California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 10, 1998

Student v. Modesto City School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 701-98, SN 675-98 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Modesto City School District must keep student at Johansen High SDC and revise a behavior plan that fell short of Hughes Bill rules.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 3 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Cases SN 675-98 (District) and SN 701-98 (Student) were consolidated on June 1, 1998. No remand, appeal, or correction is noted in the decision.

Summary

Modesto City School District and the student's family each filed for a hearing, and the cases were consolidated. The student, 16 and in tenth grade, was described as autistic and mentally retarded. He attended a special day class (SDC) for students with severe disabilities at Peter Johansen High School, his neighborhood school. After his behavior escalated in spring 1998, the District suspended him. At a May 4 IEP meeting that the mother did not attend, District staff decided to move him back to the more restrictive SDC at Thomas Downey High School. The mother refused.

Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found that Johansen staff never properly put in place the behavior plan that had worked at Downey. Their responses were inconsistent and sometimes inappropriate, including pouring water on the student. Staff also never completed a speech and language assessment, even though there were signs his behavior was a way of communicating. Because the District had to try an appropriate behavior plan before moving him to a more restrictive setting, Johansen remained the right placement. Relying on behavior analyst Theodore Schoneberger, she found the May 1998 behavioral intervention plan (BIP) did not meet Hughes Bill requirements. She also found the District denied FAPE from May 8 to May 21, 1998. During that time it kept him out of Johansen without parent consent and without filing for a hearing, but she awarded no compensatory education. The District had to complete the assessment, revise the BIP, hold an IEP meeting, and keep him at Johansen.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied California's Hughes Bill. A district that never properly used a behavior plan could not rely on the student's behavior to move him to a more restrictive class. The decision also shows that a district could not change a placement without parent consent unless it first filed for due process.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. What placement offers STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1998-1999 school year?

    Johansen SDC is the less restrictive placement; the District must implement an appropriate behavior plan and address communication needs before changing his placement to Downey.

  2. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2. Does the behavioral intervention plan (BIP) developed in May 1998 conform with the requirements of the Hughes Bill?

    Relying on the Student's behavior expert, the Hearing Officer found the May 1998 BIP did not meet 5 C.C.R. § 3001 requirements and must be revised.

  3. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE from May 4, 1998, to May 29, 1998?

    The District denied FAPE from May 8 to May 21, 1998, by keeping the student out of Johansen and providing no services without parent consent to the new placement or a District hearing request; no compensatory remedy was awarded.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to assess. If not already completed under the consented assessment plan, District shall complete a speech and language assessment within 10 business days of the decision.
  • Within 10 business days, District shall revise the BIP to conform with 5 C.C.R. § 3001(h), including specific dates for IEP team review.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 business days, convene an IEP meeting to review speech-language assessment results and decide eligibility for speech-language services (adding goals and services if eligible), discuss the revised BIP, assign a behavioral intervention case manager (BICM), and amend the IEP to reflect the BIP.
  • Placement ordered. IEP to be conformed to reflect the student's placement in the Johansen SDC.
  • Order to provide or change services. Immediately after the IEP meeting, District shall implement the BIP and speech-language services if the IEP team finds the student eligible for them.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56346; Education Code § 56520(b)(1); Education Code § 56363; 5 C.C.R. § 3001(f), (h) (Hughes Bill)

People named in the decision

  • Chris Neall, SELPA director, Modesto City School District
  • Chris Wolfley, special education teacher (SDC), Peter Johansen High School
  • Devona Degnan, special education teacher (SDC), Peter Johansen High School
  • Robert Ackerman, special education teacher (SDC), Thomas Downey High School
  • Robert Stack, school psychologist (developed 1997 behavior management plan), Modesto City School District
  • Bill O'Brien, school psychologist (conducted FAA and May 1998 BIP), Modesto City School District
  • Jeremiah Boek, paraprofessional, Peter Johansen High School
  • Elvera Hollaway, paraprofessional, Peter Johansen High School
  • Diane Jackson, home teacher, Modesto City School District
  • William B. Williams, school psychologist, witness for District, Modesto City School District
  • Leticia Vidal, paraprofessional, Thomas Downey High School (Ackerman SDC)
  • Theodore G. Schoneberger, senior behavioral analyst, expert witness for Student, Applied Behavioral Consultants (certified nonpublic agency)
  • Applied Behavioral Consultants, nonpublic agency
  • Christi McCarthy, transportation facilitator, Modesto City School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Modesto, California, on June 16 and 17, July 27 and 28, and August 3, 1998. STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Bob Varma. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were his mother and her fiancé. Modesto City School District (hereinafter “District”) was represented at the hearing by attorney Jan K. Damesyn. Also present on behalf of the District was Chris Neall, SELPA director.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was held open for closing arguments. Thereafter, the matter was closed and submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) What placement offers STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1998-1999 school year?

