California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 14, 1999
Student v. Long Beach Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 721-99 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara
Long Beach Unified must reimburse an independent assessment, but the student is not eligible for special education as learning disabled.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 16-year-old tenth grader in Long Beach Unified's accelerated Applied Technology Magnet program at Lakewood High School filed for due process. He challenged the District's finding that he was not eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability. He also sought reimbursement for an independent evaluation and compensatory education. The District's 1998 psychoeducational assessment did not use a standardized IQ test because of a district-wide policy. Instead, the school psychologist estimated an IQ range. The District also waited about a year to hold the IEP meeting on its assessment.
The Hearing Officer held that the regulation's severe-discrepancy formula (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A)) is mandatory. A district may use other methods only when standardized tests are invalid for a particular student. Relying on independent psychologist Dr. Patterson, she found a severe discrepancy in reading comprehension caused by processing disorders. Under Norton v. Orinda, however, the student was still not eligible. He kept acceptable grades in accelerated classes, and accommodations such as note-takers, tape recorders and modified assignments were available in general education. The Hearing Officer criticized the District for letting his intervention plan lapse and for not telling teachers about it. Because the District's assessment was inadequate and delayed, she ordered it to reimburse the full cost of Dr. Patterson's assessment. Without eligibility, no compensatory education was available.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated a district-wide policy of not giving standardized IQ tests in learning disability evaluations. The Hearing Officer found the assessment inadequate, which supported reimbursement for an independent evaluation. The student was still found not eligible because general education accommodations could meet his needs.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Does the Petitioner demonstrate a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement with needs that cannot be met in general education to an extent that renders him eligible for special education as learning disabled?
The District's estimated-IQ method violated 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A), and the independent assessment showed a severe discrepancy in reading comprehension caused by processing disorders. However, the student was not eligible because general education accommodations could meet his needs (Norton second prong).
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 2. Is the Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the independent evaluation conducted by Dr. Patterson?
The District's assessment was inadequate. It obtained no standardized ability score, did not properly address processing disorders or all areas of suspected disability, and was followed by a one-year delay before the IEP meeting. The parent is entitled to reimbursement for the independent evaluation.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 3. Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory education?
Because the student is not eligible for special education, he is not entitled to FAPE or compensatory education in this forum.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for the full cost of the independent assessment by Dr. Patterson. No dollar amount is stated.
Key authorities
Norton v. Orinda Union School Dist., 168 F.3d 500 (9th Cir. 1999); Larry P. v. Riles, 495 F. Supp. 926 (1979); Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist., 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994); Moubry v. Independent School Dist. No. 696; 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j); Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56344
People named in the decision
- Marlene Daniels, program specialist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Christopher Russell, educational advocate and educational consultant (witness for Student), Advocates on Behalf of Children
- Virginia Russell, educational advocate for Student, Advocates on Behalf of Children
- Leslie Jensen, program specialist (witness for Student)
- Laurie Cohen, occupational therapist (witness for Student)
- Dr. William Patterson (also called Dr. Robert Patterson), independent psychologist, expert witness for Student
- Victor de Loza, ninth grade ATM science teacher (listed as math teacher), Long Beach Unified School District
- Christopher Murphy, ninth grade social studies/sociology teacher, Long Beach Unified School District
- Brian Joseph, tenth grade English teacher, Long Beach Unified School District
- Marlyse Linder, school psychologist, District assessor, Long Beach Unified School District
- Linda Merlo, ninth grade English teacher, Long Beach Unified School District
- Monique Arbuckle, school psychologist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Dr. Jack Shenell, educational psychologist, expert witness for District
- John Hoffman, District lead psychologist (rebuttal witness), Long Beach Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Long Beach, California, on October 7, 8, 1999, December 8, 9, 1999, February 10, 11, 2000 and March 7, 8, 2000.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by educational advocates Virginia Russell and Christopher Russell of Advocates on Behalf of Children. Also present on STUDENT's behalf was his mother, MRS. PARENT.
Respondent Long Beach Unified School District (hereinafter District or Long Beach) was represented by attorneys Jeffrey Riel and Nancy Finch-Heuerman with the law firm of Parker, Covert & Chidester. Attorney Cynthia Yount from the same law firm appeared briefly on one day of the hearing. Marlene Daniels, program specialist for Long Beach, was also present on Respondent's behalf. The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: MRS. PARENT, Petitioner's mother; Christopher Russell, educational consultant; Leslie Jensen, program specialist; Laurie Cohen, occupational therapist; and Dr. William Patterson, psychologist.
The Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: Victor de Loza, math teacher; Christopher Murphy, social studies teacher; Brian Joseph, English teacher; Marlyse Linder, school psychologist; Linda Merlo, English teacher(Footnote 1); Monique Arbuckle, school psychologist; and Dr. Jack Shenell, psychologist. John Hoffman, the District's lead psychologist, was called as a rebuttal witness.
Oral and documentary evidence was received, and oral closing arguments were presented at the conclusion of the hearing. The record was then closed and the issues were submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
The Hearing Officer ruled that a prior settlement agreement between the parties dated March 25, 1998, by its terms settled "any and all claims to date" and that, therefore, the issues in the present case would date from the date of that settlement agreement. Documents pertaining to the previously resolved claim were excluded as irrelevant to the instant case. The Hearing Officer also excluded the interim mediation agreement in this case because mediation/settlement discussions are confidential and not relevant to the due process hearing.
ISSUES
1. Does the Petitioner demonstrate a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement with needs that cannot be met in general education to an extent that renders him eligible for special education as learning disabled?
2. Is the Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the independent evaluation conducted by Dr. Patterson?
3. Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory education?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a sixteen-year-old tenth-grade student who currently attends Lakewood High School within the Long Beach School District. His mother, MRS. PARENT, became troubled about his school performance toward the end of fifth grade. STUDENT scored below average on the writing portion of the standardized test given to the District's students. Although STUDENT's grades were adequate, Ms. PARENT felt that he had difficulty with mathematical word problems. She also expressed concerns about his poor handwriting and fine motor skills. Mrs. PARENT spoke with STUDENT's fifth grade teacher, who told her that she had been providing extra writing assistance to STUDENT during recess. The teacher advised Mrs. PARENT to have STUDENT read over the summer break.
