California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 21, 2003

Student v. Vacaville Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 74-03 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy

Vacaville Unified student with ADHD found ineligible for special education, but District must reimburse parents' private assessment.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 5 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A mother, representing her son herself, filed for a hearing against Vacaville Unified School District. Her son was a 14-year-old ninth grader in general education who had been diagnosed with ADHD (inattentive type) in 1995. She argued that he qualified for special education under Education Code section 56339, which covers ADHD, through the criteria for other health impairment or specific learning disability. She also asked to be reimbursed for a private psychoeducational assessment by Dr. John Miller.

The Hearing Officer assumed the student had ADHD but found he was not eligible. His teachers described him as attentive and insightful. His test scores and grades were average to above average. Missed homework lowered some grades by no more than one grade, and the student completed his work when he was motivated. Nothing linked the missed homework to ADHD. He did not show limited alertness, a processing disorder, or a severe gap between ability and achievement. A daily homework log in general education could address the homework problem.

However, the District knew about the ADHD diagnosis and still did not assess his attention or other health impairment. It had paid for an independent auditory processing assessment, but that did not cure the gap. Its testing errors were explained and harmless. The District was ordered to reimburse the parents for Dr. Miller's assessment within 20 days of receiving proof of cost.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO separated the duty to assess from eligibility. A district that knew of an ADHD diagnosis but never assessed attention had to reimburse a parent's private assessment, even though the student was found ineligible. Paying for a narrower independent assessment did not satisfy the duty to assess all suspected areas.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1(1). Does Student's alleged ADHD–inattentive type make him eligible under Education Code section 56339: is his educational performance adversely affected by ADHD?

    Missed homework lowered some grades, but Student excelled in class work, tests and standardized testing, and no link to ADHD was shown; educational performance was not adversely affected.

  2. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1(2)(a). Does Student demonstrate a need for special education by meeting the criteria for other health impairment under 5 C.C.R. § 3030(f)?

    Even assuming ADHD, Student did not show limited strength, vitality, or alertness adversely affecting his educational performance.

  3. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1(2)(b). Does Student meet the criteria for a specific learning disability under 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)?

    No evidence of a psychological processing disorder or a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement on standardized tests; homework problems could be addressed through general education adaptations.

  4. Issue 2(1). Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the Summer 2002 assessment because the District failed to assess in all areas of suspected disability?

    The District knew of the ADHD diagnosis but did not assess attention processing or other health impairment criteria, so the parents are entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Miller's assessment; the District-funded auditory processing assessment did not cure this.

  5. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2(2). Was the District's assessment inappropriate because its tests were not properly administered, scored, and reported?

    Corrections to the WISC-III birth-date scoring and WJ-R timing and totals were credibly explained, and no score combination showed a severe discrepancy; the assessments were properly administered.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof, the District shall reimburse the parents for the cost of Dr. John Miller's assessment (amount not stated).

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Cal. Educ. Code § 56339; Cal. Educ. Code § 56026; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b)(3); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(f); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(j); 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)

People named in the decision

  • Lynda Donahue, Director of special education, Vacaville Unified School District
  • John R. Capel, Ph.D., Private clinical psychologist (1995 ADHD diagnosis), Retained by parents
  • Richard Pinnell, School psychologist, Vacaville Unified School District
  • Debra Harriman, Resource specialist (RSP) teacher; administered WJ-R, Vacaville Unified School District
  • Anne Kowalski, Resource specialist (RSP) teacher; supervised WJ-R administration, Vacaville Unified School District
  • Kathy Pranke, School nurse, Vacaville Unified School District
  • Carole Mayer, Independent assessor, central auditory processing, Retained by District
  • John Miller, Ph.D., Private clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student, Retained by parents
  • John Hill, Ninth grade science teacher, Will C. Wood High School
  • Deborah Hickerson, Eighth grade honors history teacher, Vaca Pena Middle School
  • Katherine Norton, Ninth grade English teacher, Will C. Wood High School
  • Barbara DeBruler, Eighth grade pre-algebra teacher, Vaca Pena Middle School
  • Gary Kimsey, Public speaking teacher, Will C. Wood High School

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on February 6, 7, 11, 12, and 13, 2003, in Vacaville, California.

STUDENT (hereinafter “STUDENT” or “Petitioner ”) was represented by his mother. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his mother’s friends, FAMILY FRIEND 1 and FAMILY FRIEND 2, who assisted her with the hearing. The Vacaville Unified School District (hereinafter “District ” or “Respondent”) was represented by attorney Jan Tomsky. Lynda Donahue, the District’s director of special education, was also present on behalf of the District.

