California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 11, 2000

Saddleback Valley Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 723-99 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda

Saddleback Valley Unified's preschool speech assessment was inappropriate; district must reimburse parents $180 for independent evaluation.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Saddleback Valley Unified School District filed for hearing to defend the speech and language part of its May 1997 initial preschool assessment. The student, who has Down Syndrome, was assessed shortly before his third birthday. School psychologist Mary Dean and speech-language pathologist Mary Lauder conducted the assessment. In November 1998 the parents obtained an independent speech and language evaluation from Sharon Fiocca, and they asked the district to repay its $180 cost.

The Hearing Officer found that Ms. Lauder was qualified and that the tests were given according to their instructions. Leaving one graph on a test form blank was a minor error. The district argued that a hearing officer may review only whether an assessment met procedural requirements. The Hearing Officer rejected that argument. He held that state and federal law require a substantive review of whether the assessment gathered enough relevant information to help the IEP team. The district's report only noted three oral motor behaviors: drooling, an open-mouth posture, and no rotation of food while chewing. It did not actually assess the student's oral motor needs. A comprehensive oral motor exam was not required, but the assessment had to give the IEP team enough information to set placement, services, and goals. Because it failed to assess all areas of suspected disability, it was inappropriate. The Hearing Officer also rejected the district's claim that the parents disagreed only with placement. He ordered the district to reimburse the $180 within 10 days.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO treated a district's defense of its own assessment. It rejected the claim that only procedural compliance matters. The Hearing Officer asked whether the assessment gave the IEP team enough information to plan services. An assessment that merely noted oral motor symptoms without evaluating them did not meet that standard.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Did the District conduct an appropriate speech and language assessment of STUDENT?

    The assessor was qualified and the tests were properly given, but the assessment only noted three oral motor behaviors and did not assess oral motor needs in enough depth to help the IEP team, so it was inappropriate.

  2. Issue 2. Should the District reimburse STUDENT's parents the sum of $180.00, the cost of a November 1998 speech and language evaluation conducted by Sharon Fiocca?

    Because the District's assessment was inappropriate and the parents' June 1997 letter showed they disagreed with the assessment, not just the placement, the parents are entitled to $180 reimbursement under Education Code section 56329(b).

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. District to reimburse parents $180.00 for the November 1998 independent speech and language evaluation by Sharon Fiocca, within 10 days.

Total: $180 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Cal. Educ. Code § 56320; Cal. Educ. Code § 56322; Cal. Educ. Code § 56324; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(2)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.352

People named in the decision

  • Rona Martin, Special education director, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • James Blinn, Coordinator of special education; District witness, South Orange County SELPA
  • Mary Dean (formerly Parks), School psychologist; assessor, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Mary Lauder, Speech-language pathologist; assessor, Saddleback Valley Unified School District
  • Sharon Fiocca, Independent speech-language pathologist; witness for Student, Private practice
  • Dr. Supance, Physician who performed prior hearing examination
  • Dr. Weiss, Physician who performed prior vision examination
  • Intervention Center for Early Childhood (ICEC), Early intervention program that conducted a prior assessment
  • Regional Center of Orange County, Regional center that referred student for preschool assessment
  • Matthew Nelson, Attorney present for District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Saddleback, California, on August 3 and 4, 1999 and September 8, 1999. The parties also participated in a telephone conference on October 4, 1999.

Petitioner Saddleback Valley Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney A. Patrick Muñoz. Also present on the District's behalf were Rona Martin, special education director for the District; James Blinn, coordinator of special education for the South Orange County Special Education Local Plan Area; and attorney Matthew Nelson. Respondent STUDENT was represented by attorneys Leejanice Toback and Joan K. Honeycutt. (Footnote 1) Also present on STUDENT's behalf were his parents, MR. and MRS. PARENT.

