California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 18, 2003

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 728-03 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino

Los Angeles Unified must provide a trained full-time aide supervised by an agency case manager; full-time behavior specialist request denied.

Student prevailed in part

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A mother, representing her daughter herself, filed against Los Angeles Unified School District. The student is eligible for special education under autism. In kindergarten at Manchester Avenue Elementary School, she had a full-time district aide (a temporary support assistant, or TSA). She also had a behavior intervention specialist (BIS) from a nonpublic agency, and the two usually worked with her at the same time. After the district cut BIS hours in spring 2003, the mother kept her home. At hearing, the district offered a full-time TSA plus three hours of BIS each day. The mother dropped her claims for the rest of 2002-2003 and the summer. One issue remained: whether first grade in 2003-2004 required full-time BIS services.

The Hearing Officer found the student needed one full-time, properly trained one-to-one aide who works with the teacher to carry out her behavior support plan. Two aides at once cut her off from her teacher and classmates, so the district's offer was not appropriate. The district gave its TSAs little or no training. The student's TSA said the mother had taught her. Full-time BIS services were not the answer either, because in kindergarten the BIS never helped the teacher or TSA understand their roles under the plan. The district must hold an IEP meeting within 15 days and provide a full-time aide. It must also hire a nonpublic agency case manager with a master's or doctorate degree to supervise, train, and consult.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO looked past job titles to an aide's training and supervision. The Hearing Officer rejected both parties' proposals and designed a different arrangement. It also found that two aides working with a mainstreamed student at once can isolate her from her teacher and peers, which made a stacked-aide offer inappropriate.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. In order to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT's behavior-related unique needs for the 2003-2004 school year, must the District offer full-time behavior intervention specialist (BIS) services?

    The District's offer of a full-time TSA plus three hours of daily BIS services was inappropriate because two simultaneous aides isolated the student, but full-time BIS services were not required either; the student needs one full-time, properly trained one-to-one aide supervised by a qualified nonpublic agency case manager.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, and as necessary afterward, convene an IEP meeting to amend the IEP and set up the services ordered.
  • Order to provide or change services. Amend the IEP to provide a full-time one-to-one aide to address the student's behavior-related needs.
  • District must contract with a properly certified nonpublic agency for a qualified case manager to supervise the aide, oversee implementation of the behavior support plan (including collaboration), and consult with the classroom teacher, aide, and others responsible for the plan. The case manager and any designees must hold a master's or doctorate degree applicable to behavior support for students with autism.
  • Staff training. The case manager must give the aide in-service training on how the student's autism affects her behaviors and how to implement appropriate interventions. The aide must receive preparatory training before the 2003-2004 school year starts. The IEP team will set the details of that training and how often in-service training and consultation occur.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Peter Sansom, District counsel, Lozano Smith
  • Dean Adams, Attorney observer, Lozano Smith
  • Agatha Metichecchia, District due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Susan Glickman, District coordinating specialist for due process, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Susan Talesnick, District due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Victoria Windler, Certified Spanish/English interpreter
  • Graceilla Hines, Certified Spanish/English interpreter
  • Gabriella Ruvalcaba, Regional center counselor and program coordinator; witness for Student, Westside Regional Center
  • Rosa Cruz, In-home support service provider; witness for Student
  • Annette Ishisaka, Former behavior intervention specialist (2001-2002); San Fernando Valley Mental Health facilitator; witness for Student, Turning Point (nonpublic agency)
  • Ira Long, Resource specialist teacher; witness for District, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Maria Soto, Temporary support assistant (one-to-one aide); witness for District, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Barbara Washington, General education kindergarten teacher; witness for District, Manchester Avenue Elementary School
  • Susan Mora, School psychologist and assessor; witness for District, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Dr. Janet Friedman, Clinic director, behavior intervention nonpublic agency, Intensive Behavior Intervention Consultants (IBIC)
  • Turning Point, Nonpublic agency providing BIS services in 2001-2002
  • Intensive Behavior Intervention Consultants (IBIC), Nonpublic agency providing BIS services in 2002-2003
  • Westside Regional Center, Regional center

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on May 27, 28, 30, and June 3 and 4, 2003, in Los Angeles, California, by Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.(FOOTNOTE 1)

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by her mother, MOTHER. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was her father, FATHER. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorney Peter Sansom from the law office of Lozano Smith. Also present on behalf of the District at various times during the hearing were Agatha Metichecchia, District due process specialist; Susan Glickman, District coordinating specialist for due process; and Susan Talesnick, District due process specialist. Victoria Windler and Graceilla Hines were present as certified Spanish/English interpreters(FOOTNOTE 2).