The Hearing Officer received oral and documentary evidence during the course of the proceedings. On March 3, 2003, the Hearing Officer received closing briefs from the parties and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Does STUDENT’s alleged ADHD–inattentive type–make him eligible for special education services under California Education Code, section 56339?

2. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for educational assessments they obtained for STUDENT in the Summer of 2002?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, born on [date redacted], was fourteen years and eight months old at the time the hearing convened. STUDENT currently lives with his parents in Vacaville, California. He is presently attending the ninth grade in a regular education program at the District’s Will C. Wood High School. STUDENT has not previously been found eligible for special education.

STUDENT began his education in the fall of 1993. He attended kindergarten and a part of the first grade at the District’s Cooper Elementary School. During his first grade year, STUDENT’s parents enrolled STUDENT at the Vacaville Christian Academy (VCA), a private school.

In the fall of 1995, STUDENT was diagnosed with ADD/ADHD (inattentive type) by Dr. John R. Capel, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist retained by STUDENT’s parents.(Footnote 1) Dr. Capel noted in his report that “the most credible indicator of STUDENT’s symptom profile appears to be the information provided by his parents.” Dr. Capel, who also administered standardized cognitive and achievement tests, reported that STUDENT did not meet the criteria for a learning disability at that time.

STUDENT remained at VCA through the fifth grade. Thereafter, STUDENT was home schooled for the first half of his sixth grade year. In the spring of 2000, STUDENT’s parents re-enrolled STUDENT in the District where he completed his sixth grade year at Cooper Elementary School. For the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT attended the seventh grade at the District’s Vaca Pena Middle School. STUDENT continued at Vaca Pena for the 2001-2002 school year where he attended the eighth grade.

In December 2001, STUDENT’s mother, requested that STUDENT be assessed for eligibility for special education services. In her request, STUDENT’s mother expressed her concern regarding STUDENT’s school performance and noted her belief that STUDENT might have a processing disorder along with his ADD.

On January 9, 2002, a Student Study Team was convened. At that meeting STUDENT’s mother signed an assessment plan. The plan called for STUDENT to be assessed for academic achievement, intellectual development, social adaptive behavior, motor development, vision, hearing, health, and, if indicated, speech and language communication.

The District assessed STUDENT in February 2002. The District’s school psychologist, Richard Pinnell, administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children–Third Edition (WISC-III), the Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills (non-motor)–Upper Level, the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills–Upper Level, and the Beery Test of Visual-Motor Integration–Second edition (VMI). As part of his assessment, Mr. Pinnell also observed STUDENT in the classroom, interviewed STUDENT’s mother, and reviewed school records. STUDENT was administered the Woodcock-Johnson Test of Achievement–Revised (WJ-R) was administered by Ms. Debra Harriman, a resource specialist (RSP) teacher for the District. Ms. Anne Kowalski, also an RSP teacher for the District, supervised the administration and scoring of the WJ-R. A developmental history was taken by Kathy Pranke, the school nurse.

On March 6, 2002, Dr. Pinnell completed his initial psychoeducational evaluation report and an IEP team meeting was held. At the meeting, the District members of the team took the position that the assessment results demonstrated that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services. STUDENT’s mother did not agree with the District’s position. She also registered her disagreement with the District’s assessment, specifically referencing Dr. Capel’s report in which STUDENT had been diagnosed with ADHD. On March 28, 2002, Mr. Pinnell re-submitted his psychoeducational report, which included a corrected age for STUDENT as well as corrected scores on standardized tests that are age-normed. The corrected tests scores and report did not change the District’s position on STUDENT’s eligibility.

In April 2002, STUDENT’s mother requested an independent assessment of STUDENT although she did not specifically state which aspects of the District’s assessment she disagreed with. STUDENT’s mother requested that one of three assessors, whom she listed in a letter, be utilized to administer the assessment. In June 2002, STUDENT’s mother signed an assessment plan calling for STUDENT to be assessed for an auditory processing disorder. The assessment was administered on June 29, 2002, by Dr. Carole Mayer, who was not on STUDENT’s mother’s list. Dr. Mayer determined that STUDENT’s auditory processing was within normal range.

In July 2002, STUDENT’s parents retained Dr. John Miller, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist, to provide further psychoeducational assessments. As part of his assessment, Dr. Miller interviewed STUDENT’s mother, reviewed the available records, and administered several assessment instruments. Dr. Miller concluded that STUDENT had ADHD, that he had difficulties with phonemic testing, that his “immediate visual memory fell in the borderline range,” and that his delayed visual memory was in the “low average range.”

