California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 28, 2001
Student v. Fremont Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 77-01 · Hearing Officer Joseph T. Macaluso
Fremont Unified's first grade offer met IDEA procedural rules; Hearing Officer finds no duty to name a specific teacher.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a six-year-old boy filed for due process against Fremont Unified School District. He was eligible for special education because of pragmatic language deficits and behavioral issues. He had a successful kindergarten year in a full-inclusion class at James Leitch Elementary, with a one-to-one aide and behavior and inclusion specialist Dr. Julie Robinson. At a May 24, 2001 IEP meeting, the parents agreed with the goals and services. They disagreed with the District's plan to move him to first grade at his home school, Azevada Elementary. The case raised only procedural claims. The parents said the offer was contingent on enrollment, failed to name a teacher, had an inadequate transition plan, denied them meaningful participation, and was not handed over at the meeting. The Hearing Officer rejected each claim. The District confirmed the Azevada placement at the meeting and in a May 29 letter. The student's needs did not require naming a teacher because his supports were strong and he had adapted well to new teachers. The transition plan included 18 hours of specialist support in the first two weeks. The parents took part in planning sessions and the meeting, and the father ended the open-ended afternoon session by walking out. Mailing the IEP five days later caused no harm. All relief was denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Union v. Smith to offers with initially unclear wording that the district later clarified in writing. It also shows SEHO treating the choice of a particular teacher as generally within district discretion unless a student's unique needs require more specificity.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1a. Did the District fail to make a specific and coherent offer of placement? (IEP stated home school 'is dependent on enrollment status at school')
Although the IEP language was initially contingent, the District confirmed placement at Azevada at the meeting and formalized it in a May 29, 2001 letter, so the offer was clear and caused no loss of educational benefit.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1b. Was the District required to make a specific offer of a specific first grade teacher?
The student's unique needs did not require naming a teacher, given the strength of his supports and services and his proven ability to adapt to new teachers and settings.
- District prevailedTransition
Issue 1c. Did the District fail to offer an adequate transition plan for Student from kindergarten to first grade?
IDEA did not require a kindergarten-to-first-grade transition plan, but the District offered an adequate one, including 18 hours of behavior/inclusion specialist services in the first two weeks.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1d. Did the IEP team fail to provide the parents with a meaningful opportunity to participate in the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting?
The parents participated meaningfully before and during the meeting; the father ended the open-ended afternoon session by walking out.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1e. Did the District fail to provide the parents with a copy of the IEP document at the end of the IEP meeting?
No law requires that the IEP copy be handed over at the end of the meeting; mailing it five days later caused no prejudice.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's requests for relief denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23; Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm.; Mill Valley Elementary Sch. Dist. v. Eastin
People named in the decision
- Dr. Julie Robinson, full-inclusion behavior specialist; witness for Student
- Elizabeth Salvas, assistant director of special education services, Fremont Unified School District
- Martha Sivertsen, general education kindergarten teacher (listed as first grade teacher in witness list), James Leitch Elementary School
- Marie Troiano, principal, James Leitch Elementary School
- Patricia Purcell, principal, Azevada Elementary School
- Andrea Logan, 1:1 aide (also referred to once as Theresa Logan)
- Theresa Clifford, speech-language therapist
- Chantel Guite, occupational therapist
- Judy Pounder, District staff contact for classroom observations
- AnnaDell While, IEP meeting note-taker
- Dominican School, private school (kindergarten placement by parents)
- Lucile Packard Children's Health Services at Stanford, outside assessor
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Fremont, California, on July 10, 23, 24, 25, and August 30 and 31, 2001. Appearing on behalf of Petitioner (STUDENT) was attorney Eileen Matteucci. Also present on behalf of Petitioner were MR. and MS. PARENT. Respondent Fremont Unified School District (District) was represented by attorneys Bridget A. Flanagan and Chad J. Graff. Also present on behalf of the District was Elizabeth Salvas, assistant director of special education services.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: MR. and MS. PARENT and Dr. Julie Robinson, STUDENT’s full-inclusion behavior specialist. The following witnesses were called by the District: Elizabeth Salvas, assistant director of special education services; Martha Sivertsen, STUDENT’s first grade teacher at James Leitch Elementary School (Leitch); Marie Troiano, principal at Leitch; and Patricia Purcell, principal at Azevada Elementary School.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of closing briefs on September 4, 2001, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
* Please note that the Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number.
ISSUE(Footnote 1)
1. Did the District’s written placement offer to Petitioner for the 2001-2002 school year at the individualized education program (IEP) meeting on May 24, 2001, comply with the procedural requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA)?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a six-year-old student who will enter the first grade in the Fremont Unified School District (District) for the 2001-2002 school year. STUDENT is eligible for special education because of pragmatic language deficits and behavioral issues. STUDENT’s pragmatic language deficits consist of an inability to discriminate good language behavior in peers, to initiate appropriate social interaction, and to maintain conversation. STUDENT’s behavioral issues consist of occasionally responding to confusion or frustration by hitting, not consistently displaying social and safety skills on the playground, not consistently recognizing or expressing what he needs or wants in class or on the playground, and frequently modeling inappropriate behavior. STUDENT’s cognitive abilities are equivalent to or exceed the cognitive abilities of his typically developing peers. “STUDENT’s body of knowledge appears to exceed at minimum 80% of his peers.” (Petitioner Exhibit 2 and Respondent Exhibit 7). He has been a student within the jurisdictional boundaries of the District since 1998.
Ms. PARENT testified that during the 1998-1999 school year STUDENT attended an enrichment preschool program at Glankler Elementary School in the District. The class was oriented toward communicatively disabled children. MS. PARENT testified that she did not observe the teacher or class before STUDENT entered it. MS. PARENT later requested that STUDENT be removed from the teacher’s class because she thought it lacked sufficient structure for him. In January 1999, the District placed STUDENT in a new preschool class for communicatively disabled students at Glankler. While MS. PARENT felt that this new class provided STUDENT with more structure, neither she nor MR. PARENT observed the class or teacher prior to STUDENT’s placement in it. At this time, STUDENT had neither a behaviorist nor a personal aide in class. STUDENT made good academic progress in the enrichment preschool class.
MS. PARENT and Dr. Robinson testified that during the 1999-2000 school year STUDENT was educated at several different school sites. He attended a communicatively disabled class at Grimmer Elementary School, an enrichment preschool class at Marshall School and a full inclusion kindergarten class at Azevada Elementary School. STUDENT received speech and language therapy at school and discrete trial training at home. Ms. Purcell testified that STUDENT had a successful academic and social experience at Azevada. In approximately March 2000, STUDENT began to work with Dr. Julie Robinson, a behaviorist and full inclusion specialist. Dr. Robinson testified that STUDENT exhibited weaknesses in his behavior and social skills. Furthermore, she noted that STUDENT was unable to catch and bounce a ball, hold a pencil and spoon, button his shirt and zip his pants. Thus, Dr. Robinson created STUDENT’s behavioral/social curriculum at school and trained his aide for the discrete trial training at home. Furthermore, she provided behavior support to STUDENT. Dr. Robinson and Ms. Purcell testified that neither she nor STUDENT’s parents chose the teachers or aides. While the teachers were not “ideal,” they possessed sufficient qualities to educate STUDENT. Dr. Robinson met with the teacher at Azevada before STUDENT entered the class and oriented her on Dr. Robinson’s methodologies and how she and the support staff would participate in the classroom. Dr. Robinson testified that STUDENT came into classes late in the 1999-2000 school year and was required to make many different transitions throughout the week. Despite his rigorous academic schedule, STUDENT transitioned into and participated in many different groups because of his strong supports and services. Finally, Dr. Robinson testified that STUDENT’s behavior and academic progress during this time were good.
