California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 1, 2004

Student v. Los Gatos-Saratoga Joint Union High School District

SEHO Case No. SN 743-04 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino

Los Gatos-Saratoga Joint Union High School District should have found an eleventh grader with depression eligible; reimbursement and compensatory education denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 3 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A 17-year-old eleventh grader at Los Gatos High School filed for due process against Los Gatos-Saratoga Joint Union High School District. She took mostly honors and advanced classes. Her depression returned in fall 2003, and she missed many school days from October through December. Her mother told the school about the depression in October. Her pediatrician wrote that it could take months to stabilize her condition. In December, a student study team decided she did not qualify for a Section 504 plan. It suggested regular education steps instead: easier classes, tutoring, campus counseling, and waiving the attendance policy. The District did not offer a special education assessment plan until April 2004.

The Hearing Officer found that the District should have suspected a disability and referred her for assessment by the end of October 2003. Under the timelines, an IEP meeting was due by about January 24, 2004. The Hearing Officer rejected the school psychologist's six-month rule for "long period of time" and found that she met the criteria for emotional disturbance. She needed counseling designed to help her attend school, delivered through an IEP with goals and coordination. Regular education supports could not meet that need. She was denied a FAPE from January 24 through April 26, 2004. However, the Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for tutoring and for private therapy and psychiatric care. Compensatory education was also denied because no lost educational opportunity was shown. The only order declared her eligible for that period.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a high-achieving student with depression. Good grades and regular education supports did not defeat child find or emotional disturbance eligibility when she needed counseling coordinated through an IEP. It also shows that finding a denial of FAPE did not lead to reimbursement or compensatory education without proof that tied the costs or losses to that denial.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedChild find

    Issue 1A. From October 2003 through the present, did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to conduct a timely assessment for special education in accordance with "child find" requirements?

    By the end of October 2003 the District should have suspected a disability and referred Student for assessment; with statutory timelines, an IEP meeting was due by about January 24, 2004.

  2. Student prevailed in partEligibility

    Issue 1B. From October 2003 through the present, did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to find Student eligible for special education?

    Student met emotional disturbance criteria and needed counseling services delivered through an IEP, which regular education could not provide; she was denied a FAPE from January 24 through April 26, 2004, with no finding for later dates.

  3. Issue 2. If the District denied Student a FAPE, is Student entitled to reimbursement for tutoring costs, reimbursement for counseling and psychiatric therapy, and compensatory education?

    Tutoring costs mostly came before the denial period and later costs were not proven. Private therapy and psychiatric care would have been obtained anyway and did not target educational needs. No lost educational opportunity was shown to support compensatory education.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order declaring that Student was eligible for special education from January 24, 2004, through April 26, 2004; no findings on eligibility after that date.
  • All other requests for relief (tutoring reimbursement, reimbursement for therapy and psychiatric care, compensatory education) denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Student W. v. Puyallup School District

People named in the decision

  • Kathleen Eaton, assistant principal, Los Gatos High School
  • Dan Fowler, assistant principal for attendance and discipline, Los Gatos High School
  • Trudy McCulloch, principal, Los Gatos High School
  • Geraldine K. Watanabe, academic advisor, Los Gatos High School
  • Sharon Trattner, Ph.D., school psychologist, Los Gatos High School
  • Tonja Krautter, Ph.D., private clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student, Private provider
  • Kurt Croesche, regular education teacher, Los Gatos High School
  • Sandra Morse, M.D., private pediatrician, Private provider
  • Sharon Paley, M.D., private psychiatrist, Private provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, on April 22 and 23, 2004, in Riverside, California, and the hearing was concluded by telephone conference on April 26, 2004.

Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented by attorney Valerie J. Mulhollen. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was her mother, MOTHER. Respondent Los Gatos-Saratoga Joint Union High School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorney Laurie E. Reynolds from the office of Lozano Smith, Attorneys at Law. Also present on the District’s behalf was Kathleen Eaton, assistant principal at Los Gatos High School (LGHS).

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Ms. Eaton; MOTHER; Dan Fowler, assistant principal in charge of attendance and discipline at LGHS; Trudy McCulloch, principal at LGHS; Geraldine K. Watanabe, academic advisor at LGHS; Sharon Trattner, Ph.D., LGHS school psychologist; and Tonja Krautter, Ph.D., clinical psychologist. The District called the following witnesses: Ms. Eaton and Kurt Croesche, regular education teacher at LGHS.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Closing briefs were received on May 11, 2004, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

Issue 1: From October 2003 through the present, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by (A) failing to conduct a timely assessment for special education in accordance with “child find” requirements, and (B) failing to find STUDENT eligible for special education?

Issue 2: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for tutoring costs, reimbursement for counseling and psychiatric therapy, and compensatory education?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, born [date redacted], is a 17-year-old student who has resided within the District at all times pertinent to this case. She is currently in the eleventh grade at LGHS. Until the initiation of a still-pending assessment that commenced in April 2004, she had never been assessed for special education. She also has never been found eligible by the District for special education.

STUDENT’s mother testified that beginning in December 2002 or early January 2003, she noticed that STUDENT was unusually quiet, had some “issues” with clothing style, had difficulty sleeping, and was being affected by nightmares. She brought STUDENT to pediatrician Sandra Morse, M.D., who diagnosed STUDENT as having depression. After the commencement of treatment with medications, STUDENT’s moods “evened out” and her sleeplessness resolved. STUDENT’s mother further testified that because STUDENT was performing well in school during that period, she did not report STUDENT’s condition to the District.