An IEP meeting was originally set for October 2002 and then reset for November 14, 2002, at STUDENT’s mother’s request. On November 14 STUDENT’s mother asked that this meeting be postponed because she had not yet received Dr. Miller’s written report, which she wished to share with the IEP team. The District members of the IEP team went forward with the meeting on November 14 and reaffirmed their prior decision that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services.(Footnote 2)

STUDENT’s mother filed for a due process hearing on January 15, 2003.

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Petitioner contends that he is eligible for special education as a child with ADD–inattentive type. Specifically, Petitioner maintains that he was accurately diagnosed with ADD in 1995 when he was in the first grade. Petitioner asserts that he meets the criteria for ADD because he meets the criteria for Other Health Impaired (OHI) and specific learning disability (SLD).

Additionally, Petitioner alleges that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for the assessment administered by Dr. Miller because the District’s assessment was not appropriate Specifically, Petitioner contends that he District failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and that the District’s assessors did not appropriately administer, score, or report the assessments.

Respondent argues that STUDENT is not eligible for special education because he is not in fact a child with ADD, and that he does not meet the criteria of OHI or SLD. Respondent also takes the position that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Miller’s assessment because the District appropriately assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue Number 1: Does STUDENT’s alleged ADHD–inattentive type–make him eligible for special education services under California Education Code, section 56339?

Individuals with exceptional needs are those children who, because of a specified disability, require special education and related services, and who require instruction, services or both which cannot be provided by modification to the regular school program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a), (b).)

The issue in this case is whether STUDENT is eligible for special education services under Cal. Educ. Code, section 56026 and 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3) as a result of his having been previously diagnosed with ADHD. Under Cal. Ed. Code, section 56339, a child whose educational performance is adversely affected by a suspected or diagnosed ADHD and who demonstrates a need for special education and related services by meeting the criteria for other health impairment (OHI), specific learning disability, or emotional disturbance is entitled to special education and related services.(Footnote 3) (Cal. Educ. Code § 56339.) Although the District disputed whether STUDENT in fact has ADHD, the parties did not dispute that he was suspected of being ADHD and that he had previously been diagnosed with ADHD.(Footnote 4) As a result of STUDENT’s ADHD, the Hearing Officer must decide (1) whether STUDENT’s educational performance is adversely affected by a diagnosis of ADHD and (2) whether he demonstrates a need for special education services by (a) meeting the criteria for eligibility as OHI under C.C.R. § 3030(f), and (b) meeting the criteria for eligibility as a child with a specific learning disability under Title 5, C.C.R. § 3030(j).

(1) Educational Performance Adversely Affected

To qualify for special education services under section 56339 the petitioner must establish that his educational performance is adversely affected by his ADHD.

The Petitioner contended that over the past year-and-a-half his educational performance was adversely affected because he missed a number of homework assignments that resulted in some of his grades being lowered. Several of STUDENT’s eighth and ninth grade teachers testified on this issue. Indeed, Mr. John Hill, STUDENT’s ninth grade science teacher, testified that STUDENT’s grade was reduced because he failed to turn in several homework assignments, notably a series of assignments requiring STUDENT to make daily observations of the moon and then record his observations in a daily log. Ms. Deborah Hickerson, STUDENT’s eighth grade honors history teacher, reported that STUDENT missed several homework assignments in her class. Ms. Katherine Norton, STUDENT’s ninth grade English teacher, testified that STUDENT’s grade was lowered due to his missing a number of homework assignments, particularly his weekly vocabulary exercises. Ms. Barbara DeBruler, STUDENT’s eighth grade algebra teacher, reported that STUDENT missed five homework assignments the first semester of the year and six the second semester. She too said that STUDENT’s missing assignments depressed his math grade. Finally, Mr. Gary Kimsey, STUDENT’s ninth grade public speaking teacher, explained that early in the semester STUDENT did not turn in all of his written homework assignment, which resulted in STUDENT’s grade being lowered.