(2) Does the behavioral intervention plan (BIP) developed in May 1998 conform with the requirements of the Hughes Bill?(Footnote 1)

(3) Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE from May 4, 1998, to May 29, 1998?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a 16-year-old student in the tenth grade. STUDENT has been diagnosed as autistic and mentally retarded. He exhibits inappropriate behaviors that include pouring drinks over other students’ heads, snatching eye glasses worn by other students and adults, running away from staff, throwing drinking cups and other items, and verbal and physical outbursts. (See Student’s Exhibit 4, pp. 59-65.) For a majority of the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT attended the special day class (SDC) for severely disabled students at Peter Johansen High School (hereinafter “Johansen”), his neighborhood high school. The SDC was taught by Chris Wolfley and Devona Degnan. STUDENT’s individualized educational program (IEP) includes goals and objectives in the areas of toileting, mobility, receptive and expressive language, self-concept, relations with others, and play. (Student’s Exhibit 2, pp. 10-16.) The IEP also provides for STUDENT to receive the designated instruction and services (DIS) of transportation, adapted physical education (APE), and extended school year (ESY).(Footnote 2)

During the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT entered the District from a Stanislaus SELPA class. He was placed in the SDC taught by Robert Ackerman at Thomas Downey High School (hereinafter “Downey”). STUDENT’s IEP included the services of a one-to-one classroom aide, as needed, and APE. (Student’s Exhibit 2, p. 28.) On January 8, 1997, school psychologist Robert Stack developed a behavior management plan for STUDENT.(Footnote 3) The plan identified the following inappropriate behaviors:

Forcefully taking others property (pulling off glasses when angry at sam [sic], yelling he/she hit me when verbally confronted about his actions/biting self and staff.)

The behavior management plan prescribed staff intervention when STUDENT complied with staff directions as well as when he engaged in inappropriate behaviors, such as running out of the room, biting himself or staff, or resisting tasks and directions. Appropriate staff interventions identified in the plan include: praise, one-to-one attention, joking, verbal redirection, and positive reinforcement. (Student’s Exhibit 4, pp. 66-67.) Mr. Ackerman also developed two behavior modification plans for STUDENT to address STUDENT’s forcefully taking the property of others, including eyeglasses, darting out of the room, falling on the floor, and yelling. Mr. Ackerman’s interventions included giving STUDENT praise and applause, joking with him, and treating him as part of the team. Mr. Ackerman also recommended ignoring STUDENT’s swearing. (District’s Exhibit 46, pp. 101- 102.)

STUDENT returned to Mr. Ackerman’s SDC at the beginning of the 1997-1998 school year. The District completed STUDENT’s triennial assessment in September 1997. Mr. Stack conducted the psychological portion of the assessment. He concluded that STUDENT’s behavior had improved. Mr. Stack’s recommendations included that STUDENT continue in an SDC for more than one-half of his school day. At a meeting on September 19, 1997, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT’s placement be changed to the SDC at Johansen. It is noted on the IEP document that STUDENT had been much calmer and that verbal outbursts had decreased since his prior IEP. He also had not had any physical outbursts since April 1997, had shown remarkable progress while riding the bus, and was able to sit at a group activity for 60 to 90 minutes. STUDENT’s transfer to Johansen took place on October 7, 1997. STUDENT’s IEP in place at the time of the transfer included the following goals and objectives: improving domestic skills by selecting items from pictures in the newspaper and selecting items one time per month at the grocery store; improving vocational skills by engaging in varying jobs; and improving recreational skills by participating in a group bingo activity of matching sight words. (Student’s Exhibit 2, pp. 17-23) The IEP also included a transition plan. The IEP is silent as to whether the behavior management plan continued to be in effect.

According to the Johansen SDC teachers, STUDENT had some behavioral problems at the beginning of the school year which were not considered serious and were not documented. In February 1998, STUDENT’s behavioral problems began to escalate in frequency and severity. (Student’s Exhibit 4, pp. 59-65.) On April 7, 1998, the IEP team convened to review STUDENT’s IEP and to discuss STUDENT’s behavior. The team drafted new goals and objectives and continued to recommend placement in the SDC. MOTHER consented to the IEP, to the District’s undertaking a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT’s behavior, development of a BIP, and to a speech and language evaluation. (Student’s Exhibit 2, pp. 10-16 and Exhibit 3, p. 52.) Sometime thereafter, school psychologist Bill O’Brien conducted the FAA. As of the last day of the hearing, the speech and language assessment had not been undertaken.

On April 30, 1998, the District suspended STUDENT for five days (May 1, and 4-7, 1998). The following rationale was given for the suspension:

Student has been extremely disruptive and violent. These actions have escalated this week. Another student was assaulted and had his glasses broken. Student threw soda on another student.

(Student’s Exhibit 5, p. 86.)

On May 4, 1998, the District convened an IEP meeting. The District did not send a written notice of the IEP meeting to MOTHER; however, Mr. Wolfley orally informed MOTHER of the meeting. It is unclear whether MOTHER was informed that the meeting being convened was an IEP meeting and whether MOTHER initially indicated that she would be able to attend. In any case, MOTHER did not attend the meeting because of a babysitting obligation. At the meeting, District members of the IEP team determined that STUDENT should be transferred to the SDC at Downey that he had previously attended. MOTHER did not sign the IEP when later contacted by the District. The District took the position that STUDENT’s placement changed as a result of the IEP meeting on May 4, 1998, and that he was free to return to school on May 8, 1998, following his suspension, so long as he attended Downey. As of May 6, 1998, STUDENT was dropped from bus transportation and was not reinstated. (Student’s Exhibit 7, p. 109.)(Footnote 4) MOTHER understood that she was to provide transportation for STUDENT to attend Downey until transportation could be arranged by the District. MOTHER declined to enroll STUDENT at Downey.

At a subsequent IEP team meeting on May 20, 1998, the IEP team reviewed the BIP, which is dated May 4, 1998.(Footnote 5) Mr. O’Brien identified the following “presenting problems” related to STUDENT’s behavior: striking other students without overt provocation; destruction of personal property; defiance; throwing items in the classroom; and dumping liquids on other students. (Student’s Exhibit 4, pp. 55-57.) District members of the IEP team continued to recommend placing STUDENT at Downey or, in the alternative, in an SDC at John F. Kennedy School, a segregated site for students with severe disabilities. MOTHER did not consent to either of the placements proposed by the District or to implementation of the BIP. (Student’s Exhibit 2, p. 8.)

