California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 12, 2004

Student v. Pasadena Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 679-04 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard

Pasadena Unified denied FAPE from November 2003 to April 2004 by omitting behavior supports; 60 compensatory hours ordered.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 18 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None stated. The decision follows the prior SEHO decision in SN02-02461 (April 23, 2003) and CDE compliance cases S-0792-02/03, S-0097-03/04, and S-0205-03/04.

Summary

The parent and Pasadena Unified School District each filed for hearing, and the cases were combined. The student was a 15-year-old nonverbal student with autism, a movement disorder, and anxiety. He had been out of school since October 2002. A 2003 SEHO decision had ordered the District to reassess him. The Hearing Officer dismissed claims seeking to enforce that decision and a California Department of Education corrective action because SEHO had no power over them.

The Hearing Officer found that the mother blocked or hindered District assessments in spring 2003, including by insisting on videotaping, and rejected a summer diagnostic placement. Later delays in the independent evaluations by Dr. Gary LaVigna and Amy Rowell were not the District's fault, and the mother agreed to extend their timelines. The goals, home teaching offers, records claims, and parent participation claims did not deny FAPE. Holding the November 12, 2003 IEP meeting without the parent was a procedural violation that caused no harm.

However, the November 2003 and January 2004 inclusion offers for Blair High School had no specific behavior support for the student's return to school. That denied FAPE from November 12, 2003 to April 26, 2004. The April 2004 offer, which adopted Dr. LaVigna's behavior plan, offered FAPE once amended. The Hearing Officer ordered targeted IEP amendments, 30 hours of social skills instruction, and 30 hours of academic tutoring.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a parent's interference with district assessments: the student had no right to a FAPE while the district was kept from assessing him. It also shows that an offer can still deny FAPE when it leaves out known behavior supports needed for a student's return to school.

Issues and holdings

  1. Dismissed / withdrawnThreshold and jurisdiction

    Issue Procedural 1A. District motion to dismiss issues seeking enforcement of the April 23, 2003 Decision in SN02-02461 (developing compensatory services at an IEP meeting) and compliance with CDE corrective action in Compliance Case No. S-0792-02/03

    Under Wyner and Porter, SEHO lacks jurisdiction to enforce a prior hearing order or a CDE corrective action; both issues dismissed, though FAPE since April 23, 2003 remained at issue.

  2. Issue Procedural 1B. District motion to dismiss the consolidated matter as seeking impermissible declaratory relief after its stipulation

    Motion denied; a live controversy remained and Student's request for appropriate present levels, goals, and placement for 2004-2005 was implicit in his contentions.

  3. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue I.1. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from April 23, 2003 to April 26, 2004 by failing to timely and appropriately assess him, either directly or by funding requested independent educational assessments?

    The parent hindered District assessments in May-June 2003 and rejected a diagnostic placement, so Student had no right to a FAPE from May to October 2003; later IEE delays were not attributable to the District and were waived.

  4. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue I.2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to prepare appropriate goals and objectives?

    Academic goals based on the limited assessment data available at the time were a reasonable starting point.

  5. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue I.3. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to offer an appropriate placement and appropriate related services?

    The November 12, 2003 and January 7 and 20, 2004 offers lacked specific behavior support (such as a BICM) for the transition back to school, denying FAPE from November 12, 2003 through April 26, 2004; no formal offer was made September 30, 2003.

  6. District prevailedStay put

    Issue I.4. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to provide home teaching services?

    The District repeatedly offered credentialed home teachers with a sign language interpreter as stay put required; the parent refused them.

  7. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPERecords

    Issue I.5. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to timely provide accurate student records?

    The District did not rebut CDE's finding that it was late in giving access to records, but the delay did not deny FAPE.

  8. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue I.6. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by interfering with the parent's right to participate in the IEP process?

    Refusing to continue the November 12, 2003 IEP meeting so the parent could review new reports violated Ed. Code 56342.5, but caused no prejudice; bringing drafts to meetings was proper.

  9. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue II.1. Did the District fail to offer Student a FAPE for April 27, 2004 through April 26, 2005 by failing to make a sufficient written offer of placement?

    The April 26, 2004 IEP, clarified by the May 19 letter, June 7 addendum, and June 8 transition plan, was a single coherent offer that met Union.

  10. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue II.2. Failing to develop goals and objectives to address all areas of need

    Nonacademic goals, together with an IEP meeting within six weeks of return to develop academic goals, were substantially designed to meet his needs.

  11. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue II.3. Failing to offer an appropriate placement

    Blair High School's inclusion program with the offered supports was appropriate; the claim that it was an under-performing school lacked merit.

  12. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue II.4. Failing to offer appropriate behaviorist services or to develop a behavior support plan consistent with all recommendations in Dr. LaVigna's Comprehensive Functional Assessment and Recommended Support Plan

    The District adopted the LaVigna plan and Dr. Bernhardt was a qualified BICM, but the IEP was ordered amended to incorporate the plan explicitly, add BICM hours, provide monthly reviews, a facilitation protocol, and ASL-fluent aides.

  13. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue II.5. Failing to develop appropriate modifications and accommodations

    The District responded to Student's requested accommodations, including two one-to-one aides.

  14. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue II.6. Failing to offer or provide appropriate inclusion specialist services

    Ten hours weekly of flexible inclusion services was sufficient, and the District did not have to name a specific inclusion specialist.

  15. District prevailedTransition

    Issue II.7. Failing to develop an appropriate transition plan for his return to the school setting

    The transition plan was appropriate, and the District amended it to allow credit, but it was ordered to add specific readiness criteria for full-time participation.

  16. District prevailedTransition

    Issue II.8. Failing to develop an appropriate individualized transition plan (ITP)

    Adopting the LaVigna plan and a diploma track partly met ITP requirements; the District was ordered to complete the ITP by the student's sixteenth birthday.

  17. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue II.9. Failing to implement its agreement to have Ms. Hanson provide speech services

    Ms. Hanson's decision to stop direct services was her own personal choice and not District bad faith; it did not deny FAPE.

  18. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue III. If the District denied Student a FAPE, is he entitled to compensatory education services?

    Awarded 30 hours of social skills instruction and 30 hours of academic tutoring; denied requests for an independent IEP facilitator and for NPA inclusion and BICM providers.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 25 calendar days, convene IEP meeting to: (a) explicitly incorporate Dr. LaVigna's CFA support plan (pp. 27-50) and delete Dr. Bernhardt's draft BSP; (b) provide monthly periodic service reviews; (c) set BICM time at 16 hours first month, 12 second, 8 third, then 4 hours/month until April 26, 2005; (d) develop protocol distinguishing LPEP requiring physical prompting from participation with facilitated communication/assisted writing; (e) clarify paraprofessionals working on social and functional communication must be fluent in ASL; (f) identify readiness criteria for full-time academic participation.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. No later than six weeks after enrollment at Blair High School for 2004-2005, IEP team to determine need for and prepare academic goals and complete the individualized transition plan.
  • Compensatory education. 30 hours of social skills instruction by a District employee or certified nonpublic agency experienced with adolescents with autism, to be completed within three years.
  • Compensatory education. 30 hours of academic tutoring by a credentialed teacher trained in and familiar with Student's unique needs per the April 26, 2004 IEP Personnel section, to be completed within three years.

Total: 60 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified School Dist.; Porter v. Board of Trustees of Manhattan Beach Unified School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Adams v. State of Oregon; Andress v. Cleveland Independent School Dist.; Vander Malle v. Ambach; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Glendale Unified School Dist. v. Almasi

People named in the decision

  • Gary Valdez, school psychologist, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Judith Halpern O'Neal, program specialist, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Darlene Hanson, speech pathologist and facilitated communication specialist, Pasadena Unified School District (initially independent, selected by parent)
  • Pamela Mallon, special education teacher specialist; academic assessor; former BICM, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Henrietta Hendrix, resource specialist teacher and designated inclusion specialist, Blair High School, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Joseph Givens, speech pathologist, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Judy Barhydt, director of special education and SELPA director, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Alyson Beecher, program specialist, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Dr. William Bernhardt, behavior intervention case manager / school psychologist and behaviorist, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Teri Castaneda, purchasing agent, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Rich Boccia, principal, Blair High School, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Ilene Clingmon, speech pathologist, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Jacqueline Cochran, assistant superintendent, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Linda Redman, administrative designee, Pasadena Unified School District
  • William Garnett, special education teacher providing inclusion support, Pasadena High School, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Ms. Schwartz, assistive technology specialist, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Ms. Wolford, occupational therapist, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Roxanna Wilson, assigned home teacher, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Lezlie Porter, instructional aide, Blair High School, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Christina, paraprofessional aide (deaf, knows sign language), Pasadena Unified School District
  • Amy Rowell, independent school psychologist (psychoeducational/academic IEE), Whittier school district / Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program
  • Dr. Gary LaVigna, independent behavior assessor; clinical director, Institute for Applied Behavior Analysis (IABA)
  • Cindy Cottier, independent augmentative communication / assistive technology specialist, Augmentative Communication Therapies (NPA)
  • Dr. Dennis Spiro, independent vision therapy assessor
  • Big Fun Gymnastics, nonpublic agency providing gymnastics instruction by an occupational therapist
  • Pam Clark, program director, Help Group, Sunrise Program (nonpublic school)
  • Rick Clemens, inclusion expert; nonpublic agency, Inclusion Education & Community Partnerships (NPA)
  • Joseph Hardy, sign language teacher / communication aide, Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center
  • Yvette Velasquez, certified nurse assistant, Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center
  • Robert Evans, Focused Monitoring Administrator, California Department of Education
  • Judith Ganz, Hearing Officer in prior case SN02-02461, Special Education Hearing Office
  • Bonita Olszewski, family friend and non-attorney advocate; witness for Student
  • Walter Olszewski, family friend and non-attorney advocate
  • B. J. Hernandez, accompanied parent at hearing

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter convened for hearing before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific=s McGeorge School of Law, in Pasadena, California, on June 22, 23, 24, 25, 29, 30, and on July 14, 15, 16, 20, 21, 22, and 23, 2004. (Footnote 1) Student was represented throughout the hearing by his mother, Student’s Mother. Student was present at the hearing on the morning of July 22, 2004, when he testified. Also present on behalf of Student on most hearing days were his family friends and advocates Bonita and Walter Olszewski. In the Olszewskis’ absence, Student’s Mother was accompanied by B. J. Hernandez or Joseph Hardy. Pasadena Unified School District (District) was represented throughout the hearing by its attorney, Howard Fulfrost. Also present on the District’s behalf on most hearing days was director of special education Judy Barhydt. In Ms. Barhydt’s absence, the District was represented by program specialists Judith Halpern O’Neal or Alyson Beecher, or by administrative designee Linda Redman. The District called the following District employees to testify: school psychologist Gary Valdez, program specialist Judith Halpern O’Neal, speech pathologist Darlene Hanson, special education teacher Pamela Mallon, Blair High School resource specialist teacher Henrietta Hendrix, speech pathologist Joseph Givens, director of special education and SELPA director Judy Barhydt, program specialist Alyson Beecher, behavior intervention case manager Dr. William Bernhardt, purchasing agent Teri Castaneda, Blair High School principal Rich Boccia, and speech pathologist Ilene Clingmon. The District also called the following individuals as witnesses: independent school psychologist Amy Rowell, and independent assessor and director of the Institute for Applied Behavior Analysis (IABA), Dr. Gary LaVigna. Student testified by handwritten response on July 22, 2004. Student called the following witnesses from the Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center to testify on his behalf: sign language teacher Joseph Hardy, certified nurse assistant Yvette Velasquez, and Student’s cousin and respite worker, Student’s cousin. In addition, Student called as witnesses his friend and advocate Bonita Olszewski and District assistant superintendent Jacqueline Cochran. At the request of the Hearing Officer, the following persons also were called to testify: Student’s mother, Student’s Mother, and his current Pasadena High School teacher, William Garnett. Oral and documentary evidence was received. On July 23, 2004, the parties agreed that the record would remain open until receipt by the Hearing Officer of agreed upon exhibits (documents and audio tapes). Pursuant to the minute order dated August 6, 2004, the parties were advised that the deadline for receipt of this evidence was August 10, 2004. On August 10, 2004, the Hearing Officer received these exhibits from the parties. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter submitted for a decision. (Footnote 2)

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

1. District’s Motions to Dismiss A. Lack of Jurisdiction to Enforce SEHO Decision SN02-02461 The current dispute between the parties began with the April 23, 2003 Decision in Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) Case No. SN02-02461, in which Hearing Officer Judith Ganz determined that the District had failed to provide Student with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from March 2002 through October 2002, had failed to offer Student a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year (ESY), and had failed to implement his behavior intervention plan (BIP). At the heart of Hearing Officer Ganz’s Decision was her conclusion that the District had failed to assess Student for a triennial review that she determined had been due in April 2002 and that, consequently, the District had no knowledge of Student’s educational and behavioral needs, or his present levels of performance. From these conclusions, Hearing Officer Ganz issued a series of orders regarding assessment, placement, and compensatory education services for Student. In pertinent part, the District was ordered to conduct a comprehensive psychoeducational assessment within thirty-five days of the date of the Decision, and to convene an individualized education program (IEP) team meeting within fifteen days of the date the assessments were completed to offer Student an appropriate educational placement in accordance with the assessment results and to determine how to implement the compensatory education services awarded to him. At the outset of this hearing, the issues identified by Student included (1) whether the District had failed to timely and appropriately assess him in accordance with the April 23, 2003 Decision, (2) whether the District had failed to develop compensatory services at an IEP team meeting as required by that Decision, and (3) whether the District had completed assessments or offered compensatory education in accordance with California Department of Education’s (CDE’s) corrective action in its Compliance Case No. S-0792-02/03. (Footnote 3) The District requested that the Hearing Officer dismiss all issues relating to enforcement of the April 23, 2003 Decision pursuant to the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified School Board, 223 F. 3d 1026 (9th Cir. 2000). Student argued that reference to the Decision was necessary to place the current events in context and that the issue was not enforcement of the prior Decision, but whether the District had provided him with a FAPE since that Decision. In Wyner, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals determined that, pursuant to California Education Code section 56501(a), the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) does not have jurisdiction in a subsequent due process hearing to hear and decide issues concerning a school district’s alleged noncompliance with an order issued in a prior due process hearing. Under California Education Code section 56505(g), a due process hearing “shall be the final administrative determination and binding on the parties.” The Court further determined that the proper avenue to enforce SEHO orders is outlined in Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 4650, which authorizes a request for direct intervention to the Superintendent of Public Instruction, based upon an allegation that the local educational agency “has failed or refused to implement a due process hearing order....” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, ' 4650(A)(viii)(B); see also Porter v. Board of Trustees of Manhattan Beach Unified School District, 307 F. 3d 1064 (9th Cir. 2002), cert. denied, 537 U.S. 1194, 123 S.Ct. 1303 (2003) (noting the futility of requiring a complaint to SEHO alleging the failure to implement a due process hearing order given its decision in Wyner). The Hearing Officer noted that while the evidence presented at hearing would necessarily involve the parties’ efforts to comply with the assessment and placement orders issued in the prior SEHO Decision, the gravamen of Student’s case--and the permissible scope of this Decision--was on his right to receive a FAPE from April 23, 2003, to the present. The District’s compliance or attempts to comply with the orders issued in that Decision would be relevant to whether it offered Student a FAPE since its issuance. Further, the District’s knowledge of the findings, conclusions, and orders in the Decision in SN02-02461 related to its duty to reassess Student in all areas of suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56320(f). From this discussion, the parties agreed that whether the District timely and appropriately assessed Student and offered him an educational program designed to provide a FAPE following the Decision was an appropriate issue for hearing. The Hearing Officer grants the District’s motion to dismiss, however, as to two issues arising from its alleged noncompliance with the Decision and with CDE’s corrective action arising out of noncompliance with that Decision. First, whether the District denied Student a FAPE by failing to develop compensatory education services at an IEP team meeting in accordance with the April 23, 2003 due process Decision falls squarely within the scope of Wyner and is dismissed. Second, as noted by the Ninth Circuit in Porter v. Board of Trustees, supra, 307 F. 3d at 1073, under California’s complaint resolution procedure (CRP), “if the local school district refuses to comply with the state’s directives, only the Superintendent of Public Instruction is authorized to bring an action to enforce the CRP order.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, ' 4670. Accordingly, the issue of whether the District failed to complete assessments or to offer Student compensatory education in accordance with CDE’s corrective actions in Compliance Case No. S-0792-02/03, which arose out of the District’s alleged failure to comply with the Decision, is not appropriately before the Hearing Officer and is dismissed. B. Lack of Jurisdiction to Issue Declaratory Relief On June 22, 2004, following the parties’ lengthy and ultimately unsuccessful settlement negotiations, the District presented the Hearing Officer with a stipulation that it asserted resolved all of Student’s proposed resolutions outlined by the Hearing Officer in the June 21, 2004 Memorandum re: Case Status and Issues for Hearing (Memorandum), except the request for an independent notetaker. Based upon this stipulation and its assertion that any further action by the Hearing Officer would constitute impermissible declaratory relief, the District requested that the Hearing Officer dismiss both cases to this consolidated matter. Opposing this request, Student argued that there was a real controversy between the parties because the District had committed numerous serious procedural violations and did not stipulate that it had denied him a FAPE during the periods at issue. Student also asserted he sought relief in the form of the development of appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and an appropriate placement for the 2004-2005 school year, even though he had not identified this as a proposed resolution previously. The District acknowledged that this placed the entire IEP at issue. The Hearing Officer determined that Student’s newly articulated resolution was implicit in his detailed contentions underlying the issues for hearing as outlined in the June 21, 2004 Memorandum and that the District was on notice of that proposed resolution. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer denied the District’s request for dismissal of the consolidated matter and amended the proposed resolutions to include Student=s request for appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and an appropriate placement for the 2004-2005 school year. (Footnote 4) 2. Written Stipulations In an effort to further narrow the issues for hearing, the parties entered into two written stipulations. On June 25, 2004, the parties entered into a stipulation regarding adapted physical education and occupational therapy (APE/OT) pursuant to which the District agreed to provide Student with compensatory and prospective relief in the form of gymnastics instruction by an occupational therapist at the nonpublic agency (NPA) Big Fun Gymnastics. (Joint Exhibit 1.) On June 29, 2004, the parties entered into a stipulation pursuant to which the District agreed to fund an independent vision therapy assessment of Student’s visual motor integration and visual perceptual skills by Dr. Dennis Spiro and to fund an independent assistive technology (AT)/augmentative communication assessment by Cindy Cottier of the NPA Augmentative Communication Therapies, to ascertain Student’s AT needs for accessing a computer due to his movement disorder. The District further agreed to implement the recommendations of both of these independent assessments and acknowledged that “Student’s AT device is, and should be, used for both supporting Student’s access to the curriculum and expressive communication.” (Joint Exhibit 2.) 3. Request to Add Speech Services as An Issue At the outset of the hearing, the District stipulated that its speech pathologist and facilitated communication specialist Darlene Hanson is the speech therapist who will provide Student all offered speech services from April 27, 2004 through April 26, 2005, as well as any compensatory education speech services to which Student is entitled. In light of this stipulation, Student withdrew speech therapy services from his issues for hearing. On several occasions in July 2004, after Ms. Hanson testified about her decision to stop providing services to Student, as well as after the conclusion of the hearing, Student requested that this issue be addressed in the decision in light of new facts he alleged established the District’s bad faith failure to implement this agreement. The District did not take a position on this request, except to assert that it had entered into the stipulation in good faith. As discussed, infra, this unopposed request is granted for the limited purpose of addressing implementation of speech services. ISSUES (Footnote 5)

I. Did the District fail to offer and provide Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from April 23, 2003 to April 26, 2004, including the 2003 extended school year, by:

1. failing to timely and appropriately assess him, either directly or by funding requested independent educational assessments; 2. failing to prepare appropriate goals and objectives;

3. failing to offer an appropriate placement and appropriate related services; 4. failing to provide home teaching services;

5. failing to timely provide accurate student records; and/or, 6. interfering with the parent’s right to participate in the IEP process?

