent would not attend. The September 20 IEP addendum states that the parents had not responded to a formal meeting notice sent to them. The addendum also states that the special education office had made two phone calls to inquire about the parents’ attendance. District special education director Ms. Kurtz, who attended the meeting, testified that the IEP team members present waited approximately 15 to 20 minutes for a parent to arrive. Ms. Murphy, who also attended the IEP meeting, testified that the meeting was held without the parent because the District had to hold the meeting within 30 days of the parent’s request. She further testified that the meeting was scheduled for a time the mother had indicated that she was available. She testified that it was not uncommon for STUDENT’S parent not to return the meeting notice indicating an intent to attend the meeting and then to show up at the meeting. In the record are several IEP meeting notices the parent signed on the date of the IEP meeting, acknowledging that she would attend the meeting. (Pet. Exh. 98.) Ms. Murphy testified that these were copies, not the initial notices sent to the parent.
In the present case, the parent acknowledged by letter that she had received the notice of the scheduled September 20 IEP meeting at 10:30 a.m. She had previously indicated by letter that she would be available “any day” between 9:00 a.m. and 1:00 p.m. Although she informed the District of her disagreement with the Bernardo Heights placement, she did not directly communicate to the District, either in writing or by telephone call, that she would not attend the September 20 meeting. In the past, according to the testimony and documentary evidence, the parent had attended an IEP meeting without returning the meeting notice indicating an intent to attend. In this case, it was necessary timely to convene an IEP meeting, pursuant to the parent’s request, to address STUDENT’S return to the public school following approximately a year of home schooling. The Hearing Officer finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the District scheduled the IEP meeting at a mutually agreed-upon time and reasonable location, given the circumstances,(Footnote 20) and was unable to convince the parents that they should attend. The Hearing Officer further finds that the District has documented that it made reasonable attempts to schedule the meeting at a mutually agreed-on time and place. Therefore, the District did not commit a procedural violation that denied Petitioner a FAPE by holding the September 20, 2000 IEP meeting without a parent present.
(2) May 3, 2001 IEP Meeting
Before the start of the May 3, 2001 IEP meeting, the IEP team members were informed that the regular education teacher could not attend because he had a field trip, and the parent had the option to proceed with the meeting or reschedule it. The meeting proceeded with the parent’s consent. (Testimony of Mr. Eyler.) Petitioner now contends that the IEP meeting improperly was held without a regular education teacher present.
The IEP team includes “at least one regular education teacher of [a child with a disability] (if the child is, or may be, participating in the regular education environment) . . .” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B)(ii). As a member of the IEP team, the regular education teacher must, to the extent appropriate, participate in the development, review, and revision of the child’s IEP, including assisting in the determination of supplementary aids and services, program modifications, or supports for school personnel that will be provided for the child, consistent with § 300.347(a)(3). 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(d)(2).
The May 3 IEP addendum to the February 6, 2001 IEP indicates that the purpose of the meeting was to discuss the parent’s request for extending STUDENT’S school day, among other things. The addendum states that the team discussed lengthening STUDENT’S school day by adding other classes, such as regular education social studies with modifications or an elective (art, chorus, drama, or Exploring Technology) and lunch. STUDENT was called into the meeting as he was passing by and expressed an interest in the Exploring Technology elective. (Dist. Exh. 34; Testimony of Mr. Eyler.) Mr. Eyler later spoke to the Exploring Technology class teacher and was informed that because of certain personalities in the period 5 class, it might not be a good class for STUDENT. STUDENT’S mother, when informed of Mr. Eyler’s discussion with the teacher, decided not to add that class or to extend STUDENT’S school day. Thus, until the end of the school year, STUDENT continued with his modified (shortened) 4-period schedule (3 RSP classes and regular education P.E.). (Testimony of Mr. Eyler.) The question is whether the absence of a regular education teacher at the May 3 meeting resulted in denial of a FAPE.
The District asserts that although the regular education teacher was absent, the assistant principal and RSP teacher Mr. Eyler were present at the meeting and had knowledge of the grade 7 regular education curriculum. The District contends, in effect, that the absence of a regular education teacher at the IEP meeting did not result in a loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. In attendance at the May 3 meeting was the assistant principal, who had taught grade 7 for several years, most recently the prior year, and had knowledge of the grade 7 regular education curriculum. (Testimony of Mr. Eyler.) Since the assistant principal had been a grade 7 regular education teacher as recently as the previous year, he likely had recent knowledge about the regular education curriculum, including core courses and electives.
Mr. Eyler, also present at the meeting, was doing a collaborative team teaching with a grade 7 regular education teacher in the period 5, 7, and 8 regular-education core humanities block, so he also had familiarity with the grade 7 curriculum. He had specific knowledge about the social studies class, part of the humanities block, which was contemplated for STUDENT. He modified assignments such as spelling tests for the special education students in these core classes and oversaw implementation of their IEPs. (Testimony of Mr. Eyler.) The May 3 IEP addendum indicates that the parent and teacher reviewed the social studies curriculum, which was to be introduced by the RSP teacher in a small setting to enhance the regular education curriculum.
Moreover, at the December 13, 2000 and February 6, 2001 IEP meetings, when STUDENT’S proposed schedule of classes for the 2000-2001 school year had been developed and reviewed, regular education teachers were in attendance and thus participated in developing and reviewing STUDENT’S IEP, including assisting in determining appropriate supplementary aids and services, modifications, and supports. (Dist. Exhs. 14, 27.) Mr. Eyler testified that his collaborative team teaching partner was the regular education teacher at the December 13 IEP meeting. The February 6, 2001 annual review IEP provides for accommodations such as assistance with prioritizing and preparing a plan and providing handouts or assisting with notetaking.