On May 21, 1998, the Hearing Office received the District’s request for a due process hearing (SN 675-98) regarding the provision of FAPE to STUDENT. On May 22, 1998, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT also on the issue of FAPE (SN 701-98).(Footnote 6)

On May 22, 1998, the District sought and obtained an order enjoining and restraining STUDENT from attending school at Johansen for the remainder of the school year. The basis for the order was the alleged risk of STUDENT’s causing harm to other students. (District’s Exhibits pp. 220-270.) The District then provided a home teacher for STUDENT as an interim placement. An addendum to the IEP, which was signed on June 5, 1998, states that “STUDENT’s stay-put placement remains as specified on his last agreed upon IEP dated 4-7-98.” (District’s Exhibit 1.) The District assigned Diane Jackson as STUDENT’s home teacher. During Ms. Jackson’s third home visit on June 12, 1998, STUDENT struck her in the head. The District suspended STUDENT from home teaching from June 15 to June 19, 1998. (Student’s Exhibit 5, p. 108.)

For the ESY during the summer of 1998, the District offered to place STUDENT in an SDC taught by Mr. Ackerman. The class was held at Johansen. (District’s Exhibits p. 150.) MOTHER did not enroll STUDENT in the ESY.

STUDENT contends that the SDC at Johansen offers him an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment. STUDENT asserts that Johansen is his neighborhood school and provides him with more mainstreaming opportunities. STUDENT also asserts that the SDC at Johansen is designed to serve students who are autistic. Finally, STUDENT asserts that the District is required to provide him with supplementary aids and services, including implementation of a positive behavioral intervention plan, prior to removing him from the SDC at Johansen. Finally, STUDENT asserts that the District did not develop an appropriate BIP or provide him with a FAPE following his suspension in May 1998.

The District contends that the SDC at Downey, which STUDENT previously attended, offers him an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment. The District asserts that because of significant behavioral problems that pose a danger to STUDENT and to others, he requires an SDC that has a smaller teacher-to-student ratio and is more structured than the SDC at Johansen.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: What placement offers STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1998-1999 school year?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. . . ." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).

The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education, and psychological services. Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management.

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.

Special education law also requires that a student must be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031.

To summarize, under IDEA and Rowley, an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, comport with the IEP, and must also be provided in the least restrictive environment.

STUDENT’s educational needs are related to improving self-help and functional-living skills. His IEP includes specific goals and objectives related to toileting, mobility, receptive and expressive language, self-concept, relations with others, and play. The evidence also establishes that STUDENT has longstanding behavioral problems that decreased sufficiently to allow him to be placed in the Johansen SDC in October 1997. In the spring of 1998, STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior escalated and resulted in his suspension from school. The District contends that STUDENT’s behavior renders the Johansen SDC an inappropriate placement for STUDENT.

The staff of the Johansen SDC described behaviors that they considered to be dangerous to STUDENT, other students, or staff. Chris Wolfley and Devona Degnan are the teachers of the Johansen SDC. They are assisted by two paraprofessionals, Jeremiah Boek and Elvera Hollaway. Mr. Wolfley testified that when STUDENT entered the class, he responded positively to physical contact such as hugging. Working on the computer would also “pacify him for a while.” However, on February 17, 1998, when STUDENT came off the bus “visibly disturbed,” cursing, and screaming, neither offers of a hug nor an opportunity to work on the computer was effective, and STUDENT’s behavior was disruptive all day. On February 23, 1998, STUDENT picked up a mug full of coffee from Ms. Degnan’s desk and threw the cup at the wall.(Footnote 7) Ms. Degnan testified that, pursuant to the behavioral intervention plan, STUDENT was sent to sit outside the door. Shortly thereafter, he calmly helped clean up the coffee. On March 2, 1998, STUDENT cursed and once again picked up a mug of coffee from Ms. Degnan’s desk and threw it. In the cafeteria, he threw a cup of soda and a chair. Mr. Wolfley testified that STUDENT had difficulty whenever the class did not do all of the regular activities in the cafeteria such as stacking chairs and moving the tables. In response to STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior in the cafeteria, Mr. Wolfley took STUDENT for a walk to calm him down.

STUDENT also threw a jar of candy, a shoe, and potted plants. There are numerous reports of STUDENT’s snatching glasses from the faces of teachers and other students. Mr. Wolfley testified that STUDENT also had problems with compliance when transitioning from one activity to another. Mr. Wolfley reported that because of STUDENT’s agitation on two consecutive days in April, he had to put STUDENT in a basket hold on the floor. By using the basket hold, Mr. Wolfley restrained STUDENT’s movement and prevented him from leaving the room. Each of these events lasted for approximately 20 minutes. On April 28, 1998, STUDENT had a particularly difficult day, which culminated in STUDENT’s leaving the campus and going halfway across a pedestrian overpass over a busy street. Mr. Wolfley acknowledged that STUDENT had said he wanted his mother on that day and that the bridge was on the route to his home.

