California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 3, 1996

Student v. Tehachapi Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 780-93 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Tehachapi Unified prevails: fifth grader with ADHD and a 504 plan not eligible for special education as SED or OHI.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The case was filed in December 1993 and taken off calendar in March 1994 for mediation. After a dismissal warning, it was reactivated in 1995, and a further hearing request on November 28, 1995 led to the hearing. The decision notes no remand, court order, vacatur, or correction.

Summary

The student's stepgrandfather, a non-attorney advocate, filed for a hearing against Tehachapi Unified School District in December 1993. The case was reactivated in late 1995. The student was an 11-year-old fifth grader with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). He had a Section 504 plan that included a behavior plan, counseling, and transportation, and he received Title I help in reading and math. He had a long history of conflicts with peers and on the playground, but his grades were consistently average or better. The family argued he should have been found eligible for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) or other health impaired (OHI). They also sought services, a behavior program, counseling, and a placement.

Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found that the District met its "search and serve" duty. It tried regular education interventions first and assessed him promptly when the parents asked in 1993 and 1995. The IEP meeting after the 1993 Diagnostic Center assessment took place about 72 days later, past the 50-day deadline. The Hearing Officer called this a minor violation that did not deny FAPE. A checkmark next to OHI on the November 1995 IEP form was a clerical error. All three assessments were appropriate. The student did not meet SED criteria because his peer problems and occasional depression were not to a marked degree. He did not meet OHI criteria because medication controlled his ADHD. All relief was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled ADHD before the 1997 amendments. A diagnosis alone did not make a student eligible. He had to meet SED or OHI criteria and need special education. Strong grades and working regular education and Section 504 supports weighed against eligibility. An OHI checkmark on an IEP form was treated as a clerical error.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedChild find

    Issue 1 (search and serve). Has the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA? Did the District comply with the requirements of 'search and serve'?

    The District properly tried regular education interventions first (Ed. Code 56303), assessed promptly when parents asked in 1993 and 1995, and the student always performed well academically, so search and serve duties were met.

  2. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 1 (IEP meetings). Did the District convene legally sufficient IEP meetings following assessments of STUDENT in 1993 and 1995?

    The February 1993 and November 1995 IEP meetings were timely and properly constituted; the December 1993 meeting held about 72 days after the Diagnostic Center assessment exceeded the 50-day timeline, but this minor violation (and the possible absence of the teacher in February 1993) did not deny FAPE; the OHI checkmark on the November 1995 IEP was a clerical error.

  3. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2. Did the District conduct appropriate assessments of STUDENT in 1993 and 1995?

    The 1993 District assessment, the 1993 Diagnostic Center assessment, and the 1995 Kern County assessment met Ed. Code 56320 and 56327, covered social-emotional functioning, and did not need separate ADHD testing given the existing medical diagnosis; request for further assessment denied.

  4. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 3. Should the District have found STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a serious emotional disturbance (SED)?

    The student had some difficulty with peer relationships and occasional mild depression, but neither was to a marked degree or adversely affected his educational performance, so he did not meet SED criteria.

  5. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 4. Should the District have found STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a health impairment (OHI)?

    Although ADHD is a chronic health problem, medication controlled his symptoms, he showed no limited strength, vitality, or alertness, and he performed well academically, so he did not meet OHI criteria.

  6. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 5. Does STUDENT require a behavioral intervention program to benefit from his education?

    Because the student is not eligible for special education, he is not entitled to services under IDEA.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 6. Does STUDENT require counseling to benefit from his education?

    Because the student is not eligible for special education, he is not entitled to counseling as a service under IDEA; the Hearing Officer made no findings under Section 504.

  8. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 7. Does the District have a placement for STUDENT that is appropriate and that satisfies least restrictive environment requirements?

    Because the student is not eligible for special education, he is not entitled to a placement under IDEA.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Burke County Board of Education v. Denton; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Hall v. Vance County Board of Education; U.S. Department of Education Joint Policy Memorandum on ADD (1991) 18 IDELR 116; 34 C.F.R. 300.7; Education Code 56303; Education Code 56320; Education Code 56327; Education Code 56339; Education Code 56344

People named in the decision

  • Melvin Peters, attorney for District, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Catherine Salzman, District director of programs / special services, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Harold Krumpacher, school board member (observer), Tehachapi Unified School District
  • William Lund, kindergarten teacher, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Nancy Hamlin, kindergarten teacher (second year), Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Judy Ashworth, first-grade teacher, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Joan Tilley, second-grade teacher, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Carol Rapp, second-grade teacher (final quarter), Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Carol Rigby, third-grade teacher, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Margot Centanni, fourth-grade teacher (declaration), Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Terri Coward, fifth-grade teacher, Tompkins Elementary School, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Bill Halling, school psychologist; 1993 assessor and counselor, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Patricia Merritt, principal, Tompkins Elementary (formerly Golden Hills Elementary), Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Barbara Merritt, principal / special education administrator who signed February 1993 IEP, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Judy Nobles, principal, Tompkins Elementary School (1993), Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Byron Johnson, vice principal, Tompkins Elementary, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Douglas Kent Ashworth, District superintendent, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Peggy Henson, intervention specialist (social skills group), Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Joyce Black, transportation supervisor, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Cody West, bus driver, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Anna Maria Cardiel, bus driver, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Beverly Langston, bus driver, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Janna McLaughlin, bus driver/trainer, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Jeri Ellis, noon supervisor, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Thea Swan, noon supervisor, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Joann Clark, noon supervisor, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Jessica Pimental, playground supervisor, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Sheila Seymour, school librarian / former yard duty supervisor, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Barbara Wendt, school attendance clerk, Tehachapi Unified School District
  • Michael Birdsong, director; supervised 1993 assessment, Diagnostic Center of Central California
  • Larry Hughes, Ph.D., conducted 1995 on-site review, Diagnostic Center of Central California
  • Jane Dennis, Ph.D., private psychologist who provided counseling under District contract, private practice
  • John Watson, Ed.D., Kern County administrator / SELPA director, Office of the Kern County Superintendent of Schools
  • Barbara Williams, special education teacher / educational diagnostician (1995 assessor), Office of the Kern County Superintendent of Schools
  • Elvida Martinez, school psychologist (1995 assessor), Office of the Kern County Superintendent of Schools
  • Ann Marie Duquette, public health nurse (1995 health assessment), Office of the Kern County Superintendent of Schools
  • Lane West, audiologist (1995 assessment), Office of the Kern County Superintendent of Schools
  • Dr. Morong, physician who diagnosed ADHD
  • Ronald Sheppard, community program specialist, witness for Student, Developmental Disabilities Area Board VIII
  • Anne Munoz, former substitute bus driver, witness for Student, formerly Tehachapi Unified School District
  • F. Richard Ruderman, Hearing Officer (prehearing conference), Special Education Hearing Office

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Tehachapi, California, on January 23 and 24, February 22 and 23, and April 1 - 3, 1996.

Petitioner was represented by STEPGRANDFATHER, advocate. Also present on behalf of STUDENT during the first four days of hearing was STEPGRANDMOTHER. STEPFATHER appeared briefly on the first day of the hearing. Respondent Tehachapi Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Melvin Peters. Also present on behalf of the District was Catherine Salzman, District director of programs. Board member Harold Krumpacher was present as an observer on the second day of the hearing.(Footnote 1)

Oral and documentary evidence was received, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) Has the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA?

(2) Did the District conduct appropriate assessments of STUDENT in 1993 and 1995?

(3) Should the District have found STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a serious emotional disturbance (SED)?

(4) Should the District have found STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with an other health impairment (OHI)?

(5) Does STUDENT require a behavioral intervention program to benefit from his education?

(6) Does STUDENT require counseling to benefit from his education?

(7) Does the District have a placement for STUDENT that is appropriate and that satisfies least restrictive environment requirements?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner is an 11-year-old student in the fifth grade. He has been diagnosed with an attention deficit disorder with hyperactivity (ADHD), which is treated with medication. STUDENT is not currently eligible for special education. The District has found STUDENT eligible for services under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. Pursuant to STUDENT's 504 accommodation plan, STUDENT is entitled to transportation, counseling, and intervention services at school.(Footnote 2) The plan sets forth methods for dealing with STUDENT on the playground and during transportation and for administering medications, and includes a behavioral intervention plan for the classroom. (Footnote 3) STUDENT also receives assistance with reading and math through the Title I program.(Footnote 4)

STUDENT entered kindergarten during the 1989-90 school year. He participated in a "developmental" kindergarten, which was set up as a two-year program for students showing below average developmental skills on a screening instrument. STUDENT began the 1990-91 school year in the first grade; however, because STUDENT had a difficult time adjusting during the first few weeks of school, he was placed in a kindergarten class.

On July 16, 1990, STUDENT's teacher, Nancy Hamlin, referred STUDENT to the school's student study team (SST) because of concerns regarding STUDENT's behavior.(Footnote 5) Specific behaviors included STUDENT's touching and hitting peers, stealing, not following rules, and behaving defiantly. To address STUDENT's needs, the SST devised a positive behavioral management plan, agreed that counseling would be provided, and recommended daily communication between school and home. STUDENT's parents agreed that he would also receive reinforcement for positive behavior at home. (Respondent's Exhibit 57) Some improvement in STUDENT's behavior was noted when the SST plan was reviewed on September 18, 1990.

On November 14, 1990, school psychologist Bill Halling met with STUDENT's stepfather, stepgrandfather, and Patricia Merritt, school principal. It was agreed that Mr. Halling would begin weekly individual counseling with STUDENT. The family agreed to explore family counseling. (Respondent's Exhibit 57) On March 25, 1991, Mr. Halling met with STUDENT's stepfather, Ms. Merritt, and STUDENT's teacher, Ms. Hamlin. They agreed that STUDENT's classroom behavior had improved and that the behavior modification plan would continue in the first grade. (Respondent's Exhibit 57) The SST met again regarding STUDENT when he was in Judy Ashworth's first-grade class. Concerns expressed to the SST at that time were STUDENT's negative relationships with other children, impulse control problems, aggressive behavior on the playground, and withdrawn behavior when alone.

