California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 10, 1996

Student v. School district in Santa Cruz, California (name not stated in decision; operates Westlake Elementary and Natural Bridges Elementary)

SEHO Case No. SN 733-96 · Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel

Santa Cruz district may keep a 10-year-old in a special day class with nonacademic mainstreaming, but at her neighborhood school.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. A September 4, 1996 stay put order set placement at 50% SDC and 50% mainstreaming at Westlake while the case was pending. Before the hearing, the Hearing Office denied the District's request for a continuance and dismissed the Santa Cruz County Office of Education on the District's motion. During the hearing, it denied Student's motion for an expert to observe classes and her motion for reconsideration.

Summary

The parents of a 10-year-old fourth grader filed for due process against their Santa Cruz school district. They wanted her in regular education classes all day. She would leave class only for speech-language and vision services, or briefly when her loud vocalizations disrupted the class. The student is blind, uses a wheelchair, and has profound cognitive disabilities, with a developmental age of about three to six months. In Colorado, she had attended regular classes with a one-to-one aide from kindergarten through second grade. The district proposed a special day class for students with severe disabilities, with mainstreaming during nonacademic activities, and planned to move her to Natural Bridges Elementary.

The parties agreed on mainstreaming during nonacademic activities. So Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel applied the Ninth Circuit's four-factor Rachel H. test to academic time only. He found that she could not make satisfactory progress on her IEP goals during fourth-grade academics, even with an aide, because the aide spent most of her effort keeping her quiet. During academics she did not interact with or imitate classmates. Teachers testified that her vocalizations disrupted instruction, even though the district had a behavior intervention plan in place. Cost was not at issue. The district prevailed on how much she should be mainstreamed. However, the Hearing Officer ordered her program delivered at Westlake Elementary, her neighborhood school, and added hands-on science to her mainstreaming time. The parents prevailed on which school she should attend.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied the Rachel H. four-factor test to a student with profound disabilities. It looked separately at academic and nonacademic time. It also weighed disruption that was not misbehavior, and it treated the neighborhood school as the default site unless the IEP required a different school.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. What is the appropriate amount of integration with nondisabled peers for STUDENT?

    Applying the Rachel H. four-factor test, the Hearing Officer held that the maximum appropriate mainstreaming was during nonacademic activities plus hands-on science, not full-time regular education during academics.

  2. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1 (school site, footnote 10). Which school STUDENT should attend: Westlake School, her neighborhood school, or Natural Bridges School as the District proposed

    The District showed no persuasive need to move the student to Natural Bridges School, so her IEP must be implemented at Westlake, her neighborhood school.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Placement ordered. For the 1996-97 school year, placement in Ms. Antillon's special day class at Westlake Elementary School, with mainstreaming in Mr. Avery's regular education fourth-grade class during music, art, physical education, recess, lunch, field trips, and assemblies, and also during "hands-on" science.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Poolaw v. Bishop; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Wilson v. Marana Unified School Dist.; Board v. Holland; Mavis v. Sobol; DeVries v. Fairfax County School Board; Hudson v. Bloomfield Hills Public Schools; Kari H. v. Franklin Special School Dist.; OSEP Memorandum 95-9; 34 C.F.R. 300.552

People named in the decision

  • Leonard Garfinkel, SEHO Hearing Officer
  • Kathryn Dobel, attorney for Student
  • Laurie Reynolds, attorney for District, Breon, O'Donnell law firm
  • Bridget Flanagan, attorney for District, Breon, O'Donnell law firm
  • Lenore Silverman, attorney for Santa Cruz County Office of Education, Lozano, Smith law firm
  • Dr. Katie Merchant, interim director of special education, District
  • Charlotte McAfee, special education administrator, Santa Cruz County Office of Education
  • Beverly Donahue, regular education teacher (first and second grade), Flatiron Elementary School, Boulder, Colorado
  • Barbara Schuttenberg, special education teacher, Flatiron Elementary School, Boulder, Colorado
  • Dr. Kathleen Gee, expert witness for Student (rebuttal); professor of special education, San Jose State University
  • Lydia Antillon, special day class teacher, Westlake Elementary School
  • Caryl Hogan, school psychologist; conducted behavioral assessment and BIP, District
  • Lucy Fassbinder, speech and language therapist, District
  • Jill Tardiff, teacher of the visually impaired, District
  • Bob Avery, fourth grade regular education teacher, Westlake Elementary School
  • Vicki Tucci, behavior consultant, consultant to District
  • Carolyn Heier, third grade (science) teacher, Westlake Elementary School
  • Cheryl Mercurio, first grade regular education teacher, Westlake Elementary School
  • Dr. Esther Shafer, speech and language consultant, consultant to District
  • Julie O'Reilly, 1:1 aide (trial inclusion period), District
  • Mariah (last name not identified), 1:1 aide (1996-97), District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Leonard Garfinkel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Santa Cruz, California, on September 17 and 18, October 2 and 3, and November 4, 1996.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Kathryn Dobel. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were her parents,

PARENTS.

The District was represented by attorney Laurie Reynolds of the Breon, O'Donnell law firm. Also present on behalf of the District was Dr. Katie Merchant, interim director of special education.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: Mr. and PARENT;

Beverly Donahue, regular education teacher, Flatiron Elementary School, Boulder, Colorado (FOOTNOTE 1); Barbara Schuttenberg, special education teacher, Flatiron Elementary School, Boulder, Colorado; and Dr. Kathleen Gee, professor of special education, San Jose State University.

The District called the following witnesses: Lydia Antillon, special day class teacher; Caryl Hogan, school psychologist; Lucy Fassbinder, speech and language therapist;

Jill Tardiff, teacher of the visually impaired; Bob Avery, fourth grade teacher; Vicki Tucci, behavior consultant; Carolyn Heier, third grade teacher; and Charlotte McAfee, special education administrator.

Oral, documentary, photographic, and video evidence was received. At the parties' request, the record was left open until December 2, 1996 for the receipt of written closing briefs.(FOOTNOTE 2) At that time, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUE

What is the appropriate amount of integration with nondisabled peers for STUDENT?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner asserts that the appropriate placement for STUDENT in the least restrictive environment is in regular education classes, with two exceptions: (1) STUDENT can receive speech and language therapy and services from a teacher of the visually impaired (hereafter "VI" services) outside the regular education classroom and (2) STUDENT can be removed from class temporarily if she makes loud vocalizations that disrupt the class.

