California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 25, 2005

Student v. Holtville Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 67-05 · Hearing Officer Claudia J. Wrazel

Holtville Unified may proceed with expulsion of student with ADHD; manifestation determination flaws cured, all claims denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes that on January 20, 2005, the school board voted to expel the student but suspended execution pending the outcome of this due process proceeding. No appeal, remand, or correction is noted.

Summary

The student filed for an expedited hearing to stop Holtville Unified School District from expelling him. He was a 16-year-old high school student eligible for special education as other health impaired due to ADHD, with a specific learning disability in math. He had a behavior support plan and a long discipline history. The District extended his suspension pending expulsion after he struck a substitute teacher and later confronted her. The student argued that the District extended the suspension without meeting his mother and held flawed manifestation determinations. He also claimed the District ignored his mother's January 2004 request for a behavioral assessment, provided too little counseling, and gave inadequate home instruction during the suspension.

Hearing Officer Claudia J. Wrazel found that the District properly invited the mother to discuss the suspension extension. The November 2 meeting was missing required team members, and the November 29 meeting went ahead without the mother, which violated federal procedural rules. However, a full second manifestation determination on December 14, with the mother and advocates present, cured both problems. No medical doctor was required. The Hearing Officer found that the District had responded reasonably to the student's behavior. She credited teachers and psychologists who testified that the plan failed because the student would not cooperate or take his medication. Home work packets plus weekly tutoring by an RSP teacher were adequate. All relief was denied, and the expulsion may proceed.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO weighed parent participation against discipline deadlines. Holding a manifestation determination without the parent was a violation, but repeating it in full with the parent present cured it. It also shows a behavior plan held adequate where the record tied its failure to the student's refusal to take part.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 1. Did the District fail to comply with procedural requirements for extending Petitioner's suspension while undertaking expulsion proceedings against him?

    The District called the mother on November 4 to invite her to meet with the superintendent. Given the 20-day suspension limit and safety concerns, extending the suspension without waiting for her callback did not violate Education Code section 48911(g).

  2. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEDiscipline

    Issue 2(1). Did the District fail to comply with procedural requirements for conducting a manifestation determination: the November 2, 2004 return-from-suspension meeting on the October 25 incident, held without the school psychologist

    The November 2 meeting was meant to be a manifestation determination. It was defective because no general education teacher or school psychologist attended. This was a technical violation, cured by rescheduling with all required members.

  3. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEDiscipline

    Issue 2(2). Did the District violate procedural requirements by conducting the November 29, 2004 manifestation determination without Petitioner's mother present?

    Going ahead without the mother violated federal procedural requirements, because parent participation should take priority over meeting deadlines. The District cured the violation by reconvening on December 14 with her present.

  4. District prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 2(3). Did the December 14, 2004 manifestation determination violate federal law because it was held outside federal timelines and no medical doctor was present?

    The late timing was a technical violation justified by efforts to secure parent participation. No authority requires a medical doctor to attend. The December 14 meeting substantively complied with federal and state law.

  5. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 3(1). Did the District fail to appropriately address Petitioner's behavioral and emotional needs in responding to the mother's January 23, 2004 request for a functional behavioral assessment / AB 2726 referral, by failing to conduct an FBA or functional analysis assessment or to implement a BIP?

    The District responded promptly. The behavior specialist reasonably chose to revise the behavior support plan with the student's input before starting a longer BIP process. The revision was interrupted by the student's AHLP enrollment, his conduct at an IEP meeting, and a meeting the parent cancelled.

  6. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 3(2). Did the District fail to meet its obligations under 34 C.F.R. § 300.520(b) to conduct an FBA or implement or modify a behavior plan after its November 4, 2004 change in placement?

    A behavior plan was already in place. No change was needed because the plan failed due to the student's refusal to cooperate and take his medication, not because of its design or implementation.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3(3). Did the District fail to provide adequate counseling to address Petitioner's behavior problems?

    The student received ICBH case management and offers of informal counseling and the AHLP program, but he rejected them. The claim that more counseling would have prevented the misconduct was speculative.

  8. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Has the District's provision of educational services to Petitioner since the extension of his suspension failed to enable Petitioner to appropriately progress in the general curriculum or to achieve the goals in his IEP?

    Home work packets with teacher instructions, plus weekly one-hour tutoring by an RSP teacher, met 34 C.F.R. § 300.121(d)(2). The student's lack of progress came from his own choices.

  9. District prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 5. If the District failed to comply with procedural requirements regarding his extended suspension or expulsion, is Petitioner entitled to relief including the dismissal of expulsion proceedings or the expungement of the alleged misconduct from his records?

    State law provides no express sanction, and the District cured the only procedural violations it committed. Dismissal and expungement were denied.

  10. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 6. If the District has failed to provide appropriate educational services to Petitioner since the extension of his suspension, is Petitioner entitled to prospective placement in a nonpublic school?

    There was no denial of FAPE, so the student was not entitled to compensatory education or nonpublic school placement.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Petitioner's requests for relief, including dismissal of the expulsion proceedings, expungement, and nonpublic school placement, are denied.
  • The District's expulsion proceedings may go forward.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

20 U.S.C. § 1415(k); 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.519, 300.520; 34 C.F.R. § 300.121(d)(2); 34 C.F.R. § 300.346; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 48903, 48911(g), 48915.5, 48918; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, §§ 3001, 3052; Lester H. v. Gilhool (3d Cir. 1990)

People named in the decision

  • Gil Navarro, education advocate for Student (non-attorney)
  • Pat Wisdom, education advocate for Student
  • Andrea Naested, attorney for District, Holtville Unified School District
  • Jacqueline Hester, principal, Holtville High School, Holtville Unified School District
  • Maria de Lourdes Leon, certified Spanish interpreter
  • Jarene Schneider, RSP math teacher and case manager, Holtville High School
  • Robert Candland, world culture teacher, Holtville High School
  • Amy Tomlinson, agriculture/keyboarding teacher, Holtville High School
  • Carol Ruiz, administrative assistant to District superintendent, Holtville Unified School District
  • Fabiola Ibarra, academic counselor, Holtville Unified School District
  • Martha Soto, attendance secretary, Holtville Unified School District
  • Marjorie Stacey, RSP English teacher and home tutor; acting director of special education, Holtville Unified School District
  • Darrel Pechtl, vice principal, Holtville High School, Holtville Unified School District
  • Deborah Montoya, former school psychologist, Holtville Unified School District
  • Robert Whalen, school psychologist under contract to District; conducted the 2004 psychoeducational reevaluation, Holtville Unified School District (contract)
  • Norma Zuniga, former program specialist / behavior intervention specialist, Imperial County SELPA
  • Diane Estrada, case manager, Imperial County Behavioral Health
  • Alvin Martin, case manager, Adolescent Habilitative Learning Program (AHLP), Imperial County Behavioral Health
  • Ms. Abatti, substitute science teacher, Holtville High School
  • Mr. Zaragoza, school staff member selected to provide informal emotional support, Holtville High School
  • Patricia Salcido, District superintendent, Holtville Unified School District
  • Patricia McLaughlin, District witness (role not stated), Holtville Unified School District
  • Dr. Cuza, psychologist who prepared mental health evaluation, Imperial County Behavioral Health
  • Ms. Van Der Linden, general education teacher, Holtville High School
  • Mr. Sarot, SELPA director, Imperial County SELPA

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of Pacific=s McGeorge School of Law, in Holtville, California, on February 3, 4, 8, and 9, 2005.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by education advocate Gil Navarro. Also present on Petitioner=s behalf were his mother, MOTHER, and education advocate Pat Wisdom. Respondent Holtville Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Andrea Naested. Also present on behalf of the District was Jacqueline Hester, principal of Holtville High School. Certified Spanish interpreter Maria de Lourdes Leon provided a simultaneous translation of the proceedings for MOTHER.

Petitioner called as witnesses three of his high school teachers: Jarene Schneider, resource specialist program (RSP) math teacher; Robert Candland, world culture teacher; and Amy Tomlinson, agriculture/keyboarding teacher. In addition, Petitioner called his mother as a witness and testified on his own behalf.

The District called the following District employees as witnesses: Carol Ruiz, administrative assistant; Fabiola Ibarra, academic counselor; Martha Soto, attendance secretary; Marjorie Stacey, RSP English teacher; and Darrel Pechtl, vice principal of Holtville High School. In addition, the District called as witnesses Deborah Montoya, former school psychologist for the District; Robert Whalen, school psychologist under contract to the District; Norma Zuniga, former program specialist for the Imperial County SELPA; Diane Estrada, case manager for Imperial County Behavioral Health (ICBH); and Alvin Martin, case manager for the Adolescent Habilitative Learning Program (AHLP), an ICBH adolescent program. (Footnote 1)

Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the receipt of closing briefs on February 15, 2005, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On January 25, 2005, at the request of the District, a prehearing telephone conference was held to clarify the issues for hearing. A memorandum by the hearing officer presiding at the prehearing conference indicated that the two issues Petitioner would present for hearing were (1) whether the District made procedural errors in its implementation of the suspension and expulsion process, and (2) whether the District failed to adequately respond to the January 2004 request by Petitioner’s mother for additional behavioral analysis. The memo further states, without additional clarification, that Petitioner contended that his placement “failed to meet his unique needs.”

On February 4, 2005, the second day of the due process hearing, the Hearing Officer sought additional clarification of the statement that Petitioner’s placement “failed to meet his unique needs.” Petitioner contended that as a result of the District’s failure to adequately address his mother’s January 2004 request for additional behavioral analysis and intervention, he was “inappropriately placed” at the time of the November 2004 incident resulting in his expulsion.

Petitioner contended that an adequate assessment would have discovered an emotional disturbance sufficient to qualify him for special education services on that ground, which might have led his IEP team to find a nexus between his disability and the incident in question and rendered further expulsion proceedings inappropriate.