The record indicates that the parent had the opportunity to participate in these IEP meetings and in the IEP process (and also had the option to continue the May 3 meeting to a time when a regular education teacher could attend). At the May 3 IEP meeting, she was informed about the regular education social studies class team-taught by STUDENT’S RSP teacher and a regular education teacher. The IEP team also discussed possible electives. STUDENT also participated in the IEP process by expressing his preference for the Exploring Technology elective. Mr. Eyler followed up on this choice by speaking to the class teacher. From what he learned about this class and communicated to STUDENT’S mother, she decided not to add this class or to extend his school day. It is noted that at the time of the May 3 IEP meeting, only about six weeks remained in the school year. (See Pet. Exh. 107.) The evidence does not support the conclusion that the absence of a regular education teacher at the May 3 IEP meeting led to a loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringed upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. The Hearing Officer finds that this procedural violation did not result in denial of a FAPE.(Footnote 21)
B. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Educational Program
Having found no procedural violations resulting in denial of a FAPE, the Hearing Officer now turns to substantive appropriateness. To determine whether the District has offered an appropriate educational program, it is necessary to address whether its proposed program (1) was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, (2) was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit, and (3) was in conformity with his IEP. The program must also be provided in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89. The 2000-2001 school year will be discussed first, and the 2001 ESY session will be addressed separately. STUDENT continued to be home-schooled during the beginning part of the school year and started attending classes at MVMS on January 2, 2001.
a. During the 2000-2001 school year
Petitioner contends, in essence, that the District denied him a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year because the IEPs contained deficiencies and the program did not confer on him educational benefit or provide access to the general education curriculum.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’S Unique Needs
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a program during the 2000-2001 school year that was designed to meet his unique needs, the first step is to identify his needs. There was essentially no disagreement about his needs, which were established by the psychological, neuropsychological, speech and language, APE, OT, and academic assessments and IEPs up through the 2000-2001 school year. In 1998, he was diagnosed with a moderate central auditory processing disorder, mild to moderate receptive and expressive language disorder (including difficulty with receptive and expressive sequencing), and a mild articulation impairment. As in 2000, his cognitive ability was in the low average to average range. He suffered from anxiety and depression and engaged in socially inappropriate behavior. He exhibited slowed motor functions and, particularly, motor coordination and speed concerns during fine motor tasks and handwriting. To address these deficits, the IEP team agreed that he required RSP services and small-group instruction. He also required speech therapy, DIS counseling, APE, and short-term OT.
In 2000, STUDENT had significant social and emotional needs, reflected in depression, withdrawal, and suicidal ideation. He suffered from peer teasing. In November 2000, he exhibited a deficit in visual-motor-speeded tasks and inordinately slow writing ability. He had problems completing tasks and homework. He was diagnosed with dysthymic disorder. However, his speech articulation, intelligibility, and fluency improved to be within the average range, and he possessed age-appropriate gross motor skills. In January 2001, STUDENT was found to have average simultaneous and successive processing abilities but low-average attentions skills and a planning processing deficit. He continued to exhibit an auditory processing deficit. He was found to have an SLD, with deficiencies in math and written language. He obtained significant ratings on withdrawal, anxiety, depression, and social and thought problems behavioral scales. He had difficulty with sequencing in directions and prioritizing to make tasks manageable. To address the above deficits, the IEP team agreed that he continued to require RSP support, small-group instruction, and individual therapy. In addition, in December 2000 and in 2001, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT required a transitional program (such as a modified, shortened schedule) to assist his return to school.
The next step in determining whether the proposed program was designed to address STUDENT’S unique needs is to examine the IEP. The IEP is a written statement of the goals and objectives developed to meet the student’s unique needs and the special education and related services and supplementary aids and services that will be provided to assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii), (iii).
(a) February 9, 2000 IEP
The February 9, 2000 IEP was in effect at the start of the 2000-2001 school year, when STUDENT was still being home-schooled. When this IEP was developed, he had been home-schooled since December 1999, and continued to be home-schooled. Petitioner argues that the February 9 IEP is deficient in that it (1) fails to mention his speeded visual-motor copying deficit under present levels of performance, (2) contains goals and objectives based upon 1998 triennial data, and (3) does not contain goals and objectives that address auditory processing and sequencing.
First, Petitioner argues that the February 9 IEP failed to mention under present levels of performance his speeded visual-motor copying deficit which allegedly was revealed by a July 1998 assessment. An uncorrected version of Dr. McDonough’s November 2000 assessment report (District’s Exhibit 8) states on page 5 that STUDENT’S WISC-III Digit Symbol score was “essentially commensurate to one obtained on a 07/98 assessment.” The reference is apparently to Dr. Ingham’s 1998 WISC-III administration. She had noted a “slow speed of information processing” but found this and other assessment results to be consistent with reported depressive features. An October 1998 OT assessment, however, found fine-motor coordination and speed concerns and recommended short-term OT to increase hand strength and coordination to improve speed in writing tasks. STUDENT received OT during grades 5 and 6, but the IEP team agreed to discontinue OT at the November 4, 1999 IEP meeting. Thus, because OT was eliminated, the failure to mention this area in the February 9 IEP does not render the IEP defective.
Next, Petitioner argues that because the February 9 IEP mentions 1998 test results under present levels of performance, the goals and objectives were based upon these allegedly dated scores. August 1998 WIAT scores are set forth under present levels of educational performance. However, in the present levels section of the IEP, the 1998 scores are supplemented by the observations of the classroom teachers: “reads and comprehends at grade level”; “currently passing the grade-level core math class”; “correctly uses capitalization and punctuation”; “writes in simple sentences and can compose a coherent paragraph”; and “[s]pelling is a relative weakness.” Thus, the 1998 scores were not solely relied upon in drafting the goals and objectives. The undisputed testimony of District special education director Ms. Kurtz, who attended the January 20, 2000 meeting when the present levels were developed, was that all IEP members provided input, including information about STUDENT’S progress in the classroom from staff. Because the 1998 WIAT scores were supplemented by teachers’ classroom observations and assessments of STUDENT’S progress, the fact that these scores were provided does not undermine the appropriateness of the goals and objectives developed from the present levels of performance.
Finally, Petitioner argues that the February 9 IEP does not contain goals and objectives to address his auditory processing and sequencing needs. The February 9 IEP states under present levels of communication development that STUDENT had a weakness in auditory processing for spoken information and expressive language. A language goal, developed by the speech therapist, is that STUDENT will be able to summarize and predict possible outcomes to situations when presented with a paragraph or short story. According to District special education executive director Ms. Murphy, the baseline for this goal was that STUDENT’S auditory recall for messages was approximately 60% accurate. She testified that auditory recall is part of auditory processing and that this goal thus addressed this area.(Footnote 22) STUDENT’S RSP teacher, Mr. Eyler, also testified that the February 9 IEP contains the accommodation to rephrase directions to address auditory processing. The evidence is persuasive that the February 9 IEP addresses auditory processing and contains a goal in this area. As for sequencing, the 1998 Rancho Bernardo speech and language assessment recommended speech therapy directed at, among other things, receptive and expressive sequencing. As Ms. Murphy noted, the February 9 IEP contains a language goal with an objective to be able to relate 4 sequential details when presented with a paragraph or short story with 80% accuracy. The speech and language specialist, who developed the goal and objective, had primary responsibility for implementing them. Thus, the evidence establishes that the February 9 IEP contains a goal which addresses sequencing.