Respondent asserts that the appropriate placement for STUDENT in the least restrictive environment is in a special day class (SDC) for severely handicapped students, with opportunities for mainstreaming with nondisabled peers in regular education classes during certain nonacademic activities, such as music, art, physical education, recess, lunch, field trips, and assemblies. Respondent asserts that STUDENT cannot receive an appropriate education to meet her unique needs by attending only regular education classes, and that her loud vocalizations distract and disrupt the regular education students and teacher during academic activities.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

1. Santa Cruz County Office of Education

Hearing in this matter was scheduled to begin on September 17, 1996. On September 13, the Hearing Office received a request for a continuance from Bridget Flanagan, an attorney with the Breon, O'Donnell law firm representing the District. Ms.

Flanagan asserted that the District was investigating naming the Santa Cruz County Office of Education (SCCOE) as a co-Respondent. Ms. Flanagan stated that because her firm was representing SCCOE in another matter, her firm would need to obtain a waiver of any potential conflict of interest from SCCOE in order to proceed here. Ms. Flanagan noted that if SCCOE would not waive any potential conflict, her firm might need to withdraw from representing the District. Also on September 13, the Hearing Office received an opposition to the motion for continuance from Kathryn Dobel, the attorney representing Petitioner. Ms. Dobel asserted that Petitioner's dispute was with the District, not SCCOE, and that in any event, the District had been given ample time to work out any potential conflict with SCCOE. That day, the Hearing Office orally notified the parties that the continuance request had been denied.

The reason for denying the motion was that it was untimely.

On September 16, the day before the hearing was to begin, the District (1) requested that SCCOE be named as a co-Respondent, (2) advised that the Breon, O'Donnell law firm had withdrawn from representing the District, and (3) requested a continuance to obtain new counsel. Petitioner again objected. That day, the Hearing Office advised the parties, including SCCOE, that SCCOE had been added as a co-Respondent at the District's request. On the afternoon of September 16, attorney Lenore Silverman of the Lozano, Smith law firm advised that she had been retained to represent SCCOE. Ms. Silverman requested that SCCOE be dismissed or, in the alternative, that the hearing be continued. The Hearing Office attempted to arrange a telephone conference with the parties to discuss Ms. Silverman's request, but not all the parties were available to participate. The Hearing Office advised the parties that the matter would be addressed at the outset of the hearing the next day.

At the outset of the hearing on September 17, attorneys Laurie Reynolds and Ms. Flanagan appeared and advised that their firm was again representing the District and that the District was moving to dismiss SCCOE as a co-Respondent. Petitioner had no objection to the motion to dismiss SCCOE, and no one appeared on behalf of SCCOE. Accordingly, the Hearing Office granted the motion to dismiss SCCOE.(FOOTNOTE 3)

2. Motion for Observation

On October 24, after Petitioner had presented its case and the District had presented a substantial portion of its case, the Hearing Office received a letter from Ms. Dobel, Petitioner's attorney, requesting an order permitting "Petitioner's consultant" Dr. Kathleen Gee, a professor of special education at San Jose State University, to observe the classes that STUDENT had previously attended, was currently attending or that the District proposed she attend. On October 25, the Hearing Office received an opposition to the request from Ms. Reynolds, the District's attorney. Ms. Reynolds asserted that (1) Petitioner had cited no authority that would support granting such a request, particularly in the middle of a hearing, (2)

Petitioner's parents had ample opportunity to observe all of the classes in question and had in fact done so, and (3) a visit by Dr. Gee would be disruptive to the educational process.

On October 28, the Hearing Office orally notified the parties that the motion had been denied on the grounds that Petitioner had not cited any authority that would support granting such a request in a special education due process hearing. On October 29, the Hearing Office received a motion for reconsideration from Ms. Dobel. She asserted that Dr. Gee, who had not been disclosed as a potential witness prior to hearing and had not testified in Petitioner's case-in-chief, first became available on October 21, and that Dr. Gee would be called as a rebuttal witness on November 4, the final day of hearing. Ms. Dobel asserted that the proposed observation would be helpful to Dr. Gee in her testimony. Ms. Dobel further asserted that under Education Code §56505.1(e), the Hearing Officer has authority to order an impartial assessment of the student for purposes of the hearing, at state expense. Ms. Dobel stated that Dr. Gee could be considered an impartial witness who could assist the Hearing Officer in making his findings in this case. On October 30, Ms. Reynolds, the District's attorney, orally notified the Hearing Office that she opposed the motion for reconsideration on the grounds previously stated and on the additional ground that she believed Dr. Gee was not an "impartial" witness.

On October 30 the Hearing Office orally notified the parties that the motion for reconsideration had been denied. The reasons for this ruling were as follows: (1) Petitioner had not provided any authority to support granting such a request, (2) it did not appear that Dr. Gee, who had now been disclosed as a rebuttal witness for Petitioner, was an "impartial" witness, and (3) in any event, the Hearing Officer declined to exercise his discretion to order an assessment by Dr. Gee.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE

1. Introduction

STUDENT is ten years old and lives with her family in Santa Cruz, within the District. STUDENT suffered brain damage in utero and was born with hydrocephalus, requiring insertion of a shunt to recycle spinal fluid between the brain and abdomen to control the buildup of fluid on the brain. She is blind, has cerebral palsy, and uses a wheelchair. She has profound mental retardation with an estimated IQ of 23 and an estimated developmental age of three to six months. She has normal hearing and shows responses to some auditory input, but apparently does not process language.

STUDENT does not speak any words, but she does produce a variety of noises and sounds of varying loudness, which the parties refer to as "vocalizations." These vocalizations have been described as including all of the following: humming, clicking, "whooping," groaning, a guttural back of the throat sound, "huh," screaming, shrieking, "mmmm," "horse" sounds, screeching, "pfft," and "raspberry" sounds.

2. Kindergarten through second grade in Colorado (1992-1995)

In kindergarten (1992-93), first grade (1993-94), and second grade (1994-95), STUDENT attended Flatiron Elementary School in Boulder, Colorado, where her family then resided. She attended regular education classes with the assistance of a full-time, one-to-one aide.