The District protested that this issue was untimely raised. Given the lack of clarification in the prehearing conference memorandum, the Hearing Officer agreed with the District, and found that the Petitioner would not be allowed to allege that he had been inadequately assessed for the purpose of determining his qualifying disability for special education services. However, as a school district is required to address all of the educational needs of a special education student regardless of his qualifying disability, the Hearing Officer found that the Petitioner would be allowed to argue that the District’s response to MOTHER’s January 2004 request was inadequate to meet Petitioner’s emotional and behavioral needs.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

Issue No. 1: Did the District fail to comply with procedural requirements for extending Petitioner’s suspension while undertaking expulsion proceedings against him?

Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to comply with procedural requirements for conducting a manifestation determination regarding Petitioner’s last two disciplinary suspensions on October 25 and November 2, 2004?

Issue No. 3: Did the District fail to appropriately address Petitioner’s behavioral and emotional needs by failing to conduct either a functional behavioral assessment (FBA) or a functional assessment analysis (FAA), or by failing to implement a behavioral intervention plan (BIP)? Issue No. 4: Has the District’s provision of educational services to Petitioner since the extension of his suspension failed to enable Petitioner to appropriately progress in the general curriculum or to achieve the goals in his individualized education plan (IEP)?

Issue No. 5: If the District failed to comply with procedural requirements regarding his extended suspension or expulsion, is Petitioner entitled to relief including the dismissal of expulsion proceedings?

Issue No. 6: If the District has failed to provide appropriate educational services to Petitioner since the extension of his suspension, is Petitioner entitled to prospective placement in a nonpublic school?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that the District violated federal and State procedural requirements in its efforts to expel him from Holtville High School. (Footnote 2) First, Petitioner alleges that the District extended his suspension without first meeting with his parent to discuss the proposed extension. Second, Petitioner contends that the District’s attempts to conduct a “manifestation determination” of the relationship between his disability and his alleged misconduct was defective because at one such meeting the school psychologist was not present, at a second meeting his mother was not present, and a third manifestation determination at which his mother was present was untimely.

Petitioner also asserts that the District failed to conduct an appropriate behavior analysis or to implement a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) for him after his behavior support plan did not appear to be working, particularly after his mother requested an additional behavior assessment in January 2004, and failed to provide him with adequate behavioral and emotional counseling. He contends that due to these failures, his emotional and behavioral deficits were insufficiently addressed since at least January 2004. As a remedy for these alleged failings, Petitioner seeks dismissal of the expulsion proceedings and expungement of the underlying allegations of misconduct from his school records.

Although Petitioner does not admit the allegations underlying the District’s decision to expel him, he has expressly declined to challenge them for the purposes of this hearing. Further, although Petitioner had accumulated more than ten days of removal from his educational placement by October 7, 2004, he has not alleged that his accumulated removals constituted a “change in placement” at any point prior to November 4, 2004, when the District decided to extend his final suspension pending expulsion proceedings. (Footnote 3) As Petitioner has raised limited procedural issues regarding limited time periods in the suspension and expulsion process, this Decision is correspondingly limited in scope. It does not address any substantive expulsion issues, and does not address any District obligations that might have arisen due to a change in placement prior to the extension of Petitioner’s final suspension on November 4, 2004. Rather, the Decision addresses only those procedural issues raised by Petitioner regarding his final two suspensions on October 25 and November 2; the District’s decision on November 4 to extend his suspension pending expulsion; and the manifestation determinations conducted regarding his final two suspensions.

Finally, Petitioner claims that the educational services provided to him by the District since November 5, 2004, when his suspension was extended pending expulsion proceedings, are inadequate because they are “not providing him with an education.” As compensation for these alleged failings, Petitioner seeks prospective placement in “a nonpublic school” that will appropriately address his emotional as well as his academic needs. Petitioner has raised no issues regarding the District’s obligation to provide him with educational services due to a possible change in placement between October 8 and November 5; accordingly, this Decision is limited to an analysis of the services provided by the District beginning November 5, 2004.

The District responds that it complied with all procedural requirements attendant to the expulsion process and should be allowed to proceed with the expulsion. The District states that it invited Petitioner’s mother to a meeting to discuss the proposed extension of his suspension; that the meeting at which the school psychologist was absent was not a manifestation determination; and that the manifestation determination that was conducted without Petitioner’s mother present went forward only after she failed to appear on the date chosen by her educational advocate after an earlier postponement at his request. The District further asserts that it held a second manifestation determination two weeks later for the express purpose of ensuring that Petitioner’s mother was present and included in the process.

In addition, the District contends that it has made extensive efforts to accommodate Petitioner’s behavioral needs, beginning with an interim behavior support plan (BSP) implemented when he entered Holtville High School, continuation of his BSP when he was found to qualify for special educational services, special training for his teachers, and further behavioral assessment and behavior plan modification in response to his mother’s request in January 2004. The District contends that Petitioner’s continued behavior problems are due to his lack of interest in school, unwillingness to work with his teachers and counselors, failure to take his ADHD medication, and general defiance of authority.

Finally, the District asserts that it has provided appropriate educational services to Petitioner since the extension of his school suspension on November 5, 2004.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a sixteen-year-old high school student with a long history of academic, attitude and behavior difficulties in school. When he was fourteen, STUDENT was found eligible for special education services under the category of “other health impaired” (OHI) due to a medical diagnosis of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), with an additional specific learning disability (SLD) relating to math processing skills.

Prior to his November 2004 suspension from school, STUDENT’s last agreed-upon educational placement was in a general education setting at Holtville High School. In addition, STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP) included two RSP courses (math and English); a behavior support plan (BSP) implemented in all of his classes to address his ADHD and behavioral needs; and medication support services from ICBH. (Footnote 4) Since STUDENT’s suspension was extended pending expulsion proceedings on November 5, 2004, the District has provided him with services consisting of work packets prepared by his teachers for STUDENT to complete at home. Since December 14, 2004, those services have been supplemented by a weekly tutorial visit from a teacher trained in RSP math and English to help STUDENT with his work assignments.

STUDENT’s disciplinary history, ADHD diagnosis, and 504 plan (September 2003)

When STUDENT was in the sixth and seventh grades at Holtville Middle School, he was disciplined regularly for defiance, disrespectful or disruptive behavior, use of profanity, and tardiness. While in the seventh grade, STUDENT was disciplined forty-eight times in the first semester alone, and received warnings, detention, and multiple school suspensions as a result. (Footnote 5) For the most part, STUDENT was a C student while in middle school, but his grades fell due to his many school suspensions. (D. Exh. 3; testimony of MOTHER and Petitioner.)

After STUDENT had completed the seventh grade in the summer of 2003, he was permitted to skip the eighth grade and to enroll in the ninth grade at Holtville High School for the 2003-2004 school year. (Footnote 6) At the same time, STUDENT’s mother and his educational advocate, Mr. Navarro, requested that he be assessed for special education eligibility in the areas of academic ability, speech, motor skills, “emotional concerns,” and the possible presence of an attention deficit disorder (ADD). (D. Exh. 4.) When an initial evaluation by Imperial County Behavioral Health (ICBH) indicated that STUDENT showed symptoms of ADHD, the District began to develop a “504 plan” for him pending the outcome of his psychoeducational assessments. (Footnote 7)

At an IEP meeting on September 2, 2003, STUDENT, his mother, and his educational advocates met with District and ICBH personnel and agreed that pending completion of his plan, STUDENT’s teachers would be apprised of his ADHD diagnosis and would prepare weekly reports on his progress in class. (Footnote 8) The team also agreed that STUDENT would wear his prescription eyeglasses during class time and would be given preferential seating in the front of the class to address vision issues. (D. Exh. 5.)

At the next IEP meeting on September 22, 2003, STUDENT’s teachers noted that he did well in oral class participation, but had weak outside work habits and often failed to turn in his homework or bring his materials to class. STUDENT appeared to enjoy his guitar and physical education classes and had A grades in both, but in other classes he often was “off task,” talking to those around him and failing to pay attention. He currently had D and F grades in physics, math, and English, largely due to failure to turn in his assignments.

The IEP team agreed to a set of “504 plan accommodations” that included checking periodically with STUDENT to make sure he understood class lessons and assignments, allowing him extra time to complete assignments and take tests, reviewing good study habits with him, and sending weekly progress reports home to his parents. For behavior supports, the plan provided that STUDENT would be praised for positive behaviors, given nonverbal cues to redirect him to task, allowed “time outs” for restlessness, and given extra privileges or rewards for good behavior or academic progress. Inappropriate behaviors would be responded to in a “non-confronting manner,” and behaviors that were not “drastically outside the classroom rules” would be ignored.

The plan also provided that STUDENT’s parents would enforce consistent homework and study time, provide consequences or rewards based on his school progress reports, and ensure that he took his ADHD medication. (Footnote 9) Further, it provided that STUDENT would come to class prepared, do his homework, take his medication, and follow school and class rules. STUDENT and his mother agreed to the plan, and STUDENT indicated that he believed he could do the work expected of him. (D. Exh. 6.)

STUDENT’s psychoeducational assessment (October 22, 2003)

As a part of STUDENT’s initial evaluation for special education services, he was comprehensively assessed by school psychologist Deborah Montoya in October of 2003. The assessment included a review of his records, administration of standardized achievement, intelligence, auditory and visual integration, and behavioral tests, and questionnaires completed by his teachers. Ms. Montoya reported that STUDENT was fidgety and distracted during the tests, but responded to verbal redirections to task. “Overall,” she noted, “STUDENT was found to be a pleasant and friendly young man, who demonstrated no overt mood or behavior problems during the assessment sessions that would invalidate any of the assessment measures provided.”

According to his health assessment, STUDENT was nearsighted and wore prescription reading glasses, but he refused to wear his glasses during the academic portion of the assessment and reported that he also refused to wear them in school. STUDENT’s verbal and performance intelligence quotients tested in the average range, with relative strengths in abstract reasoning, logical thinking, and perceptual organizational skills. He showed relative weaknesses in numerical accuracy, mental arithmetic, and “freedom from distractability.”

