California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 28, 2001
Jurupa Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 682-00 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke
Jurupa Unified offered FAPE for 1999-2000 but must repay half of 2000-2001 nonpublic school costs.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Jurupa Unified School District filed for due process to show that it had offered a nine-year-old boy a FAPE for 1999-2000 and 2000-2001. The student first qualified under speech or language impairment. A June 2001 IEP added specific learning disability and other health impairment. His parents rejected a communicatively handicapped special day class at Ina Arbuckle Elementary and enrolled him at Summit View School, a nonpublic school, in January 2000.
The Hearing Officer found the 1999 offer appropriate. The student's behavior was not a "serious behavior problem," so the district did not have to do a Hughes Bill functional analysis assessment. Nancy Cadiente, an experienced speech-language specialist, taught the class with two aides and used multisensory methods. A behavior specialist would also consult with her. The Hearing Officer held that this class met the student's needs and upheld the district's findings that he did not need occupational therapy or vision therapy.
For 2000-2001, the district still had to make an offer because the parents had shown interest in a public placement. It made none until June 5, 2001, 12 days before school ended. Its 2001 extended school year (ESY) program at Stone Avenue Elementary was appropriate. Summit View met the student's needs. However, the parents had refused to attend an IEP meeting without first learning the placement. For that reason, the Hearing Officer cut reimbursement for 2000-2001 tuition, including speech-language services, and transportation by half. The Hearing Officer denied the claims for Dr. Robert Patterson's private assessment and for compensatory education.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated a district's duty to keep offering FAPE after a parent places a child in a private school. The district had to make an annual offer once the parents showed interest in a public placement. The parents' refusal to attend IEP meetings then led the Hearing Officer to cut reimbursement in half.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, including the 2000 extended school year (ESY)?
The SDC-CH at Ina Arbuckle with behavior-specialist consultation, ESY and transportation offered FAPE; behavior was not a 'serious behavior problem' requiring a Hughes Bill FAA, and OT and vision therapy were not required.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. If the District failed to provide FAPE for 1999-2000, including ESY, are the parents entitled to reimbursement for Summit View from January 2000 through the end of that school year?
Not addressed because the District offered FAPE for 1999-2000; District listed as prevailing party.
- Student prevailed in partIEP procedure
Issue 3. Did the District make a FAPE available to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 ESY?
No annual IEP was required in February 2000, and the 2001 ESY offer was appropriate, but the District denied FAPE by making no offer for the 2000-2001 regular year until June 5, 2001, despite the parents' shown interest in public placement.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. If the District failed to make FAPE available for 2000-2001, including the 2001 ESY, are the parents entitled to reimbursement for Summit View during 2000-2001, including ESY and transportation costs?
Summit View was appropriate, but because the parents refused to attend an IEP meeting, reimbursement for 2000-2001 regular-year tuition (including speech-language) and transportation was cut by half; no 2001 ESY reimbursement.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 5. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent evaluation and site visit performed by Dr. Robert Patterson in August and September 1999?
The parents did not disagree with the District's psychoeducational assessment, which was appropriate in any case, so no reimbursement was owed.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the areas of occupational therapy, vision therapy, and reading remediation?
OT and vision therapy were not needed, and the student was appropriately educated at Summit View in 2000-2001, so no compensatory education was owed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof of payment, District shall reimburse parents for one-half of proven Summit View tuition (including speech and language services, excluding counseling) and one-half of transportation costs for the 2000-2001 regular school year.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; W.G. v. Target Range School District; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School District; Alamo Heights v. State Board of Education; S.V. v. Sherwood School District
People named in the decision
- Tamara Elzig (formerly Tamara Concannon), principal, Sunnyslope Elementary School, Jurupa USD
- Lana Clauder, program specialist / school psychologist (psychoeducational assessor), Jurupa USD
- Brooke Martinez, speech and language specialist, Jurupa USD
- Sherrill Fergusun, resource specialist program teacher, Jurupa USD
- Lori Brown, second grade teacher, Sunnyslope Elementary School
- Carol Hogerty, second grade teacher, Sunnyslope Elementary School
- Ms. Beese, first grade teacher, Sunnyslope Elementary School
- Nancy Cadiente, SDC-CH teacher, Ina Arbuckle Elementary School, Jurupa USD
- Kathleen McLean, speech and language pathologist, witness for District, Anaheim Union High School District
- Terry Tibbetts, administrator of education and support services, Jurupa USD
- Laurie Lewis, occupational therapist (District OT assessor), nonpublic agency, Private practice
- Carl Goodman, director, Summit View School
- Anne Studer, special education teacher, Summit View School
- Ronald Fischbach, independent behaviorist, expert witness for Student, Steps to Independence Through Education
- Jerry Lindquist, licensed clinical psychologist and occupational therapist, expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Robert Patterson, independent psychologist, expert witness for Student, Private practice
- William Bescoby, optometrist (vision therapy assessor requested by District)
- Benjamin Kohn, optometrist (private developmental vision exams)
- Julie Kuto, occupational therapist (private evaluation), Loma Linda University Medical Center
- John DeMor, adaptive physical education assessor, Jurupa USD
- Mrs. Simpson, special day class teacher (fourth through sixth grade), Jurupa USD (offered Camino Real placement)
- Summit View School, nonpublic school (unilateral placement)
- Prentice School, nonpublic school (trial attendance)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Riverside, California, on September 19 and 20, 2000, November 30, 2000, December 1, 2000, January 24, 25 and 26, 2001, April 26 and 27, 2001, May 17, 18, and 31, 2001, June 1, 2001, September 13 and 14, 2001, and October 4, 2001.(Footnote 2)
Petitioner Jurupa Unified School District (hereafter, Petitioner or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Jonathan Read of the law firm Lozano Smith. Also present on behalf of the District was Terry Tibbetts, administrator of education and support services for the District. Respondent STUDENT (hereafter, Respondent or STUDENT) was represented at different times by attorneys Shelli Lewis, Thomas Beltran, Patrick Smith, and Margaret Oppel. Also present on behalf of the Respondent was his mother, MOTHER.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Tamara Elzig(Footnote 3), principal of Sunnyslope Elementary School (Sunnyslope); Lana Clauder, program specialist for the District; Brooke Martinez, speech and language specialist for the District; Sherrill Fergusun, resource specialist program teacher for the District; Lori Brown, second grade teacher at Sunnyslope; Nancy Cadiente, communicatively handicapped special day class (SDC-CH) teacher at Ina Arbuckle Elementary School; Kathleen McLean, speech and language pathologist for the Anaheim Union High School District; Terry Tibbetts, administrator of education and support services for the District; Laurie Lewis, occupational therapist in private practice; and Carl Goodman, director of Summit View School (Summit View).
The following witnesses were called by Respondent: Anne Studer, special education teacher at Summit View; Carol Hogerty, second-grade teacher at Sunnyslope; Ronald Fischbach, independent behaviorist in private practice; Jerry Lindquist, licensed clinical psychologist in private practice; Robert Patterson, independent psychologist in private practice; and MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. Closing arguments were received from both parties and the record was closed.
ISSUES
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year, including the 2000 extended school year (ESY)?
2. If the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, including the ESY, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for STUDENT’s placement at Summit View from January 2000 through the end of that school year?
3. Did the District make a FAPE available to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 ESY?
4. If the District failed to make a FAPE available to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 ESY, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for STUDENT’s placement at Summit View during the 2000-2001 school year, including the extended school year and transportation costs?
5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent evaluation and site visit performed by Dr. Robert Patterson in August and September 1999 respectively?
6. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the areas of occupational therapy, vision therapy, and reading remediation?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a nine-year-old student who initially qualified for special education services as a child with a speech and language impairment. He is currently attending Summit View School, a nonpublic school. In December 1998, during STUDENT’s first-grade year, STUDENT was first referred to determine eligibility for a special education program due to concerns regarding his developmental levels, academic program, and his speech and language. The District conducted a psychoeducational evaluation and a speech and language evaluation of STUDENT, and on February 1, 1999, STUDENT’s first individualized education program (IEP) with the District was developed, which found STUDENT eligible as a student with a speech or language impairment. The speech and language assessment yielded concerns in the areas of vocabulary, semantics, grammar/syntax, pragmatic skills, and articulation. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT was a multisensory learner who needed to be taught accordingly. At the time of his first IEP, STUDENT had no word recognition, demonstrated poor fine motor skills, and had difficulty writing his name within provided parameters. STUDENT also had difficulty with addition of 1-digit numbers and had no concept of subtraction. His behavior was noted as disruptive because he frequently wanted to talk to his teacher, Ms. Beese.
The IEP document provided for STUDENT’s continued placement in his regular education first-grade classroom at Sunnyslope Elementary School (Sunnyslope) with designated instruction and services (DIS) of speech and language and resource specialist program support.
On March 25, 1999, a second IEP team meeting was held as a result of STUDENT’s bringing a knife to school. A manifestation determination was completed and the IEP team determined that STUDENT’s disability impaired his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his behavior and his ability to control his behavior. The IEP team recommended that behavior interventions be developed and scheduled an IEP review for June 2, 1999, at 8:00 a.m. The IEP team developed and implemented behavioral reinforcement/intervention procedures.(Footnote 4)
Another IEP team meeting was held on May 24, 1999, as result of STUDENT’s being suspended for willful defiance of authority and causing physical injury to another person. During that meeting, STUDENT’s previous behavioral reinforcement/intervention procedures were reviewed and modified to address his most recent misbehavior. The IEP team also discussed the possibility of changing STUDENT’s placement to a special day class (SDC) for students with severe language disorders located at Ina Arbuckle School (Ina Arbuckle or Ina). STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, was not initially present at the May 24, 1999 IEP team meeting. However, during the meeting, Sunnyslope principal Tamara Elzig contacted MOTHER by telephone and MOTHER immediately came to the school site. According to MOTHER, she had not received prior notice about the time and place of the IEP meeting. The IEP team therefore reconvened later that same day with MOTHER present, at which time STUDENT’s goals were reviewed for progress at the first benchmark. It was determined that he had made progress and that his goals were still appropriate. The IEP team discussed with MOTHER the reasons for considering a change of placement. MOTHER believed that the SDC at Ina Arbuckle would not be successful for STUDENT. MOTHER was invited to visit the program at Ina to assist with her decision. The IEP team also asked MOTHER whether she had considered medication for STUDENT regarding his attentional issues. MOTHER told the IEP team that she had considered medication, but was reluctant to pursue it. MOTHER refused to sign the IEP in agreement to the behavior plan modifications and requested a copy of the IEP for review before giving her signature.
STUDENT’s parents never signed the May 24, 1999 IEP, and they later arranged for him to be independently assessed by independent psychologist Dr. Robert Patterson. On August 18, 1999, Dr. Patterson performed his psychoeducational study of STUDENT and prepared a written report with recommendations. Dr. Patterson concluded that STUDENT met the requirements of the California Code of Regulations (CCR), Title 5, Section 3030(j), as a child with a specific learning disability, and met the criteria of CCR, Title 5, Section 3030(f), under the category of “other health impairment” because he had limited alertness due to his attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) that was, according to Dr. Patterson, significantly impacting his ability to perform within the classroom. According to MOTHER, during his second-grade year, when he was supposed to be going to his “pull-out” DIS classes, STUDENT would leave his regular classroom and wander throughout the school. School personnel often had trouble locating STUDENT and often had to use the school’s speaker system to locate him. The school principal mentioned to MOTHER that she was concerned for STUDENT’s safety during the times when he would go from his regular class to pull-out services.