STUDENT started her eleventh-grade school year in September 2003. At the end of September or early in October 2003, STUDENT reported to her mother that the depression symptoms were returning. MOTHER brought STUDENT back to Dr. Morse, and medications were increased. By email dated October 7, 2003, MOTHER notified the District and STUDENT’s LGHS teachers that STUDENT “. . . has not been feeling well lately and is on medication for depression. We are working with her physician and a counselor. Currently, the physician is adjusting STUDENT’s medication. If she appears not quite engaged in class or a little slow with her work, it is not because she doesn’t care and is negligent. It will take a little while for her to get adjusted . . . If there is anything I can do to help support STUDENT and the work she is doing in your classes, then please, by all means, let me know.”

Dr. Morse submitted a letter to the District on October 28, 2003, stating that STUDENT was “under medical care for conditions that may require she miss school from time to time. She should be allowed to participate in classes and activities as able. We will hopefully stabilize her situation over the next few months. Her mother may need to obtain her assignments and tutoring to continue her school work when she is unable to attend school.”

According to MOTHER, the symptoms that arose in October 2003 were substantially worse than STUDENT’s symptoms in the previous winter. STUDENT became physically ill, suffering from nausea, severe headaches, bodyaches, and light sensitivity and other vision problems. She acquired self-injurious behaviors, including physically cutting herself. By late October or early November, Dr. Morse had referred STUDENT’s care to Sharon Paley, M.D., a psychiatrist. Dr. Paley treated STUDENT with various medications.

STUDENT’s symptoms caused her to miss significant amounts of school in the fall of 2003. STUDENT’s mother testified that she would often find STUDENT “curled up in a ball” and wanting to stay in a dark room. LGHS attendance records show that STUDENT was absent from school during all or major portions of two days in September, ten days in October, fourteen days in November, and eight days in December. From October through December, MOTHER attempted to help STUDENT by arranging to have school assignments either picked up from school or otherwise sent home, and by providing a tutor. The evidence was unclear as to how STUDENT actually received her assignments during that period.

A “student study team” (SST) meeting was convened by the District on December 12, 2003, to address STUDENT’s depression and difficulties with school attendance. According to the SST meeting notes, STUDENT’s grades for each class through that point in the first semester were three “A’s,” one “B,” two “C’s, and one “Pass.” Written input solicited from teachers mentioned STUDENT’s excessive absences, incomplete assignments, and, in at least one instance, declining grades. Because STUDENT was not remaining current in her work, STUDENT’s accelerated-algebra 2 teacher suggested that STUDENT drop and then retake the class. The meeting notes summarize STUDENT’s treatment for depression, specifically that medications were being changed, that she was being monitored by a psychiatrist, that she was receiving therapy from a licensed clinical social worker, and that she would begin receiving group therapy in January 2004.

The SST report contains no mention of whether or how the District or LGHS intended to assist STUDENT. However, according to LGHS assistant principal Kathleen Eaton, who attended the meeting, the SST determined that STUDENT did not have a mental or physical impairment that was substantially limiting a major life activity and, therefore, STUDENT did not meet the criteria for a “504 plan.” (Footnote 1) Considered in making that determination, according to Ms. Eaton, were the facts that STUDENT was “receiving all college qualifying grades in a schedule of mostly honors, AP, and accelerated classes”; that she “was attending her field hockey practices daily while, on many occasions, not attending some or all of her academic classes”; and that although she was diagnosed with depression, she was taking medications for her depression and was receiving therapy. Among the interventions suggested by the District at that meeting were: (1) relieve stress on STUDENT by having her move from “one, some, or all of her AP and accelerated classes to the regular college prep level class(es)”; (2) have STUDENT participate in daily tutorial and afternoon tutoring programs to try to “catch up”; (3) have STUDENT receive counseling through the “Teen Counseling Center” on campus; (4) assist STUDENT to “catch up and prepare for finals” by having MOTHER “email her daughter’s teachers to get a list of work that STUDENT could complete over the Winter Break”; and (5) have LGHS waive its attendance policy “in light of STUDENT’s condition.” MOTHER reportedly sent such emails to STUDENT’s teachers on December 15. (Footnote 2)

STUDENT did not change or drop her classes. With the aide of a tutor hired by MOTHER, by performing significant amounts of her school work at home, and by virtue of the fact that her symptoms subsided in December and January, STUDENT was able to finish the first semester on January 20, 2004, with grades of “A-” in comparative literature, “Pass” in advanced placement U.S. history, “C+” in accelerated algebra 2, “A” in varsity field hockey, “B” in accelerated chemistry, “C” in honors Spanish, and “A” in teacher/office assistant. Her “weighted” GPA for that semester was 3.00, dropping her overall weighted GPA to 3.385. (Footnote 3)

Throughout January and February 2004, STUDENT was participating in weekly group-therapy sessions and was also seeing a therapist on an individual basis. Attendance records show that she missed only one day of school in January. She missed six days in February, although not necessarily for reasons related to depression. During the week of March 8, her symptoms of depression worsened, and she resumed missing school. (Footnote 4) On or about March 15, MOTHER and Ms. Eaton met to discuss the situation. Options offered by the District included a home teacher, changing the level of one or more of her classes while not going below college preparatory level, waiving the attendance policy, dropping one or two of her current classes and taking them during the summer to allow her to concentrate during the current semester on her remaining classes, and having the District write explanatory letters to the colleges of STUDENT’s choice. MOTHER suggested that STUDENT have two classes at school and the other three at home with a teacher, and she stated that she would consider the District’s proposal during the next few days.

