California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 14, 1996
Student v. San Diego City Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 751-95 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
San Diego City Unified must fund a 35-hour-a-week home behavioral program for a preschooler with autism and reimburse the parents.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a four-year-old boy with autism filed for a hearing against San Diego City Unified School District after his July 13, 1995 IEP meeting. The District offered 12 hours a week in a preschool special day class, plus speech, adapted physical education, and occupational therapy (OT). In October 1995 it raised the offer to five hours a day, four days a week, at Wiggin School, with 3½ hours a day of one-to-one work. Meanwhile, the parents ran an in-home, one-to-one discrete trial program through the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), and the boy made large gains.
The Hearing Officer found that the IEP goals did not address attention, task completion, self-help skills, or self-stimulatory behavior. Neither offer provided a free appropriate public education. The boy needed intensive one-to-one teaching, could not yet learn in groups, and needed a low-distraction setting with few transitions and real parent involvement. The Hearing Officer relied mainly on Dr. Bryna Siegel, who had observed the boy. She found that he needed 35 hours a week, not the 40 the parents requested, year-round with breaks of no more than one week. He also needed two hours a week of program supervision and two hours a month of parent training. The request for more OT was denied. The District must hold an IEP meeting and repay tutor costs from August 1, 1995, plus program supplies (not bookshelves) and phone consultations with Dr. Granpeesheh. The Hearing Officer denied costs for training, OT equipment, travel, assessments, and legal expenses.
Why it matters
This early SEHO decision addressed an intensive in-home behavioral program for a young child with autism. The Hearing Officer gave more weight to experts who had observed the child. She rejected a group preschool offer because it had too few hours and too many distractions. She limited reimbursement to costs tied directly to the educational program.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 1. Do the goals and objectives in the IEP dated July 13, 1995, comply with IDEA and provide an appropriate educational program?
The goals did not address attending, task completion, self-help skills, or reducing self-stimulatory and other maladaptive behavior, so the IEP did not meet all of the student's needs under Rowley.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District offer an appropriate educational program at the IEP meeting on July 13, 1995?
A 12-hour-a-week group SDC offer with no specified one-to-one instruction, no behavior program, and only 4-5 home contacts a year did not meet the needs of a student who required 35 hours a week of one-to-one instruction in a low-distraction setting.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Did the District's proposed placement in the SDC at Wiggin School in October 1995 offer a free appropriate public education?
Raising the offer to 5 hours a day, four days a week, with 3.5 hours of daily one-to-one work was still far short of 35 hours and left the other defects uncorrected, so it did not offer FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 4A. Does an appropriate program include forty hours a week, fifty weeks a year, of a home-based, one-to-one instructional program using discrete task analysis?
An appropriate program is a home-based, one-to-one discrete trial program of 35 hours a week (not 40), provided year-round with breaks of no more than one week.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4B. Does an appropriate program include two hours per week of program supervision by a supervising therapist?
Two hours a week of supervision by a supervising therapist is needed to keep the multi-therapist program consistent.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4C. Does an appropriate program include two hours a month of parent training and program supervision from a program director?
Parent involvement and supervision by a qualified director are part of the appropriate program; two hours a month of parent training is required.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4D. Does an appropriate program include two hours a week of one-to-one occupational therapy?
Based on the District occupational therapist's unrebutted testimony about the student's attention span, two half-hour OT sessions a week meet his needs; the request for more was denied.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5. Is the District required to reimburse the family for one-to-one services, program supervision, and parent training between August 1, 1995, and October 5, 1995?
Under Burlington, the parents' program was appropriate, so tutor costs not paid by the Regional Center (up to 35 hours a week), program supplies other than bookshelves, and phone consultations with the program director are reimbursable from August 1, 1995; training, OT equipment, travel, assessment, unspecified, and legal costs were denied.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6. Is the District required to reimburse the family for one-to-one services, program supervision, and parent training since October 5, 1995?
Because the October 1995 offer was also inappropriate, the same categories of costs allowed under Issue 5 are reimbursable from October 5, 1995 onward.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Placement ordered. An appropriate program is a one-to-one, home-based, discrete trial program of 35 hours per week, provided year-round with breaks from instruction not to exceed one week.
- Order to provide or change services. Program must include two hours per week of program supervision and two hours a month of parent training and program supervision from a program director.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. On receipt of the decision, the District must immediately convene an IEP meeting to conform the IEP to the decision, then immediately provide a consistent placement.
- Reimbursement. Within 15 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse out-of-pocket costs listed in Petitioner's Exhibit 28: tutor costs not paid by the Regional Center for up to 35 hours per week; educational supplies and materials needed for the one-to-one program, excluding bookshelves; and phone consultations with Dr. Granpeesheh. No dollar amount stated.
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Education Code § 56441; Education Code § 56345; Education Code § 56507
People named in the decision
- Mary Sue Glynn, special education school administrator, San Diego City Unified School District
- Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., clinical director and program director; assessor and witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), private agency providing in-home one-to-one program
- Lynne Gregory, private assessor, Children's Hospital and Health Center
- Maureen Anne Moore, in-home therapist; witness for Student, CARD
- Bryna Siegel, Ph.D., expert witness for Student, University of California, San Francisco, Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic
- Coleen Sparkman, private speech-language pathologist; expert witness for Student, private practice
- Jan Blancher, Ph.D., expert witness for Student, University of California, Riverside
- Tristam Smith, Ph.D., rebuttal expert witness for Student, University of Washington
- Lauriel Adsit, adapted physical education teacher; District assessor, San Diego City Unified School District
- Sally Weisman, SEEC school psychologist; District assessor, San Diego City Unified School District
- Julie Adams, speech-language pathologist; District assessor, Wiggin School, San Diego City Unified School District
- Elise Douglas, occupational therapist; District assessor, San Diego City Unified School District
- Adriana L. Schuler, Ph.D., expert witness for District, San Francisco State University
- Lorna Jean King, occupational therapist; expert witness for District, Center for Neurodevelopmental Studies, Arizona
- Richard Jagoda, SEEC special day class teacher, Wiggin School, San Diego City Unified School District
- Mary Lou Evans, SEEC itinerant resource teacher (autism pull-out program), Wiggin School, San Diego City Unified School District
- Janet Hartley Muniz, occupational therapist, San Diego City Unified School District
- Bruce Dake, Ed.D., District psychologist; witness for District, San Diego City Unified School District
- Hector Martinez, parent of another Wiggin student; witness for District
- G. Robert Roice, educational consultant representing District
- Jose Gonzales, assistant general counsel, San Diego City Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in San Diego, California, on April 8, 9, and 10, and June 6, 7, 17, 18, and 20, 1996.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorneys Valerie Vanaman and Kathryn E. Dobel.(Footnote 1) Also present on behalf of STUDENT were his parents, MOTHER and FATHER. Respondent San Diego City Unified School District (District) was represented by G. Robert Roice, educational consultant, and Jose Gonzales, assistant general counsel for the District. Also present on behalf of the District was Mary Sue Glynn, special education administrator.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. At the request of the parties, the record was held open to allow for the submission of written closing arguments. On August 5, 1996, the Hearing Office received closing arguments from Petitioner and Respondent.(Footnote 2) Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Do the goals and objectives contained in STUDENT's individualized education program (IEP) dated July 13, 1995, comply with the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and provide STUDENT with an appropriate educational program?
(2) Did the District offer an appropriate educational program to STUDENT at the IEP meeting on July 13, 1995?
(3) Did the District's proposed placement of STUDENT in the special day class (SDC) at Wiggin School in October 1995 offer him a free appropriate public education?
(4) Does an appropriate educational program for STUDENT include the following:
(A) Forty hours a week, fifty weeks a year, of a home-based, one-to-one instructional program using discrete task analysis;
(B) Two hours per week of program supervision by a supervising therapist;
(C) Two hours a month of parent training and program supervision from a program director; and (D) Two hours a week of one-to-one occupational therapy.
(5) Is the District required to reimburse STUDENT's family for the sums they have expended in providing STUDENT with one-to-one services, program supervision, and parent training between August 1, 1995, and October 5, 1995?
(6) Is the District required to reimburse STUDENT's family for the sums they have expended in providing STUDENT with one-to-one services, program supervision, and parent training since October 5, 1995?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner is a four-year-old child with autism. He is eligible for special education and presently participates in an intensive behavioral intervention program provided for by his parents through the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD).(Footnote 3) STUDENT works individually with a number of instructors on a specific discrete task analysis program.(Footnote 4) The program is delivered in his home for six to seven hours per day. Interspersed with his sessions are a lunch break for approximately one and one-half hours and, after every two sessions, additional breaks of approximately 15 minutes each. STUDENT's parents have set up a "mock" preschool in their home and STUDENT participates in a pre-school play group one night per week. STUDENT's parents also take him once a week to the Discovery Zone for gross-motor and socialization activities.(Footnote 5)
According to the PARENTS, STUDENT appeared to reach normal developmental milestones during the first year of his life. He then lost interest in his environment and failed to develop language. The report of a neurological assessment of STUDENT at 21 months of age describes him as socially delayed and showing "limited interest in interpersonal interaction and fairly pronounced avoidance of direct eye contact." The assessor stated that, at that time, it was premature to make a diagnosis of autism and concluded that STUDENT had a profound communication disorder. (Petitioner's Exhibit 2) On July 5, 1994, the San Diego Regional Center made a provisional diagnosis of autism based on observations of STUDENT and information provided by his parents who described deficits in social interaction and play, rigidity in routines, delays in expressive and receptive language, and self-stimulatory behavior. The Regional Center recommended that STUDENT participate in an infant program to address cognitive, speech, language, and social needs. The Regional Center also recommended that STUDENT's parents participate in a training group at the Regional Center; that an occupational therapy (OT) assessment be undertaken; and that a referral be made for a behavioral consultation to determine ways to meet STUDENT's behavioral needs. (Petitioner's Exhibit 3)
An OT assessment completed on July 6, 1994, recommended that STUDENT participate in OT one to two times per week to provide sensory motor stimulation and to help him develop self-help, adaptive, play, and socialization skills. (Petitioner's Exhibits 4 and 5) In October 1994, STUDENT began receiving OT at the Children's Hospital and Health Center. For approximately seven months, beginning in October 1994, STUDENT attended twice weekly sessions of infant development program at Children's Hospital. The emphasis was on the development of language skills. MOTHER described the program as play-based. In the spring of 1995, STUDENT participated in a research program at the University of California, San Diego. The program was based on a Pivotal Behavior Modification Program. According to MOTHER, while STUDENT engaged in activities he selected, the instructor described to STUDENT what he was doing. The only program MOTHER believes STUDENT benefitted from was OT, which was one-to-one.
MOTHER apparently made several inquiries to the District regarding the availability of behavioral intervention programs for STUDENT. On May 3, 1995, MOTHER made a formal request to the District for a special education assessment of STUDENT. (Petitioner's Exhibit 6) At the request of MOTHER, STUDENT also was assessed in May 1995 by Children's Hospital and Health Center. STUDENT was then approximately two years and nine months old. Dr. Lynne Gregory of Children's Hospital found that STUDENT's cognitive abilities fell within the moderate range of mental retardation with scattered skills falling at higher levels. STUDENT's expressive and receptive communication skills fell below the 12-month level. Dr. Gregory reported that STUDENT seldom initiated social interaction or used eye contact. She also stated that STUDENT engaged in self-stimulatory behaviors including hand flapping and eye crossing. According to Dr. Gregory's report, STUDENT's parents informed her that STUDENT was also banging his head, throwing himself on the floor during tantrums, and eating inedible objects. Dr. Gregory concluded that STUDENT "will require intensive, highly individualized teaching efforts, because he is so independent and difficult to direct." Dr. Gregory also recommended adaptive physical education (APE) and/or OT, and intensive behavioral intervention services to address attentional problems and maladaptive, self-stimulatory, and self-injurious behaviors. (Petitioner's Exhibit 7)
In June of 1995, MOTHER obtained an assessment of STUDENT by Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., clinical director of CARD. Dr. Granpeesheh's assessment confirmed that STUDENT's developmental, self-help, and communication skills were delayed from one to two years and that he was essentially non-verbal. She also noted that STUDENT's social skills were limited and that he was "violent with his little sister...." Dr. Granpeesheh's report also states that STUDENT was having approximately four tantrums per day, was running away approximately five times per day, and was engaging in self-stimulatory behaviors. He also had a short attention span. Dr. Granpeesheh concluded that, to learn, STUDENT needed a "strict, one-to-one, calm environment." She also concluded that he needed to first improve his attention span, to use language appropriately, and be taught social skills before he could benefit from a group preschool setting. (Petitioner's Exhibit 8) To meet STUDENT's needs, Dr. Granpeesheh developed numerous goals and objectives in the areas of gross and fine motor, self-help, pre-speech, knowledge and comprehension, and readiness skills. She provided the goals and objectives, as well as a summary of assessment findings and recommendations. (Petitioner's Exhibit 9) STUDENT began receiving one-to-one educational services through CARD for approximately 10 hours per week. By July, STUDENT's program had increased to approximately 35 hours per week.