Mr. Wolfley and Ms. Degnan both described incidents of STUDENT’s dumping sodas on regular education students. Following such incidents, they implemented a response that had been used by STUDENT’s previous teacher.(Footnote 8) On one or more occasions, they poured water on STUDENT’s head. On at least one other occasion, they instructed a regular education student to pour water on STUDENT’s head.(Footnote 9)

Ms. Hollaway described an incident that occurred when she was trying to get STUDENT to return to his physical education class. As STUDENT approached the parking lot, he began yelling obscenities at her and hit her in the face while trying to take off her glasses. She related other incidents that made her fearful for the safety of nearby students and staff. Ms. Hollaway testified that sometimes she was able to change STUDENT’s mood by talking to him. She attributed Mr. Wolfley’s being able to control STUDENT to either some special training or to “shouting to him.” Mr. Boek, the other paraprofessional in the class, described STUDENT’s behavior as “uncontrollable.” Mr. Boek also stated that when confronted, STUDENT could become “ballistic.”

The District also cited the unpredictable nature of STUDENT’s behavior as a reason to change his placement. Mr. Wolfley and other classroom staff testified that they generally were unable to identify antecedents to STUDENT’s acting out; however, Mr. Wolfley indicated that he was able to identify some of STUDENT’s “idiosyncracies,” which enabled him to predict when STUDENT’s behavior would intensify. Ms. Degnan was also able to identify deep breathing and cussing as foreshadowing some of STUDENT’s outbursts. She also noted that Mondays were particularly difficult for STUDENT. Additionally, the functional analysis, reports of observations, and the behavioral management plan developed by Mr. Stack and other District personnel who have worked with STUDENT were able to identify antecedents. William B. Williams, school psychologist, who testified on behalf of the District, stated that antecedents to STUDENT’s behavior have been well known since 1991. Leticia Vidal, paraprofessional in Mr. Ackerman’s SDC, testified that she also was able to identify antecedents to STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior. For example, Ms. Vidal noted that when she observed STUDENT leaning back with his arms crossed, she would know that something was “brewing,” thereby allowing her to intervene before STUDENT engaged in inappropriate behavior. An additional indicator to Ms. Vidal of STUDENT’s potential for inappropriate behavior was STUDENT’s exiting the bus in the morning complaining about something. In his deposition, Mr. Stack stated that “they [Mr. Ackerman and the Downey SDC staff] got finally to the point where you’re anticipating situations almost before they happen, and that was one of the reasons we were so successful in reducing down his frequency rate, was we pretty much knew what would set him off and what wouldn’t. . . .” (Student’s Exhibit 8, p. 23.)

Theodore G. Schoneberger, who is a senior behavioral analyst with Applied Behavioral Consultants, a certified nonpublic agency, was called to testify on behalf of STUDENT.(Footnote 10) By reviewing the behavioral notes of Mr. Wolfley and Ms. Degnan, Mr. Schoneberger was able to identify several antecedents to STUDENT’s behavior, as well as the intent and consequences of his behavior. One of the conclusions Mr. Schoneberger reached was that some of STUDENT’s behaviors were attempts to communicate.

As stated above, a school district is required to provide services that are necessary for the student to benefit from special education. Education Code § 56363. Moreover, a functional analysis assessment and development of a BIP satisfying the requirements of the Hughes Bill are required whenever a special education student “exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP.” 5 C.C.R. § 3001(h). There is no dispute that STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior interfered with his ability to benefit from his education while attending Johansen; however, the only BIP developed for STUDENT to specifically address his behavior at Johansen was not developed until May 1998. This BIP was never implemented. STUDENT had entered Johansen with a behavioral management plan, which had been developed by Mr. Stack, school psychologist, while STUDENT was in Mr. Ackerman’s class at Downey. Mr. Stack described the behavioral management plan he developed as “critical” in getting STUDENT’s behavior under control and allowing him to move to the less restrictive environment at Johansen. (See Deposition of Robert Stack, Student’s Exhibit 8, pp. 32-33.) It is unclear whether Mr. Stack’s behavioral management plan constitutes a Hughes Bill BIP, and the evidence does not conclusively establish that the plan was implemented when STUDENT entered Johansen. As more fully discussed below, it is questionable whether the staff employed the behavioral strategies set forth in Mr. Stack’s plan, whether the strategies that they did employ were appropriate, and whether the plan was effective in the new educational environment, to the extent it may have been implemented.

According to the Johansen teachers and paraprofessionals, STUDENT engaged in some inappropriate behavior from the day he entered the classroom; however, their testimony establishes that the “critical” behavior management plan was not implemented when STUDENT entered Johansen. Ms. Degnan testified that because she preferred to develop her own ideas and plans to address STUDENT’s needs, she did not even review the behavior plan developed by Mr. Stack until sometime in the spring of 1998. Mr. Boek testified that he had not seen the behavioral management plan that accompanied STUDENT to Johansen and that the only information he received related to STUDENT’s behavior and appropriate interventions to employ with STUDENT was from Mr. Wolfley. There was no evidence that Ms. Hollaway had reviewed the plan. Mr. Wolfley testified that it was not until STUDENT’s behaviors escalated in the spring of 1998, that the classroom staff implemented the behavioral management plan developed by Mr. Stack. There also is no evidence that anyone from Johansen consulted with Mr. Stack or a behavioral intervention case manager (BICM) regarding implementing the behavioral management plan or for any other reason related to STUDENT’s behavior. Mr. Wolfley was unaware of whether anyone was even assigned as STUDENT’s BICM.

Even if it could be construed that Mr. Stack’s plan was implemented, the testimony of the SDC teachers and paraprofessionals establishes that their responses to STUDENT’s behavior were, at times, inappropriate, were inconsistent, or did not comport with Mr. Stack’s behavioral management plan. The SDC staff testified that, in response to STUDENT’s pouring a soda on a student, they poured water over STUDENT. On at least one occasion, the SDC staff instructed a regular education student to pour water over STUDENT even though the regular education student protested. The pouring of liquids over STUDENT is an inappropriate intervention and is contrary to the purpose and the requirements of the Hughes Bill, which provides that behavioral interventions must respect the student’s “human dignity and personal privacy” and must “assure the individual’s physical freedom, social interaction, and individual choice.” 5 C.C.R. § 3001(f).