MS. PARENT and Dr. Robinson testified that during the summer of 2000 STUDENT attended a Parks and Recreation arts and crafts, full inclusion summer program in Fremont. The class had 20 students that were all new to STUDENT. While neither STUDENT’s parents nor Dr. Robinson chose the teacher for the summer program, Dr. Robinson did orient the teacher with regard to STUDENT’s needs and his behavior program. Furthermore, STUDENT retained his aide for the extended school year. Dr. Robinson testified that while the teacher had no experience with disabled children, the teacher possessed many qualities that STUDENT needed for a successful academic experience. During the extended school year, she pointed out that STUDENT developed skills in his areas of need, met his goals and objectives, had no persistent behavior problems, and progressed academically. Dr. Robinson especially noted that STUDENT followed routines in class and listened to the teacher. Dr. Robinson concluded that by the end of the summer STUDENT was ready for a full inclusion kindergarten at Azevada.(Footnote 2)
In March, April and May 2000, STUDENT’s parents, Dr. Robinson, the various service providers, and additional District IEP team members participated in IEP meetings. The meetings resulted in goals and objectives in speech and language, speech and language pragmatics, expressive language, fine motor skills in cutting and writing, social skills in the class and on the playground, self help, and behavior. STUDENT’s IEP provided for support services from a one-to-one aide, the resource program, a play group, speech and language therapy, and occupational therapy. Dr. Robinson testified that she continued providing behavior support and services to STUDENT. Neither Dr. Robinson nor STUDENT’s parents chose a teacher for the 2000-2001 school year. Finally, the IEP team placed STUDENT in a full inclusion kindergarten class at his home school, Azevada.
In September 2000, however, STUDENT’s parents’ removed him from public school and placed him in a private full inclusion kindergarten class at Dominican School. MS. PARENT testified that she and MR. PARENT chose Dominican for two reasons. First, they were unhappy with the unpredictability of the one-to-one aides in public school. Second, private school offered STUDENT the opportunity to remain with the same peers from first grade to eighth grade, a predictable placement, structure, flexibility, and a teacher with a positive attitude toward full inclusion and STUDENT. STUDENT’s parents did not initially hire Dr. Robinson and STUDENT’s one-to-one aide to continue to work with STUDENT at Dominican and to train STUDENT’s new teacher. MR. and MS. PARENT interviewed the teacher at Dominican and concluded that she was motivated to help STUDENT.(Footnote 3) The teacher had educated one special education child in 1999. The kindergarten class had thirty-two children and one aide. MS. PARENT didn’t initially request a one-to-one aide for STUDENT because she did not feel that he needed one. However, three weeks into the year, STUDENT began to have behavior problems at Dominican. MS. PARENT testified that the teacher was rigid and did not follow support guidelines for STUDENT. Furthermore, STUDENT began to model poor behavior and misbehave. MS. PARENT admitted in her testimony that even if one chooses the teacher, one cannot predict how a teacher will ultimately treat STUDENT until he participates in the class. Nonetheless, STUDENT progressed academically at Dominican.
In October 2000, STUDENT’s parents contacted Dr. Robinson for help because they were concerned about STUDENT’s behavior. MR. and MS. PARENT did not want to take him out of Dominican because they worried that another change would negatively effect STUDENT. Dr. Robinson met with STUDENT’s teacher, STUDENT’s parents, and other support personnel to discuss STUDENT’s situation at Dominican. Dr. Robinson recommended that strong behavioral support, an aide, and strategies for the teacher could remedy the situation. However, STUDENT’s behavior worsened. In December 2000, Dominican requested that STUDENT leave the school.(Footnote 4)
In December 2000, STUDENT’s parents advised the District that they wanted STUDENT to return to a full inclusion kindergarten class at his home school, Azevada. Ms. Purcell, the principal of Azevada, testified that she advised MR. and MS. PARENT that had STUDENT entered Azevada in September 2000, the school had a space available for him at that time. However, in December 2000, the space was no longer available. Ms. Purcell testified that she advised STUDENT’s parents that there were a few kindergarten openings at Leitch. Thus, MR. and MS. PARENT observed two possible full inclusion kindergarten classes and teachers at Leitch. Marie Troiano, the principal at Leitch, testified that these observations were not part of standard District policy.
STUDENT’s parents eventually chose Ms. Sivertsen as STUDENT’s regular education kindergarten teacher. Although MS. PARENT testified that they used the same criteria that they employed to chose the teacher at Dominican, Ms. Sivertsen testified that STUDENT’s parents didn’t ask her many questions about her class.(Footnote 5) Furthermore, Dr. Robinson didn’t interview Ms. Sivertsen before STUDENT’s parents chose her. After Ms. Sivertsen was chosen, Dr. Robinson prepared her for STUDENT’s arrival. Finally, Ms. Marie Troiano, the principal at Leitch, advised STUDENT’s parents that STUDENT would have to return to his home school, Asevada at the end of the 2000-2001 school because he was an overload student. Although MR. and MS. PARENT acknowledged being told this fact, MS. PARENT testified that she expected a student from Leitch to be “bumped” for the 2001-2002 school year since STUDENT enrolled in January 2001.(Footnote 6)
Before STUDENT enrolled at Leitch, Dr. Robinson provided both his aide, Ms. Andrea Logan and his teacher, Ms. Sivertsen, with transition training for STUDENT’s arrival. When STUDENT enrolled in Leitch in January 2001, Dr. Robinson testified that STUDENT needed an intense focus on his behavior in order to minimize any opportunity for him to misbehave. This intense focus had two components. First, Dr. Robinson would manage STUDENT’s frustrations, teach him positive behavior modeling and social skills, and how to follow instructions and routines. Second, Ms. Logan would work closely with STUDENT on a daily basis. Dr. Robinson testified that this combination of intense supports and services helped STUDENT to be academically and behaviorally successful.