When STUDENT entered the sixth grade, Mrs. PARENT discussed his low language score with his new teacher. On the first report card, STUDENT received a grade of "F" in science. Mrs. PARENT arranged a meeting with the teacher. Thereafter, she sent a letter to the District asking that STUDENT be assessed for special education. In response to Mrs. PARENT's request, the District convened a student study team (SST) meeting, which Mrs. PARENT did not attend. The SST determined that it would provide a "screening" rather than an assessment. Mrs. PARENT was advised that the screening consisted of having STUDENT read a list of words and that he had done "just fine." STUDENT attended summer school following sixth grade. The family also provided private tutoring to assist him with his reading and comprehension skills.
During the seventh grade, STUDENT received two "D's" and one "F" grade on his report card. Mrs. PARENT stated that STUDENT was upset because he could not do the work required of him and he began making up excuses for his poor work. STUDENT improved his grades by staying after school and doing work for extra credit. This pattern continued in the eighth grade. Mrs. PARENT again requested an assessment for special education, emphasizing that she wanted actual testing, not another SST meeting.
In April 1998, the District conducted a psychoeducational assessment. The assessor concluded that STUDENT's cognitive ability was in the high average range and that he showed no processing deficits. His academic achievement in reading, math, and written expression tested within the average range. The District also provided an occupational therapy (OT) screening on May 4, 1998. The OT found that STUDENT relied on his auditory skills for learning even though his visual and conceptual skills were stronger. He expended an enormous amount of mental energy to remember what he heard, had difficulty performing meaningless sequential tasks, and had not developed the written expressive skills necessary to outline after reading or to compose notes during lectures. Significant findings by the school nurse were that STUDENT held a pencil with his thumb overlapping his first finger and that he was unable to skip. The original IEP meeting date to discuss the District's assessment was canceled because Mr. PARENT sustained injuries in an accident. It was not rescheduled until the following year.
Throughout the ninth grade, Mrs. PARENT continued to notice that STUDENT hid his work from her, avoided book reports by reporting on books he had previously read, and asked other students to describe the contents of assigned reading to him. She stated that STUDENT spent an inordinate amount of time on homework. She also found STUDENT to be emotionally distraught by the fear that he wrote like his autistic brother and that he would "be labeled as having something wrong with him." Ms. PARENT reports that as a result, he worked very hard to develop strategies to keep others from discovering his difficulties in school. Dissatisfied with the school's response to their requests for assistance, the parents obtained an independent assessment in October 1998. The assessor, Dr. Robert Patterson, concluded that STUDENT had a specific learning disability in the area of reading comprehension caused by several processing difficulties. Dr. Patterson also noted that STUDENT had difficulty listening and writing at the same time. The District continued to discern no problems in school that could not be adequately addressed through an intervention plan. Moreover, STUDENT was enrolled in an accelerated program called Applied Technology Magnet (ATM), and his class performance was commensurate with that of his peers.
The IEP meeting to review the results of the District's April 1998 psychoeducational assessment was not rescheduled until the Petitioner's advocate contacted the District in December 1998. Thus, although Mrs. PARENT tendered her written request for an assessment in January 1998, an IEP meeting to discuss the results of the evaluation was not convened until March 25, 1999. After reviewing the assessment conducted the previous year and the independent assessment obtained by the parents, the IEP team decided to defer a determination of eligibility for special education. Instead the District offered an intervention plan for nightly homework checks, appointment of a student note-taker, and access to a tape recorder during lectures.
On April 29, 1999, the parties met and drafted another intervention plan to address the parents' continuing concerns about STUDENT's academic performance. It was agreed that STUDENT would use a daily planner for homework assignments, which would to be checked nightly by his parents and weekly by the school psychologist. He was also to utilize post-it notes every few pages to summarize what he had read, pick up class notes after school from an assigned peer note-taker, and choose books of high interest for independent reading assignments in English class. The Petitioner claims that these modifications did not occur.
The IEP team reconvened on May 14, 1999, to evaluate the effectiveness of the intervention plan. Although the Petitioner disagreed, the District determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education because he did not have a specific learning disability with needs that could not be met within the general education environment. Thereafter, the Petitioner filed for a due process hearing to contest the District's denial of eligibility for special education services.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner contends that the District's assessment was inadequate and that it has erroneously denied him eligibility for special education within the category of a specific learning disability (SLD). He maintains that the independent testing conducted by Dr. William Patterson reveals that he has a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of reading comprehension. As a result of the District's failure to identify him as a child eligible for special education and to provide adequate services, the Petitioner claims that he is entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Patterson's evaluation, as well as compensatory education.
The District maintains that it conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT that accurately evaluated him in all areas of suspected disability. The District claims that its evaluation did not reveal a significant discrepancy between STUDENT's abilities and his performance. According to its assessment, STUDENT scored within the normal range in all areas and he did not meet the eligibility criteria for special education. Moreover, STUDENT is enrolled in an accelerated program and consistently maintains good grades in his classes. It is therefore the position of the District that STUDENT's needs can be met in the regular education classroom, and that he does not qualify for special education.
FINDINGS OF FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE ONEDoes the Petitioner demonstrate a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement with needs that cannot be met in general education to an extent that renders him eligible for special education as learning disabled?
A student qualifies as an individual with exceptional needs if he or she suffers from a disability and the impairment is to such a degree that it necessitates special education. California Code of Regulations (C.C.R.), Title 5 §3030. The categories of eligible disabilities are mental retardation, hearing impairments (including deafness), speech or language impairments, visual impairments (including blindness), serious emotional disturbance (SED), orthopedic impairments, autistic-like behaviors, other health impairments (OHI), or specific learning disabilities (SLD). C.C.R., Title 5 §3030 (a)(b)(c)(d)(e)(f)(g)(h)(i)(j). To be eligible for special education, the pupil's impairment must also require instruction, services, or both, which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. (California Education Code §56026(b).