In kindergarten, according to PARENT, STUDENT was present with the group during "circle time," and handled clay, toys, and blocks during art sessions. She was given "hand-over-hand"

guidance for coloring and fingerpainting. She had some play dates with classmates and was invited to some birthday parties. Some parents of other students told PARENT they were glad STUDENT was in the class because her presence enabled other children to learn about students with disabilities. On those occasions when STUDENT's vocalizations were too loud, she was removed from the class for a period of time.

In first and second grades, STUDENT attended Beverly Donahue's class. Ms. Donahue focused on making sure STUDENT was socially integrated into the class. In doing so, she received consultation from Barbara Schuttenberg, a special education teacher. Other students said "hi" to STUDENT, sat near her, and pushed her in her wheelchair during recess. On one occasion, STUDENT participated in a group presentation by pressing a switch to turn on a tape. When STUDENT had surgery, her classmates sent her a card and a tape.

Whereas kindergarten had been mostly social, in first and second grades academics were introduced. STUDENT's one-to-one aide was responsible for working on her academic IEP goals and objectives. In doing so, the aide received consultation from the special educator, Ms. Schuttenberg. When the other children were working on academics, STUDENT's aide tried to engage her in a parallel experience. For example, during math, STUDENT might handle manipulatives. The aide worked with STUDENT on using her hands and not putting objects in her mouth. During reading, STUDENT might touch braille for tactile stimulation or listen to tape-recorded stories or music with headphones. The aide worked with STUDENT on using a switch to turn on the tape recorder.

During drawing, the aide might provide hand-over-hand guidance to STUDENT for coloring. (Pet. Exh. C, G)(footnote 4)

At the beginning of first grade, STUDENT frequently engaged in loud vocalizations. These were more likely to occur when she was not feeling well -- for example, when she had an upset stomach -- or when she was physically uncomfortable and needed to change position in her wheelchair. When the vocalizations were too loud, she was removed from the class for perhaps five-to-ten minutes at a time. The teacher would blink an eye at the aide to call for STUDENT's removal; sometimes the aide removed STUDENT on her own. Ms. Donahue tried to ignore STUDENT's low noises, and the aide tried to keep her busy. As the year progressed, STUDENT seemed to become more comfortable in the class, and the loud vocalizations decreased. By the end of second grade, it was rarely necessary to remove STUDENT from class.

Ms. Donahue, Ms. Schuttenberg, and PARENT all believed that STUDENT's experience in regular education at Flatiron Elementary was a positive one for STUDENT and her classmates. They believed that STUDENT received a lot of stimulation, became more comfortable in the class as time went along, and was considered a full member of the class. Her presence in the class with an aide did not place an undue burden on the teacher or unduly disrupt the other students; in fact, the other students benefitted from getting to know her.

At an IEP meeting in May, 1995, at the end of STUDENT's second grade year, the IEP team at Flatiron Elementary recommended that STUDENT continue to attend regular education classes for third grade. (Pet. Exh. L)

3. Third grade in Santa Cruz (1995-1996)

The PARENTS moved from Colorado to Santa Cruz during the summer of 1995. That fall, STUDENT was placed in Lydia Antillon's special day class (SDC) for severely handicapped (SH) students at Westlake Elementary School in the District. The class was located in Room 2, next door to a regular education first grade class taught by Cheryl Mercurio in Room 1. Ms.

Antillon and Ms. Mercurio had worked together for several years on integrating disabled and nondisabled students. (R 51, 54)

When the school year began, Ms. Antillon, the SDC teacher, spoke to Ms. Mercurio's Room 1 students about "disability awareness" in general and about STUDENT and her Room 2 classmates individually. (Pet. Exh. HHH) Ms. Antillon consulted with Ms. Mercurio on an ongoing basis as to how to integrate the disabled students with the regular education students. Additionally, Mr. and PARENT spoke to Ms. Mercurio's students about STUDENT.

STUDENT and her Room 2 classmates were "mainstreamed" with the Room 1 students during nonacademic activities including:

lunch, recess, physical education, art, snack time, library visits, music, library, playgroup, assemblies, and field trips. Occasionally, the Room 2 students participated in Room 1 during academic activities such as science if the lesson was active and "hands-on." Also, at times, Room 1 students did academic work in small groups in Room 2 -- a concept known as "reverse mainstreaming." (Resp. Exh. 13, 18, 51) Typically, during reverse mainstreaming, STUDENT listened to music with headphones.

STUDENT spent very little time in Ms. Mercurio's first grade regular education class during academic activities. Ms. Mercurio found that during such times, STUDENT's vocalizations were disruptive to her and the regular education students. Therefore, she typically called for STUDENT's removal during academic times. Ms. Antillon, the SDC teacher, testified that she observed that regular education students lost attention and focus on Ms.

Mercurio because of STUDENT's vocalizations. (R 14) STUDENT's parents, on the other hand, believed that Ms. Mercurio was insufficiently tolerant of STUDENT's vocalizations, and called for her removal from the regular education class even when the vocalizations were not especially loud.

a. The IEP meeting of October, 1995

At an IEP meeting in October, 1995, District staff shared assessment results indicating that STUDENT's developmental age was approximately three to six months. The following characteristics of STUDENT were noted: (1) enjoys listening to music with headphones, (2) can activate a tape player using a switch and appears to understand that pressing the switch makes the music play, (3) shows recognition of parents' voices by making sounds of pleasure and/or smiling, (4) likes to be pushed in her wheelchair, (5) enjoys toys that vibrate, and (6) laughs when peers or staff make funny sounds.

The IEP goals established for STUDENT included reducing vocalizations, increasing amount of integration with nondisabled students, and improving gross motor skills through positioning and range of motion exercises. In the area of communication, it was determined that STUDENT would work on all of the following: oral motor exercises, associating objects that she touched with her daily schedule of activities, reaching out for objects and toys, and pressing a switch that would activate a pre-recorded voice asking: "Will you push me?"

At the meeting, STUDENT's teacher, Ms. Antillon, and the visually impaired (VI) instructor, Ms. Tardiff, stated that they believed STUDENT's vocalizations were appropriate to her infant developmental level and that it was educationally inappropriate to require her to keep quiet so that she could remain physically present in regular education classes during academic activities. Ms. Antillon noted that she had attempted a variety of methods to keep STUDENT quiet, including sensory stimulation and physical manipulation, without much success.(footnote 5) (Resp. Exh. 6) Ms. Fassbinder, the speech and language therapist, stated that STUDENT should be encouraged to engage in vocal play and babbling, and was not yet at the developmental stage at which she could imitate others. Ms. Antillon also stated that she believed the SDC was the more appropriate setting for the various positioning, standing and range of motion exercises that STUDENT engaged in during the day. The District concluded that the SDC was the appropriate setting for working on most of STUDENT's IEP goals and objectives.