In January 2001, STUDENT entered Ms. Sivertsen’s class.(Footnote 7) Ms. Sivertsen testified that while her class began in September 2000 and had already solidified as a family by the time STUDENT arrived in January 2001, she was surprised how quickly and easily the class accepted STUDENT. Furthermore, Ms. Sivertsen estimated that within two or three days, STUDENT was just another child in her class. Ms. Sivertsen pointed out that this process normally takes a few weeks for the average child. She stated that STUDENT’s parents also painted a somewhat negative picture of STUDENT when she met them. Thus, she was surprised how quickly STUDENT adjusted to his new surroundings and routines. Finally, Ms. Sivertsen testified that STUDENT did very well behaviorally, socially, and academically. Behaviorally, STUDENT only had two incidents in her class, which was normal. While his behavior was at the bottom half of the class, she pointed out that there were regular students whose behavior was worse than his. Socially, Ms. Sivertsen testified that STUDENT made friends very quickly. He liked to share with the other children in circle time and played sports with them during recess. She noted that STUDENT did have the help of his aide. Academically, she testified that STUDENT has done very well and was one of her “top five” students. He knew his math, could read and write, and performed well above most of the students in the class. Ms. Sivertsen emphasized that STUDENT is very “bright” and eager to learn. Ms. Sivertsen concluded that STUDENT is not difficult to have in a regular education class and with the appropriate supports and services should have no problems transitioning into a first grade class at any school.(Footnote 8)
Dr. Robinson arrived at very similar conclusions as Ms. Sivertsen. Dr. Robinson testified that STUDENT’s behavior was “97% problem-free.” She attributed this success to her support and the daily services of the aide focusing on STUDENT’s positive behavior and keeping STUDENT “on track.” Dr. Robinson estimated that while 3% of the time STUDENT imitated misbehavior, his misbehavior was easily avoided by the presence of the aide guiding STUDENT to successful interpersonal exchanges. Socially, Dr. Robinson testified that STUDENT was successful with this aspect of his program when he had the support of his aide. Dr. Robinson pointed out that STUDENT worked with Ms. Sivertsen and another teacher for reading and he did well socially in both classes. Academically, Dr. Robinson testified that STUDENT had a very successful year in kindergarten. She pointed out that his cognitive and academic skills are on par with his typical peers. Furthermore, STUDENT’s body of knowledge exceeds, at minimum, 80% of his peers. However, Dr. Robinson noted that STUDENT still has trouble writing the alphabet. Thus, she emphasized that his program for the 2001-2002 school year must concentrate on writing. Dr. Robinson concluded that STUDENT, by and large, met his goals and objectives for the 2000-2001 school year and was very successful behaviorally, socially and academically.(Footnote 9)
In January 2001, the IEP team scheduled an IEP meeting for March 2001. The IEP team set the IEP meeting at this time in order to allow a mutually agreed-upon assessment of STUDENT to take place at Stanford University.(Footnote 10) Because of scheduling problems, the assessment did not occur. Thus, the IEP meeting in March 2001 was continued to May 24, 2001. Prior to the May 2001 IEP meeting, the parties prepared for it. First, the service providers held meetings with MR. and MS. PARENT. Dr. Julie Robinson met with STUDENT’s parents two times prior to the IEP meeting. At the first meeting, which lasted one hour, Dr. Robinson and MR. PARENT discussed her proposed behavior/social goals and objectives for STUDENT for the 2001-2001 school year. At the second meeting, which occurred approximately 20 minutes prior to the IEP meeting on May 24, 2001, Dr. Robinson met with MR. PARENT and discussed her proposed draft goals and objectives for STUDENT. Second, Theresa Clifford, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist, met with STUDENT’s parents for two hours at their home to discuss her proposed goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year. Finally, the District also held two planning meetings with the service providers in preparation for the IEP meeting in May.
On May 8, 2001, MR. PARENT had sent Ms. Elizabeth Salvas, assistant director of special education services, a letter (Petitioner Exhibit 3) outlining two matters he wanted taken care of prior to the IEP meeting on May 24, 2001. First, MR. PARENT wanted to observe first grade classes for STUDENT. Although MR. PARENT acknowledged that Azevada is STUDENT’s home school, he requested that STUDENT remain at Leitch. He based his request upon the grounds that STUDENT needed the consistency of the Leitch environment and his peers and that Leitch had a smaller number of students and a knowledgeable special education staff. While MR. PARENT acknowledged that a new first grade teacher for STUDENT was unavoidable, he contended that a new teacher, new peers, and possibly a new speech therapist would set STUDENT up for failure for the 2001-2002 school year. Accordingly, he submitted an interdistrict transfer for STUDENT’s attendance at Leitch. Second, MR. PARENT wished to set up STUDENT’s services for his 2000-2001 extended school year program. MR. PARENT expressed interest in both enrichment courses and a regular education class with Ms. Logan, STUDENT’s one-to-one aide. To this end, he included an application for the summer school enrichment program. Finally, MR. PARENT noted a conversation with Ms. Salvas on May 4, 2001, in which Ms. Salvas indicated that Judy Pounder would contact him to set up first grade observations. Ms. Salvas testified that she contacted Ms. Pounder and requested that Ms. Pounder call MR. PARENT to discuss his request to observe first grade classrooms.
On May 15, 2001, MR. PARENT sent Ms. Salvas a second letter outlining what elements he thought were appropriate for STUDENT’s placement for the 2001-2002 school year. (Petitioner Exhibit 4.) First, he requested that STUDENT remain at Leitch for continuity purposes of his program. Second, he requested that STUDENT retain his full-time aide. Third, he requested a teacher for STUDENT who was supportive of STUDENT and his special education program and services. Fourth, MR. PARENT requested that STUDENT’s behaviorist/full inclusion specialist and occupation therapy services continue with some modifications. Finally, MR. PARENT requested that STUDENT’s language therapy continue with his requested guidelines. Ms. Salvas met with MR. PARENT on May 21, 2001 and they discussed the aforementioned concerns. Ms. Salvas testified that while there was a general agreement on STUDENT’s supports and services, there was no agreement on STUDENT’s school. Ms. Salvas stated that she told MS. PARENT at the meeting that if STUDENT attended Azevada, he would not have to make any more changes from kindergarten through sixth grade. However, if he attended Leitch, the school only went as far as second grade. Thus, he would have to transfer to another school which would not be required if STUDENT attended Azevada.
On May 24, 2001, the IEP meeting took place. It occurred in two parts that day. The morning part of the IEP meeting, which was designated as a transition IEP meeting, was scheduled for two hours. Both STUDENT’s parents and the District’s witnesses testified that they were aware of and agreed to the time set aside for the morning session. However, MS. PARENT testified that she expected a second IEP meeting to be set to resolve any unfinished business. The second part of the IEP meeting, which was entitled as a “mediated IEP,” was scheduled in the afternoon to resolve any remaining issues from the morning IEP session. There was no time limit on the afternoon session. At the morning session of the IEP meeting, teams from both Leitch and Azevada appeared for STUDENT’s transition to Azevada from Leitch. After brief introductions from all the IEP team members, a confirmation that STUDENT’s parents had received their parent’s rights, and further confirmation of STUDENT’s continuing eligibility for special education, the IEP team discussed STUDENT’s assessment at Lucille Packard Children’s Health Services at Stanford. Since the assessment had yet to be scheduled and completed, the team agreed that the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting would be continued and the assessment’s results regarding STUDENT’s primary handicapping condition would be discussed at that time. The IEP team next reviewed STUDENT’s goals and objectives from his June 2000 IEP. The IEP team confirmed that most of STUDENT’s goals and objectives from the 2000-2001 school year had been met.(Footntoe 11) Thereafter, the IEP team members reviewed STUDENT’s present levels of performance and the corresponding goals and objectives. STUDENT’s goals and objective were in communication, behavior and social skills, and the team members primarily agreed upon them. The IEP team did not write academic goals and objectives because STUDENT was progressing at or above grade level. Finally, the team members discussed STUDENT’s services.(Footnote 12) The services included a transition program from kindergarten to the first grade, a behavior and social program with Dr. Robinson, speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, resource specialist services and a one-to-one aide. While STUDENT’s parents agreed with the 2001-2002 goals and objectives and services, they felt that the transition plan was insufficient.