On September 16, 1999, another IEP meeting was held, at which time the IEP team reviewed Dr. Patterson’s August 18, 1999 assessment and information provided by STUDENT’s parent and school personnel. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in a communicatively handicapped special day class (SDC-CH) located at Ina Arbuckle Elementary School. The District agreed to provide STUDENT with assessments in adaptive physical education (APE), occupational therapy (OT), and vision therapy (VT), and to provide the SDC-CH teacher with consultation by a behavior specialist at a minimum of two hours per month. Goals and objectives from the February 1999 IEP were to remain the same. MOTHER declined to sign the IEP until she had visited the SDC at Ina. The IEP team agreed to reconvene on October 19, 1999, after MOTHER had had an opportunity to visit the offered SDC at Ina, at which time the IEP team would make a placement decision.
After the September 16, 1999 IEP meeting, MOTHER sought information about other private schools and agencies that might be appropriate for STUDENT. MOTHER investigated the Frostig Center, Landmark School, Prentice School, 2 different programs at Summit View School, and a 12-week program at the Lindamood Bell Learning Processes Center that she wanted STUDENT to attend in conjunction with the District’s program.
MOTHER, along with psychologist Robert Patterson, visited the SDC-CH at Ina; however, for various reasons, MOTHER did not believe the class would be an appropriate placement for STUDENT. According to MOTHER, the SDC’s teacher-student ratio was too high, and she believed the excessive noise and activity in the class would distract STUDENT.
On October 19, 1999, another IEP meeting was held to review the OT report and to determine a placement for STUDENT. According to the IEP notes, the IEP team believed that STUDENT’s language deficits warranted placement in a program that focused specifically on students with language disorders. The District offered STUDENT placement in the SDC-CH class at Ina, where he would have a structured environment, ongoing opportunities for interaction with regular education peers, and an increased focus on social skills, all of which the District felt were important for STUDENT. Behavior specialist services were also offered for the teacher on an as-needed basis to work with any behavior issues that might arise, and to provide assistance to the teacher in structuring social skills activities. STUDENT would have been mainstreamed for art, music, lunch, assemblies, and other school-wide activities. Extended school year services and curb-to-curb transportation were also offered to STUDENT. The IEP team agreed to reconvene in 30 days to review STUDENT’s program and determine if any additional program modifications needed to be made.
MOTHER informed the October 19, 1999 IEP team that she wanted STUDENT to attend Prentice School (Prentice), a nonpublic school, and asked that STUDENT be placed there, with a review by the IEP team in 30 to 60 days. However, the District members of the IEP team believed that the SDC-CH program at Ina would be more appropriate for STUDENT at that time and that it was the least restrictive environment. MOTHER did not consent to the October 19, 1999 IEP, and in her dissent statement, she contended that the District did not consider placing STUDENT at Prentice and did not consider Dr. Patterson’s findings. MOTHER requested that goals and objectives be developed based on Dr. Patterson’s findings. MOTHER also notified the District that she intended to place STUDENT at Prentice and requested funding and transportation services from the District. MOTHER also requested reimbursement for the costs associated with Dr. Patterson’s reports.
On November 23, 1999, Tamara Elzig, the principal at Sunnyslope, called MOTHER to inquire about STUDENT’s three-week absence from school. MOTHER indicated that STUDENT was tested at the Prentice School (Prentice) and later attended the school on a trial basis for one and one-half weeks. However, the program at Prentice was not right for STUDENT and MOTHER had removed him from the school. Then, according to MOTHER, STUDENT became sick with a cold and was out of school for an additional five days. MOTHER indicated to Ms. Elzig that she would be sending STUDENT back to Sunnyslope. (Pet.’s Exh. 37.) STUDENT returned to Sunnyslope; however, his parents ultimately disenrolled him from Sunnyslope after the 1999 Christmas holiday.
By letter dated December 22, 1999, the District’s counsel informed Respondent’s counsel that in response to Dr. Patterson’s recommendations, the District had provided the Ina SDC-CH teacher with the Lindamood Bell program training, which would include follow-up supervision and support. The District also indicated that it had provided the Ina classroom with the Earobics program as a supplement to the class language program. (Pet.’s Exh. 35.) Notwithstanding these additions to the offered program, in December 1999, STUDENT was enrolled at Summit View, and on January 6, 2000, he started attending classes there. STUDENT continued attending Summit View for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school and resumed studies there for third grade during the 2000-2001 school year.
In January 2000, Shelli Lewis, Respondent’s former attorney, forwarded a letter to the District’s counsel confirming that she had received the correspondence regarding the further training of District staff. The letter also stated that pursuant to the October 1999 dissent to the IEP, STUDENT had been placed in a private nonpublic school and that his parents would be seeking reimbursement for costs. (Pet.’s Exh. 34.)
By letter of March 21, 2000 to STUDENT’s parents, Mr. Tibbetts asked STUDENT’s parents to notify him if they wished to pursue vision therapy as a related service so that an IEP meeting could be scheduled. Mr. Tibbetts also indicated that he had been informed by STUDENT’s school principal that STUDENT’s parents had unilaterally removed him from school and placed him in a nonpublic school setting. (Pet.’s Exh. 33.)
On April 20, 2000, the Hearing Office received the District’s request for a due process hearing. In its request for hearing, the District indicated that it wanted a hearing to resolve issues regarding the offer and provision of a FAPE for the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years. The District also requested a determination as to whether Respondent was entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a nonpublic school placement after his unilateral removal from the District. On the first day of hearing, Respondent identified the remedies he was seeking, which included reimbursement for the independent educational evaluation and site visit performed in August and September 1999 by Dr. Robert Patterson, and compensatory education in OT, vision therapy, and reading remediation.(Footnote 5)
On June 5, 2000, the parties participated in a mediation session; however, no resolution was reached.
On June 21, 2000, the parties agreed to continue the scheduled June 27 and 28, 2000 hearing dates to September 19 and 20, 2000. On June 5, 2001, STUDENT’s IEP review meeting was held, at which time STUDENT was identified as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability, speech or language impairment, and other health impairment. The District recommended that STUDENT be placed in a special day class at Camino Real Elementary School with DIS in speech and language and counseling, and mainstreaming for art, music, lunch, recess, and passing periods. The District also offered ESY services and curb-to-curb transportation. MOTHER understood that the purpose of this meeting was to decide on a fourth-grade program for the 2001-2002 school year. However, the District offered STUDENT immediate placement for the end of the 2000-2001 school year. STUDENT finished out the 2000-2001 regular school year at Summit View.
STUDENT did attend the District’s offered ESY program, which was implemented at the Stone Avenue Elementary School for the 2001 ESY (July 2 - August 7, 2001). However, according to MOTHER, STUDENT had some difficulties while attending the new school. MOTHER testified that STUDENT began urinating on his bedroom floor because he believed he had been kicked out of Summit View. MOTHER also discovered that STUDENT had taken a knife to school while attending Stone Avenue.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year, including the 2000 extended school year (ESY)?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code section 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program reflected STUDENT’s needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of his disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services could not have been achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Educ. Code § 56031.)
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have met the following four requirements in order to have constituted a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comported with his IEP, and (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment.
The District contends that the offer contained in the September and October 1999 IEPs was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, would have provided him with educational benefit, and would have placed him in the least restrictive environment.
Respondent contends that the program and placement offered by the District in the September 16, 1999, and October 19, 1999 IEPs were not appropriate on several grounds. First, Respondent alleges that the District failed to identify and meet his behavioral needs.(Footnote 6) Second, Respondent contends that the proposed placement at Ina Arbuckle was not appropriate for him because of the class size, structure, and the teaching methods used by the teacher and the classroom aides. Third, Respondent disagreed with the District’s OT assessment, in which it was concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for OT services. Lastly, Respondent contends that he required vision therapy, which the District did not offer to provide. According to Respondent, the entire IEP process resulted in a denial of a FAPE.
Identification of STUDENT’s Needs
The first step in determining whether the District’s offer contained in the September and October 1999 IEPs was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs is to identify STUDENT’s unique needs at the time the offer was made. In that regard, the parties do not dispute that STUDENT qualified for special education services due to his speech and language impairment and that STUDENT required a structured environment and support in the area of speech and language.
In January 1999, the District’s school psychologist, Lana Clauder, conducted a psycho-educational evaluation of STUDENT. (Pet.’s Exh. 18.) With respect to STUDENT’s psychological processing, Ms. Clauder concluded that in sensory-motor processing, STUDENT demonstrated poor fine motor skills when writing his name or letters. His overall composite score on the Wide Range Assessment of Visual-Motor Abilities (WRAVMA) for sensory-motor processing was within the borderline range, with a standard score of 78 and in the 7th percentile. On the Motor Free Visual Perception Test Revised (MFVPT), STUDENT scored within the average range (perceptual quotient 97), indicating no problems with overall visual perceptual skills. To test STUDENT’s memory and learning, the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML) was administered. Analysis of his performance indicated a poor learning curve. The screening index indicated that STUDENT was impulsive and had inefficient attention skills, which might result in greater learning and memory difficulties as the quantity of rote material increased. His overall general memory index standard score of 84 was within the low average range. Ms. Clauder also recognized, as did Dr. Robert Patterson in his 1998 report, that STUDENT had less difficulty remembering things that were presented holistically and that had meaning, such as stories, rather than lists of words or numbers and letters. STUDENT demonstrated a major weakness in connecting sounds and visual symbols, which is characteristic of dyslexia. In terms of STUDENT’s attention skills, Ms. Clauder found that although it was reported that STUDENT had difficulty with attention in class, it was not apparent during her assessment, other than his being impulsive at times. Regarding STUDENT’s behavior, based on the Burks Behavior Rating Scale completed by STUDENT’s teacher, the results and analysis indicated that STUDENT appeared to show signs of excessive withdrawal, dependency, poor ego strength, poor physical strength, poor intellectuality, poor attention, impulse and anger control. He also demonstrated excessive aggression.
According to Ms. Clauder, STUDENT needed to be in a structured classroom with preferential seating and subtle prompts to remain on task. STUDENT also needed short work periods followed by favored tasks. His language demands needed to be reduced and directions needed to be short, repeated, and visually reinforced. STUDENT also needed to develop more automatic word attack skills and organization strategies for materials to be rote memorized. To boost his self esteem, STUDENT needed to be given positions of leadership in tasks at which he could succeed. Additionally, discipline needed to be consistent both at school and home, and direct confrontation avoided. Proximity control was important to be sure STUDENT was attending. And finally, STUDENT needed to have opportunities to make choices and be involved in interactive games with peers.
In January 1999, a speech and language evaluation was performed by Brooke Martinez, the District’s speech and language specialist. Ms. Martinez found that STUDENT demonstrated delays in the areas of semantics and syntax/morphology, and recommended that his articulation skills be monitored. She also confirmed that he met the State eligibility requirements for speech and language services under title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 3030(c). (Pet.’s Exh. 17.) Ms. Martinez testified that as of the October 19, 1999 IEP, STUDENT’s speech and language needs remained unchanged from when she evaluated him in January 1999. STUDENT still had difficulties in all of the same areas, and although he was making slow progress, he was heading in the right direction.
In September 1999, occupational therapist Laurie Lewis conducted an occupational therapy (OT) evaluation. (Pet.’s Exh. 14.) Ms. Lewis concluded that STUDENT demonstrated functional sensory, gross and fine motor skills, and that he did not exhibit deficits in any area that would qualify him as in need of educationally based occupational therapy services. Ms. Lewis did find, however, that STUDENT’s writing speed was immature and that he copied slowly from both near and far due to his reading and spelling levels. She also reported that STUDENT’s letter formation was that of a young first-grader with a decreased understanding of parts to whole for letter formation. Ms. Lewis found that STUDENT had some developmentally appropriate difficulties working with background noises.
