California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 4, 2002

Student v. Moraga Elementary School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 764-01 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown

Moraga Elementary and Contra Costa County Mental Health prevail; no reimbursement for Utah residential treatment because eligibility was not shown.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parent filed for due process against Moraga Elementary School District and Contra Costa County Mental Health (CCCMH). She sought reimbursement for her daughter's August 2000 to April 2001 placement at New Haven Residential Treatment Center in Utah. The student was gifted and had never been found eligible for special education. She had obsessive-compulsive symptoms that were severe at home but much milder at school. The parent claimed she was eligible as emotionally disturbed. The parent asked for assessments in August 2000, just before the Utah placement, and signed the assessment plan that September. The District would not send an assessor to Utah. The family did not tell the District about a December visit home. In February 2001, District school psychologist Gayle Lombardi tried to assess the student during another visit, but the student refused testing. After the student came home, the parent and her new therapist asked to delay assessment. Following Lenhoff v. Farmington, Hearing Officer Suzanne Brown found that the District did not have to assess out of state. She held that the parent's delay requests extended the timelines, and that any late or unwritten notice caused no lost educational opportunity. CCCMH's duty to assess was never triggered because no District assessment was completed. The parent had the burden of proof and did not show eligibility, because the student kept good grades and her behaviors did not carry over to school. Without eligibility, there was no FAPE denial and no reimbursement. All claims were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied the Lenhoff rule to a student the parents placed in an out-of-state treatment center. Parents had to make the child reasonably available for assessment. Without a district assessment, the parent could not prove eligibility, and the county mental health agency's AB 3632 duty to assess was not triggered.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1. Did the District fulfill its obligation to assess STUDENT?

    Following Lenhoff, the District did not have to send an assessor to the Utah placement. The parent got actual notice in November 2000, the student was not made available after one unsuccessful attempt, and the parent's requests to delay worked as an agreement to extend timelines. Any notice delay caused no lost educational opportunity.

  2. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2. Did CCCMH fulfill its obligation to assess STUDENT?

    The county mental health agency's duty to assess was never formally triggered because the referral could not include documentation of a completed District assessment, as 2 CCR § 60040(a)(1) requires.

  3. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 3. Was Petitioner eligible for special education services and AB 3632 mental health services from August 2000 to April 2001?

    Petitioner had the burden of proof and did not show emotional disturbance that adversely affected educational performance or required special education. She kept passing or good grades, and her behaviors did not carry over to school.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE from August 2000 to April 2001 by failing to offer the placement and services that Petitioner needed?

    Because eligibility was not established, no FAPE obligation was shown. The Hearing Officer did not reach placement or services but found that Respondents prevailed.

  5. Issue 5. Are Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of her placement at New Haven Treatment Center?

    No reimbursement because there was no eligibility finding and no finding that the agencies denied a FAPE.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Lenhoff v. Farmington School District; Patricia P. v. Board of Education of Oak Park; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Rim of the World Unified School District v. Student, SN 1742-98; Student v. Pleasanton Unified School District and Alameda County Mental Health, SN 1546-98; Student v. Oxnard Elementary School District and Ventura County Behavioral Health, SN 272-98

People named in the decision

  • Cheryl Hazell-Small, District director of pupil services/special education; District representative, Moraga Elementary School District
  • Laura Ing, CCCMH program manager; agency representative, Contra Costa County Mental Health
  • JoAnn DePetro, private therapist (witness for Student), Private
  • Claire Ames-Klein, private clinical psychologist (witness for Student), Private
  • Michael Allen, licensed clinical social worker, primary therapist at residential treatment center (witness for Student), New Haven Residential Treatment Center
  • Sara Harkness, registered nurse and family friend (witness for Student), Private
  • Kaaren Rose, English teacher, Joaquin Moraga Intermediate School, Moraga Elementary School District
  • Frances Strykowski, history/computer teacher, Joaquin Moraga Intermediate School, Moraga Elementary School District
  • Gayle Lombardi, school psychologist/assessor, Moraga Elementary School District
  • David Bergeson, CCCMH case manager, Contra Costa County Mental Health
  • Tom Lee, CCCMH case manager, Contra Costa County Mental Health
  • Phillip Shain, private psychiatrist, Private
  • Jeremy Coles, clinical psychologist assessor, Herrick Hospital
  • Hal Goldberg, psychiatric evaluator, Not stated
  • New Haven Residential Treatment Center, out-of-state residential treatment center (unilateral placement), Spanish Fork, Utah

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on August 20 and 21, 2002, in Moraga, California, before Suzanne Brown, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by her mother, MOTHER. Respondent Moraga Elementary School District (District) was represented by Cheryl Hazell-Small, District director of pupil services. Respondent Contra Costa County Mental Health (CCCMH) was represented by Laura Ing, CCCMH program manager.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: JoAnn DePetro, STUDENT’s current therapist; Dr. Claire Ames-Klein, clinical psychologist; Michael Allen, licensed clinical social worker at New Haven Treatment Center; Sara Harkness, registered nurse and family friend; MOTHER; and BROTHER, STUDENT’s twenty-year-old brother.

Respondents called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Kaaren Rose, English teacher at the District’s Joaquin Moraga Intermediate School (Joaquin Moraga); Frances Strykowski, history/computer teacher at Joaquin Moraga; District school psychologist Gayle Lombardi; David Bergeson, CCCMH case manager; Tom Lee, CCCMH case manager; Ms. Ing and Ms. Hazell-Small. Oral and documentary evidence was received. Upon receipt of the parties’ written closing briefs, the record closed on September 6, 2002, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

(1) Did the District fulfill its obligation to assess STUDENT? (2) Did CCCMH fulfill its obligation to assess STUDENT?