II. Did the District fail to offer Student a FAPE for the period from April 27, 2004 through April 26, 2005, by:

1. failing to make a sufficient written offer of placement;

2. failing to develop goals and objectives to address all areas of need; 3. failing to offer an appropriate placement;

4. failing to offer appropriate behaviorist services or to develop a behavior support plan consistent with all recommendations in Dr. LaVigna’s Comprehensive Functional Assessment and Recommended Support Plan; 5. failing to develop appropriate modifications and accommodations; 6. failing to offer or provide appropriate inclusion specialist services; 7. failing to develop an appropriate transition plan for his return to the school setting; 8. failing to develop an appropriate individualized transition plan (ITP); and/or, 9. failing to implement its agreement to have Ms. Hanson provide speech services?

III. If the District denied Student a FAPE, is he entitled to compensatory education services?

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Student is a fifteen and a half year old nonverbal student who has autism, an associated movement disturbance, and a generalized anxiety disorder with panic attacks. On approximately June 28, 2004, Student began to attend Pasadena High School for the 2004 extended school year (ESY) in two general education courses, Algebra I and English 9B, and to receive two hours of home or school instruction to complete assignments with assistance from one of his two paraprofessional aides. Student’s enrollment in Pasadena High School for the 2004 ESY was the first time he has attended school since October 17, 2002, when his mother removed him from the District’s Wilson Middle School, due to her concern that the District had failed to provide him with a FAPE. During Student’s twenty-month absence from school, he remained at home and received services from the Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center, including in-home behaviorist services and community-based training in American Sign Language (ASL). Student began to receive speech and language services in October 2003, from District speech pathologist and facilitated communication specialist Darlene Hanson for two hours a week at home.

Since June 1992, Student has received special education and related services due to his autism. For the vast majority of that time, Student’s autism was asserted to affect him in all areas, including academics, socialization, and communication, and he received his education in special day classes (SDC). Student communicated primarily through the use of pointing, gestures, minimal sign language, and the occasional use of assistive technology devices. In July 1999, following his last triennial assessment by the Diagnostic Center, the IEP team agreed that Student’s curriculum should emphasize the acquisition of functional skills designed to prepare him for a life in the community and that focused on telling time, recognizing numbers and money, and pre-vocational tasks. From June 2000, through October 2002, the parties participated in monthly IEP team meetings to improve collaboration and communication between District staff and Student’s Regional Center personnel. (Dist. Exh. 1, p. 5.)

During this period, Student exhibited maladaptive behaviors that required formal behavior intervention. In October 2000 while attending the District’s Sierra Madre Elementary school, Student exhibited behaviors of grabbing others and removing his shoes outside the classroom. District teacher specialist Pamela Mallon prepared a positive behavior support plan (PBSP) from her functional assessment of Student’s behaviors. In the fall of 2001, Student entered the District’s Wilson Middle School for the sixth grade in an SDC for severely handicapped (SH) students and this PBSP became part of his IEP. In November 2001, Student was involved in a severe behavioral episode at school that included noncompliance with a request, screaming, crying, kicking, running to a different room, and becoming increasingly aggressive until placed into a prone position for calming. The parties agreed to a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of Student’s behaviors by Ms. Mallon and to a behavior intervention plan (BIP). The FAA concluded that Student’s grabbing behaviors were a way to avoid requests and demands, and the BIP outlined replacement behaviors, which were to be taught using discrete trial training strategies. (Dist. Exh. 1, p. 9.)

In March 2002, Student had a “breakthrough” and discovered that he could communicate by writing. As a consequence of this discovery and at the urging of Student’s Mother and independent assistive technology specialist Cindy Cottier, the IEP team placed Student in four general education classes beginning in April 2002. Even though they acquiesced in this placement, Ms. Halpern O’Neal and Ms. Mallon testified in SN02-02461 that they actually believed Student could obtain greater educational benefit from a functional life skills curriculum. (Id. at 13.) In the fall of 2002, Student continued in general education classes in seventh grade at Wilson. In early October 2002, Student was physically aggressive toward his general education art teacher in a manner that frightened her. In response, the District proposed an interim behavior plan that called for Student’s one-to-one aide to remove him from his general education class and return him to his SH/SDC if he demonstrated out-of-seat behavior, out-of-context laughing, or if he invaded personal space. (Id. at 10.) On October 17, 2002, in response to this action, Student’s Mother removed Student from school and requested a due process hearing (SN02-02461).

As previously discussed, on April 23, 2003, a Decision was issued in SN02-02461 which determined that Student’s triennial reassessment had been due in April 2002 but was never conducted, and that the District had failed to provide Student with a FAPE from March 2002 through October 2002, had failed to offer Student a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year (ESY), and had failed to implement his BIP across school environments. Hearing Officer Ganz stated that the key to Student’s educational participation was management of his behavior. (Dist. Exh. 1, p. 17.)

In early May 2003, following receipt of that Decision, the District assembled a multi-disciplinary assessment team that was charged with the task of coordinating and completing Student’s assessment as ordered by May 28, 2003. On May 15, 2003, as required by the Decision, the District convened an IEP team meeting to address Student’s transition back to school, home teaching services pending this transition, and the feasibility of beginning speech and language services during the transition. District IEP team members identified completion of the ordered psychoeducational assessment as the initial step in Student’s transition plan back to school and offered him speech and language services three times a week for thirty minutes each session beginning May 19, 2003, to be provided at home. The District also offered to provide Student with five hours a week of home teaching by a credentialed teacher in accordance with the last agreed upon IEP of February 19, 2003. Student’s Mother advised the IEP team that the home teacher needed a method of communicating with Student and that he needed a sign language interpreter.

The District’s efforts to arrange for Student’s assessment and what occurred at the assessments actually scheduled in May and June 2003 are the subjects of conflicting facts and interpretations by the parties. Ultimately, however, Student was made available for assessment to members of the District assessment team on six occasions. Student’s Mother was present for each of the assessment sessions and each session was videotaped by the Olszewskis, purportedly at Student’s request to ensure he would have evidence of the assessment process. While some District assessors were not provided access to Student, both speech pathologist Mr. Givens and AT specialist Ms. Schwartz established good rapport with the family and had several hours to assess him. None of the assessors were able to conduct standardized testing on Student.

Under pressure to complete ordered assessments in what it asserted was an unrealistic time frame, the District assessment team members wrote reports based upon what information they were able to gather regarding Student’s needs and levels of performance in assistive technology, occupational therapy, academics, speech and language, adaptive physical education, and cognitive functioning. Several key findings were made during or from these assessments that became the focus of dispute between the parties. First, in his June 2, 2003 psychoeducational assessment report, school psychologist Gary Valdez reported that Student had an adaptive behavior composite score at an eight year, two month old age equivalent on the Vineland behavior scale, and that this indicated Student has a “severe delay in adaptive behavior given that his chronological age is fourteen years, five months.” Second, from these assessments, District members of the IEP team determined that Student had pervasive apraxia, a difficulty with motor responses not caused by lack of strength or a primary motor deficit. In Student’s Mother’ opinion, Student also had motivational/behavioral problems that prevented him from participating at school and in demonstrating tasks he already knew how to do. In her view, the District needed to distinguish between apraxia and behavior, and to address Student’s motivational/behavioral needs.

Following these assessments, the District’s assessment team concurred that they were unable to obtain sufficient information about Student’s present levels of performance under the assessment times imposed by the Decision, the assessment conditions presented to them by Student’s Mother, and Student’s complex disabilities that made him a “difficult to assess” student. The assessment team concluded that a school-based, diagnostic placement for the summer in an environment away from his parent was required to obtain necessary assessment information. On June 5, 2003, Ms. Halpern O’Neal wrote to Student’s Mother to advise her of this placement option at the Help Group, Sunrise Program, a nonpublic school, and to suggest that Student’s Mother visit the program and talk to its director, Pam Clark.

On June 12, 2003, the District convened an annual/triennial IEP team review meeting to discuss Student’s present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and placement as ordered by the Decision. The District’s assessment team members reviewed their assessment reports, and discussed their collective opinion that Student needed a diagnostic placement to obtain additional data and information about his “social/emotional status, cognitive abilities, communication abilities, functional academics, and functional living skills in school and in the community, ...overall academic skills, learning styles...since the psycho-educational testing was hindered.” District IEP team members also asserted that Student had a need for “a functional life skills program to increase functional life skills needs,” and that, “considering Student’s multiple out-put dysfunctions, the District evaluation team cannot endorse a cognitive/academic program, especially when the District cannot see an expression of Student=s capabilities.” Student’s Mother advised the IEP team that the District had not assessed Student’s present levels of performance and that she was unwilling to discuss goals or placement until this was accomplished. Before Student’s Mother left the IEP team meeting, Student was offered a diagnostic placement in a special day class at Sunrise nonpublic school (NPS) for the 2003 extended school year. Student’s Mother disagreed with the placement because it was not consistent with the requirements of the prior Decision, and because, in her view, the diagnostic placement offered was designed for lower functioning autistic students who are mildly to moderately retarded. Student’s Mother was given a copy of draft goals and objectives for Student and left the IEP team meeting.

After this meeting, Student’s Mother notified the District on several occasions of her intention to place Student in a nonpublic school for the 2003 ESY; however, this did not occur and Student remained at home without a formal school program. Throughout this time and until he returned to school in late June 2004, the District continued to make written offers for home teaching services for Student, to be provided five hours a week by a credentialed teacher, with the assistance of a sign language interpreter. According to special education director Ms. Barhydt and program specialist Ms. Halpern O’Neal, Student’s Mother refused to allow any of the teachers access to Student to provide home teaching services except on two occasions. According to Student’s Mother, Student did not use sign language for academic work, and therefore the District failed to provide for a home teacher with training on how to communicate with him or with word prediction software as required in the IEP of February 19, 2003. (Dist. Exh. 53, subExh. 2, p. 6 of 7.)

Throughout the summer of 2003, the parties engaged in correspondence regarding implementation of the Decision, Student’s Mother’ requests for independent educational evaluations (IEEs), and her compliance complaints with the California Department of Education (CDE). In addition, Student’s Mother, the Olszewskis, and occasionally Student, began to regularly attend meetings of the District’s school board to request its assistance in implementing the Decision, in obtaining educational records, and to express their concerns regarding the District’s special education staff. Student’s Mother’ correspondence and requests to the District, its school board, and CDE included repeated assertions of lying, falsification of records, and indifference to Student’s civil rights by District employees and, particularly, by Ms. Barhydt and Ms. Halpern O’Neal.

On June 16, 2004, CDE notified the parties that it was beginning a compliance investigation, Case S-0792-02/03, based upon Student’s Mother’ complaint that the District had failed to implement the orders of the April 23, 2003 Decision regarding speech/language services, assessment, and home teaching. In response to this complaint, the District argued, in part, that the assessment issues raised by Student’s Mother were moot because it had agreed to fund the IEEs for Student that she had requested.

On multiple occasions after the June 12, 2003 IEP, the District agreed in writing to fund the IEEs requested by Student’s Mother even though, in its view, she had not made Student reasonably available for assessment. In addition, the District provided Student’s Mother with a copy of the District/SELPA’s policy regarding IEEs that provided for the District to arrange the IEEs with the independent assessors once it received her signed assessment plan. Student’s Mother disagreed with the policy and advised Ms. Barhydt that she wanted to contact the IEE assessors directly to ensure that the assessments were independent and addressed her concerns. This dispute regarding the District’s policy for initiating and conducting IEEs led to a new CDE compliance complaint, S-0097-03/04 (filed August 8, 2003), that ultimately delayed their completion.

On August 4, 2003, CDE determined that the District was out of compliance with the assessment orders in the April 2003 Decision and ordered the District to provide evidence by September 30, 2003, that all the assessments ordered by the Decision were completed. On September 15, 2003, the District was verbally advised by CDE that it could not abandon its assessments and move directly forward with the IEEs as it had hoped to do, but that “it must complete the mandated assessments according to its compliance investigation requiring corrective actions for case S-0792-02/03, prior to the initiation of an IEE.” In her September 16, 2003 letter, Ms. Barhydt advised Student’s Mother that, due to CDE’s position, various District assessors needed to complete their assessments of Student before any IEEs could be conducted.

On September 30, 2003, the IEP team convened for a continued triennial/annual review and to address CDE’s mandated corrective action in S-0792-02/03. No new assessments of Student had been conducted by the District since the previous IEP team meeting and no agreement was reached at this meeting regarding placement. The District discussed its proposal for Student’s participation in a specially designed inclusion program at its Blair High School, with supports and modifications, and with a gradual re-entry to school beginning with half days. Student’s Mother advised the IEP team of her intention to wait for CDE’s determination on the appropriateness of the District’s IEE procedure, and for new goals and placement to be offered based upon the completed IEEs.

One positive development reported at this IEP team meeting was that Darlene Hanson, an independent speech pathologist and “facilitated communication” specialist selected by Student’s Mother, would begin to work with Student in his home for two hours a week in speech and language. Ms. Hanson described facilitated communication as an augmentative communication strategy that involves the provision of physical, communication, and emotional support to a person to access an alternate mode of communication or symbol system such as language or pictures, with the ultimate goal of independent communication. Ms. Hanson’s ability to work with Student and Student’s Mother was viewed as a lifeline by both the family and the District who remained trapped in their mutual distrust and inability to work together.

On October 1, 2003, in S-0097-03/04, CDE determined the District was in compliance regarding its IEE policy and procedures. On October 2, 2003, CDE Focused Monitoring Administrator Robert Evans wrote to Student’s Mother to advise her that two outstanding issues remained in compliance case S-0792-02/03: the order for the District to assess Student and Student’s availability to the District to complete the assessments. Mr. Evans advised Student’s Mother that “until such time as you and PUSD can agree on a time and place to complete the required assessment, Case #S-0792-02/03 will be held open. The language and requirements stated in the due process order are clear...there is nothing this office can do to alleviate or change your situation in the interim.” (Dist. Exh. 75.)

On October 14, 2003, in an effort to end the stalemate over completing its assessments, Ms. Barhydt wrote to Student’s Mother and offered to enter into a contract with another school district to complete the District’s assessments on its behalf. Although she rejected this offer, Student’s Mother agreed to make Student available for assessments by the District and District assessments were conducted by various assessors, including Mr. Valdez and Ms. Mallon. Ms. Hanson was present at these assessments to provide Student with facilitated communication support and to consult with District assessors in ways to present assessment materials to him.

School psychologist Valdez administered two subtests of the Matrix Analogies Test- Expanded Form (MAT-EF) to Student and determined that his performance “was more characteristic of an 8 year old child.” Ms. Mallon conducted an academic assessment using subtests of the Woodcock Johnson-Third Edition (WJ-III) that were extensively modified in light of her consultation with Ms. Hanson. From her assessment, Ms. Mallon concluded that Student was able to demonstrate age-appropriate comprehension for isolated sentences or sentences having literal connotation, but he had difficulty with sentences containing inferences or that were complex. She also determined that Student was able to demonstrate the four basic math functions, but had difficulty with fractions, factoring, exponents, and beginning algebra.

On October 29, 2003, Ms. Barhydt informed Student’s Mother that the District had completed its assessments, had received the parent’s signed assessment plan for IEEs, and that it could begin facilitating the completion of the requested IEEs. In early November 2003, the District contacted IEE assessors to begin the independent assessment process.

On November 12, 2003, an IEP team meeting was convened to review the District’s new and updated assessments and to develop a placement offer for Student. At the outset of the meeting, Student’s Mother asked that the IEP meeting be rescheduled because she had not had received the new assessment reports in advance of the IEP meeting as required by the previous Decision and could not effectively participate, and because Student, Ms. Hanson, and Student’s Regional Center staff were not present. Student’s Mother was asked to remain at the meeting and was given the copies of all reports. Student’s Mother provided the IEP team with a five-page attachment to be added to the IEP document and left the meeting.

After Student’s Mother left, District IEP team members continued with the meeting by reviewing new or updated assessment reports and new draft goals, and by discussing placement. From these assessments, the District IEP team members described Student’s unique needs as including a need for instruction based upon a functional range as an eight-year-old, and the need for a transition plan back into a public school setting. Draft goals were prepared at the fourth- to sixth-grade elementary school level. District team members recommended that Student be placed in a full-day, specially designed program at its Blair High School with courses predominantly in the resource specialist program and some in the general curriculum. Student would receive pass/fail grades and was on a non-diploma track. Student was also offered a gradual and scheduled transition back to school pursuant to a draft transition plan that called for Ms. Hanson to provide inclusion services during the transition by training Student’s one-to-one aide to support his communication and his use of assistive technology, and to respond to his anxiety.

On November 12, 2003, independent augmentative communication specialist Cindy Cottier, of the NPA Augmentative Communication Therapies, issued her latest of several independent assistive technology reports on Student. She reported that Student had “at last” accepted typing as a means of conveying information and recommended that he be provided with a DynaWrite assistive technology device with an adult male voice output. Ms. Cottier reported that, on the DynaWrite, Student was able to compose his sentences extremely quickly with its word prediction list, and wrote about “references in reports that he exhibited a cognitive delay and that ‘it just makes [him] furious.’” Ms. Cottier recommended using typing as Student’s primary means of communication and response system for academic purposes.

On November 18, 2003, Student’s Mother notified the District that she rejected all goals, placements, and assessments offered by the District at the November 12, 2003 IEP, and requested to review Student’s complete psychological file.

On November 19, 2003, CDE issued its compliance report in a third case, S-0205-03/04, which had been filed September 29, 2003. CDE concluded that the District was out of compliance with the requirement of Education Code section 56504 that the parent be provided access to educational records within five calendar days. On November 21, 2003, Student’s Mother reviewed and was provided copies of Student’s academic file, including the testing protocols for the Vineland, MAT, and WJ-III.

On December 1, 2003, Darlene Hanson prepared her speech language and augmentative communication assessment of Student. Ms. Hanson found that Student had apraxia, a difficulty in voluntary motor planning, that affected both his speech and use of his hands, that he demonstrated different levels of expressive communication with different communication partners, and that his language and communication skills would be consistent with peers of his age, as long as he is provided with support and technology. Ms. Hanson concluded that, “when the limitations of augmentative communication use is accounted for, Student’s receptive and expressive language skills do not at this time appear to be delayed or disordered.” Ms. Hanson also reported that Student did not currently have a communication device of his own. She recommended that he be provided with a DynaWrite communication device and that Student’s support persons be trained in (1) understanding how a movement disorder affects one’s ability to communicate through use of an alternate mode of communication; (2) how to use the DynaWrite; and (3) how to support a person with autism/augmentative communication needs in an educational environment. Ms. Hanson also indicated that Student would benefit from placement in a general education setting, with his success measured through participation and a work portfolio.

In November and December 2003, the District continued its efforts to secure and finalize the IEEs. Although Dr. LaVigna of the Institute for Applied Behavior Analysis (IABA) agreed to conduct an IEE in the area of behavior analysis for Student, Ms. Barhydt advised Student’s Mother in early December 2003 that Dr. LaVigna may not be able to finish Student’s assessment in a timely manner. As a consequence, she requested that Student’s Mother either agree to extend the time or pick a new person for the assessment. In early December 2003, the District received approval from the Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program SELPA for the Whittier school district approving use of Amy Rowell, a Whittier district school psychologist, to conduct Student’s independent psychoeducational and academic IEEs. On December 11, 2003, Ms. Barhydt advised Student’s Mother that WACSEP had approved using Ms. Rowell for the independent assessment and also acknowledged Student’s Mother’ agreement to extend the timelines for all the IEEs.

In January 2004, IEP team meetings were convened on January 7 and 20, to review IEEs and to discuss goals and placement. At the January 7, 2004 IEP meeting, the IEP team reviewed and adopted the recommendations in the assessments of Ms. Cottier and Ms. Hanson that Student be offered a DynaWrite assistive technology (AT) device as an accommodation. The IEP team was advised that the DynaWrite had been ordered and arrived but that there was a need to schedule training. District team members again offered Student placement in a specially designed inclusion program at Blair High School with several changes from its November 12, 2003 IEP proposal. First, Student was offered substantially more time in general education. All of his general education courses, however, would still be graded using a pass/fail system. Second, Student was placed on a high school diploma track, with an anticipated graduation date of June 2007. As related services, Student was offered a full time one-to-one instructional aide and two hours a week individual speech and language with Ms. Hanson plus twelve and a half hours of unspecified frequency of her consultation services, for training to Student’s general education and special education staff.

At this IEP meeting, Student’s Mother accepted Ms. Hanson’s three new proposed goals in communication for Student, as well as proposed services and training by Ms. Hanson, instructional aide support, and recommended assistive technology. Student’s Mother continued to reject all the District’s previously presented goals based on the Vineland and MAT that, in her view, were not accurate. The IEP team agreed to reconvene prior to the start of the new semester, when it was hoped Student would return to school.

