California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 8, 2003
Student v. Kern County Superintendent of Schools et al. (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 744-03, SN03-00744, SN03-00899 · Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz
Kern County Superintendent of Schools must restore speech and occupational therapy and set helmet-use criteria; nonpublic school request denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Corrected after issuance: on July 16, 2003, KCSOS and the District asked for amendments. The Hearing Officer corrected the name of the district that contracts with KCSOS for facilities to Panama-Buena Vista Elementary School District, corrected the school name to Buena Vista Elementary School, and corrected an IEP meeting date to February 25, 2003. None of these changes affected the findings or the outcome. The decision also notes that the Kern County Superior Court declined to issue a TRO allowing helmet use and left the matter to the Hearing Office.
Summary
The Kern County Superintendent of Schools (KCSOS) sought a ruling that its 2003 IEP offer was appropriate. The offer included a behavior plan using a soft helmet for a seven-year-old with autism who banged his head. His parents filed their own case. They challenged the 2002-2003 program, the helmet, and cuts to speech and occupational therapy (OT), and they asked for a nonpublic school offering intensive applied behavior analysis (ABA). The two cases were combined.
Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz found that the April 2002 IEP and KCSOS's "blended" program, which mixed ABA with structured teaching, gave the student some educational benefit. When his progress slowed in November 2002, KCSOS responded properly. It held meetings, assessed him, and studied his behavior after severe head-banging episodes. The Hearing Officer upheld the move to a functional life skills curriculum, which was based on new testing showing significant cognitive delays. She also upheld the helmet as a protective device. However, the offer set no objective rules for when the helmet would be used. It also cut OT and daily speech therapy, even though the behavior plan depended on the student's sensory and communication skills. No procedural violation denied a FAPE, and the nonpublic school request was denied. KCSOS had to reconvene the IEP team within 15 days. The revised program had to include 30 minutes of direct OT and 30 minutes of OT consultation weekly, five 30-minute speech sessions weekly, rules for helmet use, and a plan to ease the student back to school.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO reviewed cuts to related services in a behavior-focused IEP. The Hearing Officer upheld the overall program and a protective helmet. But she found that reducing speech therapy and OT conflicted with a behavior plan built on communication and sensory strategies. She also required clear rules for when the helmet would be used.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I. Did KCSOS offer or provide Student with a FAPE from April 2002 to March 2003?
The mediated April 2002 IEP and KCSOS's blended ABA/structured-teaching program met the student's needs and gave some educational benefit; when progress slowed in November 2002, KCSOS responded appropriately with meetings, assessment, and a functional analysis assessment.
- District prevailedCurriculum
Issue II-a. Did KCSOS offer a FAPE in the March-May 2003 IEPs: was the functional life skills curriculum in a special day class designed to meet Student's needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?
New assessments showing significant cognitive delays supported shifting from pre-academics to functional life skills in the special day class; the goals were not too simple.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue II-b. Was the behavior intervention plan, including use of a soft helmet, appropriate?
A soft helmet was an appropriate protective device given the severe head banging, but the offer lacked objective criteria for when the helmet would be used, so the IEP team must develop them.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue II-c. Was the reduction in occupational therapy (from 120 to 15 minutes weekly direct, and 30 to 15 minutes weekly consultation) appropriate?
The cut was inconsistent with the student's increased sensory needs, the behavior plan, and an upcoming teacher change; the Hearing Officer ordered 30 minutes direct and 30 minutes consultation weekly, less than the prior 120 minutes direct.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue II-d. Was the reduction of direct speech and language services from daily 30-minute sessions to three sessions weekly, with aide follow-through on other days, appropriate?
The student's progress was only intermittent, the aide was not qualified to replace the therapist, and communication was central to the behavior plan, so five 30-minute direct sessions weekly must continue; the 15 minutes of consultation offered was appropriate.
- Student prevailedTransition
Issue II-e. Did the offer need a transition plan to return Student to school after his parents kept him home from April 2003?
Because the student struggles with transitions and had been out of school since April 2003, the IEP team must develop a transition plan to ease his return.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue Procedural. Did KCSOS infringe on parent participation by holding IEP meetings without parents or with inadequate notice, and by ignoring Student's regression?
Parents got enough notice and took part meaningfully. KCSOS could have sought a waiver rather than open the March 5, 2003 meeting without the mother, but a later meeting with parents reviewed the assessments, so FAPE was not denied.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue III. If KCSOS denied or failed to offer Student a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement at a nonpublic school?
With modifications, the KCSOS placement can meet the student's needs, so a nonpublic school is not warranted under Education Code section 56365.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the decision, unless the parties agree otherwise in writing, KCSOS must reconvene the IEP team and revise the program as ordered.
- Order to provide or change services. Provide 30 minutes of direct OT and 30 minutes of OT consultation each week.
- Order to provide or change services. Provide five 30-minute sessions of direct speech and language services each week, all with the speech therapist, plus 15 minutes of speech consultation each week.
- Develop objective criteria for when, and under what circumstances, the student may wear a soft helmet as part of the behavior intervention plan.
- Provide a transition plan to ease the student's return to school.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; W.G. v. Target Range Sch. Dist.; Amanda J. v. Clark County School District; Adams v. State of Oregon; Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. of Educ.
People named in the decision
- Stacy Inman, attorney for KCSOS and District, KCSOS/District counsel
- Cindy Jackson, legal assistant to KCSOS counsel (observer)
- Donnalee Huffman, attorney for Student
- Dr. Wilma Poage, director of special education, KCSOS
- Angelina Bertran-Harris, coordinator of special education; witness, KCSOS
- Janet Swank, District representative, Beardsley Elementary School District
- Ellyn Widelock, school nurse (observer)
- Liliana Libra, bilingual teacher (observer)
- Bryon Lewis, adapted physical education teacher (observer)
- Rita Faz-Essen, psychology intern (observer)
- Micky Hennen, education advocate for Student
- Lidia Cabral, bilingual advocate for Student
- Brandy Roggentien, behavior specialist; conducted functional analysis assessment, KCSOS
- Alexis Valos, behavior specialist, KCSOS
- Dr. Edward R. Ritvo, psychiatric consultant on autism programs; expert witness for KCSOS, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
- Sherilyn Sarff, speech and language pathologist, KCSOS
- Elizabeth Zastrow, structured teaching (TEACCH) consultant, California Autism Project / S.T.E.P.S.
- Anthony Goss, special education teacher, KCSOS
- Deborah Hazel, occupational therapist, KCSOS
- Steve Shapiro, school psychologist; psychoeducational assessor, KCSOS
- Danielle Bresee, program specialist, KCSOS
- Susan Madigan, services coordinator; witness for Student, Kern Regional Center
- Jolene Billinger, director of nonpublic school; witness for Student, Valley Achievement Center
- Valley Achievement Center, nonpublic school (ABA program) requested by parents
- Leo Ocampo, 1:1 instructional/behavior aide, KCSOS
- Richardson Child Development Center, prior KCSOS preschool program
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Bakersfield, California, on May 29-30, June 3-6, and 10-11, 2003.(FOOTNOTE 1)
Petitioners/Cross Respondents Kern County Superintendent of Schools (KCSOS) and Beardsley Elementary School District (District) were represented by attorney Stacy Inman. Also present on behalf of KCSOS and the District was Dr. Wilma Poage, director of special education for KCSOS; Angelina Bertran-Harris, coordinator of special education for KCSOS; and Janet Swank, District representative. Observers were present on several of the hearing days, including Ellyn Widelock, school nurse; Liliana Libra, bilingual teacher; Bryon Lewis, adapted physical education teacher; Rita Faz-Essen, psychology intern; and Cindy Jackson, legal assistant to Ms. Inman. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Donnalee Huffman. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his mother, MOTHER. Also present on behalf of STUDENT on several of the hearing days was his father, FATHER; Micky Hennen, education advocate; and Lidia Cabral, bilingual advocate.
The KCSOS and the District called as witnesses: Ms. Bertran-Harris; Brandy Roggentien, behavior specialist; Alexis Valos, behavior specialist; Dr. Edward R. Ritvo, psychiatric consultant on educational programs for children diagnosed with autism; Sherilyn Sarff, speech and language pathologist; Elizabeth Zastrow, structured teaching consultant; Anthony Goss, STUDENT’s special education teacher; Deborah Hazel, occupational therapist; Steve Shapiro, school psychologist; and Danielle Bresee, program specialist.