Mr. Halling continued to see STUDENT intermittently while he was in the first and second grades.(Footnote 6) He also consulted with STUDENT's teachers regarding appropriate behavioral management strategies to use with STUDENT. STUDENT received satisfactory or better grades and his teachers described his academic achievement as "at grade level or above." Teachers also reported improvement in STUDENT's behavior in the classroom; however, STUDENT continued to have problems on the playground. STUDENT's behavioral problems escalated during the 1992-93 school year, particularly during a period when medications were being tried following the diagnosis of ADHD.

On January 8, 1993, STUDENT's parents requested that the District assess STUDENT. On January 11, 1993, Mr. Halling provided the parents with a proposed assessment plan. (Respondent's Exhibit 41) On February 1 and 2, 1993, Mr. Halling conducted a psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT. STUDENT's cognitive abilities fell within the average range. His academic achievement scores reflected strong reading abilities and average writing and math abilities. (Respondent's Exhibit 7) On February 16, 1993, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss the results of the assessment and to determine whether STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education; however, the team found that he qualified for services under Section 504 based on the diagnosis of ADHD. The team developed an initial 504 accommodation plan to address STUDENT's behavioral problems at school. The 504 plan called for the following: implementing a daily behavior modification contract; providing individual or small-group counseling with the school psychologist; in-servicing of yard-duty staff; providing alternatives to recess that include spending the time set aside for recess in the office or library; taking away STUDENT's recess for misbehavior and giving him with the opportunity to be successful at the next recess; providing disciplinary alternatives to suspension such as "in-house" suspension; and implementing a signal between STUDENT and his teacher to advise him of the appropriateness of his behavior.(Footnote 7) STUDENT's parents and teacher also concluded at that time that STUDENT would be transferred to a new school to give him a fresh start. (District's Exhibit 8)

STUDENT entered Tompkins Elementary School for the final quarter of the 1992-93 school term. The 504 accommodation plan continued to be implemented, with periodic revisions, as STUDENT progressed from grade to grade.(Footnote 8) At the parents' request, Mr. Halling stopped seeing STUDENT in August 1993. The District offered the services of a different school psychologist; however, the parents declined these services.

From October 4 through 6 1993, STUDENT was assessed by the California Department of Education's Diagnostic Center of Central California in Fresno (hereafter Diagnostic Center). On test measures, STUDENT's cognitive potential fell within the high average range. STUDENT's scores on measures of academic achievement fell within the average to above average range. Strengths were seen in vocabulary, listening, and reading comprehension skills. The assessment of STUDENT's social/emotional functioning found STUDENT significantly depressed, especially regarding social difficulties at school and the lack of control over his behaviors. The report of the assessment states that STUDENT did not show significant hyperactivity, impulsivity, or distractibility, and concluded that medications were successfully controlling STUDENT's symptoms of ADHD. A mild conductive hearing loss in the left ear was identified. (Respondent's Exhibit 6) On December 17, 1993, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss the assessment by the Diagnostic Center and STUDENT's eligibility for special education. District members of the IEP team maintained that with the support of services under his 504 accommodation plan, STUDENT was making academic progress and did not require special education.

On December 21, 1993, the Special Education Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from STEPGRANDFATHER on behalf of STUDENT. The issues identified for hearing regarded eligibility, placement, services, and the District's compliance with the IDEA. STEPGRANDFATHER initially waived mediation and the matter was set for hearing. Thereafter, the parties agreed to mediate. In February 1994, the District contracted with Jane Dennis, Ph.D., a psychologist in private practice, to provide STUDENT with individual counseling through the end of the school year in June 1994. On March 25, 1994, the parties agreed to take the hearing off calendar.

During the 1994-95 school year, while in the fourth grade, STUDENT's 504 accommodation plan continued. He also participated in a weekly "intervention group" at school, which was designed to help improve social skills, self-esteem, and peer relationships.

On July 31, 1995, because there was no activity in the case for over one year, the Hearing Office informed the parties that the matter would be dismissed unless one of the parties contacted the Hearing Office by August 14, 1995. On August 14, 1995, the Hearing Office received a letter from STEPGRANDFATHER indicating that the case should remain open. He did not at that time ask that the case be placed back on calendar for hearing. The Hearing Office assigned a mediator to work with the parties.

Apparently in October 1995, STUDENT's parents requested a reevaluation of STUDENT. The Diagnostic Center did not find that another full assessment of STUDENT at the Diagnostic Center in Fresno was warranted at that time. Instead, on October 25, 1995, the Diagnostic Center sent Larry Hughes, Ph.D., to conduct an on-site review at STUDENT's school. Dr. Hughes observed STUDENT for approximately two hours in his classroom and on the playground, consulted with Terri Coward, STUDENT's fifth-grade teacher, and reviewed STUDENT's school records. Dr. Hughes did not observe STUDENT engaging in any inappropriate or unusual behaviors. He indicated that STUDENT performed with adequate attention and focus, responded appropriately to questions from his teacher, and was appropriately engaged in a soccer game with peers on the playground. (District's Exhibit 6)

The District and STUDENT's parents agreed to have STUDENT assessed by the Office of the Kern County Superintendent of Schools (hereafter Kern County). The assessment, which was completed in November 1995, includes health, audiological, educational, and psychological evaluations. On the WISC-III, STUDENT obtained a verbal IQ score of 105, a performance score of 121, and a full scale score of 113. Achievement scores in reading and math fell within the average range. STUDENT's overall written language skills were lower; however, isolated skills, such as sentence construction and word order, were within the average range. The audiological evaluation again revealed a mild hearing loss in the left ear, which the assessor believed would not cause STUDENT significant difficulty hearing in most classroom situations. (Respondent's Exhibits 2 - 5)

On November 14, 1995, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss the results of the assessment and to determine whether STUDENT was eligible for special education. The following persons participated in the IEP meeting: STUDENT's parents; Patricia Merritt, Tompkins School principal; Ms. Coward; Ms. Salzman, District director of special services; and members of the Kern County team that had assessed STUDENT. Kern County members included Barbara Williams, special education teacher; Elvida Martinez, school psychologist; the school nurse; and the audiologist. On the IEP form under the heading "Disability Category," there is a check mark in the box to the left of "Other Health Impaired (OHI)" and, to the right of OHI, the letters "ADHD" are handwritten. The IEP form identifies the instructional setting as 100% in a regular education program. The IEP form also notes that STUDENT is entitled to Title I services and that his 504 accommodation plan would continue.(Footnote 9) The members of the IEP team, including the parents, signed the IEP form, indicating their agreement with the decisions made at the meeting.(Footnote 10) Attached to the IEP is a note prepared by Ms. Salzman which states that the mark next to "Other Health Impaired" was a "clerical error" and that the IEP team had not determined that STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education. (Respondent's Exhibit 10)

On November 27, 1995, the District suspended STUDENT for one day for defiance and for throwing a rock at a window. On November 28, 1995, the Hearing Office received a request from STEPGRANDFATHER for an "emergency hearing," apparently in response to STUDENT's behavior and suspension.(Footnote 11) On November 29, 1995, the parties participated in a telephone conference with Hearing Officer Cote. STEPGRANDFATHER requested that the Hearing Officer immediately order the District to (1) fund STUDENT's placement at the Bakersfield Memorial Center for Behavioral Health (hereafter Memorial Center); and (2) implement a behavioral intervention plan. The Hearing Officer informed the parties that a decision on placement and services could be made only after an evidentiary due process hearing. The matter was then set for hearing for December 14 and 15, 1995.

STUDENT's family placed him at the Memorial Center from December 1 through December 11, 1995.(Footnote 12) STUDENT did not return to school in the District upon his release from Memorial Center.(Footnote 13) During another prehearing telephone conference with Hearing Officer F. Richard Ruderman, the parties agreed to continue the hearing to January 11 and 12, 1996. The hearing was again continued and ultimately convened on January 23, 1996. On January 24, 1996, STUDENT returned to his fifth-grade class at Tompkins.(Footnote 14)

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

William Lund was STUDENT's kindergarten teacher. Mr. Lund described STUDENT as a "bright and inquisitive" student. Mr. Lund did not recall STUDENT's having any particular problems on the playground or in the classroom. He did recall that STUDENT would occasionally "poke" or otherwise bother another student. Mr. Lund testified that the color-coded behavioral management system used with his class was effective with STUDENT.(Footnote 15) Mr. Lund stated that moving STUDENT away from other students when he bothered them was also effective. Mr. Lund testified that he did not see any reason to refer STUDENT for a special education assessment.

Nancy Hamlin was STUDENT's teacher during his second year of kindergarten. Ms. Hamlin described STUDENT as "very alert and aware of what was going on in class, bright and knowledgeable." Ms. Hamlin testified that STUDENT sometimes had difficulty keeping his hands to himself when he was close to other students. Ms. Hamlin testified that she had to work on similar behavior with other students in the class. To help STUDENT manage his behavior, Ms. Hamlin daily tallied positive behavior, which was shared with STUDENT's parents and for which STUDENT received a reward. Ms. Hamlin testified that STUDENT's behavior did not interfere with his academic achievement, which was above average. She referred STUDENT to the SST for assistance with dealing with his behavioral problems. Ms. Hamlin testified that she did not, however, refer STUDENT for a special education assessment because he was able to maintain the skills that were essential for the first grade and he was able to work independently.

Judy Ashworth was STUDENT's first-grade teacher. Ms. Ashworth testified that while in her class, STUDENT had difficulty working independently and getting along with his peers. She stated that STUDENT tried to kiss the girls in the class. STUDENT also had a short attention span. To address STUDENT's behavioral problems, Ms. Ashworth used a daily behavior rating system, which was sent home to STUDENT's parents. She also gave STUDENT stickers for good behavior and rearranged his seating in the classroom. Ms. Ashworth testified that STUDENT did well academically in her class. He did not appear depressed and he did not lack strength, alertness, or vitality.