On June 21, 1995, the District provided STUDENT's parents with a proposed assessment plan. (Petitioner's Exhibit 10) The District's assessment of STUDENT by the special Education Early Childhood (SEEC) Assessment Team took place on July 6, 1995. District assessors participated in a "play-based assessment" of STUDENT that primarily included informal observations of STUDENT in unstructured activities and an interview with STUDENT's mother. STUDENT's motor development was scored on the Peabody Developmental Motor Scale and a Developmental Motor Inventory. The summary and recommendations of the team read as follows:
....Previous and current assessment findings indicate STUDENT is demonstrating a developmental profile consistent with moderate mental retardation and an autistic spectrum disorder. His communication skills are currently at a pre-linguistic level with no use of "real words" reported as yet. Some precursors to the one-word stage of language development were noted, however, during the assessment. STUDENT's gross motor skills were identified as an area of relative strength but he is not yet integrating these skills into age appropriate activities. Occupational Therapy reports indicate delays in the areas of sensory motor integration and fine motor skills....STUDENT's needs require special education intervention and services. At this time, he would benefit from participation in an integrated preschool program geared to his developmental level and emphasizing language acquisition, social interaction skills and sensory-motor integration.
(Petitioner's Exhibit 12; See also Petitioner's Exhibits 14 and 16)
On July 13, 1995, the IEP team met and determined that STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education. The team developed goals and objectives to improve STUDENT's ability to: interact and play with other children and adults; participate appropriately in school activities and routines; follow verbal directions; express wants/needs; and imitate production of speech sounds. Other goals and objectives are to improve: fine-motor skills through hand use and self-help skills; eye-hand coordination, attending, and task completion; manipulation and dexterity; balance skills; visual-motor coordination; and age-appropriate recreation skills. The IEP states that STUDENT was eligible for the following services: one hour per week of language, speech, and hearing services; one-half hour per week of APE; one to two half-hour sessions per week of OT; four to five home contacts annually; and extended school year (ESY). The District offered to place STUDENT in a SEEC special day class (SDC) four days per week for a total of 12 hours, with participation in regular education programs of from "0-39%." All services were to begin in September 1995. (Petitioner's Exhibit 17)
The PARENTS did not consent to the District's proposed placement for STUDENT. They asserted that STUDENT required a 40-hour per week program that included applied behavioral analysis instruction, speech and language therapy, OT, and social work services. They also proposed additional goals and objectives to develop STUDENT's skills in the areas of attending, requesting, non-verbal imitation, receptive instruction, pre-verbal imitation, speech and language, general knowledge and comprehension, fine and gross motor skills, readiness, pre-academic, self-help/care skills, and social and emotional behavior. (Petitioner's Exhibit 15)
On July 28, 1995, the Hearing Office received a request for a special education due process hearing from MOTHER on behalf of her son, STUDENT. The parties agreed to a number of continuances of the hearing dates while they participated in mediation. The parties were unable to resolve the dispute, however, and the matter convened for hearing on April 8, 1996.
In a letter dated October 5, 1995, Mary Sue Glynn, special education school administrator, set forth the District's proposed placement as follows:
The Special Day Class placement is at Wiggin School for 5 hours, four days a week. A trained aide or teacher will be working one-to-one with STUDENT for 3 1/2 hours daily. The remainder of the time would be in small group. As per the IEP, the District is offering speech services for 60 minutes a week, adapted physical education for 30 minutes a week and occupational therapy for 60 minutes a week. The teacher would make 4-5 home visits a year.
Following receipt of a letter from MOTHER, Ms. Glynn clarified the District's offer of placement as follows:
...STUDENT will attend school from 8:30 to 1:30, Monday, Tuesday, Thursday and Friday assigned to Rich Jagoda's class....For at least 3 1/2 hours of STUDENT's day, he would be working one-to-one with Mr. Jagoda or a special education technician in the classroom or with Mary Lou Evans, another teacher with expertise who has a pull out program....The remainder of this time would be in small groups in Mr. Jagoda's room or in DIS sessions.
(Petitioner's Exhibit 21)
In October 1995, Dr. Gregory of Children's Hospital and Health Center conducted a follow-up assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Gregory stated that STUDENT had made significant progress in the five months since she had last seen him. For example, Dr. Gregory noted that STUDENT was able to label objects, attempt approximations of sounds, and point to pictures. He was also more flexible in his play and his self-stimulatory behavior had decreased dramatically. Dr. Gregory expressed the opinion that STUDENT's progress was due to the "implementation of a comprehensive one-to-one program of applied behavior analysis with discrete trial training components as well as pivotal-response training...." Dr. Gregory recommended that STUDENT continue to participate in the in-home program. (Petitioner's Exhibit 2)
In December 1995, STUDENT's parents enrolled STUDENT in a parochial preschool program to supplement his one-to-one program. He was accompanied to the program by one of his instructors from CARD. STUDENT did not do well in the program and, after several months, his parents removed him from the program.
The PARENTS contend that as a preschool child with autism, STUDENT requires a forty hour per week, home-based, one-to-one instructional program utilizing discrete task analysis for fifty weeks of the year. They assert that an appropriate program also includes two hours a week of program supervision from a supervising therapist, two hours a month of parent training, program supervision from a program director, and two hours a week of one-to-one occupational therapy. The PARENTS also contend that the District defined STUDENT's educational needs to match its existing program, which is not designed to meet STUDENT's needs or to allow him to make educational benefit. They assert because the District has not offered an appropriate program for STUDENT, they are entitled to reimbursement for the costs they have expended to provide a program that meets STUDENT's needs. The District contends that the program offered to STUDENT, which is set forth in the IEP dated July 13, 1995, and in Ms. Glynn's letter dated October 5, 1995, is designed to meet STUDENT's needs.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
Petitioner's Witnesses
STUDENT's mother testified that she regularly observes STUDENT's therapy. Every other Friday she is present at the sessions. On other Fridays and on every Thursday, she observes videotapes of the therapists working with STUDENT. MOTHER described a typical therapy session. At 8 a.m., the therapist arrives, identifies the program/drill to use, and gets out the appropriate materials. STUDENT takes a seat and begins the program. Each therapist works a two to three lessons and then STUDENT and the therapist take a break. The therapist then reconvenes with another program. MOTHER testified that the program is fun for STUDENT. He is rewarded with what motivates him including enthusiastic praise and social reinforcements like bouncing on the therapist's knee and playing "listening lotto."
MOTHER testified that STUDENT has made great progress since he has been participating in the CARD program. She spent a great deal of time describing the skills STUDENT has learned as she referred to Petitioner's Exhibits 26 and 27. MOTHER testified that STUDENT's social skills are improving and that he is now able to communicate in different environments. For example, at the zoo, STUDENT was able to identify animals; when he went for a walk with his mother, he told her when he saw a cat or dog. MOTHER testified that STUDENT does not currently exhibit any self-injurious behavior.
MOTHER testified that STUDENT continues to require an individual program and that he will regress if he does not participate in his program for more than one week. She also testified that when STUDENT is in a group of more than four children, he engages in some self-stimulating behavior including pacing back and forth, crying, and laying on his stomach against a wall or under a table.
MOTHER testified that, in contrast to the success STUDENT has achieved in his current one-to-one program, STUDENT made very little progress during the seven months he participated in what she termed a "play-based" infant development program at Children's Hospital. MOTHER testified that while at school, STUDENT engaged in 16 different maladaptive behaviors and engaged in self-stimulation without interruption. MOTHER testified that STUDENT's participation in a parochial preschool program from December 1995 to February 1996 was also unsuccessful. MOTHER testified that when STUDENT was in the preschool program he engaged in maladaptive behaviors that had been extinguished four months earlier.
MOTHER testified regarding the reimbursement she is seeking related to the provision of services for STUDENT. (See Petitioner's Exhibit 28) MOTHER testified that in January, she paid $900 to participate in training regarding applied behavioral analysis at the University of Southern California. The costs listed as "educational materials" are all of the items necessary to implement the program and include shelving and cabinets to create the "mock" preschool at the PARENT's home. MOTHER could not recall the source of the $60 for educational costs in January. The category "OT Equipment" includes the costs of swings, hammocks, and other equipment for occupational therapy experiences. "Discovery Zone" covers the entrance fee for STUDENT and his peers. Items under the category "Travel/Transportation" include the costs of seeing Dr. Granpeesheh and Ms. Vanaman. Lodging and child care costs were incurred by the parent on trips to see Dr. Granpeesheh and Ms. Vanaman. The phone conference consultations were with Dr. Granpeesheh.
Regarding the program proposed for STUDENT by the District in July 1995, MOTHER was uncertain whether the services would be provided to STUDENT individually or in a group setting. Prior to receiving a letter dated October 5, 1995, from Ms. Glynn, MOTHER understood that the District's offer had not changed throughout the mediation process. In her letter, Ms. Glynn indicated that the District had increased its offer of placement to a five hour per day program and, for the first time, the District offered STUDENT one-to-one assistance for three and one-half hours daily. MOTHER testified that, on October 19, 1995, Mr. Jagoda's class was first identified as the proposed placement for STUDENT.
MOTHER has observed the program at Wiggin school on four different occasions--July and December of 1995 and twice in March 1996. MOTHER testified that, during one of her observations, one student engaged in self-stimulatory behavior for 10 minutes and another student gnawed the enamel off of a chair for six minutes. She testified that neither the teacher nor any of the four instructional assistants attempted to redirect either student. MOTHER testified that she also observed an instruction assistant swat a student's hand away when the student went to pull the assistant's hair. According to MOTHER, the instructional assistant also put her full head of hair in the student's lap and said, "he likes it." MOTHER testified that during an earlier visit to Wiggin, a teacher informed MOTHER that she was not trained to deal with replacing self-stimulatory behavior and that autistic children are "just there." MOTHER testified that in conversations with Ms. Glynn, she was told that "if the approach used in STUDENT's one-to-one therapy was not successful fourteen years ago, why should it be now?"
MOTHER testified that the Wiggin program is not appropriate for STUDENT for the following reasons:
(1) STUDENT's previous experiences in a similar play-based program were unsuccessful. He regressed and his self-stimulating behaviors increased. (2) The class is not appropriately structured to meet STUDENT's needs. The activities are play-based and there is no comprehensive discrete trial teaching. The teacher does not require that the students respond to instruction. The teacher uses stories and narratives, which require the students to sit and maintain attention. (3) STUDENT does not learn incidentally and needs specific instruction to learn. There is no discrete trial training taking place in the SDC. (4) STUDENT has difficulty with transitions and the program proposed by the District would involve a number of transitions. Mr. Jagoda's class has different students in the afternoon, which would also cause STUDENT to experience anxiety. (5) The class does not have an intense language program and special education students lack oral communication skills. (6) The class can have as many as 15 students.
MOTHER testified that she offered for the District to observe STUDENT in person during a therapy session or to view a video of him. According to MOTHER, the District declined. MOTHER testified that after the initial IEP meeting in July 1995, the District did not suggest that the IEP team reconvene to further address STUDENT's placement and/or services. MOTHER testified that the District never offered to provide speech and language to STUDENT after she disagreed with the District's proposed placement. She did not dispute that the District had offered to provide OT to STUDENT even if he were not attending the District's program.
Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., is a licensed psychologist and director of CARD. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that the CARD program is based on the developmental levels of the typically developing child and the specific needs of the autistic child. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that children with autism have difficulty attending to multiple cues and differentiating stimulus. She testified that CARD teaches the student through one sense at a time and then increases the senses. According to Dr. Granpeesheh, if this technique is not employed, children with autism don't know on which stimuli to focus, get frustrated, engage in excessive behaviors, and do not learn. Dr. Granpeesheh described the sequence employed by CARD therapists as trial, instruction, response, and consequence. During instruction and response, the therapist collects data. If the student gives two incorrect responses, the student is prompted to allow the student to achieve success. When a response is correct, the student is reinforced. She stated that the demands placed on the student are increased gradually. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that a number of therapists are employed with each child because it is an intense and exhausting job and it is also important for the student to learn to respond to a number of different persons. She stated that consistency is maintained by constant logging of the student's responses.