On March 17, 2004, by email to LGHS and all of STUDENT’s teachers, MOTHER stated her specific requests for accommodations. Those requested accommodations were that (1) STUDENT would attend AP history and accelerated chemistry daily; (2) for English, accelerated algebra 2, and Spanish 4, a “tutor would need to be engaged,” the class lectures would be tape recorded, and the tapes would be obtained daily by STUDENT at the LGHS guidance office; (3) at the end of the school day, every assignment would be emailed to MOTHER; and (4) progress reports by phone, voice mail, or email, would be sent to MOTHER on a “bi-weekly basis.” Ms. Eaton replied with an email stating that the District would waive the attendance policy, that the family would be responsible for tutoring assistance, that a friend of STUDENT would record lectures in the three classes pending the permission of the teachers and communicate to STUDENT all of the assignments, and that MOTHER would communicate by email to STUDENT’s teachers weekly to ask if STUDENT had completed her work for the week. However, two of STUDENT’s teachers subsequently refused to have their lectures taped, and the entire plan was reconsidered.

An email by LGHS principal Trudy McCulloch, dated March 18, 2004, purportedly summarizes Ms. McCulloch’s conversations on that date with MOTHER. The email states that as soon as Ms. McCulloch receives a note from STUDENT’s medical doctor requesting assistance, the District would place a home teacher with STUDENT for accelerated algebra, comparative literature, and Spanish 4. The home teacher would work with STUDENT three hours each week and be the teacher of record for those classes. The Spanish 4 home-teaching situation would be closely monitored due to STUDENT’s inability to participate in classroom activities. STUDENT would continue to attend AP U.S. history, accelerated chemistry, and teacher assistant classes on campus at LGHS. Because STUDENT would be attending fewer than four classes per day at LGHS, she would be prohibited from participating in field hockey. (Footnote 5)

By March 24, 2004, MOTHER’s opinion of the District had severely deteriorated. From her perspective, as set forth in her March 24 email to the District, she had repeatedly asked the District to provide a home teacher who would bring STUDENT’s assignments from school to STUDENT’s home, and she had arranged for tutors who would supplement activities of the home teacher. However, according to MOTHER, the only strategy offered to STUDENT by the District from the fall of 2003 through March 2004 was “to recommend STUDENT drop her classes and get a friend to bring her her assignments.” She demanded in her March 24 email that the District perform a “formal 504 evaluation” and provide a home school teacher by the end of that week, or at least provide assignments from STUDENT’s teachers so that the private tutors she had reserved could begin working with STUDENT. On that date, MOTHER also submitted a current letter by Dr. Paley stating that STUDENT was in treatment for depression, that she needed to be on a modified school schedule, and that a home teacher was medically necessary. The District, from its perspective, had accommodated STUDENT by, among other things, waiving the school attendance policy and repeatedly suggesting that STUDENT reduce her stress levels by dropping some of her accelerated classes and taking other classes in their place that were still considered college-preparatory level.

On March 29, 2004, a home teacher was retained by the District. Home teaching started at the end of March. The present request for due process hearing was filed by the Petitioner on March 31. At or about that time, the District arranged for a section 504 assessment. In addition, the District submitted a special education assessment plan to MOTHER on April 5, and she signed her consent on that same date. On April 7, 2004, following a conversation between MOTHER and LGHS school psychologist Sharon Trattner, Ph.D., MOTHER reportedly decided that STUDENT was not well enough to attend her classes at LGHS and that STUDENT should move from AP U.S. history to the regular, college preparatory version of U.S. history. Thereafter, the parties have been working toward additional adjustments of STUDENT’s class schedule, including the option of summer school classes and preferential placement in certain classes during the 2004-2005 school year. The proposed adjustments are intended to reduce STUDENT’s current workload while keeping STUDENT on track toward four-year-college eligibility. (Footnote 6)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue 1: From October 2003 through the present, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by (A) failing to conduct a timely assessment for special education in accordance with “child find” requirements, and (B) failing to find STUDENT eligible for special education?

Children with disabilities have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. (Footnote 7) The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit.

Assessment must be performed before action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. Moreover, “a pupil shall be referred for special education instruction and services only after the resources of the regular education program have been considered and, where appropriate, utilized.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56303. For purposes of a child’s special education eligibility under federal law, 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(ii) defines “child with a disability” as meaning a child with at least one of the several conditions listed in § 1401, and who, by reason thereof, needs special education and related services. Those conditions include, among others, “emotional disturbance” (ED) and “other health impairment” (OHI). See also Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030.

STUDENT asserts that because of her depression she should have been assessed for special education in October 2003, and the District should have found her eligible for special education under the criteria for ED and OHI at all times from October 2003 through the date of this Decision. According to the District, STUDENT’s academic progress from the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year through mid-March 2004 confirms that she should neither have been assessed nor found eligible for special education during that period. The Hearing Officer will now address those contentions.

(A) Failing to conduct a timely assessment for special education in accordance with “child find” requirements.