Although the District did not dispute that STUDENT had failed on a number of occasions over the past year-and-a-half to turn in homework assignments, the District argued that STUDENT’s educational performance was not adversely affected by ADHD. Additionally, the District took the position that there was no nexus between any ADHD that STUDENT may have and his failure to turn in some of his homework. In support of the District’s position, STUDENT’s teachers uniformly described his academic performance in their respective classes as above average. Mr. Hill testified that STUDENT has been in his ninth grade environmental science class since September 2002. He described the class as an overview of various physical science topics including scientific method, introduction to chemistry, the properties of matter, geology, and earth science. Mr. Hill explained that the material is presented through class lectures, group discussions, and the text book. Mr. Hill reported that STUDENT’s attention in class is excellent, that he is always engaged, participates regularly–receiving extra points for doing so, appears prepared, takes notes, asks appropriate questions, and offers insightful comments. Mr. Hill also described STUDENT’s participation in lab exercises and group activities as appropriate. In fact, he said other students look to STUDENT for guidance during group activities. Mr. Hill also explained that he gives in-class tests at the end of each chapter or unit, and he noted that STUDENT’s tests scores are some of the highest in the class. Additionally, Mr. Hill pointed out that several students in his class are regularly noisy and disruptive but that STUDENT has never been distracted by their conduct. Finally, Mr. Hill testified that STUDENT understands and has an above average grasp of the material covered in his class. STUDENT’s grade in Mr. Hill’s class at the time of the hearing was “a solid B.”

Ms. Hickerson taught STUDENT’s eighth grade history class. She explained that her class was an advanced honors course for students who exhibited superior abilities in the seventh grade. As discussed above, Ms. Hickerson noted that STUDENT had failed to turn in several homework assignments. However, she pointed out that STUDENT had missed these assignments following absences which he did not check the homework log on his return. Ms. Hickerson also testified that STUDENT’s responses to questions in class were “occasionally” wrong or “not on target.” Additionally she said, he was generally quiet and appeared tired at times during her seventh-period class. She formed the impression that STUDENT was not always motivated by the subject matter of her course. Ms. Hickerson said that she gave her students in-class tests approximately every three weeks. Although Ms. Hickerson did not recall STUDENT’s exact test scores, she said that she would have remembered if STUDENT had done poorly on his exams. She added that STUDENT’s participation in class was appropriate and there was no indication that he did not understand the material. Ms. Hickerson testified that STUDENT received a C grade for the first semester (fall 2001), and that his score would have been “a solid or high B” if he had not missed his homework assignments. Moreover, she stated that based on his performance in her class, STUDENT would have received an A in a regular, non-honors history course.

Ms. Norton is STUDENT’s current ninth grade English teacher. She testified that for the most part STUDENT is focused and attentive in class. Ms. Norton said that STUDENT understands the content of the course material and, if he does not understand a point, he asks appropriate clarifying questions. Ms. Norton also noted that STUDENT’s performance on in-class tests and routine quizzes is average to above-average. She stated that STUDENT’s current overall grade is a B, and that his in-class work is A or B quality.

Ms. DeBruler taught STUDENT’s eighth grade pre-algebra class, which she described as an advanced math course. Ms. DeBruler stated that STUDENT missed five or six of 50 homework assignments in each of the first two quarters, which she said was normal for a boy his age. Thereafter, Ms. DeBruler said that STUDENT virtually quit doing his homework in the third (of three) quarters after she informed him that he would not be able to take geometry in ninth grade without first taking ninth grade algebra. She also reported that she observed STUDENT to be anxious and tense in class and sometimes seemed startled or “jumpy” when she called on him in class. She did not, however, believe that STUDENT’s anxiety or tenseness interfered with his class performance. Ms. DeBruler said that STUDENT was attentive in class, on task, and eager to answer questions. She stated that STUDENT scored between 75 and 85 percent on tests covering nine of ten lessons and that he scored 91 percent on the tenth. Ms. DeBruler testified that STUDENT could understand and follow multi-step complicated algebraic problems and that he could organize and manipulate multiple factors and symbols in a math equation. She noted that STUDENT demonstrated these skills on the blackboard and in response to oral questions asked in conjunction with in-class discussions.

Mr. Kimsey taught STUDENT in a single-semester, public speaking course in the fall of 2002. Although STUDENT was in the ninth grade when he took the course, the class included students in grades nine through twelve. Mr. Kimsey described his public speaking class as a college preparatory course that is patterned along the lines of the twelfth grade English class that he also teaches. In the public speaking class, STUDENT and his classmates were required to express themselves in individual writing assignments followed by oral presentations to the class. Mr. Kimsey explained that in the first half of the course, students were required to write persuasive essays and then defend their position in an oral presentation or debate. Mr. Kimsey said that STUDENT was not always on time in completing his written essays, but that he was one of the best students in the class when it came to oral presentations or debate. He testified that STUDENT utilized good speaking skills, crafting appropriate words, employing good eye contact, and asking good rhetorical questions. The second half of the course required the students to write original poetry and orally present their writings to the class for critique. According to Mr. Kimsey, STUDENT produced some of the best poetry in the class–15 pieces in all. He described STUDENT’s skill for crafting phrases and said that STUDENT had a talent for putting words together to create a visual picture. Mr. Kimsey noted that these poems were assignments that constituted written homework and that STUDENT never missed completing these assignments. He presented his poems orally to the class on an average of four times a week, sometimes twice a day. In fact, Mr. Kimsey observed that on many occasions STUDENT’s classmates requested that he read his poems. Mr. Kimsey testified that STUDENT received a B+ or A- in his class, and that his grade would have been even higher if he had not missed some written assignments early in the semester.

