California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 16, 1998
Student v. Live Oak Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 694-97 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
Live Oak Unified denied FAPE by skipping IEP counseling and making a vague 1997-98 offer; SED eligibility claim denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A nine-year-old boy's mother filed for due process against Live Oak Unified School District. He was eligible for special education under a specific learning disability in math, with deficits in short-term auditory memory and attention. The mother argued he should also qualify as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) and be placed in a county SED program with mental health day treatment. He had several mental health diagnoses and serious behavior problems at home.
Hearing Officer Mark Paxson found that he did not meet the SED criteria. Teachers and school psychologists described behavior typical of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). He earned satisfactory grades and responded to simple behavior contracts. The mental health professionals who supported SED status had never watched him at school. The Hearing Officer gave little weight to Dr. Richard Komm's independent evaluation, partly because the testing took place at home.
The District won on 1995-96 FAPE, the adequacy of its assessment, reimbursement for Dr. Komm's evaluation, and transportation costs. Student won on two points. First, the District did not provide the weekly counseling, or the weekly contact with the mental health counselor, required by the 1996-97 IEP. Second, its 1997-98 offer was too vague to be a formal written offer. The SED program was rejected on least restrictive environment grounds. The District was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days. The new placement had to be regular education with weekly counseling, resource help in math, and the psychologist's new behavior plan. The District also had to provide two hours of tutoring per week for one year. The Hearing Officer also found that the student needed parent training.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated SED eligibility as an educational question. Serious behavior at home and psychiatric diagnoses did not qualify a student without marked effects at school. It also shows that a vague offer that changed during the hearing failed Union v. Smith, and that skipping IEP counseling sessions was a material failure to implement the IEP.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Did Respondents fail to identify STUDENT as seriously emotionally disturbed?
Student's behavior at school was not marked, did not adversely affect educational performance, and did not meet the SED criteria for inappropriate behavior or pervasive depression; serious behavior at home and mental health diagnoses did not establish educational SED.
- District prevailedChild find
Issue 2. Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education during the 1995-96 school year?
Because nothing at school suggested SED and March 1996 testing showed no severe discrepancy, the District had no reason to assess earlier, and the regular education program was appropriate.
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 3. Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education, including an appropriate behavioral intervention plan, during the 1996-97 school year?
The program met Student's math and behavior needs, but the District did not provide the weekly 30-minute counseling or the weekly contact with the mental health counselor required by the IEP, a material failure that denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 4. Did Respondents propose a free, appropriate public education for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year?
The District's shifting, vague offer was not a formal written offer under Union v. Smith and denied FAPE; however, the requested SED day class was rejected because LRE required regular education at the home school with the new behavior plan.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Is Petitioner entitled to appropriate related services to be provided by qualified personnel, including counseling, parent training, recreational therapy, respite care, and transportation?
Student needs parent training and continued educational counseling (the counseling intern was qualified), but not mental health counseling, recreational therapy, respite care, or transportation to mental health services.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. If Respondents failed to provide a free, appropriate public education, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Extra counseling was not appropriate compensation for the 1996-97 counseling failure, but the failure to offer a 1997-98 placement warranted two one-hour tutoring sessions per week for one calendar year; recreational services were denied.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 7. Did Respondents properly conduct an assessment of STUDENT's educational needs?
The fall 1996 psychoeducational assessment by school psychologists Martin and Johnson was comprehensive, and Petitioner offered no evidence it was inappropriate.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 8. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with the independent assessment completed by Dr. Richard Komm?
Because the District's assessment was appropriate, the parent was not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Komm's independent assessment.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 9. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred as a result of Respondents' failure to make an AB 3632 referral prior to March 1997 and to provide a free, appropriate public education?
Transportation costs to mental health appointments and hospitalizations were not educationally related, and Student did not need mental health services as part of special education.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the decision, convene an IEP team to develop a placement consistent with the decision.
- Placement ordered. Placement must be in a regular education environment, with educational counseling once per week for 30 minutes, resource specialist services for math, and implementation of school psychologist Monty Martin's behavior plan.
- Compensatory education. In addition to IEP services, two one-hour tutoring sessions per week, beginning within 15 days of the decision and lasting one full calendar year (about 104 hours).
Total: 104 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District; Union School District v. Smith; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(i); Education Code § 56505(e)(7); Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code §§ 56520-56524
People named in the decision
- Debra Brown, SELPA director (present for District; witness), Sutter County SELPA
- Susan Wiese, consultant and former director of special programs, Live Oak Unified School District
- Robert Manno, program coordinator, Sutter County Superintendent of Schools
- Dr. Alfred French, psychiatrist (medication monitoring), Sutter County Mental Health
- Darrell Stewart, third grade teacher, Live Oak Unified School District
- Sherri Phelan, special day class teacher; administered Woodcock-Johnson-Revised, Live Oak Unified School District
- Judith Rehermann, third grade reading teacher, Live Oak Unified School District
- Teresa Yarborough, summer school teacher, Live Oak Unified School District
- Diane Farmer, summer school teacher, Live Oak Unified School District
- Monty Martin, school psychologist; assessor and author of functional analysis and behavior plan, Live Oak Unified School District
- Tom Burgess, bus driver, Live Oak Unified School District
- Renae Richardson, resource specialist, Live Oak Unified School District
- Dorothy Johnson, second grade teacher, math tutor and summer school teacher, Live Oak Unified School District
- Barbara Forkey, second grade teacher, Live Oak Unified School District
- Michelle Ragasa, school counselor (counseling intern), Live Oak Unified School District
- Philip Pryde, program director, respite provider, Yuba Sutter Respite and Community Services
- Dr. Richard Komm, private psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
- Stephen Wellman, executive director, Family Intervention and Community Support
- William Merz, professor of school psychology training; District expert, CSU Sacramento
- Mary Counts, teacher's aide / yard duty supervisor, Live Oak Unified School District
- Vicki Johnson, school psychologist; assessor, Live Oak Unified School District
- Joan Hoss, director, Sutter-Yuba Mental Health Services
- Ramona Romero, bilingual secretary, Luther Elementary
- Norm Jensen, home instruction teacher, Live Oak Unified School District
- Vicki Carson, instructional and cafeteria aide, Live Oak Unified School District
- Michael Dahl, vice principal, Luther Elementary
- Douglas Reeder, principal, Luther Elementary
- Livien Melendez-Diaz, children's case manager, Sutter-Yuba Mental Health
- Robert Morrish, mental health therapist (LCSW); AB 3632 assessor, Sutter-Yuba Mental Health
- Lynda Corey, yard-duty aide (proposed rebuttal witness, excluded), Live Oak Unified School District
- Dr. Richard Saxton, treating psychiatrist (letter), Sutter Center for Psychiatry
- Dr. Sarah Hunter, attending psychiatrist (letter), First Hospital Vallejo
- Dr. Fernando Miranda, QEEG examiner, NeuroAccess
- Margo Schullerts, teacher, Luther Elementary
- Susan Slager, attorney for Sutter County Office of Education, Sutter County Office of Education
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Live Oak, California, on August 19, 20, 22, September 29 and 30, November 6, 7, 12, 13 and 14, and December 15 and 18, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Geralyn Clancy. Also present on STUDENT's behalf was his mother, MOTHER, and advocate Frances Wildman. Respondent Live Oak Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Terry Filliman. Also present on the District's behalf was Debra Brown, SELPA director. Nobody appeared on behalf of Sutter County Mental Health (Mental Health). (footnote 1)
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open to allow the parties to submit written closing briefs. Upon receipt of those briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
The following witnesses testified during the hearing: (footnote 2) Susan Wiese, consultant and former director of special programs for the District; Robert Manno, program coordinator for Sutter County Superintendent of Schools; Dr. Alfred French, psychiatrist, Mental Health; Darrell Stewart, STUDENT's third grade teacher; Sherri Phelan, STUDENT's third grade special day class teacher; Judith Rehermann, STUDENT's third grade reading teacher; Teresa Yarborough, one of STUDENT's summer school teachers in 1997; Diane Farmer, one of STUDENT's summer school teachers in 1997; Monty Martin, school psychologist; Tom Burgess, STUDENT's bus driver; Renae Richardson, STUDENT's resource specialist during third grade; Dorothy Johnson, one of STUDENT's second grade teachers; Barbara Forkey, one of STUDENT's second grade teachers; Michelle Ragasa, school counselor; Philip Pryde, program director, Yuba Sutter Respite and Community Services; Dr. Richard Komm, private psychologist; Stephen Wellman, executive director, Family Intervention and Community Support; MOTHER, STUDENT's mother; William Merz, professor of school psychology training, CSU, Sacramento; Mary Counts, teachers aide; Vicki Johnson, school psychologist; Joan Hoss, director, Sutter-Yuba Mental Health Services; Debra Brown, SELPA director; Ramona Romero, bilingual secretary at Luther Elementary during STUDENT's second grade year; Norm Jensen, STUDENT's home teacher during current school year; Vicki Carson, instructional and cafeteria aide; Michael Dahl, vice principal, Luther Elementary; Douglas Reeder, principal, Luther Elementary; Livien Melendez-Diaz, children's case manager, Sutter-Yuba Mental Health; Robert Morrish, mental health therapist, Sutter-Yuba Mental Health.