When the IEP meeting turned to STUDENT’s proposed placement for the 2001-2002 school year, it broke down. STUDENT’s parents requested that STUDENT remain at Leitch; the District wanted STUDENT to return to his home school, Azevada. As MS. PARENT explained why STUDENT should remain at Leitch, time for the morning session expired.(Footnote 13) Since all the terms and conditions of STUDENT’s program had not been agreed upon by the team at the morning session and the IEP document was still being filled out, STUDENT’s parents were not given a copy of the IEP document in the morning. The majority of the IEP team members were then excused and the morning IEP meeting ended.
The IEP team for the afternoon mediated IEP consisted of Ms. Salvas, Ms. Troiano, Ms. Purcell and STUDENT’s parents.(Footnote 14) The main issues of the afternoon session were STUDENT’s school and his teacher. With regard to the District’s proposed school, MR. PARENT noted that the IEP document stated that STUDENT’s “home school is dependent on enrollment status at school.” MR. PARENT contended that while the District offered Azevada as his placement for the 2001-2002 school year, the language in the IEP document was contingent. Thus, MR. PARENT argued, there was no firm offer of placement for STUDENT at Azevada from the District. Ms. Salvas placed a phone call to Azevada and confirmed that STUDENT was on a list of students to be placed in first grade at Azevada. Second, MR. PARENT noted that the IEP document failed to designate a teacher. MR. PARENT felt that it was important to know who the teacher was and to observe the teacher before agreeing to him/her because of STUDENT’s unique needs. The District disagreed because both STUDENT’s social and academic performance during the 2000-2001 school year and Dr. Robinson’s report indicated that STUDENT could be successful in a regular education first grade class with appropriate supports and services regardless if the teacher were known or not. Furthermore, the District contended that there was no requirement under the IDEA that it specifically name a teacher. Finally, the District contended that it could neither name a specific teacher nor have STUDENT’s parents observe the teacher before the 2001-2002 school year began because all the first grade teachers at Azevada had quit and new teachers had yet to be hired. At this point, MR. PARENT became angry and walked out of the afternoon meeting without a copy of the IEP document.
On May 24, 2001, the same day MR. PARENT walked out of the afternoon mediated IEP meeting, he sent Ms. Salvas a letter and requested a follow-up IEP meeting within thirty days. He advised Ms. Salvas that he and his wife would like to further discuss STUDENT’s past goals and objectives for the 2000-2001 school year and proposed goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year. He noted that they did not have an opportunity to do so at the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting. Second, MR. PARENT requested copies of the District’s policies regarding special day classes, mainstreaming, and full inclusion. Finally, MR. PARENT stated that he did not want the members of the Azevada IEP team to appear at the follow-up IEP meeting. MR. PARENT did not send include his letter to the IEP team, as agreed to at the morning IEP meeting on May 24, 2001, with his thoughts and comments about STUDENT’s 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 goals and objectives.
On May 29, 2001, Ms. Salvas sent STUDENT’s parents a letter that reviewed the events of the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting. Ms. Salvas also included a copy of the IEP document with the letter. Furthermore, Ms. Salvas outlined the District’s offer of placement and services for STUDENT’s 2001-2002 school year:
“(1) First grade general education at home school;
(2) Resource specialist-30 minutes, once per month consultation and/or direct service;
(3) Pragmatic language services-90 minutes weekly;
(4) Occupational therapy-consultation, 90 minutes montly;
(5) Behavior/inclusion specialist-18 hours during the first 2 weeks or school; thereafter 5 hours per week;
(6) One-to-one aide for first grade school hours;
(7) Parents declined bus transportation, but will receive mileage reimbursement from Special Services office;
(8) Extended year services 2002: general education school offerings with one-to-one aide if necessary with a meeting to be scheduled no later than 5/15/02 to determine the ESY 2002 specifics.”(Footnote 15)
On June 6, 2001, the District scheduled a second IEP meeting on September 7, 2001.(Footnote 16) On June 15, 2001, the 2000-2001 school year ended. Finally, STUDENT attended an extended school year program during the summer of 2001. Neither Dr. Robinson nor STUDENT’s parents observed the summer school teacher before STUDENT attended the summer program.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner alleged that the District committed five procedural violations:
(a) The District failed to make a specific and coherent offer of placement;
(b) The District failed to make a specific offer of a first grade teacher;
(c) The District failed to offer an adequate transition plan for STUDENT from kindergarten to first grade;
(d) The IEP team failed to provide Mr. and MS. PARENT with a meaningful opportunity to participate in the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting;
(e) The District failed to provide STUDENT’s parents with a copy of the IEP document at the end of the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting.
The District denied all of Petitioner’s alleged procedural violations.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
ISSUE 1: Did the District’s written placement offer to Petitioner for the 2001-2002 school year at the IEP meeting on May 24, 2001 comply with the procedural requirements of the IDEA?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; California Education Code § 56000). Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that conform with the student’s individualized educational program. “Special education” is defined as “Specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central District, et. al. vs. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized education program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school specialized instruction and related services must be reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit to the student. (Rowley, 458 at 201-208.)The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the free and appropriate public education (FAPE) to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights that extend to parents include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b) (1997) (amending 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1994)). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
1. District Offer for the 2001-2002 School Year
In this case, Petitioner’s parents contended that the District’s written offer of placement was not specific and coherent on two grounds: first, the District’s offer of placement at Azevada Elementary School was contingent upon enrollment at the school; and second, the District’s offer failed to identify a specific teacher that STUDENT’s parents could observe before accepting the District’s offer of placement. The District contended that it did offer STUDENT a placement at Azevada and that the IDEA did not require it to offer STUDENT a specific teacher.
When an educational agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child, the IDEA requires prior written notice to the parents. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(B)(3). Among the procedural violations that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA’s procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, ___U.S.___, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); see 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3) (1997). In Union, the Ninth Circuit stated, “We find that this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.” Union, 15 F.3d at 1526. The Court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement: (1) to alert the parents of the need to consider seriously whether the school district’s proposed placement is appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services; and (3) so that the school district is more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence of the appropriateness of the placement at a due process hearing. Id. The courts have continued to vigorously apply Union. See, e.g., Mill Valley Elementary Sch. Dist. v. Eastin, No. C 98-03812, slip op. at ___ (N.D. Cal. Oct. 1, 1999).
(a) Did the District fail to make a specific and coherent offer of placement?