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: MOTHER; Gabriella Ruvalcaba, Westside Regional Center (WRC) counselor and program coordinator; Rosa Cruz, in-home support service provider; Annette Ishisaka, San Fernando Valley Mental Health facilitator and former behavior intervention specialist (BIS) for a nonpublic agency (NPA); and FATHER. The District called the following witnesses: Ira Long, District resource specialist (RSP) teacher; Maria Soto, District temporary support assistant (TSA); Barbara Washington, District general education teacher; and Susan Mora, District school psychologist.(FOOTNOTE 3)

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Written closing briefs were received on June 26 and 27, 2003, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUE PRESENTED FOR RESOLUTION

In order to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related unique needs for the 2003-2004 school year, must the District offer full-time behavior intervention specialist (BIS) services?(FOOTNOTE 4)

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, born [date redacted], is eligible for special education and related services as a child with autism. Pursuant to her initial individualized education program (IEP) dated April 5, 2001, STUDENT commenced receiving District special education services to address her deficits in speech and language, school readiness, fine-motor, behavior, self-help, and social/emotional skills.

STUDENT attended a District general education kindergarten class at Manchester Avenue Elementary School (Manchester) during the 2002-2003 school year. STUDENT’s IEP during kindergarten included a behavior-support plan to address her behavior-related needs. The behavior plan states that STUDENT would become frustrated when she did not “have her own way.” Her frustration often resulted in temper tantrums and STUDENT’s refusal to perform her classroom work. She needed adult assistance to regain calmness and attend to task. She also had impulsive behaviors that were inappropriate and could pose a danger to herself or others.

To implement the behavior-support plan, one-to-one aides were assigned to STUDENT. The IEP provided for full-time one-to-one services from a District temporary support assistant (TSA). The IEP also provided for one-to-one services from a nonpublic agency (NPA) behavior intervention specialist (BIS). Thus, STUDENT usually had two aides present with her simultaneously. The frequency of the BIS services varied. STUDENT received BIS services during the fall of 2002, but the amount was not specified in the evidence. Testimony from witnesses for each party showed that at least from January 2003 through about the first three weeks of March 2003, STUDENT received BIS services for the entirety of each four-hour school day.(FOOTNOTE 5)

Beginning in approximately the last week of March 2003, the amount of BIS hours was reduced.(FOOTNOTE 6) STUDENT’s mother was concerned that the reduction and/or elimination of BIS services would result in STUDENT’s causing harm to herself or others. Because of those concerns, MOTHER withdrew STUDENT from Manchester in mid-April. After the withdrawal, MOTHER taught STUDENT at home. From the beginning of May 2003 through commencement of the hearing, STUDENT received some BIS services at home, but she did not attend classes at school.(FOOTNOTE 7)

On May 16, 2003, the IEP team met in an attempt to resolve the parties’ disagreement regarding BIS services for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, for the extended school year (ESY or summer of 2003), and during STUDENT’s placement in a general first-grade class for the 2003-2004 school year. At that meeting, the District offered to continue the full-time TSA services, but it offered no BIS services. MOTHER sought full-time BIS services for STUDENT and filed for a due process hearing.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

When the hearing commenced on May 27, 2003, the Petitioner initially was seeking full-time BIS services for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, the ESY, and the 2003-2004 school year. After engaging in settlement discussions with the Petitioner’s mother outside the presence of the Hearing Officer, the District revised its proposed resolution and made a new offer to the Petitioner. The District’s new offer was for three hours of full-time BIS services during each school day, in addition to full-time TSA services.(FOOTNOTE 8) The Petitioner was partially satisfied by the District’s new offer and withdrew her issues concerning the 2002-2003 school year and ESY. However, the Petitioner’s mother did not consider the District’s new offer to be appropriate for STUDENT’s first-grade school placement and program. First-grade school days in STUDENT’s general education placement will be about six hours in duration, compared to four hours in kindergarten. MOTHER believes that the longer school days will cause full-time BIS services to be even more important to STUDENT in first grade than those services were in kindergarten. Thus, the issue remaining for decision concerns only the 2003-2004 school year.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue: In order to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related unique needs for the 2003-2004 school year, must the District offer full-time behavior intervention specialist (BIS) services?

Individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. §1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code §56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards and conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. §1401(8). Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. To determine whether a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district's proposed program addresses the student’s unique needs, provides some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP, then that district has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314; 20 U.S.C. §1401(8)(FOOTNOTE 9).

In the present case, the District has offered a combination of full-time TSA services and part-time BIS services during each school day. The Petitioner’s objection to the District’s offer is that the offer does not provide for full-time BIS services. MOTHER believes that in comparison to a TSA, a BIS has superior training and skill to address the Petitioner’s adverse behaviors. Consequently, the Petitioner asserts that the severity of her behavior-related unique needs dictates the necessity of full-time BIS services to meet those needs. The District asserts that TSA training and services are essentially indistinguishable from BIS training and services. The District asserts that its proposal for full-time TSA services and three hours of BIS services per day, in conjunction with the agreed-upon behavior plan, is appropriate and designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related unique needs for the 2003-2004 school year.

The analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed program. Therefore, if the District’s offer is found to be appropriate, no further analysis will be necessary. However, if the District’s offer is found to be inappropriate, the Hearing Officer will then reach the specific determination of whether the District must offer full-time BIS services as proposed by the Petitioner. If neither the District’s offer nor the Petitioner’s proposal is found to be appropriate, the Hearing Officer will then determine the nature of the aide services that the District must offer as part of a program designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related unique needs. I. STUDENT’s unique needs.

Before the Hearing Officer determines whether the District must offer full-time BIS services to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related unique needs for 2003-2004 school year, those needs, with particular reference to aide services and training, must first be identified.

Susan Mora, District school psychologist, assessed STUDENT in December 2002. During the assessment, Ms. Mora reviewed STUDENT’s prior records, obtained data from STUDENT’s mother and kindergarten teacher, and observed STUDENT at school. Ms. Mora’s report and her testimony at the hearing indicated that STUDENT could participate in kindergarten classroom activities, including activities that involved raising her hand and asking questions, working at activity centers, approaching and playing with peers, writing her name, indicating preferences, and helping with classroom chores such as sweeping and putting items in their proper place. Consistent with her autism and delayed receptive and expressive language skills, STUDENT would often show frustration if she did not “get her way” and also during transitions to different activities. Her frustration could be short-lived or sometimes could escalate into prolonged tantrums. She had poor eye contact with the teacher, frequently exhibited anxiety, was sometimes defiant, often showed lack of consideration for others, and could be physically aggressive with her peers. Ms. Mora’s report also states the following:

The IEP committee should discuss the level of support that STUDENT needs. She is currently shadowed by two adults who intervene as needed. STUDENT may have more access to the curriculum, less mediation of her peer relationships and more opportunity to learn positive coping skills if she were provided with one paraprofessional who was in turn trained more specifically for intervention appropriate for a child with autism, and who could help the teacher understand the manifestations of autism and the best ways to accommodate.

MOTHER testified that without proper support, STUDENT can be a danger to herself and others. She testified that adverse behaviors include STUDENT’s trying to burn her own clothes with a candle, enjoyment of pain, attempting to use a knife inappropriately, being physically aggressive with other children, wanting to sleep under a table, wanting to sleep in the bathtub, wanting to sleep with her parents in the middle of the bed but only being able to sleep for 15-minute intervals and then being awake for hours, refusing to dress or eat, damaging or hiding other persons’ property, being aggressive with animals, yelling when the school bus comes to pick her up, locking herself in rooms, dropping dishes intentionally on a tile floor, and saying “don’t hit me” and running away. MOTHER testified that the above behaviors were prevalent at and after age 3, but had greatly diminished from January to March 2003 when STUDENT was getting four hours of BIS services daily. MOTHER testified that during the period of reduced BIS services from late March to mid-April 2003, STUDENT’s adverse behaviors increased significantly.

Ira Long, a District RSP teacher at STUDENT’s school, testified that he observed STUDENT in the classroom at various times throughout the 2002-2003 school year, attended her IEP meetings, and acted as a consultant on STUDENT’s IEP team. He testified that according to the kindergarten teacher’s statements at the May 16, 2003 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s behavior would escalate to tantruming two or three days each week, and the teacher, the TSA, and/or the BIS intervened on those occasions. Regarding his own observations of STUDENT, Mr. Long testified that after a TSA got STUDENT started on a project such as letters, coloring, or other writing skills, STUDENT could work independently. STUDENT demonstrated perfectionist tendencies and difficulty with transitions. She responded better to redirection when the aide was at close proximity and at eye level, speaking in soft tones. Reinforcement strategies such as “happy face stickers” were helpful to both STUDENT and the rest of the kindergarten class.