ISSUES
(1) Did Respondents fail to identify STUDENT as seriously emotionally disturbed?
(2) Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education during the 1995-96 school year?
(3) Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education, including an appropriate behavioral intervention plan, during the 1996-97 school year?
(4) Did Respondents propose a free, appropriate public education for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year?
(5) Is Petitioner entitled to appropriate related services to be provided by qualified personnel, including counseling, parent training, recreational therapy, respite care, and transportation?
(6) If Respondents failed to provide a free, appropriate public education, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
(7) Did Respondents properly conduct an assessment of STUDENT's educational needs?
(8) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with the independent assessment completed by Dr. Richard Komm?
(9) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred as a result of Respondents' failure to make an AB 3632 referral prior to March 1997 and to provide a free, appropriate public education?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On November 6, 1997, the sixth day of hearing, Petitioner requested that additional evidence be introduced into the record. The documentary evidence consisted of clinical notes from the Mental Health professionals, including Dr. French and Mr. Morrish, who have worked with STUDENT over the past several years; and records from STUDENT's most recent hospitalization in September 1997. The District, citing Education Code § 56505(e)(7), objected to introduction of any new evidence. The Hearing Officer notes that § 56505(e)(7) provides the Hearing Officer with the discretion to exclude evidence that is not disclosed to the other party at least five days prior to the hearing. Historically, this rule has been applied loosely when introducing additional evidence in a hearing that is continued to subsequent dates. However, the Hearing Officer upheld the District's objection for the following reasons.
Petitioner was attempting to introduce additional documentary evidence after his case was almost completely presented. Some of the documents were produced by witnesses who had already testified. All of the documentation was from mental health professionals and cumulative in nature due to the other mental health documentation that had already been introduced. The evidence Petitioner wanted to introduce consisted of several hundred pages of documents, the vast majority of which were in existence before the hearing commenced in August. The primary issue for hearing is whether STUDENT qualifies as SED for educational purposes. While mental health records have some relevance to that issue, for reasons which will be discussed below, additional mental health documentation would have provided little additional relevant information. (Footnote 3)
Petitioner also requested that two witnesses be added to his witness list as potential rebuttal witnesses. Although the District objected, the request was granted because of the relevance of their testimony and the fact that the witnesses would not be called until Petitioner presented his rebuttal in December, giving the District adequate time to prepare for the witnesses and cross-examine them.
When the hearing reconvened in December, Petitioner again requested that additional mental health records be introduced. The District again objected, citing § 56505(e)(7). The Hearing Officer notes that, at this point, Petitioner claimed that he had the right to introduce rebuttal evidence and that the five-day rule did not apply to rebuttal evidence. As noted above, the five-day rule is discretionary. The five-day rule does not include any exceptions for rebuttal evidence. The District's objection was again upheld for the same reasons as discussed above.
In December, Petitioner also requested that another witness, Lynda Corey, be added to his witness list as a rebuttal witness. According to Petitioner, Ms. Corey was a yard-duty aide during the time STUDENT was in the second and third grade. Petitioner contended that, although he knew of Ms. Corey's existence when the hearing began, he did not place her on his witness list because of Ms. Corey's concerns regarding a special education placement of her own son. Apparently, Ms. Corey was concerned that her testimony in this matter may have impacted the education her own child received. The District objected to the addition of Ms. Corey based on § 56505(e)(7). The District's objection was upheld, based on the five-day rule. Similar to the evidentiary issues that arose earlier in the hearing, Petitioner was aware of Ms. Corey's existence at the outset of the hearing. Furthermore, while the Hearing Officer is sympathetic to Ms. Corey's concerns, those concerns do not provide a legitimate excuse for failing to comply with § 56505(e)(7).
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a nine-year-old boy currently eligible for special education as a result of a specific learning disability in math and deficits in auditory short-term memory and attention. STUDENT's mother believes that STUDENT should also be eligible for special education as a result of a serious emotional disturbance (SED). STUDENT has been diagnosed with numerous mental disorders over the past few years and has received services from Mental Health since January 5, 1994, following a psychiatric hospitalization at Sun Ridge Hospital. (Footnote 4) (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 196) Those diagnoses have included post-traumatic stress disorder, psychotic disorder (NOS), and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
STUDENT's current services with Mental Health include individual psychotherapy, family therapy, group therapy, and medication monitoring. Additionally, STUDENT has been hospitalized for psychiatric reasons several times, including in December 1995, January 1996, February 1996, June 1996, and July 1996. Each of the hospitalizations resulted from behavioral incidents which occurred at STUDENT's home. Among the behaviors STUDENT has exhibited at home were expressions that he wanted to die and stabbing himself with a fork, hitting himself on the head and "crying for the voices to stop," hiding a knife under his bed, and out-of-control aggressive behavior directed toward his mother. (Testimony of MOTHER)
STUDENT has received home instruction during the entire 1997-98 school year based on a recommendation by Dr. Alfred French, the psychiatrist with Mental Health responsible for monitoring his medications.
STUDENT was first assessed by the District at the end of his kindergarten year in spring 1994. An Individualized Education Program (IEP) team was convened on June 8, 1994, and the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education because his achievement was commensurate with his ability. The IEP team also suggested that STUDENT's excessive absences may have caused any lower achievement he exhibited.
During the course of the next two years, a series of Student Success Team (SST) meetings were convened regarding STUDENT. During the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT participated in the Reading Recovery and the Special Kids programs. He was also followed by the SST throughout the year. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 104) During the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT continued in the regular education program, participated in the Special Kids program and also received some educational counseling from Michelle Ragasa, a counseling intern with the District.
On January 29, 1996, a parent-teacher conference was conducted between STUDENT's mother and his teachers, Ms. Johnson and Ms. Forkey. At that time, STUDENT's teachers noted that he had the knowledge to function at the second grade level, although he needed extra time to complete work. During the conference, MOTHER requested a special education assessment because of her concerns regarding STUDENT's increasingly disruptive behavior. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 102) Subsequently, an SST meeting was held on March 19, 1996. The SST recommended that STUDENT participate in counseling with Ms. Ragasa, continue in the Special Kids program, and also continue with services he was receiving through Mental Health. Prior to the meeting, STUDENT was administered a Woodcock-Johnson-Revised academic achievement test by Sherri Phelan. STUDENT's results indicated that he was above average in reading, slightly below average in math, and low average in written language. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 92) Ms. Phelan determined, based on those results and a comparison of prior psychological testing, that STUDENT did not have a severe discrepancy qualifying him for special education. No further assessment was completed.
From February 23 to March 20, 1996, STUDENT attended school on a half-day schedule at the recommendation of his psychiatrist. During this time, an incident occurred in which STUDENT did not want to leave early because his class was going to watch a movie. (Testimony of Douglas Reeder and MOTHER) STUDENT's mother was unable to get STUDENT into her car and requested assistance from Douglas Reeder, the principal at Luther Elementary. During the incident, STUDENT ran from his mother and Mr. Reeder, left the campus and was caught by Mr. Reeder on a street adjacent to the school. To ensure that STUDENT returned home, Mr. Reeder accompanied STUDENT and his mother home.
At the conclusion of the second grade, STUDENT's report card indicated that the only area in which he needed improvement was in mathematics. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 287) In reading, STUDENT was receiving "satisfactory" and "improving" grades. In written expression, he was receiving mostly "improving" grades, with one "satisfactory +" grade in handwriting. In oral expression, his grades were "outstanding." In social growth and study skills, all of STUDENT's grades were either "satisfactory" or "improving." During STUDENT's second grade, he had missed school due to illnesses or unexcused absences a total of 39 days and was also tardy 18 times. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 312) STUDENT also had received four citations for behavior incidents during the second grade. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 324) These incidents included playing tetherball after school and not getting on the bus, spraying students with a spray bottle, stealing a button from class, and throwing rocks on the slide.
On June 30, 1996, Dr. Richard Saxton, sent a letter to the District regarding STUDENT. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 208) Dr. Saxton was responsible for STUDENT's care at the Sutter Center for Psychiatry during STUDENT's hospitalization in June 1996. Dr. Saxton stated that there "is little clinical doubt as to the fact that STUDENT is a child who is severely emotionally disturbed. His emotional disturbance greatly interferes with his ability to benefit from classroom instruction without assistance. I would like to advocate that STUDENT be considered for SED status...."
On July 29, 1996, Dr. Sarah Hunter, attending psychiatrist at First Hospital Vallejo, submitted a letter to the district following one of STUDENT's hospitalizations. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 423) Dr. Hunter recommended that STUDENT be placed in a day treatment placement which would provide him with a small class size and more individual attention, trained mental health staff, and a therapeutic environment.
On September 16, 1996, the District developed an assessment plan for STUDENT following a referral made by STUDENT's SST on September 6, 1996. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 81) The assessment plan called for an assessment in academics, social emotional/adaptive behavior, intellectual ability, and health/vision.
On September 16, 1996, the District initiated a Behavioral Modification Contract for STUDENT with the goal "to improve [his] behavior at school and on the bus." (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 75) The contract included a "star" system by which STUDENT received stars when he went a full day without behavior problems. As STUDENT accumulated stars, he received certain rewards. The contract also provided STUDENT with the option of taking a "time out" or "take five" break before his behavior became unacceptable. STUDENT's seating on the bus was also to be arranged for him to sit closer to the bus driver.