Finally, Respondent’s parents hired licensed psychologist Robert Patterson to conduct a psychoeducational study of STUDENT in August 1999.(footnote 7) (Pet.’s Exh. 16.) Dr. Patterson found, as did Ms. Clauder, that STUDENT had difficulty connecting sounds and visual symbols, which is characteristic of dyslexia. He also found that STUDENT was performing in the average range on simultaneous processing type tasks and on language-free measures of cognition. On tasks that require sequential processing, however, he was performing at a much lower level. STUDENT’s achievement functioning skills were quite variable, as he was performing at the kindergarten level in most areas of academic skills. According to Dr. Patterson, STUDENT had an attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and met the criteria of the DSM-IV as well as the Conners’ ADHD Index. Dr. Patterson concluded that STUDENT needed to be placed in a small class that utilized multisensory methods of teaching reading and written language in all subject matter areas. Dr. Patterson recommended that the teacher utilize Project Read, Slingerland, Gillingham, or another standard strategy used to teach students who are dyslexic and dysgraphic. (Pet.’s Exh. 16.) According to Dr. Patterson, STUDENT required specific remediation in the areas of dyslexia and dysgraphia, which could be accomplished if the District provided STUDENT with Fast ForWord or Earobics and with the Lindamood Bell ADD program as a component to the classroom offered by the District. Dr. Patterson also believed that STUDENT required a specific behavioral intervention plan that was designed to control STUDENT’s targeted behaviors (i.e., hitting).(Footnote 8) Dr. Patterson recommended that STUDENT have a vision assessment, a physical therapy/occupational therapy assessment, and a speech and language assessment.(Footnote 9)
At the time the District made its offer for the 1999-2000 school year, the IEP team concluded that although STUDENT was not reading at that time, he recognized letters, knew sounds, and knew 5 out of 10 high frequency words. STUDENT had difficulty writing the letters of the alphabet and copying text from the board on to paper, and had poor letter formation and tracing skills. In math, STUDENT could count from 1 to 14, he recognized numbers up to 12, and he could add sums to 12, but only with manipulatives. STUDENT also had difficulty counting objects and sequencing numbers. In communication, STUDENT expressed difficulty with vocabulary, sentence structure, and pragmatics. He used run-on sentences and had a tendency to get off topic. STUDENT also showed weaknesses in receptive communication, having difficulty following oral directions. In terms of fine and gross motor skills, STUDENT had trouble controlling and manipulating his pencil for writing tasks and the IEP team noted that he often fell. Socially, STUDENT was immature, had difficulty keeping his hands to himself, and chatted with his friends in class. Regarding STUDENT’s behavior, the September 16, 1999 IEP noted that STUDENT had to be monitored because of his difficulty staying on task independently. It also noted that STUDENT enjoyed the teacher’s attention and that he wandered when sent from the classroom to the resource specialist program (RSP), to designated instruction and services (DIS), and to the bus. (See Pet.’s Exh. 2.)
The major dispute between the parties surrounded the identification of STUDENT’s behavioral issues. The District contends that other than STUDENT’s need to move and be active in the classroom, STUDENT had no other behaviors to address. In contrast, Respondent argues that the District should have convened an IEP meeting to supervise a functional analysis assessment (FAA), and that if the FAA had found that behavioral intervention was appropriate, the District should have developed a behavioral intervention plan. According to Respondent, he was entitled to an FAA pursuant to Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations (also referred to as a Hughes Bill assessment).(footnote 10) Respondent generally argues that his behaviors during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years, including his bringing a knife to school on one occasion, willful defiance of authority and causing physical injury to another person on a separate occasion, and wandering around school and being off task on other occasions, constituted a “serious behavior problem” as that term is defined in title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 3001(aa).
The law requires, in pertinent part, that a District conduct an FAA whenever a student demonstrates a "serious behavior problem." A "serious behavior problem" is defined as behaviors by a student which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are "pervasive and maladaptive" for which "instructional/behavioral approaches specified in [the student’s] IEP are found to be ineffective." (5 CCR §3001 (aa).)
District administrator Terry Tibbetts testified that STUDENT did not require a functional analysis assessment, since those assessments were targeted to severely handicapped children and situations involving self-injurious, assaultive, or serious maladaptive behavior and/or property destruction.(Footnote 11) STUDENT did not present these types of behaviors in school, and the Hughes bill was not designed to address the behaviors that STUDENT demonstrated. According to Mr. Tibbetts, not all evaluations of a student’s behavior require a formal assessment.
Ronald Fischbach testified on behalf of Respondent regarding his behavior. Mr. Fischbach stated that he has a doctoral degree in education psychology and has worked as a behaviorist with regional centers for 25 years. Mr. Fischbach also operates a program called “Steps to Independence Through Education,” where he works with families with special needs children to develop behavior programs in schools and homes.(Footnote 12) Mr. Fischbach testified that his opinion regarding STUDENT’s behaviors was based on his interview of Ann Studer, STUDENT’s teacher at Summit View, his two site visits and observations of STUDENT’s class at Summit View, discussions with STUDENT’s mother, and a review of selected documents related to STUDENT’s history. Although he attempted to, Mr. Fischbach was not permitted to observe the District’s offered classroom at Ina Arbuckle.
Regarding the offer made by the District in the September 16, 1999 IEP, Mr. Fischbach testified that the District failed to provide any services to address STUDENT’s behaviors. In reviewing STUDENT’s teachers’ notes regarding his class behavior (Resp.’s Exh. 77), Mr. Fischbach concluded that STUDENT’s behaviors were pervasive and maladaptive and interfered with his ability to be taught and to learn. Mr. Fischbach identified a pattern of frequency of behavior that included noncompliance, short attention span, and aggression. Mr. Fischbach stated that he identified 50 different comments by STUDENT’s teachers in their notes regarding incidents that occurred in the classroom, some incidents lasting all day and some only briefly. Because the teachers had to take out time to deal with STUDENT’s behaviors, they had less time to teach him. According to Mr. Fischbach, the decision of the IEP team to place STUDENT in a language-based program was inherently inappropriate since there was no recognition in the program of his specific behaviors and how they would be managed.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s behaviors did not amount to a "serious behavior problem." With regard to STUDENT’s bringing a knife to school on one occasion and wandering around school instead of returning to class after going to the restroom or after DIS and RSP pull-out class, an IEP team meeting was held on March 24, 1999, to address these problems. Behavioral reinforcements and interventions were developed and implemented to address those specific behaviors. (Pet.’s Exh. 4.) Thereafter, STUDENT’s mother added to his home contract the requirement that he tell his mother if he wanted to take anything from home to school. To control his wandering, students or staff were assigned to accompany STUDENT to and from classes, and a system was set up to reward STUDENT when he went straight to his destination and stayed within playground parameters. STUDENT’s behavior was not a “serious behavior problem” because “instructional/behavioral approaches specified in [the student’s] IEP” after the incident were effective. Because the District developed behavioral reinforcements and interventions that were incorporated into STUDENT’s IEP and were effective in reducing STUDENT’s behaviors of bringing inappropriate objects to school and wandering around school, these behaviors do not fall within the definition of a "serious behavior problem."
Neither do STUDENT’s other behavioral issues, including the willful defiance of authority and causing physical injury to another person, either separately or together, constitute a “serious behavior problem” necessitating an FAA. On May 13, 1999, STUDENT was suspended for one day because he “was hitting students on heads,” “pulling on another student’s shirt,” and “not following directions.” (See Resp.’s Exh. 69.) In each instance, the behaviors were isolated and not pervasive and maladaptive. Even when examined together, the behavioral incidents warranting suspension do not constitute a serious behavior problem. There is little commonality in the nature of the behaviors - one involved bringing an inappropriate object to school, one involved causing injury or annoyance to another student, and the other situation involved STUDENT’s having difficulty transitioning from class to class. Moreover, each of the behaviors warranting a review of the previously implemented behavioral reinforcements/interventions was separated in time by approximately two months.
STUDENT’s other behavioral problems occurred during the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year. STUDENT’s second-grade teachers, Lori Brown and Carol Hogerty, kept notes regarding STUDENT’s actions throughout the school day. (See Resp.’s Exh. 77.) Although that evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s misbehavior occurred regularly, the type of behavior did not amount to “maladaptive.” Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT’s misbehavior was along the lines of typical behavior of boys his age, e.g., talking in line, being out of his seat, rough housing, and wanting to be around other boys in the class. Both Ms. Brown and Ms. Hogerty testified that STUDENT’s behavior was manageable. According to both teachers, they devised plans to deal with STUDENT’s behavior, including giving him praise and providing him with structure, which tended to work.(Footnote 13) All agreed that STUDENT had more success within a structured environment and that his transition from one class to the next caused him difficulties.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not exhibit a serious behavior problem as that term is defined by the California Code of Regulations or the California Education Code. Therefore, the District was not, at any time, required to conduct an FAA.
The evidence, which included the classroom observations of STUDENT’s second-grade teachers, did demonstrate, however, that STUDENT’s mind wandered, he had difficulty staying on task and completing tasks, and he defied authority and was often late to class. As a result, his behavior was often inconsistent with whatever was going on in the class. (Resp.’s Exh. 77.) Indeed, Respondent’s witness, Robert Patterson, testified that STUDENT’s impulsivity was not a behavior problem, and that his difficulty completing tasks was an “educational problem.” Additionally, Terry Tibbetts testified that when a student’s educational progress is inhibited and the student is also exhibiting negative behavior, this may suggest an inappropriate placement.(Footnote 14) According to Mr. Tibbetts, students often “act out” when the class is not appropriate for them. The “acting out” could be the child’s way of saying “I’m lost.” STUDENT had attentional issues that made it difficult for him to independently stay on task and that led to his wandering and need for monitoring.
Testing and other evidence established that during the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’s needs were intensive. He had problems in all academic areas, he could not read, and his language impairment and academic delays negatively affected his ability to express himself in the classroom with adults and his peers. Additionally, both of his regular education teachers testified that STUDENT was increasingly off task, his tasks were not completed, he would often not follow directions, and he regularly got out of his seat and talked out in class. His teachers also noted his numerous late arrivals to school and his problems transitioning from class to DIS instruction and the bus. (Id.) STUDENT’s limited abilities made it impossible for him to perform at grade level without constant assistance.
While the parties did not necessarily agree on whether STUDENT’s disability could be defined as dyslexia or dysgraphia, there was no dispute that his disability affected the acquisition of reading and written language skills. Psychologist Lana Clauder testified that she agreed with Dr. Patterson’s 1998 conclusion that STUDENT had some of the characteristics of dyslexia. There also was no dispute that STUDENT needed a structured classroom and a language-based program that utilized a simultaneous multisensory method of instruction in reading and written language. STUDENT’s difficulties with letter name and sound recognition, oral reading, receptive and expressive communication, math, and written language warranted an intensive language-based program. Additionally, as will be discussed more fully below, the District’s school psychologist and both of STUDENT’s second-grade teachers testified that STUDENT needed more assistance than what was offered in the general education, DIS, and RSP programs. Although Respondent argued that he required a functional analysis assessment to address his alleged pervasive and maladaptive behaviors, as discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence did not support such extreme measures. STUDENT did not have a serious behavior problem that required a functional analysis assessment. However, he did have attentional issues, many of which led to behavioral problems in the classroom, such as his getting off task and disrupting the class. His attentional and behavioral issues required that he be placed in a more structured environment where he could be monitored and assisted with staying focused and completing tasks.
The inquiry then becomes whether or not the District’s proposed program and placement were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique communication needs. The Hearing Officer will also examine whether there was sufficient structure in the District’s offered placement to have addressed his attentional and behavioral needs and otherwise provided him with a FAPE in the LRE.
Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs
The IEPs dated September 16, 1999, and October 19, 1999, recommended that STUDENT be placed in the SDC-CH class at Ina Arbuckle Elementary School. Additional services of a behavioral consultant to the teacher would be provided on an as-needed basis at a minimum of two hours a month, curb-to-curb transportation, and extended school year services to assist STUDENT in maintaining his skill level. Modifications to his program would have included shortened homework assignments and some modification of its content. The September 1999 IEP also noted that behavior interventions, in the form of IEP goals, were needed.
