California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 10, 2003
Student v. Elk Grove Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 729-03, SN03-00729 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard
Elk Grove Unified wins emotional disturbance eligibility dispute but must reimburse an independent assessment, minus IQ testing costs.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The student filed against Elk Grove Unified School District. Long Beach Unified was dismissed by agreement after the student gave up her claims for September 2002 through January 23, 2003. The 16-year-old had never been found eligible for special education. She failed classes at Harriet Eddy Middle School and Laguna Creek High School. She then had a single alcohol incident at a Long Beach continuation school. After that, her family placed her at Provo Canyon School, a residential treatment center in Utah. She argued she should have been eligible as emotionally disturbed since 2000-2001. She relied on an independent diagnosis of reactive attachment disorder and depression. She sought reimbursement for Provo Canyon and continued placement there.
Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard found she did not meet any emotional disturbance criterion over a long period of time and to a marked degree. Teachers credibly testified that her poor grades came from not turning in homework, not from an inability to learn. She had friendships with peers. Provo Canyon staff did not see lasting depression or confirm the attachment diagnosis. Because she was not eligible, her FAPE, reimbursement and compensatory education claims failed. However, the district did not prove that its school psychologist's assessment was appropriate. The psychologist had not interviewed the family or teachers and had left out the student's developmental history. Elk Grove must reimburse the independent assessment, except the cost of an IQ test the district objected to under Larry P. v. Riles.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO separated a clinical diagnosis from special education eligibility. Each emotional disturbance characteristic had to appear over a long time and to a marked degree. It also shows that a district that cannot prove its own assessment was appropriate may have to fund a parent's independent evaluation, even when the district wins on eligibility.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. From the 2000-2001 school year to the present, should Student have been identified as eligible for special education and related services as a student who is emotionally disturbed (ED)?
Student did not show any ED characteristic (inability to learn, relationships, inappropriate behavior, pervasive depression) over a long period and to a marked degree; poor grades stemmed from not turning in work.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2a. If Student should have been determined eligible as ED, did Elk Grove deny her a FAPE from the 2000-2001 school year to the present on procedural or substantive grounds?
Because Student was not eligible as ED, the district did not fail to provide her a FAPE during the years at issue.
- Not reachedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2b. Was Provo Canyon School an appropriate placement for her for the 2002-2003 school and extended school year?
Not separately decided because Student was found not eligible as ED; the district was named prevailing party on Issue 2.
- Not reachedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2c. Is Provo Canyon School an appropriate placement for her for the 2003-2004 school and extended school year?
Not separately decided because Student was found not eligible as ED; the district was named prevailing party on Issue 2.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3a. If Elk Grove denied Student a FAPE, is she entitled to reimbursement for the costs of her placement at Provo Canyon School from November 19, 2002 to the present, including transportation?
No FAPE denial was found, so reimbursement for the Provo Canyon placement was denied.
- District prevailedResidential placement for mental health
Issue 3b. Is she entitled to compensatory education in the form of either lost services or prospective placement at Provo Canyon School for the 2003-2004 school and extended school year?
No FAPE denial was found, so compensatory education and prospective placement were denied.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 3c. Is she entitled to an immediate referral to Sacramento County Mental Health for an assessment?
The referral was denied along with all other relief because Student was not eligible as ED.
- Student prevailed in partIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4. Should Elk Grove be ordered to fund the cost of the July 14, 2003 independent psychological assessment of Student conducted by Todd Koch, Ph.D.?
The district did not prove its school psychologist's assessment was appropriate, so it must reimburse the IEE, minus the cost of the WASI IQ test.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- IEE at public expense. Elk Grove must reimburse Student's Aunt for Dr. Koch's psychoeducational assessment, except the time and cost of giving and scoring the Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence (WASI). Payment is due within 20 calendar days after the district receives an invoice that excludes the WASI costs. The evidence showed a $1,500 check paid to Dr. Merz; no exact reimbursement amount was set.
Key authorities
Larry P. v. Riles, 495 F. Supp. 926 (N.D. Cal. 1979), aff'd in part, rev'd in part, 793 F.2d 969 (9th Cir. 1986); Crawford v. Honig (9th Cir. 1995) 37 F.3d 485; Student v. Ravenswood Elementary School District (SEHO March 26, 1998 order); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329; Cal. Educ. Code § 56327(e); 34 C.F.R. § 300.502
People named in the decision
- William Tollestrup, Director of special education and SELPA director, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Pat Spears Lee, Lead program specialist, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Don Ross, Program specialist, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Linda Strom, Assistant superintendent, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Catherine Guy, Principal, Harriet Eddy Middle School, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Phyllis Ramsey, Program specialist, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Robbie Henle, School psychologist (district assessor), Elk Grove Unified School District
- David Vollmer, Lead school psychologist, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Shirley Sekeres, Former lead resource specialist program (RSP) teacher, Elk Grove Unified School District
- James William Murdock, Math teacher, Harriet Eddy Middle School, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Mr. Spickelmier, Math teacher, Harriet Eddy Middle School, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Mary Swanson, Former instructional aide, Harriet Eddy Middle School, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Sylvia Nelson, Retired school counselor, Harriet Eddy Middle School, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Cheryl Chargin, RSP teacher, Harriet Eddy Middle School, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Roberta Shapard Potter, Registrar, Laguna Creek High School, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Jennifer Nguyen, School counselor, Laguna Creek High School, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Rodney John DeLuca, English teacher, Laguna Creek High School, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Carol Decoux-Lantay, Computer technology teacher, Laguna Creek High School, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Ryan Myers, World geography teacher, Laguna Creek High School, Elk Grove Unified School District
- Frederick Marks, Algebra teacher, Laguna Creek High School, Elk Grove Unified School District
- James McDonald, Dean, Reid Continuation High School, Long Beach Unified School District
- David Meade, History teacher, Reid Continuation High School, Long Beach Unified School District
- Julie Butler, Physical science teacher, Reid Continuation High School, Long Beach Unified School District
- Dr. Robert Crist, Psychiatrist and chief medical director, Provo Canyon School
- Dr. Alan Crist, Clinical psychologist (assessed student May 2003), Provo Canyon School
- Kathy Jo Smith, Special education coordinator, Provo Canyon School
- Adrianna Ottonelli, Psychotherapist (November 2002 to spring 2003), Provo Canyon School
- Marc Nathan Barney, Current therapist, Provo Canyon School
- Anna McIntire, Former clinical social work intern, Provo Canyon School
- Mr. Blackburn, Therapist supervisor, Provo Canyon School
- Provo Canyon School, Residential treatment center and certified nonpublic school (unilateral placement), Provo, Utah
- Dr. Todd Koch, Independent assessor (registered psychological assistant); expert witness for Student, Works with Dr. William Merz
- Dr. William Merz, Psychologist; expert witness for Student, Private practice
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter convened for hearing before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Elk Grove, California, on June 12, July 24, 25, 29 - 31, and August 1, 11 - 15, and 18, 2003.
Student (Petitioner or Student) was represented throughout the hearing by attorney F. Richard Ruderman with paralegal Ellen Kramer. Co-counsel Perry Leonard was present at the hearing on June 12 and July 24, 2003. Also present on Student’s behalf throughout the hearing were her paternal grandmother and her paternal aunt (collectively referred to as Student’s parents). Elk Grove Unified School District (Elk Grove or the District) was represented by attorney Jack Clarke. Also present on Elk Grove’s behalf was director of special education and SELPA director, William Tollestrup, or lead program specialist Pat Spears Lee. (Footnote 1) Prior to its dismissal as a party on July 25, 2003, the Long Beach Unified School District (Long Beach) was also present at the hearing and was represented by attorney Justin Shinnefield (see: Procedural Background).
Petitioner called her paternal grandmother, her paternal aunt, Dr. Todd Koch and Dr. William Merz as witnesses. In addition, Petitioner called the following Elk Grove employees as witnesses: Harriet Eddy Middle School (HEMS) principal Catherine Guy, program specialist Phyllis Ramsey, director of special education William Tollestrup, and school psychologist Robbie Henle. Petitioner also called Long Beach’s Reid Continuation High School teacher Julie Butler as a witness, as well as the following employees or former employees of Provo Canyon School: psychologist Dr. Alan Crist, former social work intern Anna McIntire, and Student’s current therapist Marc Nathan Barney.
Elk Grove called the following employees and former employees as witnesses: lead school psychologist David Vollmer; lead program specialist Pat Spears Lee; former lead resource specialist program (RSP) teacher Shirley Sekeres; Harriet Eddy Middle School (HEMS) teacher James William Murdock (math); former HEMS instructional aide Mary Swanson; retired HEMS school counselor Sylvia Nelson; HEMS RSP teacher Cheryl Chargin; Laguna Creek High School (LCHS) registrar Roberta Shapard Potter; LCHS school counselor Jennifer Nguyen; and LCHS teachers Rodney John DeLuca (English), Carol Decoux-Lantay (computers), Ryan Myers (world geography) and Frederick Marks (algebra). Elk Grove called the following witnesses from Reid Continuation High School (Reid): Reid’s dean James McDonald and history teacher David Meade. In addition, Elk Grove called the following witnesses from Provo Canyon School: psychiatrist and chief medical director Dr. Robert Crist; special education coordinator Kathy Jo Smith; and Student’s psychotherapist from November 2002 through April 2003, Adrianna Ottonelli. All witnesses from Provo Canyon School and Reid Continuation High School testified by telephone, as did former Elk Grove instructional aide Mary Swanson.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. By September 16, 2003, the Hearing Officer had received all parties’ closing briefs. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for a decision.
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Dismissal of Respondent Long Beach Unified School District
On May 12, 2003, the Hearing Office denied Elk Grove’s motion to be dismissed as a party and granted its motion to bifurcate the issue of Petitioner’s district of residence. On June 3, 2003, the Hearing Officer denied Petitioner’s motion to dismiss Long Beach as a party as well as its motion for reconsideration of the bifurcation order.
On June 12, 2003, this matter convened for hearing on the sole issue of whether Elk Grove or Long Beach was Petitioner’s district of residence for the 2002-2003 school year. Following presentation of evidence on this issue, the Hearing Officer found that Long Beach was Student’s district of residence for the 2002-2003 school year during the period she actually attended its Reid Continuation High School from September 4, 2002, through November 18, 2002, and that Elk Grove was Student’s district of residence for the 2002-2003 school year beginning at least after her request for assessment on January 24, 2003. The Hearing Officer concluded that both Long Beach and Elk Grove were appropriate parties for the 2002-2003 school year and that whether either school district bore any additional responsibility for Petitioner’s educational services during the 2002-2003 school year would be determined at the hearing on Petitioner’s substantive special education issues (see: June 27, 2003 Order Regarding District of Residence).
On July 24, 2003, this matter reconvened for hearing on Petitioner’s special education issues. On behalf of Respondent Long Beach, Mr. Shinnefield again requested that Long Beach be dismissed as a party. That motion was opposed by Elk Grove and denied by the Hearing Officer in light of the June 27, 2003 order regarding residence.
On July 25, 2003, the parties informed the Hearing Officer that an agreement to dismiss Long Beach as a party to this matter had been reached. The parties stipulated to the following:
1. Petitioner waives all claims against both the Elk Grove and the Long Beach Unified School Districts for the period from September 2002 through January 23, 2003. 2. Elk Grove agrees that it is Petitioner’s district of residence for the 2002-2003 school year as of January 24, 2003, and agrees to the dismissal of Long Beach as a party. 3. Long Beach agrees to make its personnel available for telephone testimony.
Pursuant to the parties’ agreement outlined above, on July 25, 2003, the Hearing Officer dismissed Long Beach Unified School District as a party to Case No. SN03-00729.
Motion to Exclude Dr. Koch’s Independent Assessment Report and Testimony
STUDENT is of African-American and Native Alaskan heritage and has been raised in an African-American family. In Larry P. v. Riles, 495 F. Supp. 926 (N.D. Cal. 1979), affd in part, revd. in part, 793 F. 2d 969 (9th Cir. 1986), the federal district court determined that intelligence tests were racially biased against African-American students and issued a permanent injunction against the use of such intelligence quotient (IQ) tests by school districts in eligibility determinations for educable mentally retarded (EMR) students. The Hearing Office has determined that, even though EMR classes no longer exist, the use or consideration of IQ tests prohibited by Larry P. by school districts concerning African-American students continues to be inappropriate and that Larry P.’s prohibition is in effect. Student v. Ravenswood Elementary School District, et al., (March 26, 1998) “Memorandum of Order Denying in Part and Granting in Part Ravenswood’s Motion to Dismiss and Sequoia’s Motion to exclude Evidence.” (Footnote 2) On July 24, 2003, the District argued its motion to exclude the introduction of Dr. Koch’s report (Petitioner Ex. 2027 - 2047) and any testimony about that report because it contains the results of IQ tests that have been determined to be racially discriminatory against African-American students under Larry P. Specifically, the District objected to the inclusion in Dr. Koch’s report of the results of Dr. Alan Crist’s administration of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC-III) to Student in May 2003 and of the Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence (WASI) administered to Student by Dr. Koch. (See: District Ex. 32, June 3, 1997 memorandum by California Department of Education entitled “Clarification of the Use of Intelligence Tests with African-American Students for Special Education Assessment”). In the alternative, it requested that the report be redacted. Petitioner objected to this request, arguing, inter alia, that, under special education laws, the family has the right to obtain and submit an independent educational evaluation (IEE) at a due process hearing and that Larry P. is only binding on school districts.