The language goals mentioned above addressed STUDENT’S receptive and expressive language needs. The February 9 IEP also sets forth goals and objectives for gross motor skills, self-esteem, peer interaction, task completion, task initiation, math, written language, and spelling. The gross motor goals and objectives were designed to improve cardiovascular endurance and muscular strength. The self-esteem and peer interaction goals and objectives addressed improving his self-confidence and assisting him to avoid inappropriate comments and inappropriate responses to peer teasing, respectively. The task initiation and completion goals and objectives addressed starting assignments promptly and completing a majority of class assignments. The math goal and objectives addressed improving performance on math operations involving fractions. The written language goals and objectives addressed writing a multiple-paragraph essay and learning self-editing techniques. The spelling goal and objectives were designed to improve spelling.
The February 9 IEP recommends RSP services (with regular education for 53 to 65 percent of the time), speech and language services, DIS counseling, APE, and ESY. Because STUDENT was still being home-schooled at the start of the 2000-2001 school year, when the February 9 IEP was in effect, the RSP placement in this IEP was not implemented during this school year. However, the RSP services were intended to meet his need for small-group instruction. The IEP indicates that STUDENT would have received RSP services for math and language arts (including written language and spelling), which would have met his needs in these academic areas. The speech therapy and APE addressed his speech and language and gross motor needs. The DIS counseling was intended to assist with self-esteem, peer relation, and task initiation and completion needs. ESY addressed his need to prevent regression during the summer. The February 9 IEP also sets forth modifications, accommodations, and support, such as shortened assignments and extra time to assist with task completion, rephrasing directions to address auditory processing difficulty, school-to-home communication to assist with homework completion, and anger management class to assist with peer interactions. The Hearing Officer finds that the RSP placement, speech therapy, DIS counseling, APE, and accommodations were designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs.
(b) December 13, 2000 IEP
When the December 13, 2000 IEP meeting was held, STUDENT had been enrolled at MVMS since November 15, 2000, and he was receiving DIS counseling and APE but was not yet attending classes. The December 13 IEP was in effect when STUDENT began attending classes on January 2, 2001. Petitioner argues that the December 13 IEP is deficient in not containing new goals and objectives, including an AB 3632 goal.
The December 13, 2000 IEP sets forth, under present levels of performance, the November and December 2000 triennial assessment results obtained in the areas of speech and language, APE, health history and physical condition, neuropsychology, academic achievement, and mental health.(Footnote 23) The IEP notes that STUDENT was no longer eligible as speech and language impaired, but that special education services would continue until the February 2001 annual review.(Footnote 24) The IEP states that the IEP team recommended continued implementation of the February 9, 2000 IEP, except for speech and language and APE services.(Footnote 25) The December 13 IEP does not itself contain goals and objectives but instead refers to the goals and objectives in the February 9 IEP. As discussed above, the February 9 IEP contains goals and objectives for gross motor skills, language skills, self-esteem, peer interactions, task completion, task initiation, math, written language, and spelling. Because, in light of recent assessments, STUDENT no longer required speech and language and APE services, the gross motor and language goals no longer needed to be implemented. According to the IEP team, the goals and objectives in the remaining areas would be implemented until the February 2001 annual review IEP meeting. The February 9 IEP, when written, was intended to be in effect until February 2001, and the goals and objectives had a February 2001 projected achievement date. Moreover, because STUDENT had been home schooled, except for a few days, since approximately December 1999, he had not been working on these goals and objectives in a school setting. Therefore, although these goals and objectives were not directly based upon the most recent assessments, in light of all circumstances, they were appropriate as a short-term measure until further assessment for special education eligibility and the convening of the annual review IEP meeting less than two months hence.(Footnote 26) Moreover, as discussed above under “February 9, 2000 IEP,” the goals and objectives in the February 9 IEP were designed to meet STUDENT’S identified needs. In December 2000, he continued to have essentially the same needs.
As for an AB 3632 goal, the December 13 IEP provides for outpatient AB 3632 services. As discussed above, the December 13 IEP does not contain any goals and objectives but rather refers to the February 9, 2000 IEP goals and objectives. The February 9 IEP contains goals and objectives for self-esteem, peer interaction, and task completion developed for DIS counseling but not specifically for CMH mental health services. However, an IEP meeting was held on December 12, 2000, a day before the December 13 IEP meeting, to review the CMH mental health assessment. Attached to the CMH assessment report is a treatment plan, signed by the mother on December 12, which sets forth two goals and accompanying objectives to enhance self-confidence and self-image and to improve task completion. The December 12 IEP notes state that the IEP team, including the parent, agreed with the services and goals and that the treatment would carry out the two mental health IEP goals. There is no indication that the parent did not understand the nature of the CMH services offered. The goals and objectives themselves are not set forth in the December 12 IEP notes, and the treatment plan is not part of the IEP. The result is a deficiency in the IEP, but the Hearing Officer finds that it had a de minimis effect and did not result in denial of a FAPE, for the following reasons.
First, when the parent signed the treatment plan on December 12, she was given notice of the mental health goals and objectives, and she approved them. She does not argue that they are inappropriate, and there is no evidence to that effect. The multiple purposes underlying the statutory requirement that an IEP contain goals and objectives include providing a means to determine an appropriate placement, program, and services; giving the special education teacher or service provider specific targeted ends in providing the program and services; and providing a means of measuring progress in the educational program. In this case, STUDENT never did receive the CMH mental health services which his mother approved at the December 12 IEP meeting. The undisputed testimony is that the parent declined these services at the first appointment with the CMH therapist.(Footnote 27) (Testimony of Dr. Pizitz.) Thus, even though the failure to write the AB 3632 goals and objectives in the IEP constitutes a technical violation and is not to be condoned, in these circumstances, the omission did not result in denial of a FAPE.