STUDENT’s performance on his achievement tests indicated an average or slightly below average academic ability for his grade level. His social/emotional tests, however, revealed marked oppositional behaviors and poor attention in class. STUDENT’s teachers reported that he got along well with his peers, but often defied adult authority. His progress reports showed D or F grades in most subjects, which his teachers attributed to his failure to turn in work, behavior problems, and general lack of motivation. The assessment report noted that the academic supports provided in STUDENT’s 504 plan did not appear to be improving his academic performance, but that his discipline record showed substantially fewer “behavioral referrals” than he had received while in middle school.

Ms. Montoya reported that in her interview with STUDENT, he stated that he found all of his classes to be “relatively easy,” but did not enjoy them, and that he didn’t complete his homework assignments because he didn’t want to do more school work at home.

Ultimately, Ms. Montoya determined that STUDENT demonstrated attention and processing deficits (particularly in math) consistent with his diagnosis of ADHD, as well as some indicators of oppositional defiant disorder (ODD). (Footnote 10) She recommended placement in an RSP math class and a continuation of the academic and behavior interventions contained in STUDENT’s 504 plan. In addition, Ms. Montoya recommended that STUDENT be considered by ICBH for “additional therapy” and possible placement in its Adolescent Habilitative Learning Program (AHLP), a county school program that provided intensive peer and one-to-one behavioral counseling as well as academic classes. (D. Exh. 7, pp. 25-33.) STUDENT’s initial qualification for special education services (November 2003)

On November 7, 2003, STUDENT’s IEP team reviewed Ms. Montoya’s assessment report and determined that he qualified for special education services as Other Health Impaired (OHI) due to ADHD, with a specific learning disability (SLD) in math processing. The team developed an education plan consisting of regular classroom placement for most of the school day, with one period spent in an RSP math class. The team developed a math goal that would require STUDENT to apply math skills to life situations, and a behavior goal that would require him to report any stress factors that “may lead to behavioral outbursts.”

STUDENT’s teachers reported that STUDENT continued to show attitude and behavior problems in school, and that his most significant problem was his failure and refusal to do class assignments and homework. His science teacher reported that STUDENT was bright and did well on tests, but refused to do assignments in class. His keyboarding teacher reported that STUDENT would respond to assignments by saying “I don’t need to know this.” She added that STUDENT would complain that his eyes hurt, and had been offered a glare-free screen, but that he refused to wear his glasses in class. MOTHER observed that STUDENT uses a computer at home for hours at a time with no complaints about discomfort.

STUDENT’s English teacher said he refused to do class assignments because he “preferred to do them at home,” but his mother reported that STUDENT told her he didn’t have any homework. MOTHER asked the other team members if STUDENT could stay late after school to finish his work, but STUDENT, who was present at the meeting, interjected that he wouldn’t do it. Mr. Navarro asked STUDENT why he wasn’t doing the work, and STUDENT responded that he didn’t want to. When asked about misbehaving in class, STUDENT referred to other student’s behaviors instead of addressing his own. He also said he wanted to go to community school.

STUDENT left the meeting to return to class, and the other team members discussed his lack of motivation and possible behavior intervention strategies. MOTHER stated that STUDENT could behave himself in adult company but sometimes misbehaved in front of his friends in order to impress them. At Ms. Montoya’s recommendation, MOTHER agreed to a referral to ICBH for consideration of additional services, and agreed to consider the AHLP program for STUDENT. Finally, the team agreed that a behavioral support plan (BSP) would be developed with the assistance of the SELPA behavioral specialists. (D. Exh. 7.)

Development and implementation of STUDENT’s BSP (November 2003 – January 2004) (Footnote 11)

The BSP developed for STUDENT was founded on the hypothesis that STUDENT engaged in defiant behavior in class to increase his status among his peers and allow him to avoid doing class work. The plan’s goals were to increase teacher rapport with STUDENT, encourage him to gain attention and status in positive ways, and teach him anger management, social skills, and time management skills. To accomplish these goals, the BSP set forth the following accommodations and supports:

(1) A structured environment, in which STUDENT would be seated near positive role models, given a study carrel or non-distracting work environment when needed, and redirected to task with “nonconfrontational” prompts;

(2) Reinforcements, including use of head phones during independent work, praise for appropriate behaviors and assignment completion, and a “no homework” day as reward for consecutive completion of homework assignments;

(3) Behavior control strategies, including private discussions regarding noncompliant behavior, “cool down” periods away from class, and opportunities to meet with teachers or counselors as needed to discuss concerns or needs; and (4) Weekly behavior and grade feedback logs to STUDENT’s parents, follow-up on ICBH referral, and issuance of a case manager to meet his emotional needs. (D. Exh. 8.)

On December 10, 2003, STUDENT and the other IEP team members met to review his class performance and behavior in light of the recently implemented BSP. STUDENT’s RSP math teacher reported that STUDENT had completed only a few of his recent assignments, and had refused the teacher’s offers of assistance on his uncompleted work. STUDENT told the team that his eyes hurt, and promised to complete more assignments when he got contact lenses, which his mother had ordered for him. STUDENT also said he was bored in RSP math because there were no other students in the class.

In January 2004, ICBH began to provide STUDENT with medication support and “mental health service and targeted case management services.” Ms. Estrada, STUDENT’s ICBH case manager, began weekly one-hour visits to STUDENT at school and at home to check on his progress, teach him organization and study skills, and address behavioral or emotional issues. ICBH also recommended the AHLP program, but STUDENT did not accept that recommendation.

On January 23, 2004, STUDENT and the rest of the IEP team met to discuss his progress. Several teachers noted that STUDENT was failing in their classes, but that he had asked for the opportunity to do makeup work, which they were happy to provide for him. STUDENT had recently received a B grade on an English test, but had not turned in any of his homework. STUDENT’s guitar teacher reported that STUDENT was continually defiant and disruptive in class, rejected the teacher’s efforts to implement the BSP, and appeared to be under the impression that his BSP accommodations allowed him to “get away with anything” in class.

The RSP math teacher reported that STUDENT completed few tasks and had failed all tests. STUDENT would complain that his head hurt due to lack of eyeglasses or contacts, but appeared able to write or draw without discomfort when not doing math. STUDENT responded that he didn’t want to have to work for a whole classroom hour, but admitted he only worked ten minutes of the class period.

STUDENT reported that his teachers were picking on him and that other students were not reprimanded for their misbehavior. His education advocate asked whether his behavioral issues might stem from the fact that he had skipped the eighth grade. The team discussed this and determined that STUDENT might benefit from emotional support provided by a school staff person of his choice. STUDENT said he thought Mr. Zaragoza would be a good candidate, and arrangements were made for STUDENT to meet with Mr. Zaragoza at lunch. (D. Exh. 9.)

MOTHER’s request for additional behavioral assessment (January 23, 2004)

At the January IEP meeting, MOTHER gave school psychologist Ms. Montoya a handwritten request that STUDENT receive “a Functional Behavioral Assessment (AB 2726 referral) to County Mental Health.” Ms. Montoya immediately sent an e-mail to Norma Zuniga, the SELPA behavior intervention specialist, conveying MOTHER’s request and noting that on January 5, Ms. Montoya also had contacted Ms. Zuniga with a request for assistance in developing a Behavior Intervention Plan (BIP) for STUDENT because his BSP did not appear to be working. (D. Exh. 10.) (Footnote12)

In response, Ms. Zuniga reviewed STUDENT’s records, interviewed him, and began to observe him in his classes consistent with the statutory requirements for a BIP. In a summary of two days of classroom observations on January 28 and 29, 2004, Ms. Zuniga noted that STUDENT had a BSP in place, but refused to cooperate with his teachers. From her interview with STUDENT, Ms. Zuniga surmised that he “gets his way at home with his mother.”

Ms. Zuniga believed that, since the analysis required for a BIP would take time, it should be preceded by a more effective BSP that included STUDENT’s input and allowed him to feel some ownership and responsibility for its outcome. She began to develop a revised draft of his current BSP that would include STUDENT’s contributions. In the meantime, she noted that “it is imperative that STUDENT be on medication for the ADHD,” particularly because STUDENT had informed her that he was more able to pay attention in class when he was taking his medication. (D. Exh. 10; testimony of Ms. Zuniga.)

STUDENT’s application for, enrollment in, and discharge from AHLP (February-May 2004)

Between February and April 2004, communications between MOTHER, the District, and ICBH indicated that STUDENT was not taking his ADHD medication. (D. Exhs. 11, 12.) In February, after STUDENT had engaged in an emotional outburst at school when his mother happened to be present, MOTHER accepted ICBH’s recommendation that STUDENT apply for admission to AHLP. (Id.)

STUDENT was enrolled in AHLP on April 21, 2004. The program consisted of four class periods per day, with two hours per day of peer counseling about group members’ behavior issues. At the introductory meeting, the AHLP instructors explained that STUDENT was being accepted on a thirty-day trial basis, and would be expected to follow the program’s rules.

On May 17, 2004, the AHLP instructors convened a meeting with STUDENT, his mother, ICBH case manager Ms. Estrada, and SELPA behavior specialist Ms. Zuniga, to review STUDENT’s performance during his trial period. AHLP staff indicated that STUDENT exhibited defiant and oppositional behaviors in the program, and did not appear inclined to change his behaviors. He distracted the other students and was disruptive both in class and in peer counseling sessions. Accordingly, AHLP discharged STUDENT from the program and returned him to the District. (D. Exh. 13.)

STUDENT’s reentry to Holtville High School (May 2004)

An IEP meeting was held on May 19, 2004, to discuss STUDENT’s reentry to Holtville High School after his expulsion from AHLP. It was noted that STUDENT was failing all of his classes and would have to repeat his freshman year.

Mr. Pechtl expressed concerns that STUDENT’s behavioral history of defiance, disrespect, use of profanity, and failure to complete his work had persisted at AHLP, and stressed that STUDENT would need to be respectful and adhere to school rules. He invited STUDENT to meet with him if there were any issues STUDENT wanted to discuss. MOTHER said she was doing the best she could as a mother to guide her son, and that she was considering taking a course in parenting skills.