Dr. Granpeesheh testified that when STUDENT began the CARD program, he did not have any meaningful verbalizations, his language and social skills were delayed, and he engaged in self-stimulating behavior. Dr. Granpeesheh observed that STUDENT was not able to respond in a noisy environment or in a group setting. She testified that STUDENT's maladaptive behaviors also needed to be extinguished before he could benefit from instruction, particularly in a group setting. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that, for these reasons, she recommended an individualized program for STUDENT. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that, if STUDENT had been in a group setting, a lot of time would have been "wasted" and there was nothing to be gained by trying STUDENT in the District's program in the fall of 1995 because STUDENT had already had an unsuccessful experience in a preschool group setting.
Dr. Granpeesheh testified that the type of program offered by CARD is not necessarily appropriate for all students with autism. She stated that a student who will benefit from the program should show growth within the first three months of the program in verbal imitation, compliance, receptive commands, and gross motor skills. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that STUDENT has benefitted from the CARD program and has made "remarkable" progress. She stated that STUDENT now has expressive labels for items and actions and his behavior has also improved. She testified that STUDENT's prognosis is now good, which she believes is a direct result of the one-to-one program provided to him. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that an appropriate program for STUDENT continues to include one-to-one instruction in a calm and nondistracting environment. He also needs discrete trial training. Dr. Granpeesheh did not recommend the use of pictures or sign language with STUDENT because he has shown that he can develop speech. In her opinion, the potential exists for STUDENT to become dependent on signs and pictures rather than continue to develop his language skills.
Maureen Anne Moore, has been one of STUDENT's therapists since September 1995. She is employed by CARD and supervised by Dr. Granpeesheh. Ms. Moore has a B.A. in economics and does not hold any teaching credentials. Ms. Moore testified that STUDENT initially was withdrawn, did not talk, and was aggressive toward his siblings. Ms. Moore testified that STUDENT is a different child now. He loves his family and likes to play with his siblings.
Ms. Moore testified that STUDENT tends to tune out and self-stimulate when he is just talked to. He may also be non-compliant. Ms. Moore stated that STUDENT responds and stays on tasks when questions are directed to him and when the adult acknowledges what STUDENT does. Ms. Moore testified that she works with STUDENT for eight to ten minutes at a time. He then gets a toy and they work on play skills for three to four minutes. After this routine is repeated for five times, STUDENT is given a 10 to 15 minute break outside. Ms. Moore stated that they will go for walks or engage in other gross-motor activities. Ms. Moore testified that STUDENT does not learn well in a group. She testified that, when she took STUDENT to preschool, he "shut down" and was non-compliant. Ms. Moore testified that the current plan is to integrate STUDENT in a regular preschool in several months. The school needs to be small and have a low student-to-teacher ratio. Ms. Moore observed Wiggin in March 1994 and June 1996. Ms. Moore testified that throughout her observation, one of the adults working with a student was completely silent except for giving the child a command. The child never completed the task and the adult did not give any consequences for not doing the task. Ms. Moore also observed Mr. Jagoda's class. She described the class as "overstimulating." She found it hard to hear and to think while in the class. Ms. Moore testified that four regular education students were seated at one end of an L-shaped table and the special education students were sitting about four feet away at the other end of the table. The aides were seated behind the special education students and were talking amongst themselves. Ms. Moore testified that rather than verbalizing instructions to the students, the aides reached for the items and picked them up for the students. Ms. Moore described the process of walking from the classroom to APE as "chaotic." At APE, the aides physically moved the students through the activities rather than providing appropriate assistance to allow the students to complete the activities independently. In Ms. Evans' classroom, Ms. Moore observed that there was a lot of crying and screaming. She stated that Cheetos were being used as a reinforcer in Ms. Evans' class. Ms. Moore testified that she observed one student sitting for 30 minutes and that the student was very unhappy throughout the entire time.
Bryna Siegel, Ph.D., is an associate adjunct professor in the department of psychiatry, Psychiatric Institute, University of California, San Francisco (UCSF). She also is the director of the Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic and has assessed approximately 1,600 children with autism or autistic characteristics. (See Petitioner's Exhibit 30) Dr. Siegel testified that her assessments include formal testing procedures, information from the parent, and clinical observations.
Dr. Siegel testified that children with autism learn differently than other children. They have poor imitative skills that interfere with their ability to learn from others or by observation. Dr. Siegel testified that, over the past four to five years, she has seen an increase in the use of in-home, intensive one-to-one programs with children with autism. Dr. Siegel testified that Dr. Ivar Lovaas of the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), Dr. Tristam Smith, and others have collected data from adequate samples which support the use of an intensive one-to-one program for children with autism. Dr. Siegel testified that the studies have found that students with autism do not make progress in programs other than those that provide intensive, one-to-one interventions. She stated that, per the studies, students receiving group-based instruction actually lost ground.
Dr. Siegel testified that the appropriate intensity level of a program is determined by the child's intellectual potential, cause and effect reasoning abilities, attention and distractibility, and developmental levels. Dr. Siegel discussed one study that found that students who received less than 5 hours per week of intervention lost ground and those students who received 10 hours per week stayed even with their initial testing level. Dr. Siegel testified that children with autism clearly show statistically significant gains when they receive a program of 25 hours or more per week; however, the most successful one-to-one programs are generally 30 to 40 hours per week. Dr. Siegel testified that an appropriate program must supplement the discrete trial format with experiences in the child's natural environment and opportunities to generalize skills in a number of environments. Dr. Siegel testified that the intensive one-to-one program works best when the child's parent is significantly involved in the program so that the child learns to generalize the tasks beyond the therapy environment to the home.
On May 17, 1996, Dr. Siegel observed STUDENT at his home. She testified that STUDENT should continue with his current individual treatment program because he has been making "great" progress in cognition. Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT's progress in this area is 70% to 80% better than most of the students she sees. STUDENT has also shown gains in the amelioration of autistic characteristics. Dr. Siegel described STUDENT's progress in this area as 90% better than the progress made by most of the students she sees. Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT's language skills have progressed and he has moved from being essentially non-verbal to having spontaneous language and to speaking in sentences. Dr. Siegel concluded that 35 hours per week is an appropriate amount of time for STUDENT to receive one-to-one instruction. Dr. Siegel based her recommendation on the level of services STUDENT currently receives and how he is doing. Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT requires one-to-one instruction year round because he will lose skills or regress when he is not receiving instruction. Dr. Siegel was doubtful that STUDENT could have made similar progress in the District's program at Wiggin. She testified that, if STUDENT continues to receive services at the same level in his current one-to-one program, he has a good chance to be mainstreamed in a regular education class with minimal special education services by the time he enters kindergarten. Dr. Siegel stated that, in this sense, STUDENT's current intensive program can be considered very cost effective.
On March 7, 1996, Dr. Siegel observed Mr. Jagoda's class. She understood that the class consisted of four "at risk" students, who are considered to have normal developmental potential, and four special education students. There were two "grandmotherly" aides in the classroom to assist Mr. Jagoda. Dr. Siegel described one of the students as autistic and another as possibly autistic. They were "low functioning and pre-verbal" and neither exhibited receptive language skills. Dr. Siegel testified that one of the autistic students left circle activities to "flop" on a bean bag. An aide followed the student and proceeded to give the student a massage. Dr. Siegel stated that the massage rewarded the student for inappropriate behavior. Dr. Siegel also observed that only the regular education students participated in the activities during circle time.
Dr. Siegel testified that Mr. Jagoda's class is not appropriate for STUDENT for the following reasons:
(1) the class is not behaviorally oriented. There is no sense of cause and effect. (2) the class is not developmentally geared toward special education students. (3) the class is chaotic.
(4) A number of different communication systems are used and there is confusion regarding how the systems are being implemented. For example, the teacher had a picture system around his neck but he did not use it with the students; one student had a voice synthesizer; and the student next to her had a picture system. (5) There is no empirical data supporting the play-therapy model adopted by Mr. Jagoda.
Dr. Siegel also observed Ms. Evans' pull-out program. She testified that Ms. Evans' program has "potential" and was moving in the direction of providing a one-to-one program; however, she identified the following deficiencies in the program:
(1) Ms. Evans did not respond to the interests of the child and Dr. Siegel characterized Ms. Evans' interactions with the students as "soulless." (2) the interventions employed by Ms. Evans were not developmentally sensitive. For example, she used a videotape to show the students how other students play. Dr. Siegel testified that, by definition of the disorder, children with autism are not able to learn by observing their peers. Children with autism need to start with concrete experiences and move by gradual approximations. (3) there is no empirical research to support the use of sensory integration with children with autism. (4) the pull-out program is not of sufficient length.
(5) Ms. Evans rigidly implements the discrete trial training and does not respond to the interests of the students. She also does not employ positive reinforcement. (6) the staff is not sufficiently trained.
Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT's home-based individual program is less restrictive than the District's program. At home, STUDENT gets breaks from his work, takes trips in the community to provide him with opportunities to generalize what he is learning, and has time for free play. Moreover, a child's home is a more typical environment for a preschool-aged child than is school. Dr. Siegel stated that a preschool group-based instructional setting is a relatively new educational concept.
Coleen Sparkman is a speech and language pathologist in private practice. She holds an M.A. in communication disorders, a certificate of clinical competency, and a certificate of clinical rehabilitation from the Department of Education. Ms. Sparkman testified that the major focus of her practice during the last three years has been children with autism. She currently has a caseload of 12 to 15 students with autism. Ms. Sparkman testified that she has observed classrooms in public schools to assist parents in making placement decisions and has worked with students participating in home programs.
On March 5, 1996, Ms. Sparkman observed STUDENT at his home and also observed the District's proposed placement at Wiggin. Ms. Sparkman testified that from her reading of the evidence and observations of STUDENT, she concluded that STUDENT has made significant gains in all areas of development, which she attributed to the intense home in which STUDENT has participated. Ms. Sparkman testified that STUDENT is able to label in excess of 100 items, use understandable language, request what he wants by using phrases, and imitates and responds to a variety of "wh" questions. He also points to items and is able to demonstrate generalization skills outside of the structured therapy setting. Ms. Sparkman testified that the amount of direct learning she observed at Wiggin would not have allowed STUDENT to make the gains he did. She testified that children with autism require a more intensive program than the one offered at Wiggin. Ms. Sparkman testified that children with autism benefit from information presented repetitiously over a short period of time with information reviewed at a later date whereas Mr. Jagoda's curriculum was based on play. To benefit from a class such as Mr. Jagoda's, Ms. Sparkman testified that children with autism would first need to be under functional control. According to Ms. Sparkman, STUDENT's behaviors were not under control when the District proposed the Wiggin program for him.
Ms. Sparkman testified that the adults in Mr. Jagoda's class did not address the needs of the individual students. She observed that students at a work table were not given any instruction by the aides nor did the aides engage in conversation with the students. Ms. Sparkman testified that there did not appear to be any benefit to having the regular and special education students together in Mr. Jagoda's room. During her observation, she did not see any spontaneous interactions between the regular education and the special education students, even during their 15-minute recess on the playground. Ms. Sparkman concluded that Mr. Jagoda's classroom was too stimulating for a child with autism. She stated that there were brightly-colored objects on the classroom walls and distracting items on the tables.
Ms. Sparkman described her observations of Ms. Evans' program. Ms. Sparkman testified that a video of a nondisabled child engaged in a play activity was used to cue the special education student to watch a videotape and then to select a toy in the classroom. At the end of the video, which was only a "few seconds" long, the classroom aide directed the student to find the toy. When the child selected the wrong toy, the aide directed the student to the correct toy or gave the student the toy. Ms. Sparkman observed that one student chose the wrong toy three of four times. Ms. Sparkman testified that she has never before seen the use of video employed with children with autism. Ms. Sparkman testified that there is no reason to believe that the technique would be successful because it relies on observational learning and students with autism do not learn through observation. Ms. Sparkman testified that Ms. Evans' program did not appear to have a particular philosophical approach. The teacher and her aides did not employ discrete trial training and there was no set daily schedule. Ms. Sparkman's impression was that the aides did not have the type of training needed to implement an individual program for STUDENT.