(3) Was Petitioner eligible for special education services and AB 3632 mental health services from August 2000 to April 2001?

(4) Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE from August 2000 to April 2001 by failing to offer appropriate placement and services?

(5) Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of her placement at New Haven Treatment Center?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old student who resides with her mother, MOTHER, in Moraga, California, which is within the boundaries of Moraga Elementary School District (District) and Contra Costa County Mental Health (CCCMH). She has two older brothers who currently attend college out of state. Her father, FATHER, previously resided in Orinda but moved to Virginia in the summer of 2001.(Footnote 2) STUDENT has completed eighth grade and therefore no longer attends school at the District. She is currently a sophomore at Miramonte High School, which is within the Acalanes Union High School District. She has never been found eligible for special education.

STUDENT attended third, fourth and fifth grades at District elementary schools. Throughout those elementary school years, STUDENT received above-average to outstanding grades and progress reports. She consistently obtained high scores on the Stanford-9 Achievement Tests, Iowa Test of Basic Skills and other standardized tests, with scores in the 99th percentile in several subject areas.

For the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT attended sixth grade at the District’s Joaquin Moraga Intermediate School (Joaquin Moraga), where she received mostly A’s and a few B’s. During the late spring and summer of 1999, STUDENT’s family members noticed STUDENT performing a ritual in which she took a step forward and then a step backward. (Testimony of MOTHER, BROTHER.) STUDENT’s parents brought STUDENT to a psychiatrist, but STUDENT strongly resisted the treatment. During this time and for a lengthy period thereafter, STUDENT developed an intense hatred for her parents, in large part due to their insistence that she receive psychiatric treatment. (Testimony of BROTHER, Michael Allen.)

In fall 1999, STUDENT entered seventh grade at Joaquin Moraga. STUDENT’s family members observed that her rituals were increasing at home, although she did not appear to be displaying any noticeable behaviors at school. At school, she received above-average grades and played on the girls’ basketball team. During this time period, STUDENT’s parents brought her to Dr. Phillip Shain for psychiatric treatment, but STUDENT continued to resist that treatment. STUDENT’s behaviors at home became more severe and included aggressive behaviors as well as obsessive-compulsive behaviors; STUDENT’s mother reported that the family called the police on some occasions due to STUDENT’s out-of-control behavior. (Testimony of MOTHER; Petitioner’s Exh. p. 2.) In January 2000, STUDENT began therapy with Dr. Clare Ames-Klein, a psychologist. In February 2000, after an incident in which she punched her mother in the stomach, STUDENT was hospitalized as a danger to herself or others. During her hospitalization, an assessment conducted by clinical psychologist Dr. Jeremy Coles diagnosed STUDENT with Major Depression with psychotic features and noted that STUDENT was experiencing a great deal of anxiety. Dr. Coles recommended intensive psychotherapy and psychotropic medications. However, STUDENT refused to take psychotropic medications; eventually she received injections of anti-psychotic medication against her will, and she experienced some negative physical reactions to that medication.

After approximately two weeks, STUDENT was released from Herrick Hospital in March 2000 and returned to seventh grade at Joaquin Moraga. After returning to school, STUDENT appeared to have a brief period of relative improvement. (Testimony of Dr. Ames-Klein, MOTHER.) She resumed her treatment with Dr. Ames-Klein, but still would perform rituals before entering Dr. Ames-Klein’s office. Dr. Ames-Klein also reported that STUDENT demonstrated intense anger towards her parents. (Testimony of Dr. Ames-Klein; Pet. Exh. p. 12-13.) STUDENT continued to attend school and basketball practice, but would not go to her father’s home in nearby Orinda.

During the spring of 2000, STUDENT’s behavior deteriorated. Sara Harkness, a registered nurse and family friend, testified that STUDENT appeared more disorganized, stressed and suspicious of others as time went on. Ms. Harkness described how STUDENT exhibited ritualistic/compulsive behaviors and had difficulty with dressing and grooming herself. Ms. Harkness testified that STUDENT would refuse to get in and out of cars; however, sometimes when STUDENT would refuse to get into her mother’s car, she would agree to get in Ms. Harkness’s car, so Ms. Harkness would drive STUDENT to therapy. Dr. Ames-Klein testified that STUDENT’s rituals before entering the therapist’s office grew lengthier over time, and also that STUDENT had picked on her skin and created skin wounds. Dr. Ames-Klein further reported that STUDENT refused to have any verbal communication with her mother or father. (Pet. Exh. p. 12.)

While there is no question that STUDENT engaged in extensive obsessive-compulsive behaviors while at home, she was nevertheless able to attend school and function fairly normally there, although not as well as she had previously functioned. Her English teacher, Kaaren Rose, testified regarding STUDENT’s behavior in seventh grade. Ms. Rose testified that STUDENT was a very bright, motivated student with some organizational problems that grew significantly worse over the course of the school year. Ms. Rose described how, during the second semester, STUDENT would take fifteen to twenty minutes in class merely to get out her books and other materials. Also during the second semester, STUDENT stopped handing in any assignments. Ms. Rose contacted STUDENT’s mother and expressed her serious concerns about STUDENT’s behavior. (See also Petitioner’s Exh. pg. 7.) MOTHER concurred with Ms. Rose’s concerns but explained that STUDENT was receiving private therapy and that the family was handling the matter privately. MOTHER mentioned that STUDENT was very concerned that no one at Joaquin Moraga learn of her difficulties. Ms. Rose testified that she accepted MOTHER’s explanations, in part because she wanted to respect STUDENT’s privacy and in part because she believed that, as a school psychologist, MOTHER would handle the matter appropriately. Ms. Rose continued to discuss her concerns with some of STUDENT’s other seventh-grade teachers, who were also concerned about STUDENT’s behavior at school.