Ms. Zuniga asked for more time to develop the new BSP she had been working on with STUDENT’s input before he entered AHLP. Mr. Pechtl responded that any new behavior plan would need to be implemented immediately. The team scheduled a follow-up meeting for May 24, 2004, and agreed that the BSP in place before STUDENT entered AHLP would remain in effect until a new plan was implemented. A copy of the current BSP was distributed to STUDENT’s teachers after the IEP meeting. (D. Exh. 14.)

On May 24, the IEP team met to review Ms. Zuniga’s revised BSP, which included behavior intervention strategies suggested by STUDENT. (Footnote 13) During the discussion, MOTHER said something that apparently upset STUDENT, and he responded by kicking his mother and using profanity toward her. He also insulted Ms. Zuniga. The meeting was suspended and rescheduled for May 27, 2004, but MOTHER later cancelled the February 27 meeting. The school year ended shortly thereafter. (D. Exh. 15; testimony of Mr. Pechtl.)

STUDENT’s behavior in the 2004-2005 school year (September-October 2004)

The 2004-2005 school year began on September 6, 2004. By the time STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting took place on September 27, he already had been suspended twice for a total of eight days and had received seven hours of detention for various types of misconduct. (Footnote 14) STUDENT’s RSP math teacher stated he was not meeting his IEP goals. Progress notes by STUDENT’s teachers indicated that was failing his classes because he consistently failed to do class work or homework. Several teachers indicated that they believed STUDENT had the ability to do the work, but was unwilling to make the effort. (Footnote 15) They described their efforts to implement the BSP, but noted that STUDENT continued to be noncompliant and argumentative in class.

The team noted that ICBH had terminated services to STUDENT in June 2004 because he was noncompliant, and his ICBH counselor felt she couldn’t help him if he wouldn’t take his medication or accept her advice and assistance. At the IEP meeting, MOTHER said she wanted to reinstate ICBH services because STUDENT was better behaved and a better student when he took his medication. The District agreed to make a new referral to ICBH. In the meantime, a probation counselor who recently had joined District staff offered to meet with STUDENT to help him work on his behavior issues. (D. Exh. 17.)

By October 8, STUDENT had accumulated a total of ten days of suspension and fifteen hours of detention for defiance and disruptive conduct. At an October 12 IEP meeting, the team agreed to assign STUDENT to an RSP English class so he could receive instruction at a more individualized level. Some teachers reported that STUDENT appeared “more willing” to work in recent classes, but others reported continued defiance, use of profanity, and inappropriate remarks in class. (Footnote 16) Mr. Pechtl noted that STUDENT’s behaviors were impeding not only his own learning, but also that of his classmates. Education advocate Mr. Navarro agreed that STUDENT’s behaviors were “out of control,” and indicated that MOTHER would follow up with ICBH to reinstate services for STUDENT.

MOTHER reported that she felt like STUDENT was being treated like a potential criminal. She said she advised STUDENT to behave better in class, but that he became angrier with every suspension. In response, the District described the “cooling off” periods extended to STUDENT, and added that sometimes STUDENT was allowed to go home after an incident without a suspension or other penalty. MOTHER also said STUDENT had been “depressed” recently, and it was noted that if he became a danger to himself or others, calls should be placed to “911” and to the ICBH Crisis Center. The District repeated its invitation to MOTHER to attend school to witness STUDENT’s behaviors, and Mr. Navarro encouraged her to do so.

Following the IEP meeting, school psychologist Ms. Montoya sent to ICBH a request for re-initiation of medication support and for a new mental health evaluation. Attached to the request were several teacher progress notes describing STUDENT’s recent behaviors in class. Ms. Montoya’s request noted that STUDENT’s parent and District staff were concerned that “mental health issues are impeding learning.” (D. Exh. 18.)

On October 15, 2004, MOTHER sent to the District a written request that STUDENT be assessed for “emotional disturbance,” and that he be reassessed in reading, writing, math and fine motor skills. She also requested that STUDENT be provided with a one-to-one aide “in every class that he is failing.”

The District administered the assessments requested by MOTHER on November 16 and 29, 2004. (See Dist. Exhs. 19, 24.) (Footnote 17) Prior to these assessments, however, STUDENT received the suspensions that resulted in the initiation of expulsion proceedings against him.

STUDENT’s last two suspensions (October 25-29 and November 3-4,2004)

On October 25, 2004, Mr. Pechtl was informed that STUDENT was refusing to follow a substitute science teacher’s direction that he report to the office. Mr. Pechtl went to the class and repeatedly directed STUDENT to accompany him to the office. When STUDENT refused, Mr. Pechtl told the substitute teacher, Ms. Abatti, to take the other students out of the class, and then redirected STUDENT to accompany him. STUDENT became angry, threw a pencil across the room, and kicked another student’s backpack across the floor before following Mr. Pechtl out of the room. As he passed Ms. Abatti outside, STUDENT swung his arm out and struck her in the back, causing her to stagger slightly. STUDENT continued to walk away, then turned back and threw a pencil at Ms. Abatti. For this misconduct STUDENT was given a five-day suspension from school, bringing his accumulated total to sixteen days of suspension. (D. Exhs. 2,3; testimony of Mr. Pechtl.)

On November 2, 2004, the District convened a “return from suspension” IEP meeting to determine if STUDENT’s October 25 misconduct was a manifestation of his disability. Present were school principal Ms. Hester; STUDENT’s case manager and RSP math teacher Ms. Schneider; MOTHER; and a Spanish interpreter. Ms. Hester and Ms. Schneider signed a form indicating that they believed STUDENT was “appropriately placed” at the time of his misconduct, that the misconduct “in all likelihood” was not caused by or a manifestation of his disability, and that the consensus of the IEP team was that STUDENT should be subject to applicable disciplinary actions and procedures. MOTHER declined to sign the form because she wanted Mr. Navarro to review it first. The participants agreed to meet again on November 18.

When STUDENT returned to school on November 2, he was told that he could not attend his science class because Ms. Abatti was the substitute teacher. STUDENT was “defiant in response and attitude,” and snuck out of the office where he had been ordered to remain. He walked into Ms. Abatti’s class, refused her order to leave, and ultimately “stormed outside,” slamming and kicking the door. A few seconds later he returned to the classroom and “challenged” Ms. Abatti, saying “What? Are you afraid of me?” He then returned to Mr. Pechtl’s office. Mr. Pechtl confronted STUDENT and told him he had no right to harass Ms. Abatti. STUDENT responded that he hadn’t harassed her, and was overheard commenting to other students, “She thinks that is harassment? I’ll show her harassment!”

For this misconduct STUDENT was given a two-day suspension from school, bringing his accumulated days of suspension to eighteen (plus fifteen hours of detention) since school had begun in September. School officials did not seek a longer suspension at this point because they believed they were statutorily barred from imposing more than twenty cumulative days of suspension in a school year. (Footnote 18) Instead, the District determined to seek an extension of the suspension pending expulsion proceedings. (D. Exhs. 2,3; testimony of Mr. Pechtl.)

Extension of suspension and initiation of expulsion proceedings (November 4-19, 2004)

On November 4, 2004, the day before STUDENT was scheduled to return to school, the District began expulsion proceedings against him. Mr. Pechtl executed a written request for an extension of STUDENT’s suspension, and directed Carol Ruiz, administrative assistant to the District superintendent, to arrange a meeting between MOTHER and the superintendent to discuss the proposed extension. Ms. Ruiz telephoned MOTHER, and reported to Mr. Pechtl that MOTHER would get back to the District about a meeting date. (Footnote 19) Because he believed he was operating under statutory time constraints, Mr. Pechtl directed Ms. Ruiz to send MOTHER an official notice of extended suspension pending expulsion proceedings even though no meeting with the superintendent had yet occurred. (Testimony of Ms. Ruiz and Mr. Pechtl.) (Footnote 20)

Upon the extension of STUDENT’s suspension, the District provided for his education by having all of his teachers prepare work packets for him to complete at home, accompanied by instructions as to how the work was to be done. Once completed by STUDENT, the packets were to be returned to school by MOTHER. The teachers would then grade the assignments, prepare new work packets and instructions, and notify MOTHER that they were ready to be picked up and delivered to STUDENT. (Testimony of Ms. Stacey.)

The District notified MOTHER and Mr. Navarro that a manifestation determination regarding the October 25 and November 2 incidents would be scheduled for November 18, 2004. On November 19, Mr. Navarro called the District and requested a continuance to November 29, 2004. (D. Exhs. 20, 21; testimony of Patricia McLaughlin.)

November 29, 2004 manifestation determination

On November 29, 2004, the District convened the manifestation determination meeting, and a telephone call was placed to MOTHER to determine if she would be attending. MOTHER told District staff that she would not attend the meeting because she did not know that a meeting had been scheduled for that date. Mr. Navarro also failed to attend the meeting. (Testimony of Mr. Pechtl, Ms. Soto, and MOTHER.)

The District decided to proceed with the meeting in the absence of MOTHER and Mr. Navarro because the meeting date already had been continued once at Mr. Navarro’s request, the November 29 date had been chosen by Mr. Navarro, all fourteen of the other attendees already were assembled, and there were concerns about meeting statutory time constraints. (Footnote 21) However, the participants in the November 29 meeting agreed to schedule a second meeting to review their discussions for the benefit of MOTHER and Mr. Navarro. (D. Exh. 21.)

The November 29 hearing began with a report by school psychologist Mr. Whalen, who had just completed a psychoeducational reevaluation of STUDENT in response to MOTHER’s request of October 15. Mr. Whalen’s report was received as the evaluation required as a part of the manifestation determination process. Mr. Whalen reported that STUDENT’s cognitive and academic assessment results were consistent with those from his evaluation by Ms. Montoya the previous year, with the exception of mathematics, in which he had tested lower than before. Noting that STUDENT stated that he regularly stays up until 2 a.m., gets only a few hours’ sleep a night, and was not taking his prescribed medications, Mr. Whalen opined that these factors might have affected STUDENT’s academic scores.

