California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 6, 1996

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 69-96 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Los Angeles Unified's special day class was inappropriate for a deaf, autistic student; School for the Deaf placement continues and behavior plan ordered.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None stated. The decision notes an earlier SEHO ruling by Hearing Officer F. Richard Ruderman that CSDR had become the student's placement, and that she remained there under a stay-put order.

Summary

The mother of a girl, nearly 10, who is deaf and autistic requested a hearing after the California School for the Deaf, Riverside (CSDR) found she did not meet its admission criteria and proposed returning her to a Los Angeles Unified special day class at Marlton School. She stayed at CSDR under a stay-put order. CSDR was dismissed by a stipulation that said it would keep serving her if the district could not offer an appropriate program. The district asked to postpone the hearing because a staff member would be on vacation. That request was denied, and no one appeared for the district. The Hearing Officer denied the parent's motion for summary judgment and decided the case on the evidence.

Three experts testified without contradiction: Gisele Ragusa, Dr. Edward Ritvo, and Dr. Robert Byrd. The mother also testified. The Hearing Officer found the student needed a behavioral intervention plan. She found the Marlton class inappropriate because signing was sporadic, it lacked structure, the school day was only six hours, and classmates were aggressive. CSDR's structured, 24-hour signing environment was appropriate. The district must arrange a behavior assessment within 15 days and complete it within 30. It must hold an IEP meeting within 35 days and implement the plan within 40. It must also arrange for CSDR to keep serving the student. The Hearing Officer denied the request for attorney's fees for lack of authority.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a district's failure to appear: the hearing went forward and unrebutted expert testimony decided the placement. It also shows a deaf student with autism being found to need a full-day total communication setting plus a behavior plan, and SEHO's position that it could not award attorney's fees.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1. Does STUDENT require a behavioral intervention plan to benefit from her education and to meet her unique and individual needs?

    Based on undisputed testimony from the mother and three experts, the student needs a behavioral intervention plan, developed after an assessment by a qualified behavioral intervention specialist, to increase eye contact and attention and reduce stigmatizing behaviors.

  2. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Has the District offered an appropriate educational placement and related services for STUDENT?

    The Marlton special day class was not appropriate: it lacked a total communication environment and consistent signing, was not structured enough for a student with autism, ran only six hours a day, and had peers who were poor behavior models.

  3. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3. Is the California School for the Deaf at Riverside an appropriate placement for STUDENT?

    Unrebutted testimony showed CSDR is appropriate because it offers a structured, 24-hour total communication program with appropriate peers.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to assess. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, District shall arrange for a qualified behavioral intervention specialist to assess the student's behavior; the assessment must be completed within 30 calendar days of the decision.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 35 calendar days of the decision, District shall convene an IEP team to develop a behavioral intervention plan to increase eye contact and attention to task, reduce stigmatizing behaviors, and reinforce alternative appropriate behaviors.
  • Order to provide or change services. Within 40 calendar days of the decision, District shall implement the behavioral intervention plan.
  • Placement ordered. By stipulation of the parties, District shall arrange for the California School for the Deaf, Riverside to continue providing the student with special education and services.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16)-(18); Education Code § 56363; Education Code § 56505; Education Code § 56507

People named in the decision

  • Meredith A. Goetz, attorney for Student
  • Pat Huth, attorney, director of advocacy services, Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center
  • Penny L. Valentine, Director of Pupil Personnel Services (requested continuance), California School for the Deaf, Riverside
  • Barry A. Zolotar, attorney for CSDR (signed dismissal stipulation), California School for the Deaf, Riverside
  • Leonard Garfinkel, Hearing Officer who ruled on continuance motions, Special Education Hearing Office
  • F. Richard Ruderman, Hearing Officer who earlier found CSDR was the student's placement, Special Education Hearing Office
  • Shirley H. Brown, District coordinator of student services (sought continuance; did not appear), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Arti Nell King, person outside the District coordinator's office on hearing day, Los Angeles Unified School District (apparent)
  • Beverly G. Watkins, District director of special education, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Gisele Ragusa, expert witness for Student; assistant professor who conducted an environmental assessment, Pacific Oaks College
  • Edward Ritvo, M.D., expert witness for Student; autism specialist, professor emeritus, Neuropsychiatric Institute, UCLA School of Medicine
  • Robert Byrd, Psy.D., expert witness for Student; clinical psychologist who conducted a psychological evaluation, Saint John's Hospital and Health Center
  • California School for the Deaf, Riverside, state residential school for the deaf; student's placement
  • Marlton School, District school with special day class offered by District, Los Angeles Unified School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 69-96 Case Year: 1996 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Designated Instructionand Services Placement CDS Code: 19-64733 District: Los Angeles Unified Disability Type: Autism Hearing Impaired