Jan Blancher, Ph.D., is a professor in the department of education at the University of California, Riverside. Included in the classes she teaches to graduate students is the "characteristics of exceptionality." Dr. Blancher has published a number of articles on preschool mainstreaming and the impact on families of students with disabilities. She also serves on a panel of her peers to review articles that have been submitted to professional journals for publication. Dr. Blancher testified that professional literature and research supports the use of a behavioral approach with preschool-aged children with autism. She testified that, with children with autism, there is a window of opportunity to make gains. The data suggests that early intervention, up to the age of five or six, can result in dramatic gains. Dr. Blancher testified that the District should not deny a home-based program for STUDENT without first seeing the program. She testified that the District has made a decision without all of the available data and has made placement decisions for STUDENT into a "battle of philosophies." Dr. Blancher testified that STUDENT's IEP reflects the District's low expectations for STUDENT. The IEP also does not target some areas. Dr. Blancher particularly found the speech and language goals lacking in that STUDENT already had some sounds at the time the IEP was developed. Dr. Blancher asserted that the "doors to speaking and having verbal communication" were closed by the IEP. She testified that the most important skill to enable success for a child with autism is communication.
On March 5, 1996, Dr. Blancher observed STUDENT at home. She described the following as his strengths: spontaneous speech; social skills; the ability to make eye contact and be engaging; and a developing sense of humor. She also noted that STUDENT was having a "great time" in the home program. Dr. Blancher testified that STUDENT's home program appeared appropriate and effective. She attributed the growth STUDENT has achieved since March of 1995, when the District assessed him, to what he has been doing since then, namely, the in-home program. Dr. Blancher testified that, if STUDENT had attended the Wiggin program, it is extremely unlikely that he would have made the same gains. There is no data to support that the type of program offered at Wiggin allows children with autism to make progress. She also asserted that the District expressed low expectations for STUDENT.
On March 5, 1996, Dr. Blancher also observed the Wiggin program for approximately two and one-half hours and spoke with Ms. Glynn and Ms. Evans, which she testified provided her with sufficient information to evaluate the appropriateness of the program for STUDENT. Dr. Blancher concluded that the Wiggin program is not appropriate for STUDENT. First, the philosophical basis of Ms. Evans program is not appropriate for STUDENT. Dr. Blancher testified that Ms. Evans' program appears to be an eclectic approach to teaching based roughly on the District's document entitled SEEC Curriculum Handbook (District's Exhibit 18). Dr. Blancher testified that the eclectic approach fails to recognize the differences between children with autism and children with other disabilities. Dr. Blancher also expressed concern because none of the students in Ms. Evans' class appeared happy and Ms. Evans neither smiled nor had eye contact with the students. Dr. Blancher testified that the adults did not employ any pattern of reinforcement of the students' appropriate behavior and responses. She noted that one teacher continued an activity with a child although the child was crying, whining, and was not paying attention. She also did not see any data being maintained on the students' achievements. On cross-examination, Dr. Blancher stated that the pull-out program has potential for some autistic children but not for STUDENT.
Dr. Blancher testified that there is substantial documentation that STUDENT has trouble with transitions. She testified that the students are required to move from one area to another for different services and then back to class and that they have to go a great distance to Ms. Evans' program. Dr. Blancher stated that even she had trouble with the transitions. Dr. Blancher testified that the SDC would not provide opportunities for STUDENT to learn language and social skills. The students have to pick up cues on their own, whereas, STUDENT requires step-by-step instruction. Dr. Blancher testified that there was not enough interaction between the regular education students and the students with disabilities. There also was not enough interaction between the classroom technicians (aides) and the students. Dr. Blancher stated that the technicians did not intervene when a student in the class engaged in maladaptive behaviors.
Tristam Smith, Ph.D., assistant professor at the University of Washington, was called by Petitioner to rebut the District's testimony regarding STUDENT's educational needs. For 10 years, Dr. Smith worked with children with autism at Dr. Lovaas' clinic at UCLA. Dr. Smith met and worked with STUDENT, saw an earlier video of STUDENT, spoke with two of his therapists, and reviewed the evidence presented for the hearing. Dr. Smith testified that STUDENT has mastered many skills. For example, he can label objects and can identify pairs and opposites. He is learning pronouns. Dr. Smith testified that STUDENT used spontaneous language. STUDENT is currently working on learning to speak in sentences. He still has difficulty with pretend play.
Dr. Smith testified that there are three important components of autism: limited language, communication, and social use of language; deficits in social development; and insistence on sameness, ritualistic and repetitive behavior, and vehement reaction to being intruded upon or having ritualistic behavior interrupted. Dr. Smith testified that, without treatment, autism is a lifelong problem. Dr. Smith testified that children with autism do not have the social, language, and other developmental skills that most students of the same age have when they are old enough to enter school. Dr. Smith testified that preschool-aged children with autism specifically lack the skills to benefit from group instruction or peer models. Dr. Smith testified that young children with autism usually need one-to-one instruction to learn appropriate skills that will be necessary for group instruction.
Dr. Smith disagreed with the appropriateness of the IEP drafted in July 1995 for STUDENT. Dr. Smith testified that the IEP goals and objectives are not precise enough to allow the instructor to know what to provide for STUDENT. Dr. Smith testified that behavioral interventions are not included in STUDENT's IEP. Dr. Smith also testified that the instructional methods proposed by the District have not been scientifically validated and depart from research findings regarding successful instructional methods for children with autism. Dr. Smith testified that the time and setting offered by the District were also not appropriate to meet STUDENT's needs. No one-to-one instruction was offered in July 1995 and the subsequent offer in October 1995 of one-to-one instruction was insufficient. Dr. Smith also testified that home is the better setting in which to instruct a child of STUDENT's developmental level. Dr. Smith also testified that, if STUDENT were placed in a class of students with disabilities for the purpose of having peers from whom to model appropriate behavior, he would model their inappropriate behavior. Dr. Smith testified that when STUDENT is ready to be placed in a group situation, the appropriate peers are regular education students.
In response to the testimony of District witnesses that the appropriate placement for STUDENT is in a preschool program rather than in a home program, Dr. Smith testified that one-to-one programs for young children with autism are usually delivered in the home because the child's home is a more natural environment. He stated that children with autism are generally delayed in their overall development. For example, a three-year-old child with autism is likely to be developmentally at the level of a one-year-old child. Dr. Smith pointed out that, in STUDENT's case, assessments in 1995 found him to be functioning at a two-year old level or below. Therefore, home would have constituted a normal environment for him. Dr. Smith found it "odd" that the home setting would be described by a school district as "contrived." Dr. Smith also testified that young children generally learn certain skills in a developmental sequence. Dr. Smith testified that STUDENT's in-home, one-to-one program is designed to duplicate the sequence of typically developing students so that he will attain the necessary skills to enter school.
Regarding the intensity of the program offered by the District, Dr. Smith discussed several studies in which he has been involved regarding the success of various programs for children with autism. Dr. Smith testified that one study found that students receiving an intensive program showed more gains in all areas--IQ, language development, visual skills, and behavior--than those who did not receive an intensive program. In a later follow-up study, it was found that the students who had received an intensive program were functioning in less restrictive settings than those who had received a less intensive program. Another study came up with similar findings. Dr. Smith testified that STUDENT's program should have begun immediately after the IEP was drafted. He stated that children with autism, including STUDENT, require extended school year programs or they will lose the skills they have been taught and will revert to maladaptive behavior. Dr. Smith concurred with Dr. Siegel that it is important to provide intense early intervention services to a child with autism because there is a window of opportunity in which to alter the child's prognosis.
Dr. Smith disagreed with some of the instructional techniques contained within the District's curriculum manual. In particular, the manual espouses that the communication skills of children with autism will be enhanced by the teacher talking to the child and providing an on-going description to the child of his/her activities. Dr. Smith stated that the child with autism has heard many words from his parents; however, the child has not independently developed language. Dr. Smith also disputed the efficacy of using sensory integration therapy with children with autism. He testified that at least one study has found that sensory intervention therapy may be harmful by inadvertently rewarding inappropriate behavior.
Dr. Smith recommended that STUDENT be provided a 40 hour per week, intensive, one-to-one program home-based program. He based his recommendations on the following: the empirical data that, with less than a 40 hour program, the children with autism do not make meaningful changes; when a child with autism is not in a teaching situation, the child will not learn (For example, the child will engage in ritualistic behavior); the child with autism has to be taught nearly every skill; and it takes a great deal of time to teach all of the skills that a preschool child needs to be able to learn.
Respondent's Witnesses
Lauriel Adsit, adaptive physical education teacher, was part of the District's assessment team. Ms. Adsit testified that, during the assessment, STUDENT was not very socially interactive and had minimal eye contact; however, he was not entirely resistive to interacting with team members. When STUDENT did not want to participate, he laid down on the floor and played with a car. Ms. Adsit testified that she discussed the results of the assessment at the IEP meeting and drafted APE goals and objectives with the parent. She stated that the amount of APE listed on STUDENT's IEP was a minimum and that Mr. Jagoda's class actually receives twice that amount.
Ms. Adsit testified that Mr. Jagoda's class has APE for one-half hour beginning at 9:30 a.m. His afternoon group has APE beginning at 12:30 p.m. The entire class comes to APE, which is located in the auditorium. There usually are eight children and four adults. The students sit on a carpeted area and do basic warm-up activities that include a song and motor imitation using a big ball. The students then rotate for 15 minutes to stations set up around the room for climbing, jumping, and balancing activities. An adult is assigned to each station and describes orally what the students are to do. Ms. Adsit testified that the goal is for the students to independently participate in the activities. The students then go back to the carpeted area and get a stamp on their hands. Ms. Adsit testified that she pairs the mainstream students with the special education students and they serve as models for the special education students. Ms. Adsit testified that she meets weekly with the classroom teacher and speech and language therapist to coordinate the services and to ensure that they are implementing a consistent behavior management program.
Sally Weisman, SEEC psychologist, was part of the District's team that assessed STUDENT. She testified that the team's findings were consistent with prior assessments of STUDENT; however, she expressed surprise that during the District's assessment of STUDENT, he demonstrated some communicative intent and imitative skills. Ms. Weisman stated that STUDENT threw a ball back and forth and exchanged sunglasses with a team member. He also followed a few simple commands. She observed STUDENT engaging in some ritualistic behavior. Ms. Weisman testified that STUDENT requires intensive special education services to develop language, social, cognitive, and fine-motor skills. According to Ms. Weisman, the members of the IEP team agreed to the areas of need that should be targeted in STUDENT's educational program. She stated that goals and objectives drafted by MOTHER formed the basis for goals and objectives developed by the IEP team.
Ms. Weisman testified that the parents did not sign the IEP; however, she was under the impression that the IEP team was going to meet again to further discuss STUDENT's self-stimulatory behavior and his placement. Ms. Weisman testified that prior to developing a behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT, it would be necessary to conduct a functional analysis of his behavior to determine what motivates the behavior and how to effectively reduce or modify the behavior to make it more acceptable.
Julie Adams, speech and language pathologist at Wiggin, holds an M.A. in speech and language pathology and several licenses. Ms. Adams participated in STUDENT's assessment in July 1995. Ms. Adams testified that, because she could not administer any formal assessment measures to STUDENT, her assessment was based on observations of him over a two-hour period. Ms. Adams testified that STUDENT established eye contact with her only briefly; however, he responded to her in other ways. For example, he turned around to look at her when she chased him; he engaged in turn-taking with a basketball; and he giggled when tickled. STUDENT also responded to some "well rehearsed" directions that he had worked on at home.
Ms. Adams testified that all aspects of STUDENT's communication skills were significantly delayed and he was functioning below the 12-month level. Ms. Adams described STUDENT as "pre-verbal." Ms. Adams anticipated that she would provide STUDENT with individual speech and language therapy sessions on Tuesdays and Thursdays from 1:00 p.m. to 1:30 p.m. beginning the day after Labor Day in September. On cross-examination, Ms. Adams testified that she does not provide services to students in either Mr. Jagoda's or Ms. Evans' classes. Ms. Adams testified that she did not contact the parents to offer speech and language services when STUDENT did not attend Wiggin because she understood that the parents had not given their consent to implement any components of the IEP. As far as Ms. Adams knew, the parents have never requested speech and language services for STUDENT.