State law provides that “all individuals with disabilities . . . who are in need of special education and related services, shall be identified, located, and assessed . . .” Cal. Educ. Code § 56301. This responsibility, for what is commonly referred to as “child find,” rests with school districts, special education local plan areas (SELPAs), and applicable county offices. Similar provisions concerning child find are contained in federal law. See 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3). Referral for assessment of a student may be made by the student’s parent or guardian, teacher or other service provider, or foster parent. Cal. Educ. Code § 56029.

Whenever an assessment for the development or revision of an IEP is to be conducted, the parent of the pupil shall be given, in writing, a proposed assessment plan within 15 days of the referral for assessment (with certain exceptions for school vacations). The parent shall have at least 15 days from receipt of the proposed assessment plan to arrive at a decision. No assessment shall be conducted unless the written consent of the parent is obtained or the district prevails in a due process hearing related to the assessment. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56321(a), 56321(c), and 56506(e). Except for tolling of the timeline due to “pupil school vacations,” an IEP “required as a result of an assessment of a pupil shall be developed within a total time not to exceed 50 days . . . from the date of receipt of the parent’s written consent for assessment.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56344(a).

In the present case, the evidence showed that STUDENT was first treated for depression in the spring of 2003. By the end of September or beginning of October 2003, her depression worsened to the degree that she was frequently unable to attend school. The District became aware of STUDENT’s condition of depression when the District received MOTHER’s above-referenced October 7, 2003 email. STUDENT then proceeded to miss all or portions of 10 school days in October due to depression. Dr. Morse’s October 28, 2003 letter to the District stated that STUDENT’s condition “will hopefully stabilize . . . over the next few months,” thus indicating that STUDENT’s condition could well persist through the end of the school year and beyond. On the basis of these facts, the Hearing Officer finds that by the end of October 2003, the District should have reasonably suspected that STUDENT was a child with a disability and initiated a referral for assessment.

The Hearing Officer further finds that in accordance with the above-referenced statutory timelines, the District was required to submit a written proposed assessment plan to STUDENT’s parent by on or about November 15, 2003 (not later than 15 days after the referral for assessment). MOTHER would have had not later that 15 days from receipt of the proposed assessment plan, or until on or about November 30, to consent to the proposed plan. MOTHER’s testimony concerning her desire to help STUDENT in any appropriate manner, corroborated by the history of MOTHER’s consistent efforts to procure assistance from the District, persuades the Hearing Officer that MOTHER likely would have given timely consent to a proper assessment plan. Accordingly, the District would have been required to convene an IEP meeting, discuss the assessments, and develop an IEP within 50 days from the date of receipt of MOTHER’s written consent for assessment (i.e., 50 days from November 30, 2003). The evidence showed that a winter break “pupil school vacation” occurred for approximately two weeks in December 2003. Thus, adding an estimated 9 school vacation days for the winter break, the IEP meeting would have been due to convene by on or about January 24, 2004.

(B) Failing to find STUDENT eligible for special education

STUDENT asserts that, because of her depression, she should have been found to meet the special education eligibility criteria under the categories of emotional disturbance (ED) and/or other health impairment (OHI). The District asserts that from October 2003 through mid-March 2004, the degree and effect of STUDENT’s depression was not such that STUDENT required special education or related services. Instead, according to the District, STUDENT’s educational needs could be and were met through modification of the regular instruction program. Because a current assessment is in progress, the District has taken no position with respect to STUDENT’s prospective eligibility. In any event, STUDENT’s prospective eligibility for special education is not an issue to be decided in this hearing. (Footnote 8)

To determine whether STUDENT met the eligibility criteria for special education at some time during the period at issue, the Hearing Officer will first examine whether STUDENT exhibited the characteristics of either ED or OHI as set forth in 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.7(c)(4)(i) and 300.7(c)(9), or the equivalent provisions of Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, §§ 3030(i) and 3030(f), respectively, and then examine whether, because of the degree thereof, STUDENT needed special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(ii); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030.

1) Did STUDENT exhibit the characteristics of ED?

Federal regulations define ED as a condition whereby the student is “exhibiting one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree that adversely affects a child’s educational performance:

(A) An inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (B) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (C) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. (D) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.

(E) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.” (Footnote 9) 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i).

The testimony of MOTHER and the notes from STUDENT’s physicians established that commencing in early October 2003, STUDENT exhibited “a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i)(D).

With regard to whether STUDENT exhibited the general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression to a “marked degree that adversely affects a child’s educational performance,” MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s symptoms and behavior included physical illness, light sensitivity, engagement in self-injurious behaviors, and wanting to remain curled up in a dark room instead of going to school. STUDENT’s condition was serious enough to require treatment with medications, but the medications had limited effectiveness. Her condition was affecting her to such a degree that she was missing school nearly as often as she was able to attend school. The Hearing Officer notes that such a deficiency in school attendance, persisting over a period of one or more months from the outset of eleventh grade for a high-achieving student taking accelerated classed in preparation for college, was virtually certain to have an adverse affect on that student’s academic performance. This was confirmed by STUDENT’s teachers who, in December 2003, expressed concern that STUDENT was missing time in class, including vital participatory time in Spanish and chemistry lab. Her grades and work output in accelerated algebra were declining to such an extent her algebra teacher suggested that STUDENT consider dropping and retaking the class. STUDENT’s algebra teacher also wrote in December 2003 that STUDENT appeared to be withdrawn, had erratic moods, and, with regard to following directions, “seems lost” and “often off-task.” Moreover, STUDENT’s licensed clinical psychologist, Tonja Krautter, Ph.D., testified that STUDENT’s depression was adversely affecting STUDENT in school by causing lack of motivation, inability to concentrate, distraction (i.e., listening but not assimilating the information), and difficulty getting to school. She also stated that STUDENT’s problems were compounded by STUDENT’s anxiety about falling behind in her classes and her resultant feelings of hopelessness. (Footnote 10)

Thus, the degree of STUDENT’s condition was such that she was missing excessive amounts of classroom time, she was unable to stay current with her assignments, she had difficulty remaining on task while at school, and she was in danger of having to drop classes. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that in the fall of 2003, STUDENT exhibited the general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression to a “marked degree that adversely affects a child’s educational performance,” within the meaning of 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i) and Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, §§ 3030(i).