In October 1996, STUDENT was referred by Mental Health for a QEEG test. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 169) The test was performed by Dr. Fernando Miranda of NeuroAccess in Corte Madera. Dr. Miranda's results "suggest a decreased reticular activating system function, a maturational delay, or a toxic metabolic encephalopathy. The first two may present clinically as ADD and/or a processing deficit."
On October 23, 1996, several students who rode the bus with STUDENT wrote a letter to Mr. Dahl, the vice principal at Luther School. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 406 The students raised concerns regarding STUDENT's behavior on the bus. Subsequently, on November 13, 1996, Margo Schullerts, the teacher who recommended that the students write the letter, wrote a letter to Mr. Dahl indicating that STUDENT was no longer a problem on the bus because he was now sitting at the front of the bus. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 409)
On October 26, 1996, Monty Martin and Vicki Johnson, school psychologists, completed a psychoeducational report based on the assessment plan dated September 16, 1996. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 172) The assessment addressed STUDENT's cognitive and sensory motor skills, academic skills, and social/emotional/adaptive behavior skills. Based on the results, the assessors concluded that STUDENT qualified for special education as a result of a significant discrepancy in the area of math attributable to a disability in short-term memory and attention. Specifically addressing SED, the assessors administered the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC), Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist (Achenbach), Piers-Harris Children's Self-Concept Scale (Piers-Harris), Kelly-Differential Problem Sorter, and Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale: Parent Edition (Vineland). The assessors also conducted a series of observations of STUDENT in the educational environment and interviewed STUDENT and his mother.
On the Vineland, STUDENT's adaptive behavioral strengths were in socialization and communication and his "adaptive behavior composite" was in the moderately low range. On the Achenbach, STUDENT's mother reported significant problems in all areas except for "somatic complaint." The problem areas included "withdrawn," "anxious/depressed," "social problems," "thought problems," "attention problems," "delinquent behavior," and "aggressive behavior." On the other hand, STUDENT's teacher, Darrell Stewart reported all behaviors in the normal range except for "thought problems." According to the report, Mr. Stewart's high score for STUDENT on thought problems was based on STUDENT's reporting that he could not get his mind off certain thoughts, fears, and voices.
On the Piers-Harris, STUDENT's self-concept was rated in the highly favorable range. The report notes that STUDENT reported "feelings of high self-esteem and overall contentment with his life." On the BASC, STUDENT's teachers, Mr. Stewart and Dorothy Johnson, reported significant problems in the areas of hyperactivity, attention, and study skills. Mr. Stewart additionally reported problems in leadership, while Ms. Johnson reported problems in depression, learning, adaptability, and social skills. STUDENT's mother reported significant problems with hyperactivity, conduct, depression, attention, atypicality, and adaptability. STUDENT reported problems in self-esteem and relations with parents.
After reviewing the test results, the assessors addressed the SED criteria and concluded that STUDENT did not meet any of the criteria. Specifically, the assessors noted that, while STUDENT had difficulty with math, this difficulty was attributable to learning difficulties rather than a serious emotional disturbance; while STUDENT could benefit from a social skills/self-esteem program, STUDENT had demonstrated an ability to maintain peer relationships both at school and at church, as well as satisfactory adult relationships at school; STUDENT did not exhibit any overtly bizarre, psychotic, or self-injurious behaviors; STUDENT did not display any symptoms of depression (the assessors noted that his appetite was good, he laughed at jokes, actively participated in sports, socially interacted with peers and staff, and remained energetic); and that there was no indication from any individual that physical symptoms or fears were a problem. The assessors noted that, although STUDENT had numerous mental health diagnoses, those disorders did not appear to be global in nature and did not appear to be adversely affecting his educational performance.
Following completion of the assessment, an IEP team convened on November 1, 1996. The team concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education as a result of a specific learning disability in math and deficits in auditory short-term memory and attention. The IEP team reconvened on November 15, 1996, to develop goals and objectives and finalize STUDENT's IEP. STUDENT's IEP called for him to be educated in a regular education class with resource specialist assistance for 150-200 minutes per week. The IEP team continued STUDENT's behavior contract, included 1:1 counseling at least once per week for 30 minutes, and offered STUDENT the opportunity to participate in after-school tutorials for homework support. Finally, the IEP team developed several goals and objectives to address STUDENT's needs in math.
On November 18, 1996, STUDENT's behavior contract was modified. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 50) The new contract's goal was for STUDENT "to improve [his] behavior and have [him] accept responsibility for both good and bad behavior." The contract continued with the star system but incorporated different rewards.
On February 7, 1997, STUDENT's IEP team convened to review STUDENT's program. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 38) The IEP team noted that STUDENT rode the bus on Fridays only and that since the prior IEP meeting, STUDENT had received no bus citations. The IEP team also noted that STUDENT had received so many stars under the behavior contract that charting was no longer needed and that STUDENT had seen the counselor only once because the counseling sessions were scheduled for Wednesdays and he had missed all but two of the six Wednesdays since his IEP was developed.
On February 18, 1997, STUDENT's behavior contract was again modified. (Petitioner's Exhibit, P. 35) The new contract identified four goals, including achieving academic and social success, increasing time spent working on academic tasks, successfully engaging in peer interactions at school, and increasing ability to do tasks independently. The contract provided for STUDENT to receive daily rewards and incentives from his teachers. Furthermore, upon completion of ten days of cooperation and completed work, STUDENT was entitled to a trip to Taco Bell with the vice principal, Mr. Dahl. The contract also provided STUDENT with a 15-minute "timeout" as needed when he was unable to focus on work, was disruptive, or refused to do work. During the timeout, STUDENT was expected to work on a "focus form" and return to class after discussing the problem with staff.
On March 18, 1997, Dr. Alfred French, the child psychiatrist with Mental Health responsible for monitoring STUDENT's medication, prepared a letter stating his opinion that STUDENT is "very severely impaired neuropsychiatrically. He is unable to function adequately in any ordinary environment." (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 161)
On March 21, 1997, STUDENT's IEP team convened to review his progress. (Petitioner's Exhibit, P. 27) The IEP team noted that STUDENT was having more discipline problems and was on bus suspension. The IEP team decided to continue STUDENT in his counseling, to refer STUDENT for 3632 services, to have the school psychologist develop a behavior plan for STUDENT, to refer STUDENT to the County Office of Education (COE) for possible placement in an SED program, and to place him in a special day class (SDC). STUDENT would continue receiving math assistance in the resource specialist program (RSP) and attend the SDC for the remainder of his academic subjects.
On April 18, 1997, an assessment plan for the purpose of conducting a functional analysis of STUDENT's behavior was developed by the District and signed by STUDENT's mother. The assessment was completed by Monty Martin, school psychologist, on May 30, 1997. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 141) Mr. Martin noted that STUDENT was, at the time of the analysis, prescribed Adderall, Depakote, Tegretol, and an Albuterol inhaler.
Mr. Martin, after discussions with STUDENT's mother and teachers, identified four problem behaviors to target in his functional analysis. Those behaviors were "not raising hand," "out of seat," "off-task during individual academic assignment," and "quarrelsome/argumentative when called ‘out' playing bang-ball." The fourth behavior was added at the request of STUDENT's mother. (Testimony of Monty Martin) Following completion of his functional analysis, Mr. Martin completed a "Proposed Positive Behavior Intervention Plan" on June 1, 1997. The goals of the proposed plan included increasing on-task academic behaviors, increasing the rate of raising his hand, increasing the length of time STUDENT remains in his seat, teaching STUDENT how to de-escalate his anger. Mr. Martin identified a multitude of "direct treatment strategies" to address each of these goals. These strategies ranged from ignoring STUDENT when he blurts out an answer and praising those who properly raise their hands to having STUDENT regularly review the rules of bang-ball or provide him with a modified recess that would be more teacher-directed and less independent.
On May 7, 1997, STUDENT was suspended for two days for an incident on the playground. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 18) The suspension notice describes the incident as follows:
STUDENT was playing bang ball and was being observed by Mrs. Counts, the yard duty supervisor. STUDENT was called out by the students because he caught the ball inside the court and walked out. Mrs. Counts witnessed the incident and indicated that STUDENT was out. STUDENT began arguing with the other student over the call and appeared to be getting ready to push or shove the child. Mrs. Counts walked up behind STUDENT and put her hand on his right shoulder to talk to him. STUDENT turned around quickly and punched her very hard in the stomach. STUDENT remarked that he thought he was being jumped and he didn't know it was a teacher.