The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: FATHER, school psychologist Mary Dean, speech and language pathologist Mary Lauder, and James Blinn. Respondent called the following witness to testify: speech and language pathologist Sharon Fiocca.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

The District Exhibit Nos. 8, 11 and 13, and the Handwritten Notes of Sharon Fiocca

During a telephone conference held on October 4, 1999, the attorneys representing the District and the Respondent agreed to discuss and attempt to reach an agreement with regard to the admission of several of the District's exhibits which were not admitted at the hearing, and to relay the result of their discussions to the Hearing Officer. The parties subsequently informed the Hearing Officer that Respondent did not object to District Exhibit Nos. 1-7, 9, 10, 12 and 14-19. The Hearing Officer hereby admits those documents into evidence. Respondent did object, however, to the admission of District Exhibit Nos. 8, 11 and 13 by letter dated October 29, 1999. The District responded to Respondent's objections by letter dated November 4, 1999.

With regard to District Exhibit Nos. 8 and 13, the Hearing Officer finds that they are irrelevant with regard to the narrow issues presented by this hearing, whether the District's speech and language assessment was appropriate, and whether the Respondent should be reimbursed for the $180.00 assessment he obtained. Therefore, the Hearing Officer sustains Respondent's objection to those exhibits. District's Exhibit Nos. 8 and 13 are not admitted. With regard to District's Exhibit No. 11, Respondent's objection is sustained on the grounds that the identical document has already been admitted into evidence as Respondent's Exhibit No. 113.

Finally, the parties were ordered to send the Hearing Officer a copy of a ten-page document containing handwritten notes of witness Sharon Fiocca. That document was admitted into evidence by the Hearing Officer on September 8, 1999, but was not assigned an exhibit number. (Footnote 2) The Hearing Officer hereby identifies Ms. Fiocca's notes, pages 1-10, as District's Exhibit No. 20.

The Respondent's Motion to Strike the District's Closing Brief

Respondent requested by letter dated November 3, 1999, that the District's closing brief be stricken because it was not served in a timely manner on the Respondent. The Hearing Officer had ordered the parties to mail their closing briefs no later than October 29, 1999. The District responded to Respondent's motion by letter dated November 8, 1999, and explained that, although the Hearing Officer's copy was mailed on October 29, 1999, the District inadvertently failed to forward a copy to Ms. Toback. The District discovered its omission on November 1, 1999, and immediately forwarded Ms. Toback a copy. The Hearing Officer finds that the District's failure to serve Respondent with its closing brief in a timely fashion was inadvertent and did not prejudice Respondent. As such, the Motion to Strike the District's closing brief is denied. (Footnote 3)

ISSUE(Footnote 4)

1. Did the District conduct an appropriate speech and language assessment of STUDENT?

2. Should the District reimburse STUDENT's parents the sum of $180.00, the cost of a November 1998 speech and language evaluation conducted by Sharon Fiocca?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT was born on [date redacted]. He has been diagnosed with Down Syndrome. Shortly before his third birthday, STUDENT was referred to the Saddleback Valley Unified School District for a preschool assessment by the Regional Center of Orange County. The assessment was completed on May 16, 1997, a month and ten days before Respondent's third birthday. District school psychologist Mary Dean (Footnote 5) and speech therapist Mary Lauder evaluated STUDENT on May 15, 1997, and prepared a report of their findings. In addition to the area of speech and language, Ms. Lauder and Ms. Dean assessed STUDENT's cognitive skills, fine motor skills, gross motor skills, preacademic skills, self help/adaptive skills, and social/emotional skills. (Footnote 6) District's Exhibit No. 1.

Mary Dean administered the Bayley Scales of Infant Development-II, as well as the Child Development Inventory. District's Exhibit No. 1; Testimony of Dean. Mary Lauder administered the Preschool Language Scale (PLS-3). District's Exhibit No. 1; Testimony of Mary Lauder.

The assessment report indicates that, in addition to testing, Mary Lauder and Mary Dean also considered STUDENT's history and other examinations. Specifically, they considered (1) Respondent's medical history, including his open-heart surgery; (2) Respondent's previous hearing and vision examinations performed by Dr. Supance and Dr. Weiss, respectively; (3) Respondent's family and care-giving dynamics; and (4) Respondent's experience and previous therapy, focusing particularly on a previous assessment conducted by the Intervention Center for Early Childhood (ICEC). District's Exhibit No. 1.