Case Details This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Los Angeles, California, on May 2, 1996.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Meredith A. Goetz. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were STUDENT's mother, and attorney Pat Huth, director of advocacy services, Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center. No one appeared on behalf of Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (District).

Oral and documentary evidence was received. At the request of Petitioner's representative, the record was held open to allow her to submit a written closing brief. Petitioner's closing brief was received on May 9, 1996. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) Does STUDENT require a behavioral intervention plan to benefit from her education and to meet her unique and individual needs?

(2) Has the District offered an appropriate educational placement and related services for STUDENT?

(3) Is the California School for the Deaf at Riverside an appropriate placement for STUDENT?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Failure of Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District to appear at hearing.

On January 25, 1996, the Special Education Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from MOTHER on behalf of her daughter, STUDENT. MOTHER indicated that the issue for hearing related to attempts by the California School for the Deaf in Riverside (CSDR) and the District to terminate STUDENT's placement at CSDR. MOTHER named both CSDR and the District as respondents in this matter. The Hearing Office set the hearing for February 20 and 21, 1996. By agreement of the parties, the hearing was continued several times. On March 22, 1996, the Hearing Office notified the parties of the May 2 and 3, 1996, dates for hearing.

On April 1, 1996, the Hearing Office received a request from Penny L. Valentine, Director of Pupil Personnel Services for CSDR, to continue the hearing from May 2 and 3, 1996, to a later date. Ms. Valentine stated that a continuance was needed because CSDR's legal representative would not be available on the dates set for hearing. On April 12, 1996, Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel denied the motion for a continuance because there was "insufficient information to determine whether CSD's counsel has a conflict on the scheduled hearing dates that constitutes good cause."

On April 25, 1996, the Hearing Officer received another request to continue the hearing. Shirley H. Brown, District coordinator of student services, stated that a continuance was needed because she would be "out of town on vacation" on the dates set for hearing. On April 25, 1996, Petitioner stated the following reasons for opposing any continuance of the hearing: the motion for a continuance was untimely in that the current hearing dates had been set since March 22, 1996; Petitioner's three expert witnesses had adjusted their schedules to arrange to appear at the hearing on May 2-3, 1996; Petitioner's mother had been under a great deal of stress because of the dispute regarding Petitioner's placement; and Petitioner is entitled to a speedy resolution of the dispute. On April 25, 1996, Hearing Officer Garfinkel determined that Ms. Brown's vacation did not constitute good cause for a continuance and denied the District's motion to continue the hearing.

Following receipt of the order denying the continuance, Ms. Brown submitted a motion for reconsideration in which she stated the following additional reasons to support her request for a continuance: the District has another special education due process hearing scheduled on the same dates; "there is no other individual in the Los Angeles Unified District that has the expertise to represent the district in a special education hearing"; if an administrator were to attend the hearing, he/she would "be unable to present a case for the District or to respond to the issues...."; and if the District attempted "to retain counsel to represent them in this matter, counsel would not have sufficient time to prepare...." On April 26, 1996, Hearing Officer Garfinkel denied the District's motion to reconsider its request for a continuance for the following reasons: the other case in which the District was involved had been rescheduled; Ms. Brown's vacation did not constitute good cause to continue the hearing; and the District had sufficient time to prepare for this hearing, which had been scheduled on May 2-3 since March 22, 1996.

Special education law requires that the hearing be completed and a written decision mailed to the parties within 45 days of receipt of the request for hearing. California Education Code § 56505(f). A continuance of the hearing may be granted for good cause, which extends the period for rendering a decision accordingly.