On May 14, 1997, Robert Morrish, a licensed clinical social worker with Mental Health, completed the 3632 assessment. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 153) Mr. Morrish's diagnostic impression of STUDENT included the following diagnoses: ADHD, impulse control deficit, psychotic disorder (NOS), mathematics disorder, asthma and allergies, and chronic conflict with peers and some adults. Mr. Morrish also noted that STUDENT had reported visual and auditory hallucinations and that results from the Rorschach indicated a "neurological impairment with serious disturbance of both thinking and perceptual accuracy." Mr. Morrish made the following recommendation:
STUDENT will continue to receive the highest level of treatment through our outpatient services which includes individual psychotherapy, parent counseling, family therapy, recreational group therapy and medication monitoring. However, due to his length of treatment to date, the complexity of his treatment with medications, the severity of his disturbance in both thinking and perception as determined by recent Rorschach test results and clinical observation, and the potential for impulsive violent outbursts, his current clinical picture requires consideration of a higher level of Mental Health services that can be provided through a children's day treatment program. Such a program may help reduce the risk of angry outbursts, personal injury, and suspensions, all of which ultimately impede STUDENT's educational progress and emotional development.
On May 27, 1997, STUDENT's IEP team met to review the 3632 referral and the COE referral. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 10) The IEP team noted that STUDENT "continued to be successful at Luther School. Trouble areas are the freedom of lunch/recess. Homework, attendance, learning and the tutorial have all continued to improve." Based on the 3632 referral, Mental Health agreed to serve STUDENT "in as many ways as possible." Regarding the COE referral, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT did not qualify as SED and, therefore, should not be placed in an SED program.
STUDENT's IEP team again met on June 3, 1997, to review the functional behavioral analysis completed by Mr. Martin. The team agreed to reconvene on Thursday, August 28, 1997, to review the analysis. Apparently, that review never took place as a result of this matter proceeding to a due process hearing. Additionally, STUDENT did not return to school for the 1997-98 school year due to his placement in home instruction. Therefore, the behavior intervention plan proposed by Mr. Martin was never implemented.
STUDENT's report card at the end of the third grade shows that he was receiving "improving" grades in reading and writing, "outstanding" grades in oral expression, and "satisfactory" grades in all other areas, including spelling, handwriting, mathematics, social studies, science, art, music, and physical education. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 282) In the areas of social growth and study skills, all of STUDENT's grades were either "improving" or "satisfactory." All of the marks in social growth and study skills indicated improvement over the first three quarters of the school year. During the third grade, STUDENT missed 12 days of school due to illness, and five days due to unexcused absences. STUDENT was also tardy 24 times. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 308) During the third grade, STUDENT received four citations for behavioral incidents on the bus. (Petitioner's Exhibit, pp. 324-326) These incidents included slapping a student, elbowing another student, and throwing a binder on the bus. As a result of the final citation, STUDENT was suspended from the bus for two weeks. STUDENT also received numerous cations for behavioral incidents at school. These incidents included running in the hallway, not returning to class when directed to do so, pushing and shoving another student, playing after the recess bell, kicking at another student while in line, not staying in his chair as directed, and hitting the yard duty supervisor.
On June 16, 1997, Dr. Richard Komm conducted a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT at his mother's request. (Petitioner's Exhibit, p. 118) Dr. Komm noted that STUDENT had been previously diagnosed with a range of mental disorders, including Psychotic Condition NOS, Major Depression, ADHD, and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. During the course of the evaluation, Dr. Komm spent approximately four to five hours with STUDENT, including approximately 20 minutes observing him at school, during a summer school class. (Testimony of Dr. Komm). During the school observation, Dr. Komm observed that STUDENT, upon seeing his mother and Dr. Komm, broke out of the line he was in and ran over to meet them in the school office. Dr. Komm also noted that, in his opinion, the school's principal minimized STUDENT's negative behaviors.
The formal testing took place at STUDENT's home. Dr. Komm administered a range of tests, including the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III, the Woodcock-McGrew-Werder Mini-Battery of Achievement, the Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test, Thematic Apperception Test, Children's Depression Rating Scale-Revised, Draw A Person, and House Tree Person. Dr. Komm concluded, based on his observation, testing, and review of prior assessments and other documents, that STUDENT is a "significantly disturbed student and, indeed, should be considered multiple handicapped possessing both a learning disability as well as a significant emotional disturbance." Dr. Komm concluded that STUDENT has "marked difficulties with both teachers and peers that interfere with his educational progress," demonstrates inappropriate behaviors interfering with the welfare of his peers, including choking, spitting, fighting, biting, and other aggressive behaviors, and is clinically depressed. Dr. Komm suggested that the various intervention strategies implemented by the District were, in effect, a "de facto" recognition of STUDENT's SED status. Interestingly, Dr. Komm recommended that those interventions should be continued and that 3632 services and counseling continue. Dr. Komm recommended that a day treatment or residential treatment program be considered only if his behavior deteriorated.
STUDENT attended summer school following the 1996-97 school year. He had three teachers during the summer session: Teresa Yarborough, Dorothy Johnson, and Diane Farmer. The summer session was scheduled to last for 18 school days. However, a couple of weeks into the summer session, STUDENT indicated that he no longer wanted to attend summer school. Since summer school is a voluntary program, STUDENT was allowed to withdraw from summer school. (Testimony of Teresa Yarborough and MOTHER)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
In his closing brief, Petitioner stated that he has no issues with Mental Health regarding the services provided by Mental Health. Therefore, this decision will address only issues relating to the provision of educational services by the District.
(1) Did Respondents fail to identify STUDENT as seriously emotionally disturbed?
California Code of Regulations, Title 5, § 3030(i) provides the criteria for determining whether a student is eligible for special education services under the category of serious emotional disturbance (SED). Section 3030(i) provides that a student is eligible as SED if, because of a serious emotional disturbance, he or she exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance:
(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
It is significant that § 3030(i) requires that for any of these factors to qualify a child for special education, they must adversely affect the child's educational performance. For example, if a child engages in inappropriate types of behavior at home, but is able to control his behavior in an educational environment, the child would not qualify under criteria #3. Similarly, a child who is depressed or unhappy in other environments may not qualify for special education if he does not exhibit depression or unhappiness at school or if his depression or unhappiness does not adversely impact his educational performance. In other words, for a child to qualify under any of these criteria, the behaviors should be exhibited in an educational environment and exist to a marked degree such that they adversely impact the child's performance. As will be discussed below, while STUDENT may have some serious behavior problems at home, there is no evidence that those behavior problems exist at school to any significant degree or that the behavioral issues he does have at school have adversely affected his educational performance.
In his closing brief, Petitioner contended that he qualifies as SED under criteria #3 (inappropriate behavior) and #4 (depression). Therefore, this decision will address only those criteria.
Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations.
Petitioner contends that STUDENT fits this category due to "hassling of peers -- kicking, spitting in faces, choking, hitting with hands, hitting with objects, stealing, name-calling, yelling, threatening." (Petitioner's Closing Argument, p. 20) As evidence of his inappropriate behavior, Petitioner cited the incident during the second grade when he ran across the school campus and left the campus through a gate. Petitioner also contends that his hallucinations, feelings of sadness, late arrival, inability to focus on work, and sitting by himself are evidence of his inappropriate behavior or feelings.
The testimony of the District employees who have worked with or observed STUDENT at school establishes that STUDENT, while having some behavioral problems, does not have inappropriate types of behavior to a marked degree which adversely affect his educational performance. Darrell Stewart, STUDENT's third grade teacher until March 1997, testified that STUDENT was a typical child with ADHD. STUDENT loved to have friends and wanted to feel included. According to Mr. Stewart many of STUDENT's behaviors, like talking out of turn, were attention-seeking in nature. Mr. Stewart also testified that, while STUDENT told him about hearing voices, Mr. Stewart did not believe the voices were a problem at school.
Sherri Phelan, STUDENT's SDC teacher at the end of the third grade, testified that STUDENT was in her class for math, writing, spelling, art and current events. Ms. Phelan testified that STUDENT was an easy student to work with in her classroom and that STUDENT frequently read to the other students. According to Ms. Phelan, while STUDENT needed redirection occasionally, he did his work and was performing at a higher level than the other students in her class. Ms. Phelan testified that she never saw STUDENT "shut down" and that he did not get into arguments with other students in her class or cause any other problems.
Judith Rehermann, STUDENT's reading teacher during the third grade, had STUDENT in her class for approximately 50 minutes per day until March 1997, when he moved to the special day class. Ms. Rehermann testified that STUDENT was off task a lot, like other children with ADHD, but that there was nothing significant or unusual about his behavior. Ms. Rehermann testified that she had recess duty and bus duty occasionally but that she never remembered having to intervene with STUDENT and other students on the playground or having any problems with STUDENT on the bus. Ms. Rehermann also indicated that STUDENT's social skills were within the range of third grade social skills and that he never said or did anything inappropriate to her or to other students.
STUDENT's teachers from the summer 1997 session, Teresa Yarborough, Diane Farmer, and Dorothy Johnson, testified that they had no more problems with STUDENT than with any other third grade student and that he did not talk out in class or otherwise disrupt the class. According to Ms. Yarborough, STUDENT's interactions with the other students were typical of other third and fourth graders and he did not seem behind in his social skills. Ms. Farmer testified that STUDENT worked on projects as well as the other students and that his off-task behavior was not any worse than that of other students. Ms. Farmer testified that she did not have any significant behavior problems with STUDENT.