The Hearing Officer next examines whether the general pervasive mood of unhappiness, was exhibited “over a long period of time” within the meaning of 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i). The regulations do not define “long period of time.” Dr. Trattner, LGHS school psychologist, testified that, under her view of District policy, the threshold for “long period of time” is generally six months. The Hearing Officer considers that to be an arbitrary number. By not defining “long period of time,” the respective lawmakers showed an intent that “long period of time” should be determined on a case-by-case basis in accordance with a child’s circumstances and individual needs.

In the present case, STUDENT’s symptoms of depression arose as early as December 2002. The symptoms temporarily subsided with the use of medications, but then worsened in October 2003. Dr. Morse’s October 28, 2003 letter stated that “we will hopefully stabilize her situation over the next few months.” Thus, Dr. Morse’s letter indicated that STUDENT’s condition was likely to prevent STUDENT from attending school for a major portion of the school year. Following Dr. Morse’s October 28 letter, STUDENT continued to miss classes. She missed school on all or parts of fourteen days in November and five days in December before the District took the action of convening an SST meeting on December 12, 2003. The cycling of STUDENT’s depression, dating back to December 2002, was consistent with testimony by STUDENT’s clinical psychologist, Tonja Krautter, Ph.D., who stated that “although depression can remit, it often resurfaces.” (Footnote 11) Thus, during the fall of 2003, there was no reason to expect that STUDENT’s problems with depression would be short-lived. To the contrary, by that time STUDENT’s depression had either been present or had beena threatening to recur as a “major episode” for almost an entire year. (Footnote 12)

In summary, the evidence showed that from October 7 through the date of the December 12, 2003 SST meeting, STUDENT consistently exhibited a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression, to a marked degree, that was adversely affecting her educational performance. There was no information to indicate that the depression would be short-lived. To the contrary, the information available to the District as early as October showed that the longevity of STUDENT’s depression would at least be for several months and could continue indefinitely. Under these circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that by the fall of 2003, STUDENT exhibited the characteristics of ED “over a long period of time” within the meaning of 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i)(D) and Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i)(4).

2) Did STUDENT exhibit the characteristics of ED to such a degree that she needed special education and related services?

With the Hearing Officer having found that STUDENT exhibited a general or pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression over a long period of time and to a marked degree that adversely affected STUDENT’s educational performance, the final question for determining eligibility under the criteria for ED is whether, because of the degree of that condition, STUDENT needed special education and related services. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i) and Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i).

STUDENT asserts that she needed special education and related services in the nature of a comprehensive behavioral assessment and behavior plan, collaboration among teachers and mental health professionals, tutoring or home instruction, flexible scheduling, note taking, taping of classroom lectures, and psychological services. The District asserts that accommodations and modifications within the regular instruction program were sufficient to meet the Petitioner’s needs and special education and related services therefore were not required. In addressing these contentions, it will be helpful to first take a closer view of what is meant by the term “special education.” The Hearing Officer will then review and discuss the applicable evidence.

As discussed above, State law defines “special education” as meaning “specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent, to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs, whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and related services, at no cost to the parent, that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

Although the core element of special education is “specially designed instruction,” there is no direct definition of that term in State law. However, a workable definition of the term is derived from Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030. Section 3030 states that a pupil shall qualify for special education if “the degree of the pupil’s impairment as described in Section 3030 (a through j) requires special education in one of the program options authorized by Section 56361 of the Education Code.” Section 56361 states that the continuum of program options shall include, but not be limited to, a resource specialist program pursuant to § 56362, designated instruction and services pursuant to § 56363, special classes pursuant to §§ 56364 or 56364.2, itinerant instruction in classrooms and other settings, instruction using telecommunication, and instruction in the home, hospitals, or other institutions. Thus, the program options listed in § 56361 can be construed as comprising “specially designed instruction.” (Footnote 13) Finally, “a pupil shall be referred for special education instruction and related services only after the resources of the regular education program have been considered and, where appropriate, utilized.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56303.

In the present case Dr. Trattner, District school psychologist, testified that, in general, special education assessment occurs for students such as STUDENT (i.e., high school students with depression) when all regular education options have been exhausted. She testified that before referring a student for a special education assessment, the procedures at LGHS may first include having an STT meeting and plan to determine if a student can function in a regular education program with regular education interventions. Dr. Trattner, a participant in STUDENT’s December 12, 2003 SST meeting, further testified that the SST decided to first try regular education modification strategies for STUDENT. The SST had hoped that implementation of those strategies, in conjunction with Dr. Paley’s plan to change STUDENT’s medications, would result in STUDENT’s succeeding at school. The specific strategies suggested by Dr. Trattner at that time included the relief of stress by changing her advanced placement (AP) classes to less academically challenging college preparatory classes, providing site-based counseling at school by a marriage and family therapist (MFT) intern, waiving the school attendance policy, and receiving “afterschool” or “private faculty” tutoring. Dr. Trattner testified that such an approach would help to keep STUDENT engaged in school, and that such engagement was important for keeping STUDENT out of the depression “cycle” (i.e., staying at home because she was depressed yet becoming more depressed because she was staying at home and missing her classes).

