California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 10, 2005

Student v. Newark Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 72-05, SN05-00072, SN05-00152 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski

Newark Unified's special day class offer for 2004-2005 held to be FAPE in the LRE; all reimbursement claims denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 13-year-old seventh grader and Newark Unified School District each filed for due process, and the cases were consolidated. The student was eligible for special education with specific learning disabilities in reading and written language. He read and wrote at about a second-grade level. He also had significant social skills and behavior needs. After sixth grade at Charles Armstrong School, a District-funded nonpublic school, the school told the IEP team it would not take him back. The District then offered a small special day class (SDC) at Newark Junior High School. The offer included mainstreaming, a social skills group, behavior consultation, parent training, and an aide for mainstream times. The parents enrolled him at New Horizons, a non-certified private school. They claimed procedural violations at three IEP meetings, inaccurate present levels and goals, and a placement that was too restrictive. Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski found no procedural violations. The parents took part meaningfully. The law does not require the full range of placements to be discussed at every meeting, and the August team included people who knew the student. The present levels and goals were accurate and appropriate. Applying the Rachel H. factors by analogy, the Hearing Officer held that the SDC was the least restrictive environment. All of the student's claims were denied, including tuition, tutoring, transportation, compensatory social skills training, and a $645 Lindamood-Bell evaluation.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled an LRE dispute after a nonpublic school placement ended. The Hearing Officer weighed the views of teachers and assessors who knew the student well. He held that IEP teams need not discuss every placement option at each meeting. He also held that a privately obtained evaluation not tied to a disagreement with a district assessment is not reimbursable as an IEE.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1 (procedural). Has the District offered Student a FAPE in the LRE for the 2004-2005 regular school year? Procedural claims: failure to collaboratively discuss the full continuum of placement options, including regular education, at the April 26, May 24, and August 25, 2004 IEP meetings, and failure to have a majority of knowledgeable team members at the August 25 meeting.

    No procedural violation: parents meaningfully participated; the law does not require the full continuum to be discussed at every meeting; and the August team included enough members who knew the student, his assessments, and the placement options.

  2. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1 (present levels and goals). Whether the District accurately documented Student's present levels of performance, relied almost exclusively on teacher reports, and developed appropriate goals and objectives, and whether additional goals were needed.

    Present levels rested on District and private assessments as well as teacher reports and were accurate. All disputed goals were appropriate, and no additional goals were needed.

  3. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1 (placement and LRE). Whether the District's offer of an SDC at Newark Junior High School, with mainstreaming, social skills, and behavior supports, was designed to meet Student's unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and was the least restrictive environment.

    Applying the Rachel H. factors by analogy, the Hearing Officer held that the small, structured SDC with mainstreaming and behavior and social skills supports was the LRE and offered FAPE under Rowley.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2a. If the District failed to offer a FAPE in the LRE, is Student entitled to compensatory education services?

    Because FAPE was offered, the request for one hour per week of social skills training for one year was denied.

  5. Issue 2b. If the District failed to offer a FAPE in the LRE, are Student and his parents entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained education-related services?

    Because FAPE was offered, reimbursement for New Horizons tuition, tutoring, and transportation was denied. The Lindamood-Bell evaluation was not reimbursable because it did not arise from a disagreement with a District assessment.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Student's claims for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Rachel H.; W.G. v. Target Range; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Daniel R.R.; Burlington; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup; Walczak; Roland M.

People named in the decision

  • Leslie Koelsch, Ed.D., director of special education, Newark Unified School District
  • Eric Burkholder, behavior specialist, Newark Unified School District
  • Rosalie Whitlock, Ph.D., head of school, Charles Armstrong School (nonpublic school)
  • Carol Galletta, sixth-grade and summer teacher, Charles Armstrong School
  • Jayne Fong, speech-language pathologist, Newark Unified School District
  • Gina Wilburn, occupational therapist, Newark Unified School District
  • Claudia Riley, adaptive physical education specialist, Newark Unified School District
  • Vicki Pyper, special day class teacher (proposed placement), Newark Junior High School
  • Debra Kane-Nolan, physical education teacher, Newark Junior High School
  • Barbara Casey, social skills (Skills for Adolescents) teacher, Newark Junior High School
  • Kellene Cousins, Ph.D., school psychologist; social skills group leader, Newark Unified School District
  • Melinda Pickens, resource specialist; academic assessor, Newark Unified School District (Snow Elementary)
  • Jennifer Rinna, school psychologist, Newark Unified School District
  • Russ Riley, program specialist and speech-language therapist, Newark Unified School District
  • Beth Choate, speech-language assessor, Newark Unified School District
  • Bonnie G. Rattner, Ed.D., speech-language pathologist (assessment report)
  • Vicki Wells, behaviorist; expert witness for Student, Synergistic Interventions
  • Kim Stokes, director; private behavioral assessor, Synergistic Interventions
  • Synergistic Interventions, private behavioral assessment agency
  • Ayse Kaya, head teacher, New Horizons (private school)
  • Kathryn Liu, principal and owner, New Horizons (private school)
  • Ms. Ingles, private tutor, New Horizons
  • Janine Friend, paraprofessional / 1:1 aide, Charles Armstrong School placement
  • Ms. Rose, co-teacher, Charles Armstrong School
  • Ms. McAllister, co-teacher, Charles Armstrong School
  • Belen Majers, principal, Newark Junior High School
  • John Howard, resource specialist, Newark Junior High School
  • Neal Fragus, science teacher, Newark Junior High School
  • Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, private evaluator (parent-obtained evaluation)
  • Scottish Rite Center (Oakland), private childhood language intervention provider for dyslexia

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Newark, California, on February 15-18, February 23, and March 10-11, 2005.

STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Eileen Matteucci. Also appearing on behalf of Student were his mother and father, PARENT and PARENT. Newark Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Dora J. Dome of Miller Brown & Dannis. Also present on behalf of the District was Leslie Koelsch, Ed.D., the director of special education.

The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Eric Burkholder, a District behavior specialist; Rosalie Whitlock, Ph.D., head of school at Charles Armstrong School, a certified nonpublic school (NPS); Carol Galletta, a sixth-grade teacher at Charles Armstrong School; Jayne Fong, a District speech language pathologist; Gina Wilburn, a District occupational therapist; Claudia Riley, a District adaptive physical education (A.P.E.) specialist; Vicki Pyper, a District special day class (SDC) teacher; Debra Kane-Nolan, a District physical education teacher; Barbara Casey, a District social skills teacher; Kellene Cousins, Ph.D., a licensed school psychologist for the District; Melinda Pickens, a District resource specialist; Jennifer Rinna, a licensed school psychologist for the District; and Leslie Koelsch, Ed.D., the District’s director of special education.

Student called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: STUDENT (Student); Vicki Wells, behaviorist and co-owner of Synergistic Interventions; Ayse Kaya, head teacher at New Horizons, a non-certified private school; Kathryn Liu, principal (and owner of) New Horizons; and PARENT, Student’s mother.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the parties’ written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Has the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2004-2005 regular school year?

2. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the above-mentioned period, are STUDENT and his parents entitled to:

a. compensatory education services?

b. reimbursement for privately obtained education-related services?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District contends that it offered STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the 2004-2005 regular school year at the April 26, May 24, and August 25, 2004 individualized education program (IEP) meetings. Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE in the LRE for the 2004-2005 regular school year on both procedural and substantive grounds.

Student asserts that the District committed procedural violations by failing to engage in a collaborative discussion of the full continuum of placement options, including placement in a seventh-grade regular education classroom, at each of the three IEP team meetings held in April, May, and August 2004, and by failing to have in attendance at the August 25 meeting a majority of team members with sufficient knowledge of his unique needs. Student contends that the violations resulted in a denial of meaningful parental participation in the IEP process and thus caused a procedural denial of a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year.

Student initially contended that the District substantively denied him a FAPE in the LRE by failing to assess him appropriately in all suspected areas of need in academics, in pragmatic speech including social skills, and in social skills/behavior with a focus on peer relationships; however, Student later explained during the clarification of issues that he was not challenging the appropriateness of any of the District’s formal assessments. Rather, Student challenges the accuracy and lack of documentation of his then-current levels of functioning (at Charles Armstrong) to determine his program for the 2004-2005 school year. Student also asserts that the District relied almost entirely on teacher reports to determine his then-current levels of functioning. Student contends that deficiencies in the description of his present levels led, in turn, to goals and objectives that were not appropriate for him. Student challenges the appropriateness of all goals and objectives as to content and asserts that he needed additional goals and objectives.

Student also contends that the District’s placement offer at Newark Junior High School was not designed to meet his needs and would not have been the LRE because he does not need an SDC placement and because there would have been no typically developing peers in the classroom during academic instruction.

Student seeks compensatory education services of “additional” social skills training in a small group “natural paradigm” (a natural social setting) of one hour per week for one year. Student also seeks reimbursement of $645 for the cost incurred by his parents for an independent educational evaluation (IEE) conducted by Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center in the summer of 2004 as a remedy for the District’s failure to offer him an appropriate program. Student also seeks reimbursement of $650 per month for his services and placement at New Horizons School during the 2004-2005 school year, and additional costs for tutoring services provided by Ms. Ingles at New Horizons to address his delays in reading. Student also seeks reimbursement for transportation provided between his home and New Horizons in Fremont and between his home and the Scottish Rite Center in Oakland where he received childhood language intervention for dyslexia.

The District contends that because it offered Student a FAPE, it is not obligated to provide him with compensatory education services and is not obligated to reimburse his parents for the costs of privately obtained services. The District also asserts that the Hearing Officer does not have the authority to reimburse Student’s parents prospectively for placement at New Horizons, a private school that is not certified. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56500.2. The District further asserts that the parents cannot be reimbursed for the Lindamood-Bell IEE because it was not conducted because of disagreement with a District assessment. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56329. The District also asserts that Student’s parents failed to provide the District with the necessary ten-day notice prior to his unilateral placement at New Horizons, and thus reimbursement must be denied or reduced accordingly. See 34 C.F.R. § 300.403.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old student who resides with his parents within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Newark Unified School District. STUDENT has attended District schools since he was three and a half. STUDENT has been identified as eligible for special education and related services as a student with specific learning disabilities (SLDs) in reading and written language since age four. STUDENT also has social and behavioral issues and has received social skills training “over the years.” (Test. of Dr. Koelsch and Dr. Cousins.) At present, STUDENT is a seventh-grade student at New Horizons, a private non-certified school in Fremont, having been placed there unilaterally by his parents on September 1, 2004, the start of the 2004-2005 school year.

During the 2003-2004 regular school year, STUDENT attended sixth grade, by agreement of the parties, at Charles Armstrong School (Charles Armstrong), a nonpublic school in Belmont. The placement was funded by the District. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch.) STUDENT’s class was taught by Ms. Carol Galletta who was assisted by a co-teacher. Charles Armstrong is a specialized school with 248 students in grades one through eight. Most of the students are diagnosed with a “learning difference,” which includes specific learning disabilities, but “just one percent” of the students have IEPs with goals to be implemented. (Test. of Dr. Whitlock and Ms. Galletta.)

Although STUDENT made academic progress at Charles Armstrong, he experienced persistent social and behavioral difficulties at school in his relationships with peers and adult staff members. For example, STUDENT did not understand the rules for basketball which resulted in conflicts with peers. Once he picked up a chair in class and allegedly threatened another student. Another time he pushed or brushed into his teacher. (Test. of Ms. Galletta and Student.) The disruptive effect of his behaviors on his peers in the classroom led Dr. Whitlock, the head of school, to inform PARENTS about STUDENT’s “behavioral setbacks” by email on February 24, 2004. Dr. Whitlock stated that Charles Armstrong was not the right placement for STUDENT and that the school’s teachers were not equipped to handle STUDENT. (Test. of Dr. Whitlock; Dist. Exh. 16.)

Neither the school nor the PARENTS reported STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties to the District at the time. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch.) Instead, Dr. Whitlock met with the PARENTS to address the school’s concerns. (Test. of Dr. Whitlock and PARENT.) After the meeting, the PARENTS did not request an IEP meeting and did not request support from the District. (Test. of Dr. Whitlock and Dr. Koelsch.) Rather, the PARENTS contacted Synergistic Interventions to conduct a private behavioral assessment at the school. On March 10 and 18, 2004, Synergistic directors Vicki Wells and Kim Stokes observed STUDENT at school and saw him briefly during a home visit on March 31. They issued an assessment report on April 6, 2004. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Wells.)