Student called as witnesses: MOTHER; FATHER; Susan Madigan, Kern Regional Center (KRC) services coordinator; and Jolene Billinger, director of Valley Achievement Center (VAC), a nonpublic school.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of the parties’ written closing briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.(fOOTNOTE 2)
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(FOOTNOTE 3)
I. Did KCSOS offer or provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from April 2002 to March 2003?
II. Did KCSOS offer STUDENT a FAPE in the March 5, March 20, April 4, April 10 and May 19, 2003 IEPs?
III. If KCSOS denied or failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement at a nonpublic school?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES(FOOTNOTE 4)
KCSOS maintains that it has provided and offered to provide an educational program that meets STUDENT’s unique needs. The IEP team adopted many of the goals and objectives found within the IEP from his previous county of residence as a result of a mediation and STUDENT initially made progress. According to KCSOS, when STUDENT was unable to achieve many of the identified short-term objectives needed to reach his goals and objectives, the KCSOS sought a full assessment. KCSOS contends that the assessment results that found STUDENT to be moderately mentally retarded in addition to the finding that he has a diagnosis of autism, warranted modifications to STUDENT’s educational program to emphasize functional life skills, rather than pre-academics. KCSOS maintains that its “blended” program which combines applied behavior analysis (ABA) and discrete trial training (DTT) in a “structured teaching” environment provides the appropriate program that STUDENT needs. KCSOS argues that it considered parent input but that Mr. FATHER’ intimidating conduct hampered the team’s ability to reach consensus.
In addition, KCSOS asserts that STUDENT’s occupational therapy and speech therapy hours should be reduced because STUDENT receives assistance in both these areas from other staff throughout his day as part of his integrated program. Finally, KCSOS argues that its behavior intervention plan is appropriate. In particular KCSOS contends that STUDENT needs a soft helmet for his head banging, both to protect him from serious injury and to help teach him replacement behaviors.
MOTHER and FATHER believe that STUDENT regressed under the program provided by KCSOS and contend that he made better progress when he was in an intensive ABA program. STUDENT’s parents asserted that during the 2002-2003 school year some of the IEP meetings were held in their absence and lacked sufficient advance notice. According to STUDENT’s parents, for the IEP meetings they did attend, the rest of the IEP team was dismissive of their suggestions and input. MOTHER and FATHER disagree with the assessment that found STUDENT to be mentally retarded and maintain that the proposed IEP goals and objectives that emphasize functional life skills rather than pre-academics offered by KCSOS do not reflect his actual abilities. STUDENT’s parents maintain that the occupational therapy and speech therapy hours should not be reduced, but should remain as was provided in the mediated IEP because STUDENT has unique needs in the areas of sensory input and communication. With regard to managing STUDENT’s behaviors and in particular his head banging, STUDENT’s parents consider the helmet as a restraint rather than a protective device. Because they believe that the helmet would cause STUDENT additional injury and trauma, they refuse to consent to its use. STUDENT’s parents request placement in a nonpublic school that provides an ABA program rather than the blended approach used by KCSOS.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seven-year-old boy who has received special education and related services since he was two years old when he was assessed as having developmental delays by a regional center in another county. When he was nearly three, STUDENT was diagnosed with autism and he has remained eligible for special education and related services under that category since 1999. STUDENT and his mother and two half brothers moved within the boundaries of KCSOS and the District in July 2001 (see footnote 4). FATHER lives in the same area, although in a separate residence, and is involved in STUDENT’s parenting. After one year at the Richardson Child Developmental Center, STUDENT “graduated” to the Buena Vista Elementary School where he attends a mixed first through third grade special day class for children diagnosed with autism. Since April 2003, after a disagreement between STUDENT’s parents and KCSOS staff over whether STUDENT should wear a soft helmet, his parents have kept him at home.
STUDENT achieved normal developmental milestones until he was eighteen months old. However, according to MOTHER, when STUDENT reached that age, it was if “the lights went out.” STUDENT lost his speech, no longer followed simple directions, spun, banged his head, stood on his head and stopped playing with his brothers. (Student Exh. C). In the spring of 1998, when STUDENT was two years old, MOTHER took STUDENT to her local regional center in Oxnard to be assessed. The evaluator found STUDENT to be developmentally delayed with autistic tendencies and explained to MOTHER that because STUDENT was so young, it was too early to make a conclusive diagnosis of autism.
Just before STUDENT reached his third birthday, in March 1999, he was diagnosed as a child with autism. While in the Somis School District in Camarillo, California, STUDENT received speech and occupational therapies in their infant development program. After three months, the family moved to San Luis Obispo (SLO). At first STUDENT attended school for three hours each day, but starting in May 2000, STUDENT was in a full day program. There STUDENT made some, but not a lot, of progress. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was no longer a “wild monkey.”
For the 2000-2001 school year, while still in SLO, STUDENT was placed in a pre-school classroom with children with multiple disabilities. STUDENT received thirty hours per week of DTT with a one-to-one aide, speech and occupational therapies, and introduction to the Lovass reading and writing program. Positive behavior intervention plans were developed to address STUDENT’s serious behavior problems which included head banging, biting himself, and aggressive behaviors towards others. From January through June 2001, the regional center provided additional assistance through several nonpublic agencies and STUDENT received ten hours of in-home ABA therapy each week. The in-home behaviorist attended the IEP meetings, and according to MOTHER, consistent strategies were implemented across both home and school environments. MOTHER testified that STUDENT did very well in this program, and could say “up” and “yeah,” make several sign language signs, nod for “yes,” and shake his head for “no.” According to MOTHER, when STUDENT learned to communicate in this manner, many of his maladaptive behaviors diminished or were nonexistent during this period.
In February 2001, STUDENT was assessed to assist in the development of his educational program. The psychoeducational assessment diagnosed STUDENT’s autism as severe. At the time of testing when he was fifty-eight-months-old, his overall developmental functioning was between eight and thirty-two months with scattered skills up to a sixty-two-month level; it was concluded that he was developmentally delayed. (Student Exh. H.) On June 8, 2001, the IEP team in SLO agreed upon a new IEP.
Shortly thereafter, in July, the family relocated to Bakersfield and brought the IEP with them. (Student Exh. F.) On July 26, 2001, KCSOS accepted STUDENT as a transfer student and agreed to implement the SLO IEP. (KCSOS Exh. 67, p. 28.) From the end of July 2001 through August 10, 2001, STUDENT was placed in a special day class at the Richardson Child Development Center and attended a four-hour-per-day program, five days each week. Later that month, STUDENT’s school hours were increased to six and one-half hours per day to comport with the SLO IEP. The special day class emphasized speech and language development, basic skill development, performance under direction, transitioning, and mainstreaming with typically developing peers. STUDENT was provided with a one-to-one behavior aide. STUDENT also received direct speech and language services (SAL) in the amount of three thirty-minute sessions each week as well as sixty minutes of indirect SAL each week from his behavior aide. STUDENT was also given thirty minutes one time each week of direct occupational therapy (OT), and sixty minutes of indirect OT services by his behavior aide.
According to the addendum attached by the KCSOS IEP team to the July 2001 IEP, KCSOS agreed to continue the services provided by SLO including the reading and writing program since STUDENT was making progress in letter matching, the picture exchange communication system (PECS), and the positive behavioral support plan developed by SLO. The addendum noted that no restraints except a harness on the school bus would be permitted. KCSOS also agreed to provide behavior specialist consultation during the 2001-2002 school year. It was agreed that monthly team meetings with STUDENT’s parents and the staff would be held. STUDENT’s parents requested assessments. In October 2001, following an adapted physical education (APE) assessment, it was determined that STUDENT was not eligible for APE because his gross motor performance was commensurate with his cognitive abilities. (KCSOS Exh. 49.) The occupational therapy assessment found STUDENT to be eligible for OT services based upon his sensory needs and his decreased independence with basic self-care skills. (KCSOS Exh. 50.) A speech and language assessment found STUDENT to be eligible for SAL services and reported that STUDENT demonstrated severe delays in both speech and language skills (KCSOS Exh. 51.) The assistive technology evaluation performed in November 2001 found that STUDENT enjoyed the use of a computer program that read him stories and found that he could use the mouse appropriately. The report recommended the use of a vocal communication aid. (KCSOS Exh. 52.)