Mr. Wolfley described some of the other interventions employed in the class with STUDENT. Those interventions included: talking to STUDENT to calm him down; hugging him; giving him time out; joking; rubbing his shoulders and arms; patting his arms; holding him in a basket hold; and going on walks. Ms. Degnan added the following interventions: changing STUDENT’s seat in the classroom so that he had walls on two sides; moving other students away from him; altering STUDENT’s schedule; and adjusting the environment to determine the most conducive learning environment for STUDENT. As an example of adjusting the environment, Ms. Degnan stated that they played music and videos and, at other times, they did not. They also tried having the lights on, as well as off. In summary, the staff provided STUDENT with hugs or talked to him following some inappropriate behavior, whereas Mr. Boek sometimes confronted STUDENT, and Mr. Wolfley’s repertoire of responses included all of the above, as well as yelling and physically restraining STUDENT.

The behavioral management plan developed by Mr. Stack called for redirecting STUDENT verbally, waiting for STUDENT to refocus on task and then providing him with positive reinforcement, and minimally using physical contact to direct STUDENT, if needed. To reduce escape/avoidance behavior, the plan called for STUDENT to be “treated as part of a team, following role models of the class, with a student helper. Using humor to diffuse anxiety.” To encourage STUDENT to comply with verbal commands, the plan called for staff to provide “positive verbal reinforcers, one on one time, praise, and applause.” (Student’s Exhibit 4, pp. 66-67.) Based on the testimony of the SDC staff, it is concluded that not all of the interventions they employed were consistent with the behavioral management plan. The testimony also establishes that the staff’s response to STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior was inconsistent, whereas all of the evidence regarding STUDENT’s needs included in assessments and by report of his teachers, establishes that STUDENT requires consistency. Additionally, there was little evidence of the use of positive reinforcement at Johansen as called for by the plan.

Mr. Stack’s report, the result of multiple observations of STUDENT’s behavior in December 1996 and January 1997, identified receptive and expressive communication as crucial factors in defusing STUDENT’s anxiety and frustration leading to inappropriate behaviors. (See also Student’s Exhibit 8, pp. 24-25, 38-39.) Mr. Schoneberger also concluded that some of STUDENT’s behaviors have communicative intent and suggested that a speech and language specialist may help develop ways for STUDENT to communicate. An assessment plan dated January 19, 1997, identified communication as an area to be assessed; however, the plan also states, “Speech eval to be conducted later in semester after transition to Johansen. Parent to contact site when STUDENT is successfully transitioned.” (Student’s Exhibit 3, p. 53.) Apparently MOTHER did not contact anyone at the school to initiate the assessment. The IEP dated April 7, 1998, states, “We will refer STUDENT to the speech therapist for a current assessment (language assessment).” (Student’s Exhibit 2, p. 11) However, the assessment plan developed on that same date does not include a language assessment. (Student’s Exhibit 3, p. 52.) Although the communicative intent of STUDENT’s behavior and the need for an evaluation of STUDENT’s communicative skills were identified prior to STUDENT’s entering Johansen, neither was addressed. MOTHER has signed an assessment plan; however, as of the date of the hearing, an assessment had not been completed.

Moreover, by the time the Johansen staff attempted to implement the behavioral management plan, the plan was more than one year old and STUDENT’s behavior had escalated significantly. No reevaluation of the plan by the appropriate professionals occurred for the purpose of determining whether it needed modification in the new environment or whether it remained appropriate to address the behaviors STUDENT was then exhibiting. There also is no evidence that data were collected, as called for by the plan, or that a review of the plan was held when STUDENT’s behavior escalated to being a threat to his safety or to that of the staff or other students. (See Student’s Exhibit 4, p. 67.)

Student additionally asserts that the services of an aide are also a related service that is necessary to allow him to remain in the Johansen SDC. The evidence does not substantiate that STUDENT requires a one-to-one aide. Based on his observations of STUDENT, Mr. Ackerman expressed the opinion that a one-to-one aide would not be helpful for STUDENT. In his experience, STUDENT’s behavior deteriorated whenever he was assigned an aide. Mr. Ackerman stated that when more than one person works one-to-one with STUDENT it is difficult to maintain consistency, which may result in STUDENT’s being confused about what is expected of him. Mr. Stack also did not believe a one-to-one aide should be assigned exclusively to STUDENT; however, Mr. Stack testified that the FAA should really address the issue of whether an aide is a necessary component of a BIP for STUDENT.

The District argues that seven people testified that the SDC at Johansen does not offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT and that implementation of a BIP will not make it appropriate.

The testimony of Ms. Degnan and Mr. Wolfley establishes that the following are available at Johansen to address STUDENT’s unique and individual needs: the class serves students with autism, mental retardation, and developmental disabilities; the students range in age from 15 years to 21 years; the class curriculum focuses on functional living skills; the classroom schedule rarely changes; there are opportunities for job training in the cafeteria and in the gym, where students sort football jerseys; and there are opportunities for one-to-one instruction. The TEACCH curriculum for students with autism is employed.