As noted above, the parties did not dispute that STUDENT failed to turn in some of his homework assignments, which resulted in his grades being lowered. But whether STUDENT turned in all of his homework assignments is not the only measure of his educational performance. Each of STUDENT’s teachers who testified at the hearing explained that homework was only one component of the work in their respective classes. In fact, homework comprised no more than 25 percent of the total grade points in any of these classes, and STUDENT’s missed assignments accounted for no more than one grade reduction. As discussed above, the majority of STUDENT’s educational program included lectures, discussions, group activities, in class reading and written assignments, oral presentations, lab projects, tests, and quizzes. The evidence established that STUDENT excelled in virtually every aspect of these components to his educational program, and that these components comprised the bulk of his entire program. This fact is borne out by STUDENT’s grades. In spite of missing assignments, STUDENT continued to demonstrate superior knowledge of the subject matter and receive average to above average grades.

Moreover, STUDENT’s teachers stated that STUDENT actually turned in the vast majority of his assignments. In most cases, STUDENT’s missed assignments amounted to approximately ten percent of the total homework assigned. The only exception was that STUDENT quit doing his homework entirely in the final quarter of his eighth grade pre-algebra class. But the evidence indicated that STUDENT consciously made this decision after being told by Ms. DeBruler that he could not advance directly to geometry in the ninth grade without first taking ninth grade algebra. In contrast, the evidence suggests that when STUDENT is motivated by a particular teacher or enjoys the content of the course work, such as Mr. Kimsey’s poetry class,he remembers to do all of his homework. Thus, his failure to complete some of his homework assignments over the past year-and-a-half does not appear to be the result of a disability.

In short, STUDENT excelled in almost every aspect of his educational program, and his failure to complete some of his homework assignments does not override this fact. Additionally, STUDENT’s scores on his annual standard achievement tests (SAT) consistently ranged from average to significantly above average, with most of the scores being above average, in virtually every academic area. These scores confirm the teachers observations that STUDENT grasped the subject matter presented in his courses. Finally, the Petitioner did not establish any nexus between STUDENT’s ADHD and his failure to turn in some of his homework assignments.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s educational performance is not adversely affected by his ADHD.

(2) Need for Special Education Services

To be found eligible under section 56339, Petitioner must also demonstrate that he needs special education services because he meets the eligibility requirements for (a) other health inpaired and (b) specific learning disability.

(a) Other Health Impairment

A pupil qualifies for special education as OHI if, due to an acute or chronic illness, he has limited strength, vitality, or alertness that adversely affects his educational performance. (Title 5 C.C.R. § 3030(f).)(Footnote 5)

Petitioner did not directly address the issue of whether STUDENT exhibited limited strength, vitality, or alertness that adversely affects his or her educational performance. However, Petitioner, who was not represented by counsel, attempted to establish that he has ADHD and that his impairment adversely interfers with his educational performance. Again, for purposes of analysis, the Hearing Officer will assume that STUDENT has ADHD and will review the evidence to determine whether STUDENT exhibits limited strength, vitality, or alertness that adversely affects his educational performance.

STUDENT’s abilities and classroom performance are set forth in detail above. To summarize, STUDENT’s teachers portrayed him as intelligent and insightful. Their testimony made clear that STUDENT could recall and manipulate data, make logical inferences, follow the course materials, remain focused and on task, and appropriately participate in class. The testimony provided by STUDENT’s teachers indicated that STUDENT was usually alert in class, energetic during oral presentations and group activities, responsive, and fully aware of what was going on in class. In addition to the testimony from STUDENT’s teachers, Dr. Miller indicated in his report that STUDENT “does not have deficits in his ability to plan ahead, to exercise adequate judgement in a number of situations, to separate critical from irrelevant aspects of a situation, and to benefit dependably from trial-and-error experiences in a variety of environmental types of feedback.”