Goals and objectives from the February 1, 1999 IEP were continued as they were deemed to be appropriate. The IEP contained seven goals and objectives, including one goal that addressed STUDENT’s identified need to improve morphological skills, one reading goal, one written language/spelling goal, one math goal, and two goals that addressed STUDENT’s need to improve his time on task, independent task completion, and pragmatic skills, including staying on topic and appropriately responding to questions or comments. A review of these goals indicates that they were based upon current assessment data and input from STUDENT’s teachers, appropriately drafted, and continued to address his areas of need. Each goal also established STUDENT’s present need in that area. District administrator Terry Tibbetts testified that the September 1999 IEP team determined that STUDENT had made little progress on the goals noted in the February 1999 IEP, and therefore believed that the objectives were still viable since he had not met his benchmarks. From this information, the IEP team decided to transfer those same goals and objectives to the current IEP and give the new SDC-CH teacher an opportunity to work on them with STUDENT in the new placement.
Ina Arbuckle - Class structure and program
The District contends that the program offered in the September and October 1999 IEPs was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. According to the District, during both IEP meetings, the IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s present levels of performance, discussed Dr. Patterson’s and other assessments, and adopted appropriate goals and objectives that would have allowed his service providers to address his academic and organizational skills and to analyze his progress throughout the year. (Pet.’s closing argument, pgs. 42-43.)
According to Respondent, without compliance with the mandates of the Hughes Bill, and provision of afternoon aides in a classroom with fewer children, the District would not be able to provide him with a FAPE in the SDC-CH at Ina. Respondent argued that in order to learn, he needed to be placed in a small, quiet environment with intense structure, close supervision, constant reminders to stay on task, and more one-on-one attention than Ms. Cadiente’s class offered. Respondent also contends that he required the provision of individualized speech and language services, individualized resource help in areas such as math and handwriting, and a specialized reading program such as that offered by Lindamood Bell.
Behavior, Attention, and Speech and Language Needs Addressed in SDC-CH at Ina
Nancy Cadiente testified that during the 1999-2000 school year, her class was composed of approximately 14 to 16 students in grades first through third, all of whom had normal intelligence, but who had language deficits. Ms. Cadiente is a credentialed speech and language specialist and has taught an SDC-CH for the past 18 years.(Footnote 15) Ms. Cadiente is assisted by two well-trained aides in her class in the morning for core curriculum support. The offered program would have allowed STUDENT to be mainstreamed for art, music, lunch, assemblies, and other school-wide activities.
Behavior
The Hearing Officer has already determined that STUDENT did not require a functional analysis assessment or a behavioral intervention plan to address his behavior issues. However, the Hearing Officer finds that it is necessary to evaluate the District’s offered program to determine whether it addressed his attentional needs and related behaviors.
District witnesses who observed Ms. Cadiente’s classroom all testified that they did not observe any students being willfully defiant or acting out. The classroom was very structured and no one was walking over to the windows or crawling under the tables. (Testimonies of Kathleen McLean and Terry Tibbetts.) Additionally, Ms. Cadiente believed that STUDENT had not demonstrated any behaviors that she could not handle in her class. (Testimony of Nancy Cadiente.) Ms. Cadiente utilized a class-based behavior program in which students have behavior charts on their desks that depict a possible total of two apples each day that can be lost due to continued misbehavior. The children must cross off an apple when they continue to exhibit a negative behavior after a warning. If a child loses three apples during a week, his/her chart is sent home at the end of the month. There is a reward at the end of the month for not losing apples. If a child has lost more than 30% of his/her apples, then he/she cannot participate in the month-end reward, which might be a prize from the prize box, extra time at recess, a party, or a video. According to Ms. Cadiente, the behavior charts help remind the students of how they are behaving.
With respect to the behavioral program implemented in Ms. Cadiente’s room, Dr. Patterson testified that although these types of plans are commonly used in regular education, for a child like STUDENT who has impulse difficulties, a reward at the end of the month is inappropriate because there is too much time between the intervention and the behavior. Dr. Patterson characterized Ms. Cadiente’s apple chart behavior plan as a punishment paradigm in which there is no positive reinforcement. A positive behavioral program allows the student to keep the reward regardless of what else happens. According to Dr. Patterson, punishment works, but it takes a long time to be effective; therefore, positive behavioral interventions work more effectively. Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT needed continual positive praise and needed to take breaks for the teacher to get his attention. Because STUDENT is a complex child with mood issues and low frustration tolerance, a behavior plan would have to be specific to his needs for it to be successful.
In response to a description of Ms. Cadiente’s apple chart behavior program, Mr. Fischbach testified similarly to Dr. Patterson, stating that the time line between the behavior and the consequence was too long, and under those circumstances, the probability that such a plan would be effective goes down tremendously. According to Mr. Fischbach, one would not know what time frame for a reward would be appropriate for STUDENT until an assessment was done. The evidence established that STUDENT’s behaviors rose mostly out of his attentional issues, such as his being off task and his difficulty keeping his mind focused. Ms. Cadiente’s class-wide behavioral program would have addressed STUDENT’s attentional issues by monitoring his behavior, giving him individual attention and praise, and helping him stay focused. With respect to Ms. Cadiente’s behavioral plan, the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Patterson’s testimony was inconsistent when he described a similar “turn-a-card” behavior plan that was implemented in STUDENT’s current classroom at Summit View. Dr. Patterson referred to the Summit View turn-a-card plan, which imposed consequences and could lead to privileges being taken away, as “assertive discipline,” as opposed to a “punishment paradigm,” which was the characterization he gave to Ms. Cadiente’s class behavior plan. Additionally, as stated earlier, less weight is given to Mr. Fischbach’s testimony given the fact that he had not observed STUDENT in any classroom, he is not licensed to implement behavior modification plans nor is he a licensed psychologist, and he acknowledged having a financial interest in the outcome of the hearing. The Hearing Officer gives more weight to Ms. Cadiente’s testimony because of her vast experience working in the SDC-CH class with students who have needs similar to STUDENT’s and her stated confidence that she could handle STUDENT’s attentional issues in her class. The Hearing Officer also recognizes that the District offered to provide the Ina classroom teacher with consultation by a behavioral specialist at a minimum of two hours each month. The September 1999 IEP document noted that the behavior specialist could work with the teacher on any behavior issues that might arise, and could provide assistance to the teacher in structuring social skills activities. Additionally, the IEP team decided that it would reconvene in 30 days to review STUDENT’s progress and to determine if any additional program modifications were necessary. Individual Attention
Respondent argued that a classroom where the teacher’s aides were present for only two and one-half hours of the day would not be appropriate to meet his needs. According to Respondent, the five-to-one ratio of students to adults should have been consistent throughout the entire school day so that he could receive the individual attention and support that he needed. However, during the morning core curriculum, Ms. Cadiente’s class would have provided STUDENT with small-group instruction with either of the three adults in the room, which included the teacher and her two aides. Ms. Cadiente testified that one of her aides has been working with her for nine years and the other has been with her for 15 or 16 years. Each is very familiar with the language arts program, has been personally trained by her, and has attended in-service training provided by the District. Ms. Cadiente also testified that she is in constant communication with her aides regarding the progress of the students, and if a student has a specific articulation or language deficit, she works individually with that student for approximately one-half hour a day and then reinforces that instruction throughout the day.
Ms. Cadiente acknowledged that in the afternoon when only one adult is in the class, it is not as easy to tailor the class to any particular student. However, she handles this situation by sometimes having older students work with younger students during this time or allowing the older students to work on their own while she works with the younger ones. Ms. Cadiente testified that she shifts her resources to tailor the class. Ms. Cadiente also stated that she is familiar with working with students who drift, don’t stay on task, fidget and talk to their neighbors, and who need more attention. For those students who have such attentional difficulties, Ms. Cadiente provides one-to-one attention and reminds them to give eye contact and to stay on task. After a period of time, she is able to get the students to self-motivate and move away from the need for so much teacher attention.
STUDENT demonstrated a need for attentional supports that addressed his impulsiveness, his difficulty staying on task independently, and keeping his hands to himself. The evidence establishes that Ms. Cadiente’s well-structured program would have provided STUDENT with the small-group and individual attention and instruction that he needed to maintain his attention and assist him in completing tasks. STUDENT also would have had opportunities in the afternoon to work on goals involving his ability to independently complete tasks with minimal prompts. Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive the fact that Ms. Cadiente’s aides have been with her for numerous years and are familiar with, and well trained in, her programs, particularly the reading programs.
Speech and Language
Dr. Patterson reported that the classroom offered by the District was an excellent, well- run classroom with a knowledgeable and experienced teacher who could certainly work with STUDENT in terms of consistency of effort and with his language and communication development. (Pet.’s Exh. 11.) However, notwithstanding this contention, Dr. Patterson believed that the classroom at Ina was not “the best possible fit” because it did not fully meet STUDENT’s needs in terms of the teacher’s and aides’ skills in working with a multisensory method of teaching reading and written language in all academic areas throughout the day. (Pet.’s Exh. 11, pg. 2.) In his September 30, 1999 observation report of Ms. Cadiente’s classroom, Dr. Patterson stated that if the District provided STUDENT with Fast ForWord or Earobics and with the LMB ADD program as a component to the Ina classroom, that classroom might become an appropriate classroom for STUDENT. (Pet.’s Exh. 11.)
Ms. Cadiente and other District witnesses who either observed or were familiar with Ms. Cadiente’s classroom all testified that the SDC-CH program at Ina offered a language-rich, structured environment, which had speech and language integrated into the program throughout the day. The class employed a multisensory approach by which the teacher used many manipulatives and made certain that the students understood the concepts.
According to Ms. Cadiente, her approach to teaching reading is similar to that of the Lindamood Bell (LMB) program in that it is multisensory. For instance, Ms. Cadiente talks with her students about the meaning of words and about the way words sound. She also uses rhyming activities, has the students write words, and allows them to view the words on a card. Ms. Cadiente was trained in the fall of 1999 and received a certificate of completion in the phonemic awareness portion (ADD) of the LMB program. She stated that she felt comfortable using the technique in her class and that the LMB techniques were similar to what she had already been using. Ms. Cadiente also testified that she had obtained the Earobics program in her classroom.
Ms. Cadiente testified that the students in her class receive speech and language instruction throughout the entire school day, as opposed to just a few times a week on a pull-out basis. Speech and language instruction is ongoing and reinforced throughout the day through an integrated curriculum. Ms. Cadiente testified that if a student has a breakdown in his/her auditory processing, that student typically has visual strengths. In such an instance, she writes things on the board, has the student write letters in the air, and uses many other techniques, such as working with clay or other manipulatives that help the student learn what she is teaching. Ms. Cadiente also stated that she uses tape recorders and songs and gives each student access to the computer, which is used as an adjunct to her classroom program. Ms. Cadiente utilizes the Earobics phonics computer program and the Sticky Bear reading and math computer programs. She also employs a kinesthetic approach to teaching, allowing the students to use their bodies to learn by using techniques such as play acting. The students in her class are able to practice their speech and sounds by modeling the teacher and the aides in the classroom, since most of the students in her class have normal articulation. Ms. Cadiente testified that she uses a great deal of repetition, and instruction is given in small segments. There also is a great deal of talking and explaining in the class, and if a student does not understand something, she reiterates it for the student. The class structure allows her to modify the pace of her instructions if necessary. Additionally, Ms. Cadiente stated that she would be able to address problems associated with STUDENT’s writing disability.