The Hearing Officer initially determined that, while Larry P. does not mandate the exclusion of an IEE that includes racially-discriminatory IQ tests at a due process hearing or of testimony regarding that IEE, the results of the prohibited IQ tests would not be considered or used to make any findings on the results of those tests. The Hearing Officer further ordered Dr. Koch’s report to be redacted to exclude such IQ results. The Hearing Officer subsequently granted Petitioner’s motion for reconsideration of this ruling, in particular to allow Petitioner time to brief this issue and to avoid prejudice to Petitioner’s case. Dr. Koch’s report and testimony were conditionally admitted and the parties were granted leave to address this issue in their closing briefs.
Scant argument on this issue was provided in the parties’ closing briefs. Elk Grove requested only that Dr. Koch’s report be given much less weight and that Petitioner should not be entitled to reimbursement for his report because he administered a discriminatory intelligence test to Student as part of his assessment.
The Hearing Officer notes that, ultimately, this evidentiary issue played a minor role in the presentation of the parties’ respective cases. There was no dispute of fact that STUDENT is a student of average intellectual capability, and Petitioner expressly stipulated that her eligibility as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) from 2000-2001 school year to the date of the hearing was not at issue in this hearing. (Footnote 3) Dr. Koch testified that the results of STUDENT’s IQ tests were considered by him as a very small part of his analysis. Petitioner’s offer of proof that a lowered IQ score could demonstrate depression was not borne out in Dr. Koch’s testimony. Rather, he testified that depression might be revealed as a lowered IQ score only within the context of a series of IQ tests and that this situation was not present with STUDENT. The Hearing Officer therefore admits Petitioner’s Exhibit 2027 - 2047 in its entirety and makes no finding in reliance on the IQ scores reported by Dr. Koch within his report.
ISSUES (Footnote 4)
1. From the 2000-2001 school year to the present, should Student have been identified as eligible for special education and related services as a student who is emotionally disturbed (ED)?
2. If Student should have been determined eligible as ED, (a) did Elk Grove deny her a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from the 2000- 2001 school year to the present on procedural or substantive grounds; (b) was Provo Canyon School an appropriate placement for her for the 2002-2003 school and extended school year; and (c) is Provo Canyon School an appropriate placement for her for the 2003-2004 school and extended school year?
3. If Elk Grove denied Student a FAPE, is she entitled to (a) reimbursement for the costs of her placement at Provo Canyon School from November 19, 2002 to the present, including transportation, (b) compensatory education in the form of either lost services or prospective placement at Provo Canyon School for the 2003-2004 school and extended school year, and (c) an immediate referral to Sacramento County Mental Health for an assessment?
4. Should Elk Grove be ordered to fund the cost of the July 14, 2003 independent psychological assessment of Student conducted by Todd Koch, Ph. D.?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Student contends that she has an emotional disturbance rooted in her abandonment at birth and placement in foster care for the first eight to nine months of her life and that it was this crucial life event that led to her independent diagnosis of reactive attachment disorder (RAD) and major depression by Dr. Koch in July 2003. In her view, as a result of these emotional disturbances, Elk Grove should have determined her eligible for special education and related mental health services as emotionally disturbed (ED), from the 2000-2001 school year through the present. Student asserts that these emotional disturbances have resulted in her inability to learn or to build or maintain satisfactory relationships, her inappropriate behavior or feelings, and her pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression, and that these characteristics have, in turn, adversely affected her educational performance. In her closing brief, Student contends that the only question is whether her emotional disturbance is significant enough to establish her eligibility as ED. Student also argues that the District denied her a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds because it failed in its “child find” obligation, failed to conduct an appropriate assessment of her, and failed to offer her special education and related mental health services. In her view, Provo Canyon School was and is the appropriate placement to address the educational issues arising out of her emotional disturbance. Student requests reimbursement for her placement at Provo Canyon since November 2002, as well as prospective placement at Provo Canyon for the 2003-2004 school year.
Elk Grove argues that Student has never satisfied the eligibility criteria for special education as a Student with an ED. In its view, Student is a shy, capable, general education Student who has never exhibited any inappropriate behavior while attending its schools in Elk Grove and living with her paternal grandmother (hereafter Student’s Grandmother). Elk Grove further asserts that Student’s predominantly D and F grades and low SAT 9 scores during ninth grade at its Laguna Creek High School do not mandate a conclusion that she is emotionally disturbed. Rather, it argues that Student’s educational performance has been adversely affected by her ongoing choice not to complete and/or turn in her homework assignments. Elk Grove contends that Student’s only concerning behavior–becoming extremely intoxicated one time at school–occurred in October 2002 while she was attending Reid Continuation High School and living with her Aunt in Long Beach. In Elk Grove’s view, Student’s parents unilaterally placed her at Provo Canyon due to her ongoing oppositional and defiant behaviors at home shortly after the intoxication incident. Elk Grove argues that Student’s behaviors at home were mainly the result of normal adolescent interests and desires that were contrary to her parents’ wishes and beliefs, as well as from her oppositional defiant disorder diagnosed by Provo Canyon’s chief psychiatrist in November 2002. If Student is determined to be eligible as ED, Elk Grove contends that she is not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of Provo Canyon because her parents did not give it the ten-day notice required prior to placing her in a private school. In addition, it asserts that placement at Provo Canyon is not appropriate because it is not the least restrictive environment and is unnecessary to address Student’s very mild mental health needs.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Student is a sixteen-year-old student who has never been determined eligible for special education and related services. Student began tenth grade in the 2002-2003 school year at Reid Continuation High School (Reid) within the Long Beach Unified School District while living with her aunt, Student’s Aunt. On October 25, 2002, Student became extremely intoxicated at Reid. As a consequence of her drinking episode, Student was suspended for several days and then returned to school. For her parents, this episode was “the last straw” after a series of school failures and defiant and isolative behaviors. On November 19, 2002, Student’s family placed her at Provo Canyon School, a Level 14 locked residential treatment center and certified nonpublic school, in Provo, Utah, where she currently remains. Student is housed on a campus with approximately 120 other girls, approximately one-third of whom receive services pursuant to an Individualized Education Program (IEP).
Student was abandoned at birth by her biological parents and placed in foster care. When Student was eight months old, Student’s Grandmother was contacted by Holy Family Services, an adoption agency, during its effort to locate Student’s biological parents and free her for adoption by the foster mother with whom she had resided since shortly after her birth. When Student’s biological parents were located, they placed her in Student’s Grandmother’s care for the purpose of guardianship. A formal guardianship has never been established. Student’s Grandmother and her adult daughter, Student’s Aunt, raised Student with her older brother, Student’s Brother, who had also been abandoned. The parents agreed that Student’s Grandmother, who Student calls “mother,” was her primary caretaker. Student’s Grandmother testified that Student’s biological parents abused alcohol, marijuana, and crack cocaine during the mother’s pregnancy with Student’s Brother and that she suspected Student’s biological mother had also used drugs while Student was in utero.
Since 1992, Student has lived with Student’s Grandmother in Elk Grove. In approximately 1993, Student’s Aunt moved from her home in Elk Grove to Long Beach where Student and Student’s Brother spent their summer and other school vacations. In the summer of 2000, the parents unilaterally placed Student’s Brother at Provo Canyon School. Elk Grove then funded Student’s Brother’s placement at Provo Canyon until he graduated in 2002.
Elk Grove Unified School District
Student attended schools within the Elk Grove Unified School District from kindergarten through the conclusion of her ninth grade in the 2001-2002 school year. According to the parents, as a toddler, Student resisted being held and exhibited anger and aggression by hitting and abusing her toys. Once in school, Student was initially aggressive with her peers, but later became quiet and withdrawn. In second and third grade, Student’s teacher advised Student’s Grandmother that Student was struggling academically. As a result of this information, Student’s Grandmother hired a college Student to tutor Student and tutoring continued through the sixth grade.
A. Harriet Eddy Middle School
Student attended Elk Grove’s Harriet Eddy Middle School (HEMS) for seventh grade in the 1999-2000 school year and eighth grade in the 2000-2001 school year. Student’s school counselor during both her middle school years was Sylvia Nelson, who met with Student on a regular basis and described her as “beautiful and very shy.” In addition, Ms. Nelson and Student’s Grandmother communicated about Student’s education approximately three to four times a month. During middle school, Ms. Nelson developed various strategies to help Student improve her grades and credits, including entering into contracts with Student to complete her homework, attend and pass all classes, and offering her the opportunity to earn extra credits.
In seventh grade at HEMS, Student received grades ranging from B+ through F. In March 2000, Student participated in the Stanford 9 (SAT-9) national standardized test and received a total reading score at the forty-first national percentile rank (41 NPR), a total written language score at the forty-third (43) NPR, and a total mathematics score at the twenty third (23) NPR. At the end of seventh grade, Student had only sixteen of the seventeen credits required to be in good standing. Student was also determined to be at risk for retention due to her low math SAT 9 score, pursuant to a District policy concerning Students whose SAT-9 scores were below the twenty-fifth (25) percentile. (Footnote 5)
At the beginning of her eighth grade during the 2000-2001 school year, Student signed another contract with Ms. Nelson in which she agreed to earn additional credits by attending the Learning Center and “Program Choice,” a collaborative program with Consumnes College, during the October 2000 intersession. During eighth grade, Ms. Nelson also included Student in a girls’ social skills/friendship group she facilitated with girls who had received grades of D or F.
In the spring of 2001, Student’s Grandmother began to look for a private school placement for Student. In her April 9, 2001 letter to Ms. Nelson, Student’s Grandmother stated her intention to enroll Student at Capitol Christian for her high school years because of her belief that smaller classes and more hands-on assistance would help Student to grow academically, socially, and spiritually. Student’s Grandmother asked for and received Ms. Nelson’s assistance in completing a form required for Student’s admissions packet to Capitol Christian School. Student’s Grandmother testified that Student was ultimately denied admission to Capitol Christian and another private school because of her poor grades.
In March 2001, Student participated in the SAT 9. Student received a total reading score at the 35 NPR, a total written language score of 55, and a total mathematics score of 17 NPR. Student’s grades in the eighth grade included Ds and Fs, as well as Bs and Cs. At the end of the eighth grade, Student’s cumulative grade point average (GPA) was 1.83. In addition, Student had earned only 33 of the required 34 credits. Although Student’s Grandmother initially requested that Student be retained, she agreed to Student’s promotion to the ninth grade after Ms. Nelson told her about the potential negative impact this might have on Student’s self-esteem. Student was not allowed to participate in the eighth grade graduation ceremony. Ms. Nelson recommended that Student enroll in a high school summer school class designed for Students who are authorized to matriculate to high school but lack a credit. Instead, Student spent the 2001 summer in Long Beach with her Aunt.
B. Laguna Creek High School
During the 2001-2002 school year, Student attended ninth grade at Elk Grove’s Laguna Creek High School (LCHS). During this school year, Student was assigned to high school counselor Jennifer Nguyen, who had limited contact with her and had no knowledge of Student’s grades or credits at HEMS. Nonetheless, Student was placed in the year-long alegbra class for Students with math difficulties that covered in one year what was typically covered in a quarter. Student was also placed for one term in an English review class as well as the standard college preparatory English class.
Student’s grades declined further in ninth grade. As Student’s Grandmother later informed the admission committee at Provo Canyon School, once Student entered LCHS, she became more social, but also more disobedient, closed/secretive, and rebellious against parental direction. Student refused to attend an after-school study program at LCHS. Student isolated herself at home and would not participate in family activities. Student began to sneak out of the house and lie about where she was going. On one occasion, Student lied to her Grandmother about going to take pictures with a group of girls. Instead, she went to a party where no adults were present and was out until 11:00 p.m., when she finally called for a ride home. On a second occasion, Student pretended she was in bed. Student’s Grandmother discovered that she had actually placed a ball under a blanket to look as though she was sleeping and sneaked out of the house. Student then rushed into the house “fully dressed, including make up and eye shadow,” and refused to tell her Grandmother where she had been. Student’s Grandmother also indicated that Student chatted on the phone or e-mail constantly, and was “totally consummed with a pursuit of teenage boys,” as well as with her appearance.