On January 20, 2004, the IEP team met to continue the January 7, 2004 IEP meeting. Blair’s Algebra I teacher was present to discuss Student’s participation in general education algebra. Academic goals for Student in math and writing using the DynaWrite were proposed by Ms. Hanson but rejected by his mother. The IEP team identified Blair’s RSP teacher, Ms. Hendrix, as the inclusion specialist and case carrier/manager for Student. Student’s Mother continued to reject home teaching because the home teacher was not trained to work with Student. In an attachment to this IEP, Student’s Mother reiterated her rejection of all placement offers from June 12, 2003, to January 20, 2004.

In early 2004, the District purchased the DynaWrite for Student’s home and school use and provided two DynaWrite training sessions for Student and individuals who were likely to work with him on this device. A two-hour training conducted on January 21, 2004, was attended by Ms. Hanson, Regional Center ASL communication teacher Mr. Hardy, Student’s Mother, Student, Ms. Hendrix, and her instructional aide (IA) Lezlie Porter. Ms. Hanson testified that, during this training, Student demonstrated knowledge of advanced functions of the DynaWrite. A two-hour in-service training conducted on February 26, 2004, was attended by Blair High School staff who would work with Student, including his assigned home teacher, Roxanna Wilson.

In March 2004, Student’s independent psychoeducational/academic and behavioral assessments began. On March 8, 2004, Ms. Rowell began meeting with Student and Student’s Mother in their home to assess Student’s learning style, learning strengths and weaknesses, social-emotional functioning, and adaptive skill levels. This IEE took place over a total of twenty-five hours broken in eight sessions (March 15, 22, 29, and May 3, 10, 17, and 24, 2004). Dr. LaVigna also began his detailed review of Student’s educational records, interviews with a wide range of service providers including Ms. Rowell, Ms. Hanson, and Regional Center staff, observations, and assessment of Student’s behavior, particularly in the area of his anxiety and how it affected his educational participation and performance.

On March 25, 2004, Student’s Mother filed a request for the present due process hearing.

On April 12, 2004, Dr. LaVigna provided his fifty-three page “Comprehensive Functional Assessment Report and Recommended Support Plan” (CFA) for Student, in which he characterized Student’s key educational and behavioral problem as a “Lack of Participation and Exhibited Progress” or LPEP, that was manifested in its most severe form in Student’s total absence from school. (Footnote 6) The essential conclusion reached by Dr. LaVigna was that it is impossible to determine Student’s present levels of performance with specificity given his anxiety, his motor disturbance from his autism, and his difficulty in demonstrating what he knows. Dr. LaVigna concluded that there was sufficient indication of Student’s ability to understand and learn at a higher level to conclude that he should be given the opportunity to participate in age-appropriate curriculum without assessing his “present level of performance.” Dr. LaVigna also concluded that Student needed a reliable form of communication so that he could receive formal credit for his academic progress and perhaps even pursue higher education. In the meantime, Dr. LaVigna recommended that Student be exposed to mainstream, age-appropriate curriculum and that testing and assessment of his progress should be addressed separately.

On April 26, 2004, Student’s sixteen-member IEP team met for over four hours to discuss Dr. LaVigna’s CFA report and support plan and to conduct Student’s annual IEP review. Dr. LaVigna reviewed his report, and discussed the detailed support plan he recommended for Student. The District staff proposed new draft annual goals for reducing both the occurrence and severity of Student’s LPEP and offered special program goals based upon Dr. LaVigna’s report. School psychologist and behaviorist Dr. William Bernhardt also prepared a four-page behavior support plan (BSP) for Student that he testified was intended to incorporate the CFA report and recommendations. The District again offered Student placement at Blair in an inclusion program with related services that included individual speech and language therapy and speech consultation services, ten hours a week of inclusion specialist consultation services, two one-to-one aides (one shadow aide six hours a day and one homework assignment support aide two hours a day), a DynaWrite AT device for both home and school use and one hour a month AT consultation, and behaviorist consultation and supervision six hours per month by a District behaviorist/school psychologist who would act as Student’s BICM and supervise the implementation of Student’s behavior support plan (BSP). The District also offered to convene monthly IEP team meetings to address numerous issues, including future program modifications and planning and implementation of the IEP. At the conclusion of this IEP, Student’s Mother took the document home to review.

On May 4, 2004, the District filed its request for a due process hearing.

On May 19, 2004, Ms. Barhydt wrote a letter to Student’s Mother supplementing and clarifying the District’s offer at the April 26, 2004 annual IEP, regarding paraprofessional services, training, inclusion specialist services, and behavior. Of particular note was the District’s offer, in addition to the behavior consultation and supervision services outlined in the IEP, to contract with Dr. LaVigna for his “behavior intervention technical support and expert guidance” services for eight hours for the first month and two hours per month until the end of the fall 2004 semester, with services to include consultation regarding training the IEP team to implement Student’s BSP, implementing and supervising the implementation of the BSP, and modifying the BSP as necessary. Ms. Barhydt also clarified Student’s transition plan for return to school by advising Student’s Mother that the District IEP team members recommended that Student audit his courses during the 2004 ESY and work toward a limited set of non-academic goals from the April 26, 2004 IEP. Ms. Barhydt explained that they had determined that Student’s goals and needs in anxiety must be addressed before he would be able to work toward academics goals. She further clarified that the IEP team would reconvene four to six weeks after the start of the 2004-2005 school year to review Student’s progress and to develop goals and objectives in the remaining areas of identified, assessed need.

On June 1, 2004, Whitter school psychologist Amy Rowell completed her independent psychoeducational/academic assessment of Student. From her assessment, Ms. Rowell concluded that Student is capable of participating in typical grade-level curriculum, “if not more advanced. He has an abundance of knowledge in his head; his problems are in accessing and demonstrating that knowledge for others. Student has difficulties demonstrating knowledge and skills in demand situations.” Ms. Rowell made many recommendations to address Student’s learning style, including that he be provided instruction with typical, same-age peers utilizing grade-appropriate, general education curriculum and grade level standards, that “those who work and interact with Student most are fluent in sign language,” and that staff be trained to work with Student regarding (1) autism spectrum disorders, movement/motor planning/organization of behavior issues, with emphasis on how autism and movement issues impact a student=s functioning in academic and social situations; and (2) facilitated communication strategies (i.e, not motoring Student through a task, but providing emotional support and having the expectation that Student can demonstrate his knowledge given necessary accommodations).

On June 7, 2004, the IEP team met to review Ms. Rowell’s assessment. As indicated in the IEP addendum notes, the IEP team agreed that her recommendations would be used in Student’s instructional program. The District also amended its previous transition plan that Student audit his ESY classes to an offer that Student would be able to earn credits for ESY 2004 classes.

On June 8, 2004, Ms. Barhydt wrote up a transition plan for Student for ESY 2004 and for the 2004-2005 school year, based upon the notes she had taken at the June 7, 2004 IEP team meeting. Of significance in this transition plan was the determination that, for the 2004-2005 school year, Student would enroll in tenth grade at Blair in just two of his four core academic courses initially. At the end of the second week, Student, Student’s Mother, and Student’s support team were to meet and review his “readiness” to attend all classes.

As previously discussed, after the hearing began, in early July 2004 Student enrolled in two general education high school classes at Pasadena High School, with inclusion support from special education teacher William Garnett, Ms. Hanson, and two paraprofessional aides. On July 8, 2004, Ms. Hanson advised Student, Student’s Mother, and the District that she could no longer work with Student following an incident in which Student’s Mother sharply criticized her professional capacity and work with Student and Mr. Garnett. Ms. Hanson subsequently testified that after Ms. Barhydt urged her to continue until a replacement could be found, she agreed to continue working in the role of a trainer for Student’s support staff so they would have sufficient knowledge of Student’s communication needs, movement disorder and autism.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

I. Did the District fail to offer and provide Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from April 23, 2003 to April 26, 2004, including the 2003 extended school year?

Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. ' 1400; California Education Code ' 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student=s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401 (25). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(22). Education Code section 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

To determine whether the District offered Student a free appropriate public education from April 23, 2003 to April 26, 2004, the Hearing Officer must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). At the administrative hearing, the school district has the burden of proving that it has complied with the IDEA, including that it has offered an appropriate educational placement for the student. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student=s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student=s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205.

The analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold. The hearing officer must determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been satisfied and whether the FAPE offered was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207. To constitute a FAPE as required by the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s offer must meet the following substantive requirements: (1) have been designed to meet Student’s unique needs, (2) have been reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit, and (3) have comported with his IEP. (Footnote 7)

1. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to timely and appropriately assess him, either directly or by funding requested independent educational assessments?

Under the IDEA, the individualized education program (IEP), informed and driven by current assessment data, is the blueprint for a child’s special education program. As part of the assessment or reassessment process, the IEP team must review existing assessment data on the child and identify the child=s present levels of performance and educational needs, whether the child continues to need special education and related services, and whether any additions or modifications to the special education and related services are needed to enable the child to meet the measurable annual goals set out in the IEP and to participate, if appropriate, in the general curriculum. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(c)(1). Statements regarding each of these elements must be included in the child=s IEP. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(A).

There is no dispute that after the April 23, 2003 Decision was issued, the District was required to conduct a comprehensive assessment of Student. Under both the IDEA and California law, a child must be assessed in “all areas of suspected disability,” and assessments conducted must be “sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of the child’s special education and related services needs, whether or not commonly linked to the disability category in which the child has been classified.” 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(a)(1); 34 C.F.R. ' 300.532(h); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56320(f). A student must be reassessed “if conditions warrant” or if requested by the child’s parent or teacher, but at least once every three years. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(a)(2)(A); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56381. In SN02-02461, Hearing Officer Ganz found that Student’s triennial had been due in April 2002. (District Exh. 1, p.13, fn. 12.) Thus, at the time that Decision was issued, Student’s triennial assessment was one year overdue. In discussing his assessment, Hearing Officer Ganz described Student as a “difficult to assess” student whose cognitive and academic abilities “had stymied all who worked with him, and there was no way to know what Student was capable of, why he resisted performing and what measures could be attempted so that his behaviors did not impede him from taking advantage of his educational program.” Id. at p. 18.

The District was ordered to conduct a comprehensive psychoeducational assessment of Student’s educational needs that, at a minimum, addressed (1) his behavioral and emotional needs, including his anxiety and lack of motivation, (2) his communication and socialization needs, including his ability to write, type, or use a keyboard, and (3) his academic needs, including identification of his present levels of performance and his ability to be involved in or progress in the general education curriculum. In describing the type of comprehensive assessment the District was required to conduct, Hearing Officer Ganz stated that “attention shall be paid to Student’s resistant behaviors and efforts will be made and strategies developed, if necessary, to use a variety of assessment tools at the discretion of the assessors.” She also indicated that the District “shall select assessors who have experience with children diagnosed with autism and with difficult to assess children,” and that “test instruments shall be selected to assess the relative contribution of cognitive and behavioral factors to Student’s need for services.” Id. at pp. 14, 19.

Student asserts that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to timely and appropriately assess him, either directly or by funding requested independent educational assessments. Because the District never asserted that the assessments its assessors were able to conduct on Student were comprehensive, it is unnecessary to review Student’s challenges to their appropriateness. Rather, the focus is on whether the District acted in a timely manner to assess Student by its own assessors or through independent assessors. At the due process hearing, Student’s Mother conceded on cross-examination that the District had sufficient information to craft an appropriate educational program for Student after the independent assessments by Dr. LaVigna and Ms. Rowell were completed in April and June 2004, respectively. Thus, it is undisputed that the District had completed comprehensive assessments of Student by June of 2004. Viewing the record as a whole, including the prior Decision, there was a total delay of over two years, extending from the April 2002 triennial reassessment due date to the completion of these evaluations in June 2004, in obtaining the comprehensive data necessary to design an appropriate educational program for Student. The only delay at issue in this hearing, however, is that which occurred following the issuance of the April 2003 Decision, a period of approximately fourteen months. The Hearing Officer must determine where responsibility for this delay in completing Student’s assessments rests.

In considering whether the District denied Student a FAPE by failing to assess him fully in a timely manner, a hindsight analysis is inappropriate. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999). The proper inquiry is on whether the District acted in a timely fashion to assess Student directly or through independent assessors in light of the facts and circumstances known to it at the time. The Hearing Officer notes that the reasons for the delay in completing Student’s assessments were numerous, and the culpability for this delay was hotly disputed. On the one hand, Student’s Mother argued that the District failed to comply with the orders as written in the April 2003 Decision, and then sought to place Student in what, in her view, was an open-ended diagnostic placement not authorized by the Decision. Student’s Mother argued that the District then agreed to conduct independent educational evaluations (IEEs), but delayed the process for initiating the IEEs and ‘doled them out’ one by one. Student’s Mother further contended that, throughout this period, the District continued to offer Student placements that were not based on any current assessment data. On the other hand, the District argued that it attempted to comply with all the orders in the Decision, but that its assessment efforts were hindered in some cases and completely blocked in others by Student’s Mother’ conduct. In the District’s view, because it could not assess Student appropriately under the time constraints imposed by the Decision in light of his complex needs and under the conditions imposed by Student’s Mother, a diagnostic placement was required to complete comprehensive assessments of Student and to then develop a long-term educational program. When Student’s Mother rejected its proposed diagnostic placement, the District chose another avenue to assess Student by agreeing to have the assessments completed by independent assessors of Student’s Mother’ choosing. In the District’s view, the delay in completing the independent assessments was substantially attributable to Student’s Mother’ conduct of filing a CDE complaint to challenge its IEE policy and not allowing the District to complete its assessments as instructed by CDE, and to the scheduling difficulties of the assessors chosen by Student’s Mother. Finally, the District argues that it offered Student’s Mother the opportunity to select other assessors to obtain more timely assessment results, but that she agreed to waive time for the completion of assessments by Dr. LaVigna and Ms. Rowell. The Hearing Officer reviews the relative conduct of the parties to determine whether the District denied Student a FAPE by failing to timely complete necessary assessments.

Assessment by District Personnel: May through June 2003

At hearing, Student specifically challenged the psychoeducational assessments by District school psychologist Gary Valdez and the academic assessments by special education teacher Pam Mallon. (Footnote 8) Mr. Valdez’s June 2, 2003 psychoeducational assessment report was based upon his observations of Student on two occasions, for ten minutes on May 22, 2003, while Student worked at school with District speech therapist Joe Givens, and for approximately one hour in Student’s home on June 3, 2003, during Student’s Mother’ completion of the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, Interview Edition. Each of these sessions was videotaped and attended by two to three other adults brought by Student’s Mother as observers and videographers. Mr. Valdez did not attempt to administer any standardized tests to Student during these observations. Ms. Mallon’s June 2, 2003 academic assessment summary report was based predominantly upon her review of Student’s educational records, including new assessment reports by other District assessors. Ms. Mallon testified that she was prohibited by Student’s Mother from administering any testing materials to Student during what was intended to be a joint assessment session with the District’s occupational therapist (OT), Ms. Wolford, and its assistive technology specialist, Ms. Schwartz, on May 20, 2003. After being informed by Student’s Mother that Student would not allow Ms. Mallon to assess him, Ms. Mallon observed Student’s work with Ms. Wolford. Ms. Mallon testified that she again attempted to assess Student on May 21, 2003, when she accompanied Ms. Schwartz to Student’s home. Ms. Mallon testified that, at this meeting, Student’s Mother reiterated that Student did not want Ms. Mallon to assess him and that her observation might result in Student’s refusal to work with Ms. Schwartz. As a result, Ms. Mallon waited outside. Finally, Ms. Mallon testified that she telephoned Student’s Mother to schedule an assessment on May 28, 2003, but was again told that she could not assess Student. As a consequence of Student’s Mother’ actions, there was no formal academic assessment.

The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s Mother’ conduct during the course of the District’s assessments in May and June 2003 interfered with the District’s ability to conduct its assessments. In particular, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s Mother’ videotaping of the assessments created an atmosphere that was not conducive to assessing Student. The evidence established that special education director Ms. Barhydt gave Student’s Mother her conditional permission to videotape the assessments but left the final decision to the assessors. District school psychologist Mr. Valdez testified that the District’s assessors expressed concern to the parent about videotaping the assessment; however, Student’s Mother made it clear to the assessors that the assessment would not continue unless it was videotaped. The Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Valdez’s testimony persuasively established that the best practice for conducting an assessment is to minimize distractions, that Student’s was the only assessment of all the numerous assessments he had ever conducted in which the videotape equipment was in the same room with the student being assessed, and that Student repeatedly turned to look into the camera during the assessment. In fact, in his June 2003 report, Mr. Valdez recommended that Student be “reevaluated after he is assigned to a school classroom program where he is in the company of peers” away from undue influence of “outside factors such as the presence of parent, other adults, and video taping equipment. Such disruptions influence and contaminate assessment results.” (Footnote 9) From his testimony, the Hearing Officer also finds that Mr. Valdez was a qualified school psychologist able to conduct Student’s psychological assessment as required by California Education Code section 56324(a) and the April 23, 2003 Decision. (Footnote 10)

Further, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s Mother prevented Ms. Mallon from conducting an academic assessment of Student. As a threshold matter, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Mallon is a qualified, competent assessor as required by California Education Code section 56322. This finding is based upon Ms. Mallon’s testimony regarding her educational background and experience as a special education teacher specialist, as well as on the testimony of Ms. Hanson regarding the appropriate testing modifications Ms. Mallon developed for Student when she finally assessed him in October 2003. The weight of the evidence established that the District had included Ms. Mallon in its multi-disciplinary assessment team based upon its knowledge that Student had difficulty with unfamiliar people and that Ms. Mallon had worked with Student for many years. (Test. Mallon, Halpern O’Neal.) Student’s Mother testified that she was upset that the District had chosen Ms. Mallon to assess Student due to Ms. Mallon’s testimony at the prior hearing which Student’s Mother believed did not properly depict Student’s cognitive potential, and because Hearing Officer Ganz found that as Student’s behavior intervention case manager (BICM) Ms. Mallon had failed to implement his behavior intervention plan (BIP) across school environments. Student’s Mother reported that Student shared her displeasure and that he refused to work with Ms. Mallon; however, Ms. Mallon’s observations of Student’s willingness to work with her on May 20, 2003, directly contradicted this claim. While Student’s Mother’ distrust may have been understandable, the Hearing Officer finds that the District had a right to select its assessors. The District’s discretion to select assessors was explicitly stated in the prior Decision, and nothing in the Decision in any way prohibited the District from including Ms. Mallon on the assessment team. (Dist. Exh. 1, p. 24.) (Footnote 11)

Nonetheless, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was effectively prevented by Student’s Mother’ actions from conducting psychoeducational and academic assessments of Student in May and June 2003. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has determined that, if parents want their child to receive special education and related services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), the parents must allow the educational agency to assess their child. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F. 2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987). In this regard, a school district may insist on conducting its assessments using its own qualified personnel. Andress v. Cleveland Independent Sch. Dist., 64 F.3d 176, 178 (5th Cir. 1995), cert. denied, 519 U.S. 812, 117 S. Ct. 58 (1996); accord Vander Malle v. Ambach, 673 F.2d 49, 53 (2nd Cir. 1983). In Andress, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals concluded that “a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to evaluate the child ... there is no exception to this rule.” Id.

From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that Student had no right to a FAPE during the period that his mother refused to permit an academic assessment by the District’s chosen and qualified assessor Ms. Mallon and hindered the psychoeducational assessment of Mr. Valdez in May and June 2003. This lack of entitlement to a FAPE continued until late October 2003, when Student’s Mother finally agreed to allow District assessors, including Ms. Mallon, to assess Student as a precondition to conducting the IEEs. The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s Mother did not interfere in the October assessments but allowed them to be conducted at District sites outside of her presence and without being videotaped.