Mr. Long described the behavior-support plan in STUDENT’s IEP and testified about the importance of the plan. He stated that the plan is designed to facilitate STUDENT’s educational progress by striving to keep her on task and in her seat. The plan lists STUDENT’s behaviors and where particular behaviors occur, what generally occurs before and after the behaviors, and the purposes the behaviors are serving for STUDENT. The plan recommends redirection during transitions by using “touch and proximity,” i.e. by rubbing her hand gently when speaking to her. As reinforcement strategies, the plan recommends giving STUDENT an item or activity she likes to do, comforting her by rubbing her back when she experiences frustration, and using happy face stickers. The plan also recommends certain other support strategies, recommends certain curriculum modification strategies, and includes specific goals and objectives in the area of behavior. The plan identifies the special education team, including the classroom teacher, the TSA, and the BIS as the persons responsible for its implementation. The list of persons responsible for implementing the plan is consistent with Ms. Mora’s testimony that when a special needs student is integrated into a general education classroom, the general education teacher has a vital role in working closely with the TSA and the IEP team to implement the student’s behavior plan and its goals and objectives pertinent to the classroom.

Barbara Washington, STUDENT’s kindergarten teacher in the 2002-2003 school year, testified that STUDENT’s behavior-related needs include structure in the classroom, structure in classroom activities, and support for focusing on task and making transitions. She testified that in kindergarten, STUDENT made progress academically and in interactions with peers. She testified that STUDENT had good days and bad days with the TSA and the BIS, and on some days STUDENT’s behaviors required Ms. Washington’s direct intervention. Ms. Washington noted that first-grade meets for more hours than does kindergarten, and she believes that STUDENT will need a full-time one-to-one aide during the first-grade school year. She expressed concern that the TSA and the BIS, especially when they are with STUDENT at the same time, may interfere with STUDENT’s peer interaction and direct interaction with the classroom teacher, thereby diminishing the value of having STUDENT mainstreamed in a general education class. Consistent with Ms. Washington’s concerns, testimony from District witnesses described the aides as simultaneously “hovering around STUDENT” in the classroom, thus isolating STUDENT from her teacher and peers.

The evidence confirms and the parties are in agreement that concurrent with her placement into a general education first-grade class during the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT will need the services of a one-to-one aide on a full-time basis. Furthermore, having considered Ms. Mora’s testimony and other evidence cited above, the Hearing Officer finds that the aide must be properly trained in understanding how STUDENT’s autism affects her behaviors and in implementing interventions appropriate to STUDENT’s deficits and needs. The aide must understand STUDENT’s behavior-support plan and work in collaboration with the classroom teacher in implementing the plan.

In addition to STUDENT’s above-stated needs regarding aide services and training, the testimony of Ms. Mora, Ms. Washington, and MOTHER, and the content of the agreed-upon behavior-support plan show that the primary tasks addressed by the aide will include assisting STUDENT with starting her classroom projects and assignments; assisting in transitioning STUDENT to different classroom and school activities throughout the day; and monitoring STUDENT’s behavior for the purposes of keeping STUDENT focused on classroom activities, reducing tantrums, reducing the length and intensity of her tantrums, and guarding against behavior that could pose a danger to STUDENT or others. There was no evidence to indicate that more than one aide was required to appropriately address those tasks. Moreover, the evidence showed that multiple aides working simultaneously with STUDENT would unduly interfere with her ability to receive direct instruction from the first-grade teacher and with her ability to engage in appropriate interaction with peers. On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires only one aide working with her at any particular time, and the presence of multiple aids working simultaneously with STUDENT would be inappropriate.

In summary, to meet her behavior-related unique needs with regard to aide services, STUDENT requires one, full-time and properly-trained, one-to-one aide working in collaboration with the first-grade teacher to implement STUDENT’s behavior-support plan.

II. The District’s offer.

The Hearing Officer has already determined that assigning two aides to work simultaneously with STUDENT would be inappropriate. Therefore, the District’s offer for full-time TSA services combined with three hours of daily BIS services is not designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related unique needs.