Joan Tilley was STUDENT's teacher for the first three quarters of the second grade. Ms. Tilley described STUDENT as a "good" student. He did not have any attentional problems while in her class, and he was able to work independently. He also did not appear lethargic or depressed, and did not engage in self-injurious behavior. Ms. Tilley testified that STUDENT was not, however, a very popular student and had a reputation as a "bully." Ms. Tilley recalled one incident in which STUDENT kicked a teacher who was escorting him to the school bus because he did not want to ride the bus home after school. STUDENT also had problems with other students when standing in line and on the playground. Ms. Tilley regularly monitored STUDENT's behavior, which was recorded on a chart. She sent the chart home to STUDENT's mother and spoke with her each Friday. Ms. Tilley testified that STUDENT's behavioral problems did not interfere with his academic achievement.

Carol Rapp was STUDENT's teacher for the final quarter of the second grade. Ms. Rapp testified that she began implementing STUDENT's 504 behavioral contract when he entered her class. "Success sheets" of targeted behaviors were marked frequently and regularly, and Ms. Rapp constantly spoke with STUDENT regarding the proper way to deal with different situations. According to Ms. Rapp, the following worked with STUDENT: speaking to him in a calm manner and explaining what was expected of him; providing him with consequences for his behavior; and being consistent. Ms. Rapp testified that STUDENT was not always self-motivated to do his work and he continued to have some behavioral problems. She testified, however, that STUDENT's behavior did not interfere with his achievement. He made academic progress, as shown by his oral and written performance on academic tasks, and his behavior also improved. Ms. Rapp testified that STUDENT was alert and on task. Ms. Rapp attributed STUDENT's occasional unhappiness or moodiness to specific events that generally occurred outside of the school environment. For example, STUDENT would be very upset if he did not have lunch money or his behavioral check sheet from home.

Carol Rigby was STUDENT's third-grade teacher. Ms. Rigby testified that STUDENT was a smart student and a good reader. She stated that STUDENT was not a self-starter and would have "mini temper tantrums" if he did not want to do a certain task. Ms. Rigby testified that STUDENT had difficulty getting along with other children, accepting responsibility for his actions, and following directions. These problems primarily occurred on the playground. It was Ms. Rigby's opinion that STUDENT's behavior stemmed from his desperately wanting to get the attention and respect of his classmates. Ms. Rigby testified that she implemented STUDENT's 504 plan, including hourly charting his behavior. She also instituted a "buddy" system to help STUDENT's self-esteem. Ms. Rigby testified that STUDENT does not need a special education program because he does well academically.

Margot Centanni, STUDENT's fourth-grade teacher, was unavailable to testify and prepared a declaration of her impressions regarding STUDENT. She noted the following: STUDENT attended regularly; he completed the majority of his assignments in a satisfactory or above average manner; and he was accepted by his peers "for many activities, but continually wished to draw attention to himself through unsuitable behavior usually stemming from the playground." She also noted that "relatively speaking" STUDENT had a successful year. (Respondent's Exhibit 1)

Terri Coward is STUDENT's current teacher. Ms. Coward testified that STUDENT's 504 plan addresses his needs related to ADHD and, for this reason, STUDENT does not require a special education program. Ms. Coward also testified that STUDENT performs average or above-average in all academic areas and fits well into the fifth-grade regular education class. She stated that STUDENT has some difficulty with written language; however, as of the date of the hearing, STUDENT had earned an A+ on spelling quizzes and an A- on a written language assignment. Ms. Coward testified that the class has an instructional aide who is available to provide STUDENT assistance as needed. Based on STUDENT's performance in her class, Ms. Coward does not believe that STUDENT's lower-than-average CTBS scores that qualify him for Title I services accurately reflect STUDENT's current level of academic achievement.(Footnote 16) Ms. Coward noted that STUDENT is sometimes depressed or moody about a specific incident that has occurred outside of school. For example, one day STUDENT had mistakenly been told that there was no school that day and, in fact, his sister and the son of his babysitter were both on a school track that was not scheduled to attend school. When STUDENT was apprised of the mistake and sent to the bus, he became upset and was involved in an incident at the bus stop.

Ms. Coward testified that STUDENT's relationships with peers and his self-esteem have improved since the beginning of the school year. As to STUDENT's behavior, Ms. Coward testified that STUDENT has had few behavioral problems in the classroom and on the playground, and also has been defiant on occasion. Ms. Coward stated that one day STUDENT did not return to class after recess. She has not observed STUDENT being physically aggressive toward other students. Ms. Coward testified that she has good rapport with STUDENT. To meet his needs, she speaks with him in a calm manner, does not reprimand him in front of the other students, and seats him close to either herself or her aide. Ms. Coward also holds weekly class meetings to allow the students to address concerns and to pay compliments to each other. Ms. Coward stated that the meetings provide an opportunity to address alternatives for poor language and aggressive behavior.

Bill Halling is a credentialed school psychologist. Mr. Halling worked with STUDENT from 1990 to 1993 and assessed him in February 1993. Mr. Halling testified that STUDENT had issues regarding isolation, rejection, separation, loneliness, not being included, sadness, and depression. He did not find STUDENT self-injurious or suicidal. Mr. Halling testified that the Diagnostic Center incorrectly interpreted an incident involving reckless behavior on his bike as evidence of intentional self-injurious behavior. Mr. Halling testified that STUDENT has also had to deal with difficult family dynamics.

Mr. Halling testified that he did not refer STUDENT for a special education assessment in 1990 because STUDENT was performing at or above grade level in academics and that neither STUDENT's parents, STEPGRANDFATHER, nor STUDENT's teacher requested a special education assessment. Mr. Halling testified that the District is also mandated to attempt modifications to a student's program before making a special education referral. Mr. Halling stated that in light of this requirement, he initiated weekly counseling to address STUDENT's aggressive behavior with other children, advised the parents to seek family counseling regarding family dynamics, and consulted with the teachers to develop appropriate behavioral interventions to use with STUDENT.

Mr. Halling testified that he did not refer STUDENT for a special education assessment between 1990 and 1993 because the behavioral intervention plan and counseling were working well with STUDENT and STUDENT continued to perform well academically. Mr. Halling testified that his opinion regarding STUDENT's eligibility for special education has not changed since his assessment of STUDENT in 1993. His opinion that STUDENT does not meet special education eligibility criteria is based on the results of formal testing, observations of STUDENT in his class and on the playground, reports by other staff working with STUDENT, and information gained by working directly with STUDENT. Mr. Halling stated also that STUDENT's aggressive behavior has decreased over time and has all but ceased since he started attending Tompkins. Mr. Halling testified that even if STUDENT's conflicts with peers, and intermittently with teachers, could be construed as indicators that STUDENT is emotionally disturbed, STUDENT's problems have never been to a marked degree and at no time has STUDENT's educational performance been impacted by his behavior. Mr. Halling testified that the escalation of STUDENT's behavioral problems in the second grade coincided with changes to STUDENT's medication and would not make him eligible for special education. Mr. Halling testified that a diagnosis of ADHD does not automatically qualify a student for special education. Mr. Halling did not consider STUDENT eligible for special education as OHI because STUDENT does not suffer from limited alertness or vitality, he does not lack strength, the ability to stay awake, or to produce in school, and his academic achievement is average or better. Mr. Halling testified that it is not necessary to develop a behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT under the Hughes Bill because the Hughes Bill applies only to special education students.

Michael Birdsong, director, Diagnostic Center, supervised STUDENT's assessment, participated in a conference following the assessment with STUDENT's parents and District representatives, and was a member of the IEP team that met in December 1993. Mr. Birdsong testified that at the time of STUDENT's assessment by the Diagnostic Center, STUDENT was exhibiting depression that warranted further investigation. Mr. Birdsong stated that an AB3632 assessment by mental health would have been one way to further assess STUDENT's need for additional services. There was no evidence that STUDENT had limited strength, vitality, or alertness. Mr. Birdsong testified that the results of testing indicated that STUDENT was at grade level in all academic areas and was benefitting from participating in a regular education class. Mr. Birdsong testified that, for these reasons, he personally agreed with the consensus of District representatives at the IEP meeting that STUDENT was not eligible for special education.

Jane Dennis, Ph.D., is a psychologist in private practice who provided STUDENT with counseling in 1994 under a contract with the District. Dr. Dennis testified that in June 1994, she scheduled a session with STUDENT's parents but they did not attend and she did not hear from them thereafter. During sessions with STUDENT, Dr. Dennis employed play therapy techniques and engaged in games with STUDENT to change STUDENT's behavior and to promote his thought processes. Dr. Dennis testified that STUDENT was very intelligent, cooperative, and pleasant. He was also eager to understand why people do not like him and wanted to change his behavior. Dr. Dennis found positive social reinforcement to be effective with STUDENT. Dr. Dennis testified that under the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-IV, STUDENT would be diagnosed with a conduct disorder and have a secondary diagnosis of a depressive disorder, signs of which appear "now and then." In her opinion, when she last saw STUDENT, his problems were mild and were not pervasive. Dr. Dennis testified that she does not consider STUDENT disabled. She testified that SED characteristics from the education code "do not describe STUDENT." Dr. Dennis also did not find that STUDENT's attentional problems meet OHI criteria. Dr. Dennis testified that STUDENT did not exhibit problems focusing or filtering stimuli. She also did not observe any symptoms of ADHD during her sessions with STUDENT.

Peggy Henson is an intervention specialist who led intervention groups at STUDENT's school during the 1994-95 school year. The groups were made up of students in grades four through six referred by their teachers to work on social skills, getting along with peers, and self-esteem problems. STUDENT and two to three other students met with Ms. Henson on a weekly basis for 30-minute sessions. Ms. Henson testified that STUDENT needed to work on social skills, working cooperatively with other children, and understanding other children's feelings. Ms. Henson testified that she first worked with the students to get them in touch with their own feelings. She then used role playing and games to develop social skills. Ms. Henson testified that STUDENT benefitted from the program. She did not see any evidence of anger or emotional problems in STUDENT and he did not appear depressed. Ms. Henson characterized STUDENT's relationship with her as normal and cooperative.