Assessment in a Diagnostic Placement: Extended School Year 2003

A student who is eligible for special education and related services may be placed temporarily in an educational program as part of the assessment process to assist the public education agency in determining the appropriate placement for a child or if there is some question about the child=s special education or related services needs. Such a placement, known as a diagnostic placement, can occur and may be appropriate on a case-by-case basis before the IEP is finalized. As such, a diagnostic placement does not run afoul of federal and State law requiring that an IEP be “in effect before special education and related services are provided to an eligible child....” 34 C.F.R. ' 300.342(b)(1) (italics added); 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(2)(A); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56344(b); 64 Fed. Reg. No. 48, App. A to 34 C.F.R. Part 300 – Q. 14; 64 Fed. Reg. 48 at 12592. (Footnote 12)

On June 5, 2003, Ms. Halpern O’Neal wrote to Student’s Mother to advise her of a diagnostic placement option for the summer 2003 at the Help Group, Sunrise Program, a nonpublic school, and to suggest that Student’s Mother visit the program. Ms. Halpern O’Neal explained that from the assessment reports “it is clear that additional data is needed to develop long-term placement and service recommendations” for Student and that “a summer diagnostic placement, such as the Help Group, would allow an environment for Student to be among his peers, receive academic instruction, related services and provide the assessors with a school environment in which to observe Student=s present needs.” At the June 12, 2003 annual/triennial IEP team review meeting, the District recommended that Student participate in a diagnostic summer placement at the Sunrise Program for the specific purpose of continuing his assessment. Student’s Mother rejected this manner of assessing Student due to her belief, as explained in her correspondence and testimony, that the diagnostic placement was in a special day class (SDC) designed for students of significantly lower cognitive functioning than Student, similar to those educational settings in which he had previously been placed, and was therefore unlikely to result in an accurate determination of his present levels of performance and unique needs.

In this case, both Mr. Valdez and Ms. Mallon testified that they had not been able to obtain sufficient assessment data in June 2003 and that they believed Student required a diagnostic placement to further assess his abilities. In fact, in his June 2003 report, Mr. Valdez strongly recommended that District “need[s] to make the hearing officer aware of the above requirements. Student, due to his diagnosis, should be evaluated in his regularly assigned school setting so that there is continuity between his daily academic program and the evaluation process. A more accurate measurement of such areas as communication, socialization, cognition, academics, life skills, and emotional development could be achieved in that setting.” The weight of the evidence established that a diagnostic placement for assessment as recommended at the June 12, 2003 IEP meeting was supported by all District staff involved in Student=s IEP, including program specialist Judy Halpern O=Neal and District school psychologist Gary Valdez, each of whom testified that they had experience in assessing “difficult to assess” or “inexplicable” students at California=s specialized Diagnostic Centers.

The Hearing Officer finds that a diagnostic placement such as that which the District proposed at the Sunrise Program was an appropriate assessment strategy in June 2003, given the District’s recent lack of success in assessing Student at home, and Student’s Mother’ interference in the assessment process, as well as Student’s multiple communication needs and general status as a “difficult to assess” student. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that the diagnostic placement was designed for a limited period over the extended school year, that the District offered to conduct the assessment in conjunction with the independent Help Group due to its acknowledgment of the parent’s distrust of District personnel, and that Student would have had an opportunity to access other academic areas of interest to him through the HELP Group. (Test. Halpern O’Neal.) The Hearing Officer further finds that Student’s Mother’ rejection of this viable assessment strategy further limited the District’s ability to comprehensively assess Student during the summer of 2003. As discussed below, after Student’s Mother rejected this placement, the District abandoned the diagnostic placement as a means of completing its assessment and elected instead to complete its assessment of Student by hiring independent assessors.

Assessment by Independent Educational Evaluations (IEEs)

The parent of a student with a disability has a right to an independent educational evaluation (IEE) funded by the local education agency if the parent disagrees with that agency’s evaluation. Once an IEE is requested, the local education agency must either initiate a due process hearing to show that its assessment is appropriate or ensure that the IEE is provided at public expense without unnecessary delay. The agency “may not unreasonably delay either providing the independent educational evaluation at public expense or initiating a due process hearing to defend the public evaluation.” 34 C.F.R. ' 300.502(b); see also Cal. Educ. Code ' 56329. As previously discussed, the IEEs in question were not completed until approximately fourteen months after the April 23, 2003 Decision. Dr. LaVigna’s independent assessment was completed on April 14, 2004, and reviewed at the IEP team meeting of April 26, 2004. Amy Rowell’s independent psychoeducational and academic assessment was not completed until June 3, 2004, and reviewed at the June 7, 2004 IEP team meeting.

The evidence persuasively establishes that the District acted swiftly to complete Student’s assessment once Student’s Mother rejected a summer diagnostic placement as a means to complete its assessment. On June 13, 2003, Student’s Mother requested that the District fund IEEs. Within days of this request, the District provided Student’s Mother with written assurance of its willingness to fund her requested independent assessments. In fact, due to Student’s Mother’ repeated requests to know if it would fund the IEEs, the District wrote three letters assuring her of its willingness to fund the IEEs, even though she had not made Student reasonably available for assessment. The evidence also establishes that because the District had not completed its assessments of Student, there was no completed assessment with which Student could disagree and thus trigger his statutory right to an IEE. Nonetheless, to complete the assessment process and have Student return to school, the District agreed to fund independent assessments. In this regard, the Hearing Officer notes that the District’s decision to complete its assessments with independent contractors was in keeping with the discretion vested in it by Hearing Officer Ganz to select qualified assessors for Student.

From the totality of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the delay in IEE completion was attributable predominantly to factors outside of the District’s control. For example, Student’s Mother’ CDE complaint regarding the District’s IEE policy, CDE case S-0097-03/04, delayed action on the IEEs from the date the complaint was filed by CDE on August 8, 2003, to the date CDE determined that the District’s IEE policy was in compliance on October 1, 2003. Testimonial and documentary evidence, including CDE’s finding of “due diligence” by the District, established that the District had agreed to conduct the IEEs as early as June 17, 2003, and that it had begun to take affirmative steps to conduct the IEEs in July 2003. In addition, the evidence established that Student’s Mother refused to allow the District to complete its assessment for a period of approximately three weeks after being specifically advised by CDE that she needed to make Student available to the District (October 2, 2003, to October 20, 2003). Moreover, the evidence persuasively established that, after it completed its assessments, the District acted with reasonable diligence in November and December 2003 to arrange IEEs by securing necessary information from and arranging assessments by Dr. LaVigna and Ms. Rowell. The Hearing Officer also finds that a significant portion of the delay in completion of assessments was attributable to the schedules of the independent assessors Student’s Mother had chosen as well as the detailed nature of those assessments. For example, Dr. LaVigna testified that his comprehensive behavior assessment took four months, from December 2003 to mid-April 2004, to complete and that this was largely due to his busy schedule. Similarly, Ms. Rowell’s availability to conduct the psychoeducational and academic assessment was confirmed by Whittier’s SELPA on December 11, 2003, and personally by Ms. Rowell after her return from vacation on January 9, 2004. Ms. Rowell’s thorough assessment of Student then spanned eight sessions from March through May 2004.

Finally, the evidence persuasively established that Student’s Mother acquiesced in this delay because she wanted these particular assessors. For example, on December 8, 2003, Ms. Barhydt advised Student’s Mother that IABA indicated that Dr. LaVigna may not be able to finish Student’s assessment in a timely manner. As a consequence, Ms. Barhydt requested that Student’s Mother either agree to extend the time or pick a new person for this assessment. On December 11, 2003, Ms. Barhydt acknowledged Student’s Mother’ agreement to the extension of the timeline for all the IEEs, as contained in Student’s Mother’ facsimile dated December 11, 2003. (Testimony Barhydt; Dist. Exhs. 126, 132, 133.) * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s Mother’ conduct interfered with the District’s right to assess Student in May and June 2003, by preventing an academic assessment of Student by Ms. Mallon and by hindering the psychoeducational assessment of Dr. Valdez and other members of the Distric’s multi-disciplinary team. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s Mother’ rejection of a summer diagnostic placement interfered with the District’s right to assess Student during the 2003 extended school year. The Hearing Officer further finds that the delay in completing Student’s IEEs was not attributable to the District. Rather, the Hearing Officer finds that the majority of the delay was due to Student’s Mother’ insistence on waiting until CDE completed its investigation of her complaint regarding the District’s IEE policy, to her delay in allowing the District to complete its assessment after CDE advised her to do so, and to her decision to continue with assessments by Dr. LaVigna and Ms. Rowell rather than selecting different assessors. The Hearing Officer finds that a portion of the delay was attributable to Dr. LaVigna’s and Ms. Rowell’s scheduling issues that were outside the District’s control. Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s Mother waived the time for completion of the IEEs by Dr. LaVigna and Ms. Rowell.

From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not deny Student a FAPE by failing to timely complete his assessments. Rather, by interfering with the District’s right to assess Student, Student’s Mother prevented the District from completing its assessment. Student was therefore not entitled to special education and related services for the period from May 2003 through October 2003, when Student’s Mother consented to Student’s assessment by District personnel, including Ms. Mallon, without imposing conditions. The Hearing Officer concludes that after it completed its assessments in late October 2003, the District acted to arrange and fund the IEEs “without unnecessary delay,” and that the subsequent delay in completing the IEEs was waived by Student.

2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to prepare appropriate goals and objectives? (Footnote 13)

The IEP team must include a “statement of measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to meeting the child=s needs that result from the child=s disability to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum; and meeting each of the child’s other educational needs that result from the child=s disability.” 20 U.S.C. ' 1414 (d)(A)(ii). Student asserts that the academic goals and objectives prepared by the District were inappropriate because they were based upon inaccurate and incomplete assessment data from Mr. Valdez and Ms. Mallon that concluded he was functioning at the level of an eight- year-old student, significantly below his chronological age level.

As discussed above, due to Student’s Mother’ interference in its assessment process and the delays in completing the IEEs that were outside the District=s control, the District did not have comprehensive assessment data about Student’s unique academic needs during this time period. Rather, the District had some information about Student’s functional range as exhibited in the Vineland completed by Student’s Mother in June 2003 and in portions of two test instruments administered to Student in a non-standardized manner with facilitated communication support from Ms. Hanson: two subtests of the Matrix Analogies Test Expanded Form (MAT-EF), a nonverbal reasoning skills test, that Mr. Valdez administered to Student on October 27, 2003, and four extensively modified subtests of the Woodcock Johnson-Third Edition (WJ-III) that Ms. Mallon administered to Student on October 22, 2003. From his assessments, Mr. Valdez made a qualified finding that the best estimate of Student’s overall development would place him in the eight-year-old range. Ms. Mallon concluded that Student was able to demonstrate age-appropriate comprehension for some sentences (isolated content or literal connotation), but had difficulty demonstrating comprehension for very complex sentences (inferences or compare and contrast statements). She concluded that Student was able to demonstrate the four basic math functions (addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division) but had difficulty with fractions, factoring, exponents, and beginning algebra. It was clear from the testimony of both Mr. Valdez and Ms. Mallon that their test results were not intended to be comprehensive statements of Student=s present levels of performance, but rather as a piece of diagnostic information about Student that could be used as a starting point for educational planning, including the preparation of goals and objectives.

Because more comprehensive information was not available at the June 12, 2003, September 30, 2003, and November 12, 2003 IEP meetings, the District IEP team members relied on information they were able to obtain about Student’s abilities from these assessments to conclude that Student needed “instruction based upon a functional range as an eight year old” and to develop goals and objectives. At the November 11, 2003 IEP team meeting, after Student=s initial academic assessment by Ms. Mallon and additional assessments by Mr. Valdez outlined above, the District proposed academic goals utilizing data obtained from the assessments. Specifically, the draft goals included a reading goal at the fourth-grade, second-month elementary language arts standard (ELA), a written expression goal at the sixth-grade, second- month ELA, and a mathematics goal at the fifth-grade, second-month ELA.

Although all parties currently agree that Student is capable of learning general education curriculum at his age level or higher, the District did not have comprehensive assessment data available to it when it drafted these academic goals. The Hearing Officer finds that the District reasonably relied on the existing current assessment data that it was able to obtain to prepare these goals. Although the District had anecdotal information from its June 2003 assistive technology report by AT specialist Ms. Schwartz that Student appeared to read at grade level, Ms. Mallon’s October 2003 academic assessment fleshed out the strengths and weaknesses that Student was able to demonstrate to her in her carefully modified assessment format. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive Ms. Mallon’s testimony that these goals were a reasonable starting point for Student in light of her assessment. As discussed in Issue II, the parties currently agree with the conclusion in Dr. LaVigna’s IEE that Student is able to learn at a much higher level than he is able to demonstrate and that he should therefore be exposed to age-appropriate curriculum. However, because the District did not have the benefit of this comprehensive assessment data at the time these goals were drafted, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny Student a FAPE from April 23, 2003 to April 26, 2004, by failing to offer appropriate academic goals.

3. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to offer an appropriate placement and related services?

As previously discussed, an offer of FAPE must have been designed to meet Student=s unique needs and have been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. (Footnote 14)

Student’s Unique Needs

After Student’s Mother rejected the diagnostic placement offered at the June 12, 2003 IEP team meeting, the District proposed three educational placements for Student in various inclusion configurations at its Blair High School at the IEP meetings of September 30, 2003, November 11, 2003, and January 7 and 20, 2004. Student asserted that these offers of placement were not designed to meet Student’s unique needs. As previously discussed, the District had limited information regarding Student’s then-current unique needs because it had been effectively prevented from conducting a comprehensive assessment of Student either directly or through a diagnostic placement, and was awaiting assessment results from IEEs. Mindful that the District was unable to obtain detailed information about Student’s needs until April and June 2004, the Hearing Officer nonetheless finds that Student had unique behavioral needs that were known to the District prior to that time that must have been addressed in any proposed educational placement to constitute an offer of FAPE.

Unique Behavioral Needs

In developing an IEP for a child whose behavior impedes his learning, the IDEA requires that the IEP team shall “consider, when appropriate, strategies, including positive behavioral interventions, strategies, and supports to address that behavior...” 20 U.S.C. ' 1414 (d)(3)(B)(i); 34 C.F.R. ' 300.346(a)(2)(i). If, in considering a child’s behavioral needs, the IEP team determines that the child needs a particular device or service (including an intervention, accommodation, or other program modification) to receive a FAPE, the IEP team must make a statement to that effect in the child’s IEP. 34 C.F.R. ' 300.346(a)(2)(i). A behavior intervention plan (BIP) is a written document which must be part of an individual’s IEP that is “developed when the individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP.” Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, ' 3001(f).

The April 2003 Decision established that Student required a BIP to participate effectively in his education. In that Decision, Hearing Officer Ganz found that the implementation of Student’s behavior intervention plan (BIP) was a “critical” component of his education program as reflected “by the IEP team’s determination that the key to Student’s participation was the management of his behavior.” (Dist. Ex. 1, at 16-17.) The record in that case established that the BIP in effect at the time was prepared by Ms. Mallon in March 2002. Hearing Officer Ganz also determined that it was not possible to identify Student=s then current unique behavioral needs without a new behavioral assessment. As a consequence, she ordered the District to conduct an updated functional analysis assessment (FAA) to identify Student’s unique behavioral needs. Under the time constraints mandated by that Decision, Student would be in school for over two months --sixty-five days--before the IEP team was required to reconvene to review and adopt the updated functional analysis assessment and draft BIP. (Id. at 23.) The Hearing Officer finds that Student had unique behavioral needs for behavior support services during the transition period from his return to school to the completion of the updated FAA and BIP.

Designed to Meet Student=s Unique Needs

Although an IEP team meeting was convened on September 30, 2003, a review of the record, including the audio-cassette of that IEP, indicates that a formal offer of placement was not made at this IEP meeting. Rather, the thrust of the meeting was informational with Blair’s principal, Mr. Boccia, present to discuss the inclusion program available at Blair. While the District IEP team members discussed possible components of such a program, no specific offer of placement and services for Student was made.

The District first formally offered Student a placement in an inclusion program at Blair at the November 12, 2003 IEP team meeting, following the completion of the District’s assessments. As discussed more fully below, Student’s Mother came to the meeting, requested that the IEP meeting be rescheduled to give her time to review newly provided reports, and left when the meeting was not rescheduled. At the meeting, the District offered Student a full-day program at Blair in a specially designed inclusion program with classes in both the resource specialist program and general education program following typical course work expectations for ninth- grade students. A transition plan was offered that proposed a gradual return to classes and an unspecified amount of inclusion support by Ms. Hanson. The IEP addressed Student’s behavioral support needs by indicating that he required modifications of the classroom management system in the form of techniques to reduce anxiety and supports to assist Student with communication.

The Hearing Officer finds that the November 12, 2003 IEP was not designed to meet Student’s unique behavioral needs. As indicated above, it was well established that Student’s behavior, including his intense anxiety, was a critical factor in his ability to participate in his education. Due to Student’s anxiety disorder and his (at that time) one-year absence from school, the Hearing Officer finds that a focused and specific offer of services to address Student’s behavior during the transition time, extending from his re-enrollment in school through the period when an updated FAA and BIP would have been prepared and adopted by the IEP team as ordered in SN02-02462, was essential to an offer of a FAPE. Historically, Student had a behavior intervention plan and an assigned behavior intervention case manager (BICM), who by definition was “trained in behavior analysis with an emphasis on positive behavioral interventions.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, ' 3001(e). While some strategies were suggested to address Student’s anxiety, the District failed to offer Student the support of a BICM or any other personnel specifically trained in this area. Ms. Hanson’s services were offered to facilitate Student’s inclusion, including by discussing his anxiety needs with school staff. While the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Hanson is a qualified speech pathologist, there is no evidence that Ms. Hanson was trained as a BICM. Furthermore, even assuming Ms. Hanson was qualified to provide behavioral support to Student during the hiatus between his re-entry to school and the adoption of a new BIP, the District failed to make any specific offer of duration and frequency of these critical services. Cal. Code Regs., tit. v, ' 3051.

Neither the IEP of January 7, 2004, nor of January 20, 2004, corrected this deficiency. While the January 7, 2004 IEP was the first IEP to mention that the FAA required by the prior Decision would be completed, the IEP team failed to offer any specific transition services that would address Student=s unique behavioral needs.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offers of placement for Student in the November 12, 2003, January 7, 2004, and January 20, 2004 IEPs were not designed to meet Student’s unique behavioral needs necessary for participation in his educational program.

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit

The Hearing Officer finds that the District=s placement offers were not reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit. While many of the placement components offered by the District were appropriate, management of Student’s behavior was a recognized key to his successful participation in school. Student would not be able to benefit from any services unless he could successfully transition back to a school environment. The Hearing Officer has determined that support for Student’s unique behavioral needs was essential during his transition back to any school placement and that the District failed to offer services to meet his unique needs in this critical area. Accordingly, in the absence of these services, the Hearing Officer finds that the programs offered on November 12, 2003, January 1, 2004 and January 20, 2004, were not reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit.

4. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to provide home teaching?

At the February 19, 2003 IEP meeting, which produced the last agreed-upon IEP, the District agreed to provide Student with home teaching services pending completion of the triennial assessment. Hearing Officer Ganz ordered the District to provide Student with “home teaching by a credentialed teacher in accordance with” that IEP until the transition plan was completed and Student was returned to school. (Footnote 15) (Dist. Exh. 1, p. 22.)

Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to provide home teaching services as ordered by the Hearing Officer and as required by the last agreed-upon placement in the IEP of February 19, 2003. Specifically, Student’s Mother asserts that the home teachers offered were not trained in how to communicate with Student and that, consequently, appropriate home teaching was not offered. The District asserts that it repeatedly offered to provide Student with five hours of home teaching services as ordered and that it was ready, willing, and able to do so whenever Student’s Mother consented to these services, but that she repeatedly refused to allow the home teacher access to Student. The District provided evidence, principally through the testimony of Ms. Barhydt and Ms. Halpern O’Neal, of its repeated attempts to provide Student with home teaching in accordance with the Decision by offering four different credentialed teachers and the assistance of a sign language interpreter, and of Student’s Mother’ repeated refusal on all but a few occasions to allow the home teacher to meet with Student. On December 3, 2003, for example, Student’s Mother advised Ms. Barhydt that the home teacher had been given a laptop computer with a Co-Writer and Write Outloud program so she could use it with Student. Student’s Mother gave permission for the home teacher to come to the home when Ms. Hanson is there “to see if they can figure a way to use for home teaching.” On December 8, 2003, Ms. Barhydt informed Student’s Mother that the home teacher had observed Student with Ms. Hanson, and was ready to provide five hours a week of home teaching. Student’s Mother continued to reject home teaching services even after the assigned home teacher was trained to use the DynaWrite assistive device in February 2004.

The Hearing Officer finds Student’s argument unpersuasive. The April 23, 2003 Decision established that Student’s stay put placement pending his transition back to school was home teaching by a credentialed teacher as required by the February 19, 2003 IEP. The District offered to provide him with a credentialed special education teacher accompanied by a sign language interpreter. The purpose of stay put is to maintain the status quo during the pendency of a due process hearing. Stay put services, however, may or may not constitute what is necessary for a free appropriate public education. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny Student a FAPE by failing to provide stay put services that were offered but not accepted by the parent.