Meanwhile, the District was preparing for STUDENT’s annual review which had initially been scheduled for mid-March. By letter dated March 5, 2004, the District provided the parents with a description of the District’s proposed assessments in academic achievement, occupational therapy, and speech and language, and included qualifications of the proposed assessors. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 19.)

During the first week of March, Melinda Pickens, a District resource specialist at STUDENT’s home school (Snow Elementary), assessed STUDENT to measure his academic progress and to determine his present levels of academic performance. Ms. Pickens prepared a report dated March 8, 2004. (Test. of Ms. Pickens; Dist. Exh. 29.)

At age twelve years and six months and a sixth-grade student, STUDENT received the following grade-level equivalents (GE) on the standardized and normed Woodcock-Johnson Test of Academic Achievement -- Third Edition (WJ-III) for basic reading skills: 1.8 in letter word identification; 1.8 in reading fluency; and 2.9 in word attack, for an overall (cluster score) GE of 2.1. On the Brigance standardized test for word recognition, STUDENT received a GE of 1.7, indicating word recognition skills at the “1.4 to 1.9 grade level.” Ms. Pickens described the reading scores as significantly below average and a major need for him to develop automaticity in word recognition as well as in word analysis or word phonic skills. (Test. of Ms. Pickens; Dist. Exh. 29.)

On the WJ-III test for reading comprehension and on the Brigance test for reading comprehension skills, STUDENT’s grade equivalents showed no growth over scores on the same test conducted the previous year, 2003. On the WJ-III, STUDENT received a cluster reading comprehension score of GE 2.2, and on the Brigance, a GE of 2.1. Ms. Pickens identified oral reading fluency as a significant weakness and concluded that the reading assessment indicated that STUDENT has deficits in basic reading skills (sight words and word analysis) and in reading comprehension, giving him an overall GE of 1.8, well below his 6th grade placement. (Test. of Ms. Pickens; Dist. Exh. 29.)

However, on the WJ-III for listening comprehension/oral comprehension, STUDENT’s G.E was 12.5 and for oral expression picture vocabulary, his GE was 8.2. Ms. Pickens noted STUDENT’s very good strengths on the listening test, an oral test of analogies, and on an oral expression test of vocabulary. (Test. of Ms. Pickens; Dist. Exh. 29.)

On the WJ-III for basic writing skills, STUDENT received a GE of 1.3 for spelling, 3.7 for editing -- a relative strength for him because it was oral and not written -- and 2.1 for punctuation and capitalization, for an overall GE of 2.3. On the WJ-III for written expression, STUDENT received a GE of 2.8 for writing fluency and a 1.7 for writing samples. Ms. Pickens noted that STUDENT’s written production was “large and kind of immature” for his age and very difficult to read. STUDENT received a written language GE of 1.8, for an overall GE of 2.2. Ms. Pickens characterized STUDENT’s basic writing skills and written expression as areas of weakness. (Test. of Ms. Pickens.)

For math calculation and problem solving on the WJ-III for basic math skills (calculation subtest), STUDENT received a GE of 5.7 and on the timed math fluency subtest, a GE of 4.0, for an overall GE of 5.1. On math reasoning, on the WJ-III, for applied problems, STUDENT received a GE of 6.0, and on quantitative concepts, a GE of 2.9, for an overall GE of 5.5. Ms. Pickens described math as a “relative strength” for STUDENT. (Test. of Ms. Pickens.)

In April 2004, District speech-language therapist Beth Choate assessed STUDENT to determine his current level of communicative functioning. On the Test of Language Competence-Expanded Edition, STUDENT was tested in ambiguous sentences, listening comprehension, making inferences, oral expression, recreating sentences, and figurative language. On the Comprehensive Assessment of Spoken Language, STUDENT was tested in antonyms, grammatical morphemes, sentence comprehension, nonliteral language, pragmatic judgment, idiomatic language, and inferences. Each of the subtest scores were within the average to above average range for his age. (Dist. Exh. 29; Test. of Ms. Fong.)

A few days prior to the IEP meeting which had been rescheduled from mid-March to April 26, Dr. Koelsch received from the PARENTS a copy of the Synergistic Interventions report dated April 6, 2004. Dr. Koelsch gave the report to District behaviorist Eric Burkholder to review and invited him to attend the April 26 IEP meeting. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch and Mr. Burkholder.)

The IEP team met on April 26, 2004, for STUDENT’s annual review to consider new information and his present levels of performance, to develop goals and objectives, and to review progress. The PARENTS were present and participated in the meeting with their attorney. (Dist. Exh. 29; Test. of Dr. Koelsch.) Carol Galletta reviewed her written report of STUDENT’s present levels of performance in academics, social adaptation (social and behavioral needs), and sensory integration. (Dist. Exh. 29.) Dr. Koelsch presented Melinda Pickens’ March 8 academic assessment. Speech-language pathologist Bonnie Rattner reviewed her report of STUDENT’s progress in speech and language therapy and present levels, and Russ Riley, a District program specialist who is also a speech and language therapist, reviewed the April 2004 assessment conducted by District speech-language pathologist Beth Choate. Gina Wilburn, the District’s occupational therapist, then reviewed her March 2004 OT report and present levels and progress. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch, Ms. Galletta, Dr. Whitlock, PARENT, and Ms. Wilburn.)

The team also reviewed STUDENT’s prevocational/self-help skills and health and then discussed the behavioral/social-emotional concerns reported by Charles Armstrong staff. Eileen Matteucci presented the Synergistic report and the team discussed STUDENT’s behavioral issues and social skills. The parties agreed to a behavioral assessment by Mr. Burkholder, and PARENT signed an assessment plan at the meeting. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch.)

The IEP team agreed to reconvene on May 24 to allow Mr. Burkholder time to conduct his assessment and to develop behavioral goals and objectives. After the meeting, the attorney for the District documented the parties’ agreement. The District agreed to provide STUDENT with a one-to-one aide, trained by Mr. Burkholder, at Charles Armstrong from May 3 through May 24 to collect data in the classroom and assist in the development of a behavior assessment. (Test. of Mr. Burkholder, Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 27.)

Mr. Burkholder observed STUDENT at Charles Armstrong in the classroom, during physical education, at recess, and as he transitioned between activities (on six occasions for approximately twenty hours) in April and May 2004. The paraprofessional who was imbedded in the classroom provided behavioral assistance to STUDENT and collected data. Mr. Burkholder concluded that STUDENT “definitely” had some social skills deficits. STUDENT had “some” kind of emotional reaction or would not respond in a way contextually appropriate for his age when confronted by a peer or by some kind of peer provocation. Mr. Burkholder also noted that STUDENT did not handle disappointment appropriately and engaged in tantrumming as well as behavioral excesses relating to his social deficits, such as his lack of awareness of other people. STUDENT would run into other persons, accidentally or on purpose. (Test. of Mr. Burkholder; Dist. Exh. 29.)

The IEP team reconvened on May 24, 2004, to review Eric Burkholder’s report, to develop and finalize goals and objectives, and to discuss placement and services for the 2004-2005 school year. The meeting lasted from 2 to 3 hours. Mr. Burkholder reviewed his report and discussed his findings, and the IEP team completed work on goals and objectives in academics, speech pragmatics, social skills, and OT. Charles Armstrong representatives discussed STUDENT’s performance at the school. Although Dr. Whitlock indicated that she was “quite pleased” with the behavioral support provided by Mr. Burkholder and the paraprofessional at Charles Armstrong, Dr. Whitlock told the IEP team, toward the end of the meeting, that the school would not accept STUDENT back in the fall because of his behavioral difficulties. This was the first time that the District learned of the school’s decision. Dr. Koelsch testified that up to that point, the District had assumed that STUDENT would continue at Charles Armstrong and that the District would fund that program. Because of the short notice, the team discussed ESY 2004 and whether STUDENT could attend Charles Armstrong during the summer, and the Charles Armstrong representatives agreed that he could. (Test. of Dr. Whitlock and Ms. Galletta.)

Dr. Koelsch then offered STUDENT a placement at Newark Junior High School (Newark) in an SDC taught by Vicki Pyper in the fall. The offer included OT, speech, social skills, and behavioral support. Dr. Koelsch described Ms. Pyper and the proposed SDC and also provided information about the Newark Junior High School staff members who would be supporting the program -- as much as she knew at that point -- because some new staff were going to be hired. The District also offered to meet again prior to the start of the 2004-2005 school year to finalize specifics of the offer such as the amount of mainstreaming. Dr. Koelsch testified that the PARENTS said that they were not interested in an SDC at Newark and did not want to discuss the matter any further. PARENT testified that had the District proposed a regular education placement instead, she “absolutely” would have discussed the matter further. Attorney Eileen Matteucci then said, “Well if that’s your offer, write it up.” The offer was written on the IEP. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch and PARENT; Dist. Exh. 29.)

In early June, Vicki Pyper observed STUDENT at Charles Armstrong after spending an afternoon at the District office reviewing STUDENT’s special education cumulative file, his assessments, and his IEP. Ms. Pyper observed STUDENT for an hour and a half in class, as he transitioned to and while on the playground. Ms. Pyper also spoke with Ms. Galletta and the paraprofessional. (Test. of Ms. Pyper.)

Meanwhile, the District attempted to schedule a July IEP meeting. By email sent on June 8 to team members, including the PARENTS, Dr. Koelsch provided four July dates on which to discuss placement and to give the parents an opportunity to meet Ms. Pyper. In a June 11 note, PARENT informed Dr. Koelsch that she could not reach her attorney regarding the proposed IEP dates. In a June 14 reply, Dr. Koelsch provided notice of an IEP meeting scheduled for July 8, but the PARENTS would not agree to that date.

STUDENT attended the Charles Armstrong summer class taught by Ms. Galletta and assisted by paraprofessional Janine Friend, who also provided transportation for STUDENT. The class met for three hours in the mornings, and the class size was small (eight students). The summer program met in two three-week sessions -- June 21 to July 9, and July 19 to August 6. (Test. of Ms. Galletta; Student Exh. 24.) Additionally, at a District school, speech and language pathologist Jayne Fong provided STUDENT with individual therapy services, and Ms. Wilburn provided STUDENT with OT services. STUDENT also attended a social skills group of two students which included a younger student, led by District school psychologist Kellene Cousins, Ph.D., from June to July 2004. (Test. of Ms. Fong, Dr. Cousins; Student Exh. 47.)

In a July 1 email, the PARENTS indicated that there would not be another IEP meeting held “this summer.” On July 13, Dr. Koelsch provided notice of a July 28 IEP meeting. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch, PARENT; Dist. Exhs. 33, 35, 36, 37, and 39.) In a July 19 reply, Ms. Matteucci asserted that the parents intended to challenge the District’s May IEP offer as a substantive denial of a FAPE and as a procedural denial of the parents’ right to participate in developing the IEP, and said that unless the District was now willing to discuss and consider the range of placements (starting with the LRE), “we see no purpose in such a meeting as your client has already pre-determined the offer...” (Test. of Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 41.) In a July 22 reply, the District expressed a willingness to discuss fall placement options and that it was exploring other options for STUDENT. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 42.)

Meanwhile, the PARENTS had STUDENT tested at Lindamood-Bell on June 18, 2004, but did not inform the District. (Student Exh. 27.) The PARENTS also looked into private placement options during the summer while Dr. Koelsch searched websites for “all possible” nonpublic schools in Contra Costa, Alameda, and San Mateo counties. By “process of elimination” (having already discussed various programs with PARENT the previous year), Dr. Koelsch determined that there were few, if any, nonpublic school programs that would meet STUDENT’s needs, taking into account his age and disability. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch, PARENT; Dist. Exh. 42.)

In a July 21 email to Carol Galletta, Dr. Koelsch noted that STUDENT’s parent wanted an “LRE placement such as full inclusion” and asked, “Do you see that - Regular 7th grade with shadow aide? OR RSP 3 periods a day?” Ms. Galletta’s reply noted that she would have a “very hard time seeing STUDENT in a regular 7th grade [classroom] with or without a shadow aide.” (Test. of Dr. Koelsch, Ms. Galletta; Dist. Exh. 43.) On August 10, the District informed the parents by letter that the District had considered various alternative programs and that although the programs did not appear to meet STUDENT’s needs, the District was “open and willing” to consider and discuss any alternative placements that the parents felt would be appropriate. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 44.)