The District’s witnesses, including the classroom teachers, Mr. Ackerman, and Mr. Williams, testified that the noise or business or some other factor resulted in STUDENT’s behaving inappropriately and, thereby, rendered Johansen an inappropriate placement. For example, the number of students in the class creates a higher noise level and additional visual stimuli, which could be distracting to STUDENT; the students are higher functioning than STUDENT, which may cause him to feel “left out” because he does not possess similar skills; and, at Johansen, there are fewer opportunities for one-to-one and small-group instruction than at Downey. Mr. Ackerman also testified that the techniques he employed to manage STUDENT’s behavior could not be used at Johansen. As previously noted, STUDENT was moved to Johansen in the fall of 1997, by the decision of the IEP team. The decision was based, in part, on STUDENT’s improved behavior while the behavioral management plan was being implemented at Downey. Mr. Ackerman was a member of that IEP team and there is no indication that, at the time the decision was made, he disagreed with the recommendation to transfer STUDENT to Johansen or then held any of the concerns expressed at the hearing. There is no evidence that Mr. Ackerman has first hand knowledge of the Johansen class or that he has observed STUDENT while at Johansen. There also was no testimony regarding the basis for his having changed his opinion regarding the appropriateness of the Johansen class.

Mr. Williams’ concerns were related to the effect of the noise and activity levels and the general “busyness” of the classroom. Mr. Williams reviewed STUDENT’s educational records; however, he has not met STUDENT. Mr. Williams visited the SDC at Johansen; however, the students were not present during his visit and Mr. Williams did not speak with the teachers. For these reasons, the testimony of Mr. Williams and Mr. Ackerman is not persuasive on this issue. The Johansen SDC staff has familiarity with STUDENT; however, they worked with STUDENT without the benefit of appropriate behavioral interventions. As to whether the SDC is designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s interests expanded while attending Johansen. For example, he developed an interest in using the computer. According to MOTHER, STUDENT also became more interested in going places. During the summer, STUDENT successfully participated in a horse riding program and engaged in numerous activities during a family vacation. MOTHER testified that, for most of the school year, STUDENT was successful in the Johansen SDC and that his behavioral difficulties did not escalate until the end of the school year. The testimony of MOTHER and Christi McCarthy, transportation facilitator, establishes that while attending Johansen, STUDENT was able to independently ride the bus to and from school without difficulty, whereas the prior school year, the bus company had not allowed STUDENT to ride the bus without an aide. Ms. McCarthy also testified that STUDENT did not receive any bus citations during the 1997-1998 school year, which was a big improvement from the prior school year.

The testimony of Johansen SDC staff and documentary evidence provided conflicting information regarding STUDENT’s ability to benefit from the placement. For example, STUDENT’s report card indicates that he received all “A” grades except for a “B” in APE. Additionally, all of his citizenship grades were marked “satisfactory.” (Student’s Exhibit 7, p. 107.) On the other hand, Mr. Wolfley characterized the report card as a “mark on a piece of paper so the people in the office will not have to send out progress reports or do a lot of needless paper work.” Mr. Wolfley testified that the daily recordings in STUDENT’s binder are a more accurate reflection of his performance. The binder sheets in evidence indicated that STUDENT’s behavior was generally “very good.” However, the only sheets that had been maintained by either party were for the period from October 7 through October 24, 1997. Mr. Wolfley testified that STUDENT did not make progress while in the Johansen SDC and had met only one of his goals. On the other hand, Ms. Degnan testified that the goals and objectives in effect when STUDENT entered the class were not even implemented.

It is clear from the testimony that STUDENT’s behavior and the lack of an effective behavioral plan impeded the ability of STUDENT’s IEP to be implemented at Johansen. Despite the failure of the Johansen SDC to implement a behavioral intervention plan or to address STUDENT’s communication needs, STUDENT exhibited some potential to benefit in the Johansen SDC. He rode the bus successfully without the assistance of an aide and his behavior was acceptable until the spring of the school year.

As to whether the Johansen placement conforms to STUDENT’s IEP, the evidence establishes that all of the services called for by the IEP are available at Johansen. Ms. Degnan testified that the goals and objectives contained in STUDENT’s when he entered were not appropriate to the Johansen SDC setting; however, new goals and objectives were drafted in April 1998. The staff of the Johansen SDC participated in drafting those goals and objectives and there was no testimony that the goals and objectives could not be implemented.

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s unique needs require implementation of a behavioral intervention plan to allow him to benefit from his education. The District’s BIP developed in May 1998 was not implemented because STUDENT was suspended and then prevented from returning to Johansen for the remainder of the 1997-1998 school year. California special education law provides that a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) is a related service that must be implemented in an effort to ensure that the student is able to be educated in the least restrictive environment. Education Code § 56520(b)(1); Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3001(f). STUDENT’s neighborhood school is Johansen and there are opportunities for him to participate in school activities with neighborhood peers. The Johansen SDC’s curriculum also offers him opportunities to develop functional skills that will allow him to be integrated into the community. The evidence also established that STUDENT is able to ride the bus independently to Johansen. For these reasons, placement at Johansen offers STUDENT a less restrictive environment than Downey.

The evidence establishes that, when Mr. Stack’s behavioral management plan was properly implemented during the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT’s behavior improved and he benefited from his special education instruction. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that it is more likely than not that properly addressing STUDENT’s behavioral and communication needs may alleviate the intensity and frequency of STUDENT’s misconduct. With the provision of a BIP and speech and language services, if determined necessary by the IEP team, the Johansen SDC can offer a placement that is sufficiently designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and to allow him to benefit from his education. STUDENT should not be deprived of his right to be educated in the least restrictive environment because the Johansen staff did not implement a behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT as required under special education law. California law expresses a clear preference for school districts to attempt to eliminate maladaptive behavior and to substitute positive behavior that will allow the student to remain in the least restrictive educational environment. Such a plan was not implemented in STUDENT’s case while he attended Johansen. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District is required to implement an appropriate behavior plan prior to changing STUDENT’s placement from Johansen. The District must also complete an assessment of STUDENT’s communication skills, if it has not already done so and provide speech and language therapy, if so determined by the IEP team.