Regarding the social/emotional assessments, Mr. Whalen reported that STUDENT demonstrated behaviors consistent with “oppositional defiant disorder” (ODD). He tested in the average range in autonomy, identity and ego, but low in “industry” (orientation toward learning or accomplishment). STUDENT also displayed a higher-than-average level of mistrust, inferiority, and “stagnation” (living for the moment). Mr. Whalen observed that STUDENT believes he is largely in control of his behaviors, but is unwilling to develop a positive attitude toward learning.

Mr. Whalen concluded that STUDENT’s primary disability continued to be ADHD, with ODD behaviors as well. Upon receipt of Mr. Whalen’s report, the IEP team determined that it was “very clear” that STUDENT’s behaviors in striking Ms. Abatti on October 25 and threatening her on November 2 were not manifestations of his disability. (D. Exhs. 21, 24; testimony of Mr. Whalen and Mr. Pechtl.)

Expulsion recommendation (December 2, 2004)

On December 2, 2004, District superintendent Patricia Salcido sent a letter to the FAMILY informing them that the principal of Holtville High School was recommending that STUDENT be expelled from school. The letter described the October 25 and November 2 incidents forming the basis for the expulsion recommendation, explained the District’s expulsion policy, and enclosed copies of the Education Code sections related to expulsion. Ms. Salcido’s letter noted that an administrative hearing panel would hear the matter on December 15, 2004, and would make its recommendations to the school board on December 16, 2004.

The letter summarized the FAMILYS’ rights regarding the expulsion process and invited them to attend the proceedings. (D. Exh. 2, pp. 13-14.) MOTHER signed a notice acknowledging receipt of the letter, and wrote on the notice that she would consult her representative about attending the proceedings. (Id., p. 15.)

December 14, 2004 manifestation determination

On December 14, 2004, a second manifestation determination was held regarding STUDENT’s recent suspensions. Almost all of the participants in the November 29 meeting were present, as well as MOTHER, STUDENT, Mr. Navarro, and Ms. Wisdom.

Mr. Whalen reviewed his recent evaluation of STUDENT in detail. He discussed the test results and noted that STUDENT showed average abilities and was able to do the work assigned to him if he chose to do so. He also discussed STUDENT’s lack of motivation, including the fact that STUDENT did not see the need to go to high school or college. MOTHER stated that Mr. Whalen’ report gave her a lot of information she had not previously known.

An ICBH caseworker then reported on the mental health evaluation administered by ICBH in response to MOTHER’s October 15 request. The report prepared by ICBH psychologist Dr. Cuza indicated that STUDENT was of average intelligence, but with poor judgment, limited insight, and poor impulse control. The report gave a “diagnostic impression” of ADHD, academic problems, and ODD. (D. Exh. 23.)

The question of whether a nexus existed between STUDENT’s disability and his behavior on October 25 and November 2 was then posed to the group. Mr. Whalen stated that in his opinion, no nexus existed. Mr. Navarro stated that the family did not concur because no medical doctor was present at the meeting. MOTHER sought an extension of the administrative expulsion proceeding scheduled for the following day, and the District agreed to reschedule the matter for January 12, 2005. (D. Exhs. 2, 22.)

Due process request and expulsion proceedings (January 2005)

On January 11, 2005, the Hearing Office received from MOTHER a notification of the pending expulsion proceedings and a request for an expedited due process hearing.

On January 12, the administrative panel met and recommended that STUDENT be expelled. The District notified Mr. Navarro that the school board decision on the administrative recommendation would take place on January 20, 2005. (D. Exh. 2, p. 17.) On January 20, 2005, the school board decided to expel STUDENT from the Holtville Unified School District. The board suspended execution of the suspension pending the outcome of due process proceedings in this matter. (D. Exh. 2, pp. 20-21.)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Did the District fail to comply with procedural requirements for extending Petitioner’s suspension while undertaking expulsion proceedings against him?

The federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) gives disabled students certain rights in disciplinary matters. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k); 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.519-529. State law provides that disabled students may be disciplined or expelled in accordance with IDEA requirements, and also under State statutes “that do not conflict with federal law and regulations.” Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5(a).

To the extent disciplinary suspensions would apply to students without disabilities, federal regulations permit the suspension of disabled students for not more than ten consecutive school days, plus additional suspensions for not more than ten consecutive school days in the same school year for separate incidents of misconduct, “so long as those removals do not constitute a change in placement.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.520(a)(1)(i). A “change in placement” is defined as a removal for more than ten consecutive school days or a series of removals that “constitute a pattern” because they cumulate to more than ten school days in a school year, and because of “factors such as the length of each removal, the total amount of time the child is removed, and the proximity of the removals to one another.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.519.

Under State law, a student may not be suspended for more than twenty days in any school year, unless the suspension is extended pending expulsion and the District superintendent or designee has determined, “following a meeting in which the pupil and the pupil’s parent or guardian are invited to participate,” that the pupil’s presence at school would cause a danger to persons or property or threaten to disrupt the instructional process. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 48903, 48911(g).

By October 7, 2004, Petitioner had accumulated nine days of school suspension plus ten hours of in-school detention. Assuming a regular six-to-seven hour school day, Petitioner’s cumulative “removals” from his educational placement in a single school year would have exceeded ten days by that date. Over the next several days, Petitioner received two more days of suspension and five more hours of detention, followed by a five-day suspension on October 25 and a final two-day suspension on November 2, 2004. Under federal regulations, Petitioner’s suspensions and detentions between October 7 and November 4, when the District decided to extend his final suspension, might have constituted a “change in placement” if the length, proximity and cumulative time of each removal constituted a “pattern” of removals from his educational placement. See 34 C.F.R. § 300.519.

If a change in placement were found to have occurred during this period, it would have initiated District responsibilities to convene an IEP meeting to develop an assessment plan regarding Petitioner’s conduct, to implement a behavior intervention plan, or if a plan already was in place, to modify the plan or its implementation. See 34 C.F.R. § 300.520(b)(1). However, as Petitioner did not allege that his suspensions and detention hours between October 7 and November 4 constituted a change in placement, and as no evidence or argument was offered regarding this issue, this Decision will not address whether Petitioner’s suspensions and expulsions prior to the District’s decision on November 4, 2004 to extend his final suspension constituted a change in placement.

Petitioner does contend that the District violated State law by extending the two-day suspension he received on November 2, 2004, without first meeting with his parent to discuss the proposed extension. The District responds that it invited MOTHER to such a meeting, but when she failed to respond promptly, it felt obliged to extend the suspension immediately to ensure school safety.

The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence favors the District. Administrative assistant Ms. Ruiz credibly testified that she called MOTHER on November 4 to invite her to meet with the superintendent about the intended extension of STUDENT’s suspension. Although MOTHER did not remember receiving the call, she acknowledged receiving other calls from Ms. Ruiz regarding similar matters. Moreover, the consistent documentation of this and other District efforts to comply with notice requirements throughout STUDENT’s various disciplinary proceedings constitutes additional persuasive evidence that Ms. Ruiz’ November 4 telephone call inviting MOTHER to participate in such a meeting in fact took place.

Although the District might have waited longer than a day for MOTHER to call back with her response to the invitation, its decision not to do so is adequately explained by the time constraints under which it was operating. STUDENT’s November 2 suspension was necessarily short because his cumulative suspensions for the year were approaching the State statutory limit of twenty days. The District’s concerns that STUDENT’s return to school pending expulsion proceedings would cause a danger to person or property or disrupt the educational process is supported by the allegations underlying his most recent suspensions -- that he hit a teacher on October 25 and threatened her on November 2 – as well as by extensive documentary and testimonial evidence of STUDENT’s regular misbehavior in class.

Finally, both Ms. Ruiz and Mr. Pechtl credibly testified that if MOTHER had called back after November 4, a meeting with the superintendent would have been arranged, but MOTHER did not call back. As STUDENT was scheduled to return to school on November 5, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s November 4 decision to extend his suspension without waiting for a callback from MOTHER did not violate its obligations under Section 48911(g) of the California Education Code.

Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to comply with procedural requirements for conducting a manifestation determination regarding Petitioner’s last two disciplinary suspensions on October 25 and November 2, 2004?

Under federal and State law, the protections afforded to disabled students in disciplinary proceedings include the right to a determination of whether their misconduct arose from either a disability or an improper educational placement. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(4); Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5(a). Federal law provides that if a disabled student is suspended for ten days or less, or if disciplinary action is contemplated involving a change of the student’s placement for more than ten days, “a review shall be conducted of the relationship between the child=s disability and the behavior subject to the disciplinary action” within ten school days of the decision to take disciplinary action. 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(k)(4)(A). (Footnote 22) Petitioner alleges procedural violations regarding manifestation determinations on November 2, November 29, and December 14, 2004. These allegations are addressed below.

(1) November 2, 2004 manifestation determination

Under federal law, STUDENT’s periodic disciplinary suspensions for ten days or less required the District to conduct manifestation determinations regarding his misconduct within ten days of each decision to impose a suspension. 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(k)(4)(A). The District addressed this obligation by holding a “return-from-suspension” meeting the day STUDENT returned from school following a suspension to determine if a relationship existed between his disability and his misconduct.

Petitioner contends that the November 2, 2004 return-from-suspension meeting to address the misconduct resulting in STUDENT’s October 25 suspension was procedurally defective because the school psychologist was not present. The District responds that the November 2 meeting did not constitute the manifestation determination regarding the October 25 incident; rather, that meeting was scheduled for November 18 and then continued at Petitioner’s request to November 29.

Under federal law, a manifestation determination is to be conducted by the IEP team and “other qualified personnel.” 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(k)(4)(B). An IEP team is composed of the parents of the disabled student; at least one of the student’s regular education teachers; at least one of his special education teachers; a district representative knowledgeable about the curriculum and the district’s resources; an individual “who can interpret the instructional implications of evaluation results;” the student, where appropriate; and other personnel at the discretion of the parent or the district. 24 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B).