At the IEP meeting, the parties agreed that STUDENT would be placed 50% in the SDC, and be mainstreamed with nondisabled students for 50% of the school day. She would receive speech and language therapy twice weekly for a minimum of twenty minutes per session, and instruction from a teacher of the visually impaired once weekly for thirty minutes. (R 6)

At the IEP meeting, the parents expressed their desire that STUDENT be integrated with regular education peers more often. They agreed that STUDENT's vocalizations needed to come under better control so as not to interfere with the learning of other children, particularly during academic activities when children needed a high degree of concentration. However, they also believed that there were many times during the school day when STUDENT could be appropriately included, and that in any event, STUDENT should not be held to the same standard of quietness as other students. (R 6, Pet. Exh. Z) It was agreed that the District would conduct a behavioral assessment and design a plan to attempt to reduce the disruptive vocalizations.

b. Trial inclusion period (February-April 1996)

As the fall 1995 semester progressed, the parents and school staff continued to disagree on the appropriate amount of mainstreaming for STUDENT. In December, 1995, SCOE administrator Charlotte McAfee wrote to the parents that the teachers were finding the PARENTS' visits to STUDENT's classroom disruptive. (R 35) In January, 1996, the parties participated in mediation in an attempt to resolve their differences. The result of the mediation was an agreement that STUDENT would participate in regular education classes during the afternoon (1:00 p.m. to 2:30 p.m.), with the assistance of a one-to-one aide, for an eight-week "trial period," from late February through late April, 1996. The parties agreed that at the conclusion of the eight-week trial period, they would discuss the results at an IEP meeting.

District school psychologist Caryl Hogan completed her assessment of STUDENT's vocalization behavior in February, 1996, prior to the beginning of the trial period.(footnote 6) Ms.

Hogan concluded that the primary function that the vocalizations served for STUDENT was to entertain herself, that is, self-stimulation. (R 16) She noted that the vocalizations could increase if STUDENT was not kept busy. Based on her assessment, Ms. Hogan developed a behavioral intervention plan, or BIP, designed to reduce the disruptive vocalizations and have STUDENT engage in more socially appropriate communication behavior. (R 17) The parents expressed concern that Ms. Hogan's observations of STUDENT were made almost exclusively in the SDC, not the regular education class, and that Ms. Hogan did not appear to distinguish between loud and low vocalizations. (R 58) The parents wanted the District to attempt to moderate STUDENT's loud vocalizations and remove her from class when necessary, but to be more tolerant of her low vocalizations.

During this time period, the District also received consultation about STUDENT from Vicki Tucci, a behavior specialist. Ms. Tucci, in turn, suggested that the District seek consultation from Dr. Esther Shafer, a speech and language therapist with extensive knowledge of the communication needs of students with significant disabilities. Dr. Shafer viewed a video of STUDENT at school and read reports about STUDENT prior to making her suggestions. She suggested that STUDENT work on turntaking and elementary cause and effect using switches and other objects. (R 22) At the hearing, Ms. Tucci testified that in order to develop STUDENT's communication skills using Dr.

Shafer's suggestions, STUDENT's instructor and STUDENT needed to work in a distraction-free environment where they did not need to be concerned about STUDENT being removed for vocalizing.

Just before the trial period was to begin, Ms. Antillon wrote a letter to parents of regular education third grade students, introducing STUDENT and indicating that she would be participating in their children's classes. (R 41) From February 21 until April 24, 1996, STUDENT attended regular education third grade classes for ninety minutes each afternoon, accompanied by a one-to-one aide, Julie O'Reilly. (Pet. Exh. OO) The subjects in these classes included science, physical education, and reading. Ms. Antillon spoke to the teachers and students about "disability awareness," and the PARENTS spoke to the students about STUDENT. Carolyn Heier, the science teacher, testified that she, Ms.

Antillon, and the aide, Ms. O'Reilly, held frequent discussions regarding how to make inclusion work for STUDENT. Frequently, during direct instruction or student presentations in science or reading STUDENT's vocalizations were disruptive to the teacher and students and STUDENT was removed by her aide, Ms. O'Reilly. Ms. Heier stated that during such activities it was important for students to be able to concentrate and focus on the speaker.

Some students seated next to STUDENT complained that her low humming noises distracted them and they asked to move. Most of the aide's efforts during these times were focused on keeping STUDENT quiet. Ms. Heier stated that inclusion was successful for STUDENT during times when the class was engaged in hands-on, less academic activities, when the students were free to wander, explore, talk in small groups, or go outside. For example, during art, music, interactive projects and hands-on science, STUDENT could touch objects or show vocal enthusiasm that did not distract other students.

Ms. Heier noted that other students were respectful, patient, and kind with STUDENT. However, she believes that any educational benefit STUDENT derived from the trial inclusion experience was derived from being pushed in her wheelchair by peers on the playground. She does not believe STUDENT derived any educational benefit from the classroom.

c. IEP meeting of April 24, 1996

On April 24, 1996, at the end of the eight-week "trial"

period, the IEP team met to discuss the results. (R 28) Ms.

Antillon stated that while other students took an interest in STUDENT, STUDENT did not model or respond to peers, or recognize their voices or presence. It was noted that her vocalizations were disruptive, requiring that she be removed frequently during academic activities such as teacher instruction, reading, or student presentations. Various means of controlling the vocalizations, including sensory stimulation and physical manipulation, had been attempted to no avail -- with the exception of chocolate milk. The aide, Ms. O'Reilly, had encouraged other students to push STUDENT in her wheelchair during recess, and STUDENT continued to enjoy that. The District's notes of the meeting attribute the following comments to District staff:

[One-to-one aide] Ms. O'Reilly:

Have to give stimulation in order to try to stop vocalizations rather than helping her to explore the world tactily [sic] and auditorily. Stressful for STUDENT and CLASSMATE to keep quiet so don't disrupt education of other students. When STUDENT is vocalizing she is not behaving inappropriately and she does not know the negative effect her vocalizations have on others.