The hearing was set to begin at 9:30 a.m. on May 2, 1996, in Room H-120 at the main offices of the Los Angeles Unified School District. Ms. Brown's office is located in Room H-120. No one appeared on behalf of the District at the time and place for the hearing. At approximately 9:45 a.m., the Hearing Office inquired of Arti Nell King, who was seated outside of Ms. Brown's office, if a District representative would be present at the hearing. Ms. King indicated that she did not have any information regarding a District representative. The Hearing Officer then inquired at the office of Beverly G. Watkins, District director of special education, whether the District would be sending a representative to the hearing. Ms. Watkins was not in her office and the Hearing Officer was directed back to Ms. Brown's office. The Hearing Officer also contacted the Special Education Hearing Office to ascertain whether the District had left a message with the Hearing Officer regarding whether a representative for the District would be present at the hearing. It had not.

The Hearing Officer determined that the District had been properly notified of the time and place for hearing. On March 22, 1996, the Hearing Office notified the parties of the dates and time for hearing. All requests for a continuance had been denied. For these reasons, at approximately 10:00 a.m., the Hearing Officer concluded that the hearing would go forward in the absence of Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District.

Dismissal of California School for the Blind, Riverside, as a Respondent.

At the beginning of the hearing, Petitioner's representative indicated that the parties had stipulated to dismiss respondent CSDR. The stipulation, which is signed on behalf of the District by Ms. Brown, by attorney Barry A. Zolotar on behalf of CSDR, and by Ms. Goetz on behalf of Petitioner, reads as follows:

All of the parties have agreed to the dismissal of Respondent, California School for the Deaf, Riverside (CSD-R) from this matter. This action is reasonably based upon Petitioner's Statement of Issue: Has Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) offered appropriate educational placement and related services to STUDENT, and the fact that STUDENT is currently receiving special education instruction at CSD-R.

In the event that the Special Education Hearing Office rules that LAUSD cannot provide STUDENT with an appropriate special education, CSD-R will continue to provide special education and related services to her.

(Petitioner's Exhibit Q)

Based on the stipulation of the parties, as set forth above, the Hearing Officer dismissed CSDR as a respondent in this matter.

Petitioner's Motion for Summary Judgment

At the beginning of the hearing, Petitioner's representative made a motion for summary judgment. Petitioner contended that the motion for summary should be granted for the following reasons:

(1) on June 29, 1995, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in a 24-hour per day total communication environment;

(2) in September 1995, STUDENT entered CSDR for an assessment;

(3) Hearing Officer F. Richard Ruderman determined that STUDENT had been receiving special education and services at CSDR for "such a long time" that CSDR constituted a placement;

(4) CSDR no longer disputes STUDENT's placement at CSDR;

(5) the District is proposing to change STUDENT's placement and, therefore, bears the burden of proof at the hearing to demonstrate that it has an appropriate placement for STUDENT; and (6) by failing to submit a statement of issues, proposed resolution of the issues, evidence, or a list of witnesses for the hearing, as required by California Education Code § 56505(e)(6 and (7), the District has failed to meet its burden.

There are no provisions for summary judgement in the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), federal regulations, or state special education law. Moreover, the IDEA defines "special education" as "specifically designed instruction...to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). Thus, the underlying policy governing decisions regarding the education of students with disabilities is that such decisions must be made on a case by case basis to meet the unique and individual needs of the student. In this case, STUDENT has multiple disabilities and requires a unique combination of special services to address her needs. For these reasons, it is particularly important that decisions regarding her placement and services are made based on the expertise of the professionals who have assessed and observed her, and on the information available from her mother. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concluded that it was in the best interest of STUDENT to conduct the evidentiary hearing and to make a decision regarding her placement and need for related services on the testimony presented at the hearing. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer denied Petitioner's motion for summary judgment.

Petitioner's request for attorney's fees

As part of the relief requested on behalf of Petitioner, Ms. Goetz requested in her closing brief that the Hearing Officer order the District to "pay all of Petitioner's costs and attorney's fees associated with preparing for and appearing at this hearing." Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the Hearing Officer must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided as a result of the due process hearing. The Hearing Officer, however, does not have authority to award attorney's fees. Subsection (b) of Section 56507 states that an award of attorney's fees to a prevailing parent or student "may only be made either with the agreement of the parties following the conclusion of the administrative hearing process or by a court of competent jurisdiction pursuant to paragraph (4) of subsection (e) of Section 1415 of Title 20 of the United States Code." The decision below indicates the prevailing party on each issue heard and decided; however, based on the lack of jurisdiction to award attorney's fees and costs, the Hearing Officer denies Ms. Goetz's request for an order to the District to pay for attorney's fees and costs.