Monty Martin, the school psychologist who assessed STUDENT in November 1996 and conducted a functional analysis of his behavior in May 1997, testified that STUDENT's "voices" were "nothing more than his conscience" and were not indicative of a delusional thought disorder. Mr. Martin testified that the social skills problems that STUDENT exhibits are likely attributable to his ADHD rather than a serious emotional disturbance. According to Mr. Martin, much of STUDENT's problems had to do with poor impulse control. Mr. Martin testified that he did not believe a functional analysis was necessary because STUDENT's behaviors were not serious enough to require such an assessment. In his assessment of STUDENT, Mr. Martin testified that he concluded that there was no information to suggest that, under normal circumstances, STUDENT exhibited overtly bizarre behaviors at school. Mr. Martin testified that, a child could have multiple diagnoses of mental illness, but the issue is whether the effects of mental illness are affecting the child at school. In Mr. Martin's opinion, STUDENT does not fit the SED criteria. Mr. Martin stated that the typical SED profile includes behaviors that are global in nature, poor academics in all areas, and an inability to be successful with simple behavior management plans. Mr. Martin testified that STUDENT was successful with the behavior management plans that had been implemented during the 1996-97 school year and that any behavior problems he exhibited were not affecting his educational performance.
Vicki Johnson, the school psychologist who worked with Mr. Martin on the assessment in fall 1996, testified that she observed STUDENT at school for approximately four hours and that he exhibited typical ADHD behaviors. Ms. Johnson stated that, during her observations, she did not observe any disruptive behaviors in the classroom and that STUDENT was not out of control or argumentative. Ms. Johnson testified that STUDENT was easily redirected, pleasant, and did not exhibit extremes of behavior. Similarly, during observations of STUDENT on the playground, Ms. Johnson observed that STUDENT laughed and played with the other children appropriately. Ms. Johnson testified that STUDENT was "not close to SED."
Renae Richardson was STUDENT's RSP teacher for a portion of the 1996-97 school year. STUDENT attended her class for one period per day to work on math beginning about Christmas, and then when he enrolled in the SDC, he came to her class for reading and stayed in the SDC for math. Ms. Richardson testified that STUDENT never hit or pushed any other children in her class and that he did not show any signs of disrespect for her or the other students. Ms. Richardson stated that STUDENT's behaviors, such as blurting out answers, lacking the ability to stay on-task, and occasionally "roaming" around the room, are typical of a child with ADHD. She did not consider him disruptive or threatening to her safety or that of the other children.
Dorothy Johnson, one of STUDENT's second grade teachers, provided some math tutoring for him at the beginning of the third grade, and was one of his teachers during summer 1997. Ms. Johnson testified that STUDENT's behaviors were typical of ADHD students and that there was nothing out of the ordinary. Ms. Johnson testified that STUDENT's social skills were typical of second-graders. According to Ms. Johnson, STUDENT fell asleep a few times in her class, but she attributed this to the medications he was on. Ms. Johnson testified that STUDENT was enthusiastic and eager to please and that he was one of her "most enjoyable students" because of his enthusiasm. Ms. Johnson testified that she does not remember ever having to send STUDENT out of the room or to the office because of behavior problems. Ms. Johnson also stated that, although STUDENT got out of his seat frequently, he was not disruptive because he was not moving around and bothering other students. Instead, he would stand by his desk or sit up on his knees at his desk. Ms. Johnson stated that she has four "standers" in her class this year. The behavior is typical of ADHD students.
Michelle Ragasa, a counseling intern employed by the District, provided educational counseling for STUDENT beginning January 1995. Ms. Ragasa testified that STUDENT's behavioral problems were related to impulsivity and low-self-esteem. According to Ms. Ragasa, STUDENT does not respect the personal boundaries of others. For example, she observed STUDENT grabbing a ball from another student during recess when STUDENT was in the first grade. Ms. Ragasa testified that she had a good rapport with STUDENT until approximately October 1996, when STUDENT became uncooperative during his sessions with her.
Ramona Romero, a secretary in the office at Luther Elementary, testified that she intervened with STUDENT several times during the 1995-96 school year. Ms. Romero, who also worked as a housekeeper for STUDENT's mother for awhile, testified that Ms. Forkey, STUDENT's afternoon teacher, occasionally asked her to come in and talk to STUDENT to "calm him down." Ms. Romero testified that she did not talk to the teacher about what was going on when she came in the room. On at least one occasion, Ms. Romero took STUDENT back with her to the office for about 20 minutes.
Michael Dahl, vice principal at Luther Elementary, became STUDENT's designated contact person when he needed a "focused timeout." Mr. Dahl described these timeouts as an opportunity for STUDENT to "vent." According to Mr. Dahl, these timeouts were voluntary and only occurred when STUDENT requested one. Mr. Dahl recalled that there were four focused timeouts during the five-week period beginning on February 18, 1997. Mr. Dahl testified that he was unaware of STUDENT ever being sent by a teacher for a timeout for disciplinary reasons. Also responsible for discipline at Luther Elementary, Mr. Dahl testified that, although STUDENT had more citations than a typical third grader, his behavior was similar to that of other third graders. Mr. Dahl, who was on yard duty every day during lunch, also testified that STUDENT did not need any more supervision on the playground than other students.
Dr. Richard Komm, the independent assessor who assessed STUDENT in June 1997, testified that STUDENT's behaviors were consistent with a child who has difficulties with boundaries and that STUDENT has significant psychiatric problems that manifest themselves in every environment. Dr. Komm testified that there is evidence in STUDENT's school records that he is disruptive towards his peers and, therefore, he qualifies as SED due to inappropriate behavior under normal circumstances. According to Dr. Komm, STUDENT's behavior is more serious than a "typical ADHD child" and his social skills are seriously impacted.
As outlined above, the testimony of those District personnel who were most familiar with STUDENT's behavior at school establishes that, while STUDENT may have some behavioral problems, they do not rise to the level required for qualification as SED. Some behavior problems do not qualify as SED. Low self-esteem or getting upset in class occasionally does not qualify as SED. While some of the behavioral incidents, including STUDENT's striking of an aide on the playground and his refusal to leave school, are troubling, those incidents have been relatively few and far between. To qualify STUDENT as SED, such incidents would have to happen on a more frequent basis; otherwise the behavior is not occurring to a marked degree. Similarly, there was some evidence that STUDENT has auditory hallucinations or "hears voices." However, there was no evidence that those hallucinations are interfering with his ability to benefit from his education or conform his conduct appropriately. Furthermore, while some of the behavior described in STUDENT's citations was inappropriate, those behaviors are not unusual for a child STUDENT's age. Pushing a student while in line, running in the hallway, not staying in his chair as directed, or arguing during a game at recess would not seem to be atypical behavior for a third-grader. There is no evidence that STUDENT's behavior in the educational environment is so out of control that he qualifies as SED.
Much of Petitioner's evidence is irrelevant to a determination of whether STUDENT qualifies as SED for educational purposes. A history of mental health interventions and diagnoses, along with serious behavior problems at home, does not qualify a child as SED for educational purposes. While there were several mental health professionals, including Dr. Alfred French, Mel Diaz, and Robert Morrish, who testified that STUDENT is SED, it is significant that none of these individuals has ever observed STUDENT in the educational environment. It is also significant that they are speaking from a mental health perspective rather than an educational perspective. As to Dr. Komm, there are several reasons why his opinion warrants little weight. Dr. Komm's observation of STUDENT in school consisted of a very brief observation during a summer school class. Dr. Komm's assessment included tests, the results of which were not included in his report. Dr. Komm's report included conclusory and negative statements regarding school personnel and their opinion of STUDENT's behavior with little support. Most importantly, Dr. Komm conducted the testing in STUDENT's home, the environment in which STUDENT has had the most behavior problems. STUDENT's hospitalizations have occurred as a result of behavior problems in his home, and the descriptions of his behavior at home establish that his behavior at home is much more serious than even STUDENT's worst behavior at school. The fact that Dr. Komm administered the testing in such an environment raises serious issues regarding the validity of his assessment results.
It must be stressed again that for a STUDENT to qualify as SED, the behaviors have to adversely affect his educational performance. There is no evidence that STUDENT's behavioral problems are interfering with his ability to benefit educationally. In addition to the testimony outlined above, District witnesses testified regarding STUDENT's progress in school. STUDENT's report cards demonstrate that STUDENT was receiving satisfactory marks in academics and social skills. With the exception of math, STUDENT progressed steadily in all academic areas.
Finally, while there is substantial evidence of STUDENT having serious, out of control behaviors at home, there is no evidence of STUDENT exhibiting behaviors that are even close to those behaviors exhibited at home and which have given rise to his hospitalizations. In many respects, the evidence presented portrays two different children. On the one hand, in the home environment, STUDENT exhibits out of control, aggressive, and inappropriate behavior. On the other hand, while experiencing some behavior problems, STUDENT is able to substantially conform his behavior to what is expected of him in the educational environment.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that, while STUDENT has some behavior problems at school, those behavior problems to not rise to the level the SED criteria require. Additionally, even given STUDENT's behavior problems, there is no evidence that he engages in inappropriate conduct that interferes with his ability to benefit from his education.