The December 13 IEP provides for a regular education placement, with RSP services for 35 to 75 percent of the time. The IEP sets forth a proposed 8-period schedule, but the IEP team agreed that STUDENT required a modified program to assist his transition back to school and that he would start with a 4-period schedule (including RSP classes in language arts, math, and study skills). The IEP also provides for AB 3632 mental health services and ESY. The RSP services were intended to meet STUDENT’S need for small-group instruction. The shortened-day schedule met STUDENT’S need for a transitional program to help him adjust to school following about a year of home-schooling. The AB 3632 services were intended to improve his self-esteem and task completion, and ESY addressed his need not to regress during the summer. Although the IEP does not contain a “special factors” page for accommodations and modifications, Mr. Eyler’s undisputed testimony was that the special factors page from the February 9 IEP was implemented when STUDENT entered MVMS and was to be in effect until the February 2001 annual review. As discussed above, the accommodations and modifications in the February 9 IEP were designed to meet STUDENT’S needs, which were essentially the same in December 2000.
(c) February 6, 2001 IEP
When the February 6, 2001 IEP was developed, STUDENT had been attending classes at MVMS on a modified 4-period schedule since January 2, 2001. Petitioner argues that the February 6 IEP is deficient in that it (1) contains goals and objectives that are inappropriate or that do not address all of his needs and (2) does not offer AB 3632 or alternative services. The February 6 IEP contains goals and objectives for math, writing, and organization. The math goal addressed the ability to perform basic math operations involving fractions and decimals. The writing goal was to improve the ability to write a multiple-paragraph essay, with self-editing. One organization goal addressed recording and prioritizing homework. Another organization goal was intended to improve notetaking skills, particularly when information was given auditorily. Petitioner contends that the written language goal in the February 6 IEP is the same or similar to his grade 5 written language goal, with the implication that it is therefore inappropriate.(Footnote 28) STUDENT’S RSP teacher, Mr. Eyler, testified that the written language goal in the February 6, 2001 IEP is similar to a prior year’s written language goal. He further stated, however, that although short-term objectives are more attainable and, thus, progress can be made toward a long-term goal, a goal in an area of difficulty may not be achieved within one year and may need to be continued to the next year. The February 9, 2000 IEP states that the IEP team agreed to continue the written language goal because it was not met in its entirety with multiple attempts, and the grade 6 curriculum focused on essay development.
District special education director Ms. Kurtz testified that the grade 5 writing goal in the January 13, 1999 IEP was concerned with a more basic format, whereas the February 2001 goal emphasized fluency and self-editing. She also testified that the February 2000 written language goal focused on working on the parts of a piece of writing separately and with more assistive tools, in contrast to the February 2001 goal, which emphasized synthesizing the parts into a whole. She testified that in February 2001, STUDENT had returned to school after being out for a long while, and writing is a skill that is refined year to year.(Footnote 29) Similarly, after reviewing the writing goal in the IEPs of January 13, 1999; February 9, 2000; and February 6, 2001, Ms. Murphy testified that the goal on successive IEPs was becoming more comprehensive. Because both Ms. Kurtz and Ms. Murphy have extensive special education experience, including the development and review of IEPs, and Ms. Kurtz also has an English teaching background, the Hearing Officer finds their testimony to be persuasive. The mere fact that the writing goal in the February 6, 2001 IEP is similar to the writing goal in a prior IEP in focusing on writing a multiple-paragraph essay does not render the February 6 goal inappropriate. The testimony, supported by the IEP documents, reveals a change in emphasis in the writing goal since 1999 from rudimentary elements and more assistance to more advanced concerns, such as transitions and varied sentence structure, and self-editing. The recent academic assessment revealed that written language is a continuing area of deficit for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that the writing goal in the February 6 IEP is appropriate in addressing a continuing area of need.
Next, Petitioner argues that the February 6, 2001 IEP contains no goals to address his auditory processing, sequencing, behavior, or self-esteem needs, or needs identified by Dr. McDonough’s and Ms. Adams’ November 2000 assessments. Regarding auditory processing, Ms. Murphy testified that the baseline for the organization goal for notetaking in the February 6 IEP indicates that STUDENT had difficulty taking notes, particularly when information was given auditorily. She testified that this was part of a central auditory processing problem. Mr. Eyler testified that STUDENT has difficulty processing directions auditorily. He testified that rather than an auditory processing goal, accommodations are often provided in the classroom. In class, he gave written as well as oral directions and used visual prompts. The evidence establishes that the February 6 IEP addressed STUDENT’S auditory processing need through the notetaking goal and also classroom accommodations.
With regard to sequencing, it was initially identified as an area of need in relation to receptive and expressive language. By December 2000, STUDENT no longer qualified for special education as speech and language impaired. Mr. Eyler identified sequencing and prioritizing as areas of need for STUDENT in approaching a task. He testified that although the February 6 IEP contains no goal that specifically addresses sequencing, it does have a goal for organization, which encompasses sequencing. Sequencing and prioritizing would be components of the organization goal related to notetaking. The IEP also contains accommodations to help STUDENT prioritize by making a plan and using a checklist. The evidence establishes that this area of need was adequately addressed in the February 6 IEP.
With respect to behavior or self-esteem needs, the IEP team determined that STUDENT had no behavioral problems that interfered with his academic performance. (Dist. Exh. 14.) There was no evidence of a serious behavioral problem that required interventions.(Footnote 30) Thus, no behavioral goal was required. As for self-esteem, one of the CMH mental health goals developed in December 2000 addressed this need. However, because the parent declined the proffered mental health services, no services were actually provided to implement this goal. The February 6 IEP notes expressly state that the parent was not accessing CMH services and did not want DIS counseling, which was offered, because STUDENT was going to return to Dr. Hogan for therapy. Since the parents declined CMH and DIS counseling services in favor of a private therapist, no basis exists to support a claim that the lack of a self-esteem goal constitutes denial of a FAPE.(Footnote 31)
As for needs identified by Dr. McDonough and RSP teacher Ms. Adams in their assessments, Ms. Adam’s assessment of STUDENT’S academic achievement found deficiencies in math and written language, and goals and objectives were developed for both areas. Dr. McDonough concluded that psychiatric problems (poor self-image, depression, anxiety, and social isolation) were primary concerns. As noted above, because the parents made clear at the February 6 IEP meeting that they preferred private therapy and declined proffered CMH and DIS counseling services, the failure to develop an IEP goal to address STUDENT’S social and emotional needs did not result in denial of a FAPE. For the same reason, the failure to offer AB 3632 or other counseling services in the February 6, 2001 IEP did not constitute denial of a FAPE.(Footnote 32)
The February 6 IEP provides for RSP services for 50 to 75 percent of the time and notes that STUDENT was transitioning to regular education. Starting in January 2001, he was attending three RSP classes in language arts, math, and study skills and regular education P.E. According to teacher Mr. Eyler, the RSP classes had 10 to 11 students and an instructional assistant, besides himself. In the math class, a student also had his own one-to-one aide. In the language arts class, Mr. Eyler used the Rewards program (recommended for grade 4 to 12 students), which focused on decoding, spelling, and timed reading fluency. According to Mr. Eyler, this program addressed STUDENT’S low word-recognition, reading fluency, and spelling needs. In that class, the students also worked on very structured writing assignments, for example, using a prompt for each paragraph. To address spelling, Mr. Eyler focused on teaching strategies such as patterns in words, not mere memorization skills. In the math class, two days were spent reviewing basic math facts and operations, and the other days were spent on new concepts and vocabulary. According to Mr. Eyler, because math was difficult for STUDENT, RSP math was appropriate. In the study skills class, the students worked on homework assignments individually, with one-to-one help from Mr. Eyler and the instructional assistant as needed. Mr. Eyler worked closely with STUDENT in observing and assessing his work in the small RSP classes and had firsthand knowledge of his areas of weakness and progress; thus, the Hearing Officer accords substantial weight to his testimony.