Michael Birdsong, director, Diagnostic Center, supervised STUDENT's assessment, participated in a conference following the assessment with STUDENT's parents and District representatives, and was a member of the IEP team that met in December 1993. Mr. Birdsong testified that at the time of STUDENT's assessment by the Diagnostic Center, STUDENT was exhibiting depression that warranted further investigation. Mr. Birdsong stated that an AB3632 assessment by mental health would have been one way to further assess STUDENT's need for additional services. There was no evidence that STUDENT had limited strength, vitality, or alertness. Mr. Birdsong testified that the results of testing indicated that STUDENT was at grade level in all academic areas and was benefitting from participating in a regular education class. Mr. Birdsong testified that, for these reasons, he personally agreed with the consensus of District representatives at the IEP meeting that STUDENT was not eligible for special education.

Patricia Merritt, principal of Tompkins, has known STUDENT since kindergarten. Prior to becoming principal of Tompkins, Ms. Merritt was principal of Golden Hills Elementary School, which STUDENT attended during kindergarten, first, and second grades. Ms. Merritt testified that STUDENT has had on-going problems related to the bus and with peer relationships. She testified, however, that STUDENT has made friends and that he is able to get along with peers and adults. For example, STUDENT gets along well with his current teacher and with teachers from prior school years. Ms. Merritt believes that she also has a good relationship with STUDENT. Ms. Merritt testified that none of STUDENT's problems rise to the level that require special education. She stated, however, that STUDENT could benefit from counseling to assist him with social skills and to allow him to have someone in whom he can confide. Ms. Merritt testified that STUDENT has never been found eligible for special education by an IEP team. Ms. Merritt did not recall anyone suggesting at the most recent IEP meeting on November 14, 1995, that STUDENT meets special education eligibility criteria. Ms. Merritt testified that the team concluded that STUDENT's needs could best be served in the regular education program with accommodations through Section 504.

Ms. Merritt testified that STUDENT was suspended for one day only in November 1995 and that, per parental decision, STUDENT did not return to school until the third week in January 1996. Ms. Merritt testified that the District has referred STUDENT to mental health for an AB3632 assessment; however, it was her understanding that the assessment was not done because STUDENT's parents did not consent to the assessment.

Byron Johnson is the vice principal at Tompkins. Mr. Johnson recalled receiving a total of four written referrals for behavioral intervention regarding STUDENT. He also recalled STUDENT being sent to the office for "time out" by a teacher or playground supervisor fewer than 10 times. Mr. Johnson stated that STUDENT has not been referred to him for disciplinary reasons since he returned to school in January 1996. Mr. Johnson testified that STUDENT had spoken to him in the past about being depressed and suicidal. He recommended counseling to help STUDENT learn to control his behavior and to come in contact with his feelings. Mr. Johnson testified that he has no concerns regarding STUDENT's academic performance. He stated that STUDENT's communication skills are above his grade level, he functions well in the classroom, and he does not require additional supervision. Mr. Johnson testified that STUDENT has formed peer relations and also has positive relationships with adults.

Douglas Kent Ashworth, District superintendent since 1990, testified that STUDENT does not meet eligibility criteria for special education as SED or OHI. Mr. Ashworth testified that STUDENT has some difficulty with relationships; however, he has shown that he is capable of forming relationships.

John Watson, Ed.D., Kern County administrator, testified that in his capacity as SELPA director, he reviewed the report of the November 1995 IEP meeting regarding STUDENT. In speaking with Elvida Martinez, a Kern County employee who had assessed STUDENT and participated in the IEP meeting, it was brought to Dr. Watson's attention that the IEP appeared to indicate that STUDENT was OHI and eligible for special education, which was contrary to the decision of the IEP team. Mr. Watson informed Ms. Salzman of the error, and she wrote the addendum that is attached to the IEP.

Joyce Black, District transportation supervisor, testified that STUDENT has not been a "real" problem on the bus. She stated that, at times, STUDENT did not want to catch the bus on his side of the street and attempted to catch the bus on the other side of the street. Ms. Black testified that STUDENT has also gotten out of his seat while the bus was moving and has teased other students. She noted that other students also engage in similar behavior. Ms. Black testified that STUDENT received four bus citations during March of 1996 related to changing seats, waving a wire at a student, and throwing things at a passing car. Ms. Black testified that to reduce STUDENT's problems on the bus, the bus driver has now assigned STUDENT the first seat to her right. Ms. Black held the opinion that the assigned seat has improved STUDENT's behavior.

Cody West, bus driver, has sporadically had STUDENT as a passenger on her bus over the past five years. STUDENT regularly rode her bus home from school during the 1994-95 school year. Ms. West testified that STUDENT never misbehaved and exhibited above-average behavior on the bus. She stated that he periodically would stand up or would not sit in his assigned seat; however, he did not engage in any more inappropriate behavior than any of the other students on the bus.

Anna Maria Cardiel currently drives STUDENT home from school. Ms. Cardiel described STUDENT's behavior as "mild" when compared to behavior of some of the other students' behavior on the bus. She testified that STUDENT does not have continuous or ongoing problems on the bus. Ms. Cardiel believes that STUDENT just wants attention on occasions. Ms. Cardiel testified that she has written bus tickets for STUDENT several times for being out of his seat and for waving an object at another student. Ms. Cardiel also stated that STUDENT has indicated to her that he wants to ride the bus that picks up students on the other side of the street because the ride is shorter. STUDENT is not, however, allowed to cross the street for safety reasons.

Beverly Langston currently drives STUDENT to school in the morning. Ms. Langston testified that STUDENT likes to come to the bus stop early to cross the street in an attempt to catch the bus on the other side of the street. This is not STUDENT's assigned bus stop. Ms. Langston testified that she has written bus tickets for STUDENT over the past four years when he has been on her bus. She described his behavior as "moderately negative." He can be oppositional and defiant. She has not observed him to be depressed. Ms. Langston testified that interventions usually work with STUDENT, and she does not believe that he requires a more intensive behavioral plan for the bus.

Janna McLaughlin, bus driver/trainer, testified that the bus drivers receive training annually regarding bus safety and how to handle students on the busses. Ms. McLaughlin has observed STUDENT on the bus several times. During one of her observations, until the bus driver intervened, STUDENT would not let another student get off the bus. Ms. McLaughlin stated that a van could be an alternative way to transport STUDENT.

Jeri Ellis, noon supervisor, testified that she sees STUDENT daily while he is in the cafeteria for lunch, as he exits the cafeteria, and on the playground during lunch period. Ms. Ellis testified that she has not observed anything out of the ordinary about him.

Thea Swan, noon supervisor, testified that the only problem she has had with STUDENT is that he has lied to her a few times. For example, STUDENT did not go to the office on two occasions when told to do so by Ms. Swan. Ms. Swan stated that STUDENT has appeared somewhat withdrawn in the last two months. She testified that STUDENT interacts with his peers and that she has observed him playing games with peers in a manner appropriate for his age.

Joann Clark, noon supervisor, did not know who STUDENT is. Jessica Pimental, playground supervisor, also initially did not recall STUDENT. When told that he was the child who "went over the fence" several months ago, Ms. Pimental stated that the fence incident was the only recollection that she had of STUDENT. She indicated that she was not successful in persuading STUDENT to come back to the playground. Instead, he went to a vacant field near the school.

Sheila Seymour, school librarian, did not recall any specific problems with STUDENT on the playground when she was a yard duty supervisor during the 1992-93 school year. She also did not recall any discipline problems with STUDENT when she worked with him in the computer lab during 1993. She testified that STUDENT did not require any special assistance utilizing the computer or with the computer lessons in reading and math. She described STUDENT as "very alert and attentive."

Barbara Wendt, school attendance clerk, testified that she has not had any problems with STUDENT in dispensing his daily medication to him.

The following additional witnesses were called on behalf of STUDENT. Christine Leishman has been a neighbor of the PARENTS for seven years and provided child care for STUDENT starting last year. Ms. Leishman has not taken care of STUDENT recently because he is currently living with his mother elsewhere in Tehachapi. Ms. Leishman testified that STUDENT and her son have been friends and have played together since they have been neighbors. Ms. Leishman testified that STUDENT disregards authority and is manipulative. She testified that STUDENT's behaviors have worsened over the last few years and that he needs help. On the other hand, Ms. Leishman characterized STUDENT as a "good kid" who wants to be liked. Ms. Leishman testified that STUDENT thinks very highly of himself and believes that he can do anything. Consequently, he likes to take risks but, in her opinion, STUDENT is not dangerous or reckless. Ms. Leishman expressed concern because STUDENT has set fires at her home, has hidden his medication rather than taking it, and has lied. Ms. Leishman testified that STUDENT is better at times and that she has noticed the positive effect of STUDENT's medication on his behavior.

Ronald Sheppard, community program specialist, Developmental Disabilities Area Board VIII, testified that STUDENT needs assistance adjusting to structured situations in school and home. Mr. Sheppard testified that STUDENT would benefit from counseling and training regarding handling of social situations. Mr. Sheppard did not express an opinion regarding whether STUDENT qualifies for special education.

Anne Munoz is currently a bus driver for Bakersfield Association for Retarded Citizens. Ms. Munoz was a substitute bus driver with the District for over three years and was assigned to STUDENT's afternoon bus route for three to four months. The District dismissed Ms. Munoz from her position and she later filed a complaint against the District. Ms. Munoz testified that STUDENT had problems staying in his seat and keeping his hands to himself. Ms. Munoz testified that by moving STUDENT to the front of the bus and providing him face-to-face instructions, she could ensure that STUDENT would behave appropriately. Ms. Munoz testified that she had to rely on the training she received while employed by another school district in order to know how to deal with STUDENT. Ms. Munoz testified that the District did not provide bus drivers with training to deal with students with special needs.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Has the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.