The assessment report concludes, in pertinent part :

STUDENT is a soon to be three year old boy with a diagnosis of Down Syndrome. Current evaluation suggests overall functioning around the 16 to 18 month level suggesting a moderate developmental delay . . . . Assessment findings will be shared with the Individual Education Program Team. Actual program placement recommendations shall be made at that time. District's Exhibit No. 1.

On October 29, 1998, STUDENT's parents advised the District of their intention to obtain an independent speech and language evaluation at District's expense. Respondent's Exhibit 115.

STUDENT's parents obtained an independent assessment in November 1998. Sharon P. Fiocca, a speech pathologist, assessed STUDENT and prepared a report of her findings. Respondent's Exhibit No. 116. In November 1998, Sharon Fiocca's report was furnished to the District, accompanied by a bill for the sum of $180.00. Testimony of FATHER.

On December 3, 1998, STUDENT's parents sent a letter to Rona Martin, the District's director of special education, requesting reimbursement for Ms. Fiocca's evaluation. Respondent's Exhibit No. 124. On December 14, 1998, an IEP meeting was held. The IEP notes, in pertinent part, that STUDENT's parents "are requesting reimbursement for independent evaluation by Sharon Fiocca" and that the "District believes its evaluation is appropriate." Respondent's Exhibit No. 126.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District conduct an appropriate speech and language assessment of STUDENT?

For the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320. That section provides, in pertinent part, that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student's primary language or other mode of communication; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Assessment and testing materials also must not measure the student's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless that is what the test purports to measure.

Subsection 56320(e) states that no single procedure shall be used as the "sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for and individual with exceptional needs." Subsection 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. Pursuant to subsection (g), the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician. These assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Cal. Educ. Code § 56324(a) and (b). Section 56322 additionally states that assessments "shall be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area."

In the present case, the parties are generally in agreement that the testing and assessment materials and procedures used were not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory, were provided and administered in STUDENT's primary language or other mode of communication, and were validated for the specific purpose for which they were used. There is also no issue with regard to whether the assessment and testing materials used by Mary Lauder and Mary Dean measured STUDENT's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills. Moreover, the District used several tests and procedures to evaluate STUDENT's speech and language deficits.

The parties dispute the following with regard to the District's speech and language evaluation: (1) whether the testing was administered by trained and knowledgeable personnel; (2) whether the tests were administered in accordance with test instructions; and, (3) whether STUDENT was assessed in all areas of suspected disability. (Footnote 7) Each will be addressed below.

Administered by Trained and Knowledgeable Personnel

The Respondent argues that Mary Lauder, the District's speech and language pathologist who assessed STUDENT, was not trained and knowledgeable in the area of STUDENT's disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(g). Based on the weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Lauder is trained and knowledgeable in the area of STUDENT's disability. Ms. Lauder is a credentialed speech pathologist, with over twenty years of experience. (Footnote 8) She has a bachelor's degree in clinical rehabilitative services, and over 75 post graduate credits in the area of communicative disorders. Ms. Lauder has performed over 550 speech and language assessments. Testimony of Lauder. She has also received ongoing training from the District and outside the District, including training in the area of conducting oral motor assessments and remediation. (Footnote 9) Testimony of Blinn; Testimony of Lauder.

Administered in Accordance with Test Instructions

The District's used three tests to assess STUDENT: the Bayley Scales of Infant Development - II, the Child Development Inventory (CDI) and the Preschool Language Scales-3 (PLS-3). Ms. Lauder also used the Birth to Three Checklist, but only as a "scratch sheet" for her own observations (she completed a small portion of this test). Testimony of Lauder. Respondent argues, in pertinent part, that the Birth to Three Checklist was not administered properly and that Ms. Lauder failed to complete the graph of the standard scores on the first page of the PLS-3. Respondent's Exhibit Nos. 103 and 106. With regard to the Birth to Three Checklist, because the test was used only as a scratch sheet and was not administered to STUDENT (and referenced only in passing in the body of the District's report), the test is irrelevant for purposes of determining whether the District's speech and language assessment was appropriate. With regard to the PLS-3, Ms. Lauder's failure to graph the standard scores on the first page of the PLS-3 is a de minimis violation of that test's protocols, especially in light of the fact that the standard scores are written elsewhere on the same page as the incomplete graph. The Hearing Officer finds, based on the weight of the evidence, that the District administered all tests in accordance with the test instructions.