Speech and language specialist Brooke Martinez provided speech and language services twice a week to STUDENT during the 1998-1999 school year and the first part of the 1999-2000 school year. Ms. Martinez testified that she agreed with the District’s offer to place STUDENT at the SDC-CH at Ina because that class offered a language-based program taught by a credentialed speech and language specialist. In her opinion, the class at Ina was more attuned to the specific needs of the students, and the instructor would have been able to give STUDENT individual speech and language services as part of the class, rather than pulling STUDENT out of class for those services. STUDENT’s previous IEPs noted that he had trouble transitioning from his regular class to receive his DIS for speech and RSP. In transitioning, STUDENT would get deterred and not go directly to his class, and as a result, STUDENT’s IEP had to be amended to include his being escorted to and from his DIS classes. Being able to receive speech and language services within his assigned SDC would have alleviated this transitioning problem for STUDENT.
Although Dr. Patterson testified that the Ina classroom was not the best possible fit for STUDENT, the District’s offered program and placement are not required to be sufficient to maximize STUDENT’s potential. (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 198.) Rather, a district is only required to provide a student with a “basic floor of opportunity” (Id at 200-201.), and that basic floor of opportunity must consist of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. (Id. at 201.) In addition, although Dr. Patterson made recommendations regarding particular reading programs, such as Project Read, Slingerland, and Orton Gillingham, that he believed would be best suited to STUDENT’s needs, the Hearing Officer finds that it is more appropriate that the specific methodological components of STUDENT’s reading program be chosen at the discretion of the teacher herself, since she is the individual who would be providing the service. (Rowley, supra,458 U.S. at 207.)
Ms. Cadiente credibly testified that the multisensory approach and strategies used in her program would address areas in which STUDENT demonstrated weakness, such as phonemic awareness, morphological skills, pragmatics, reading, written language and spelling, vocabulary and semantic knowledge skills, and math. According to Ms. Cadiente, her program would have met STUDENT’s needs and addressed his goals.
*** The Hearing Officer concludes that the class structure and program of the SDC-CH class at Ina were consistent with recommendations made by the District’s psychologist Lana Clauder and speech and language specialist Brooke Martinez, and Respondent’s psychologist, Robert Patterson. The class would have ensured that STUDENT had the support necessary to allow him to direct his attention and enable him to avoid the tendency to act out when he gets off task. The classroom, although it consisted of approximately 15 students, provided instruction of the core curriculum (reading and math) in small groups of approximately four to five students, where STUDENT would have received the individual attention that he needed. Additionally, the class was focused on speech and language throughout the day so that STUDENT would receive intense instruction from a well-qualified teacher and aides who were well-versed in using the multisensory teaching method that the parties agreed STUDENT needed. The classroom at Ina provided a structured environment that was set up to intensely remediate the speech and language and reading difficulties that STUDENT possessed. Ms. Cadiente persuasively identified how the class structure and the educational strategies employed in her SDC would have successfully met STUDENT’s unique needs.
Designated Instruction and Services
A free appropriate public education is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student's unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student's individualized education program. (20 U.S.C. §§ 1401(8)(D), (25).) Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from his education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56303(a).) Occupational therapy and vision therapy are related services under Title 5, California Code of Regulations, Section 3051.75.
Occupational Therapy
Respondent disagreed with the conclusions reached in the District’s occupational therapy (OT) evaluation, which indicated that STUDENT did not qualify for OT services. The District argued that the OT assessment conducted by Laurie Lewis was appropriate to determine STUDENT’s needs for educationally based OT and that the District was not required to provide STUDENT with medically based OT.
Laurie Lewis testified that her 1999 assessment of STUDENT included a one-half day classroom and school area observation of STUDENT, an ecological evaluation, a review of STUDENT’s cumulative file, discussions with STUDENT’s service providers, a review of relevant assessment reports, including one completed by the Regional Center and the District’s psycho-educational evaluation, educational and medical records provided by the family and the District, a questionnaire completed by STUDENT’s mother, and a gross and fine motor skills/functional performance skill inventory conducted by Ms. Lewis. Ms. Lewis testified that her tests were not biased in any way, and that she believed her tests accurately reflected STUDENT’s aptitude for occupational therapy.(Footnote 16)
Ms. Lewis concluded that STUDENT demonstrated functional sensory, gross and fine motor skills, and did not exhibit deficits in any area that qualified him as in need of educationally based occupational therapy services. According to Ms. Lewis, STUDENT’s speed in learning to write was delayed; however, the skills that he lacked were obtainable by practice, which did not require OT. OT was not relevant and necessary for STUDENT to meet educational goals and to access the educational environment. Her recommendation was based on the Guidelines for OT and PT in California Public Schools, published by the California Department of Education in 1996.(footnote 17) Ms. Lewis’s report concludes that providing therapy in an educational setting is appropriate only when it will result in facilitating the student’s independent functioning, decreasing the effects of the student’s handicapping condition on his ability to participate in, and to benefit from, his individualized program of educational instruction. (Pet.’s Exh. 14.)
Ms. Lewis testified that discussions with STUDENT’s RSP teacher revealed that STUDENT was struggling to learn to read and was having difficulty writing. Ms. Lewis advised the RSP teacher that STUDENT should observe and use the same handwriting style as that used by his teacher. She also concluded that STUDENT’s writing problems would resolve with maturation, as one’s writing is correlated with one’s ability to read. Ms. Lewis observed that STUDENT’s writing was immature and that he copied slowly from both near and far due to his reading and spelling skill level. Ms. Lewis testified that, developmentally, if a child is not ready to understand the concepts of writing symbols, he can be trained by practice and repetition to write symbols (letters). But, he will not understand the symbols. However, she concluded that STUDENT did not require an occupational therapist to help him learn how to write letters because it is not a motor issue - any teacher could do this. The teachers know just as well as, and in many cases better than, many occupational therapists how to teach a student to write letters because the teachers receive more training in that area than do occupational therapists.
As a part of Ms. Lewis’s evaluation, MOTHER completed the Analysis of Sensory Behavior Inventory-Revised, and her scores revealed no areas of sensory concern. Additionally, the areas of sensory input and processing that Ms. Lewis evaluated during her classroom and home observations were vestibular, proprioceptive, tactile, auditory, and visual. Ms. Lewis also found no areas of concern. (Pet.’s Exh. 14.)
Laurie Lewis reported that the classroom staff indicated that STUDENT did not demonstrate tactile difficulties. From her observation, STUDENT demonstrated touching of several different textures, including glue, dirt, and foods in the lunch line. STUDENT did not respond negatively to being touched on his arms, hands, ears, or face. According to Ms. Lewis, these are all examples of a child who is taking in and processing tactile input in an appropriate manner. Ms. Lewis’s report also noted that it is important to keep in mind that one or two reactions to touch do not indicate that a child is defensive to touch. To be defensive to tactile stimulation, a child must react negatively to touch sensations across a wide range of activities. (Pet.’s Exh. 14, pg. 4.)
Jerry Lindquist testified in support of Respondent’s position that he required OT.(Footnote 18) Mr. Lindquist assessed STUDENT in the clinic in February 2001 over three sessions. He administered the Sensory Integration and Praxis Tests (SIPT), which test visual perception, perception to touch, vestibular function, and motor planning. Mr. Lindquist did not observe STUDENT in the classroom. Mr. Lindquist concluded that as of February 2001, STUDENT had a moderate sensory processing deficit affecting the tactile, proprioceptive and visual sensory systems, contributing to poor visual perception and visual motor coordination, tactile and proprioceptive discrimination deficits, sensory defensiveness, motor planning deficits, and bilateral motor coordination difficulties. (Resp.’s Exh. 99.)
According to Mr. Lindquist, these deficits affected STUDENT in the classroom. For example, STUDENT had defensive responses to touch, a generalized sensory defensiveness that affected his reaction to kids touching him. When touched by Mr. Lindquist, STUDENT would rub himself in that same area. STUDENT was also affected by extraneous sensory input such as being distracted by noises outside Mr. Lindquist’s office. Mr. Lindquist testified that children who have sensory defensiveness problems often appear to have attentional issues. However, the only way to confirm this is to conduct attentional tests. According to Mr. Lindquist, children with sensory processing issues often look impulsive and may often get out of their chair, hit, or have trouble keeping their hands to themselves. Mr. Lindquist stated that he believed Ms. Lewis’s classroom observations of STUDENT failed to pick up on STUDENT’s sensory processing issues. He further stated that MOTHER did not identity the same problems in the inventory questionnaire for the District that she identified in his evaluation. Mr. Lindquist believed that sometimes the parents do not see behaviors that might be important, and therefore, they may not indicate them on the questionnaires. Mr. Lindquist testified that MOTHER told him she was “clueless” at the time of the District’s evaluation, which Mr. Lindquist stated was common with parents.
Mr. Lindquist’s conclusions, that as of February 2001 STUDENT needed OT services and that Ms. Lewis may have overlooked STUDENT’s sensory processing issues, raise the possibility that STUDENT might have needed OT during the 1999-2000 school year. However, the results of Ms. Lewis’s assessment indicated that STUDENT did not require OT services to benefit from his education. In light of the information obtained through other witnesses and documentary evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no significant evidence rebutting the conclusions reached by occupational therapist Laurie Lewis.(Footnote 19) The evidence establishes that STUDENT did not require OT during the 1999-2000 school year to facilitate his independent functioning and decrease the effects of his handicapping condition on his ability to participate in, and benefit from, his IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP team’s decision not to offer STUDENT OT services was appropriate.
Vision Therapy
Respondent alleges that he was entitled to vision therapy during the 1999-2000 school year. Although no expert testimony was presented regarding vision therapy, Respondent submitted documents regarding vision assessments conducted in 1996 and 2000 by optometrist Benjamin Kohn, and in 1999 by optometrist William Bescoby.
STUDENT was assessed by optometrist William Bescoby on or about October 1999. (Resp.’s Exh. 47.) Mr. Bescoby’s report indicates that he performed a sensory motor evaluation on STUDENT and concluded that STUDENT was suffering from a constant left exotropia at distance with fusion at near; amblyopia of his left eye; bilateral astigmatism; delayed gross motor development; and an oculomotor dysfunction.
Mr. Bescoby’s report states that the “exotropia and amblyopia are medical conditions, which require medical management.” The report also states that the exotropia and amblyopia needed to be treated first, either by surgery or orthoptics (very specialized vision therapy). Mr. Bescoby’s report suggested that the orthoptics was the better course of action since surgery would be complicated. Mr. Bescoby’s report concludes by stating that “after the exotropia has been treated and the gross motor skills have improved, reevaluate the oculomotor (focusing and tracking) skills for possible vision therapy.” (Id.)
Notwithstanding his November 1999 letter to STUDENT’s parents suggesting that orthoptics may be available to STUDENT as a DIS service, Mr. Tibbetts testified that Mr. Bescoby’s vision therapy evaluation concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for vision therapy and that STUDENT’s vision condition required medical treatment before vision therapy would be pursued. (See Resp.’s Exh. 47.)
Respondent submitted developmental vision examination results from November 1996 and 2000 prepared by optometrist Benjamin Kohn. However, the results of those evaluations were gathered almost 3 years prior to the 1999-2000 school year and at the end of the 1999-2000 school year, and therefore, do not give an indication of STUDENT’s vision needs at the time of the District’s offer for the 1999-2000 school year. Neither party offered expert testimony regarding STUDENT’s need for vision therapy. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must rely on the documentary evidence presented and the relevant testimony of Terry Tibbetts and MOTHER. Mr. Bescoby’s October 5, 1999 report is persuasive in that it reveals the results of his evaluation, provides an analysis of the results, and recommends a course of action. Respondent did not object to the findings made in Mr. Bescoby’s report; however, MOTHER testified that she discussed Mr. Bescoby’s report with him, and reportedly, Mr. Bescoby told her the same thing as Mr. Kohn -- that STUDENT would need vision therapy to remediate his tracking and focus control problems. According to MOTHER, the optometrists led her to believe that STUDENT’s vision problems were related to his education. MOTHER also testified that Mr. Kohn told her that STUDENT was receiving orthoptics.