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner STUDENT will be 10 years old in July 1996. She has a severe to profound bilateral hearing loss and is autistic. According to an assessment conducted by the California School for the Deaf in Riverside (CSDR), STUDENT is mentally retarded and, at the time of testing, was functioning at the overall developmental age of 30 months. (Exhibit O) STUDENT currently attends the residential program at CSDR.

Prior to moving to California with her mother in March 1995, STUDENT received early intervention services, participated in a Head Start preschool program, and attended schools for the deaf in Maryland and Louisiana. On March 14, 1995, STUDENT enrolled in the District and was placed in a special day class (SDC) at Marlton School. STUDENT's IEP dated May 6, 1995, includes goals and objectives to improve expressive and receptive language, self-help, pre-vocational, and social skills. There also is a goal to increase socially appropriate behaviors. (Exhibit C) On June 29, 1995, the IEP team reconvened to discuss the results of a recent brain stem evoked hearing test. At the IEP meeting, MOTHER requested that STUDENT be placed at CSDR. The IEP states that the team recommended that STUDENT participate in a "24 hour total communication educational school environment." (Exhibit B)

On September 11, 1995, STUDENT began attending CSDR for a 30-day assessment. The initial meeting to review the assessment was continued several times and, on October 18, 1995, the assessment period was extended for an additional 30 days. At the CSDR review meeting on November 27, 1995, CSDR staff identified problems with STUDENT in the dormitory setting and her teacher noted some progress in the classroom. At that meeting, it was concluded that STUDENT would remain at CSDR to allow the staff to further observe STUDENT prior to making a decision regarding STUDENT's eligibility for placement at CSDR. A new assessment plan was then developed and the next review meeting was set for January 8, 1996. The meeting took place on January 23, 1996. At the meeting, CSDR representatives concluded that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria for CSDR and proposed that she return to Marlton on January 29, 1996. STUDENT has remained at CSDR pursuant to a stay-put order.

Petitioner asserts that to meet her unique and individual needs she requires a 24-hour per day total communication program and an intensive behavioral intervention program. Petitioner contends that the SDC at Marlton is not an appropriate placement because it does not offer a 24-hour total communication program, does not offer an appropriate peer group, and is not sufficiently structured to meet Petitioner's needs. Petitioner contends that, with the addition of a behavioral intervention program, CSDR offers Petitioner an appropriate placement.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

STUDENT's mother testified that when she enrolled STUDENT in the District, she expressed an interest in STUDENT attending CSDR. The District informed her, however, that STUDENT could not be referred to CSDR until she had been in a District program for at least 30 days. MOTHER testified that at the IEP meeting in May 1995, the District questioned the level of STUDENT's hearing impairment and told MOTHER that she needed to obtain a current assessment of STUDENT's hearing. A subsequent brain stem assessment of STUDENT confirmed that she is deaf. MOTHER testified that at home, STUDENT is able to dress and feed herself. She also is able to do other tasks with firm encouragement. MOTHER testified that STUDENT requires a highly structured and routine educational environment that emphasizes development of language and self-help skills. MOTHER testified that STUDENT also requires an intensive behavioral intervention program to help her learn to focus. MOTHER stated that STUDENT needs to be able to focus to learn signs so that she will be able to increase her communication skills. MOTHER testified that because the diagnosis of autism was made within the past year, STUDENT has not previously participated in an intense behavioral intervention program. MOTHER testified that STUDENT previously was diagnosed with a hearing impairment and mental retardation.

MOTHER testified that the SDC at Marlton is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT. The class does not offer an appropriate peer group for STUDENT. The six students in the class, all of whom are boys, have a wide range of disabilities. MOTHER testified that STUDENT's first language is American Sign Language (ASL); however, none of the students in the SDC are proficient at signing and most of the students do not sign at all. According to MOTHER, the instructional assistant is also not proficient at signing nor does the teacher employ a total communication system. MOTHER testified that the teacher does not sign all communication that goes on in and outside of the classroom. MOTHER testified that the class is unstructured and, during the period STUDENT was in the SDC, she modeled the inappropriate behavior of the other students. For example, she began to lick herself. MOTHER testified that a major portion of the six-hour school day was spent in physical education activities, lunch, and walking back-and-forth to the gym or cafeteria.