Because of STUDENT’s history of severe behavior problems and his recent admission to the KCSOS program, KCSOS conducted a functional behavioral assessment. Data was collected from the end of October 2001 through mid-November 2001. (KCSOS Exh. 54.) The assessor reported that STUDENT’s head banging was a serious behavior problem and recommended that positive intervention strategies be developed. Other maladaptive behaviors that disrupted STUDENT’s learning included spitting and applying his own hand with pressure to the roof of his mouth. The positive behavior intervention plan that targeted STUDENT’s head banging in both the classroom and on the bus that transported STUDENT to and from school, suggested that STUDENT be taught appropriate means to communicate wants, needs and frustrations as replacement behaviors. An aide trained in ABA accompanied STUDENT on the school bus. (KCSOS Exhs. 57, 59.)
IEP meetings as well as a mediation were held between September 2001 and April 2002, until a new IEP was agreed upon. (KCSOS Exh. 44.) Many of the annual goals and objectives from the July 2001 IEP were incorporated into the April 2002 IEP.
In May 2002, STUDENT’s teacher reported that he was making some progress. STUDENT had good imitative skills, was able to complete a 24-piece jigsaw puzzle with some prompting, and was able to request a variety of objects using the PECS cards, although he did not consistently attach the picture icon of the desired object to the “I want” strip. (KCSOS Exh. 83.) Summarizing teacher observation, data collected from DTT sessions, and STUDENT’s class performance, STUDENT’s teacher reported that STUDENT was making progress but appeared to be performing at levels below those described by the previous school he had attended. (KCSOS Exh. 81.)
In July 2002, an independent neuropsychological assessment was performed at STUDENT’s parents’ request based upon their concern that STUDENT had regressed. In the written report dated September 26, 2002, the evaluator reported that STUDENT was unable to be tested because of the behaviors he displayed during testing and his inability to attend. Relying upon a review of records, an interview with MOTHER, and a behavioral observation of STUDENT, the assessor concluded that STUDENT required an intensive ABA program by specialists trained in teaching children with autism. (KCSOS Exh. 61.) The recommendation identified a nonpublic school, Valley Achievement Center (VAC) in Bakersfield, that provided an intense ABA program. MOTHER testified that she provided the name of the nonpublic school to the evaluator and that he had not observed the program.
In August 2002, STUDENT was enrolled in a special day class at Buena Vista Elementary School where KCSOS continued to be responsible for STUDENT’s educational program. Each of the four other children in STUDENT’s class was diagnosed with autism and each had an individual behavioral aide in addition to the teaching staff. The class was a mixed-grade class from the first through the third grade. By teacher report, at the beginning of the school year in August 2002, STUDENT successfully completed many of the short-term objectives on his IEP.
At a November 2002 IEP meeting, members of the team reported that STUDENT was beginning to have some trouble advancing towards the more difficult short-term objectives and that STUDENT might not achieve the goals and objectives set out in the April 2002 IEP. Noting that the independent assessor had been unable to test STUDENT, members of the IEP team suggested that a new assessment plan be developed in another attempt to determine STUDENT’s cognitive abilities. (KCSOS Exh. 46.)
After a mediation, on January 16, 2003, MOTHER consented to assessments in the areas of academic performance, self-help, social and emotional status, motor abilities, language and speech, general ability, assistive technology, sensory, and behavior. (KCSOS Exh. 22.) On February 19, 2003, STUDENT banged his head into two walls, creating dents in both walls. As a result of this severe behavior, MOTHER consented to a functional analysis assessment (FAA). (KCSOS Exh. 23.) After the data was collected a draft behavior intervention plan (BIP) was fashioned which recommended that STUDENT wear a soft helmet. By the time the assessment results were completed, it was time for STUDENT’s triennial review. The IEP team met on several occasions to offer a new IEP, to complete the FAA by obtaining parent input, and to incorporate and complete the draft BIP into the IEP. No consensus was reached and KCSOS sought this due process hearing for a determination whether the educational program contained within several IEPs offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year and whether the BIP, that included the use of a soft helmet, was appropriate. (SN03-00744.)(FOOTNOTE 5)
On April 28, 2003, MOTHER wrote a letter to KCSOS informing it that she was removing STUDENT from school because she did not want STUDENT to wear a helmet. (Student. Exh. 11.) STUDENT has remained at home. On May 12, 2003, Student requested a due process hearing to challenge the use of the helmet, to assert numerous procedural and substantive violations that denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, and to object to KCSOS’s educational program offer.(FOOTNOTE 6) (SN03-00899.) The two cases were consolidated and this due process hearing commenced.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE I: Did KCSOS offer or provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from April 2002 to March 2003?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), all students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s IEP must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit.
The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. (Rowley, at 198-200.) The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id., at 201.) Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the student. (Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1994, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 969 (1994).) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some benefit.” Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir.1998). However, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).
The Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural protections offered by the IDEA, which are designed to ensure effective parental participation in the IEP process and careful consideration of a student’s educational needs. Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of a FAPE. Procedural violations must result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process to constitute a denial of a FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207; W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); see also Amand J. v. Clark County School District, 267 F.3d 877 (9th Cir. 1992).
Student has alleged numerous procedural and substantive violations that he contends amounted to the denial of a FAPE. Some of the substantive complaints relate to the educational program that was provided during the 2002-2003 school year. Other of the Student’s substantive allegations as well as KCSOS’s assertions pertain to the educational program that KCSOS recently offered for the 2003-2004 school year. Because STUDENT’s annual review occurs in April, the school years at issue will be analyzed according to the period covered by the IEPs. The Hearing Officer will then address the Student’s procedural allegations because they apply to the entire time period in question.
APRIL 2002- MARCH 2003 SCHOOL YEAR
SUBSTANTIVE VIOLATIONS
Was the educational program provided by KCSOS designed to meet Student’s unique and individual needs?
April 2002 to November 2002.
In order to determine whether the educational program provided by KCSOS in the 2002-2003 school year was a FAPE, it is necessary to evaluate whether the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. To assist in that determination, it is first necessary to identify STUDENT’s unique and individual needs at the time the April 2002 IEP was devised. There is little dispute that STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of communication and speech and language; auditory processing; social skills; self-help and self-care; sensory processing; and behavioral control. In the area of communication and speech and language, STUDENT had severe delays in speech and language skills. He was non-verbal and had few vocalizations or word approximations that he used consistently. STUDENT was a visual learner and had significant auditory processing deficits, the latter resulting in his difficulty following simple directions. STUDENT rarely initiated interactions or played with toys. STUDENT had difficulty with toilet training and other self-help skills. In the area of sensory processing, STUDENT had a difficult time regulating his responses to his environment and integrating his five senses. Ms. Hazel explained, for example, that when STUDENT attempted a task, he was unable to avoid listening to a neighbor’s pencil scraping.
There was also no dispute that STUDENT had behavioral problems that included head banging. The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT had been head banging since he was two years old and that his head banging behavior had been the subject of many behavior support plans and attempts at intervention. STUDENT’s head banging behavior was cyclical, increasing and decreasing in frequency.
Having completed the program at the Richardson Center, in August 2002 STUDENT was enrolled in a special day class at Buena Vista Elementary School. STUDENT started the 2002-2003 school year with the IEP developed as a result of a mediation on April 5, 2002. Turning to the adequacy of the IEP with which STUDENT entered the 2002-2003 school year, a review of the April 5, 2002 IEP indicates that it included goals and objectives designed to improve STUDENT’s deficits as described above. Annual goals were in the areas of self-help, imitation, physical education, visual processing, mathematics, receptive language, visual processing, fine motor, social/emotional, behavior, communication, assistive technology, pre-reading, expressive language (word approximation and understanding language concepts), self-care, and participation in the regular education program at lunch and recess. STUDENT also received thirty minutes of direct SAL services each day, consultation twice a month in the use of assistive technology devices, two hours each week of OT direct service and thirty minutes each week of OT consultation services, one hour each week of direct service and thirty minutes each week of consultation by a behavior specialist, as well as after school services funded by the Kern Regional Center (KRC). STUDENT was provided with a one-to-one behavior aide in the classroom and another aide for the bus used to transport him to and from school. Many of the short-term instructional goals strove toward consistency, generalization across environments, and achievement of goals with faded prompts or the ability to perform a task independently. A positive behavior support plan was also in place to address STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors.