The evidence presented at hearing clearly demonstrates that STUDENT has not exhibited limited strength, vitality, or alertness that adversely affects his educational performance. In fact, STUDENT’s performance in school as described by his teachers demonstrates that he is alert and possesses mental vigor and strength. He clearly has the mental ability to perform complex algebraic calculations, learn sophisticated physical science concepts, understand the lessons presented in an honors history class, write quality poetry, and orally present and defend his positions before his classmates. Moreover, the evidence established that STUDENT is alert, vital, and sufficiently possessed of mental strength to consistently add insightful comments to class discussions. Finally, there was no evidence to indicate that STUDENT’s failure to turn in all of his homework assignments was a result of his having limited strength, vitality, or alertness. STUDENT’s mother credibly testified that STUDENT tended to complete his assignments and do well when he was motivated by a particular teacher or his interest in the subject matter. STUDENT’s mother’s observations were borne out by STUDENT’s completing all of his poetry homework assignments in Mr. Kimsey’s class. Thus, whatever the reason for STUDENT’s not completing all of his homework assignments, the evidence establishes that STUDENT does not have an inherent inability to understand or complete his homework.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not exhibit limited strength, vitality, or alertness that adversely affects his or her educational performance and thus he does not meet the eligibility requirements under OHI.

(b) Specific learning disability(Footnote 6)

Under Title 5, C.C.R. §3030(j), a pupil is considered eligible for special education with a specific learning disability if:

The pupil has a disorder of one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, spoken or written, which may manifest itself in an impaired ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations, and has a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the academic areas specified in §56337(a).

As set forth above, Mr. Pinnell, Dr. Mayer, and Dr. Miller each administered a variety of assessments to determine whether STUDENT was eligible for special education services. Mr. Pinnell and Dr. Mayer testified that their assessments indicated that STUDENT did not demonstrate a disorder of any of his basic psychological processes. Additionally, Mr. Pinnell reported that the assessments indicated that STUDENT did not demonstrate a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the academic areas specified in §56337(a). Although Dr. Miller testified that STUDENT’s “immediate visual memory fell in the borderline range,” and that his delayed visual memory was in the “low average range,” he did not assert that STUDENT has a disorder of any of the basic psychological process specified under title 5, C.C.R. § 3030(j)(1). Moreover, Dr. Miller did not claim that STUDENT demonstrated a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement–as measured by standardized achievement tests–in one or more of the academic areas specified in §56337(a).(Footnote 7)

In short, there was no evidence presented at the hearing to suggest that STUDENT demonstrated a severe discrepancy between intellectual and achievement within the meaning of Cal. Ed. Code, section or Title 5, C.C.R. § 3030(j).

Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not establish that STUDENT meets the eligibility requirements for a specific learning disability under title 5, C.C.R. § 3030(j).

Conclusion

The evidence established that STUDENT is a personable, intelligent, bright, and hardworking student with above average academic skills and abilities. The fact that he has recently encountered problems completing all of his homework assignments should not be ignored. However, there was no evidence presented at the hearing to indicate that STUDENT’s failure to turn in all of his homework assignments cannot be addressed by implementing adaptions to his regular education programs adaptions that could include daily homework logs to be monitored by both STUDENT’s teachers and his parents, as provided for under Cal. Ed. Code, section 56339(d).

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that even assuming that STUDENT is ADHD, he does not demonstrate a need for special education services because he does not meet the criteria for eligibility under section 56339, or as a child with OHI, or a child with a specific learning disability.

Issue Number 2: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for educational assessments they obtained for STUDENT in the Summer of 2002?

State special education law states that a parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by a public agency and the agency’s assessment is determined to be inappropriate. (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).)

Petitioner asserts that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for assessments administered by Dr. Miller because the District’s assessment was inappropriate in that (1) the District did not assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, and (2) the District’s assessments were not properly administered, scored, and reported.(Footnote 8)

(1) Assessment in All Areas of Suspected Disability

Special education law requires that a student be tested in all areas related to the suspected disability. (Cal. Ed. Code § 56320(f).)

In this case, Petitioner asserted that the District’s assessment was not appropriate because it failed to consider STUDENT’s previous diagnosis of ADHD and to consider whether STUDENT was eligible for special education as a result of it.

The District argued that its February 2002 assessment was appropriate, and that even if it was not, the District is not required to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for Dr. Miller’s assessment. The District asserts that it is not required to reimburse the PARENTs because after STUDENT’s mother expressed her disagreement with Mr. Pinnell’s February 2002 assessment and requested an independent educational evaluation (IEE), the District granted STUDENT’s mother’s request for an IEE and retained Dr. Mayer to assess STUDENT for an audio processing disorder. The District takes the position that it has the right to select an IEE of its choice, and that the PARENTSs do not have the right to reimbursement for an educational assessment since the District provided such an assessment.