On August 19, the PARENTS paid New Horizons School $900.00 for one month’s tuition that included $250 for enrollment costs for STUDENT’s attendance at the school for the 2004-2005 school year. On September 1, the PARENTS paid New Horizons an additional $650.00 for tuition (one month in advance), and STUDENT started school at New Horizons on September 1. (Test. of PARENT; Student Exh. 46.)

The IEP team met for a third time on August 25, 2004. The meeting began at 9:15 a.m. and Dr. Koelsch informed the team that Carol Galletta would be participating by telephone beginning at 10:00 a.m. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 45.) The PARENTS attended the meeting with their attorney, and PARENT brought with her to the meeting a folder that contained information about twenty-five schools she had looked into and considered over the summer, including information about New Horizons and Lindamood-Bell. (Test. of PARENT.) Dr. Koelsch introduced the new team members: a newly hired district psychologist and three individuals from Newark Junior High School who had not previously worked with STUDENT. Dr. Koelsch then summarized the contents of the spring IEP and reviewed the goals and objectives to acquaint the new members with STUDENT’s needs. During a review of Ms. Pickens’ achievement assessment, about one-half hour into the meeting, the PARENTS and Ms. Matteucci expressed their concern that the new IEP team members had not reviewed the IEP, did not know STUDENT’s needs, and were unprepared to discuss placement. The PARENTS and Ms. Matteucci then left the meeting, giving the District five minutes to decide on how to proceed. After returning briefly, the PARENTS and Ms. Matteucci left the meeting again and did not return.

The District members of the IEP team resumed the meeting. Mr. Burkholder presented an updated report, Ms. Fong presented a speech-language progress report about her work with STUDENT over the summer, and Ms. Galletta provided updates on STUDENT’s progress by speaker phone. Ms. Galletta noted that STUDENT had been able to work well within a structured summer school program and with the support of a one-to-one aide. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 45.)

Ms. Pyper described her SDC classroom to the IEP team. Ms. Pyper testified that the class of ten students included five seventh and five eighth-graders at the time and that she is assisted by a full-time classroom instructional assistant who acts under her direction. None of the students have their own aide. The instructional assistant conducts small group tutoring, provides direct instruction, provides behavior management and redirection, and performs other duties assigned to her by Ms. Pyper. Each student in Ms. Pyper’s SDC is mainstreamed for general education academic classes. (Test. of Ms. Pyper.)

Ms. Claudia Riley presented an A.P.E. assessment report and recommended A.P.E. consult, and Ms. Jennifer Rinna discussed her proposed services to support STUDENT’s social skills development. Ms. Gina Wilburn presented an OT update. The team discussed a social skills class to be taught by Barbara Casey and a choir class. The team made a program and placement offer of Ms. Pyper’s SDC classroom at Newark Junior High School. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch, Ms. Galletta, Ms. Pyper, Ms. Wilburn, Ms. Fong, Ms. Riley; Dist. Exh. 45.)

Following the IEP meeting, Dr. Koelsch learned that during the meeting her secretary had received a handwritten note from the PARENTS. The note informed the District that due to its failure to make an “appropriate, timely placement offer,” the PARENTS had been “forced” to place STUDENT in a private school to address his needs. This was the District’s first notice of the PARENTS’ placement of STUDENT in a private school. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch and PARENT; Dist. Exh. 47.) On August 26, the District requested the name of STUDENT’s private school to observe him there and also requested consent for an assessment by Alameda County Mental Health (Alameda County). (Test. of Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 48.)

On September 1, PARENT declined to provide consent for a referral to Alameda County, noting that STUDENT continued to receive “private counseling through Kaiser,” and stated that he would only contact the District about an observation when the school’s staff had had “sufficient time to assess him and refine a program to best address his unique needs.” PARENT did not identify the private school. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 49.) Thereafter, the District agreed on September 9 to the PARENTS’ September 9 request to observe the District’s proposed placement and provided a copy of the proposed class schedule. PARENT observed the placement on October 4 and 8, 2004. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch and PARENT; Dist. Exhs. 50 and 51.)

On October 5, Dr. Koelsch requested that the PARENTS identify the private school “by October 11.” The letter noted PARENT’s statement to Dr. Koelsch that Ms. Matteucci had advised the PARENTS “not to let [the District] know” the name of the private school. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 53.) In an October 11 reply, PARENT noted that “you could have saved us both some time by just threatening me in person.” The letter ended with the notation, “New Horizons 791-5683,” and was the first time the PARENTS had provided the District with the name of the private school. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 54.) Dr. Koelsch then called New Horizons to schedule observations and to request a class schedule. The class schedules initially provided by the school were unclear and contributed to a nearly one month delay in scheduling observations. Dr. Koelsch attributed the delay to the school’s failure to return phone calls and its failure to provide class schedules when requested. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch and Dr. Liu; Dist. Exhs. 55, 56, and 57.) On November 10, Eric Burkholder, Dr. Koelsch, and SDC teacher Vicki Pyper observed STUDENTat New Horizons School.

On January 11, 2005, the Hearing Office received the District’s request for a due process hearing. The District’s case was designated as Case No. SN05-00072. On January 21, the Hearing Office received Student’s request for a due process hearing. The Student’s case was designated Case No. SN05-00152. On January 27, 2005, the Hearing Office issued a minute order that granted Student’s unopposed motion to consolidate the two cases, and the hearing on the consolidated cases commenced on February 15, 2005.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Has the District offered STUDENTa free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2004-2005 regular school year?

Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, (1982) the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s IEP must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean that the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education must be provided for the student. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1994, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965 (1994). However, de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1997).

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural protections afforded by the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 205. States are required to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each child with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled, and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE. Id. at 1483; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).

Additionally, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must meet the following substantive requirements to constitute an appropriate educational program: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and (3) comport with his IEP. Additionally, the District must have offered him an education in the least restrictive environment.

In determining whether the District offered STUDENTa FAPE, the Hearing Officer must consider whether the District complied procedurally with the legal requirements and whether the offer is substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-208. The Hearing Officer first examines whether the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA.

A. Procedural Appropriateness

Student contends that the District committed the following procedural violations during the IEP team meetings held in April, May, and August 2004: failed to engage in a collaborative process to discuss the full continuum of placement options for him and LRE considerations at all three IEP team meetings and failed to have a majority of IEP team members in attendance at the August IEP meeting with sufficient knowledge of his unique needs. Student asserts that the new IEP team members had not reviewed his March and April IEPs, had never observed him, did not have any knowledge of his unique needs, and therefore were not adequately prepared to make an informed offer of placement and services for him.

California Education Code section 56342(a) provides, in pertinent part, that the individualized education program team shall determine the content of the individualized education program and make program and placement recommendations. Section 56342(b) provides that in determining the program and placement of an individual with exceptional needs, each district shall ensure that the placement decisions and the child’s placement are made in accordance with Sections 300.550 to 300.554, inclusive, of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations. California Education Code section 56342.5 provides that districts shall ensure that “the parent of each individual with exceptional needs is a member of any group that makes decisions on the educational placement of the individual with exceptional needs.” However, school districts are allowed to engage in preparatory activities to develop a proposal that will be discussed at later IEP meetings. 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.501(c)(1), 300.510.(b)(2).

April 26, 2004 IEP meeting

Federal special education law provides that in developing each child’s IEP, the IEP team shall provide the child’s parents with the opportunity to participate in the meeting, and consider the strengths of the child and the concerns of the parents for enhancing the child’s education. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(3)(A)(i); 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.345(a), 300.346(a)(1)(i), and 300.501(a)(2)(i).

Student contends that the District failed to engage in a collaborative process to discuss the full continuum of placement options, including placement in a regular education classroom. The District contends that the IEP team did engage in a collaborative process at the April IEP meeting and that Student’s parents and attorney actively participated in the April IEP meeting.

It is undisputed that the District did not make a 2004-2005 school year program and placement offer for STUDENTat the April 26, 2004 IEP meeting. During the two to three hour meeting, the IEP team considered and discussed STUDENT’s present levels of performance and a report made by his teacher at Charles Armstrong, Ms. Galletta. The team also considered and discussed Dr. Koelsch’s presentation of Melinda Pickens’ March 8, 2004 academic achievement assessment, Ms. Rattner’s speech-language assessment, Mr. Riley’s presentation of Ms. Choate’s speech-language assessment, Ms. Wilburn’s OT assessment, and attorney Eileen Matteucci’s presentation of the private behavioral assessment conducted by Synergistic Interventions. Because of the behavioral concerns described by Dr. Whitlock and Ms. Galletta, the IEP team discussed STUDENT’s behaviors and agreed to reconvene after the District’s behaviorist, Eric Burkholder, conducted a behavioral assessment of STUDENTat Charles Armstrong. The team’s agreement to conduct a behavioral assessment was the product of concerns shared not only by Charles Armstrong staff members in attendance at the meeting, but also by concerns expressed by PARENT at the meeting. (Test. of Ms. Galletta, Dr. Koelsch, Mr. Burkholder, Ms. Pickens, Dr. Whitlock, Ms. Wilburn, and PARENT.)

The credible evidence establishes that the PARENTS meaningfully participated in the IEP team’s lengthy discussions held on April 26. Furthermore, the PARENTS were represented by counsel, Ms. Matteucci, who also actively participated in the meeting and presented the Synergistic Interventions behavioral report and asked questions during the meeting. Moreover, it is undisputed that the District did not make a program and placement offer at the meeting and that the parties agreed to reconvene on May 24. The Hearing Officer finds that the manner in which the District conducted the April 26 IEP meeting did not result in procedural violations and did not seriously infringe on the PARENTS’ right to participate meaningfully.

May 24, 2004 IEP meeting

In accordance with 34 C.F.R. § 300.551, each public agency “shall ensure that a continuum of alternative placements is available to meet the needs of children with disabilities for special education and related services (emphasis added).” See also Cal. Educ. Code § 56360. School staff may come to an IEP meeting prepared with evaluation findings and proposed recommendations regarding IEP content so long as there is full discussion with parents before finalization of the IEP. See 64 Fed. Reg. 48 at 12478. Student contends that at the meeting held on May 24, 2004, the District’s director of special education, Leslie Koelsch, unilaterally offered him an SDC placement at Newark Junior High School without engaging the IEP team in a collaborative discussion concerning the full continuum of placement options available for him. The District asserts that the entire IEP team engaged in a collaborative discussion at the May meeting, and that once Charles Armstrong representatives had notified the IEP team, late into the meeting, that STUDENTcould not return to the school for the 2004-2005 school year, the District’s special education director described and offered a new SDC program at Newark Junior High School, and that the PARENTS indicated that they were not interested. At that point, the District maintains that attorney Eileen Matteucci told the District to just “write up the offer,” and the District did. The District maintains that it intended to convene another IEP meeting in the fall to discuss mainstreaming and alternative placement options in the fall, and that it did.

The credible evidence shows that the District made its offer of an SDC placement at Newark Junior High School at the very end of the IEP meeting just after it had learned that Charles Armstrong was not going to allow STUDENT back for the 2004-2005 school year. There is no persuasive, credible evidence that the District knew about the decision of Charles Armstrong in advance. Dr. Whitlock credibly testified that Charles Armstrong did not give its official notice that STUDENT would not be able to return in the fall until the end of the May 24 IEP meeting after a lengthy discussion had occurred at the meeting. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch, Dr. Whitlock, and PARENT.) Although the record does not show that a discussion was held to consider the full continuum of placement options or the LRE, the record establishes that the District offered to hold another IEP meeting prior to the start of the school year in the fall to continue discussions about STUDENT’s placement. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch.)

Moreover, Student provides no persuasive authority for the proposition that the full continuum of placements must be discussed at each IEP team meeting. Rather, the law requires only that a full continuum of options be made available in the district so that the needs of all children residing within the district can be met. Furthermore, there is no credible evidence that the PARENTS ever asked to discuss other placement options, including mainstreaming or a regular education placement, or that the District IEP team members had at any time, including during the May IEP meeting, ever refused to discuss other placement options. (Test. of. Dr. Koelsch and PARENT.)