In addition to the requirements of an appropriate education, Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the appropriate public education to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the child's educational program. The procedural rights extended to parents include in part: the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to participate in the development of the child's IEP; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the right to a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415.

In Rowley, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of compliance with the procedural provisions of the IDEA. The Court stated:

It seems to us no exaggeration to say that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every state of the administrative process, see, e.g., §§ 1415(a)-(d), as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard. We think that the Congressional emphasis upon full participation of concerned parties throughout the development of the IEP, as well as the requirements that state and local plans be submitted to the Commissioner for approval, demonstrate the legislative conviction that adequate compliance with the procedures prescribed would in most cases assure much if not all of what Congress wished in the way of substantive content in an IEP.

458 U.S. 175, 205-206.

In summary, the Court concluded that the inquiry in suits brought under §1415(e)(2) is twofold--whether the district complied with procedural safeguards and whether it offered an appropriate educational placement. 458 U.S. 205-7.

Based on the reasoning in Rowley, several federal circuit courts have found that under certain circumstances procedural violations of the IDEA can result in the denial of a free appropriate public education. In W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, the Ninth Circuit held that procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP process "clearly result in the denial of FAPE." See Burke County Board of Education v. Denton (4th Cir. 1990) 895 F.2d 973; Rowland Md. v. Concord School Committee (1st Cir. 1990) 910 F.2d 983; Hall v. Vance County Board of Education (4th Cir. 1990) 774 F.2d 629.

Petitioner contends that the District failed to follow the procedures set forth in IDEA for assessing and identifying students with disabilities, and for convening an IEP meeting following an assessment. Petitioner asserts that beginning in 1990, he exhibited social, emotional, and behavioral problems, and caused injury to students and teachers, all of which should have triggered a referral for special education. Petitioner asserts that he has continued to exhibit behavioral problems resulting in numerous referrals for discipline. Petitioner also asserts that he suffers from depression.

Petitioner contends that the District failed to develop appropriate IEPs that include goals, objectives, placement, and services, even after finding him eligible for special education as OHI in November 1995. Petitioner also asserts that the District inappropriately disciplined him for acts related to his disability and excluded him from participation in the regular education program and bus transportation for "lengthy" amounts of time.(Footnote 17)

Petitioner contends that he is entitled to compensatory education as a remedy for the District's failure to adhere to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. He also requests reimbursement for the costs of advocacy services and for unspecified private counseling services.(Footnote 18)

The District contends that, as required by special education law, it made appropriate modifications to STUDENT's regular education program prior to referring him for special education. The District asserts that it conducted appropriate assessments of STUDENT in 1993 and 1995, and convened legal IEP meetings to discuss the results of each assessment. The District asserts that the 504 accommodation plan successfully addresses STUDENT's needs and that, because STUDENT has not been determined eligible for special education, the District is not required to develop goals and objectives or provide services pursuant to a special education IEP.

Did the District comply with the requirements of "search and serve?"

Each district, special education local plan area, or county office of education shall provide for the identification and assessment of individuals with exceptional needs. Education Code § 56302. Pursuant to Education Code § 56303, a pupil shall be referred for special educational instruction and services only after the resources of the regular education program have been considered and, where appropriate, utilized. All referrals for special education and related services shall initiate the assessment process. California Code of Regulations § 3021(a). A referral for assessment means any written request for assessment made by a parent, teacher, or other service provider. Education Code § 56029.

There was no evidence that the District failed to act upon a request for an assessment of STUDENT by either his parents, teachers, or advocates. However, STUDENT's behavioral and social problems have been documented since kindergarten, and STEPGRANDFATHER raised the issue of whether the District had an independent obligation under "search and serve" requirements to assess STUDENT for special education. It is somewhat difficult to recreate what occurred over six years ago. The only witnesses who had observed STUDENT at school between 1990 and 1993 were District employees. No additional witnesses were called on behalf of Petitioner to offer an opinion regarding his need for an assessment. Only Ms. Munoz offered an opinion regarding STUDENT's school performance based on her observations of STUDENT while transporting him on the bus. Petitioner did provide several documents for consideration by the Hearing Officer. The documents generally provided information regarding ADHD and proposed behavioral intervention programs, goals, and objectives. Petitioner's documentary evidence did not include any independent assessments or reports by individuals regarding STUDENT's educational performance during the period in question. For this reason, the Hearing Office must generally rely on the testimony of District personnel who worked directly with STUDENT and STUDENT's educational records presented by the District.

No one rebutted the testimony of STUDENT's kindergarten teachers, Mr. Lund and Ms. Hamlin, and the school psychologist, Mr. Halling, that a referral of STUDENT for special education while in kindergarten was not warranted. Their testimony and STUDENT's report cards establish that STUDENT was receiving good marks and performing well academically. It was also the consensus of the SST that a plan should be developed and implemented to address STUDENT's behavioral problems rather than to refer him to special education at that time. The decision of the SST to implement behavioral interventions and counseling is consistent with the requirement of Education Code § 56303 that resources of the regular education program must be utilized prior to making a referral for special education. In this case, it was appropriate to attempt interventions in the regular education program, given that STUDENT was in kindergarten and was performing well academically. Moreover, Ms. Hamlin and Mr. Halling, who both worked with STUDENT in an educational setting during kindergarten, testified that the behavioral intervention program and counseling resulted in some improvement to STUDENT's behavior.

As to whether the District should have assessed STUDENT for special education during the 1991-92 school year, Ms. Ashworth, STUDENT's teacher, testified regarding frustrations she experienced dealing with STUDENT's behavior and with his family. Her opinion, however, was that STUDENT did not require special education. Moreover, the testimony of Mr. Halling and Ms. Ashworth, as well as STUDENT's report card, establish that STUDENT continued to perform well academically. The SST also decided to continue the course of counseling and implementation of a behavioral intervention program to address STUDENT's continuing behavioral problems. No one testified that a special education assessment of STUDENT was warranted during the first grade.

Mr. Halling and Ms. Tilley, STUDENT's teacher for the first three quarters of the second grade, testified that STUDENT continued to perform well academically and that his behavior did not interfere with his education. STUDENT's behavioral problems escalated; however, the most difficult time was during the period when certain medications were being tried with STUDENT following a diagnosis of ADHD. During this time, STUDENT's parents made a written request for an assessment. The request was apparently made by STUDENT's parents on January 8, 1993.(Footnote 19) In response to this request, school psychologist Bill Halling prepared an assessment plan, requested that the parents complete a health history, and on February 1 and 2, 1993, conducted an assessment of STUDENT.

Mr. Halling testified that he referred STUDENT for an assessment by the Diagnostic Center because of concerns regarding the parents' acceptance of his findings. This assessment was completed in October 1993. The District also referred STUDENT to Mental health for an assessment. Assessments conducted by Mental Health are generally to determine whether students who are SED require AB3632 services. In this case, when STUDENT's parents did not consent to an assessment, the District offered to continue providing services to STUDENT under Section 504. STUDENT's parents requested further assessment of STUDENT in 1995 because of ongoing concerns regarding his behavior. In response, the District referred STUDENT for an assessment by the Kern County and the Diagnostic Center completed an on-site observation as a follow-up to their earlier assessment of STUDENT. The Kern County assessment was completed in November 1995. STUDENT's teachers from 1993 to the present testified that STUDENT has continued to do well academically, that his behavior has improved, and that they did not believe STUDENT required special education. There is no evidence of any further requests for an assessment or referrals for special education. Consequently, there also is no evidence that the District failed to assess STUDENT in response to a request for an assessment.

In summary, the District completed an assessment of STUDENT in February 1993 in response to the parents' request and referred STUDENT for an assessment by the Diagnostic Center in 1993. The District referred STUDENT for an assessment by Kern County in response to a request for assessment in October 1995. Neither the school psychologist who worked with STUDENT over a period of time nor any of STUDENT's teachers believed that a referral of STUDENT for special education has ever been warranted. The Hearing Officer notes also that STUDENT has performed well academically at all times during the period in question and the District implemented interventions under a 504 accommodation plan. There were no witnesses called by Petitioner to rebut any of the above. Therefore, the Hearing officer finds that the District adequately complied with "search and serve" requirements in regard to STUDENT.

Did the District convene legally sufficient IEP meetings following assessments of STUDENT in 1993 and 1995?

An individualized educational program team conference (IEP) shall be scheduled to discuss the initial formal assessment. Education Code § 56343(a). An IEP required as a result of an assessment shall be developed within 50 days, not counting days between regular school sessions or school vacation in excess of five school days, from the date of receipt of the parent's written consent for assessment. The 50-day time line may be extended by the parent. Education Code § 56344.

The IEP team shall include the following: a representative other than the student's teacher who is knowledgeable of program options and who is qualified to provide, or supervise the provision of, special education; and the student's present teacher. The students' parents must be notified of the meeting and they may invite a representative to participate in the meeting with them or to stand in their place. When the IEP meeting is following an assessment, the IEP team shall include a person who has conducted the assessment or who is knowledgeable about the assessment procedures used to assess the student and is familiar with the results of the assessment. Education Code § 56341(b)-(d). The IEP team shall review the assessment results and determine eligibility. Education Code § 56342.

1993 Assessment by District

On February 16, 1993, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss the results of the assessment it conducted in response to the request on January 8, 1993, by STUDENT's parents for an assessment. February 16, 1993, was 39 days after the request for an assessment and, therefore, falls within the 50 days allowed for convening an IEP meeting following an assessment, as set forth in Education Code §56344. The written report of the IEP meeting was signed by the following: Barbara Merritt, principal, who functioned as the special education administrator; Judy Nobles, principal of Tompkins Elementary School; Mr. Halling, who had conducted the assessment; and STUDENT's mother. It was unclear whether STUDENT's teacher attended the IEP meeting and her signature does not appear on the document. Some of the witnesses recalled that she was there for at least a portion of the meeting. The evidence establishes that the District otherwise met the requirements set forth above for completing an assessment and convening an IEP meeting. Mr. Halling testified that the team determined that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria for special education following a discussion of the District's assessment. Because the IEP team determined that STUDENT did not require special education, it was not legally required to draft goals and objectives at that time.