In the ninth grade, Student also hid her progress reports and report cards from her Grandmother. Student’s Grandmother testified that when she learned of Student’s failing grades, she did not contact anyone at LCHS to express her concerns. In June 2002, Student received Ds and three Fs. At the end of the ninth grade, Student had a cumulative GPA of .62 and was ranked 798 out of 823 ninth grade Students at Laguna Creek. On her March 2002 SAT 9, Student received a total reading score at the 26 NPR, a total written language score of 38, and a total mathematics score of 18 NPR.
Student’s Grandmother testified that, at the end of the ninth grade, she was informed by Elk Grove that Student would be transferred from Laguna Creek to a new high school, Franklin, for the 2002-2003 school year due to a boundary adjustment. Student’s Grandmother testified that she decided not to allow Student to attend Franklin, because of her failing grades and withdrawal from her family. Rather, she and Student’s Aunt agreed to look for appropriate private schools in Elk Grove for Student for the 2002-2003 school year.
Reid Continuation High School, Long Beach Unified School District
In June 2002, Student went to Long Beach to spend the summer with her Aunt. The parents testified that, at the time, their intention was for Student to return in the fall to Elk Grove to attend school. By late August 2002, however, Student’s Grandmother had not found a private school for Student in Elk Grove. In addition, Student’s brother had returned home from Provo Canyon School and Student’s Grandmother was experiencing significant problems with his behavior. The parents were concerned about his potential negative influence on Student and extended Student’s stay with her Aunt in Long Beach on a temporary basis.
On August 28, 2002, Student was enrolled in school in the Long Beach Unified School District. When her Aunt tried to enroll her in a comprehensive high school, she was informed by Long Beach personnel that Student had too many Fs and that she must attend a continuation high school. Student’s Aunt testified that she verbally requested an assessment of Student from Long Beach on several occasions because of Student’s possible learning problems, but that no action was ever taken.
As later described in Student’s Aunt’s letter to the Provo Canyon admissions committee, Student’s behavior changed while in Long Beach: Student transformed “to an out of control, severely depressed, boy crazy teenager,” who “over indulge[d] in make up and oftentimes insist on looking like she just stepped out of a playboy centerfold shoot,” and derived her self-worth from male attention. Student’s Aunt described herself to the Provo Canyon admissions committee as “by all measures a very strict parent” who was in constant conflict with Student regarding her “dress code limitations” and her interest in boys. She also expressed fear that Student would begin to engage in sexual behavior even though the parents had “made it very clear to Student that we were opposed to her dating until she was sixteen years old and even then it would only be allowed under controlled situations.” Student’s Aunt advised the admissions committee that “the reasons often given for her poor [school] performance were things like not turning in her homework....that she has completed the night before but simply neglected to turn in over and over again.”
On October 25, 2002, while at Reid, Student’s fifth-period-teacher, Julie Butler, noticed Student moaning in class and unable to keep her head up. Reid staff discovered that Student was severely intoxicated and had a water bottle with alcohol in her backpack. Student’s Aunt took Student to the hospital where her stomach was pumped. As a result of her intoxication at school, Student was suspended for three or four days, then returned to classes.
Shortly after Student’s drinking episode, the parents increased their efforts to have Student admitted to Provo Canyon School. On October 28, 2002, Student’s Grandmother wrote a three-page letter to the Provo Canyon admissions committee, in which she provided a detailed description of Student’s background and current problems, summarized above. On October 31, 2002, Student’s Aunt faxed a four-page letter to the Provo Canyon admissions committee detailing her concerns about Student, including her self-destructive behavior over the previous six to nine months. Both Student’s Grandmother and Student’s Aunt expressed their conviction that Student would be lost completely without appropriate intervention.
Student’s last day of school at Reid was November 18, 2003. Student’s Long Beach withdrawal record, dated November 25, 2002, indicates that she attended Reid for at least fifty (50) school days at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year. Student’s grades at Reid Continuation High School varied from As to Fs, with lower grades occuring during the second grading cycle. (Footnote 6) Student earned 10.5 credits of the 15 credits attempted and had a GPA of .87. Provo Canyon School On November 19, 2002, Student was placed at Provo Canyon School by her Aunt. Student met with Provo Canyon’s medical director, psychiatrist Dr. Robert Crist, for one to two hours that day for a psychiatric evaluation. (Footnote 7) Dr. Robert Crist described Student as appropriately dressed, with normal facial expression, normal speech and good eye contact. She was cooperative and related to him in a “friendly and trustful way.” He reported that Student’s “thought content revealed no delusions, illusions, hallucinations, perseverations, or obsessions. She denied suicidal thoughts or intent to harm others....Mood was euthymic with a little blunting of affect....Estimated intelligence was in the average range. Judgment was impaired pertaining to substance abuse, family relationships, and motivation for school. Insight was limited.” (Footnote 8)
From the history provided by the family, Dr. Robert Crist concluded that Student “is being sent here to reengage education and to receive treatment in an effort to normalize her relationships and gain self-esteem.” He noted that Student “may have some attachment problems and is highly lacking in self-confidence and mastery.” Dr. Robert Crist’s initial Axis I diagnosis of Student was Oppositional Defiant Disorder [ODD], and “Rule out Reactive Attachment Disorder [RAD] of Early Childhood, Inhibited Type.”
On November 25, 2002, Student was given the Woodcock Johnson III Tests of Achievement and received a standard score (SS) of 107 in broad reading, an SS of 111 in broad written language, and an SS of 90 in broad math. These scores indicated that “when compared to others at her grade level [10.3], Student’s academic skills, her ability to apply those skills, and her fluency with academic tasks are all within the average range.” In addition, her composite score report indicated that “Student’s conversational proficiency seemed typical for her grade level.” That same day, clinical social worker intern Anna McIntire prepared a psychosocial assessment of Student in which she indicated that Student has “done poorly in school. She does not turn her work in, although she appears to be intellectually appropriate for her age. She is capable and has received Bs and B+s in two of her classes; however, in her other classes she is failing for lack of work and effort in class assignments and turning those in....”
On November 27, 2002, Ms. McIntyre prepared a “diagnostic summary” for Student that encompassed all of the written and oral assessments completed by Provo Canyon staff following her admission. The summary identified the “controversy” that led to Student’s admission as follows: “Other than the lack of consistent family communication with her Student’s Aunt, the substance abuse and the alcohol precipitated her admission to Provo Canyon School. Her substance abuse was short term. The patient appears to have a poor self-concept yet has some peer relationships with teens her age. She may be experiencing adjustment issues and a transition between her grandmother, whom she lived with for 14 years. She is now transitioned to live with her aunt at her aunt’s residence in Long Beach, California.” Dr. Robert Crist signed his approval to this diagnostic summary on January 10, 2003.
Ms. McIntyre also prepared a treatment plan with related goals and objectives to address Student’s two main problems: (1) her difficulty accepting the authority of adults, including that of her parents and (2) her “inadequate plans for her future as evidenced by a lack of focus in academic achievement and inadequate discharge and continuing care plans.” Student’s goals were to “demonstrate an ability and willingness to comply with societal expectations at the treatment milieu and in the home” after discharge and, to “establish continuing care plans which are likely to result in a safe and productive lifestyle... [and] demonstrate academic performance which is commensurate with her estimated ability.” Student’s treatment plan involved weekly individual therapy to “focus on treatment for oppositional and defiant behavior; low self-concept.” Family therapy was recommended once a week. Student was involved in several group therapy sessions, recreational group therapy, and a nutrition therapy group. Student’s Individual Treatment Plan (ITP), prepared by Dr. Robert Crist on December 20, 2002, was signed by Student and AUNT in January 2003.
Student was admitted to Provo Canyon as an “intensive treatment” patient, as required by Student’s Aunt’s medical insurance. (Footnote 9) As an intensive patient, Student received more individual therapy, between three and four hours of group therapy each week, and family therapy that involved both Student’s Grandmother and her Aunt on the telephone. In addition, Student’s treatment team from her academic, therapeutic, psychiatric, and residential program components met and reviewed her status and progress in the program on a weekly basis. Student was also seen by Dr. Robert Crist on a weekly basis to determine her need for medication. Student’s primary therapist at Provo Canyon from November 2002 through mid-May 2003 was Adrianna Ottonelli.
Request for Assessment by Elk Grove Unified School District
On January 24, 2003, Student’s Grandmother submitted a letter to Elk Grove’s director of special education, William Tollestrup, requesting an educational and psychological assessment of Student. Student’s Grandmother signed the District’s assessment plan on February 12, 2003.
On March 13, 2003, Student left Provo Canyon School to fly to California for her assessment. On March 14, 2003, Student’s Grandmother brought Student to the Elk Grove office of district school psychologist Robbie Henle. Ms. Henle spoke briefly to Student’s Grandmother and gave her three parent rating scales to complete: the Behavior Assessment System for Children- Parent Form (BASC), the Differential Test of Conduct and Emotion, and the Behavior Evaluation Scale (BES). Student’s Grandmother left the office to complete these scales while Student was being assessed. Ms. Henle spent a total of two hours informally interviewing Student in conjunction with the administration of the following assessment instruments: the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning-Memory Screening Index (WRAML), the Bender Test of Visual-Motor Functioning (VMI), the BASC-Self Report, the Connors-Wells’ Self Report Scale, the Adolescent Psychopathology Scale (APS), and the Reynold’s Suicide Ideation Questionnaire, Form HS (RSIQ). During the assessment, Student told Ms. Henle that she lived in Long Beach with her Aunt in the fall of 2002 and attended Reid High School. This statement caused Elk Grove to question whether it was Student’s district of residence. (Footnote 10)
At the end of the assessment, Student’s Grandmother returned the completed rating scales. Ms. Henle did not interview Student’s Grandmother and had no contact with Student’s Aunt. On March 15, 2003, Student’s Grandmother typed a nine-page letter to Ms. Henle detailing Student’s background and history for Ms. Henle’s consideration in the assessment. In addition to information previously provided to the Provo Canyon admissions committee, Student’s Grandmother described Student’s inconsolable grief when left by her foster mother and her difficulty in bonding with family and friends, her unusual behavior of never making eye contact with her math teacher at HEMS, and her action of writing and hiding a suicide note and stating on several occasions that she did not deserve to live or to be a part of a family.
From her assessment, Ms. Henle concluded that Student did not satisfy any of the criteria for eligibility as a Student with an emotional disturbance. She reported that Student does “experience difficulties which are acknowledged both by this IEP team and by staff at Provo Canyon. These difficulties do not meet the level of severity required to meet educational code criteria as a Student with emotional disturbance.” Ms. Henle stated that Student “is currently demonstrating that she is able to make expected progress in school, given appropriate levels of structure and guidance,” and that such strategies could be devised within a non-special-education school setting.
Student returned to Provo Canyon School on March 14, 2003. A week after her assessment, on March 21, 2003, Dr. Robert Crist met with Student and indicated in his progress notes that she “has shown increased anxiety and is depressed.” He began Student on an anti-depressant medication, Lexapro 10 mg.
In late March or early April 2003, Student’s Aunt’s insurance coverage for Student was exhausted and she assumed full financial responsibility for the cost of Student’s treatment at Provo Canyon School. Tensions between the parents and Student’s therapist, Adrianna Ottonelli, erupted. The parents testified that Ms. Ottonelli was not very experienced or helpful in family therapy. In Student’s Aunt’s view, Ms. Ottonelli used inappropriate therapeutic interventions and she persistently failed to obtain a diagnosis and treatment plan for Student. (Footnote 11) Ms. Ottonelli testified that Student’s Aunt became increasingly rude and confrontational with her over the need to obtain funding from the District for Student’s treatment until Ms. Ottonelli asked to be reassigned.
On April 11, 2003, Petitioner filed a request for a due process hearing against Elk Grove. Petitioner also made a written request to Mr. Tollestrup for Elk Grove to assume funding Student’s placement at Provo Canyon School on May 1, 2003.
On April 28, 2003, Elk Grove convened an initial IEP meeting for Student. At the IEP team meeting for the District were program specialist Phyllis Ramsey, lead resource specialist program (RSP) teacher Shirley Sekeres, school psychologist Robbi Henle, and attorney Jack Clarke. None of Student’s general education teachers from the District was present. Provo Canyon’s special education coordinator, Kathy Jo Smith, and Student’s psychotherapist, Adrianna Ottonelli, as well as her supervisor, Mr. Blackburn, were present on the telephone for a portion of the IEP meeting. Student’s Grandmother, paralegal Ellen Kramer, and Petitioner’s attorney, Perry Leonard, were present at the IEP meeting for the family.