This Petitioner asserts a specific learning disability. A child is eligible for special education under the category of SLD when he or she has a "disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations." 20 U.S.C. §1401(26)(A). California has a similar definition, but also requires that the student have a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in one of the seven areas enumerated above. 5 C.C.R. §3030(j). California further requires that: (1) the discrepancy must be the result of a disorder of basic psychological processing, and not the result of environment, cultural, or economic disadvantages, 5 C.C.R. §56337(b), and (2) the discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. 5 C.C.R. §56337(c). Thus, for a child to qualify for special education as a result of a severe learning disability, two elements must exist: (1) a significant discrepancy between the child's ability and achievement caused by a processing disorder, and (2) an inability by the school district to address that discrepancy in the regular education classroom. The necessity of satisfying both prongs to acquire special education eligibility was recently addressed by the Ninth Circuit in the case of Norton v. Orinda Union School District, 168 F.3d 500 (1999, 9th Cir), Cert. denied 120 S.Ct. 74 (Oct. 1999). The Hearing Officer will therefore address the dual criteria set forth by the Norton court when it held:
A learning disability, by itself, is insufficient to qualify a child for IDEA services under California's IDEA statutes and implementing regulations. A student has a ‘specific learning disability' only if he exhibits (1) a discrepancy between ability and achievement in one or more specified academic areas that is caused by a psychological processing disorder, and (2) that discrepancy cannot be corrected through ‘other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.'
1. A Significant Discrepancy Between Ability and Achievement Caused by a Processing Disorder.
In this case, Ms. PARENT requested a special education assessment because she felt that her son was spending excessive time on homework that was too difficult for him. The school psychologist, Marlyse Linder, evaluated STUDENT on behalf of the District to determine his eligibility for special education. The assessment was conducted on April 7 and 8, 1998. The IEP meeting to discuss the result of the assessment was not held until March 25, 1999, almost one year after the evaluation. Ms Linder had reviewed teachers' reports and school records. She had also utilized the following assessment procedures: Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration (VMI); Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills (TAPS); Wide Range Assessment of Learning and Memory (WRAML); Matrix Analogies Test (MAT); and Woodcock Johnson, Revised (WJ-R). Following her assessment, Ms. Linder concluded that STUDENT did not meet the eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability. She based this determination on STUDENT's grades, teacher reports of successful classroom performance, and his assessment test scores. Ms. Linder testified that STUDENT's teachers did not relate any concerns regarding his school performance. She also found no problems with STUDENT's grades when she reviewed his report cards. His grade point average in sixth grade was 2.80 and in seventh grade it was 3.20.
Ms. Linder reported that STUDENT's evaluation test scores were as follows: MAT - 92nd percentile; WJ-R - broad knowledge 45th percentile; broad written language 50th percentile; broad mathematics 82nd percentile; broad reading 48th percentile; WRAML - verbal memory 27th percentile; visual memory 79th percentile; learning index 9lst percentile; general memory 73rd percentile; VMI - 57th percentile; and TAPS - auditory quotient 31st percentile with subtests ranging from the 6th percentile on auditory sentence memory to 92nd percentile on thinking and reasoning. She testified that his MAT score, which measures nonverbal reasoning and is some indication of ability, was within the superior range. On the WJ-R, STUDENT scored within the average to high average range on all academic achievement subtests. Ms. Linder stated that she was not concerned by the range of standard scores on the subtests of the WJ-R. It was her testimony that everyone has strengths and weaknesses, and that stronger skills are used to compensate for weaker skills. The TAPS, which measures auditory perception, revealed an overall performance in the low average range with a wide range of scatter in the scores. STUDENT's TAP scores ranged from standard scores of 77 in auditory sentence memory, 82 in auditory number memory forward, 84 in auditory word memory, and 81 in auditory interpretation of direction, to 103 in auditory number memory reversed, 114 in auditory word discrimination, and 121 in thinking and reasoning. Ms. Linder testified that it was normal to have this wide range of scores on the TAP, so she was not concerned that STUDENT's low scores might indicate a processing problem. She did, however, administer the WRAML to investigate STUDENT's low scores on the TAPS. On the WRAML, which evaluates memory and learning, STUDENT scored within the average range in all areas. The VMI measures the ability to see shapes and control a pencil. STUDENT's visual motor integration was within the average range of 90 to 109, with a score of 105.
Ms. Linder testified that it is contrary to District policy to administer tests measuring intelligence quotas (I.Q.) when evaluating students for special education. She testified that rather than administering standardized I.Q. tests to its potentially disabled students, the District looks to other test results and teacher reports to estimate an I.Q. range. Consequently, she did not obtain an ability score for STUDENT utilizing a standardized ability test which was capable of being "converted into a common standard score, using a mean of 100 and standard deviation of 15" as specified in C.C.R. Title 5 § 3030(j)(4)(A) to compare against his WJ-R achievement scores that did meet this criterion. Instead, Ms. Linder gave STUDENT the MAT, which she testified measures only nonverbal reasoning ability, and is not an I.Q. test. On the MAT, STUDENT received a standard score of 121 and a percentile rank of 92. Ms. Linder explained that a standard score of 121 was in the superior range. After evaluating STUDENT's overall test scores, acquiring teacher information, and reviewing school records, she estimated his I.Q. range. Based on the information she acquired, Ms. Linder testified that STUDENT's I.Q. was between 100 and 115. Later in her testimony, Ms. Linder confirmed that her written assessment report stated that STUDENT "appears to be functioning within the high average range of cognitive ability" (emphasis in original text). She testified that the high average I.Q. range was 110 to 119. Thus, Ms. Linder established an I.Q. range for STUDENT of 100 to 119. Although she could not provide the ability and achievement test scores she compared to make her determination, Ms. Linder concluded that STUDENT did not exhibit a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement. Ms. Linder further testified that she found no processing disorders. Consequently, in her opinion, STUDENT did not have a learning disability nor did he qualify for special education in any other category.