In June 2000, STUDENT completed her seventh grade year at Joaquin Moraga. She received an overall grade point average of 3.2 for the year. However, for the final term, Ms. Rose gave STUDENT a grade of “NM,” meaning “No Mark.” Ms. Rose testified that she knew about STUDENT’s personal difficulties and, in light of that information, did not want to give STUDENT the grade of D or F that she had earned and would have otherwise received.

After school ended in June 2000, STUDENT’s behaviors deteriorated much further. STUDENT enjoyed school and it provided her with needed structure, so the removal of that positive aspect of her life appeared to contribute to her further deterioration. (Testimony of BROTHER, Mr. Allen, Dr. Ames-Klein.) STUDENT’s mother also testified that another key factor in STUDENT’s decline at this time was her distress over her brother BROTHER’s high school graduation and impending move out of the house to attend college out of state.

During this period in June and July 2000, STUDENT engaged in extensive rituals that often took hours and interfered with her performing regular activities, including leaving the house each day. In the evening, STUDENT would go outside onto the family’s driveway, where she engaged in lengthy rituals that often lasted until 3 or 4 o’clock in the morning and required another family member to stay awake in order to let STUDENT into the house after the rituals were completed. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Harkness, BROTHER.) STUDENT would not touch the doorknob or open the door herself, and would become extremely agitated and aggressive if someone was not available to open the door for her when she wanted. STUDENT also demonstrated disturbances in eating, sleeping, dressing, grooming and elimination. She stopped grooming herself, refused to eat most foods, and would sometimes defecate onto newspaper instead of using the toilet. (Testimony of Dr. Ames-Klein, Ms. Harkness.) She generally stopped communicating verbally and instead communicated primarily with grunts. On some occasions, STUDENT would scream uncontrollably or become aggressive, which sometimes resulted in police visits to the home. (Id.; testimony of MOTHER, BROTHER.) Because her behaviors prevented her from being transported to therapy, Dr. Ames-Klein instead went to the family’s house to see STUDENT.

On July 30, 2000, during a period when Dr. Ames-Klein was on vacation, STUDENT was hospitalized, apparently pursuant to a determination by her parents, her pediatrician and Dr. Ames-Klein. A psychiatric evaluation of STUDENT by Dr. Hal Goldberg on August 2 contained diagnoses including obsessive-compulsive disorder (Axis II) and a global assessment of functioning (GAF) of 20 (Axis V).

On August 11, 2000, MOTHER both sent a letter to and telephoned the District’s director of special education, Cheryl Hazell-Small, to request a concurrent special education assessment and AB3632 mental health assessment for STUDENT. In her letter, MOTHER stated that she anticipated “that STUDENT will be transferred to New Haven, a residential treatment facility next Monday, August 14th.” (Dist. Exh. II-75.)

On August 13, 2000, STUDENT was admitted at New Haven Residential Treatment Center in Spanish Fork, Utah. Her treatment plan at New Haven, dated August 27, contained Axis I diagnoses of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), Oppositional Defiant Disorder (ODD) and Parent-Child Relational Problem, and a then-current GAF of 50, although noting that in the past year her best GAF had been 30. (CCCMH Exh. 4; Pet. Exh. pgs. 20-23.) Her primary therapist at New Haven, Michael Allen, testified that STUDENT had two primary issues: (1) disturbed emotions and poor coping skills, which included her OCD and (2) poor family relationship, including ODD at home although not at school. Mr. Allen indicated that, at admission, STUDENT’s problems included that she was moody, angry, irrational, emotionally unstable, frequently depressed, very distraught with her home situation, very anxious and socially withdrawn. She also had poor social judgment, poor understanding of social rules, and paranoid thoughts about other people. She demonstrated acute OCD, and was preoccupied with unusual activities such as her obsessive-compulsive behaviors. These problems were generally identified by the physician who participated in drafting STUDENT’s New Haven Master Treatment Plan. (Id.)

Shortly after her admission to New Haven, New Haven staff conducted a battery of psychodiagnostic tests on STUDENT, including the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory - Adolescent (MMPI-A) and the Millon Adolescent Clinical Inventory (MACI). The assessing psychologist’s findings included that STUDENT tends to minimize and deny problems, that she tends to avoid any self-disclosure of problems, and that she may have a diagnosis of Histrionic and Antisocial Personality Disorder with Narcissistic and Compulsive features. New Haven staff also administered cognitive and achievement tests to STUDENT. On the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC-III), STUDENT obtained IQ scores of 140 verbal IQ, 133 performance IQ and 140 full-scale IQ(Footnote 3). On the Woodcock Johnson-Revised (WJ-R), she obtained scores primarily in the 98th and 99th percentiles, with a few scores in the 77th to 88th percentiles and a Word Attack subtest score in the 58th percentile. (CCCMH Exh. 1.)

On September 13, 2000, MOTHER met with Ms. Hazell-Small, the District’s special education director. MOTHER signed a special education assessment plan and signed consent for a referral to CCCMH for an AB3632 mental health assessment. (Dist. Exhs. II-71, II-72.) MOTHER wrote on the assessment plan: “All assessments to be coordinated through Mike Allen, STUDENT’s therapist at New Haven.” Ms. Hazell-Small indicated to MOTHER that STUDENT would need to be made available for an assessment locally. MOTHER indicated that STUDENT’s condition was fragile and requested that the District send someone to Utah to conduct the assessment there. Ms. Hazell-Small said she would look into whether that was possible.

On September 20, 2000, the District sent CCCMH a mental health referral regarding STUDENT. The letter stated that it was “a request for a concurrent assessment between the Moraga School District and Contra Costa County Children’s Mental Health/AB 3632.” (Pet. Exh. pg. 33.)