MOTHER testified that CSDR, whose purpose is to education children who are deaf, is an appropriate placement for STUDENT because CSDR offers a total communication program in which signing is encouraged and a highly structured special education program with appropriate peers. CSDR also offers opportunities for STUDENT to integrate with non-special education deaf peers.

Gisele Ragusa, assistant professor at Pacific Oaks College, is currently a doctoral candidate in special education and holds several special education credentials. For the past 14 years, Ms. Ragusa has conducted assessments and made placement recommendations for special education students. In February 1996, Ms. Ragusa conducted an "environmental assessment" of STUDENT, which included the following: a review of recent assessments and IEPs; four hours of interaction with STUDENT and her mother at their home; four hours of observation and discussion of STUDENT with her teacher at CSDR; and 1.5 hours of classroom observation and conversations with the principal and teacher at Marlton. (See Exhibits E and F) Ms. Ragusa testified that STUDENT's motor skills are age appropriate. STUDENT is able to toilet independently and to do some independent living skills such as dressing. STUDENT is able to engage in some parallel play; however, her social skills are delayed. Ms. Ragusa testified that STUDENT requires a consistent behavioral intervention plan to address inappropriate behaviors that are interfering with STUDENT's ability to communicate.

Ms. Ragusa testified that, for the following reasons, the Marlton SDC is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT: the teacher does not sign consistently; not all of the students sign; the students do not employ alternative communication methods nor do they have assisted technology devices; the distance between STUDENT's home and the school is lengthy and, even if the bus does not make any other stops, it takes approximately one hour to travel each way; and the school is not safe for STUDENT. Ms. Ragusa testified that STUDENT goes by herself to the bathroom, which is located at the front of the school. The front gate of the school is open while students are present and STUDENT left the building on at least one occasion. Ms. Ragusa testified that the students in the class do not offer an appropriate peer group for STUDENT. They are aggressive and engage in self- stimulating behavior. Ms. Ragusa testified that during her observation of the class, the aggressive behavior escalated to the point that it was difficult for the teacher to maintain control over the students.

Ms. Ragusa testified that CSDR offers STUDENT an appropriate placement. It provides her with a total communication environment in which everyone signs. Ms. Ragusa testified that STUDENT experiences some problems at CSDR when the environment is less structured, for example, after class when STUDENT is in her dormitory.

Edward Ritvo, M.D., professor emeritus, Division of Mental Retardation and Child Psychiatry, the Neuropsychiatric Institute, University of California School of Medicine, Los Angeles, has extensive experience and is the author of many articles and books in the area of child and adult psychology. Dr. Ritvo testified that his "specialty" is children with autism. In February 1996, Dr. Ritvo reviewed STUDENT's medical records and observed STUDENT at CSDR. (See Exhibit G) He also observed the SDC at Marlton. Dr. Ritvo testified that STUDENT's capacity to communicate using symbolic language is very delayed and that she has only recently learned to model and to understand that signs are meaningful. Dr. Ritvo testified that STUDENT requires a behavioral intervention program to deal with behaviors that interfere with her ability to learn. Dr. Ritvo recommended that an assessment be conducted by a behavioral specialist, that a structured behavioral program be developed and implemented in all of STUDENT's environments, and that the program be reviewed in approximately six months. Dr. Ritvo testified that CSDR currently offers an appropriate program for STUDENT because it provides her with a structured environment, consistency across school and residential components, and offers appropriate communication models throughout the day. Dr. Ritvo testified that Marlton's program is only six hours per day, which would not meet STUDENT's need for services to continue in all of her environments.

Robert Byrd, Psy.D., clinical psychologist, is employed at the Saint John's Hospital and Health Center, which provides mental health services for deaf and hard of hearing people. In April 1996, at the request of the Lanterman Regional Center, Dr. Byrd completed a psychological evaluation of STUDENT. (See Exhibit D) Dr. Byrd testified that he has spent a total of over four hours with STUDENT. On April 3, 1996, he met with MOTHER for approximately two hours and obtained STUDENT's health and developmental history. On April 19, 1996, Dr. Byrd met with STUDENT and her mother and attempted unsuccessfully to administer to STUDENT the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised (PPVT- R). MOTHER completed the Achenbach Child Behavior Check List and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales. On April 20, 1996, Dr. Byrd was able to administer to STUDENT both the PPVT-R and the Expressive One Word Vocabulary Test-Revised (EOWVT-R). Dr. Byrd testified that STUDENT's receptive and expressive language scores fell just below the two-year old level and she is able to use approximately eight signs expressively and understands 20 to 25 signs receptively. Dr. Byrd testified that STUDENT's primary means of communication is by one-word statements.