In spite of what the District asserted at the hearing as being an appropriate offer, the District argued for yet another proposed resolution in its closing brief. In its closing brief, the District changed its position and presented argument acknowledging that a TSA and a BIS working simultaneously with STUDENT could be unduly restrictive to STUDENT’s interaction with her teacher and peers. The District then argued for a resolution that generally would involve having an NPA provide four hours of training to District personnel prior to commencement of the school year, having the NPA essentially train the IEP team to train the TSA at the commencement of the school year, having the BIS “phased out” during third and fourth weeks of the school year, and having the NPA provide two to four hours of monthly consultation services for the entire 2003-2004 school year.

Although some aspects of the District’s latest proposed resolution may be useful to the ultimate resolution of the Petitioner’s issue, the proposal is not appropriate. No persuasive purpose has been demonstrated for having two aides working with STUDENT simultaneously for the first month of her first-grade school year. STUDENT would be unduly isolated from her teacher and peers during a month when new relationships between classmates and between the students and the teacher may often be developed.

III. The Petitioner’s proposal.

With the District’s offer and its latest proposal having been found inappropriate, the Hearing Officer will proceed to determine whether the District must offer full-time BIS services as proposed by the Petitioner. If the Petitioner’s proposal is found to be inappropriate, the Hearing Officer will then determine the nature of the aide services and training that the District must offer as part of a program designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related unique needs. Because the Petitioner’s proposal and certain potentially useful aspects of the District’s latest proposal might involve services from a TSA, a BIS, or some combination of the two, an understanding of the nature of TSA and BIS services and training will be helpful.

TSA services and training were described by witnesses from the District. Mr. Long testified that the function of a temporary support assistant (TSA) is to provide non-academic support in accordance with the student’s needs, such as the student’s ability to move or walk. He stated that TSAs are not considered to be teachers’ aides. With regard to TSA training, Mr. Long testified that TSAs and all other District employees must pass a generalized test before they are hired by the District. The particular nature of the test was not specified. Mr. Long stated that TSAs have various levels of education, background, and experience related to serving pupils with special needs. For example, some TSAs may have prior experience and special training, and others may have none. Mr. Long was aware of no formal training given to TSAs by the District. He testified, in essence, that the District expects the IEP to be roughly equivalent to a job manual for the TSA, and in some instances the IEP may be the sole source of what the District considers to be training for the TSA.

The testimony of Ms. Soto, STUDENT’s TSA, illustrated in practical terms how the District’s approach to training its TSAs may affect the preparedness and performance of its TSAs. Ms. Soto testified that she received no training prior to becoming STUDENT’s TSA, that she received no training from the District during her tenure as STUDENT’s TSA, and that she received no supervisory or consultative input regarding her services to STUDENT. Ms. Soto’s testimony also showed that the District’s analogy of the IEP’s serving as the job manual for the TSA was unfounded. Ms. Soto testified that she had looked at the behavior-support plan contained in STUDENT’s IEP, but “it was not my knowledge that she needed that behavior plan.” When asked how she had learned to assist STUDENT, Ms. Soto testified that she had been taught by STUDENT’s mother.

BIS services and training were described by several witnesses and by documentary evidence. Turning Point, an NPA, provided STUDENT’s behavior intervention specialist (BIS) services in the 2001-2002 school year. STUDENT’s BIS from Turning Point, Annette Ishisaka, testified that BIS’s are specifically trained in behavior modification and intervention techniques, and a BIS can work with the student either in school or at the student’s home. She did not specify whether some portion of that training is provided before the BIS is assigned to provide services. During the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s BIS was provided by Intensive Behavior Intervention Consultants (IBIC), an NPA. According to the written contract between MOTHER and IBIC executed in October 2002, “compliance with California Education Code requirements” mandates that the BIS providing direct one-to-one behavior intervention services would receive a minimum of one hour of supervision per week for every ten hours of direct services provided to STUDENT. The IBIC contract emphasizes that BIS services are to be provided only in accordance with the provisions of STUDENT’s IEP, with IBIC retaining some discretion over the particular methodologies to be used. Dr. Janet Friedman, a clinic director at IBIC, provided a description of BIS training and services at the May 2003 IEP meeting. Mr. Long and Gabriella Ruvalcaba, a counselor at WRC, attended that meeting. They testified concerning Dr. Friedman’s description of BIS services and training. Dr. Friedman reportedly characterized the weekly supervision as “in-service” training for the BIS, and stated that the in-service training was directed at addressing STUDENT’s specific behavioral challenges. He also reportedly stated that BIS supervisors at IBIC have either a master’s or doctorate degree in an applicable area.