Assessed in All Areas of Suspected Disability

The parent's primary concern is related to whether the District assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. Specifically, the parents assert that the District's speech and language assessment and the resulting report fail to explore in sufficient depth and detail STUDENT's oral motor deficiencies. In contrast, the independent assessment and report completed by Sharon Fiocca in November 1998 provides significant detail about STUDENT's oral motor deficiencies, and develops proposed goals, in addition to assessing other speech and language concerns.

The District's position at the hearing and in its closing brief was that a determination on the merits of whether its assessment was appropriate must only consider if the District's assessment complied with all "procedural" requirements of the California Education code and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). (Footnote 10) It argues that "the purpose of an assessment is to make a determination of eligibility for special education, and to determine what areas of educational need exist (without any regard to why they exist) -- a procedural function -- in order to allow the IEP team to determine what services will be provided to address such educational needs -- a substantive function." District's closing brief, p. 11:22-26. In essence, the District argues that the Hearing Officer may not make any substantive or qualitative determinations about the content of the District's speech and language assessment; if the "procedural" requirements are met, the inquiry ends there. In the present case, the District argues that because STUDENT's oral motor skills were addressed in the District's assessment, regardless of the depth of the analysis, the procedural requirement that the District assess in all areas of suspected disability in the area of speech and language has been met, and the assessment is appropriate.

Both the California Education Code and the IDEA, require a hearing officer to make substantive determinations with regard to a District's assessment in order to determine if it was appropriate. California Education Code § 56320(g) states that "special attention shall be given to the unique educational needs, including, but not limited to, skills and the need for specialized services, materials, and equipment consistent with guidelines established pursuant to Section 56136." A hearing officer's determination with respect to whether "special attention" was given to a child's unique educational needs is a substantive one. Moreover, the IDEA states that, when conducting an evaluation(Footnote 11), a district must "use a variety of assessment tools and strategies to gather relevant functional and developmental information . . . that may assist in determining whether a child is a child with a disability and the content for the child's individualized education program, including information related to enabling the child to progress in the general curriculum, or for preschool children, to participate in appropriate activities; . . ." 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(2)(A). Likewise, a hearing officer's determination of whether an assessment gathered relevant information that may assist in determining the content of a child's IEP is substantive in nature. See also, 34 C.F.R. 300.352.

In the alternative, the District argues that its assessment was substantively appropriate, specifically with regard to STUDENT's oral motor issues. As developed above, the District's assessment was substantively appropriate if it gathered sufficient relevant information to assist the IEP team in determining the content of STUDENT's IEP. The District's assessment report states, in pertinent part:

1. Speech and Language

STUDENT presented as a cute, social boy. Although somewhat distractible, he responded positively to attempts at redirection. Fish crackers were used successfully as a reinforcement. He chewed them on the right side of his mouth. No rotation of the bolus was observed. STUDENT maintained an open mouth posture much of the time and drooling was observed.

. . . .

Regarding assessment of STUDENT's oral motor issues, Ms. Lauder explained that the oral motor portion of the assessment is "incorporated" into the speech and language section. Specifically, her observations that she saw no rotation of the bolus, an open mouth posture and drooling, sufficiently identify STUDENT's oral motor issues. She testified that it was not necessary to do a comprehensive oral motor examination as part of STUDENT's initial assessment, which would include a visual examination of the palette, dentician, lips, oral movement, etc. The initial assessment, Ms. Lauder explained, need only determine eligibility and areas of need. Testimony of Lauder. A comprehensive oral motor assessment "would come later" as part of an ongoing assessment; only if oral motor problems constituted the only area of suspected disability would a child receive a comprehensive oral motor examination as part of an initial evaluation. Testimony of Lauder. Ms. Lauder further explained that as part of the initial evaluation, her role as an assessor was merely to identify that STUDENT had oral motor issues, and that the IEP team's role is to develop appropriate goals and objectives and to determine appropriate related services to address his oral motor issues. (Footnote 12) Testimony of Lauder.