The Hearing Officer finds that although both Mr. Kohn and Mr. Bescoby appeared to have recommended vision therapy in the form of orthoptics, Mr. Bescoby’s report indicates that such a specialized form of vision therapy was actually medical management for medical conditions. Additionally, Mr. Tibbetts’s testimony indicated that he understood that the District was not required to provide vision therapy because STUDENT first needed medical treatment. An IEP team meeting first needed to be held in order to make a determination as to STUDENT’s vision needs. However, according to Mr. Tibbetts, STUDENT’s parents did not respond to his offer to hold an IEP meeting. MOTHER testified that she did not respond to Mr. Tibbetts’s letter because STUDENT had already left the District to attend Summit View, and she believed that STUDENT had to return to the District in order to receive vision therapy.
Having failed to provide significant evidence rebutting the conclusion that STUDENT did not require vision therapy until after he received medical treatment, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s VT assessment and the conclusions reached therein were appropriate, and that the IEP team’s decision not to offer STUDENT vision therapy did not deny him a FAPE.
**** In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the assessments upon which the IEP was based were appropriate and the recommendations contained therein were adequately addressed in the IEP, with respect to the offered placement, goals and objectives, and related services. There was no evidence that the assessments did not adequately identify STUDENT’s needs in the respective areas. Additionally, the overall program was designed quite carefully to address STUDENT’s collective needs. The Hearing Officer found persuasive Ms. Cadiente’s testimony regarding how the program, class structure, and the strategies employed in her SDC could have successfully met STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of behavior. Ms. Martinez gave credible testimony about the appropriateness of the SDC for STUDENT and his speech and language needs. Ms. Martinez’s testimony also reflected her high regard for Ms. Cadiente’s experience and expertise in handling misbehavior in her classroom. District administrator Terry Tibbetts testified that given his knowledge of Ms. Cadiente’s SDC, he believed that the SDC was an appropriate placement where the teacher could consistently address STUDENT’s academic and communication needs by utilizing a multisensory methodology that focused on building language skills. Finally, based on his knowledge and experience, Mr. Tibbetts gave credible testimony regarding STUDENT’s expected success in a more restrictive school environment with the support of a language specialist who could focus on his language needs and work with him on goals and objectives that the IEP team believed were still viable.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
The Hearing Officer finds that the placement and services described above also were designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. The primary goal of improving STUDENT's language skills would have been addressed in the SDC, by direct instruction from the teacher and the aides, and through the group experiences. An appropriate curriculum at STUDENT’s developmental level would have allowed him to develop reading and written language skills. With an appropriate curriculum in place and a well-structured environment, it is anticipated that STUDENT's frustration level, attention, and behavior would have improved.
The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the District witnesses’ testimony regarding STUDENT’s potential success had he been placed in the SDC-CH with the services outlined in the September and October 1999 IEPs. For instance, Ms. Cadiente stated that she has successfully served students who have had attentional difficulties and learning disabilities, and students whose learning disabilities were a manifestation of their attentional needs. She also has successfully served students with reading, writing, and auditory processing deficits similar to STUDENT’s. The Hearing Officer also gives deference to the testimony of Brooke Martinez. On the strength of her previous experience as a teacher for communicatively handicapped students and as a speech and language specialist, Brooke Martinez testified credibly about STUDENT’s potential success if placed in the SDC-CH at Ina. Mechanisms and support systems were offered to ensure STUDENT’s successful integration into the new placement. Although a specific behavioral plan was not drafted for STUDENT, class-wide behavioral plans were in place and could have been supplemented at any time with the assistance of a behavioral specialist. Additionally, an IEP team was scheduled to convene within 30 days of his commencement in Ms. Cadiente’s class, and any behavioral issues could have been further addressed at that time.
The Hearing Officer also found persuasive the fact that Ms. Cadiente has been teaching an SDC-CH for 18 years and has a considerable amount of experience working with children with attentional difficulties, learning disabilities, and language-based disorders. Ms. Cadiente’s credible testimony about her program and the specific strategies that she successfully uses in her class, including her behavior plan, as well as her assertion that the goals and objectives could be implemented in her class, establishes that the District’s offer of placement in the SDC-CH at Ina would have provided STUDENT with educational benefit during the 1999-2000 school year.
Conform to the IEP
There was no dispute that STUDENT’s program conformed to the IEP. There is no dispute that services identified in the IEPs dated September 16, 1999, and October 19, 1999, would have been provided to STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year.
Least Restrictive Environment
There was no dispute that the program offered by the District would be provided in the least restrictive environment.
Conclusion
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer contained in the September and October 1999 IEPs met the requirements of the law. Although an individualized behavioral plan would have been optimal, the District’s offer to provide the classroom teacher with consultation by a behavioral specialist for a minimum of two hours a month satisfied the District’s duty to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Placement in the SDC-CH also would have provided STUDENT with a more structured environment, which all parties agreed was essential for STUDENT’s attentional issues. Additionally, had this arrangement not effectively addressed STUDENT’s attentional issues, any defect in the program could have been corrected by the IEP team when it reconvened in 30 days (as anticipated in the IEP dated October 19, 1999). Therefore, by itself, failing to devise a behavioral intervention plan pursuant to the Hughes bill did not rise to the level of a denial of a FAPE.
From the weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit for the 1999-2000 school year, was in conformity with the IEP, and would have been provided in the least restrictive environment. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 1999-2000 school year, including the 2000 ESY.(Footnote 20)
2. If the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, including the 2000 ESY, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for STUDENT’s placement at Summit View from January 2000 through the end of that school year?
Given the Hearing Officer’s determination above that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, including the 2000 ESY, the Hearing Officer does not address this issue.
3. Did the District make a FAPE available to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 ESY?
The analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed program and placement are substantively appropriate. (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207.)
A. Procedural Appropriateness
Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and federal regulations implementing the IDEA. (20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300 et seq.) Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the appropriate public education to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student's educational program. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).) The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that "Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation" at every step "as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP." (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 205-206.) Procedural flaws, however, do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. (W.G., supra, 960 F.2d at 1484.) Procedural violations which result in a "loss of educational opportunity" or which "seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE." (Id.)
Respondent contends that the District failed to follow IDEA procedural requirements when it failed to provide him notice of his annual IEP meeting that was due in February 2000. Respondent also contends that the District failed to make a timely offer of a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year. According to Respondent, it was not until July 3, 2000, that the District, through its attorney, Mr. Read, addressed the issue of an offer of placement and that any time between October 2000 and June 2001, the District could have held an IEP without MOTHER. The District argues that it was not obligated to notice the Respondent of an IEP meeting in February 2000, and that it made a FAPE available to Respondent for the 2000-2001 school year. According to the District, it committed no procedural errors that resulted in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT. Convening Annual IEP meeting
The District contends that when Respondent’s parents unilaterally removed him from the District in December 1999 and placed him in a private school, they did so out of preference, not necessity. According to the District, once Respondent’s parents removed him from the District, he was no longer entitled to special education services as a public school student, and therefore, the District’s obligations at that point did not require it to hold an annual IEP meeting in February 2000.
According to the October 19, 1999 IEP document, STUDENT’s annual IEP was due January 31, 2000. However, the facts do not support Respondent’s contention that the District was required to notice an annual IEP meeting in February 2000. The parties had recently met in September and October 1999, and as held above, the District offered STUDENT a FAPE at that time. The September and October 1999 IEP teams had reviewed STUDENT’s progress, the IEP, including whether his annual goals were being achieved, and the appropriateness of his placement. The IEP team also made the necessary revisions to STUDENT’s IEP during the September and October 1999 IEP meetings. (Educ. Code § 56343(d); Pet.’s Exhs. 1 and 2.)
Although STUDENT’s October 1999 IEP states that the next annual review was due January 31, 2000, an IEP meeting was not necessary at that time because the September and October 1999 IEPs, taken together, collectively fulfilled the requirements for an annual IEP meeting, thus changing the date for the next annual IEP. Such a meeting of the IEP team is only required to occur annually. Therefore, unless STUDENT had received an initial formal assessment, demonstrated a lack of anticipated progress, or his parents or teacher had requested that the IEP team convene a meeting, the District was not required to hold an annual IEP meeting in February 2000. Therefore, the District did not commit a procedural violation of the IDEA.
B. Substantive Appropriateness
Making FAPE available for the regular 2000-2001 school year
Next, the Hearing Officer considers the District’s responsibility regarding the 2000-2001 school year. The District argued that STUDENT had no individual entitlement to special education and related services once his parents unilaterally placed him at Summit View, regardless of whether or not FAPE was at issue, and, consequently, the District was obligated only to make a FAPE available to STUDENT should his parents re-enroll him in the public school.
STUDENT had been unilaterally withdrawn by his parents from the District and placed in a private school during the previous school year. By letter dated January 11, 2000, Respondent’s former attorney, Shelli Lewis, notified the District that STUDENT had been placed in a nonpublic school and that his parents would be seeking reimbursement from the District for the costs. (Pet.’s Exh. 34.) Notwithstanding STUDENT’s unilateral placement by his parents in a private school, according to the District, the parties agreed to convene an IEP meeting on September 5, 2000, to discuss the 2000-2001 school year; however, Respondent’s counsel, Shelli Lewis, cancelled the meeting. (Pet.’s closing brief, pg. 67.)(Footnote 21) Respondent alleges, however, that the September 5, 2000 IEP meeting did not occur “due to negotiations about where the meeting was to take place (Summit View or Jurupa).” (Resp.’s closing brief, pg. 62.)
On or about September 7 and 8, 2000, MOTHER, on the advice of counsel, attempted to register STUDENT at Sunnyslope Elementary School in spite of the fact that he was continuing to attend Summit View. Numerous letters were exchanged between the parties’ counsel regarding the parents’ interest in a “public school placement” and the parties’ willingness to hold an IEP meeting. However, MOTHER testified on the first day of hearing that she was interested in an appropriate public school placement that met STUDENT’s needs. Later during that first day of hearing, the parties stipulated to conduct an IEP meeting on October 26, 2000, to determine a program for STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year, and agreed that STUDENT’s current teacher and an administrator from Summit View would be present at the IEP meeting.
At the time the October 26, 2000 IEP was scheduled, Respondent’s parents were represented by attorney Shelli Lewis. However, prior to the next hearing dates in November 2000, Respondent’s parents changed counsel to their current attorneys, Beltran, Smith and Oppel. The scheduled October 2000 IEP meeting was again cancelled by Respondent. (Pet.’s Exh. 57.) However, the District conditioned its agreement to reschedule the IEP meeting on the assurance that Respondent’s counsel would “immediately forward a written timeline waiver pertaining to the annual IEP for the 2000-2001 school year and that [they would] confirm in writing that STUDENT’s parents will not seek reimbursement relating to the portion of the 2000-2001 school year that has already occurred.” (Pet.’s Exh. 57.)
During the course of the hearing, Respondent’s counsel indicated that it was his understanding that the District was offering the program outlined in the September and October 1999 IEPs for the 2000-2001 school year, and based on that assumption, he had advised his client not to attend any IEP meeting regarding the 2000-2001 school year because he believed an offer for that year was already on the table. Respondent requested that the Hearing Officer order the parties to an IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer informed the parties that such an order would not be made at this juncture in the hearing, but that the parties could agree on their own to convene an IEP meeting. The parties then informed the Hearing Officer that they had agreed to convene an IEP meeting and to proceed with the hearing.
Numerous letters were again exchanged between both parties’ counsel, the District claiming to be trying to confirm whether Respondent had a bona fide interest in a “public school placement,” and Respondent attempting to determine, outside of the IEP meeting, what program and placement the District intended to offer. The District responded by telling Respondent that it would not provide that information outside of an IEP meeting. MOTHER, through her counsel, indicated that she was unwilling to attend an IEP meeting regarding an unknown placement if she could not learn anything about it ahead of time and could not see the offered placement or have STUDENT’s psychologist assess it for her. (Testimony of MOTHER.) Neither party could agree on a time and date for the IEP meeting.