[SDC teacher] Ms. Antillon:

I agree with consultants that attempts should be made to teach STUDENT how to communicate and respond to people in her environment. Full inclusion is the least appropriate place to teach this. Same holds true for sensory stimulation. STUDENT is oblivious to peers' voices unless they bark or make other silly sounds.

[Regular education third-grade] Teachers:

She is not a burden with a one-to-one aide but what is the purpose. She is unaware of peers, does not respond to them. Curriculum offers nothing to her. (Pet. Exh.

WW)

At the meeting, the behavior specialist, Ms. Hogan, concluded that STUDENT's vocalizations were appropriate to her infant developmental level of three to six months. The speech and language therapist, Lucy Fassbinder, agreed and noted that STUDENT's vocal play and babbling should be encouraged, not discouraged. The parties reviewed an April 2, 1996 Diagnostic Center report about STUDENT, which concluded:

the vocalizations that STUDENT makes are intrinsic to who she is and are not subject to modification to any great degree. (R 55)

At the April 24, 1996, IEP meeting, the parties did not reach agreement on the appropriate amount of integration for STUDENT. The District concluded that the trial inclusion period had been, for the most part, unsuccessful. The District concluded that the appropriate placement for STUDENT remained in Ms. Antillon's SDC with mainstreaming opportunities during nonacademic times or during hands-on academic activities when quiet was not so important. The parents, on the other hand, believed that the trial period was successful to the extent that STUDENT was able to remain in the regular education class for significant periods of time and that the aide could remove her when she was disruptive. (R 26)

On May 24, 1996, Ms. Antillon wrote to the parents that STUDENT had been assigned for the 1996-97 school year to a special day class at Natural Bridges Elementary School, which is located a few miles from Westlake. (Pet. Exh. ZZ) The District explained that, the following year, Ms. Antillon's class would be an SDC exclusively serving students with autism and that, therefore, it would no longer be appropriate for STUDENT.

On July 3, the parents requested a due process hearing. On August 28, they submitted a request for "stay put." 20 U.S.C. §1415(e)(3). On September 4, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT's stay put placement, pending resolution of due process, and, absent an agreement otherwise, was 50% in Ms. Antillon's SDC at Westlake, with 50% mainstreaming with regular education students.(footnote 7) This ruling reflected STUDENT's placement in the last-agreed upon IEP, that of October, 1995.

4. Fourth grade in Santa Cruz (1996-1997)

During the fall of 1996, pursuant to the stay put order, STUDENT attended Ms. Antillon's SDC in the morning and Bob Avery's regular education fourth grade class in the afternoon. In Ms. Antillon's class, which now consists mostly of students with autism, STUDENT has continued to work on her IEP goals and objectives. Additionally, STUDENT received speech and language therapy from Ms. Fassbinder and VI services from Ms. Tardiff in the SDC room.

When school began, Ms. Antillon and the VI specialist, Ms.

Tardiff, spoke to Mr. Avery's students about "disability awareness," and Mr. and PARENT spoke to the students about STUDENT. Mr. Avery described his daily schedule as follows:

8:15 - 8:20 Daily opening. Attendance, lunch count, collect homework.

8:20 - 9:00 Spelling. Phonics, vocabulary, synonyms, consonant blends, vowels, pronunciation, definitions, spelling games, use words in sentences, practice spelling with a partner, spelling activities.

9:00 - 10:00 Math. Addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, fractions, geometry, measurement, metric system. Review of old unit, introduction of new unit. One day per week use manipulatives such as forms, boards, charts, graphs, and items of measurement.

10:00 - 10:25 Recess.

10:25 - 10:45 Silent reading.

10:45 - 11:45 Reading groups. Introduction of vocabulary and theme; comprehension checks.

11:45 - 12:30 Lunch.

12:30 - 12:50 Teacher reads aloud.

12:50 - 1:00 "Child of the week" question and answer game.

1:00 - 1:20 Journal writing.

1:20 - 1:50 Social studies. California history and geography. Teacher-directed instruction, report-writing, read textbook, class discussions.

1:50 - 2:15 Physical education. Warmup exercises, directed game.

2:15 - 2:45 Science: earth science, electricity, mammals, magnetism, volcanoes, human body, and/or Health: tobacco/alcohol education, getting along with others.

The above schedule varies on certain days:

Monday 1:40 - 2:40 Art.

Tuesday 12:30 - 1:30 Computer lab.

Thursday 10:30 - 11:30 Library.

" " 1:30 - 2:30 Music.

Mr. Avery testified that he believes STUDENT gets no academic or social benefit from his class. STUDENT joins the class each day at about 11:40 a.m., just as the students are getting ready to go to lunch. During the afternoon academic activities, STUDENT does not participate in the curriculum. Her one-to-one aide, Mariah,(footnote 8) engages her in a variety of activities, including touching rice and vibrating toys, feeling the sensation of a small fan blowing in her face, listening to music with headphones, standing, massage, and drinking chocolate milk. Although other children at times walk by and say "hello" to STUDENT, she does not appear to acknowledge them. She does not interact with her classmates and does not model their behavior or language. She does seem to enjoy being pushed in her wheelchair during the afternoon physical education session.

Additionally, the other children showed interest when Mariah talked to them about STUDENT.

Mr. Avery testified that STUDENT's presence is disruptive to the students. The noise from her vocalizations and the vibrating toys distracts them. Also, the students turn around to watch STUDENT because what she is doing is interesting and different. Students seated near STUDENT have asked Mr. Avery to repeat instructions and to move them to different seats because they were distracted by STUDENT. Because of this effect on the students, STUDENT is disruptive to Mr. Avery, too. At times, he has to interrupt the lesson, tell the students to focus on him, and repeat himself. Perhaps two to four times each day, STUDENT is so loud that either Mr. Avery will direct Mariah to remove STUDENT from the classroom or Mariah will decide, on her own, to remove STUDENT.

Mr. Avery, who has been a teacher for twenty-five years and has taught all grades between kindergarten and fourth grade, described some of the differences between lower and higher elementary grades. In the lower grades, students engage more in working in groups and moving around the room. By fourth grade, there is more teacher-directed instruction, and more focus on quiet, individualized, seat-based work. It is a critical year for developing concentration and good study habits.