Over the next few months, MOTHER and Ms. Hazell-Small spoke with each other regarding arranging the assessment of STUDENT by District staff. Ms. Hazell-Small testified that, as a professional courtesy to MOTHER, who is a school psychologist, the District attempted to arrange for a District school psychologist to travel to Utah to assess STUDENT, but was not successful in those attempts. Thereafter, Ms. Hazell-Small verbally informed MOTHER that no District staff member was available to go to Utah. (Testimony of Ms. Hazell-Small.) However, MOTHER understood that the assessment would be conducted in Utah by CCCMH staff. (Testimony of MOTHER; Pet. Exh. pgs. 38-40.)

In late November 2000, MOTHER spoke with CCCMH case manager David Bergeson regarding the logistics of arranging STUDENT’s assessment. MOTHER explained that STUDENT might be able to come back to Moraga for a visit during the winter break but that her condition was very fragile. MOTHER expressed her concern that STUDENT might become destabilized by an assessment and that then the family would be unable to get her back on the plane to Utah. (Testimony of David Bergeson; see also testimony of MOTHER; Pet. Exh. pgs. 38-40, 54.) MOTHER also mentioned that she was nervous about whether STUDENT would be able to travel to Mr. Bergeson’s office for an assessment, but Mr. Bergeson indicated that he could visit STUDENT at her home in Moraga to do the assessment. (Id.)

STUDENT did visit Moraga for one week over the winter break, but her parents did not inform the District or CCCMH of the visit. Mr. Allen advised MOTHER that STUDENT’s condition was fragile and being assessed might negatively affect her. Mr. Allen testified that, during that period, STUDENT would likely have been very uncooperative, anxious and suspicious towards a new, unknown person conducting an assessment of her.

In January 2001, CCMH caseworker Tom Lee visited STUDENT at New Haven. Mr. Lee was in Utah on another case and had agreed to drive from that destination to Spanish Fork to see STUDENT. Mr. Lee met with STUDENT only briefly, in part because she had the flu. During their discussion, STUDENT admitted to Mr. Lee that she had previously had problems with OCD and that she had had a lot of anger towards her parents, but stated that both her OCD symptoms and her anger towards her parents had subsided. Mr. Lee also spoke with STUDENT’s therapist, Michael Allen, who described the severity of STUDENT’s behaviors when she had been admitted to New Haven. Mr. Lee did not reach any conclusions regarding STUDENT’s eligibility for mental health services, but did conclude that STUDENT appeared to have benefitted from her time at New Haven. He did not observe any OCD symptoms, although he did notice, and Mr. Allen later confirmed, that STUDENT avoided touching doors and light switches.

Also in January 2001, MOTHER and Ms. Hazell-Small discussed by telephone the scheduling of the assessment and the subsequent IEP meeting. In a phone call and follow-up letter, both dated January 29, 2001, Ms. Hazell-Small informed STUDENT’s parents that the District was willing to hold the IEP meeting but would not be able to determine STUDENT’s special education eligibility because the District still had not been able to complete its own assessment of STUDENT. The letter acknowledged that the District had received assessment information about STUDENT from New Haven, Herrick Hospital and Dr. Claire Ames-Klein; however, the letter explained that while the District would consider that information, it had “no obligation to accept that data in lieu of completing its own assessment.” (Pet. Exh. pgs. 36-37.)

In response, STUDENT’s mother sent a reply dated January 30, 2001, disputing the District’s position. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 38-40.) MOTHER wrote that, while she understood the District’s right to have its own staff perform the assessment, she did not understand why that was necessary in light of the circumstances; MOTHER noted that the District “already [had] ample data upon which to base an eligibility determination” and always had the option of hiring someone in Utah to do the assessment if District staff could not travel to New Haven. MOTHER wrote that “there is nothing I would like more than to have STUDENT be well enough to be home and be evaluated in Moraga. Unfortunately, the severity of her condition has precluded that.” MOTHER confirmed that STUDENT might be returning home for another visit in early February, which might offer an opportunity for the District to attempt an assessment, depending on STUDENT’s condition. (Id.) Thereafter, in a letter dated January 31, 2001, Mr. Allen wrote Ms. Hazell-Small regarding the same issue. Mr. Allen’s letter explained that “it is part of STUDENT’s pattern to be very guarded, suspicious of adults and their motives, distressed by a change and intervention in her life and mortified at the prospect of being scrutinized and judged.” The letter asserted that the proposed attempt to assess STUDENT at that point was “too risky.” (Dist. Exh. II-55.)

STUDENT did return to Moraga for a family visit in February 2001. STUDENT’s parents arranged with the District to have District school psychologist Gayle Lombardi visit STUDENT at her father’s home in Orinda and conduct the assessment there. When Ms. Lombardi arrived at STUDENT’s father’s home to conduct the assessment, FATHER warned her that STUDENT had indicated that she would not participate in any formal testing. Ms. Lombardi testified that when she met STUDENT, STUDENT politely but firmly stated that she would not do any tests. Thereafter, STUDENT chatted with Ms. Lombardi about various topics, including movies, television and New Haven. However, STUDENT continued to refuse to do any testing activities for Ms. Lombardi, either that day or the following day.(Footnote 4) (Testimony of Ms. Lombardi.) At one point during the conversation, STUDENT went into another room to obtain a folder that she wished to show Ms. Lombardi. Ms. Lombardi observed STUDENT open doorknobs and walk through doorways without any apparent difficulty. (Id.)