Obviously, the issue is not how many assessments the District provided, independent or otherwise. The pertinent question is whether the District in fact assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. If it did not, STUDENT’s parents have the right to reimbursement for Dr. Miller’s assessment under section 56329(b). Thus, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the District assessed STUDENT in all areas of his suspected disability.

Notes from the January 9, 2002, Student Study Team (SST) meeting indicate that STUDENT’s mother expressed her concerns over STUDENT’s academic progress as a result of auditory or visual processing disorders. The notes also reflect that STUDENT’s mother told the team that she observed STUDENT to “become overcome” and be “forgetful.” Additionally, two different portions of the report indicate that STUDENT’s mother reported that STUDENT was diagnosed with ADHD and was taking the drug Adderal. In February 2002 the District conducted its assessment and Mr. Pinnell issued his report. Mr. Pinnell’s assessment report specifically notes that STUDENT’s mother had provided a report from Dr. Capel that included the 1995 ADHD diagnosis. Mr. Pinnell’s report, however, indicates that he did not address STUDENT’s suspected ADHD, i.e., issues relating to attention processing–one of the basic psychological processes identified in Title 5, C.C.R. § 3030(j). Instead, Mr. Pinnell’s assessment report suggests that information regarding STUDENT’s ADHD be obtained in the future and the matter should be addressed in a future 504 plan.

At the March 6, 2002 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s mother registered her disagreement with the District’s February assessment. The IEP notes reflect that STUDENT’s mother did not believe that the District’s assessment provided a “true and accurate synopsis of STUDENT,” and she specifically expressed her concern that STUDENT had regressed since Dr. Capel’s assessment. (As previously noted, Dr. Capel was the person who had assessed STUDENT in 1995 and diagnosed him as being moderately ADHD–inattentive type.)

Following the March 2002 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s mother and the District exchanged a series of letters and e-mails regarding assessments, both before and after the June 2002 independent assessment for central auditory processing undertaken by Dr. Mayer. The exchanges generally related to the scope of the independent assessment and selection of the assessor. Although the letters and testimony regarding this issue are confusing (it appears that the parties were talking past each other) the gist of STUDENT’s mother’s point was that STUDENT needed “neuropsychological” testing and the District believed that it had obtained the assessment STUDENT’s mother wanted–assessments for central auditory processing. The evidence derived at hearing indicates that STUDENT’s mother does not possess the expertise to necessarily use accurate or precise terms to communicate her concerns, but since at least January 2002, she had clearly expressed a concern that STUDENT’s ADHD might at least play a role in his alleged academic difficulties.

As discussed above, a child is eligible for special education with OHI if due to an acute or chronic illness he has limited strength, vitality, or alertness that adversely affects his educational performance. (Title 5, C.C.R. § 3030(f).) Thus, under section 56320(f) the District should have assessed STUDENT to determine whether his suspected ADHD constituted an acute or chronic illness and whether STUDENT exhibit limited strength, vitality, or alertness. The District, however, did not undertake such an assessment, nor did it assess STUDENT’s attention processes and specifically analyze them to determine whether there was a nexus between his ability to attend and his academic performance. Thus the District did not assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. And the fact that the Hearing Officer found that the evidence adduced at hearing did not support a finding of eligibility does not negate (after-the-fact) the District’s obligation to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that because the District did not assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, Petitioner’s STUDENT’s parents are entitled to be reimbursed for Dr. Miller’s assessment.

(2) Appropriate Administration of Assessments(Footnote 9)

Special education also requires that assessments be administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and assessment material. (Cal. Ed. Code § 56320(b)(3).)

At the hearing, Petitioner questioned Mr. Pinnell, Ms. Harriman, and Ms. Kawalski regarding the administration and scoring of the assessment tests, specifically the WISC-III and the WJ-R. Ms. Harriman and Ms. Kowalski were questioned regarding erasure marks on the scoring sheets on the WJ-R. Both witnesses credibly testified that at Ms. Kowalski’s suggestion, Ms. Harriman had merely changed how the time on the test was recorded, i.e., she had initially recorded the time in hours and minutes and changed the format to only minutes. The actual time was not changed. Ms. Harriman was also questioned regarding the scoring of two subtests. Ms. Harriman, with the protocol in front of her, credibly pointed out that the scoring was accurate, but that the correct answers on the protocol were not correctly totaled. However, the error was in STUDENT’s favor. In other words, the corrected scores diminished even further the discrepancy between the WISC-III and WJ-R scores.