Additionally, as outlined above, Dr. Koelsch made subsequent diligent efforts to schedule another IEP meeting in the summer before the start of school and to identify possible alternative nonpublic schools to consider as options at the proposed IEP meeting. An IEP team meeting was held on August 25, 2004, to discuss placement options, as well as to consider updated progress reports and the A.P.E. assessment requested by the PARENTS. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch.)

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the manner in which the District conducted the May 24, 2004 IEP team meeting did not result in a procedural violation and did not seriously infringe on the PARENTS’ right to participate meaningfully in that IEP meeting.

August 25, 2004 IEP meeting

Student contends that the District convened the August IEP meeting with a “majority” of IEP team members who were new to the team, did not know him, and had not reviewed his IEP. Student contends that the new IEP team members were not sufficiently prepared and informed to participate in the team’s discussions about program and placement options because the new team members did not know his unique needs. Student also contends that the District failed to discuss the full continuum of placement options for him. Thus, the Student asserts that the District committed procedural violations that resulted in a serious infringement on the PARENTS’ right to participate meaningfully in the August IEP meeting.

The District asserts that it did not commit procedural violations and that a sufficient number of the August IEP team members who knew STUDENT either by assessment, observation, or by having worked directly with him participated in the meeting. The District also asserts that Dr. Koelsch reviewed the April and May IEP for the benefit of new IEP team members who had been on summer vacation. The District contends that the District team members collaboratively discussed appropriate placement options, including mainstreaming and a regular education placement at Newark Junior High School, prior to making its program and placement offer.

In determining the educational placement of a child with a disability, 34 C.F.R. § 300.522 provides that each public agency shall ensure that the placement decision is made by a group of persons, including the parents, and other persons knowledgeable about the child, the meaning of the evaluation data, and the placement options.

The Hearing Officer first addresses Student’s contention that the District committed a procedural violation by convening the August meeting with a majority of IEP team members who were new to the team, did not know STUDENT, had not reviewed his April and May IEPs, and did not know his unique needs. The Student’s contention fails. Student provides no persuasive authority for the proposition that a majority of IEP team members must be knowledgeable about the child, the meaning of the evaluation results, and the placement options, at the outset of each IEP team meeting. Nor does the law require that each team member be knowledgeable about the child. Instead, the law requires that the group includes the parents and also includes “other persons knowledgeable about the child.”

The Hearing Officer notes that the following individuals, in addition to STUDENT’s parents, were physically present at the August IEP meeting and had assessed and/or worked with STUDENT: Eric Burkholder, the District behaviorist who assessed STUDENT at Charles Armstrong in April and May 2004 and who had observed STUDENT for approximately twenty hours in various settings at school; Gina Wilburn, the District occupational therapist who assessed STUDENT in the spring of 2004 and had provided him with OT services for many years; Jayne Fong, a District speech-language therapist who provided STUDENT with sixteen hours of individual therapy services during ESY 2004; and Claudia Riley, an A.P.E. consultant to Charles Armstrong during the 2003-2004 school year who had assessed STUDENT during the summer of 2004, had known STUDENT for approximately ten years, and had assessed him seven times previously and had provided direct services to him from 1999 through 2003. (Test. of Mr. Burkholder, Ms. Wilburn, Ms. Fong, and Ms. Riley.) Moreover, Ms. Carol Galletta, STUDENT’s teacher at Charles Armstrong during the 2003-2004 school year and 2004 ESY participated in the IEP team meeting by telephone after the PARENTS and their attorney had left the IEP meeting.

Also present at the August meeting were Dr. Koelsch, director of special education, who had known STUDENT since 1995 and had participated in previous IEP meetings regarding STUDENT over the years, in addition to the three meetings in dispute in this case; Vicki Pyper, the proposed SDC teacher, who had reviewed STUDENT’s IEP and special education cumulative file and assessments, and had observed STUDENT at Charles Armstrong in June; and Russ Riley, program specialist, who had facilitated the April and May IEP meetings. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch and Ms. Pyper.)

Also present at the August IEP meeting were Jennifer Rinna, the District’s school psychologist, who had not yet read the spring IEPs but had just been hired and had been on the job only a few days (since August 23), but who had come prepared to discuss social skills. Also present were three new IEP team members from Newark Junior High School who did not know STUDENT. However, the three Newark team members, school principal Belen Majers, resource specialist John Howard, and science teacher Neal Fragus, were knowledgeable about placement options at Newark and its programs, including regular education program and curriculum and mainstreaming opportunities, as well as supports and services available to students at the school. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch.)

Thus, the credible evidence establishes that the IEP team members who participated in the August IEP team satisfied the legal requirement that the IEP team include the parents and other persons knowledgeable about the student, about the assessments, and about program options.

The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation when it convened the IEP team meeting on August 25, 2005, with four new IEP team members who did not have firsthand knowledge of STUDENT’s needs, because the IEP team included those most knowledgeable about STUDENT who would share their knowledge about STUDENT’s needs at the meeting. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch, Mr. Burkholder, Ms. Galletta, Ms. Wilburn, Ms. Fong, Ms. Riley, and Ms. Rinna.)

The Hearing Officer next addresses Student’s contention that the IEP team failed to engage in a collaborative discussion of the full continuum of placement options for an appropriate LRE determination for the 2004-2005 school year. Student’s contention fails.

As discussed previously, Student cites no persuasive authority for the proposition that a full continuum of placement options must be discussed by the IEP team at each team meeting for an appropriate LRE determination. Nevertheless, the credible and unrebutted evidence establishes that the August IEP team discussed mainstreaming and inclusion opportunities for STUDENT, as well as placement in a general education classroom. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch, Ms. Rinna, Ms. Pyper, and Ms. Galletta.) Ms. Pyper testified that she described her SDC classroom while Ms. Galletta was on the phone and that Ms. Galletta said that the SDC was appropriate for STUDENT. Ms. Pyper also recalled that Ms. Galletta expressed concern over Newark’s campus size and that STUDENT’s behaviors might not be appropriate for a general education classroom. Ms. Pyper further recalled that Ms. Galletta had mentioned that STUDENT could become “aide dependent” and that she had worked with “shadowing concepts.” Ms. Pyper recalled that Ms. Galletta was on the phone for the entire discussion about placement and answered questions by team members. Dr. Koelsch and Ms. Rinna also recalled discussions concerning a regular education placement with Ms. Galletta, and Dr. Koelsch specifically recalled asking Ms. Galletta about whether she believed that STUDENT could be successful, with or without a shadow aide, in a regular education classroom at Newark Junior High School, the very question (as discussed above) raised in emails exchanged between Dr. Koelsch and Ms. Galletta during the summer. Ms. Galletta also recalled discussing placement options while on the speaker phone. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch, Ms. Rinna, and Ms. Galletta.)

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the manner in which the District conducted the August IEP team meeting did not result in procedural violations and did not result in a serious infringement on the PARENTS’ right to participate meaningfully in that IEP meeting.

B. Substantive Appropriateness

Student generally asserts that the District’s program and placement offer at Newark Junior High School was not designed to meet his unique needs and did not offer him a placement in the LRE, although Student does not dispute the appropriateness of the designated services offered by the District for occupational therapy, speech and language therapy consultation, and adapted physical education services.

Student also asserts that by not documenting his progress and by not accurately determining his then-current levels of functioning, the District did not identify all of his suspected areas of need in academics, in pragmatic speech, and in social skills/behavior with a focus on peer relationships. Student also asserts that the District relied “almost exclusively” on teacher reports to determine his then-current levels of functioning and that the deficiencies in the description of his present levels led, in turn, to goals and objectives that were not appropriate for him. Student thus challenges the appropriateness of all of the goals and objectives developed by the IEP team, except his sensory integration goals and objectives, as discussed previously, and asserts that he needed additional goals and objectives.

The District contends that STUDENT’s progress was properly documented and that the District provided accurate, then-current levels of performance in academics, speech and language including speech pragmatics, and in social skills and behavior with a focus on peer relationships. The District further asserts that it did not rely exclusively on teacher reports but also relied on appropriate assessments conducted by Ms. Pickens, Ms. Choate, Ms. Rattner, Ms. Fong, Mr. Burkholder, Ms. Wilburn, and Ms. Riley, as well as reports from Ms. Galletta. The District also asserts that each of STUDENT’s goals and objectives are appropriate and that its offered program and placement, within Ms. Pyper’s SDC at Newark Junior High School, is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and would have provided him an education in the LRE.

1. Was the District’s placement offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

The Hearing Officer first addresses Student’s contentions regarding present levels of performance and goals and objectives, and then addresses whether the District’s placement offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

The credible evidence establishes that during the school year leading up to and through the April and May IEP meetings, STUDENT’s parents were given detailed report cards by Charles Armstrong with grades for academics, elective courses, and behavior. Moreover, Ms. Galletta provided to the IEP team during the April 2004 IEP meeting a detailed, written report of STUDENT’s functioning in the areas of academics, social adaptation, and sensory integration. (Test. of Ms. Galletta and Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 29.) Further, Ms. Galletta’s testimony established that she had sufficient knowledge of STUDENT’s level of progress on the goals and objectives in effect from September 2003 to April 2004 as a result of her work with him. (Dist. Exh. 63.)

As discussed previously, Ms. Melinda Pickens’ comprehensive March 2004 academic achievement assessment was presented to the IEP team at the April 2004 IEP meeting. Moreover, Ms. Pickens provided detailed, credible testimony at hearing regarding the accuracy and validity of STUDENT’s test scores and grade equivalents obtained by her assessment. Ms. Pickens’ testimony was unrebutted. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch, Ms. Pickens; Dist. Exh. 29.)

In speech and language, including speech pragmatics, Bonnie G. Rattner, Ed.D., provided her February 2004 speech-language assessment report to the IEP team during the April meeting. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 29). Ms. Rattner recommended that STUDENTbe given the Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing (CASL) and that he be retested with the Test of Language Competence Expanded Edition (TLC-E). Ms. Rattner also noted STUDENT’s deficits in speech pragmatics and the need for goals in that area. Student did not challenge or rebut the accuracy or appropriateness of Ms. Rattner’s assessment. As discussed previously, Ms. Choate later administered the CASL and the TLC-E and found that STUDENT’s test scores were within the average to above average range for his chronological range. Mr. Russ Riley, a District program specialist and speech-language therapist, presented Beth Choate’s April 2004 speech-language assessment to the IEP team. Moreover, Ms. Fong corroborated Ms. Choate’s findings, based on her work with STUDENT in the summer of 2004. Ms. Choate’s assessment findings and Ms. Fong’s testimony were unrebutted. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch, Ms. Fong; Dist. Exh. 29.)

In behavior and social skills, Student’s attorney, Eileen Matteucci, presented the privately obtained behavioral assessment conducted by Synergistic Interventions at the April IEP meeting. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch; Dist. Exh. 29.) It is undisputed that Mr. Burkholder reviewed the Synergistic report and considered its findings and recommendations. Additionally, Mr. Burkholder reviewed his behavioral assessment with the IEP team on May 24. (Test. of Mr. Burkholder; Dist. Exh. 29.) Mr. Burkholder had observed STUDENT engage in tantrumming behaviors that included crying and screaming or falling to the ground when he was upset. He had also reviewed data collected in the classroom by paraprofessional Janine Friend during May and June 2004 and during the 2004 summer program.

In March 2004, Ms. Wells of Synergistic Interventions observed STUDENT engaging in behaviors such as loud verbal outbursts from his desk and lengthy verbal protesting behaviors. Ms. Wells had also observed the following social deficits: STUDENT repeatedly attempting to initiate play and conversation with peers inappropriately by yelling, or by throwing the ball to a peer when the peer was not looking, or by walking into the middle of an organized game. Ms. Wells testified that she spoke with STUDENT’s physical education teacher who told her that STUDENT had difficulty understanding the rules of games. Synergistic also confirmed Ms. Galletta’s reports that STUDENT was often oppositional and noncompliant, and at times disruptive in class. Ms. Wells also testified that Mr. Burkholder’s impressions of STUDENT’s social skills deficits, as well as Mr. Burkholder’s recommendations, were consistent with the Synergistic report. Although Student’s expert, Ms. Wells, and District behaviorist Mr. Burkholder, disagreed in their respective recommendations about a placement for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that the observations reported by Ms. Wells and Mr. Burkholder are generally consistent. The Hearing Officer also finds that the observations of Ms. Wells and Mr. Burkholder within their respective reports adequately and accurately portrayed STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties and social skills deficits, including a focus on peer relationships, during the spring of 2004. (Test. of Ms. Burkholder and Ms. Wells.)