Dr. Krautter, STUDENT’s licensed clinical psychologist, testified that as of March 2004, helpful accommodations for STUDENT would include (1) having a modified school day whereby she would be at school for some classes and taught at home, by a home teacher, for other classes, (2) having teachers email assignments to her home, as she was too distracted at school to reliably record her assignments, and (3) possibly having a note taker in class. As noted above, Dr. Krautter testified that depression can often remit and resurface, and she believed that it would be preferable to have intervention plans already in place for such recurrences. She noted that having STUDENT physically at school was important, referring to the “cycle” issues as mentioned by Dr. Trattner. She stated that although home teaching could help STUDENT stay current in certain classes, having STUDENT at home for an extended period could “feed into” her depression. (Footnote 14)

The testimony of Dr. Trattner and Dr. Krautter, along with the other evidence recited above concerning STUDENT’s absence from school and the adverse effects of those absences, established that, because of STUDENT’s fragile condition and the academic and emotional consequences of her inability to attend class, accommodations were required to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs. Accommodations such as providing home teaching for certain classes, switching to less demanding classes, waiving the attendance policy, emailing assignments, and notetaking were recommended by Dr. Trattner and/or Dr. Krautter. Although the statutes and regulations referenced above show that such accommodations could, under appropriate circumstances, be part of a special education student’s IEP, testimony of District witnesses showed that such accommodations could also be made available to STUDENT independently from a special education program. Because those accommodations were available as regular education interventions, their appropriateness or lack thereof is not determinative of the eligibility issue.

The evidence also established, however, that STUDENT had unique educational needs arising from her depression which could not be met through regular education interventions. Specifically, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that psychological and/or counseling services were among the services required to address STUDENT’s educational needs. In that regard, Dr. Trattner had recommended the on-campus counseling services of a marriage and family therapist (MFT) intern. Dr. Krautter had counseled STUDENT for depression, thus also demonstrating her belief that counseling was necessary. Both experts were in agreement that keeping STUDENT engaged in school was and would continue to be important for combating her depression, and combating her depression was, in turn, important for STUDENT’s ability to attend school. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that counseling or psychological services specifically designed to assist STUDENT in being able to productively attend and remain at school for some portion or the entirety of each school day was among STUDENT’s unique educational needs. (Footnote 15)

Although on-campus counseling was available to LGHS students as a regular education intervention or service, the evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s receipt of such counseling services solely as a regular education intervention would not be sufficient to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs. The reasons are several. First, as described by District witnesses, the counseling services offered within the regular education program were from an MFT intern and were available only on the campus. Thus, the on-campus MFT services were not specifically designed to serve students so affected by depression as to be unable to attend school. Also, STUDENT’s accessability to on-campus MFT services would have been problematic by requiring her presence at school when she was unable to attend school.

Furthermore, STUDENT was already receiving private treatment and therapy directed at trying to resolve, or at least stabilize, her condition. More of such counseling through an MFT intern would not necessarily have addressed STUDENT’s educational needs. What STUDENT needed from the District was counseling specifically directed at enabling STUDENT to productively attend and remain at school. Those services foreseeably would include counseling at home, counseling in a clinic-based setting, counseling at the LGHS campus, or a combination of all the above.

Finally, an effective counseling program would likely have required some coordinated involvement among STUDENT’s counselor, teachers, parents, and STUDENT herself. Consequently, what STUDENT ultimately needed was the formulation and execution of a plan that delineated a) the type of counseling services required to meet her unique educational needs in that area, b) who would administer those services and where, c) how frequently those services would be given, d) the goals to be achieved through those services, and e) how her progress toward those goals would be measured. Such a plan is, in fact, a special education student’s written IEP. (Footnote 16) Under STUDENT’s circumstances as described above, the District’s proffered approach of providing counseling solely as a regular education intervention would have been inappropriate as an alternative to the formal elements of an IEP. As an example, the December 12, 2003 SST meeting yielded no plan, written or otherwise, for coordination of effort, monitoring, accountability, or goals with respect to counseling services. Also, there was no indication from the evidence that access to the on-campus MFT services would have provided such structure, coordination, and accountability. (Footnote 17)

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that commencing in the fall of 2003, STUDENT exhibited the characteristics of ED to such a degree that she need special education and related services. As found above that the District was not required to conduct STUDENT’s initial IEP meeting until January 24, 2004. Thus, by January 24, 2004, with STUDENT having met the eligibility criteria for special education as a child with ED, the IEP team should have found her eligible. These findings are made notwithstanding the evidence that STUDENT’s condition temporarily improved in January 2004. At that time, the strong likelihood of STUDENT’s depression being cyclical or episodic had been established, and a program should have been formulated to address her condition. (Footnote 18) Accordingly, with April 26 being the last date that evidence was presented in this hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was denied a FAPE from January 24, 2004, through April 26, 2004. (Footnote 19)

3) Did STUDENT meet the eligibility criteria for OHI?