In this case, the May 24, 2001 IEP contained primarily all of the requisite elements for a legally sufficient offer. Such an offer must include the child’s present levels of performance, annual goals and objectives, related services and aides, whether the child shall partake in regular education or not, achievement test modifications, and the frequency, location, and duration of those services and modifications. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(i-vi); California Education Code § 56345(a)(1-6). The May 24, 2001 IEP contained STUDENT’s present levels of performance, his annual goals and objectives in behavior and social skills as written by Dr. Julie Robinson, in speech and language as written by Theresa Clifford, occupational therapy as written by Chantel Guite, the services and one-to-one aide, Ms. Theresa Logan, the frequency and duration of his services, and placement for STUDENT in a regular education first grade class with resource specialist services. Finally, Dr. Robinson and the District’s witnesses testified that academic goals and objectives were not written for STUDENT’s May 24, 2001 IEP because he functions at or above a first grade educational level.(Footnote 17)
However, MR. and MS. PARENT contended that the District’s offer failed to alert them of the need to consider seriously whether the school district’s proposed placement at Azevada is appropriate under the IDEA because its offer of placement at Azevada was contingent. In order to determine whether the proposed placement was contingent or complied with the requirements of a formal offer under Union, it is necessary to examine the proposal as set forth in the IEP and any supplementary correspondence between the parents and the District. The language in the IEP document that Petitioner alleged was contingent is as follows: “Home school is dependent on enrollment status at school.” STUDENT’s parents testified that this language in the IEP document proved that the District’s offer at Azevada was contingent on there being room at the school. Furthermore, MR. PARENT testified that he feared showing up with STUDENT on the first day of school at Azevada and having one of the District’s administrator’s advise him that there was no room for STUDENT. MR. PARENT said he worried that STUDENT would ultimately be sent to another school in the District because of insufficient space at Azevada. At the mediated IEP meeting in the afternoon, MR. PARENT and Ms. Salvas testified that Ms. Salvas made a telephone call to Azevada to confirm a placement for STUDENT. Ms. Salvas testified that she advised MR. PARENT at the mediated IEP that STUDENT was number 51 on a list of 55 students to attend first grade at Azevada for the 2001-2002 school year. MR. PARENT confirmed this fact. However, MR. PARENT testified that when he requested that the IEP team members provide him with a written confirmation of STUDENT’s placement at Azevada at the mediated IEP, Ms. Salvas would not provide it to him. While the District did not immediately rectify this ambiguity at the mediated IEP on May 24, 2001, it did formally offer Azevada in Ms. Salvas’s letter dated May 29, 2001: “1st grade general education at his home school.” The term “home school” was clearly defined on page one of the May 24, 2001 IEP as Azevada. (District Exhibit 9.) Furthermore, all the District’s witnesses and STUDENT’s parents concurred that Azevada is STUDENT’s home school. Petitioner alleges that since the IEP document contained the contingent language regarding STUDENT’s placement, the District’s offer is irreparably flawed. However, Petitioner provides no authority and the Hearing Officer is aware of none that states the District may not expeditiously clarify a vague term in its offer. The District confirmed placement at Azevada at the mediated IEP for the 2001-2002 school year and formalized this offer in its written letter on May 29, 2001. While the District’s offer of placement at Azevada, then, was initially contingent, the District alerted STUDENT’s parents of the need to seriously consider and to ultimately accept or deny Azevada as the placement for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year. Thus, STUDENT suffered no loss of educational benefit.
(b) Was the District required to make a specific offer of a specific first grade teacher?
STUDENT’s parents contend that because the District did not offer a specific first grade teacher in the May 24, 2001 IEP document, the District again did not alert them of the need to seriously consider the District’s offer for the 2001-2002 school year. However, the District contended that it was not required to offer a specific teacher for three reasons. First, all the first grade teachers at Asevada left at the end of the 2000-2001 school year. Thus, the District was precluded at the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting from offering STUDENT’s parents a first grade teacher for the 2001-2002 school year at Azevada. Ms. Purcell testified that the District was interviewing first grade teachers for the 2001-2002 school year and it would offer STUDENT’s parents a teacher before the start of the new school year. Second, the District contended that the IDEA did not require it to offer a specific teacher in the IEP document. Finally, Ms. Purcell testified that the District did not generally allow parents to chose teachers because there were numerous factors and considerations that dictated how a child was placed in a specific class room. Those factors and considerations included gender, the behavior, physical, emotional, and special needs of the children, and the academic abilities of the various students. Ms. Purcell testified that blending a class was critical for its and the students’ overall success. On those grounds, the District did not offer STUDENT a specific first grade teacher.
While personnel issues are generally left to the discretion of the district, there may be circumstances when a special education student’s unique and individual needs require more specificity regarding the location and composition of the class, the number of students in the classroom, and the experience and training of the teacher. California special education law defines “educational placement” as that “unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the individual education program, in any one or a combination of public, private, home and hospital or residential settings.” Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3042(a). Thus, the question in this case is whether STUDENT’s unique and individual needs required the District to offer a specific teacher in the IEP document.
The evidence presented at the hearing established that STUDENT’s unique and individual needs did not require a specific teacher to be offered at the May 24, 2001 IEP. Dr. Julie Robinson’s testimony established that the strength of STUDENT’s program, supports, and services will ensure STUDENT’s academic, behavioral, and social success. Dr. Robinson testified that she preferred to know who STUDENT’s teacher is beforehand because she could determine if the teacher was enthusiastic about full inclusion, had a positive attitude toward special needs children, was structured, flexible, and gentle.(Footnote 18) (Dr. Robinson did not testify that there were any objective, educational qualities STUDENT’s teacher needed to have.) However, Dr. Robinson pointed out that if a teacher lacked these subjective qualities, was not ideal and even had reservations about STUDENT’s program, she could still ensure STUDENT’s success in the classroom because STUDENT’s supports and services for the 2001-2002 school year were so strong. Furthermore, Dr. Robinson stated that proper preparation, orientation, and training of the teacher, aide and STUDENT would further ensure STUDENT’s success. Dr. Robinson emphasized that STUDENT’s aide, Ms. Logan, is a crucial element in STUDENT’s success at school because STUDENT likes Ms. Logan and works well with her. Dr. Robinson pointed out that Ms. Logan is present in class every day to implement Dr. Robinson’s program and guides STUDENT both emotionally and academically. Ms. Salvas testified that both Ms. Logan and Dr. Robinson are returning for the 2001-2002 school year. Finally, Dr. Robinson testified that during the 2001-2002 school year she will meet with Ms. Logan and the teacher to discuss strategies and to ensure that STUDENT’s behavior and social program are on track.