However, STUDENT’s parents contended that the educational program provided by KCSOS did not meet STUDENT’s needs because it only used an ABA “approach” rather than being an intensive ABA program. KCSOS employed a “blended approach,” that is, ABA and DTT are used throughout the day within a “structured teaching” environment. The program was adapted from the TEACCH principles developed at the University of North Carolina. Ms. Zastrow explained that the classroom provides a clear physical structure so that a student knows what happens in each area of the room. Each student has an agenda or schedule to assist in moving around within the physical structure. Tasks are presented in a manner that is very predictable for the student, while at the same time the structure provides visual organizational skills. The classroom is set up with minimal distractions. Ms. Zastrow explained that when STUDENT gets to his independent work area he knows what he has to do. The environment is organizing, calming, and predictable. Ms. Zastrow added that the structure itself acts as a behavioral management tool.(FOOTNOTE 7)
Mr. Goss, an experienced and well-trained teacher, explained that all learning tasks are presented in an ABA style.(FOOTNOTE 8) Because STUDENT had visual processing strengths, STUDENT’s work station and independent work area and schedule was designated with the color red. Red was chosen in order to be consistent with the color STUDENT used at the Richardson Center, the year before. STUDENT always had an one-to-one aide to assist with gestural prompts (pointing, or use of a sign for “come here”), physical prompts (guiding hand over hand, tilting student’s chair), model prompts (do this) or verbal prompts (“come here”). The ABA approach is used with a hierarchy of prompts designed to lead to independent performance. This system was applied to all the goals and objectives in the IEP. Dr. Ritvo has been a psychiatrist and professor in residence at the Neuropsychiatric Institute at UCLA School of Medicine since 1977.(FOOTNOTE 9) Dr. Ritvo observed STUDENT’s classroom, although STUDENT was not present. Dr. Ritvo reviewed STUDENT’s school records and recent assessments. Based upon his experience and record review, Dr. Ritvo concluded that the program he observed was “highly appropriate” for STUDENT because the program was designed for children with similar developmental delays and cognitive and social functioning levels that STUDENT’s school records revealed. Dr. Ritvo observed that the data collection and monitoring of the students’ work was excellent. He noted that STUDENT’s schedule provided for three to four hours of DTT each day. Dr. Ritvo testified that in his opinion, children need DTT interspersed with other educational experiences, such as being provided with sensory choices, circle time, playground, real life experiences and social time. In Dr. Ritvo’s opinion, at STUDENT’s level, three to four hours of DTT per day was appropriate.
According to MOTHER, her friends’ children made better progress and were better behaved than STUDENT because they were provided an intensive ABA program rather than the “blended” program. MOTHER testified that STUDENT performed more successfully while he was in pre-school in SLO and received in-home ABA for four months in 2001. MOTHER relies on the conclusion of the independent evaluator who unsuccessfully tried to assess STUDENT in July 2002 in support of her contention that STUDENT would fare better in an ABA program. In his written report, the evaluator concluded that STUDENT would benefit from an intensive ABA program. However, MOTHER conceded that she did not describe the program provided by KCSOS to the evaluator at the time he attempted to assess STUDENT. Because the independent evaluator was not apprised of the KCSOS program, was unable to provide an opinion as to the relative merits of a “blended” program for STUDENT, and did not testify, the Hearing Officer gives his written recommendation very little weight.(FOOTNOTE 10)
The Hearing Officer finds more convincing the testimony of KCSOS’s highly trained and qualified witnesses that the “blended” program that uses an ABA style provided STUDENT with appropriate instruction to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. Because the April 2002 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s identified needs and provided him with appropriate instruction to meet his deficits as they were known in April 2002 and at the start of the 2002-2003 school year in August 2002, the Hearing Officer concludes that KCSOS satisfied the first prong of an appropriate education under Rowley and the IDEA.
Was the educational program provided by KCSOS reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit?
By teacher report at the end of May 2002, STUDENT had begun to make progress towards attainment of the goals and objectives of the April 5, 2002 IEP. Although it was suggested that STUDENT’s progress appeared to be less than had been reported at STUDENT’s pre-school, the evidence also established that in August 2002, STUDENT continued to show advancement. Mr. Goss explained that mastery of the IEP goals depended on the level of prompting that was required. When the IEP was first implemented in April 2002 and continuing through the beginning of the school calendar year in August 2002, achievement of the short-term objectives included many prompts and STUDENT was successfully able to meet them. In addition, STUDENT’s ability to attend improved. Mr. Goss found that matching and sorting were STUDENT’s strong skills. Ms. Zastrow reported that in September 2002, STUDENT was successfully learning the classroom routine. In November, Ms. Zastrow reported that STUDENT appeared calmer in the classroom. (KCSOS Exh. 78.) Both Mr. Goss and Ms. Zastrow observed that STUDENT performed better on functional skills than on academic tasks. STUDENT’s head banging had decreased in frequency and was manageable. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of these trained and experienced educators persuasive that STUDENT was making some progress toward his goals and objectives.
In summary, goals and objectives, an instructional program that applied ABA and DTT methods within a structured environment, support by speech and occupational therapists as well as a behavior specialist, and a positive behavior support plan for both the classroom and the bus were provided to address STUDENT’s multiple deficits. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that KCSOS provided a program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
However, starting in November 2002, Mr. Goss found that while STUDENT ably followed the classroom routine and expressed himself using signs and picture icons, STUDENT was less successful advancing to the more difficult short-term objectives when prompts or gestures were faded or reduced. (KCSOS Exh. 79.) When this new information became available, KCSOS was required through a variety of procedures to address these changed circumstances. Whether KCSOS responded appropriately will be addressed in the section below.
November 2002 to March 2003.
Did KCSOS take appropriate steps to define and address STUDENT’s unique needs when circumstances changed starting in November 2002?
The law requires a school district to make an appropriate offer of placement based upon information reasonably available at the time an offer is made. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999) (citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. of Educ., 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3d Cir. 1993)). However, the rule does not eliminate a school district’s obligation to revise a student’s educational program if it becomes apparent over the course of the school year that the student is not receiving educational benefit.
As the school year progressed, STUDENT started to falter. By teacher report, starting in November 2002, and by January 2003, it was becoming more apparent that STUDENT performed better on tasks that involved functional life skills, but he demonstrated increasing frustration and less success when presented with Lovass reading program activities or academic drills. In addition, the testimony and documents demonstrated that when the tasks became increasingly more difficult or when the prompts were faded, STUDENT became increasingly frustrated. In part as a result of his increased frustration and partly to meet his sensory needs, STUDENT’s head banging behaviors increased in frequency and intensity.
The question to be addressed is whether KCSOS responded properly to these changed circumstances. As soon as it became aware that STUDENT was no longer progressing, starting in November 2002, KCSOS convened IEP meetings to discuss the teachers’ progress reports and to request parental permission to conduct a full assessment. The independent evaluation that had been conducted in July 2002 had produced no useful results and members of the IEP team wanted to better understand STUDENT’s inability to perform tasks independently. The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s parents initially refused to provide their consent. According to the testimony, KCSOS initiated a due process hearing to override STUDENT’s parents’ refusal, but as a result of a mediation parental consent to assess STUDENT was ultimately provided in January 2003.