At the August IEP meeting, Ms. Galletta also gave an updated report of STUDENT’s progress during the two summer sessions, and Ms. Fong provided an “individual speech and language progress” report based on her work with him over the summer of 2004. Ms. Riley also provided her A.P.E. assessment report to the August IEP team. (Test. of Ms. Galletta, Ms. Fong, Ms. Riley; Dist. Exh. 45.) Moreover, each of the IEP team members, including the PARENTS and their attorney, Ms. Matteucci, were given adequate opportunities at three IEP team meetings to question various IEP team members, including Ms. Galletta, Ms. Fong, and Mr. Burkholder, about STUDENT’s then-current level of functioning in academics, in speech and language, and in behavior and social skills.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s progress was adequately documented by Charles Armstrong and through District and private assessments. The Hearing Officer also finds that the District did not rely “almost exclusively” on teacher reports in describing STUDENT’s present levels of performance and developing goals and objectives and that instead, the District also relied on assessments from District assessors as discussed above. The District also considered the assessments of Synergistic and Ms. Rattner as well as input from the PARENTS in its identification of STUDENT’s areas of need in academics, speech and language -- including speech pragmatics, and in social skills and behavior, including a focus on peer relationships.

Because Student generally disputed whether the District’s offer was designed to meet his unique needs, the Hearing Officer must first identify STUDENT’s unique needs.

STUDENT’s unique needs

Under federal special education law, “the services and placement needed by each child with a disability to receive a [FAPE] must be based on the child’s unique needs and not on the disability.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.300(a)(3)(ii).

It is undisputed that STUDENT has significant needs in reading, reading comprehension, and oral reading fluency due to his dyslexia. It is also undisputed that STUDENT has significant needs in basic writing, written expression, and written language due to his dysgraphia. As discussed above, the academic achievement testing conducted by Ms. Pickens in March 2004, and as reported at the April IEP meeting revealed that STUDENT’s then-current level of functioning in reading and writing was basically at a second grade level, at least four grade levels below his sixth grade placement. For oral reading fluency, according to Ms. Pickens’ testimony, STUDENT was at a “really beginning” first grade or “maybe” kindergarten level and his instructional level was at the “beginning to mid-first grade.” Ms. Galletta also testified that STUDENT exhibited a resistance to writing. There was no credible evidence or argument to rebut the validity of Ms. Pickens’ assessment results, and her results were generally consistent with the results of standardized tests conducted the previous year and with the in-coming assessments conducted in September 2004 by Charles Armstrong. (Test. of Ms. Galletta; Dist. Exh. 30.) Moreover, Dr. Koelsch’s testimony established that Ms. Pickens’ assessment was adequately discussed at the April IEP meeting and that the PARENTS participated in that meeting. The PARENTS were provided with a copy of the report prior to the April IEP meeting. (Dist. Exh. 3.) The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has significant needs in reading, reading comprehension, oral reading fluency, basic writing, written expression, and written language.

It is also generally undisputed that STUDENT has significant social skills needs and behavioral needs. Ms. Galletta testified that STUDENT had demonstrated an inability to work in a group because he was not willing to listen to the ideas of the other children. STUDENT engaged in behaviors that disrupted the classroom which led to his removal from the classroom setting. STUDENT exhibited difficulty understanding and interacting with his peers and could not engage in reciprocity. Ms. Galletta stated that STUDENT resisted using a locker or would not lock his lock, or would leave his backpack on the floor in the aisle even after the teacher reminded him not to leave his backpack on the floor in the aisle. Dr. Whitlock also noted, based upon reports from teachers, that STUDENT displayed inappropriate interactions with teachers and an inability to control and direct his behavior at Charles Armstrong. Dr. Whitlock recalled that STUDENT would “easily break down,” describing it as a “meltdown” and be upset by something and that would provoke him to become “more and more upset until we actually had to get him out of the classroom.” STUDENT would then be brought “up the hill” to Room 1 and be given counseling services. The testimony by Ms. Galletta and Dr. Whitlock was unrebutted.

The testimony by Ms. Galletta and Dr. Whitlock about STUDENT’s social skills needs and behavioral needs was corroborated by the testimony of Dr. Cousins. Dr. Cousins, the school psychologist who has had significant experience working with STUDENT in social skills groups during previous school years and during the summer of 2004, testified that STUDENT has difficulty thinking beyond his own needs and putting himself in other people’s shoes and that he misinterprets social interactions. Dr. Cousins characterized STUDENT’s level of sophistication, in terms of “give and take,” as at a much younger age developmentally. Dr. Cousins also noted that STUDENT has difficulty with reciprocity and rarely calls people by their names, and that while in some contexts he is polite and has some “superficial social skills,” he has more difficulty understanding social nuances and how people interact and is “definitely” below his age expectancy level in that respect. Dr. Cousins further testified that it is challenging for STUDENT when he is in contact with typically developing peers and in getting a clear knowledge of what a student is trying to convey to him, and that he sometimes misinterprets others’ meanings, and so tends to be defensive with other students. Dr. Cousins also noted that STUDENT feels isolated sometimes from other groups of peers. The testimony of Dr. Cousins was detailed and generally consistent with the testimony of Ms. Galletta and Mr. Burkholder. Dr. Cousins’ testimony was unrebutted.

Student took the position at hearing that his behavioral needs were not as severe as the District contends and that Charles Armstrong and the District exaggerated the behavioral incidents at Charles Armstrong. (Test. of PARENT.) The Student’s position is not supported by the evidence. On April 26, 2004, Ms. Galletta reported to the IEP team the following entry contained within her written report, under the category social adaptation: “STUDENT has intense social and behavioral needs. He lacks theory of mind, perspective taking, taking responsibility for his actions, and the ability to appropriately initiate peer contact and solve conflict.” Ms. Galletta’s report also noted that STUDENT’s “history of negative peer relations has left him extremely defensive and angry” and that he “expects to be victimized.” (Test. of Ms. Galletta; Dist. Exh. 29.) The Hearing Officer also notes that Ms. Rattner reported in her speech language assessment that STUDENT “takes little responsibility for his own behaviors with peers, [and] blames others.” (Dist. Exh. 29.)

Additionally, the IEP team on April 26 was informed by Ms. Galletta of two incidents that had occurred at Charles Armstrong involving physical aggression by STUDENT. Moreover, Ms. Galletta testified at great length to a number of escalating behaviors engaged in by STUDENT that involved not only peers but also staff members at Charles Armstrong and that she communicated “pretty regularly” with the PARENTS by phone and by email. Ms. Galletta testified that the PARENTS had an understanding of the following reported behaviors as they were occurring, incidents that Ms. Galletta had witnessed and described in emails (most of which were sent to the PARENTS): poking a student with a bent stapler; running backwards into a staff member and attempting to blame another student; announcing to the whole class a derogatory comment made by one student about another that caused anger between the students; putting his hands around a student’s neck and squeezing out of frustration over not being allowed to participate in a basketball game; flinging a pencil during small group time that landed on a classmate and then getting explosive in his language (i.e., yelling at the teacher) after being taken outside, and then returning to class and becoming confrontational with the student and with other students; raising a chair in the classroom and threatening another student, and then being asked to remove his backpack to the space allocated (and refusing to do so), and then pushing into the teacher while walking past the teacher. (Test. of Ms. Galletta; Dist. Exhs. 6 through 13.)

Ms. Galletta also testified that on February 16, 2004, STUDENT tantrummed and was sent out of the classroom (when Ms. Galletta was not in school that day) for attempting to kick Ms. Rose (co-teacher). Additionally, Ms. Galletta testified that on March 4, 2004, Ms. McAllister (the classroom’s other co-teacher) had reported that STUDENT was engaged in a wrestling and shoving match with another boy over a girl’s bracelet, and that STUDENT was sent to the counseling office for the rest of the day to work alone outside the class. (Dist. Exhs. 15 and 16.)

As discussed above, the behavioral assessments of Synergistic Interventions and of Eric Burkholder are generally consistent as to social skills deficits and behaviors observed during the spring of 2004. Vicki Wells and Kim Stokes, after two observations of STUDENT conducted at Charles Armstrong and one at his home that mainly involved speaking with PARENT and with STUDENT, noted in the Synergistic report that at school, STUDENT spent a “lengthy amount of time engaging in verbal protesting behaviors with the adults over the order of completion of an assigned report.” Ms. Wells said that STUDENT’s social skills deficits are “very high.”

Moreover, as discussed above, Mr. Burkholder concluded that STUDENT has social skills deficits in dealing with frustration in a socially acceptable manner consistently, handling peer provocation, handling disappointment, tacting (discerning) the social appropriateness of his own behaviors, and recognizing the impact of his behaviors on others (perspective taking). Mr. Burkholder also noted the following behavioral excesses in emotional responding: crying, whining, laughing at peers, insulting peers, difficulty maintaining appropriate physical boundaries (running into peers and pushing peers), shouting out in class, keeping his knees and feet off the desk, staying at his desk, and tantrumming. (Test. of Mr. Burkholder; Dist. Exh. 29.)

The Hearing Officer gives great weight to the detailed testimony of Ms. Galletta, who worked directly with STUDENT not only during the regular school year (a period of approximately eight months) but also during the summer that followed. The Hearing Officer also gives great weight to the testimony of the District’s behaviorist, Eric Burkholder, who observed the student for approximately twenty hours in a variety of school settings and reviewed school records, and the detailed testimony of Dr. Cousins, a very experienced and well qualified school psychologist who has had experience working with STUDENT within social skills groups over the past three years. The Hearing Officer gives less weight to the observations of Ms. Wells, who observed the student for a few hours at school on two occasions in March 2004 and reviewed records and assessments, and the anecdotal testimony of PARENT concerning her understanding of a few of the reported behavioral incidents at Charles Armstrong. The Hearing Officer also notes Ms. Wells’ acknowledgement that STUDENT has a “very literal understanding” of others, that he wasn’t able to read social nuances, and that she agreed with Mr. Burkholder’s impressions about STUDENT’s social skills deficits and the need for prompting for him to consistently use the skills that he has. (Test. of Ms. Wells; Dist. Exh. 29.) The Hearing Officer also considers the testimony of the student himself, STUDENT, who replied, “I don’t remember” or “I don’t know” several times in response to questions about specific reports of behavioral incidents at Charles Armstrong. The Hearing Officer found STUDENT’s responses to be generally lacking in detail.

Thus, the Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the testimony of Ms. Galletta, Mr. Burkholder, and Dr. Cousins, and less weight to the generally exculpatory testimony of PARENT and STUDENT regarding a few of the incidents. The sheer number of incidents reported at Charles Armstrong and the general consistency of the testimony of the witnesses called by the District (Ms. Galletta, Dr. Cousins, and Mr. Burkholder) cannot plausibly be attributed to the reason belatedly raised – that the reports of behavioral incidents were exaggerated or fabricated by Mr. Burkholder or by Charles Armstrong staff in order to remove STUDENT from Charles Armstrong. (Test. of PARENT.)

Additionally, the PARENTS’ belated position is not supported by the testimony of Ms. Wells about her classroom observations in March 2004 or by Mr. Burkholder’s testimony. (Test. of PARENT, Mr. Burkholder, and Ms. Wells.) Moreover, Ms. Wells testified that during a “focused” conversation she had with STUDENT’s teacher at Charles Armstrong, the teacher told her that STUDENT had engaged in acts of aggression -- altercations between him and his peers -- that caused STUDENT to have to go to the office.

Although PARENT asserted that Synergistic’s recommendation of intensive interventions to address STUDENT’s behaviors and social deficits represented an “easy fix” and not “long term,” PARENT stated that STUDENT previously had had “twelve or thirteen” social skills groups at the District. (Test. of PARENT.) The Hearing Officer finds that the volume and frequency of STUDENT’s behavioral incidents, however characterized (as either social skill deficits or as behavioral excesses) represented a significant area of need for STUDENT and affected his ability to remain in the classroom and to access the curriculum at Charles Armstrong, and led to his forced departure from Charles Armstrong. Moreover, STUDENT’s behavioral and social skills deficits indicated a need for a structured classroom setting with appropriate behavioral supports, as discussed further within.