After numerous letters back and forth between counsel, the parties finally agreed to hold an IEP meeting on June 5, 2001, at which time an IEP was developed for STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer finds that under the circumstances described above, the District was required to develop an IEP for STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year and offer him a FAPE designed to meet his needs. The overall statutory scheme of IDEA ‘97, particularly the notice requirement for unilateral parent placements, embodies the concept that a school district is to be given a legitimate opportunity to offer a student a FAPE for the year initially at issue and every year thereafter before incurring the responsibility for reimbursing a parent for a unilateral private placement. (See 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10).) Thus, a school district is not required to develop an IEP or make a specific formal offer of FAPE every year for every student who has been unilaterally withdrawn from the district by his or her parents without some indication that the parents are seeking services from the district, even where FAPE had been put in issue in the past. (34 C.F.R., Attachment 1, p. 12601 (1999).)
However, the evidence established that STUDENT’s continued unilateral placement at Summit View during the 2000-2001 school year was not a matter of his parents simply preferring one educational facility over another. Rather, STUDENT’s parents were attempting to find an alternative to the District’s program, which they found inadequate. Additionally, STUDENT’s mother had indicated on the last IEP that she did not agree with the District’s offered program. Through his attorney and through the direct testimony of his mother, Respondent also gave the District sufficient indication that he was interested in a public school placement for the 2000-2001 school year. Therefore, the District erred when it failed to make an offer of FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year to STUDENT, as it was not excused from doing so because his parents had unilaterally placed him in a private school.
Making FAPE available for the 2001 Extended School Year (ESY)
As stated earlier, the parties convened an IEP meeting on June 5, 2001. At that time, the District found STUDENT eligible to receive special education services under the categories of specific learning disability, speech or language impairment, and other health impairment. The District offered to immediately place STUDENT in an SDC at Camino Real, with DIS of speech and language on a one-to-one and small-group basis two times per week for 30 minutes, and on a consultative basis one time per week. The District also offered STUDENT one-to-one counseling two times per week for 30 minutes. Curb-to-curb transportation was offered, as well as extended school year. A referral was made for STUDENT to receive an OT and behavioral assessment. STUDENT’s present levels of performance were identified and 12 different goals were drafted in the areas of reading, math, morphological and semantic skills, pragmatic skills, writing, social-emotional functioning, and staying on task.
Although the District offered STUDENT immediate placement in a public school program, only 12 days remained in the regular 2000-2001 school year. MOTHER testified that since STUDENT had changed schools a number of times in the past, it would have been difficult for him if he had another change in schools that was sporadic and abrupt. With only 12 days left in the school year, STUDENT finished out the regular 2000-2001 school year at Summit View. MOTHER testified that she understood that the June 5, 2001 IEP was for STUDENT’s fourth-grade year during the 2001-2002 school year because Mrs. Simpson had discussed her fourth- through sixth-grade class, and STUDENT was still in third grade.
There is no dispute that STUDENT’s needs entitled him to an ESY program during the summer of 2001. However, in a letter dated June 14, 2001, addressed to the District’s counsel, Respondent’s counsel indicated that MOTHER disputed the appropriateness of the District’s offered program. Specifically, MOTHER disputed the lack of provision of OT and VT. MOTHER also disagreed that the IEP team reviewed all of the appropriate assessments, contending that the multidisciplinary members of the IEP team did not have sufficient time to make an independent review of the OT and VT assessments. (Resp.’s Exh. 118.)
Extended school year programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. (Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b).) In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043; compare with 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(a)(2).) Section 3043 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations defines such students in the following manner:
Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition.
Where a child has been determined eligible for ESY services by his or her IEP team, the written IEP must include an ESY program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(b)(3); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b)(1)(ii).)
For the 2001 extended school year, the District offered STUDENT placement at Stone Avenue Elementary School in the District. (Pet.’s Exh. 100.)(Footnote 22) The District offered STUDENT an ESY placement for the period of July 2 through August 7, 2001, from 8:00 a.m. through 12:30 p.m., Monday through Thursday. Transportation was offered and the class curriculum was focused on remediation of language arts and mathematics deficits. STUDENT was offered a one-to-one aide and the opportunity to continue participating in the Lindamood-Bell phonemic awareness program as a part of his program. Speech and language services were offered on a twice-weekly basis, in 30-minute sessions. STUDENT attended Stone Avenue Elementary School during the 2001 ESY.
The Hearing Officer finds that Respondent’s challenges to the District’s lack of offer of VT and OT unpersuasive for the same reasons stated above. Those reasons, in short, were that STUDENT did not require VT or OT in order to benefit from his education. Additionally, although MOTHER contends that the IEP team did not review all of the appropriate assessments, the June 5, 2001 IEP team summary states that the assessments reviewed included Dr. Patterson’s (revised) report of 9/00 (1/01); Loma Linda OT report of 3/00; OT report by Dr. Lindquist 2/01; and his current NPS teacher in the classroom informal assessment. Dr. Kohn report 7/17/2000 and the report of 8/4/2000 from Benjamin Kohn was reviewed by the team. Kohn report recommendations were reviewed (report provided by parent) The APE (Adaptive Physical Education) 10/99 District report by John DeMor was reviewed. The results of Dr. Bescoby’s independent (requested by District) vision therapy report/assessment were also reviewed.
(Pet.’s Exh. 98, pg. 14.) MOTHER attended the June 5, 2001 IEP along with her counsel; however, nowhere on the IEP document does it state that the IEP team failed to review any appropriate assessments.
During his 2001 ESY program, STUDENT received instruction in a group and on a one-to-one basis, with a program, goals, and objectives that were focused to address his demonstrated needs in the areas of language arts (including reading) and mathematics. STUDENT’s 2001 ESY program also provided him the structure and individual attention that helped to minimize his misbehavior and maintain his attention. Additionally, as reflected in his 2001 ESY report card, STUDENT made satisfactory progress on all of the standard topics taught in reading, writing, and math. (Pet.’s Exh. 105.) The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offered placement in a special day class at Stone Avenue Elementary School for the 2001 ESY was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, provided him with educational benefit, and prevented regression.(Footnote 23)
4. If the District failed to make a FAPE available to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 ESY, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for STUDENT’s placement at Summit View during the 2000-2001 school year, including the extended school year and transportation costs?
In light of the conclusion reached in Issue 3, that the District had a duty to develop an IEP for STUDENT during the 2000-2001 school year and that it failed to make a FAPE available to STUDENT during the 2000-2001 regular school year, there exists a basis upon which to award reimbursement for expenses related to the parents’ unilateral placement of STUDENT at Summit View during the 2000-2001 regular school year. However, given the Hearing Officer’s decision that the District provided STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001 ESY, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for any costs incurred during the 2001 ESY.
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).) The Burlington rule of reimbursement is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the IDEA. (Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).) Parents are expressly exempted from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. (Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993).)
For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student’s IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the State. (Id. at 13-14.) Although the Court recognized that the parents’ placement does not have to meet a standard as high as that required of a school district, the parents’ placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. (Id.) In summary, to be entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private services, it must be determined that (1) the student was denied a FAPE, and (2) the student’s private placement or program addresses the student’s educational needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him or her with educational benefit.
In this case, Respondent seeks reimbursement for his attendance at Summit View and for transportation costs. Given the Hearing Officer’s determination that the District failed to make a FAPE available to STUDENT during the regular 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT’s placement at Summit View constitutes replacement services for services that the District failed to provide.(Footnote 24) Therefore, Respondent may be entitled to reimbursement for replacement of educational services for the 2000-2001 school year, if the replacement school is generally appropriate and the parents are not barred from recovery based on equitable considerations. (See Burlington, supra, 471 U.S. 359, 370.)
First, the District failed to make STUDENT a timely offer for the 2000-2001 regular school year. Second, the evidence indicates that the Summit View placement met STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Ms. Studer, STUDENT’s Summit View teacher, testified that during the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT was in her mixed second- and third-grade class, where he received instruction in phonemic awareness using the Lindamood-Bell multisensory program. Ms. Studer had no aide in her class during the 2000-2001 school year because she had only four students. According to Ms. Studer, STUDENT fit well into the class since it had a small-group setting where he received a great deal of one-on-one attention from her. Ms. Studer testified that she had a lot of opportunity to sit individually with STUDENT at least once a week and review reading strategies, in addition to the normal one-on-one that he received. Ms. Studer reported that STUDENT was reading much better during the 2000-2001 school year. Ms. Studer also stated that for students who have difficulty with mental effort and completing tasks, she does a great deal of repetition and uses a direct teaching approach that includes questions and answers to ensure the students are listening. In his program, STUDENT worked on reading, writing, math, and pragmatics, including morphological skills, sentence structures, daily living skills, and addition and subtraction. Additionally, Ms. Studer also utilized a class-wide behavior system, which was further individualized for STUDENT. STUDENT worked on cooperation skills, and according to Ms. Studer, he was very honest and very enthusiastic about helping to determine the rewards and consequences associated with the class behavior plan. Ms. Studer testified that her students are very motivated and that STUDENT now asks for more homework and harder things to do. The Hearing Officer finds that Summit View’s program adequately addressed STUDENT’s speech and language, behavior, attentional, and reading needs.
Because Respondent was denied a FAPE during the 2000-2001 regular school year, and the Summit View program met his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, Respondent is entitled to reimbursement, albeit on a limited basis, for the reasons discussed below.
As discussed above in issue 3, the evidence establishes that the parents hindered the IEP process. Although the parties were engaged in a due process hearing at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, the focus of the parties should have remained on the identification of STUDENT’s needs and the development of an appropriate educational program that would meet his needs. The parents’ refusal to participate in an IEP meeting without first knowing the placement that the District intended to offer thwarted attempts the District might have made to address concerns that MOTHER had regarding the September and October 1999 IEPs and to develop an IEP and offer a placement for the 2000-2001 school year. The parents’ refusal to participate made it more difficult for the District to develop an IEP for the 2000-2001 school year because, while the District technically could have held an IEP meeting without the parents’ participation, it would not have had all of the current information about STUDENT with which to develop an appropriate IEP, particularly since he had not been in a District program since January 2000.
Notwithstanding the parents’ unreasonableness in refusing to participate, the evidence establishes that by January 22, 2001, the District had been served with most of the current information regarding STUDENT’s levels of performance and progress, including Dr. Patterson’s September 2000 psychoeducational evaluation, the optometrists’ reports through August 2000, the Loma Linda Medical Center OT reports through February 2000, STUDENT’s Summit View school work, report cards, and progress reports through December 2000, Dr. Tibbetts’ April 2000 Summit View classroom observation and teacher/staff interview, and counseling notes. Therefore, as of January 22, 2001, the District had sufficient information to conduct an IEP meeting without STUDENT’s parents.
The refusal of the parents to attend an IEP meeting did not relieve the District of its obligation to timely make a FAPE available to STUDENT. However, where, as here, a school district is attempting to fulfill the mandate of the IDEA and the parents unreasonably refuse to participate, “equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning relief.” (Burlington, supra 471 U.S. at 374; Florence County School District Four, et al., v. Carter, (1993) 510 U.S. 7, 16.) Essentially, the parents withheld information from the District and refused to attend an IEP meeting for approximately one semester. Therefore, in balancing the equities, the Hearing Officer finds that such actions warrant reducing the parents’ reimbursement award for the costs of Summit View tuition (including speech and language services) and transportation costs for the 2000-2001 regular school year by one-half.(Footnote 25)
5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment and site visit performed by Dr. Robert Patterson in August and September 1999 respectively?