In her subsequent report, Ms. Lombardi summarized her interviews with STUDENT and MOTHER and her review of STUDENT’s various private assessments. Ms. Lombardi concluded that she did not have adequate data to determine whether STUDENT was eligible for special education, although she indicated that during the interview STUDENT’s behavior “was appropriate and did not indicate any significant emotional distress, including depression, histrionics or obsessive-compulsive disorder.” (Dist. Exh. II-16.) Additionally, noting STUDENT’s good grades at Joaquin Moraga, Ms. Lombardi concluded that “there is no evidence of characteristics adversely affecting educational performance.” Ms. Lombardi also stated that she had established rapport with STUDENT during the interview and could likely complete an assessment in two or three subsequent sessions.

STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP) team met on March 20, 2001. District staff and CCCMH staff concluded that “additional assessment is necessary - there is not adequate data to determine eligibility for special education and related services.” STUDENT’s mother disagreed with that finding, although she agreed to try to make STUDENT available again for assessment once STUDENT permanently came back from Utah and returned to school at Joaquin Moraga in April 2001. Thereafter, in a letter dated March 30, 2001, MOTHER wrote that “given [STUDENT’s] extreme sensitivity to being perceived as ‘different,’ I am requesting that an assessment not be attempted at the school and that I be contacted to arrange another location.” (Pet. Exh. 59.) The IEP team agreed to give STUDENT some readjustment time before attempting the assessment again.

During her time at New Haven, STUDENT consistently did well in her academic classes. She completed her stay at New Haven with a 3.69 grade-point average.

As scheduled, STUDENT completed her stay at New Haven and returned to attending Joaquin Moraga in April 2001, at the beginning of the fourth quarter of the school calendar. Upon her return to California, STUDENT began seeing a new therapist, JoAnn DePetro. In a letter dated April 26, 2001, Ms. DePetro wrote the District to request that any assessment be postponed to allow STUDENT time to readjust to living at home and attending Joaquin Moraga. (Dist. Exh. II-7.)

On April 18, 2001, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing. In early June 2001, prior to STUDENT’s graduation from Joaquin Moraga, Ms. Hazell-Small attempted to arrange with the parents for another assessment attempt, but no further assessment ever took place. In June 2001, STUDENT completed the fourth quarter at Joaquin Moraga, earning all A’s on her report card and graduating from the District, which serves only kindergarten through eighth grade students. For the 2001-2002 school year, she attended ninth grade at Miramonte High School in the Acalanes Union High School District. During that school year, she earned all A’s and played on sports teams. She continued to see Ms. DePetro for therapy sessions. She also continued to exhibit some OCD symptoms at home, such as avoidance of turning on water or walking through the front door, but was nevertheless able to attend school and function relatively normally. (Testimony of BROTHER, Ms. DePetro, MOTHER.)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

(1) Did the District fulfill its obligation to assess STUDENT?

Before any action is taken with respect to the initial special education placement of a student, the student must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. (California Education Code § 56320.) The process for assessment begins with a written referral for assessment by the parent, teacher, school personnel, or other appropriate agency or person. (California Education Code § 56302, 56321(a); Title 5 CCR § 3021.) Within 15 days of referral, not counting days between the pupil’s regular school sessions or terms, or school vacations in excess of five days, the parent must be given a written assessment plan which explains the types of assessments to be conducted and meets certain other requirements. (California Education Code § 56321.) The parent then has 15 days to consent in writing to the proposed assessment. (California Education Code § 56321(c).) Once the signed assessment plan is received by the school district, it has 50 days, excluding vacation days in excess of five school days, to complete the assessments and develop an initial IEP if the student is found eligible for special education. (California Education Code § 56344.) During that 50-day period, the parents must make the student reasonably available to the District’s assessors, so that the assessment may be completed. (See Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987); Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176, 178 (5th Cir. 1995).)

In the present case, STUDENT’s mother requested the assessment on August 11, 2000, between STUDENT’s regular school sessions. The District developed the assessment plan and MOTHER signed her consent to the assessment on September 13, 2000, but then did not make STUDENT available to be assessed in the Moraga area because STUDENT had been placed at New Haven Treatment Center in Utah since mid-August 2000. Therefore, the primary question becomes whether the District was obligated to conduct the assessment in Utah, and if so when that obligation was triggered. There are two time periods at issue: (1) between September 13, 2000, and early February 2001 and (2) after early February 2001.

Regarding assessments of students unilaterally placed outside the state, the Hearing Office generally follows the line of cases ruling that school districts are not legally obligated to travel out of the state to conduct assessments. (See, e.g., Lenhoff v. Farmington School District, 680 F.Supp. 921 (E.D.Mich 1988), 1997-1998 IDELR Dec. 559:401; Patricia P. v. Board of Education of Oak Park, 8 F.Supp.2d 801 (Ill.1998); Rim of the World Unified School District v. Student, Case No. SN 1742-98 (Decision, April 7, 1999); Student v. Oxnard Elementary School District and Ventura County Behavioral Health, Case No. SN 272-98.)

However, the Hearing Office has also recognized that the application of this rule may depend on the facts of the particular case at hand. In a 1999 order, the Hearing Office held that California has no per se rule automatically relieving LEAs from the obligation to assess students who have been unilaterally placed out of state. (Student v. Pleasanton Unified School District and Alameda County Mental Health Case No. SN 1546-98 (Order Re: Motion To Dismiss Alameda County Mental Health, January 25, 1999).) That order explained that while the reasoning of Lenhoff is generally persuasive, the question of whether Lenhoff controls in a given case may be influenced by the circumstances of the particular case. Such circumstances may include the nature of the student’s disability, the level of risk involved in removing the student from the placement and transporting him or her back to the assessing agency, whether or not the student has already been found eligible for special education services, and the potential levels of cost and difficulty in arranging for an assessment at the student’s out of state placement.