Ms. Adams testified regarding the way in which speech and language goals and objectives could be addressed. To help STUDENT improve following verbal directions, Ms. Adams testified that she would consult with STUDENT's teacher to ensure that the same vocabulary and gestures were being used by all of the staff. She would also consider developing a set of pictures to use with STUDENT so that he could make choices. Photographs could also be used to represent activities to help STUDENT transition from one to another. She would also teach him active vocabulary words. To improve STUDENT's social communication skills, Ms. Adams testified that she would first work to get STUDENT's attention and then would engage him with peers in activities of interest to him.
Ms. Adams testified that in the five years she has been at Wiggin, she has seen students move in one year's time from pre-verbal to verbal. Ms. Adams stated that one-to-one instruction is an important part of the program but that she also supports the need for students to have opportunities for peer interactions. She testified that one-to-one instruction allows the student to learn play and imitative skills, which are directed toward functional use of the skills in the child's environment.
Elise Douglas, occupational therapist, was also part of the District's assessment team. Ms. Douglas testified that STUDENT was able to sit for approximately two minutes; however, if trucks were any where in his visual field, STUDENT would focus his attention to them rather than her. Ms. Douglas stated that STUDENT had difficulty transitioning to different tasks. The only self-stimulatory behavior she observed was STUDENT lying on the floor rolling a truck or "looking out the side of his eye." Ms. Douglas recommended that STUDENT participate in one to two, one-half hour sessions of OT weekly. She stated that STUDENT's attention skills would not then have allowed for longer OT sessions. Ms. Douglas reviewed her recommendations as recorded on the report of her assessment. She stated that "STUDENT needs a firm, structured routine with consistency within the classroom as well as with other disciplines. Work area and stimuli should be limited to decrease distractions." (Petitioner's Exhibit 14) She stated, for example, that STUDENT should have only a few crayons and one sheet of paper if he is working at a table and that the environment should be free of distractions in his visual field.
Ms. Douglas recommended that STUDENT's program include brushing of STUDENT's skin and joint compression. She stated that these techniques help students to attend and to diminish tactile defensiveness. She also recommended that STUDENT receive sensory integration therapy to assist him deal with his environment. Ms. Douglas testified that at the IEP meeting, the only areas of agreement between District IEP members and MOTHER were the findings of the OT portion of the assessment, OT goals and objectives, and the frequency of OT. Ms. Douglas stated that MOTHER was ready to consent to OT services but that she was advised not to by STUDENT's godfather.
Adriana L. Schuler, professor of special education at San Francisco State University, holds an M.A. in speech and hearing sciences and a doctorate in neurolinguistics. Since 1982, Dr. Schuler has taught graduate-level courses in special education. Dr. Schuler has not met STUDENT and made it clear that she was not making specific recommendations for him. Dr. Schuler testified that she has experience teaching the discrete trial training format and developed a manual for teachers regarding use of the technique. Dr. Schuler testified that she observed that the students participating in discrete trial training exhibited very stereotypical behavior and were unable to respond in absence of prompts. Dr. Schuler then became interested in developing a more comprehensive educational program for people with autism. In the 1980's, she developed curriculum for language development in more naturalistic environments. In the 1990's, Dr. Schuler has focused on the need for children with autism to develop social skills. She currently recommends supported play groups.
Dr. Schuler testified that current treatment for students with autism has moved from highly structured intense programs to an emphasis on developmentally appropriate programs that incorporate the use of language for social purposes. Dr. Schuler testified that the problem with discrete trial training is that students have difficulty generalizing what they have learned to other environments. She also not believe that language or play skills can be taught through discrete trial training. She did acknowledge that, for some children with autism, discrete trial training helps them to become observant of their environment. Dr. Schuler stated that Dr. Lovaas' original studies, which support the use of the discrete trial format, did not include preschool-aged children. On cross-examination, Dr. Schuler testified that Dr. Lovaas includes in his current treatment formula the child's participation, with the assistance of a shadow aide, in a preschool program with typically developing children. Dr. Schuler discussed an article by Geraldine Dawson that reviewed programs that have been successful with children with autism. Dr. Schuler testified that the critical ingredient of successful programs is the intensity of the program. Additional components of successful programs include the following: making the child focus; home involvement; emphasis on socialization and language that may include gestures and signing; and supported interactions with more competent peers. Dr. Schuler testified that treatment studies have found that a minimum program is between 20 to 25 hours per week.
Dr. Schuler observed Ms. Evans' program at Wiggin. Dr. Schuler was impressed with Ms. Evans' thorough understanding of early childhood development as well as her use of the discrete trial format in conjunction with a more naturalistic environment. Dr. Schuler described Ms. Evans' program as an "open-minded effort to use the best practices as expressed in the literature."
Lorna Jean King, occupational therapist, is the director of the Center for Neurodevelopmental Studies in Arizona, which is a certified nonpublic school for students with autism. Ms. King began her work as an occupational therapist in a Veteran's Hospital in 1947. Since that time she has been a consultant to numerous universities throughout the country and has written a number of papers regarding autism and the use of sensory integration as an effective approach with children with autism. Ms. King testified that the following elements are important in programs for children with autism: strong appropriate developmental components; a strong communication program; a program to enhance concept formation; appropriate help to enable the child to gain control of his/her reactions and emotional responses; opportunities to learn social behaviors; positive means to deal with students; and choices for the students. Ms. King also stated that a good program requires adequate staffing, positive interactions between the staff and students, and lots of communication. Ms. King testified that brushing and joint compression are widely used programs for students with autism. Ms. King testified that deep pressure brushing is calming. Joint compression provides internal input to the tendons and enhances awareness of the body for motor planning.
Ms. King observed at Wiggin for an entire morning. She testified that students had access to a large variety of gross-motor activities on the playground and that there was good equipment for sensory integration and gross-motor activities. Ms. King found Ms. Evans to be pleasant and stated that the children were smiling and actively participating in her program. Ms. King described Mr. Jagoda as a "good role model" and stated that the children responded well to him. Ms. King observed a music activity in Mr. Jagoda's class, which she stated was a good activity for children with autism. Regarding the "T" stool used in Mr. Jagoda's class, Ms, King testified the purpose of the stool is to increase vestibular input and balance, which helps the student to concentrate, be alert, and organized.On cross-examination, Ms. King testified that early intervention is important for children with autism; however, the children also need time to "be children" and to have "normal" time at home to do as they please. Ms. King noted that most preschool-aged children with autism are not "group oriented." She also testified that it is important to keep parents involved in their child's program; however, parents should not be expected to be teachers or therapists. Ms. King testified that it is important to know the child before defining an appropriate program for him.
Mary Sue Glynn, special education school administrator, holds an M.A. in special education, as well as several credentials. She oversees the infant, preschool, and kindergarten special education programs. Ms. Glynn testified that the District's curriculum manual (Respondent's Exhibit 18) discusses the District's approach to enhance the development of the whole child. She described the District's approach as "eclectic" in that it is a play-based, developmental approach that borrows strategies and methods from many programs. Ms. Glynn stated that the book addresses the autistic child's need for different approaches to learning. Included in the approaches employed by the District pre-school program is TEEACH, which is a systematic approach to meeting students' needs. For example, students are taught to always work from left to right; they are always made aware of when activities start and stop; and they are provided an individual picture schedule. Ms. Glynn testified that Ms. Evans' program is also based on the fact that autistic children tend to be more visual than auditory and have a strong interest in videos. The videos in Ms. Evans' program were developed by the speech and language therapist and Ms. Evans based on the use of videos at the University of California, San Diego.
Ms. Glynn testified that Phil Strain, who conducted research regarding children with disabilities, concluded that students make better gains when they are placed with their typically developing peers. Ms. Glynn testified that, based on this information, the reverse mainstreaming component was implemented at Wiggin. She also stated that the interactions between the regular and special education students need to be planned and directed. She testified that the regular education students have been taught how to deal with students who do not respond to them. Ms. Glynn testified that the staff at Wiggin has had extensive training in the use of the techniques employed in the classes. Ms. Glynn testified that she is in Mr. Jagoda's class monthly and in Ms. Evans' class weekly. She has observed the students interacting in Mr. Jagoda's class. Ms. Glynn testified, for example, that during snack time Mr. Jagoda has the students request what they want to drink.
Ms. Glynn testified that, if MOTHER had elected to place STUDENT in the District's program, the one-to-one program would have been in place for him. She testified that the SDC has a transdisciplinary team of certified teachers and licensed therapists who have a wealth of knowledge, experience, and skills related to teaching students with disabilities. They employ a variety of strategies to meet the students' needs and are able to recognize the "teachable" moments. Ms. Glynn testified that the Wiggin program has been successful with some students. One student who had no language when he entered the program now participates unassisted in a Head Start preschool program. Other students with the diagnosis of autism have been placed in regular education programs.
Richard Jagoda, SEEC SDC teacher, holds an M.A. in special education and several special education teaching credentials. Mr. Jagoda testified that, as of September 1995, his morning class consisted of five special education students and three reverse mainstreaming students. All of the students were three, four, or five years old. Of the special education students, two have Down's syndrome, one has autistic-like characteristics, one is autistic, and one is developmentally delayed. There were three reverse mainstreaming students in Mr. Jagoda's afternoon class. None of the reverse mainstreaming students have developmental delays. Mr. Jagoda testified that the primary purpose for their participation in the class is to engage the special education students in activities and to "pair up" with them. Mr. Jagoda was assisted by two special education technicians and one foster grandparent. At the time of the hearing, there were nine students in the morning session. One special education student was added after the beginning of the school year. In June 1996, the afternoon session had four special education students and two mainstreaming students. From 10:00 a.m. to noon, there were fifteen students in the class. None of the students spent the entire day in the class. Mr. Jagoda testified that none of the students in his class have participated in Ms. Evans' pull-out program. Mr. Jagoda testified that Wiggin will not be a special education school site during the 1996-1997 school year. He testified that all of his students will continue in special education with a "great deal" of mainstreaming.
Mr. Jagoda described the classroom schedule in September 1995. The students arrived at 8:30 a.m. From 8:30 a.m. until 8:45 a.m., the students used the bathroom and practiced self-help skills. OT began at 8:50 a.m. and last for 25 minutes. OT activities started with the students putting on their t-shirts to practice self-help skills and doing warm-up exercises with several different body parts. Mr. Jagoda testified that he gave instructions regarding activities both verbally and by pictures. The students participated in six different warm-up songs. The students then selected activities at different locations in the room that had already been set up by the teacher. At approximately 9:30 a.m., the students transitioned to a circle on the floor and from the circle to APE in the auditorium. APE lasted until 10:00 a.m. Each child was then called to the door by the teacher and paired with a regular education student to go to the bathroom and then to the play yard for large-motor activities. At 10:40 a.m., the students transitioned back to the circle for songs, finger plays, name and picture-board activities, stories, and sorting and classifying activities. At 11:00 a.m., the students transitioned from circle to the lunch tables. At 11:30 a.m., the students carried their lunch remains to the garbage, returned to their lunch tables, and were paired with regular education students to walk to the bathrooms to brush their teeth and engage in other self-help activities. At 11:40 a.m., the students were paired for circle time. During circle, students received stickers and small candy gummi bears. A second OT session occurred at noon and, at 12:30, another session of APE. The above schedule applied to Mondays and Fridays.
On Tuesdays and Thursdays, the students selected optional activities that lasted from 8:50 a.m. to 9:20 a.m. Mr. Jagoda testified that there were activities for all developmental levels. From 9:20 a.m. until 9:35 a.m., the students had snack time. Mr. Jagoda testified that the students were provided with an opportunity to ask for a food or drink item that was commensurate with their communication levels. For example, the Down's syndrome child use a communication board or signed, the autistic and the mainstream students used verbal communication. The autistic-like student used an augmentative system. The speech therapist led an activity with students from 10:10 a.m. to 10:40 a.m. Mr. Jagoda testified that there is no school for students on Wednesdays to allow the teachers to make home visits.
Mr. Jagoda testified regarding the program proposed for STUDENT. On Mondays, STUDENT would have been accompanied to class from 8:30 a.m. until 10:00 a.m. by a shadow aide. Mr. Jagoda explained that a shadow aide is a person that helps the student engage in activities and with other students. From 10:00 am until 11:30 a.m., STUDENT would have been in Ms. Evans' program. From 11:40 a.m. until 1:00 p.m., STUDENT would have been in class with the shadow aide and would have participated in OT. From 1:00 p.m. until dismissal, STUDENT would have been with the speech facilitator who conducted group activities with the students in the class. On Tuesdays, STUDENT would have been with Ms. Evans from 10:10 a.m. until 11:40 a.m. On Thursdays, STUDENT would have received OT beginning at 8:50 a.m. and then would have had snack time with the rest of his class. At 10:00 a.m., STUDENT would have then transitioned to Ms. Evans' class and back to his class with the shadow aide for speech.
Mr. Jagoda testified regarding the ways in which he would have implemented STUDENT's goals and objectives in his class. Mr. Jagoda noted that he had not participated in the IEP meeting at which they were drafted nor has he met STUDENT. Mr. Jagoda testified that, even if STUDENT's skills were higher than when the goals and objectives were developed, they could be addressed by the variety of activities provided in his class because the activities are suited to the developmental levels of the students. Mr. Jagoda testified that in September, November, as well as at the time of the hearing, there were students in his class with goals and objectives similar to STUDENT's goals and objectives. Mr. Jagoda testified that IEPs are reviewed annually and he did not think it would have been necessary to hold a new IEP when STUDENT entered his class.
Mary Lou Evans is an itinerant resource teacher for SEEC. She holds an M.A. in special education and regular and special education teaching credentials. She provides a pull-out program for students with autism at Wiggin and is a resource to other teachers. Ms. Evans testified that there are ten stations in her room, which are partitioned off from one another. The areas are also clearly identified with a number and the activity that takes place in the area. The areas are: patterning; stacking and chaining; water table; pre-literacy; building; pretend play/housekeeping; gross motor; group; fine motor/art; and games/lunch. In the room there also are two small carpeted areas and a quiet corner with bean bag chairs. Ms. Evans testified that record-keeping is done daily. The class uses monthly themes in conjunction with the SDC and the other services. Ms. Evans testified that she employs an "eclectic" approach that includes a variety of strategies. Some activities are directed by the teacher and others are not. She also uses discrete trial format, positive behavioral management techniques, TEEACH philosophies, and the natural language paradigm. Ms. Evans initially testified that she began working with the students in her class on October 23, 1995. During cross-examination, she confirmed with notes that the first day she worked directly with students was on November 1, 1995. Ms. Evans testified that, at that time, there was one child in her class from 10:10 until noon on Tuesdays. There were two adults. On Thursdays and Fridays, there was also one child and two adults in the class.
According to the schedule prepared for STUDENT, he would have worked with Ms. Evans for 95 minutes on Mondays, 110 minutes on Tuesdays, 65 minutes on Thursdays, and 95 minutes on Fridays. Ms. Evans testified regarding STUDENT's schedule, had he been in her class. Beginning at 10 a.m., the occupational therapist would have supervised brushing, joint compression, and other OT activities. STUDENT would then have participated in social games to work on non-verbal imitating skills. Next, STUDENT would have selected an activity; participated in structured and language activities and then expressive language drills; participated in fine-motor activities and oral-motor work; and then would have had lunch in the classroom, followed by toileting.
Ms. Evans testified regarding the ways in which she would have implemented STUDENT's IEP goals and objectives. She stated that she would first have needed to work with STUDENT to see whether he was able to transition to different areas in her room. If not, Ms. Evans indicated that she would have worked with STUDENT in one area until he learned to transition. Ms. Evans testified that she would have worked with scissor skills in the fine motor corner to develop STUDENT's fine-motor skills; she would have worked on the second objective during lunch; and she would have worked with STUDENT to copy block designs in the building area. To teach STUDENT to imitate, Ms. Evans stated that she would have imitated STUDENT's actions and then expand on what he was doing. She would also have told him to "do this." If STUDENT did not follow her instructions, Ms. Evans testified that she would have physically prompted him. Ms. Evans testified that to meet gross-motor objectives, she would have worked with STUDENT with a ball; to improve tracking, she would have had him pop bubbles and ride a tricycle between classes. Ms. Evans testified that the objective related to following commands would have been constantly met by reinforcing STUDENT when he followed her directions. To increase STUDENT's language skills, she would have asked STUDENT to tell her what he wanted for lunch and what he wanted to play with. To gain STUDENT's attention, Ms. Evans testified that she could have turned him to face her and call his name. If he did not respond, she could gently turn his head. To increase STUDENT's social skills, she would have asked a reverse mainstreaming student to join her class to participate in an activity with STUDENT. Basically, Ms. Evans testified that she could have addressed all of STUDENT's goals and objectives in her program.
Janet Hartley Muniz, occupational therapist, testified that children with autism have difficulty with sensory processing and most have defenses to sensory input. For these reasons, they are treated with brushing and deep joint compression to calm the state of the nervous system and to make them more receptive for learning. Ms. Muniz testified that children with autism also have difficulty with motor planning and benefit from sensory-motor activities of increasing difficulty such as obstacle courses. Some students with autism also have fine-motor and oral-motor deficits. Ms. Muniz has not met STUDENT. She testified that she would have been available to provide direct OT to STUDENT from 11:30 a.m. to noon on Mondays and 9:00 a.m. to 9:30 a.m. on Thursdays. Ms. Muniz testified that she maintains daily therapy notes for each individual OT session. To meet STUDENT's objective regarding scooping food, she would have provided the appropriate equipment for him to use at lunch and would have demonstrated its use to the teacher and other classroom staff. To meet STUDENT's objective regarding block designs, she testified that they would practice with cards and models and do "copy me" games. Regarding STUDENT's objective to open containers, Ms. Muniz testified that she would focus on motor planning and development of the muscles need for the task. For example, she would use playdough to roll and cut.
Ms. Muniz testified that on Mondays from 9:00 a.m. to 9:30 a.m., the students participate in OT activities in Mr. Jagoda's class. The students are brushed first. They then put on pants and shirts for APE and are seated on T-shaped stools for finger plays and other activities. Mr. Jagoda then describes the morning's activities and the students self-select their first activity, which has been set up at a table or other area in the classroom. For example, one day the activities included chalk drawings, putting items into a slot cut into a can; cutting; and playdough. Ms. Muniz collaborates with the teacher and aides regarding appropriate activities and how to correct the activities for the students in the class. She also does some one-to-one activities with the students, if she is present.
Bruce Dake, Ed.D., is a psychologist with the District. He coordinated a state-wide study on behavioral interventions and sits on a State Department of Education team to look at quality programming for students with autism. Dr. Dake testified that the best current practices for working with preschool-aged students with autism include highly structured programs that emphasize pragmatic communication and has appropriate role models, including non-disabled peers. Dr. Dake testified that it is also important that the child build skills through a variety of structured and unstructured environments, including a play-based setting.
Dr. Dake observed Ms. Evans' program at Wiggin. Dr. Dake was impressed by the program's structure, the ease with which the staff delivered the services, and the fact that play and language were infused in the activities. Dr. Dake testified that for preschool-aged children, the preschool and home environments are the most natural environments. Dr. Dake expressed concern that a 40-hour program is too intensive for a preschool child.
Hector Martinez, parent, testified that his son has achieved great progress, which he attributed in part to his participation in Mr. Jagoda's class at Wiggin. Mr. Martinez's son participated at Wiggin for four hours daily and then his program was replicated at home by his parents. He also received daily speech and language therapy, which was also provided for by the parent. Mr. Martinez testified that the Wiggin program made is son "aware of things" for the first time. Mr. Martinez's son has Landau-Kleffner Syndrome, which he stated includes autistic conditions.(Footnote 6)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Do the goals and objectives contained in STUDENT's individualized education program (IEP) dated July 13, 1995, comply with the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and provide STUDENT with an appropriate educational program?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.
To be appropriate, the student's IEP must include, among other things, the following: present levels of the student's educational performance; annual goals and short-term instructional objectives; specific special education instruction and related services required by the student; the extent to which the student will participate in regular education; the projected date for initiation and duration of special education programs and services; a statement of transition services for students beginning no later than age 16; and objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining, at least annually, whether objectives are achieved. Education Code § 56345(a) Goals describe what a student can reasonable be expected to accomplish within a year's period and objectives are measurable, intermediate steps toward meeting the goals. 34 C.F.R. 300.346, Appendix C, Questions 37, 38, and 39.
Petitioner contends that the IEP developed in July 1995 does not meet his needs and is not designed to provide him with educational benefit. He asserts that the goals and objectives are deficient for the following reasons: they do not address all identified areas of need; they are generalized rather than specific to his needs; they were drafted to meet an existing program rather than to meet his needs; and they express the District's low expectations for him. The District contends that the goals and objectives were based on goals and objectives recommended and approved by the parent, and focus on STUDENT's primary areas of need.
In order to determine what goals and objectives should have been included in STUDENT's IEP developed in July 1995, it is first necessary to understand what his needs were at that time. In the months immediately prior to the drafting of the goals and objectives, several assessments of STUDENT were completed. The assessments by Dr. Granpeesheh, Children's Hospital, and the District similarly found that STUDENT's social and language skills were significantly delayed and that he exhibited delays in sensory-motor integration and fine-motor skills.
All of the witnesses with expertise in autism testified that it is necessary to have the child's attention before he/she is able to learn. District witnesses, including Ms. Adsit and Ms Adams who participated in STUDENT's assessment, described STUDENT's eye contact as "brief" or "minimal," and noted that STUDENT had a short attention span. Assessments by Dr. Granpeesheh and Children's Hospital also noted STUDENT's limited eye contact and short attention span.
MOTHER and Dr. Granpeesheh, as well as members of the District's assessment team, testified that STUDENT engaged in some self-stimulatory and ritualistic behavior. MOTHER testified that STUDENT also exhibited self-injurious behavior, including banging his head, tantrumming, and running away. Dr. Smith testified that STUDENT requires instruction and services to address the behaviors that are interfering with STUDENT's ability to learn. Regional Center reports and the report from Children's Hospital document the need to address STUDENT's maladaptive behaviors as well. There also was credible testimony that when a student is engaged in self-stimulatory behavior, the student is not learning. Several of the District assessors noted this in their testimony as well. For example, they recounted how they were able to engage STUDENT for brief periods of time during the assessment but they were not able to gain his attention when he was engaged in ritualistic behavior with a truck or when he was rolling his eyes while on the floor. Based on STUDENT's identified needs and the significant relationship between attending and the need to reduce self-stimulatory behaviors to learning, the Hearing Officer finds that, to be appropriate, STUDENT's IEP must address these areas.
STUDENT's IEP describes his educational needs as follows: to improve his ability to communicate wants and needs; to improve his ability to interact with adults and other children; to improve his ability to follow verbal directions; to improve his self-help skills; to improve fine- and gross-motor skills; and to improve his ability to attend and complete tasks; and reduce self-stimulatory behavior. (Petitioner's Exhibit 17) Based on the needs identified by the IEP team, which are supported by the results of assessments and testimony at the hearing, the Hearing Officer concludes that an appropriate IEP for STUDENT includes goals and objectives to address deficits in language, social skills, fine- and gross-motor skills, self-help, and attending. STUDENT's IEP also must include goals and objectives to address reducing self-stimulatory and other inappropriate behavior.
The goals and objectives developed on July 13, 1995, address development of STUDENT's social and communication skills; school readiness skills; and motor skills; however, the goals and objectives do not address attending, completing tasks, or self-help skills. Nowhere in the goals or objectives is there any mention of reducing STUDENT's self-stimulatory behavior or any other maladaptive behavior. Ms. Weisman, the school psychologist, testified that it was her impression that the IEP team would meet again to discuss STUDENT's self-stimulatory behavior because of the need to conduct a functional behavioral analysis; however, the IEP team did not reconvene and there is no mention in the IEP of a functional analysis. Therefore, because the IEP does not include goals and objectives to improve attending, completing tasks, and self-help skills, and also does not include any goals and objectives regarding STUDENT's self-stimulatory behavior, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's IEP dated July 13, 1995, does not address all of his needs and, therefore, is not appropriate according to the standards set forth in Rowley and the IDEA.
ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District offer an appropriate educational program to STUDENT at the IEP meeting on July 13, 1995?
An appropriate placement must be designed to meet a student's unique and individual needs pursuant to the standard set forth in Rowley. Petitioner contends that the program proposed by the District in July 1995 was based on what was already available at the school rather than on his unique and individual needs. Petitioner contends that to meet his needs as a preschool child with autism in July 1995, when the IEP was developed, he required a one-to-one, home-based, behavioral program utilizing discrete task analysis. Petitioner asserts that the program needed to be delivered 40 hours per week for fifty weeks of the year. Petitioner asserts that an appropriate program also included two hours per week of program supervision from a supervising therapist, two hours per month of parent training, program supervision from a program director, and two hours per week of one-to-one OT.
The District contends that it offered Petitioner a program that was designed to meet his unique and individual needs. The program proposed by the District for STUDENT on July 13, 1995, included the following: One hour per week of language, speech, and hearing services; one-half hour per weak of APE; one to two half-hour sessions per week of OT; four to five home contacts annually; and ESY services. In July 1995, the District offered to place STUDENT in a SEEC special day class four days per week for a total of 12 hours with participation in regular education programs for 0 to 39%. All services were to begin in September.(Footnote 7)
The first issue raised by STUDENT's parents is whether, in July 1995, STUDENT required significant one-to-one instruction to benefit from his education. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that children with autism have difficulty focusing and do not know on which stimuli to focus. As discussed above in Issue No. 1, the evidence established that STUDENT had limited eye contact and a short attention span. All of the persons who have observed or worked with STUDENT, other than the District personnel who assessed STUDENT, concluded that STUDENT has benefitted from one-to-one instruction and recommended, without reservation, that he should continue to participate in his one-to-one program. None of the District's witnesses testified that STUDENT does not require one-to-one instruction and the District apparently no longer disputes STUDENT's need for one-to-one instruction. In October 1995, the District modified its original offer of placement to include one-to-one instruction and spent a great deal of time at the hearing discussing how STUDENT would receive individual instruction. The District's offer of placement in July 1995, however, did not specifically provide for STUDENT to receive one-to-one instruction. The IEP also does not indicate whether DIS therapy and OT would be delivered individually or in a group setting.
Dr. Smith testified that the nature of autism is that young children with autism cannot, without first learning the necessary skills, benefit from group instruction. Dr. Siegel described one study that found that students receiving group instruction actually lost ground. Ms. King, one of the District's witnesses, acknowledge that most preschool children are not "group oriented." Their understanding of the minimal, if any, benefit of group instruction for the young child with autism is consistent with the testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Granpeesheh, and Ms. Moore, one of STUDENT's therapists, regarding STUDENT's group-learning experiences. They testified that STUDENT did not benefit from placement in a parochial preschool program in early 1996, even though he had improved language and social skills and even with the assistance of an aide. In their closing argument, the District challenged whether a parochial preschool was taught by persons with the same expertise as District staff and whether the curriculum was appropriate for STUDENT; however, the District did not present any evidence regarding the parochial program and none of the District's witnesses observed STUDENT at the program. Moreover, MOTHER's based her testimony not only on STUDENT's experiences at the parochial preschool, but also on her attempts to have STUDENT interact with a group of children at a "mock" preschool set up at her home and STUDENT's earlier group experiences in the Children's Hospital program. Ms. Moore also had direct experience with STUDENT in a group preschool experience. Therefore, based on their testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that a group setting as proposed by the District for STUDENT in July 1995 was not appropriate to meet his unique and individual needs. Another issue raised by Petitioner is the length or intensity of the program offered by the District in July 1995. Many of the witnesses with expertise in autism discussed studies regarding the effectiveness of educational programs for children with autism. There were some common factors among the studies discussed by witnesses called by Petitioner, as well as witnesses called by the District. For example, all of the studies cited by the witnesses found that successful programs were intense and involved significant home involvement. They also include language and social skills components. (Testimony of Dr. Siegel, Dr. Smith, Dr. Schuler, and Ms. King) There was no agreement as to the amount of time per week that constitutes an intense program. Dr. Siegel testified that children in programs of 25 or more hours per week made statistically significant progress, children in programs between 30 to 40 hours per week made the most progress, and children in programs of 10 hours or less remained static.
Petitioner's parents have requested a program of 40 hours per week. Dr. Smith concurred with their recommendation, whereas other witnesses for Petitioner recommended 35 hours per week, which is approximately the number of hours of one-to-one instruction that he currently receives. Dr. Siegel recommended a 35 hour per week program for STUDENT because of the success he has achieved while participating in a program of this length. Based on STUDENT's achievement over the five-month period between Dr. Gregory's two assessments of STUDENT, Dr. Gregory recommended that STUDENT continue in his current program at the same rate. Other witnesses for Petitioner testified similarly.
Dr. Schuler, who testified on behalf of the District, defined an intensive program as being 20 to 25 hours per week. None of the other witnesses for the District specified the length of an appropriate program for autistic children in general or for STUDENT particularly except for Dr. Dake, who expressed the opinion that 40 hours was too intense for a preschool-aged child. Ms. King noted that children need to have time to themselves.
A great deal of testimony by the witnesses was regarding children with autism in general. This testimony provides some guidelines for developing a program for a preschool-aged child with autism. However, according to the testimony of the witnesses, there is no consensus in the literature regarding the amount of time that a school district must provide to meet the needs of children with autism. Moreover, decisions regarding educational programs must be based on the individual needs of the child. The only District witnesses who have met STUDENT are those who participated in his initial assessment. None of the District witnesses have ever observed STUDENT in his current program either in person or on videotape, whereas all of Petitioner's witnesses have had the opportunity to observe and interact with STUDENT. The Hearing Officer gives particular weight to the testimony of Dr. Siegel because she based her recommendations for a 35 hour per week program for STUDENT not only on studies in the field and her own experiences following many children with autism, but also on the particular needs of STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires a program of 35 hours per week to meet his unique and individual needs.
The entire program offered by the District to STUDENT in July 1995 was for 12 hours per week, which included APE, OT, and speech and language services. The Hearing Officer finds 12 hours per week so minimal that it would not meet STUDENT's many needs that have been identified by the assessors and with which the IEP team concurred. Moreover, 12 hours per week would not even fall within the recommendations of the District's own expert, Dr. Schuler. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the length of time the District offered to provide STUDENT with an educational program in July 1995 was not designed to meet his unique and individual needs.
The Hearing Officer notes that the State has adopted as one of the primary purposes of early intervention services for children from three years old to five years old reducing "the need for special class placement in special education programs once the children reach school age." Education Code § 56441(f). State special education law related to this age group also provides that services may be provided individually or in small groups and may delivered in a number of environments including the home, community, and regular preschool classes. Education Code § 56441.3-4.(Footnote 8) Several witnesses credibly testified that children with autism have a window of opportunity in which to make gains that will affect their ability to learn and function independently in life. That window of opportunity exists for preschool-aged children with autism and will not exist later. Moreover, the nature and extent of STUDENT's disability require that to meet his unique and individual needs, he required in July 1995 an intense program of specialized instruction to ameliorate his deficits that will allow for successful integration into school. For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's unique and individual needs can only be met by an intense, one-to-one program of 35 hours per week.
There are other aspects of the program that also would not have met STUDENT's needs. It was established above in Issue No. 1 that STUDENT required a behavioral intervention program. There was no evidence in the IEP of a behavioral intervention program designed specifically for STUDENT. There also was no evidence of a general behavioral intervention plan in the SDC. As discussed by the witnesses, successful programs for children with autism include home involvement. (Testimony of Dr. Siegel and the District's witnesses Dr. Schuler and Ms. King.) The program offered by the District in July 1995 included four to five home contacts annually. There was no credible evidence that four to five home contacts is sufficient to involve the parents in STUDENT's educational program. All of the students in Mr. Jagoda's class are entitled to home contacts and it is typical that regular education teachers evaluate their students and have parent contacts quarterly. The District's offer of only one additional contact cannot be construed as satisfying the need for significant home involvement in STUDENT's case.
Additional elements of the Wiggin program and Mr. Jagoda's class in particular would also not have been appropriate for STUDENT. First, Ms. Douglas, who was part of the District's assessment team, observed that STUDENT had difficulty making transitions. Other evidence supports Ms. Douglas' observation. The schedule proposed by the District (Respondent's Exhibit 26) includes a series of transitions from one classroom to another location at the school site, as well as a number of transitions within the classroom. The students go from the carpeted area of the class to the various stations set up within the class, from the activity areas to the carpeted area, from the carpeted area to APE, and so forth. Ms. Douglas and others also found STUDENT's attention span to be limited and recommended a relatively distraction free environment for STUDENT. Ms. Douglas stated that STUDENT's work area and stimuli should be limited to decrease the distractions. Based on the testimony of Ms. Douglas and other evidence regarding STUDENT's attention span and needs as a young child with autism, the Hearing Officer concludes that an appropriate placement for STUDENT must be relatively free of distraction.
Witnesses described Mr. Jagoda's class as "chaotic" and "overstimulating." Ms. Sparkman noted that there were many distracting items on the tables at which activities were set out for the students. No one testified that the stimulating environment or the numerous transitions required of students in Mr. Jagoda's class would be of benefit to STUDENT. The evidence establishes that at some times there were as many as 15 students and four adults in Mr. Jagoda's class. The sheer number of students potentially would have been distracting for STUDENT.
In summary, the program offered to STUDENT by the District in July 1995 was for only 12 hours per week, whereas STUDENT required a program of 35 hours per week to meet his needs. The program offered by the District in July 1995 was in a group setting and did not specify that STUDENT would receive one-to-one instruction. It was established that to benefit from his education, STUDENT needed one-to-one instruction. The District's proposed placement also did not include a sufficient home component. Moreover, the IEP developed in July 1995 was deficient in that it did not include goals and objectives to address all of STUDENT's unique and individual needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District's placement proposed for STUDENT in July 1995 was not appropriate.
ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District's proposed placement of STUDENT in the special day class (SDC) at Wiggin School in October 1995 offer him a free appropriate public education?
In a letter dated October 5, 1995, the Ms. Glynn set forth a proposal by the District to supplement its original offer of placement. The new proposal called for an increase in the daily program to five hours per day on Mondays, Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Fridays. The letter also indicated that an aide or teacher would be working one-to-one with STUDENT for three and one-half hours daily. A second letter further clarified that the District was proposing Mr. Jagoda's class and that one-to-one instruction would be provided by either Mr. Jagoda, an aide, or Ms. Evans. (Petitioner's Exhibit 21)
It was determined above in Issue No. 2 that the appropriate number of hours for STUDENT's program was 35 hours per week. For this reason, the increase in the time allotted by the District for STUDENT's program in October 1995 was not sufficient to meet his unique and individual needs. Moreover, according to Ms. Evans' testimony, the pull-put program was not available to students until November 1, 1995. Thus, even if the District were able to provide STUDENT with the newly promised one-to-one instruction, it would have been in Mr. Jagoda's class where STUDENT would have been subject to group instruction for a portion of the day. There also was no evidence that all of the other concerns regarding the program had been eliminated. The District did not offer any additional goals and objectives or any increase to the parent component of the program. The Hearing Officer concludes, therefore, that the mere increase in the program hours and a promise of one-to-one instruction did not make an otherwise inappropriate placement appropriate.
ISSUE NO. 4: Does an appropriate educational program for STUDENT include the following:
(A) Forty hours a week, fifty weeks a year, of a home-based, one-to-one instructional program using discrete task analysis.
In STUDENT's case, the evidence establishes that to meet his unique and individual needs and to allow him to benefit from his education, he requires an intense, one-to-one program. It was determined above that an appropriate program is 35 hours per week.
As to whether the program must be provided 50 weeks per year to meet STUDENT's needs, MOTHER testified that if STUDENT misses one week of instruction, he is likely to regress. Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT requires a year-round educational program. STUDENT's IEP indicates that he is eligible for services only during the regular and extended school year; however, the District did not through documentary evidence or testimony oppose the request for 50 weeks per year of services. That program is year round. Based on the discussion earlier regarding the need for an intense program, as well as credible testimony regarding the potential for STUDENT to regress and the need to take advantage of the limited window of opportunity for STUDENT to develop the appropriate skills he needs, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires a year round program and that breaks from his program shall not exceed one week.
The State recognizes the child's home as a potential environment in which to deliver services to the child. The Hearing Officer also found compelling Dr. Smith's testimony regarding home as an appropriate environment in which to provide STUDENT's services. As he discussed, STUDENT's developmental level in most areas is one to two years below his chronological age. There can be no disagreement that for children of his developmental level, home is a natural and appropriate environment. Moreover, his current successful program has been delivered in this environment.
As to the nature of the instruction STUDENT should be provided, STUDENT's current program is based on discrete task analysis, which has been delivered in the manner described by Ms. Moore and Dr. Granpeesheh. As determined above, this method has been successful in the past and it has been recommended by numerous experts that have observed and/or worked with STUDENT that he continue in this program. There is also support for this methodology in the literature. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that the program implemented with STUDENT follows recognized developmental sequences, which District witnesses testified was appropriate for a preschool-aged child.
All of the witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT recommended that he continue the program he is currently receiving because it meets his needs, because he cannot benefit from group instruction, and because of the progress that he has made during its implementation. STUDENT was not involved in any other program during the period in which he made his progress. For this reason, the witnesses credibly attributed his progress to the one-to-one, in home program. The evidence establishes that the program STUDENT receives is one-to-one, home-based, and the instructors employ discrete task analysis. All of Petitioner's witness have, at a minimum, observed STUDENT in his program and several have worked directly with him. Moreover, there is support in professional literature and studies undertaken in the field for the appropriateness of the components afforded to STUDENT by the one-to-one program. The State has also recognized the importance of having a range of different services in varying locations available to children of preschool age. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that an appropriate program for STUDENT must be provided year round with breaks from instruction not to exceed one week. The appropriate program also must be individual, based on discrete task analysis and provided in STUDENT's home for a total of 35 hours per week.
(B) Two hours per week of program supervision by a supervising therapist.
Dr. Granpeesheh testified that the way in which consistency is ensured in STUDENT's program, given that he has a number of therapists, is by maintaining logs, having a therapist to supervise the program, and meeting weekly to review and plan. MOTHER, Ms. Moore, and Dr. Granpeesheh testified that a number of persons provide STUDENT's instruction. As determined above, STUDENT's current program is meeting his needs. Therefore, to maintain consistency the Hearing Officer concludes that an appropriate program for STUDENT includes two hours per week of program supervision by a supervising therapist.
(C) Two hours a month of parent training and program supervision from a program director.
STUDENT's current program includes parent training and program supervision from a program director. It was determined that the current program is appropriate for STUDENT and the benefit of parental involvement has also been discussed above. Moreover, the program needs to be supervised by someone with appropriate credentials and expertise in autism and the type of program being provided for STUDENT. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that an appropriate program for STUDENT includes two hours a month of parent training.
(D) Two hours a week of one-to-one occupational therapy.
Petitioner provided no persuasive testimony to support his need for two, one-hour sessions of OT per week. Ms. Douglas, the District's occupational therapist, testified that STUDENT's attentional skills would not allow for therapy sessions of longer than one-half hour. STUDENT's attentional problems are well documented. Moreover, because Ms. Douglas is an experienced occupational therapist and no one of the appropriate qualifications contradicted her recommendations, the Hearing Officer finds that two, one-half hour sessions of OT meets STUDENT's unique and individual needs and denies the Petitioner's request for additional OT.
ISSUE NO. 5: Is the District required to reimburse STUDENT's family for the sums they have expended in providing STUDENT with one-to-one services, program supervision, and parent training between August 1, 1995, and October 5, 1995?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the placement they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and the placement provided by the parent was appropriate. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education 471 U.S. 359 (1985). The parents seek reimbursement for a number of items set forth in Petitioner's Exhibit 28. Included in the itemized expenses are the following: costs of tutors after Regional Center contributions; training; educational supplies; additional unspecified education costs; OT equipment/materials; Discovery Zone fees for STUDENT; travel/transportation, lodging, and child care associated with consultations with Dr. Granpeesheh and attorney Vanaman; educational assessments; phone consultations with Dr. Granpeesheh; commercial photocopying; federal express/postage; attorneys' fees; legal related costs; and expert witness costs.
In this case, it has been determined that the District failed to develop an IEP that included goals and objectives to meet some of STUDENT's most significant needs and failed to offer an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. On the other hand, according to the testimony of a number of witnesses who have a great deal of experience with children with autism, the parents provided STUDENT with a program that was appropriate. The evidence documents the progress made by STUDENT in a number of areas, all of which can be attributed to the one-to-one program provided by the parents. The program was designed to meet STUDENT's needs in that it provided him individual instruction in areas of deficit utilizing a curriculum that follows typical developmental sequences. The parents have also provided opportunities for STUDENT to interact with other children to enhance his social development and they have provided experiences for STUDENT in a number of environments to foster his ability to generalize what he has learned in individual sessions. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of providing STUDENT's program.
As to the period for which they are entitled to reimbursement, it has been determined that the District's IEP of July 13, 1995, was not appropriate. The District's proposed placement would have begun the first week of September 1995. The parents, however, seek reimbursement from August 1, 1995. The District made no offer to provide services to STUDENT between July 13, 1995, and September 1995. Given the significance of STUDENT's disability, the mandate to provide educational services to children between the ages of three and five that will ameliorate the need for special education, and the fact that it was concluded above that STUDENT requires a year round educational program because of the likelihood of regression, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents are entitled to reimbursement beginning with August 1, 1995.
(1) Costs of tutors after Regional Center contributions.
The costs of tutors clearly is related to the provision of STUDENT's educational program. Therefore, the parents are entitled to reimbursement for their actual costs expended for tutors up to 35 hours per week and excluding the costs that have been provided for by the Regional Center.
(2) Training.
MOTHER testified that training consisted of a class in applied behavioral analysis that she took at UCLA. There was no evidence that MOTHER was required to take a class in applied behavioral analysis at UCLA to meet STUDENT's unique and individual educational needs. Therefore, this request for reimbursement is denied.
(3) Educational supplies.
MOTHER testified that educational supplies includes materials necessary to implement STUDENT's language program and mock preschool. The costs of the mock preschool including shelving. There was no evidence that the cost of bookshelves was necessary to implement STUDENT's one-to-one program. Subject to proof, the costs of educational supplies and materials that have been incurred by the parent to provide STUDENT's one-to-one program are reimbursable as set forth in Petitioner's Exhibit 28.
(4) Additional unspecified educational costs.
No other costs were identified by any of the witnesses. The Hearing Officer declines to award reimbursement for "unspecified" educational costs.
(5) OT equipment/materials.
MOTHER testified that OT and related expenses includes the costs for swings, hammocks, and other equipment to set up gross-motor activities in the home. The costs also include entrance fees to the Discovery Zone. There was no evidence that the District failed to offer appropriate OT. Moreover, MOTHER testified that she was aware of the District's offer to provide OT, even if she did not enroll STUDENT in the District's educational program. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer denies the request for reimbursement for the costs of OT equipment, materials, or other associated costs.
(6) Travel/transportation, lodging, and child care associated with consultations with Dr. Granpeesheh and attorney Vanaman.
The Hearing Officer does not have authority to award attorneys' fees or other costs related to the hearing. An award of reasonable attorneys' fees may only be made by agreement of the parties or by a court of competent jurisdiction. Education Code § 56507(b). Therefore, the request for reimbursement for travel/transportation, lodging, and child care that are related to the costs of the due process hearing procedures are denied.
There was no evidence to substantiate that the costs related to travel/transportation/lodging, and child care associated with visits to consult with Dr. Granpeesheh were necessary expenses incurred in relation to providing STUDENT with an appropriate educational program. There was no evidence that MOTHER was required to travel to see Dr. Granpeesheh in person or that she was otherwise unavailable for telephone consultation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer denies this request for reimbursement.
(7) Educational assessments.
Under some circumstances, when a parent disagrees with a district's assessment, the parent is entitled to reimbursement for independent educational assessments. Education Code § 56329(b) MOTHER did not identify for which assessment or assessments she is seeking reimbursement. Moreover, assessment was not an issue identified for the hearing nor was testimony at the hearing elicited in regard to the appropriateness of assessments procured by the parent in relation to the appropriateness of the District's assessment. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer denies the request for reimbursement for unspecified assessments.
(8) Phone consultations with Dr. Granpeesheh.
It was determined above that consultations and parent training by the director of STUDENT's educational program are a necessary component of his program. To this extent, the costs of phone consultations with Dr. Granpeesheh, who served as the director of STUDENT's program are reimbursable as set forth in Petitioner's Exhibit 28.
(9) Commercial photocopying, federal express/postage, attorneys' fees, legal related costs, and expert witness costs.
As stated above, the Hearing Officer does not have authority to award attorneys' fees and other legal costs related to the hearing process. For this reason, the request for attorneys' fees, legal related costs, and expert witness costs is denied.
ISSUE NO. 6: Is the District required to reimburse STUDENT's family for the sums they have expended in providing STUDENT with one-to-one services, program supervision, and parent training since October 5, 1995?
It was determined above the District's supplemental services offered on October 5, 1995, did not constitute an appropriate placement for STUDENT. For this reason, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's parents are entitled to reimbursement under Burlington for the same costs set out in Issue No. 5 for the period commencing with October 5, 1995.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
ISSUE NO. 1: Do the goals and objectives contained in STUDENT's individualized education program (IEP) dated July 13, 1995, comply with the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and provide STUDENT with an appropriate educational program?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District offer an appropriate educational program to STUDENT at the IEP meeting on July 13, 1995?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District's proposed placement of STUDENT in the special day class (SDC) at Wiggin School in October 1995 offer him a free appropriate public education?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
ISSUE NO. 4: Does an appropriate educational program for STUDENT include the following:
(A) Forty hours a week, fifty weeks a year, of a home-based, one-to-one instructional program using discrete task analysis.
Petitioner substantially prevailed on this sub- issue.
(B) Two hours per week of program supervision by a supervising therapist.
Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue.
(C) Two hours a month of parent training and program supervision from a program director.
Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue.
(D) Two hours a week of one-to-one occupational therapy.
Respondent prevailed on this sub-issue.
ISSUE NO. 5: Is the District required to reimburse STUDENT's family for the sums they have expended in providing STUDENT with one-to-one services, program supervision, and parent training between August 1, 1995, and October 5, 1995?
Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.
ISSUE NO. 6: Is the District required to reimburse STUDENT's family for the sums they have expended in providing STUDENT with one-to-one services, program supervision, and parent training since October 5, 1995?
Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.
ORDER
(1) An appropriate educational program for Petitioner is a one-to-one, home-based, discrete trial analysis program of 35 hours per week with two hours per week of program supervision, and two hours a month of parent training and program supervision from a program director. An appropriate program for STUDENT must be provided year round with breaks from instruction not to exceed one week.
(2) Upon receipt of this decision, the District is required to immediately convene an IEP meeting to conform STUDENT's IEP to the findings of this decision and immediately thereafter to provide a placement for STUDENT that is consistent with this decision.
(3) Within 15 calendar days of receipt of proof from the parents, the District shall provide retroactive reimbursement to the parents for their out-of-pocket expenses as set forth in Petitioner's Exhibit 28 and pursuant to the findings in Issue No. 6: costs that have not been paid for by the Regional Center for STUDENT's tutors for up to a total of 35 hours per week; the costs of educational supplies and materials necessary to the implementation of the one-to-one program, excluding bookshelves; and the costs of phone consultations with Dr. Granpeesheh.
(4) Petitioner's other requests for relief are denied.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: October 14, 1996 _____________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1:Ms. Dobel was added as co-counsel on April 12, 1996. Footnote 2:At Petitioner's request, which was not opposed by Respondent, the original agreed upon date to submit closing arguments was extended. Footnote 3:The Regional Center serving San Diego funds 44 hours per month of STUDENT's program. (Regional Centers provide a number of services for developmentally delayed persons.) The senior therapist is an employee of CARD. The parents pay for three of STUDENT's therapists through CARD and pay the other therapists directly at a rate of $15.00 per hour. Footnote 4:STUDENT's individual instructors are sometimes referred to as "trainers" or "therapists." Footnote 5:The Discovery Zone is a privately owned facility in the community in which equipment is set up for young children to participate with other children in unstructured gross-motor activities. Footnote 6:Landau-Kleffner Syndrome is "an epileptic syndrome of childhood characterized by partial or generalized seizures, psychomotor abnormalities and aphasia...." (Dorland's Illustrated Medical Dictionary (28th ed. 1994) p. 1633) Footnote 7:The District's modified offer of placement, which was made in October 1995, is addressed under Issue No. 3. Footnote 8:Related services (or designated instructional services, DIS, as referred to in California) are specifically included as one of the options for early intervention services. Education Code § 56441.3(a)(7). If the student requires only related services, the services can constitute an appropriate placement. Union School District v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1519, 1527, cert. denied, ____U.S.____(1994).