If in fact STUDENT's teacher was not present at the IEP meeting, her absence did not result in a denial of a free appropriate education to STUDENT. STUDENT's teacher had input into the assessment process by providing information regarding STUDENT during interviews with Mr. Halling and by completing the Burks' Behavior Rating Scale. STUDENT's parents also had input into the assessment, attended the IEP meeting, and participated in the decisions of the IEP team.

1993 Assessment by the Diagnostic Center

The assessment by the Diagnostic Center was completed on October 6, 1993. On October 22, 1993, the Diagnostic Center reviewed the results of the assessment with the parents and school district representatives and a written report of the assessment was sent to the parties on November 16, 1993. The District convened an IEP meeting on December 17, 1993, some 72 days from the date the assessment was completed. A written extension of the time lines for convening an IEP meeting following an assessment was not included in the evidence packet.

Present at the IEP meeting on behalf of the District were an administrator, STUDENT's teacher, the school principal, the attorney, and the school psychologist. Thus, all of the necessary members of an IEP team were present. District members of the IEP team testified that the IEP team discussed whether STUDENT met eligibility for special education. The minutes of the meeting confirm the discussion of eligibility. Because agreement was not reached regarding special education eligibility, the IEP team was not legally required to develop goals and objectives.

It appears that the period between the referral to the Diagnostic Center and the convening of an IEP meeting exceeds the 50-day requirement. There was credible testimony, however, that the IEP meeting had been rescheduled at least one time at the request of STUDENT's parents and ultimately was scheduled at a time that allowed a representative of the Diagnostic Center to participate in the IEP meeting, as well as the parents, their advocates, and District representatives. Moreover, for the following reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the delay in convening the IEP meeting is a minor procedural violation which did not result in the denial of a free appropriate public education to STUDENT: The Diagnostic Center's assessment was completed eight months after the District's assessment and assessed the same general areas; a meeting took place prior to the IEP meeting at which the results of the assessment were discussed; and the parents participated in both the assessment and the IEP processes.

1995 Assessment by the Kern County Office of Education

In October a request for an assessment was made by STUDENT's parents. In November 1995 Kern County completed the assessment and, on November 14, 1995, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss the results of the assessment. Therefore, the IEP meeting took place within the 50-day requirement. In attendance at the IEP meeting were the school principal, director of special education, a special education teacher, members of the Kern County assessment team, STUDENT's teacher, and STUDENT's parents. Therefore, all of the persons required to constitute a legal IEP team were present.

There was a great deal of discussion at the hearing regarding whether the IEP team, in fact, had determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education. It could be inferred from the checkmark next to OHI on the IEP document that the IEP team had concluded that STUDENT met OHI criteria. However, all of the testimony at the hearing supported the District's position that the IEP team concluded that STUDENT did not meet special education eligibility criteria as OHI or anything else. Ms. Salzman and Ms. Merritt, who attended the IEP meeting on behalf of the District, testified that the IEP team did not find STUDENT eligible for special education. Mr. Watson explained that the error on the IEP form came to his attention during a discussion of the IEP with one of the Kern County assessors who had been present at the IEP meeting. Petitioner's advocate did not call any witnesses to testify to the contrary. There is no other indication on the document itself to support the position that the IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education. For example, the IEP document indicates STUDENT's placement as regular education 100% of the time and does not include goals and objectives or special education services. The services listed are for 504 and Chapter I [Title I]. Ms. Merritt testified that she is generally familiar with requirements of special education and has participated in a number of IEP meetings. She testified that if the IEP team had found STUDENT eligible for special education, it would then have developed goals and objectives as part of the IEP process. It did not.

Based on the unrebutted testimony of District witnesses, it is concluded that at the IEP meeting on November 16, 1995, the IEP team did not find that STUDENT was eligible for special education. The Hearing Officer also finds that the District complied with the requirements for convening an IEP under IDEA following the Kern County assessment. It was not necessary for the IEP team to develop goals and objectives, given that the team did not find STUDENT eligible for special education.

In conclusion, a majority of the procedural allegations by Petitioner were not substantiated by the evidence. Those that did occur were minor and did not result in a denial of a free appropriate public education to STUDENT, as set forth in W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range. As discussed more fully below, STUDENT has never been eligible for special education. Thus, there was no loss of educational opportunity to him. Moreover, STUDENT's parents have participated throughout the process of assessment and as members of the IEP team. Therefore, any minor procedural problems did not seriously infringe on the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Based on the findings above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District has sufficiently complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA and, therefore, denies Petitioner's request for relief on this basis.

ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District conduct appropriate assessments of STUDENT in 1993 and 1995?

In order for the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be: selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student's primary language or other mode of communication; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Assessment and testing materials must also not measure the student's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless that is what the test purports to measure.

Section 56320(f) also requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. Pursuant to subsection (g), the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician. These assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Education Code § 56324(a) and (b).

In addition, the assessor is required to prepare a written report of the results of the assessment which, in relevant part, includes the following: whether the student requires special education and services; the basis for making the determination; relevant behavior of the student during an observation in an appropriate environment; the relationship of the behavior to the student's academic and social functioning; educationally relevant health and development; and, when appropriate, medical findings, and a determination of the effects of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage. Education Code § 56327.

Petitioner contends that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability. Specifically, Petitioner asserts that the District has never assessed him for ADHD and has not conducted an assessment of his social and emotional needs. Petitioner did not specify with clarity other areas which he disputed. Petitioner requests that the District be ordered to complete an appropriate assessment that identifies his needs in all areas of suspected disability.

The District contends that in 1993, it conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT and obtained a further appropriate assessment of STUDENT by the Diagnostic Center. The District contends that at its request, Kern County conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in 1995. As to whether the District assessed STUDENT's social and emotional needs, the District contends that all of the assessments addressed these areas. The District asserts that STUDENT's parents did not consent to further assessment by Mental Health.

1993 Assessment by the District

Mr. Halling was responsible for observations, review of records, interviews with STUDENT's parents and teacher, and administration of assessment instruments. He also obtained a health and developmental assessment from STUDENT's mother. Mr. Halling administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III) and the Test of Non-Verbal Intelligence-2 to measure STUDENT's cognitive potential. To assess STUDENT's memory and perceptual skills, Mr. Halling administered the Test of Auditory Analysis Skills, the Bender Motor Gestalt Test, the Visual-Aural Digit Span, and the Jordan Left-Right Reversal Test. Mr. Halling testified that the resource teacher administered the Woodcock-Johnson Test of Academic Achievement-Revised (WJ-R) to assess STUDENT's academic achievement.

In regard to Petitioner's contention that the District did not assess STUDENT's social and emotional functioning, the evidence establishes that Mr. Halling's assessment included the Kinetic Family Drawing, Human Figure Drawing, Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, and Burks' Behavior Rating Scale. Mr. Halling testified that each of these measures assessed STUDENT's social and emotional functioning. Information from STUDENT's teachers and parents, as well as observations of STUDENT, also were considered in assessing STUDENT's social and emotional functioning. As to whether ADD or ADHD were assessed, Mr. Halling testified that certain subtests of the WISC were used to determine STUDENT's "freedom from distractibility." Mr. Halling testified that other measures that assisted in evaluating for ADD or ADHD included the Burks' Behavior Rating Scale, observations of STUDENT, teacher report, and information provided by the parent in the health and developmental history. Given that the District had received Dr. Morong's ADHD diagnosis of STUDENT, it was unnecessary for another medical examination for this purpose. Moreover, the District's assessment evaluated the effect of the ADHD in his educational setting.

There was no evidence that the testing and assessment materials and procedures were racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. They also were administered in English, which is STUDENT's primary language. The assessment was administered by trained personnel. Mr. Halling, who administered a majority of the test, is a credentialed school psychologist. The academic achievement portion was administered by a resource teacher. There was no evidence that the assessment instruments were administered in a manner inconsistent with test instructions or that testing and assessment materials were invalid for the specific purpose for which they are used. Moreover, the assessment instruments used by the District in its assessment of STUDENT are commonly used by school psychologists to assess students for special education.

The District's assessment measured STUDENT's cognitive ability, academic achievement, health and developmental areas, and social and emotional functioning. It also assessed STUDENT's distractibility in an educational environment. Therefore, the District assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. The evidence establishes that Mr. Halling employed a number of assessment instruments, as well as observations and input from STUDENT's teacher and parent, to assess STUDENT's social and emotional functioning, which were the primary areas of concern. There were no concerns at that time regarding STUDENT's speech or language skills. Based on the testimony of Mr. Halling, which is substantiated by the report of the assessment and was not rebutted by any of Petitioner's witnesses, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District's assessment of STUDENT in 1993 was appropriate.

Mr. Halling's 12-page report of the assessment includes the following: reason for referral; procedures utilized in the assessment; background information, including developmental and health histories; observations; assessment results; a statement of eligibility; and recommendations. Mr. Halling recommended family counseling. He also recommended that a 504 accommodation plan be designed to reduce STUDENT's aggressive behavior. Mr. Halling concluded that STUDENT did not meet special education criteria for the following reasons: there was no evidence of a psychological processing disorder; STUDENT's social/emotional problems were not impacting his academic performance; and the District had not yet attempted modifications to STUDENT's regular program. Based on Mr. Halling's testimony and the contents of the assessment report, and the lack of any testimony to the contrary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the report of the District's assessment of STUDENT satisfies the requirements of Education Code §56327.

1993 Assessment by the Diagnostic Center

An assessment by the Diagnostic Center must also be conducted pursuant to the provisions of Education Code § 56320. 5 C.C.R. 3025(b). The assessment of STUDENT by the Diagnostic Center in October 1993 included the following: developmental, medical, familial, and educational histories from STUDENT's parents; the District's educational records; directed observations; and formal and informal assessments of educational, psychological, perceptual-motor, pediatric-neurological, language, speech, and hearing skills. To assess STUDENT's educational achievement, the team administered the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT). Psychological processing was assessed using the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children.