At the April 28, 2003 IEP meeting, the IEP team members received approximately 400 pages of documents from Provo Canyon for the first time (District Ex. 18). These records indicated that Student lived in Long Beach with her Aunt. Mr. Clarke expressed Elk Grove’s concern about whether Student was currently a resident of the District, and stated that Provo Canyon documents reinforced this concern. The IEP team agreed to complete the meeting to determine Student’s eligibility for special education with the understanding that the District disputed her residency and would likely forward the results of the meeting to the Long Beach Unified School District for its consideration. District members of the IEP team then concluded, consistent with Ms. Henle’s assessment, that Student did not meet the eligibility criteria for ED. Student’s Grandmother disagreed with this determination.
On May 7, 2003, Dr. Robert Crist changed Student’s Axis I diagnoses to major depression, single episode, moderate, and oppositional defiant disorder. He also increased Student’s Lexapro dosage to 20 mg. a day.
On May 10 and 24, 2003, Student was assessed for approximately eight hours by Provo Canyon clinical psychologist Dr. Alan Crist “due to requirements from her school district in California as well as some questions from her therapist regarding reactive attachment disorder.” Dr. Alan Crist assessed Student’s personality integration with the Sentence Completion test, the Millon Adolescent Clinical Inventory (MACI), and the Rorschach Inkblot Test. He also administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC-III). Student appeared very “motivated to please the examiner,” and had good eye contact. Dr. Alan Crist reported that Student gave “the impression of being somewhat superficial in her affect and tended to deny negative feelings.” She repeatedly made references to the importance of focusing on positive topics.
Dr. Alan Crist’s diagnostic impression was that Student “probably does have some reactive attachment issues, in that she appears to be quite insecurely attached to her aunt. In addition, she appears predisposed to significant underlying depression. ...” From this evaluation, he recommended that Student (1) learn the value of self-awareness, to identify her needs and feelings, and learn to express those to important people in her life, and (2) develop improved social skills. He reported that Student “is able to relate to others superficially, but she does so in a way that is always seeking approval and attention rather than a mutual relationship.”
On June 12, 2003, the due process hearing convened on the issue of residence. During the week of June 20, 2003, Petitioner contracted with Dr. Merz and registered psychological assistant, Todd Koch, Ph.D., to conduct an assessment of her to be completed for the due process hearing, scheduled to recommence on July 24, 2003.
On July 2, 2003, Dr. Todd Koch, Ph.D., met with and assessed Student at Provo Canyon School. Dr. Koch also spoke to Student’s teachers and her current therapist, Marc Barney, who had begun working with Student in late May 2003. As part of his evaluation, Dr. Koch administered to Student the Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence (WASI). In his July 14, 2003 assessment report, Dr. Koch diagnosed Student with (1) reactive attachment disorder of infancy or early childhood, inhibited type (RAD), (2) major depressive disorder, recurrent, moderate, with atypical features, in partial remission, and (3) a mathematics disorder. Dr. Koch recommended that Student continue receiving treatment in a highly structured, therapy-intensive, residential facility such as Provo Canyon School and that she should be involved in intensive out-patient psychotherapy to address issues of self-worth and depression, with medication supervision, and social skills training when she returns home.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “child with a disability” is a child with mental retardation, hearing impairments, speech or language impairments, visual impairments, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairments, or specific learning disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A). As previously discussed, Petitioner stipulated at the commencement of the hearing on substantive issues that she is not contesting her eligibility as a Student with a specific learning disability. Accordingly, the sole eligibility issue is whether she should have been determined eligible for special education as a Student with an emotional disturbance from the 2000-2001 school year to the present.
ISSUE NO. I: From the 2000-2001 school year to the present, should Student have been identified as eligible for special education and related services as a Student with an emotional disturbance (ED)?
A student meets the eligibility criteria for emotional disturbance (ED) when, due to an emotional disturbance, he or she exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect his or her educational performance:
(A) An inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (B) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.
(C) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. California regulations add that any inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances must be “exhibited in several situations.” Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 5 § 3030(i)(3). (D) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
(E) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i); Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 5, § 3030(i). A student does not meet special education eligibility criteria as ED if he or she is “socially maladjusted,” unless it is determined that the student has an emotional disturbance. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(ii). For example, a diagnosis of oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) and ED are not mutually exclusive, and students with an ODD diagnosis, like Student, may also satisfy the educational criteria of ED if it is determined that they are emotionally disturbed.
In this case, Student argues that she has had an emotional disturbance at all times from the 2000-2001 school year to the present because she was diagnosed in July 2003 with reactive attachment disorder (RAD) of infancy or early childhood, inhibited type, by her independent assessor, Dr. Koch, and because Dr. Robert Crist diagnosed her with major depression in May 2003 and Dr. Koch diagnosed her with major depressive disorder, recurrent, moderate, with atypical features, in partial remission, in July 2003. In Student’s view, she exhibited characteristics (A) through (D) of the above eligibility criteria over a long period of time and to a marked degree and these characteristics adversely affected her education from the 2000-2001 school year to the present.
The Hearing Officer notes that substantial evidence was presented at the hearing regarding reactive attachment disorder or RAD, including whether and to what degree it was manifested in Student. As indicated in a scholarly article cited by Dr. Koch in his assessment report, attachment problems are exhibited in a graded continuum, with RAD recognized as the most severe form of psychopathology in terms of attachment disturbances. Attachment Disorders: Review and Current Status, Samantha Wilson, Vol. 135, No. 1, Journal of Psychology, January 2001, 40, 42, 44 [criticizing the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders - Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) RAD criteria as allowing such a “diagnosis only in extreme cases of attachment disturbances.”]. (Footnote 12) In addition, according to the DSM-IV, RAD “appears to be very uncommon,” and persists throughout an individual’s life because it “typically remains impervious to traditional treatment methods.” DSM-IV at 117. The controversy regarding whether Student had reactive attachment issues of a sufficient severity to establish a RAD diagnosis under the DSM-IV was fueled by the fact that Provo Canyon staff never made that diagnosis in the ten months they had to observe and evaluate Student after Dr. Robert Crist’s diagnosis to “rule out” RAD and that Dr. Koch was able to make the diagnosis following a day at Provo Canyon and two hours with Student.
It is well-established that a diagnosis of an emotional disturbance under the DSM-IV alone does not mandate a finding of eligibility as emotionally disturbed under special education laws. Dr. Koch acknowledged that a diagnosis of RAD does not mandate a finding of eligibility under special education laws. He testified that, in his opinion, Student met the ED eligibility criteria due to her RAD because, as a consequence of this emotional disturbance, she is not able to build or maintain satisfactory relationships and she exhibits inappropriate behaviors or feelings of withdrawal, isolation, immaturity and avoidance of any strong emotion. Dr. Koch also testified that Student exhibits a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression due to these diagnosed conditions.
The Hearing Officer will now examine whether Student exhibited one or more of these ED characteristics during the years at issue to a marked degree and for a long time.
A. Does Student Have an Inability to Learn Which Cannot Be Explained by Intellectual, Sensory, or Health Factors?
Student contends that she fits precisely into this criterion. In her view, this conclusion is supported by her poor grades during each of the years at issue, her intellectual capacity to perform grade level work, teacher testimony that she appeared to be trying to do her work in class, and, particularly, her failing grades and declining SAT-9 scores in the ninth grade.
Elk Grove asserts that Student does not demonstrate an inability to learn as intended by this criterion. It argues that Student’s poor grades throughout middle school and in ninth grade are more a reflection of her poor work production, as evidenced by her failure to do her homework consistantly, than an inability to learn.
Eighth Grade: 2000-2001 School Year
As evidence of Student’s inability to learn, Student’s Grandmother testified that Student was overwhelmed by the transition to middle school. When Student’s Grandmother tried to help her with homework, Student would “shut down” and refuse to talk to her about it. If Student’s Grandmother demanded that Student work on her homework, Student would say “I can’t do it, I can’t understand!” According to Student’s Grandmother, Student would allow her brother to help her.
However, the evidence persuasively establishes that, during the 2000-2001 school year at HEMS, Student did not have an inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory or health factors.
In the eighth grade, with the exception of mathematics, Student received all passing grades in her final report card issued in June 2001. As to mathematics, it is apparent that Student has struggled in this area throughout the years at issue and the evidence strongly suggests that Student has a mathematics disability. (Footnote 13) As previously discussed, this is not an issue for this hearing (see: footnote 3, supra). In addition, the evidence established that Student was not turning in her homework. Student’s school counselor, Ms. Nelson, testified that she had teacher meetings on a weekly basis to discuss why Students on her caseload were failing. She was advised by Student’s teachers that Student was not turning in her homework and was not paying attention in class. In her opinion, Student did not have an inability to learn. Ms. Nelson’s testimony that Student’s poor grades were related to her lack of effort is supported by her notes made during counseling sessions with Student. For example, during a counseling session on January 19, 2001, Ms. Nelson noted that Student was turning in her science assignments and understanding it better. On March 5, 2001, Ms. Nelson met with Student about her failing grades in science and social studies. She noted that Student did not read her social studies book, and stated that she did not understand science. In her final grading period in June 2001, however, Student had increased her science grade to a C- and raised her humanities grade to either a C+ or a B. (Footnote 14) While Student’s grades were concerning, Ms. Nelson testified that they were not unusual, particularly as she had both high and low grades. Similarly, Ms. Nelson testified that Student’s wide range of scores on the SAT 9 tests was an indication that she has the ability to learn. For example, on the March 2001 SAT 9, Student’s reading vocabulary decreased but her reading comprehension increased; her spelling dropped from 86 to a 66 NPR, but her language mechanics increased from a 33 to a 67 NPR.
HEMS resource specialist program (RSP) teacher Cheryl Chargin testified that she worked with RSP Students in Student’s classes during both her seventh and eighth grade year. Ms. Chargin testified that to avoid stigmatizing RSP Students in class, she worked with regular education Students as well. In this context, Ms. Chargin testified that she observed and interacted with Student on a daily basis. In addition, Student was one of the regular education Students who volunteered in her reading class to help Ms. Chargin work with a student who had severe reading difficulties. According to Ms. Chargin, Student was a good reader, even though her teacher said some of Student’s grades were not good. Ms. Chargin testified that, in her opinion, Student did not have an inability to learn, and there was no reason to have considered her for special education.
The Hearing Officer gives great weight to Ms. Nelson’s testimony because she had extensive interaction with Student during her seventh and eighth grade years at HEMS, both as her counselor and, in eighth grade, as a facilitator of a girls’ social skills group Student participated in on a weekly basis over a period of approximately three months, In addition, Ms. Chargin’s testimony is entitled to weight in light of her frequent observation of Student and her knowledge and experience as a special educator.
Ninth Grade: 2001-2002 School Year
Student’s grades during her ninth grade at Laguna Creek High School (LCHS) were described by Dr. Koch as “abysmal.” Student’s Grandmother testified that, once Student entered ninth grade at LCHS, she “crashed and burned.”
As discussed above, the evidence established that Student does not meet this eligibility criterion in the specific area of mathematics because she has an mathematics disorder. Excluding her failing grades in her year-long ninth grade algebra course, the record demonstrates that Student’s grades declined over the course of the ninth grade. In October 2001, Student received a C+ in art, a C- in English, a D+ in English review, and a D in creative writing. In January 2002, she received a D in physical education, a D- in computer technology, an an F in general science. In March 2002, Student received a D in health, a D- in English, and an F in art. In June 2002, Student received a pass in advocacy, a D+ in physical education, a no-pass in community service, and Fs in world geography and general science.
The District called Student’s algebra teacher, Mr. Marks, and three of Student’s other ninth grade teachers as witnesses. As discussed below, the testimony of these three teachers established that Student’s worsening grades were due to her failure to do her homework rather than an inability to learn.
For example, Carol Decoux-Lantay testified that she taught the ninth grade computer technology class at LCHS in which Student received 59.27% of the total points possible and a D- for the course. Ms. Lantay testified that the work Student did for the class was acceptable; however, she had numerous missed assignments. Student did not turn them in despite repeated notice of which assignments were missing and the opportunity to turn them in at any time during the class. Ms. Lantay testified that she keeps each Student’s computer file and that she reviewed Student’s computer file in preparation for her testimony. During this review, Ms. Lantay discovered several assignments that Student had completed or partially completed but had not turned in for credit. Ms. Lantay reviewed these assignments using her standard grading rubric and determined that Student would have received a course grade of C- if she had turned in this work. In her opinion, Student was more than capable of learning and none of the assignments she turned in showed a lack of understanding.