Dr. Robinson also testified that her behavioral goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year were also an important part for STUDENT’s continued success. STUDENT’s parents agreed to Dr. Robinson’s goals and objectives. Furthermore, STUDENT’s parents testified that they agreed to the goals and objectives of Theresa Clifford, the speech and language specialist for the 2001-2002 school year. Additionally, Dr. Robinson testified that STUDENT is very bright and is not difficult to place in a first grade class. Finally, Dr. Robinson testified that STUDENT can make changes if the supports and services are in place. Thus, Dr. Robinson concluded that while it would be preferable to know, interview, and observe STUDENT’s teacher before selecting him/her, it is not absolutely necessary due to the strength of STUDENT’s supports and services for the 2001-2002 school year.(Footnote 19)
The testimony of STUDENT’s parents also established that STUDENT’s unique needs did not require a specific teacher to be identified in his IEP document. First, both MR. and MS. PARENT, like Dr. Robinson, testified to the subjective qualities they would like in a teacher for STUDENT. However, MS. PARENT, who also is a teacher, admitted that STUDENT’s supports and services are so strong, that any general education teacher at the elementary school level could implement his IEP.(Footnote 20) Furthermore, MS. PARENT testified that it was “highly unlikely” that the first grade teacher could not make STUDENT’s program work. Second, STUDENT’s parents testified that while there were a few items in STUDENT’s behavior, speech and language, and social goals and objective which still needed to be discussed, they agreed with Dr. Robinson’s behavior and Theresa Clifford’s speech and language goals and objectives for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year. Finally, STUDENT’s parents agreed that his supports and services were critical to his success and those offered by the District would meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.
STUDENT’s educational history also established that STUDENT did not need a specific teacher to receive educational benefit. First, STUDENT’s education history established that the majority of his teachers were not chosen. In preschool at Glankler, Marshall, and Azevada, MR. and MS. PARENT did not choose STUDENT’s teacher beforehand. Nonetheless, STUDENT did very well in school. Both STUDENT’s parents and Dr. Robinson testified that the strong supports and services were primarily responsible for his success during this time. In the private Kindergarten at Dominican, MR. and MS. PARENT chose the teacher. While they initially thought that the teacher possessed the subjective qualities they required for STUDENT, the teacher, within three weeks, turned out to be quite poor.(Footnote 21) Furthermore, STUDENT did not have the supports and services he had in public school. During the summer of 2000 and 2001, STUDENT’s parents did not chose the teachers for the extended school year and STUDENT still did quite well.(Footnote 22) In January 2001, STUDENT’s parents did interview Ms. Sivertsen, STUDENT’s kindergarten teacher at Leitch. However, Ms. Sivertsen testified that she had only taught school for a few years and STUDENT’s parents did not ask her many questions before choosing her class. STUDENT ultimately performed excellent in her class. Second, STUDENT’s educational history established that STUDENT could easily adjust to new teachers and surroundings without any problem. When STUDENT attended preschool at Glankler, Marshall, and Azevada, he entered classes mid-stream and had no trouble adjusting to the teacher or the other students. The most compelling testimony on this point came from Ms. Sivertsen. She pointed out that when STUDENT entered her class in January 2001, the kindergarten class had been together since September 2001. Ms. Sivertsen emphasized while the average child requires a few weeks to assimilate when entering a class “mid-stream,” STUDENT adjusted to the new surroundings within two to three days, learned the routines, made friends, and was quickly just another one of the students in the class. Finally, STUDENT’s ability to easily adapt to new teachers and surroundings was demonstrated during the 2000 and 2001 extended school years. The evidence, then, established that while it might be helpful to know and to observe a teacher before STUDENT begins school, STUDENT’s needs do not require a specific teacher to be identified before he begins a class. Thus, the District’s offer was complete and it was not required to name a specific teacher because of the strength of the supports and services in the May 24, 2001 IEP document and STUDENT’s ability to adapt to new teachers, surroundings and routines.
(c) Did the District fail to offer an adequate transition plan for STUDENT from kindergarten to first grade?
Dr. Robinson and the District witnesses testified that the purpose of the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting was to ensure a smooth transition for STUDENT from kindergarten at Leitch to a first grade regular education class room at his home school at Azevada. Present at the IEP meeting were teams from both Leitch and Azevada. While the IDEA does not require a transition plan from kindergarten to the first grade, the District nonetheless provided a transition plan for STUDENT from Leitch to Azevada.(Footnote 23) 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); California Education Code § 56345.1. Dr. Robinson testified that when STUDENT transferred from Dominican School back into the District in January 2001, the District provided a transition plan for STUDENT. In preparation of the 2001-2002 school year, the District again offered a transition plan for STUDENT. Dr. Robinson recommended intensified services for STUDENT’s transition from kindergarten to first grade and the District concurred with her recommendation. Thus, the District agreed to provide STUDENT with 18 hours of behaviorist/full inclusion specialist services during the first two weeks of the 2001-2002 school year. Furthermore, Dr. Robinson testified that if additional intensified services were needed after the initial two weeks, the situation would be reevaluated at that time. Again, the District did not object to Dr. Robinson’s recommendation. If the initial two-week transition period goes well, Dr. Robinson will provide STUDENT with five hours per week of her services for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year. At the hearing, Petitioner did not present any evidence to contradict Dr. Robinson’s testimony. Furthermore, the evidence regarding STUDENT’s educational history established that he had no problem transitioning into a new class with a new teacher and peers if the appropriate supports and services were in place. Dr. Robinson testified that such supports and services are in place for the 2001-2002 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT an adequate transition plan from kindergarten at Leitch to first grade at Azevada.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District made a specific and coherent offer to STUDENT’s parents which contained STUDENT’s present levels of performance, goals and objectives in behavior, speech and language, services and aides, a general education placement and a resource specialist, the anticipated frequency, location and duration of those services and a transition plan from kindergarten to the first grade. The District’s offer alerted STUDENT’s parents of the need to consider seriously whether the school district’s proposed placement was appropriate under the IDEA and helped them to decide whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services. Finally, the District’s offer was specific and coherent enough to enable the District to prepare to introduce sufficient relevant evidence of the appropriateness of the placement at a due process hearing. Thus, the District’s offer satisfied the procedural requirements of both the IDEA, California education law and the provisions of Union v. Smith.
(d) Did the IEP team fail to provide MR. and MS. PARENT with a meaningful opportunity to participate at the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting?
MR. and MS. PARENT testified that the IEP team did not provide them with a meaningful opportunity to participate at the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting. The District’s witnesses testified that STUDENT’s parents not only had a meaningful opportunity to participate at the May 2001 IEP meeting but also began to participate well before the actual IEP meeting began. Federal law provides that the education of children with disabilities can be made more effective by strengthening the role of parents and ensuring that families of such children have meaningful opportunities to participate in the education of their children at school and at home. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c)(5)(B). Federal law further provides that in developing each child’s IEP, the IEP team shall provide the parents with the opportunity to participate in the meeting, consider the strengths of the child and the concerns of the parents for enhancing the education of their child. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(3)(A)(i); 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.345(a), 300.346(a)(1)(i), and 300.501(a)(2)(i).