5/6. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to provide timely access to records and/or by interfering with parental participation at the IEP meetings?

The parents of a student with a disability must be provided with an opportunity to examine all records relating to their child. 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(b)(1). Under State law, parents have a right to examine and receive copies of all school records relating to their child within five days after a written or oral request. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56504. On November 19, 2003, CDE issued its compliance report in its case S-0205-03/04 which had been filed September 29, 2003, and concluded that the District was out of compliance with the requirement of Education Code Section 56504 that the parent be provided access to educational records within five calendar days. Specifically, CDE found that even though the District reported that it did not receive Student’s Mother’ August 26, 2003 request for Student’s records, it acknowledged her request in an open Board meeting on September 9, 2003, but did not make Student’s educational records available for review until October 31, 2003. The evidence at hearing established that Student’s Mother reviewed and was provided copies of Student’s academic file, including the testing protocols for the Vineland, MAT, and WJ-III instruments used for Student’s psychoeducational and academic assessments, on November 21, 2003. The Hearing Officer notes that, while District employees testified regarding the District’s efforts to respond to Student’s Mother’ record requests, the District did not produce evidence to challenge this noncompliance finding by CDE. A substantial delay in providing student records may infringe on a parent’s ability to participate in IEP meetings as discussed further below.

Student contends that the District denied Student’s Mother her parental right to attend and participate in IEP meetings on several grounds. First, on November 12, 2003, the District members of the IEP team proceeded with the IEP meeting after denying Student’s Mother’ request to reschedule the meeting. The evidence established that Student’s Mother requested copies of new assessment reports from Ms. Halpern O’Neal on November 10, 2003, and that Ms. Halpern O’Neal obtained all new reports except the November 6, 2003 psychoeducational assessment addendum report and offered them to the parent. The IEP notes indicate that Student’s Mother was asked if she wanted to continue the IEP meeting on November 10, 2003, but that she did not respond. At the November 12, 2003 IEP team meeting, Student’s Mother appeared, was provided all the new assessment reports, including the newly available psychoeducational assessment report, and requested a continuance of the meeting to review the reports. Student’s Mother also expressed concern that Student, Ms. Hanson, and Mr. Hardy were not able to attend the meeting. The request to continue the meeting was declined and District IEP team members proceeded with the IEP team meeting in Student’s Mother= absence. The IEP team notes indicated that, “at the request of the parent, the IEP [team] will reconvene to present the proposed goals/objectives, assessments and placement as was discussed at this meeting.” (Dist. Exh. 109, p. 8f of 10.)

The parents of a student with a disability must be provided with an opportunity to participate in meetings with respect to the identification, evaluation, educational placement decisions, and the provision of a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(b)(1), 34 C.F.R. ' 300.345; Cal. Educ. Code ' 56342.5. Parents are essential members of the IEP team and IEP team meetings may not be conducted in a parent’s absence unless the District has taken reasonable, and documented, steps to ensure his/her attendance at the meeting. 20 U.S.C. 1414 (d)(1)(B), 34 C.F.R. '' 300.344, 300.345(d); Cal. Educ. Code '' 56341(b), 56341.5(g).

There is nothing in the IDEA or State law specifically addressing a parent’s request for a continuance of an IEP meeting on the date of that meeting. However, as noted above, both State and federal law emphasize the importance of parental participation in IEP team meetings, particularly in educational placement decisions, and establish a high bar for districts to demonstrate their efforts to ensure parental participation. In addition, as noted in Student’s Mother’ testimony, Hearing Officer Ganz had ordered that the District provide her with a written copy of the assessment report(s) five days after their completion and prior to the IEP team meeting. Student’s Mother also testified that at the time of this IEP meeting she had requested, but had not yet received, an opportunity to review Student’s psychological file. Given the ongoing controversy over the assessment of Student’s cognitive potential, and the District’s undisputed failure to provide Student’s Mother with timely access to Student’s educational file as determined by CDE (Case S-0205-03/04), the Hearing Officer finds that the failure to continue this IEP team meeting until the parent had an opportunity to review the assessments and underlying files deprived Student’s Mother of an opportunity to participate in the educational placement decision for Student at the November 12, 2003 IEP. The Hearing Officer further finds that this violated California Education Code section 56342.5 that requires education agencies to ensure that the parent is a member of any group that makes educational placement decisions for a student with a disability.

It is well established that “procedural flaws will not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE.” W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist., 960 F.2d 1479, 1485 (9th Cir. 1992). Only “procedural inadequacies that result in a loss of educational opportunity, or seriously infringe the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process, clearly result in the denial of a FAPE.” Id. The evidence established that Student’s Mother was intensely involved in an ongoing IEP process that spanned an extended period of time, that she was provided with the November 12, 2003 draft IEP and an opportunity to request another IEP to discuss it, and that she desired to take no action regarding Student’s placement until the IEEs were completed. In electing to proceed with this IEP, the District was cognizant of the parties’ mutual desire to complete the District’s own assessment and review process so it could proceed with completion of the IEEs. (Test. Halpern O=Neal.) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Student failed to demonstrate any prejudice resulting from Student’s Mother’ lack of participation at this particular IEP meeting.

Second, Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE by bringing draft goals and placement recommendations to IEP team meetings. There is nothing to prohibit school staff from brings proposed recommendations to an IEP team meeting as long as it is clear that these are only recommendations for review and discussion with the parents. See 64 Fed. Reg. No. 48, App. A to 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Q. 32. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s practice of bringing draft documents and placement offers to IEP team meetings does not constitute a denial of a parent’s right to participate in the IEP process. Rather, given Student’s complex unique needs as described below, such preparation is highly desirable. In this case, the weight of the evidence, including a review of audio cassettes of IEP team meetings, establishes that Student’s Mother had ample opportunity to participate in all IEP team meetings, with the one exception addressed above, and that no member of the District’s IEP team believed that the documents brought to the IEP meetings were final or not subject to appropriate change and input by the parent. In fact, the District clearly identified its proposed recommendations as “drafts,” and numerous instances of handwritten additions from the IEP meetings are apparent. As a consequence, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no denial of FAPE by either the delay in providing access to Student’s records or by interfering with the parent’s right to participate in the IEP process.

* * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District did not deny Student a FAPE by failing to assess him in a timely manner because Student’s Mother interfered with its right to conduct an assessment using its own personnel and because the District was not responsible for the ultimate delay in completing the IEEs. From this finding, the Hearing Officer has determined that, in light of the information reasonably known to the District at the time, the goals it prepared for Student were appropriate. The Hearing Officer has also determined that the District did not deny Student a FAPE by failing to provide an appropriately trained home teacher or by failing to reschedule the November 12, 2003 IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer has determined that the District failed to address Student’s known unique behavioral needs in the offers of placement made from November 12, 2003 through January 20, 2004. As a consequence, the Hearing Officer now concludes that the District did not offer Student a FAPE for the period from November 12, 2003, through April 26, 2004. The parties’ relative conduct regarding home teaching will be addressed in considering compensatory education in Issue III, below.

II. Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the period from April 27, 2004 through April 26, 2005?

A. Procedural Appropriateness

1. Did the District make a sufficient written offer of placement?

As previously discussed, the District’s offer to Student for the annual period extending from April 27, 2004, through April 26, 2005, is contained in four separate documents: the April 26, 2004 IEP, the May 19, 2004 letter clarifying and supplementing that IEP, the June 7, 2004 IEP addendum, and the June 8, 2004 transition plan. Student contends that the District’s offer during this period was vague and confusing.

“The IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child.” Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S. Ct. 428 (1994); see also 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(b)(3). Pursuant to this obligation, a school district must make a formal written offer of placement to the parents of a student with a disability. Referring to the “great importance” the Supreme Court in Rowley placed on such procedural components of the IDEA, the Union court found that “this formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and ...should be enforced vigorously.” Id. The Court also emphasized that a school district cannot escape its obligation to make a written offer of placement based upon the parents’ unwillingness to accept it. The Union court identified three important purposes of a written offer. First, “the requirement of a formal, written offer creates a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later about when placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any.” Second, “a formal, specific offer from a school district will greatly assist parents in ‘presenting complaints with respect to any matter relating to the … educational placement of the child’ …by alerting [them] to the need to consider seriously whether [the particular school offered] was an appropriate placement under the IDEA” and whether they should oppose it or accept it with the supplement of additional educational services. Third, “by making a formal offer, the District would have been more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence to the hearing officer of the appropriateness” of the placement. Id. In Union, the Court left intact the hearing officer=s conclusion that she was unable to determine the appropriateness of the placement because the District had failed to set forth sufficient evidence about it.

After carefully reviewing the four documents provided to the parent, the specific components of the placement offers over time, and the testimony relating to their creation, the Hearing Officer finds that the April 26, 2004 IEP was a sufficiently coherent placement offer for the parent to consider whether to accept or reject the proposed offer. The Hearing Officer also finds that the subsequent documents either gave greater specificity to components of the educational program offered at the April 26, 2004 IEP or provided additional services to enhance the existing placement offer. In addition, the Hearing Officer notes that Student’s Mother testified that the clarification provided in May 19, 2004 letter was very helpful. Furthermore, unlike the situation where parents are offered distinct educational placements with significant program differences in ‘smorgasborg’ fashion, here, Student was offered a single educational placement, the details of which were further fleshed out. (compare, Glendale Unified School District v. Almasi, 122 F. Supp. 2d 1093, 1107 (N.D.Ca. 2000).) The District’s placement recommendation as offered on April 26, 2004, that was be implemented during the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year, the 2004 extended school year, and the 2004-2005 school year, remained essentially unchanged in its broad outlines throughout the subsequent letter, IEP addendum, and transition plan. Furthermore, as is apparent from the discussion regarding substantive appropriateness below, the offer was sufficiently detailed to allow Student’s Mother to present specific complaints about the appropriateness of the offered placement. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of placement, as contained principally in the April 26, 2004 IEP and as further elaborated in the May 19, 2004 letter, the June 7, 2004 addendum IEP, and the June 8, 2004 transition plan, does not violate Union’s mandate regarding prior written notice of placement offer.

B. Substantive Appropriateness

Is the District’s offered program designed to meet Student’s unique needs?

Student contends that the District’s offer for the period from April 27, 2004, through April 26, 2005, was not designed to meet his unique needs for a variety of reasons. Specifically, Student asserts that the District’s offer failed to include academic goals and objectives, that Blair High School is an under-performing school and is therefore not an appropriate placement for him, that the District failed to include appropriate modifications and accommodations including a sign language interpreter, that the placement offered was not designed to meet his unique needs, and that the District’s proposed a behavior support plan (BSP) did not incorporate all of the recommendations of the April 14, 2004 independent Comprehensive Functional Analysis (CFA) prepared by Dr. LaVigna of the Institute for Applied Behavior Analysis (IABA). Student further asserts that the District failed to have an independent behavior intervention case manager (BICM), an inclusion specialist, a sign language interpreter, and a paraprofessional hired and trained to work with him before he began to transition back to school, that it failed to develop an appropriate individualized transition plan (ITP) for him, and that it acted in bad faith by failing to provide agreed upon speech services by Ms. Hanson.

What are Student=s Unique Needs?

Student’s unique needs as set forth below were derived primarily from the testimony and assessment reports of Darlene Hanson, Dr. LaVigna, and Amy Rowell. The Hearing Officer gives significant weight to the testimony and reports of each of these individuals based upon their training, their professional experience, and their experience with Student. Ms. Hanson testified that she has worked as a speech pathologist for eighteen years primarily with individuals with severe communication impairments, that she has a California license as a speech pathologist and a national certificate of clinical competence. She also testified that for the past twelve to thirteen years, she has practiced “facilitated communication” as a strategy for communication, and that she is a recognized expert in this field. Ms. Hanson testified that she has given numerous presentations and workshops on this topic and is the only private practitioner of this strategy in southern California. Ms. Hanson has worked with Student approximately eight hours a month since October 2003. Dr. LaVigna testified that he is a licensed clinical psychologist and board certified behavior analyst who has been the clinical director of the Institute for Applied Behavior Analysis (IABA) since 1981. His publication and work history is detailed in his curriculum vita. (Joint Exhibit 3.) Ms. Rowell testified that she has a master=s degree in school psychology and has been a school psychologist for seven years. She testified that she has assessed over five hundred students, approximately two-thirds of whom are nonverbal and one-fifth of whom are autistic. As previously indicated, she spent twenty-five hours assessing Student.

To determine whether the District’s current offer is designed to meet his unique needs, the Hearing Officer must first determine what those needs are. Due to the parties’ historical dispute regarding Student’s cognitive abilities, many conflicts exist between Student’s Mother and District staff regarding Student’s unique needs, particularly in the areas of academics, communication, and behavior. It was clear from testimony at the hearing that, while many of these disputes were resolved by information and assessment data provided by Ms. Hanson, Dr. LaVigna, and Ms. Rowell, confusion about Student’s needs still exists. Given the complexity of Student’s unique needs, and the parties’ desire to clearly establish their current mutual understanding of those needs, Student’s undisputed unique needs and the areas of current dispute are discussed below.

a. Student’s Unique Needs Arising Out of Apraxia and Movement Disorder

It is undisputed that Student has a movement disturbance associated with his autism. Following receipt of Dr. LaVigna’s April 14, 2004 CFA report, the District for the first time included “associated movement disturbance” in its description of Student’s special education eligibility. In his CFA report, Dr. LaVigna defined movement disturbance as “a disruption in the regulation of movement which involves the loss of typical movements and excessive atypical movements which affects the person=s ability to initiate, switch, efficiently perform, or continue any action, including those involving communication, social interaction, or performing useful activities.” Adding to the complexity of this disturbance is the fact that each episode “may vary in its frequency, duration, intensity, and composition, given different contexts, emotions, and physical states. Further, the phenomenon of kinesia paradoxa, adds to the complexity of understanding movement disturbance in which the individual who typically experiences severe difficulties with the simplest of movements may suddenly perform complex and skilled movements and then return to the prior inactivity.” Dr. LaVigna reported that Student appears to have a significant movement disturbance, a condition that “is increasingly recognized for those facing the challenge of Autism.” (Dist. Exh. 170, italics original, p. 4, 12.)

The evidence clearly establishes that Student has apraxia and a movement disorder that impairs his ability to control his voluntary movements and impacts both his ability to communicate and his ability to demonstrate his knowledge. Ms. Hanson reported that Student’s apraxia affects both his speech and use of his hands. Student’s movement disturbance is also manifested in his unpredictable and frequently displayed motor responses such as repeatedly removing his shoes, suddenly getting up from his seat, and/or running out of the assigned area. As discussed below, Student’s specific unique needs arising out of his movement disorder are intertwined with his unique communication needs for assisted writing and typing with facilitated communication.

b. Student’s Unique Communication Needs

To understand Student’s unique needs in any area, it is necessary to understand the manner in which he communicates. As previously indicated, Student is a nonverbal student whose associated movement disorder impedes his ability to communicate in a variety of ways. As indicated in Darlene Hanson’s December 1, 2003 speech, language, and augmentative communication assessment, Student’s oral-motor structures are adequate for speech production, but he is not able to add the coordination of breath to his oral-motor movements. Consequently, while Student has chosen to work on speech production and does produce vocalizations, speech is not a functional mode of communication for him.

Student has four primary modes of communication: body language and gestures, sign language, assisted handwriting, and typewriting with facilitated communication. Of these, written language is his most expressive means of communication. As described in greater depth below, Student’s communication modes have made it very difficult for him to consistently demonstrate what he knows, particularly in on-demand testing situations. Dr. LaVigna reported that Student’s primary communication partners, his mother and Ms. Hanson, acknowledge that, “on any given day, at any given time, they must be vigilant in determining what communication mode is going to work with him at that particular time.” (Dist. Exh. 170, p. 5.) In addition, from her experience working with Student since October 2003, Ms. Hanson has concluded that Student’s ability to communicate varies depending on the support provided, and on the experience of his communication partners.

1. Body Language and Gestures: It is undisputed that Student communicates with body language and gestures. Student uses head nods of ‘yes’ and ‘no’ and also points to responses, for example, he will point at cards printed with yes/no or at cards printed with multiple choice options (a,b,c,d) for ease of communication.

2. Sign Language: Because Student is not hearing impaired, it is not necessary to use sign language to communicate with him; however, Student needs to work with people who can understand what he is trying to communicate with sign language. While it is undisputed that Student communicates with sign language, the parties have disputed, and confusion still exists, whether Student communicates fluently in American Sign Language (ASL) or whether he uses some more functional variation for expressing his wants and needs, referred to by the parties occasionally as “signing the Student way.” Due to the ongoing dispute about Student’s cognitive ability and the implication that, in signing his own way, he is developmentally delayed, this dispute was particularly concerning to the Student.

The evidence persuasively established that Student communicates with American Sign Language (ASL). Since early March 2000, Student has worked with communication aide and Regional Center ASL teacher Joseph Hardy, who testified that he is currently employed by Los Angeles Unified School District as a special education teacher in special day classes for autistic students, has a moderate to severely handicapped teaching credential, and teaches sign language to nonverbal students. Mr. Hardy has worked with Student for approximately twenty-five hours a month on the weekends when he takes Student into the community to promote Student’s spontaneous communication using ASL. Mr. Hardy testified that efforts between the District’s sign language interpreter and himself during the 2000-2001 school year to create and share lists of signs Student knew were abandoned after it became apparent that Student knew in excess of 150 signs. Mr. Hardy testified that Student is currently more descriptive in his use of ASL and that Student makes more of an effort to communicate using sign language when he knows that others can sign. Both Ms. Hanson and Mr. Hardy concurred that Student’s signs are recognizable variations of American Sign Language, although his manner of producing signs may appear to be a variation, like that of a dialect in spoken language. The Hearing Officer gives Ms. Hanson’s and Mr. Hardy’s testimony regarding Student’s use of ASL great weight, in light of their training, experience, and familiarity with Student. Their testimony, as well as that of Student’s Mother, established that Student uses sign language for social and functional communication rather than for academic work.

As a consequence of the above-described confusion, the parties disagreed about the level of sign language fluency required to work with Student (i.e., whether it is necessary for those who work with him to be fluent in ASL or whether it is sufficient for them to be trained to recognize the signs he uses). (Footnote 16) In her independent psycho-educational assessment and her testimony, independent school psychologist Amy Rowell recommended that “a great deal of anxiety and confusion may be eliminated or prevented if those who work and interact with Student most are fluent in sign language.” (Dist. Exh. 190, p. 11). The Hearing Officer finds that this recommendation, amply supported by the testimony of Mr. Hardy and Ms. Hanson, establishes that Student has a unique need to use ASL for communication and for his paraprofessional staff who work with him in social and functional communication to be fluent in ASL.

3. Assisted Handwriting: It is undisputed that Student communicates by handwriting that is assisted by the light touch of a finger or pen/pencil tip on the back of his hand. In her December 2003 assessment, Ms. Hanson reported that Student=s handwriting “is slow and often faint,” but that he could give single word responses with a ‘shadow,’ meaning the physical presence of a facilitator who provides verbal reminders to stay focused on task and to continue communication. For example, when asked “What is the word for difficulty in voluntary motor planning?” Student wrote ‘apraxia.’ Currently, Student can communicate by handwriting with the physical presence of a facilitator/shadow, as well as independently.

Until recently, District staff were concerned about whether Student’s assisted handwriting was an expression of his independent thoughts and desires, particularly in light of the perception that Student’s Mother was a strong influence on him. This concern and that related to facilitated communication in typing discussed below has since dissipated. For example, Ms. Rowell reported that either Ms. Hanson or Student’s Mother facilitated Student’s communication during her eight assessment sessions and that “at no time did either facilitator indicate correctness of his responses through verbal input, gesture, or body language.” (Dist. Exh. 190 p. 3.) Similarly, the Hearing Officer observed no prompting of Student’s handwritten communication during his testimony at the hearing. Student wrote single words and sentences in response to questions posed by his mother and the Hearing Officer, with the assistance of Student’s Mother’ pen lightly touching the back on his hand and her verbal encouragement to finish his responses. (See Hearing Officer Exhs. 1 - 9.) For example, when asked by the Hearing Officer what he needed to benefit from his education, Student wrote “communication, kindness, and an end to retaliation.” (Hearing Officer Exh. 9.)