ISSUE NO. 2: Does the behavioral intervention plan (BIP) developed in May 1998 conform with the requirements of the Hughes Bill?

The IEP team determined that STUDENT required a FAA and a BIP. The requirements of a BIP are set forth in 5 C.C.R. § 3001(h) and must include the following: the frequency of consultation to be provided by the BICM to the staff and parents; summary of relevant information gathered by the FAA; objective and measurable descriptions of the targeted maladaptive behaviors and replacement positive behaviors; goals and objectives specific to the BIP; a detailed description of the behavioral interventions and circumstances for their use; specific schedules for recording the frequency of the use of interventions, targeted behaviors and replacement behaviors; specific criteria for discontinuing or replacing the use of the intervention for lack of effectiveness; fading or phasing out the intervention; interventions that will be used in settings other than the school; and specific dates for periodic review by the IEP team.

The BIP developed for STUDENT in May 1998 identifies the following “presenting problems” related to STUDENT’s behavior: striking other students without overt provocation; destruction of personal property; defiance; throwing items in the classroom; and dumping liquids on other students. The target behavior of the BIP was “striking or grabbing the glasses of other students.”

The assessor made the following environmental recommendations:

1. Provide STUDENT with highly structured for success work tasks that he has previously demonstrated near masterly [sic] level of performance when he is not being taught individually.

2. Monitor noise level of room consistently.

3. Remove most throwable objects from within STUDENT’s immediate reach.(Footnote 11) (Student’s Exhibit 4, pp. 55-57.)

The BIP also prescribes “altered antecedents” that include utilizing verbal humor to “coach” STUDENT into productive behavior, providing STUDENT with more time to adjust to transitions, and explaining to STUDENT the reason other students have schedules that differ from his. To increase STUDENT’s keeping his hands to himself and staying on task, the BIP provides for the staff to provide STUDENT with short and variable positive primary and secondary reinforcers at a “fairly high” frequency. To decrease STUDENT’s striking or grabbing the glasses of other students, the staff is to immediately intervene to ensure the safety of STUDENT and the other students. The BIP also calls for the staff to provide STUDENT with an alternative choice of behavior that was reinforcing to him.

Mr. Schoneberger testified on behalf of STUDENT regarding the requirements of the Hughes Bill. He testified that an FAA under the Hughes Bill includes systematic observations of the student in a number of environments, data collection, and analysis of the antecedents and consequences of the student’s behavior, including how the student is affected by the environment in which the behavior occurs. Additional information should be collected from interviews with significant persons in the student’s life, from a thorough review of the student’s cumulative file, and from a review of any medical factors. The data collected are analyzed to determine the function of the behavior for the child and to develop a BIP. Mr. Schoneberger testified that the Hughes Bill emphasizes changing a student’s behavior, rather than punishing the student for inappropriate behavior, and providing other behaviors to decrease the likelihood of the inappropriate behaviors occurring. Mr. Schoneberger testified that data need to be collected while the BIP is implemented to evaluate its effectiveness. Hughes Bill BIPs are overseen by a behavioral intervention case manager (BICM). Mr. Schoneberger went on to describe numerous inadequacies in the District’s BIP developed for STUDENT in May 1998. The description of target behaviors is incomplete because it does not identify who STUDENT is striking or with what he is striking; the frequency of the behavior is not identified; the communicative intent is vague; and the description of antecedents is too general. (See Student’s Exhibit 4, pp. 55-57) By targeting only this one behavior, the BIP, in effect, neglected other potentially dangerous behaviors of STUDENT. Mr. Schoneberger testified that the “description of antecedents” should include the following: a description of the specific events that occurred immediately prior to the behavior; who was present, the time of day, the day of the week, and environmental conditions such as noise and lighting at the time the behavior occurred; and what task STUDENT was being asked to do at the time. Mr. Schoneberger raised the following concerns about the “environmental recommendations” section of the plan: the plan recommends monitoring the noise level but does not indicate the noise level at the time behaviors were observed during the FAA; the plan recommends removing throwable objects, which does not have any relation to the targeted behaviors; and the plan does not identify what is meant by “success work tasks.” Additionally, Mr. Schoneberger testified that the “altered antecedents” should flow from the FAA; however, in STUDENT’s plan, there is nothing in the FAA about humor, schedules, or transition, which are recommended altered antecedents. Mr. Schoneberger also testified that the section regarding “positive behavioral interventions” does not sufficiently describe the behaviors that will be increased as a result of implementation of the plan. Mr. Schoneberger also testified that because the FAA does not include any baseline data, it is impossible to evaluate the success of the plan. In conclusion, Mr. Schoneberger testified that the BIP is insufficient to allow the staff to implement it successfully.

The evidence presented to rebut Mr. Schoneberger’s testimony was not persuasive. Mr. Schoneberger is appropriately qualified and has a great deal of experience conducting functional analysis assessments and developing behavioral intervention plans. In fact, Mr. Schoneberger has been employed by the District and the County Office of Education on many occasions to perform these tasks. Therefore, the Hearing Officer relies on Mr. Schoneberger’s testimony to conclude that the BIP developed for STUDENT in May 1998 did not conform to the requirements of the Hughes Bill and must be revised so that it conforms to the requirements of the Hughes Bill.