It is undisputed that STUDENT needs to participate in social skills groups and to work on social pragmatics. The development of social pragmatics for communications within a social skills group is an important area of need for STUDENT because STUDENT has demonstrated difficulties communicating with peers in a social setting. Moreover, STUDENT needs to generalize social and speech pragmatics skills outside of a social skills group setting. (Test. of Dr. Whitlock, Ms. Galletta, PARENT, Dr. Cousins, Dr. Koelsch, and Ms. Rinna; Dist. Exh. 29.) However, STUDENT does not need individual speech and language therapy. As discussed previously, STUDENT’s scores on his speech and language assessment conducted by Ms. Choate in April 2004 were in the average to above average range for his age. The accuracy of the test scores was corroborated by the testimony of Ms. Fong, who worked directly with STUDENT in the summer 2004. Ms. Fong testified that STUDENT is able to communicate with verbal language and with appropriate voice, intonation and pitch, as well as nonverbally. Ms. Fong’s testimony was unrebutted. (Test. of Ms. Fong; Dist. Exh. 29.)

It is also undisputed that STUDENT needs to improve his keyboarding skills to type accurately and at a higher rate of speed. STUDENT has shown frustration in using a keyboard because he types slowly. (Test. of Ms. Galletta.)

It is also generally undisputed that at the time of the District’s offer, STUDENT needed a small, structured classroom setting. Ms. Galletta testified that although STUDENT’s behavior had improved during the summer session within a structured environment with a one-to-one aide, Ms. Galletta attributed the improvement in part to the fewer number of class hours, three, and the structured setting of eight students. Dr. Whitlock testified that STUDENT needed a “small enough” classroom environment to get “really good” attention and that he needed “a lot of” one-to-one attention. Dr. Whitlock noted that when Charles Armstrong was able to give him one-to-one or two-to-one attention, STUDENT was able to work through his emotional issues and to work on his academic issues. Dr. Cousins also testified that STUDENT performed better within a structured environment and noted that STUDENT did not perform as well in less structured environments. Mr. Burkholder and Ms. Wells also recognized the value of structure, including the need for development of appropriate socials skills and behavioral support for STUDENT. (Test. of Mr. Burkholder, Ms. Galletta, Ms. Pyper, and Ms Wells).

In summary, STUDENT’s needs are in reading, reading comprehension, oral reading fluency, basic writing, written expression, written language, social skills, behavior, social pragmatics in social skills groups, and keyboarding, and for structure within a small classroom setting with a relatively low student-to-adult ratio.

Because Student placed in dispute each of the goals and objectives developed at the IEP team meetings in April and May, the Hearing Officer next considers the goals and objectives (except, as discussed above, the sensory integration goals and objectives.).

The District’s proposed goals and objectives

Section 56345(a) of the California Education Code provides, in pertinent part, that the written individualized education program shall include (1) a statement of the present levels of the pupil’s educational performance, including for a schoolage child, how the pupil’s disability affects the pupil’s involvement and progress in the general curriculum and (2) measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives related to the following: (A) meeting the pupil’s needs that result from the pupil’s disability to enable the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and (B) meeting each of the pupil’s other educational needs that result from the pupil’s disability.

During the first hearing day’s discussion when the parties’ issues and contentions were clarified, Student initially contended that all of the proposed goals and objectives were not appropriate for him because the goals were based upon inadequate present levels. However, as discussed above, the parties later stipulated that the OT assessment and its recommendations and goals and objectives were not in dispute. Thus, the Hearing Officer does not address the appropriateness of the two sensory motor IEP goals and objectives. (Dist. Exh. 29.) As noted previously, Student also contends that he needed additional goals and objectives.

The District contends that academic, behavioral, speech-language, (and OT) assessments had all been conducted within a few months prior to the April IEP, and that the assessments, together with the reports by STUDENT’s classroom teacher, Ms. Galletta, provided the IEP team with then-current and accurate present levels of performance.

The Hearing Officer addresses each goal in dispute as expressed within the April 26 and May 24, 2004 IEP. To facilitate analysis, the Hearing Officer will note, under each goal heading, the present level of performance/baseline data as of April or May 2004, as expressed on STUDENT’s IEP, unless otherwise noted.

Behavior/Non-Academic

The IEP indicated that STUDENT engaged in talking out (statements that were unsolicited or contextually inappropriate) a minimum of two to three times per period. Student challenges the accuracy of the present level. Based upon their observations of STUDENT in class, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the unrebutted testimony of Mr. Burkholder and of Ms. Galletta that the present level of performance adequately and accurately reflected STUDENT’s then-current level of functioning. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the goal and objectives are appropriate for STUDENT and would have met STUDENT’s need to reduce his talking out in class.

Social Adaptation

In the social adaptation goal, the District noted that STUDENT was “not independent” and had to have one-to-one prompts and scripting. Student challenges the accuracy of the present level. The measurable annual goal is that STUDENT would develop group interaction skills by confronting controversial situations and work through them in an non-aggressive manner four out of five times, nine of ten days, with no staff assistance. Based upon observations of STUDENT in class by Ms. Galletta, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the unrebutted testimony of Carol Galletta that the present level of performance accurately reflected STUDENT’s then-current level of functioning. Ms. Pyper also testified to the accuracy of the present level based upon her review of the IEP, her conversation at Charles Armstrong with Ms. Galletta, and her observation of the student at Charles Armstrong. Ms. Pyper testified that she could have implemented the goal in her SDC classroom. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the present level was accurate as to STUDENT’s then-current level of functioning and that the goal is an appropriate one for STUDENT and would have met his need to confront controversial situations and work through them in a non-aggressive manner.

Organizational Skills

In organizational skills, the IEP noted that STUDENT used his locker when prompted by staff, locked his locker when prompted, and kept his backpack in the classroom. The measurable long term annual goal provides that by April 2005, when arriving at school and transitioning between classes and subjects, STUDENT would appropriately use his locker to store his lunch, backpack, books, and binders without teacher prompt five out of five days, six out of six trials. (Dist. Exh. 29.) Student challenges the accuracy of the present level. Based upon observations of STUDENT in class by Ms. Galletta, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the unrebutted testimony of Ms. Galletta that the present level of performance accurately reflected STUDENT’s then-currentpresent level of performance. Ms. Pyper testified that she could have implemented the goal relating to keeping the backpack in the classroom. Ms. Pyper stated that apart from physical education class, there are no lockers at Newark Junior High School. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal and objectives are appropriate for STUDENT and would have met his need to improve his organizational skills.

Social Adaptation

With regard to social adaptation, the IEP notes that STUDENT was “prompt dependent” 100% of the time. (Dist. Exh. 29.) The proposed goal provides that STUDENT, by April 2005, would express his emotional state by using appropriate tone and language four out of five times on four out of five days without staff assistance. Student challenges the accuracy of the present level and appropriateness of the goal and objectives. Based upon classroom observations by Ms. Galletta, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the unrebutted testimony of Ms. Galletta that the present level accurately reflected STUDENT’s then-current present level of performance. Ms. Pyper testified that this goal could have been implemented in her SDC. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal and objectives are appropriate for STUDENT and would have met his need to improve his ability to express his emotional state with appropriate tone and language.

Reading Fluency

In reading fluency, the District noted that STUDENT’s grade equivalent for reading fluency on the WJ-III administered on March 8, 2004, was 1.8, at a second grade level, sixty words per minute. (Dist. Exh. 29) The proposed goal is that STUDENT would read aloud a narrative and expository text with appropriate intonation and expression in a manner that sounds like natural sounds (seventy words per minute). Student challenges the accuracy of the present level. The Hearing Officer found persuasive Ms. Pickens’ unrebutted testimony regarding the accuracy and validity of the WJ-III that she administered and STUDENT’s reading fluency score of 1.8. The Hearing Officer also found persuasive Ms. Galletta’s unrebutted testimony concerning the appropriateness of the goals and objectives. Ms. Pyper testified that this goal could have been implemented in her SDC. The Hearing Officer finds that the present levels were accurate and that the reading fluency goal is an appropriate goal for STUDENT and would have addressed a significant need for him -- to improve his reading fluency.

Reading

In the reading goal, the IEP noted that STUDENT’s consonant-vowel-consonant (CVC) words grade equivalent score on the Word Attack subtest for the WJ-III in March 2004 was 2.9. (Dist. Exh. 29.) The proposed goal is to generate sounds from all the letters and letter patterns including consonant blends, long and short vowel patterns, and to blend those sounds into recognizable words. Student challenges the accuracy of the present level. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Pickens’ unrebutted testimony that her administration of the WJ-III was valid and that STUDENT’s score of 2.9 on the Word Attack accurately stated his present level. The Hearing Officer is also persuaded by the unrebutted testimony of Ms. Galletta concerning the appropriateness of the goals and objectives. Ms. Pyper testified that this goal could have been implemented in her SDC. The Hearing Officer finds that the present level was accurate and that the goal and objectives are appropriate for STUDENT and would have met his significant need to improve his reading.

Reading/Sight Word Vocabulary

The IEP noted that STUDENT’s grade equivalent on the WJ-III Word Recognition subtest was 1.8 in March 2004. (Dist. Exh. 29.) The proposed goal is to read common sight words (e.g., they, have, said, come, of) from a list of one-hundred priority sight words with 80% accuracy. Student challenges the accuracy of the present level. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the unrebutted testimony of Ms. Pickens regarding the validity of the WJ-III test scores and the accuracy of STUDENT’s GE of 1.8 on Word Recognition. The Hearing Officer also finds persuasive the unrebutted testimony of Ms. Galletta that the goal and objectives are appropriate for STUDENT. Ms. Pyper testified that this goal could have been implemented in her SDC. The Hearing Officer finds that the present level was accurate and that the goals and objectives are appropriate for STUDENT and would have met his need to improve common sight word recognition.

Penmanship

In penmanship, it was noted that STUDENT wrote three to five letters with appropriate spacing, case, and size. (Dist. Exh. 29.) The proposed goal is that STUDENT print legibly and space letters, words, and sentences appropriately. Based upon the classroom observations of Ms. Galletta, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive the unrebutted testimony of Ms. Galletta concerning the accuracy of the present level and the appropriateness of the goals and objectives. Ms. Pyper testified that this goal could have been implemented in her SDC. The Hearing Officer finds that the present level was accurate and that goals and objectives are appropriate and would have met a significant need to improve STUDENT’s penmanship.

Technology

The proposed technology goal did not have a present level. The proposed goal is that by April 2005, STUDENT would utilize efficiently and independently a reading software program. Student challenges the technology goal on the basis that it lacks a present level of performance. Ms. Galletta testified that she drafted this goal at the IEP meeting and that Eric Burkholder wrote the benchmarks and that no present level was given because STUDENT had not been using a reading software program at that point. Ms. Pyper testified that this goal could have been implemented in her SDC and that there are computers in her classroom. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the credible explanation given by Ms. Galletta concerning the absence of a present level and finds that the omission of a present level did not render the goal inappropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives are appropriate for STUDENT because they would have met a significant need to improve his reading and his reading speed.

Keyboarding

The keyboarding goal noted that STUDENT was able to type his first name accurately. (Dist. Exh. 29.) The proposed goal is that by April 2005, STUDENT would type at a rate of twenty correct words per minute when given a passage of instructional level text. Student challenges the accuracy of the present level. Based upon the classroom observations of Ms. Galletta, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive the unrebutted testimony of Ms. Galletta that the present level is accurate and that the goals and objectives are appropriate for STUDENT. Ms. Pyper testified that this goal could have been implemented in her SDC. The Hearing Officer finds that the present level was accurate and the goals and objectives are appropriate for STUDENT and would have met his need to improve his typing in both speed and accuracy, which would have reduced his frustration level when typing. (Test. of Ms. Galletta.)