Sharon Fiocca conducted the independent evaluation of STUDENT. Ms. Fiocca, a licensed speech pathologist, has almost twenty years of experience in speech and language therapy and assessments. She has a master's degree in communicative disorders, is a member of ASHA, and has a Certificate of Clinical Competence. She has taken multiple courses in myofunctional therapy and oral motor training. Ms. Fiocca testified that the District's assessment addresses all of STUDENT's speech and language issues "briefly, but not in depth." District's Exhibit No. 20. She explained that the assessors "made observations" but did not evaluate STUDENT's oral motor issues. In contrast, her assessment, in addition to considering other speech and language areas, developed STUDENT's oral motor issues in considerable depth. She observed STUDENT's oral structure and function and attempted to determine range of movement. Ms. Fiocca also observed STUDENT's cheeks, lips and developed "possible" oral motor goals. Testimony of Fiocca; Respondent's Exhibit No. 116.

The Hearing Officer finds, based on the weight of the evidence, that the District's assessment failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, specifically in the area of speech and language. Ms. Lauder's assessment did not "assess" STUDENT's oral motor needs, it only identified three behaviors related to oral motor problems. Moreover, her assessment contains no meaningful discussion or depth with regard to these three behaviors. While the District was not required to conduct a "comprehensive" oral motor examination as a part of STUDENT's initial examination, it should have, at the very least, provided enough information to assist the IEP team in determining the content of STUDENT's IEP, including an appropriate placement, related services, and proper goals and objectives. (Footnote 13) 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(2)(A).

The Hearing Officer finds that, because the District failed to assess in all areas of suspected disability, its assessment of STUDENT was inappropriate.

ISSUE NO. 2: Should the District reimburse STUDENT's parents the sum of $180.00, the cost of a November 1998 speech and language evaluation conducted by Sharon Fiocca?

As developed above, the speech and language portion of the District's initial assessment was inappropriate. As such, STUDENT's parents are entitled to reimbursement for the independent speech and language assessment they obtained from Sharon Fiocca. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). The District, however, argues that the parents are not entitled to reimbursement because they did not "disagree" with the District's speech and language assessment. It argues that the parents actually disagreed with the proposed placement, not the assessment. STUDENT's parents wrote a letter dated June 23, 1997 (Petitioner's Exhibit No. 4), which states, in pertinent part:

We disagree with the district recommendations that our son does not need individual speech therapy and a monthly occupational review. We feel that both of your evaluations are inadequate and do not concur with the recent assessments from his present program (ICEC). The school district results are at odds with the ICEC, so we seek clarification of testing results.

The Hearing Officer rejects the District's argument. The letter clearly explains that STUDENT's parents were in disagreement with the District about the District's proposed placement and the assessment. (Footnote 14)

ORDER

Within 10 days, Petitioner shall reimburse STUDENT's parents the sum of $180.00.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(j).

DATED: February 11, 2000 ____________________________________ Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Ms. Honeycutt and Mr. Nelson were present on the final day of the hearing only. 2. This document was received by the hearing office on October 11, 1999.

3. The Hearing Office received the District's closing brief on November 1, 1999. The envelope indicates that it was mailed on October 29, 1999.

4. The issues listed here differ slightly in content and number from the issue noticed by the District before the hearing. Changes were made for the purposes of clarification.

5. Ms. Dean has recently changed her name from Parks to Dean. To avoid confusion, she will be referred to by her current name only, Mary Dean.

6. Only the speech and language assessment is at issue.

7. Numerous arguments were made by the parties both at the hearing and in their respective closing briefs with regard to the District's speech and language evaluation. The Hearing Officer, however, will address only those arguments necessary to resolve this case.

8. Respondent argued that Ms. Lauder was not qualified to assess STUDENT because she is not a member of the American Speech and Hearing Association (ASHA) and does not have her Certificate of Clinical Competence. Respondent provided no authority for this proposition.

9. Mr. Blinn testified that Lauder has attended two eight-hour training sessions in the area of oral motor assessments and remediation in the last three years, one in March 1997, and another provided by the SELPA in February of 1998.

10. The District states in its closing brief that "the inquiry into whether an assessment was appropriate is purely procedural in that if the assessment complied with all of the procedural provisions of the Education Code and IDEA, the assessment is appropriate, end of inquiry." District's Closing Brief, p. 8:20-22.