The RSP classes met STUDENT’S need for small-group instruction. The RSP classes in language arts, math, and study skills were designed to meet his needs in writing, spelling, math, and assignment completion. The IEP team agreed that a gradual transition to regular education classes would be appropriate and considered adding another period of a humanities core or an elective, subject to a determination by the parent. The plan to add regular education classes gradually met STUDENT’S need for a smooth transition to the regular education environment. The IEP provides for no DIS services “at this time.” As discussed above, the failure to offer AB 3632 services did not result in denial of a FAPE under the circumstances. The IEP offers ESY, which addressed STUDENT’S need not to regress. It also provides for accommodations and modifications, such as assistance with prioritizing and making a plan and using a checklist and graphic organizer to address his task completion need, and assistance with notetaking, or the provision of handouts, to address his auditory processing need.
Based upon the foregoing, it is concluded that the goals and objectives and program set forth in the IEPs were designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
Petitioner argues that the District’s program did not confer on him educational benefit. He contends that at the time of the February 6, 2001 IEP meeting, he was earning Ds in RSP math and RSP language arts. He further asserts that as of June 2001, he was making insufficient progress on one of his organization goals (related to use of a homework binder) to meet that goal by February 2002. The District contends that the parent did not consent to the entire program offered by the District, including CMH services, DIS counseling, extending the school day, and ESY, but that STUDENT still received educational benefit.
STUDENT’S report card for the 2000-2001 school year shows the following grades for the second, third, and fourth quarters, respectively, when he attended school: RSP Language Arts, D, C, C; RSP Math, D, F, D; RSP Study Skills, A, P, P; and P.E., B, C, B. Comments indicate that the fourth-quarter language arts and math grades were at the lower range of the letter grade and that there were missing or late math assignments.
The testimony of RSP teacher Mr. Eyler reveals that there was an initial transitional period for STUDENT upon his return to school following approximately a year of home schooling. Later, however, STUDENT participated more in class and showed improvement in his academic classes. He was in the top half of the language arts class, with reading a strength and average writing ability in relation to classmates. Although he had great difficulty initially, with the structure imposed and using a graphic organizer, by the end of the year he could write on his own an essay which contained an introduction, body, and conclusion. He was progressing toward meeting the writing goal and objectives. (Testimony of Mr. Eyler.) Math was more difficult for STUDENT than language arts, but even in the math class, he volunteered information, and he improved in the ability to organize the math problems spatially on a sheet of paper. Over time, he learned to correct his mistakes, and he showed progress in the class work. Moreover, although STUDENT suffered from high anxiety and peer difficulties when he first returned to school, he had a positive relationship with Mr. Eyler and the instructional assistant and was able to interact with other students, although he remained a social bystander. (Id.) As noted above, because the small class size permitted Mr. Eyler to work closely with STUDENT and to assess his progress on an individual or small-group basis, his testimony about STUDENT’S progress is given substantial weight.
The IEP goal progress report that Mr. Eyler prepared reveals that for the third and four quarters, STUDENT was making sufficient progress to meet (by February 2002) three February 6, 2001 IEP annual goals in math, written language, and organization (related to notetaking). As Petitioner notes, STUDENT was making insufficient progress to meet the second organization goal (related to recording and prioritizing homework in the Binder Reminder). (Pet. Exh. 12.) According to Mr. Eyler, STUDENT did not show much progress in self-initiation or working by himself, particularly in the less structured study skills class. Although he used the class time to work on assignments, he consistently tended to be distracted and off-task with his own thoughts, and, when working independently, required more redirection. He also did not use the Binder Reminder to record his assignments. When he turned in his homework the following day, he had not done any more of the work than what he had completed in the study skills class. (Testimony of Mr. Eyler.) At the hearing, the mother questioned Mr. Eyler extensively about STUDENT’S difficulty with homework completion and use of the Binder Reminder. He pointed out the parent’s shared responsibility with District staff in monitoring use of the binder and homework completion, as indicated in the IEP. (Id.).
The District notes that the parents declined certain services offered, such as CMH and DIS counseling services. One of the CMH treatment goals was in the area of task completion, specifically, that STUDENT will initiate a task with a maximum of one prompt by the teacher to get started and will remain on task and complete at least 70% of all assignments.(Footnote 33) The objectives address acknowledging strategies STUDENT uses to avoid work and developing strategies to assist him in self-monitoring his work production. STUDENT’S report card indicates that his math grade was adversely impacted by missing assignments. He had an ongoing problem with initiating and completing assignments, and the CMH services had as one goal improving task completion. Because the parents did not avail themselves of these services for STUDENT, his ability to benefit from his educational program was diminished. Nevertheless, based upon the preponderance of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the educational program and services offered were reasonably calculated to, and did, provide some educational benefit.
(3) Conformity with IEP
Petitioner acknowledges receiving DIS counseling and APE starting after November 15, 2000, when he enrolled at MVMS, but contends that no other educational program was provided until he started attending classes on January 2, 2001. He appears to be arguing, in essence, that the educational program provided did not conform to his IEP. The February 9, 2000 IEP was in effect at the time STUDENT enrolled at MVMS. (Testimony of Ms. Murphy.) The February 9 IEP provided for, among other things, RSP services, DIS counseling, and APE. Following an October 26, 2000 mediated agreement in another due process proceeding, the parties agreed that STUDENT would receive DIS counseling and APE immediately. (Testimony of Ms. Murphy and Ms. Gonzalez.) According to Ms. Murphy, the parties also eventually agreed upon MVMS as STUDENT’S placement. The mother testified that STUDENT enrolled at MVMS on November 15 in order to receive the DIS services.