A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
Similar to the testimony related to STUDENT's behavior at school, District witnesses testified that STUDENT does not exhibit symptoms of depression at school. Several witnesses, including Mr. Martin, Ms. Johnson, and Mr. Dahl, testified that STUDENT was an enthusiastic student, eager to please, and frequently seeking the attention and approval of others. These witnesses also testified that they had positive relationships with STUDENT and considered him to be their friend. Mr. Martin and Ms. Johnson, the psychologists who assessed STUDENT in fall 1996, noted that his appetite was good, he laughed at jokes, actively participated in sports, socially interacted with peers and staff, and remained energetic and concluded that he did not exhibit unhappiness or depression.
Petitioner cited Dr. Alfred French's testimony as an explanation of why STUDENT may appear happy in an educational environment, even though he is clinically depressed. Dr. French, STUDENT's psychiatrist at Mental Health, testified that STUDENT tries to mask his depression with an outer appearance of happiness. Dr. French testified that STUDENT is, in reality, in turmoil, overwhelmed, and stressed out. The problem with Dr. French's testimony is that, in his own words, he did not have a positive clinical relationship with STUDENT, STUDENT was not a good self-reporter of information, and "STUDENT does not really talk to him that much." Interestingly, Dr. French testified that, because of STUDENT's lack of communication, he cannot get concrete information to meet the specific symptoms of the specific diagnoses contained in the Diagnostic and Statistic Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV). Dr. French also has never observed STUDENT in an educational setting. It is difficult, therefore, to put much weight on Dr. French's testimony that STUDENT's depression is adversely affecting his educational performance. Finally, Dr. French testified that STUDENT will "explode" at some point in the future. The fact is that, in the educational environment, STUDENT has not done so. The criteria for SED look at a child's current behavior and functioning and do not allow for eligibility based on the anticipation of future conduct.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not qualify for special education as SED due to a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. It is significant that the criteria require that the unhappiness or depression be general and pervasive. There is simply no evidence that STUDENT is depressed or unhappy across the board. As noted by the assessors, STUDENT is an energetic child who regularly participates in all aspects of his education, including classroom and playground activities. STUDENT is also diagnosed as ADHD. As testified to by many of the witnesses, much of STUDENT's behavior at school can be attributable, not to an emotional disturbance, but to his ADHD. In addition, the Hearing Officer again notes that the evidence establishes that STUDENT has continued to benefit from his education by progressing and receiving satisfactory grades. Therefore, even if he exhibits symptoms of unhappiness or depression, it cannot be said that his educational performance has been adversely affected.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to establish that STUDENT has at any time qualified for special education due to a serious emotional disturbance.
(2) Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education during the 1995-96 school year?
As described above, there was no evidence that STUDENT should have been found eligible for special education services as a result of a serious emotional disturbance during the 1995-96 school year. Furthermore, there is no evidence that suggests STUDENT qualified under any other criteria. The District's assessment at the end of the 1993-94 school year, a little more than one year before the start of the 1995-96 school year, established that STUDENT was not eligible at that time. In addition, Ms. Phelan administered the Woodcock Johnson-Revised in March 1996 and, based on those results, determined that STUDENT still did not meet the criteria for a specific learning disability. While STUDENT struggled in math and the District did find STUDENT eligible with a specific learning disability in November 1996, there is nothing in the record that suggests STUDENT's academic functioning should have been comprehensively assessed any earlier than it was.
It is significant that Petitioner's primary concern during the 1995-96 school year was not whether he qualified as learning disabled, but, rather, whether he qualified as seriously emotionally disturbed. With that primary concern expressed by Petitioner's mother and the lack of evidence in the educational environment that STUDENT was seriously emotionally disturbed, the District did not have reason to conduct an assessment any earlier than it did. While the District had information about STUDENT's hospitalizations in January 1996, there was nothing in STUDENT's educational environment that suggested that he should be assessed for SED. Again, the Hearing Officer notes that, for purposes of special education, the SED criteria are educational, not mental health, in nature. The information regarding the hospitalizations should raise concerns regarding STUDENT's emotional status. However, the lack of any comparable behavior at school suggesting that STUDENT was SED suggests that the District did not have reason to conduct an assessment.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not have reason to assess STUDENT during the 1995-96 school year and that, under the circumstances, the regular education program provided by the District was appropriate for STUDENT for the 1995-96 school year.
(3) Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education, including an appropriate behavioral intervention plan, during the 1996-97 school year?
State and federal law require that students with disabilities receive a free appropriate public education. California Education Code § 56000 et seq. and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq. "Free appropriate public education" means special education and related services, provided at public expense, that conform with the student's individualized education program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). "Special education" is defined as specifically designed instruction designed to meet the unique needs of a disabled child. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, EHLR 553:656, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the ‘basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialist instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." 458 U.S. 175,200.
Taken together, the IDEA and Rowley provide four factors for analyzing whether the District's proposed placement is appropriate. Those three factors are as follows:
(A) Was the District's placement designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs? (B) Did the District's placement conform to STUDENT's IEP?
(C) Did the District's placement provide STUDENT with educational benefit?
(A) Was the District's placement designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs?
During the course of the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT's placement changed several times: from a regular education placement with additional tutoring in math, to regular education with resource specialist services in math, and to placement in a special day class with resource specialist services in reading and math. STUDENT's program also included 1:1 educational counseling and a series of behavioral contracts designed to encourage positive behavior.
The evidence also establishes that STUDENT had a learning disability in math. Throughout the 1996-97 school year, the District provided STUDENT with additional help in math. Prior to finding him eligible for special education, Ms. Johnson provided tutoring in math. Once STUDENT was found eligible, the District provided STUDENT with resource specialist services to address his needs in math. There has been no contention that these services were inappropriate, and the Hearing Officer can find no reason to question their appropriateness.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's educational program met STUDENT's unique needs in the area of behavior, counseling, and math remediation.
(B) Did the District's placement conform to STUDENT's IEP?
STUDENT's IEP from November 1996 called for STUDENT to receive counseling at least once per week for 30 minutes each session. According to Ms. Ragasa, the person responsible for the counseling, she did not start providing counseling for STUDENT until February 1997. Once she began providing the counseling, sessions occurred on February 12, March 5, March 19, March 26, April 9, April 16, April 23, April 30, May 7, May 14, May 21, and May 28. (District's Exhibit, p. 158) Ms. Ragasa testified that five sessions ended early either because STUDENT "shut down" or because of a "power struggle" with STUDENT. Ms. Ragasa also testified that she did not provide counseling from October until February because STUDENT was not effectively participating in the counseling.
In addition to providing the counseling, Ms. Ragasa was required by STUDENT's IEP to contact Mr. Morrish, STUDENT's Mental Health counselor, on a weekly basis. According to Ms. Ragasa, she did not contact Mr. Morrish until March 1997, and then only sporadically. The Hearing Officer finds, based on Ms. Ragasa's testimony, that the program provided to STUDENT once he was found eligible did not conform to his IEP in the area of counseling. Considering the significance of counseling to STUDENT and his mother, and the significance of STUDENT's behavioral issues, the lack of conformity cannot be considered to be merely a technical failure to comply with one component of STUDENT's IEP. Rather, the failure to fully implement the counseling portion of STUDENT's IEP and to maintain consistent contact with STUDENT's Mental Health counselor constitute a sufficient enough breach that STUDENT's placement was inappropriate as a result.
The Hearing Officer notes that, while Ms. Ragasa may have had difficulties providing services for STUDENT, her responsibility was to notify his IEP team and suggest appropriate changes to his IEP rather than simply shortening the sessions or not providing them at all. Similarly, if she had difficulties contacting Mr. Morrish, her responsibility was to notify the IEP team.
(C) Did the District's placement provide STUDENT with educational benefit?
The evidence establishes that while STUDENT was in the resource specialist program he received educational benefit. His teachers testified regarding the progress he made in his classes, and his report cards demonstrate that he was, for the most part, receiving satisfactory marks in academics and social skills. STUDENT continued receiving this academic benefit when he was enrolled in the SDC because the resource specialist services continued in reading and math.
Also of significance is that the District was also meeting STUDENT's behavioral needs and providing him with benefit in that area. With a child of STUDENT's age and needs, academics are not the only educational benefit he requires. In addition, it is important that he be able to conform his behavior appropriately. The behavioral contracts designed by District staff and the extra attention STUDENT got in the SDC provided STUDENT with benefit by providing with him guidance in conforming his behavior.
Based on the fact that STUDENT was not provided with the counseling services and coordination called for in his IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's program did not conform to his IEP and was, therefore, not an appropriate placement pursuant to the test established by Rowley.
(4) Did Respondents propose a free, appropriate public education for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year?
In addition to the substantive appropriateness test identified above, the Rowley Court also held that school districts, to meet the obligations of IDEA, must comply with the procedures contained therein. The Court stated that when the elaborate and highly specific procedural safeguards embodied in § 1415 are contrasted with the general and somewhat imprecise substantive admonitions contained in the Act, we think that the importance congress attached to these procedural safeguards cannot be gainsaid. It seems to us no exaggeration to say that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process... EHLR 553:656, 669-670.
In 1992, the Ninth Circuit held that procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP process "clearly result in the denial of FAPE." W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range, 18 IDELR 1019 (9th Cir. 1992). Among the procedural violations which the Ninth Circuit has held constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with IDEA's procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith, 20 IDELR 987 (9th Cir. 1994). The Smith Court stated that the "IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child." Smith, 20 IDELR 987,990. The requirement of a written offer serves several purposes, including creating "a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later" and "will greatly assist parents in ‘present[ing] complaints with respect to any matter relating to the ... educational placement of the child.'" Id.