Ms. Lantay’s opinion that Student did not have an inability to learn is reinforced by Student’s Aunt’s testimony, in which she affirmed her statement to the Provo Canyon admissions committee that she “cannot accept the fact that Student is without the ability to perform standard task[s] due to the fact that she shows high levels of attentiveness and ability when she is doing something she likes. She can sit at a computer screen for hours and program it like a college-trained programmer. She shows high levels in writing efficiency and poetry and does well in this subject academically because she chooses to do so. She will even do well in all her subjects long enough to get the attention off her back.” It is clear from this statement that Student was able to demonstrate the computer skills learned in Ms. Lantay’s class despite her poor grade.
LCHS English teacher Rodney DeLuca testified that he taught Student for two terms during the ninth grade and that she was easy to remember because the class had a ratio of 20:1 and she sat close to him. Although Student received a C- the first term, her grade dropped to a D- in the third term. Mr. DeLuca testified that this lower grade was due to Student’s inconsistency on homework and poor test grades. Mr. DeLuca testified that Student generally gave content-appropriate answers even if she did not know the specific answer and that she seemed to be learning. Mr. DeLuca also concurred with Student’s Aunt’s statement regarding Student’s high levels of attentiveness and ability when doing something she liked. In his experience, Student was selective in doing some assignments and not others. Mr. DeLuca described Student’s written language ability as grade appropriate for the ninth grade. She was able to express herself, to write complete sentences, paragraphs and essays. Mr. DeLuca concluded that Student’s academic problem was the result of her inconsistency in turning in her homework and coming to unprepared rather than her ability to learn.
Similarly, Student demonstrated her ability to learn in Mr. Myers’ world geography class at the end of the ninth grade at LCHS, despite the fact that she received a failing grade. Mr. Myers testified candidly that he had no recollection of Student and remembered her only after seeing her yearbook photograph and reviewing his grade book for the 2001-2002 school year. He testified that Student received an F based on her test grades in the sixty to sixty-sixth percentile and poor homework completion, and that her grades were consistent with not turning in a large portion of her homework. Based on his review of Student’s grades as recorded in his grade book, however, Mr. Myers testified that Student was able to do satisfactory work. Student completed one project that had to be presented to the class: she prepared and presented a poster on culture and family, and received an A or a B on this assignment.
The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of Ms. Decoux-Lantay, Mr. DeLuca, and Mr. Myers is persuasive and entitled to considerable weight. Specifically, Ms. Decoux-Lantay’s testimony and actual work samples from Student’s computer file demonstrating her use of powerpoint, word processing, and spreadsheets graphically illustrates a Student who was interested in computers, enjoyed designing web pages, and was able to perform the required work. Mr. DeLuca’s testimony was strongly persuasive in light of his clear recollection of Student, his contact with her over two quarters, and his fifteen years of teaching experience. While Mr. Myers’ memory of Student was admittedly poor, his specific example of her above-average ability on a classroom project recorded in his grade book persuasively established that Student had an ability to learn and to perform when she desired. By contrast, Dr. Merz testified that a Student with average intellectual capacity like Student who does not achieve passing grades can be demonstrating an inability to learn based upon an emotional disturbance at that time. Dr. Merz also testified that it would be important to have a better picture of the Student, for example, by talking to her teachers. Dr. Merz further testified that passive-aggressive behavior can be a serious problem in a Student that can affect his/her ability to learn. Dr. Koch also testified that he had never spoken to any of Student’s teachers at Elk Grove and that, in his opinion, Student’s emotional disturbances only “intermittently” affected her ability to learn. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer gives his testimony much less weight.
Petitioner argued that her decline in SAT 9 scores demonstrated that she had an inability to learn arising from her emotional disturbances. Student’s March 2002 ninth grade SAT 9 composite scores declined from the previous year in both total reading in which she scored at the 26 NPR (-9) and total written language at which she scored at the 38 NPR (-17). Student also exhibited a decrease in other skill areas on the ninth grade SAT 9 as compared to her scores on the eighth grade SAT 9. For example, in reading comprehension, she fell from an NPR of 46 to NPR of 29 [-17]; in spelling, she fell from NPR 86 to NPR 66 [-20]; in language mechanics, she fell from 67 NPR to 47 NPR [-20]; in language expression, she fell from 42 NPR to 32 NPR [-10]. Student increased her ranking in reading vocabulary from NPR 21 to NPR 26 [+5]. Dr. Koch testified that these scores indicate that Student did not keep pace with her peers.
Former District lead RSP teacher Shirley Sekeres testified that an “inability to learn” would be established by an inability across all academic domains and subject areas. In addition, she testified that the average range on the SAT 9 is 45 to 55; 38 is low average. Ms. Sekeres’ testimony was uncontradicted on these points. Applying these ranges to Student’s scores, in March 2002, despite her decline in scores, Student had average SAT 9 scores in the areas of spelling (66 NPR) and language mechanics (47), and a low average score in total language (38). In addition, as a ninth-grader, Student was tested for the first time in a new subject area. Ms. Sekeres testified that Student’s social studies score of 50 NPR is within the average range and indicates that she can read and comprehend information in the subject area.
From the above testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that Student did not have an inability to learn during the ninth grade, despite her poor educational performance as reflected in her grades. In addition, while Student’s SAT 9 scores are certainly concerning, the Hearing Officer finds that, because Student had high average as well as below average SAT 9 scores, these SAT 9 scores do not establish an inability to learn during the ninth grade. When viewed in light of her grades, it is apparent that Student did not keep pace with her peers because she did not do her work and not because she had an inability to learn.
Tenth Grade, 2002-2003 School Year, to Present
The Hearing Officer finds that Student did not have an inability to learn during the 2002-2003 school year and that she does not have a present inability to learn. As previously discussed, the evidence established that Student does not meet this eligibility criterion in the specific area of mathematics because she has an mathematics disorder.
First, Student did not demonstrate an inability to learn while attending Reid Continuation High School in Long Beach at the beginning of her tenth grade year. Student’s transcript from Reid reflects grades ranging from A to F. The testimony of Reid’s world history teacher, Mr. Meade, established that Student was able to learn in his class, that she earned a B, but that she was not academically challenged. Mr. Meade conceded that the curriculum in his class was not at grade level. The testimony of Reid’s physical science teacher, Julie Butler, established that Student did her work and was capable, but did not turn it in. Ms. Butler testified that, prior to her drinking episode, Student told Ms. Butler that her Aunt told her she would be sent to Provo Canyon if she did not “shape up.” After her drinking episode, Student advised Ms. Butler she would not turn in any more homework because she was definitely being sent to Provo Canyon. (Footnote 15) Student received an A in Ms. Butler’s class the first time and an F in the class the second time [see footnote 6, supra]. It is clear from Ms. Butler’s testimony that Student’s F grade was the consequence of not turning in homework, not an inability to learn.
Second, Provo Canyon records and testimony of its staff confirm that Student’s academic problems were consistently identified as attributable to her lack of school effort rather than any inability to learn. As reflected in the November 2002 Woodcock Johnson III achievement scores, Student’s academic skills, her ability to apply those skills, and her fluency with academic tasks were all within the average range compared to other students at her 10.3 grade level. Further, as indicated in the testimony of Provo Canyon special education coordinator, Kathy Jo Smith, Student fit the profile of the type of Student Provo Canyon likes to work with because she was capable, at or near grade level, but not succeeding. Student’s grades at Provo Canyon School up to the April 28, 2003 IEP team meeting again ranged from As to Fs. Ms. Smith testified that, as summarized in her April 25, 2003 academic report prepared for the IEP team meeting, the general consensus of Student’s Provo Canyon teachers was as follows: Student is a “capable Student who often acts helpless and needy. Her assignments are turned in late 50% of the time. She does get her late assignments turned in, [but] the cycle of turning assignments in late is causing her test scores to be low.....” As indicated by Ms. Smith’s testimony, Student’s pattern of turning in homework assignments late resulted in a cycle of inability to complete her present assignments and to understand her present schoolwork. Ms. Smith also testified that Student was improving academically because she was failing fewer classes.
Ms. Smith and other Provo Canyon staff testified that Provo Canyon does not determine a Student’s eligibility for special education services under the IDEA. Nonetheless, when asked about specific ED eligibility criteria, these witnesses expressed differing opinions. Ms. Smith testified that Student does have an inability to learn because she is capable but for some reason is not performing. By contrast, Dr. Alan Crist testified that he was not aware of any difficulties Student had with learning. The Hearing Officer finds support for Dr. Alan Crist’s conclusion that Student does not have an inability to learn in the academic progress reports regularly prepared by Provo Canyon teachers. For example, on January 21, 2003, although Student turned in only twenty percent of her literature assignments, she received one hundred percent on those that were turned in and sixty-three to one hundred percent on her biology assignments. Student’s acknowledged fluctuation in motivation to perform her school work does not establish that she has an inability to learn.
From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that Student does not fit the ED eligibility category as a Student who has an inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors from 2000-2001 school year to the present.
B. Does Student Have an Inability to Build or Maintain Satisfactory Interpersonal Relationships With Peers And Teachers?
Although Student makes no specific argument in her closing brief, she generally asserts that she meets this eligibility requirement. Her position as developed in witness testimony at the hearing was that she did not have friendships and became increasingly isolated over time. Student’s Grandmother testified that Student did not socialize after school, came home and went right into her bedroom, particularly in the ninth grade, and had only one long-time friend, who initiated most of their contact. Student’s Aunt testified that, particularly in the summer of 2002, Student stopped interacting with the children of family friends she had previously enjoyed and became increasingly isolated. Petitioner attributed her relationship inabilities to her RAD.
Dr. Koch testified that an inability to build or maintain relationships is inherent in the reactive attachment disorder (RAD) he diagnosed in Student. As indicated by the DSM-IV, the “essential feature” of RAD is “markedly disturbed and developmentally inappropriate social relatedness in most contexts that begins before age 5 years and is associated with grossly pathological care....that may take the form of persistent disregard of the child’s basic emotional needs for comfort, stimulation, and affection;..[or] of the child’s basic physical needs; or repeated changes of primary caregiver that prevent formation of stable attachments (e.g., frequent changes in foster care)....The pathological care is presumed to be responsible for the disturbed social relatedness.” In the inhibited type, the child with RAD “persistently fails to initiate and to respond to most social interactions in a developmentally appropriate way...[and] shows a pattern of excessively inhibited, hypervigilant, or highly ambivalent responses (e.g. frozen watchfulness, resistance to comfort, or a mixture of approach and avoidance).” Dr. Koch testified that Student probably had RAD from the moment she was placed in her parents’ care and that she fit the inhibited type due to her isolativeness. He also testified that Student was not an accurate self-reporter and would try to tell people what she thought they wanted to hear. In his opinion, Student’s poor grades were caused by a combination of depression and her inability to form relationships with her peers, teachers, and parents, which he attributed to RAD.
The District argues that there was ample evidence of Student’s peer and teacher relationships during eighth and ninth grades. In addition, District school psychologist Robbi Henle, concluded that Student did not have an “inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers” because she “adequately describes friendships which existed both prior to and during her stay at Provo Canyon School. She had a steady boyfriend at Reid...in Long Beach. Current and previous teachers describe Student as having appropriate interactions with both peers and teachers. She is described as being sometimes quiet in class, but does participate in class discussions.”
Eighth Grade: 2000-2001 School Year
The Hearing Officer finds more than sufficient evidence to establish that Student had satisfactory relationships in eighth grade at the District’s HEMS.
First, the evidence established that Student had satisfactory relationships with peers at HEMS. According to Ms. Nelson, in the two years she worked with her, Student did not have an inability in the area of relationships. Ms. Nelson testified that Student had a group of friends with whom she interacted regularly and she was well-liked even though she was shy. In addition, Student was in Ms. Nelson’s social skills group of girls with D and F grades. The main purpose of this group was to work on improving grades and doing homework; however, Ms. Nelson also worked with the girls on social skills such as how friends get along. Ms. Nelson testified that, while Student was one of the least vocal girls in this group, she participated in the games and was liked by the girls. Ms. Nelson testified that Student was involved in many typical middle school girl behaviors such as sharing gossip and rumors. During the eighth grade, Student initiated an “incident report” in which she expressed her concern about another Student who was gossiping and calling a third Student a bad name. Student was also involved in several “peer conflict management agreements,” in which she and other girls involved agreed to be friends, to problem solve, and to not tell other people secrets they had shared with each other. These documents indicate that Student had friends at school and that she was interested in and able to work on improving her relationships with them. In addition, former HEMS instructional aide Mary Swanson testified that she worked with two special education Students in Mr. Murdock’s math class, and in this context, saw Student in the math class one hour every other day. In her observation, Student was engaged in typical behavior for an eighth grade girl. For example, Student and two other girls sat together, appeared to be friends, and passed notes during class. Mr. Murdock recalled that Student was “kind of talkative” to one girl and they seemed to be friends. In addition, District RSP teacher, Ms. Chargin, testified that she observed Student regularly in class and that Student was “buds” with a Student on her caseload.