4. Typewriting with Facilitated Communication: Student currently communicates through typing with the support of facilitated communication, generally provided by Ms. Hanson. Ms. Hanson testified that the physical support provided to Student is minimal and involves positioning the support person’s hand under his armpit, providing a light touch off and on of the elbow area, or lightly holding his sleeve above his elbow. Ms. Hanson testified that, unlike most individuals needing facilitated communication support she has worked with, Student principally requires the emotional support. As acknowledged by Ms. Hanson and confirmed by Dr. LaVigna, it is imperative to distinguish between true facilitated communication, when physical contact from the communication partner does not provide any information or indication as to what the content of the communication response should be, and prompted communication, when the physical contact (or other prompt) provided by the communication partner deliberately or unknowingly provides information or an indication as to what the content of the communication response should be.

Ms. Hanson testified that no one in the District has ever said she cannot use facilitated communication with Student. In the prior due process hearing and through late 2003, however, there was skepticism among some District staff regarding whether Student was communicating his own thoughts and desires independently, either in handwriting or typing, or whether his communication partner was prompting the content of his answers. For example, several of the District assessors commented that they could not make any determination regarding the independence of Student’s responses in view of either Student’s Mother’ presence and assistance or the use of Ms. Hanson as his facilitation communication partner. (Footnote 17) At the present time, there appears to be a consensus that Student is, in fact, expressing his own ideas and responses, but that it is important for everyone who participates as a facilitated communication partner with Student to be aware of the difference between facilitated and prompted communication. This caution is contained in Amy Rowell’s recommendation that District staff be provided training in and opportunities to practice facilitated communication strategies, and to “understand that ‘facilitation’ is not the same as motoring a student through or providing hand-over-hand assistance to complete a task. Rather, facilitation is providing emotional support and having the expectation that the student can demonstrate his knowledge given necessary accommodations.” (Dist. Exh. 190, p. 11.)

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student has a unique need to communicate in each of the four modes described above and a related unique need to have staff trained in understanding each of these modes of communication. Specifically, the Hearing Officer finds that Student has a unique need (1) to communicate using body language and gestures, American Sign Language, assisted handwriting, and facilitated communication for typing, (2) for paraprofessional staff who work with Student on social and functional communication to be fluent in ASL, and (3) for general and special education teachers and staff working with Student to be trained to understand Student’s need for assistance in handwriting and facilitation in typing.

c. Student’s Unique Behavioral Needs Arising From Anxiety

As discussed in the April 2003 Decision, it was undisputed that Student had unique behavioral needs that interfered with his ability to learn, and that he had “developed sophisticated behavioral mechanisms that stymied the District staff and Regional Center personnel.” Hearing Officer Ganz noted that the ambiguity about Student’s behavioral needs stemmed, in part, from the parties’ discrepant views of his abilities, i.e., with the parent asserting that Student was able to do the work but refused to and with District staff uncertain if Student’s lack of performance was due to his inability or his lack of interest. (Dist. Exh. 1, p. 15.)

Student has been diagnosed with a general anxiety disorder with panic attacks. In June 2003, Student was prescribed Zoloft for this disorder. As indicated in the testimony of Ms. Hanson, Ms. Rowell, Mr. Hardy, and Dr. LaVigna, Student’s anxiety is demonstrated in a variety of ways, including by showing worried facial expressions, by rapid heavy breathing, by frequent signing that he wants to eat, drink, or that his stomach hurts, by getting up from his chair, and by generally being in a constant state of motion. The evidence established that Student’s anxiety disorder has interfered with both his educational participation and his ability to exhibit educational progress.

Dr. LaVigna concluded that Student’s primary concerning behavior of “lack of participation and exhibited progress” (LPEP) is not manipulative and avoidant, but, instead, is based upon the extreme anxiety of “a terrified boy.” Dr. LaVigna identified certain events that increase the likelihood of Student’s anxiety-driven LPEP, including placement in special education settings, having infrequent opportunities for sensory input, or working with people with whom he has not established rapport, who have expectations of poor performance from him, or who are unsupportive authority figures. High triggers for LPEP occur when Student makes an incorrect response to a question he has been asked to answer, during transitions, unexpected or unexplained changes in schedule or agenda for a day, interruption of ritualized routine, or the use of punitive procedures (for example, time out or removal of sensory items).

Student’s anxiety is most acute in relation to his performance in a test or evaluation context. Ms. Rowell noted that there is “a huge emotional overlay to many of Student’s actions” and that having to perform under time constraints or demonstrating skills on demand is very difficult for him. (Dist. Exh. 190, p. 4.) This already heightened anxiety is compounded by Student’s concern that he will give an “automatic answer” due to his movement disorder that is not what he wants to communicate. As noted in the prior due process hearing, Student testified that “when he felt anxious, he sometimes laughed when he felt sad and said ‘yes’ when he meant ‘no.’” (Dist. Exh. 1, p. 15.) In the absence of an informed response to his anxiety, Student may give incorrect “automatic answers” rather than communicating what he knows or wants to say. For example, during his initial rapport building session with Ms. Rowell, Student typed “Please help...test good...Don’t take automatic answers.” (Dist. Exh. 190, p. 4.) Ms. Hanson also reported that “Student’s emotional regulation is a significant factor in his communication. At times he is calm and his communication is fluent. On other occasions, Student may be anxious. True anxiety does appear to affect his ability to motor plan and make decisions on what he wants to say and how he can say it...it is helpful to reorganize Student in his thinking, making questioning more direct and slowing down the pace of communication so that there are opportunities for clarification and verification of communication.” To address this issue, Ms. Hanson recommended adding a “no” in the middle of a multiple-choice “a, b, c, d” answer sheet in order to give Student a way to change his mind or to show that the initial answer was not correct.

From this, the Hearing Officer finds that Student has unique behavioral needs arising out of his anxiety disorder for strategies to respond to and address his anxiety in a manner that will increase his participation in his education and his ability to demonstrate progress, as well as for a general and special education staff who work with Student to be sufficiently trained to understand and implement such strategies.

d. Student’s Unique Academic Need for Age-Appropriate Learning Separated from Testing and Assessment of Performance

Student’s unique movement, communication, and behavioral/anxiety needs turn the traditional model of special education program development on its head. Due to Student=s extremely complex unique needs, the traditionally mandated requirement of assessment to determine present levels of performance prior to and as the basis for development of goals and objectives and educational placement cannot be followed without relegating Student to an educational program far below his cognitive potential. Student’s Mother has consistently argued that Student should be allowed to participate in age-appropriate learning without being required to demonstrate his learning. This has been a major dispute between the parties.

The link between Student’s development of a consistent mode of communication and his ability to demonstrate what he knows was widely acknowledged by witnesses familiar with him. In his testimony, Dr. LaVigna confirmed his reported opinion that Student has “not yet been provided or taught a reliable communication system that would allow an accurate or meaningful evaluation of the academic skills he has learned nor the cognitive skills he can perform. Accordingly, until this is accomplished, which should be the primary focus of his educational plan, it may be inefficient and nonproductive to pursue or carry out such evaluations. That is, his ‘present levels of performance,’ as determined by educational evaluations and assessment techniques most certainly do not reflect what he has learned academically and what he can do cognitively.” (Dist. Exh. 170, p. 6.)

The evidence is undisputed that Student cannot participate in standardized testing due to a myriad of factors, including his nonverbal status, his inability to respond without another person to provide assistance in writing or facilitation for typing his responses, the need to change test questions and response formats, and the need for extensive time to respond to due to his movement and anxiety issues, which are exacerbated in a testing situation. (Testimony of Ms. Mallon, Ms. Hanson, and Ms. Rowell.) When assessment instruments were administered to Student in a non-standardized manner but scores were based on the normative population for the standardized test, such as in Mr. Valdez’s psychoeducational assessment, Student’s abilities appear to be seriously delayed. Based upon such assessment interpretation in the past, Student has been placed predominantly in special day classes with a functional life skills curriculum.

By contrast, when Student’s abilities were explored in a non-standardized format over time, such as during Ms. Rowell’s eight assessment sessions over a twenty-five hour period, Student’s cognitive potential, learning style, and ability to benefit from traditional academic content can be more accurately understood. Ms. Rowell testified that to gain an understanding of Student’s academic potential and learning style, she administered to him eight subtests of the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children-Fourth Edition (WISC-IV) [picture concepts, vocabulary, matrix reasoning, comprehension, picture completion, information, similarities, and arithmetic], and three subtests of the nonverbal Leiter International Performance Scale-Revised (Leiter-R), a nonverbal measure of a person=s cognitive functioning [sequential order, repeated patterns, and form completion]. (Footnote 18) These subtests were administered using facilitated communication support provided either by Student’s Mother or Ms. Hanson, as well as verbal prompts (to finish or to look at what he was doing), and sometimes were extended over several sessions. From Student’s responses on four of the WISC-IV’s five verbal comprehension subtests, Ms. Rowell determined that Student demonstrated (1) strong auditory comprehension, a rich vocabulary (using words such as ‘contingent,’ ‘monopoly,’ and ‘dissemination’), and higher-level thinking, (2) a very strong knowledge base about object characteristics and relationships, as well as social mores and conventions, and adequate language processing skills (e.g., strong receptive language skills), (3) predominantly accurate responses to higher-end perceptual reasoning items that test the ability to perceive detail and relationships in and among visual stimuli and problem solve given visually presented novel or abstract information, and (4) accurate responses to mid-range items in Matrix Reasoning, with greater difficulty on higher-end items that were increasingly abstract.

Ms. Rowell testified that, in her opinion, all of Student’s abilities were in the average range, and that his difficulties with abstract items were a relative weakness. From Student’s responses to these tests and her observations, Ms. Rowell also determined that Student has very good math reasoning but that his movement issues negatively impact his response time, that he has strong short-term and long-term memory, and that he has “difficulty managing his emotional responses to his processing issues, which then interferes with his output.” As an example of his emotional response, Ms. Rowell reported that Student had difficulty answering the same type of questions on the Leiter-R that he did without problem on the WISC-IV. After struggling to complete the question, Student clearly wrote for her, “I hate nonverbal test because they remind me I can’t speak.”

The testimony of Ms. Rowell, Ms. Hanson, and Dr. LaVigna persuasively established that over the past year there has been a growing understanding and acknowledgment within the District that Student should be provided the opportunity to participate in an age-appropriate general education curriculum with accommodations, modifications, and adaptations. Given the tremendous emotional impact on Student from his experience in SDC/SH classes, it is crucial to emphasize that District staff testified that they do not believe that Student is mentally retarded and that they believe that his writings are reflections of his own thoughts, ideas, and opinions, and are not channeled by his assisted or facilitated communication partners. (Testimony of Ms. Mallon, Ms. Halpern O’Neal.)

Because there is a strong suggestion that Student understands much more than he is able to communicate, Dr. LaVigna concluded that in developing Student=s IEP, “it will be inherently counterproductive to combine into one basket, educational opportunities that attempt to simultaneously instruct, test and assess learning and performance... To limit his educational opportunities to the level of his ability to communicate is to inherently and inappropriately keep him from learning all he is capable of learning. Accordingly, these three aspects of his educational plan should be separated and each developed to the maximum degree possible, without being hindered by the others.”

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student has a unique academic need to be provided an age-appropriate general curriculum. The Hearing Officer further finds that Student has a unique academic need to be separately assessed to determine his need for remediation in specific academic areas, and to be provided the opportunity to earn high school credit for the classes in which he enrolls pursuant to guidelines and protocols developed by the IEP team.

e. Student’s Unique Social Emotional Needs

Unlike many autistic individuals, Student enjoys interacting with both adults and peers. Mr. Hardy testified that Student enjoys the attention he receives from two thirteen-year-old girls with whom he associates in the community and that he is beginning to demonstrate an expanded ability to describe his experience in the community using sign language. It was apparent from the testimony of Ms. Hanson and Ms. Rowell that Student is eager to communicate and initiate touch (by shaking or holding hands). Furthermore, as indicated in the testimony of Dr. LaVigna and Ms. Hanson, Student has a strong desire to express himself. From his assessment and observation of Student, Dr. LaVigna concluded that Student=s “desire to socialize with his peers, coupled with his profound impairment in his communication and social skills provides a cruel combination that should be addressed in his educational plan.” (Dist. Exh. 170, p. 9.)

The evidence also established that Student has a unique emotional need for support by trained individuals who respect him, who believe that he is an intellectually capable individual with emotional and movement issues, and who are genuinely interested in helping him to communicate. While these needs have been met largely through his facilitated communication work with Ms. Hanson, Student’s needs in this area will expand as he re-enters a school environment and works with a wider group of communication partners. In addition, from a review of Student’s communications through documentary evidence as well as his written testimony at the due process hearing, the Hearing Officer concludes that Student has unique emotional needs arising out of his intense anger and frustration at the District. In addition, it is of great concern that these intense emotions may be causing Student to withdraw from educational participation and performance, for example, by ‘boycotting’ the use of the DynaWrite for some time after the District asked Student’s Mother to sign forms regarding its use. (Testimony of Ms. Hanson.) (Footnote 19)

f. Student’s Unique Transition Needs for Trained Staff

As is apparent from the discussion of his complex needs, Student has unique needs relating to his transition back to a school environment. Specifically, the Hearing Officer finds that to be successfully transitioned back to full-time school enrollment, Student has a unique need for paraprofessional, resource, inclusion, and behavior support staff who are trained to understand his communication needs, his movement disorder, motor planning, and organization of behavior issues, with an emphasis on how autism and movement issues impact his functioning in academic and social situations. Student=s general education teachers also must have familiarity with his unique needs in these areas, to a degree sufficient to support his participation in general education curriculum. * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that Student has unique needs arising from his movement disorder, his nonverbal status and unique communication modes, his anxiety and related behavior issues of lack of educational participation and exhibited progress, his age appropriate cognitive ability and inability to demonstrate his knowledge through routine assessment and testing, and his unique social and emotional issues. These unique needs must be addressed in his educational placement. In addition, the Hearing Officer concludes that Student has a unique need for paraprofessional staff who work with him in social communication to be fluent in American Sign Language, and for paraprofessional, resource, inclusion, and behavior support staff who are trained to understand his unique movement, communication, behavioral-anxiety, academic, and social-emotional needs to successfully transition back to full-time school placement. Finally, the Hearing Officer notes that this itemization of Student’s unique needs does not include areas of need which the parties resolved via stipulation.

Designed to Meet Student=s Unique Needs?

As previously discussed, at the April 26, 2004 IEP, the District offered Student placement at its Blair High School in an inclusion program with a variety of related services and supports. The Student’s specific concerns about the appropriateness of distinct components of the placement offer are addressed below to determine whether the offer was designed to meet Student=s unique needs. As discussed more fully below, the Hearing Officer finds that the District=s annual program offer outlined in the April 26, 2004 IEP as clarified and supplemented is substantially designed to meet Student=s unique needs. In making this finding, the Hearing Officer is mindful of the enormous complexity of Student’s unique needs, the wide array of services and supports offered to him by the District, as well as the District’s substantial efforts to meet Student’s needs and to, at times, offer him more than required. This conclusion is supported by the record as a whole as well as by Dr. LaVigna’s opinion that, while in the past “there has been a lack of an appropriate IEP,” this “is not a reflection of the District’s performance of its responsibilities so much as it is a reflection of the complexities of Student’s needs” (Dist. Exh. 170, p. 23.) In light of this conclusion, the Hearing Officer will order the District to convene an IEP team meeting to specifically amend its placement offer in the particular areas outlined below.

2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to develop appropriate goals and objectives?

At the April 26, 2004 IEP, the District staff proposed new annual goals for reducing the occurrence and severity of Student’s lack of educational participation and exhibited progress as recommended by Dr. LaVigna, as well as goals in special program areas designed to help Student to demonstrate his knowledge in light of his intense anxiety. For example, goals were prepared in the areas of anxiety reduction (making an error and continuing to answer other questions), assertiveness (not changing his answer when he knows it is right), vocation and participation (tolerating interruptions in his schedule), and communication, anxiety, and test taking (learning to attempt answering hard questions and to continue on with subsequent questions, answering multiple choice questions within a timed setting), socialization with non-disabled peers, and spontaneous communication (introduce self to new people and ask their names). No academic goals were offered.

In her May 19, 2004 letter to Student’s Mother supplementing and clarifying the District’s offer at the April 26, 2004 IEP, Ms. Barhydt wrote that the District “determined that Student’s needs in certain areas (e.g., anxiety) must be addressed before Student is able to work toward achieving goals and objectives in other areas (e.g., academics),” and that as a result, the nonacademic goals in the April 26, 2004 IEP should be the focus of Student’s program during his gradual transition through the end of the extended school year. Ms. Barhydt further clarified that the IEP team would be reconvened four to six weeks after the start of the 2004-2005 school year “to review Student’s progress and to develop goals and objectives in the remaining areas of identified, assessed need to be addressed during the 2004-2005 school year.”

Student argues that the April 26, 2004 IEP is not designed to meet his unique needs because it failed to contain academic goals and objectives. The District asserts, and various District witnesses testified, that Student does not need academic goals because the IEEs concluded that he is capable of accessing age-appropriate general education curriculum. In its view, the District is required only to provide Student with appropriate accommodations and modification to progress in the general curriculum. Alternatively, the District asserts that the IEP team will meet as outlined by Ms. Barhydt’s May 19, 2004 letter to develop such goals as necessary.

The record as a whole establishes that Student has not been in a school-based placement for over twenty months and that, although his specific present levels of performance cannot be determined, he is capable of learning an age appropriate curriculum. Until Student actually attends these classes and is separately assessed as outlined in Dr. LaVigna’s support plan, however, there is no way to determine what relative strengths and weaknesses he has in particular academic subjects. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offered goals, in conjunction with its proposal for the IEP team to meet to develop further goals no later than six weeks after Student returns to school for the 2004-2005 school year, are substantially designed to meet Student’s unique academic needs.

3. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to offer him an appropriate school placement?

Since September 30, 2003, the District has consistently recommended that Student be placed at its Blair High School and Student has consistently rejected Blair as a placement site. (Footnote 20) Student challenges the appropriateness of Blair High School because he asserts that it is an under-performing school. The Hearing Officer finds no merit to this contention. In determining the appropriateness of the District’s school placement offer, the relevant inquiry is whether Blair is an appropriate school placement designed to meet Student’s particular unique needs. As discussed below, the Hearing Officer concludes that it is. (Footnote 21)

District witnesses consistently testified that Blair is an appropriate placement for Student because it is the smallest of the District’s high schools and because it has an inclusion program with staff who understand how to modify and adapt core curriculum for inclusion students. (Testimony of Mallon, Barhydt, O’Neal, Hendrix, Boccia.) District resource specialist teacher Henrietta Hendrix testified that, in her opinion, Blair is an appropriate placement for Student in which he can be included in the general curriculum and she provided details regarding how general and special education staff work together to serve an inclusion student. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Hendrix’s testimony to be persuasive in light of her many years of experience as a resource teacher at Blair. In addition, Ms. Hendrix’s testimony is entitled to weight given her frank disagreement with the District’s earlier position that Student should be on a non-diploma track without letter grades. Similarly, Blair’s principal Rich Boccia testified that Blair is a fully accredited high school that follows California curriculum content standards. Mr. Boccia also testified that, in addressing the needs of inclusion students, he carefully assigns students to general education teachers who have the interest and flexibility to make appropriate accommodations and modifications. The Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Boccia’s testimony is entitled to weight in light of his education and experience as a principal in the inclusion of many special education students at prior schools, as well as at Blair.

From this testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that Blair is an appropriate placement for Student in conjunction with the supports and services itemized in the IEP.

4. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to offer appropriate behaviorist services or to develop an appropriate behavior support plan?

1. Did the District Adopt the Recommendations of the LaVigna Report?

One of the primary bones of contention between the parties was whether the District adopted and offered to implement Dr. LaVigna’s detailed behavior support plan for Student as outlined in his April 14, 2004 Comprehensive Functional Analysis Assessment (CFA) at the April 26, 2004 IEP team meeting, or whether it intended to supplant the CFA with the four-page draft behavior support plan (BSP) prepared by its behaviorist, Dr. Bernhardt. Student’s Mother testified that after Dr. LaVigna presented his CFA report and plan at the April 26, 2004 IEP meeting and then left the meeting, Dr. Bernhardt presented the District’s abbreviated BSP. In her view, this meant that the District did not intend to adopt the CFA. The District contends that the April 26, 2004 IEP clearly demonstrates the District=s intention to offer and to implement the CFA in its entirety.