The evidence establishes that when STUDENT enrolled at MVMS, he had an IEP which could have been implemented there. No evidence was presented to the contrary. If the parent felt that an IEP meeting should have been convened to assist STUDENT’S transition back to school, she could have requested one, as she had in August. In fact, Ms. Murphy testified that within 30 days of STUDENT’S enrollment, an IEP meeting was held on December 13, 2000, to discuss his transition back to the public school. Since STUDENT had a school site acceptable to his parents, an IEP in effect, and was enrolled at MVMS, it is not clear why he did not attend classes at MVMS prior to January 2, 2001. No evidence was presented that the District somehow prevented him from attending. Thus, it is disingenuous for Petitioner’s parents to argue that the District denied him a FAPE because of their own failure to place him back in school earlier or timely to take steps toward that end.(Footnote 34)
(4) Least Restrictive Environment
Petitioner asserts that he was denied access to the general education curriculum in that he did not access lunch or any extracurricular activities. Consequently, he argues, he was not in the least restrictive environment when he attended MVMS from January 2, 2001, to the end of the school year. The District asserts, in essence, that at the February 6, 2001 IEP meeting, the IEP team was prepared to extend STUDENT’S school day beyond his 4-period modified schedule to include lunch and a regular education core curriculum class or an elective, but that the mother did not agree then or later.
At the December 13, 2000 IEP meeting, pending further assessment to determine continuing special education eligibility, the IEP team set forth a proposed 8-period schedule for STUDENT when he started at MVMS on January 2, 2001. However, to assist with his transition back to school after about one year of home schooling, the team agreed that he would start on a modified 4-period schedule with RSP classes and regular education P.E. The December 13 IEP notes state that the parent and case manager Mr. Eyler would work collaboratively to determine when STUDENT was ready to add some general education classes to his schedule.
The February 6, 2001 IEP states that STUDENT would participate in the regular education environment for P.E., break, lunch, field trips, assemblies, and an elective, if appropriate. At this IEP meeting, the regular education teacher provided information regarding basic education courses, specifically, social studies. The IEP team felt that STUDENT would benefit from a gradual transition into regular education classes. The team proposed adding to his schedule another period, such as a humanities core every 6 weeks, or an art, chorus, or drama elective, and lunch. The IEP states that the mother would decide and let the case manager know by February 9, 2001. (Dist. Exh. 14.) Mr. Eyler testified that the next time the subject of adding a class was discussed was at the May 3, 2001 IEP meeting, convened at the parent’s request.
At the May 3 meeting, the IEP team discussed adding lunch and a fifth period to STUDENT’S schedule. The May 3 addendum states that the team discussed classes such as social studies with modifications or an elective (art, chorus, drama, or Exploring Technology). STUDENT was present for a portion of the meeting and expressed interest in the Exploring Technology elective. As a follow-up to the meeting, Mr. Eyler spoke to the Exploring Technology teacher and explained STUDENT’S needs. The teacher candidly told Mr. Eyler that because of certain personalities in the class, it might not be a good choice for STUDENT. Mr. Eyler communicated what the teacher said to STUDENT’S mother, and she told him that she did not want to add that class or to extend STUDENT’S school day. (Testimony of Mr. Eyler.) Mr. Eyler testified that the mother’s approval was necessary to add another class to STUDENT’S schedule.
Regarding lunch, the May 3 addendum states that the parent requested lunchtime support for STUDENT to avoid negative interactions. The assistant principal explained the support available for lunch (supervisors, volunteer activity coordinator, library access, and peer buddy). The addendum states that the case manager would walk through the lunch period with STUDENT. According to Mr. Eyler, the parent did not want STUDENT to stay for lunch after his fourth period until Mr. Eyler had walked through the lunch period with him. The problem was that there were no breaks, only passing periods, between the first four class periods, and the bus picked STUDENT up right after period 4. Lunch was right after period 4. Because STUDENT was not on campus during the lunch period, Mr. Eyler had no opportunity to walk him through the lunch period. The parent thus told him that she did not want STUDENT to stay for lunch or to extend his day. (Testimony of Mr. Eyler.) Mr. Eyler testified that he did walk through the lunch area with STUDENT, but not during the lunch period. He also offered his room during lunch if STUDENT wanted to go there.
Ultimately, STUDENT remained on his 4-period schedule of only RSP classes and regular education P.E. until the end of the school year. The testimony of Mr. Eyler and the supporting IEP documents indicate that the District offered STUDENT access to the general education curriculum through a regular education core class or elective and lunch. The Hearing Officer found Mr. Eyler to be forthright and credible. The December 13 IEP team had agreed that Mr. Eyler would work collaboratively with the parent to determine when STUDENT was ready to add general education classes to his schedule. The parent informed Mr. Eyler that she did not want to add lunch or a regular education class to STUDENT’S schedule. The implication is that the parents thought that STUDENT was not yet ready to stay at school for lunch or to take a general education class. The Hearing Officer finds, based upon a preponderance of the evidence, that the District offered STUDENT access to the general education curriculum and provided a program in the least restrictive environment under the circumstances.(Footnote 35)
In sum, the evidence supports the conclusion that during the 2000-2001 school year, the District offered STUDENT an educational program that was designed to meet his unique needs, was reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit, conformed to his IEP, and was provided in the least restrictive environment.
b. Summer 2001 ESY Session
Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide ESY services pursuant to his February 6, 2001 IEP. The February 6 IEP provides for ESY. It is undisputed that STUDENT did not attend ESY during summer 2001. The question is whether the result is denial of a FAPE.
The February 6 IEP states that the mother wanted to see what summer programs were available and that STUDENT could attend regular education summer school, pursuant to the parent’s request. RSP teacher Mr. Eyler testified that at the February 6 IEP meeting, the parent requested information about the summer program, and he believed that both ESY and regular education summer school were discussed. According to him, both are for 4 hours each day, and the ESY program would entail one or two special education classes starting in June. He testified that, as with regular education summer school, the parent would enroll the student in ESY. He further testified that for regular education summer school, the parent takes the initiative in enrolling the child, and that he did not know the process for ESY, but that ESY was made available to STUDENT. Ms. Murphy testified that the case manager at the school has responsibility for providing the application for special education summer school or linking the parent up with regular education summer school and that this is generally discussed at the IEP meeting. She further testified, however, that there are times when parents do not take advantage of ESY, although it is offered.