ISSUE NO. 3: Did the district provide STUDENT with a FAPE from May 4, 1998, to May 29, 1998?(Footnote 12)

STUDENT’s suspension ended on May 7, 1998. Hence, he should have returned to school at Johansen on that date and should have been allowed to continue to attend school until the District obtained the restraining order on May 22, 1998. The District attempted to change STUDENT’s placement to Downey at an IEP meeting on May 4, 1998. MOTHER was not present and did not consent to the change in placement. Pursuant to Education Code § 56346(a), parental consent is required prior to implementing the IEP. Furthermore, if the parent does not agree and the school district determines that implementation of the program is necessary to provide FAPE, the District must initiate a due process hearing. Education Code § 56346(b). The District did not initiate a due process hearing until May 21, 1998. The District’s assertion that STUDENT’s placement changed as of May 4, 1998, and that the parent failed to take advantage of the placement by refusing to enroll STUDENT at Downey is faulty. Because the District prevented STUDENT from attending Johansen and did not provide him with any services from May 8 through May 21, 1998, and the parent had not consented to a change in placement, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to provide STUDENT with FAPE during that period. The Student did not present persuasive evidence that he is entitled to a compensatory remedy for the approximately 10 days of school that were missed.

ORDER

(1 ) If a speech and language assessment has not been completed in accordance with the District’s assessment plan to which MOTHER previously consented, the District shall complete such an assessment within 10 business days of the date of this decision.

(2 ) Within 10 business days of the date of this decision, the District shall revise the BIP to conform it with the requirements of 5 C.C.R. § 3001(h), including specific dates for review by the IEP team.

( 3) Within 15 business days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to do the following:

(a) If not previously addressed, discuss the results of the speech and language assessment and determine STUDENT’s eligibility for speech and language services. If determined eligible for speech and language services, the IEP team shall develop goals and objectives, add speech and language services to the IEP, and provide services at the rate and frequency the IEP team deems appropriate.

(b) Discuss the proposed revisions to the BIP, assign a BICM, and amend the IEP to reflect the BIP adopted by the IEP team.

(c) Conform the IEP to reflect STUDENT’s placement in the Johansen SDC.

( 4) Immediately following the IEP meeting, the District shall implement the BIP and speech and language services, if determined eligible for speech and language services by the IEP team.

(5) All other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

(1) What placement offers STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1998-1999 school year?

STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

(2) Does the behavioral intervention plan (BIP) developed in May 1998 conform with the requirements of the Hughes Bill?

STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

(3) Did the district provide STUDENT with a FAPE from May 4, 1998, to May 29, 1998?

STUDENT prevailed on this issue as to the District’s failure to provide a FAPE for the dates May 8, 1998 to May 21, 1998.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: November 10, 1998 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: California law providing for behavioral intervention plans is generally referred to as the “Hughes Bill.” Footnote 2: Designated instruction and services or “DIS” is California’s term for “related services.” Footnote 3: There is some confusion as to whether Mr. Stack’s “Behavior Management Plan” constitutes a Hughes Bill behavior intervention plan (BIP). Mr. Stack stated that Hughes Bill BIPs are recorded on “Form SE70," whereas the behavioral plan developed by Mr. Stack for STUDENT is on a “Form SE67.” On the other hand, the report of the IEP meeting on January 22, 1997, at which the plan was adopted, states that the “IEP Addendum dated 1/22/97 is solely for the purpose of adopting the attached Hughes Bill Behavior Plan and reviewing school psychologists report titled: Observation Notes and Recommendations.” (See Student’s Exhibit 2, p. 25 and Exhibit 4, pp.66-73.) Footnote 4: In his submission of supplemental evidence, Student duplicated several exhibit numbers. For this reason, pages 107 through 118 have been renumbered as “Student’s Exhibit 7" and the deposition of Mr. Stack has been renumbered as “Student’s Exhibit 8.” Mr. Stack was unavailable to testify on the dates originally scheduled for hearing. The parties agreed to depose him in advance of the hearing and to submit his deposition into evidence at the hearing. Footnote 5: The District’s copy of the BIP is dated May 6, 1998. No explanation was given for the discrepant dates. Footnote 6: On June 1, 1998, the cases were consolidated.

Footnote 7: According to Mr. Wolfley, the coffee had been prepared by another child with autism as part of her job skills training. According to Ms. Degnan, the student prepared the coffee to help the student transition from home to school. Footnote 8: Ms. Ackerman testified that MOTHER suggested that he respond to STUDENT’s dumping a liquid on another student by doing the same to him. MOTHER testified that Mr. Ackerman initiated the procedure without her permission and, when questioned about it by MOTHER, Mr. Ackerman told her that he was employing “responsive behavioral therapy.” This practice of dumping liquids on STUDENT in response to his dumping liquids on another student continued when he entered the Johansen SDC. Footnote 9: The regular education student had initially refused to pour water on STUDENT. Footnote 10: Mr. Schoneberger is a vendor for Valley Mountain Regional Center and provides FAAs and develops BIPs for several school districts, including the Modesto City Schools and the Stanislaus County Office of Education. Mr. Schoneberger worked with STUDENT during the 1992-1993 school year. At that time, which was prior to the Hughes Bill, goals for STUDENT were to decrease his dependence on a one-to-one aide, aggressive behavior, and damaging of property. Footnote 11: These recommendations are confusing and would appear difficult to implement. Footnote 12: These dates were identified in the Student’s issues.