Second, the evidence also established that Student had appropriate relationships with adults at HEMS. In Ms. Nelson’s opinion, Student had a good relationship with her and would voluntarily approach her with questions and concerns about her grades and school activities. One example of Student’s relationship with Ms. Nelson occurred after Ms. Nelson received a letter from Student’s Grandmother, in which she expressed her concern about Student’s “negative habit” of being tardy for school. Student’s Grandmother advised Ms. Nelson that she would no longer support this behavior and that she wanted Student to suffer whatever consequences were involved for tardiness to school. Ms. Nelson testified that, after this letter, Student would act “silly” and smilingly show herself so Ms. Nelson could see she was at school on time. Both Ms. Swanson and Mr. Murdock testified that Student had an appropriate relationship with her Mr. Murdock.
In this case, the weight of the evidence established that, while Student is a quiet and shy Student, she had a group of friends at HEMS, she was able to maintain a relationship with Ms. Nelson over a two-year period, she was responsive to her teachers, and she participated in class group activities and discussions.
Ninth Grade: 2001-2002 School Year
Student’s teachers in the ninth grade at Laguna Creek High School (LCHS) generally testified that she was fairly quiet, polite, participated in small groups, and was responsive to questions posed to her. They also testified to observing Student talk to one or two female friends before and after class. The evidence established that, while Student did not have close relationships with her counselor or her teachers at Laguna Creek High School, she became more social with her peers in ninth grade at LCHS.
Student’s ability to build and maintain relationships with peers in the ninth grade was demonstrated by Student’s Grandmother’s own testimony about Student’s troubling behavior in the ninth grade. According to Student’s Grandmother, Student began ninth grade with good attendance, but toward the end of ninth grade, she started cutting class midday during her third through fifth periods. LCHS counselor Ms. Nguyen testified that Student’s pattern of tardies was consistent with visiting other Students after lunch hour. In addition, as indicated in Student’s Grandmother’s description of Student’s concerning behavior at home, Student had made friends with both girls and boys at school whom she tried to meet after school without parental knowledge or permission.
Student’s relationships with peers is also reflected in her own writings contained in her computer file in Ms. Lantay’s class. For example, on Nov. 27, 2001, Student wrote a two-page description of her Thanksgiving holiday that was very positive in tone and included her comment that “I’m a teen and half the time I only want to talk to or be around teens and not have to deal with people over 25 for some strange reason.” Student also gave thanks for “all my friends and most of all my good friend ..., who was always there for me and alway helped me out whenever I needed him.” In her final exam power point presentations in Ms. Lantay’s computer class, Student wrote, “over the year, there is a numerous amount of drama in all my friends lives. They seem to surpass that drama over to me and I get caught up in flow less games, but I get out without a scratch.”
To demonstrate this ED characteristic, Student must have an inability to build or maintain relationships with peers and teachers. This is a high standard to meet because it requires that Student’s difficulties with relationships be with both peers and teachers. Although there is little evidence to demonstrate that Student had a satisfactory relationship with a particular ninth grade teacher, Student was described as responsive to her teachers in ninth grade, and able to participate in class activities and discussions. In this case, however, the weight of the evidence established that Student did build and maintain friendships with both girls and boys at school and that her attempt to expand these friendships outside of school created tensions with her family. In addition, Petitioner did not dispute that she had a long-term relationship with at least one girl who lived close to her. Accordingly, because the evidence demonstrated that Student was able to build or maintain relationships with peers, she does not meet this eligibility criterion.
Tenth Grade, 2002-2003 School Year, to Present
Although Student was on the Reid campus for only fifty days, the testimony of Mr. Meade persuasively established that Student did begin to develop friendships at school. Mr. Meade described observing Student laugh and interact with other Students on the campus. In addition, the testimony of both Mr. Meade and Ms. Butler established that Student had appropriate relationships with her teachers. For example, even though Ms. Butler described Student as very shy, she testified that Student was able to speak to her about her family’s plan to send her to Provo Canyon School.
Since her admission to Provo Canyon, Student’s interactions with peers has been recorded and described in weekly progress notes detailing her participation with other group members and in weekly progress notes from her residential living unit. The general impression from these reports is that Student has been and remains a quiet individual, that she initially did not involve herself to the level of self-disclosure and honesty expected within the therapeutic mileau, but that she has been able to engage and has increasingly participated in group therapy by talking and sharing her experiences with peers. For example, Student’s former therapist, Ms. Ottonelli, described her as having primitive communication skills and not trusting anyone when she first came to Provo Canyon School. On April 18, 2003, Ms. Ottonelli described a “tremendous change” in Student, who “was so supportive, positive and open with her peers to help her to change.” Ms. Ottonelli also testified that Student was able to relate well to her before the dispute erupted with her parents and they requested a new therapist. In Ms. Ottonelli’s opinion, at that point, Student had to pick sides. Given the conflict between the parents and Ms. Ottonelli, and Ms. Ottonelli’s obvious distress in testifying, the Hearing Officer reviewed Ms. Ottonelli’s testimony with some caution; however, the Hearing Officer finds that her testimony is entitled to weight on these points in light of her supporting progress notes. In addition, Student’s current therapist Marc Barney describes her as kind to others, interacting with peers but without any close friends. Given the unusual circumstance of being placed in a highly structured “24/7" residential facility with students who have difficult behaviors and where high expectations have been placed on her, the Hearing Officer finds that Student has established appropriate relationships with staff and that her relationships with peers are developing. (Footnote 16) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Student did not have an inability to build or maintain satisfactory relationships with peers and teachers from the 2002-2003 school year to the present.
Furthermore, the evidence does not support the conclusion that Student’s attachment issues are as severe as the reactive attachment disorder (RAD) diagnosed by Dr. Koch. Since November 2002, Student has been placed in a Level 14 residential placement with highly trained psychological and psychiatric personnel who were well aware of Dr. Robert Crist’s November 19, 2002 “rule out RAD” diagnosis. Within this facility, Student has been closely observed, and, at least until March 2003, reviewed on a weekly basis by a treatment team that included staff from the residential, academic, therapeutic, medical/psychiatric components of her program. Provo Canyon staff has collectively spent thousands of hours observing and interacting with Student, with knowledge that additional information was necessary before determining whether Student did or did not have RAD. Dr. Robert Crist testified that Provo Canyon has made no firm diagnosis of RAD for Student in the nearly ten months she has been in placement, that the RAD diagnosis given to her by Dr. Koch was “very debatable,” and that most individuals who have this disorder are much more severe than Student. In his opinion, based on her history, Student probably has some difficulty in forming secure attachments, but she does not have a severe attachment disorder. In addition, after he spent eight hours interviewing Student in May 2003, Dr. Alan Crist concluded only that she probably had “some” attachment issues because she appeared to be “quite insecurely attached to her aunt.” By contrast, Dr. Koch only spent two hours interviewing Student and was not aware of Student’s conflicts with her aunt, the no-dating rule, Student’s Aunt’s self-characterization as a “very strict parent,” or other defiant behaviors that led to Student’s conflicts at home and supported her diagnosis as ODD. Dr. Koch testified that he was not aware of Student’s treatment plan at Provo Canyon, and had reviewed only limited documents from Provo Canyon. In addition, although Dr. Merz testified that the RAD diagnosis was “tenable,” he was unfamiliar with many of the documents and records from Provo Canyon. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of Dr. Koch and Dr. Merz on the severity of Student’s attachment issues is entitled to much less weight. The Hearing Officer concludes that any inability Student has to build or maintain relationships with peers and teachers is not of a “marked degree” required to establish eligibility as a student with an ED for special education.
C. Does Student Have Inappropriate Types of Behavior or Feelings under Normal Circumstances?
As previously discussed, Student’s parents testified that she exhibited unusual behaviors of increasing withdrawal and unwillingness to participate in activities and failure to make eye contact. The parents also described behaviors involving lying and/or sneaking out of the house to meet friends, go to a party without approval, or to talk to a boy on the telephone. In addition, Student’s Aunt testified about unusual behaviors relating to Student’s dress and hygiene while in Long Beach in 2002. In addition, Dr. Koch testified that Student’s withdrawal, her immaturity, her lack of insight, her constant desire for approval, and her avoidance of strong emotion were part of her reactive attachment disorder and therefore satisfied this criterion.
The District argues that the inappropriate behaviors described by Student’s parents occurred outside of the school setting and were not seen at school. In her March 2003 assessment, school psychologist Robbie Henle concluded that Student did not have inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances because “there is no other documentation which would indicate the presence of inappropriate types of behavior or feelings in the school setting. Throughout school history, Student was described as being quiet at times, and as periodically having difficulty focusing. She generally, however, was described as being receptive to teacher guidance and redirection, when needed.”
Withdrawal from Family - 2000-2001 School Year to the Present
Student’s parents testified that she became increasingly withdrawn from them in the years at issue and that, particularly in the summer of 2002, she was not engaging in social activities attempted by her Aunt. Student would walk behind a group or stay off to one side with her earphones on, listening to music. She refused to engage with relatives at a large family reunion.
The weight of the evidence established that, particularly beginning in the 2001-2002 school year, the fourteen-year-old Student was moving further away from her family into a teenage world of friends, music, and a search for self-identity, including her cultural identity. As conceded by many witnesses, such behavior is not unusual in a teen. In addition to this normal developmental process of becoming more independent, the evidence also established that Student’s increasing withdrawal at home was heightened by her growing struggle with her parental figures. Student’s behaviors in turn triggered reactions from the parents, such as removing the door, the television, and the telephone from Student’s bedroom to keep her from isolating herself. Student then retreated to her headphones, listening to music. In addition, the parents conceded that one of the reasons for sending Student to her Aunt’s was the difference in parenting styles between Student’s Grandmother, who was less demanding, and Student’s Aunt, who described herself as a very strict parent who would definitely require Student to comply with parental rules, including the “no dating until sixteen” rule. The evidence also established that once Student was in Long Beach, the conflict between her and her Aunt increased. (Footnote 17) Taken as a whole, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s withdrawal from her family did not demonstrate inappropriate behaviors or feelings under normal circumstances.
Lack of Eye Contact - 2000-2001 School Year to Present
The primary unusual behavior of concern to Student’s parents in eighth grade was her failure to make eye contact. Student’s Grandmother testified that Student’s math teacher, Mr. Spickelmier, wrote a letter in support of her application to Capital Christian School in which he stated Student never looked him in the eye and kept her eyes on the floor the entire year.
The Hearing Officer finds that Student did not exhibit any disturbing pattern of unusual lack of eye contact at HEMS, LCHS, Reid or Provo Canyon. For example, HEMS RSP teacher Ms. Chargin testified that she typically works on eye contact with her RSP students and would have noticed if Student did not make normal eye contact with her. This was not something she recalled with Student. Ms. Nelson testified that, due to some hearing problems, she does not speak to students who do not look at her and she had no recollection of Student’s failing to make eye contact. Mr. DeLuca testified that, when Student was in ninth grade at LCHS, she had no inappropriate or unusual behaviors and made eye contact when speaking. No unusual behavior was noted by other LCHS teachers. The two teachers from Reid who testified had different experiences with Student regarding eye contact, with Mr. Meade not noticing a problem and Ms. Butler testifying that Student was very quiet, insecure, and avoided eye contact. The record is not clear regarding whether this behavior occurred throughout her time in Ms. Butler’s class or only after Ms. Butler discovered Student drunk in her class. By the time of her admission to Provo Canyon on November 19, 2002, however, Student made good eye contact with Dr. Robert Crist during his initial one-to-two-hour interview of her. In all of the progress reports from Provo Canyon, there were no subsequent references of concern, with the exception of two occasions when she was confronted on the residential unit about her refusal to participate. This entry perhaps explains Student’s unwillingess to make eye contact with her parents when confronted with behavior of which they did not approve. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that, if Student actually had episodes of not making eye contact, they were was not pervasive or to a marked degree.
Poor Hygiene and Excessive Layers of Clothing- 2000-2001 School Year to Present
Student’s Aunt described Student’s daily routine in the summer of 2002, as watching TV, listening to music on her headset, and sleeping. Because Student’s Aunt worked from 2:00 a.m. to 8:00 a.m., Student was alone in the house in the evenings. Student’s Aunt testified that Student’s had very poor hygiene while living with her in Long Beach in 2002. Specifically, she testified that she needed to remind Student to shower and wash her hair, and that Student went “months” without washing her hair, which smelled dirty. However, the evidence as a whole does not support the notion that Student was exhibiting this type of inappropriate behavior. In fact, at least one witness commented on how beautiful Student’s hair was, her teachers at both Elk Grove and Reid testified that her dress was appropriate, and her parents testified that she was obsessed with her appearance at that time. In addition, weekly notes from the Provo Canyon residential unit rated Student’s hygiene/grooming as consistently neat and appropriate. Although Dr. Merz expressed his concern about the subjectivity of these types of progress reports, he acknowledged that information from them is more reliable when they span a long period of time. The Hearing Officer finds that the Provo Canyon progress reports are entitled to weight in light of their consistency over long periods of time.