The IEP document for the November 2 meeting indicates that the participants were Holtville High School principal Ms. Hester; STUDENT’s RSP teacher Ms. Schneider; MOTHER; and a Spanish interpreter for MOTHER’s benefit. (D. Exh. 20.) (Footnote 23) The meeting notes indicate that Ms. Hester and Ms. Schneider signed a form indicating that STUDENT’s misconduct on October 25 “in all likelihood” not a manifestation of his disability, but that MOTHER wanted to consult with Mr. Navarro, who was not present, before deciding whether to sign the form. The meeting participants decided to meet again on November 18, and prepared a notice for a meeting on that date that also invited Ms. Van Der Linden, one of STUDENT’s general education teachers; Mr. Whalen, the school psychologist; Ms. Stacey, the acting director of special education for the District; and Mr. Sarot, the SELPA director. The parties do not dispute that the November 18 meeting date, which also was selected to address STUDENT’s November 2 suspension, was later continued to November 29 at the request of Mr. Navarro.

Based on these facts, it appears to the Hearing Officer that the November 2 return-from-suspension meeting was intended to be the manifestation determination regarding STUDENT’s October 25 misconduct. District witnesses testified that return-from-suspension meetings were the standard process for addressing the District’s obligation to address the relationship between a suspended student’s disability and his misconduct, and the form document signed by some of the participants clearly sets forth a manifestation determination analysis. It further appears that, as alleged by Petitioner, the meeting was procedurally defective because at the very least, none of Petitioner’s general education teachers were present, and the absence of the school psychologist would constitute a procedural defect as well. (Footnote 24)

Finally, the fact that the meeting was rescheduled for November 18 with all required IEP team members asked to attend is a further indication that the November 2 meeting lacked all of its required participants. However, the Hearing Officer finds that this procedural defect was at most a technical violation, because the meeting was rescheduled at a later date precisely to ensure that all necessary personnel could be in attendance. Although the November 18 meeting date was outside the statutory time line, and was continued a second time (at Petitioner’s request) to November 29, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s efforts to secure the attendance of necessary personnel at Petitioner’s disciplinary proceedings remediates any technical violations caused by the delay in those proceedings.

(2) The November 29, 2004 manifestation determination meeting

Federal special education law requires manifestation determination meetings to be conducted by a student’s IEP team, which includes the student’s parents and, where appropriate, the student. 20 U.S.C. §§ 1414(d)(10(B),1415(k)(4)(B). The manifestation determination must take place within ten school days of the District’s decision to expel the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(4)(B). State law requires expulsion hearings to proceed within thirty days of a school’s decision to seek expulsion, with the student entitled to at least one continuance of the hearing for up to thirty days, and with additional requests for continuances subject to the discretion of the school board. Cal. Educ. Code § 48918(a).

The parties agree that the District decided to take disciplinary action involving a change in STUDENT’s placement for more than ten days on November 4, 2004, when it extended his suspension and began expulsion proceedings against him. Further, they do not dispute that the meeting to determine if STUDENT’s alleged misconduct on November 2 was a manifestation of his disability initially was scheduled for November 18, 2004, the same date as the rescheduled manifestation determination regarding the October 25 incident, but that this meeting was rescheduled for November 29 at the request of STUDENT’s education advocate Mr. Navarro. Finally, the parties agree that when the District telephoned MOTHER on November 29 to remind her of the meeting, she declined to attend, stating that she had not known that a meeting was scheduled for that date, and the District proceeded to conduct the manifestation determination in her absence.

Petitioner contends that the November 29 manifestation determination meeting violated federal law because it took place without STUDENT’s mother in attendance. The District acknowledges that MOTHER was not present at the November 29 meeting, but asserts that it decided to proceed with the meeting in her absence because the meeting date already had been continued once at Mr. Navarro’s request, the other attendees already were assembled, and there were concerns about meeting the statutory time constraints for expulsion proceedings.

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the District’s reasoning. Both the IDEA and State law regarding disciplinary proceedings place considerable emphasis on the importance of parental participation in those proceedings. Although the District’s obligation to comply with statutory deadlines at times may conflict with its duty to secure parental participation in various proceedings, in the case of a manifestation determination the duty to make all reasonable efforts to secure parental participation should be paramount.

For example, as discussed above, the District’s decision to extend STUDENT’s suspension without waiting for his mother’s input correctly gave more weight to the District’s duty to ensure school safety than to its duty to secure parental participation in the extension decision – particularly as the extension easily could be rescinded if later parental input convinced the District that STUDENT’s readmission would not endanger the school.

By contrast, in deciding to proceed with the November 29 meeting, the District placed its duty to meet a statutory deadline above its obligation to secure parental participation even though (1) missing the deadline would have amounted to merely a technical violation justified by its efforts to ensure MOTHER’s presence; (2) the deadline could have been extended at the FAMILYS’ request (which likely could have been obtained in exchange for rescheduling the meeting); and (3) the manifestation determination was a substantive step in the disciplinary process with far more profound consequences for STUDENT than the extension of his suspension.

The fact that fourteen other participants already were assembled on November 29 was an inconvenience, but was irrelevant to the District’s obligation to make reasonable efforts to secure the attendance of STUDENT’s parents. Further, the fact that Mr. Navarro already had continued the meeting once and failed to appear on the date he had chosen no doubt was a source of irritation, but the evidence indicates that both he and MOTHER attended IEP meetings regularly and called in advance when they needed a continuance. There is no indication that their failure to appear on November 29 resulted from anything other than inadvertence.

For the reasons set forth above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s decision to proceed with the November 29 meeting in the absence of MOTHER violated federal procedural requirements for the conduct of a manifestation determination. However, as explained below, this violation was remedied by the District’s decision on November 29 to reconvene the meeting at a time MOTHER could be present. (3) The December 14, 2004 manifestation determination meeting

The parties agree that on December 14, 2004, with MOTHER, STUDENT, and Mr. Navarro in attendance, a second manifestation determination was held regarding the same issues considered at the November 29 meeting. Petitioner contends that the December 14 meeting violated federal law because it occurred “outside federal timelines” and because no medical doctor was present to determine whether a nexus existed between his disability and the conduct resulting in the decision to seek his expulsion. The Hearing Officer is unpersuaded by Petitioner’s arguments.

As discussed above, any failure by the District to conduct the December 14 manifestation determination within statutory time limits was a technical violation justified by its efforts to ensure the participation of STUDENT and his mother in the proceedings. It is undisputed that the District initially scheduled the manifestation determination meeting for November 18, within ten school days of the November 4 expulsion decision; that the meeting was continued at Petitioner’s request to November 29; and that Petitioner and his mother failed to appear on November 29. Presented with the choice of holding a timely meeting or rescheduling the matter to ensure parental participation, the District essentially covered its bets by choosing both options: It held a timely meeting on November 29 and repeated the proceedings with MOTHER present on December 14.

The Hearing Officer finds that the second choice was the correct one, because the December 14 meeting gave due weight to the importance of parental participation in a proceeding that would greatly affect STUDENT’s educational future. Further, the evidence indicates that the December 14 meeting was no brief summary but rather a full-fledged repetition of the earlier proceedings: Almost all of the earlier participants, including the District superintendent, were present on December 14; the presentations by school psychologist Mr. Whalen and the ICBH representative were detailed and extensive; and STUDENT, his mother, Mr. Navarro, and Ms. Wisdom actively participated in the proceedings. (See D. Exh. 22.)

Petitioner’s argument that a medical doctor should have been present at the December 14 meeting to determine if a nexus existed between his disability and his misconduct is equally unpersuasive. Federal law requires a manifestation determination to be conducted by a student’s IEP team “and other qualified personnel.” 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(4)(B). The December 14 meeting was attended by all appropriate District personnel, including STUDENT’s teachers, academic counselors, and school psychologist Mr. Whalen, who performed the assessment used as the basis for the manifestation determination review. Petitioner has cited no authority, and the Hearing Officer is aware of none, that would require a medical doctor to render an opinion at a manifestation determination meeting.

For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the manifestation determination conducted on December 14, 2004, substantively complied with federal and State requirements for the conduct of disciplinary procedures.

Issue No. 3: Did the District fail to appropriately address Petitioner’s behavioral and emotional needs by failing to conduct either a functional behavioral assessment (FBA) or a functional assessment analysis (FAA), or by failing to implement a behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

Under federal and State law, students with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a student free of charge, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, and that are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student, which may include cognitive, developmental, physical, and behavioral needs. 20 U.S.C. §§ 1401(a)(16), 1414(b)(2)(C).

In addressing a disabled student’s behavioral needs, the student’s IEP team must consider the inclusion of positive behavioral interventions and supports if the student’s behavior “impedes his or her learning or that of others.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.346. If those behavioral supports prove ineffective or if the student otherwise exhibits a “serious behavior problem,” State law requires the student’s IEP team to conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) as a basis for developing a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) for that student. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, §§ 3001(f), 3001(aa), 3052.