PARENT testified that during the fall of 1996, STUDENT's one-to-one aide, Mariah, has helped STUDENT to have positive social experiences with Mr. Avery's regular education fourth grade students. For example, Mariah has (1) eaten lunch with STUDENT and peers, (2) encouraged students to push STUDENT in her wheelchair at recess, (3) based on the parents' input, told students what STUDENT did over the weekend during sharing/journal writing, (4) showed students STUDENT's tapes, toys, and pictures, and (5) given STUDENT hand-over-hand guidance so that she could participate in an art project. STUDENT also participated in the class Halloween parade and went on a field trip to a pumpkin patch. On the field trip, a parent of one of Mr. Avery's students told PARENT that she viewed STUDENT's presence in the class positively.

5. Petitioner's Expert Witness

Dr. Kathleen Gee is a professor of special education at San Jose State University who was retained by the parents to provide rebuttal testimony on STUDENT's behalf. (Because Dr. Gee testified on rebuttal, her testimony is discussed in this portion of the Summary of Relevant Evidence.) Dr. Gee has significant experience in attempting to "fully include" students with significant disabilities in regular education classes. In preparation for her testimony, Dr. Gee observed STUDENT at home for several hours, spoke with her parents, and reviewed STUDENT's school records.

Dr. Gee stated that in her opinion, STUDENT could be successfully "fully included" in a regular education fourth grade class. She was critical of the District's efforts to include STUDENT thus far. First, she stated that the District had provided STUDENT with inconsistent inclusion experiences. For example, as a third grader, STUDENT spent some time in a regular education first grade class (Ms. Mercurio's) that was not age-appropriate for her. Also, she attended that first grade class with multiple children with disabilities from Ms. Antillon's SDC, which can be overwhelming for a regular education teacher. Next, during the trial inclusion period, STUDENT attended three separate regular education classes, rather than just one.(footnote 9) Finally, the District has never attempted to "fully include" STUDENT. Rather, she has been "in and out" of regular education classes.

Second, Dr. Gee stated that STUDENT's IEP does not indicate that the District developed a clear curriculum and strategy for teaching STUDENT in regular education classes. She pointed out that District teachers have commented that the regular education curriculum "offers nothing to her" and that it is "impossible" to meet a significantly disabled child's IEP goals and objectives within the regular education class. (Pet. Exh. WW, R 51) The IEP does not specifically indicate what STUDENT will do while the class is engaged in reading, math, social studies, and other subjects. She further stated that there is no evidence that STUDENT's regular education teachers have received guidance from special educators as to how to successfully include STUDENT. She acknowledged that Dr. Shafer, the communications consultant, made some appropriate recommendations regarding improving STUDENT's communication skills, but saw no evidence that the District had actually incorporated the suggestions into STUDENT's program.

Dr. Gee believes that the data kept by District staff show that it has not been necessary to remove STUDENT from class very often because of vocalizations, and that in any event, the vocalizations were more frequent because the District did not develop a curriculum to keep her busy and interested. She acknowledged that even with an appropriate curriculum, STUDENT may be disruptive during tests or other academic activities when the room must be very quiet.

Third, Dr. Gee stated that STUDENT's school records appear to show that the District lacks a commitment to full inclusion. She believes Ms. Antillon's March, 1995 letter to parents of third grade regular education students advising that STUDENT would be participating in those classes portrayed STUDENT in a negative way. (Pet. Exh. ZZ) She acknowledged that Ms. Antillon has prepared some appropriate written material on facilitating friendships (P 54), that the "ability awareness" presentations that Ms. Antillon gives to regular education teaches and students are appropriate, and that the parents told her that STUDENT's current one-to-one aide, Mariah, has done an excellent job of facilitating friendships between STUDENT and her peers in Mr.

Avery's fourth grade regular education class this fall.

Dr. Gee did not make any specific recommendations as to what STUDENT should do during particular academic activities in the regular education classroom. She stated, generally, that appropriate activities for STUDENT could include using an object association communication system, touching objects, engaging in vocal turntaking, and using a "talking book" to interact with peers.

Dr. Gee did not make any specific recommendations as to criteria for measuring STUDENT's progress on her IEP goals and objectives. She suggested that one measure of whether STUDENT's inclusion experience is successful could be whether she is invited to peers' parties.

DISCUSSION

1. Summary of applicable law

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities are entitled to a free, appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1400(c);

§§1401(a)(16-18). A FAPE includes special education and related services that are individually designed to meet a disabled student's unique needs and that are reasonably designed to provide him with educational benefit. Id.; Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207 (1982).

One element of a FAPE is that the student must be educated in the "least restrictive environment," or LRE. 34 C.F.R.

§300.550 et seq.; California Education Code §56031. The federal LRE provision states:

. . . to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities . . . [should be] educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment [shall] occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

20 U.S.C. §1412(5)(B) (emphasis supplied); see also Education Code §56001(g); 56031; 56364. The federal regulations note that the term "supplementary aids and services" is synonymous with "modifications," and describes what is done to the regular education program to ensure a disabled student's satisfactory participation in that program. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix Part C, q. 48. Common examples of supplementary aids and services include a one-to-one aide, curriculum adaptations, and assistive technology.

The IDEA's LRE provision reflects Congress' preference for educating disabled students in regular classrooms with their nondisabled peers. On the other hand, mainstreaming is not an "absolute commandment." Poolaw v. Bishop, 67 F.3d 830, 836 (9th Cir. 1995). The Supreme Court has stated "Despite this preference for mainstreaming handicapped children . . . Congress recognized that regular classrooms simply would not be a suitable setting for the education of many handicapped children." Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 181 n. 4 (1982). The Ninth Circuit has stated that the preference for mainstreaming must be "balanced with the primary objective of providing handicapped children with an appropriate education." Wilson v. Marana Unified School District v. Pima County, 735 F.2d 1178, 1183 (9th Cir. 1984). The Ninth Circuit reiterated this view recently when it stated:

In some cases, such as where the child's handicap is particularly severe, it will be impossible to provide any meaningful education to the student in a mainstream environment. In these situations continued mainstreaming would be inappropriate and educators may recommend placing the child in a special education environment.

Poolaw, supra, 67 F.3d at 834 (13-year-old deaf child who communicated at a very primitive level could not benefit from mainstreaming until he acquired communication skills).

The Ninth Circuit has adopted a four-factor test to consider in determining the "maximum extent appropriate" of integration in regular classes in a particular case:

a. the educational benefits available in the regular class with the use of supplementary aids and services;

b. the nonacademic benefits of interacting with nondisabled students;

c. any negative effects that the child's presence in the regular class has on the teacher and other students;

d. the cost of mainstreaming.