The February 6 IEP notes indicate that the parent had an interest in regular education summer school, rather than ESY, or at the least in both. At the IEP meeting, she did not communicate an intent to send STUDENT to the ESY session. However, if, at a later date, the parents were to have decided to avail themselves of ESY services for STUDENT, they knew to contact case manager Mr. Eyler or the special education office. No evidence was presented that the parents at some point decided to send STUDENT to the ESY session but were in fact unsuccessful in obtaining the necessary information or application in timely fashion. The evidence establishes that the District offered ESY during summer 2001. If the parents chose not to take advantage of the offer or failed to act in timely fashion to do so, they cannot now claim the denial of a FAPE.
Issue 3: If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, including summer 2001, is he entitled to the following as compensatory education services:
a. Lindamood Bell?
b. Cognitive Remediation?
c. Counseling services from Charles Hogan, Ph.D.?
As discussed above, the District did not deny Petitioner a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, including summer 2001. Therefore, he is not entitled to compensatory remedies.
ORDER
1. Within twenty-five calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall arrange for, provide, and have completed an occupational therapy assessment of Petitioner’s educational need for occupational therapy by a qualified occupational therapist.
2. Within forty calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to review the occupational therapy assessment and to revise Petitioner’s IEP as necessary.
3 All of Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Petitioner prevailed on these issues: Sub-issue 1(b).
Respondent prevailed on these issues: Sub-issue 1(a); Issues 2 and 3.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: March 4, 2002 ____________________________________ Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Petitioner filed an original closing brief with a February 4, 2002 postmark, the parties’ agreed-upon due date. On February 5, 2002, he also faxed an amended closing brief with attachments. No objection was raised to the amended brief, and any objection is deemed to have been waived. In any event, the attachments contained information that was essentially cumulative of evidence presented at the hearing. A February 14, 2002 minute order granted Petitioner’s request that the Hearing Officer listen to an audiotape admitted as his Exhibit 50, stating that the tape would be given its due weight. Subsequently, Petitioner filed motions to submit an “updated” closing brief and for protection against retaliation. The motions were denied on February 27, 2002, by a minute order. 2. The issues have been clarified to facilitate the analysis. On August 7, 2001, another hearing officer convened the hearing, admitted documentary evidence, and set forth the issues for hearing in an August 10, 2001 order. On September 18, 2001, the Presiding Hearing Officer further clarified the issues, as set forth above. The issues for hearing were limited to the 2000-2001 school year. Thus, issues related to other years are not addressed. Petitioner stipulated that there were no speech and language or health issues that required resolution at hearing. At the hearing, Petitioner’s mother requested reimbursement for “parent’s fees.” The attorney for the District objected on grounds of lack of a statutory basis for such fees. There is no statutory provision for reimbursement for such fees. 3. The mother testified that she removed STUDENTfrom Black Mountain because he was very depressed and threatened to harm himself if he had to return to that school. STUDENTbegan private therapy with Dr. Hogan. 4. According to the mother, STUDENTleft school because he was deeply depressed and also did not understand what he had done to warrant being sent to Bernardo Heights. 5. The final version of Dr. McDonough’s report is set forth as Petitioner’s Exhibit 141. According to Dr. McDonough, he revised the original report to reflect a corrected birth date and to delete references to a prior neuropsychological assessment purged from STUDENT’Sstudent file at the parent’s request. 6. Assembly Bill (AB) 3632/882, codified at California Government Code §§ 7570-7588 as Chapter 26.5, provided for inter-agency responsibility for furnishing certain related services to children with disabilities. Legislation enacted in 1996 (AB 2726) amended or enacted provisions of this chapter. The commonly used term “AB 3632" will be used to refer to mental health services under this chapter. 7. The report states that “[p]lanning is the ability to determine, select, apply and evaluate solutions to problems.” 8. A “P” is a passing grade. (Pet. Exh. 119.)
9. An August 28, 2001 IEP meeting was convened to address the parent’s request to extend STUDENT’Sschool day. The IEP provides for an 8-period schedule, including three RSP classes. According to the IEP, the parent indicated that STUDENTmay not require DIS counseling because he was not withdrawing, and the team agreed to discontinue DIS counseling at the time. 10. Petitioner’s arguments regarding assessments that were performed prior to the 2000-2001 school year, the school year identified at the hearing as the time period for the issues raised, will not be addressed. As the District notes, Petitioner has had due process hearings and Hearing Office Decisions rendered on issues raised under the IDEA related to the 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years. (Dist. Exhs. 15 and 16.) 11. The September 8, 1998 IEP also states that although STUDENT had an auditory processing disorder, no severe discrepancy existed between his IQ and academic scores (as Dr. Ingham had determined in her July 1998 assessment). Thus, he failed to meet the SLD eligibility criteria at that time. 12. For a child to qualify for special education because of an SLD, the following requirements must be met: (1) a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in specified areas, such as basic reading skills, written expression, and mathematics calculation; (2) a causal basic psychological processing disorder; and (3) the inability to correct the discrepancy within the regular education program. Cal. Ed. Code § 56337. 13. According to the mother, the reason that she removed STUDENT from Black Mountain during the 1999-2000 school year was that he was very depressed and threatened to harm himself if he had to return to that school. She testified that, at that time, he was withdrawn, would not make eye contact, and would gouge his scalp until bloodied. In early 2000, STUDENT began private therapy from Dr. Hogan. According to STUDENT’S mother, it took 8 months of therapy for him to be ready to go back to school. 14.According to the District’s letter, STUDENT had previously received OT during grades 5 and 6, but the IEP team had agreed to discontinue OT at the November 4, 1999 IEP meeting. 15. In 1998, when STUDENT was age 10 years, 6 months, he obtained an age equivalent score of 8 years, 2 months, on the B-O Upper Limb Speed and Dexterity subtest, in contrast to an average score in 2000. In 1998, the OT assessor stated that he showed adequate manipulative abilities but that his speed was below age expectancy. 16. Petitioner contends that the District improperly denied his request for an IEE. In September 2000, his mother requested an IEE to assess for suspected SLD, and Ms. Murphy of the District denied the request. Ms. Murphy stated that the psychological and neuropsychological assessments conducted by the District had assessed for a possible learning disability and found no learning disability. She stated that if the mother still wanted an IEE, the District would file for due process to prove that its assessments were appropriate and that it, therefore, need not pay for an IEE. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). The District did not file for due process. However, according to the mother, in August 2000 she filed for due process (case number SN 1523-00). She testified that on the October 26, 2000 hearing date, the parties met to discuss the IEE matter. The Hearing Officer takes official notice of an October 23, 2000 Hearing Office order issued in number SN 1523-00 stating that the hearing request and other documents indicated that the issues for hearing related to the need for an IEE and other testing for STUDENT. District special education director Ms. Kurtz testified that the matter was resolved in a mediated agreement, and the parties agreed to conduct the triennial assessments early. Later, it was agreed to have an independent assessor, Dr. McDonough, conduct a neuropsychological assessment. Official notice is taken of the October 30, 2000 order dismissing case number SN1523-00 in accordance with the parties’ settlement agreement. Because this matter was resolved by the parties’ agreement, Petitioner is now barred from relitigating it. 17. An IEP meeting requested by a parent to review an IEP shall be held within 30 days of receipt of the parent’s written request, not counting days in July and August. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343.5. 18. Ms. Murphy also noted that an August 2000 Hearing Office Decision had determined that the RSP program and placement at Bernardo Heights offered STUDENT a FAPE. 19. In an August 24, 2000 letter addressed to Ms. Murphy, the mother requested due process, stating that STUDENT would not return to Bernardo Heights “under any circumstances.” 20. Bernardo Heights was the last agreed-upon placement and the last school STUDENT attended, and a recent Hearing Office Decision had found that it offered a FAPE. In an August 21, 2000 letter, Ms. Murphy had informed the parent, in essence, that if she disagreed with a Bernardo Heights placement, she could seek an intradistrict transfer, with help from the home-school principal. Ms. Murphy testified that the District is a “choice” district (i.e., students can apply to attend any school within the District). The mother’s August 24 letter stating that she would not consider a transfer to another district reveals her misunderstanding, but that is not the fault of the District. 21. At the hearing, Petitioner questioned witnesses about a voice mail message left by a District school psychologist in July 2001 regarding a protocol for the Sentence Completion test administered by Dr. McDonough in which STUDENT allegedly made an implied threat against a District staff. Concerns raised about the manner in which the matter was handled are outside the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. Cal. Educ. Code § 56501(a). To the extent that Petitioner is contending that the handling of this matter resulted in denial of a FAPE, the contention lacks merit. Similarly, a claim of harassment stemming from the home visit by the director of student welfare and attendance regarding the affidavit for home schooling falls outside the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. Id. 22. Ms. Murphy has a master’s degree in special education with an emphasis in learning disabilities and has 14 years’ experience as a regular education teacher, resource specialist, and program specialist and 10 years’ experience as a special education administrator. She possesses California credentials in general education multiple subject, learning disability specialist (preschool to adult), and administrative services (K to 12). She has 10 years of classroom experience assessing students in academic areas on standardized tests. 23. Petitioner’s claim that the present levels of functioning in the December 13, 2000 IEP are based upon 1998 assessment data is unfounded. 24. The IEP states that before the February 2001 IEP meeting, the staff would be able to observe STUDENT in the school setting, and further assessment would be conducted for ED eligibility. 25. The November 2000 assessments revealed STUDENT’S speech and language skills to be within normal limits and no need for APE. 26. The allegation that the December 13 IEP improperly fails to contain a new “special factors” page setting forth such matters as modifications and accommodations and amount of time in general education lacks merit for the same reasons. The special factors page of the February 9, 2000 IEP continued in effect until February 2001. 27. Moreover, implementation of the DIS counseling goals and objectives in the February 9, 2000 IEP, which continued in effect until February 2001, would have been appropriate, if necessary, as a short-term measure. 28. To the extent that Petitioner is arguing that he thus failed to make educational progress on the grade 5 written language goals, as noted above, the FAPE issue related to his grade 5 year was already litigated in a prior due process proceeding. (Dist. Exh. 15.) 29. Ms. Kurtz has a bachelor’s degree in secondary education with an emphasis in English and special education and a master’s degree in educational administration. She has California credentials in learning handicapped, single subject (English) teaching, and educational administration. She has taught regular education high school English and was a resource specialist for three years. She has also been a program specialist and SDC teacher. She has 19 years’ experience writing IEP goals and objectives. 30. Mr. Eyler testified that there were two incidents involving STUDENT and another student, but they were resolved through conflict resolution and, in one case, between the students themselves. He did not indicate that STUDENT had serious behavioral problems warranting a behavior intervention plan. 31. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds that, under the circumstances, the District was not required to file for due process pursuant to California Education Code Section 56346(b) because the parents indicated that STUDENT would be returning to Dr. Hogan for therapy and, thus, that he would be receiving from a private therapist counseling services that the District offered. 32. There is no merit to Petitioner’s arguments that the goals in the February 6, 2001 IEP lack a baseline to measure progress and do not indicate how they will be implemented. Each goal has a baseline, though perhaps without numerical measures, and progress can be assessed by the short-term objectives or benchmarks, which set forth objective evaluative parameters. Moreover, the goals and objectives are sufficiently clear as to how they will be carried out. Regarding a goal for STUDENT to transition to general education, Petitioner has failed to show a need for such an IEP goal. As discussed below under “Least Restrictive Environment,” the IEP team addressed such a proposed transition at three IEP meetings. 33. The baseline for this goal was that STUDENT had a history of difficulty initiating a task and not completing class assignments at least 50% of the time. This baseline, taken from a task completion goal on the February 9, 2000 IEP, was consistently referred to by Petitioner’s mother in questioning the District’s witnesses. It appeared to be a source of grave concern. 34. The evidence was that in October 2000, the mother had the requisite affidavit for home schooling to be in compliance with the mandatory attendance law. (Testimony of Mr. Hudgins.) The District was thus under the impression that STUDENT was being home-schooled. (Testimony of Ms. Murphy.) 35. Regarding extracurricular activities, the evidence was that assemblies, for example, were held on rotating days and times, although it was not clear during which periods. There was no evidence that STUDENT was denied access to these activities if he was on campus at the time. At the hearing, the parent referred to a May 22, 2001 District letter stating that because STUDENT had not maintained a 2.0 GPA, he was ineligible to participate in “performance-related” school activities. (Pet. Exh. 17.) However, no evidence was presented that STUDENT was interested in school activities requiring public performance, such as athletics.