The above evidence shows that neither a TSA nor a BIS necessarily has pertinent experience or training before being assigned to a student with special needs. However, in spite of the District’s insistence that a TSA is indistinguishable from a BIS for purposes of meeting STUDENT’s behavior-related needs, the evidence shows a substantial and critical difference arising from in-service training. The BIS’s receive weekly in-service training in behavior modification and intervention techniques by a qualified supervisor with a master’s or doctorate degree, and the in-service training is intended to be specific to the needs of the student. In contrast, the testimony of District witnesses confirms that the TSAs receive no in-service training, and in most instances no training whatsoever. The differences in training should be expected to have a significant effect on services. Because the TSA may have no training, whether in-service or otherwise, no prior experience, and no background in special education, the services and methodologies used by the TSA may be limited to whatever guidance is in the student’s IEP, if any. By comparison, the weekly in-service training and supervision received by the BIS’s should result in services that are undergoing frequent refinement by a qualified supervisor, in accordance with the progress and needs of the particular student.(FOOTNOTE 11)

Returning to the Petitioner’s proposal for full-time BIS services, the Hearing Officer considers certain aspects of BIS services and training to be favorable for meeting the Petitioner’s needs. However, events in the 2002-2003 school year confirm that the Petitioner’s proposed resolution for the 2003-2004 school year would most likely not result in a program designed to meet her behavior-related unique needs previously identified in this Decision. Specifically, the Hearing Officer has previously found that the one-to-one aide must work in collaboration with the first-grade teacher to implement STUDENT’s behavior-support plan. STUDENT’s kindergarten classroom teacher testified that she had little or no familiarity with the behavior-support plan and she was unaware of her responsibility for implementing the plan. Instead, the kindergarten teacher thought that implementation of the plan was solely the responsibility of the BIS. Similarly, the testimony of the TSA confirmed that the TSA had no understanding of her own responsibility for implementing the behavior-support plan, and she had no understanding of the plan’s application to matters she and the kindergarten teacher should have been discussing as part of a collaborative effort. Thus, although the behavior-support plan specified that the BIS was jointly responsible with the TSA and the classroom teacher for implementing the plan, the evidence showed that the presence of the BIS did nothing to correct the lack of understanding by the teacher and the TSA regarding their responsibility for implementing the plan. The persistence of that lack of understanding throughout the entirety of the school year confirms a failure by the BIS to collaborate with the classroom teacher and the TSA with reference to implementing the plan. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that adopting the Petitioner’s proposed resolution would likely result in a recurrence of the above-described problems, thereby inviting the failure of designated personnel to understand and execute their responsibilities with regard to implementing the behavior-support plan and operating in a collaborative manner.

IV. Appropriate aide services and training for the 2003-2004 school year.

With neither party having proposed an appropriate resolution to the Petitioner’s issue, the Hearing Officer will now determine the nature of the aide services and training that the District must offer as part of a program designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related unique needs. STUDENT requires one-to-one aide services on a full-time basis, as found above. In addition, the Hearing Officer observes that whether the job title of STUDENT’s full-time one-to-one aide is “TSA,” “BIS,” or some other term is immaterial to meeting STUDENT’s needs. The defining element for the position as STUDENT’s one-to-one aide is that the aide must receive proper training and ongoing supervision.

Having considered all of the above, including the need for proper training of STUDENT’s aide, the need for collaboration between the aide and the classroom teacher in implementing STUDENT’s behavior-support plan, the District’s policies regarding training of TSAs, and the District’s past performance in overseeing the activities of STUDENT’s TSAs and BIS’s, the Hearing Officer finds that appropriate aide services and training for meeting STUDENT’s behavior-related needs will require and include both a full-time one-to-one aide and supervision of that aide by a case manager. To avoid a probable recurrence of prior situations wherein, under District procedures, STUDENT’s one-to-one aides were not adequately directed toward understanding their duties, the Hearing Officer will order the District to contract with a properly certified NPA for the purpose of obtaining the case manager. To execute his or her duty to supervise STUDENT’s one-to-one aide, the case manager shall oversee the implementation of STUDENT’s behavior-support plan, including responsibilities regarding collaboration; provide in-service training to the one-to-one aide; and provide consultation to the classroom teacher, the one-to-one aide, and any persons listed in the IEP as being responsible for implementation of the behavior-support plan. The case manager and persons the case manager may designate to provide consultation and training must have a master’s or doctorate degree applicable to behavior support for students with autism. The one-to-one aide shall have appropriate preparatory training prior to commencement of the 2003-2004 school year. Details regarding the aide’s preparatory training and the frequency of in-service training and consultation shall be determined by the IEP team.