The District argues that, pursuant to Lenhoff and related cases, it was not obligated to assess STUDENT while she was in Utah. Moreover, the District argues that Petitioner’s parents were obligated to make her available for assessment when she returned to the Bay Area for a visit in December 2000, but that the parents did not notify the District of Petitioner’s availability and thus did not fulfill that obligation.

In contrast, Petitioner argues that the Lenhoff rule should not be strictly applied here due to the circumstances of this case. In her closing brief, Petitioner argues that “given the nature and severity of STUDENT’s emotional difficulties...prior to February [2001], transporting her to Moraga and making her available for an assessment presented significant risk to her emotional well-being.” (Pet. Closing Brief, p.10.)

STUDENT’s mother had informed the District in September 2000 that STUDENT’s condition was fragile and that the parents sought to have the assessment conducted in Utah. Both MOTHER and STUDENT’s New Haven therapist, Michael Allen, indicated via testimony and letters they wrote to the District in late January 2001 that undergoing an assessment could create a setback for STUDENT, that she would likely have a negative reaction to an assessment conducted by a stranger, and that she would be unlikely to comply with those assessment attempts. MOTHER was credible in her testimony that, in light of information from Mr. Allen about STUDENT’s condition, she was reluctant to allow the assessment in Moraga because of concerns that an assessment by an unknown individual outside of STUDENT’s therapeutic environment could destabilize her already fragile condition.(Footnote 5)

However, prior to late January/early February 2001, the District did not have the benefit of this information in its evaluation of whether it would need to send staff to Utah to conduct the assessment. In addition, MOTHER failed to inform the District that STUDENT was home in December 2000 but that it was believed that an assessment would be too risky due to STUDENT’s condition. While MOTHER discussed with CCCMH employee David Bergeson the concerns that STUDENT would not be able to handle assessment in Moraga during a planned visit in December 2000, that information was never conveyed to the District. Had the District been informed ahead of time of the December 2000 visit, and had it known of the supporting information from New Haven regarding STUDENT’s condition, the District could have participated with the parents in evaluating what accommodations STUDENT required to be able to undergo the assessment, including whether her condition warranted assessing her in Utah instead of Moraga.

Therefore, in light of all circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the Lenhoff rule remains applicable in this case. At least as early as December 2000, STUDENT was able to travel back to California. Moreover, from September 2000 until approximately January 31, 2001, the District did not have sufficient information that would have indicated a need to travel to Utah to assess STUDENT. While MOTHER was genuine in her concerns about the effect of an assessment on STUDENT’s well-being, those concerns did not justify the failure to notify the District of STUDENT’s presence in Moraga in December 2000; at a minimum, the District should have been given the opportunity to determine whether STUDENT’s condition would have permitted an assessment in Moraga at that time or whether her condition warranted sending an assessor to Utah. Accordingly, the factual information available to the District prior to approximately January 31, 2001, did not trigger an obligation of the District to travel to Utah to assess STUDENT.

Petitioner further argues that, in any event, the District took an ambiguous position regarding whether it would be able to conduct the assessment in Utah and that, therefore, her parents did not know until January 29, 2001 that the District was insisting upon STUDENT being made available for assessment in the Moraga area. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 38-40.) The Hearing Officer considers that, in November 2000, Ms. Hazell-Small verbally informed MOTHER that the assessment would have to take place in the Moraga area, not in Utah, because the District would not be able to send an assessor to Utah. (Testimony of Ms. Hazell-Small; see also Pet. Exh. pgs. 36-40.) Thus, MOTHER received actual notice of the District’s determination that it would not be sending an assessor to Utah and that therefore the assessment would need to be conducted in the Moraga area.

The District did not provide this information in writing until January 29, 2001, when Ms. Hazell-Small informed MOTHER by telephone and in writing that the District was still not able to determine STUDENT’s special education eligibility because it still had not been able to conduct its own assessment of STUDENT. In a letter dated January 30, 2001, MOTHER replied that she had been under the impression that the District had obtained enough information from private assessments and CCCMH’s assessment to determine eligibility, although she acknowledged that she understood that the District had the right to conduct its own assessment. (Id.)

It is of concern that in November 2000 the District did not provide clearer and more timely notice of its refusal to travel to Utah. Arguably the District’s refusal to travel to Utah may have warranted written notice pursuant to the IDEA as a refusal to “change or initiate the identification, evaluation or educational placement of the child....” (34 C.F.R. section 300.503(a)(ii).) Had the District provided this information in writing, the Hearing Officer would be able to review the exact language of the notice and therefore be better able to evaluate whether the parent could have reasonably been confused about the meaning of the information provided to her.

Additionally, given that the parent signed the assessment plan on September 13, 2000, it is of concern that the District did not confirm until November 2000 that the assessment could not take place in Utah. Although it is appreciated that the District was making attempts to accommodate the parents’ request beyond the District’s legal obligation to do so, the fifty-day timeline for assessment and convening the IEP meeting permits little delay in conducting the assessment.

While the above facts raise concerns, the Hearing Officer also considers that MOTHER nevertheless received actual notice in November 2000 that the District would not be sending an assessor to Utah. Furthermore, as discussed below, this Decision does not find STUDENT eligible for special education. In light of all factors, any delay in notifying MOTHER of the District’s decision not to travel to Utah, or any delay in providing written notice of this decision, did not create a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT or seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP process. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).) Because the District was not obligated to travel to Utah to conduct the assessment, and because it provided MOTHER with actual notice of its decision not to go to Utah, the District had no legal obligation to assess STUDENT while she remained in Utah prior to late January 2001.