With the Hearing Officer having found that STUDENT was eligible under the criteria for ED, the OHI analysis is unnecessary.

Issue 2: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for tutoring costs, reimbursement for counseling and psychiatric therapy, and compensatory education.

When a school District denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 358 (1985). Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist., 960 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992). Included in the available relief, is reimbursement for privately procured educational services and compensatory education.

The Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT was denied a FAPE from January 24, 2004, through April 26, 2004. As remedies for the denial of a FAPE, MOTHER has requested reimbursement for tutoring costs, reimbursement for therapy and psychiatric care, and compensatory education for STUDENT.

1) Tutoring costs.

Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement of the services they have procured for their children when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370.

With regard to tutoring costs, MOTHER testified that she paid about $1000.00 for private tutoring expenses from late October 2003 through the end of the first semester on January 20, 2004. However, the denial of FAPE did not occur until January 24, 2004. Consequently, the tutoring costs incurred by MOTHER through January 24, 2004, proceeded the period where FAPE was denied. For the period after January 24, 2004, MOTHER testified that she intended to retain tutoring services upon commencement in-home teaching services by the District at the end of March 2004. However, there was no specific showing as to the cost of tutoring, the nature or frequency of the tutoring, benefit derived by the tutoring, or whether the tutoring was necessary to address the denial of FAPE. Accordingly, MOTHER’s request for reimbursement of tutoring expenses is denied.

2) Reimbursement for therapy and psychiatric care.

MOTHER also requests reimbursement for private therapy and psychiatric care provided to STUDENT from October 2003 through the present. However, many of those services were obtained prior to the period that denial of FAPE commenced. Moreover, there was no evidence to suggest that the failure of the District to provide a FAPE led to MOTHER’s decision to obtain those services for STUDENT. To the contrary, the evidence showed that MOTHER had already commenced treatment for STUDENT starting in the late winter or early spring of 2003, when STUDENT’s educational performance was not a concern. The treatment and counseling subsequently obtained in October 2003 and thereafter was intended to address STUDENT’s depression, but it was not necessarily designed to address STUDENT’s educational needs or provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Specifically, the psychiatric care obtained by STUDENT in the fall of 2003 and continuing thereafter was primarily focused upon the provision and adjustment of medications, and districts are not responsible for medical services other than for certain diagnostic and evaluation purposes. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z). With regard to group and individual services provided by or through Dr. Krautter’s office, Dr. Krautter first counseled STUDENT in January 2004 in a focus group for teenage girls, addressing various topics not necessarily related to education or school. The individual therapy provided by Dr. Krautter was focused upon STUDENT’s self-injurious behaviors, and there was no evidence that the self-injurious behaviors occurred at school.

Thus, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that substantially the same private treatment and counseling would have been obtained by MOTHER irrespective of whether the District had offered appropriate and accessible psychological services or counseling to address STUDENT’s unique educational needs arising from her disability. Additionally, the private services did not specifically address STUDENT’s educational concerns. Accordingly, the request for reimbursement of therapy and psychiatric care costs is denied.

3) Compensatory education.

Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. See Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d. Cir. 1990); Miener v. State of Missouri 800 F.2d 749 (8th Cir. 1986). There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation for missed services. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).

In the present case, STUDENT completed her first semester on January 20, 2004, several days prior to the date (January 24) the District should have found her eligible for special education. With regard to the period from the end of the first semester through April 26, 2004, STUDENT asserts that she is entitled to compensatory education to overcome lost educational opportunity. The Petitioner presented no specific evidence as to the degree of lost educational opportunity, if any, or what form of compensatory education would be required to address lost educational opportunity. STUDENT’s depressive symptoms had improved and she had been attending school regularly during January and February. In March 2004, STUDENT’s depression worsened, and she again was missing school. However, the District provided a home-teaching program commencing on or about March 30. Hence, the evidence demonstrated no loss of educational opportunity to a degree that would merit compensatory education, and there is no basis for ordering compensatory education for the denial of FAPE from January 24, 2004, through April 26, 2004. The request for compensatory education is therefore denied.

ORDERS

1. The Petitioner has been found eligible for special education for the period from January 24, 2004, through April 26, 2004. No findings are reached with regard to the Petitioner’s eligibility thereafter.

2. All of the Petitioner’s remaining requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.

Issue 1: From October 2003 through the present, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by (A) failing to conduct a timely assessment for special education in accordance with “child find” requirements, and (B) failing to find STUDENT eligible for special education? STUDENT prevailed on subpart A. STUDENT prevailed in subpart B to the extent the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT was eligible for special education from January 24, 2004, through April 26, 2004.

Issue 2: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is STUDENT entitled to remedies including, but not limited to, reimbursement for tutoring costs, reimbursement for counseling and psychiatric therapy, and compensatory education? The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: June 1, 2004 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The term “504 plan” arises from Section 504 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973. See 29 U.S.C. § 794 and 34 C.F.R. § 104.1. In certain situations, a child with learning difficulties may be ineligible for special education because the learning difficulties fit within none of the special education eligibility categories or because the degree of the learning difficulties is insufficient to qualify the child for special education. However, such a child may be eligible for accommodations at school under Section 504. Eligibility for Section 504 accommodations arises from a child’s having a physical or mental condition which substantially limits a major life activity.