In the present case, the District clearly did not comply with the procedural requirements of IDEA in providing a specific placement offer. In many respects, it is impossible to complete the Rowley analysis of the substantive components of the District's 1997-98 "offer" because of the vagueness of that offer. The District submitted a written position paper on the first day of hearing. In relevant part, the position paper states:
The District has proposed in mediation and now takes an official position that STUDENT attend Central Gaither School in order to benefit from the day treatment program operated there by Mental Health. We propose he receive appropriate resource services in math and participate in group services within the SED classroom as appropriate without being identified as SED. (District's Position Paper, p. 2)
Subsequently, in its closing brief, the District proposed the following:
a change in Petitioner's placement to allow him to participate at least a half-day in the instructional activities of the Twin Rivers SED class in order to facilitate receiving day treatment services from Mental Health. Petitioner would be mainstreamed in regular fourth grade classes at Central Gaither School under an interdistrict attendance agreement with Yuba City School District or enrolled in the SED class by Sutter County Office of Education if necessary. (District's Closing Brief, p. 30)
The statement contained in the District's Position Paper is so vague as to not constitute a formal, written offer of placement. It is not clear from the statement whether STUDENT would be in a regular education class or in the SED special day class. It is also not clear exactly how he would participate in the day treatment services. At the outset of the hearing, the Hearing Officer understood the District to be offering STUDENT a placement in the regular education program at Central Gaither with some resource specialist services and the opportunity to participate in the day treatment services there as needed. However, by the conclusion of the hearing, the District's position had changed so that STUDENT's placement would consist of at least a half-day of instruction in the SED special day class. There is no mention of resource specialist services.
It is clear that the District either changed its proposed placement as the hearing progressed or is unsure of what exactly it was proposing. Under such circumstances, it is difficult to imagine that Petitioner could know what placement the District was proposing and be able to make an educated and informed decision regarding that proposed placement. Under the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to make a formal, written offer specific enough to allow Petitioner to participate effectively in decisions regarding that placement. The District's failure constitutes a violation of the procedures of the IDEA such that the District did not propose a placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year that can be considered in this decision.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year.
Petitioner contends that if the District has failed to offer an appropriate placement, STUDENT requires placement in the SED program at Twin River South (also referred to as Central Gaither). The District has also proposed placement, the form of which is unclear, at Twin River South. However, for the following reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the SED program at Twin River South is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
Both state and federal law require that students be educated in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031. A school district is required to implement and evaluate supplementary aids and services in the less restrictive environment in order to determine if the student is able to remain in that less restrictive environment. The supplementary aids and services must be implemented based on the unique needs of the student involved. See Rowley. If the supplementary aids and services prove to be ineffective, the District may propose a more restrictive environment. In addition, if compelling circumstances exist, a more restrictive environment may be appropriate before the school district has fully implemented and evaluated supplementary aids and services. However, to propose a more restrictive placement prior to implementation of supplementary aids and services which appear to hold a reasonable chance of success is to ignore the provisions of state and federal law.
Both federal and state law provide that a behavioral intervention plan is a related service that should be implemented in an effort to ensure that a child is educated in the least restrictive environment possible. The California Legislature has passed Education Code §§ 56520-24 and California Code of Regulations § 3052 to establish the procedures under which behavioral intervention plans are to be adopted. These statutes and regulations indicate a clear preference for schools to implement behavioral intervention plans which attempt to eliminate maladaptive behavior and encourage positive behavior to allow the student to remain in the less restrictive environment. California Code of Regulations § 3001(d).
As noted above, STUDENT's unique needs include a behavioral modification plan, whether a formal behavior intervention plan or a less formal behavior contract, to address his behaviors associated with ADHD. By the end of the 1996-97 school year, Mr. Martin had developed a more comprehensive behavioral plan than those that had been used with some success during the year. Mr. Martin's behavioral plan was based on a functional analysis of STUDENT's behaviors. However, that plan has not been implemented because STUDENT did not return to school. The record establishes that STUDENT was experiencing success and progressing within the regular education environment at Luther Elementary and that his needs in the area of math were being met in the resource specialist program. Considering STUDENT's progress at Luther Elementary and the fact that the District has not been given the opportunity to implement the behavioral plan developed by Mr. Martin, the least restrictive environment provisions of special education law require that STUDENT's placement be at Luther Elementary, his home school, with appropriate related services, including the implementation of Mr. Martin's behavioral plan.
Regarding related services, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continues to need additional educational counseling and resource specialist services in math. Based on STUDENT's eligibility and functioning in the regular education environment, there is no reason for STUDENT to enroll in a special day class. While STUDENT received some benefit from his SDC placement at the end of the third grade, the evidence does not demonstrate that STUDENT is incapable of functioning in the regular education environment. STUDENT requires a regular education placement with a fully implemented behavioral plan, counseling, and resource special services in math.
(5) Is Petitioner entitled to appropriate related services to be provided by qualified personnel, including counseling, parent training, recreational therapy, respite care, and transportation?
Special education includes related services that are necessary for a child to benefit from his or her special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56363 provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." It is obvious that Petitioner is entitled to necessary related services that are provided by qualified personnel. Addressing each of Petitioner's requests individually, the Hearing Officer makes the following findings:
Counseling
Petitioner contends that Ms. Ragasa is not qualified to provide counseling for STUDENT at Luther Elementary. Petitioner states that
STUDENT requires counseling pursuant to his IEP. Despite STUDENT's need for counseling, the counseling sessions were held very sporadically, due in part to Ms. Ragasa and in part to STUDENT's attendance difficulties. It is clear from Ms. Ragasa's testimony that she believes that STUDENT's difficulties are much more intense than those of the typical students whom she counsels. The District has not identified anyone other than Ms. Ragasa who can provide counseling for STUDENT. This supports STUDENT's position that he requires SED/Day Treatment placement so that the Day Treatment social worker can provide the necessary counseling... (Petitioner's Closing Brief, p. 36)
According to Ms. Ragasa, she has a master's degree in school counseling and has worked as a counseling intern under the supervision of a counselor since January 1995. Petitioner's contention assumes that STUDENT is SED and requires Mental Health counseling to benefit from his education. It is important to note that education counseling and mental health counseling are not the same. A child could require one or the other to benefit from his education, or he can require both. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not need mental health counseling to benefit from his education. As already noted, STUDENT's behavior, while significant enough to require some interventions, is not so serious as to disrupt his ability to benefit from his education and require mental health counseling.
Petitioner does not contend that Ms. Ragasa is not qualified to provide educational counseling. California Code of Regulations, Title 5, § 3001(x) defines "qualified" as meaning a person who has "met federal and state certification, licensing, registration, or other comparable requirements which apply to the area in which he or she is providing special education or related services... Nothing in this definition shall be construed as restricting the activities in services of a graduate needing direct hours leading to licensure, or of a student teacher or intern leading to a graduate degree at an accredited or approved college or university...." Based on Ms. Ragasa's degree in school counseling, the supervision of her program by a lead counselor, and the lack of any contention by Petitioner that Ms. Ragasa is not qualified to provide educational counseling, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Ragasa satisfies the definition of "qualified" pursuant to § 3001(x).
Parent training
Petitioner contends that "STUDENT's IEP has never included parent training for MOTHER. The District has done very little to support MOTHER in her care of STUDENT. The District failed to offer parenting classes to MOTHER. Even the District's expert, Dr. Merz, testified that she needed parent training." (Petitioner's Closing Brief, p. 36)
Based on the evidence that STUDENT has had a significant number of tardies and absences which have stemmed from his behavior at home and the potential for these tardies and absences to have adversely impacted STUDENT's educational benefit, the Hearing Officer finds that parent training is a related service STUDENT needs prospectively to benefit from his education. With appropriate parent training, it is hoped that STUDENT's attendance will improve so that he will be able to avail himself completely of the education and services offered at school.
Recreational therapy and respite care
Petitioner contends that "according to Dr. Komm, Mr. Morrish and Dr. French, STUDENT has difficulty relating to adults across multiple settings. This includes Dr. French, Mr. Morrish, Mr. Stewart, and Ms. Ragasa. STUDENT needs to learn how to have meaningful interaction with adults and to develop social skills in the community. Therefore, STUDENT must receive recreation services from an agency similar to what Phil Pryde described in his testimony." (Petitioner's Closing Brief, p. 36)
On the other hand, numerous District employees, including Monty Martin, Dorothy Johnson, Vicki Johnson, Sherri Phelan, Norm Jensen, and Vicki Carson, described the positive relationships they had with STUDENT and the positive social interactions they experienced with him. Petitioner also provides no basis for how recreation services provided by Mr. Pryde's agency, Yuba Sutter Respite and Community Services, would meet this "need." Mr. Pryde described his services as respite care designed to give parents a break from 24-hour day care of a child. Mr. Pryde described the benefit to the child as getting out into the community and doing things the parent may not otherwise be able to do with the child. Based on Mr. Pryde's testimony, there is nothing in the respite care his agency provides that is specifically designed to benefit STUDENT's education. Practically, any child would benefit from the type of service provided by Mr. Pryde. However, there is no evidence that STUDENT needs such a service to benefit from his education.