In October 2002, Student’s Grandmother advised the Provo Canyon admission committee that a few months before the summer of 2002, Student began to dress very provocatively and that, previously, Student was extremely modest and had a habit of covering her body with clothes. Student’s Aunt also reported to the committe that during the summer of 2002, Student began to dress in a very provocative manner and to look as though she stepped out of “a playboy centerfold.” According to her Aunt, Student began to crop her shirts to show her belly and to wear lowered pants exhibiting borrowed thong underwear. Because of this behavior, Student’s Aunt reported that, once Student started school at Reid, she had to supervise Student’s dress on a daily basis. At the hearing, Student’s Aunt testified about Student’s unusual behavior of wearing excessive layers of clothing. Specifically, Student’s Aunt testified that when she took Student to the hospital on October 25, 2002, she was given an excessive amount of clothing removed from Student by medical staff, including three layers of bras, shirts and pants. This testimony is inconsistent with the parents’ testimony that, by the summer of 2002, Student behavior changed to “provocative” dressing. It is also inconsistent with the testimony of both Mr. Meade and Ms. Butler that Student’s appearance while at Reid was conservative and appropriate.
The Hearing Officer finds that testimony regarding Student’s poor hygiene and excessive layering of clothes in 2002 is not credible, because it is in glaring contrast to the detailed letters submitted by the parents to the Provo Canyon admission committee just days after Student’s intoxication at Reid. Student’s Aunt’s four-page letter specifically outlines Student’s “increasing self-destructive behavior over the last six to nine months.” The gist of the behavior described is Student attraction to boys, her insistence on talking to them in defiance of family rules, and her intoxication at Reid. Student’s Aunt’s letter to the Provo Canyon admission committee makes no mention of Student’s filthy hair and abnormal layering of clothing. Her more recent recollection of these details in the context of a request for reimbursement leads the Hearing Officer to conclude that her testimony is not a trustworthy portrait of Student’s behavior and demeanor at that time.
Alcohol Use: 2002-2003 School Year to the Present
Student’s behavior of becoming drunk at Reid Continuation School in October 2002 was clearly an inappropriate behavior under normal circumstances. Student’s parents were justifiably extremely concerned about this behavior, particularly in light of the substance abuse history of Student’s biological parents. The evidence established that Student admitted to using alcohol approximately seven times and reported that she used more alcohol on each occasion to obtain the same feeling. While this behavior is clearly one of concern, the undisputed evidence was that there was only a single drinking episode at school. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that, while Student’s behavior of becoming intoxicated at school was of a marked degree on one occasion, it did not occur over a long period of time. From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student did not exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances for a long time or to a marked degree from the 2000-2001 school year to the present. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that she does not meet this eligibility characteristic for emotional disturbance under the IDEA.
D. Does Student Exhibit a General Pervasive Mood of Unhappiness or Depression?
Petitioner contends that her eligibility for this category from the 2000-2001 school year to the present is supported by Dr. Koch’s July 2003 diagnoses of RAD and major depressive disorder, recurrent, moderate, with atypical features, in partial remission, as well as Dr. Robert Crist’s May 2003 diagnosis of major depression. She further contends that, throughout the years at issue, her pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression was manifested in her increased isolation at home, her refusal to accept help with her homework, her lack of communication with her family, her extreme shyness, and her low self-esteem.
Dr. Koch testified that, during his two-hour assessment interview with Student on July 2, 2003, she told him that “she believes she has experienced depressive symptoms regularly since she was twelve years old...and reported behaviors including constant complaining and negative thoughts, isolativeness, and asocial behavior with both her parents...and others.” According to Dr. Koch, Student’s self-report of her past depression was supported by the reports of her parents. At the hearing, Dr. Koch testified that, in his opinion, Student has experienced depression since age twelve and that, at some point, her depression became clinically significant. Dr. Koch testified that he could not specify when Student’s depression became clinically significant and that he did not have any conversations with Student’s Elk Grove teachers.
The District contends that Student did not demonstrate a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression while she attended HEMS or LCHS and that it had no information from the parents regarding Student’s asserted depressive symptoms at home.
2000-2001 through November 18, 2002
From the totality of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that Student did not exhibit a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression either while attending school within the Elk Grove district or while attending school in Long Beach until November 18, 2002.
First, during Student’s eighth grade year at HEMS, there was no evidence that she suffered from a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Ms. Nelson testified that, in her experience and observation, Student did not exhibit a pervasive mood of sadness or depression during the time she worked with her. She testified that Student did come to her “unhappy” on several occasions regarding specific problems she had with other Students, but that Student was not a sad Student on a regular basis. Ms. Nelson testified that, even though Student was extremely shy and did not like being “put on the spot,” she would talk and respond once she knew you. For the reasons previously stated, the Hearing Officer again finds that the testimony of Ms. Nelson entitled to great weight. Similarly, Ms. Chargan, Mr. Murdock, and Mary Swanson each testified that Student did not seem to be sad or depressed to any greater extent than other Students. Because Dr. Koch had no knowledge of Student’s behavior or demeanor at HEMS, the Hearing Officer finds his opinion entitled to less weight.
Second, the evidence established that Student did not exhibit a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression at LCHS during the ninth grade. In fact, Student’s ninth grade English teacher, Mr. DeLuca, testified that Student had a “great smile,” which he characterized as her “distinguishing feature.” According to Mr. DeLuca, Student’s general mood was quiet, but she never seemed sad or depressed. School counselor Ms. Nguyen also recalled Student’s big smile and described her demeanor as calm, sweet, polite, and without “an attitude.” According to Ms. Lantay, Student did not stand out in class as either troubled or having difficulty. She testified that one of Student’s writings from her power point final exam captured her perception of Student’s attitude. On this exam, Student wrote that she makes up mottos “to help me through the years. This year’s ‘motto’ is ‘I won’t do it to make you happy, but I’ll do it to prove you wrong.’ I chose this motto because everyone is forcing me to do things and they think that I can’t get them done. So I’ll only do it to prove them wrong. And it works for me because then I get things done.” Other writings by Student from this class also reflect a Student who is excited about life, about her friends, and about designing Web pages.
Student’s Grandmother testified that she discovered a suicide note that Student had written and hidden in her own drawer sometime in the ninth grade. In addition, Student’s Aunt testified that Student has threatened suicide on multiple occasions. Specifically, she testified that Student was asked to write a report at Reid High School about the person she admired most in the world and that Student wrote a report about a girl in Elk Grove who had tried to commit suicide on multiple occasions. According to Student’s Aunt, when she tried to dissuade her from writing about this girl, Student insisted that this girl was the one person she admired most. In addition, Student’s Aunt testified that, at age thirteen, Student wrote letters about suicide that Student’s Grandmother found, that Student included references to suicide in the poems that she likes to write, and that Student frequently blurted out “I don’t deserve to live.” No suicide letters or poems were introduced into evidence.
While suicidal threats must always be taken seriously, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents’ testimony regarding Student’s emotional state prior to her admission to Provo Canyon is entitled to much less weight for the following reason. There was no mention of any threats of suicide by Student in either of the parents’ detailed letters to the Provo Canyon admissions committee in late October 2002. It is clear that Student’s intoxication at Reid placed the parents in crisis and reinvigorated their determination to find what they believed to be an appropriate placement for her. This is evident in the extremely specific details provided by both parents in their lengthy letters to the Provo Canyon admission committee describing their concern about “losing [Student] forever.” It is frankly inconceivable that a matter so serious as repeated threats of suicide would have been omitted by both parents if Student had been actively making such threats. In addition, Student’s Grandmother testified that she never mentioned this letter to anyone in the Elk Grove district, despite her considerable involvement in Student’s education during her eighth grade year. In light of Student’s overridingly quiet yet positive demeanor at school, the District had no basis to suspect any depression. Student’s Aunt testified that Student told her she got drunk at Reid because she was depressed. In light of Student’s increasing conflict with her aunt at this time, including her restriction from talking on the telephone to her boyfriend, some unhappiness or depression is not unusual. As previously indicated, however, Student’s drinking was of short duration and was not a demonstrable exhibition of depression over a long period of time. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Student did not exhibit any pervasive unhappiness or depression to a marked degree or over a long period of time during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years in Elk Grove, or while she was in Long Beach from June through early November 2002.
November 19, 2002 to the Present
As previously detailed, when she was admitted to Provo Canyon School on November 19, 2002, Student was determined by Dr. Robert Crist not to be clinically depressed and to have no suicidal ideation. Over the following five months while she was classified as an “intensive treatment” patient, Student was not noted to exhibit depression of any lasting significance by Provo Canyon staff. While at Provo Canyon, Student admitted to having had thoughts of suicide in the past, when she felt that her Grandmother loved her brother more than her, but she denied every having had a plan. Ms. Ottonelli testified that Student was never suicidal. In addition, Student was never considered a suicide risk by Provo Canyon School (see: Pet. Ex. 3039).
As discussed below, the Hearing Officer finds that Student did not exhibit a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression for a long time or to a “marked degree” from her admission to Provo Canyon until the IEP team met on April 28, 2003.
While Student’s therapist Adrianna Ottonelli testified that Student was depressed, in her own world, and had primitive communication skills when she first entered Provo Canyon, the testimony and psychiatric assessment of Dr. Robert Crist established that Student was not clinically depressed at that time. Rather, Dr. Robert Crist acknowledged that all students who enter Provo Canyon are initially depressed due to the radical change in their life circumstances, including removal from the familiarity of home and family, as well as the imposition of rules and expectations for their behavior. As a consequence, he follows up with students after several weeks to see if the depression persists. As demonstrated by Provo Canyon’s detailed records, Dr. Robert Crist met with Student on a weekly basis and, with a single exception following a bad group therapy session, never indicated that Student’s mood was anything but “euthymic”–i.e., not depressed. His conclusion is reinforced by detailed weekly reports from Student’s residential and therapeutic staff which do not rate her as depressed. Testimony of Provo Canyon staff established that these reports were regularly maintained by Provo Canyon personnel, prepared at the time of observation, and generally trustworthy. In addition, these reports were maintained consistently over a period of months. While the Hearing Officer acknowledges Dr. Merz’s concern regarding subjectivity of such progress note reports, the Hearing Officer also finds that these reports are entitled to weight in light of their consistency over a long time and corroborating evidence and testimony.
Student’s depression that precipitated her use of antidepressant medication on March 25, 2003 manifested itself shortly after her return from Elk Grove and just days after she had had a significant family therapy session in which she confronted her Aunt regarding her perception of their relationship. (District Ex. 18, 0205) The Hearing Officer notes that this is the only time when the progress notes indicate that Student is withdrawn or sad. It is clear that a festering crisis exploded and that this occurred within days of her return from California and thoughts that she might be leaving Provo Canyon. As acknowledged by various witnesses, Student has experienced situational stress arising out of her placement. As indicated from the Provo Canyon records as a whole, as well as the testimony of Provo Canyon staff, Student’s depression was not exhibited to a marked degree at the time of the IEP team meeting. (Footnote 18)Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Student did not demonstrate a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression to a marked degree at the time of the IEP team meeting in April 28, 2003.
Present Eligibility
Following the IEP team meeting, on May 7, 2003, Provo Canyon’s Dr. Robert Crist changed Student’s diagnosis to major depression, single episode, moderate, and ODD. Later that month, Dr. Alan Crist noted in his assessment that “Student’s situation is also made worse by the fact that she is experiencing considerable situational stress. She is also likely to experience difficulties with depression.” Dr. Alan Crist reinterviewed Student after reviewing the results of her completed assessments and confronted her regarding some issues, including suicidal ideation, which Student denied. Dr. Alan Crist’s diagnostic impression was that, in addition to some attachment issues, Student “appears predisposed to significant underlying depression.....” (Footnote 19) In his July 2003 assessment report, Dr. Koch stated that Student “has experienced depressive symptoms for at least four or five years, and has a poor and immature grasp of reality.” In his opinion, Student’s high degree of insecure attachment predisposes her to significant depressive symptoms.
The District argues that any diagnosis of depression made following the IEP meeting should be viewed with disfavor and as evidence of a concerted attempt by Petitioner to obtain funding. It notes that Student’s current therapist, Marc Barney, testified on August 1, 2003, that Provo Canyon School has not officially changed Student’s treatment plan, which remains focused on ODD and rule out RAD, with no depression diagnosis.