The Hearing Officer must now consider whether the District was obligated to conduct STUDENT’s assessment in Utah after New Haven’s notification in late January 2001 that sending STUDENT back to Moraga for assessment would likely be detrimental to her. Within a few days of that notification to the District, STUDENT returned to California for a visit and was made available for assessment. At that time, a District school psychologist met with STUDENT and attempted to conduct the assessment on February 5, 2001. Because this attempt was unsuccessful, the District’s school psychologist required additional days to conduct the assessment.

However, STUDENT was not made available for assessment thereafter. Shortly after meeting with Ms. Lombardi on February 5, 2001, STUDENT went back to New Haven and remained there until early April 2001, when she returned home to attend school in Moraga. Regarding whether the District was obligated after late January 2001 to travel to Utah to complete the assessment, the information from New Haven regarding STUDENT’s fragile condition was, to some extent, tempered by Ms. Lombardi’s observations of STUDENT during the assessment attempt on February 5. Ms. Lombardi did not observe any indicia consistent with emotional disturbance, and noted that STUDENT appeared comfortable chatting with the school psychologist. Ms. Lombardi’s observations were consistent with other evidence at the hearing indicating that STUDENT’s condition was showing significant improvement during that time period. (See testimony of Mr. Allen, MOTHER, Mr. Lee.) Thus, to the extent Mr. Allen’s letter in late January 2001 created an obligation for the District to travel to Utah to conduct STUDENT’s assessment, that obligation was mitigated due to the improvement in STUDENT’s condition and the District’s assessor’s observations of STUDENT’s improved condition. In any event, the District learned in late March 2001 that STUDENT would likely be returning to Moraga in late April 2001; at that time, the District could have reasonably concluded that it did not need to travel to Utah because STUDENT would soon become available for assessment in Moraga.

Shortly before STUDENT’s scheduled return to Moraga, STUDENT’s IEP team convened. MOTHER indicated to the other members of the IEP team that STUDENT needed time to readjust to Moraga before she would be able to undergo assessment. (See Pet. Exh. pgs. 59, 60.) The IEP team agreed to give STUDENT some readjustment time before attempting the assessment again. In late April 2001, Ms. Lombardi contacted MOTHER to schedule the assessment; in response, MOTHER requested that the assessment be delayed until after June 25 because STUDENT was having a difficult time readjusting to Joaquin Moraga. (Dist. Exh. II-3.) Additionally, STUDENT’s new therapist, JoAnn DePetro, wrote to Ms. Hazell-Small to explain that STUDENT needed more time to readjust before undergoing testing. (Dist. Exh. II-2, II-7.) In early June 2001, prior to STUDENT’s graduation from Joaquin Moraga, Ms. Hazell-Small wrote to MOTHER regarding arranging a new date for the assessment, but no further assessment took place.(Footnote 6) In mid-June 2001, STUDENT graduated from both eighth grade and the District.

In light of these facts, the District did not fail to fulfill its obligation to assess STUDENT. As detailed above, the District notified the parent in November 2000 that STUDENT would need to be made available in the Moraga area. While STUDENT was made available on February 5, 2001, that attempt was unsuccessful, and therefore the District’s school psychologist required additional days to complete the assessment.(Footnote 7) Because STUDENT was not made available on any subsequent days thereafter, the District did not have any further opportunity to conduct its assessment. Regarding MOTHER’s requests in spring 2001 to delay the assessment until after STUDENT had time to readjust, in effect these requests operated as a temporary withdrawal of consent or, at a minimum, an agreement to delay the assessment and extend the timelines.

Thus, in light of all circumstances, the District met its obligations regarding assessment of STUDENT.

(2) Did CCCMH fulfill its obligation to assess STUDENT?

California law defines a mental health assessment as “a service designed to provide formal, documented evaluation or analysis of the nature of the pupil’s emotional or behavioral disorder,” and requires that a mental health assessment be conducted in accordance with Education Code sections 56320 through 56329. (2 C.C.R. § 60020(g).) A local educational agency (“LEA”), individualized education program team or parent may initiate a referral for a student’s assessment to the community mental health agency. (Cal. Gov’t Code § 7576(b); 2 C.C.R. § 60040(a).) Within five days of receiving the referral, the community mental health agency shall review the recommendation for a mental health assessment and determine if such assessment is necessary. (2 C.C.R. § 60045(a).) However, in the case of a psychiatric emergency, this referral process does not apply, and instead a parent may seek services from other public programs or private providers, as appropriate. (2 C.C.R. § 60040(e).)

In the present case, the District sent CCCMH a concurrent referral dated September 20, 2000. The letter stated that it was “a request for a concurrent assessment between the Moraga School District and Contra Costa County Children’s Mental Health/AB 3632.” (Pet. Exh. pg. 33.) Thereafter, CCCMH never completed the requested assessment of STUDENT’s eligibility for AB 3632 mental health services. CCCMH argues that its obligation to conduct that assessment was never triggered because the District never made a finding of special education eligibility, and thus did not formally make a mental health referral pursuant to California Government Code section 7576(b) and Title 2, Cal. Code of Regulations section 60040.

While section 60040(a) permits a district to refer a student suspected of having a disability to the community mental health agency, section 60040(a)(1) requires that prior to such referral a district assessment must have been completed. The regulations are not clear on whether a district must have previously found a child eligible prior to a referral to the community mental health agency. Section 60040(a) does state that an IEP team may refer for a mental health assessment a child suspected of having a disability. Section 60040(a)(1), however, requires that as part of the referral package, the district shall include documentation that “the pupil has been assessed by school personnel in accordance with Article 2, commencing with section 56320 of Part 30 of the Education Code.”

In the present case, the District’s referral to CCCMH did not provide documentation of STUDENT’s assessment by District personnel, because that assessment never took place. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concurs that CCCMH’s duty to assess was not yet formally triggered because the District had not found STUDENT eligible for special education. Accordingly, CCCMH did not fail to fulfill any obligations to assess Petitioner.