Dr. Robert Patterson, the Petitioner's expert, testified concerning the results of his evaluation of STUDENT on October 6, 1998. When he administered the WJ-R test of Broad Cognitive Ability, STUDENT's standard I.Q. score was 100. On the WIAT he found STUDENT to be within the 14th percentile in total reading, the 63rd percentile in total math, and the 91st percentile in total writing. On the WJ-R test for auditory processing, STUDENT's scores were in the 1st percentile for Incomplete Words, and the 39th percentile for Sound Blending. The WJ-R for visual processing revealed scores in the 89th percentile for Visual Closure and the 23rd percentile for Picture Recognition. The WJ-R psychomotor and processing speed scores were at the 54th percentile in Visual Matching and at 93rd percentile in Cross Out. The WJ-R test for language functioning showed STUDENT to be in the 31st percentile in Picture Vocabulary and the 50th percentile for Oral Vocabulary. On the WJ-R test for conceptualization, STUDENT scored in the 90th percentile for Analysis-Syntheses and the 92nd percentile for Concept Formation. STUDENT's memory functioning scores as tested on the WJ-R were: Short Term Memory for Words--38th percentile, Sentences--33rd percentile Numbers Reversed--75th percentile, Long Term Memory for Names--53rd percentile; and Visual/Auditory Memory-- 66th percentile. On the Learning Efficiency Test-II (LET-II), STUDENT's immediate, short-and long-term auditory memory scores were at 37th percentile, 63rd percentile, and 75th percentile, respectively. Dr. Patterson administered the Slingerland Dyslexic Screening Test to STUDENT. He reported that this battery of tests indicated dysgraphia and auditory perception and/or memory problems. Dr. Patterson also evaluated STUDENT's social emotional functioning utilizing the Personality Inventory for Children (PIC) completed by Ms. PARENT, and the Piers-Harris Self-Concept Scale (Piers) completed by STUDENT. Ms. PARENT's answers on the PIC indicated that STUDENT was often sad, had frequent unexplained mood changes, and tended to isolate himself from his peers. He exhibited somatic symptomatology, difficulties with social competence, adjustment difficulties, depression, and withdrawal within the mild range. He was moderately anxious. On the Piers, STUDENT rated his self-concept as above average, but with a high degree of anxiety and dissatisfaction with his personal life. STUDENT stated that he dislikes his appearance and is shy, nervous, unpopular, clumsy, unhappy, and worries a lot.
Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT functions within the mid-average cognitive range with a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of reading comprehension. He supported his testimony with his own test results, which showed a standard I.Q. score of 100 and a standard achievement score of 78 on the WJ-R in the area of reading comprehension. Dr. Patterson determined that the difference between the two test scores constituted a significant discrepancy under C.C.R. Title 5 § 3030(j)(4)(A). It was Dr. Patterson's further opinion that STUDENT's learning disability was the result of several processing disorders that interacted in combination. Those processing deficiencies were evidenced in the areas of auditory closure, the memory involved with auditory closure, visual distractibility, and visual motor integration. Dr. Patterson based his opinion on the test results he obtained when he administered the Auditory and Visual Processing tests of the WJ-R. On the Incomplete Words Subtest that measures auditory closure, STUDENT's standard score was 67%, which is in the 1st percentile. On the Picture Recognition Subtest, which tests a student's ability to recall pictures previously seen, STUDENT had a standard score of 89, or in the 23rd percentile. On the Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test, STUDENT performed within the range of a ten- to eleven-year-old child, when his chronological age was fifteen years. Dr. Patterson further found that STUDENT displayed atypical disgraphia. It was his conclusion that STUDENT's difficulties impacted his reading, decoding, and comprehension skills, as well as his ability to listen and write at the same time.Because the District had not procured a standardized I.Q. score, Dr. Patterson looked to the score of 121 that STUDENT obtained on the MAT that the District administered to evaluate STUDENT's performance on the District's achievement tests. Dr. Patterson testified that the MAT is an imprecise indicator of I.Q. It is a multiple-choice test on which the student chooses the correct response from several answers provided, rather than initiate his or her own answer. In the absence of standardized ability tests, it provides some information about cognitive abilities. Dr. Patterson stated that when comparing the District's MAT score of 121 to its achievement score of 95 on the Reading Passage Comprehension portion of the WJ-R, STUDENT showed a discrepancy of 26 points between the two tests. Another point difference of 26 points existed between the MAP and STUDENT's achievement score of 95 on the Knowledge-Social Studies component of the WJ-R. When comparing STUDENT's score of 121 on the MAP and his achievement score of 89 on the WJ-R Written Language-Dictation, his discrepancy was 32 points. As an alternate method of comparison, if the mid-number of 114.5 obtained from the District's estimated I.Q. in the superior range of 111 to 119 were used as the ability score, STUDENT's discrepancy between that score and the low achievement scores noted above, would still show a point discrepancy that ranged between 19.5 and 25.5 points. In Dr. Patterson's opinion, these District assessment scores supported his conclusion that STUDENT has a specific learning disability. Dr. Patterson further bolstered his opinions with STUDENT's school records, which he testified documented STUDENT's difficulties with reading comprehension, writing, pencil grasp, and note-taking.
Dr. Jack Shenell, an educational psychologist, testified as an expert witness on behalf of the District. Dr. Shenell testified that the District's assessment was appropriate as it contained all necessary information, analyzed relevant data, and reached conclusions. He stated that the existence of a learning disability cannot be determined solely through test results. It is also important to connect test results with school performance through corroboration from teachers. In this case, Dr. Shenell noted that all of STUDENT's scores on the District-administered WJ-R achievement tests were within the average range. He found validation of the WJ-R scores in STUDENT's average scores on the Stanford test which is given to all District students, his grades of "A's," "B's," and "C's," and the absence of evidence in his records to indicate a disability.