2. The quoted portions are taken from a March 30, 2004 email from Ms. Eaton to LGHS principal Trudy McCulloch. Other information concerning that meeting is derived from that email and from documents and testimony presented by both parties. Ms. Eaton stated in her March 30 email that, after the December 15 email, she had no further communication with MOTHER during the first semester. The first semester ended on or about January 20, 2004.

LGHS has an attendance policy which provides, generally, that if a student misses fifteen days of a particular class, the class is considered as either dropped or failed.

3. “Weighted” GPA arises from added weight given to advanced placement, accelerated, and/or honors courses.

4. Attendance records ending March 18, 2004, show that STUDENT was absent on eleven school days during March.

5. The content of this email was consistent with testimony by both parties.

6. These latter facts involving events from April 7 through the present were derived from an April 9 letter by Ms. McCulloch to MOTHER and from testimony presented by both parties.

7. Federal special education law uses the term “child with a disability.” The corresponding provisions of State law use the term “individuals with exceptional needs.”

8. As stated under Background Facts, the worsening of STUDENT’s depression-like symptoms in mid-March 2004 led to the District’s submitting a special education assessment plan to STUDENT’s parents on April 5, 2004. The plan was signed and approved by MOTHER on April 5. The assessment had not been completed as of the date of the hearing, and thus an IEP team had not yet met to discuss the assessment information or consider eligibility.

9. The term “emotional disturbance” includes schizophrenia but “does not apply to children who are socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that they have an emotional disturbance.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(ii). A nearly identical definition of ED is set forth under State law in Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i), except § 3030(i) specifies, in a somewhat circular fashion, that for a student to qualify under the category of ED, one or more of the five specified characteristics of ED must be exhibited by the student “because of a serious emotional disturbance.”

10. Dr. Krautter testified that she first met STUDENT in January 2004 when STUDENT began attending a focus group for female teenage students coping with anxiety and depression-related issues. She became STUDENT’s individual therapist in March 2004 after STUDENT’s symptoms had worsened, and she subsequently has met individually with STUDENT on a weekly basis for six or seven sessions through April 6, 2004. Her testimony described in the main text above was primarily intended by Dr. Krautter to be applicable to STUDENT’s condition during and after March 2004, but overall testimony showed that the same considerations were applicable to STUDENT in the fall of 2003.

11. Indeed, the symptoms again subsided in January 2004, but worsened in March 2004.

12. Witnesses referred to STUDENT’s “first major episode of depression” as having commenced in October 2003, and her “second major episode of depression” as having commenced in March 2004.

13. “Resource specialist programs” pursuant to § 56362 include, but are not limited to (1) instruction for students whose needs have been identified in an IEP and who are assigned to regular classroom teachers for a majority of the school day, (2) provision of information and assistance to individuals with exceptional needs and their parents, (3) provision of consultation, resource information, and material regarding individuals to with exceptional needs to parents and regular staff members, (4) coordination of special education services with the regular school programs for each student enrolled in the resource specialist program, (5) monitoring of student progress on a regular basis and participation in the review and revision of IEPs, and (6) emphasis at the secondary school level on academic achievement, career and vocational development, and preparation for adult life. Cal. Educ. Code § 56362(a).

“Designated instruction and services” pursuant to § 56363 shall be available when “necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a). Designated instruction and services (DIS) may include, but are not limited to (1) language and speech development and remediation services, (2) audiological services, (3) orientation and mobility instruction, (4) instruction in the home or hospital, (5) adapted physical education, (6) physical and occupational therapy, (7) vision services, (8) specialized driver training instruction, (9) counseling and guidance, (10) psychological services other than assessment and development of the IEP, (11) parent counseling and training, (12) health and nursing services, (13) social worker services, (14) specially designed vocational education and career development, (15) recreation services, and (16) specialized services such as readers, transcribers, and vision and hearing services for children with low incidence disabilities. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b).

“Related services” include but are not limited to: “transportation, and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services (including speech pathology and audiology, psychological services, physical and occupational therapy, recreation, including therapeutic recreation, social work services, counseling services, including rehabilitation counseling, and medical services, except that medical services shall be for diagnostic and evaluation purposes only) as required to assist an individual with exceptional needs to benefit from special education.” Related services include, but are not limited to, designated instruction and services. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z).

14. Dr. Krautter and Dr. Trattner both testified that STUDENT’s diagnosis of depression was subject to change, noting that Dr. Paley reportedly was beginning to consider that some form of bipolar disorder might be indicated.

15. Such additional services as mentioned above would be equivalent to “counseling and guidance,” “psychological services,” and/or “social worker services,” all listed as designated instruction and services under Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b)(9), (10), and (13), respectively. Such services would also be equivalent to “psychological services,” listed as a related service in Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z).

16. The necessary components of an IEP for a special education student are specified in Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.

17. An IEP designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs would not only provide appropriate counseling services, it would also incorporate and coordinate the provision of other potentially appropriate services or accommodations, including some of the District-recommended services and accommodations such as in-home teaching and attendance policy waivers, that would otherwise be available as regular education interventions.

18. The program could have included for example, strategies for reducing the likelihood of a recurrence, reducing the severity of a recurrence, and promptly addressing a recurrence.

19. Because no evidence was presented after April 26, 2004, the Hearing Officer does not know the results of the current assessment and does not know whether an IEP team has met to determine eligibility. Accordingly, instead the Hearing Officer makes no findings in this Decision with regard to STUDENT’s eligibility after April 26, 2004.