Poolaw, supra, 67 F.3d at 836; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, 35 F.3d 1396, 1401 (9th Cir. 1994);

Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398, 1404 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994).

The parties agree that STUDENT should be mainstreamed during nonacademic activities such as music, art, physical education, recess, lunch, field trips, and assemblies. See 34 C.F.R.

§300.553 (disabled students should be mainstreamed to the maximum extent appropriate during nonacademic activities). Therefore, the Hearing Officer applies the four-factor test to the facts of this case for the purpose of determining to what extent STUDENT should be mainstreamed during academic activities.

2. Application of law to facts of this case a. Educational benefits available in the regular class

The evidence was undisputed that STUDENT does not participate in or gain academic benefit from the regular education fourth grade academic curriculum. See Hudson v.

Bloomfield Hills Public Schools, 910 F. Supp. 1291 ((E.D. Mich. 1995) (14-year-old student with mental retardation worked in isolation with her aide on first and second grade material that was completely different from those used by seventh-grade classmates, and did not participate in the lesson); DeVries v. Fairfax County School Board, 882 F.2d 876 (4th Cir. 1989)

(disabled student would simply be "monitoring" regular education classes). The relevant issue here, however, is not whether STUDENT, who is at the infant stage of development, can keep pace with regular education fourth grade students. Rather, the issue is, given her significant disabilities, whether she can make satisfactory progress on her IEP goals and objectives, with supplementary aids and services such as a one-to-one aide and/or curriculum modification, in the regular education classroom.

See, e.g., Board v. Holland, 786 F.Supp. 874, 882 and n.9 (E.D.Cal. 1992); Mavis v. Sobol, 839 F.Supp. 968 (N.D.N.Y 1994) ("In assessing whether [student] can make satisfactory progress in a regular classroom with supplementary aids and services, such progress must be measured in terms of his abilities as a disabled child.")

The District has provided STUDENT with supplementary aids and services in regular education classes. Her one-to-one aides have given STUDENT hand-over-hand guidance in art, told students about STUDENT during sharing, and encouraged students to push her in her wheelchair during physical education and recess.

STUDENT's regular education teachers and one-to-one aides have received consultation from a special educator, Ms. Antillon, on how to successfully include STUDENT. Ms. Antillon has made presentations on "disability awareness" to regular education students. The District has developed and implemented a behavior plan for STUDENT.

It is undisputed that a main focus of STUDENT's educational program must be in developing her communication abilities.

According to District witnesses, including speech therapist Ms. Fassbinder and VI instructor Ms. Tardiff, meeting STUDENT's IEP goals and objectives in such areas as turntaking and cause and effect requires somewhat noisy, animated interaction between STUDENT's aide and STUDENT. The aide must encourage STUDENT to engage in vocal play and babbling. The aide must use dramatic gestures, physical manipulation, and stimulating materials to attempt to communicate with STUDENT and "bring her out" of her self-stimulating, hands-in-mouth, phase.

However, when STUDENT attends regular education classes during academic activities, the aide is unable to provide her with appropriate instruction. Because STUDENT's vocalizations often disrupt the class, much of the aide's energy during these times is spent trying to keep STUDENT quiet, rather than providing STUDENT with instruction to meet her unique, educational needs. District witnesses testified persuasively that when the regular education class is concentrating on academic activities (direct teacher instruction, student presentations, or quiet, individualized seat work) the regular education class is not an appropriate setting for meeting STUDENT's academic IEP goals and objectives.

The fact that STUDENT attended regular education classes in Colorado in kindergarten through second grade, and that her teachers viewed the experience positively, is relevant but not dispositive here. This case concerns the appropriate placement for STUDENT for fourth grade. The evidence showed that the regular education curriculum changes as one progresses from the lower to higher elementary grades. Whereas in the lower grades, the students engage more in nonacademic activities, group work and moving around the room, the fourth-grade curriculum emphasizes more academics, teacher-directed instruction, and quiet, individualized, seat-based work. Presently, during academic activities, the regular education classroom is not the appropriate place to meet STUDENT's unique, educational needs.

Petitioner's expert witness, Dr. Gee, testified that, in her opinion, the District's inability to meet STUDENT's IEP goals and objectives in regular education classes thus far is attributable to the District's failure to specifically identify what STUDENT will do during each time period when the class is engaging in an academic activity. However, Dr. Gee did not suggest any additional or different activities that STUDENT should engage in; rather, she made reference, generally, to the various activities that STUDENT currently engages in during the school day.

For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that this factor weighs against mainstreaming during academic activities. The evidence shows that during such times, STUDENT cannot make satisfactory progress on her academic IEP goals and objectives in regular education classes, even with supplementary aids and services.

b. Nonacademic benefits of interacting with nondisabled students

Nonacademic benefits of mainstreaming may include having appropriate peer language and behavior role models. Board v.

Holland, supra, 786 F.Supp. at 879. Here, the evidence was undisputed that STUDENT does not model peers' language or behavior. The speech therapist, Ms. Fassbinder, noted that STUDENT has not yet reached the stage of development at which one can imitate others. The evidence further showed that STUDENT engages in very little, if any, interaction with peers during academic activities. See, e.g., Student v. Somerset County Board of Education, 24 IDELR 743 (D. Md. 1996) (ten year old with profound mental retardation did not exhibit any tendency to interact with or model others). District witnesses testified that STUDENT does not appear to recognize or acknowledge peers in class. Rather, she works in isolation with her aide. In fact, during academic activities students have asked to move away from her, and she has been removed from class because of disruptive vocalizations.

The evidence showed that there have been positive social interactions between STUDENT and peers during nonacademic activities. She enjoys being pushed by peers in her wheelchair at recess, other students sit with her and her aide at lunch, students have shown interest in her during sharing, and she has participated in field trips and other special events. The PARENTS and District witnesses have been equally complimentary of the efforts of STUDENT's current one-to-one aide, Mariah, in facilitating these interactions. While it appears that STUDENT derives social benefit from interaction with nondisabled peers during nonacademic activities, there was no evidence that she derives social benefit from attending regular education classes during academic activities. As the Ninth Circuit noted in Poolaw, the "IDEA is primarily concerned with the long term educational welfare of disabled students." 67 F.3d at 836.