Dr. Shenell testified that Dr. Patterson had utilized standardized tests to determine both I.Q. and achievement. However, the only below-average score STUDENT obtained during Dr. Patterson's assessment was on the WIAT Reading Comprehension Subtest on which he scored in the 7th percentile, or 3.9 grade equivalency. He assumed that this extremely low score was an aberration as it was not duplicated on any other tests in STUDENT's school records. STUDENT's grades were consistent with all of his other average test scores, not with Dr. Patterson's low score in reading comprehension. Thus, the only assessment in which STUDENT qualified for special education with a specific learning disability was that conducted by Dr. Patterson. Dr. Shenell further testified that to complete high school courses successfully, a student must be able to read and comprehend at an age-appropriate level. If STUDENT read at a 3.9 grade level, he would be having serious difficulties in all of his high school classes, which he was not. Dr. Shenell also disputed Dr. Patterson's conclusion that STUDENT's school records and his score in the 1st percentile on the WIAT Auditory Processing-Incomplete Words Subtest established auditory processing deficits. Dr. Shenell again testified that if STUDENT's auditory processing abilities were in the 1st percentile, he would not be able to acquire the information from class lectures necessary to make the grades shown on his report cards. Moreover, if STUDENT actually has the reading and auditory processing difficulties seen in Dr. Patterson's testing, he has learned to compensate and succeed in school. Therefore, he does not require special education intervention. Dr. Shenell also said that research has not established a correlation between auditory processing deficits and reading comprehension problems.
On cross-examination, Dr. Shenell did agree that Dr. Patterson's opinion of an auditory processing deficit could be supported by STUDENT's documented inability to listen and take notes. He concurred that a further basis for this finding could be found in the protocols from the District administered WJ-R. Ms. Linder had written on the WJ-R Passage Comprehension protocol that STUDENT "needs to hear what he reads . . . does not process well what he only sees, needs to draw a picture in his mind, slow down and get the main idea." On the Applied Problems protocol, Ms. Linder wrote, "inconsistent auditory processing." Additional evidence of an auditory processing problem was acknowledged by Dr. Shenell in the IEP of March 25, 1998, which stated that STUDENT "exhibits visual strengths, however, relies on auditory skills which present as a weakness." The IEP further states that STUDENT has a "relative weakness and delays have been found in the processing area of auditory closure. STUDENT has difficulty taking notes from lectures . . . as he cannot outline information out of context." Dr. Shenell also agreed that the OT report indicated auditory processing problems in the finding that STUDENT "expends enormous mental energy to remember what was said . . . he has difficulty performing sequential, unmeaningful components of a task . . . as a result, he has not developed the written expressive skills needed to outline key elements for the purpose of studying after reading material and to compose upon dictation out of context."
Dr. Shenell further testified that the concerns identified in STUDENT's intervention plan could provide support for Dr. Patterson's finding of a learning disability. He agreed that the goals contained therein could also have been written as IEP goals to be implemented in the regular education environment. When questioned regarding the District's ability to determine the existence of a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement in compliance with C.C.R. Title 5 § 3030(j)(4)(A) without a standard I.Q. score, Dr. Shenell testified that it could not be accomplished. Because the District estimated an I.Q. range, it would only be possible to compare that estimated I.Q. range to the achievement test results and arrive at an estimate of any discrepancy between the two tests. He was unable to provide the number within the estimated I.Q. range that would be chosen to compare to the achievement test results to determine a discrepancy. He acknowledged that as a result, whether or not a significant discrepancy existed could be dependent upon which number within the I.Q. range was selected for comparison to the achievement scores.
The District's lead psychologist, John Hoffman, testified on rebuttal concerning the appropriateness of the District's policy to eliminate standardized I.Q. testing. Mr. Hoffman testified that since the case of Larry P., 495 F. Supp. 926 (1979)(Footnote 2), Long Beach Unified School District no longer uses standardized I.Q. tests on any student within the District. To informally determine a student's cognitive abilities, the District assessors instead rely upon the IEP team members, school records, teacher/staff reports, grades, and class performance. When conducting a formal assessment, the examiner may add the MAT, Differential Performance Test, and/or the Knowledge portion of the WJ-R. Mr. Hoffman explained that these tests provide "a narrow focus" into some aspects of a student's cognitive abilities, but they do not establish a standardized full-scale I.Q. score. After acquiring the above-described information, the District then estimates an I.Q. range and compares that with the student's school performance and achievement tests. Mr. Hoffman agreed that the District's method for determining whether a significant discrepancy exists primarily relies upon the clinical judgement of the school psychologist. Mr. Hoffman asserted that obtaining a standard I.Q. score would violate the provision of the law that prohibits the use of a single score to determine eligibility (California Education Code §56320(e)). This contention is addressed below.
When asked to explain why the District does not use the formula for determining a significant discrepancy as set forth in C.C.R. Title 5 § 3030(j)(4)(A), Mr. Hoffman responded that that code section merely provides a "guideline." Although he agrees that this statute utilizes "shall," which is a mandatory word, he maintained that a district may choose to comply with its choice of either §3030(j)(4)(A)(B)or(C) (respectively: (A) standardized testing, (B)alternate means when standardized testing is invalid, (C) finding of significant discrepancy when standardized testing within normal). Mr. Hoffman's attention was directed to the first phrase of subsection (B), which states, "when standardized tests are considered to be invalid for a specific pupil . . . ." He was then asked if it was his position that there was not a single student within the District for whom a standardized I.Q. test would be valid. Mr. Hoffman responded that standardized I.Q. tests are of questionable value and that they are not valid for any student. Thus, it was unnecessary to make that determination for each "specific pupil" within the District. He acknowledged, however, that the District does administer standardized I.Q. tests to determine eligibility for the GATE program (gifted and talented education). Thus, he modified his prior testimony by stating that I.Q. tests are not, in fact, invalid for all students; rather, they are invalid only for potential special education students.