The assessments identified areas of need in academic and cognitive development and behavior management that were dramatically different from those recognized when the April 2002 IEP was agreed upon. In addition, by February 19, 2003, when STUDENT banged his head into two walls, his need for a different behavioral intervention plan became apparent. To address these needs, the IEP team offered a new educational program that emphasized a functional life curriculum in place of academic skills, included additional behavioral interventions in a draft BIP and provided for the use of a soft helmet to protect STUDENT from self harm. When STUDENT’s parents refused to consent to implementation of the new IEPs or allow use of the helmet, KCSOS sought this due process hearing.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that KCSOS acted appropriately. It convened several IEP meetings to discuss the problem, initiated a full assessment when STUDENT slowed his progress, studied STUDENT’s worsening behaviors by conducting an FAA, and drafted a new IEP and BIP in response to the testing results. In addition, KCSOS met its obligations under State special education law and the IDEA by seeking due process hearings to override STUDENT’s parents’ lack of consent to the assessments and disagreement over implementation of the new IEP.
Did KCSOS provide STUDENT with a program and services that conformed to his IEP?
No concerns were expressed regarding conformity with the IEP.
Summary.
It is concluded that the program in place at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, based upon the mediated April 5, 2002 IEP, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit from the information as it was known at the time. As soon as STUDENT’s progress slowed and circumstances changed, KCSOS acted appropriately. Accordingly, KCSOS provided STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year.
By the time assessments were completed, the revised IEP coincided with the triennial review. The Hearing Officer will next address whether KCSOS’s revised program offer provided STUDENT a FAPE.
APRIL 2003-APRIL 2004 SCHOOL YEAR
ISSUE II: Did KCSOS offer STUDENT a FAPE in the March 5, March 20, April 4, April 10 and May 19, 2003 IEPs?
Was KCSOS’s offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs?
KCSOS stated that its offer for STUDENT is contained in the IEPs dated March 5, March 20, April 4, April 10 and May 19, 2003. Goals and objectives were presented in the areas of functional life skills which included setting a table, grooming and self-care; speech and language which included demonstrating receptive understanding of basic pictures and words, using a computer mouse appropriately, using a picture symbol to ask for help, using a vocal communication aid device, making word approximations, following instructions, following a multi-step project with one prompt, imitating vertical and horizontal lines; and mathematics which included sorting and building a block structure. Behavior goals included reducing the incidents of head banging and using a picture symbol for head pressure to replace head banging.
Related services were offered in the areas of speech and language in the amount of thirty minutes of direct service three times per week and fifteen minutes of consultation services. OT was offered for fifteen minutes each week and consultation services in the amount of fifteen minutes each week. Assistive technology services were to be provided for thirty minutes each month. Direct behavior services were to be provided for thirty minutes each month and thirty minutes each month as consultation services. A draft BIP was also included. STUDENT was mainstreamed for lunch and recess and required close supervision.
Student contends that the program offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because it contained an inappropriate behavior intervention plan that included the use of a soft helmet. According to STUDENT’s parents, the helmet was a restraint and they refused to consent to its use. Student also objected to the proposed program because it reduced the amount of SAL and OT despite STUDENT’s needs in both these areas.(FOOTNOTE 11) The evidence established that previously, STUDENT had received thirty minutes of direct SAL services each day and two hours each week of direct OT service and thirty minutes each week of OT consultation services.
KCSOS maintained that its offer, that included the use of a helmet as a protective device, was appropriate due to the severe nature of STUDENT’s head banging. KCSOS also contended that its offer of reduced SAL and OT was appropriate because STUDENT’s needs in these areas were met throughout the day as part of his integrated program by other staff.
In order to analyze KCSOS’s offer for the 2003-2004 school year, the Hearing Officer turns first to STUDENT’s needs. There is no dispute that many of STUDENT’s needs identified earlier in April 2002, remained the same in March 2003. STUDENT continued to exhibit severe deficits in speech and language, auditory processing, sensory processing, social communicative skills, and self-help and self-care skills. However, the more current assessments as well as STUDENT’s February 2003 severe head banging episodes, revealed that STUDENT’s cognitive and academic needs as well as his behavioral needs had changed significantly.
Unique Cognitive and Academic Needs
Recent assessments revealed that STUDENT’s unique cognitive and academic needs were exacerbated by significant developmental delays. Mr. Shapiro, who assessed STUDENT using several standardized non-verbal testing instruments, reached the conclusion that STUDENT’s intellectual functioning was equivalent to a mental age of about a mid-two-year-old level and that STUDENT was moderately mentally retarded. Moreover, an educational evaluation showed that at age six years nine months, STUDENT’s developmental abilities ranged from a seven-month-old to a six-year-old level. It was also found that STUDENT’s general knowledge abilities fell within the one-year-old level. His self-help skills were very limited. STUDENT showed no interest in people in his environment. In addition, STUDENT’s classroom teacher testified that STUDENT’s failure to perform tasks independently, his limited responses to verbal prompts, as well as his inability to generalize, that is to reproduce a task or response in a different environment or from one day to another, led him to suspect that STUDENT was mentally retarded. Furthermore, Dr. Ritvo examined STUDENT’s school records and based upon his review, concluded that while STUDENT’s performance varied over the past few years, the changes in performance fell within a very narrow range. Dr. Ritvo further observed that STUDENT had never developed cognitive language and his behaviors were very regressed.
STUDENT’s parents resisted the mental retardation diagnosis and Dr. Ritvo testified that the label “mental retardation” is rarely used because of the emotional response to the term. Nevertheless, Mr. Shapiro’s assessment result was not refuted by any convincing evidence and the Hearing Officer finds the standardized testing results very persuasive.(FOOTNOTE 12) Taken together with the educational evaluation and the corroborating testimony of Mr. Goss and Dr. Ritvo, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s unique cognitive and academic needs included significant developmental delays.
Unique Behavioral Needs
At the time of the revised program offer, the overwhelming evidence established that STUDENT’s head banging behaviors had markedly increased in severity and required a different approach.
The parties agree that STUDENT head bangs as a means to communicate frustration, to get what he wants, to avoid a task, and to achieve sensory input or stimulation. Attempts at teaching replacement behaviors, such as using picture icons to communicate, providing pressure to STUDENT’s head to meet his sensory processing needs, and redirection, have met with varying degrees of success. Under previous behavior support plans, when STUDENT attempted to bang his head, he was prevented from doing so by a staff member placing his or her hand between STUDENT’s head and the surface, or by placing a soft surface under STUDENT’s head. STUDENT head banged on the floor, a wall, a person, a table, or the computer. By teacher report, STUDENT’s head banging had decreased over the 2002-2003 school year. It is without dispute that STUDENT’s head banging behaviors are cyclical, increasing and decreasing in frequency and duration.
In January and February 2003, KCSOS conducted a functional behavioral assessment in order to update its behavior plan. When the data gathering was nearly completed, on February 19, 2003, STUDENT’s teacher reported a sharp increase in the intensity of STUDENT’s head banging. On that day, STUDENT banged his head using a lateral instead of a back and forth movement. Despite close supervision, staff was surprised at the radical change in direction and was unable to intervene to protect STUDENT’s head as they had been able to do before when he moved his head back and forth. As a result, STUDENT banged his head into walls on two occasions hard enough to create small dents in each wall. At STUDENT’s parents’ request, an FAA was conducted to address this severe behavior. Additional data was collected from February 27, 2003 through March 31, 2003. (KCSOS Exh. 32.) A proposed behavior support plan was attached to the offered IEP. (KCSOS Exh. 15.)
Testimony persuasively established that because STUDENT’s head banging had dramatically increased in severity, had a long history and appeared to be for a strong purpose, namely to communicate rather than as an attention-getting device, previous interventions were ineffective. Ms. Roggentien concluded that ignoring the head banging did little to diminish the behavior. As a consequence, Ms. Roggentien recommended that STUDENT develop understanding of icons to ask for help and to express frustration and that STUDENT be taught alternative means to communicate his wants and needs. Ms. Roggentien also encouraged the use of a sensory activity before all DTT sessions and suggested that the staff draw upon STUDENT’s preferred activities to identify reinforcers. She recommended assistance from the occupational therapist to develop appropriate deep head pressure activities.
In sum, because STUDENT’s head banging was so much more severe in the February 2003 episodes and because he was too quick to be protected from harm despite the close supervision he received, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s behavioral needs include the need to be protected from self-injury.
Was the offered program designed to meet STUDENT’s cognitive and academic needs?
The Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives that emphasized functional life skills rather than the development of pre-academic skills were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique cognitive and academic needs as described above. Moreover, because of STUDENT’s unique need to be protected from self-injury until replacement behaviors are taught and the severe behaviors substantially reduced, an approach that limits frustrating circumstances throughout the school day may contribute to the success of the behavior intervention plan. By teacher report, STUDENT became increasingly frustrated when academic skills were being taught. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the emphasis on a functional life skills curriculum is designed not only to meet STUDENT’s cognitive and academic needs, but may contribute to meeting STUDENT’s behavioral needs as well.
STUDENT’s parents continued to attribute STUDENT’s inability to reach his annual goals and objectives to the nature of the instructional program. However, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the uncontradicted testimony of Mr. Goss, Dr. Ritvo, and Mr. Shapiro that it was both the nature of the disease of autism and STUDENT’s cognitive deficits, rather than the intrinsic nature of the instructional program, that explained STUDENT’s faltering performance. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds convincing the testimony of Ms. Hazel that the skills and tasks required of STUDENT were more challenging than what was asked of him at the pre-school level. In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the instructional program which emphasized functional life skills was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique cognitive and academic needs.
Was the offered program that proposed to use a soft helmet designed to meet STUDENT’s unique behavioral needs?
STUDENT’s parents objected to the use of a soft helmet as part of a behavior plan to reduce STUDENT’s head banging. KCSOS asserted that the soft helmet would protect STUDENT from self-injury while replacement behaviors are taught.
FATHER testified that a helmet is a restraint and that STUDENT is more likely to injure himself in other ways if the helmet is used. While STUDENT’s parents approve of a behavior plan which targets STUDENT’s head banging behaviors, STUDENT’s parents objected so strenuously to the use of a helmet as part of that intervention, that they have removed STUDENT from school. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by FATHER’ unsupported testimony that the use of a soft helmet amounts to a restraint. The Hearing Officer finds more convincing the testimony of Dr. Ritvo that because STUDENT is growing bigger and heavier, head banging could result in brain injury or damage. Dr. Ritvo, who ran an in-patient program for disabled individuals, testified that a soft helmet was frequently used as a protective device, not as a restraint.
The Hearing Officer finds that because STUDENT’s head banging markedly increased in intensity to the point that he put dents in hard surfaced walls even while he was closely supervised, his unique needs to be protected from self-injury and harm can be appropriately met by the use of a soft helmet as a protective device that is part of a behavior intervention plan. (KCSOS Exh. 83.)
The Hearing Officer is troubled however, by the lack of consistent standards or criteria defining when the helmet will be used. Staff testimony differed widely from believing the helmet would be placed on STUDENT all day, to assertions that the helmet would be used on an “as needed” basis, or to Ms. Roggentien’s testimony that the helmet would be put on “anytime head banging was a concern.” Ms. Roggentien suggested that the helmet would be placed on STUDENT approximately 70% of the school day. No criteria were suggested as to how the staff would determine when the helmet would be used. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer orders the IEP team to convene and determine objective criteria that will be applied across all STUDENT’s school environments and consistently by all staff when, and under what circumstances, STUDENT will wear the protective helmet.
The Hearing Officer will next address whether the proposed reduction in designated instructional services offered STUDENT a FAPE.
Occupational Therapy.
The offered program included a reduction in the provision of OT services from 120 minutes per week of direct service to fifteen minutes per week. Consultation OT services were decreased from thirty minutes to fifteen minutes each week. Ms. Hazel, the occupational therapist who knew STUDENT for the past three years, testified that the previous provision of services was not derived from her input, but rather was the result of a negotiated settlement agreement. Ms. Hazel stated that, at the time the April 2002 IEP was written, she had recommended thirty minutes of direct service and fifteen minutes for consultation each week. Student maintains that STUDENT requires the same amount of services that he received under the April 5, 2002 IEP and that a reduction in OT services does not meet his unique needs.
Ms. Hazel testified that at the present time, STUDENT does not require more than fifteen minutes of direct service each week, because STUDENT’s needs for sensory input and head pressure are ongoing, not merely once a day, and are more effectively provided by staff. Ms. Hazel has trained the staff to provide these over the course of the day. Ms. Hazel also has assisted the staff to identify sensory choices and has trained the staff to assist STUDENT in selecting a sensory activity from a sensory choice board. According to Ms. Hazel, if she is present with STUDENT too much, then she serves as a distraction.
The Hearing Officer finds that the marked reduction in direct OT services is inconsistent with STUDENT’s unique needs for sensory input and his more recent displays of severe self-injurious behaviors. Mr. Shapiro reported that STUDENT appeared to perform actions for sensory input and there was little dispute that STUDENT’s unique needs in this area did not diminish. Not only did the testimony support STUDENT’s continued need for sensory input, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique need for sensory stimulation had intensified. Both MOTHER and the behaviorist concluded that STUDENT’s severe head banging was, in part, for sensory stimulation. According to the behaviorist, the revised behavior intervention plan emphasized teaching replacement behaviors, such as the provision of head pressure, to reduce STUDENT’s severe self-injurious behaviors. The BIP provided that the OT would determine what head pressure activities were appropriate. In addition, the suggested use of a soft helmet contemplates desensitization to the use of such a helmet. As MOTHER testified, STUDENT is resistant to even wearing a hat.
Moreover, the recommendation of fewer hours of direct service was premised in part, upon Ms. Hazel having already trained the staff who worked with STUDENT. However, according to Ms. Bertran-Harris and Mr. Goss, Mr. Goss will not be STUDENT’s teacher for the coming school year. Ms. Hazel conceded in her testimony, that if there were staff changes, she might have to reevaluate her recommendation. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that reliance on the fact that trained staff provided sensory experiences throughout the day as justification for a reduction in the number of hours of direct services, is no longer supportable.
The Hearing Officer further finds that a reduction in OT consultation services is particularly incongruous with the recommendations set out in the draft behavior intervention plan. Thus for example, the BIP depends upon considerable input from the occupational therapist to meet STUDENT’s need for sensory stimulation and to assist the staff to diminish STUDENT’s head banging behaviors. The Hearing Officer finds that the reduction in OT consultation service is inconsistent with the proposed behavior plan -- the implementation of which is at the crux of STUDENT’s ability to benefit from his education.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the reduction in OT services was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for sensory input or to be protected from self harm. The Hearing Officer agrees with Ms. Hazel, that STUDENT needs sensory experiences throughout his school day, not just when a therapist is in his classroom. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will order that Ms. Hazel’s original recommendation of thirty minutes of direct OT services each week is appropriate to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. However, because STUDENT will have a new teacher starting in August 2003, and because STUDENT’s teacher and other staff require extensive OT consultation in order to implement the behavior intervention plan, the Hearing Officer orders the same level of consultation services that had been provided under the previous plan, namely, thirty minutes each week.
Speech and Language Therapy.
KCSOS’s offer reduces SAL services from thirty minutes each day by the speech and language specialist to thirty minutes three times each week with follow through on the other two week days by STUDENT’s one-to-one behavior aide. In addition, the offer included an increase from no consultative SAL services to consultation fifteen minutes each week.
The speech and language assessment that was conducted in March 2003, concluded that STUDENT had developmental apraxia, that is difficulty with oral motor planning, that made it more difficult for STUDENT to vocalize. The evaluator concluded that STUDENT was functioning at about the one-year-old level in the area of speech and auditory comprehension. Accordingly, there was no dispute that STUDENT continued to have severe speech and language delays.
However, Ms. Sarff testified that in March 2003, STUDENT had begun to show some progress, choosing from among a wider field of picture icons. Ms. Sarff concluded that based upon this advance, the provision of direct services every day was excessive. She characterized STUDENT’s progress as a “wave,” that is, on some days STUDENT would make progress and on other days he would regress. The Hearing Officer finds that because the documents and testimony establish that STUDENT progresses only intermittently, the minimal advancement observed in March 2003, was an insufficient justification to reduce direct speech and language services by the trained therapist.