Communication

The District proposed three communication goals for STUDENT. The first communication goal indicated that STUDENT displayed a major episode of non-compliance coupled with emotional responding .2 times per day. (Dist. Exh. 29.) Student challenges the accuracy of the present level. The goal states that by May 2005, within ongoing activities and routines, STUDENT would engage in expressing his frustration with a situation by using a replacement skill (including but not limited to talking in a contextually appropriate manner, asking for a break, or writing in a journal) 100% of occasions for two consecutive weeks. Ms. Galletta testified that on a “typical” day, she had to provide STUDENT with one-to-one support “at least” once per hour and that this meant that she had to stop what she was doing, sit down with him, and take “two or three minutes” to give him redirection and academic or behavioral support. Sometimes, Ms. Galletta took him out of the classroom and sat down with him and talked with him, or took him on a walk around the school yard.

School psychologist Dr. Cousins testified that the goal was attempting to teach self-awareness, self-monitoring of behavior and appropriate replacement skills, noting that she could have implemented this goal in her social skills group, coupled with teaching assertive communication skills -- “I statements.” Ms. Rinna stated that the three replacement skills (stop, think, and calm down) she would have taught STUDENT were self-awareness such as “stop and think” strategies, taking deep breaths or self-talk statements to calm down, and writing in a journal to process the emotion after it happens to continue to calm himself down (a skill for the natural setting in the classroom.) Based upon the classroom observations of Ms. Galletta, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive the unrebutted testimony of Ms. Galletta that the present level accurately and adequately stated STUDENT’s then-present level of performance. Based upon the unrebutted testimony of Ms. Galletta, Mr. Burkholder, Ms. Rinna, and Dr. Cousins, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the goal and objectives appropriately addressed STUDENT’s need to use a replacement skill when feeling frustrated.

The second communication goal indicated that STUDENT had pragmatic difficulties exhibited within social and academic settings. (Dist. Exh. 29.) The proposed goal is that STUDENT would request information by asking questions with appropriate verbal language, voice, intonation, pitch, and nonverbal communication (eye contact - body communication). Student contends that the then-present level of performance was not adequate to develop appropriate goals and objectives. Mr. Burkholder acknowledged that the goal did not contain present levels of performance. However, the Hearing Officer notes that Beth Choate’s speech-language assessment and Bonnie Rattner’s speech-language assessment were made part of the IEP. Although Ms. Choate’s report did not refer to speech pragmatics, Ms. Rattner’s report did. Ms. Rattner’s report described STUDENT’s difficulty with social pragmatic skills (“the ability to use language functionally to communicate and interact”) and the need for goals in that area. Ms. Jayne Fong testified that she reviewed Ms. Choate’s assessment and that she found the report to be an accurate assessment of STUDENT’s current level of functioning (in the summer of 2004) during one-to-one therapy sessions with her. Ms. Fong testified that she worked with STUDENT on the goal and objectives during the summer and that STUDENT met the goal and objectives within the individual therapy sessions held with her. The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP included Ms. Rattner’s speech and language report which adequately reflected STUDENT’s then-current level of functioning and pragmatic difficulties for social and academic settings. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal is appropriate in that it addresses STUDENT’s need to improve his communication skills to communicate and interact with peers and adults.

The third communication goal indicated that STUDENT had pragmatic difficulties exhibited within social and academic settings. The goal is to “request information by asking questions with appropriate verbal language, voice, intonation, pitch, and nonverbal communication (eye contact -- body communication). This communication goal has the same present level as the previous goal. As discussed above, because the IEP contained Ms. Rattner’s speech and language assessment which described STUDENT’s communication and pragmatic difficulties in social and academic settings, the Hearing Officer finds that the goal’s present level of functioning is adequate. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal is appropriate in that it addresses STUDENT’s need to improve his communication skills with peers and adults.

The Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives developed by the IEP team for communication (including pragmatic speech), behavior, social adaptation, organizational skills, reading fluency, reading, reading sight word vocabulary, penmanship, technology (for using a reading software program), and keyboarding (to improve typing speed and accuracy) are appropriate to address STUDENT’s needs in communication, reading, writing, behavior, social skills, keyboarding, and technology.

The Hearing Officer also finds that the goals and objectives adequately addressed all of STUDENT’s needs and that there was no persuasive evidence to the contrary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that additional goals and objectives were not needed.

The District’s proposed placement

The District contends that its offer of placement for STUDENT in a small, structured learning handicapped (LH) SDC classroom at Newark Junior High School taught by an experienced SDC teacher, would have met his need for a small, structured classroom setting with adequate behavioral supports and related services. The District contends that the behavioral supports, including six hours of behavioral training for STUDENT’s parents to support generalization of skills, six hours of training for an aide to support STUDENT during mainstreamed classes and unstructured times, and one hour per month of ongoing consultation by the District behaviorist for staff members working with STUDENT, is appropriate. The District contends that its offer of mainstreaming opportunities at lunchtime and during an elective course was appropriate.

Although Student generally asserts that the District’s program and placement offer was not designed to meet his unique needs, Student raised no specific challenges to the District’s program and placement offer other than the contentions previously addressed regarding goals and objectives and Student’s assertion that the offer was not in the LRE.

The District’s offer of Ms. Pyper’s SDC, a classroom with a low student to adult ratio (ten to two) would have met STUDENT’s need to address his significant learning disabilities in reading and writing and to provide adequate support for his behavioral needs. As discussed previously, the structure of the classroom provides for two language arts periods per day that includes (but is not limited to) direct instruction in oral language, reading, reading fluency, and phonemic awareness. Ms. Pyper also uses basal readers, in use by general education students, at her students’ “frustration levels,” to increase their ability to read. (Test. of Ms. Pyper.) Science and math are also taught in the classroom. Moreover, the social skills class teaches the development of appropriate social skills. Ms. Pyper’s SDC class has students with specific learning disabilities (in the areas of reading and written language) as well as students with processing difficulties and students with behavioral challenges. Ms. Pyper uses “a lot of visuals” and hands-on instruction that reinforces what the class is studying and also uses different approaches to meet the needs of each student.

The structured SDC setting includes a behavioral modification system that uses a point system that rewards appropriate behavior and successful academics performance Ms. Pyper has received specialized training in Project Read and SRA (a word study program), and in Lindamood-Bell’s Lips, Visualizing & Verbalizing, Seeing Stars, and On Cloud Nine programs. She has also received training in behavioral modifications and in Physical Assault Response Training (PART) and has a certificate from the Crisis Prevention Institute. Ms. Pyper is an experienced and credentialed SDC teacher. The District’s offer also provides six hours of behavioral training for STUDENT’s parents for prompting strategies to support generalization of skills learned by STUDENT in his social skills group. The behavioral services also include an instructional aide for STUDENT during the mainstreaming time and six hours of training for the aide. The behavioral services also include one hour per month of consultation by the District behaviorist of staff members working with STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Pyper is adequately trained to meet the needs of students with dyslexia, dysgraphia, and behavioral issues such as STUDENT.

STUDENT would also have received mainstreaming opportunities at “brunch” (morning recess), at lunch, during physical education, and during a “life skills” class. Ms. Debra Kane-Nolan, a Newark physical education teacher, described her class and stated that she has had experience working with a mainstreamed special education student in her class. Ms. Barbara Casey described her Newark seventh grade Skills for Adolescents class. The class helps a student learn about emotions, how to improve peer relationships and to develop positive social behaviors. The multifaceted program and curriculum includes drug education and human sexuality. Ms. Casey stated that she has had experience with special education students in her class before and can deal with behavioral challenges in the classroom. (Test. of Ms. Kane-Nolan, Ms. Casey; Dist. Exh. 59.)

As discussed previously, Dr. Cousins, who had worked with STUDENT in social skill groups during previous school years as well as during the summer 2004, and had previously assessed him formally in 2002, agreed with the service recommendation of one hour per month consult and two thirty minute sessions per week for a social skills group (small group) and that it was appropriate and would have met STUDENT’s need for the development of his social skills. Moreover, Dr. Cousins testified that a special education setting would have been more appropriate to address STUDENT’s needs and that even if STUDENT’s needs were only to address social skills deficits, she did not believe he could have been successful in a general education or a more mainstream environment (than the offered SDC) because STUDENT acts as a “much younger child” and is “much less sophisticated” in social interactions and is more defensive and has difficulty with reciprocity and understanding. Dr. Cousins also noted that a social skills group is not the same as going out on the recess ground and having the “give and take” with peers. Dr. Cousins persuasively testified that STUDENT’s social skills issues are significant and also overlap with some of STUDENT’s cognitive and learning disabilities (and noted that it is very hard to separate the deficits).

Ms. Wells stated that STUDENT would have benefited from a small class size but she would have needed to observe him in a larger setting before making a determination as to whether a small classroom setting would have been useful at the beginning of the school year.

The Hearing Officer gives great weight to the detailed testimony of Ms. Galletta, Mr. Burkholder, Dr. Cousins, and Dr. Koelsch which supported the District’s proposal of placement within Ms. Pyper’s SDC classroom placement, with appropriate supports within that structured setting. The Hearing Officer accords less weight to the testimony of Ms. Wells who took the position that a regular education classroom with appropriate supports could have addressed STUDENT’s needs. The Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the testimony of Ms. Galletta and Dr. Cousins because of the significant amount of time both individuals spent with STUDENT and because their detailed testimony was generally consistent. The Hearing Officer also gives greater weight to the testimony of Mr. Burkholder than to the testimony of Ms. Wells because Mr. Burkholder spent considerably more time observing STUDENT (twenty hours) in a variety of settings, and had trained a paraprofessional who collected data in the classroom, and because Ms. Wells spent no more than two hours observing STUDENT in the classroom and no more than two hours observing STUDENT at recess, lunch, and during transitions. The Hearing Officer also considers the testimony of Dr. Whitlock who did not believe that STUDENT could have been successful in a regular education classroom.

The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of the District’s witnesses and finds that the District’s program and placement offer would have met STUDENT’s need for a small, structured classroom with appropriate academic and behavioral supports, instruction by an adequately trained and credentialed teacher, and mainstreaming opportunities. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer also finds that the IEP goals and objectives developed at the April and May IEP meetings were appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs.

2. Is the District’s program and placement offer reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?

The credible evidence establishes that the District’s offer is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

The District’s proposed program and placement offers educational benefits to address STUDENT’s significant reading and writing deficits and his deficits in social skills, speech pragmatics, and behavioral functioning. Ms. Pyper credibly testified that she has the training necessary to employ different methodologies (e.g., Project Read, Lindamood-Bell and SRA) and has a positive behavioral system in place in the classroom that would have provided STUDENT with some educational benefit. Dr. Cousins credibly testified that STUDENT would have derived benefit from a social skills group to address his significant deficits in social skills and peer relationships. The District offered a skills class taught by a credentialed teacher, Ms. Casey, who testified to the benefits of her class. (Test. of Ms. Casey; Dist. Exh. 51.) Student did not rebut the testimony by District witnesses regarding educational benefit, nor did Student provide credible evidence that the District’s program and placement offer would not have provided some educational benefit.

3. Did the District’s offer comport with his IEP?

This is not at issue because Student did not enroll in Newark Junior High School. The District has shown that it was ready, willing, and able to implement its offered program and placement at Newark Junior High School. (Test. of Ms. Pyper, Dr. Koelsch, and Ms. Casey.)

4. Is the District’s offer of placement in Ms. Pyper’s SDC classroom at Newark Junior High School the LRE?

Student contends that the placement offer is not appropriate for him because it is not in the LRE and is too restrictive. Student maintains that he was able to function independently at Charles Armstrong and that he is able to function independently at his current private school, New Horizons. The District contends that Ms. Pyper’s SDC at Newark Junior High School is the LRE for STUDENT.

The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming” or education in the LRE. The law demonstrates a “strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” Daniel R. v. State Bd. of Educ., 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45 (5th Cir. 1989)

In determining whether a disabled child should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental aids and services, the Ninth Circuit has created a four-part test that requires consideration of: (1) the academic benefits available to the disabled student in a regular education classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the academic benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the nonacademic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled; (3) the effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and other children in a regular education classroom; and (4) the costs of supplementary aids and services necessary to mainstream the handicapped child in a regular education classroom setting. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).

The Hearing Officer notes that in Rachel H., the LRE question was whether the student should be placed full-time within a public school’s regular education classroom with some supplemental services, or whether the student should be placed half-time within a special education placement and half-time within a regular education class. As previously noted, STUDENT attended Charles Armstrong, a specialized nonpublic school that serves students with learning disabilities (dyslexia and dysgraphia) during the 2003-2004 school year. As discussed above, the District offered a program and placement in an SDC at Newark Junior High School for the 2004-2005 school year with some mainstreaming.