Respondent contends that his parents should be reimbursed for the psychoeducational study and site observation performed by Dr. Robert Patterson in August and September 1999, respectively. A parent may obtain an independent educational assessment performed by a qualified specialist at public expense if (1) the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the educational agency and (2) the educational agency is unable to show that its assessment was appropriate at a due process hearing. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b).) Federal and State special education law provide that before any action can be taken with regard to the placement of a child in special education, an assessment of the student’s educational needs shall be conducted. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320.) When a parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency, the parent has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense, unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency’s assessment was appropriate. (Education Code § 56329(b).)
MOTHER testified that, in general, she agreed with school psychologist Lana Clauder’s observations in her January 1999 report, including notations that STUDENT was impulsive and had inefficient attention skills and anger control. MOTHER did not testify that she disagreed with the District’s psychoeducational assessment. Additionally, notations on the September 16, 1999 IEP state that “Dr. Patterson wrote an updated report, which was discussed by team members.” Thus, it appears that the purpose of Dr. Patterson’s August 1999 assessment and report was to update his previous 1998 report. Dr. Patterson’s August 1999 report states that the reason STUDENT’s parents referred STUDENT to him was that “STUDENT has had extreme difficulties this past school year so his parents brought him in for a reassessment.” It does not state that his parents brought him in for a second opinion or that they disagreed with the District’s previously completed psychoeducational evaluation. Thus, there was no indication that the parents sought the assessment because they disagreed with an assessment the District had performed or with a refusal by the District to assess.
According to Mr. Tibbetts, during the September 1999 IEP meeting, there was no objection to the IEP’s goals and objectives, to the District’s assessments, or with regard to STUDENT’s present levels of performance. Mr. Tibbetts stated that he believed that MOTHER was only concerned with the proposed placement.
The evidence also does not support a finding that Dr. Patterson’s September 1999 site visit to the proposed placement at Ina was done to dispute any previous site observation. Rather, the evidence suggests that Dr. Patterson’s site observation was to provide STUDENT’s parents with outside assistance in making an individual determination regarding the appropriateness of the District’s proposed placement.
Even if the parents had disagreed with the District’s psychoeducational assessment, the testimony of District psychologist Lana Clauder established that the District’s assessment met the requirements of the law, including California Education Code section 56320, and was appropriate. Ms. Clauder credibly testified that the tests she administered were not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory, and were presented in STUDENT’s primary language. Ms. Clauder also stated that she tested STUDENT’s specific areas of need and that she used a variety of assessment tools and strategies and technically sound instruments. STUDENT wore his glasses during the assessment and they took breaks when he became restless. Ms. Clauder testified that she took into account different types of assessments, each of which were valid for the specific purpose for which they were used. Ms. Clauder also indicated that she assessed STUDENT in all areas of his suspected disability. As a school psychologist with a substantial background as an educational diagnostician, Ms. Clauder demonstrated that she was knowledgeable of STUDENT’s general special education needs and trained to administer the assessment tests. Respondent did not present any evidence to refute the credible testimony of Ms. Clauder with respect to this issue.
In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that Respondent did not disagree with the District’s psychoeducational assessment and that the District conducted an appropriate psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT. Consequently, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for expenses related to the assessment and site observation they obtained from Dr. Patterson in August and September 1999.
6. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the areas of occupational therapy, vision therapy, and reading remediation?
In light of the Hearing Officer’s decision above regarding occupational therapy and vision therapy, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education in those areas. With regard to reading remediation, the Hearing Officer considers whether compensatory education is warranted.
Compensatory education is an equitable remedy that may be available when the school district has failed to provide the student with appropriate, special education services. (Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; see also S.V. v. Sherwood School District 75 F.Supp.2d 1153, 1157 (D. Oregon, 1999).) Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” (Puyallup School District, supra, 31 F.3d at 1497.)
Given the Hearing Officer’s conclusion above that Summit View met STUDENT’s unique needs and provided him educational benefit during the 2000-2001 regular school year, and given the Hearing Officer’s decision to award the parents reimbursement for one-half the cost of Summit View tuition and transportation costs incurred during that time, compensatory education is not necessary because STUDENT was appropriately educated during that time frame, and therefore, there was neither opportunity lost nor time missed.
ORDER
1. Within 30 calendar days of the District’s receipt of proof of STUDENT parents’ payment for Summit View tuition (including speech and language services) and transportation costs for the 2000-2001 regular school year, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS for one-half of the proven costs of the Summit View tuition (including speech and language services) and one-half of the transportation costs.
2. All of Respondent’s remaining claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement.
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year, including the 2000 extended school year (ESY)?
The District prevailed on this issue.
2. If the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, including the ESY, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for STUDENT’s placement at Summit View from January 2000 through the end of that school year?
The District prevailed on this issue.
3. Did the District make a FAPE available to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 ESY?
The District prevailed in part and Respondent prevailed in part.
4. If the District failed to make a FAPE available to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 ESY, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for STUDENT’s placement at Summit View during the 2000-2001 school year, including the extended school year and transportation costs?
The District prevailed in part and Respondent prevailed in part.
5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent evaluation and site visit performed by Dr. Robert Patterson in August and September 1999 respectively?
The District prevailed on this issue.
6. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the areas of occupational therapy, vision therapy, and reading remediation?
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: December 28, 2001 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Please note that the Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number. 2. The Hearing Officer regrets that this hearing lasted for an unusually extended period of time. During the course of this hearing, there were a number of serious incidents that protracted the hearing, such as deaths in the families of Respondent’s attorney and the Hearing Officer, separate incidents of illness and injury of Respondent’s mother, who attended each day of the hearing, and Respondent’s change of attorneys. 3. At all IEP meetings that she attended, Tamara Elzig was noted on the IEP document as Tamara Concannon, her former name. 4. The behavioral reinforcements and interventions implemented by the District for STUDENTare in sharp contrast to the “behavioral intervention plans” that are developed pursuant to the Hughes bill. A Hughes bill behavioral intervention plan is a much more elaborate program designed to address serious behavior problems that significantly interfere with the implementation of the goals and objectives of an individual’s IEP. 5. Normally, the Respondent does not raise issues, absent a cross-filing. However, in this case, the parties agreed that the issues and remedies as stated by both parties would be heard and decided. Additionally, since the District had raised the question of remedies for each of the years of FAPE at issue, it is precluded from limiting the consideration of remedies only to those remedies it has raised. The hearing process is designed to resolve issues in a comprehensive and expedient manner. Therefore, the Hearing Officer’s consideration of remedies that were raised by Respondent is appropriate in the interest of judicial economy. 6. The Hearing Officer notes that at the beginning of this hearing, Respondent initially argued that his goals and objectives were generally not appropriate. However, Respondent later refined his argument to state that the goals and objectives ineffectively addressed his behaviors. 7. Dr. Patterson previously conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT in August 1998. (Pet.’s Exh. 19.) 8. Hereafter, references to a “behavioral intervention plan” (“BIP”) refers to a BIP designed pursuant to the Hughes bill. 9. The Hearing Officer notes that although Dr. Patterson recommended that STUDENT receive a speech and language assessment, the District’s speech and language pathologist had already conducted such an assessment in January 1999. Dr. Patterson testified that at the time that he conducted his assessment, Respondent’s parent had not provided him with a copy of Ms. Martinez’s speech and language report, and therefore, he had no knowledge that a speech and language assessment had been previously performed. 10. The Hearing Officer notes that the specific behavioral assessment sought by the Respondent in the instant case is an FAA pursuant to California law. An FAA (also called a “Hughes bill assessment”) pursuant to state law is a Hughes bill term, and is a highly complicated process that is required when a student has a“serious behavior problem” as defined by State law. 11. Mr. Tibbetts was a member of the task force that wrote the Hughes bill. 12. The Hearing Officer notes that Mr. Fischbach also testified that he is not licensed to implement behavior modification plans, nor is he a licensed psychologist. Mr. Fischbach did not observe STUDENT in any classes at any time, and did not draft a report concerning his review. Additionally, the Hearing Officer is also cautious in reviewing Mr. Fischbach’s testimony and gives it less weight, given his admission that he was guaranteed an hourly rate beyond his paid standard retainer if the parent prevailed at this hearing, thus indicating that Mr. Fischbach had a potential financial interest in the outcome of this hearing. 13. Ms. Hogerty testified that some of STUDENT’s behavioral issues could be attributed to his coming to school late and his being pulled from his regular class to attend RSP class. 14. Mr. Tibbetts testified that he has two masters’ degrees, one in behavioral psychology and the other in social work with an emphasis in children and youth. He also has a Ph.D in clinical psychology and a juris doctor degree. He is certified nationally as a behavioral analyst and holds credentials as a multisubject teacher and learning handicapped specialist. He is a certified school psychologist and a licensed clinical and educational psychologist. Mr. Tibbetts currently serves as the administrator of education support services for the District, where he directly supervises the District’s psychologists, speech and language therapists, school nurses, and two of the program specialists. He also holds credentials as an education administrator and in pupil personnel services. 15. Ms. Cadiente testified that she has a bachelor of science and master’s degrees in communicative disorders and that she is authorized to conduct speech and language therapy. 16. Ms. Lewis testified that she has a bachelor’s degree in occupational therapy and a master’s degree in physical therapy (PT). She is a registered occupational therapist, and since 1993, she has operated as a State-certified nonpublic agency as an occupational therapist that serves students in public schools. 17. The Hearing Officer notes that although Ms. Lewis’ report references the State of California’s guidelines for OT and PT, these guidelines have no authority over Hearing Office decisions. Therefore, to the extent that Ms. Lewis’s report relied on those guidelines, the Hearing Office disregarded those references. 18. Mr. Lindquist is a licensed clinical psychologist and a licensed occupational therapist. He has been in private practice since 1984 as an occupational therapist. He currently performs psychotherapy and conducts neuropsychological assessments of children. He also consults with teachers as a psychologist and occupational therapist. 19. On October 27, 1999, a pediatric occupational therapy evaluation was completed by occupational therapist Julie Kuto at the Loma Linda University Medical Center. (Resp.’s Exh. 76.) However, the clinical observation results of her written report are not clear because there is no analysis or summary made by the evaluator. Since Ms. Kuto did not testify at this hearing to offer explanation and clarification of her report, the Hearing Officer cannot rely on the inconclusive information contained in her report. 20. The Hearing Officer notes that although the parties identified the 2000 ESY as an issue for hearing, the parties were not in dispute regarding STUDENT’s need for ESY services. Additionally, there was no evidence offered that the District’s proposed program would have differed significantly for the 2000 ESY. Therefore, the Hearing Officer need not analyze the 2000 ESY apart from the 1999-2000 regular school year. 21. The District notes in its closing brief the fact that MOTHER wrote a check totaling $7,835.38 dated July 21, 2000, made payable to Summit View, $7,000.00 of which stated it was for “deposit for year 00-01.” (Pet.’s Exh. 70.) However, the Hearing Officer also notes that Summit View’s enrollment agreement states that a refund will be provided if a school district approves nonpublic school funding after the parents have paid tuition. (Resp.’s Exh. 75.) 22. At the June 5, 2001 IEP meeting, the District was not yet aware who was going to be the ESY teacher, so when that information later became available, the District informed STUDENT’s parents that ESY services would be provided at Stone Avenue Elementary School. (Testimony of Terry Tibbetts.) 23. Respondent did not allege nonconformity with the IEP for the 2001 ESY. Therefore, the Hearing Officer does not address this issue. 24. The District made a belated June 5, 2001 offer of a FAPE just 12 days prior to the end of the 2000-2001 school year, which MOTHER legitimately understood applied to the subsequent school year. 25. The Hearing Officer notes that the Summit View invoices indicate that STUDENTreceived speech and language and counseling services as a part of his program during the 2000-2001 school year. (Pet.’s Exh. 97.) As a case was not made that STUDENT needed counseling services, Respondent’s award does not include the related service of counseling.