Further, when a disabled student is suspended for more than ten school days in a school year, federal regulations require the IEP team to conduct a functional behavioral assessment (FBA) of that student and implement a behavioral intervention plan or, if such a plan already is in place, must review the plan and modify it as necessary. 34 C.F.R. § 300.520(b)(1). (Footnote 25)

In this case, Petitioner contends that the District denied him a FAPE by (1) failing to conduct an additional assessment or to develop a BIP in response to MOTHER’s request in January of 2004; (2) failing to conduct an FBA after initiating a “change in placement” by extending his November 2, 2004 suspension; and (3) failing to provide adequate counseling to address his behavior problems. These allegations are addressed in turn below. (1) The District’s response to MOTHER’s request of January 23, 2004 On January 23, 2004, MOTHER requested in writing that the District make “a Functional Behavioral Assessment (AB 2726 referral) to County Mental Health.” (D. Exh. 10.) (Footnote 26) At the hearing, Petitioner acknowledged that MOTHER’s request as written was unclear, and that the essence of his complaint is that his mother’s request should have prompted an appropriate behavioral analysis and the development of a more effective intervention plan for him prior to the incidents resulting in his expulsion in October and November of 2004. The District responds that it repeatedly attempted to address STUDENT’s behavior with a variety of approaches both before and after MOTHER’s January 2004 request, but that STUDENT would not cooperate with its efforts. Based on the testimony of Ms. Montoya, Ms. Zuniga, and Mr. Pechtl, and STUDENT’s teachers, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence favors the District. By the time MOTHER requested the referral to ICBH in January 2004, school psychologist Ms. Montoya already had asked SELPA behavior specialist Ms. Zuniga to develop a BIP for STUDENT because his BSP was not helping him. (Footnote 27) On the same day she received the request from STUDENT’s mother, Ms. Montoya forwarded it to ICBH and repeated her request for help to Ms. Zuniga. In response, Ms. Zuniga promptly began the required steps for the systematic analysis that forms the basis for a BIP, but soon determined that a more immediate revision to STUDENT’s current BSP, in which he would be allowed to suggest his own intervention strategies, might supply the necessary motivation to comply with the BSP that STUDENT clearly lacked.

Ms. Zuniga began to revise the BSP immediately, but suspended her work on it in February when STUDENT began the process for enrolling in AHLP in February. In May 2004, when STUDENT returned to school after being discharged from AHLP, Ms. Zuniga resumed her work on the revised BSP, but her first attempt to obtain approval for it was disrupted when STUDENT kicked his mother at an IEP meeting, and her second attempt was prevented when MOTHER cancelled the follow-up meeting. Shortly thereafter, school let out for the summer.

At STUDENT’s first IEP meeting in September of 2004, the general consensus of the IEP team was that the reason STUDENT’s BSP wasn’t working was because he didn’t want to cooperate. ICBH services also had been terminated because STUDENT was noncompliant. The District offered the services of a probation counselor on staff to talk to STUDENT, but Mr. Pechtl testified that STUDENT had little to say when the counselor attempted to talk with him.

At an October 12 IEP meeting, MOTHER said STUDENT was depressed and sought a new referral to ICBH, which the District filled out and sent the same day. On October 15, MOTHER requested a one-to-one aide for all classes STUDENT was failing, and new assessments for emotional disturbance, academic needs, and motor skills. The District was in the process of responding to these requests when STUDENT’s final suspensions occurred on October 25 and November 2, 2004. In light of this unrebutted history, the Hearing Officer finds that the District made reasonable efforts to address STUDENT’s behavior problems through assessments, implementation of a BSP, and referrals for ICBH support services. Based on the testimony of Ms. Montoya and Ms. Zuniga, the Hearing Officer finds that the District responded promptly and appropriately to MOTHER’s requests for referrals and additional assessments, and was in the process of revising STUDENT’s BSP when he was referred to AHLP. STUDENT’s teachers credibly testified to their efforts to implement the BSP, and the Hearing Officer is persuaded by their conclusions that the reason the BSP did not appear to be helping STUDENT had more to do with STUDENT’s unwillingness to work with them in implementing the plan or with ICBH in taking his medication than to any failings in the plan itself.

The Hearing Officer also finds that Ms. Zuniga’s decision to revise STUDENT’s BSP before engaging in the lengthier process of developing a BIP was an appropriate decision by a behavioral expert who had determined that STUDENT’s main problem was his lack of motivation, which might be addressed more promptly by a BSP that he helped to design. The fact that the revised BSP never was implemented resulted not from any negligence on the part of the District, but by STUDENT’s referral to AHLP and later, to STUDENT’s disruptive behavior at an IEP meeting. (2) The District’s obligations after its November 4 decision resulting in a “change in placement” for STUDENT The parties agree that the District’s November 4 decision to extend STUDENT’s last suspension constituted a “change in placement” placing certain obligations on the District. Federal regulations require that, either before or not more than ten business days after commencing a removal constituting a change in placement, a school district that has not already conducted an functional behavioral assessment (FBA) and implemented a behavioral intervention plan for the student must convene an IEP meeting to develop an assessment plan. 34 C.F.R. § 300.520(b). Further, the school district must implement a behavior intervention plan or, if a plan already is in place, must convene an IEP meeting to modify the plan or its implementation as necessary. Id. In this case, STUDENT already had a behavior plan in place when the District extended his suspension pending expulsion proceedings on November 4, 2004. (Footnote 28) His IEP team had last met to review his behavior on October 12, and team members were in general agreement that his misconduct was becoming more serious. They were aware that ICBH had terminated services in June because STUDENT was uncooperative, but agreed that STUDENT was better behaved and a better student when he took his medication, and ICBH services should be reinstated. On the same date as the IEP meeting, Ms. Montoya forwarded to ICBH a request for reinstatement of medical support and for a new mental health evaluation. (D. Exh. 18; testimony of Ms. Montoya.) Although the IEP team did not modify STUDENT’s BSP or its implementation on or after November 4, the Hearing Officer finds that no modification was necessary because none would have been effective. STUDENT’s BSP already was designed to replace his negative behaviors with more positive ones by attempting to forge teacher/student bonds to discourage his defiance; seating him by positive role models to teach him more positive ways of gaining peer attention and respect; allowing him to take breaks and “time outs” when he was angry or upset; teaching him other anger management skills; using praise and rewards for positive behavior or academic achievement; ignoring petty misbehavior; and taking a nonconfrontational approach to correct more serious misconduct. At the hearing, the school psychologists, behavior specialist, and STUDENT’s teachers all credibly testified that the reason STUDENT’s BSP was not working was because of his attitude toward the plan, not because of any failure in the plan’s concept or its implementation. As STUDENT repeatedly informed his teachers and assessors, he simply was not interested in his classes and did not want to do the work assigned to him. Further, most of his misconduct appeared to be prompted by boredom, showing off, or seeking to escape from class. Finally, both District personnel and MOTHER (and at times, STUDENT himself) agreed that STUDENT’s failure to take his ADHD medication contributed significantly to his behavior problems. Accordingly, STUDENT’s BSP appeared to be failing not because of any faults in the plan or its implementation, but because STUDENT had no interest in its success, and refused to take his medication or otherwise do his part to help the plan to succeed. For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s BSP in place on November 4 complied with federal regulations, and that no modifications of the plan or its implementation would have been necessary or effective at that time. (3) The District’s provision of counseling services

The Hearing Officer also finds that Petitioner’s claim that the District should have provided him with more adequate counseling services is unsupported by the evidence. STUDENT received behavioral counseling from his ICBH case manager, but rejected her efforts to help him. (Footnote 29) He also received offers for informal counseling on school or personal problems from several teachers and administrators (including Mr. Pechtl, the probation counselor, and Mr. Zaragosa, who was selected for this purpose by STUDENT himself), but failed to take advantage of them. Further, the District encouraged STUDENT from the outset to enroll in AHLP precisely because it offered daily peer counseling and individual counseling by staff psychologists, but when STUDENT finally enrolled in the program, he was disruptive and noncompliant, and was discharged.

Further, the Hearing Officer finds Petitioner’s contention that additional counseling might have prevented the misconduct resulting in his expulsion to be speculative as well as unsupported by the evidence. AHLP case manager Alvin Martin credibly testified that counseling only helps people who are motivated to change their behaviors, and that STUDENT’s failure to benefit from AHLP was due largely to his refusal to acknowledge that his behaviors needed changing.

* * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately addressed Petitioner’s emotional and behavioral needs, conducted appropriate behavioral and emotional assessments of him, and provided him with adequate counseling in the months preceding his alleged misconduct on October 25 and November 2, 2004.

Issue No. 4: Has the District’s provision of educational services to Petitioner since November 4, 2004 complied with federal law?

When a child with a disability has been removed from his or her current placement for more than ten school days in the same school year, during any subsequent removals the school district must provide services to the extent necessary to enable the child to appropriately progress in the general curriculum and in achieving the goals in the child’s IEP. 34 C.F.R. § 300.121(D)(2).

Petitioner asserts that the educational services provided to him by the District since his final suspension was extended on November 4, 2004, “aren’t giving him an education” and thus have failed to comply with the law. (Footnote 30) The District responds that its services have been appropriate and that Petitioner’s failure to learn is due to his own lack of motivation. For the reasons stated below, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence favors the District.

STUDENT’s home instruction services

The educational program implemented for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year consisted of regular education classes for most of the day, with an RSP math class to address his math processing learning disability, and a BSP implemented by all of his teachers to address his ADHD and behavioral issues. STUDENT’s IEP contained one math goal requiring him to solve mathematical equations in word-based problems, a second mathematical reasoning goal requiring him to “apply computation skills to life situations,” and a behavior goal requiring him to follow all classroom rules and teacher directions. (D. Exh. 17.) In October of 2004, STUDENT’s IEP was modified to include an RSP English class.

Beginning November 5, 2004, in accordance with the District’s standard practice for students on suspension, STUDENT’s teachers were asked to prepare work assignments for STUDENT to complete at home and have his mother return to school. (D. Exh. 2, p. 12; testimony of Ms. Stacey.) The packets contained the assignments STUDENT would have received had he been in class, and were accompanied by written instructions from his teachers as to how the work was to be performed. After STUDENT completed the assignments and his mother returned them to school, the teachers would grade the work, take STUDENT’s progress into account in compiling the next assignment and instruction packet, and send the new packets home with his mother. (Id.)

At the second manifestation determination hearing on December 14, it was noted that STUDENT had not yet returned any of the work that had been picked up for him by his mother. MOTHER indicated that STUDENT had told her he didn’t know how to do the work. In response, STUDENT’s RSP English teacher, Marjorie Stacey, offered to provide weekly tutorials to STUDENT. Ms. Stacey testified that since that date, she has visited STUDENT for one hour per week to help him with his work assignments, which include course work from all of his teachers.