In conclusion, this factor weighs against mainstreaming during academic activities.

c. Negative effects that the child's presence in the regular class has on the teacher and other students

Such negative effects may include (a) disruptiveness and/or (b) taking up so much of the teacher's time that other children suffer from lack of attention. Rachel H., supra, 14 F.3d at 1401. This factor is derived in part from the federal regulations, which state in relevant part:

[W]here a [disabled child] is so disruptive in a regular classroom that the education of other students is significantly impaired, the needs of the [disabled]

child cannot be met in that environment. Therefore regular placement would not be appropriate to his or her needs.

34 C.F.R. §300.552, Note.

Both Mr. Avery, the fourth grade teacher, and Ms. Heier, the third grade teacher, testified persuasively that STUDENT's presence is disruptive to the students and the teacher during academic activities. Before determining that a child is too disruptive to be included in the regular class, however, a school district must ensure that consideration has been given to the full range of supplementary aids and services that could be provided to the student in the regular education environment to accommodate his unique needs. U.S. Department of Education, Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP), Memorandum 95-9, 21 IDELR 1152, 1155 (1994); see also Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, 35 F.3d 1396, 1401 n.7 (9th Cir. 1994). One such supplementary aid or service is a behavioral intervention plan, or BIP.

Under California's so-called Hughes Bill, if a child is exhibiting serious behavior problems that significantly interfere with implementation of his IEP, the District should conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of his behavior for the purpose of developing a BIP. Title 5, California Code of Regulations (CCR), Sections 3001(f), 3052(b). The term "serious behavior problems" includes those behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive or cause property damage, and other behaviors that are pervasive, maladaptive and require a systematic and frequent application of behavioral interventions. Title 5, CCR Section 3001(y). Behavioral interventions are to be used to assure the student's placement in the least restrictive environment. Education Code §56523(b)(2)(D); Title 5 CCR Section 3001(d). A BIP sets forth behavioral interventions designed to replace maladaptive behavior with alternative acceptable behaviors that serve the same function for the student. Title 5 CCR Section 3052(a)(2).

The parties agree that this is not a typical Hughes Bill case in that STUDENT's vocalizations, while disruptive, cannot be characterized as misbehavior. The vocalizations are intrinsic to her and her infant stage of development. The evidence showed that, in fact, it is educationally appropriate to encourage STUDENT to engage in vocal play and babbling. However, the federal regulations' reference to "disruptive" behavior is not limited to behavior that is traditionally regarded as misbehavior -- for example, verbal or physical abuse. 34 C.F.R. §300.552, Note; see also Kari H. v. Franklin Special School District, 23 IDELR 538 (M.D. Tenn. 1995) (14-year-old student with severe mental retardation and IQ of 21 engaged in kitten-like sounds, hand-clapping and other loud noises which disrupted the regular education class lessons).

In any event, the evidence showed that pursuant to the Hughes Bill, the District conducted an FAA and developed and implemented a BIP. The District made appropriate, albeit unsuccessful, efforts to replace STUDENT's disruptive vocalizations with other communication behavior that would not disrupt the regular education students and teacher during academic activities.

In conclusion, this factor weighs against educating STUDENT in regular education classes during academic activities.

d. Cost of mainstreaming

Neither party contends that this factor weighs against mainstreaming during academic activities in this case.

3. Conclusion

Based on application of the Ninth Circuit's four-factor test to the facts of this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the "maximum extent appropriate" of mainstreaming for STUDENT is primarily during nonacademic activities such as music, art, physical education, recess, lunch, field trips, and assemblies. Based on the persuasive testimony of the third grade teacher, Ms. Heier, STUDENT should also be mainstreamed during "hands-on"

science.

The District sought herein to move STUDENT from Westlake School, her neighborhood school that she currently attends, to Natural Bridges School, which is approximately two miles away. The Hearing Officer finds that the appropriate school site for implementation of STUDENT's IEP is Westlake School. The federal regulations note that a disabled student should attend school as close to home as possible, and that unless the child's IEP requires some other arrangement, the child should be educated in the school that he or she would attend if nondisabled. 34 C.F.R. 300.552(a)(3); (c). The District did not present any persuasive evidence that STUDENT must attend Natural Bridges School in order for the District to successfully implement her IEP. Rather, the evidence showed that STUDENT's needs can be met by attending Ms. Antillon's SDC that primarily serves students with autism, with mainstreaming with Mr. Avery's regular education fourth grade students as described above.

ORDER

The appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year is in Ms. Antillon's special day class at Westlake Elementary School, with mainstreaming with Mr. Avery's regular education fourth grade class during music, art, physical education, recess, lunch, field trips, and assemblies. STUDENT shall also be mainstreamed during "hands-on" science.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: Respondent prevailed on the issue of the appropriate amount of integration with nondisabled peers for STUDENT.(footnote 10)

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(I).

Dated: December 10, 1996 ______________________ Leonard Garfinkel Hearing Officer California Special Education

Footnotes 1. Ms. Donahue and Ms. Shuttenberg testified by telephone from Colorado by agreement of the parties 2. At the conclusion of the hearing on November 4, 1996, the parties agreed to submit closing briefs on November 25. The parties subsequently agreed to submit the briefs by December 2. 3. On September 23, the Hearing Office received a letter from Ms. Silverman, SCCOE's attorney, stating that SCCOE had consented to waive any potential conflict of interest regarding the Breon, O'Donnell law firm's representation of the District in this case. On the final day of hearing, November 4, Charlotte McAfee, SCCOE, administrator, was present as the District's representative in the absence of Dr. Merchant, the District's interim director of special education.

4. Petitioner's exhibits are designated by "Pet. Exh." followed by exhibit letters. Respondent's exhibits are designated by "R" followed by exhibit numbers.

5. Ms. Antillon testified that during this time period, she telephoned STUDENT's previous teachers in Colorado for advice on this issue. 6. The parents had agreed, in December 1995, to extend the timeline for completion of Ms. Hogan's behavioral assessment. (R 15)

7. As it turned out, Ms. Antillon's SDC in 1996-97 served primarily, but not exclusively, students with autism.

8. Mariah's last name was not identified at the hearing.

9. The Diagnostic Center report, which was completed towards the end of the trial inclusion period, concluded that it would have been preferable for STUDENT to participate in just one regular education third grade class. (R 55, page 4)

10. Petitioner prevailed on the issue regarding which school STUDENT should attend