In addition, the Hearing Officer further finds that assigning STUDENT to his instructional aide two days each week for speech and language therapy was not designed to meet his unique needs. STUDENT’s one-to-one instructional aide, Leo Ocampo, did not testify and his resume did not include his educational background. While Mr. Ocampo has received some on-the-job training, the Hearing Officer finds that his credentials are inadequate to assume the speech therapist’s responsibilities two days each week, given STUDENT’s severe speech and language delays. There is further support to continue with the same number of hours of direct SAL services that STUDENT had before. Assisting STUDENT to communicate his wants, needs and frustrations by means other than head banging is unequivocally a crucial area of need at this time so that STUDENT can benefit from his education. Reduction in speech and language services is in sharp opposition to the goals of the BIP that seeks to diminish STUDENT’s severe and self-injurious behaviors by increasing his ability to communicate his needs in acceptable, alternative ways. In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the reduction of direct SAL services by the speech and language therapist did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE.
Speech and language goals written into the offered program required cooperation with STUDENT’s classroom teacher to help STUDENT develop receptive understanding of basic words and with the behavior specialist to increase STUDENT’s communication. The Hearing Officer agrees that fifteen minutes of consultation is sufficient to accomplish these collaborations.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the reduction in direct speech and language therapy by the trained specialist was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique speech and language and behavioral needs and denied STUDENT a FAPE. The Hearing Officer orders that the same level of direct SAL services that have been provided should continue, namely five thirty-minute sessions with the speech therapist each week. The Hearing Officer finds that the offer of fifteen minutes of consultation SAL services offered STUDENT a FAPE. Was KCSOS’s offer that emphasized a functional life skills curriculum in a special day class reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit?
Student asserts that the offer was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit because the goals and objectives were too simple for STUDENT. KCSOS maintains that the goals and objectives were appropriately determined by the full assessment that was conducted and by STUDENT’s waning performance as he tried to achieve the goals and objectives in the April 5, 2002 IEP.
Responding to MOTHER’s assertions that STUDENT had made more progress in SLO and seemed to have regressed in Kern County, the Hearing Officer finds convincing Dr. Ritvo’s explanation that regression is part of the natural course of the disease of autism. Mr. Goss’s testimony is similarly convincing that it is not unusual for a child diagnosed with autism to perform a task on one environment such as his home, but then be unable to generalize and perform the same task in the school setting.
Moreover, addressing STUDENT’s parents’ complaint that some of the goals and objectives were too simple for STUDENT, while it appeared that certain goals were ones STUDENT had achieved before, such as the use of a scissor or a computer mouse, persuasive testimony established that greater demands were made of STUDENT in using these devices than previously. Thus, for example, according to Ms. Hazel, while STUDENT might have been able to use a scissor in a simple manner in pre-school, STUDENT was unable to meet the greater demands she placed on STUDENT in terms of scissor use that required more sophisticated dexterity. In addition, according to the testimony, while STUDENT was able to click a computer mouse, he did not use the mouse appropriately and repeatedly clicked the mouse even after he had accessed a desired program.
The Hearing Officer finds convincing the recent assessment results, STUDENT’s teacher’s progress reports, and STUDENT’s faltering performance as he tried to achieve the more difficult short term objectives of the previous IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the goals and objectives and emphasis on functional life skills within the special day class setting offered by KCSOS are appropriate to meet STUDENT’s cognitive and academic needs and are reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
* * * * *In sum, placement in the special day class with emphasis on a functional life skills curriculum is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique cognitive and academic needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Likewise, the Hearing Officer finds that the behavior intervention plan is appropriate to address STUDENT’s severe maladaptive behaviors, but that the IEP team should reconvene to develop objective criteria when, and under what circumstances, to use a soft helmet with STUDENT to protect him from self-injury. However, the Hearing Officer further finds that the reduction in the related services of SAL and OT is inconsistent with the goals and objectives of the behavior intervention plan and STUDENT’s critical needs to develop alternative means to communicate and to receive sensory input. Accordingly, KCSOS’s program offer to reduce services in both these areas was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. Developing alternative means to communicate his wants and needs and alternative means to avoid self-injury are essential to his ability to benefit from his education at this time.
In addition, because STUDENT has been kept out of school by his parents since the beginning of April 2003, and the record is clear that STUDENT has a great deal of difficulty with transitions, the IEP team shall develop a transition plan to ease STUDENT back to school.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that to the extent the KCSOS program offer for the 2003-2004 school year reduced the numbers of hours of SAL and OT and omitted objective criteria when the soft helmet would be used, it did not offer STUDENT a FAPE.
Did KCSOS offer STUDENT a program and services that conformed to his IEP?
Because STUDENT’s parents did not consent to the IEP, STUDENT never participated in the program offered by KCSOS, it is therefore unnecessary to address this element.
PROCEDURAL VIOLATIONS
STUDENT’s parents allege that KCSOS committed procedural violations from April 2002 through the present that infringed on their participation in the IEP process because KCSOS: (1) held IEP meetings without parent participation; and (2) failed to give adequate attention to the increasingly regressive behaviors that STUDENT exhibited at the IEP meetings that his parents did attend. KCSOS contended that it acted appropriately.
The testimony and documents established that there were many formal IEP meetings as well as informal team meetings over the course of the time period at issue regarding STUDENT’s educational program. MOTHER testified that meetings were run with a pre-set formal written agenda that limited informal discussion and parental input. Ms. Madigan testified that it appeared to her that concerns that were not listed on an “agenda” were not discussed.
The Hearing Officer finds that several modifications to STUDENT’s program were made at MOTHER’s request. Thus, for example, at a November 2002 IEP meeting, vocalization goals were added to STUDENT’s program at MOTHER’s urging. MOTHER’s list of proposed goals and objectives were discussed at the April 2003 IEP meeting. According to the convincing testimony of Ms. Bertran-Harris and Mr. Goss many of MOTHER’s proposals were reviewed, and it was explained that several were either already included in the draft goals and objectives or inappropriate for the school setting. (Student Exh. V.) The Hearing Officer finds that whether there was a formal or informal agenda that guided the meeting, MOTHER was not denied participation in the IEP meetings.
In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents were regularly kept apprised of STUDENT’s progress. Monthly team meetings were convened that included STUDENT’s parents, as well as STUDENT’s teacher, behavior aide, speech therapist and occupational therapist, where STUDENT’s performance was reported and discussed. Mr. Goss testified that the meetings were structured but that all participants were allowed to discuss STUDENT’s progress. The facilitator checked with STUDENT’s parents to ensure their issues were included and each team member, including STUDENT’s parents, was given the chance to speak. MOTHER conceded, however, that despite this opportunity, she did not always attend these team meetings. STUDENT’s teacher, Mr. Goss, sent home regular reports concerning STUDENT’s progress in STUDENT’s backpack for parental review.
MOTHER further testified that she was not given sufficient notice of several IEP meetings. She explained that she did not attend the February 25, 2003 IEP meeting because she did not know about the meeting until the day before, that she was sick and unable to attend the March 5, 2003 IEP meeting, and that she missed the May 19, 2003 IEP meeting because she was not available on that date and had received notice only two days earlier.
The law requires that “parents or guardians shall be notified of the individualized education program meeting early enough to ensure an opportunity to attend.” Cal. Education Code § 56341.5. Here, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents were given sufficient notice of the meetings and that no procedural violation occurred. According to Ms. Bertran-Harris the purpose of the February 2003 meeting was to develop a data collection plan for the FAA. She called FATHER on February 19, 2003 right after the head banging episodes to inform him that the IEP team wanted to meet on February 25, 2003 to discuss these severe behaviors. Ms. Roggentien called MOTHER and informed her of the meeting and MOTHER agreed to the date. Written notice of the meeting was faxed to STUDENT’s parents and returned by MOTHER. (KCSOS Exh. 1.) According to the credible testimony, FATHER said he would not attend because he did not like IEP meetings.
Advance written notice was provided for the March 5, 2003 IEP meeting. (KCSOS Exh. 3.) The purpose of the meeting was to discuss the assessment results. MOTHER advised the KCSOS staff on the morning of March 5th that because she and STUDENT were ill she could not attend. Although KCSOS opened the meeting so that they could comply with the time line to hold an IEP meeting within fifty days after the assessment reports, KCSOS could have requested a written waiver from MOTHER to postpone the meeting. See, Cal. Education Code § 56344(a). Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no procedural error that amounted to the denial of a FAPE because another meeting was held shortly thereafter with STUDENT’s parents present, where the assessment results and reports were reviewed by all the assessors. Furthermore, as to the May 19, 2003 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents refused to attend any further IEP meetings because of the pending due process hearing. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that the notices provided to STUDENT’s parents were enough to ensure their attendance.