At the hearing, STUDENT testified that he doesn’t understand the work that is sent to him at home and that Ms. Stacey’s visits aren’t helping. He said he especially doesn’t understand his RSP math assignments and that since Ms. Stacey isn’t a math teacher, she can’t explain them to him. At another point in his testimony, STUDENT said that Ms. Stacey’s visits were helpful.

Ms. Stacey testified that as a former RSP math teacher, she was competent to instruct STUDENT in RSP math as well as in his other assignments. When she began her home tutorial visits to STUDENT, however, he told her he didn’t know why she was visiting him. STUDENT said that he knew how to do the work, but didn’t want to do it, or would “do it later.” Ms. Stacey attempted to help him with various assignments, and at times, STUDENT would do assignments if they interested him. Ms. Stacey was convinced that STUDENT was capable of doing the work if he chose to apply himself to it. Usually, however, before her hour was up STUDENT would say “it’s time for you to go; I have to go to work,” or “I want to be with my friends.”

Discussion

STUDENT’s educational program primarily consists of general education courses, with RSP courses in math and English containing materials tailored to his abilities in those subjects. Neither STUDENT nor any of his teachers testified that he had any difficulty comprehending his teachers’ instructions on class assignments when he was present in class. Further, although MOTHER at one point sought a one-to-one aide for STUDENT “in all the subjects he is failing,” teacher questionnaires filled out in response to that request indicated that STUDENT did not need an aide to help him succeed academically at school.

Although STUDENT testified that he was unable to do the assignments sent to him at home, the Hearing Officer finds that the combined testimony of STUDENT’s teachers and assessors is more credible on this point. STUDENT’s teachers testified to his ability to read, type, play the guitar, do computer games, engage in classroom discussions when they interested him, and do class assignments when he chose to do so. STUDENT’s assessors agreed he was of average intelligence and competent to do his assignments at school or at home, and that his failure to do his homework was due to the fact that he was given “no boundaries” at home and was allowed to neglect his schoolwork without consequences. Further, any difficulties STUDENT might have experienced in completing his class assignments at home could have been addressed by the weekly tutoring he has received from Ms. Stacey since December 14, had he chosen to avail himself of her help.

Further, STUDENT’s contradictory statements that he can do the work but doesn’t want to, or will do it later, or will do it when he finds his glasses, or when he gets contact lenses, seem to constitute a pattern of making excuses to avoid work he simply doesn’t care to perform. Significantly, STUDENT appears to tailor his excuses to his environment: To his mother, who has the authority to discipline him but does not know when he has homework or whether he is capable of doing it, he says he has no homework or cannot understand the work he has been given. By contrast, to his teachers, who know he can do the work but are limited in their authority to discipline him, he says he will do his work later or refuses to do it at all.

As STUDENT has not been completing his assignments or complying with Ms. Stacey’s efforts to tutor him at home, he clearly is making little if any progress in the general curriculum, his IEP math goals, or his behavior goal requiring compliance with teacher directions. The evidence makes clear, however, that these failures are attributable to STUDENT’s own choices, and are not the fault of the District.

In summary, the educational services provided to STUDENT by the District during his extended suspension have consisted of assignment packets containing the work STUDENT would have been asked to do in class and written instructions to take the place of classroom instruction, supplemented by weekly tutorial visits from a teacher trained in RSP math and English. For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s provision of these services complied with its obligation to provide services enabling STUDENT to appropriately progress in the general curriculum and to achieve the goals in his IEP.

Issue No. 5: If the District failed to comply with procedural requirements regarding his extended suspension or expulsion, is Petitioner entitled to relief including the dismissal of expulsion proceedings or the expungement of the alleged misconduct from his records?

State law provides no express sanctions for procedural violations of expulsion proceedings. In any case, as the Hearing Officer has determined that the District remedied the only procedural violations it committed in regard to Petitioner’s suspension and expulsion, Petitioner is not entitled to the requested relief. (Footnote 31)

Issue No. 6: If the District denied Petitioner a FAPE, is Petitioner entitled to prospective placement in a nonpublic school?

Court decisions have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE in order to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d. Cir. 1990). As the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE, he is not entitled to compensatory education.

ORDER

1. The Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

2. The District’s expulsion proceedings may go forward.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on all of the issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).

Date: February 25, 2005 _________________________________________ Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

The District responds that its services have been appropriate and that Petitioner’s failure to learn is due to his own lack of motivation. For the reasons stated below, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence favors the District.

STUDENT’s home instruction services

The educational program implemented for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year consisted of regular education classes for most of the day, with an RSP math class to address his math processing learning disability, and a BSP implemented by all of his teachers to address his ADHD and behavioral issues. STUDENT’s IEP contained one math goal requiring him to solve mathematical equations in word-based problems, a second mathematical reasoning goal requiring him to “apply computation skills to life situations,” and a behavior goal requiring him to follow all classroom rules and teacher directions. (D. Exh. 17.) In October of 2004, STUDENT’s IEP was modified to include an RSP English class.

Beginning November 5, 2004, in accordance with the District’s standard practice for students on suspension, STUDENT’s teachers were asked to prepare work assignments for STUDENT to complete at home and have his mother return to school. (D. Exh. 2, p. 12; testimony of Ms. Stacey.) The packets contained the assignments STUDENT would have received had he been in class, and were accompanied by written instructions from his teachers as to how the work was to be performed. After STUDENT completed the assignments and his mother returned them to school, the teachers would grade the work, take STUDENT’s progress into account in compiling the next assignment and instruction packet, and send the new packets home with his mother. (Id.)

At the second manifestation determination hearing on December 14, it was noted that STUDENT had not yet returned any of the work that had been picked up for him by his mother. MOTHER indicated that STUDENT had told her he didn’t know how to do the work. In response, STUDENT’s RSP English teacher, Marjorie Stacey, offered to provide weekly tutorials to STUDENT. Ms. Stacey testified that since that date, she has visited STUDENT for one hour per week to help him with his work assignments, which include course work from all of his teachers.

At the hearing, STUDENT testified that he doesn’t understand the work that is sent to him at home and that Ms. Stacey’s visits aren’t helping. He said he especially doesn’t understand his RSP math assignments and that since Ms. Stacey isn’t a math teacher, she can’t explain them to him. At another point in his testimony, STUDENT said that Ms. Stacey’s visits were helpful.

Ms. Stacey testified that as a former RSP math teacher, she was competent to instruct STUDENT in RSP math as well as in his other assignments. When she began her home tutorial visits to STUDENT, however, he told her he didn’t know why she was visiting him. STUDENT said that he knew how to do the work, but didn’t want to do it, or would “do it later.” Ms. Stacey attempted to help him with various assignments, and at times, STUDENT would do assignments if they interested him. Ms. Stacey was convinced that STUDENT was capable of doing the work if he chose to apply himself to it. Usually, however, before her hour was up STUDENT would say “it’s time for you to go; I have to go to work,” or “I want to be with my friends.”

Discussion

STUDENT’s educational program primarily consists of general education courses, with RSP courses in math and English containing materials tailored to his abilities in those subjects. Neither STUDENT nor any of his teachers testified that he had any difficulty comprehending his teachers’ instructions on class assignments when he was present in class. Further, although MOTHER at one point sought a one-to-one aide for STUDENT “in all the subjects he is failing,” teacher questionnaires filled out in response to that request indicated that STUDENT did not need an aide to help him succeed academically at school.

Although STUDENT testified that he was unable to do the assignments sent to him at home, the Hearing Officer finds that the combined testimony of STUDENT’s teachers and assessors is more credible on this point. STUDENT’s teachers testified to his ability to read, type, play the guitar, do computer games, engage in classroom discussions when they interested him, and do class assignments when he chose to do so. STUDENT’s assessors agreed he was of average intelligence and competent to do his assignments at school or at home, and that his failure to do his homework was due to the fact that he was given “no boundaries” at home and was allowed to neglect his schoolwork without consequences. Further, any difficulties STUDENT might have experienced in completing his class assignments at home could have been addressed by the weekly tutoring he has received from Ms. Stacey since December 14, had he chosen to avail himself of her help.

Further, STUDENT’s contradictory statements that he can do the work but doesn’t want to, or will do it later, or will do it when he finds his glasses, or when he gets contact lenses, seem to constitute a pattern of making excuses to avoid work he simply doesn’t care to perform. Significantly, STUDENT appears to tailor his excuses to his environment: To his mother, who has the authority to discipline him but does not know when he has homework or whether he is capable of doing it, he says he has no homework or cannot understand the work he has been given. By contrast, to his teachers, who know he can do the work but are limited in their authority to discipline him, he says he will do his work later or refuses to do it at all.

As STUDENT has not been completing his assignments or complying with Ms. Stacey’s efforts to tutor him at home, he clearly is making little if any progress in the general curriculum, his IEP math goals, or his behavior goal requiring compliance with teacher directions. The evidence makes clear, however, that these failures are attributable to STUDENT’s own choices, and are not the fault of the District.

In summary, the educational services provided to STUDENT by the District during his extended suspension have consisted of assignment packets containing the work STUDENT would have been asked to do in class and written instructions to take the place of classroom instruction, supplemented by weekly tutorial visits from a teacher trained in RSP math and English. For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s provision of these services complied with its obligation to provide services enabling STUDENT to appropriately progress in the general curriculum and to achieve the goals in his IEP.

Issue No. 5: If the District failed to comply with procedural requirements regarding his extended suspension or expulsion, is Petitioner entitled to relief including the dismissal of expulsion proceedings or the expungement of the alleged misconduct from his records?

State law provides no express sanctions for procedural violations of expulsion proceedings. In any case, as the Hearing Officer has determined that the District remedied the only procedural violations it committed in regard to Petitioner’s suspension and expulsion, Petitioner is not entitled to the requested relief. (Footnote 31)

Issue No. 6: If the District denied Petitioner a FAPE, is Petitioner entitled to prospective placement in a nonpublic school?

Court decisions have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE in order to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d. Cir. 1990). As the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE, he is not entitled to compensatory education.

ORDER

1. The Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

2. The District’s expulsion proceedings may go forward.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on all of the issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).

Date: February 25, 2005 _________________________________________ Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office