As to the primary areas of concern expressed by Petitioner's advocate, the evidence establishes that the Diagnostic Center utilized the following test instruments to assess STUDENT's social and emotional functioning: the Revised Children's Manifest Anxiety Scale; the Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist-Revised; the Draw-A-Person; Kinetic Family Drawings; Roberts Apperception Test for Children-Revised; and Sentence Completion Test. The assessment team included a pediatrician who holds the appropriate credentials to diagnose ADD and ADHD. The Diagnostic Center did not, however, conduct an independent assessment of whether STUDENT has ADHD. The assessors indicated that STUDENT already had been given a diagnosis of ADHD and that he did not appear to have attentional problems over the four days he was at the Diagnostic Center. The lack of observable attentional problems was attributed to STUDENT's receiving an appropriate course of medication. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that it was not necessary for the Diagnostic Center to conduct additional ADD or ADHD testing. Based on the testimony of Mr. Halling and Dr. Birdsong, and on the information contained in Respondent's Exhibit 6, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Diagnostic Center assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.

There is no evidence that the testing and assessment materials and procedures utilized by the Diagnostic Center were racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. There also is no evidence that the assessment instruments were administered in a manner contrary to test instructions. The assessment was administered in English, which is STUDENT's primary language. The Diagnostic Center assessment team included a pediatrician, a school psychologist, a clinical psychologist, a licensed speech and language pathologist, and an educational specialist. The education and experience required to obtain the credentials held by the members of the assessment team substantiate that the assessment was administered by trained personnel.

The instruments used by the Diagnostic Center to assess STUDENT were not challenged by Petitioner's advocate. Moreover, the assessment instruments are commonly used by psychologists in psychoeducational assessments of students in elementary school. The assessment by the Diagnostic Center assessed STUDENT in social/emotional, academic, speech, language, and hearing. The report by the Diagnostic Center includes the following: history and background information; focus of assessment; summary and implications of findings; diagnostic questions and responses; and recommendations. The report does not make specific recommendations regarding STUDENT's eligibility for special education. The report includes a number of other recommendations, including that STUDENT remain in his regular education class and that he be provided appropriate support services. Based on the information contained within the report, the Hearing Officer finds that the report complies with the requirements of Education Code § 56327.

1995 Assessment by Kern County

Kern County's assessment of STUDENT in October and November 1995 included health, audiological, educational, and psychological evaluations. The health assessment was conducted by Ann Marie Duquette, public health nurse. Ms. Duquette's assessment includes the following: a summary of STUDENT's current health and medical status; prenatal, birth, developmental, and speech histories; current socialization and behavior information; family history; and systems review. Ms. Duquette obtained information from STUDENT's mother and administered the Quick Neurological Screening Test. (Respondent's Exhibit 2) The audiological portion of the assessment was conducted by Lane West, audiologist. (Respondent's Exhibit 3)

Evaluation procedures used by Barbara Williams, educational diagnostician, included the following: review of STUDENT's educational records, previous testing, and class work; observation of STUDENT in his classroom and during testing; interview of STUDENT's teacher; and administration of certain tests. To assess STUDENT's academic achievement, Ms. Williams administered the WJ-R; to assess STUDENT's spelling, she administered the Test of Written Spelling (TWS-2); to assess STUDENT's reading skills, she administered the Spadafore Diagnostic Reading Test; and to assess STUDENT's visual skills, she administered the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration-3rd Revision and the test of Visual-Perceptual Skills. Ms. Williams also administered the Visual-Aural Digit Span Test, a diagnostic measure of sensory integration and short-term memory, and the Learning Efficiency Test, a measure of processing and retention of visual and auditory information. Ms. Williams summarized the results of her portion of the assessment and included over two pages of recommendations regarding ways by which to improve STUDENT's written language skills. (Respondent's Exhibit 4)

Elvida Martinez, school psychologist, conducted the cognitive and social and emotional portions of STUDENT's evaluation. The assessment included the following procedures: observations of STUDENT in his classroom, the cafeteria, playground, and during testing; interviews with STUDENT, his parent, and his teacher, Ms. Coward; review of STUDENT's educational records; and administration of several assessment instruments. To assess STUDENT's intellectual functioning, Ms. Martinez administered the WISC-III. To assess his perceptual performance, she administered the Bender Visual-Motor Gestalt Test. To assess STUDENT's social and emotional functioning, Ms. Martinez had STUDENT, his parent, and Ms. Coward complete the Social Skills Rating System. Ms. Coward also completed the Conners' Rating Scales and STUDENT completed the Piers-Harris Children's Self-Concept Scale and Roberts Apperception Test for Children. Ms. Martinez made recommendations to continue the accommodations called for in his 504 plan and to provide counseling and social skills training. (Respondent's Exhibit 5)

The assessment conducted by Kern County was very thorough and included numerous testing procedures and instruments. There was no evidence that any of the testing and assessment materials and procedures were racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. The assessment was administered in English, which is STUDENT's primary language. There was no evidence that the tests were administered other than in conformance with test instructions. The tests utilized are commonly used by psychologists and educators in assessing students. There was no evidence that the instruments utilized were invalid for the specific purpose for which they were used. The Kern County assessment measured STUDENT's academic, social, emotional, cognitive, perceptual, and speech and language skills. The primary area of suspected disability--social and emotional functioning--was assessed by a number of measures administered to STUDENT, his parent, and teacher. There was no evidence that STUDENT required any further testing for ADHD, given the diagnosis by Dr. Morong and the reduction of any symptoms of ADHD through the course of medication. The Hearing Officer finds that the Kern County assessment assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and, in all regards, was an appropriate assessment.

Each assessor prepared thorough individual reports that summarize background information and the results of testing. Each report also includes recommendations. The Hearing Officer finds that the Kern County reports conform with the requirements of Education Code § 56327.

In summary, appropriate assessments of STUDENT have been completed by the District in 1993, by the Diagnostic Center in 1993, and by Kern County in 1995. All of the assessments included measures of STUDENT's social and emotional functioning. The assessors also had the benefit of Dr. Morong's diagnosis of ADHD and addressed the effect of attentional problems through observation, interview, and some test measures. For these reasons, Petitioner's request for an additional assessment is denied.

ISSUE NO. 3: Should the District have found STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a serious emotional disturbance (SED)

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA), children with disabilities are entitled to a free, appropriate education. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c); California Education Code § 56000. "Children with disabilities" includes children who because of a serious emotional disturbance (SED), specific learning disability (SLD), other health impairment (OHI), or other disability defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 1401 of Title 20 of the United States Code, require instruction, services, or both, which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Education Code § 56026(b).

The evidence shows that STUDENT has been diagnosed with an attention deficit disorder with hyperactivity (ADHD). Daily medication is prescribed to alleviate the condition. ADHD is not listed in federal or state law as one of the disabilities which establish eligibility for special education. The United States Department of Education has stated in a policy memo that a student with an attention deficit disorder (ADD) or ADHD is eligible for special education only if by reason thereof (1) the student meets the eligibility criteria for a listed disability such as SLD, OHI, or SED; and (2) the student needs special education. U. S. Department of Education Joint Policy Memorandum, (1991) 18 IDELR 116; see also 20 U.S.C.1401(a)(1). California law similarly states that a student whose educational performance is "adversely affected" by ADHD is eligible for special education if the student demonstrates a need for special education and related services by meeting eligibility criteria in the category of SLD, OHI, or SED. Education Code § 56339(a).

Petitioner contends that because of an ADHD, social and emotional problems, and poor school performance, he meets special education eligibility criteria as SED. Petitioner asserts that the District should have found him eligible for special education in 1990, when he began exhibiting behavioral problems at school.

The District contends that Petitioner does not meet eligibility criteria for special education as SED. The District asserts that Petitioner's needs are being met in a regular education program with counseling and other services, including a behavioral intervention plan, which are provided to him under a 504 accommodation plan. The District also asserts that any condition STUDENT may have is not to a marked degree and that he has always maintained good grades and achieved well academically.

The federal regulations implementing IDEA set forth at 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(a)(9) the criteria that must be met to satisfy eligibility for special education as SED:

(i) The term means a condition exhibiting one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree that adversely affects a child's educational performance-- (A) An inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors;

(B) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers;

(C) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances;

(D) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression; or (E) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.

(ii) The term includes children who are schizophrenic. The term does not apply to children who are socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that they have a serious emotional disturbance.(Footnote 20)

All of STUDENT's teachers from kindergarten to the present testified that STUDENT has achieved academically and performs at grade level. Therefore, STUDENT does not have an inability to learn. There also was no credible evidence that STUDENT has exhibited physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems or has exhibited inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. Therefore, the two remaining areas under consideration, subsections B and D, are addressed below.

Does STUDENT exhibit an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers?

Mr. Halling and STUDENT's teachers testified that, beginning in kindergarten, STUDENT has had poor social skills with peers and difficulty maintaining interpersonal relationships. STUDENT was described by one teacher as "aggressive toward peers" and a "bully." On the other hand, STUDENT's fourth-grade teacher stated that he was accepted by peers for some activities, and his fifth-grade teacher testified that STUDENT's relationships with peers is improving. Ms. Leishman, STUDENT's neighbor and caretaker, testified that STUDENT has been friends with her son during the seven years they have been neighbors. School administrators Ms. Merritt and Mr. Johnson testified that STUDENT has made some friends. A number of witnesses have observed STUDENT on the playground appropriately engaged in games with peers. Some of STUDENT's teachers, as well as the administrators, testified that they have good relationships with STUDENT. Based on the evidence discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has some difficulty building interpersonal relationships. He does not, however, have a marked inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. Does STUDENT exhibit a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression?