(3) Was Petitioner eligible for special education services and AB 3632 mental health services from August 2000 to April 2001?

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and state law, only children with certain disabilities, including emotional disturbance, are eligible for special education services. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); Education Code § 56026(a).) In order for a student to be determined eligible for special education, the student’s school district must conduct an evaluation of the student’s special education eligibility pursuant to Education Code sections 56320 to 56329, and an IEP team must make an eligibility determination. (Cal. Education Code § 56329(a).) The eligibility determination involves three questions: (1) whether the student has a qualifying disability and (2) by reason thereof needs special education and related services and (3) the student’s needs cannot be met in the regular classroom with modifications. (Cal. Education Code § 56026; 34 C.F.R. § 300.7.) Petitioner alleges that she was eligible for special education as emotionally disturbed (ED) pursuant to the third criterion of Title 5, California Code of Regulations section 3030(i). Specifically, that criterion states that a student qualifies as ED when he/she exhibits inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations, over a long period of time and to a marked degree which adversely affect educational performance. (34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9)(i); Title 5 CCR § 3030(i).)

As addressed previously in this Decision, the District did not have the opportunity to conduct the evaluation of STUDENT’s special education eligibility as required by the Education Code. Because the District could not conduct the assessment, it could not reach a determination regarding STUDENT’s eligibility for special education services and therefore could not make a referral to CCCMH for AB 3632 mental health services. While some procedural errors occurred, they likely would not have resulted in the District having the opportunity to complete its assessment of STUDENT. This Decision’s analysis determined that those errors did not create a loss of educational opportunity or seriously interfere with the parents’ participation in the IEP process.When a school district does not have the opportunity to conduct an assessment, it cannot reach a determination regarding the student’s eligibility for special education. In any event, in the present case the testimony and documentary evidence presented are insufficient to support a determination that STUDENT was eligible for special education from August 2000 to April 2001.

Although STUDENT underwent some psychological tests while at New Haven, she was never assessed for ED. Without such an assessment, the Hearing Officer has little expert opinion upon which to rely regarding whether STUDENT met the three tests for eligibility. The evidence does not establish that STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors or feelings adversely affected her educational performance, that her disability required special education and related services, or that her needs could not be met in the regular classroom with modifications. Even considering her difficulties in Ms. Rose’s English class, overall STUDENT received passing grades in her seventh grade year at Joaquin Moraga, as well as her good grades the following year at New Haven. While STUDENT’s condition deteriorated during the summer following seventh grade, her behaviors at that time never carried over to any school setting. Several witnesses testified that school provided a positive structure that motivated STUDENT to keep her behaviors under control. (Testimony of BROTHER, MOTHER, Ms. Rose.) In light of the available evidence, it would be speculation for the Hearing Officer to assume that STUDENT would not have been able to return to school and resume functioning there.

While a school district or other LEA has the burden of proving at hearing that it offered a FAPE, the party seeking to establish special education eligibility has the burden of proof on that issue. Because the evidence is insufficient to support a finding of special education eligibility, the Hearing Officer cannot find Petitioner eligible as ED, and therefore was not eligible for special education or AB 3632 mental health services.

(4) Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE from August 2000 to April 2001 by failing to offer the placement and services that Petitioner needed?

Because this Decision could not determine STUDENT’s eligibility, Respondents’ obligation to provide a FAPE has not been established. Therefore, the Hearing Officer does not reach the issue of Petitioner’s placement or services.

(5) Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of her placement at New Haven Treatment Center?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the LEAs have failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services were appropriate under the IDEA and replaced services that the LEAs failed to provide. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1997).) In the present case, there was no determination as to STUDENT’s eligibility, and thus no determination regarding whether the LEAs denied STUDENT a FAPE. Therefore, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s placement at New Haven.

ORDER

All of Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

(1) Did the District fulfill its obligation to assess STUDENT?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(2) Did CCCMH fulfill its obligation to assess STUDENT?

CCCMH prevailed on this issue.

(3) Was Petitioner eligible for special education services and AB 3632 mental health services from August 2000 to April 2001?

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(4) Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE from August 2000 to April 2001 by failing to offer the placement and services that Petitioner needed?

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(3) Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of her placement at New Haven Treatment Center?

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: November 4, 2002 ___________________________________ Suzanne B. Brown Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The Hearing Officer has reorganized and revised some phrasing of the issues. However, the substance of the issues remains the same as those identified at hearing. 2. In order to avoid confusion of FATHER, STUDENT’s father, with BROTHER, STUDENT’s now-twenty-year-old brother who testified as a witness at the hearing, this Decision will refer to each of them by his full name. 3. The assessor noted that STUDENT’s scores may have been slightly artificially inflated due to STUDENT’s prior exposure to the WISC-III and WJ-R due to MOTHER’s occupation as a school psychologist. 4. STUDENT’s refusal to participate in the assessment appeared to be self-generated, not due to any instructions from her parents; Respondents have not argued otherwise. 5. There is no evidence whatsoever to indicate that MOTHER’s reluctance was due to a desire to be uncooperative with the District or to impede the assessment. 6. The Hearing Officer does not know whether the parent’s April 2001 request for due process hearing affected the negotiations regarding another assessment attempt. 7. While generally school district assessors should successfully complete their assessment of a child in a short period of time, it is not unusual for an assessor to require more than one session to complete an assessment. Depending on the assessment tools used, the assessment may take more than one session to complete; alternatively, a variety of circumstances might arise, ranging from a student’s illness to the student’s refusal to participate, which could warrant terminating the assessment attempt and rescheduling for another day.