In this case, STUDENT’s parent’s had a meaningful opportunity to participate in the morning and afternoon May 24, 2001 IEP meeting. MR. and MS. PARENT’s participation in the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting began before the IEP gathered. On May 8 and May 15, 2001, MR. PARENT sent Ms. Salvas letters and communicated his concerns regarding STUDENT’s education for the 2001-2002 school year. MR. PARENT also met with Ms. Salvas on May 21, 2001 to discuss the concerns expressed in those letters. Furthermore, the District made arrangements for STUDENT’s parents to meet with the service providers to form acceptable goals and objectives before the IEP meeting began. STUDENT’s parents met with Theresa Clifford, STUDENT’s speech and language specialist, for two hours at their home to formulate goals and objectives for STUDENT. STUDENT’s parents testified that they agreed with Ms. Clifford’s goals and objectives for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year. MR. PARENT also met with Dr. Robinson twice prior to the IEP meeting. MR. PARENT’s first visit with Dr. Robinson lasted for one hour and they discussed STUDENT’s behavior goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year. Their second visit occurred the day of the IEP meeting before it began and lasted approximately 20 minutes. Dr. Robinson put their initial discussion regarding STUDENT’s goals and objectives into draft form and then reviewed them with MR. PARENT. MR. and MS. PARENT also testified that they agreed with Dr. Robinson’s goals and objectives for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year. Dr. Robinson and STUDENT’s parents testified that both the behavior and speech and language goals and objectives, along with the supports and services, are the driving force behind STUDENT’s program. STUDENT’s parents took a major role in the preparation of these goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year with the service providers. Thus, MR. and MS. PARENT had an effective opportunity to participate in the IEP and played an influential role in its direction well before it began on May 24, 2001.
MR. and MS. PARENT’s participation at the IEP meeting on May 24, 2001 was equally effective though their amount of participation was limited in scope by the two-hours allotted to the morning meeting. Initially, STUDENT’s parents participated in the discussion about STUDENT’s assessment at Stanford University. MS. PARENT advised the IEP team that they had consented to the District assessing STUDENT and to a mutually agreeable outside assessor. MS. PARENT also added that they had three prior outside assessments of STUDENT to determine if STUDENT were autistic and nonetheless agreed to the assessment at Stanford University. When asked if they had set up a date for STUDENT’s assessment, MR. PARENT stated that he had been unable to do so at the time of the IEP meeting. MR. PARENT and Ms. Salvas also agreed that when the results of the Stanford assessment were ready, they would reconvene the triennial IEP meeting to discuss the results. Moreover, MR. PARENT participated in the discussion about STUDENT’s 2000-2001 IEP goals and objectives. MR. PARENT told the IEP team that he had already reviewed all of STUDENT’s goals and objectives for the 2000-2001 school year prior to the IEP meeting and there were two areas which he perceived as not being met. While Ms. Salvas offered to write MR. PARENT’s concerns in the parent comment section of the IEP document, he acknowledged that time was a factor in the IEP meeting and volunteered to write a letter with his thoughts on this issue. Ms. Salvas agreed to MR. PARENT’s suggestion. Nonetheless, STUDENT’s parents still expressed some concerns about whether STUDENT had met specific goals and objectives for the 2000-2001 school year. MR. PARENT pointed out to the IEP team that while STUDENT was able to raise his hand in class, he might not be able to provide an answer. MS. PARENT also stated that that STUDENT still had trouble zipping a zipper. Thus, STUDENT’s parents were active in the early part of the IEP meeting.
STUDENT’s parents continued to participate when the IEP team discussed STUDENT’s program for the 2001-2002 school year. MR. and MS. PARENT provided their thoughts when the IEP team discussed STUDENT’s present levels of performance. Mrs. PARENT gave her opinion about STUDENT’s social nature, his eagerness to make friends, his love of sports and emerging gross motor skills, and his need for an FM communication system. MR. PARENT volunteered his thoughts about STUDENT’s problems using syntax in natural settings, communicating with his peers at times, his fine and gross motor skills, STUDENT’s medical problem with milk, and MR. PARENT’s thoughts on an FM system for STUDENT. Again, MR. PARENT volunteered to write down his additional concerns and attach them to the IEP document. STUDENT’s parents also participated in the discussion about STUDENT’s goals and objectives. MR. PARENT advised the IEP team that he thought Ms. Clifford’s speech and language goals and objectives were “excellent.” He also requested that Theresa implement them for the 2001-2002 school year. When Dr. Robinson discussed her behavior goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year, MR. PARENT advised the IEP team that STUDENT imitated other children’s bad behavior. STUDENT’s parents also participated in the discussion about STUDENT’s supports and services. MR. PARENT contributed his thoughts about the necessity for a one-to-one aide and a consistent environment for STUDENT. MR. PARENT and Dr. Robinson also had a discussion about the importance of accurate data collection and how it relates to his behavior goals. Furthermore, MR. PARENT provided his thoughts on the methodologies of implementing STUDENT’s pragmatic language goals and how this responsibility will be divided between Dr. Robinson and the aide. MR. PARENT said he would provide an attachment regarding how STUDENT’s speech and language goals are met. On the issue of STUDENT’s transition program, MR. PARENT said he had no problem with it. Finally, STUDENT’s parents contributed their thoughts about STUDENT’s appropriate placement for the 2001-2002 school year. MS. PARENT gave a long and detailed explanation about why she thought STUDENT should remain at Leitch school. Furthermore, MR. PARENT and Ms. Troiano had a lengthy discussion about District policy on intradistrict transfers. Before the IEP team could finish its discussion about the appropriate placement for STUDENT, the time for the morning IEP meeting expired. The parties then went into an afternoon mediated IEP session where STUDENT’s placement for the 2001-2002 school year was discussed. However, the IEP team was unable to conclude discussing all issues in the afternoon session because MR. PARENT became angry and walked out of the meeting.
Petitioner contends that because all issues relating to the District’s proposed placement and services for STUDENT for the 2001-2001 school year were not discussed at the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting, the District failed to comply with the procedural requirements of the IDEA. However, the facts establish that this allegation is incorrect. STUDENT’s parents initially spent over three hours prior to the IEP meeting discussing STUDENT’s goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year with Dr. Robinson and Ms. Clifford. On May 15, 2001, MR. PARENT met with Ms. Salvas to discuss STUDENT’s program for the 2001-2002 school year. On May 24, 2001, MR. and MS. PARENT spent two hours in the morning IEP and at least an hour in the afternoon mediated IEP discussing STUDENT’s program and placement. Up to that point in time, STUDENT’s parents spent over five hours discussing STUDENT’s educational program for the 2001-2002 school year. While the District didn’t limit the time for the afternoon session of the IEP meeting, MR. PARENT unilaterally ended the meeting by walking out. MR. PARENT then wrote the District a letter on May 24, 2001, the same day he walked out of the afternoon mediated IEP meeting, and requested that the IEP team reconvene the meeting within 30 days to discuss STUDENT’s goals and objectives further. MR. PARENT also advised the District that he did not want the Azevada part of the IEP team to attend the second IEP meeting. Furthermore, MR. PARENT offered at the morning IEP meeting to write a letter with his thoughts and concerns about STUDENT’s 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 goals and objectives. However, he never wrote the letter. On May 29, 2001, MR. PARENT advised the Hearing Office that he wanted STUDENT’s case to proceed to hearing. MR. PARENT made this request despite agreeing with the IEP team at the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting to discuss the results of STUDENT’s Stanford assessment at a second IEP meeting. Although the District noticed the second IEP meeting on September 7, 2001 to discuss the results of STUDENT’s assessment, MS. PARENT chose to proceed to hearing without completing STUDENT’s assessment. Thus, while STUDENT’s parents contend that they did not have a meaningful opportunity to discuss all issues related to the District’s offer and placement for the 2001-2002 school year, the totality of the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s parent’s had a meaningful opportunity to participate both before and at the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting.(Footnote 24)
(e) Did the District fail to provide STUDENT’s parents with a copy of the IEP document at the end of the IEP meeting?