Mr. Halling, Dr. Dennis, and several of STUDENT's teachers testified that, on occasion, STUDENT has appeared depressed. The 1993 assessment by the Diagnostic Center also notes depression. Dr. Birdsong, from the Diagnostic Center, as well as all of the District's witnesses who testified at the hearing, did not believe that STUDENT's depression was of sufficient severity to met special education criteria under SED. None of the witnesses testified that any of the occasional depression they had observed in STUDENT was to a marked degree or pervasive, or has interfered with his educational performance. Dr. Dennis, who worked with STUDENT during 1994, described STUDENT's depression as "mild" and appearing "now and then." Ms. Henson, the intervention specialist who worked with STUDENT during the 1994-95 school year, did not find STUDENT to be depressed.

The Hearing Officer finds credible the testimony of the teachers and other professionals who have worked with STUDENT in regard to the nature of STUDENT's depression. Each of these witnesses has worked individually with STUDENT and has known him for a considerable period of time. Three of the witnesses are specifically trained to assess and work with students with social and emotional problems. Specifically, Mr. Halling is a school psychologist. He has observed STUDENT while working with him from 1990 to 1993 and formally assessed him in 1993. Ms. Henson, who has a great deal of experience working with children with social problems and low self-esteem, met weekly with STUDENT during the previous school year. Dr. Dennis is a psychologist in private practice, has a number of years of experience working with children, and provided individual therapy to STUDENT. On the other hand, Petitioner did not call any witnesses to testify regarding STUDENT's depression. The Hearing Office notes that several District witnesses held the impression that STUDENT has received private therapy and was placed by his parents at Memorial Center in December 1995. Petitioner did not make any information regarding these services available for consideration by the Hearing Officer.

STUDENT's school performance is further evidence that any depression he may have experienced is not to a marked degree. Testing in 1993 and 1995 measured STUDENT's academic achievement in the average range. All of STUDENT's teachers testified that STUDENT is a good student, fits well into regular education classes, and performs at grade level. STUDENT has always earned good grades in school and his citizenship grades have generally been satisfactory.(Footnote 21) No evidence was presented to substantiate the assertion that STUDENT has missed a lot of school years because he was expelled or suspended by the school or because he was too depressed to attend school.

For all of the reasons discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not exhibit a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression that is to a marked degree. STUDENT, therefore, does not qualify for special education as SED.

ISSUE NO. 4: Should the District have found STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a health impairment (OHI)?

Petitioner contends that he is eligible for special education as OHI by reason of the diagnosis of ADHD and that, on November 16, 1995, the IEP team found he met OHI criteria for special education. The District contends that the IEP team did not find Petitioner eligible for special education and that any indication on the IEP to the contrary is erroneous. The Hearing Officer determined above in Issue No. 1 that the IEP team did not find STUDENT eligible for special education. The District contends that Petitioner does not meet eligibility for special education as OHI because he does not have limited strength or alertness and does not require special education to benefit from his education.

A student is eligible for special education if the student has an "other health impairment" and, by reason thereof, needs special education 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(1). Other health impairment means having limited strength, vitality, or alertness that is due to chronic or acute health problems that are not temporary in nature, and that adversely affect the student's educational performance. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(8); Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3030(f).

STUDENT has been diagnosed as ADHD by Dr. Morong in 1993. The District has accepted this diagnosis. Therefore, there is no dispute that STUDENT suffers from a chronic health problem. It must then be determined if, because of ADHD, STUDENT has limited strength, vitality, or alertness. No one has suggested that STUDENT has limited strength. Although STUDENT has been diagnosed as having an ADHD, the consensus of the witnesses was that STUDENT's medication has successfully ameliorated the symptoms of ADHD. STUDENT's teachers did not observe STUDENT to have limited vitality or alertness. Ms. Seymour, who assisted STUDENT in the computer lab in 1993, described STUDENT as "alert and attentive." The Diagnostic Center did not find evidence of significant hyperactivity, impulsivity, or distractibility during its assessment in 1993 nor during the on-site visit in 1995. Dr. Dennis, who met with STUDENT in 1994, testified that STUDENT did not have any problems focusing or filtering stimuli. Ms. Henson, who worked with STUDENT during the 1994-95 school year, testified similarly. The testimony of STUDENT's teachers from kindergarten to second grade also does not establish that STUDENT had limited vitality or alertness for which he required special education prior to Dr. Morong's prescription of medication for ADHD. Moreover, it was concluded above that STUDENT has consistently performed well educationally. There was no credible testimony to the contrary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not meet special education criteria as OHI.

ISSUES NOS. 5, 6, and 7:

Because STUDENT is not eligible for special education, he is not entitled to services or placement under IDEA.(Footnote 22)

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

ORDER

All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

DATED: May 3, 1996 _____________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES:

1. Mr. Krumpacher died before the hearing reconvened.

2. The intervention program consists of a small group of students who meet weekly with a specialist to improve social skills and self-esteem, and to address problems that arise at school.

3. At the hearing, the District stated its willingness to continue to provide the services called for in STUDENT's 504 plan.

4. Students who score below average on tests of academic achievement may be eligible for services funded under Title I, which was previously referred to as "Chapter I."

5. The SST meets periodically to address individual students that have been referred to the SST by their teachers, typically because of poor academic performance or social, emotional, or behavioral problems. Members of the team include special and regular education teachers, an administrator, and the school psychologist, and may also include the parent and student.

6. There is some indication that STUDENT received private individual and/or family therapy as well. The specifics of any counseling were not provided by the PARENTS.

7. On March 1, 1993, the behavioral plan was enhanced by identifying specific ways in which the plan would be implemented. For example, the plan indicates that the behavior modification contract would be based on "success charts" on which STUDENT could earn points for appropriate behavior. The plan also sets forth the way in which STUDENT would earn rewards and also suggests appropriate rewards. The plan also includes handwritten suggestions from STUDENT's mother regarding means by which to address STUDENT's behavior. (Respondent's Exhibit 11)

8. STUDENT's 504 plan was modified in August 1993, and again in both March and August 1994. A meeting was set for November 1995 to further revise the plan; however, this meeting was canceled by the parents. Ms. Merritt indicated that she had met with the parents during the course of the hearing to work on revisions to the plan. The August 1993 revision adds instructions for administering medications to STUDENT and specific suggestions for dealing with STUDENT on the playground and in class. It also indicates that counseling is a part of the plan but that counseling had been suspended at the request of the parents. The March 1994 revision to the plan includes specific procedures to follow in providing transportation to STUDENT, for dealing with STUDENT on the playground, and in administering STUDENT's medication. The plan also identifies targeted behaviors for the behavior modification plan and states that counseling would be provided by an independent contractor. (See Respondent's Exhibits 8, 12-15, and 60)

9. On the IEP form, Title I services are referred to by their prior name, "Ch. I services."

10. Next to STEPFATHER's name it indicates that he agreed with recommendations "at this time."

11. Earlier in the school term, STUDENT had served a two-day "in-house" suspension for stealing some materials from the school's book fair.

12. The only information regarding this time period is contained in letters from Kern County, which operates the Community School STUDENT attended during his stay at Memorial Center. According to the information contained in the letters, except for the first day of his enrollment at the Community School, STUDENT performed in a "satisfactory manner" and was an "excellent, cooperative student." (Respondent's Exhibits 16-20) Records from the Memorial Center were the subject of a subpoena duces tecum (SDT) requested by the District. Memorial Center did not comply with the SDT because STUDENT's parents did not consent to release of the requested documents. There was no evidence that the District sought enforcement of the SDT from a court of competent jurisdiction.

13. STEPGRANDFATHER maintained that the District had "disenrolled" STUDENT from school and that he could not return to the District until they "re-enrolled" him. During the telephone conference on November 28, 1995, and on the first day of the hearing, the District maintained that STUDENT had been suspended for one school day only and that he was expected to return to school following the one-day suspension.

14. STUDENT attends a year-round school. His track was not in session from December 25, 1995, through January 21, 1996.

15. For example, a green card indicated that a student's behavior was appropriate whereas a red card indicated that the student's behavior was not appropriate.

16. The Comprehensive Test of Basic Skills (CTBS) is a series of group-administered tests of academic achievement used by some school districts on an annual basis.

17. Other assertions made by STEPGRANDFATHER on behalf of Petitioner are not addressed in this decision because they either do not fall under the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office, are not specifically regarding Petitioner, or are incomprehensible. For example, this decision does not address Petitioner's assertions regarding the District's alleged failure "to discuss at the IEPT Meetings (and act) concerning the amount of accountability the T-Dist is liable for 'if the child with disabilities does not achieve the growth projected by the Annual Goals and Objectives...; to show the IEPT all the Kern Co. SELPA forms available for consideration of options in every area discussed or referenced for information and programs etc for assessments and evaluations and developing IEPs...; and to carry out a T-Dist level Due Process Hearing, requested by the Parent, where STUDENT was refused in writing that a LEA Hearing was denied, where STUDENT was claimed unidentified by T-Dist, but infact was entitled to a LEA Due Process Hearing (re 9th Circuit Court/92)." (See Petitioner's statement of issues for hearing.)

18. Petitioner indicated at the hearing that he was not seeking reimbursement for any educational costs his parents may have incurred.

19. The PARENTS' request for an assessment is not contained within the documents submitted by the parties. Several other documents refer to their request on this date.

20. California's definition of SED is almost identical to the federal definition. Under (C) above, the California requirement includes that the inappropriate behavior must be "exhibited in several situations." Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3030(i)(3).

21. In the second grade, all of STUDENT's marks in academic subjects were at or above grade level. During the third grade, all of STUDENT's grades were As and Bs. Of the 24 letter grades STUDENT received in academic subjects over the four quarters of the fourth grade, three were Cs, three were A-s, and the remainder ranged from B- to B+. In other subjects, STUDENT received all satisfactory grades, except in handwriting. For the first quarter of the current school year, STUDENT received one each of the following: C; C+; B-; and B. He also received two B+ grades. (Respondent's Exhibits 22 and 49)

22.The Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction to determine matters under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act. Therefore, no findings are made regarding STUDENT's entitlement to services under Section 504.