At hearing, Student characterized Charles Armstrong (and his current private school placement at New Horizons) as “regular education classrooms.” Without making a determination on whether either educational setting is a regular education classroom, the Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Galletta’s Charles Armstrong classroom has two important characteristics found in an SDC: a small class size and a low student-to-adult ratio. Ms. Galletta’s class had fourteen students, and Ms. Galletta was assisted by a co-teacher much of the time for a student-to-adult ratio of seven to one, whereas Ms. Pyper’s class has ten children in her SDC and an instructional aide, for a student-to-adult ratio of five to one. The ratio is comparable to the ratio Ms. Galletta’s classroom. In contrast, regular education classrooms for public middle school students within the District typically have thirty students. (Test. of Ms. Galletta, Dr. Koelsch, and Ms. Pickens.)

The Hearing Officer also notes that Charles Armstrong is a “specialized school,” and basically serves students with learning disabilities, some of whom have IEPs. (Test. of Dr. Whitlock and Ms. Galletta.) Notably, there was no credible evidence at hearing that STUDENT’s classroom at Charles Armstrong is directly comparable to a seventh-grade regular education classroom at Newark Junior High School, because those classrooms have 30 students, and there is no evidence that the students in those classrooms have learning disabilities or other disabilities.

The Hearing Officer applies Rachel H. criteria by analogy only to the extent that the criteria assist in an analysis of the LRE issue in this case.

(1) the educational benefits of placement in a regular education classroom

The first criterion involves consideration of the educational benefits of Student’s placement in a regular education classroom setting. Ms. Galletta testified that academic demands in seventh grade are “very stringent,” and that based upon the amount of transitions required, the number of changes, and the number of social issues that middle schoolers come up against, Ms. Galletta “just had a very hard time” seeing STUDENT being able to handle everything that a typically developing seventh-grade student has to handle, with or without an aide. Ms. Galletta also testified that STUDENT required more supports to meet his academic needs than Charles Armstrong typically provides in the classroom.

Ms. Pickens, the resource specialist who conducted academic achievement testing, testified that based upon her understanding of the academic environment at the junior high school level, STUDENT would have been “very challenged” even in a resource program, and that an SDC might have been more appropriate, although STUDENT has some strengths and learns very well “auditorially.” Regarding a regular education placement with supports, Ms. Pickens testified that regular education is “very challenged right now” because the standards movement has had an impact on what teachers expect from students. As discussed above, Ms. Pickens felt that STUDENT would have required a “great deal of support” from a resource specialist and that an SDC teacher with fewer students could have focused more on STUDENT’s needs than a resource specialist.

Although Ms. Pyper testified that in her opinion, STUDENT could have been successful in a regular education classroom with support and that she did not express that opinion at the August IEP meeting, Ms. Pyper later testified that in her opinion many students can be successful with support but that generally, at the beginning of the year, a student is supported in her SDC and [then] “they move out.” In answer to the question, “do you think STUDENT should have been given the opportunity to start out in a regular education classroom in August, was that your feeling, or in an SDC?” Ms. Pyper replied, “from the paperwork and my observations, I felt it would be appropriate that he start out in my class in an SDC.”

Ms. Wells testified that STUDENT has a “very good” chance of “making it” in a regular education classroom with proper supports (and the use of a one-to-one full-time aide (a “paraprofessional”) and the use of social stories and verbal scripting to put him in a situation where he can be “primed and rehearsed” on how to appropriately solicit the attention of others, on how to ask for help, and on how to interact with his peers -- methodologies for showing how behaviors affect others “to lay out the parameters” of expected behaviors.

Ms. Wells stated that STUDENT was functioning, cognitively, “where he needs to be,” and that he has “very good” verbal abilities and appears to be functioning academically at grade level. Ms. Wells’ testimony is contradicted by the testimony of STUDENT’s classroom teacher, Ms. Galletta, and by Ms. Pickens, who both found that STUDENT functions at the second grade level in reading and in writing, at least four grades behind his sixth grade class. Ms. Wells stated that she was unable to give a direct opinion on LRE because she would have needed to make an observation of STUDENT in a larger setting to make that kind of determination. Nevertheless, Ms. Wells felt that a small setting would have been useful for STUDENT at the beginning part of “laying down” intervention to provide more opportunities for those interventions to be rehearsed with STUDENT.

Although it is likely that STUDENT could have received some academic benefits in a regular education classroom or resource support with or without aide support, STUDENT’s then-current levels of academic functioning in reading and writing which placed him at least four grade levels behind grade level, made it unlikely that STUDENT would have received significant educational benefits within a regular education classroom or resource program, particularly given his significant social skills and behavior deficits.

(2) the non-academic benefits of placement in a regular education classroom.

This criterion involves consideration of non-academic (such as social) benefits of placement in a regular education classroom.

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found the testimony of Ms. Galletta, Dr. Cousins, and Mr. Burkholder persuasive concerning STUDENT’s significant difficulties in developing satisfactory peer relationships. STUDENT was often in conflict with and experienced difficulty understanding his peers at Charles Armstrong. Ms. Galletta testified that STUDENT had difficulties establishing peer relationships and accepting personal responsibility for his behaviors.

Dr. Cousins testified that even if STUDENT’s only deficits were in the area of social skills, she could not see STUDENT succeeding in a regular education or mainstream environment because of his immaturity – he acted as a “much younger child” – and he was defensive and had difficulties with reciprocity. Dr. Cousins also noted that while STUDENT was improving in his handling of frustrations, such as losing a game, when there was not an obvious reward at the end of playing a game and for being a good sport, Dr. Cousins wondered how STUDENT would have behaved outside of that situation and stated that STUDENT “still has that need.” Dr. Cousins also commented on STUDENT’s need for structure, believing that STUDENT “worked well” with structure and that he responded positively to consistent expectations and that having “fewer variables” sometimes helped him because he had a hard time manipulating a lot of information at one time and being able to take care of the various tasks and responsibilities expected of his age level. Dr. Cousins stated that when things are structured for STUDENT, he had a clear expectation and did a “lot better.” Significantly, STUDENT was paired with a younger child in his social skills group during the summer of 2004 because he could relate better to the younger child. (Test. of Dr. Cousins.)

The Hearing Officer finds that the extent of non-academic benefits one could have reasonably expected for STUDENT within a regular education classroom placement at Newark Junior High School was relatively insignificant, considering STUDENT’s lack of maturity and his significant difficulties establishing peer relationships with students with learning disabilities in Charles Armstrong’s smaller classroom setting. Dr. Cousins described STUDENT’s difficulties in misinterpreting communications with peers and of his feeling defensive and isolated.

The Hearing Officer notes that because STUDENT has demonstrated difficulties interacting with peers with learning disabilities at Charles Armstrong within a small classroom setting, it is reasonable to expect that STUDENT would have experienced even greater difficulties interacting with typically developing peers within a regular education classroom with thirty students. The weight of the credible evidence establishes that although STUDENT might have received some non-academic benefits (social) within a regular education classroom, STUDENT’s significant social skills deficits would have been more appropriately addressed within a small structured SDC classroom with appropriate supports for social skills development and behavior.

(3) the effect the disabled child will have on non-disabled students

This criterion considers the effect the disabled child will have on nondisabled students in a regular education classroom. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s behavior and experience in a specialized small, structured classroom at Charles Armstrong is relevant, by analogy, to how STUDENT’s behaviors would have affected nondisabled students in a larger, more unstructured regular education classroom setting.

Ms. Galletta provided credible and detailed testimony about STUDENT’s behaviors and the detrimental effect of his behaviors on his peers in the classroom. For example, Ms. Galletta testified that she had to expend a significant amount of time and energy working with STUDENT, who was at times oppositional and refused to work, and that this affected the amount of time Ms. Galletta could spend with other students in the classroom. Ms. Galletta noted that she coached STUDENT through academic activities and through “anything” involving the writing process and keyboarding, and that she encouraged STUDENT to keep going and to keep working and made sure that whatever he was presented with was not going to be overwhelming and cause him to be upset. Ms. Galletta testified that she tried to be in close proximity when STUDENT was working independently or in a group and felt that she had to be very aware of him “100 percent of the time.” When STUDENT needed to be removed from class, Ms. Galletta took him on walks to calm him down which meant that she was not in the classroom for the other students. Ms. Galletta eventually called a class meeting in the spring when STUDENT was not present, in response to complaints from students and parents about STUDENT’s behaviors and the disruptive impact of his behaviors on the classroom and on his peers. Ms. Galletta used the meeting to teach STUDENT’s peers about patience and tolerance and to provide an understanding of special education.

Dr. Whitlock also characterized STUDENT’s behaviors as frequent and disruptive of the classroom, causing great concern to the teachers who couldn’t be fully focused on the other students when they were focused on him. Dr. Whitlock also stated that Charles Armstrong had “run out of interventions” such as taking STUDENT out of the classroom when he became “really upset,” or to having him “come up to room 1,” in an office “up the hill from the classroom,” where she thought he received counseling. (Test. of Dr. Whitlock.) As discussed previously, STUDENT was not allowed to return to Charles Armstrong, an educational setting that included a small, structured classroom taught by Ms. Galletta who had several years of experience teaching students with behavioral challenges and that included, in the late spring and summer, assistance by a paraprofessional trained to provide behavioral support. Notwithstanding all of the supports at Charles Armstrong, Dr. Whitlock and Ms. Galletta concluded that STUDENT was not successful in that environment and that STUDENT’s appropriate placement was in an SDC with appropriate behavioral supports and with social skills groups. (Test. of Dr. Whitlock.)

Mr. Burkholder also credibly testified to the significant degree of STUDENT’s social and behavioral challenges and the need for a more structured classroom setting. Mr. Burkholder believed an SDC classroom was appropriate for STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s behaviors interfered with his teacher’s ability to serve her classroom and with the learning of his peers in the classroom as well as his own learning. The credible evidence establishes that STUDENT had significant behaviors and displayed significant social skills deficits at Charles Armstrong that interfered with the learning of his peers in the classroom as well as his own learning.

(4) the cost of mainstreaming

Neither party provided evidence on the cost of mainstreaming STUDENT at Newark Junior High School.

The Hearing Officer weighs the criteria discussed above, and having made findings with respect to criteria one, two, and three, the Hearing Officer finds that at the time of the District’s placement offer, the LRE was Ms. Pyper’s SDC at Newark Junior High School, with mainstreaming opportunities, supports, and accommodations as discussed previously.

The credible evidence establishes that the District’s offer of program and placement for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 regular school year as expressed within the April, May, and August 2004 IEP was an offer of FAPE for STUDENT in the LRE.

ISSUE NO. 2: If the District failed to offer STUDENTa FAPE in the LRE for the above-mentioned period, are STUDENTand his parents entitled to:

a. compensatory education services?

Compensatory education is an equitable remedy to compensate a student for lost educational opportunity when the District has failed to provide the student with appropriate special education services. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii). “Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief...designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1496, 1497 (9th Cir. 1994).

Student seeks, as a remedy for a finding that the District denied him a FAPE, compensatory education services “additional social skills training of one hour per week for one year of small group natural paradigm in a natural social setting.”

Because the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the 2004-2005 regular school year, STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education services.

b. reimbursement for privately obtained education-related services?

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, a student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA, including reimbursement for costs incurred for educational services obtained at private expense. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i).

Because the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the 2004-2005 regular school year, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the unilateral placement at New Horizons, for expenses incurred for transportation to New Horizons or Scottish Rite, or for the costs of tutoring.

The Hearing Officer also notes that Student is not entitled, in any event, to reimbursement for the costs of the IEE. A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment at public expense from qualified specialists if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the school district and the school district is unable to establish at a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); 34 C.F.R. § 300.502. Student made no showing that the assessment was procured as a result of a disagreement with any of the District’s formal assessments. Moreover, Student never provided a copy of the assessment to the IEP team and only served it on the District as part of his evidence packet. (Test. of Dr. Koelsch.)

ORDER

All of Student’s claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

In accordance with Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on each issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety calendar days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: May 10, 2005 ____________________________________ Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office