In his July 14, 2003 assessment report, Dr. Koch concluded that Student’s depression was “in partial remission.” As described in the DSM-IV, partial remission means that the “symtoms of a major depressive episode are present but full criteria are not met, or there is a period without any significant symptoms of a Major Depressive Episode lasting less than two months following the end of the Major Depressive Episode.” To the extent Student has recently experienced depression, the totality of the evidence supports the conclusion that her depression is caused in large measure by her current circumstances and placement. In addition, while it is apparent that Student has experienced some depression, the Hearing Officer finds that her depression is not of a marked degree and has not existed for a long period of time. Accordingly, Student does not presently exhibit this eligibility characteristic for ED. * * * *
For all the reasons expressed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that Student did not meet the IDEA eligibility criteria as an individual with an emotional disturbance from 2000-2001 school year to the present.
ISSUES TWO THROUGH FOUR
Because Student did not meet the eligiblity criteria as a student with an ED from the 2000-2001 school year to the present, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not fail to provide Student with a FAPE during the years at issue as outlined in Issue 2 and that it has no obligation to provide her with either compensatory education or reimbursement as outlined in Issue 3. In Issue 4, Student seeks an order requiring Elk Grove to pay for the cost of the July 14, 2003 independent psychological assessment of her conducted by Todd Koch, Ph. D.
California Education Code Section 56329(b) provides that “a parent or guardian has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists,...if the parent or guardian disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency, in accordance with Section 300.502 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.” In such a case, the school district may initiate a due process hearing to show that its assessment is appropriate. If the final determination from the hearing is that the assessment is appropriate, the parent is not entitled to public funding for the independent assessment, but “...the results of the assessment shall be considered by the public education agency with respect to the provision of a free, appropriate public education to the child, and may be presented as evidence at a due process hearing....” Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(c).
In its closing brief, the District asserted that Ms. Henle’s assessment report is entitled to substantial deference because she has extensive experience with Students with emotional difficulties, spent twenty-eight hours working on her assessment, interviewed Student and spoke by telephone to her therapist, Ms. Ottonelli. In addition, the District argues that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Koch’s assessment for a variety of reasons, including that Dr. Koch’s assessment was not truely an independent assessment because it was created solely for the purpose of the due process hearing; that Dr. Koch’s opinion regarding Student’s ongoing need for residential placement at Provo Canyon conflicted with scholarly literature regarding RAD treatment methologies he cited in his assessment report; that reimbursement for Dr. Koch’s assessment would sanction the use of a racially discriminatory IQ test he administered to Student; and that Dr. Koch’s RAD diagnosis was contradicted by Drs. Robert and Alan Crist.
None of the District’s arguments address the statutory requirements for an appropriate assessment as outlined in California Education Code Section 56320, et seq. The Hearing Officer finds that the District has failed to meet its burden of proof on the appropriateness of Ms. Henle’s assessment. In reaching this conclusion, the Hearing Officer notes Petitioner’s concerns regarding the adequacy of Ms. Henle’s report, including her failure to write a developmental history outlining the crucial facts of Student’s early abandonment and placement in foster care; her failure to conduct a parent interview with either Student’s Grandmother or Student’s Aunt; her failure to interview Student’s current or former HEMS/LCHS regular education teachers or to request that these teachers complete the BASC - teacher rating form; her administration to Student of the Reynold’s Suicide Ideation Questionnaire, Form HS (RSIQ), but failure to mention of the results of the RSIQ in her report, and her reference to a single alcohol episode by Student when her protocol indicated additional reported episodes of alcohol use. At the hearing, Ms. Henle testified that she was attempting to honor Student’s Grandmother’s request for a quick assessment due to the parents’ concerns about funding Student’s placement. Ms. Henle later conceded, however, that there was pressure on her to complete the report from the District, because of its growing belief that Elk Grove was not Student’s district of residence. Ms. Henle testified that, in other circumstances, she might have worked harder to follow up, for example, by obtaining information from Student’s Elk Grove teachers.
It is clear that Ms. Henle should have followed up on some key areas. For example, although Ms. Henle had information about Student’s background from her review of the cumulative file and from Student’s Grandmother’s detailed letter, this information should have been summarized in her report. An assessment report, under Education Code Section 56327(e) must include “educationally relevant health and development, and medical findings, if any.” In addition, there was a significant discrepancy in the results of the BASC rating scales between Student’s Grandmother and Student. As indicated by both Dr. Koch and Dr. Merz, even thought Student’s Grandmother’s BASC results received an “extreme caution” rating on its validity scale or F index, Ms. Henle should have interviewed Student’s Grandmother to determine why she rated Student’s behavior so negatively. In addition, as indicated by Dr. Merz, Ms. Henle should have conducted a follow up interview with Student regarding her results on several assessments, including on the Reynold’s Suicide Ideation Questionnaire, Form HS (RSIQ), despite Student’s responses in the non-clinical range (total score zero). Dist. Ex. 35, 117. A more thorough assessment report following interviews such as those detailed above would likely have given the parents a greater sense of confidence in Ms. Henle’s assessment, and thus, in the entire IEP process of determining Student to be ineligible as ED. (Footnote 20)
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Koch’s assessment. Although, ultimately, the Hearing Officer concluded that Student’s attachment issues did not satisfy ED eligibility criterion because they were not of a marked degree, Dr. Koch’s assessment, with its detailed summary of Student’s developmental and educational history, was helpful in understanding Student’s potential RAD issues that were initially raised by Provo Canyon School in November 2002. The Hearing Officer agrees with the District, however, that reimbursement for Dr. Koch’s time and cost for administering and scoring the Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence (WASI) is not appropriate. Petitioner submitted into evidence a copy of her Aunt’s check to Dr. Merz, with whom Dr. Koch works, in the total amount of $1,500.00 (Petitioner Ex. 3059). Petitioner must now provide the District with an invoice from Dr. Merz that excludes Dr. Koch’s time and cost spent in administering and scoring the WAIS to Student. Upon receipt of such invoice, the District must reimburse Petitioner as outlined in Order 2, below.
* * *
SUMMARY
As they have done throughout her life, Student’s parents have gone to great lengths to ensure that she is provided with the tools and opportunities necessary for her healthful development, and to improve the quality of her life. As the family’s attorney, Perry Leonard, recognized at Student’s IEP meeting, Student is a young woman who is “at risk” in the regular education program without any support. While Student is not eligible for special education as an individual with an emotional disturbance, the Hearing Officer strongly recommends that the District and the family work together without delay to determine whether Student has a specific learning disability in the area of mathematics and/or to develop reasonable accommodations to ensure that her return to the Elk Grove Unified School District is successful.
ORDER
1. The Long Beach Unified School District is dismised as a party to this action, effective July 25, 2003.
2. The Elk Grove Unified School District shall reimburse Student’s Aunt for the cost of Dr. Koch’s psychoeducational assessment, except for his time and cost spent in administering and scoring the Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence (WASI) to Student. Payment shall be made within twenty (20) calendar days following receipt from Petitioner of an invoice for Dr. Koch’s assessment that excludes his time and cost in administering and scoring the WASI.
3. All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief against the Elk Grove Unified School District are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing Decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
The Elk Grove Unified School District prevailed on Issues I, II, and III. The Petitioner substantially prevailed on Issue IV.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: October 10, 2003 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Mr. Tollestrup was present as Elk Grove’s representative from the commencement of the hearing through August 12, 2003, except for July 31, 2003, when Ms. Spears Lee was present. Ms. Spears Lee was also present on the District’s behalf from August 13 to August 18, 2003. On July 24 and 31, 2003, the District’s representatives for a portion of the day were program specialist, Don Ross, and assistant superintendent, Linda Strom.
2. In 1986, the court expanded its 1979 injunction prohibiting the use of intelligence tests to include the use of intelligence tests in the assessment of African-American students for eligibility as learning disabled and when referring the students for any special education assessment. The expansion of the injunction occurred following a stipulation by the parties. (See Larry P. v. Riles (1986) Order Modifying Judgment.) Thereafter, in 1992, the 1986 modification to the original Larry P. injunction was vacated by the District Court on the ground that it violated the due process rights of a group of plaintiffs affected by the modification. Crawford v. Honig; Larry P. v. Riles (1992) Memorandum and Order. Under Crawford, the original Larry P. decision stands. The 1992 Crawford decision has been affirmed by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Crawford v. Honig; Larry P. v. Riles (9th Cir. 1995) 37 F. 3d 485. The most recent decision states that the original injunction in Larry P. is reinstated.
3. On July 24, 2003, Petitioner stipulated that she sought a determination only of her ED eligibility during these years and that she was not challenging her eligibility as a student with an SLD, based upon the mathematics disorder diagnosed by Dr. Koch’s in his July 14, 2003 psychoeducational evaluation.
4. The issues have been reorganized for clarity of analysis.
5. Student’s Grandmother was notified on several occasions that Student might be at risk for retention at HEMS because of her low SAT 9 math score, as well as her forty (40) percent math score on a mid-year assessment designed to identify Students who were below grade level standards of 70% in reading, language or mathematics.
6. While the record is unclear whether she actually received two separate report cards, it appears that there were two grading cyles. For example, Student received an A in English 1-2 and an F in English 3-4. Similarly, her physical science teacher, Ms. Butler, testified that Student received an A in her physical science class the first time and an F the second time.
7. Dr. Robert Crist dictated and signed his written report on December 3, 2002. His son, Dr. Alan Crist, is a psychologist at Provo Canyon who assessed Student in early May 2003. Both Drs. Crist testified in this hearing. To avoid confusion, their full names will be used.
8. Meriam Webster Dictionary defines “euthymia” as (1) joyfulness, mental peace and tranquility; (2) moderation of mood, not manic or depressed. Dr. Robert Crist testified that, when he said Student was euthymic, he meant she was not clinically depressed.
9. The parents testified that Student’s Aunt is the financial support for the family.
10. In her request for assessment, Student’s Grandmother advised Elk Grove that Student had spent her “entire academic life in the Elk Grove Unified School District.”
11. Student’s Aunt testified that, although Ms. Ottonelli may have said something about ODD, she had no knowledge of Student’s ODD diagnosis until it was explained to her by Ms. Ottonelli’s supervisor, and that she was never aware of Student’s treatment plan signed by her mother and Student in January 2003 until the hearing.
12. Attachment has been defined as “a ‘lasting psychological connectedness between human beings’ ...recognized as a crucial factor for healthy human development.” Behavioral and Personality Characteristics of Children With Reactive Attachment Disorder, Hall and Geher, Vol. 173, No. 2, Journal of Psychology (March 2003), p 146 [Dist. Ex. 30].
13. The Hearing Officer notes that Student was diagnosed with a DSM-IV mathematics disorder by Dr. Koch in his July 2003 assessment. Student’s therapist Marc Barney testified that, in regard to her ability to learn, he had asked for more information regarding a possible mathematics disability.
14. In eighth grade, Student had two humanities courses each trimester: one in language arts (LA)and one in social studies (SS). The report card for June 2001 does not distinguish which humanities course was LA and which was SS, but Student received a B in one of her humanities classes and a C+ in the other.
15. Student’s Aunt corroborated Ms. Butler’s testimony that she had talked to Student about placing her at Provo Canyon before the drinking episode.
16. Ms. Henle testified that, during her assessment, Student told her the students at Provo Canyon were “mostly crazy and bad” and gave an example of being spit in the face by another girl passing her in the hall. Student was trying to establish appropriate boundaries with these peers. As noted in Student’s Grandmother’s March 2003 letter to Ms. Henle, Student was developing relationships with friends and staff at Provo Canyon School.
17. Student’s writing samples from Ms. Lantay’s computer class reflect her pre-existing tension with her Aunt, who she viewed as “so very strict and always has to know everything, and everything has to be her way or no way at all. But I deal, and learn to live with her deffisionsys [sic] over the few days she’s visiting.”
18. Because Ms. Ottonelli testified that Mr. Blackburn wrote the March 17, 2003 letter to Elk Grove program specialist Ms. Ramsey that she signed and because Mr. Blackburn did not testifiy, the Hearing Officer gives little weight to its contents. Elk Grove Ex. 6, p 17.
19. When Dr. Alan Crist asked Student about difficulties that were revealed in her testing but not in her initial interview, Student “seemed to have some difficulty understanding what is going on within herself. When asked about suicidal thoughts or plans, she denied that she is experiencing these thoughts at this time...[however], she indicated that she feels under a great deal of pressure to keep her grades up, to behave consistently, and,...she is very worried about how her parents and her therapist view her....When asked about anger, she grudgingly admitted that she feels angry but was resistant to the idea of sharing her feelings openly with her aunt or her grandmother....”
20. Ms. Henle testified that she later spent approximately forty hours reviewing Provo Canyon’s detailed reports and that nothing in those documents altered her opinion regarding Student’s eligibility as ED.