The April 26, 2004 IEP objectively demonstrates the District’s intent to implement Dr. LaVigna’s support plan and recommendations in its entirety. First, the Hearing Officer notes that the detail and complexity of Dr. LaVigna’s fifty page CFA, with its twenty-five page behavior support plan, is not amenable to compression in an IEP document. For that reason, throughout the April 26, 2004 IEP document, the District made specific references to the CFA report and to specific pages within this report that outlined Dr. LaVigna’s recommendations in a particular area. (See, for example, Dist. Exh. 174, BSP, pages three of ten and nine through twelve of twelve.) The Hearing Officer finds that the repeated references to the CFA report throughout the April 26, 2004 IEP evidenced the District’s intent to adopt all of its recommendations and support plan for Student. Second, Dr. Bernhardt testified that he did not intend his BSP to replace that by Dr. LaVigna. Although his testimony in this regard was in response to leading questions, an independent review of Dr. Bernhardt’s BSP reveals that it is an attempt to track the principal ideas of Dr. LaVigna’s plan onto what appears to be a short BSP template format. Third, the District included within the IEP Dr. LaVigna’s three-page “Comprehensive Functional Assessment and Support Plans at-a-Glance,” which specifically states in bold that it is not to be used independent of the CFA dated April 12, 2004. Fourth, while Dr. LaVigna testified that certain ambiguity existed in the manner in which the District sought to incorporate his recommendations, he also testified that he understood that the District’s intention at the April 26, 2004 IEP meeting was to adopt and to fully implement his report as written. The Hearing Officer further finds that the evidence outlined above gave Student’s Mother an objective indication that the District intended to fully adopt and to implement the CFA.

To avoid future confusion and controversy, however, the Hearing Officer will order the District to convene an IEP team meeting during which it shall explicitly incorporate the CFA report and support plan as Student=s behavior support plan and to remove its draft behavior support plan dated April 25, 2004.

2. Dr. LaVigna’s Behavior Support Plan and Behavior Services Are Substantially Designed to Meet Student=s Unique Needs

In addition to adopting Dr. LaVigna’s BSP at the April 26, 2004 IEP meeting, the District offered Student behaviorist consultation and supervision services of six hours per month by the District behaviorist/school psychologist who would be Student’s behavior intervention case manager (BICM) and specified that the BICM would implement and supervise the implementation of the BSP. In her May 19, 2004 clarifying letter, Ms. Barhydt advised Student’s Mother that Dr. Bernhardt would be Student’s BICM. Dr. LaVigna testified that Dr. Bernhardt had worked with IABA in the past, and that he was well qualified and would be an appropriate BICM to implement the support plan. He also noted however that, due to the parent’s strong opposition to Dr. Bernhardt, an outside consultant might be required. From Dr. LaVigna’s testimony and the testimony and resume of Dr. Bernhardt, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Bernhardt is qualified to act as Student’s BICM, and that the District’s offer of his services as BICM was appropriate. The District’s subsequent agreement to hire an independent BICM from IABA was an appropriate response to the history of parental distrust discussed in Dr. LaVigna’s report and further evidence of its desire to implement the support plan.

In her May 19, 2004 clarifying letter, Ms. Barhydt also advised Student’s Mother that, in addition to the behavior consultation and supervision services outlined in the IEP, the District would contract with Dr. LaVigna for “behavior intervention technical support and expert guidance” services for eight hours for the first month and two hours per month until the end of the fall 2004 semester, with services to include consultation regarding training the IEP team to implement Student=s BSP, implementing and supervising the implementation of the BSP, and modifying the BSP as necessary. At the hearing, Dr. LaVigna testified that to implement his recommended support plan for Student, he would require sixteen hours for the first month, twelve hours for the second month, eight hours for the third month, and four hours a month for the remainder of the school year, with a parallel amount of time for the assigned BICM. After hearing Dr. LaVigna’s testimony, Ms. Barhydt stipulated that the District was willing to provide these hour amounts for Dr. LaVigna.

By agreeing to implement Dr. LaVigna’s behavior support plan (the CFA), the District offered Student an ambitious and comprehensive plan that the Hearing Officer finds is designed to meet his unique academic, communication, behavioral-anxiety, and social emotional needs. The focus of the CFA was to reduce the existence and severity of Student’s lack of participation and exhibited performance (LPEP) in his education and to create conditions in which Student could return to school and earn high school credits before the end of the 2004-2005 school year that would count toward his achievement of a high school diploma. To achieve this goal, Dr. LaVigna recommended a complex structure for Student’s IEP that addressed many of his unique needs. For example, the plan was designed to meet Student’s unique academic needs by recommending that Student participate in age appropriate mainstream curriculum where he would (1) learn passively, separate from any expectation to demonstrate his learning, (2) participate in a separate assessment activity for each class to determine his rate of learning and his need for tutorial assistance, if any, and (3) participate in “adapted end of class testing” to determine whether he has mastered the course material at a sufficient level to earn credit toward his high school diploma. The plan also recommended a series of “positive programs” designed to meet Student’s unique communication, behavioral-anxiety and social-emotional needs, as well as his academic need to learn to demonstrate his knowledge via participation in social skills training with typical peers, and programs to increase independence and reducing the need for facilitation when communicating. Other “focused support strategies” were designed to meet Student’s unique communication, academic, behavior-anxiety, and social emotional needs by use of a variety of protocols for building rapport and interaction between Student and school staff. The plan also recommended a series of detailed provisions for monitoring the implementation of the CFA that the Hearing Officer finds are designed to meet Student’s unique needs in the same areas outlined above as well as his unique staff training and transition needs.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement offer outlined in the April 26, 2004 IEP, viewed in conjunction with the incorporated LaVigna report and support plan, is substantially designed to meet Student’s unique needs relating to movement disorder, anxiety, behavior, academics, and transition, and are partially designed to meet Student’s unique communication and social emotional needs, with the limited exceptions addressed below.

First, the Hearing Officer finds that, for Student to receive a FAPE, proper implementation of the behavior support plan outlined by Dr. LaVigna is essential. To ensure proper implementation, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. LaVigna’s testimony about the amount of hours required for the BICM’s services to implement the support plan is entitled to great weight. Consequently, the Hearing Officer orders the District to amend the total hours of services to be provided for the assigned BICM to conform with his testimony as follows: sixteen hours for the first month, twelve hours for the second month, eight hours for the third month, and four hours a month for the remainder of the school year. As previously indicated, the District stipulated that it would provide these hour amounts for Dr. LaVigna. In addition, Dr. LaVigna’s support plan mandated initially weekly and then monthly “periodic service reviews” (PSRs) to review, score, and graph the implementation of the support plan to achieve an eighty-five percent implementation rate. The District specifically incorporated this portion of the CFA report in one portion of the IEP; however; in another portion, it inconsistently offered quarterly PSRs. The Hearing Officer therefore orders the District to amend its offer to clearly provide for monthly PSRs to ensure that implementation review occurs on a regular and timely basis. Because the District has offered to convene monthly IEP meetings, the IEP team can review the status of implementation of the BSP with information provided by the monthly PSRs and recommend modifications, as necessary.

Second, Ms. Hanson testified that there is an inconsistency between Student’s unique need for facilitation in written communication and Dr. LaVigna’s description of LPEP and its episodic severity scale. Specifically, Dr. LaVigna’s applied behavior analysis scheme envisions ‘physically prompted participation’ as a more severe expression of LPEP by Student than ‘verbally prompted participation (staff within three feet).’ While the ultimate goal of facilitated communication for Student is to fade physical support, Student currently has a unique need for such contact and physical support and this need may continue throughout the school year. Ms. Hanson testified that at the April 26, 2004 IEP, she recommended that the IEP team develop a protocol for distinguishing between an LPEP that requires actual physical prompting and educational participation by Student with facilitated communication support. Dr. LaVigna testified that IABA does not rely solely on applied behavior analysis theory but rather incorporates other theories and strategies necessary for the student, such as facilitated communication. From their testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that there is no essential dispute on this point; however, to avoid any possible confusion, the Hearing Officer orders the District to convene an IEP team meeting to develop such a protocol.

Third, the June 7, 2004 IEP meeting was convened specifically to review the psychoeducational and academic IEE by Ms. Rowell. By the time of that meeting, Ms. Rowell’s conclusions and recommendations regarding Student’s cognitive abilities were not new but rather reinforced those of Ms. Hanson and Dr. LaVigna, who had interviewed Ms. Rowell for his assessment. (Footnote 22) At that meeting, the District specifically incorporated Ms. Rowell’s recommendations into its offer for Student. However, due to the dispute regarding Student’s need for and use of ASL, the Hearing Officer will order the District to specifically clarify that Student’s paraprofessionals who work with him on social communication are fluent in ASL. The Hearing Officer further finds that this amendment to the IEP is necessary to meet Student’s unique behavior, social-emotional, and communication needs.

5. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to offer him appropriate accommodations and modifications?

As noted in the notice of proposed rulemaking to IDEA regulations, “public agencies often require all children, including children with disabilities, to demonstrate mastery in a given area of the general curriculum before allowing them to progress to the next level or grade in that area. Thus, in order to ensure that each child with a disability can effectively demonstrate competencies in an applicable area of the general curriculum, it is important for the IEP team to consider the accommodations and modifications that the child needs to assist him or her in demonstrating progress in that area.” 64 Fed. Reg. No. 48 at p. 12472 (March 12, 1999).

Student’s Mother argued that the District failed to consider Student’s input in the accommodations and modifications they offered him in April 2004 by ignoring specific requests Student made in an accommodations sheet which he had completed and provided to the IEP team in November 2003. The Hearing Officer finds no merit to this contention. The record indicates that the District was responsive to these requests. For example, on this accommodation sheet, Student requested two paraprofessional aides. At the April 26, 2004 IEP meeting, the District specifically offered Student two paraprofessional aides: a full time one-to-one shadow aide for six hours a day (to enable him to meaningfully participate and progress in the general curriculum, to assist him in working toward achievement of his goals and objectives, and to facilitate and mediate social interactions with peers) and a second one-to-one aide for two hours a day five days a week (to assist with homework assignments at school). Testimony at hearing established that one of Student’s aides, Christina, is deaf and knows sign language. It was not clear from the evidence presented whether the signing aide is Student’s full time aide; however, as previously discussed, the District must ensure that the paraprofessional staff who work with Student are fluent in ASL, particularly for social and functional communication.

6. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to offer appropriate inclusion services?

In the April 26, 2004 IEP, the District offered Student ten hours a week of inclusion specialist consultation services at Blair by a credentialed special education teacher. Pursuant to this offer, the inclusion specialist would supervise Student’s one-to-one paraprofessionals, act as Student’s case manager and service coordinator, identify and recommend accommodations, modifications, and adaptations to the general curriculum to allow him to meaningfully participate and progress in that curriculum, and train Student’s IEP team to implement these services. Prior to this offer, at the IEP of January 20, 2004, District IEP team members had identified Blair’s RSP teacher Ms. Hendrix as Student’s inclusion specialist and also had offered Ms. Hanson’s services to facilitate inclusion at various IEP meetings. In her May 19, 2004 clarifying letter, Ms. Barhydt advised Student’s Mother that the District had “contacted NPA Inclusion Education & Community Partnerships (run by noted inclusion expert Rick Clemens)” to provide some of the inclusion specialist services specified in the IEP, which would be a combination of direct, consultation, or supervisory services. Ms. Barhydt testified that Student’s Mother rejected the services of this NPA for unknown reasons. (Footnote 23)

Student contends that the inclusion services offered are inappropriate because the District failed to specify how the inclusion services would be divided between direct, consultative, and supervisory services and failed to have a specific inclusion specialist hired and trained to work with Student.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of ten hours a week of combined direct, consultative, and supervisory services is designed to meet Student’s unique needs to access the general curriculum, particularly in light of his extended absence from school and the extremely complex support plan that is to be implemented across school environments. The inclusion specialist will work with a wide array of individuals including general and special education teachers, instructional aides, and IEP team members. Under these circumstances, it is reasonable to allow flexibility in the allocation of weekly hours to maximize the effectiveness of Student’s needed inclusion support. In addition, given the totality of the services offered to Student, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered Student a sufficient amount of inclusion services. In fact, Ms. Hanson testified that ten hours a week seemed to be more than was necessary.

The Hearing Officer further finds that the failure to identify a specific inclusion specialist in the offer did not render the offer inappropriate to meet Student’s unique needs. First, the Hearing Officer finds that Student was well aware from previous IEP meetings that Ms. Hendrix was the inclusion specialist at Blair. Student neither asserted nor produced evidence to indicate that Ms. Hendrix was not qualified to act in this capacity. Second, the evidence established that, in an effort to accommodate Student’s Mother, the District was attempting to locate and hire a nonpublic agency to provide inclusions services. After Student’s Mother rejected the District’s offer to have Mr. Clemons’ NPA participate in the provision of inclusion services to Student, the District continued to seek an independent inclusion specialist. In her July 8, 2004 letter to Student’s Mother, for example, Ms. Barhydt indicated that the District had names of two recommended inclusion specialists that she was pursuing. (Dist. Exh. 201.) The exact status of the District’s effort to locate an independent inclusion specialist is unknown. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that the essential requirement for an inclusion specialist is that he or she is trained adequately to understand Student’s unique needs as outlined above to perform the necessary functions of that critical position. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is not required to identify a particular individual as inclusion specialist and that the offer of inclusion services is not rendered inappropriate because it did not identify a particular individual as the inclusion specialist.

7. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to offer him an appropriate transition plan?

Student raises three challenges to the District’s transition plan. First, he asserts that the transition plan is not adequate unless the inclusion specialist, the BICM, and all service providers are hired, trained, and ready to work with him before he returns to school. Second, he asserts that the transition plan offered in the April 26, 2004 IEP and clarified in the May 19, 2004, letter was inappropriate because the District wanted him to audit classes instead of working towards credit. Third, he asserts that the transition plan fails to provide specific criteria for determining when he will be “ready” to attend school full time.

First, the Hearing Officer finds that, although the transition plan does not explicitly state that all offered support services would be staffed and ready, this is implicit in the offer as a whole. In particular, the April 26, 2004 IEP includes a detailed offer regarding the qualifications, training, and knowledge of the personnel or contractors to be provided, including Student’s two paraprofessional aides. This offer was enhanced by the District in its May 19, 2004 clarifying letter. (See: Dist. Exhs. 174, at p. 10 of 12, and 185.) The Hearing Officer agrees with Student that the transition plan must be capable of being implemented by staff or contract personnel who are trained in Student’s unique needs to be appropriate. The District does not dispute this, but argues that Student’s Mother’ ongoing refusal to consent to the IEP has resulted in delay in its ability to implement the offer as well as the loss of available and qualified staff, like Ms. Hanson. In addition, the District notes that Student’s Mother has refused to accept qualified District and independent professionals. For example, at the April 26, 2004 IEP, Ms. Hendrix was available as inclusion specialist, and Dr. Bernhardt was available and well qualified to act as Student’s BICM. As previously discussed, these individuals are qualified to work with Student. Thus, the IEP and its transition plan could have been implemented immediately following the April 26, 2004 IEP team meeting had Student’s Mother consented to it.

Second, Student argued that the District’s decision not to offer Student an opportunity to earn credit during the initial months of his transition period (from April 2004 through the end of the 2004 ESY) denied him a FAPE. The Hearing Officer construes this as an assertion that this portion of the offer was not designed to meet his unique academic or emotional needs. Although Student’s concerns in light of his total educational history and experience are understandable, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer did not fail to meet his unique needs on this basis. First, the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. LaVigna’s report recommended “trifurcation” of Student’s learning, assessment, and testing, and emphasized the need for Student’s educational input (learning) to be provided “through passively listening to lecture presentations, reading of text material, or other input modes, e.g., computers or multi-media presentations, segregated from any expectation or requirement that he actively participate by answering questions or in other ways actively indicate that he is taking in the information that is being presented.” While Dr. LaVigna’s testimony also emphasized the importance that Student immediately be given an opportunity to earn high school credit, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s initial determination that Student should audit courses during a brief transition period was objectively reasonable in light of his twenty-month absence from school and his complex behavioral needs arising from his anxiety. Second, the Hearing Officer finds that, in deference to Student’s desires, the District amended its transition plan offer at the June 7, 2004 IEP meeting. Specifically, the IEP addendum notes provide that the District “offers and recommends an incremental transition back to school based upon Ms. Rowell and Dr. LaVigna’s reports. During this transition to full-time school, required coursework will be provided during this period so he can earn credits.” Thus, Student’s articulated concern was addressed appropriately by the District.

Third, the June 8, 2004 transition plan for the 2004-2005 school year provided that Student would enroll initially in tenth grade at Blair in just two of his four core academic courses and that, at the end of the second week, Student, Student’s Mother, and Student’s support team would meet and review his “readiness” to attend all classes. Student’s Mother expressed concern about the lack of criteria for determining Student’s “readiness” for full-time school participation. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Bernhardt’s testimony persuasive that the “readiness” provision in this transition plan was to be interpreted in light of Dr. LaVigna’s specific LPEP severity criteria. For example, if Student were participating without severity indicators above the middle range of severity, then he would be ready to transition to all of his academic classes. By contrast, if he were at severity level of nine or higher, Student’s ability to participate effectively in his education would be questioned and reviewed before having him take additional general education classes. (Footnote 24) While this interpretation is reasonable, the Hearing Officer is very mindful of Student’s history of removal from general education classes due to his behavior problems arising from his unique needs. As a consequence, the Hearing Officer finds that this component of the transition plan must be amended to ensure that Student is not excluded from full participation in education at his cognitive level. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer orders the District to convene an IEP team meeting to amend its transition plan to specifically identify appropriate readiness criteria and to specify that any such criteria not be automatically used to keep Student from full participation in his general education classes.

8. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to offer him an appropriate individualized transition plan (ITP)?

State and federal law require that, beginning at age fourteen, or younger if determined by the IEP team, the IEP contain a “statement of the transition service needs of the child...that focuses on the child’s courses of study (such as participation in advanced-placement courses or a vocational education program).” 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(1)(A)(vii)(I), (II); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56345.1(a), (b). Beginning at age sixteen, or younger if determined by the IEP team, the IEP must contain a “statement of needed transition services for the child, including, when appropriate, a statement of the interagency responsibilities or any needed linkages.” Id. California law and federal implementing regulations provide a detailed definition of transition services as, in part, “a coordinated set of activities” in an outcome oriented process that “promotes movement from school to post-school activities, including postsecondary education, vocational training, integrated employment, included supported employment, continuing and adult education, adult services, independent living, or community participation.” Cal. Educ. Code ' 56345.1(c); 34 C.F.R. ' 300.29. Transition services must be “based on the individual student’s needs, taking into account the student’s preferences and interests” and may include instruction, related services, community experiences, the development of employment and other post-school adult living objectives, and, if appropriate, acquisition of daily living skills and functional vocational evaluation. Id.

Student asserts that the District’s proposed individualized transition plan (ITP) was not designed to meet his unique ITP needs, essentially because it did not have sufficient information about his interests and desires. The April 26, 2004 IEP contains a draft ITP that indicates only that Student “needs to investigate post-education options” and that other areas need “to be explored.” The IEP team notes indicate that Student’s Mother refused to review the draft ITP. In her May 19, 2004 letter, Ms. Barhydt advised Student’s Mother that Student’s ITP was based upon information about Student obtained from Student’s Mother.

The record establishes that Student has been out of school since shortly before his fourteenth birthday and that he will not turn sixteen until December 2004. Thus, at the April 26, 2004 IEP team meeting, the District was required to prepare a statement of Student’s transition service needs with a focus on his courses of study, but was not required to include a statement of interagency responsibilities or linkages. The Hearing Officer notes that while the draft ITP is minimal, the CFA support plan is premised on a long-range goal of enabling Student to earn a high school or advanced degree and to live independently in his own home as an adult, with minimum support, and with gainful employment. As previously discussed, the support plan specifically focuses on a course of study appropriate to Student’s cognitive level, while attempting to develop his skills necessary to communicate and to demonstrate his learning and thus earn a high school diploma. (See Dist. Exh. 170 p. 27.) In addition, by the April 26, 2004 IEP, the District had placed Student on a diploma track specifically to support his goal regarding his course of study. In adopting Dr. LaVigna’s recommended support plan as part of its offer to Student, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has complied partially with the requirement for ITP development. To prepare the type of comprehensive ITP required by Student’s sixteenth birthday, however, the District must work directly with Student after his return to school to discuss his specific needs and desires. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer orders the District to complete the development of Student=s ITP, including a statement of interagency responsibilities or linkages, within a reasonable time after his return to school and by no later than this sixteenth birthday.