STUDENT’s parents allege that the District failed to provide them with a copy of the IEP document at the end of the IEP meeting. The District contends that it was unable to give STUDENT’s parents a copy of the IEP document at the end of the mediated IEP since MR. PARENT angrily left the mediated IEP. While federal and State law provide that an education agency shall provide the parents with a copy of the child’s IEP at no cost to the parents, there is no specific provision in either federal or State law that the education agency shall provide the parents with a copy of the IEP document at the end of the IEP meeting. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(F); California Education Code § 56341.5(i). On May 29, 2001, the District mailed STUDENT’s parents a copy of the IEP document and a letter. The letter outlined the terms and conditions of its offer for the 2001-2002 school year. Since the IEP document was mailed only 5 days after the conclusion of the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting and the 2001-2002 school year did not begin until September 2001, there was neither prejudice nor loss of any educational benefit to STUDENT.
(f) Conclusion
The evidence at the hearing established that the District made a specific and coherent offer of placement at Azevada and was not required to make an offer of a specific teacher for the 2001-2002 school year. Furthermore, the District offered STUDENT an appropriate transition plan from kindergarten to Leitch to first grade at Azevada. Finally, the IEP team provided MR. and MS. PARENT with a meaningful opportunity to participate at the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting both prior to and the day of its assembly. However, IEP team, pursuant to agreement of the parties, was to reconvene in order to review the results of the Stanford assessment of STUDENT. Finally, The District timely offered MR. and MS. PARENT a copy of the IEP document after the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting.
ORDER
1. The District’s written placement offer to Petitioner for the 2001-2002 school year at the IEP meeting on May 24, 2001 complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA.
2. All Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Respondent, Fremont Unified School District prevailed on all issues herein.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decisions. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: September 28, 2001 _____________________________________ Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. Petitioner did not raise a substantive issue regarding whether the District’s proposed placement and services for the 2001-2002 provided STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). Thus, the District’s discussion of FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year in its closing brief shall not be considered.
2. Dr. Robinson testified that she neither selected nor interviewed the teachers at Azevada before STUDENT was scheduled to begin kindergarten. However, she recognized the need to meet, orient, and prepare the teacher before STUDENT began the class.
3. Neither STUDENT’s parents nor Dr. Robinson observed any full inclusion general education kindergarten classes at Azevada before deciding to remove STUDENT from public school. MS. PARENT, however, did observe some special day classes.
4. Dr. Robinson testified that with her behavioral program and a one-to-one aide for STUDENT, she could have made STUDENT’s class at Dominican a successful experience for him.
5. Ms. Sivertsen testified that STUDENT’s parents interviewed her approximately one week before STUDENT entered her class.
6. MS. PARENT testified that she also knew that while Azevada was a K-to-6 elementary school, Leitch was only a K-to-2 elementary school.
7. Ms. Sivertsen pointed out that she had only taught for a few years and had great success with STUDENT.
8. MR. and MS. PARENT testified that they were also very pleased with STUDENT’s social and academic progress in Ms. Sivertsen’s class. MS. PARENT also testified that STUDENT possesses all the academic skills that are necessary for a beginning first grade student.
9. Dr. Robinson testified that as the 2000-2001 school year passed, Ms. Sivertsen became less positive about STUDENT’s role in her class. However, Dr. Robinson emphasized that the supports and services in STUDENT’s program were so strong that they helped to keep him on task and guide him to a successful school year.
10. On August 31, 2001, the last day of hearing, Ms. Matteucci advised the Hearing Officer that the assessment of STUDENT had been completed at Stanford University. Ms. Matteucci wished to introduce the report into the evidence. After counsel discussed the relevance and admissibility of the report, the Hearing Officer excluded its admission into evidence because its contents were not available to the IEP team at the IEP meeting on May 24, 2001, were not relevant to the procedural issues, and went beyond the scope of the hearing.
11. MR. and MS. PARENT felt that there were a few aspects about STUDENT’s goals and objectives from the 2000-2001 school year which had not been met and needed to be included in the 2001-2002 goals and objectives. MR. PARENT offered to submit his concerns in a follow-up letter.
12. Ms. Chantel Guite, STUDENT’s occupational therapist, and Dr. Robinson attached copies of their most recent reports to the IEP document. Ms. Salvas testified that she provided STUDENT’s parents with a copy of Ms. Guite’s report prior to the IEP meeting.
13. As the morning IEP meeting transpired, Ms. AnnaDell While transcribed the discussions onto the IEP document. (Petitioner Exhibit 2 and Respondent Exhibit 8.) 14. Counsel for both parties waived the confidentiality and privilege of the afternoon mediated IEP.
15. Both MR. and MS. PARENT testified that terms number seven and eight of Ms. Salvas’ letter were never discussed at the IEP meeting or the mediated IEP. However, MR. PARENT testified that STUDENT’s 2001 summer extended school year was not an issue for the hearing.
16. Ms. Salvas testified that the 2001-2002 school year at Azevada begins on September 5, 2001.
17. STUDENT’s parents testified that certain aspects of STUDENT’s goals and objectives from the 2000-2001 school year were not met and that certain of STUDENT’s goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 needed some clarity. However, STUDENT’s parents testified that they generally agreed that STUDENT’s goals and objectives for the 2000-2001 school year had been met and that STUDENT’s goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year were appropriate.
18. MS. PARENT testified to the same facts.
19. Dr. Robinson also testified that it is not difficult to place STUDENT in a first grade class because of the strength of his supports and services for the 2001-2002 school year. Furthermore, Dr. Robinson testified that STUDENT’s program could be implemented at Azevada and that STUDENT could be successful at Azevada.
20. Dr. Troiano and Ms. Salvas also testified that STUDENT’s program for the 2001-2002 school year was so strong that it could be implemented at any school in the District.
21. MS. PARENT testified that one cannot know how the teacher will turn out until the child is in the class.
22. Both STUDENT’s parents and Dr. Robinson testified that STUDENT’s science teacher for the 2001 extended school year was unprepared. Thus, they withdrew STUDENT from the class. However, STUDENT’s parents also did not choose his physical education teacher for the extended school year who turned out to be very good.
23. The IDEA first requires a transition plan when a child reaches the age of 14. While the IDEA does not require a transition plan for children under 14 years of age, such a plan might be necessary for a child younger than 14 years of age with special needs.
24. Petitioner alleged during the hearing that Leitch was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT and that placement at Leitch overrode the District’s policy on intradistrict transfer. However, the substantive appropriateness of the District’s proposed placement for the 2001-2002 school year was not an issue at the hearing. Furthermore, STUDENT’s assessment results from Stanford University were not available to the IEP team at the first IEP meeting on May 24, 200 when it discussed placement. Finally, the IEP team agreed to discuss the results of STUDENT’s assessment at the second IEP meeting on September 7, 2001. Therefore, the Hearing Officer shall not consider this issue.