Finally, as discussed above, contrary to Student’s assertions, the Hearing Officer found that KCSOS did not ignore STUDENT’s school performance and that it acted appropriately by funding an independent evaluation, convening IEP meetings, conducting a full assessment, developing a BIP, and presenting a revised IEP.
In sum, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the above evidence that the parents’ participation in the IEP was not infringed upon nor did the actions of KCSOS result in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT.(FOOTNOTE 13)
ISSUE III: If KCSOS denied or failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement at a nonpublic school?
Student has requested a nonpublic school placement at KCSOS expense. A nonpublic school placement can be provided when no appropriate public education is available. Cal. Education Code section § 56365. As discussed above, with some modifications, KCSOS’s placement can appropriately meet STUDENT’s needs. Therefore, it cannot be said that no appropriate education is available within the meaning of Cal. Education Code § 56365.
ORDER
Within 15 days from the date of this Decision, unless the parties agree in writing otherwise, KCSOS shall reconvene the IEP team and revise STUDENT’s educational program as follows:
(1) to provide thirty minutes of direct OT services and thirty minutes of consultation OT services each week;
(2) to provide five thirty-minute sessions of direct SAL, all with the speech therapist, and fifteen minutes of consultation SAL services each week;
(3) to develop objective criteria when, and under what circumstances, STUDENT may wear a soft helmet as part of the behavior intervention plan;
(4) to provide a transition plan to ease STUDENT’s return to school.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Cal. Education Code section 56507(d) , the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
I. Did KCSOS offer or provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from April 2002 to March 2003?
KCSOS/District prevailed on this issue.
II. Did KCSOS offer STUDENT a FAPE in the March 5, March 20, April 4, April 10 and May 19, 2003 IEPs, including an appropriate behavior intervention plan?
Student prevailed on this issue to the extent that the educational program failed to include an appropriate number of hours of OT and SAL services, failed to contain objective criteria to determine when, and under what circumstances, STUDENT will wear a protective helmet, and failed to contain a transition plan.
III. If KCSOS denied or failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement at a nonpublic school?
KCSOS/District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: July 8, 2003 _________________________________ Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. On July 16, 2003, after the Decision was first issued, the Hearing Office received from Petitioner/Cross-Respondents KCSOS and the District a request to amend the Decision in several respects. The Hearing Officer has made the requested changes. Footnote 4 (originally footnote 3) was modified to correct the name of the school district that contracts with KCSOS to use its facilities from “Beardsley Elementary School District” to “Panama-Buena Vista Elementary School District.” The second paragraph of page nine of the Decision was modified to reflect that in August 2002 STUDENT was enrolled in “Buena Vista Elementary School” instead of “Beardsley Elementary School.” Lastly, page 23, paragraph 3 was amended to reflect that the date of the IEP meeting was February 25, 2003, instead of February 26, 2003. None of these modifications affect the findings of fact or conclusions of law or the outcome of the Decision.
2. On June 30, 2003, the Hearing Office received from KCSOS/District, a motion to disallow Student’s final written argument from being submitted as part of the record. According to KCSOS/District, the written brief was filed one day late. On July 2, 2003, the Hearing Office received an opposition to KCSOS/District’s motion from the Student. The Hearing Officer finds that the Student’s closing written brief was submitted in a timely fashion on the due date of June 26, 2003, as scheduled by the Hearing Officer, and accordingly denies KCSOS/District’s motion. 3. On May 23, 2003, Hearing Officer Ganz presided over a prehearing telephone conference to clarify the issues for hearing. At that time, the Student alleged various procedural and substantive violations of FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year. On the first day of hearing, on May 29, 2003, STUDENT’s attorney withdrew all assertions regarding the 2001-2002 school year, explaining that those matters had been resolved through a previous mediation and were moot. Further changes in the presentation of issues were made for the purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis. 4. According to the testimony, STUDENT resides within the boundaries of the Beardsley Elementary School District. However, KCSOS contracts with the Panama-Buena Vista Elementary School District to use its facilities. Consequently, although STUDENT attends Buena Vista Elementary School, which is a Panama-Buena Vista Elementary School District school, it is KCSOS, rather than the District, that is responsible for providing STUDENT’s educational program. For purposes of this Decision, Petitioner/Cross-Respondent shall be referred to as KCSOS throughout.
5. KCSOS sought injunctive relief in the Kern County Superior Court to override STUDENT’s parents’ lack of consent to the use of a soft helmet. (KCSOS Exh. 33.) According to the testimony, the superior court judge declined to issue a temporary restraining order or provide injunctive relief, deciding that the matter was more properly addressed to the Special Education Hearing Office.
6. As noted, Student originally asserted allegations of a denial of FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, but these allegations were withdrawn on the first day of hearing by Student. 7. Ms. Zastrow has had extensive training at the University of North Carolina in implementing the TEACCH or “structured teaching” program and understanding the disease of autism. Ms. Zastrow has a private consultation business called “California Autism Project” and “Structured Teaching Environments Promoting Success (S.T.E.P.S.)”. She consults with thirty-five California SELPAs and LEAs. She has taught many groups and individuals how to develop programs for infants through adults who are diagnosed with autism. From 2001 to the present, Ms. Zastrow was employed as a program specialist for another school district. There she coordinates all the programs for children diagnosed with autism and those with other handicapping conditions. 8. . Goss has been a special education teacher since 1996. He has had a California special education credential for the severely handicapped since 1997, and possesses a multiple subjects credential. He has had significant training in teaching children diagnosed with autism, including DTT, use of the PECS system, and behavior management. 9. Dr. Ritvo has participated in extensive professional activities that involve children diagnosed with autism, including writing publishing many papers and delivering numerous lectures worldwide. He has received several prestigious awards for his work.
10. The Hearing Officer observes that while STUDENT was in SLO, he was provided with in-home assistance after school by the regional center. MOTHER attributed STUDENT’s progress, in part, to the fact that the home and school programs were consistent and that STUDENT responded well when there was consistency across environments. The Hearing Officer further observes that the April 2002 IEP provided for in-home consultation by Ms. Zastrow to assist with STUDENT’s behaviors. Ms. Zastrow explained that she attempted to provide a structure in STUDENT’s home that was similar to the school environment. According to the testimony and documents, however, STUDENT’s parents rejected Ms. Zastrow’s assistance. To the extent that the Hearing Officer agrees that consistency across environments is important for STUDENT to benefit from his education, the Hearing Officer finds that because STUDENT’s parents’ refused these consultations, the suggestion that KCSOS’s program lacked similar consistency as was provided in SLO must be rejected. 11. During the prehearing conference, Student’s attorney asserted that STUDENT wanted fewer hours of related services than MOTHER wanted. Accordingly, the number of hours actually requested by MOTHER in her testimony, instead of the amount of hours specified in the prehearing conference order, were clarified to be consistent with MOTHER’s wishes.
Student had also asserted during the prehearing telephone conference, that KCSOS had failed to conduct an appropriate FAA. However, Student presented no evidence in support of this contention and this Decision will not address that claim. 12. MOTHER argued that because STUDENT exhibited behaviors at home, including by way of example that STUDENT was very “crafty” and could retrieve a favorite snack despite the fact that she had hidden it, STUDENT was not mentally retarded. However, Mr. Shapiro testified that such behavior was consistent with his findings and conclusion that STUDENT was mentally retarded. The independent evaluator who attempted to test STUDENT’s intellectual functioning in June 2002, was unable to test STUDENT when STUDENT became extremely agitated and reached no conclusion about his current intellectual functioning. 13. The Hearing Officer observes that unfortunately the relationship between KCSOS and STUDENT’s parents was complicated by FATHER’s confrontational style that only served to minimize rather than enhance the opportunity for consensus. The Hearing Officer understands FATHER’s zealous advocacy on behalf of his son, but also observes that efforts should be made by both sides to reduce the tensions and attempt to achieve a more collaborative approach that focuses on STUDENT’s interests and educational programming, rather than on adult personalities.