The Hearing Officer does not engage in a philosophical discussion regarding the validity or reliability of standardized ability tests as defined by C.C.R. Title 5 § 3030(j)(4). Instead, the Hearing Officer focuses only upon whether the method used by the District to determine whether STUDENT exhibited a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement complied with the law as set forth in C.C.R. Title 5 § 3030(j)(4). According to the testimony of its lead psychologist, the District contends that this code section is merely advisory, or, in the alternative, standardized I.Q. tests are invalid for all students who reside within the District and are evaluated for special education. The Hearing Officer does not agree with this interpretation of the law.
Courts generally find that the legislative use of the word "shall" impose a mandatory, not a discretionary duty of compliance. U.S. v. Chavez, 627 F.2d 953 (9th Cir.1980), U.S. v. Kaluna, 152 F.3d 1069 (9th Cir. 1998) and 192 F.3d 1188 (9th Cir.1999), Doggett v. U.S., 875 F.2d 684 (9th Cir. 1989). C.C.R. Title 5 § 3030(j)(4) uses the word "shall" as follows:
In determining the existence of a severe discrepancy, the individual education program team shall use the following procedures (emphasis added): (A) When standardized tests are considered to be valid for a specific pupil a severe discrepancy is demonstrated by: first converting into common standard scores . . . the achievement test score and the ability test score . . . (B) when standardized tests are considered to be invalid for a specific pupil, the discrepancy shall be measured by alternative means as specified on the assessment plan. (C) If the standardized tests do not reveal a severe discrepancy as defined in subparagraphs (A) or (B) above, the individualized education program team may find that a severe discrepancy does exist.. . .
Subsection (A) is the mandated method for determining the existence of a severe discrepancy if standardized tests are "valid for the specific pupil." Only when it has been determined that standardized tests are invalid for the individual student being assessed, can subsection (B) be utilized. (This is where the Larry P., [supra] directive would apply.) If the use of either the (A) or (B) method does not result in a discrepancy, subsection (C) authorizes the IEP team to issue a written report finding a significant discrepancy caused by a processing disorder. Thus, contrary to Mr. Hoffman's assertion, subsections (A), (B), and (C) of C.C.R. Title 5 § 3030(j)(4), are not multiple choice from which a district may choose. Instead, the subsections are sequential with subsequent subsections authorized only when the preceding subsection fails. A severe discrepancy between ability and achievement must first be determined by administering standardized tests. Only if standardized tests are not valid for the particular student, may alternate means of determining a severe discrepancy be used.
The Respondent also argues that the law specifically prohibits the use of a single test to qualify a child for special education, and using a standardized I.Q. test would violate this provision. The Hearing Officer does not agree that complying with the provisions of C.C.R. Title 5 § 3030(j)(4) would result in a student being qualified for special education solely as a result of a single test instrument. The controlling statute requires a comparison of a standardized ability test score and standardized achievement test scores, as well as a determination that any discrepancy between ability and achievement is caused by a processing disorder. This cannot be accomplished using only a single ability test score. Moreover, all other relevant material on the student must also be considered in addition to test results.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not establish whether a severe discrepancy existed between STUDENT's ability and achievement as required by C.C.R. Title 5 § 3030(j). (Footnote 3) The District did not obtain a standard ability score nor did it determine that such a score would be invalid for STUDENT. Its assessment, therefore, cannot be relied upon to determine whether STUDENT has a specific learning disability. Instead, the Hearing Officer bases her determination regarding a severe discrepancy upon the independent assessment conducted by Dr. Patterson, as well as upon the other evidence of STUDENT's academic difficulties. Dr. Patterson's report provides the requisite standard ability score that can be compared to STUDENT's standard achievement scores. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer accepts Dr. Patterson's conclusion that STUDENT has a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of reading comprehension.
2. The Discrepancy Cannot be Corrected in Regular Education
The Hearing Officer next addresses the second element required to qualify for special education with a specific learning disability, whether STUDENT's learning disability can be addressed in regular education. The Petitioner contends not only that he suffers from a specific learning disability in reading comprehension, but that his needs cannot be accommodated in regular education. Ms. PARENT testified that her concerns about STUDENT's school performance began in the fifth grade when he scored in the sixteenth percentile on the language portion of the standardized test given to all District students. She expressed her concerns to both his fifth and sixth grade teachers. Both teachers responded that STUDENT's school performance was within the normal range for his grade. Ms. PARENT testified that during the seventh, eighth, and ninth grades, STUDENT continued to have difficulties with reading and writing and had to work excessively to complete his schoolwork. He would stay after school to finish assignments, work long hours on homework, and invent excuses for poor work quality. She also expressed her belief that STUDENT had developed strategies to hide his reading difficulties. He would do such things as report on books he had previously read or ask other students to tell him the plot of assigned books. Ms. PARENT stated that her son could not take notes and listen to a lecture at the same time. According to Ms. PARENT, these academic problems caused STUDENT great emotional upset. His anxiety was exacerbated by the fact that his brother is autistic. STUDENT was very concerned that he would appear to have "something wrong with him," like his disabled sibling.
STUDENT's teachers disputed Ms. PARENT's evaluation of her son's school performance. Victor de Loza was STUDENT's ninth grade science teacher. He testified that STUDENT was enrolled as an "applied technology magnet" (ATM) student. This was a group of students with increased abilities and interests in technological fields who were enrolled in an accelerated program for math and science. The science text used by STUDENT's ATM science class was the equivalent of that used in a college freshman science class for nonscience majors. Mr. de Loza said that he taught using a combination of lectures, independent reading followed by written questions, and labs. His students were required to take notes in class, and STUDENT did so. When he called on STUDENT in class, STUDENT understood the subject matter and was able to discuss the topic. STUDENT completed and returned his homework. The tests consisted of multiple choice, math and short answers to written questions. As evidenced by the appropriate responses on his tests, STUDENT was able to read, understand and provide correct written answers regarding the subject matter. STUDENT received a grade of "A" with 91% for the first semester and a grade of "B" with 87% for the second semester. Mr. de Loza also testified that it was difficult to obtain an "A" grade in his ATM science class.