Dr. Byrd recommended that STUDENT participate in a highly structured classroom that emphasizes behavior modification and ASL, and that has a low child-to-teacher ratio. He also recommended that a behavioral intervention specialist, who is knowledgeable about deaf culture, develop behavioral interventions for STUDENT to increase her eye contact, attention to task, and vocabulary, to decrease stigmatizing behaviors including hand flapping, licking, and teeth grinding, and to reinforce alternative acceptable behaviors. Dr. Byrd also recommended that a behavioral specialist work with STUDENT in the dormitory to increase STUDENT's self-help skills and independence and that a tutor work with STUDENT to help her learn survival signs and signs relevant to her environment. Dr. Byrd testified that STUDENT would benefit from a social skills group to provide her with opportunities to interact with other deaf children, to increase exposure to sign language, and to build appropriate social interactions. Dr. Byrd recommended an occupational therapy assessment because "autistic children have typically benefitted from this intervention."

Dr. Byrd testified that CSDR offers an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. At CSDR, STUDENT has access to information in all environments all of the time. CSDR also is structured. Dr. Byrd testified that STUDENT has not, however, had all of the appropriate pieces in place for her to fully benefit from her education. Dr. Byrd testified that STUDENT's program should be reevaluated after additional services are implemented for approximately six months to determine to what extent STUDENT has benefitted from the interventions.

On April 30, 1996, Dr. Byrd testified that he met with STUDENT's teacher at Marlton and observed the SDC for approximately 45 minutes. Dr. Byrd testified that Marlton is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT because it does not provide a total communication environment and there are no opportunities for STUDENT to generalize what she learns outside of the SDC. Dr. Byrd testified that

STUDENT's teacher demonstrated good command of ASL; however, the instructional assistants did not. Dr. Byrd testified that the teacher signed only intermittently when communicating directly with individual students. The teacher did not sign when she was communicating with aides or other persons in the room. Dr. Byrd testified that he also did not observe anyone signing on the playground, in the office, or in the hallways of the school. Dr. Byrd testified that based on research and on his experiences working with hearing impaired children, he has concluded that access to communication in all environments fosters the student's ability to communicate, lessens the student's disruptive behavior, and results in the student functioning more independently as an adult. Dr. Byrd testified that the aides were also not employing appropriate techniques to get the attention of the deaf students. He stated that the aides physically turned the students' heads to get their attention.

Dr. Byrd also expressed the opinion that the SDC staff does not have the expertise to work with hearing impaired students who are also autistic. Dr. Byrd testified that students with autism rely on structure and that "breaches" in structure result in students having behavioral problems and engaging in more stereotypical behavior. Dr. Byrd testified that the Marlton SDC was "loose and unstructured" and that students were wandering around the classroom. Dr. Byrd expressed concern that STUDENT would regress if she were to return to Marlton.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Does STUDENT require a behavioral intervention plan to benefit from her education and to meet her unique and individual needs?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.

The term "related services" includes transportation and other services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education, and psychological services.

All of the witnesses who appeared on behalf of STUDENT testified that she exhibits certain behaviors that interfere with her development of communication and other skills. The witnesses uniformly testified that, following an assessment by a qualified behavioral intervention specialist, a behavioral intervention plan should be designed to increase STUDENT's eye contact and her attention to task, to reduce stigmatizing behaviors, and to reinforce alternative appropriate behaviors. The witnesses also recommended that the behavioral intervention plan be implemented in all of STUDENT's environments and that the plan be re-evaluated in six months to determine whether STUDENT has benefitted from the additional services.