ORDERS

1. Within 15 calendar days from the date of this Decision and as necessary thereafter, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to accomplish the following:

(A) Amend STUDENT’s IEP to provide for a full-time one-to-one aide to address STUDENT’s behavior-related needs.

(B) Establish a contract between the District and a properly certified NPA for the purpose of providing a qualified case manager to supervise the one-to-one aide. To execute his or her duty to supervise STUDENT’s one-to-one aide, the case manager shall oversee the implementation of STUDENT’s behavior-support plan, including responsibilities regarding collaboration; provide in-service training to the one-to-one aide; and provide consultation to the classroom teacher, the one-to-one aide, and any other persons listed in the IEP as being responsible for implementation of the behavior-support plan.

2. The case manager and persons the case manager may designate to provide the consultation and training ordered above must have a master’s or doctorate degree applicable to behavior support for students with autism.

3. The in-service training ordered above must be designed to provide the one-to-one aide with an understanding of how STUDENT’s autism affects her behaviors and how to implement interventions appropriate to STUDENT’s behavior-related deficits and needs.

4. Details regarding preparatory training of the one-to-one aide prior to commencement of the 2003-2004 school year and the frequency of in-service training and consultation shall be determined by the IEP team.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.

Issue: In order to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related unique needs for the 2003-2004 school year, must the District offer full-time behavior intervention specialist (BIS) services? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that she will receive a properly-trained full-time one-to-one aide. Although the program ordered by the Hearing Officer has some resemblance to certain portions the resolution proposed in the District’s closing brief, that proposed resolution was not made until after the conclusion of the Hearing, does not reflect the District’s position at the hearing, and was found by the Hearing Officer to be inappropriate.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code §56505(i).

Dated: July 18, 2003 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. As an accommodation necessitated by the medical condition of the Petitioner’s mother, the hearing was conducted in five half-day sessions. 2. FATHER was present on May 27 and June 4. Ms. Metichecchia was present on May 28 and 30. Ms. Glickman was present on June 3. Ms. Talesnick was present on June 4. Ms. Windler was present on May 27, 30, and June 3 and 4. Ms. Hines was present on May 28. Attorney Dean Adams from the law office of Lozano Smith was present as an observer on May 30. 3. The testimony of Ms. Ruvalcaba and Ms. Ishisaka was received by telephone. 4. This issue was narrowed at the commencement of hearing, as will be explained below under Procedural Matters. 5. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT first began receiving BIS services in approximately December 2001 6. A prior agreement between the parties had provided for a certain number of BIS hours, characterized in the agreement as “compensatory education.” The exhaustion of those hours resulted in a reduction of BIS services. Testimony varied with respect to the amount of the reduction in BIS services. District witnesses testified that the reduction was only one or two hours per day. MOTHER testified that in the latter part of March 2003, BIS services were reduced from four hours to two hours per day, and that for approximately a two-week period in April, no BIS services were provided. 7. At various times, portions of STUDENT’s BIS services have been financed by public agencies other than the District. 8. In its closing brief, the District proposed yet another resolution to the Petitioner’s issue, but the latest proposal by the District was neither known to the Petitioner nor addressed by the Petitioner during her presentation of evidence and argument. Therefore, the resolution proposed in the District’s closing brief is neither fact nor evidence, but it will be considered in this Decision as argument. 9. Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and mandates that removal of a child with disabilities from the general education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in general classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §56031. In addition, a student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. §1414(d), 34 C.F.R. §300.347(a). None of the above factors are at issue in the present case. 10. Specific citations to California codes and regulations were not provided. 11. Although the descriptions of BIS services and training were partially hearsay, the hearsay evidence was supplemented by direct testimony from Ms. Ruvalcaba and Ms. Ishisaka concerning their personal knowledge of BIS training and services. In any event, the Hearing Officer’s observations regarding the differences in TSA and BIS services and training do not ultimately determine the outcome of this Decision.