STUDENT was enrolled in Christopher Murphy's ninth grade sociology class. Mr. Murphy also testified that STUDENT was part of the ATM program and that students must satisfy and maintain increased standards to be in this program. Typically, only high school students in tenth and eleventh grade take sociology, but ninth grade ATM students are also provided with this subject. Mr. Murphy stated that he gave his ATM students substantial classwork and homework. STUDENT performed well, was a good student, did all of the work expected of him, and displayed skills commensurate with his classmates. He also testified that STUDENT's reading and writing abilities were at grade level. His students were required to take notes in class and STUDENT did so. Mr. Murphy collected the notes and they became a component of the final grade. It was Mr. Murphy's testimony that STUDENT performed well in all aspects of his class as evidenced by his test results, classroom performance, homework completion, and his resulting class grade of "B."
STUDENT's ninth grade English teacher was Linda Merlo. Ms. Merlo testified that STUDENT's skills were at grade level. The amount of work he produced was appropriate, he read aloud "beautifully," and his decoding skills were "perfect." She stated that STUDENT told her that he had difficulty understanding and remembering what he had read. Ms. Merlo suggested and implemented a strategy for STUDENT to use post-it notes on which he would summarize what he had read every two to three pages. She further suggested that he choose books that interested him for his free reading assignments. On Fridays, when the class had silent reading, she frequently provided STUDENT with one-on-one assistance. Ms. Merlo testified that although STUDENT stated that he had problems with reading comprehension, she did not observe this. He was always able to answer questions correctly about his reading assignments, he remained on task, and he exhibited an understanding of the literature being read and discussed in class. She recalled that he had some problems with his penmanship. Her students were required to take notes in class, which STUDENT did. She walked around the class and checked the content of her students' notes. During the first semester of the ninth grade, STUDENT received a final grade of "D" in her class. The final examination constituted a significant portion of the semester grade. Because STUDENT missed the final examination, a zero was factored into his grade and was the sole cause of the "D" grade. For the second semester, STUDENT's final grade was a "B."
Brian Joseph is the Petitioner's current tenth grade English teacher. Mr. Joseph testified that STUDENT's reading and writing skills were "definitely tenth-grade appropriate." All of his students are required to read aloud in class. STUDENT had read to the class several times and his reading abilities are consistent with those of his peers. He further stated that STUDENT showed good critical thinking skills and had "decent" spelling and grammar that "was definitely readable." Mr. Joseph found STUDENT's handwriting to be "a little sloppy, but not unlike other guys, and always readable." Mr. Joseph stated that STUDENT's skills were grade-appropriate. He noticed that STUDENT was quiet in class and hesitant to participate in oral discussions. However, when called upon, STUDENT was always "clearly following the discussion." STUDENT completed 100% of his in-class assignments and typically scored a "B" or a "C" on tests; however, his final grade was a borderline "D" to "C," with a score of 66.2%, because he missed one half of his homework assignments. Mr. Joseph stated that STUDENT told him that he had "put his English class on the back burner" so he could spend more time on his other courses. Mr. Joseph understood STUDENT to be saying that English was one of his easier classes so he could "float along in English." STUDENT's final grade declined further when he received a "D" on his sustained reading book report. Sustained reading requires the student to read a book(s) throughout the semester. The grade is then determined based on a combination of an oral book report and the number of pages read. Grades descend from an "A" for 650 to 800 pages read. STUDENT received a "D" for reading only 271 pages. (Footnote 4) Sustained reading and homework completion each constitute 20% of the final grade.
Mr. Joseph also testified that he had taught two periods of RSP English during the prior school year. He found STUDENT to be similar to the RSP students in those classes. He could tell that STUDENT was bright when speaking with him, yet his work product often did not reflect his apparent ability. Mr. Joseph said that he was never made aware of an intervention plan for STUDENT. When shown the intervention plan, he agreed that some of the accommodations listed would be relevant to his class. Had he known of the plan drafted for STUDENT, he would have modified STUDENT's grade requirements.
The Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT has a learning disability in the area of reading comprehension. This finding is consistent with Mrs. PARENT's testimony that STUDENT struggles with reading and spends a substantial amount of time on his school work to maintain his grades. STUDENT's problems with reading comprehension were also evident in the testimony from Ms. Merlo regarding the benefit STUDENT received from periodically summarizing reading assignments on post-it notes. Further confirmation is found in Mr. Joseph's testimony. Despite STUDENT's difficulties, with diligent effort he remains enrolled in an accelerated school program with acceptable grades. He has accomplished this even though the District failed to implement the intervention plans developed on March 25 and April 29, 1999, beyond the end of his ninth grade year in June 1999. District witnesses suggest that the intervention plans were not intended for use beyond the end of the 1998-99 school year. The Hearing Officer finds this contention specious and accepts Mrs. PARENT's testimony that STUDENT must work excessively to attain his grades. It is not plausible that STUDENT's need for a note-taker, post-it note summaries, homework monitoring, and a tape recorder would cease within two months of their conception.
Notwithstanding STUDENT's need for classroom modifications, he has managed to maintain the grades necessary to remain enrolled in an accelerated program. This leads the Hearing Officer to the conclusion that STUDENT's needs can be met through services available in the general education classroom. Appropriate modifications such as a tape recorder, reduced reading assignments, and modified class and homework demands are available through regular education. Implementing the types of accommodations previously written into STUDENT's intervention plan will allow him to sustain his academic progress without placing unreasonable demands on him. As a result, the Petitioner fails to satisfy the second prong of the severe leaning disability eligibility requirement because his disability can be accommodated in the regular education program.The Hearing Officer is concerned by the District's conduct in this matter. It blatantly disregarded its obligation to convene a timely IEP meeting following its evaluation, by waiting a year to hold a meeting to discuss the results of its assessment. It is the District's obligation, not the parent's, to ensure that such a meeting is scheduled. (California Education Code §56344.) Once it was determined that STUDENT required an intervention plan, the District failed to ensure its application. Additionally, the District unilaterally determined that the mandatory language of C.C.R. Title 5 § 3030(j)(4)(A), requiring a comparison between standardized ability and achievement scores unless such tests were determined to be invalid for a specific pupil, could be disregarded by claiming that all I.Q. tests are invalid for every potential special education student within its boundaries.