Mr. Pinnell was also questioned about corrections that he made to the scores on the WISC-III. Mr. Pinnell credibly testified that he had initially inserted the wrong birth date for STUDENT when he scored the WISC-III. He explained that the test is age normed and computer scored. Mr. Pinnell pointed out that by initially putting the wrong birth date into the computer the raw scores on the test were incorrectly translated into standard scores and percentiles. Mr. Pinnell corrected the birth date and scoring and a corrected report was issued on March 28, 2002, after the March 6 IEP meeting. Petitioner did not present any evidence that scores, i.e., the number of his right and wrong answers to the test questions, were anything but what was recorded on the test protocols. It is also important to note that no combination of WISC-III and WJ-R scores–corrected or uncorrected-demonstrated a severe discrepancy as defined in Title 5, C.C.R. § 3030(j). Finally, Dr. Miller, who was retained by Petitioner to assess STUDENT and provided expert testimony on his behalf, relied on the District’s assessment tests in making his own assessment.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the assessments administered by the District were administered appropriately.

ORDER

1. Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner’s parents for the cost of Dr. Miller’s assessment.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Does STUDENT’s alleged ADHD–inattentive type–make him eligible for special education services under California Education Code, section 56339? Respondent prevailed on this issue.

2. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for educational assessments they obtained for STUDENT in the Summer of 2002? Petitioner prevailed on this issue as it relates to assessing in all areas of suspected disability, and Respondent prevailed on the issue as it relates to the administration, scoring, and recording of the assessment.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties in this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)

Date: March 21, 2003 ___________________________________ Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Due to the ever-changing and often confusing acronyms for attention deficit disorder and attention deficit hyperactive disorder, i.e., ADD and ADHD–both of which include the subgroup “inattentive type,” the Hearing Officer will utilize the acronym ADHD when referring to the general condition and will specify the “type” when it is relevant to the discussion. 2. STUDENT’s mother originally alleged several procedural violations in the case. At the hearing, STUDENT’s mother conceded that if the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services, Petitioner would not be entitled to a remedy. Conversely, the District agreed that if STUDENT was found eligible, it would be liable for compensatory education. Thus, the parties agreed that it was not necessary to litigate the claims of procedural violations. 3. Emotional disturbance was not an issue in this case.

4. Although the Petitioner did not establish that he is in fact ADHD, for purposes of analyzing this case, the Hearing Officer will assume that he is. 5. Although the Hearing Officer’s finding that STUDENT’s educational performance was not adversely affected by his diagnosis of ADHD is dispositive to his being found eligible under section 56339, the Hearing Officer will analyze whether STUDENT’s is eligible under OHI for purposes of analytical continuity. Additionally, Petitioner did not allege or present any evidence that STUDENT exhibited any limitations to his physical strength, alertness, and vitality. Thus, the Hearing Officer will review the evidence to determine whether STUDENT exhibited any limitations to his mental strength, alertness, and vitality. 6. Although the Hearing Officer’s finding that STUDENT’s educational program is not adversely affected by his diagnosis of ADHD is dispositive as it relates to section Cal. Ed. Code § 56339 and title 5, C.C.R. § 3030(f), it does not necessarily negate a finding that STUDENT is eligible under Title 5, C.C.R. § 3030(j); therefore, the Hearing Officer will consider whether STUDENT is eligible as a student with a specific learning disability. 7. Although, Dr. Miller opined that STUDENT met the criteria under the DSM IV for “learning disability–not otherwise specified,” he did not attempt to assert that STUDENT met the criteria for special education eligibility under Title 5, C.C.R. § 3030(j). Dr. Miller also believed that STUDENT demonstrated a discrepancy between his aptitude and his grades, he did not allege that STUDENT demonstrated a severe discrepancy between his intellectual ability and achievement based on standardized tests described in Title 5, C.C.R. § 3030(j)(3) and (4). 8. The parties did not dispute the fact that Petitioner obtained an independent assessment from Dr. Miller because his parents disagreed with the assessments undertaken by the District. 9. Because the Hearing Officer found that the District did not assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and that Petitioner’s STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Miller’s assessment, it is not necessary to address Petitioner’s claims regarding the administration of the assessments for purposes of resolving the question of reimbursement. However, since the Hearing Officer relies in part on the District’s assessment in determining that STUDENT is not eligible for special education as a child with a specific learning disability, it is necessary to address Petitioner’s claim on this issue.