* * * In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that, with the changes ordered, the District=s offer for the annual period from April 26, 2004, through April 26, 2005, was substantially designed to meet Student’s unique needs that were at issue in this hearing.

Is the District’s offered program reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit?

As discussed above, the placement offered to Student by the District for the period from April 26, 2004, through April 26, 2005, is substantially designed to meet his complex unique needs. With the amendments ordered as described above, the Hearing Officer finds that the offered program is also reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit by placing him in an appropriate school environment with age-appropriate curriculum, appropriately trained and qualified support staff to implement his inclusion in general education, his behavior support plan, and his accommodations and modifications.

Do the services offered comport with Student’s IEP?

9. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing in bad faith to implement its agreement to have Ms. Hanson provide speech services?

The only portion of the District’s offer accepted by Student was for speech services. As previously discussed, Student disputed this offer only because it failed to identify Ms. Hanson as the provider of speech services. Student withdrew his issue relating to speech and language services at the outset of the hearing, after the District stipulated that Ms. Hanson would provide all required speech services. Thereafter, Student requested to have the issue reinstated due to the District’s alleged bad faith in failing to implement agreed upon services, after Ms. Hanson quit, then reconsidered but decided to stop providing direct services and to focus on training personnel to understand Student’s communication needs. The District did not take a position on this request, but disputed that it acted in bad faith. Because the change in Ms. Hanson’s availability was unknown to Student at the time he withdrew the speech and language issue, the Hearing Officer will consider it for the limited purpose of addressing implementation of speech services.

The Hearing Officer finds that there is no persuasive evidence that the District acted in bad faith by stipulating that speech services would be provided by Ms. Hanson to induce Student to withdraw a viable issue for hearing. To the contrary, the testimony of Ms. Hanson and Ms. Barhydt persuasively established that the District increased Ms. Hanson’s hours to enable her to spend more time on Student’s case. Ms. Hanson’s testimony about her decision to quit working with Student, when viewed in light of the extremely caustic tone of Student’s Mother’ criticisms of Ms. Hanson’s professional judgment, clearly establish that this was a personal decision that did not involve District decision makers. In addition, the evidence established that Ms. Barhydt promptly took measures to ensure continuity in services for Student and that her efforts led to Ms. Hanson’s agreement to continue providing training services for Student=s staff.

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Hanson’s decision and interrupted services to Student are not attributable to the District and do not mandate a conclusion either that the District acted in bad faith or that this constituted a denial of a FAPE.

* * * In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer for the period from April 27, 2004 through April 26, 2005, is a legally sufficient offer that is substantially designed to meet Student’s unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. The Hearing Officer concludes that any failure to comport with offered speech services was not in the District’s control. With the amendments ordered below, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District has offered Student a FAPE for this time period.

III. If the District Denied Student a FAPE from April 26, 2003 to the Present, Is He Entitled to Compensatory Education Services?

The Hearing Officer has concluded that the District failed to address Student’s known unique behavioral needs in the offers of placement made from November 12, 2003, through January 20, 2004, and that Student could not participate in his education unless these needs were addressed. Consequently, the Hearing Officer has concluded that the District did not offer Student a FAPE for the period from November 12, 2003, through April 26, 2004.

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also U.S.C. ' 1415(i) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District , 916 F. 2d 865 (3rd Cir. 1990); Miener v. State of Missouri, 800 F.2d 749 (8th Cir. 1986).) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1497 (9th Cir.1994).

In determining appropriate compensatory services, the Hearing Officer considers the specific educational loss occasioned to Student by the denial of FAPE, and the relative conduct of the parties, including services that were offered or provided to Student by the District during the period from November 12, 2003 through April 26, 2004. (Footnote 25) The record establishes that, with the exception of two hours a week of speech and facilitated communication services from Ms. Hanson, Student received no educational services from November 12, 2003, until he returned to school in July 2004. Because the Hearing Officer has determined that the District offered Student a FAPE at the April 26, 2004 IEP meeting, however, the District is only responsible for a period of five months of lost educational opportunity. The Hearing Officer finds that Student is entitled to compensatory education services for this period.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District has consistently offered Student home teaching services by a credentialed education teacher as required by the stay put order, and that it did so during the time FAPE was denied. The evidence also established that while the District was required only to provide Student a credentialed teacher for home teaching, the District consistently offered him home teaching services by a credentialed special education teacher with the assistance of sign language interpreters. While Student asserts that the home teacher needed additional training to provide instructional services to him, this was not required by the order. In addition, the record persuasively established that Student’s Mother was not genuinely interested in obtaining home teaching services for Student. Rather, she focused on the completion of the IEEs and Ms. Hanson’s speech services, and advised the District on one occasion that home teaching may interfere with these services. (Dist. Ex. 73, page 8f of 10.) Even in December 2003, after the assigned home teacher, Roxanna Wilson, had received some training from Ms. Hanson and a software program she could use with Student, Student’s Mother did not allow her to provide Student with instruction. Student’s Mother’ refusal to allow home instruction persisted even after Ms. Wilson was trained in February 2004 on the DynaWrite, a device with which she could unquestionably communicate with Student. As a consequence, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s Mother’ actions hindered the District from providing any academic instruction to Student at home during the period of the denial of FAPE.

The Hearing Officer also finds that during the relevant time period, Student received educational benefit in the area of communication via speech and language services provided to him by Ms. Hanson, as well as by receiving and being training in the use of the DynaWrite assistive technology device by the District in January 2004.

Student has requested various forms of compensatory education services to remedy this denial of FAPE. Student’s Mother requested that the Hearing Officer order an independent IEP team meeting facilitator/notetaker to ensure parental participation at IEP team meetings. The Hearing Officer has determined that the District denied Student’s Mother the right to participate in the development of the November 12, 2003 IEP, but that it did not interfere with her right to participate in the IEP process in the other five IEP team meetings convened during this time period. In addition, to ensure parental participation during the 2004-2005 school year, the District has offered to convene monthly IEP team meetings. While the District may elect to hire an independent IEP team facilitator to build trust with Student’s Mother and Student, the Hearing Officer finds that there is an insufficient connection between this request and the denial of FAPE Student experienced to order this as a compensatory service.

Student has requested that the District be ordered to contract with nonpublic agencies (NPAs) to provide an independent inclusion specialist and an independent behavior intervention case manager (BICM) to implement all of Dr. LaVigna’s CFA recommendations. The basis offered for this requested remedy is Student’s distrust of the District emanating from its previous denials of FAPE as outlined in SN02-02461, including its failure to implement Student’s BSP across school settings. The Hearing Officer notes that the BICM who failed to implement Student’s plan in SN02-02461 was Ms. Mallon, not Dr. Bernhardt, who the Hearing Officer has determined to be a qualified BICM. Because this request is premised on generalized distrust and there was no evidence to support this particular remedy or to establish its connection to the denial of FAPE experienced, the Hearing Officer finds that there is basis to order the District to hire NPAs to provide inclusion and BICM services as a compensatory remedy. As discussed above, the District may well elect to hire such independent service providers to build trust with Student’s Mother and Student, but it is not required to do so.

Student has requested that he be provided with twice-weekly social skills instruction with a nonpublic agency adolescent group experienced in working with social skills for autistic adolescents. In light of Student’s lengthy absence from a school environment, and his desire to communicate and socialize with peers as acknowledged by Mr. Hardy, Dr. LaVigna, and Ms. Hanson, the Hearing Officer finds this request to be reasonably related to the denial of FAPE experienced. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will order that the District provide such instruction, either directly or by funding such instruction at a certified nonpublic agency. Due to the anticipated infusion of educational and other compensatory services Student will be involved in during the 2004-2005 school year, however, the Hearing Officer will order the District to provide him with a set number of hours rather than order twice-weekly social skills instruction. These hours can then be used at a time of Student’s choosing. In light of the record as a whole, the Hearing Officer finds that thirty hours is a reasonable amount of compensatory social services.

Student has requested an unspecified amount of compensatory academic tutoring. Because Student could not participate in his education unless his behavioral needs were addressed, the Hearing Officer finds this request is reasonably related to the denial of FAPE experienced. Student’s Mother requested that this tutoring be in the form of computer and augmentative communication assisted instruction by a non-public agency (NPA) to assist in adapting his assignments and homework. The Hearing Officer notes that the District has separately agreed to fund an assistive technology (AT) and augmentative communication assessment by Cindy Cottier of NPA Augmentative Communication Therapies “in order to ascertain Student’s AT needs for accessing a computer due to his movement disorder.” (Joint Exh. 2). While it may be reasonable to involve Ms. Collier in compensatory academic tutoring in light of her history of assessing Student and developing AT strategies for him, the Hearing Officer does not have sufficient information to order the District to do so. However, the Hearing Officer finds that an award of compensatory academic tutoring in the amount of thirty hours is reasonable in light of the denial of FAPE and relative conduct of the parties and that the tutoring shall be provided by a credentialed teacher who is trained and familiar with Student’s unique needs as outlined in the Personnel section of the April 26, 2004 IEP. (Dist. Exh. 174, page ten of twelve.) In its discretion, the IEP team may decide whether Ms. Cottier’s participation in the provision of these compensatory services is appropriate. (Footnotes 26)

ORDER

1. Within twenty-five (25) calendar days from the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to conform Student’s IEP to this Decision in the following respects, to the extent that it has not done so already:

a. Revise Student’s draft behavior support plan in the April 26, 2004 IEP to explicitly incorporate the support plan outlined in Dr. LaVigna’s CFA report dated April 12, 2004, at pages twenty-seven through fifty (27 – 50), and to delete Dr. Bernhardt’s draft behavior support plan.

b. Amend its offer to provide for monthly periodic service reviews of the implementation of the CFA behavior support plan.

c. Amend the frequency and duration of offered time for Student’s BICM to sixteen hours for the first month, twelve hours for the second month, eight hours for the third month, and four hours a month thereafter until April 26, 2005.

d. Develop a protocol for distinguishing between Student’s lack of participation and exhibited progress (LPEP) that requires physical prompting and Student’s educational participation that requires facilitated communication and/or assisted writing.

e. Amend its offer to clarify that paraprofessionals who work with Student in social and functional communication must be fluent in American Sign Language.

f. Amend its transition plan to specifically identify appropriate “readiness” criteria for Student’s full-time participation in academic work at his cognitive level.

2. No later than six (6) weeks after Student enrolls at Blair High School for the 2004-2005 school year, the IEP team shall meet to (a) determine whether Student requires academic goals and to prepare academic goals and objectives, if necessary, based upon information and observation since his enrollment, and (b) complete the development of his individualized transition plan.

3. Student is entitled to the following compensatory education services for the denial of FAPE from November 12, 2003, through April 26, 2004. Unless otherwise specified, the compensatory services shall be completed within three years of the date of this Decision:

a. Thirty (30) hours of compensatory social skills instruction to be provided by a District employee or by a certified nonpublic agency experienced in working on social skills for adolescents with autism.

b. Thirty (30) hours of compensatory academic tutoring by a credentialed teacher who is trained and familiar with Student’s unique needs as outlined in the Personnel section of the April 26, 2004 IEP. (Dist. Exh. 174, page ten of twelve.)

4. Student’s remaining requests are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing Decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

The Student prevailed in part on Issues I and III.

The District prevailed on Issue II and prevailed in part on Issues I and III.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).

Dated: October 12, 2004 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

On May 27, 2004, the parties discussed potential settlement outside the presence of a different hearing officer. At that time, at the request of the parties, the matter was continued to June 10, 2004. At the reconvened hearing on June 10 and 11, 2004, the Hearing Officer and the parties discussed the issues for hearing and potential settlement. The parties also met off the record and outside the presence of the Hearing Officer on June 15 and 17, 2004, in an attempt to settle the matter. On June 17, 2004, a continuance was granted to afford Student’s Mother an opportunity to review the proposed settlement agreement with her advisors.

2The Hearing Officer received and reviewed audio cassette tapes from Student (Stud. Ex. 56) and the District (Dist. Ex.210) for the following IEP team meetings: May 15, 2003, June 12, 2003, September 30, 2003, January 7 and 20, 2004, April 26, 2004, and June 7, 2004.

3 In Compliance Case No. S-0792-02/03, CDE determined that the District was out of compliance because the June 12, 2003 IEP reflected that the assessments required to be completed pursuant to the Decision by May 28, 2003 were not complete and because home instruction was not implemented as required by the May 15, 2003 IEP and the Decision.

4Following this ruling, the District requested and was granted leave to brief this issue; however, it did not do so nor did it request reconsideration of the Hearing Officer’s ruling denying its motion.

5The issues for hearing have been reorganized for clarity of analysis, to eliminate compliance issues as discussed above, and to eliminate issues and proposed resolutions resolved by the parties= stipulations.

6Dr. LaVigna defined Student’s LPEP in descending order of severity as follows: physical absence from school, not being in the assigned school area, inappropriate physical actions directed toward others (spitting at, scratching, kicking, grabbing, or pulling them or getting within their personal space, such as moving his face to less than one and a half feet away); engaging in off-task behavior (out of seat, removing shoes); not doing what he is asked to do; physically prompted participation; verbally prompted participation (staff within three feet); and independent participation but without demonstrating indicators of progress established by his IEP team.

7 Other requirements, such as that the placement be in the least restrictive environment, are not at issue.

8After the parties entered into written stipulations eliminating APE, OT, AT, and vision therapy issues, Student’s Mother testified that she was challenging unspecified findings in these assessments. The Hearing Officer finds that Student expressly waived his right to challenge the APE, OT, AT, and vision assessments because, in each stipulation, the parties acknowledged their understanding and agreement that they resolved “any and all issues” concerning APE/OT, vision therapy, and/or AT raised in the consolidated matter and agreed not to call specified witnesses to testify at the hearing on these matters. In addition, to the extent Student’s Mother was attempting to appeal the District’s December 19, 2003 denial of her challenge to the content of Student’s educational records because they contained findings or conclusions with which she disagreed, the Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction over such challenges. Rather, under federal and State law, a separate hearing procedure exists for amending a student’s educational records. See 34 C.F.R. ' 300.570; Cal. Educ. Code ' 49070.

9The Hearing Officer also finds Student’s Mother’ testimony and her correspondence describing illegal and/or unprofessional assessment techniques by District assessors to be entitled to very little weight in light of her failure to produce any videotapes at the hearing. The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s Mother’ testimony that the videotapes were Student’s personal property that she could not independently release to be unpersuasive in light of his status as a minor. In addition, from a review of the audio cassette tape of the May 15, 2003 IEP team meeting, the Hearing Officer finds no merit to the parent’s assertion that Ms. Halpern O’Neal stated she did not intend to implement the assessment as ordered in the Decision.

10Mr. Valdez testified that he has had twenty-three years of experience as a school psychologist, that he had assessed thousands of students, including approximately one hundred autistic students, and that he had assessed students who were particularly difficult to assess due to a variety of factors, including one nonverbal student who communicated in writing. Mr. Valdez also testified that he had worked for over three years at the Central Valley Diagnostic Center assessing students who presented unique assessment difficulties.

11 The Hearing Officer notes that Student’s Mother’ conduct was not the only reason the District was unable to conduct a comprehensive assessment of Student in May and June 2003. During the May and June 2003 assessments, no consistent method or strategy for encouraging or facilitating Student’s communication had been developed. Although Student used sign language, his primary mode of communication fluctuated according to his setting, the task required, and the person trying to communicate with him. (Dist. Exh. 37, p. 6c of 7.) Student’s Mother testified that she was constantly in the role of both ‘the help and the hated’ because she was frequently asked by District staff to help them communicate with Student, and was then vilified for doing so.

12These Comments note that it is essential that the temporary placement not become the final placement before the IEP is finalized. To ensure this does not happen, it is recommend that the “State might consider requiring LEAs to take the following actions: (a) develop an interim IEP for the child that sets out the specific conditions and timelines for the trial placement …, (b) ensure that the parents agree to the interim placement before it is carried out, and that they are involved throughout the process of developing, reviewing and revising, the child=s IEP, (c) set a specific timeline (e.g., 30 days) for completing the evaluation, finalizing the IEP, and determining the appropriate placement for the child, and (d) conduct an IEP meeting at the end of the trial period in order to finalize the child’s IEP.” Id.

13Student’s Mother agreed to speech goals proposed by Ms. Hanson at the January 7, 2004 IEP team meeting and the appropriateness of these goals is not disputed.

14 Because Student did not accept these offers, it is not necessary to address whether the services provided comported with those offered in the IEP.

15The Decision incorrectly identified the IEP as dated February 29, 2003; however, there was no dispute that the correct date of the IEP referenced in Order 1(b) was February 19, 2003.

16At the January 7, 2004 IEP meeting, for example, District members of the IEP team asked Mr. Hardy how long it would take him to train someone to understand Student’ sign language. Mr. Hardy reported to the IEP team, as he testified at hearing, that in his opinion Student needs a person to work with him who already knows ASL. This confusion continued to manifest itself at the June 7, 2004 IEP meeting. For example, the IEP team notes inconsistently provide that knowledge of “basic signs at a minimum” is necessary to work with Student, but then state that a person “fluent” or “reasonably fluent” in sign is needed. (Dist. Exh. 192, p.3b.)

17The Hearing Officer also notes that, in the audiotape of the June 12, 2003 IEP team meeting, a female voice laughingly says, “We will call you Ouija,” in obvious reference to the Ouija Board, a device “used to seek spiritualistic or telepathic messages.”

18Student is a student of African American and Filipino descent. Ms. Rowell reported that because the WISC-IV is an intelligence test whose use for determining cognitive limitations or IQ is prohibited for students of African American descent, she used the test results only to determine Student’s learning style, strengths, and weaknesses. The Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Rowell did not report any standardized scores for these tests.

19During his testimony, Student expressed dismay at what he perceived to be Ms. Barhydt’s speaking to him as if he were deaf (“reasoning that autistic individuals are deaf she talks loudly”) and wrote that the District and its attorneys “say horrible things about my mom and supporters.” (Hearing Officer Exhs. 1,2,3).

20The IEP notes from the January 7, 2004 IEP reported that Student’s Mother was willing to sign in agreement for placement at Blair; however, Student’s Mother testified that she never consented to placement at Blair and she never signed this IEP.

21In support of his contention, Student submitted a hearsay document, Student Ex. 36, which purports to be an audit of district and school leadership. (See: Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 5, ' 3082(b).) Mr. Boccia’s testimony established that this report is outdated.

22A review of the audiocassette from the April 26, 2004 IEP team meeting indicates Student’s Mother’ acknowledgment that Ms. Rowell’s IEE would not provide essential new information.

23In the parties’ June 16, 2004, compensatory services agreement settling CDE compliance case S-0792-02/03 (Stud. Exh. 59), the parties agreed that District special education teacher William Garnett would perform duties during Student’s ESY program that, although not described as such, are similar to those performed by an inclusion specialist. During his testimony, the parties stipulated that Mr. Garnett was recommended by a noted inclusion specialist. In addition, Mr. Garnett testified that he is currently working toward his master’s degree in inclusion practice.

24Episodic severity level (ESL) nine is indicated by “grabbing, spitting at, pulling or otherwise touching another person in any way that has not been invited,” ESL ten is “hitting, biting, kicking or otherwise physically aggressing against another in such a way that harm or injury could occur,”and ESLs eleven and twelve are respectively either not being in or leaving the assigned school area, or lack of physical presence at school. While Student’s Mother and Mr. Hardy testified that these more severe level behaviors were based on a few instances in the 2001-2002 school year and have not been recently demonstrated, Student has not been in a school environment, with the educational demands that may trigger various behaviors, since October 2002.

25 The Hearing Officer notes that Student has been awarded compensatory services from the prior Decision, by CDE settlement, and by stipulation between the parties, but that none of these awards are for the period that he was denied a FAPE. See:Dist. Exh. 1, p. 24, Order 9, Joint Exhs. 1-2, Stud. Exh. 59.

26Student’s Mother also requested a full-time, trained shadow aide for Student and appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and placement for the 2004 extended school year and for the 2004-2005 school year. In light of the conclusion reached in Issue II, this request is denied.