All of the witnesses who testified have assessed STUDENT, met with her mother and her teachers, and have observed her at school and during testing. The witnesses have impressive credentials and extensive experience working with children who have hearing impairments and/or autism. No one appeared on behalf of the District to dispute STUDENT's need for a behavioral intervention plan. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the undisputed recommendations of MOTHER, Ms. Ragusa, Dr. Ritvo, and Dr. Byrd, that to allow STUDENT to benefit from her education and to meet her unique and individual needs, STUDENT requires a behavioral intervention plan to increase eye contact and attention to task, to reduce stigmatizing behaviors, and to reinforce alternative appropriate behaviors. Therefore, the Hearing Office concludes that an appropriate behavioral intervention plan shall be developed following an assessment of STUDENT by a qualified behavioral intervention specialist.

ISSUE No. 2: Has the District offered an appropriate educational placement and related services for

STUDENT?

As stated above, an appropriate education for STUDENT must be designed to meet her unique and individual needs and allow her to benefit from her education, and must also conform to her IEP. The testimony of the witnesses and the reports of assessments presented as evidence at the hearing establish that STUDENT requires a highly structured milieu in which signing is used in all aspects of the program throughout the day. The evidence also establishes that STUDENT requires an educational program that emphasizes the development of communication and self-help skills.

All of the witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT concluded after observing the Marlton SDC that the class is not designed to meet STUDENT's needs related to her hearing impairment nor is it designed to meet her needs related to autism. MOTHER, Ms. Ragusa, Dr. Ritvo, and Dr. Byrd all testified that because of her hearing impairment, STUDENT requires a total communication environment in which signing is used for all communications. The Hearing Officer notes that it appears that in June 1995, the IEP team also had determined that STUDENT required a 24-hour total communication program. All of the witnesses concurred that the SDC does not offer a total communication program and that signing is sporadic. The witnesses all testified that the SDC teacher is the only proficient signer in the class and that signing is not routinely done in the classroom or outside of the classroom during other school activities. The SDC program also is a total of six hours per day and, therefore, not of sufficient length to provide a consistent program for STUDENT in her daily environment.

The witnesses also concurred that the SDC is not sufficiently structured to meet STUDENT's needs as a student with autism. The evidence also establishes that the SDC does not include an appropriate peer group for STUDENT and that their aggressive and self-stimulating behaviors do not provide appropriate models for STUDENT. There was some evidence that STUDENT acquired inappropriate behaviors, such as licking herself, from the other students in the class. Moreover, Dr. Byrd expressed concern that STUDENT would regress if she were to return to Marlton.

All of the witnesses who testified on behalf of STUDENT have assessed and observed STUDENT. They have also observed the SDC at Marlton. The witnesses have a great deal of experience working with students with hearing impairments and autism and hold appropriate credentials to assess and express opinions regarding the appropriateness of a placement for STUDENT. The District did not present any evidence to support its contention that Marlton offers an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Based on the unrebutted testimony of the witnesses that the SDC at Marlton does not meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has not offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT.

ISSUE NO. 3: Is the California School for the Deaf at Riverside an appropriate placement for

STUDENT?

The witnesses appearing on behalf of STUDENT testified that CSDR meets STUDENT's unique and individual needs, is designed to provide her with educational benefit and, therefore, is an appropriate placement for STUDENT. The witnesses testified that CSDR is appropriate for STUDENT because it offers her special education and services in a structured environment, offers a 24-hour total communication program, and allows her access to appropriate peers. Based on the undisputed testimony of the witnesses who have assessed and observed STUDENT and the proposed placements for her, the Hearing Officer finds that CSDR offers an appropriate placement for STUDENT.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

ISSUE NO. 1: Does STUDENT require a behavioral intervention plan to benefit from her education and to meet her unique and individual needs?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE No. 2: Has the District offered an appropriate educational placement and related services for

STUDENT?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE NO. 3: Is the California School for the Deaf at Riverside an appropriate placement for

STUDENT?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

ORDER

(1) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall arrange for a qualified behavioral intervention specialist to conduct an assessment of STUDENT's behavior.

(2) Within 30 calendar days of the date of this decision, the behavioral intervention specialist shall complete an assessment of STUDENT's behavior.

(3) Within 35 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team to develop a behavioral intervention plan to increase STUDENT's eye contact and attention to task, to reduce stigmatizing behaviors, and to reinforce alternative appropriate behaviors.

(4) Within 40 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall implement the behavioral intervention plan.

(5) By stipulation of the parties, the District shall arrange for CSDR to continue providing STUDENT with special education and services.

DATED: June 6, 1996 _____________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes