California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 30, 2003
Mount Diablo Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 76-03 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino
Mount Diablo Unified's Sunrise School placement upheld, but district must add auditory processing remediation and repay $675 for evaluations.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision describes earlier filings. A prior case, SN99-01431, was dismissed under an August 14, 2001 settlement. The District withdrew an earlier filing on December 24, 2002. The father filed a case on December 27, 2002 and later withdrew it. The decision notes no remand, court order, vacatur, or correction of this decision.
Summary
Mount Diablo Unified School District asked for a hearing to confirm that its 2002-2003 offer gave a 10-year-old fifth grader a free appropriate public education (FAPE). The student had auditory processing deficits, learning difficulties, and anxiety-related behavior problems. The offer placed him in William Sheffel's special day class at Sunrise School, a therapeutic campus. It also included speech-language and behavior services, a social worker, reading tutoring, and an assistive technology assessment. The parents represented themselves. Relying on a doctor's home-and-hospital recommendation, they kept him home most of the year.
The Hearing Officer upheld Sunrise as appropriate and the least restrictive environment, because behavior plans in less restrictive classes had failed. The doctor's notes did not certify, as the regulation requires, that his condition prevented a less restrictive placement, and the father would not let the district talk to her. But the offer fell short of FAPE. It lacked intensive one-to-one remediation of auditory processing deficits and listed no classroom accommodations. It also did not include a new occupational therapy (OT) evaluation. The district had to repay $350 for Denise Killingsworth's independent OT evaluation and $325 for Dr. Deborah Ross-Swain's auditory processing evaluation. The IEP team had to propose an OT dexterity assessment and add either 80 to 160 hours of Lindamood-Bell LiPS or 70 hours of Tomatis Method, plus accommodations. Because of the parents' conduct, compensatory education was denied. The Hearing Officer declined to decide a claim for an autism-spectrum evaluation under a prior settlement.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO split a district-filed FAPE case. It upheld a restrictive therapeutic placement but still ordered auditory processing services and accommodations. It also shows a parent's refusal to share a doctor's information weighing against compensatory education, and a home-instruction note being rejected because it lacked the required medical certification.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2002-2003 school year?
The Sunrise therapeutic SDC placement and behavior services were appropriate and met LRE, and refusing home/hospital instruction was proper. The offer denied FAPE because it lacked intensive one-to-one auditory processing remediation, classroom accommodations, and a new OT evaluation.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 2. Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the October 2002 independent occupational therapy (OT) evaluation performed by Denise Killingsworth?
The district's OT assessment was competent, but the district's overall OT assessment was inappropriate because it did not follow Dr. Peterson's recommendation to reassess, so the father gets $350 back.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3. Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the October 2002 auditory processing evaluation performed by Dr. Ross-Swain?
The district should have had a specialist evaluate auditory processing, so its assessment was not appropriate and the father gets $325 back.
- Not reachedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4. Is STUDENT entitled to an independent pervasive developmental disorder (PDD) evaluation at the District's expense?
The evidence did not show a need to assess for PDD. The claim under the 2001 settlement agreement was a contract dispute the Hearing Officer would not decide, and neither party prevailed.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education and other remedies because of the District's failure to offer a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?
Compensatory education and $900 Tomatis reimbursement were denied because of the parents' conduct. The district must offer an OT assessment, add LiPS or Tomatis services and accommodations to the IEP, and pay future transportation costs.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the decision, and as necessary after that, the District must convene an IEP meeting to carry out Orders 1(A)-(D).
- Order to assess. Develop an OT evaluation of dexterity and fine-motor skills and submit it for parental consent. The evaluator must consider the findings and concerns in Dr. Peterson's May 2002 report.
- Order to provide or change services. Amend the IEP to add intensive one-to-one auditory processing remediation, including either 80 to 160 hours of the Lindamood-Bell LiPS program or 70 hours of the Tomatis Method (on top of any Tomatis hours already received). In choosing, the IEP team must consider Dr. Peterson's testimony. Other services in the current offer may not be reduced.
- Order to provide or change services. Amend the IEP to add these accommodations: information given in advance, with cues and more time to respond; visual cues alongside spoken input; seating near the speaker; reduced background noise as feasible; brief, sequential instructions given with eye contact; and frequent listening breaks.
- Reimbursement. Within 15 days, reimburse the father $350.00 for the Killingsworth independent OT assessment and $325.00 for the Ross-Swain auditory processing evaluation.
- Reimbursement. Reimburse the parent for transportation costs, if any, of future Tomatis or LiPS services under the amended IEP. No amount was set.
Total: $675 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education; Title 5, C.C.R. §3051.4; Cal. Educ. Code §56329(b)
People named in the decision
- Ken Ferro, District alternative dispute resolution (ADR) administrator, Mount Diablo Unified School District
- Connie Cushing, District special education program specialist, Mount Diablo Unified School District
- Shari Curtis, occupational therapist (District witness), Progresses
- Jennifer Barre, occupational therapist; conducted District OT assessment, Progresses
- Arlee S. Maier, Ph.D., licensed educational psychologist; psychoeducational assessor
- John Light, mental health specialist, Contra Costa County Mental Health
- Harold Johnson, Ph.D., behavior specialist
- William Sheffel, special day class teacher, Sunrise School, Mount Diablo Unified School District
- Daniel T. Bullara, Ph.D., behavior consultant
- Cynthia Peterson, Ph.D., pediatric neuropsychologist; evaluator, Children's Hospital
- Robin Asher, M.D., treating doctor (pediatric psychologist per decision); witness for Student, Kaiser Permanente Department of Mental Health
- Deborah Ross-Swain, Ed.D., speech and language pathologist; independent auditory processing evaluator; expert witness for Student
- Lyn Gunter, education advocate; witness for Student
- Denise Killingsworth, independent occupational therapist
- Beth Dillon, occupational therapist, Therapy Link for Children
- Ms. Blackmun, assistive technology assessor, CAT
- Dr. Elliott, PDD Clinic clinician, UCSF PDD Clinic
- Active Reading Clinic, private reading provider (Reading Revolution)
- John F. Eubanks, District attorney (morning of March 4, 2003), Miller Brown & Dannis
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on March 4, 5, 6, 7, 11, and April 3, 2003, in Concord, California.
Petitioner Mount Diablo Unified School District (Petitioner or District) was represented by attorney Elizabeth Estes from the law office of Miller Brown & Dannis.(Footnote 1) Also present on behalf of the District was Ken Ferro, District alternative dispute resolution (ADR) administrator. Respondent STUDENT (Respondent or STUDENT) was represented by his father, FATHER, and his mother, MOTHER.
The District called the following witnesses: Connie Cushing, District special education program specialist; Shari Curtis, occupational therapist; Arlee S. Maier, Ph.D., licensed educational psychologist; John Light, mental health specialist at Contra Costa County Mental Health (Mental Health); Harold Johnson, Ph.D., behavior specialist; William Sheffel, District special day class (SDC) teacher at Sunrise School; Daniel T. Bullara, Ph.D., behavior consultant; Ken Ferro; Cynthia Peterson, Ph.D., pediatric neuropsychologist.
The Respondent called the following witnesses: Robin Asher, M.D., Department of Mental Health at Kaiser Permanente; FATHER, Respondent’s father; Deborah Ross-Swain, Ed.D., speech and language pathologist; MOTHER; Lyn Gunter, education advocate.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Written closing briefs were received on April 14, 2003, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
Issue 1: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2002-2003 school year?
Issue 2: Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the October 2002 independent occupational therapy (OT) evaluation performed by Denise Killingsworth?
Issue 3: Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the October 2002 auditory processing evaluation performed by Dr. Ross-Swain?
Issue 4: Is STUDENT entitled to an independent pervasive developmental disorder (PDD) evaluation at the District’s expense?
Issue 5: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education and other remedies because of the District’s failure to offer a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?(Footnote 2)
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, age 10 years, was born on [date redacted]. Antioch Unified School District developed STUDENT’s first individualized education plan (IEP) in January 1998 while STUDENT was in kindergarten. The IEP identified STUDENT as having “a learning disability in the reading and math skills areas” and “a processing disorder in both the auditory and cognitive expressive areas.” STUDENT transferred to the Mt. Diablo Unified School District in June 1998 and was placed in an SDC. STUDENT’s IEP for first grade listed “speech impaired” as STUDENT’s eligibility category and provided for an SDC placement and speech and language services.
Thereafter, behavior difficulties became an increasingly significant factor adversely affecting STUDENT’s educational progress. Auditory processing difficulties were also identified. In the fall of 1999, STUDENT was placed in a general education class. In November 1999, the District school psychologist concluded that current testing indicated a specific learning disability in the area of reading, writing, and mathematics, with “disordered auditory processing.” The school psychologist also believed that STUDENT met the special education criteria for being eligible as “emotionally disturbed” (ED). The examiner believed that stress related to the divorce of STUDENT’s parents was contributing to STUDENT’s emotional difficulties.
The District changed STUDENT’s placement to an SDC in January 2000. STUDENT’s mother asserted in a March 2000 letter that the necessity for an SDC placement had resulted from discriminatory practices against STUDENT by his first-grade general education teacher. The mother wanted to have STUDENT returned to a general education class, and she wanted support to be focused upon STUDENT’s sensory and auditory processing issues. The District offered a similar program for the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, and the mother continued to insist upon a general education class with services focused upon sensory and auditory processing issues.
Arlee Maier, Ph.D., performed a psychoeducational assessment in the fall of 2000 pursuant to an agreement between STUDENT’s father and the District. Dr. Maier concluded that STUDENT had average intellectual ability but his performance on classroom tasks was more than 1.5 standard deviations below his potential, consistent with a specific learning disability. Her report stated that testing showed deficits in short-term memory, attention, social judgement, organization and processing of information. Academically, he was performing significantly below age level. Dr. Maier considered STUDENT to be “emotionally fragile,” and she believed that STUDENT exhibited symptoms of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Dr. Maier believed that control of STUDENT’s behavior was essential to his educational progress. She recommended placement in an SDC with a high adult to student ratio and a high degree of organization and structure. She also recommended various supportive services.(Footnote 3)
The March 27, 2001 annual IEP, agreed upon by the District and STUDENT’s father, provided for full-time SDC placement, speech and language services, a behavior plan, and vision-related services. On the basis of a March 27, 2001 discharge report by Therapy Link for Children, OT was discontinued. STUDENT’s mother again objected to the IEP. On August 14, 2001, the District and STUDENT’s father entered into a settlement agreement, resulting in the dismissal of case number SN99-01431.(Footnote 4) Under the terms of the agreement, Dr. Maier would review her recommendations to ensure they were being implemented as part of STUDENT’s program, and the District agreed to fund certain assessments.
During the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT attended the fourth-grade SDC at Highlands, a District school. His performance during the 2001-2002 school year was a major factor in the District’s formulation of STUDENT’s program for 2002-2003, the school year at issue in the present case. According to a psychoeducational reassessment report written by Dr. Maier in October 2001, a behavior plan developed by Harold Johnson, Ph.D., had been implemented and was reportedly “working well in encouraging STUDENT to participate in classroom activities and to do his work, both in school and at home.” Dr. Maier recommended continuation of the behavior plan at home and at school, as the plan appeared to be benefitting STUDENT. Dr. Maier found that in reading, STUDENT had maintained his performance at the same level relative to his age, but no remedial effect or accelerated progress had been demonstrated by recent testing. His reading comprehension was at the beginning second-grade level and was impeded by poor attention to task. Dr. Maier believed that a multi-sensory approach to reading decoding and word recognition was needed because although STUDENT had “stronger verbal skills,” he appeared to be a visual learner. Writing was frustrating for STUDENT. He had difficulty with manuscript letter formation. During testing he was unwilling to attempt to copy words and became upset when asked or encouraged to copy words. Dr. Maier believed that STUDENT needed continuing OT to address fine-motor skills in the areas of motor planning and organization, especially as related to his ability to use written language.
Pursuant to his agreed-upon January 1, 2002 IEP, STUDENT continued to attend an SDC and receive speech and language, vision, and behavior-related services at Highlands. An extra assistant was assigned full-time to the classroom and had reportedly been helpful to STUDENT’s progress in academics and behavior. STUDENT was to commence attending the Active Reading Clinic for three hours per week. Dr. Maier told the IEP team that when she had observed STUDENT in the classroom in December 2001, he appeared to be “far more happy, compliant, and friendly” than in October. “Cognitive debriefing” after behavior incidents was found to be productive. Instead of having behavioral “meltdowns” lasting an entire day, the duration of the meltdowns had been reduced to five or ten minutes.(Footnote 5) A successful strategy involved leaving STUDENT alone when he was having a meltdown, then having a discussion with him about alternative behaviors when he was ready to “debrief.” STUDENT was having difficulty with transitions, especially when he anticipated an event that did not occur. In class meetings, STUDENT was beginning to accept the fact that he had acted inappropriately, and he was apologizing to his classmates. The IEP team planned reassessment in OT because the team could not determine whether STUDENT’s reluctance to write was caused by lack of instruction, lack of motivation, behavior issues, or sensory-integration deficits.
Although STUDENT’s behavior had improved during the fall of 2001, his behavior problems increased thereafter. STUDENT’s IEP team met on April 9, 2002, for the purpose of attempting to complete the annual IEP. The behavior plan was updated by Dr. Johnson. The meeting notes state that STUDENT could be aggressive, that he might speak rudely and insist he did not have to listen to the adults, or that he might silently refuse to comply. Dr. Maier stressed that control of STUDENT’s behavior was the most important factor for enabling STUDENT to progress academically. He was successful in the Active Reading Clinic. The team decided that Dr. Johnson would be at the school each day on a short-term basis and work with STUDENT, even on academics. STUDENT’s father requested an “AB3632 referral” to Mental Health for an evaluation of STUDENT, and arrangements would be made for him to complete the appropriate forms. Vision therapy was dropped and time designated for the Active Reading Clinic was slightly increased. STUDENT’s teachers and other service providers were to collaborate for the purpose of formulating new and/or updated goals and objectives. All services and goals and objectives would be subject to reconsideration after receiving the anticipated report by Dr. Cynthia Peterson from Children’s Hospital.
Dr. Peterson conducted her evaluation from January through March 2002, and she submitted her report in May 2002. STUDENT’s mother viewed the report unfavorably. However, Dr. Peterson’s recommendations were accepted by the District members of the IEP team and those recommendations were largely incorporated into subsequent placement and program offers. Dr. Peterson’s report will be examined in detail elsewhere in this Decision.(Footnote 6)
STUDENT’s IEP team met on May 3, 2002, to discuss Dr. Peterson’s report and consider a new placement. STUDENT’s behavioral status was addressed in the meeting notes. The SDC teacher reported that STUDENT’s behaviors began escalating in January. She stated that after the April 9, 2002 IEP, STUDENT had “shut down” and “was not working.” Primarily because STUDENT had reportedly exhibited “fairly normal/average behavior in November and December 2001,” Dr. Johnson and the IEP team generally believed that STUDENT was aware of good social skills, but his choice to behave and ability to behave were dependent upon other factors as stated in Dr. Peterson’s report. The team agreed that when STUDENT’s behavior was “stabilized,” an assistive technology assessment would be initiated. The notes state that an AB3632 assessment was in progress. Program accommodations included pre-teaching, more time for assignments, advance cues in the classroom, and STUDENT’s use of a ruler to track small print while reading.
The primary significance of the May 3, 2002 meeting, as it relates to the parties’ present dispute regarding placement, is that the District members of the IEP team adopted Dr. Peterson’s recommendations and agreed that STUDENT needed integrated services in a “therapeutic setting” where behavior issues could be promptly addressed. The District recommended Sunrise as a school that provided a therapeutic setting. STUDENT’s father stated that he would view one or more suggested placement sites before making a decision. STUDENT’s mother expressed her opinion that none of the proposed placements were appropriate.
On May 30, 2002, STUDENT’s father met with Mental Health and withdrew his consent to perform the AB3632 assessment. STUDENT’s IEP team met on June 7, 2002, to complete a “manifestation determination” review following an incident wherein STUDENT had been suspended for kicking his classroom aide. The team determined that the incident was a manifestation of STUDENT’s disability. During the summer of 2002, STUDENT attended the Active Reading Clinic (ARC) and was successful in learning the strategies taught at ARC. According to an August 14, 2002 letter from ARC, STUDENT had mastered the Reading Revolution strategies, and ARC had nothing further to offer him other than consultation to his teachers and tutors at school. The letter states that STUDENT now needed to concentrate on applying the ARC strategies to the comprehension of his school assignments and homework.
The August 22, 2002 IEP contains a placement and program offer for the 2002-2003 school year. The District offered an SDC placement at Sunrise for 25 hours per week, plus one hour of speech and language, three hours of behavior management services, and one hour of consultation with a social worker, per week. All of the services would be rendered at Sunrise, and STUDENT would attend Mr. Scheffel’s fifth-grade class. The meeting notes state that the basis of the recommendation for Sunrise was the District’s belief that STUDENT needed a therapeutic setting, with all the necessary supports readily available at that setting, to enable STUDENT to make behavioral and educational progress. The Active Reading Clinic would be dropped, and a tutor would assist STUDENT with transferring the skills learned at the Active Reading Clinic into the school setting. Accommodations included use of a ruler to help STUDENT with tracking smaller print. Because of the staffing already available at Sunrise, the extra classroom assistant would be dropped from the IEP. The District believed that STUDENT needed a mental health case manager. An assessment plan for AT was given to STUDENT’s father for consideration. The IEP meeting notes indicate that the father wanted the AT assessment to be performed by the “CAT-Center.”
STUDENT’s father did not sign his consent to the August 22, 2002 IEP. Discussions continued between the father and the District. On August 30, 2002, the parties signed an agreement for a program and placement. The agreement provided for placement in Mr. Sheffel’s class at Sunrise; therapeutic and case management services by a licensed clinical social worker or therapist at a frequency of one hour per week; AB3632 services upon parent referral and consent; two hours of weekly tutoring at STUDENT’s residence to reinforce the application of Reading Revolution strategies to STUDENT’s school curriculum; and ongoing monitoring of STUDENT’s progress by the District’s ADR office relative to services, goals and objectives, and the recommendations listed in Dr. Peterson’s report. However, by letter dated September 2, 2002, STUDENT’s father withdrew his consent to the August 30 agreement. He requested that placement continue at Highlands and that STUDENT’s aide be removed from “shadowing” STUDENT and collecting ongoing data “through every minute of the school day.”
STUDENT commenced the 2002-2003 school year at Highlands on or about September 4, 2002. On the first day, his father expressed concerns to the District about STUDENT’s desk being segregated from the class and placed about three feet from the desk of a student with autism and her one-to-one aide. STUDENT’s father stressed that he intended no blame upon the student with autism, but he was concerned because STUDENT had been placed next to the same student in a prior school year with negative results. STUDENT’s father withdrew STUDENT from Highlands on the morning of September 5.(Footnote 7)
By letter dated September 5, 2002, the District informed STUDENT’s father that it had filed for a due process hearing to establish the appropriateness of its offer delineated in the August 22, 2002 IEP and the August 30, 2002 settlement agreement. The letter confirmed that Highlands would remain the “stay put placement” pending resolution of the due process hearing.(Footnote 8)
On September 10, 2002, STUDENT’s father obtained a handwritten memo from Robin Asher, M.D., STUDENT’s pediatric psychologist at Kaiser Permanente. The memo recommended a home and hospital program in lieu of STUDENT’s attendance at school. The purpose of the recommendation was to remove STUDENT from the stressful setting of the classroom. On or about September 19, 2002, STUDENT’s father wrote letters to each expert who had assessed or treated STUDENT. In those letters, he retracted all authorizations for the release of information regarding STUDENT to the District or anyone else. In a series of written communications, the District sought permission from the father to obtain further information from Dr. Asher regarding the recommendation for home and hospital placement. The father refused to provide consent. Citing a lack of sufficient information, the District members of the IEP team did not recommend a home and hospital placement. Meanwhile, the father did not allow STUDENT to attend Highlands, and STUDENT remained at home without a formal educational program.
The IEP team met on September 30, 2002, for the purpose of discussing the father’s request for a home and hospital placement. At the meeting, however, STUDENT’s father rendered discussion of a home and hospital placement temporarily moot when he announced his intent to return STUDENT to the stay put placement at Highlands.(Footnote 9) The District reiterated its belief that Sunrise was the appropriate placement for STUDENT, and the father renewed his request for an AB3632 referral.
STUDENT returned to Highlands on October 4, 2002. During the morning hours that STUDENT attended class, the father observed him to cover his ears in response to cheering noises from his peers following a game, and soon thereafter STUDENT refused to participate in a writing assignment. The father was convinced that STUDENT had covered his ears because of an auditory processing or sensory-integration problem, and he again removed STUDENT from the classroom.
In October 2002, the father had STUDENT independently assessed by Dr. Ross-Swain and by Denise Killingsworth, OT. Dr. Ross-Swain conducted an auditory processing evaluation and concluded that STUDENT had significant auditory processing deficits in multiple areas. In her OT evaluation, Ms. Killingsworth concluded that STUDENT had “good but slow” visual perception, poor body awareness on his right side, poor fine-motor control, and tactile defensiveness.
With STUDENT out of school and receiving no program, the IEP team met on October 30, 2002, to again discuss the father’s request for a home and hospital placement. The District informed the father that Dr. Asher’s report did not provide enough information to support an IEP team recommendation for a home and hospital placement, and the District reiterated its request for permission to communicate with Dr. Asher. The father stated that he would have to confer with legal counsel before responding to the District’s request. By letter dated October 30, 2002, the father expressed to the District his perception that by asking for a release to obtain information from Dr. Asher, the District was seeking to conduct an “ex-parte deposition” of his son’s treating doctor prior the due process hearing set for December 2. The father requested that the District submit to him in writing a list of specific questions that he would forward to Dr. Asher for an immediate response. A list of questions for Dr. Asher was prepared by Dr. Bullara and forwarded to the father on November 6. No response was submitted to the District.
Meanwhile, during the 2002-2003 school year STUDENT has not attended school and has received no services from the District except for his brief appearances on September 4, September 5 and October 4. According to the perspective of his parents, STUDENT remains on a home and hospital placement under authority of the memos written by Dr. Asher.(Footnote 10)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue 1: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2002-2003 school year?
Individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. §1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code §56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards and conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. §1401(8). Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. To determine whether a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district's proposed program addresses the student’s unique needs, provides some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP, then that district has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314; 20 U.S.C. §1401(8).
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and mandates that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. §1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code §56031.
In the present case, the District seeks a finding that its placement and program offer for the 2002-2003 school year meets the requirements for an offer of FAPE. The overall areas of inquiry applicable in the present case for determining whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE are: (I) was the offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (II) was the offer reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit; and (III) did the offer meet the requirements of least restrictive environment?(Footnote 11) STUDENT’s main objections to the District’s placement and program offer for the 2002-2003 school year are that instead of addressing STUDENT’s behavior problems by providing appropriate services to address auditory-processing and OT-related deficits, the District has instead chosen to emphasize direct control of STUDENT’s behavior by placing him at Sunrise, a school that is designed to serve individuals with exceptional needs that also have significant behavior problems. STUDENT’s parents also believe that Sunrise would be an inappropriately restrictive placement and that STUDENT would view Sunrise as a punitive placement, thereby exacerbating his anxiety. STUDENT also asserts that pursuant to the recommendations by Dr. Asher, the District should have offered a home and hospital placement and program.(Footnote 12) The Hearing Officer will now address STUDENT’s objections to the District’s placement and program offer within the context of the three overall areas of inquiry referenced above.
(I) Was the District’s offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
A. STUDENT’s unique needs.
Before determining whether the District’s placement and program offer for the 2002-2003 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, STUDENT’s deficits and his unique needs arising from those deficits must be identified.
The District’s position is generally that although STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder and elements of a specific learning disability, his primary deficit is in the area of behavior. The District believes that until STUDENT’s behavior is modified, he will be unable to progress appropriately in the academic portions of his program. The District believes that STUDENT’s behavior problems are due to a generalized anxiety disorder and are largely exacerbated by stress from the custodial situation arising from his parents’ marital dissolution and from the receipt of conflicting instructions from his parents. District program specialist Connie Cushing testified that STUDENT’s deficits and needs related to behavior and auditory processing are best identified in Dr. Peterson’s May 2002 report. The District’s view of STUDENT’s deficits and needs have led to the District’s assertion that STUDENT requires a therapeutic setting, such as a placement at Sunrise, to meet his behavior-related needs.
The parents’ position is generally that STUDENT’s auditory processing disorder and sensory-integration/fine-motor deficits are the root cause of his behavior and academic problems. They also believe that poor service from STUDENT’s primary aide for the 2001-2002 school year severely exacerbated STUDENT’s behavior. The parents believe that until auditory processing and sensory integration are appropriately addressed, STUDENT’s behavior will not improve and he will not progress academically. The parents believe that the pervasive role of auditory processing and sensory-integration deficits in STUDENT’s behavior is best identified by the report and testimony of Dr. Ross-Swain and by the report of Ms. Killingsworth. As shown by the parents’ testimony and their various letters to the District and to persons who have evaluated STUDENT, the parents discount the notion of their divorce and ongoing custody dispute having a materially negative effect upon STUDENT’s behavior and emotional status.
The Hearing Officer will now examine the evidence and identify STUDENT’s deficits and his unique needs arising therefrom for the 2002-2003 school year. Three overall areas of deficits and needs are in contention: (1) auditory processing, (2) sensory-integration/fine-motor, and (3) behavior. Those areas are not necessarily listed in their order of importance. Because deficits in auditory processing and sensory-integration/fine-motor may be affecting STUDENT’s behavior, behavior will be examined last.
(1) Auditory processing. The parties agree that STUDENT has needs in the area of auditory processing. The parties disagree regarding the extent that auditory processing deficits have affected and continue to affect STUDENT’s behavior and academic progress. The chief evidence regarding auditory processing was in the reports and testimony of Dr. Peterson and Dr. Ross-Swain. Dr. Peterson evaluated STUDENT from her perspective as a psychologist, while Dr. Ross-Swain evaluated STUDENT from her perspective as a speech and language pathologist specializing in auditory processing disorders. Their findings and recommendations, as related to auditory processing, were similar.(Footnote 13)
Dr. Peterson describes STUDENT’s auditory processing disorder as a “phonemically based verbal learning disability,” explained in general terms by Dr. Peterson as a weakness in the ability to discern and process sounds at the phonemic level. Dr. Peterson testified that because STUDENT has weaknesses in processing phonemic information, he has difficulty with word recall, manipulation of verbal information, working memory, and language-based tasks in general. Academically, these weaknesses are further manifested by difficulties with word-finding, reading, spelling, and deciphering complex directions.(Footnote 14) Her report noted that when STUDENT participated in Reading Revolution strategies at the Active Reading Clinic, he struggled with decoding words. He confused vowel and consonant sound, added and deleted letters, incorrectly sequenced letters, and had difficulties with multi-syllable words. According to her testimony and report, STUDENT needs continuing speech and language services to address word finding difficulties, articulation errors, and expression within complex situations. Because of STUDENT’s limitations in processing information, Dr. Peterson recommends that information be provided to STUDENT in advance, with cues and more time for responding. She recommends individual tutoring for Reading Revolution techniques, writing, and reading comprehension. Dr. Peterson states that STUDENT needs help with basic organization and organizational strategies, including the ability to make adjustments. She states that STUDENT needs to learn context, cueing, and recognition strategies to address his difficulty with retrieving certain types of information.
In her October 2002 audiology evaluation report, Dr. Ross-Swain concludes that STUDENT has significant auditory processing deficits in multiple areas, including auditory attention, immediate auditory memory, auditory sequential memory, auditory discrimination, auditory conceptualization, phonemic awareness, auditory association and interpretation, and following directions. Dr. Ross-Swain believes that STUDENT’s behaviors show STUDENT to be at risk for auditory overload resulting from his many auditory weaknesses. She recommends the “Tomatis Method,” a seventy-hour “protocol of psychoacoustically modified music designed to improve the aforementioned auditory processing skills.” She recommends participation in the Lindamood-Bell phoneme sequencing program (LiPS), designed to develop written language skills in children with auditory processing disorders. She also recommends several classroom strategies. The classroom strategies include “use of visual cues concurrent with auditory input in a learning situation,” placing STUDENT near the speaker in the classroom, reducing classroom background noise whenever possible, delivering brief and sequential instructions while having STUDENT retain direct eye contact with the speaker, and frequent breaks from listening. Finally, she recommends pragmatic language skill training. In her testimony, Dr. Ross-Swain emphasized her opinion that tutoring services will have limited usefulness if STUDENT’s underlying processing disorder is not addressed, and she cautioned that the opportunity for remediating STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits is becoming more limited as STUDENT grows older.
As testified to by Dr. Maier and noted in Dr. Peterson’s report, STUDENT showed some academic improvement for the prior year when reassessed by Dr. Maier in October 2001, but the gap between his cognitive and/or intellectual ability and his academic achievement had not been narrowed. More recent data was obtained by Dr. Peterson in the spring of 2002 during the latter stages of STUDENT’s fourth-grade school year. Testing by Dr. Peterson showed that in spite of STUDENT having a performance IQ of 121, he was still reading, spelling, and performing numerical operations at the second-grade level as measured by subtests on the WIAT–II.(Footnote 15)
In determining STUDENT’s needs related to auditory processing, the Hearing Officer has considered the recommendations made by Dr. Peterson and Dr. Ross-Swain. The Hearing Officer has also considered the testimony and documentary evidence that STUDENT’s auditory processing disorder has had significant adverse effects on STUDENT’s academic achievement, that STUDENT’s prior programs generally have not provided remediation, that tutoring will have limited usefulness if STUDENT’s underlying processing disorder is not addressed, and that the opportunity for remediating STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits is becoming more limited as STUDENT grows older. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a program designed to address his auditory processing needs through a combination of remediation, compensation, and accommodation strategies. STUDENT needs remediation strategies to address the source of his auditory processing disorder. He needs compensation strategies to help him circumvent some of his auditory processing deficits while performing language-based tasks such as reading, writing, and spelling. He needs accommodation strategies to assist with the receipt and understanding of language-based information and the completion of assignments.(Footnote 16)
(2) Sensory-integration/fine-motor. The District asserts that STUDENT has no OT-related needs. STUDENT asserts that he has OT-related needs arising from sensory-integration and fine-motor deficits. STUDENT asserts that his sensory-integration deficits, manifested primarily by tactile defensiveness and hypersensitivity to auditory stimuli, cause anxiety at levels that adversely affect his behavior. STUDENT further asserts that his fine-motor deficits adversely affect his ability to write, thereby also increasing his anxiety and leading to defiant behaviors, such as refusal to commence or complete writing assignments.
The District’s position is based primarily upon the findings of Jennifer Barre, OTR. Ms. Barre’s February 2002 OT report states that Ms. Barre examined STUDENT on three separate dates in February 2002. The assessment methods listed in the report include the Sensory Profile, a standardized questionnaire given to STUDENT’s teachers, services providers, and father. The Sensory Profile elicits information about a child’s unusual responses to various sensory experiences. Other assessment methods listed in the report include clinical observations, informal interviews, handwriting samples, and “functional assessments.” Ms. Barre evaluated STUDENT in areas that included behavior, fine motor, neuromuscular, gross motor, ocular motor, and sensory processing. Within the area of sensory processing, Ms. Barre evaluated STUDENT for tactile defensiveness, vestibular control, visual motor, auditory sensitivity, proprioceptive function, and olfactory/gustatory function. Ms. Barre concluded that STUDENT had no sensory-integration or motor difficulties affecting his behavior or interfering with his learning.
STUDENT’s position is based primarily upon the findings of Denise, Killingsworth, OTR. Her report states that she examined STUDENT on October 31 and November 6, 2002. STUDENT had an episode of vomiting during the October 31 session, but thereafter the assessment continued. The assessment methods listed in the report were “clinical observations” and the “Sensory Integration and Praxis Tests” (SIPT). According to the report, those “tests look at visual, tactile, and vestibular processing, bilateral integration, midline crossing, and fine-motor skill.” Ms. Killingsworth concluded that the results of the SIPT and her observations of STUDENT during testing showed “good but slow” visual perception, poor body awareness on his right side, poor fine-motor control, and tactile defensiveness.
Neither Ms. Barre nor Ms. Killingsworth testified at the hearing.(Footnote 17) For a variety of reasons, the Hearing Officer finds the report by Ms. Barre to be significantly more persuasive than the report by Ms. Killingsworth. Ms. Killingsworth’s findings were derived almost entirely from her administration of the SIPT, with minimal or no consideration of other sources of information. Moreover, the SIPT results are suspect. Ms. Killingsworth administered the SIPT to STUDENT when he was 14 months older than the children she compared him to in the test sample. From the SIPT results, Ms. Killingsworth concluded that STUDENT had various deficits as listed above. Curiously, however, Ms. Killingsworth’s data summary showed that in all areas tested on the SIPT, STUDENT performed in the “typical” to above-average range. Also, Ms. Killingsworth’s report states that STUDENT’s previous OT had concerns about several specified OT-related areas. However, the March 2001 OT discharge report by Beth Dillon at Therapy Link for Children stated that STUDENT was not displaying difficulties with tactile or auditory sensory-integration or processing in his school environment, and Ms. Dillon’s report mentioned no ongoing OT-related concerns. Ms. Dillon noted in her report that from December 11, 2000 through the date of her report, improvement had been observed in STUDENT’s ability to cope with stressful situations, and he was responding more positively toward redirection from adults. She believed that incidents involving STUDENT’s covering of his ears when receiving adult instruction were non-compliance behaviors, not related to auditory hypersensitivity. The Hearing Officer also notes that STUDENT’s illness during the October 31 session with Ms. Killingsworth may have skewed STUDENT’s performance in a negative manner.
In contrast to Ms. Killingsworth’s report, the assessment information in Ms. Barre’s report was obtained from multiple sources in addition to Ms. Barre’s own observations, including information from STUDENT’s father. Ms. Barres’s findings were derived from and largely consistent with the available data. Her findings were also consistent with the March 2001 findings by Ms. Dillon, a person who was familiar with STUDENT as his therapist.
Other information considered by the Hearing Officer on matters related to sensory integration and fine motor included the reports and testimony of Dr. Maier, Dr. Ross-Swain and Dr. Peterson. With respect to auditory sensitivities, STUDENT’s father has observed STUDENT to react negatively to persons making loud conversational noises. STUDENT also reported the same problems to Ms. Barre. The most credible explanation for such reactions was Dr. Swain’s belief that STUDENT’s multiple auditory processing deficits were making him susceptible to “auditory overload” on certain occasions, resulting in inappropriate behavioral reactions. With respect to fine-motor skills, Dr. Peterson believes that STUDENT had some dexterity issues that negatively influenced his handwriting and frustrated him. That opinion was shared by Dr. Maier, as stated above in the Background Facts. Dr. Peterson’s opinion was made on the basis of STUDENT’s low-average to borderline-deficient performance on some pegboard tests, his aversion to handwriting, and his problems with design copying. Dr. Peterson considered those dexterity weaknesses to be related to overlapping deficits in motor coordination, visual-perceptual skills, and organization. Because her opinion was in conflict with the District’s OT report by Ms. Barre, Dr. Peterson recommended another OT evaluation and an assistive technology (AT) evaluation.
Having considered the above, the Hearing Officer finds that on some occasions, STUDENT demonstrates negative behavioral reactions consistent with “auditory overload” as described by Dr. Ross-Swain. However, such “overload” most likely is an ancillary result of his multiple auditory-processing deficits, and not a matter to be addressed by OT services. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not demonstrate tactile defensiveness at a level adversely affecting his educational performance. Regarding fine-motor and dexterity issues, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that STUDENT’s aversion to writing may well be caused by factors other than mere behavioral defiance. However, although deficits in motor coordination may exist, they were not persuasively demonstrated by Ms. Killingsworth’s recent OT evaluation, and Dr. Peterson’s pegboard observations are not sufficient to obviate the need for a new OT evaluation. Dr. Peterson recommends further OT evaluation of STUDENT’s dexterity by examining his motor coordination, visual-perceptual skills, and organization. She also recommends an AT assessment to assist the IEP team in determining whether alternatives to handwriting would be appropriate. The Hearing Officer finds there is a continuing need to implement those recommendations, notwithstanding the recent evaluation by Ms. Killingsworth. The parties are appropriately in agreement that STUDENT needs accommodations to address his visual-tracking deficits. Dr. Peterson recommended visual guides to help STUDENT in his ability to scan documents.
(3) Behavior. Dr. Peterson’s report states that STUDENT is “an anxious, easily frustrated, though socially vigilant young boy who is experiencing high levels of psychological stress, as well as ongoing academic difficulties.” He has considerable amounts of anxiety and worrisome thoughts that he cannot control. He demonstrates anxious symptoms such as eye blinks, hand wringing, excessive worrying, and tendencies toward perfectionism. His strategies for coping with stress include “pessimistic or helpless/giving up, avoidance or providing simplistic responses.” She believes that STUDENT has a generalized anxiety disorder, “exacerbated by his coping/problem-solving style, the way he sees himself, and his environment at large.” His poor coping strategies are compounded, according to the report, by his poor frustration tolerance, his perception that he must have his needs met quickly before the opportunity vanishes, and his lowered self-esteem and self-confidence. He wants to please the adults in his life, but he has found that by making one person happy he might be making another unhappy. Consequently, according to Dr. Peterson, he is likely to demonstrate behaviors that are inconsistent with the context of the situation, thereby getting himself into trouble. Dr. Peterson believes that STUDENT needs adults to respond to him in a therapeutic manner, as opposed to showing frustration. The report states “it is the belief of this examiner that until situational stress related to his feeling helpless to control unwelcome circumstances in his life can be relieved, such concerns and concurrent behavior will continue to interfere with his being able to think clearly, concentrate effectively, and utilize his resources to the best of his ability.”
Dr. Peterson emphasized the need to provide multiple services in an integrated fashion by having professionals on site at all times, trained to respond to STUDENT in a more therapeutic manner and also able to address his learning issues. She recommends training in social skills, taught in the context of problem solving and taught by a professional. He needs ongoing medications and monitoring of the medications. She recommends a case manager to help with the integration and coordination of services, both in and out of school. Finally, she recommends that both parents be involved in assisting with treatment for anxiety and emotional distress and developing “mutually satisfying interactions.”(Footnote 18)
Dr. Johnson, STUDENT’s behaviorist at Highlands during most of the 2001-2002 school year, testified that STUDENT is capable of appropriate behavior, as demonstrated by his success during the initial months of the 2001-2002 school year, but he does not consistently show appropriate behavior. The evidence showed that STUDENT’s frequent failure to engage in appropriate behavior arises from several factors. Dr. Maier believes that STUDENT has an “Adjustment Disorder, With Mixed Disturbance of Emotions and Conduct.” Dr. Peterson believes that STUDENT has a “generalized anxiety disorder.” In either event, as described by Dr. Peterson, STUDENT has anxiety and behavior problems that extend beyond what one would expect to observe in a child exhibiting stress solely from the effects of a phonemic-based learning disability. Thus, STUDENT has an actual behavior disorder of some type. The Hearing Officer agrees with the opinion that STUDENT’s family situation contributes to his stress, anxiety, and inappropriate conduct. The Hearing Officer also agrees with the parents’ viewpoint that STUDENT’s auditory processing disorder and his poor academic performance contribute to his stress, anxiety, and behavior problems. This latter point was advanced by Dr. Swain’s report, was acknowledged by Dr. Peterson, and is consistent with the fact that STUDENT reportedly performed well under the reduced stress of one-to-one learning situations, such as at the Active Reading Clinic and during home instruction provided by the parents.
The evidence showed that placement in an SDC with implementation of an extensive behavior intervention plan, even with a behaviorist frequently on site, was inadequate for managing and modifying STUDENT’s behavior during the 2001-2002 school year. STUDENT had stopped responding to purely behavioral interventions.(Footnote 19) STUDENT’s behavior deteriorated from January 2002 through the end of the school to the extent that, as described by his classroom teacher, STUDENT had “shut down and was not working.” Because of the complex and interwoven nature of the factors negatively influencing STUDENT’s behavior and the demonstrated problems in prior placements, the Hearing Officer agrees with Dr. Peterson’s recommendation that STUDENT needs to be placed in a learning setting where, in addition to having a behavior plan, STUDENT has a wide array of therapeutic services readily available that are integrated into the learning setting.(Footnote 20) Also with respect to behavior, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team should, with parental consent, initiate a referral for a Mental Health assessment, as described by the criteria in Title 2, C.C.R. section 60040.
B. The District’s offer.
The District’s offer for the 2002-2003 school year is set forth in the August 22, 2002 IEP, and in August 30 and November 21, 2002 letters from Ms. Estes to the Respondent’s father. The basic elements of the offer are (a) placement in a fifth-grade SDC; (b) therapeutic services and case management by a licensed clinical social worker or therapist; (c) AB3632 services, contingent on parent consent; (d) tutoring to reinforce Reading Revolution instruction; (e) ongoing monitoring of STUDENT’s IEP progress, to be performed by the Distict’s ADR office; (f) speech and language services; (g) behavior management services; and (f) assistive technology assessment. Annual goals and objectives stated in the April 9, 2002 IEP are incorporated into the District’s offer. The Hearing Officer will now examine whether the program and placement offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of auditory processing, sensory-integration/fine-motor, and behavior as identified above. The Hearing Officer will also examine other objections that the Respondent has raised regarding the District’s offer.
(1) Auditory processing. STUDENT has a phonemic-based learning disability adversely affecting various areas related to auditory processing. The specific elements of his phonemic-based learning disability/auditory-processing disorder were described by Dr. Peterson and Dr. Ross-Swain, as recounted above. The Hearing Officer has found that in the area of auditory processing, STUDENT needs a program designed to address his auditory processing needs through a combination of remediation, compensation, and accommodation strategies. The Hearing Officer will now examine whether the District’s program was so designed.
Remediation. The Hearing Officer has previously found that STUDENT needs services specifically designed to remediate his auditory processing disorder by addressing the source of the disorder. The Hearing Officer agrees with Dr. Ross-Swain’s opinion that the degree of STUDENT’s auditory-processing deficits requires intensive, one-to-one services. No such program was offered by the District in the area of auditory processing. The evidence showed that Reading Revolution was completed in the summer of 2002 and STUDENT still has significant auditory-processing deficits as measured by Dr. Ross-Swain in the fall of 2002. The evidence does not suggest that tutoring to reinforce what STUDENT has already learned in the Reading Revolution program will suffice to appropriately address the need for remediation. Dr. Ross-Swain recommended the Tomatis Method to improve STUDENT’s auditory processing skills. She also recommended the Lindamood-Bell phoneme sequencing program (LiPS), a program specifically designed to develop written language skills in children with auditory processing disorders. Both are intensive, individualized programs. She testified that in her opinion, those programs would likely resolve or remediate many of STUDENT’s auditory-processing deficits. Dr. Peterson testified that the LiPS program would be a good alternative to Reading Revolution if Reading Revolution was not offered. Dr. Peterson was familiar with the Tomatis Method as being a program that “trains the ear” to listen more carefully to certain sounds. She testified that she was aware of no data to support the effectiveness of the Tomatis Method and, therefore, she would offer no opinion as to whether STUDENT should have that program.
On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that tutoring to reinforce what STUDENT has learned in the Reading Revolution program was an appropriate component of the District’s offer, and it should be implemented. However, neither the tutoring nor the other provisions of the District’s offer are sufficient to appropriately address STUDENT’s need for remediation. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that District’s offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s need for intensive, one-to-one services to remediate his auditory processing deficits. Compensation strategies. STUDENT needs compensation strategies designed to help him circumvent some of his auditory processing deficits during the performance of language-based tasks such as reading, writing, and spelling. Dr. Peterson stated that STUDENT needs continuing speech and language services to address word finding difficulties, articulation errors, and expression within complex situations. She recommends individual tutoring for Reading Revolution techniques, writing, and reading comprehension. Dr. Peterson states that STUDENT needs help with basic organization and organizational strategies, including the ability to make adjustments. She states that STUDENT needs to learn context, cueing, and recognition strategies to address his difficulty with retrieving certain types of information. During her testimony, Dr. Peterson was asked to review the services and goals and objectives applicable to the District’s program offer and state whether they were consistent with her above-stated recommendations. The substance of her testimony was that although she would have made some adjustments to the goals and objectives, the services and goals and objectives were generally appropriate. No contradictory expert opinion was offered on that point. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique need for compensation strategies to help him circumvent some of his auditory processing deficits during the performance of language-based tasks such as reading, writing, and spelling.
Accommodations. STUDENT needs accommodation strategies designed to facilitate his receipt and understanding of language-based information and his completion of assignments. Dr. Peterson recommends that because of STUDENT’s limitations in processing information, STUDENT should be provided information in advance, with cues and more time for responding. Dr. Ross-Swain recommends classroom strategies including use of visual cues concurrent with auditory input, placing STUDENT near the speaker in the classroom, reducing classroom background noise whenever possible, delivering brief and sequential instructions while having STUDENT retain direct eye contact with the speaker, and frequent breaks from listening.
The District’s program offer specifies none of the above-referenced accommodations. This may have been an oversight by the District, as the May 3, 2002 IEP expressly incorporates and lists most of Dr. Peterson’s accommodation recommendations.(Footnote 21) Whether some or all of the above-referenced accommodations would have been incorporated into the highly-structured placement offered at Sunrise was not demonstrated by the evidence presented. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program offer as written was not designed to meet
STUDENT’s unique needs for accommodation strategies to facilitate STUDENT’s understanding of language-based information and his completion of assignments.
(2) Sensory-integration/fine-motor. The Hearing Officer has determined that in the area of sensory-integration/fine-motor skills, STUDENT needs further OT evaluation of his dexterity. STUDENT needs an AT assessment to assist his IEP team in determining whether alternatives to handwriting would be appropriate. STUDENT needs accommodations to address his visual-tracking deficits. The District’s offer includes a recommendation for an AT assessment. The offer also adopts Dr. Peterson’s recommendation for use of a ruler to help STUDENT with tracking smaller print. The District has not offered to conduct a new OT evaluation. The Hearing Officer finds that except for the District’s failure to offer a new OT evaluation to address STUDENT’s dexterity, the District program offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs related to sensory-integration/fine-motor skills.
(3) Behavior. The Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT needs to be placed in a learning setting where, in addition to having an appropriate behavior plan, STUDENT has a wide array of therapeutic services readily available that are integrated into the learning setting. Furthermore, upon receipt of parental consent, STUDENT needs a referral for a Mental Health assessment, as described by the criteria in Title 2, C.C.R. section 60040.
The District’s offer provides for placement at Sunrise in William Sheffel’s fifth-grade class. Mr. Sheffel testified that he has been the fifth-grade teacher at Sunrise for the past 26 years. He described his class and the Sunrise school. The school has seven classes, all for students with behavior and socialization problems. His fifth-grade class has a maximum of nine students. Sunrise has a full-time psychologist present on the campus everyday except Fridays. Sunrise has a “learning center” that functions as a “time-out” room when a student needs to be removed from the classroom. Instead of a student being punished for inappropriate behavior, the learning center is designed as a positive tool where the students have access to the learning center staff, including a teacher, assistant, and social worker. The learning center staff operates to help the child regain his or her composure and return to the classroom as soon as practical. Sunrise also has adapted physical education, OT, and speech and language services on site. Mr. Sheffel described his classroom as quiet and highly structured. He testified that although students are placed at Sunrise because of their behavior problems, the therapeutic and structured environment at Sunrise results in a setting wherein behavior problems are hardly noticed. Incentive systems include a “country store” where the students can spend their dollars earned by appropriate behavior, and access to field trips and assemblies with typical peers. All of the students at Sunrise have a behavior support plan adapted to the special personnel and options available at Sunrise, and STUDENT’s behavior plan would have been so adapted. Mr. Sheffel testifed that at Sunrise, the many available options result in students rarely being sent home for behavior problems. Mr. Sheffel testified regarding how he would implement STUDENT’s academic goals and objectives. He also testified regarding the school’s success at improving its students’ behavior and transitioning them into less restrictive placements, usually within one or two school years. Dr. Johnson and Dr. Bullara testified that they believed the placement at Sunrise would be appropriate for STUDENT.
On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer for placement at Sunrise was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for placement in a structured learning setting where he would have access to integrated therapeutic services to address his behavior. The evidence showed that had STUDENT attended Sunrise, his behavior plan would likely have been appropriately modified and adapted. Finally, the District appropriately offered a referral for Mental Health assessment, as described by the criteria in Title 2, C.C.R. section 60040.
(4) Home and hospital placement. A pupil’s placement for purposes of special education may include placement in a home or hospital. Title 5, C.C.R. §3042. Designated instruction and services as specified in an IEP shall be available when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. Such services may include instruction in the home or hospital. Cal. Educ. Code §56363. Special education and related services in the home or hospital are limited to those pupils who have been identified as individuals with exceptional needs and for whom the IEP team recommends such instruction or services. Title 5, C.C.R. §3051.4(a). When recommending placement for home instruction, the IEP team shall have in the assessment information a medical report stating the diagnosed condition and certifying that the severity of the condition prevents the pupil from attending a less restrictive placement. The report shall include a projected date for the pupil’s return to school. Title 5, C.C.R. §3051.4(d).
STUDENT asserts that on the basis of two memos written by Dr. Asher, the District should have offered and provided STUDENT with a home and hospital placement. The District asserts that the memos written by Dr. Asher provided insufficient information for the IEP team to have recommended a home and hospital placement.
The first memo by Dr. Asher, STUDENT’s pediatric psychologist at Kaiser Permanente, is dated September 10, 2002. The memo, written “to whom this may concern,” states “I recommend that [STUDENT] be placed in a Home and Hospital program in order to allow him an opportunity to fully focus on academics without exacerbation of his Anxiety Disorder (frequent gastrointestinal complaints, fears, ect) and his difficulties with anger and behavioral dyscontrol. In my opinion, based on information from [FATHER] and [STUDENT], the classroom setting has intensified many of [STUDENT’s] difficulties.” The second memo by Dr. Asher, dated October 10, 2002, states “I would recommend [STUDENT] continue in the Home and Hospital program through December 2002.” Members of the District’s IEP team, including Dr. Bullara and Mr. Ferro, testified that when the team met on September 30 and October 30, 2002, to consider the request for home and hospital placement, the District members of the team were concerned that Dr. Asher may have had insufficient information when she made her recommendation. For example, Mr. Ferro’s testimony demonstrated his concern whether Dr. Asher had considered, or even known about, the proposed program and placement at Sunrise and how the therapeutic aspects of that proposed placement were intended to address STUDENT’s behavior-related needs. Dr. Bullara was concerned that a home and hospital placement would be too restrictive and would especially limit the ability to provide social skills training. Moreover, Dr. Asher’s knowledge or expertise in matters related to special education were unknown to the IEP team.(Footnote 22)
Dr. Asher’s memos are phrased as recommendations intended to alleviate stress on STUDENT and assist him in focusing on academics. The memos do not certify that the severity of STUDENT’s condition prevents him from attending a less restrictive placement than home and hospital. Thus, the memos do not satisfy the requirements of Title 5, C.C.R. §3051.4(d). The Hearing Officer also notes that STUDENT’s anxiety and stress as reported to Dr. Asher by STUDENT and his father in September 2002 were occurring at Highlands, the stay put placement. Thus, the IEP team was required to consider the appropriateness of the home and hospital recommendation by assuming that the alternative, until resolution of the due process matter pending at that time, was placement at Highlands or some other agreed-upon placement. Meanwhile, as testified to by Connie Cushing, the IEP team had been in agreement at the June 17, 2002 IEP meeting that placement at Highlands had not been appropriate for STUDENT, which led to the team’s recommendation for placement at Sunrise.
All of the above factors provided compelling reasons for the IEP team to seek additional information from Dr. Asher before deciding whether to recommend the highly restrictive environment of a home and hospital placement. The District sought to obtain further information from Dr. Asher, but STUDENT’s father did not allow that to occur. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that the District acted appropriately in not recommending or providing a home and hospital placement.
(5) Other contentions. Other contentions raised by STUDENT regarding FAPE are that (a) instead of the therapeutic services and case management offered by the District, the District should be required to maintain and pay for the services that STUDENT currently receives from a private therapist; (b) the April 9, 2002 version of the behavior plan written by Dr. Johnson should not be implemented; (c) AT assessment should be performed by “CAT,” not by Ms. Blackmun.
None of the above assertions were supported by the evidence. The District appropriately addressed STUDENT’s behavior-related needs by offering a placement at Sunrise with supporting services and recommending a referral to Mental Health for assessment and services; accordingly, the District is not required to use STUDENT’s private therapist in lieu of its own personnel. Regarding the behavior plan, the evidence showed that the plan would be modified and adapted to STUDENT’s environment at Sunrise and the therapeutic services available at Sunrise when STUDENT attended and could be observed at Sunrise. Such modification and adaptation has been prevented only because STUDENT has not attended Sunrise. Regarding the AT assessment, the evidence showed that the District is already offering an AT assessment by CAT. Mr. Ferro testified that Ms. Blackmun was an employee of CAT, but it was unknown whether CAT would assign Ms. Blackmun to perform the assessment. In any event, Mr. Ferro’s testimony established that Ms. Blackmun was competent to conduct the AT assessment. No reason was established by the Respondent to support a finding that Ms. Blackmun should not conduct the AT assessment.
(II) Was the program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?
An appropriate educational program must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Rowley, supra. The Hearing Officer has found that the District’s offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s need for intensive, one-to-one services to remediate his auditory processing deficits. Furthermore, the District’s program offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s need for accommodation strategies to facilitate his understanding of language-based information and his completion of assignments. The Hearing Officer has also found that to the limited extent the District did not offer to conduct a new OT evaluation to address STUDENT’s dexterity, the District’s offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs related to sensory-integration/fine-motor skills. In all other respects, the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Auditory processing is a crucial area of need for STUDENT. Thus, the failure to offer intensive one-to-one services to address STUDENT’s need for remediation of his auditory processing deficits was a major flaw in the District’s program offer. As testified to by Dr. Ross-Swain and as demonstrated by the continuing and significant discrepancy between STUDENT’s intellectual/cognitive ability and academic achievement throughout prior school years, the effectiveness of methods for addressing STUDENT’s auditory-processing difficulties, such as extensive tutoring and other compensatory-type strategies offered by the District, will be either thwarted or severely limited if the underlying processing disorder is not lessened or remediated. This situation was compounded by the District’s failure to specify accommodation strategies for use in the classroom and elsewhere to facilitate STUDENT’s understanding of language-based information and his completion of assignments. Therefore, to the extent that the District’s program failed to appropriately address STUDENT auditory processing disorder, the Hearing Officer finds that the program offer was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
(III) Did the placement offer meet the requirements of least restrictive environment?
The Hearing Officer has found that the proposed placement at Sunrise, although more restrictive than STUDENT’s prior placements in terms of his ability to interact with typical peers, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. There was no showing that an alternative, less restrictive placement, would have been appropriate. Instead, the evidence showed that prior, less restrictive placements, had recently been unsuccessful at addressing STUDENT’s behavior. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement offer met the requirements of least restrictive environment.
(IV) Summary and conclusions.
The District’s offer failed to include services designed to remediate STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits and failed to specify accommodation strategies to address STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits in the classroom and learning environment. To that extent, the District’s program offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was not reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and did not meet the requirements for an offer of FAPE.(Footnote 23)
Issue 2: Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the October 2002 independent OT evaluation performed by Denise Killingsworth?
Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56329(b) provides that a parent has a right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, if the district’s assessment, through a due process hearing, is determined to be appropriate, the parent is not entitled to have the independent assessment be at public expense.
STUDENT’s parents assert that they are entitled to reimbursement in the amount of $350.00 for the independent OT evaluation performed in October 2002 by Mr. Killingsworth. In his September 16, 2002 letter to the District, STUDENT’s father stated that he believed the District’s OT assessment did “not show an accurate picture of my son’s fine-motor functioning” and he planned to obtain an independent evaluation at the District’s expense. Thus, the evidence shows that STUDENT’s father obtained the independent OT assessment because he was in disagreement with the District’s OT assessment.
The next question is whether the District’s OT assessment was appropriate. The OT evaluation by Ms. Barre, conducted on the District’s behalf, has been discussed above. The evidence suggests that Ms. Barre conducted her OT evaluation in a manner consistent with the requirements in Cal. Educ. Code section 56320. However, Dr. Peterson believed that STUDENT had some dexterity issues negatively influencing his handwriting and causing him frustration. Dr. Peterson recognized that her opinion was in conflict with the OT evaluation performed by Ms. Barre, and she appropriately recommended further OT assessment by the District. The District has not offered further OT assessment, and the Hearing Officer has found further OT assessment is necessary.
In summary, the OT assessment performed on the District’s behalf by Ms. Barre was appropriate, but the District’s overall assessment in the area of OT was rendered inappropriate by the District’s failure to follow Dr. Peterson’s recommendation for reassessment. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that for purposes of this reimbursement issue, the District’s OT assessment was inappropriate and STUDENT’s father is entitled to reimbursement in the amount of $350.00 for the independent OT assessment performed by Ms. Killingsworth.
Issue 3: Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the October 2002 auditory processing evaluation performed by Dr. Ross-Swain?
STUDENT’s parents seek $325.00 as reimbursement from the District for the independent auditory processing evaluation performed by Dr. Ross-Swain in October 2002. The pertinent question for the purposes of this reimbursement issue is whether the District’s assessment in the area of auditory processing was appropriate. In formulating the portions of STUDENT’s program directed at addressing STUDENT’s auditory processing disorder, the District relied almost exclusively on the findings and recommendations in Dr. Peterson’s May 2002 report. Dr. Peterson, a psychologist, appropriately described STUDENT’s auditory-processing disorder as a phonemic-based learning disability. Her report and testimony demonstrated her competence in the subject of auditory processing as it relates to a learning disability. However, Dr. Ross-Swain’s report illustrated the value of having an auditory-processing evaluation performed by a specialist in that field. By applying her expertise to a more extensive battery of applicable tests than had been administered by Dr. Peterson, Dr. Ross-Swain produced a report containing additional and useful information and recommendations on a major and critical area of need for STUDENT. Although the District’s witnesses and even Dr. Peterson sought to minimize the value of Dr. Ross-Swain’s report, the Hearing Officer found the report to be of substantial usefulness in both confirming and supplementing the findings of Dr. Peterson.
In summary, the Hearing Officer considers Dr. Peterson’s portion of the auditory processing evaluation to have been appropriate, but the District should have obtained further evaluation by a specialist in the area of auditory processing. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that for purposes of this reimbursement issue, the District’s assessment in the area of auditory processing was not appropriate. STUDENT’s father is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Ross-Swain’s October 2002 auditory processing evaluation.
Issue 4: Is STUDENT entitled to an independent pervasive developmental disorder (PDD) evaluation at the District’s expense?
STUDENT asserts that the August 14, 2001 settlement agreement in Case No. SN99-01431 obligated the District to provide a pervasive developmental disorder (PDD) assessment, but the District has not complied with that portion of the agreement. The applicable portion of the settlement agreement, as stated in an August 14, 2001 letter from the District’s attorney to Mr. PARENT, is that upon the father’s request, the District would initiate a “referral to the PDD Clinic at UCSF to rule out suspected disabilities, such as Asberger’s, Autism, SID, and Tourettes Syndrome.” Mr. Ferro testified that the District has denied the father’s request because the District had already provided two assessments by Dr. Maier and one assessment by Dr. Peterson, and none of those assessments suggested a need for further evaluation in the area of PDD. The District also presented evidence showing that at some point prior to Dr. Peterson’s evaluation, STUDENT had been presented to Dr. Elliott at the PDD Clinic, but on Dr. Elliot’s recommendation assessment at the PDD Clinic was deferred pending the outcome of other ongoing assessments.
The evidence did not demonstrate that assessment at UCSF’s PDD Clinic was necessary or that PDD should be further assessed as a suspected area of disability. Therefore, the question of STUDENT’s entitlement to a PDD assessment is strictly in the nature of a contractual dispute, and the Hearing Officer will not rule upon that dispute.
Issue 5: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education and other remedies because of the District’s failure to offer a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?
The matter of remedies for the denial of FAPE will now be addressed. When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district fails to provide a FAPE, and the placement or services are determined to be appropriate under the IDEA. Equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358. Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1486. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. See Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation for missed services. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.
In the present case, the relief requested by the Respondent is itemized in the Respondent’s closing brief. Requests related to assessment and reimbursement for independent assessments have already been resolved above. Regarding relief applicable to the District’s failure to offer a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, the Respondent requests reimbursement for Tomatis sound therapy expenses incurred to date in the amount of $900.00. The Respondent has listed other requests for relief, classified by the Respondent as compensatory education. As compensatory education, the Respondent requests 240 hours of the Lindamood-Bell LiPS program; 90 hours of Tomatis sound therapy, less the hours already received; private school placement to be implemented when Dr. Asher has “released” STUDENT from what the Respondent’s parents persist in characterizing as a home and hospital placement; tutoring at a frequency of 10 hours per week by a tutor trained in Lindamood-Bell techniques, pending STUDENT’s “release” from home and hospital placement; transportation costs for all of the above; and continuation of all the above services until STUDENT reaches grade-level performance.
The Hearing Officer has found that the District’s offer for the 2002-2003 school year failed to include services designed to remediate STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits and failed to specify accommodation strategies to address STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits in the classroom and learning environment. To that extent, the District’s program offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was not reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and did not meet the requirements for an offer of FAPE.
In addition to the above, however, the Hearing Officer has found that except in the area of auditory processing and the need for further OT assessment, the District’s offer was appropriate. Appropriate components of the offer included placement at Sunrise to address behavior issues, behavior management services, tutoring to reinforce what STUDENT had learned in the Reading Revolution program at the Active Reading Clinic, speech and language services supported by goals and objectives, and special academic instruction by Mr. Sheffel in the fifth-grade class at Sunrise. The program also appropriately addressed at least some of STUDENT’s auditory-processing issues to the extent that, in addition to Reading Revolution tutoring, compensatory strategies were identified to help STUDENT circumvent some of his auditory-processing deficits during the performance of language-based tasks such as reading, writing, and spelling.
In response to the above offer, STUDENT’s parents removed STUDENT from school for all but about three days of a school year that now is nearing completion. The parents’ ongoing insistence on characterizing STUDENT’s situation during the 2002-2003 school year as a “home and hospital” placement has been illusory. STUDENT is not in a home and hospital placement or program, notwithstanding Dr. Asher’s memos and the parents’ interpretation of those memos. STUDENT’s parents made a decision to have STUDENT receive no formal educational program or services during the 2002-2003 school year, except to whatever degree his parents have taught him at home and possibly some Tomatis training. Moreover, the prospects of STUDENT actually receiving a program, either by his IEP team recommending home and hospital instruction or by his parents agreeing to return him to school, were unreasonably obstructed by the refusal of STUDENT’s father to allow the IEP team to obtain additional information and input from Dr. Asher. After considering the respective conduct of the parties in this matter, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the portion of the Tomatis Method already administered, and STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education.
STUDENT is, however, entitled to some relief. STUDENT needs further OT assessment of his dexterity, and the District will be ordered to offer that assessment.(Footnote 24) To correct the deficiencies in the IEP, STUDENT’s IEP team shall be required to amend STUDENT’s IEP in accordance with the findings in this Decision. The IEP shall be amended to provide for intensive one-to-one services designed to remediate STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits. Within the discretion of the IEP team, those added services shall consist either of the Tomatis Method or the LiPS program. On the basis of Dr. Ross-Swain’s testimony, the amount of those services shall either be 80 to 160 hours of LiPS or seventy hours of the Tomatis Method. In choosing between the two alternatives, the team shall consider Dr. Peterson’s testimony that although the likely effectiveness of the LiPS program is supported by data, the LiPS program is similar to Reading Revolution, and STUDENT will already be receiving individual tutoring services to assist him in applying and reinforcing what he has already learned in Reading Revolution. STUDENT’s IEP shall also be amended to provide for accommodation strategies designed to facilitate his receipt and understanding of language-based information and his completion of assignments. The IEP shall provide for implementation of the recommendation by Dr. Peterson that to address STUDENT’s limitations in processing information, STUDENT should be provided information in advance, with cues and more time for responding. The IEP shall also provide for implementation of the recommendations by Dr. Ross-Swain for classroom strategies including use of visual cues concurrent with auditory input, placing STUDENT near the speaker in the classroom, reducing classroom background noise whenever possible, delivering brief and sequential instructions while having STUDENT retain direct eye contact with the speaker, and frequent breaks from listening. Finally, the Respondent shall be reimbursed for transportation costs, if any, associated with his future receipt of Tomatis Method services or the LiPS program.
ORDERS
1. Within 15 days from the date of this Decision and as necessary thereafter, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to accomplish the following:
(A) Develop and submit for parental consent an OT evaluation directed at assessing STUDENT’s dexterity and fine-motor skills. The person or persons conducting the OT evaluation shall consider the findings and concerns that were expressed on that subject by Dr. Peterson in her May 2002 report.
(B) Amend STUDENT’s IEP to provide for intensive one-to-one services designed to remediate STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits. Those added services shall include, but not necessarily be limited to, either the Tomatis Method or the LiPS program. On the basis of Dr. Ross-Swain’s testimony, the amount of those services shall either be 80 to 160 hours of LiPS or seventy hours of the Tomatis Method. The seventy hours of the Tomatis Method would be in addition to whatever number of hours STUDENT may already have received in the Tomatis Method through the date of this Decision. In choosing between the Tomatis Method and LiPS, the team shall consider Dr. Peterson’s testimony that although the likely effectiveness of the LiPS program is supported by data, the LiPS program is similar to Reading Revolution, and STUDENT will already be receiving individual tutoring services to assist him in applying and reinforcing what he has already learned in Reading Revolution.
(C) Amend STUDENT’s IEP to provide for accommodation strategies designed to facilitate STUDENT’s receipt and understanding of language-based information and his completion of assignments, including the provision of information in advance, with cues and more time for responding; use of visual cues concurrent with auditory input; placing STUDENT near the speaker in the classroom; reducing classroom background noise as feasible; delivering brief and sequential instructions while having STUDENT retain direct eye contact with the speaker; and frequent breaks from listening. (D) Reimburse the parent for transportation costs, if any, associated with STUDENT’s future receipt of Tomatis Method services or the LiPS program pursuant to STUDENT’s amended IEP. 2. The order for the above-described amendments to the IEP shall not be construed as permission to reduce the other services specified in the District’s current program offer.
3. Within 15 days from the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s father in the amounts of $350.00 for the OT assessment performed by Ms. Killingsworth in October 2002 and $325.00 for the independent auditory-processing evaluation performed by Dr. Ross-Swain in October 2002.
4. All other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
Issue 1: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2002-2003 school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue only to the extent that the Hearing Officer found the offer to be deficient in the area of auditory processing and that the District needed to conduct further OT assessment. The District prevailed on all other aspects of this issue.
Issue 2: Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the October 2002 independent OT evaluation performed by Denise Killingsworth? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
Issue 3: Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the October 2002 auditory processing evaluation performed by Dr. Ross-Swain? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
Issue 4: Is STUDENT entitled to an independent pervasive developmental disorder (PDD) evaluation at the District’s expense? Neither party prevailed on this issue.
Issue 5: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education and other remedies because of the District’s failure to offer a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year? STUDENT prevailed partially on this issue. Although some relief was ordered, it was predominantly not the relief sought by STUDENT.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(i). Dated: April 30, 2003 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Attorney John F. Eubanks from the law office of Miller Brown & Dannis was present and represented the District on the morning of March 4, 2003. Ms. Estes appeared in place of Mr. Eubanks during the afternoon of March 4, and she was the sole attorney representing the District thereafter. 2. The District, seeking a finding that FAPE was offered, did not specifically state this issue. However, the Hearing Office does not render advisory opinions. Issue 5, inferred from Issue 1, will therefore be addressed in the event that the Hearing Officer finds a denial of FAPE. 3. By letter to Dr. Maier dated February 8, 2001, STUDENT’s mother wrote a lengthy dissent to Dr. Maier’s report. The letter expressed her concern that Dr. Maier had not adequately addressed prior information regarding, among other matters, an auditory processing disorder and sensory-integration dysfunction. 4.STUDENT’s mother did not give her consent to the settlement agreement, and she objected to the dismissal of case number SN99-01431. By order from the Hearing Office dated August 15, 2001, it was determined that pursuant to child custody orders applicable at that time, STUDENT’s mother lacked legal standing to object to the dismissal, and dismissal was granted. 5. The terms “cognitive debriefing” and behavioral “meltdowns” are quoted from the IEP meeting notes. 6.According to Dr. Peterson’s report, STUDENT has average intelligence with “significantly better visual-perceptual skills than verbal intellectual skills overall, with more specific weakness in the areas of working memory.” As measured by Dr. Peterson using the WISC-III, STUDENT had a performance IQ of 121 and a verbal IQ of 98, considered by Dr. Peterson to be a significant discrepancy. 7. In a September 9 letter to the Highlands principal, STUDENT’s father explained that he had removed STUDENT from Highlands because he believed the District was setting the groundwork for STUDENT to fail at Highlands, thereby reinforcing its case for placing STUDENT at Sunrise. He also expressed his suspicions that the District had allowed STUDENT to fail during the prior school year with the intent of necessitating his eventual placement at Sunrise. 8. Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, a special education student shall remain in his or her current educational placement pending resolution of due process hearing procedures, unless the parties agree otherwise. 20 U.S.C. §1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code §§56346(b), 56505(d). This provision is commonly referred to as “stay put.” The purpose of stay put is to maintain the status quo of the student’s educational program pending resolution of the due process hearing. For purposes of stay put, the current educational placement is typically the placement agreed upon in an individualized education program and implemented by the parties prior to the dispute arising. Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education (6th Cir. 1990) 918 F.2d 618. 9. Although the District had not consented to a home and hospital placement, some form of school work had been provided to STUDENT at home. The IEP meeting notes state that upon STUDENT’s expected return to Highlands on October 1, 2002, STUDENT would bring his “completed work.” 10 The District’s program offer for the 2002-2003 school year was reiterated in a November 21, 2002 letter to the father. By letter to Hearing Office dated December 2, 2002, the father expressed his concern that the District’s tactics were jeopardizing his continued legal and physical custody of STUDENT. Consequently, according to the letter, STUDENT and his father had left California with no intention of returning. The letter requested dismissal of the two due process cases pending at that time, citing lack of jurisdiction. The District opposed dismissal of its case, and the request for dismissal denied by the Hearing Officer. On December 24, 2002, the District withdrew its case and informed the Hearing Office that it intended to refile in the event it received information that STUDENT had returned to the District’s jurisdictional boundaries. Three days later, notwithstanding his alleged move out of California, the father filed a new due process hearing request seeking a determination that the District had failed to offer a FAPE from the 1999-2000 school year through present. The District filed the instant due process hearing request on January 15, 2003. The case filed by the father was subsequently withdrawn. The instant case was the only case pending between the parties at the time of hearing. 11. The District’s program offer for the 2002-2003 school year was reiterated in a November 21, 2002 letter to the father. By letter to Hearing Office dated December 2, 2002, the father expressed his concern that the District’s tactics were jeopardizing his continued legal and physical custody of STUDENT. Consequently, according to the letter, STUDENT and his father had left California with no intention of returning. The letter requested dismissal of the two due process cases pending at that time, citing lack of jurisdiction. The District opposed dismissal of its case, and the request for dismissal denied by the Hearing Officer. On December 24, 2002, the District withdrew its case and informed the Hearing Office that it intended to refile in the event it received information that STUDENT had returned to the District’s jurisdictional boundaries. Three days later, notwithstanding his alleged move out of California, the father filed a new due process hearing request seeking a determination that the District had failed to offer a FAPE from the 1999-2000 school year through present. The District filed the instant due process hearing request on January 15, 2003. The case filed by the father was subsequently withdrawn. The instant case was the only case pending between the parties at the time of hearing. 12. The Respondent’s specific objections to the District’s program and placement offer are summarized somewhat differently in the February 28, 2003 Prehearing Conference Order. The Respondent’s contentions as stated by the Hearing Officer throughout this Decision reflect the actual contentions made during the course of the hearing and fully addressed by each party in the evidence and argument presented. The overall issues listed in this Decision remain effectively the same as stated in the Prehearing Conference Order. 13. Dr. Peterson testified regarding her belief that she and Dr. Ross-Swain expressed similar opinions and recommendations, notwithstanding their usage of different terminology. 14. As stated in more detail by Dr. Peterson’s report, STUDENT demonstrates “word-finding difficulties, some articulation problems, as well as difficulties responding at a complex level verbally.” He demonstrates “working memory issues, difficulties processing information quickly, and difficulties organizing himself verbally and visually.” He has weakness in reading fluency and comprehension for complex passages, although single-word decoding when tested by Dr. Peterson was much improved compared to previous tests. Written expression, such as sentence formulation and writing organization are weak. He has difficulties retrieving strategies for solving simple math problems and math facts. Memorization of unrelated facts and sequential memorization are weak. Tasks requiring verbal output are adversely affected by his poor rapid naming, word finding, and working memory skills. His organizational strategies are described as “piecemeal and rarely effective for complex situations.” His assessment scores are considered by Dr. Peterson to “reflect ongoing, residual difficulties classic of a phonemically based learning disability.” 15. The performance IQ of 121 placed STUDENT in the 92nd percentile as measured by the WISC–III. 16. Whether STUDENT’s needs would be better met by the recommendations of Dr. Peterson or the recommendations of Dr. Ross-Swain need not be analyzed. Instead, the pertinent inquiry to be made subsequently in this Decision is whether the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of auditory processing and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. 17. Shari Curtis, an occupational therapist, testified that she and Ms. Barre were both employed by Progresses. She testified that Ms. Barre evaluated STUDENT pursuant to a contractual arrangement between Progresses and the District. She testified regarding the findings in Ms. Barre’s report, but she offered no new information about STUDENT. 18. Dr. Peterson testified at the hearing, and her recommendations remained essentially the same as stated in her report. 19. This meant, as described by Dr. Peterson, that STUDENT was not motivated to respond to rewards such as candy. STUDENT had no interest in such rewards. Instead, his interest was in pleasing the adults important to him, meaning predominantly his parents. However, he perceived his parents as having divergent views of how he should respond to certain situations, and this sometimes led to inappropriate behavioral responses. 20. Dr. Peterson’s recommendation for placement in a more therapeutic setting, such as Sunrise, was shared by Dr. Johnson and Dr. Bullara, behaviorists who had worked with STUDENT. 21. The short-lived August 30, 2002 agreement, considered by the District to be part of its current offer, makes a general reference to adopting Dr. Peterson’s recommendations and monitoring their implementation. 22. Dr. Asher’s testimony at the hearing confirmed that she had no knowledge about STUDENT’s then-current placement and program at Highlands, the proposed placement at Sunrise, or what services would have been provided at Sunrise. Dr. Asher also confirmed in her testimony that she was not an expert in special education matters, and the purpose of her recommendation was basically to give STUDENT some relief from being in a stressful environment at school. 23. The District also failed to offer an OT reassessment.
24. Pending parental consent, STUDENT needs an AT assessment to assist his IEP team in determining whether alternatives to handwriting would be appropriate, and he needs an AB3632 Mental Health assessment. Both are currently being offered by the District.