Transportation
Transportation may be included as a related service if it can be shown that transportation is necessary for a child to benefit from his education. Petitioner contends that he needs transportation to and from his Mental Health services to allow him to access those services. As already noted, there is nothing in the record to suggest that STUDENT needs Mental Health services for educational purposes. Furthermore, none of STUDENT's IEPs makes any reference to Mental Health services as a component of STUDENT's special education program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that transportation is not a necessary related service.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that parent training is a necessary related service to allow STUDENT to benefit from the educational services offered by the District. Parent training is necessary to address STUDENT's significant number of tardies and absences. Petitioner has not established that STUDENT needs respite care, recreation therapy, transportation, or Mental Health counseling.
(6) If Respondents failed to provide a free, appropriate public education, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Compensatory education is an appropriate remedy where a school district has failed to provide in appropriate education. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(I)(1)(B)(iii); School Comm. Of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992). Based on the holdings in Burlington and W.G. equitable considerations are relevant and the conduct of both parties should be reviewed in determining whether compensatory education is appropriate.
There were two periods during which the District did not provide STUDENT with an appropriate education. First, from November 1996 through the end of the 1996-97 school year, the District failed to provide an appropriate education for STUDENT by failing to provide counseling that conformed with his IEP. Second, the District, by failing to make a specific, formal, and written offer of placement for the 1997-98 school year, has failed to offer an appropriate education for STUDENT during the current school year.
The District's failure to provide counseling as required by STUDENT's IEP constitutes a significant breach of the requirement to provide a free appropriate education. Although STUDENT's behaviors do not rise to the level of SED, he does exhibit some behavior and social problems which could be addressed in counseling. This fact was recognized by the District before STUDENT was qualified for special education. As early as January 1995, the District provided counseling for STUDENT. While some of the problems with counseling may have been attributable to STUDENT's conduct, the fact remains that the District had an obligation to provide services consistent with his IEP. The fact that STUDENT's conduct was interfering with his counseling makes suggests that rather than cutting back on counseling, additional counseling should have been provided to address that conduct. If those services could not be provided, the District had an obligation to modify his IEP to meet his needs in a more appropriate manner. The District did not do so. However, there is also no evidence that additional counseling would benefit STUDENT. Counseling is not the type of service, such as tutoring in math, where additional sessions will help remediate a deficit. Therefore, additional sessions of counseling would not be an appropriate form of compensatory education.
Compensatory education is appropriate, however, for the District's failure to propose an appropriate placement for the 1997-98 school year. As noted above, the District submitted a proposed placement in its position paper at the outset of this hearing that was so vague that Petitioner could not have known what was being offered. This failure to propose a specific placement constitutes a significant procedural violation that has essentially denied STUDENT access to an appropriate placement during the 1997-98 school year to date. While the District has continued providing home instruction for STUDENT, there is nothing in the record, even considering Dr. French's opinion, to support a finding that home instruction is an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Based on the testimony of teachers and District staff, and the documentary evidence, it is clear that STUDENT was functioning appropriately in a regular education environment during the 1996-97 school year. Dr. French's opinion alone does not justify removing STUDENT from an educational setting and providing only home instruction. The District took the position throughout the hearing that they were required to provide home instruction once Dr. French recommended it. The Hearing Officer can find no authority for such a position in special education law, and the District did not cite any such authority. While STUDENT's IEP team was required to consider Dr. French's recommendation, the fact is that the IEP team was still responsible for developing and proposing an appropriate placement. If the IEP team did not agree with Dr. French's recommendation, the IEP team had a responsibility to continue offering an appropriate placement. In this case, the IEP team did not do so.
The District's failure to provide or propose an appropriate placement for the 1997-98 school year warrants an award of compensatory education to Petitioner. In his closing brief, Petitioner requests two forms of compensatory education. First, Petitioner requests recreational services as provided by Yuba Sutter Respite and Community Services. The Hearing Officer, however, finds that these services are not appropriate. As noted above, there does not appear to be a connection between these services and STUDENT's educational needs.
Second, Petitioner requests "tutorial services one hour per day, two days per week to make up for the academic instruction that he has missed." (Petitioner's Closing Brief, p. 37) The Hearing Officer finds that such services are appropriate under the circumstances. Beginning fifteen days from the date of this decision, the District shall provide additional tutoring for STUDENT two times per week, one hour per session. This tutoring shall be provided for one full calendar year.
(7) Did Respondents properly conduct an assessment of STUDENT's educational needs?
(A) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with the independent assessment completed by Dr. Richard Komm?
In reference to this issue, Petitioner made the following statement in his closing brief:
MOTHER is entitled to an independent assessment at public expense. In a letter dated May 27, 1997, MOTHER informed the District of her intent to obtain an independent assessment and to have the District fund the assessment. Dr. Komm's assessment presented the District and the Hearing Officer with an accurate picture of STUDENT's then current functioning. Dr. Komm agreed with the concerns of the Mental Health staff and assisted in presenting evidence of STUDENT's qualification as an SED child. (Petitioner's Closing Brief, p. 38)
Education Code § 56329(b) provides that "a parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists, ... if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency." However, the public education agency has the right to present evidence at a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate. If the public education agency prevails, the parent does not have a right to reimbursement for the independent assessment.
In the present case, Petitioner has provided no grounds on which to find that the District's assessments were inappropriate. It is difficult, therefore, to determine the exact basis for Petitioner's claim for reimbursement. The evidence establishes that Monty Martin and Vicki Johnson conducted a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT's academic, cognitive, social, emotional, and adaptive skills. The assessment consisted of several different instruments designed to assess STUDENT's social and emotional functioning to determine whether he qualified as SED for educational purposes. The assessment also included numerous observations of STUDENT and conversations with STUDENT by the assessors.
The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to present any evidence that the District's assessment was inappropriate. Therefore, Petitioner's request for reimbursement for Dr. Komm's assessment is denied.
(9) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred as a result of Respondents' failure to make an AB 3632 referral prior to March 1997 and to provide a free, appropriate public education?
In reference to this issue, Petitioner made the following statement in his closing brief:
MOTHER is entitled to the following costs incurred as a result of the District's failure to provide STUDENT with FAPE: transportation costs to and from Mental Health out patient appointments; transportation costs to and from hospitalizations in 1993 and 1996. (Petitioner's Closing Brief, p. 38)Petitioner does not cite any legal authority or grounds under which he is entitled to these costs. As already noted above, Petitioner has failed to establish that STUDENT is SED or that he requires Mental Health services as a part of his special education program. Therefore, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for expenses relating to transportation to and from Mental Health appointments. Furthermore, Petitioner has provided no grounds for finding that transportation to and from the hospitalizations are educationally related expenses. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the expenses listed above.
ORDER
(1) Within 15 days of the date of this decision, the Live Oak Unified School District shall convene an IEP team to develop an appropriate placement for STUDENT consistent with the terms of this decision. Such placement shall include placement in a regular education environment, educational counseling once per week for 30 minutes, resource specialist services designed to address STUDENT's needs in math, and the implementation of Monty Martin's behavior plan.
(2) In addition to the services provided in STUDENT's IEP, the Live Oak Unified School District shall provide STUDENT with two one-hour sessions of tutoring each week. The tutoring services shall commence within fifteen days of the date of this decision and last for one full calendar year.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
The hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. Education Code § 56507(d). The following findings are made in accordance with § 56507(d).
(1) Did Respondents fail to identify STUDENT as seriously emotionally disturbed?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
(2) Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education during the 1995-96 school year?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
(3) Did Respondents provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education, including an appropriate behavioral intervention plan, during the 1996-97 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(4) Did Respondents propose a free, appropriate public education for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(5) Is Petitioner entitled to appropriate related services to be provided by qualified personnel, including counseling, parent training, recreational therapy, respite care, and transportation?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue only to the extent that STUDENT is entitled to parent training and continuing educational counseling.
(6) If Respondents failed to provide a free, appropriate public education, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(7) Did Respondents properly conduct an assessment of STUDENT's educational needs?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
(8) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with the independent assessment completed by Dr. Richard Komm?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
(9) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred as a result of Respondents' failure to make an AB 3632 referral prior to March 1997 and to provide a free, appropriate public education?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(I).
DATED: February 16, 1998 ___________________________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. Sutter County Office of Education (COE) and the Sutter County SELPA (SELPA) were originally also named as Respondents. However, the SELPA was dismissed because the SELPA had no past or future role in STUDENT's education. The COE was dismissed because the COE had no past involvement in STUDENT's education. Additionally, while the COE operates the SED program requested by Petitioner, the COE through its attorney, Susan Slager, stipulated that if the final decision is to enroll Petitioner in the SED program, the COE would accept the decision and enroll Petitioner.
2. Many of the District employees were called by both Petitioner and the District.
3. Furthermore, based on the findings of this decision, additional mental health documentation would have had no impact on the ultimate findings in this matter.
4. The Mental Health services, other than medication monitoring, were terminated in December 1994 because STUDENT's behavior appeared stabilized. The other services, including individual therapy, resumed on April 26, 1995, as a result of increased behavior problems.