The consequence for the District's actions, however, is not to find that STUDENT is a special education student when he does not require that designation. Ms. PARENT emphasized the emotional distress STUDENT exhibits as a result of his fear that he will be viewed as a disabled student, like his autistic brother. Her credible testimony highlighted the impact an unnecessary special education identification would have on STUDENT's emotional well-being. The Hearing Officer, therefore, concludes that it would not be beneficial to STUDENT to find that the remedy for the District's conduct is a determination that STUDENT requires services outside the general education program. STUDENT is capable of being a full participant in the regular school environment with his typical peers. With the development of an appropriate, rigidly enforced intervention plan, STUDENT can continue his outstanding academic performance while eliminating much of the pressure he places upon himself as he struggles to complete school work without an acknowledgment of his need for modifications. At the same time, he will gain the needed reassurance that he is as capable as his peers, and that there is nothing "wrong with him."
ISSUE TWO
Is the Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the independent evaluation conducted by Dr. Patterson?
California Education Code §56329(b) provides,
A parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists . . . if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, the public education agency may initiate a due process hearing . . . to show that its assessment is appropriate. If the final decision resulting from the due process hearing is that the assessment is appropriate, the parent still has the right for an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense.
For a district's assessment to be appropriate, it must satisfy the following requirements: (1) it must be conducted by a qualified person who possesses the requisite state and federal certifications in the area in which they are assessing; (2) the testing materials cannot be racially, culturally or sexually biased; (3) the tests must be provided in the student's primary language or method of communication; (4) the test given must be validated for the specific purpose for which it is being used; (5) the assessor must be trained and administer the test in conformance with the test's instructions; (6) intellectual or psychological tests must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist; (7) the pupil must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability; and (8) the assessor must be knowledgeable of the student's disability. California Education Code §36320(e). At the conclusion of the evaluation, the assessor must provide a written report containing the results of the assessment. California Education Code §56327.
In this case, the District's psychoeducational assessment did not comply with the requirements of C.C.R. Title 5 § 3030(j)(4)(A). The District did not obtain an I.Q. or achievement test score for STUDENT that could be converted "into common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and standard deviation of 15." In fact, the District did not obtain an actual achievement score at all. Rather, it assigned an estimated I.Q. range to STUDENT based upon anecdotal information and scores he achieved on various tests administered during his psychoeducational assessment.
The purpose of the District's evaluation was to determine whether STUDENT was eligible for special education as a result of a specific learning disability. To qualify with a SLD, a student must first have a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement resulting from a processing disorder. Unless it would be invalid for the particular child, a student is entitled to a determination of a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement pursuant to the same objective formula available to all California students similarly situated. In this case, the District did not obtain the ability score mandated by California law. Consequently, the existence or nonexistence of a significant discrepancy could not be accurately established through the District's assessment. The District's assessment also provided suspect conclusions regarding the absence of a processing disorder. The final report did not reflect the evaluator's observations of STUDENT's processing difficulties as noted on the test protocols, nor did it relate these observations to the findings of the OT. The Hearing Officer therefore determines that the District's assessment was inadequate. It did not properly assess in all areas of suspected disability, and it could not be used for its intended purpose. Furthermore, the District delayed a year between conducting the assessment and convening an IEP to discuss the results of its assessment. This procedural violation alone justifies the Petitioner's decision to obtain an independent assessment. The passage of a year also raises doubts about the current validity of the District's evaluation. For these reasons, the Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the independent evaluation he obtained from Dr. Patterson.
ISSUE THREE
Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory education?
Under both federal and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1401. If it is determined that a school district failed to provide a disabled student with a FAPE, compensatory education designed to compensate that student for lost educational opportunity may be awarded. 20 U.S.C. §1415(i)(2)(B)(iii); Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F. Supp. 867 (8th Cir.1996); Student W. V. Puyallup, 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir.1994). However, a child must qualify for special education services before he is entitled to a FAPE and a resulting compensatory education remedy when a FAPE is not provided. Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachucetts, 471 U.S. 360 (1985); 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(10)(C)(i). Because STUDENT is not eligible for special education, he is not entitled to compensatory education in this forum.
CONCLUSION
STUDENT's needs can be met through services offered within the general education program. Thus, he does not meet the second legal prong required to establish eligibility for special education as SLD. This, however, does not mean that STUDENT requires no assistance in his classes. The Hearing Officer has found that he has a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of reading comprehension. The District has acknowledged that STUDENT is in need of an intervention plan, and it has created one. It did not, however, continue to implement this plan, nor did it inform STUDENT's teachers of his required accommodations. It must do so. If it does not, it is highly probable that STUDENT will fall behind his peers and require future special education services to meet his needs.
ORDER
1. Within 30 days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for the full cost of the independent assessment conducted by Dr. Patterson.
2. All Petitioner's other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on the issues of eligibility and compensatory education. The Petitioner prevailed on the issue of reimbursement for the independent assessment.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Education Code §56505(i).)
Dated:_________________________ _________________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
1. Both parties listed as witnesses the school personnel named above. To avoid two appearances by each witness, the parties agreed to conduct both their direct and cross-examination during a single appearance by the witnesses.
2. The Larry P. case prohibits the use of I.Q. tests, which may be culturally biased, when determining placement for black students in special education programs.
3. The District cites two SEHO decisions finding that the District's eclectic estimate of a student's ability adequately complies with C.C.R. Title 5 § 3030(j)(4)(A). This Hearing Officer arrives at a contrary conclusion. Pursuant to California Code of Regulations, Title 5 §3085 SEHO decisions do not establish binding precedent.
4. Mrs. PARENT maintains that each year STUDENT uses the same book for any required book report. This book is the "Wind and the Willows" which has 271 pages. Mr. Joseph testified that STUDENT chose the "Wind and the Willows" for his book report.
